I’d sell the commercial property even at a loss. A cap rate below a near risk-free bond yield doesn’t pay you for the risk. I start with news: the Episode 429 retirement tables are now an online calculator at investopoly.com.au. Then a 33-year-old specialist asks whether $660,000 sitting in an offset is dead money. On a risk-weighted basis, I don’t think it is, though $300,000 to $400,000 is probably enough buffer for maternity leave. I also weigh up land in an established suburb against a new townhouse, and explain why I wouldn’t change anything in a small family trust yet. A 66-year-old retiree with about $6 million, mostly in property, is tired of land tax, low income, and tenants. I’d gradually move into shares and other liquid investments over the next decade, ideally selling into a better market. Finally, a couple aged 49 with $2.6 million of property debt want to retire in their late 50s. I’d keep the residential properties and build an ETF portfolio alongside them, but sell the commercial property, even at a loss. 00:00 Intro: an online version of the Episode 429 retirement calculator 01:17 The new Investopoly resource website 02:52 Saving a base case and testing changes 04:08 Coming soon: a tool for searching past Q&A answers 06:43 A 33-year-old specialist: what to do with $660,000 in offset 09:25 Risk-weighted returns: offset vs shares 11:17 Negative gearing is still a loss 12:09 How big a buffer for maternity leave? 13:03 Buying a home: established land or a new townhouse? 14:31 Which will be scarcer in 20 years? 16:12 Why I’d weight financial outcomes at 33 16:34 The family trust and the proposed 30% minimum tax 17:53 A 66-year-old retiree with $6 million in property 19:06 The bias of building wealth in one asset class 19:58 Low, unpredictable income and rising holding costs 21:26 Tenants, and why location matters 23:28 Strategically exiting into liquid investments 24:18 Why I’d wait for a better market to sell 25:45 What a retirement portfolio should do for you 26:52 Property as a driver, not the whole golf bag 27:37 Why investing in both property and shares early helps 28:13 A couple at 49: carrying too much debt? 30:12 Don’t let a paper loss decide 31:44 The decision you’ll wish you’d made in 2026 32:18 Why commercial property looks like a bubble 33:06 Episode 412: cap rates and mean reversion 33:37 Why subordinated debt ETFs set the benchmark 35:39 The missing number: surplus investable cash flow 36:53 Mean reversion and the risk of negative equity 38:01 The residential properties: Belmont and Torquay 38:40 Why I’d sell the commercial property, even at a loss Related episodes: Ep 429: How much do you need to retire & are you on track? Work it out here. https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/19893951-ep-429-how-much-do-you-need-to-retire-are-you-on-track-work-it-out-here Ep 412: Beware: Commercial property values look stretched https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/19306940-ep-412-beware-commercial-property-values-look-stretched Ep 432: Bond ETFs vs 10-Year government bonds: Lock in or not? https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/20012238-ep-432-bond-etfs-vs-10-year-government-bonds-lock-in-or-not Q&A - Debt recycling when you sell your home: keep the deduction https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/19934965-q-a-debt-recycling-when-you-sell-your-home-keep-the-deduction Q&A - ETF portfolio construction at 28: is 8.4% too low? https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/19978320-q-a-etf-portfolio-construction-at-28-is-8-4-too-low Ep 425: Family trust investing: Are trusts still worth it under proposed tax changes? https://investopoly.buzzsprout.com/2005600/episodes/19764156-ep-425-family-trust-investing-are-trusts-still-worth-it-under-proposed-tax-changes Read Stuart's latest book? He's only got 19 reviews on Amazon so far, if Wealth by Design helped you, leaving one would mean a lot: https://www.amazon.com.au/review/create-review?asin=192318654X Run your own business? Check out Business by Design, Stuart and Mena's show on starting, growing and exiting a business, at https://www.businessbydesignpodcast.com/ Our most popular free guides: Over the years we've written hundreds of articles. These three bring our best thinking together on the topics that matter most right now: choosing a super fund, debt recycling, and navigating the new tax changes. Download them here Got a question for the podcast? Email us at questions@investopoly.com.au Subscribe to my weekly blog: Stay connected here Important This podcast provides general information about finance, tax and credit. It doesn't take into account your specific objectives, financial situation or needs, so you need to assess whether it's relevant to your circumstances before acting on it. If you're not sure, speak to a licensed, trustworthy professional.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00My name's Stuart Weams and welcome to the Investopoly podcast. Our goal is to share easy to understand, evidence-based, holistic insights to help you master the game of building wealth. Now, before we get started in today's episode, just a bit of a heads up. Early last month, 5th of October, I published an episode, Are You on Track for Retirement? You might remember that one where on the blog and the website we had different tables and allowed you to sort of work out if you have a certain super balance at the moment, you're making certain contributions, you've got some investment properties with some borrowings, all these sorts of things.
