These will be the shortest show notes yet because I have more than enough words in the episode itself. Listen for some unique insights from Board Game Arena developer ufm, and check out all of their BGA adaptations here (you might need to have an account to see this page?). Also, thanks for being a part of this journey. It's been a blast. Also also, I think the instructions for the giveaway are pretty clear, so listen to the episode for details on that. ---------------------------------------------------------- Contact, follow, and support information: vodthepod@gmail.com Twitter Instagram Buy Me a Coffee TikTok
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Intertextual Cardboard Experience. Hello and welcome to Intertextual Cardboard Experience. Kind of a different episode today. A hybrid show of sorts and well, if you can't tell, it's going to be a just me. But I didn't want to necessarily title this one a vodcast, which would be the fourth one in that series of it just being me,
because there is an interview in it. But the transcription or the audio retelling of that interview is just going to be done with me as well. And in a second, you'll kind of find out why that actually works out. pretty well outside of the fact that, again, it's just me. So for the sake of titling, numbering, this is episode 24, but I'll put that four in parentheses, and
that's just a nod to the fact that this is kind of podcast number four, but getting into the weeds of arbitrary titling and numbering and some of the goofy stuff. that I wind up doing with the show. I might change the way that those are seasoned, quote unquote. And I'll get into that in a second. So I'll just start off with the title. The title today is Let's Get Digital,
an asynchronous interview with UFM, BGA developer, and a one year celebration. So we'll start at the back end of that and kind of do some of the intro work for the show. And then we'll go from that intro into the interview, which I don't think is going to be super long. And then I have some thoughts that I have because I really don't want to interrupt the kind of the Q &A session. It kind of works like a Reddit AMA of sorts where
all of the questions were set up by me and then answered. by uh UFM with some really neat insight and and some answers that I would say were relatively unexpected to uh just kind of some things I'm like oh I I didn't think that's what the response was going to be but I guess that's why it makes it interesting because if I had known what it was going to be about well then I wouldn't have had to ask uh but just one really quick interruption
I don't want to make the episode longer as you can see it's a pretty lengthy episode there's a lot going on but immediately listening back to it after having had said all those words and just kind of processing these thoughts for some time i think it's a it's a good one um well i mean i hope so i've i've been you know negative on some of my solo episodes in various ways for various reasons but the balance, the pacing, I hope everything feels like solid and I hope
that you're able to listen to it because there's some good stuff in there especially from UFM in the middle portion and then hopefully you can just kind of think about some of the thoughts being presented listen till the end have fun and I just appreciate it so thank you yeah we'll get into that in a second and we'll just touch on the the one -year celebration so technically This episode is going to be released on August 12, 2024, and the first episode of the show,
episode one with John Cloudis, was aired, debuted on August 21, 2023, so it's not quite one year. So a little early in the celebration, but two weeks after. This episode comes out so 26 It's going to be after that one -year mark and that's going to be with somebody So live well Live interview
not asynchronous interview Getting to talk a non -vodcast or non -hybrid episode. So therefore Wouldn't really take Wouldn't make sense to take a ton of time from that episode in order to go through that mini celebration. So one year in, and if we're kind of just thinking about episodes on the whole, I have 23 guest interviews with
a little asterisk and kind of talk about that in a second. And then, well, we have this hybrid episode, which could be another asterisk on top of that asterisk, and then three podcasts. A series intro which was like a I didn't put out as a full episode is kind of like episode zero and then the first kind of asterisk was my yearly review which I Think is definitely the worst
of the kind of like four things That I've done by myself I think the other ones were a lot more focused and I think this one's gonna be way more focused especially due to the fact that it is an interview just not a talking one one -on -one and so yeah I I counted myself as a guest in that because I didn't order that one differently but all the other ones became the vodcast so
I guess I was a guest on my own show more than one time And, you know, technically, if I introduce the shows the way that I do, like, you know, spectacular 17th or whatever alliterative or word playy type of thing that I try to wind up doing and I have a repeat guest in the future, which I really hope to do. I mean, I would love to have repeat episodes with like every single person I've talked to. Because. I enjoyed each
and every one of them. I think maybe a follow -up interview to some of the topics that were talked about in some episodes would work better to have a follow -up. If I introduce somebody as the fantastic 44th guest, and they were already a guest, I don't know. We're getting into something that nobody cares about, but that is what it is. Long story short, you know, kind of 23, quote,
unquote, normal, as normal as I can make an episode to be. And then a few of these VOD casts and just, you know, blown away, blown away by the community in general, just being able to reach out to guests and have such like gracious and graciousness and willingness to chat with me. kind of especially out of nowhere. I think, as I can see, more and more people do listen to
it. And I think the feedback has all been really positive from both listeners and guests. And that makes me extremely happy and grateful as well, of course. And yeah, that's really what I got. I don't... I think I have any huge changes for the year ahead. I hope I can kind of get my scheduling a little bit better. You know,
I was thinking that summer was going to be a bit more normal, but I guess, you know, summer too is where there is a lot of the conventions. So I think some communication there got a little goofy and I didn't go to any cons this summer. Maybe I could have tried to set up something live there, but that's not really what people would be going to them for anyway. And yeah,
I traveled in the Midwest where I'm located quite a bit more than I expected to, and that just definitely threw a wrench in what I was doing. I've worked on some different projects and whatnot, and it's been an awesome summer. And I've had a few basically over, we're thinking summer, whatever that means to people in different spots in the world, Northern hemisphere, Midwest United States, summer from like June to, well now August,
had some really awesome guests on as well. And I'm just looking forward to continuing that. If I make a change or I think of doing something different, I kind of try to peel back that curtain as much as I can and give people notes and say what I'm thinking. Just see if it makes sense, bounce that idea, put it out in the universe. And if it's only me responding to me with that thought, well, I guess I have that to work with. So yeah, that's the one year celebration. I'll
probably talk about it in the kind of quick support section at the end of the intro before getting an interview. But thanks for listening. Thanks for being a part of this journey. And yeah, I think for being able to set up interviews with like extremely busy people and different parts of the world and having like weird schedule with teaching and coaching at times in spots and just like never being home during those stretches and making this all work was just way more than
