Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Intertextual Experience: A Board Game Podcast

Intertextual Experience: A Board Game Podcast artwork

#34 - Carl Robinson—Kelp: Fun vs. Fun

Mar 20, 20252 hr 14 minAudio

In this interview, fun isn’t actually competing, but different types of fun and the way they interact with each other are being examined. As a little thought experiment, which games pop into your head when you think about the thrill of danger? Carl Robinson, designer of the hit game Kelp: Shark vs. Octopus, joins the show to discuss something that has been on his mind for quite some time, and that’s the way fun is discussed when examining board games. As a designer of a game that is a whole lot of fun, Carl has some great insights into this matter. And the discussion is well… it’s just fun. Enjoy! Check out Carl’s work on BoardGameGeek and reflections on Bluesky. Introductory Questions (0:00) Carl’s early experiences with board games. Introduction to this Episode’s Structure (12:38) And why Carl has been thinking about this topic. Here is the trimmed up sheet with the links and everything for all of the game’s Carl mentioned. It serves as a good extra set of show notes to link the BGG pages of the games (so you can all see credits on there), and it’s a fun look behind the scenes, of sorts. Social Interaction and Fellowship (23:11) Discovery (26:53) Winning/Competition (37:07) Comedy (49:00) Application of an Ability (54:25) Being Silly (59:31) Relaxation/Immersion/Submission (1:09:46) Discovery Revisited (1:22:08) Sensation (1:26:47) Failing/”Stupid” Games (1:34:48) Power (1:41:08) Fun in Kelp! (1:51:07) Wrap-up Questions (1:59:52) A text on Carl’s mind, what to look out for from him, and how thinking about the focus of this episode has impacted those particular projects. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- If you like this show, liking it on whatever platform you listen to and writing a review would mean so much! Furthermore, it's as independent as it gets, so any financial support would help with the subscriptions that make this project go smoothly. That can be done here: Buy Me a Coffee vodthepod@gmail.com Bluesky Instagram TikTok

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello and welcome to Intertextual Cardboard Experience, where we'll be exploring fun and laminarials with our illuminating 34th guest, Carl Robinson. How are you doing today, Carl? Yeah, I'm good. Thanks, Ryan. Exploring fun and laminarials, did you say? I don't know if I'm pronouncing it right. Laminarials. That's what my very in -depth Google search A scientific name for Kelp.

Nice. I was like, I don't think I should know that one. Google has done one over on me there because, wow, yeah. I've done some research on Kelp, but I haven't gone that deep. Yeah, again, I've done no research on Kelp. So it just goes through name, class, all those different things. I'm like, oh, well. Well, that's cool. You learn something new every day. Yeah. Well, we could also in the future learn that I'm wrong, which

happens pretty frequently, right? But yeah, I guess kind of before just asking about some of your gaming background and a little bit about you, I just think it's a pretty fun story. We kind of communicated this a little bit, but. I don't think I actually told you the full story. And that's that this past December, I went to my first convention at PAX Unplugged and I didn't have like a buy list. You know, some people go

to conventions to buy things. I went there for the indie games night market and just to kind of experience traveling and doing all sorts of different things. But there was like one or two games. on my list and honestly it may have just been one and I wanted to get the deluxe version of kelp and and it wasn't there so mild addendum here Listening back to this part, I heard myself

say that Kelp Deluxe was not at Pax Unplugged, and that wasn't what I meant to say. I meant to say that Kelp Deluxe was sold out at Pax Unplugged, which is why I was unable to get it there and had to purchase it afterwards, and is also why, in the proceeding conversation, Carl thinks that it wasn't there and tries to work out the timeline. But that's only because I was goof and said something that I didn't. Mean to say. On my travel back,

I was able to came back in stock on the online store that I had got my notification and I bought it. So I technically didn't buy it at the convention, but I it was like my first convention purchase because it was the only game I really bought that weekend. And I thought that was really funny. And then you. I kind of on on Instagram just mentioned that you found this podcast and that you're enjoying it and then we connected and I just think that the the coincidence was Was

pretty funny. So yeah, there's the stars lining there both Simultaneously got interested with some with the others output and yeah, that's cool. I Am yeah, I guess when was Pac some plug that was sort of you said it was November Early early December. I want to say December. Yeah Yeah, yeah, Kelp Kelp would have been probably sort of the end of the wrap -up of the Kickstarter campaign and and sort of slowly moving into distribution since then and So yeah that meant that that tracks

how was packs unplugged overall. Did you enjoy it? I did enjoy it overall. I I'm not much of a city person and and just kind of managing travel and being not even that far away from the convention hall, but getting to and from and I brought a little game for that indie games night market. So just overstressing about that. Took away a little bit, but I had some really good experiences, got to play some fun games and just talk with

people and I'm really glad that I went. I hear the only really Well, there's Brussels Games Convention, which happens every year, which is pretty small, but the only real convention I go to is Essen every year. And that always feels like, I mean, even if you go for a day, it feels like a week, because it's just so massive. But yeah, I know that experience, the travel, there's

all that tied into it. And then there's the buzz of the event and the games. I find it's worth it in the end, even with all of that baggage that goes along. Yeah, I just, you know, there are those people that they go to, you know, all of the conventions all the time. And obviously, you know, if you're a publisher to a degree, you know, you kind of have to. And I don't know, I can't imagine that. I feel like that'd be way too socially taxing for somebody like me. But I think it's probably akin to being like a member

of a band just. constantly on the road and yeah, or like we were talking just before about theater, my background in theater and it's the same reason probably I didn't end up long -term in as a theater maker because I just I like home comforts. I like the reliability of home and being on the road at a long time. Not for me either. Well, I think we're definitely in alignment there for sure too. That's funny. But yeah, I did mention

that I have a little bit of a surprise. But before getting to that, just reflecting on you and your gaming background a little bit with my newer introductory question. And that's having you reflect on either a formative gaming memory, that you remember that made you fall in love with board games, or a gaming experience that was more recent that reaffirmed that love or reminded you of that love of board games. Yeah,

gosh, I mean, I can. I've really fond memories of playing games as a kid, nothing particularly revolutionary, but just checkers, drafts with my grandfather and Scrabble with him and playing. traditional card games, Rummy and things like that with parents. I have a pretty strong memory of playing Grape Escape. Did Grape Escape, it was like a, actually there's a, I've seen a newer

Dungeon Crawl with the same mechanism, but it's, it's like a roll and move game for kids, but they are a little playdoll. little Play -Doh grapes that you make molds out of and you chop them. There's a pair of scissors around the board, a bit like mousetrap, and you chop the head off a grape and squish it under a boot and stuff like that. But I guess a lot of that time games were just sort of built into the culture of... I just remember all families around us sort of

played the odd game and it wasn't particularly... We didn't do any differently to anybody else around us. I suppose it wasn't really until I got into high school, secondary school, where I really started to, I really wanted to play games. And I didn't really know anything outside of card games. So I'd be at school, we'd have a free period or something, and I'd be like, please, let's play a card game in the common

room or something. I remember there was a period of time when we started playing and I apologize for the curse. I know this game by no other name except Shithead. Yeah, I think it does have some other names, but that's the only one I know it as. It's a shedding game where you ask for a kind of a little traditional card game. I think it has some pretty cool hooks about it. The cards have some special powers to them and they they

burn the deck or reset the deck for as a kind of as you're shedding. And we will play that a whole bunch in the common room. And I, I heard as well, like I played it through the period of time when I was at school and then through to university. And as people went off on gap years between at like 18 between going from school to university, a lot of kind of friends did. They came back from those gap years talking about how on the tour, on the kind of the circuit,

the traveling circuit, like through Asia and through Australia in hostels and places like that, everyone was playing this game. And so they brought back all these different rules for it. And they said, oh, the sevens do this, all the nines do this in the game. And I was absolutely taken by the idea that the game could be kind of... modified and changed and so i started like going okay then it then maybe the the nine should be a higher or lower card the next card player should be higher or lower because the nine saw

somewhere in the middle of the deck and i was starting to make kind of decisions and i think both that was the kind of beginning of me really wanting to play games a lot more in a way discovering kind of design as well through through that process so I think that was pretty formative. And still to this day, I would love to make a version of that game that was a little more balanced, a little more streamlined. But yeah, I think that for me, playing that game through that period,

pretty formative. Nice. That sounds really cool. A couple of reflections. When you mentioned Grape Escape, I don't think I've... seen this or heard of it. But when you were describing the newer one, the name did pop into my head. I think the game you're mentioning was Necromolds. That's it. Yeah, yeah. Which I also haven't played. But when you were talking about it being like Play -Doh, I'm like, oh, I think there's only one game that could make that fit. But it is interesting, too, just those reflections on some

of these more traditional card games and their variations and and how they have like these different regional uh you know differences and yeah it's fun that like you know you had a group of friends that all went out and played something a little bit different but similar and yeah yeah i think um there's a ton of um a ton of interesting things about to, to be gained from classical card games. And I think was it, you had Marcel and layman

on your podcast a little while ago, right? Yeah. Yeah. And she, she was saying that, um, the, like, I think she's did diving really deep into those, um, classic card games now. And because of the, well, they've stood the test of time in many ways, but they've also got these kind of, they've just been sort of designed by the masses over time. And so there's a lot of, um, I think because they've stood the test of time because they've been through so many iterations that they've really streamlined and well sometimes if not streamlined sometimes they've bloated

but often they've kind of streamlined down to a really interesting core or something really interesting stuck along the way and yeah it's something I um I would love to I would love to spend more time digging into it especially trick -taking games and all of those because the history of all those kind of games well there's just so much there I think yeah yeah I think diving into it and actually doing some study, because I think a lot of people, like us included, grew

up playing them in some capacity. But deep diving it, like you mentioned, I think could definitely shed some light. And if you can even tie into some of those fun regional quirks or even naming differences as to why one place calls it this as opposed to one calls it that, I think you could definitely gain a lot from that, for sure. Neat. Well, I think let's kind of get to this.