SPEAKER_00You could work out kind of you if you're on track, and if not, what you'd need to do to, you know, to build a perpetual portfolio or a depleting portfolio. And I got some great feedback from that uh episode. So it's episode 429. So firstly, thanks for the feedback. And the idea came about because there's a lot of articles and tools online that allows you to work out how much super you need. But of course, if you've got you know substantial geared property investments, and one of the examples I used in that episode was, you know, someone that's relatively young that has virtually very little super, but substantially geared assets, they're probably going to be okay as long as they can hold those assets for many decades.
SPEAKER_00That's probably going to generate enough wealth for them to retire and probably retire sooner. So that was the observation that I kind of wanted to solve. And my idea is that we've created a resource website, so Investopoly.com.au. If you're a subscriber to the blog, all you need to do is put in your email address and you get email to code and it'll give you access to all the downloadable tools in that website. And it'll, using a cookie, it'll remember who you are. So you only have to do that once unless you use different computers. If you don't subscribe to my blog, guess what you need to do?
SPEAKER_00You need to subscribe. So put in your email and uh you'll still get the code. Anyway, the goal is over the coming months and years is to build out a resource page that has a lot of resources that helps you put into practice all the theory that we talk about in the podcast and both in the QA episodes like today, but also in the usual standard Wednesday episodes, the topic-based episodes. So that's the goal, and I want to build it out as much as possible. Anyway, coming back to episode 429, Are You on Track for Retirement?
SPEAKER_00The a lot of users asked, look, it'd be great to have a tool that we could use online. So I've created one using the same sort of assumptions and analysis and so forth that I used in that blog. So that's now available. So you can go to, this is a very long-winded way of saying it's now available, but you can go to investopoly.com.au and it's an HTML page as opposed to a spreadsheet. So you should be able to use it on lots of different devices, you know, whether they're uh tablets or phone or whatever it might be, and it'll do the calculations for you.
SPEAKER_00You can actually save a base case and then tinker with the numbers. So you could say, well, this is my base case, this is what I'm planning to do. What happens if I increase my contributions, super contributions or contributions towards a share portfolio by$1,000 a month? It'll then tell you, well, you could retire a little bit earlier or you could spend a little bit more in retirement, whatever it is. So it allows you to sort of save a base case. Plus, also there's a few other, you know, flexibility that the tool provides you, much more than what I could probably do in a spreadsheet.
SPEAKER_00So if you plan to change your investment contributions over time, you're able to sort of do that and put in some parameters. And that'll deal with situations like, for example, if you have a young family at the moment, you might have, you know, a relatively low surplus investable cash flow. But you might think, look, in five to seven years, you know, both spouses will be back at work full-time, kids will be in school, expenses are lower, you know, childcare, so forth, incomes higher. So we're gonna have more investable surplus cash flow. So both in the share portfolio outside super and super contributions, you can change those contributions.
SPEAKER_00Also with the investment properties, of course, what I'm assuming is you're gonna fund that from cash flow. So we don't include the cash flow impact of properties in the in the model. Remember, this is all information only, just a tool to really help you. But hopefully we're heading in the right direction. And I am also working on, I work on a a number of different things all at once, but I am working on a notebook LM tool. So one of the challenges, I think, at the moment is that we have a lot of content in the QA session, and a lot of people find them really useful.
SPEAKER_00And particularly, I guess, if the scenario is similar to yours, you know, it's obviously a lot more relatable from that perspective. But how do you go and find that advice? How do you go and find that commentary? Well, we're gonna use Notebook LM. So that's a Google Gemini tool. So it uses the Gemini engine, if you like. We're gonna feed it all the transcripts from the podcast, and so then you can jump into that tool and ask questions. And the goal is that it'll tell you go and listen to this episode, or this is the information that Stuart and Campbell gave that listener that in a similar situation, this is what they suggested you look out for.
SPEAKER_00So that's another thing I'm working on. I'll let you know when that's uh available. But what we really want to do is build out this resource website and as I said, bridge the gap between knowledge and information, fundamentals, and theory to how do you apply it to your specific circumstances. Again, none of this is personal advice, of course, nor a substitute for it, but just trying to think of a way where, you know, we can add a lot more value for our listeners. And of course, please share, right? So this is the whole thing.
SPEAKER_00You build a tool, and if 10 people use it and get value from it, that's fantastic. But if 10,000 people use it and get a lot of value from it, you move the dial in terms of helping people. So, of course, there's a selfish commercial interest here. I like the podcast to be as successful as possible. If people, of course, like what I'm talking about, you know, they might reach out to my business. Of course, that's always the hope as well. Of course, there's, you know, information's not going to help everyone. Some people need specific advice. So I get there's a commercial incentive there for me to say that, but really ultimately put a lot of effort and time and energy into this podcast.
