
Is this your show? Claim this page
PodCred
The people behind this show
People get invited back because someone remembered they were great.
PodCred is the verified record of who made this show. A credit here means people who were there confirmed the work.
Hosts
Who is on this show?
Think of the guest you still think about. The producer who makes the host sound smart. The editor who saves every episode. If a name is missing here, that person is invisible everywhere.
Add a creditEpisodes
91 episodesWhy The Supreme Court Is Confused About Religious Freedom: St Mary's v Roy Oral Arguments Reaction
The Supreme Court just heard oral arguments in a major religious freedom case involving Catholic schools, LGBTQ families, and Colorado's taxpayer-funded preschool program. Can Catholic schools receive public funding...
I'm an Agnostic. I Read Every Religion's Holy Book. | River Ward's Journey from Christian Apologetics to Agnosticism
What happens when you stop learning about other religions from Christian apologists and actually read their sacred texts? In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, I'm joined by River Ward (@SiennaRiverWard), a...
Can You Be Catholic And A Feminist? | Salina.Bear On Birth Control and Women's Rights
In this episode, I sit down with Catholic feminist, lay theologian, and spiritual director-in-training Salina Bear to talk about her unlikely journey from Reformed Protestantism, through deconstruction, and ultimately...
Why Aquinas' Five Ways Fail: Two Ex-Catholics Debunk JesusAndWhatnot's "How The Communist Manifesto Proves God's Existence"
In this episode of Apostate’s Imprimatur, Colin and I react to Jesusandwhatnot’s video titled "How the Communist Manifesto Proves God's Existence," explanation of Aquinas’s famous Five Ways: the arguments from motion,...
Debunking: "Does Porn Make You Gay?" | What Psychological Studies Actually Shows About @JesusAndWhatnot's Claim
After seeing Catholic apologist Noah (@Jesus.andwhatnot) argue that pornography may cause homosexual desires, I decided to dig into the actual research. In this video, I work through more than two dozen academic sources...
No, The Resurrection Is Not A Historical Fact - Part 2 - Responding to Trent Doherty on Pints With Aquinas
Is the resurrection of Jesus actually a historical fact or does the argument only work if you begin with Christian assumptions? In part two of our deep dive into the historical case for the Resurrection, Colin and I...
Coming Out Made Me A Stronger Man: Gym Culture, Masculinity, and Entrepreneurship | @SigurdAuthentic
In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, I sit down with @SigurdAuthentic, founder of Gay Unmasked, to hear his coming out story and explore what it actually takes to accept that you're gay....
We Visited the Biggest Catholic Cult in America: The SSPX in St Mary's, Kansas (With Atheist Church Audit @Heliocentric and Mormons @AllThoseInFavor)
I took an atheist and a Mormon on a road trip to St. Mary’s, Kansas to experience the SSPX firsthand. We attended a traditional Latin Mass, toured the massive Immaculata, talked with members of the community, and tried...
Is the Resurrection of Jesus a Historical Fact? Atheists Respond to EVERY Resurrection Claim - Part 1 - (Trent Dougherty on Pints With Aquinas Reaction)
Can history actually establish that Jesus rose from the dead? In this episode of Atheist Imprimatur, Colin and I take on one of the central arguments in Christian apologetics: that the Resurrection isn't merely...
Left-Wing Influencers Share Why They Left Christianity: @OneHandPolitics @GregFromVideo1
I sat down with @onehandpolitics and @GregFromVideo1 to compare three very different journeys out of Christianity. We talk about growing up Catholic and Evangelical, youth group culture, religious colleges,...
How My ADHD Made Me a Religious Extremist: From Joining Catholic Cults to Starting Medication This Year (Responding to Matt Walsh)
DISCLAIMER: None of today's video should be used as medical advice. I am not a doctor, nor do I have any degrees in psychology/medication/etc. Only take medication under the supervision of a licensed medical provider....
Catholic Apologist Accidentally Makes The Case for Secular Morality: Reacting to Brian Holdsworth
In this episode, Colin and I react to Brian Holdsworth's video "I'm Not Strong Enough to Be an Atheist." We unpack his portrayal of atheism through John Lennon and Nietzsche, discuss whether morality really requires...
Atheists, Here's How to Treat Joe Schmid After He Reverted to Catholicism.