I expected, way more than I could even hope for. And the hope is just to be able to continue and talk to different people and get to the point where I'm playing all sorts of different games to reach out to different designers and people working in space in different ways. And having a developer for board game arena today is an interesting side to the board gaming hobby space as well. Okay, there's going to be another giveaway
at the end. So when I get to the end of me going through the different ideas of this episode, hopefully I take the time to say it in a way that makes sense, because the very first one that I did was on that yearly wrap -up, which was technically a non -vodcast normal episode. And I think the way I described that, actually did make sense, so the responses on the response form actually came in, so I could do a normal
giveaway with a lot of things to respond to and think about. And then I think the last couple that I did, I just took for granted that that had been the method, and yeah. So I'll try it a little bit differently. That was all done through Google Form. So thanks to anybody who has filled out that Google Form, that is going to exist. So it's a feedback form. It just kind of asks what you'd like to show, if there's anything that you would want to see with it. And that could literally be anything. If you're like,
hey, I think you should really reach out to this creator, this person who's doing that, whatever it might be. I'd love to hear it. Like I said, feedback that I've received in different ways have all been really positive, and I appreciate that. So that's going to exist, but it's not going to be the way that this giveaway goes. So I will explain that at the end. And it's going to be a little bit different because, well, it's a digital episode. So yeah, stick around if you
want to potentially win something free. Oh, yeah, one kind of other technical note, the outro. So for that next episode, hopefully after two weeks from the release of this, two weeks from the 12th, I'm hoping that the outro is slightly tweaked because I just am trying to do more work in social media. And again, I just really haven't been around. So sometimes I'm on Twitter or Blue
Sky or Instagram. or TikTok, still only the two TikToks. And just trying to put things in different spaces definitely could be more active. I think the algorithms would be kinder if that was the case, but check them all out. They all are in the show's info notes. So if you wanna see what I'm up to, either personally or gaming -wise,
it's a puzzle. Some things are posted in one spot, some are posted the other. You put it all together and you can see what's up. Quickest plug ever. I've tried to express gratitude as much as I possibly can all the time because I, like I said, couldn't be more thankful to everybody who's been a part of this. Thanks for listening. Share it with friends. If you could... like whatever platform, Spotify, Apple, do the likes, do the comments. Cool, cool, great. And I mentioned
that with like that one year celebration, these interviews that I do are done through Zoom. So, I mean, honestly, that's like the biggest expense that kind of goes into the show, obviously. Not going to ask you to support my game buying, but I guess I guess nonetheless, that would go towards us as well. So, you know, I do constantly want to like think about new things for the show.
I just put the show on YouTube. So I have like a YouTube channel, but it's literally just a podcast right now. And if I keep creating different things in different ways, I would love to think about YouTube as a place to go as well. So like equipment. making things good, you know, that would be what the support's going to. So 100 % would be going towards the show. This is as
independent as independent media can be. Obviously, the people that take their time to interview, like that makes it a nice collaboration, like all these kind of mini fun collaborations, but yeah, I mean, I don't do reviews, so. not getting review copies or anything like that. And I'm happy with intertextual cardboard experience so far. And I know I'm going to be happy with
it moving forward. So that's the one year celebration. That's the mini plugs at the end giveaway to celebrate as well at the end doing that differently. Hopefully I actually explained that well. So if I don't reach out via email also in the show notes and I can get you clarification as quickly as possible. So let's talk about the main core of this episode though, and that's thinking about digital adaptations of board games. So I am definitely
not an expert in this. I'm not an expert in anything really. I definitely play a good amount of digital implementations primarily on the site for Game Arena. So first and foremost, I think a lot of people who might be listening to this are familiar that there are different ways to play games online. And if you're not, well, hopefully you learn a little bit something. If not from me, definitely
from our guest will be... relaying their responses to you. Like I said, I definitely learned some things there, but just some things to consider and think about as well. So BoardGame Arena is a website and there's a premium version. I could have put down how much that premium subscription for the year is. I don't think it's super...
crazy, but you don't even need to really have that if you want to play even some of the locked premium games. So if you wanted to play something that was premium, you could have somebody who was or had that subscription invite you to one of those games and you'd be able to play it. Some other, and I mean, I'm going to be missing a lot, so I'm just going to be highlighting. A few so, you know board game arena is definitely a big one uh, yukata If I am pronouncing that
correctly, I think it's yukata .de I Actually, you know again for for kind of the sake of this episode my normal amount of online and digital gaming which is Typically pretty steady increase. So I started playing a couple more games there I'd really only played a couple in the past and I like that one free as well. And we can think about kind of some of the pros and cons of that in a second. Then there's Tabletopia. Experience
with Tabletopia is probably the least of the four that I'm really going to highlight. So four in Board Game Arena, Yukata, Tabletopia, and Tabletop Simulator. It could be Ty, not a ton of experience in Tabletop Simulator. I think I mentioned that before. But if you're looking to do board games to putting them on a table, obviously Tabletop Simulator is going to try to 3D represent that, and I think Tabletopia
is as well. I think the biggest catch or hold up that I had with that one was the times in which I was trying to play games on Tabletopia were also times where I was trying to learn those games that I was playing. And that's kind of a mixed bag. I think one of the perks of these sites, or primarily something like Board Game Arena or Yukata, is the rules are built into
the site, so you can't break them. That doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to internalize them well right away, but there have been different ways in which I've approached... Learning games on board game arena, which I think some are better than the others. Maybe I'll watch a video Maybe I'll read the rules or maybe I'll read the rules overview Or maybe I'll just for the sake that I was invited to play I'll click around then I'll like go back and look at some of that stuff and learn it but you know, I think There are
definitely some where just like the way that the game is set up. You can you can kind of just play and learn from, you know, what you can and can't do. Like, you can kind of figure it out. That's interesting. That's definitely a perk. Like, especially if the people that you're engaged in that game with, if they're kind of doing that same thing, you can learn it together. And that is neat as well. Tabletop simulator. Then...