SPEAKER_00And ultimately the reward is that it helps as many people as possible. And if I achieve that, the natural consequence will be, of course, my business will benefit. But so I don't need to worry about that so much. But please share. I mean, the whole thing is it's the highest-rated Australian finance podcast, which I'm very, very proud of. And we just want to make it even better. So hang in there. It's a long preamble today's show, but hang in there, we'll uh give you a lot more resources as we go through. And of course, you've got any suggestions and questions, you can always send them to questions at investopoly.com.au.
SPEAKER_00Okay, let's get into today's episode. And the first question is from a listener that wants to remain anonymous. The person is a medico, a specialist doctor, earning about$550,000 a year, and is only newly qualified, so hasn't been earning that level of income for a long period of time, really since 2022, but went through a divorce, a separation a while ago, which so had to give away or was relieved of, you know, some of her her wealth. And essentially there's three questions.
SPEAKER_00The person has three questions. I'll just give you a rundown quickly of rents and works in a rural area and families in Melbourne. So they've got three properties. There's one in Melbourne that used to be a former home. There's one in Adelaide, in McGill in Adelaide, and another one in Brisbane. I don't have the current values. I've got the purchase dates and amounts, but you know, that there's nothing that stands out there with those three properties. Obviously, the one in Melbourne is still claimed as a principal place of residence given this individual is renting elsewhere.
SPEAKER_00So at least getting nil capital gains tax, although there's nil capital gain in Melbourne. It's not that tax advantageous, I should say. But anyway, it is what it is. Hopefully there will be some gains in the near future. So, anyway, there's three properties there. I should say that the previous home is fully offset, so there's no debt against that. And there's about 1.7 mil of debt against the other two assets. Again, I don't know what their current values are, only have purchase price, but there's a bit of equity in there. In terms of assets outside of the three investment properties, Vanguard ETF's 150,000, DirectShares about 100,000, super is about 300,000.
SPEAKER_00And then there's a family trust with about 26,000. So obviously you must have just established the family trust. The first thing, oh, and the plan is this person's repartnered, and the plan is mid-28 to potentially take maternity leave. So obviously, I'm reading between the lines here, that relationship is pretty serious, and they're going to have children. So the first question really is what do I do with the cash in the offset? So put some numbers around. There's about 660,000 of cash in offset. It's offsetting the Melbourne property debt, which is now obviously investment debt given that property is rented out.
SPEAKER_00Anyway, so the first question is about what I do with the money in the offset account. And the observation this listener shares is that I should be utilizing negative gearing and I should be investing the cash elsewhere. But they're concerned, or this person's concerned, that I want to be reliant on their partner for future income, particularly during if they take maternity leave. And then also it's really about, you know, having a cash buffer and those sorts of things. But I just want to address should utilize negative gearing and invest the cash elsewhere. Let's start with the latter one first.
SPEAKER_00So you've got to look at risk-weighted return. And I've mentioned this a few times. So when you're weighing up investment opportunities, yes, you need to weigh up the potential return, but you also need to weigh up the potential risk. And the potential risk, the best way to explain that is what probability do I have of achieving that target return? So with respect to putting money in offset account, let's say your interest rate is 6.5%. So that's your return. What is the chance of receiving that return? 100%. There's actually no chance that you won't save 6.5% if you put the cash in the offset account.
SPEAKER_00So therefore, if you want to go and invest elsewhere, what do you need to achieve in terms of returns to be better off? Well, if you go in the share market, long-term returns about 10%. But look, you might have to wait 20 years to get that average return, depending on the distribution and the sequencing of returns. But there's going to be an element of risk there. So you probably want, you probably want 10% in terms of return. But on a risk-weighted basis, I would say if you can get 10.5% in the share market or 6.5% in the offset account, on a risk-weighted basis, I'd say those two opportunities look relatively similar.
SPEAKER_00Yes, the headline return's different, but also the risk is substantially different to that as well. So I wouldn't look as money in offset as dead money. You've just got to make a, it's you've got to have the context of your financial position and goals and then work out whether that is a good outcome, particularly if it's non-tax-deductible debt. It's not in this example for this listener, but if it's a non-tax deductible debt, you're saving 6.5% after tax. So before tax, to earn even just that rate, you've probably got to earn 9 or 10% in terms of return.
SPEAKER_00And that doesn't even compensate your allow for the risk as well as different investment opportunities. So putting money in an offset account isn't necessarily a bad thing. And then I should utilize negative gearing. Remember, negative gearing is a loss. Like you're making a loss. And sure, the whole premise of negative gearing, any investment, including property, is that yes, I'll make an income loss today, but if I keep this asset and I enjoy the power of compounding capital growth, I'm making a$20,000 loss today in the hope that I'm going to generate$2 million of equity in this asset over the next 20 years.
SPEAKER_00And if I do that, then I've been handsomely rewarded. That's the thesis behind it, of course. But it does not just make losses, you know, just chase those losses, chase those tax deductions. That's only half of the equation. So I don't mean to labor this point, but you know, I just wanted to point out that I don't really think I'm not persuaded by either of those two observations that this listener has shared with. And in fact, I would say that, well, do you need 660,000 to, you know, have a baby go on maternity leave, etc., etc.