Joe Schmid from @MajestyofReason announced that he has returned to Catholicism. As an agnostic/atheist YouTuber who left catholicism, I’ve been thinking about how people should respond when someone leaves their...
Ex-Priest Psychologist: The Hidden Psychology After Coming Out as LGBT
Coming out is often portrayed as the happy ending - but for many people, it's only the beginning. In this conversation with former Catholic priest and licensed therapist Danny Peterson, we explore why so many LGBTQ...
Why Anti-Gay Catholic Arguments Assume Everyone is Bisexual
In this episode, Colin and I react to Brian Holdsworth's video asking whether "gay priests" are even a real thing. What starts as a discussion about labels quickly turns into a much bigger conversation about sexual...
Hollywood Cinematographer Debunks "Miracle of the Sun" Photo | Our Lady of Fatima (re: Ethan Muse)
A Catholic priest (Fr Philippe Dalleur) and youtuber (Ethan Muse) have argued that shadows in photographs taken at Fatima in 1917 provide scientific evidence for extraordinary sources of light in the sky. So I spent...
Inside the SSPX: Former Member Explains the ENTIRE History and Excommunication of the Society of Saint Pious the X
The recent SSPX excommunications have left a lot of Catholics - and even journalists - trying to understand what actually happened. In this episode, I sit down with Hunter, a former SSPX traditionalist (and also former...
Why Do Catholic Influencers Excuse Right-Wing Catholics and Condemn Left-Wing Catholics?
In this episode of Apostate Imprimatur, Colin and I react to Brian Holdsworth's video asking how to tell a "real" Catholic from a "fake" Catholic. What starts as a discussion about Catholic identity quickly turns into...
Why Conservative Christian Should Oppose Conversion Therapy - Pieter Valk (LPC)
What if the conversation around Christianity and LGBT people is far more complicated than either side admits? In this episode, I sit down with therapist, author, and speaker Peter Valk (LPC) to explore one of the most...
Why Online Catholics Are Fighting About Pre-Marital Kissing: Online Extremism and Toxic Saint Quotes
In this episode, Colin, Kevin NonTradiCath, and I react to Christian Wagner and Noah/Jesus and Whatnots' argument that kissing before marriage is sinful and compare it with the historical sources he cites. Along the...
Ex-Pastor Reacts to Famous Christian Pastor's Toxic Relationship Advice w/ Brian Recker
Christian marriage advice often sounds inspiring, but what happens when it encourages people to ignore compatibility, personal calling, financial realities, or even their own well-being? In this episode, I sit down with...
How to Find a Spiritual Home During Deconstruction with @GospelSimplicity
For years I assumed the choice was simple: Catholicism or Protestantism. But the deeper I looked, the more I realized there is an entire world of high church Christianity that most people never hear about. In this...
Why I No Longer Call Myself An Atheist
When I was a traditional Catholic, I was taught exactly what atheism was supposed to be: lonely, meaningless, directionless, and ultimately incapable of providing a fulfilling life. Then I became an atheist myself. In...
Why Catholicism Is Just Protestantism With Extra Steps - Atheist Imprimatur - Brian Holdsworth
Today on the Intrinsically Ordered Podcast, Colin returns for the first episode of our new reaction series: The Apostates' Imprimatur. We react to a video from @BrianHoldsworth titled “I’m Not Smart Enough to Be...
I Watched Every Video by FORMER "De-Transitioner" Neeza Powers: Right-Wing Christian Celebrity
I spent a week researching one of the internet’s most viral and controversial gender stories - someone who detransitioned, became a Christian influencer, and then ultimately transitioned again. In this video, I break...
I Left the Church: Talking With My Former Youth Minister about Mental Health
Former youth minister (and current Catholic) Ashley Kiefer joins me to talk about the messy overlap of faith, OCD, and scrupulosity. We trace her journey from professional Catholic youth worker to licensed therapist,...
I'm a Gay Atheist. I went to a Christian YouTuber Conference with @heliocentric
I got invited by @HeliocentricOfficial to one of the biggest evangelical Christian YouTuber conferences in the country… as a gay atheist. Surrounded by Christian apologists, pastors, influencers, Mormons, Catholics, and...