I think a couple of the adaptations or games that I've played on there have been some of the fully automated ones. So if you click something, it actually does it as opposed to the manipulation of moving the pieces or having your cards and doing what that does. I think if you've listened to the shows and the episodes with the interviews, you'll have heard that some designers do use
Tabletop Simulator, and it seems like there's a lot of perks for that. Say if you wanted to swap out a component or change the cards, obviously you don't need to re -prototype that in a way that is physically demanding. I think some of the drawbacks that we'll get to in a second, it's not the physical experience still, but especially during the pandemic or the lockdown portion of
the pandemic, because I guess you know what I mean. And I think that like necessitated digital play. So that was a good outlet too. And I think it also helped, you know, the designers in that time be able to get play testers and work on it. Some people really like the platform. Some people... think of it more as a necessary evil or maybe just a necessary compromise more so than a necessary evil and Some people just won't
use it. I don't think I'm in the I won't use it camp. I just haven't found the need to have to yet So not not ruling it out. I do have it and I've played a couple games on it. I tried setting up a solo Gloomhaven campaign, and that didn't work out the best. I think I played some fantasy realms against AI, and I don't think
that most of the games do have AI, but I tried that out because I saw that was the case, so I just wanted to see how it went, and it worked, and it was neat. So, that. Okay, so for the actual interview, so you don't have to hear my opinions because I guess I'll kind of sandwich this interview. I just wanted to introduce some of the different ones. So if you're unfamiliar, hadn't heard of any of those, or maybe you hadn't heard of one
of them, you could definitely look into them. Furthermore, I know that there are different sites for war games, like none of them are coming. to my head right now. I know that for some card games there's like playing cards .io, so people will use that. Same with like 18xx games. Vassal is something. Never done anything on that, but again just kind of wanted to give a little bit
of an introduction and kind of highlight the ones that I'm most familiar with even if my experience with a couple of them is not the highest. So yeah, something like Table Topia where I've tried to learn the games and it is more in that sandbox style and makes it a little bit trickier to learn. I think now I might want to go back and see the functionality of it with a game that I do know because there are definitely games on that site that I am familiar with just to see how that goes. And then finally, I guess one of the things
that I was going to talk about just kind of, you know, Steam implementation. So taking something that is a board game and making it more of, you know, like a video game or just a fitting the interface of something that you could play on your PC or Steam Deck or however you play your PC games that would work. And then obviously, you know, some games have digital apps for mobile. Some games exist on, you know, console as well.
So those are video games that have been kind of even more animated, automated, having, you know, kind of different art and making it look different for that space. So I've definitely played games in that capacity as well. And I'll talk about that in a bit. But as I was stating, we are now to the interview. So I was in correspondence
with board game arena developer UFM. I was thinking about kind of digital implementations for quite some time and I was playing a lot of live or asynchronous versions of trick taking games and ladder climbing slash hand shedding types of games. And just trying to look at the developers, like who's making them. I saw like UFM, UFM,
UFM for all of these games that I was playing. I'm like, wow, the timing for this is really great because I am increasing my digital plays, kind of seeing more discourse about digital implementations online on Discord, Reddit, BoardGameGeek, probably elsewhere too. I think the amount of things that I read or consume related to board games, sometimes
too much, actually kind of taking a pause. Not a pause, but trying to be more well -rounded, I guess. um but yeah so so yeah it was definitely something that i've been thinking about so just kind of the timing and thinking about it and i was like well okay hey yeah ufm uh i reached out i said like would you be curious or would you would you be willing to do an interview and
with some correspondence back and forth we worked out to do it this way is just like what uh what fit the best and and I had like some good kind of like pre -chatting and post -chatting about, you know, things in general. And then I had kind of like a bulk Q &A session in which they graciously went through all the questions and answered them. So I have these kind of clumped into some different
categories. So I'll probably just introduce category, say the question. And for the most part, okay, here's the thing. I'm going to try to like directly quote everything as much as I can. I'm not going to, if I change anything, like when you're reading an interview with somebody and then you kind of have like... like you see like sick or you see some brackets and that's just kind of like ways in which the things would be changed that's
what I might do so it's not like I would be indirectly citing the thing here but it would just be like the the minorest tweaks for the sake of having the way that it sounds in the the Q &A and me saying it aloud make them make make the most sense but yeah again I'm not going to change the words if that makes sense. So yeah, I've never actually thought a ton about taking somebody's,
you know, type response for an interview and saying them aloud in a way that keeps the integrity. But being said, I obviously wouldn't change the integrity at all. But, you know, thinking about like the ways in which, yeah, like again, like sick and bracketing and and like that kind of the way that it exists in physical form the way that people manipulate that and taking it to the me saying it aloud thing but again sometimes
go on to these things for for like a hair too long so the the short of it is i'm reading ufm's responses and potentially kind of like tweaking some things, but not. Anyway, for the basics, the first question that I asked was, how many games have you developed on board game Arena? And the number is 101 games on their own, some
things currently being like worked on, and then they've also revamped or fixed some other games as well. How much have you worked in other platforms such as Yukata, Tabletopia, Tabletop Simulator, et cetera? So the ones that I'd mentioned. And the answer is none. So as we can kind of put like one and two together, that's a lot of games solely for game. arena, but none anywhere else.