So what I'm going to do, I'm springing a lot on you right at once. And I hope that it's not too much. So you can slow me down at any point. But this was my thought. So I have a Google Doc. And this is an absolute first. So I'm going to be sharing a Google Doc, I'll send it over. We're on Zoom, so I will share it with you. It should be set up in a way that this is yours. You can

edit this, all right? All right. And one of the things that you've been reflecting on a bit in various social media are these different types of fun. So I don't want to oversimplify it, and you can correct me. once I'm done introducing this, but you've been reading, you know, different books. And I don't actually haven't really looked into the books too much. So I don't know if they are like fun related to board games or just fun

in general. And you've come up with a list of 20 kind of like types of fun that that you think are worthwhile in breaking down our experiences, more or less. And yeah, yeah. And so what I did, and this is actually, so you have your form. I have my own as well. So what I'll do is like, when this is all said and done, well, or once this episode's published, I will share out my

Google Doc, not yours. Yours is yours. I'll share the one that I'm working on, and it'll kind of like make more sense as we go along. But we're going to kind of randomly, I will roll a D20. Yeah, no audience doesn't get to see this, but I have like a really fancy chip theory dice tower. Nice. Show me that again. OK, sorry, sorry. I'll slow it down. Oh, yeah, yeah. It looks kind of marble. Yeah, this is the one that came with

my big haplomachus pledge. Oh, yeah, that's good. Is it soft inside? Is it like padded at the bottom or is it hard? Oh, it's soft at the bottom. It's got like this felt bottom. Nice soft rolling. Yeah. I'm not a big fan of dice towers that go clickety clack. Like I like a kind of soft smooth one that rolls. It's got that elegance. Yes. I typically don't even use this. I usually just use, I have like a smaller dice tray, but this will be nice. I'll see. Actually, I have a whole

bunch of bags of dice. I should probably grab this beforehand that have all... All my D20s in them? Actually, no. I think I have a bag that has all my dice in them in general. Anyway, so I'll roll a die, a D20. And if it's a number that we haven't done, we'll take a look at that number. And all I want you to do to start is see if you can come up with a game that, when you're thinking about these different types of

fun, that just pops into your head. But if you're struggling with the particular number, we've got some rerolls on this sheet at the bottom. Oh, yes. So you can take a pause. We'll copy and paste one of those rerolls into that example for now, and then maybe return to it. Furthermore, And I think this is fitting with the aquatic theme. There are some deep dive stars. So once

you're done kind of working through the examples here, if you want to be like, oh, I really want to talk about the thrill of danger and this game, we can copy and paste one of those stars into that special column. OK. And if you want more stars, I think I put five there. We can add more. We don't need to limit ourselves. But I figure talking about five in depth and so on could definitely

get us a lot of time. This should be adequate, I think. And potentially other stuff after. I mean, again, the way things go. And then also, if you want, in the specials area, I have medium dives. So if there are other text types, Such as like shows or movies, which I have captured it just in the one Kind of directors cut thing a book video game or music that you feel would be fun to come up with another Sorry another

title for that particular type of fun We can copy and paste that in and then we can talk about that once we just get through the list Great. All right, sounds good. Yeah, sounds fun. Okay, so before before we started up before I roll the first the first D20 role, I guess, do you want to kind of initially explain where this interest started for you and kind of like what you've been reading and thinking about before

we talk about some examples? Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, of course, where did it start is a good question, because I'm not entirely sure how I first got onto it. I mean, at some point I was just doing some digging around, I think, and reading and on general kind of game design principles. I'd read Jesse Schell's book of lenses, which is a fantastic introductory book on game design.

And in a way, there's a lot of... lot of crossover to this kind of way of thinking of thinking a little bit more granular about well in this case fun but a little bit more granular about that um in with his book but um i first came across a post from alexander alexander banal i want to make sure i get his full name correct um let me just see am i um Pierre Alexandre Ganneau,

that was it, Pierre Alexandre Ganneau. He had a post called 14 forms of fun. And I think Pierre Alexandre was more of a video game designer or at least more interested in video games. So this, it was just a blog post that was written quite a few years ago talking more about, like I said, game design, video game design. But I was... kind of captivated by that idea that fun is a

lot more complex than often we give it credit for. Often when you hear about someone describing a game or a designer saying what they would like the game to be, they say, I want it to be fun. But it sort of got me thinking, well, what does that really mean? What are we talking about when we say a game is fun or that was fun? And so off the back of that I started looking around and I think that that post referenced another

post of Nicole Lazzaro who's another game designer and she had four kinds of fun and they were big kind of broad groupings of it and I found that interesting and then I just kept going further and further and found some more and there was a few that were more Less related to board game design or game design in general, so Steven Rice's 16 basic human motivators. And then Kevin Verbach's,

I think it's Verbach, 14 elements of fun, Marc LeBlanc's 8 kinds of fun. So I'm kind of spewing that list out just to give people some context if they want to dig into these a little bit deeper because I think it is a fascinating subject. So like you said, I've kind of... collated a list of 20 based on all of those different lists that I thought were most applicable to board game design. Actually since then I've extended it a couple because like you said I posted quite

a bit of this quite a bit about this on Blue Sky and a few game designers have jumped in and suggested others and so I would extend it by two extra to the ones that are missing from this list would be organizing sorting. Nick Bentley talked about that. And then mischievousness, which I thought was a great one. If you want to add them in on the bottom of the list. But you've only got a d20, so we've got a problem now. Well, once we get through the 20 random

ones, you can come up with the examples for those two. Would you like me to read the whole list? Is that useful? Sure. Yeah. Just as a kind of a summary at the start. Yeah. So people at the start do know what they're going to be getting into of the examples and then some deep dives. Yeah. Read through that list. They'll be perfect. All right. So application of an ability. That's number one. Two is beauty. Three, being silly.

Four, a few kind of clunked together. Challenge, mastery, or problem solving, and or problem solving. 5 is collecting 6 is comedy 7 is completion 8 is creativity 9 is discovery 10 is expression 11 is failing or in air quotes stupid games 12 is fantasy 13 is narrative 14 is physical activity 15 is power 16, another kind of grouping of relaxation,

immersion, submission. 17, sensation. 18, social interaction or fellowship. 19 is thrill of danger. 20, winning slash competition. And then organizing and sorting was 21. And mischievousness, 22. Perfect. Okay, so. Yeah, so we'll start off with the non -new ones, 21 and 22. We'll randomly

get a number. And the first board game title that pops into your head will list. And again, if you're struggling to have that game pop up for you, you got some re -rolls, which then you can think about that a little bit more. when it comes back and say if you know number two beauty is rolled and then like I do roll another two just for the sake of not like wasting a whole bunch of time we'll just like hop down to the next available one underneath okay cool cool we'll do it that way all right that's going into

the dice tower the first one that we have is 18 social interaction and fellowship Well, the first game that jumps to mind for me is Robinson Crusoe Adventures on the Cursed Island, which maybe that's just my own personal experience because it's pretty crushing, brutal game at

times, but it's one of the few co -ops that I really enjoy. I've got a group of friends that we've had a lot of good experiences going through that and I think the fellowship part of trying to survive together and the highs and lows of that and it's a very, it's a very, it's a game that instigates a lot of conversation and a lot of planning and teamwork and we had this one

moment many years ago where we were playing it into the early hours of the morning. and i used to live in a block of flats and we got down to the kind of last last turn it was do or die we we needed we needed another bit of wood on the fire before the boat arrived to save us and we were all about to die and my friend found some mushrooms while out on a hunt and came back and with we managed to get the last log on the fire

and we we just have this Vision all of us sitting on the fire eating these mushrooms which may or may not been poisonous or hallucinogenic. Well the camp can the campfire saved us through the night and we so this final moment we were all gonna die when he when he got those mushrooms we jumped up and cheered and the neighbors next door banged on the wall and I was thinking. Oh man, we've managed to wake up neighbors at three o 'clock in the morning with a board game. If only they knew what we were actually doing. It

wasn't a party or anything like that. So yeah, I think that's one for fellowship more than the social interaction part, but there you go. Perfect. Well, I like that a ton and we got our first one in and just as a... Kind of a not not a clarification or heads up But just know that any point like all of those like little specials with the like, you know deep dive star or like a different text in a different medium if you ever want to like throw those into That final column like I really

want to talk about, you know social interaction or fellowship more like after Do it like that's that's you have the control of that. All right Got it, but that sounds like an awesome example and I'd I've definitely heard of the, you know, Robin's Crucible, but I have not played it. So I really like that story. Okay. Well, we have half of 18. The next one is nine. So discovery. Hmm. Well, immediately near and far, the Ryan

Lawcutt Red Raven games designed jumps to mind because for anybody that doesn't know, it's a game with a storybook. You're going out on a map of these kind of fantasy worlds, building camps and traveling across the world and going on adventures. And I think in terms of fun, a game that kind of epitomizes that. version of fun discovery i think there are games that probably

do the discovery part even better like um like uh seventh continent which i haven't played but i know of and games that really harness the the essence of discovery but i think it's pretty it's certainly a pretty substantial part of near and far as well um because you'll you'll go to you'll build a camp somewhere on a on a far outpost or a or in a new town that is so you're kind of just discovering for the first time open up this book and you go off on an adventure and the adventure takes different paths in different

ways and it's always a you're discovering you're really discovering the world through that process and all sorts of strange things can happen from a a robot and magician that's buried under the ground to a a frog that's lost its parents or like all sorts of, I don't even know if those are exactly the stories in the book, but certainly things like that. And yeah, it's, I, discovery

is one of those forms of fun that I, I am fascinated by because I think, and maybe Maybe we can put a little, let's put a deep dive on discovery because I want to hear your thoughts on this as well. Okay. Discovery to me is really interesting because of the, like the nature of discovery is often about surprise. It's like, and surprise

can only happen once and you can't be expecting it in a way to be surprised. And so I'm fascinated by those games that The tension between discovery and replayability and if replayability is even necessary in a game that is about discovery if it is just about that that first moment and and discovery I think is also interesting as a form of thought fun because it can be Kind of incremental as you go along and be lots of little discoveries

or a game can have one big discovery It can be a discovery that the game gives you through narrative or it can be discovery that the game gives you through play, through the social interaction. It's a discovery about your friends or it's a discovery about a piece of hidden information that we've been waiting for for some time and it suddenly gets revealed. I think discovery is also really interesting because of the kind of tension as well around horror and how horror

as a genre is... within game, within board games, and is only just really being scratched the surface off with games like Final Girl and things like that. Were you playing? You were playing Final Girl, am I right? Yes, yeah. Yeah, I did. One of my solo rambling talks, I talked about Final Girl a little bit. So, and if I... Has that got an element of discovery in it? So, yeah, it's like right behind me in that big werewolf -y looking box. Right, there it is. Oh, yeah. That's

my Final Girl set. Hmm, let me try to think about it. It's been a minute. I've only played that a few times now So I think for final girl there like there's good discovery in you know, each each map is going to have a small kind of Like mini decks of cards for like equipment or events that are happening based on the locations that are on that map so I think that's where the biggest

bit of discovery and narrative comes from for that. And are they a same thing? Sorry, go ahead. Oh, no. And because it's such a modular game, I think it's just a lot of those moments and being able to pop open the new... scene or character or whatever is what's really going to drive the discovery in that one and and like a lot of the fun cinematic moments too which i think is a strength of the game for sure yeah i mean that