Is the Latin Mass Really Saving the Catholic Church? (w/ Kevin Nontradicath)
What if the Latin Mass isn’t the magic solution everyone online says it is? In this episode of the Intrinsically Ordered Podcast, I sit down with Kevin Non-Trad, who was literally born into an FSSP Latin Mass community,...
I Read The Entire Supreme Court Conversion Therapy Case (It's Not What The Media is Telling You)
I've been working on this case for almost a year now - and I figured I'd give you the ultimate guide to understanding what is evening happening with conversion therapy and the Supreme Court. In this video, I break down...
"I Was Brainwashed Into Making Ex-Gay TikToks" - Interviewing Griffin on Conversion Therapy
In this episode of the Intrinsically Ordered Podcast, I sit down with Griffin to hear one of the most intense and personal stories I’ve encountered about growing up gay in a Christian environment. We talk about what...
Catholic Apologist Says Slavery Is Okay In Debate About Jesus' Resurrection
*Skip to 01:23:00 - if you just want to see the slavery bit* After a few months off podcasting, I came back with one of the wildest conversations I’ve had with a Catholic apologist. This is my third debate with Noah...
"I Was Raised In the Latin Mass. Here's Why I'm Not Catholic Anymore" - @KevinNonTradicath
I got to sit down in person with fellow ex-Catholic creator @Nontradicath for a long-awaited crossover: why we’re not Catholic anymore. Kevin shares his journey from being “born into” the traditionalist FSSP world -...
Natural Law Actually Disagrees with the Catholic Church on Sexual Ethics w/ Chris Damian
In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, Cade sits down with gay Catholic writer and lawyer Chris Damian to unpack one of the most abused buzzwords in Catholic debates: natural law. They trace how Aristotle, Aquinas,...
Why I Didn't Covert to Catholicism - Ex-Catholic Philosopher and Catholic YouTuber w/ @evan_raugust
I sit down with Catholic YouTuber @evan_raugust after a wild weekend where we went to seven churches in one weekend: Messianic Jewish, Catholic, Pentecostal, Orthodox, Anglican, non-denominational megachurch, and a...
No, Gay People Didn't Ruin Your Friendships (Religious Catholic Homophobia Did)
Christian youtube video essays keep claiming that “LGBT ideology” ruined male friendship, but I have no clue what they're on about. As a gay ex-Catholic, I use my old theological training to look at the “and they were...
Catholic vs Protestant vs Atheist Debates Online with Elijah Lamb (Christian Preacher)
After debating together on the Ellen Fisher Podcast, Elijah Lamb (Gen-Z Christian preacher and well-known TikToker) and I (ex-Catholic, now atheist debater) sat down to unpack Gen-Z Catholicism,...
How the Right-Wing Is Bringing Back Conversion Therapy Through The Supreme Court (Chiles v Salazar)
My infographic about this case: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1a6-vYf6qIZ8r9xS3G_dRGTaF6qi-hOVK/view?usp=sharing A new “victim” has entered the culture war stage at the Supreme Court. After the “No Cake” baker and the...
Religious Trauma Therapist On Identity, Self Sabotage, and Queer Identity After Religion (SC Nealy)
On this episode of The Intrinsically Ordered Podcast, I sit down with SC Neely - therapist, author of 30+ books, and specialist in religious trauma and queer/trans identity. We explore the real signs of religious...
I Left the Catholic Church (Online Radicalization, The Latin Mass, and Finding Meaning Without God)
In this episode, I share my raw and personal journey through Catholicism - from being raised in a suburban Catholic family to becoming an intense religious fundamentalist who nearly entered a monastery. I explain what...
Catholic Mass & Drag Brunch: Community Meaning-Making Rituals (w/ Co-Host Colin)
What happens when you attend a traditional Latin Catholic Mass in the morning and a drag brunch in the afternoon? Surprisingly, these seemingly opposite worlds share more than you’d expect. In this episode, we unpack...
'Help, My Loved One Joined Fundamentalist Catholicism' - How to React with @LeaveLaughLove
In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, Evelyn from @leavelaughlove joins me to tackle one of the hardest questions we get asked: how do you talk to loved ones who are falling into fundamentalist Catholicism? We...