So kind of due to that, I actually had a follow -up question. And that was basically why haven't you worked in any of those other spaces? And there were two reasons. The game platform does not enforce a time limit, and there's no localization. So yeah, that's interesting because The no time thing, I think, could be tricky for a player,
but I haven't really thought about it from the development standpoint, because, yeah, I played a handful of games on Yukata now, and I haven't had any of the issues. The people I've played with there have all been really great, played some good games, and I get the email that it's my turn. I go on when I see it, and I take the turn. requested that we're playing one turn a day, everybody's playing at least one turn a day, and if the request is that we're playing
a few turns, everyone's played a few turns, and that has been awesome. But I think without having thought about it previously, that could even be more stressful from the development side of it. Tabletopia, too heavy as a sandbox platform, the program uses too too much in regards to resources. And for Tabletop Simulator, the note was that it's better than Tabletopia for the sake of development,
but they don't like sandbox platforms. So I guess, you know, those interestingly are the ones that I've kind of stayed away from, from like a plane standpoint. And... And that's where UFM has kind of stayed away from from adult development standpoint and there's zero chance that I could develop a game so as tricky as it would be for me to like maybe manipulate some of the plane in those
different spaces I'm going to know that developing is going to be even harder. I also, just kind of looking at UFM's board game arena page, a lot of the 101 games that I saw, and there's also a note on translations. So I asked, how many translations have you created for online
implementations of board games? And they said around 97 or 98 % of the whole Korean Board game arena system and games So I don't actually know what the full number for that is necessarily, but that's that's crazy. That's very cool and And just kind of like my final like feedback to that before going from like the basics to Some background questions would be the fact that
it's like You know obviously in a lot of the early the bulk of who I've talked to have been designers. And interestingly, a couple of the other people that, you know, create podcasts or YouTube videos in Taylor Reiner and Liz Davidson are doing game design or we're working on like game design, but, you know, are doing even more
so or having more kind of like announced and doing more. since like the year ago that kind of chatted. But again, a lot of designers trying to think about different spaces. So I've talked to artists, I've talked to designers and designers that do like development, all sorts of different stuff. But a lot of people are putting in work into the board games that we enjoy and different
ways in which we do enjoy them, such as sites like board game arena or these digital implementations. So just kind of like a huge shout out to like everybody who is putting in that work and is making things accessible. In this case, taking all these games and making them accessible for people playing the game with the Korean language and that translations and and everybody else
so I mean again part of my exploration moving forward in the show is definitely going to be trying to find even more people that are doing different things and this is I think a really unique thing that maybe that I guess I hadn't really thought about a ton like I obviously knew that somebody was making these implementations and I know that there's times where I'd play something like wow this is like a really good Board game arena implementation and I was kind
of like in awe and I clicked on the page But it hasn't like manifested into Anything like this until now. So just thank you UFM. Thank you to everybody Who is doing that work for this and and everything making the hobby great for people who want to enjoy it okay, so that's kind of the all the crazy amount of work and I will kind of see when UFM started that development.
So this is like a ton of work in a very short period of time as we'll find out in a second. So I had some background questions and one of the questions that I have was, what board game made you fall in love with gaming? UFM said, I'm not sure. I just enjoyed all games with good tabletop and role playing, good tabletop role playing friends. So just kind of, kind of an always things. There, then I have another question. I said, what types of board games are your favorite?
They said, my focus changes frequently, currently solo games and co -op games. However, my most favorite game is D &D and Pathfinder. I've been running my own campaigns for more than 10 years. I then asked, I kind of just... to the second ago, what prompted you to want to start creating digital implementations of games? How long have you used online platforms before starting to
work in them? I said, I just wanted to share some games I liked, or I want to share some games I liked at the time. And then I started implementing games three years after my BGA registration. So then I kind of asked some questions that were specific to development. And a lot of these questions, it's kind of my typical multi -question clumped
into one. So UFM did a nice job of kind of like responding to all of them in one. And I will go through this section on some specifics. How long does the average game take for you to develop? which one was the fastest, and how quickly were you able to finish that, which one is the slowest, and how long did that take you. UFM said, I can't give you specifics as it vastly differs among games. Some simple trick -taking games took two
or three hours as I was able to reuse many codes from other games I implemented already. The definition of the slowest varies by including any sort of hiatus. So if it does go stop, I started the project in the middle of 2022 and finished in March of 2024. If it does not, then regicide would be the longest. It took a month due to some adjusting during the development and addition
of a lot of variants. Then I asked which Project provided the most challenges along the way. Which development are you currently the most proud of? Response for this are regicide and for Northwood for both questions The latter is still in the development stage. The base game is already available. So hey awesome game I talked about for Northwood At least in some capacity at least once on the
show So that's available. If you're looking to play it, go check it out. But U of M is still working on some scenarios. Then I had the question, I said, your work for board game arena is a labor of love, as in you're not currently accepting commissions for your projects. How does the process go of deciding which games you want to or are able to work on? Do publishers or designers reach
out to you? Do you ever reach out to anyone because you really want to see a digital version of a game? And then the response. Sometimes I find the license available. BGA internally manages a license list. Sometimes I try contacting them. Sometimes they contact me. But the most important thing is the publisher must allow implementing the game on BGA and must be responsive enough. Publishing the implementation requires their
approval, obviously. Also, they have to supply some assets like component images and anything else kind of along those lines. So, yeah, definitely, well, again, none of the stuff I have any internal knowledge of, but that's kind of like an interesting, that is an interesting process for sure. But just thinking about could be UFM having reached out, having been reached out, but in order to
make it happen, obviously that the approval is needed, but also just that as stated, the responsiveness as an element of the success too. Okay, then I asked, do you currently play more games online or in person? And for me right now, it's definitely online. I've been doing a lot of homework for