makes me think because is the discovery there is that happening for example are these these items these objects are they facedown or something like that during the game and you discover them or are you discovering them as you unpack that scenario yeah yeah you you shouldn't be uh I mean, I think you probably run the mildest risk of seeing what's going to be in it. But on the whole, I think just the event deck and the items and everything like that, even if you just get

a glimpse at them and turn them over so you can shuffle them and not see them, you really shouldn't be discovering them upon setup, I don't think. Right, right, right. because I was thinking if you were discovering them as you kind of unpack the scenario that in a way that's almost like a boost the booster pack philosophy of uh tcgs and things like that those this this form of fun discovery is so far reaching actually within board gaming they I mean you could also say the discovery of just a new board game and the fun

of constantly getting new games and things and so it's it's a fascinating one and a really powerful form of fun for designers to think about. And it's addictive, I would imagine, constantly wanting to discover something new. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, now that you mentioned it too, one of the games I've played quite a bit of has a very similar feel to the TCGs, but would be... unmatched,

you know, you get new unmatched characters and you just kind of want to see how those play. And that's another thing, too. Yeah, I could look at every single, you know, I don't know, it's like 30 cards or whatever per character, something like that. You could like look through them and get an idea of what your character does, or you could just like shuffle them up and then just see what happens when you draw. It's like, what can I do in the moment of play? And that's the way I've always done it. I'm not like terribly competitive. when it comes to those so yeah i

think um i think that's that's another reason i got into this just circling back to the kind of reason i got thinking about fun is because i was at a period in my kind of own gaming where i was a little bit dissatisfied playing some games and i realized it wasn't the game's fault necessarily it was it was something within me where i was too focused on the the winning competitive side of fun and I think it is important to try

to win to strive to win in a game so the game functions and it is competitive but when that is your sole purpose or your your main purpose of or your main source of satisfaction with the game then often you are left disappointed when you don't win and once I kind of realized that there were other things or just became more conscious of the other things that were satisfying in games and it was also about spending time with friends, which of course I knew, but I just never really

acknowledged that that was something I... Yeah, I can control that a little bit. I can let go of my need to win so much or be satisfied by the victory. And so... And once I got that, it unlocked, I think, a whole new appreciation of board gaming and the depth of why we play games and why I play games. Yeah, I mean, that makes a ton of sense. And I think that thought, too,

of being competitive to the point where you do lose some of the other elements of fun or you're so locked into one. Obviously, you know, Think it goes without saying that Like 1 through 22 or 1 through 22 and beyond of these like they're not they're not going to exist in in a vacuum Like many many games capture many of these different things in different ways But yeah, if you're so locked into just like trying to win you know

by doing whatever whether it's like a digital game or a Board game and you become like that expert. I mean like yeah, there's so many things that you're going to shut yourself off from because I mean you might play with people and you want to teach them your favorite game that you've played a hundred times and it's their first time playing it and it's like yeah I mean if you can't like tap into you know maybe a little bit of like discovery of the game or some of the social elements or whatever that might be like yeah you're just going to be a little too locked in

so nice very cool uh i i think the discovery like you we put a special star on it we can definitely hop back we obviously chatted about a little bit more but you're you're bringing up a lot of thoughts during it that i thought were really interesting and well i'll hold on to those too but we have near and far as we got a new role the answer for that oh wow the dice have listened to our conversation uh we hit 20 winning slash

competition okay well congratulations you won you won the dice rolling competition yeah natural 20 there um oh what's the game that i think about uh now we've won in competition um oh i'll tell you what i can do as a quick thing which might be interesting would be to because i keep board game stats do you do board game stats do you do you track your plays or anything like that I, for the most part, have been tracking them

on BoardGameGeek. I haven't used VGStats, I don't think. I have maybe used one of the different ones. But yeah, if I go on BoardGameGeek, I can definitely see how many games I've played, at least in the past two or three years. Because I was curious what my best... My strongest game is, what's the game I'm gonna, you know, what's

that question? You can pick a game to play against the devil. Like, which one are you going to pick? It's like, which game are you going to pick if you got to play it for your life? You know, if your life is on the cards, which one is it? Oh, I've got a pretty good win percentage in this. And this is an interesting game to talk about. It's a game called Shanghai. and it is my, I've got a 72 % win rate across 33 games, which I

think is pretty decent rate. Shanghaian is a criminally underrated game, in my opinion. It's by Michael Schott and it came out, oh god, it must be over 10 years ago now. The artwork on it is... No offense to the illustrator, but the artwork leaves a lot to be desired, and it's

very cartoony. It's these cartoony pirates, and the colors just are not great. It's just not a very good production. But the game is like a precursor to me to something like Hanama Koji or Air Land and Sea. It's a two -player dual game. It's a lame battler, but it's a lame battler where you're rolling dice and placing them and it is you basically have six each round you have six cards laid out in a line and the first player

rolls and they choose they choose which end of the line is one and which end of the line is six and then they place one of their dice next to the matching card. So if they have rolled a four, they can choose where in the line the four is on that first turn, and they place their four next to that card, and they've now got a kind of majority of that card. And they've also defined for that round which order the cards are going to go in, which has some interesting decisions in it. And then the next player rolls

two dice, picks one of them, places it, and you kind of go backwards and forwards trying to gain control over these cards. And then it's got a sort of Reinekenizia hook at the end where when you score the cards at the end, they're in sets and like families and they've got different point values. If you have all of the cards in the set and your opponent has none, if you have some and your opponent has none, then you score all your points. But if you have the majority of cards in the set, and your opponent has Sun,

then instead you score their points. So it kind of, you get this kind of chicken, game of chicken with all these different sets where you're trying to get as close, you're trying to be in a very tightly fought battle but just be one point ahead. Or if your opponent's got a big majority, then you're just trying to get one point in the suit to kill their score. And... Yeah, I absolutely love it. I wish it would get a reprint, and I'm pretty good at it, it turns out, according to my stats. So, yeah. Yeah, I just think, I think

like an interesting element of that too is like, I mean, that game does sound really neat. I like playing those two player, you know, lane battlers or head to head, you know, lane battler slash S games quite a bit. And, you know, like with the with like the exploration of kind of like competition or thinking about, you know, winning is like oftentimes you do play those types of games with like the same person as well. And

then you can like have the see the metas and counter metas or whatever just like develop and like, and then it becomes, you know, then it's like linked to that social fun to the person you're playing with it as well. Yeah, that's interesting. I just made me think now that I because I do love to play games. I think that is my ballpark. Like the game that I designed, the games I'm designing now are to play games to and very much high interaction head to head.

And I wonder if it's because in a way that it because it is head to head. it's the competition is more what's the word I want to say it's just in a way it's more acceptable to be really cutthroat because you're not you're not kind of gonna all gang up on one person it's you versus me and it's zero sum in a way and the games are built around that and everybody knows you and your partner usually know what you're getting into

with that and so Often the stakes are zero -sum. They often have endgame triggers that are earlier, like Seven Wonders Duel, where the game can end earlier than the scoring at the end. So there's this tension that's baked into it where the stakes are much higher. So I love that thrill of being head -to -head against someone. Yeah, and the

winning isn't up isn't. I don't care so much about the winning, but that it's really thrilling because of that, because it is me or you. And one of us is going to win this. So, yeah. Yeah, no, yeah, that definitely that definitely does. I think, you know, I mean, there are definitely going to be some people to that when it comes to two player games, they still would even shy away from something that is so directly competitive and are going to find something that isn't. But I think like you said, yeah, it just kind of

kind of gives you an excuse. It's like not even an excuse. It's just an accepted element. Like, OK, we're going to I'm going to go for something you're going for. You're going for something I'm going for, because it's the only thing that you can go for. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I think here, let's put a star on this because there's an interesting tangent. I think that's. In the conversation, in the ballgame design conversation right now, online on Blue Sky and Historic, and just today in Cardboard Edison, the Cardboard

Edison newsletter that goes out every Sunday, there's a new publisher set up that's primarily focused on, or solely focused on, victor -less games, or unranked games, where there's either multiple victors or... no victor or no winners, no losers. And I think that's a really interesting thing to think about. Like you were just saying about some people would shy away from that. I am actually in this sort of because of this new

publisher set up and I've seen the talk around it, I've become interested in it myself and started working on a Victorless game myself, just ideating and starting very early kind of vision, vision forming around the game. But I believe that it is going to be an interesting new trend or genre within ballgames and I think there is a hugely untapped market of people that I could say are turned off by that or you know just want something

like cozy is a real buzzword right now in the hobby I think and rightfully so that people sometimes do just want a nice experience, or they just want to go on adventure. I love a lot of those. We've played, like I said, Robertson Crusoe, Near and Far, we played Clank Legacy with the same group of friends. I talked to them about this and I said, would you be interested in a game where you just discover stories, you go on adventures, but there's no winning or losing? They said, those games exist? Yes, sign us up.

Yeah, we really don't care about the winning side of things. This is absolutely a double -edged sword, or I don't know what the analogy is, but it's something that some people absolutely thrive on within Hobbities. This might be the most important thing for some people, and yet it might be the most turn -off thing for other people. It's possibly the most divisive out of a lot of these. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. And yeah, I know that

even just Even in solo games, too, you see a little bit more of that thought regarding games without win conditions. And thinking about that within the context of something that is solo or cooperative, too, is not... Yeah, it's parallel to that thought. It's not necessarily the same as playing a game with a couple people and just having neither of the two people win, but it's you playing... against a system or within a system

and then just having that be that. I mean, that's role -playing. That's D &D, right? There is no winning D &D, as they say, right? It's just you do it for the journey, you do it for all of the things that go along the way and nobody at the end of a session at D &D has declared the winner. It just goes on and I think there is absolutely a space for that in the hobby and I'm excited to see I'd like to see what's going to happen in the next few years. I know there have been a few releases recently. I think is it the something

about some the shiny something, Isla and the shiny something is one that maybe I don't know if that is Victilous or it's certainly in this kind of bucket and the dwarf romantic that won Did it win the spiel or nominated for the spiel a few years ago? That one kind of where it's just goal -based and there isn't, it's cooperative but goal -based, but there isn't a kind of a, there isn't a victory condition as far as I know. So yeah, it's fascinating to think about. Perfect.

