Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Good morning, everyone. This is Barry Knapp from Ironsides Macroeconomics. It's Monday morning, November 18th at about 8am East Coast time down in Florida on my way to Tucson later this week. As a note, there will be a delay in this week's note. I'm not going to have time late this week to get it together. We'll do it when we get back to Colorado on a Sunday. So you'll probably receive it a week from today rather than the typical Friday morning time.
SPEAKER_00So our note this week was titled Our Dollar, Everyone's Problem. There was lots of discussion over the weekend. It almost seemed a little bit of post facto that the weakness in the equity market had to do with the debate about who's going to be Treasury Secretary. And while We think that those that may have been some level of concern about that, that's not really what we think was happening in the markets last week. From our perspective, 10 is getting close to four and a half percent 10 year reels or tips well through 2%.
SPEAKER_00and the strength of the dollar in particular. If you're watching this as a video, you can see that near-term forward spread, which is a measure of Fed expectations, has steepened considerably. It hasn't quite disinverted, but that's taken the dollar with it. And in recent years, monetary policy has played a very considerable role in the direction of the dollar. You may all recall the start of this chart is back in September of 22 when we think
SPEAKER_00we hit what we define as our double start or the financial instability rate when the Fed raised above 3% turned down. Larry Silverstein, carry on their portfolio negative, which was also true of much of the big banks set off a sharp decline in the end that the Japanese needed to intervene to the tune of $21 billion or so caused a flash crash and pound sterling US mortgage market to go bid list. Larry Silverstein, The feds. Seemingly turned towards a more hawkish stance the repricing of the terminal rate
SPEAKER_00forecast much closer towards our our expectations of 4% has led the dollar higher and, as we know, the dollar can be an absolute. global liquidity wrecking ball and can trigger weakness across just a broad range of assets. And so that's what we think is really going on and why the market struggled. So the note this week began with this discussion of dollar disruption. We then reviewed inflation, the inflation data from last week, inflation week.
SPEAKER_00We then discussed monetary policy, the debate that they are seemingly having about where the real rate or terminal rate should be neutral rate, if you will. There was a little bit of a revisiting of productivity discussion in there because the Kansas City Fed president in a speech spoke about churn within the labor market, potentially creating a cyclical surge in uh productivity which may then fade this is something we've written a lot about we were thrilled to see that he had picked up on this and so we took the passage out
SPEAKER_00and discussed that a little bit and then you know wrapped it up with our thoughts on latest thoughts on the on the trump trade so um Just to begin, we do not think that President Trump is inheriting a great economy. We reviewed earnings a little bit and noted that S&P, ex-tech, and comm services earnings growth was only 4%. It's only expected to be 6% next quarter. That's not exactly robust mid-cycle type growth. And the Russell 2000 is still a problem. The one-year forward estimate through earnings season has fallen from negative 10.5% to negative 14.9%.
SPEAKER_00That's one year forward. the problems in the small business sector might be alleviated or helped to some extent by more favorable tax policy. But the real issue is monetary policy. And we noted a quote from the NFIB survey that said the average financing rate came down from 10.1 to 9.7%. But 9.7% financing rate for small businesses is quite prohibitive. And we do really need a
SPEAKER_00fairly painless disinversion of the curve to relieve all that pressure on the supply of credit as well as the price of credit. So getting the Fed to ease is crucial for stabilizing small cap and small company earnings, highly leveraged company earnings. We then moved on to a little bit of a discussion of the policy sequencing. So there is a continuing resolution that matures or expires on December 20th. And what the Congress decides to do with that is going to be crucial if they do
SPEAKER_00their typical, let's do an omnibus spending bill and extend it all the way out till next September. That would be a negative scenario in our view, very similar to what happened in 2017, where the Trump administration got bogged down in Obamacare repeal and replace and didn't get to tax policy for a full year. That made things a little more difficult in the first year of the Trump presidency than they needed to have been otherwise.
SPEAKER_00So we have a similar dynamic now. Clearly, they're not going to get bogged down in Obamacare repeal and replace. from a legislative perspective, but we have the issue of tariffs and taxes. So if there is another CR continuum resolution that pushes the tax debate out a couple of months and at the same time that they're implementing increased tariffs, they're also addressing tax policy, markets may be able to look through the disruptive impact of tariffs,
SPEAKER_00which will undoubtedly push the dollar higher and you know, exacerbate the current liquidity situation. Of course, that does depend on what the Fed's doing at that time, what happens with the labor market. But we're just trying to make the point here that this taxing and tariff stuff needs to happen virtually simultaneously for, you know, the markets to get the carrot and the stick at the same time. So that's just something we wanted to raise and get people to start thinking about.