this episode, but that's not a question for me. Anyway, UFM says, actually, I don't play board games online much nowadays. I'm spending most of my weekend free time with my D &D campaigns. Hey, seems like a really good use of time, so that is awesome. On my next question, how many of the games that you've developed did you own first? Zero. I'm serious. I don't bother with
physical games as I don't have enough time to play in person. That's really interesting. So overall, I'm not trying to jump in here. I think in this next section with the opinions, which is going to be coming in after some of the specifics section, I'll maybe try to finish the episode with some of my thoughts before getting to that giveaway. But yeah, I don't know. Like I said, definitely some unexpected responses. But I think
that's really neat. And I think it's that like a perk, if we're kind of thinking of like pros and cons, which is something that's going to come up in the opinions section. One thing to consider is having the access to being able to play games digitally could make your collection a little bit smaller if you're willing to just play them in that particular space. I think I've
kind of read in various spots thinking about this idea of digital games that on the whole publishers are going to have increased sales from board game arena implementation. I don't know if I found like the most credible sources for that, but that seems to be the online consensus. And, you know, personally, again, kind of like my main interjection into the interview before
getting to some of my thoughts later. You know, I think about my own collection, I've definitely bought games that I've played on board game arena and I'm like, wow, I like this game. I purchased it. I've also done this thing where, you know, I played a game on Board Game Arena, and I realized that, like, okay, this is not going to be a game that I buy. Also pretty normal. And I've done a thing where either Board Game Arena or Yukata, and I'll probably, I'll just bring up the specifics
now. I've had instances where I have the game. and it's just not really getting played. And, yeah, I've talked about my taste before. I mean, I'll play anything. I love board games, so I'm not particularly picky, but when it comes to my multiplayer, like, in -person gaming, I typically tend to, like, stay away from some of the mid
-weight conversion euro types of games because... A lot of them have at least a decent amount of complexity. And some of them are lacking some of that more direct interactions that I just tend to favor when it comes to in -person gaming. I play games online. I play a lot of solo games. So I think I kind of look for different things in different games. So a couple of games that I owned, I... Learned, multi -handed and played
and liked. I thought they were really neat games. Are my two most recently played games on Yukata in the Red Cathedral and Lorenzo Il Magnifico. And, you know, I had them and I'm like, oh, like, well, for Lorenzo, I had it. played it multi -handed, saw that it was on Yukata. I'm like, oh, this is cool. I'll be able to play it here. And then I came to the realization, it's like,
okay, wow, I'm not really going to be playing this game in person. It's not what I want to get to with it. So I sold it and then... continued playing it on Yukata, and then Red Cathedral hasn't happened yet, where I haven't sold it or given away or anything like that. But I played it multi -handed. I played the solo as well, and both were good experiences. I think the game
is cool. The dice system with the rondel is neat. But then I played it online. I'm like, hey, you know... There are some interaction points. There are definitely things that you want to try to get to on the cathedral in terms of building. And if you move a dice, well, obviously that's going to move it. And the way that the other people can use it is going to change. But again, it's a conversion light to mid weight euro. And that's not what I typically tend to play. So
the ability to hop on and play a game over four or five days with somebody. is fun. I've really enjoyed that experience and I'm fine with getting rid of that game because I probably haven't played it in a couple years. So yeah, that's kind of where I'm at with that question of, well, I don't develop games, but thinking about games and collections, I know it could go one of a few ways and seemingly people will try a game and then buy it. And I've
done that a lot. A couple of the recent games that I played a lot of, online were gnar and far away. And I bought them. I haven't played them in person. Sometimes they're introducing games or just asking people if they want to play. I'll have a few. Maybe give a pitch. Maybe just have them pick based on the looks of the box or components and then go from there. And those
haven't made it into. The the live play list, but I know they will Definitely going to stick around the collection for a bit because I think they're fun games and I bought them because of Playing them online first and I know that there are other instances of that happening as well Okay That actually knocks out a decent chunk of some of the things I'm gonna say after the interview Anyway, so enough me rambling back to the thoughts So then I said, if you didn't
own a game in advance, and this question was actually pre -made, so I didn't know that the answer was zero, I said, do you only use the rulebook or are there any other methods you seek to learn the game, playthrough videos, et cetera? UFM says, basically I implement games I know well already unless the game is a novelty. The publisher or the designer gives a rule document as well. If needed, I ask them directly. So that's it. Definitely a unique way in kind of like internalizing
rules like either have had that experience or are working learning it and Developing at the same time from the rules document And more and more skills that I do not possess okay, so the final category is what I titled kind of like opinions and You know a lot of the things That I asked here I've maybe comment on some I haven't so I'll wrap this up and they'll maybe get to
some of my final thoughts which should be relatively brief because I've said some of the things already and Then we will move on What are some of the benefits of online board gaming so Ufm said easier to find players and play together for sure less setup time and less rules Issues, especially with complex games. Yeah, 100%. If somebody's already set up the rules to make you have to
follow them, that winds up, well, maybe not being an issue for the flow of the game, but could be an issue for you if you don't really know the rules and mess up, but that is what it is. Then I asked, what's lost or at least what could be lost when playing a game online? UFM says, I cannot explain it well, but in my opinion, the unique ambiance of playing games in real life with friends cannot be replaced by online
games. Very, very fair. Yeah, there's definitely a social element, even if you are playing it online and you've got like zoom up. or some type of audio, or whatever it might be. Yeah, I think there's different levels of magic that games can create, and some of the magic is in the game itself. A lot of the magic is the people that you're playing with. So I get that. Next question,
what type of games are best for asynchronous play? I don't play async games nowadays, but probably games which allow simultaneous actions across players, such as roll and write games. And again, I kind of concur. So a lot of the games that I do play asynchronously are roll and write games. What types of games are worse for asynchronous play? Games with tons of interruption abilities, games requiring frequent communications, trick -taking games, draw and discard games.