SPEAKER_00You probably don't need that much. So you probably could utilize or put some of that cash elsewhere. But if you told me, if you came to me and said, well, this is what I want to do, I don't want to be relying on my partner's income. I do want to have to flexibly have a baby in the future, I'd probably say to you, look, keep at least three or four hundred thousand in the offset account. That would give you a really healthy buffer, plus also help you, you know, because when you have a child, of course, you might plan. What you plan for might not actually happen. Like some people might say, look, I'm gonna have a child, I'll have four months off work and I'll go back to work full-time.
SPEAKER_00But, you know, circumstances or health issues or other challenges that might may or may not be expected might interrupt that plan. So I think you've got to plan on the basis you're gonna have a year off. You know, you're not gonna earn income for a year, so you need to cover living expenses for a year, and then you need to have a buffer. So, you know, 300 is probably more than enough, I would expect. But if you want to be conservative, maybe 400. But this really leads me into the next question, which is the listener's looking for a primary place of residence, and they've got two options to consider. And there's they're thinking about spending about$2 million on a home.
SPEAKER_00One option is to buy an established home on a decent land, but the house is going to be pretty ordinary, like it's going to need some renovations, some repairs, all those sorts of things, just because probably spending most of the budget on land value rather than improvements. Or alternatively, uh, their parents are doing a two-town house subdivision. I'd imagine might be their home or whatever it might be. Anyway, in Glen Waverly, the subdivision is in a particular school zone, and that might be an attractive proposition where this listener could buy, you know, the front townhouse on that block.
SPEAKER_00Anyway, listeners asked me to weigh up those two options. I think what I'd say to you if I met you in person, I think what I'd say to you is what's what's more important, money or lifestyle? And one has to be more than 50%. So you've got to tell me which one's more important. So you might say, look, money 70% and lifestyle's 30%. If that was the case, go and buy yourself a bit of land in an established suburb. And yes, I get the point that you don't really want to renovate or rebuild, but financially, that's probably going to work out in the longer run.
SPEAKER_00But what you've got to think about is in 20 years' time, which one's going to be the more attractive, scarcer asset? The asset that can't really ever be developed anymore because it's already been subdivided. The asset that had a lot of money poured into it 20 years ago and yes, might be in a good location, but still a relatively small parcel of land. Or will it be the asset that is on a relatively large block of land that can be developed down the track in terms of subdivided and so forth? Not that I'm saying that, you know, people should be subdividing their property, but I'm saying there's always an alternate use.
SPEAKER_00And when you're buying property, you want your return, your potential future return to potentially come from a couple of different parts. It could be general market improvement, it could be improvements that you could make to the property, or it could be alternate uses of that property. Well, a family home or a house on a relatively large block of land, I think has more alternate uses than a subdivided townhouse. And so I think in the long run, over the next 20 or 30 years, financially that's likely to be better. If you tell me lifestyle is more important, then what you're saying is that you like the location of the townhouse.
SPEAKER_00It's probably going to be a better quality asset in terms of accommodation-wise, you know, more livable, newer, etc. And the listeners shared the observation, they can see themselves living there for a couple of decades. So that looks like it ticks most boxes. I guess the thing you want to think about is space, depending on, you know, how many children you want to have and whether that's really going to suit you or not. That's the way I see those two options. I think the buying the house in an established location that's mostly land value is going to be most likely going to be a bet a more attractive proposition.
SPEAKER_00Financially, the townhouse might be more attractive from a lifestyle perspective. Only you can make the decision or way up between those two. I should say the listener's 33 years old, so I'd probably put greater weight towards financial at 33 rather than lifestyle. I think if you prioritize your financial outcomes at 33, not always to the detriment of lifestyle, of course, you need to have balance. But if financial is a priority in early 30s, you know, I think by the time you get into your 50s, you're probably in a fantastic position or more likely to be in a fantastic position than prioritizing lifestyle decisions too early in the investment journey.
SPEAKER_00And the final question is what do you do with the family trust? Obviously, there's$26,000 of ETFs in the family trust, given the minimum 30% tax rate that's proposed in it's in Parliament at the moment. I've mentioned this, I think I mentioned this last week. You know, I said many months ago that I think these policies might not be permanent. And I actually will do a podcast episode on where I think it might be going. Crystal ballgazing, admittedly, but it's still worthwhile sharing. So I wouldn't do anything. I would just keep going. I would just I think if you just work on the assumption that nothing's going to change, and certainly you don't need to do anything now.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't start until 1 July 28. We'll have a federal election before then. A lot of water needs to go under the bridge. So I wouldn't do anything. If you wanted to pause the investing and do the investing in your personal name, I would think that's okay. But equally, I would think it's okay to continue investing more. We're only talking at least at the moment, 26 grand. So we're not talking about big problems down the track. And we know that there'll be rollover relief. You can move into your personal name down the track. So you've got that optionality. I just wouldn't react to what's proposed at this stage. Anyway, thank you for your question.