SPEAKER_00As far as the inflation data goes, we did the CPI report as inline. We were always likely to have a bit of a seasonality issue here. We're copping against some very soft numbers from a year ago. We're not worried about goods prices in the least. We still think there is issues with respect to super core, non-housing services, that comes from the fiscal theory of the price level of fiscally driven inflation, government wages running nearly 100 basis points above the private sector,
SPEAKER_00Employment growth running nearly 100 basis points above the private sector. So there's issues with inflation and we don't think it's going to get easily back to the Fed's target. But we don't think there's a reason for them to be pausing in December because PPI and import prices were a little hotter. By the way, import prices haven't picked up is not going to persist with the strength of the dollar that we're currently seeing. Yes, we may very well get a 0.3 on core PCED at the end of the month,
SPEAKER_00but it's not a reason for the Fed to pause. They need to get to four sooner rather than later. That really just took us into the next section where we discussed the terminal rate, our view of why we think they need to get to four based upon the banking system, based upon painlessly disinverting the curve. Fed seems oblivious to a lot of those issues other than maybe Kansas City Fed president. or Dallas Fed President Logan. We're still anxious to hear more from Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammock.
SPEAKER_00We suspect she'd be cognizant of the same issues given her background at Goldman Sachs on the trading side of the firm. But that notwithstanding, That's where we think they need to be getting to sooner rather than later. Were they to skip December, for example, that would, in our opinion, be a very big mistake. So I did touch on that productivity discussion. If you're a full subscriber, you go and have a look at that. We thought it was interesting. one of the points we've been making around the productivity outlook is it's a
SPEAKER_00little there is some evidence that we're getting uh accelerated technology innovation adoption like we got in 2018 and 2019 and we see it we've tried to measure it through sales per employee deflated in the various s p sectors and so there's some evidence we're getting more technology adoption and we may be getting um you know stronger total factor productivity growth which is the technology component of productivity but you know president schmidt brings up a
SPEAKER_00good point that we had brought up previously which is that big churn we had in the labor market from mid-21 to mid-22 caused the surge in productivity as employees settled into their jobs some two years in they're at their maximum point of productivity before they get to the inevitable grumbling hey i don't like this job that much i want to move on but they're sort of trapped now because churn has collapsed and whether we're getting a cyclical turn in productivity or more of a secular trend is a little bit unclear and that is a major issue for 2025 is do those strong productivity numbers persist
SPEAKER_00or do they fade if they fade that means weaker profit margins slower earnings growth and a problem for a problem for equities particularly if the trump administration doesn't get the sequencing of tariffs and tax policy correct. Wrapping it up, we don't really think the issue is about the Treasury Secretary here, not that we don't think it's significant. We've written quite a bit about how important a Treasury Secretary is given the size of our debt. The issuance,
SPEAKER_00in a lot of ways, the position is as important as the Fed chair, which is something that wasn't true for the last few decades. So that is a crucial decision, but we don't really think that's what drove the markets last week. We think it had more to do with rates getting to uncomfortable levels, tightening of dollar liquidity, certainly the pain in the healthcare sector, which is something that we addressed by downgrading the sector before we got to the RFK appointment. Of course, the group got shellacked. And if anything, from this point, we'd be tempted to even
SPEAKER_00reduce our exposure to zero in the sector because we do think it does need disrupting. We've been on the wrong track with this sector for a long time. 30 years of successively lower profit margins in the sector ought to get you kind of scratching your head as the price goes up. But bottom line here is we're into a favorable period of seasonality for equities, not so much for fixed income. Trump administration has to get all this policy stuff right. They were not left with a really great hand by the Biden administration.
SPEAKER_00There's some serious problems that need to be addressed. And the Fed needs to continue the recalibration process as well. So that's it for me this week. Again, I apologize for next week's note being a little bit delayed, but I've got a golf member guest to play in down in Tucson this week, and this is a mini break for us. So have a good week, everyone. Thank you.
Note: We only made one video this week, consequently free subscribers are also receiving the long form version. Please consider supporting our work. Executive Summary We see the case for further Fed tightening weakening...
Note: Both introductory and paid subscribers are receiving the same video summary this week, we did not have time to record an abbreviated version. If you find the content helpful to your investment process, please...
This is a video summary of our January 17 note, The Dog That Didn’t Bite Ironsides Macroeconomics ‘It’s Never Different This Time’ is a reader-supported publication. To receive posts and support our work, consider...
This is a video summary of our January 3 note, Merry New Year, we are making this available to free subscribers this morning. Ironsides Macroeconomics 'It's Never Different This Time' is a reader-supported publication....
This is a video summary covering our annual thematic note released December 18, Macro Themes: Reversing Financial Statism and a second note covering last week’s employment and inflation data released on December 19,...