Yeah, definitely some categories I've half thought about and some that I haven't there. Is having an undo button and or a confirm button, turn button mandatory? Response, yes, especially in mobile. I always add one. Most games are fine with an optional confirmation button, but some games which offer complex actions require an undo button. I'll touch on that in a second. Then I said, do you log your board game arena
plays on BoardGameGeek? and the response was never. I didn't ask if a few of them logs their plays on Bar Game Geek in general. Maybe that would have been a good clarifying question from me. Then the second to last question I have is, do you play any digital implementations of games on Steam? And they said, if or then I said If so, what feels different about these compared to something like Board Game Arena? Also, if
so, do you log these plays? And they said, I own Tabletop Simulator and Tabletopia, but I don't play there. And finally, this is kind of a goofy question with a funny response from them. I said, why do you feel people are so opinionated when it comes to some thoughts regarding online playing of board games? And UFM said, nowadays people are so opinionated on anything and everything, why should board games be different with a nice
parenthetical shrub? So yeah, I think just kind of the sheer amount of work with all of those implementations, the duration in which it took to make some of those games just due to some... complications or breaks, or developing a game and going back to it and working on the scenarios
for something like For Northwood, helping people redevelop games, doing all those translations if I didn't say that already, and not having these games first physically before working on the BGA developments. and all other insights shared. When I read them, I was like, oh, wow, okay. And yeah, there's definitely like a lot to chew on there. I did try to add some minor
feedback to some of the questions. Like if I was kind of chatting back and forth, I talked about the one bit about... a couple of bits about some kind of like the pros and cons as well, and thinking about how online plays could impact one's collection, specifically thinking about my own methods, because that's what I have to draw on the most. But I'll just kind of like run down some other of the opinions and just
kind of like insert some of my thoughts, especially because I've been playing a good amount of online games on board game arena lately, a little bit on Yukata, and even kind of hop back into Steam. So as stated, UFM mentioned that it's easier to find players and play together when it comes to online board gaming, as well as like the bit about less setup time and the rules issues, which I commented as well. So yeah, 100 % on all of
those thoughts. depending on the game, sometimes, you know, you'll run into situations where you create an invite for a game and if it's like a lesser played game at the time, you're not getting you're not getting paired up with people or you know, you have set up for a four player game and two people join and then that fourth person doesn't and then the game just never materializes and you know, that can kind of be a bummer then
Two but yeah other benefits I You know, I I know that I mentioned it in in a previous vodcast but Eric From the board game dojo that episode that we did we we'd kind of been in communication before that episode Before we chatted there but have been in more communication since and we'll communicate on discord, but honestly primarily we'll kind of play through board game arena.
We've set up a live play and that's a fun thing too. There are other friends that I have in other places around the state, country, and world that I'll be able to play games with primarily asynchronously but it's nice to kind of take a turn, send a message, or you know even play a couple games and then start sending messages just kind of depending on how that communication is going and I think that's like a perk as well. I've said some other things such as being able to
learn games, just being able to get exposure to different games, and obviously plenty of other perks there too. I think the main thing that is lost when playing a game online is definitely what was stated. UFM's response, kind of that hard to describe in -person feeling. And I think sometimes I might come down on a game a little
too harshly if I am only thinking about the mechanics of it from playing it online as opposed to having some of the fun in -person experiences that could really bring out a different side of a game. There are definitely going to be other games that suffer a little bit more from it. being played online only. And I think most people, most people in most contexts are going to want
pick wanting to play a game in person as opposed to like online. But, you know, like I said, I've seen a lot of discourse and there's some people that that prefer like some different games in different contexts online. I again. Very probably like corner cases edge cases but yeah on the whole like whenever I play games I I Know that
I'm sometimes giving a game a like an unfair Viewpoint of it if if my first play of it is Digital, but then I also try to put it in like my mental space of like okay. Let's think about it in this way. I've played You know Santa Monica in person and some of the fun of that game is kind of like marveling at the art. Seeing the way that your little tableau and having the tourist
visit like a donut shop or a skate park and seeing like just kind of like the funny touches and realizing the Santa Monica Pier that you're building in comparison to your opponent's is is part of the fun of it. So when I played it on Yukata, some of those things did not happen. And then I know that it's like, OK, well, I like this game, and I did like playing it online. It wasn't
the same experience. So then I have to think about the fact that I know that if I'm playing a game online first, and I didn't have that experience, what about this game could be brought out? when being played live, so I try to be turbo fair. I typically don't write off many games in general as ones that I dislike, and I don't think that just playing something on board game arena or digitally is going to make me dislike a game
and not try to look for things that I might like in person, but obviously lacking some of that in -person experience just isn't going to give me that complete picture, and I get that too. The response for types of games that are best for asynchronous play. If I mentioned some that allow simultaneous actions or rolling rights, I think those work well. A lot of the games that I play are some of those mid -weight, euro -y
conversion things. We're going into the next question. Ones that don't have a ton of interruptions, that helps too. So sometimes there is kind of going to be that middle space of like a mid -weight euro, but that does have some interactions where somebody does something and then all three people have to respond. Then it goes back to the person who took that turn. That could get a little, disrupt the flow or make things take a little bit longer than necessary. But yeah, I play one of my... more played games on board game arena
is TWA and we'll kind of scoot ahead because I think you know what types of games are worse for asynchronous play is maybe one of the things that like I agree with what was stated the interruptions ability for sure maybe some the ufm said trick -taking games and I think that's a a contentious bit some people will like those games, but I
think more people are definitely on U of M's side with this one. I haven't fully formed because I'll just kind of do whatever. As long as I'm playing, I'm happy. That's where I'm at. In -person, digital, happy me, I'll play. If I realize that a particular game doesn't work the best asynchronously, I'll bake that note. on board game eek so I do log my board game arena plays going to another question later on and I'll hopefully remember it and if I forgot then I'll go back and see
it's like oh yeah I didn't want to play this one asynchronously but yeah so the the having an undo button or confirm button being mandatory you know I think the implementation of TWA on board game arena is solid it does not have that this was not a game breaking thing but I meant to place one of my citizens on the I don't know which which area of the board is called it's like the where you place your your red workers
which wouldn't then unlock you red dice and I had all my citizens kicked out of that area therefore I needed to get one back so the next turn I would have red dice to do the actions that I wanted and I just had like a little glitch in my browser screen, and instead I clicked my die on a card where I already had a worker, and it was the one where you can, if you, okay, this is very