Well, we already, we started that dive and there's a star for more, but we've got like, Three games and and two stars, so you gotta you gotta hold on to your stars All right, I'll go we'll do some rapid -fire ones. No, no, I'm just kidding Six comedy Well, I'm legacy the writing and plank legacy I found I found hilarious at times There's

some pretty funny funny characters and funny stories We still joke about the horse that's in that game. Anybody who's played Clank Legacy, is it called the nearly dead horse or the definitely not dead horse, something like that. So yeah, there's some pretty funny writing in there. But yeah, comedy's a funny one. I think it can come through in narrative, but it can also really backfire in narrative. But then I also think

about on the flip side of that just a game like Time's Up or we've never I've never played Time's Up but we just play a parlor version of it called the Hat Game where everybody just writes the clues and chucks them in a hat and that you just end up in creases just you know the hilarity of of people's mistakes or misheard things or the the memes that are created within that group as you play it I think Yeah, that for me is where comedy within games really, it's exciting and

interesting when it's coming from the players. Is there a game that you can think of that you found particularly funny or you've really laughed at just because of either the writing or the social side of things? Yeah, I was just kind of thinking about when you were talking and, you know, obvious, well, not obviously, but I think most of the games that are going to fit into this category would probably be in either Either the storytelling from from the narrative or probably being more of a of a party game.

Mm -hmm. So So a couple I mean, yeah, you you mentioned times up as a good one but I think a couple of games that have been Funny I was like looking it's not on the shelf right now. It's in there's actually like a bag but Monstrosity have you made that one? No, I know about it, I think, but you talk about it because I hadn't played it. Yeah, so I mean, it's a game where

one person sees the suspect monster. They get 20 seconds to take a look at the card and then they have two minutes to relay the details of the card, what they can't look at anymore. So they see it for 20 seconds and then they put it down and then from memory they have to. try to like relay what it looks like to all these other people who are then drawing it and The anybody who is Like trying to draw they can ask

questions and and I actually had Eric Lawson the designer of the the game on in he went through a really good breakdown of all these different reveals and all these different abilities. So you don't even have to be a great artist. You could score points or do well by having a good memory and trying to come up with the details or come up with good questions or just really listen to what it is that the person's trying

to describe. And it's, I don't know, it's just a really fascinating design because there's a good amount of like commentary in there too about like people's memories and stuff it's it's yeah it's a great combo with him to check out but i think that's gone high onto my list then i'm gonna have to check that out that sounds good yeah it's a fun one and it just uh it has a lot of funny moments especially once once you get these different reveals and and you see some people's drawings and you're like what Then you

see what the card was that the person had looked at. It's like, wait, what card were you looking at that you gave us this description for? I don't know. I feel like that one. I mean, it is in that party game space, but it's created a lot of laughs, for sure. So that one sticks out to me quite a bit. All right, let's roll again. That was a little quicker. Hello. We're getting

there. Clank Legacy, I really need to start playing the Clank games, because that one sounds fun. I have one of the Clanks. Yeah, I hadn't played Clank before playing Clank Legacy, but we had a lot of fun out of it. We're tempted to do the new one. we've all got kids since playing legacy the first time so it's like let's let's shelve that for a few years. You played the first one and then then like had had different legacy elements

in your own life that of uh yeah exactly yeah yeah we opened up with we've all recently unpacked a box which included a baby inside of it and now we're now we're into the next campaign. Well, I hope you're all able to find time for Clink Legacy 2 sometime, or 3 at that point in time, who knows. Yeah, yeah. We are on number 1, Application of an Ability. All right. Maybe I'll start by just unpacking this, because sometimes it can

be like, well, what is that application of ability? What does that mean? So I think the definition of this is that it's a game where you apply Any skill that you have in your life, and it could be that you have some knowledge of mathematical reasoning, it could be that you have... some, you know, trivia, you know, you know, just a particular field of trivia, or you're a really good drawer, like you were just talking about most recently, or it's where you get to you get

to use the skills and knowledges that you have within the within the game. And that is that is a deep well of satisfaction. And and it's also really, really broad. But, you know, often when we play a game, we go, we don't realize how much of our own abilities and skills we're using and gaining a lot of feedback on that because this direct feedback again gives you on it and you see the outcomes of your abilities and skills and when those things go successfully you get

a kick out of it so that's sort of this one what this one groups I think and so oh yeah well that the one that comes to mind for me is werewolf Because of my drama background because I was a I studied theater and I I am a drama teacher now and I use werewolf a lot within my classroom to to teach Kind of bluffing and keeping a poker face managing your nervous energy building building

tension and creating atmosphere and all those things and I get to I get sort of hammered up a little bit and I'm always the moderator so I'm telling the story and using a lot of my drama skills to model for the students some of those skills and abilities and knowledge related to drama so it's one that I enjoy applying my own abilities within that I think. And do you use

do you if you played werewolf it is because I know your teachers or is it something do you use in your classroom at all I? Haven't used any any sort of like social deduction game in the classroom I Think in an English English your English English teacher right high school English teacher you Probably be a bit more of a shoe into using directly to teach but yeah Well, yeah, I typically if anything and not unfortunately

I do I always want to see if I can like tie in more games But the most recent thing that I did that actually worked pretty well, which is is not really an application of an ability It's not not the same as like werewolf which I think it's an interesting answer too because you know Within acting it makes a lot of sense, especially if You know, that's what the students want to be doing but it also this idea of you know lying does make people uncomfortable so I think yeah,

I think within that context it it works. Well, and it's it's an interesting exploration But yeah, and I don't I don't I don't I can't really think of like a good example based on well, just this category or the one that you have but The most recent game I played is I kind of adapted the word game, Just One, because, well, we got done reading Macbeth, the play, and we did different activities with Macbeth, so sometimes I'll take

themes or the names of characters and then just make those be the words that the guessers have to get from, like, Just One, so that was pretty fun. I think that absolutely applies. I mean, that's... Like I said, it's not just an application of an ability, but I think application of knowledge, application of wisdom, if that is even possible kind of thing. But yeah, that's probably deeply satisfying for the students to be able to play a game and to be able to use the knowledge that they've just gained from reading and digging

into Macbeth and do that in a way that's fun, but also it. Again, it's something in a safe environment that gives them feedback on that knowledge and rewards them for having that knowledge and not in a rewarding way that's going to be sitting in an exam that's going to cost them the rest of their lives or something, maybe. Cool. Well, yeah. Well, thanks for justifying

my non -answer answer a bit more. But yeah, I see it. Yeah. All right. Well, from application of an ability to being silly. Number three. Oh, I know. I know. I know one. Right. Let me get the title right. So this is a this is one of best Shah Shah Shah Shahrihari Shahrihari's games.

Wait a second, it is a game about making... No, a game about cute... Wait, she has such fantastic titles. A game about cute, comical creatures. A game about cute, comical creatures and trying to identify them after someone makes noises. That's the title of the game. All of her games are... with these fantastically long, very descriptive

titles. And that does tell you what the game is. It is a game about cute, comical creatures and trying to identify them after someone makes noises, which is a very, very silly game where you're invited to be silly. So it's all these beautiful, cartoony... It actually reminds me a little bit of Mondrosity that you were talking about. Yeah. But, you know... each card is a is a monster and they are all with their mouth open or kind of they're all they all look like they're making sounds they all look like they're

roaring or tooting or sneering or something like that and then they have kind of lined up in a in a um in a suspect's gallery one player knows which one or picks one of them that they're going to try to communicate to everybody but they do it through making a noise So they just go, you know, but of course the animals have some features that are similar, you know, and they have two or three animals in the lineup may look like they've got the same emotional experience going

on. Some of them have two or three mouths. Some of them have the same kind of, I don't know, eyes that open or whatever it might be. So you have to be very, very particular about the sound that you make. And so, you know, we've played this in a bar or something and I've played it in a bar before and it's a game that anybody who's passing by and looking at you is thinking, what on earth are they doing? Like just hearing everybody's really deeply in thought or conversation

about someone who's just made out or whatever it might be. And then everybody thinks about it really deeply. It's fantastic. It's such a silly game and so easy to jump on board with and play. I love it. Yeah, that's great. I can't say that I've heard of this one previously but the the premise sounds very interesting and it also yeah, like you said the images of the cards that you're seeing are very Like specific and

yeah, that looks perfect It's just a little deck of cards. It's it's perfect. You can pack it in the bag and and it's really disarming as long as people I think this is another interesting form of fun where buying is really important with this. You've got to make sure the group are up for it, otherwise they're not going to jive with that experience at all. So, yeah, try to tread with caution, perhaps, or make sure you get... you get buying from everybody before

you try playing it. But if you do have a group of people who are willing to be silly and do it like that, it works really well. And I see the link that you've posted is the other version of the game, which was worth mentioning. The other version? Oh my goodness. I posted the wrong one. No, no, it's good because they're exactly the same, just with different monsters. But a game about wee whimsical creatures and trying to identify them after someone makes a noise is a... a standalone sequel to a game about cute, comical creatures and trying to identify them.

I will fix the name and the link. I got it all set up much, much better. So there are two, and they're working at the same thing. Yeah, they're compatible, yeah. I think one's colored and one is black and white, torrents, but they're essentially the same thing. And you can make some matching, I think. Very cool. I think you can actually put them together to play with 12 players. I think they play six, like something like two to six each. And if you merge them together,

you can play 12 players, which would be hilarious to see that many people taking it very seriously that the noise that you're about to make. I think you've like bring up a good point. You know, you definitely have to consider buy in and you definitely have to think about who it is that you're playing with. But I also think that You know, well, I mean you don't want to you don't want to create a scenario where somebody's gonna be uncomfortable doing anything in any capacity I mean, that's that's just gonna turn people

away from wanting to play a game or potentially even games in general but I guess the the one flip side that I think that I have I've noticed and I'm not like a game pusher like I love playing games, but if if I know that people aren't really interested I'm not gonna like I'm that's not gonna be my angle, right? Yeah, but I do think that if people are interested in playing games, more often than not, maybe this was a bad generalization on my part, people are willing to buy into being

silly or to doing something that they didn't necessarily think that they knew that they wanted to do ahead of time, if that makes sense. games are that wonderful catch -all that, in a lot of ways, that they do, well, because it's play, because they are inherently play, they allow us to tap back into that. Some people perhaps are ready to go. Some people are already open

to playing and comfortable playing. Some people maybe need a little bit more time, a little bit more encouragement. But all of these different forms of fun, are also within that big group of play and I think it's yeah that and sports and which of course are games there's that space for play and I think it's why it's seen continues to see growth because as an industry because we we need it we need it within our lives and

it's something it gives us space to be silly because You may be comfortable being silly in the office with your colleagues or something but some people need that environment and that reason to do it and that's all they need actually. Yeah, I think I think like one game I just I kind of like look over if that's nine my collections all spread all over place So if you see me looking it's not me being distracted. It's me like thinking