SPEAKER_00Hopefully that helps you at least to some degree to navigate some of those decisions. And all the best. Okay, next question is from AN. So just a bit of a rundown. Ayan's 66 retired single net assets, around$6 million. From what I can understand, mostly in a discretionary family trust. Two Brisbane properties, one with subdivision potential in Logan, and another with multiple flats, and then one luxury property in New South Wales also holds some Vanguard ETF investments.
SPEAKER_00And AI's really worried about a couple things. The minimum 30% tax on family trusts, and the investment properties are becoming a bit of a pain to manage, and the taxes are mounting up and really eating into income. So the net income that Ayan's getting off these investments isn't great and doesn't give a lot of flexibility. Let me see if there's anything else that I've missed. I think that's it. That's sort of summary. It's a bit of long email, but that's kind of a summary of the situation. Look, I think the and the there's a sorry, the other observation is that Ain likes bricks and mortar.
SPEAKER_00Obviously, that's how he built the portfolio. And, you know, there's natural comfort with that. Remembering that we've got to be careful about that. Like if all my experience has been investing in property and that experience has been positive, I'm probably going to have an unbalanced view towards property in that I think it's better than shares, that maybe I think it's less risky than shares. And look, my success might have been good down to good fundamentals and good decision making, or it could have been just good timing and luck.
SPEAKER_00So it's funny with that, and something we're always quite conscious of, particularly when I look at a client in their circumstances, always look for some sort of bias or emotional bias that sort of drives decisions. You've got to be careful. Like try and not let it drive your decisions as much as possible. The issue is that if you have most or all of your assets in property, you're going to have to make friends with a couple of different outcomes, potential outcomes. Firstly, income is unpre is low and unpredictable. So low as in as a percentage of the market value of the asset, it's not going to give you a lot of income.
SPEAKER_00And unpredictable because expenses can rise sometimes permanently, like taxes, like cancel rates, insurance. None of these things ever go backwards. And I think if you have a look over the COVID period, last sort of six or seven years, things have risen considerably. I've mentioned Brisbane City Council rates before in terms of the cost of rates in Brisbane. Often land tax in Victoria gets a lot of commentary around it. But you know, there's some other states and locations where those expenses are substantial.
SPEAKER_00And then of course there's maintenance, vacancy, these sorts of things that can be unpredictable. So you might look at the average income from a property, you know, over the last few years might have been 50 grand, but it can easily be$10,000 in the preceding 12 months because of those sorts of things like vacancies and expenses. So that's a big problem. And then secondly, you are more exposed, I think, to changes in laws and taxes with property because it's less less liquid. So you it's harder to navigate those changes. Plus, also the states are very reliant on taxes, property-related taxes to generate income tax, of course.
SPEAKER_00So you're almost a sitting duck from that perspective. And you can't sell like 5% of your assets, all or nothing. So I think in those sorts of situations, and then finally you've got to think about tenants and managing tenants. Look, I think that can be, I don't want to overemphasize the challenges that can present because they tend to be sporadic. And I've mentioned this before. I find sometimes for whatever reason, every tenant in a property has a question or an issue over a two month period, and then you won't hear from anyone for six months.
SPEAKER_00So don't be too quick to overreact sometimes to, oh, look, this property's a pain in the neck. I'm just going to get rid of it, because it does come in waves. I find that to be the case. And also All tenants can be annoying from time to time. But that's one of the things that I don't think is written about enough is the location of the property will really dictate to a large extent how many problems in averted commerce you will get. And property in lower socioeconomic locations are likely to attract tenants that are going to give you more challenges than ones that aren't in those locations.
SPEAKER_00And so Logan, you know, no offense. Anyone lives in or invests in Logan, but it's not, it's not one of those premium blue chip suburbs that are going to attract, you know, professional tenant professionals that are great tenants that hardly are using the property that are either at work or out most of the time and are pretty easy going. That probably doesn't describe your typical Logan tenants. So again, not picking on anything there. But so I think that's the first thing, right? Is that you've got to set realistic expectations.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, for this listener, they're in this position, but they've got to expect to be in this position where, you know, that they're getting hammered with land tax, that they're not getting a lot of income off this portfolio, that the tenants are annoying them. And remember, these things are easy to navigate in our 30s because it's part of the process of building wealth. But ultimately, we want passive income when we're retired. So I find people that are retired become more fatigued on dealing with property-related matters than when they were in accumulation.
SPEAKER_00And rightly so, right? You've done all the hard work, you've done all the heavy lifting, you've got the compounding capital growth. You should be able to sit back and not be bothered and just enjoy your retirement. So, what does this person do? Well, you've got to strategically exit your investments. I think you've got to clearly, you know, add in some more equities and more liquid investments. As I talk about in Wealth by Design, there should be inherent in every strategy some sort of asset allocation changes that occur over time to get yourself in a position in retirement where your investments aren't being a nuisance, that you've got you've got enough liquidity.