specific, if you like activate that card in multiples of two, so if you have like a six, you would get this three times, then you would roll another, die which is automated by the game so you don't get to roll it and if it hits like four through six or even three through six, you're able to place a cube on an event card. That's not what
I wanted to click. I clicked on it, didn't roll what would have hit for the event card. I didn't get it. It was just like turbo antichymactic because I wanted the worker in the spot, and instead literally got nothing, didn't even get to roll the die, and it just was... it was very bleh. I don't think the overall standings of the game were impacted. I was pretty close to taking third out of three in that one, and if
I did take third out of three because of that, that would have been a little bum, but I did sneak away in the middle of the pack, so that made me a little... Little happier. So yeah, I'm all I'm all for the undo button or just at least that kind of confirming The the action so Yeah, thank you you FM for always adding it I Am I'm grateful. I like I said I've been playing
a lot of a lot of your games been playing. Oh Yeah, I don't know go go look like a lot of like trick taking and climbing games. I don't want to misspeak, but I know I've been playing, uh, spring cleaning. I think you did a haggis if I'm not mistaken. Uh, crisps, lunar, and others are things that I think cat in the box as well. So again, you know, I feel like all these ones that I have been playing can be accredited to,
uh, UFM and they're all really well implemented. And yeah, I haven't made any mistakes in that similar nature because there are like those click checks and balances in order to get to finalizing my turn. Thank you. Thank you and thank you. I said that I do log my board game arena plays on BoardGameGeek and I guess the only other note that I have to this is kind of linked to that
my overall final thoughts and this is just going to be a story that doesn't really... I think it makes sense, but I don't know why it makes sense to me. So I'm not sure if I started logging my board game arena plays on BoardGameGeek from the beginning. I definitely do now, and I definitely have for probably most of my time in logging plays on BoardGameGeek in general. But up until
last week, when I was thinking about this question, I had never logged a digital implementation of a game that I played on Steam, or an app for that matter, on BoardGameGeek, and I just did for one. I didn't go back and log other ones, and I don't necessarily know why. But, you know, on the whole, I think when I'm playing a game, I want to be able to input my feelings on it.
As I mentioned with my thought process, if I log something that I've first and only played on board game arena, I try to make note of that and say, here are the things about the game that I liked. I would love to play this in person. I would probably say that's kind of like my overwhelming bit of commentary on a BGA to BGG log play type of thing is that like, hey, this is cool. I really want to play it in person. Simple. I can go to
the game, be like, hey, I played it. I typically don't forget the games I play, but it is just nice having that information, that data, seeing some notes, some things that I would look forward to in a live play or on the inverse, like I have mentioned there are games that I play online and realize I don't really need to play them in person because You know, it's just not like a game for me and I've played a few games of Captain flip like three or four now and I'm I'm
just kind of shrugging I've got nothing against it. I you know, it was nominated for the spiel and There's some kind of like fun things in it, but I did didn't rush out to try to buy it If somebody ever wanted to play it online or in person I would, but I cannot see myself going on board game arena and clicking to start another play. I cannot see myself ever buying it unless
it's a gift for somebody that I think would like it. And that's the thing, like I know now what the game is and maybe, you know, Spiel being more like family geared, I could buy it for... like a younger family member or a friend that has children or something along those lines. And that might be a perfect fit due to that. The core action system of the game is pretty
straightforward. And I think a lot of people can learn it. And it's a great game for that. And I logged it. So I know that I played the game. I know my thoughts on it. So two years down line if I want to read it I can kind of get that game flow put into my head and And then I can think about it and and I have that there Okay. Oh, I've been talking a bit so Final final
little anecdote and that was me logging my first digital implementation or steam implementation game on board game geek So one of my favorite games in general, I don't know where the spranks is, Dune Imperium. There's a lot of Dune Imperium fans out there. There are a lot of Dune Imperium not fans out there, people that don't like the game, just doesn't work for them. And I've had the Steam app for a little bit, just haven't played it. And I finally did. I played against
two AI bots and the game was wild. Like, for people that haven't played the game, kind of describing it, it has deck building. People say it doesn't have deck building or deck building the way that you expect it. And work replacement has some tracks in which you're trying to get influence on those tracks to beat other people. There's combat and And like the way that this
game played out was just so silly. I may have had one entry card, which I think if you play the game, you know that that's not amount the two bots I was playing against. They typically had like two or three or four at all times. And we're playing them and getting huge advantages. I didn't get unlock my extra worker until I think three rounds after the second AI bot had there. So I was working from like a really limited space, I felt locked out of a lot of things that I was
really trying to do. But in other capacities, I was building towards these kind of unique and interesting cards that I hadn't really seen or played with much before and was utilizing those in a way that worked out pretty well. Combat wasn't going in my favorite ton. I think we did the full 10 conflicts and I won two. There's a lot of things that looked dire and that's not
meant to be a pun on the dire wolf digital thing. Yeah, it was rough, but I was clawing, I was hanging on, I was doing everything I could. And after that 10th conflict was resolved, every single person had nine victory points. So if you get 10, you win or you kind of get to the point and more than one person has 10 at the end of that round. Then it's whoever would have more than 10. I think, I don't know, it's been
a while since I've actually played it and nobody got the 10. And then the tiebreakers are determined by spice. So it was 999. And then I just had the least spice of the three. And it was, I don't know, it was just like such a, like a crazy outlandish game. It, you know, sparked a lot of the motions of like what playing the game feels like. But a lot of what was mentioned about some of that magic being lost definitely was lost. A lot of
the things that the opponent was doing and the way that they were just automated definitely glossed over their actions. I could parse the game state afterwards. I could see what sort of resources, where they'd gone. But I didn't go back and click every single card that they played. I was playing on my Steam Deck. Maybe that was limiting my willingness to want to. So if I just hovered over with a mouse on PC
instead, maybe that'd change it. But honestly, when their turns went two, three seconds for player one, two, three seconds for the next one, and then me, I was more than fine seeing what like I could do based on where they were, kind of seeing what they had gone towards and what they're trying to work toward, not like overly concerned myself with a lot of their cards. So that was definitely a thing that was lost. You know, playing in person, if somebody played like
a strong card that did a lot, I would want to know what that card was when, in this case, I was really only interacting with my own. It went pretty quick. I think the whole thing took under an hour and and it was kind of a longer uh punch it out slugfest of of sorts because the way that the things were going so it'd be like way quicker than that would have gone in person but yeah
i don't know it felt nonetheless uh some of those things that were lost it didn't take away from the fact that it felt like a game and I just wanted to log that play for the sake of doing it because I had never done so. So like a game such as Onirum, I have the app on my phone and I've played 50 plus games on that app and I've lost the grand majority of them and I haven't logged a single one. I'm not going to retroactively do that and I probably won't do in the future.