“I Followed Every Catholic Marriage Rule… Until I Realized the Harm" - An Ex-Catholic Wife's Story
In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, I sit down with Isabelle, who grew up immersed in traditional Catholicism - daily rosaries, novenas, and all. Over time, she shifted toward progressive Catholicism before...
How the Left Can Win Debates - Actual Jubilee Participants Talk About Their Experience
In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, I'm joined by Greg and Oliver - two seasoned left-wing voices who’ve appeared on Jubilee, the Whatever podcast, and in brutal six-hour debates with professional sexists,...
Gay, Catholic, and OnlyFans Star: Darian Black's Story of Reconciling Faith and Sexuality
I sat down with Darian, a gay creator who once wanted to be a Catholic priest and now runs an OnlyFans - while still attending Mass. We talked about scrupulosity, being queer in the church, spirituality beyond dogma,...
Two Atheists Go to a Latin Mass - Behind @HeliocentricOfficial's 'Atheist Church Audit'
Jared from Heliocentric joins me to talk about his experience attending a Latin Mass for the first time and what it reveals about the explosive growth of Rad Trad Catholicism online. We dive into the aesthetics, the...
Dialogue: Does the Bible Condemn Homosexuality? Catholic Apologist vs Gay Atheist
In this episode of the Intrinsically Ordered Podcast, I’m joined again by Noah from Jesus and Whatnot for part two of our deep-dive into what the Bible says - or doesn’t say - about homosexuality. As a gay atheist and...
Coming Out As Gay In Canadian Catholic Hockey Culture - @bradyvandruenen's Story
I got to sit down with @bradyvandruenen55, a former Catholic school student and hockey player from small-town Canada, to hear his powerful story of growing up gay in a conservative Catholic environment. We dive into...
The Ultimate Guide to Coming Out - A Philosopher's Perspective
This is the ultimate guide to coming out - philosophically, practically, and personally. Whether you’re just starting to question your identity, preparing for your first conversation, or figuring out how to rebuild your...
Being Gay At The Most Conservative Catholic Universities - Newman Guide - @leavelaughlove
In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, Cade chats with Evelyn from Leave Laugh Love about the hidden world of Newman Guide colleges - those elite, ultra-conservative Catholic universities designed to "protect" young...
Eucharistic Miracles Are FAKE - Actual Scientist Review "Scientific Evidence" of Catholic Miracle Claims w/ @Nontradicath
Join the community and join the group discussion on discord: https://www.patreon.com/c/gayextrad I’m joined by Kevin for a deep dive into one of Catholicism’s most emotionally compelling and scientifically dubious...
Why Jordan Peterson Made Me An Atheist
Jordan Peterson is famous for inspiring many to take religion seriously - but for me, he had the opposite effect. In this video, I walk you through how reading Maps of Meaning turned me from a devout Catholic who almost...
debunking EVERY catholic apologetic argument - ex-catholic apologists
On today's episode, we react to a 27 page document that reports to take people from agnosticism to catholicism. Myself and Colin (ex-traditional catholics) debunk this document while getting an outsider's perspective...
Was Pope Francis Really an LGBT Ally? A Critical Analysis
In this critical follow-up to our earlier reflections on Pope Francis’s passing, three gay ex-Catholics break down the truth behind the progressive myth. While headlines hail him as a revolutionary, we ask: did anything...
Pope Francis LGBTQ Legacy? What He Did (and Didn’t Do) for Us
Pope Francis has passed - and within hours, I sat down with Justin from Empty Chairs for an off-the-cuff emergency podcast. As a gay ex-Catholic and a gay current Catholic, we unpack Pope Francis’s complicated legacy on...
What Does Pope Francis' Death Mean for LGBT Catholics?
Pope Francis has passed. And as someone who was once on the path to becoming a conservative Catholic priest - and now lives openly as a gay man - his death hits hard. In this video, I break down what Pope Francis...
the STRANGEST anti-gay philosophical arguments I've ever heard - w/ @Kenapologeticscatholic
In this episode of the Intrinsically Ordered Podcast, I sit down with Minh (@Kenapologeticscatholic) a Catholic apologist and street evangelist, for one of the most intense and philosophical debates I’ve had on the...
Why I Treat Homophobic Christians Like Vegans
In today's episode, I unpack the mental model I use when Christians try to impose their beliefs - especially around queer rights. I compare their moral arguments to veganism (yes, really) to show how the more forcefully...