SPEAKER_00So in the years where your property income is a little lower, you can sell some of those liquid investments to compensate. And you don't need to worry about, you know, where your next month's uh income's gonna come from. Now, Anne's correctly identified, look, I don't really want to sell in this market. And I hear you, I don't think you probably need to necessarily I mean, don't have your entire all your numbers in one place in terms of to be able to reach that conclusion with a high degree of confidence. But if possible, look, I I would, I'd probably write out the next few months and sell into perhaps a a better market.
SPEAKER_00Interest rates have a big impact, right? A lot of the taxation changes that occurred in May are blamed, are often blamed for, you know, a reduction in property prices. But it's hard to separate rising interest rates and tax changes. I mean, they've occurred both at the same time. I'm not defending the Albanese government by any stretch of the imagination, but interest rate changes have a significant impact on money flows, and money flows into the property market have a significant impact on that. I think also, of course, the taxation changes had a negative impact as well.
SPEAKER_00But I guess what I'm saying is at the beginning of the 26 calendar year this year, we were sort of anticipating, well, maybe we'll get some interest rate cuts this year, but that's turned around very quickly. We've had five interest rate hikes. So all we need is maybe in the first half of the 27 calendar year for it to become obvious that inflation's getting under control and the market will start talking about interest rate cuts. And that that doesn't have to happen straight away for sentiment to improve. So sentiment can improve just on the expectation that interest rates are going to come down.
SPEAKER_00So I think if I was in your situation, it's certainly a divestment. I'm not sure I'd take on any more subdivision or development opportunities. I mean, I would argue with six million dollars of assets, you don't need to. What you need, what would be perfect is if you had six million dollars of assets that didn't attract growing taxation or expenses, that didn't create any problems for you, management problems that sort of looked after itself, and that you that provided you with a steady stream of income, two or three percent on six million dollars, probably enough to for you to enjoy retirement and also enough liquidity that if you needed, you know, some quick money, a couple hundred grand, you're able to do that.
SPEAKER_00I think if you could tick all those boxes, you'd be happy, right? So I don't think you need more assets, nor do you need to take more risk, I don't think. So if you if you can do a development or get a DA or a subdivision or whatever, and you don't think it's a big deal, of course, maximize the exit value. But I would really be focusing on, you know, how do I gradually reduce my property exposure over the next, say, 10 years to a point where you don't necessarily want to get down to zero, but I think you certainly do want to introduce some more liquidity and diversify away from some of those other risks I spoke about in terms of tenancy laws, taxation changes, and illiquidity in your portfolio.
SPEAKER_00So I think it's a perfect example of all the things I talk about in Wealth by Design in that that new book, in terms of having a good strategy and understanding that when you're playing golf, you start off with a driver, but you don't use that one club throughout the whole game that because of course that that's not what it's used for. It's used for a particular purpose. Property is like that. And I think property is a great asset, and I think in the long run, you know, the taxes will will change. And one day property, hopefully soon, will again be, you know, back on the menu for most people as an investment option.
SPEAKER_00It's a great investment option, but it's got its purpose, and you really just have to build a firm strategy. So and that's why I think actually, sorry to digress, but that's why I think actually investing in both property and shares relatively early on in your life, and a lot a lot more people do that now with ETFs. I think it's quite good because it gets you comfortable with shares, it gets you comfortable with property, and so you don't necessarily have that bias, but just be a wary of that bias. If you've made all your money in the share market, all your money in the property market, most likely you're gonna have that bias.
SPEAKER_00And that might not allow you to see, you know, what is the next right move for you. Anyway, and thanks so much for your question. Hopefully that answer's helpful and all the best with it. Okay, I'll squeeze one more question in here. Well, one more answer to a question from another listener that wants to remain anonymous. Okay, so wife and him are in late 40s, 49 to be exact. That's as late in your 40s as you can get. Kids are 14 and 16, trying to work out if carrying too much debt. Uh, would like to transition to part-time over the next five years and potentially early retirement, late 50s.
SPEAKER_00Income is 250 for him, 40 for the wife, homes worth 1.4 no debt. And then there are there's four investment properties: a commercial property in Brisbane, about 14Ks from the CBD. So it's sort of in the suburbs of Brisbane, worth about 1 million with about 1.1 of debt, costs about 21,000 negative cash flow per year. A property, residential property in Belmont in Geelong, I would assume. I think there's only one Belmont in Victoria. There's one in Torquay, also in Victoria, and another one in Queensland.
SPEAKER_00So roughly there's$3.7 million of property against$2.6 million of debt, with a portfolio costing around about$30,000 after tax. In terms of liquid investments, there's about$430,000, which is a combination of$125 of cash,$145 of ETFs, and$160 in a trust investment that will be cashed out mid-27th. So I don't know what that is. Combined supers about just over a million dollars. So the question is if this was your portfolio, would you sell one or more properties?