and I really couldn't tell you why. So you're getting a non -concrete thought to end this off. This is definitely a bit longer, but I've been playing so many games on board Game Arena, a couple on Yukata, and I've been playing, well, I played that game of doing Imperium on my app, but I'm going to start, I'm just going to keep playing more. I think Maybe this is, at least
for now, an open and closed thought, but it's not one that I've shut the book on per se. So, yeah, I don't know. I don't know if this is a huge number, but I was playing like 11 to 12 games on Board Game Arena. It gave me a little accomplishment. It's like, hey, playing at least 10 games at once was an achievement on there. Oh man, this is a lot to juggle and play in, you know, 10 or 11 different games here, a couple
on Yukata. And then one of the people I was playing against, I clicked on their profile and it said they're playing 111, currently playing 111 games right now, which kind of blew my mind. So maybe my ability to process the information for anything for that matter, it's just not on par. Maybe I overthink some things, which I guess is not
terrible and surprising. That said, I also just play games really quick, too. When I do play them, I don't overthink my turns. I overthink everything else, just not my turns. And yeah, that's kind of it. So I spend on my mind a lot. Really glad that U of M... uh took a lot of time to just communicate with me before and after these questions and provide the answers that you heard hopefully my interruptions for them
didn't interrupt the the interesting like thoughts and insights and insights and work overall that was being done uh there too oh different episode because of that other stuff and me rambling per usual this is relatively long and my throat and chest were already kind of sore and this didn't help so there's that uh final bit before kind
of uh closing up is the giveaway you made it you've you survived you are here uh and i mentioned that this is going to be a digital uh one So, okay, here's the deal. There was like a, like a sale, like a humble bundle sale of a whole bunch of games. And there was like a handful that I didn't have, but there are three that I already did. One of them was Dune Imperium. One of them was Scythe. So here's the deal. Yeah,
I, Scythe was another game. I liked it. I just, in terms of like thinking about teaching it, there was other things that I figured I wanted to have more. I get to the table, yada yada. I played a bit on the Steam app. I've had it. I think the Steam implementation is pretty interesting. And like, I like the game. I would love to play it in person if people kind of brought it out or had it. But yeah, same, same deal there. And so I own that and I was like, okay, this is game.
I can keep playing it. I have it digitally, play it forever. So Dune Imperium, Scythe and Root and Root. It's actually one that I haven't played yet either. I think I started doing the tutorial. The implementation seems awesome. And I'm looking forward to learning that as well. But yeah, there's like a handful of other games that I got. So long and short of it, in the information for
this episode, I've got contact information. There is that feedback form. Do not fill out the form. If you sent an email to, it says vodthepod at gmail .com. That's my email. Say one of those three games, Dune Imperium, Scythe, or Root, you're interested in the digital code. First off, I hope I can do this. Secondly, I don't know if anybody cares. Thirdly, I see people do it on Reddit. Like, hey, I've got extra codes
if anybody wants them. Fourth, I guess I don't really care, because I don't think anybody else cares. Just kind of sharing something that I already have. Send an email, say what you're interested in. If you could add maybe some of your thoughts about kind of like digital implementations of games, like whether or not you play them, whether you don't, what you like, what you don't like. Responding to a particular part, a particular question of this episode, that'd be really cool.
Furthermore, if you did provide any sort of feedback about the show that you'd like, maybe just an episode. I really liked whatever episode, probably not this one, because again, we have cool insight from other people and then just too much of me, my apologies. And then if there's like multiple people, yeah, this is another part. So send me an email, we'll say August 12th. through the 26. If there's multiple people that are buying
for Scythe, I will randomly select. And I think I also received Munchkin in that bundle. And let's just say the first person that sends an email saying that they want Munchkin, you don't even need to say answer any of those other questions. I guess technically you don't even need to if you're entering into the the other ones either then to say I want the munchkin digital code
first person gets that one we'll put it that way I do not own that code I don't want it it's yours okay so happy one year happy me rambling thank you and Goodbye Intertextual cardboard experience the most digital podcast about board games and any other text that they connect to Thank you so much for choosing to spend your time here any further support such as sharing
the show with friends Following the pages socials in the episode description Writing a review filling out the feedback form or doing anything else you can think of is greatly appreciated Keep playing watching reading listening experiencing
You are chasing the elusive high score-the ability to carve your initials (or some other inappropriate word or abbreviation) digitally into your favorite machine. The perfect combination of greasy, sticky, and fast...
From the slight burn of a slide that’s gotten too hot in the late afternoon sun to the sense of ecstasy (mixed with a slight tinge of panic) from getting a little higher on the swing than you’d ever gotten before-and...
As fate and coincidence would have it, designer Jeff Grisenthwaite and I had actually met and played games together once and then played games at different tables of a smaller meetup just months after that. It wasn’t...
Back like it never left, Intertextual Experience welcomes Amabel Holland - designer, video essayist, author, and co-owner of Hollandspiele - for its forty-sixth episode. Amabel has been making my favorite board game...
Taylor Reiner. The Quiz 2. Since Taylor was on the show in September 2023, he’s been busy with designing, developing, making videos, and more. We get to explore some of the things Taylor has been working on through the...