about what you're saying is The game don't get got Do you know that one? Yes, okay It's a meta game, isn't it? Yes, it is a meta game. And it could be a meta game, it could be just something that you introduce for a weekend, or for a night, or whatever it is that you have set up to, and you're trying to trick people into doing something, or get them to bring up the... or tell you the

plot of the movie Inception or something. Have you played it in some, you've done like a weekend where you've. Yeah, I've probably played it like at least at least four or five times and with a variety of groups, you know, like like people or, you know, young adults that I've like, you know, like coach and you're going up to state for for track and field or something like that. And it's like a group that's not necessarily. quote -unquote game players but they love it

like everybody loves it yeah oh god i'd love to play it i would absolutely love it um when i used to work in summer camps in america um in my kind of my 20s and i did a few years and every summer there'd be about a week when we'd play a game called assassins um where everybody gets given a target everybody that's playing gets given a target and you've got to get a you've got to get a Basically like a shot glass worth of water onto your target to eliminate them without

that it has to be within the rules that It can only be you and the target that sees it No, no other observers can can see it and if if they do then the the the kind of assassinations like terminated but they're still your target which makes it even harder to then get them because they now know you are their kind of you that you're hunting them and stuff and then once you eliminate them you get given their target and it kind of gradually whittles down until there's

two people left both trying to eliminate each other. without anybody else seeing and without the other person preventing it from happening and it couldn't be under closed doors it had to be outside so you couldn't be under a roof so we would end up in all these shenanigans and people crawling under crawling into crawl spaces under cabins and waiting in a tree for three hours in the early morning and all of these things so i would i would probably take it far too seriously but i would love it yeah That's good. I think

I think all of those are definitely examples of being silly and the initial one that you brought up about making Ram noises is literally perfect. Oh Back to the tower. Let's see if we got a new one here. Oh Okay, so I got a squint a little bit. We're on 16. So relaxation immersion or submission or the category of all of them, not all. Gosh, that's a hard one. I think... Yeah.

I started trying to think about a multiplayer game that kind of satisfies that fun thing. And I don't know if I've really been immersed that much in a or relaxed or kind of felt submission with a multiplayer game not least what I can remember but solo games is then what I thought about and I think about some of my favorite solo games like Onirim is a great one for relaxation

for me that it's just something shuffling a deck and playing out cards in a very kind of peaceful it's quite repetitive but in a really nice relaxing way. Do you know about the Dektet? Have you ever come across the Dektet? I have. I feel like I just heard about the Dektet from the Biff Spacecast

podcast because Dan Theroux had the designer of Pax Illuminatin on. And here, I'll type this in so I can get the name. And that designer was Oliver Kiley. And I feel like Oliver mentioned being inspired by the deck tat in the creation of Pax Illuminatin. OK, yeah, I see. So that was the only time that I had heard of it. Yeah,

it's it's sort of gone under the radar it came out a few years ago Basically what it is for them that doesn't know it's a it's just a card system. It's a deck of cards a card system for Playing games with but it hasn't it's kind of came up with a book of games That are specific to that deck and the deck but the deck has a couple of unique hooks about it every card has or certain cards have multiple suits on the card so some cards have just one suit one of the six

suits but some cards have two or three suits on the card so a card can can kind of exist within multiple suits which is really interesting for for yeah trick -taking games or any games that kind of rely on on suit play but also the card has certain cards are in there they all have a piece of art on them and some of them are person personages some of them are locations and some

of them are events so it's also a really interesting game for building storytelling games or games that have a narrative built into them but also then while still being kind of in a traditional deck of cards in a way. And the game that I've played the most of that is actually a fan -made game that is a riff on the Friedman Friess game,

Friday. So there is a fan -made version of that called Thursday that you can play with the dekta. And then I think somebody else riffed on that with a game called Tinker Sailor. soldier spy which is it's just this tiny little like it's a narrative it's a real like adventure game where you start out with a tinker a sailor a soldier

and a spy those are your kind of like beginning team and that's your deck and you gradually go through trying to overcome events or events or locations to build your deck to then kind of do this final journey at the end where you go from the you go from it's something like you have to make it all the way to the sea and I've been on these like it's so hard to describe but

I've been on these epic adventures with a deck of like whatever it is 50 cards just by like It just evokes a beautiful narrative. If you let it, if you kind of just go, OK, well, what's the spy? Why is the spy overcoming the castle? Well, there's a... And if you can imagine that story as you go along... And because it's a solo game, you can take as long as you want playing it and thinking of those little narrative beats. And then if you overcome the castle, well, then

the spy now has people in the castle that are working for it, and the castle gets added into your deck, and... um later on then when you try to go on the adventure when the castle comes up you you know you're calling on the people that you've recruited in the castle and it's them that are helping you overcome the next uh kind of part of the adventure because the suits in the deck and the it's another beautiful part of it like the suits are things like leaves sun moon um uh there's like a snake in there the

images in the deck if the suit is let's say, leaf and moon, then the card's image is a location. Maybe the location would be the forest at night. It matches the suit, in a way. If it's the water, then there will be water in the image somehow. If it's a water suit, there'll be a watermill or something like that. So as you go through, the narrative connection's just... unfold and

in this really organic way and I find that really relaxing and actually quite immersive like I say for such a small form factor so yeah it's a fantastic tool for also for designers to play around with something that I believe many many more people should own and know about it's a fantastic little little deck of cards the Pd Magnusson is the designer I think okay I'll uh I'll link well basically for that not like a huge my my intent with the form was to uh well

share share the form well i said that already to share the form in the in the show notes so well hey so i don't have to like have super extensive show notes kind of highlighting all these awesome games that you've brought up but If anybody wants to look at them, then they can just go to this document and then just click on the board game geek page and see the designers and artists and everything and kind of have credit. I know, look at that. But I'm linking the Dektet in this as well. So those two games you mentioned, though,

just for clarification, Thursday and then the Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, if that was the name of it. Those are both solo games? They're both solo games. Okay, so I know that Friday is, and you said that Thursday was a fan -made kind of variant on that, but they're both solo games. I'm trying to think, would you feel as if then, you brought it up before and I haven't played it, so I can't say if it would work here, but

you mentioned Dorf romantic as a co -op game. Do you feel like that one could? bit into this as a, not competitive, but as like a co -op experience, like multi -player experience. Yeah, I think that's what people, from what I've heard of the game, that's how people describe it, that it is just, well, I've heard it described as quite relaxing, that you're just kind of working on your objectives, but then I've also heard it described as still having quite a lot of tension.

because you self -impose your own goals. And in a way, if you are a person who's very goal -driven and you want to impose your own goals quite stringently on yourself, then in a way you can disguise your limit in your goals within that game. So I would imagine for most people it's relaxation. For some people maybe it can be still quite like, I've got to get this done because I've got my own personal goal. But yeah, it's definitely one that I want to try for that reason. Nice. Yeah, and I think, and you mentioned

it kind of at the top of rolling this number, but I'm curious to like what this might look like or how it could exist in a multiplayer game that isn't cooperative. I mean, I think it's definitely a possibility. I would have to like kind of jog my memory of examples of games that I play to see how this is really fit. So I think, I mean, I think immersion could definitely work, but I feel like thinking about immersion combined

with relaxation could make it a little bit trickier. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, and maybe there's an argument to be made that immersion should be a separate category to this. That perhaps relaxation and submission are different from immersion because immersion can be immersion in a horror. You could be immersed in a horror which is absolutely not a relaxing thing. entirely sure why I grouped

them together. Perhaps just because I wanted a nice clean number of 20, which I've now broken and it's now 22. So I guess it could come out and become 23. Hold on. I'm not trying to make you make more numbers. I was just reflecting. Well, speaking of numbers here, just one thing. So we've got one, two, Wait, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven. We only have seven numbers.

If I'm being honest with us at this moment in time, I think we should chop our list in half for now. We'll do a few more, but that's good news. It means that we don't have to be surprised by these numbers, but when we talk in the future, because I definitely will want to, because this is going to be the incomplete. episode, quote unquote. And I want to talk about your game too a little bit in relation to this as well. So

I don't want to spend like four hours talking about it. That would be a long podcast. But I reckon we could go 10 if we really put out my instruments. Oh, I know. I feel like, as is, we're taking our time, but we're still going quick. And we're not super far. So let's do a few more. And we can chat about, I had a question related to the list and Kelp for sure and other

ways that you're thinking about this in your design process. And then if we want to maybe talk about like one of the special stars for now, we can before getting into like some wrap up thoughts. But let's do a few more. We're doing well, but we're not gonna get like - Oh, I misunderstood the stars. I thought I was chucking in stars when I was like in the moment saying - So we're saying we're deep diving on them now. Oh, yeah. Yeah, I get. OK. That's I mean, that's the main thing. I probably 100 % described that wrong.

But no, we definitely did deep dive those more when we were talking about them. Yeah. OK, so I'm pretty happy. I think we're covered with that with discovery, at least for now. OK, at least for now. Well, the way you brought it up, too, I think like here, I'll share my my secrets on discovery before going to the next one. I think you brought up. Seventh Continent and you brought up some other games and I think it's interesting. I mean, you know both discovery within like a game system Discovery within like the type of game, you know, it could be a map

book you brought up near and far but the other bigger Ryan Lockett game is like even more discovery. Oh, yes sleeping gods sleeping gods and you know going through the story books and you know with Seventh Continent and other games like that that have you a huge deck boxes where the cards make up the map, and then that discovery is intriguing as well. But I think when you mentioned that idea of replayability, there's also the sense

of the core loop within those games that makes you want to continue with the discovery. Not those games in particular, but when I think about those types of games, I think it's challenging to come up with like a mechanical game loop that makes you want to keep going in those games. And again, not those ones in particular, but I've just kind of thought about it because, you know, if the experience is going to be, you know, 50 hours, the balance of the discovery of the

world and, you know, the mechanisms that are linked to it. I don't know. It's just like an interesting thought. So that's like the only thing that was on my brain. It's something I've been thinking about because I have been thinking about discovery quite a bit recently because I'm working on an expansion to Kelp and the publisher had said when we were kind of brainstorming together like what it could be that it would be cool to have an element of discovery in the game and

so I've been unpacking like well what does that mean you know what do you because I think there's with with discovery, like you say, there can be some kind of mechanical hook, you know, there's, perhaps it's a discovery of strategy, right? That's one element of discovery, but I don't think that's really what, when people talk about the discovery as an element of fun, they're meaning, they're meaning, like you say, something, the content, discovering the world, discovering the people, discovering the events. And, you know,

that really is, you need, kind of more and more content. Why, like, why Sleeping Gods is this big game with a lot of content in there? It's because once you've discovered some of it, unless you come back to it far in the future and you've forgotten it, you've discovered it and so it needs a lot of content there. The other kind of flip side of that is that I wanted moments of discovery and really what help actually is

a big part of kelp is hidden information and revealing hidden information and so it's a much more it's a much more scaled down version of discovery in that it it exists within the game system it's discovery between players it's discovery of hidden information and um kind of the dna of kelp is is android netrunner my love of android netrunner the game and in that it's it's this a lot of tension designed around flipping a card,

placing a bet on what that card is going to be, and it's either going to be lucrative for you, or it's going to be deadly for you, and stakes are really high. So the discovery moment is the reveal, the flip, or the flop. So when I think about discovery, I think about it in those two big groups in a way, content or a flip. Yeah.