SPEAKER_00If so, which property would you sell, if any, or hold longer term? And would you take the equity from any sale and put it into super or keep it outside of super in diversified investment portfolio? And importantly, would you be prepared to sell at a loss, such as the Brisbane commercial property, if getting rid of the debt and the annual cash flow drain produces a better long-term outcome? Okay, so I mean there's a couple of things that jump out at me here. First thing is don't worry about a paper loss. When looking at investment decisions, you should not let sunk costs influence them.
SPEAKER_00Easier said than done, I appreciate. And emotionally, none of us want to sell at a loss, even if we're we're just kicking the can down the road. Like even if it's an investment that might not ever recover, it's still difficult to crystallize a loss. The point is you've got to forget about what you paid for an asset, what you thought, or the reasons you bought that asset. You've got to really put all that aside and just say, okay, my decision now is to keep or or sell. It's really just about future returns. It's really about, you know, future allocation of cash flow.
SPEAKER_00So can I put that cash flow towards something else? Can I put that borrowing capacity towards somewhere, something else? And can I reinvest any equity that I might have in a different asset as well? Don't worry about so much about the sunk cost, which is not to say, you know, I mean, property is a hard one to analyze, right? Because I can go and buy a property and fundamentally do everything right. And in the first few years, I might be worse off because, you know, you just don't know the distribution of returns and how markets behave. So I don't think it's a case of, well, as soon as you don't get any returns, you know, take your money and run.
SPEAKER_00That's not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is don't worry about sunk costs. You've really got to make what is the best decision. Ultimately, what this listener wants to do is really look back if they want to contemplate earlier retirement, say at 58 or 59 in eight or nine years, what will they look back and go, well, I should have made this decision in 2026? That's the time horizon. And then also beyond that, I mean there's a bit of super there, but we're going to need other assets. So there's a million dollars, there'll be two million dollars by the time this listener gets to age 60, probably, which is okay.
SPEAKER_00It's a good starting point. But, you know, maybe you want, you're going to need some more money beyond that. So we do need those other assets to perform, of course. The big thing is commercial property. And I've I, you know, you might recall that I recorded an episode not that long ago about commercial property. And it's funny, it's just not, I don't know why the penny's not dropping with it. But if you think about commercial property, particularly given the tax rule changes and higher interest rates, compression of borrowing capacity, it's going to force more and more people into commercial property.
SPEAKER_00It's already a busy landscape. You're already seeing buyers' agents expanding to New Zealand. They've run out of property to buy in Australia. They're now going across the ditch to New Zealand and go and buy commercial property there. It's a bubble, people. Like it is a bubble. If it's not a bubble already, it's going to be very soon, although I think it probably is already. Just be wary. Be very, very careful. Remember, the price you pay for an investment has a big impact on future returns and risk. So quality first, then value, then diversification.
SPEAKER_00So I spoke about this back in June, not that long ago, actually. I thought it was longer than that. Episode 412, I spoke about. And in that, in that episode, I talked about capitalization rates. So how much what should these assets be yielding? And this is not my opinion. Looking back over time, you know, what is the average cap rate? What is the average yield from a commercial property that makes them attractive as an investment? And then what are other assets delivering? Remembering that you can get a tier two subordinate debt bond from a bank, which I would say it's not zero risk, but it's pretty close to zero.
SPEAKER_00Remember, I spoke about B sub and sub D, two ETFs, only a few weeks ago in the bond episode I did. They're going to pay you 6.5%. That's risk-free. A lot of these commercial properties are selling on cap rates sub 6.5%, which means you're getting less income than virtually a risk-free bond. So where is the compensation? Well, you've then got to get substantial capital growth. But where's that capital growth going to come from given the value of these assets are driven by the income that they can deliver?
SPEAKER_00Can you increase rentals above CPI, materially above CPI, to get that growth? The answer is no. The answer is there's going to be some mean reversions. So back in that episode, I talked about what happens if cap rates revert to their mean. Well, essentially, you're probably going to lose 20 to 30% of the asset value and that'll wipe out your equity, or in this listener's position, create negative, substantial negative equity, which is not ideal and not something you want to risk in the last 10 years of accumulation leading into retirement.
SPEAKER_00So, for instance, if that happened in five years' time for this listener, what happens to retirement? It gets delayed. It's not going to work. So look, part of it is in terms of financial planning and working out what to do with assets and whether to retain debt and all these sorts of things. Part of it is what are returns? Where am I going to maximum return? And then what are the risks associated with the portfolio? And if those risks materialize and if those risks are, I don't know if I say likely, but probable, if those risks are probable, how are we going to mitigate them today?