How to Leave Catholicism/High-Control Religion & Stay Happy w/ Evelyn from Leave Laugh Love
Leaving a fundamentalist or conservative form of Catholicism is more than just walking away from a church - it’s walking away from an entire worldview, identity, and sometimes your community. In this episode of...
What Sends You to Hell in Catholicism? Apologist & Atheist Debate Catholic Teaching
In this episode of the Intrinsically Ordered Podcast, I sit down with guest Cameron Riecker, a prominent Catholic YouTuber, discuss the complexities and uncertainties within Catholic moral teaching. We dive deep into...
101 Ways to Go To Hell in Catholicism (And Why It Makes No Sense)
In this episode, I discuss my journey from being a traditional Catholic to questioning and ultimately leaving the faith. I delve into the ambiguities and contradictions within Catholic teachings about sin and morality....
The False Promises of Traditional Catholicism - Inside Catholicism's Most Radical Sect
Join the community and join the group discussion on discord: https://www.patreon.com/c/gayextrad As someone who was once a zealous traditional Catholic - praying daily rosaries, attending Latin Mass, and even discerning...
Christians, What if Being Gay Were a Choice?
For years, I begged God to make me straight. I read every book, watched every lecture, and tried every method of "healing." But what if being queer isn’t something to fix? What if it's something you could choose - not...
Catholicism & Gay Marriage Debate: Natural Law, Ethics, and Legal Considerations in a Modern Society
I got to sit down with a professional catholic apologist to have perhaps the most comprehensive discussion on natural law & gay marriage. We originally planned an hour discussion on a number of topics but found enough...
Catholic Sacraments Make No Logical Sense: Placebo, Ritual, and Boundary Maintenance
Are Catholic sacraments truly channels of divine grace - or just powerful human rituals? In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, we question the supernatural claims behind sacraments like baptism and marriage. With...
Catholic Apologist vs Ex-Catholic Atheist: Evidence for God, Morality, and Catholic Infallibility
Does faith require evidence, or is experience enough? In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, I sit down with Noah from @Jesus_and_Whatnot to debate Catholicism, the role of suffering, religious disagreement, and...
5 Things That Would Make Me Believe in God - Ex-Catholic Atheist On Divine Hiddenness & Interstellar
After years of grappling with this question, I finally have an answer - thanks to Interstellar. This film unknowingly lays out the six conditions that could actually convince me a higher intelligence exists. But even if...
I Debated Michael Knowles on Jubilee - Yes, Gay Marriage CAN Exist - DEBUNKING Bad Conservative Philosophy
In this video, I break down my debate with Michael Knowles on Jubilee about the topic of same-sex marriage, philosophy, and conservative ideology. We go deep into metaphysics, logic, and how anti-LGBT arguments are...
The WEIRD Reason The Catholic Church Wants To Control Your Sex Life - Trent Horn Debunked
Catholic apologist Trent Horn recently posted a video titled "The Sex Questions Almost No One Can Answer", where he attempts to justify Catholic sexual ethics using Natural Law philosophy. But are these arguments sound?...
Finding Meaning Without God: Running A Thousand Miles, Secular Buddhism, Addiction, and Trauma
In this episode of Intrinsically Ordered, I sit down with Jason - a long-time friend, ultramarathoner, and secular Buddhist - to explore life beyond dogma. We dive deep into questions of meaning, suffering, and personal...
'just STOP being gay' - chastity speaker's desperate plea to end gay marriage (Jason Evert)
What if you're gay but don't want to be gay? Jason Evert has the perfect solution, just hate yourself. He gives us a 'third option' to homosexuality where you can hate yourself, but publicly. Someone please patent this...
Posts
No posts yet. Posts Intrinsically Ordered shares on PodSubs, and what it publishes on Substack, YouTube and its own site, will show here.

Subscribe
Be on the front line of the show
Everything Intrinsically Ordered sends its own people, first. Resources, announcements, behind the scenes, events, and giveaways, straight from the host. No account needed.
- The resources the host shares with subscribers
- Announcements before anyone else hears
- Behind the scenes from the team
- Events, invitations, and giveaways
- Only what the host sends, nothing else
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
