Perfect. Like I said, I'm glad you feel content with our star deep dive into those, but yeah, I was just thinking about it. It's very, again, these elements, they could mean so many different things within each category and the way that they interact with the other ones. Yeah, there could be books written about this thing. There probably are. All right. Well, let's try to knock

out a few more before a couple Kelp -specific, well, Kelp and you designing specific questions. And we'll take a look. So we are on sensation. So we've got a few on this document that are right next to each other and are going to be filled in. So sensation, I guess, for me is like, The the haptics the touch of the game and it's it's not only the kind of feel of the components But it's also what you are doing with the components

with your hands or your body during the game as well So it's this kind of a sense of action and things and moving things around or collecting them or whatever It might be rolling rolling dice touching things So what is a game that jumps to mind for sensation for me? Oh, that's tough. Do you have something in mind that jumps to you? Well, I think a fun one. I mean, you mentioned,

you know, feel of things. And, you know, my mind jumps to dexterity kind of initially. And again, I don't think it's limited to dexterity. And one of them, I like a lot of dexterity games, but... I'll give two, because I play a lot of Dexterity games. So one of them that's kind of funny is the little game Tinder Blocks, where

you're just stacking with the tweezers, and the Board Game Podcasts so very wrong about games, they like talking about that game because the tweezers are kind of... they're not great and that's almost like a part of the game. It's just like manipulating these tweezers to try to grab the pieces and if you like grab the the wooden block wrong it just like shoots across the table or whatever yeah yeah yeah that's kind of funny and then the game uh hamster roll not sure right

yeah i do i know it yeah the big ring the big ring right the big ring yeah oh that's cool so um And what are the pieces like in hamster roll? They're wooden pieces. Yeah, they're wood pieces. Yeah, I mean, you're getting feedback, aren't you, from that wheel, right? You're placing something on, you're getting immediate feedback. I imagine it wobbles underneath your touch and stuff. Actually

something came to mind which is the complete opposite end of them in a way that those are quite tense Tense thrilling games. They also fit into like failing games where the fail is the fun but um, I have a I haven't got like the collector's edition, which is a fancy name for what it is, but of Quiracle Do you know Quiracle the tile lane game? Definitely know it. I I've not played that one though It's so good for what

it is. I play with my parents and it's basically scrabble without words. That's how I would describe it. It's scrabble where you don't have to make words, you're just making patterns. But it comes, the version I have are these chunky, urea or bake alike, whatever they are pieces. Mine mines the pieces all black with really kind of nice embossed colors on them. They're heavy They we

need to yes a big bag of them that you have to Like we have to put Because they have a young kid at home the if we need to shake up the bag We have to put like a tea towel like a car a little towel under the table on the table Because the bag is so heavy that it will make her a really loud clunk when you kind of put it down or if you're shaking it. Which is, there's not many games you have to actually like, sort of deaden the table, soften the table because it's so loud

while you play. But I just love the satisfying, like, you stack them up and then you kind of, you stack them up in front of you so the other players can't see and you pick one up and set it down. There's something so rewarding in that. It's... probably another reason kelp my game which has these chunky chunky mahjong tiles that the i love the haptics of manipulating them particularly that there's something really satisfying about

laying it from a standing position to a flat position i don't know 10 15 years ago i would have thought you'd have asked me like Will you take satisfaction from laying a mahjong tile down? I would have thought you were crazy, but right now, it's so satisfying. It is, and well, now that you're bringing up these non -dexterity examples, I was just thinking to another game that's right behind me, Big Top. I don't know

if you're familiar with Big Top at all. So it is an auction a bidding game, and it is by, I want to say it's a Taiki Senzawa game, so you mentioned, yeah, it is a Taiki Senzawa game. Taiki makes a ton of really kind of experimental trick takers and climber shedders, but this is an auction game, and you're bidding a currency,

these coins, and I have the Deluxe little All play coins and you know people could argue if coins are necessary or not But I think in the instance of this game You have your little player shield because you don't want people to know how much money you have you're hiding it but you can kind of play with your money in a way that's almost like borderline bluffing or You can you can kind of give a tell as to how much money you may or may not have based on like the

way your money feels and sounds, how you manipulate it. So I think that's interesting too. Yeah, it reminds me somebody commented, was it on Blue Sky or something that we were talking about sensation recently and how it makes sense that metal coins, the fact that they're metal, if they're heavier or poker chips, heavier poker chips, subconsciously play into loss aversion. that if you are kind

of, they're more satisfying to add to your collection and more painful when you have to give them away or spend them or lose them than a cardboard chip would be. And that's a way that kind of, and especially thinking about design, like when you really start to go deep in thinking about design, like the choices that you make in terms of components can deeply impact satisfaction or fun or things like loss of origin. things like bluffing, you know, yeah, that's really interesting. I like

that. Again, yeah, this, the whole conversation and just like the examples you've brought up and, and kind of not deep diving all of them, but many, many deep diving them all at the very least has been keeps like bringing new examples to my mind. I could talk about this all day. I absolutely could. This is my most interesting topic, I think, that I love thinking about. Perfect. Well, we got a couple more. And then hopefully,

like I said, maybe continuing this at some... Oh my gosh, look at this. The die is listening, though. So we went from Sensation, in which we talked about some Dexterity games, to... failing and stupid games, which coincidentally was brought up in that last topic. Yeah, so these are the games where the fun is because one person or lots of people fail and that is the kind of usually the climax of the game and Jenga being the kind

of most probably the most famous version they saw or Twister. Is there one? Failing? Oh, I can think of one that's really, it's got a great element of failing in it. Did you ever play Cheating Moth? Oh, I've heard of it, have not played Cheating Moth. It's in the same line as Cockroach Poker, which is the most, probably the most famous, at least the most famous that I know of within

that line of games. I can't remember the publisher, but... Yeah, cheating moth or muggle muggle moth muggle moth something like that in the German is a is a game where you are obliged to cheat to win. So basically, it's a it's a shedding game where you've got to get rid of your hand of cards, but you're kind of playing them to the plane into the central deck. Certain cards trigger like mini games, but there is a there is a a card within the deck, in this case the

moth, that cannot be played legally to the deck. So you have to get rid of it from your hand in any way possible by sliding it up your sleeve, tucking it under another card as you play it, just going whole hog and throwing it from the table over players' heads. But the hook of the game is that one player is the guard. So The guard, each round, well, changes. If the guard

catches you cheating, you become the new guard during midway through the round. So the guard is kind of always changing. So all the other players are trying to get rid of their moths without the guard catching you. And so the moments of failing when, you know, people try to pull off some audacious cheat to to get rid of a get rid of a moth. Like, I mean, I've seen people I've seen people like, you know, really just

the guard is looking at them and they throw the card or they do it in such a way that they can pull it off. That's hilarious after the fact, because you can't laugh during the... You're not allowed to snitch on the people as they cheat, if you're players. It's hilarious if they pull it off. That's funny, but it's even more funny if they fail, like, and they get caught doing something ridiculous trying to cheat. Yeah, it's a good one. That's good. I've definitely... I'm

trying to think which, yeah, I've watched and listened to a lot of people talking about board games and I'm... i've heard some fun stories about cheating moth but i have not played that it's really good actually that was my just as a tangent i've i um i made a custom version of it um i loved it so much and then designed a bunch of kind of mini mini expansions to it that i only i have but we play with some fun ones and and so like other ways of there's a few other kind of ways of cheating that are built into

the game and um one of them is ties back to um what's that meta game called sorry don't get got yeah yeah yeah so there's a there's this one card in my version where um during the game you've got to steal in order to play the card you have to steal something from another player like a possession from them like their drink or their coat or something so layering on another layer of kind of cheating a meta version of cheating within the game and then once you if you were

able to steal that and keep it for a full round of cards, a full turn, then you announce it and you can play your card and get rid of it. Oh nice. Oh that is funny. How many little cards or mini expansions did you make for your Cheating Moth deck? Well in Cheating Moth there are in addition to the moth i think there are four four

kind of basic cards so i've i have an entirely different set of them so i have at least four so i can i can switch out the four mini games with four other mini games they're basically like one of them is like if when you play the card everyone has to slap the table and the person on top of the pile is gets a penalty and stuff like that so i've switched out some of those mini games and um and then I think like I added in this um yeah this other this meta stealing

card and then I've expanded the game the game only plays five players but with my mini expansions I can play bigger but then you need you need more guards so I have a temporary guard that appears it kind of appears during the game and and becomes a temporary guard for a while Until they catch someone and then they let go of it and they go back for one card and stuff like that So I kind of had to make it function a little bit more Yeah, it's been a while. It was one

of those projects that I did like Must be six or seven years ago now when I kind of did all that tinkering So I'd be and I haven't played it with my mini expansions for a while I'd be curious to see how they stack up with a few years a few more years experience into my vault now That is perfect Well, for now, we are having the last die roll. Are you ready? I'm ready. Let's see. Okay, I say this now, and I know that it's going to double up, but I haven't actually

bumped down from a number. We haven't re -rolled the number. They've all been unique numbers. I haven't gone from the next to the next. Let's see how well this die has been listening. Has it listened to you? It did. 15. Power. Oh, it's a nice one. It's a new one. Oh, power. Oh, man. I did some thinking about power on Blue Sky. It was one of the posts that I went a little bit deeper on recently. I think power, the thrill

of power is actually often knowing that you know something or have something, but not using it yet. I waiting to use it. and and then of course seeing the consequences but there's something really exciting about the build up of the build up of having something that others don't so what's um yeah i mean uh i love i love games with with hidden information so anytime that you know something

other players don't is it's very werewolf android netrunner these games that i've talked about already fit into that because of that um Well, sorry, I don't want to go on no jumping have you played blood on the clock tower because that one Feels like it could be a mixture Due to all of the the unique powers that it has in conjunction. Yeah, I Haven't no I love to okay. It's it's it's one of those things that like in my current

period of my life with family and stuff, getting a such a big group together. A friend of mine owns it and he's desperate to get it played. Okay, the only reason I bring it up is because just that, you know, that hidden information mixed with a good variety of player powers, I think makes that one interesting. But okay, sorry, I didn't. No, not at all. No, I would love to play that. I mean, I don't know if I can think of anything better at the moment. I was like, where you really have power? I mean, Ghost Stories

is one that like, I don't know why that comes to mind. I haven't played it in years, but Ghost Stories jumps to mind as being, I like feeling the power of the ghosts is sort of reversed, that they're really powerful. Sometimes there's some ghosts come out that you think, how are we gonna beat this ghost? Like it, especially when you get towards the boss at the end, it just seems so powerful and yet, That's the beauty of that game is that you you have built all power by that point if you do if you played the game

well and So you can you feel so powerful by the end because you if you win because you've overcome massive odds it feels like Yeah Nice Yeah, I haven't this is nice because I feel like yeah a lot of a lot of the games that you've brought up are ones That I haven't played And some of the ones that I've brought up are ones that you haven't played, too. Yeah, absolutely. Nice cross