SPEAKER_00How are we going to steer around them? So that's the first thing that jumps out at me. If I've got a commercial property today and I bought it today and I hold it for 30 years, it's probably going to work out okay. Because even overpaying for a quality asset in the fullness of time, when I say fullness of time, multi-decade periods, it'll work out okay. It'll smooth returns. But in the short term, not so much. So I think the first thing I would say is the number I don't have, this listener hasn't given me, is what is surplus investable cash flow. So how much cash flow outside of or in addition to funding this uh$30,000 negative shortfall from this property portfolio, do you have?
SPEAKER_00Because let's put the commercial property thing aside for a second. If you had four investment properties and they were all great assets and they're all going to perform really well, I would say hang on to them for another eight years. And your early retirement strategy, maybe not partial retirement, but certainly your early retirement strategy could be sell one or two of these assets in, say, seven years' time, for instance, put a lot of money in your bank account, and then that'll fund the years of early retirement between that and age 60, as well as supplement super down the track.
SPEAKER_00So therefore, the debt doesn't really worry me as long as you're going to be get rewarded for holding on to that debt. The other thing is other surplus investable cash flow. So if you said to me, oh, look, we can invest another$50,000 a year for the next eight years, you're already going to build a liquid portfolio of ETFs out in addition to those property assets. Again, that would add further weight to saying, well, no, let's keep that level of debt. So the level of debt in this situation by itself doesn't worry me necessarily for someone that would like to consider early retirement.
SPEAKER_00So retiring before they can access super. What worries me in this portfolio is the probability there's a reasonable, I mean there's a reasonable, well, when I say reasonable probability, it's going to happen. There's going to be mean reversion because there's mean reversion in every market. We don't know when that mean reversion is going to happen. So this listener could hang on to this commercial property. And in fact, because of higher interest rates, tax settings, all those sorts of things, it could work out really well for them and they'll make a lot of money. But I think there's a higher probability that eventually the RBA is going to get on top of inflation.
SPEAKER_00Interest rates will start to come down. If those tax changes get reversed, maybe not fully, but significantly, and property in Melbourne and Sydney comparatively look attractive, which they will, there could be a flip in terms of what happens. And then a couple of bad stories about commercial property, all of a sudden it's on the nose. It mean reverts and this listener is going to have a, you know, potentially three or four hundred thousand dollar negative equity, which is going to put the plans, frustrate the plans. So that's the big risk that kind of stands out to me.
SPEAKER_00The other properties, Belmont, Torquay. You know, I I know that Eric grew up in, I lived in Belmont when I was, you know, going to uni and uh going through high school. I don't think it's such a bad, bad location. I mean, it's not a it's not an investment grade prime location, but you know, I I think it'll do okay. Torquay, I think, will continue to do pretty well. I don't know the other, the other location of the other Queensland property. So the three residential investment properties don't, I mean, I'm not saying they're great, but don't necessarily worry me too much. So if you hang on to them and build some more liquid assets, you're probably doing pretty well.
SPEAKER_00And you you might get yourself in a position where you can contemplate early partial retirement and then certainly potentially early retirement before 60. But the commercial property is probably the one that I would move. Would I worry about selling it at a loss? No, I wouldn't because the alternative is not attractive. And also the market is pretty buoyant for commercial property at the moment in terms of there's a lot of investors wanting to put a lot of money towards it, which should be enough evidence, I think, for you not to do it. You know, when everyone's doing it, that's probably the worst time to do it.
SPEAKER_00You want to be almost sort of counter-cyclical or counterintuitive with these things. You want to go against the grain. That's typically when you're going to buy well, at least a quality asset at an attractive price. So exiting now is probably a good idea, whereas if you wait too long and the market does turn, you know, you could be more difficult to get rid of. So look, that's my view on it. I acknowledge it's one person's view. So I never think, you know, this is the be all and end all, of course. But yeah, you've written in ask asked for my review, my view. So that's certainly it. Of course, it's not advice, just information only, but that's the bit in your strategy, at least from the information I've been told, that sort of sticks out and concerns me.
SPEAKER_00Okay, well, over time. Apologies for that. I'll leave it there today until tomorrow. Bye for now.
Read Full Blog Here Transparency is the best way to keep your money safe. If you can’t see a problem, you can’t assess it, price it in, or avoid it. Most investors think about returns, fewer think about risk, and very...
Read Full Blog Here A handful of stocks deliver most of the market’s return, and no one can pick them in advance. That’s why owning the whole market wins. The evidence that index funds beat active managers is well...
I wouldn’t rush to repay an SMSF property loan before retirement. I’d switch it to interest-only and put spare cash into growth ETFs. In this listener Q&A, Gary is 56 and plans to move his property wealth into his SMSF...
Read Full Blog Here I wouldn’t sell your Australian shares, but I’d put most new money into global shares. The ASX is concentrated, expensive, and slow-growing. The ASX 200 returned a solid 9.4% a year over the past...
Moving into a rentvested property no longer dilutes your CGT because of the 1 July 2027 deemed disposal. I’d keep one property CGT-free. In this listener Q&A, I explain why Daniel’s plan to move into one of his...