-section. Power. How, I guess, when you're thinking about... So, yeah, you brought up a few things. You brought up power of information and knowing things that other players might not know or just having access to that information. the example you picked with ghost stories is the power from, you know, like the AI or the enemy that you're going up against. How about, I mean, I'm just

curious. I actually don't really play a ton of the the kind of quote unquote Euro games that grant players unique powers that Where they, you know, they'll be described as all of them are broken, but you all have like your, you each have your own. Yeah. Yeah. Huh. Well, I don't know. I am immediately struck by my, probably my favorite game at the moment. I don't know why I didn't think of this, but Cosmic Encounter. Oh, okay. Cosmic Encounter is, it's like head

to head, neck and neck with Android Netrunners, my favorite game. Cosmic is absolutely that it's these completely broken powers and it does it in such a beautiful way as well where it your power is only active when you reveal it and So unless it's one that well, there's certain ones that require setup at the beginning of the game So you you are forced to reveal that immediately but all the others You you start with your power

card face down And sometimes you'll go the entire game without revealing it and manage to win just because the threat of revealing it is enough sometimes. People wonder what it is and suspect what it might be, why you're still holding it back. And we just have a little, in my group that plays it, we have this when you reveal it, you also have to read the flavour text at the

bottom, which kind of introduces your alien species on the universal stage. And then these kind of pretty cheesy bits of writing and stuff, but we do it in such a way that it's like, do not laugh at my do not laugh at my alien race you know this is that would be my alien species do not laugh at my alien species you know i'm gonna read this very seriously and you're gonna take me very seriously even though i'm a cute cuddly

cat called the loser or something you know but then the power behind it is like everybody goes like you can do what no way that is it's crazy that's so powerful and then another person reveals what so Yeah, that's why I love it because it's so wonky and funny and yet at the same time knows exactly what it's doing with giving you a feeling of power. Yeah. That's awesome. Okay. Well, yeah,

you hit... I mean, in general, there's... You know billions or not billions. There's so many games I haven't played but you're hitting on another one that I haven't So the only thing it's not even it doesn't even seem analogous to me but a game that has an interesting escalation of power and You know, maybe some of that that knowledge of like the cards you have and others don't have and and there's I think one card of each each Era that isn't available in it, but innovation Have you played innovation? Yeah,

once or twice. I need to get back to it. I've played that one so many times, but in that one, once you get into those higher ages, some of those cards are so wild and you have to balance so many other things to the point where you might not even get to those higher age cards. The game could be over way before then. You could see your opponent Just adding, you know, boatloads of cards to their hands like do they have the

card that's going that they're gonna play it and then they can score all the cards from their hand and and in this case, it's not necessarily the reveal of a an alien race or character that you have but it's just like, you know, which cards are in the deck still which cards do I have which cards might they have and and as you do climb higher just the the ability to you know, destroy especially in the new version Destroy achievements or get rid of like an entire deck or things like that. I don't know. It's it's

funny. I like it Yeah, Carl Chudik is a master of that. I mean Glory to Rome. It's one of my favorites. That's I played that a lot more than innovation yeah, just a master of the power curve and Once you get rolling in some of it some of these games like there's no stopping you and it's it's such a thrill again You can get completely off the rails with just some crazy deck, but then I've seen I've seen games where I've, like I played a game of Glory to Rome where it seemed like I was on this huge power curve and then

another player got on a different power curve and then completely overtook me and it was this, wow, like how, that's even crazier. Like it's, yeah, so good. I've got to get back to innovation, especially with that new version. Yes. It looks so good. Yeah, it was funny because I mean, I've... Basically, all of my plays have been online, so I was playing with the old Deluxe one, and then the new version came out. Speaking of mastering

competition and things like that, I like to try to play to win. I'm not going to get crazy about it. But at this point... my knowledge of the cards, it's always been fine. I've played the game like 60 or 70 times, but I don't, I couldn't even tell you what the main differences between the two are. And I know, I know that some of them are like, you know, junkie an entire like era of cards or getting rid of achievements is more prominent in this one. But I know that some of the individual cards have been tweaked and, and other things. And it's just funny, like my

brain has shifted to the new version. And yeah, I I so I would recommend the new one at first I was like a little hesitant because I'd played so many games at the other one right but now that the shift is is complete and I'm into that one so well I think a friend of mine picked it up so the new version so I'm gonna have to chase him down and see uh see if we can get a game of it yeah yeah I think yeah you mentioned the power curve that's like a really good phrase to to uh to know what uh Carl Chudik is doing

well but speaking of Carl's and and doing let's transition to help a little bit and In in that conversation you did bring up some some of these you know elements of fun or types of fun in relation to to your game Some of the you know, the tactility you mentioned the tiles specifically as one that you liked and I know that came up a couple other times But you know to you having played your

game Well, you having played your game a whole bunch, which I'm going to give you two or three of these 20 types of fun do you feel that Kelp hits on the most? Like if you're going to like synthesize and again, obviously it's more than just a few of them as to why like people are loving your game. But what are the three in your mind that you think it is kind of like doing

the most? The first one is, is a, is a no brainer for me. And that's the one we didn't talk about. She, she's interesting, which is the thrill of danger. Um, I think that is, I absolutely designed the game around everything around that core experience of a thrill of danger. And it's, it's the thrill of danger for both sides. It's, um, the friend that doesn't know kelp is a game of court. Octopus vs Shark. It's about a pajama shark hunting an

octopus in a kelp forest. I was inspired by the Netflix documentary My Octopus Teacher, which I highly recommend if you haven't seen it. In a nutshell, it's a deeply asymmetric game where the octopus player is playing with these mahjong blocks on which one of them the octopus is hidden, and they are upright facing the octopus player. And they're manipulating them, they're using

kind of a deck building game to manipulate these blocks, move them around, keep them hidden, shuffle them up at a cost of like every time they want to play a card, they have to reveal one of these nine blocks to the shark by giving away information to gain kind of a chance to... play a shell game with these blocks mix them around and try to survive. Meanwhile the shark on the other side is playing a dice pool building game where they're rolling dice placing them on the board for their their effects which are to move faster to reveal

blocks and ultimately to attack them. But the octopus player also has some trap blocks that they can put out that that affect the shark and I kind of built it around these trade -offs that both players are playing so the shark, the trade -off is the shark in order to gain abilities that allow it to reroll dice and manipulate its kind of position on the board. The cost of that is that they advance their, they advance closer to death and to lose in the game. And every time

they attack and miss, that advances and closer to death as well. So you've got the thrill of danger, which I love from the octopus side is this kind of I like the heart pounding, but you've got to keep a poker face because you can't reveal all the information that you know where you're hiding a lot of bluffing and things like that. And then the thrill, hopefully, for the shark is that the stakes are really high. If they don't catch this octopus, it could result in their loss, their death. And like I talked about multiple

times, Android Netrunner, this kind of core of that experience is, for me, the same as in Netrunner, that you are, that's a game where you're, one player's a corporation, the other player is like a futuristic mega -coop, and one player's a hacker trying to break into their systems and steal files, and the corporation has traps and ambushes and all these very dangerous things that can kill the hacker and so, or the runner. So, I... I absolutely love that experience in games. That's

like a drug to me. I just want that kind of like that thrill of danger because yeah, talking about real like horror and you know, in a way like real world analogies. I think the same reason we watch horror films at the same region. I like to play games with the thrill of dangers because hopefully in our lives, we're not experiencing a lot of that and it's a really safe environment with which to get a yeah and that's why it is thrilling because it's a safe environment where we can explore that feeling and sensation and

i for one love it yeah um so that was that's one of them you you said for three but i'll give you i'll give you a one one to three you can pick a couple more okay i'll just say one more then i think um so um and well i already talked about discovery so that's come back to, but I talked about Kelp a little bit there with discoveries and the moment of the flip, the moment of the big reveal. And so that's a part of it. And there

are a couple of elements else, like the kind of final moment of Kelp is what we call the confrontation, where it's this rock, paper, scissors -like mechanism where each pair, well, the octopus has three options of escape and the Shark has three counters to counter those escape strategies, and each of the cards has a different effect that the Octopus can employ, which will be better or worse depending on the situation that they're in. So

there's a lot of mind games that take place in that moment, and it's a moment for me of discovery where each player simultaneously picks one of them, places it face down and then... you simultaneously reveal. And that's usually a big moment where it's this moment of discovery. What did you play and what's the outcome of the game going to be? And it can resort in some stand -up moments where victory is gained or lost. So that's one. That's two. And then sensation. I talked about the other

one, but it's a game where the components, the publisher that made Kelp. did just an absolutely stellar job with a production. And these, from the dice to the moving of the mini, the shark, I really wanted the shark to feel as fine as you move it around the board. It looks like it's swimming up on this. It's raised up on a swirl of kelp. So it looks like it's patrolling and swimming above the board. And you can do jaws, sound effects as you move it around the board.

both sides have really satisfying I believe really satisfying haptics in the game where the octopus is manipulating these blocks that revealing them and swapping them and shuffling them in a bag and meanwhile the shark is rolling and placing dice on the board and moving this this miniature around the board in a really hopefully thematic and satisfying way so I really thought a lot about sensation while designing the game and and how I could make that as satisfying as possible for both sides, given that it's an asymmetric

game and you're doing different things. Yeah. That's awesome. And, and yeah, I mean, you mentioned that, you know, you know, between like publishing, production, art, like helps bring all of this to life. The game, the game is, is really good. So the game would have been really good no matter what, but it definitely like thinking of those sensation elements and and how they tie into the thrill of danger and the discovery. They

all tie together really well. When it is that reveal, when you have that discovery and having these things exist in different ways at different times. That's awesome. Again, we didn't really get super... Super. Well, we got far. We got almost halfway through our list. It just means we can have another session another time. I know.

And that one, too, well, speaking of discovery for that one, you'll have the game plan ahead of time. You know what's coming. There's going to be no surprise there, unless I pull a twist on you or something. We'll wrap up with like kind of like the two questions and I had I had even more and I think I'll try to tie one of the thoughts Into like the the final final question,

but the final two questions are, you know asking you about a text It doesn't have to be a game Something that's been on your mind and then also just what you've been working on and things that you want people To look out for from you, but but I'll also tie this conversation of fun into that that question a little bit But again, I don't want to keep you here forever. But we'll start with that penultimate one. And what's something that you have been watching or playing or listening to that has stuck out to you? Yeah, sure. The

thing that comes to mind recently, actually, is a YouTube channel called Wintergarten. I don't know if you're familiar with Wintergarten. It's a channel where the guy on the channel is trying to make a marble machine. In fact, for the third time, he's trying to make a marble machine that plays music. He made the marble machine, I almost

got a decade or more ago now, and it was this viral video. It's this kind of whirly, what was it called? Whirly gig? Is it a whirly gig? Well, I can think of his Cole Worley's design studio now when I think of Worley. Like a Rube Goldberg? Yeah, but a Worley gig is like a music machine that you wind up and it plays. He made this wooden contraption organ Worley gig music box machine

thing. A bit like a little music box that you might buy in a in a gift shop on steroids and more. And then he was kind of disappointed in that as a finished project. So started working on the Marble Machine X and did a lot of work on that for a few years and then canned that. And he's now working on another version of the Marble Machine. And his plan is to kind of tour

the world with a huge stage size machine that can play music alongside him and his band. But what's really fascinating to me particularly is what took place last year through 2024 in his videos. He sort of had a bit of an existential crisis about the project and about his place as a designer and went back to some kind of fundamental

things about how he approaches design. And of course, it's got nothing to do with board game design and yet everything to do with board game design and just design in general. And so he went through this sort of crisis where he dug into some real core principles about what makes good design and how you design something. And he posted this one video, I don't remember the title of it, but it was something like slaying the 10 slaying the ten monsters of design. And

it was absolutely fascinating to see him go through this process of kind of wrestling with the vision of this project and how to implement it and his instincts as a designer and where to curb them and curtail them and when to let them flourish. And just there's been so many bits of wisdom from it. And he's working on this really fascinating and inventive and seemingly impossible project

as well. I highly recommend it. If you're interested in design in general, if you're interested in music, he's a fantastic musician, or just you want to go down a rabbit hole on YouTube for a while, Wintergarten, really, really recommend. Oh, awesome. I can't even say that I heard of it, but I do have it pulled up. And I like falling down YouTube rabbit holes, so I've got a new one. That's a good one. All right. Perfect. Well,

we're toward the wrap up question or the wrap up for now. And you mentioned that you were working on some expansion material for Kelp, or we're in talks with the publisher about that a little bit previously. And I know you've talked about Blue Sky and kind of like reflecting on your design process and then fun as well. But I've seen that you've been posting about a, I think it was at least the working title is Den. So

kind of another two player head to head game as well. But I guess the final question then is, What are some things that you want people to look out for from you? And then just kind of tying that into another question that I had linked to this conversation about the different types of fun. So what do you want people to look out for from you and how has this kind of like recent exploration into these ideas and you know

collaborating and talking about people informed some of the things that you're currently working on? I mean you know obviously in an abridged version because we talked about it a bit but like how you know yeah that's that's a question I won't keep you to that question. Yeah sure um yeah it's interesting I So Den, I have been posting about that. Like it's not a confirmed game or anything like that from, it's not a signed game or anything. I'm still in development with it, but it's Den Fox versus Badger is my kind

of working title. You're absolutely right. Yeah. It's another two player asymmetric game, deeply asymmetric nature themed. I'm fascinated by these relationships in nature. And that's one that is interesting. It's a very different relationship to the one from Kelp, which is hunter -hunted. In Den, it's a commensal relationship, and commensalism is where two animals kind of work, not together, but they have some benefit, they have a relationship

in which it gives some kind of benefit to maybe one party more than another party permits it because it gets some benefits from it. It's not a mutualist, it's something similar to mutualism. I think I'm not a biologist so I don't know the exact kind of nuances of these things but essentially the relationship is it's been kind of studied that foxes will have been known to try to move into the den or the set of a badger while the

badger is still living there and they do this even though the badger is the dominant animal. could kill a fox, they do it by leaving food, tributes, like gifts, in the den as they kind of move in. And they kind of sustain that food giving until the badger has kind of permitted it to move into the den. And so that would be fascinating in itself, but then the relationship can also extend to them going and hunting together. So they'd be kind of... build relationships to

the point where they may go out regularly and hunt side by side. And even to the point, which has not been studied so much, but seems to be evidence that they may even raise cubs together. So there's photographs of badges, adult badges in the field with fox cubs and vice versa. So there's this sort of fascinating relationship in nature, but yeah, it's laced with tension. because, like I said, the badger can kill the fox or the fox could take too much of it. They're

competing for the very similar food in the food that they eat. So there's an element of competition there where the badger could also be kind of in decline because if the fox flourishes too much. So I'm trying to capture that in a game that is for two players. And, you know, the second part of your question, like how is thinking about fun influenced that? It absolutely has because I'm getting better and I think I've still got

a long way to go. When I start working on a project, having a really robust and complete vision for the game, specifically relating to what kinds of fun and experiences I'm trying to deliver for players. So I'm now on a kind of a third major version of Den because each time I have realized my vision for the game wasn't rich or strong enough. Like I was capturing elements of the theme, but not everything. So like the first version was just about them being in competition

and collaborating a little bit and the fox kind of leaving gifts in the den. And then I realized that wasn't really enough. So I went back and added in a level of survival, like just trying to survive at the same time a year and get through winter, very cruel, brutal winter, which kind of heightened the stakes. And then I realized still that wasn't enough. It was like, well, what's special about these characters? So my current version, I'm really trying to bring an element of the, well, the Fox is a trickster in folklore. So, and kind of bringing in a little

bit of more bluffing and sneakiness on the part of the Fox. And our, we talked about power for the Badger. I want the Badger player to feel like they're the dominant one in this relationship, but that they can't. abuse that too much, or it will backfire on them. So as I kind of work through this vision, I'm going back to my core systems again, and trying to make them deliver that in as holed a way as possible, and then

in the most direct way as possible. So yeah, that's one of the big things I'm working on at the moment. And as you said, as I said, the Kelp, an expansion for Kelp is something that's hopefully in the pipeline at some point that I'm still developing and testing a lot and working on that. And then also I had the idea because of again thinking about fun of potentially coming up with a kelp junior or a kid's kind of a kid's version of kelp that I think has some potential. So that's

another project that I'm having a go at. It's a lot of kind of related projects at the moment because my time is fairly limited. So a lot of my other ideas for games like said I kind of had an idea for a, um, a, um, Victorless game, an unranked game. That's still really much just an idea and kind of working on the vision. But, uh, and then, uh, uh, last thing I'll quickly mention is also, I think there's a lot of space within the system of kelp of revealing blocks

and the hidden kind of movement game. So I had another game about, again, a relationship, a hunter -hunted relationship that I'm working on with a, uh, collaborator called field. which is field owl versus mice and so that's kind of more of a direct if that ever came to be it would be more of a direct sequel to to kelp just with a different set of animals so a different kind of a different flavor to the game some different mechanisms in there but um yeah it's a lot of exciting stuff for me also frustrating because

i want to do so much and i've only got limited time but yeah yeah that. I mean, that all sounds like absolutely fantastic. And, you know, first off, you know, congratulations on the success, like the tremendous success of a first project. Like, you know, it's been extremely well received. I've I've got we mentioned we talked previously, I've been able to play at the one time and I really like it. And I'm looking forward to losing at it many more times in the future. So yeah,

I I Great. I'm excited to, you know, see your development process, like appreciative, well, A, that you outline it and like post and, you know, work through it in the social media space. And I really appreciate you taking the time to talk about the thoughts here and just taking the time to talk with me in general. I've had what I can only deem, well, it was super fun. Me too right now. I really, really enjoyed it.

I'm glad to do this again at some point in the future. Finch it off. Perfect. Well, we definitely will. We will finish. Or else, yeah. Or else it is, we're incomplete right now. We're like two hours in and we're not done, so. All right. Well, have a great day. Oh yeah, you too. Intertextual Cardboard Experience. the most fun podcast about board games and any other text that they connect to. Thank you so much for spending your time

here. Your support through listening to this podcast means everything to the show's success. If you enjoyed the project, consider giving us a rating or review and sharing it with any other people in your life you would feel would like it as well. Any further support such as sending an email to say hey, following some of the show's social media accounts, or contributing any monetary support to help pay for some necessary subscriptions would be greatly appreciated. All of that information can be found in the show notes. Until next time,

keep playing, watching, reading, listening, experiencing.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. #49 - Eric Dietel: Good Conversation High Intertextuality

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    You are chasing the elusive high score-the ability to carve your initials (or some other inappropriate word or abbreviation) digitally into your favorite machine. The perfect combination of greasy, sticky, and fast...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. #48 - David Masnato: Pax @ PAX

    Sep 3, 20261 hr 36 minAudio

    From the slight burn of a slide that’s gotten too hot in the late afternoon sun to the sense of ecstasy (mixed with a slight tinge of panic) from getting a little higher on the swing than you’d ever gotten before-and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. #47 - Jeff Grisenthwaite: Board Game Are(ca)na

    Aug 13, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    As fate and coincidence would have it, designer Jeff Grisenthwaite and I had actually met and played games together once and then played games at different tables of a smaller meetup just months after that. It wasn’t...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. #46 - Amabel Holland: Episode of Six Video Essays

    Jul 24, 20261 hr 30 minAudio

    Back like it never left, Intertextual Experience welcomes Amabel Holland - designer, video essayist, author, and co-owner of Hollandspiele - for its forty-sixth episode. Amabel has been making my favorite board game...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. #45 - Taylor Reiner: The Quiz 2 – Trick-Taking Romanticism – Everything’s a Sequel – You Can’t End on a Toot for Me, I’m Gonna Toot on You

    Apr 2, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    Taylor Reiner. The Quiz 2. Since Taylor was on the show in September 2023, he’s been busy with designing, developing, making videos, and more. We get to explore some of the things Taylor has been working on through the...

    Credit the people on this episode