Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Intertextual Experience: A Board Game Podcast

Intertextual Experience: A Board Game Podcast artwork

#18 - David Thompson: Collabstraction 2: The Collabstractioning

Apr 22, 20241 hr 36 minAudio

In the rare sequel that’s just as good as its predecessor, David Thompson joins the show for “Collabstraction 2: The Collabstractioning.” We talk about some similar ideas in the topics of collaboration and abstraction, but we also discuss the ideas of sequels/iterations/expansions. It was really interesting getting to hear the slight differences in the overall approach to design and the fact that David has designed in the solo and historical spaces a little more, and, obviously, it was just a blast. Collab-introduction From growing up in “board game adjacent” spaces of RPGs and skirmish games to how David’s background in different types of systems led to early designs to David’s response to a couple of the questions that the “Grim Reaper” received in the previous episode, there are many stories and laughs in this part. “His Favorite Color is Chrome” (1:01:53) Hearing David talk about chrome and “chrome budget” (I love that phrase/had never heard it before) brought about the title of that ridiculous 2001 Trace Adkins song. I was going to link it, but I couldn’t bring myself to do it. So if you seek it out, that’s on you. Anyway, David discusses why certain choices are made for certain games and talks about the Valiant Defense series of games, which are wonderfully interesting solo war games. Following-up (1:13:30) As this is a part two, I have some questions and thoughts that almost come out as questions about some of the aforementioned sequels/iterations/expansions. Naturally, David answers them wonderfully. Wrapping-up (1:24:43) A text on David’s mind and the many things to look out for from him soon! David on BoardGameGeek & Twitter ---------------------------------------------------------- Contact, follow, and support information: vodthepod@gmail.com Twitter Instagram General feedback form - (your thoughts are appreciated!) Buy Me a Coffee

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Intertextual cardboard experience. Two episodes in a row, two prologues in a row. So my apologies for having you stuck with me for a minute before the episode starts. But if you couldn't tell by the episode's title, this is A, it's going to be awesome. And B, it is a follow -up, a sequel. or perhaps even in board game terms a standalone

sequel to my last episode with Trevor Benjamin. So just keeping things consistent and also honestly just the way that things felt and flowed for this conversation and last. So an interesting parallel there. Coming up with an audio break, having kind of that that chapter sound effect just just wasn't working uh so we'll we'll keep

it consistent so colabstraction one well now colabstraction one and now this colabstraction two the colabstractioning with david thompson will not have the sound effects but i have been trying to have the episode image for for each episode and this one will tie to something that

happens within the episode itself so take a look at that picture listen to the episode and see where it all comes together but enough of that it is time for the cola abstractioning Hello and welcome to intertextual cardboard experience a podcast that is now old enough to vote Thanks in part to its excellent 18th guest David Thompson. How are you doing today? I'm awesome. Yeah, thanks

for having me Yeah, yeah, I I Wanted to clarify quick. I wasn't making light of voting rights by this podcast being 18 I was mostly thought of it because I've seen Pictures video or heard you talking about votes for women so many times. I just wanted to just kind of give that game a shout out Yeah, that was one of my favorites. It was probably my favorite game of 2022 and Definitely one that my daughter and I have played

a lot. So we only play it I will say we only play it co -op. We don't actually play Competitive because neither neither of us wants to play opposition Yeah, yeah, I think I I heard Uh, you talking about that pretty recently that that's how you play it. So is through the co -op but um kind of a Well, because I was thinking about it a a little bit of a side tangent. I i've I mean it's been on my radar everybody loves that game Yeah, and I Previous episode or a few episodes

back. I I think I mentioned that where I live, um Like the town I live in just got a new you know, local game store. And on my birthday, my wife took me into the game store for the first time. We were able to kind of like make it out there. And it was really neat. Big fan of the store. It was just a cool place. They had really promoted, you know, diversity, inclusivity, just, you know, those were like all the posters, all

on the forefront. It's like kind of just making sure that everyone feels like welcome. And they really kind of spotlighted a lot of... I talked to them later about some independent designers that they're in contact with, and they're really spotlighting certain games like Votes for Women. So I'm working up my store credit by selling some consignment to get that game. No, it's awesome. Yeah, I love the game. That sounds like an amazing store. So that's really cool. Yeah, I've only

been in a few stores total, and maybe due to the fact that it's relatively close to me, I have that bias, but it's the coolest one I've seen, so it's very nice. It sounds great. And you know, one thing I just thought about, and I said it was my favorite game of 2022, and that is true, my favorite game of 2023 was a game called Land and Freedom, and it just occurred to me that both, and I know this, but both of those are by first -time designers, so that's really interesting. and both great games, both designed by great people. Yeah, I've heard a

lot about that. That's a three player semi co -op game. Yeah, I mean, technically you can play it solo or two player, but you really, I think you really want to have three players to get the full experience. And it is a semi co -op game. I'm not really a fan typically of semi co -op, but it does it in an extremely smart way. that keeps all three players in it until the very end. Your chances of winning might be low or extremely low, but you're in it. So it doesn't come up, that issue of, oh, well, I'm

out of the game, so I'm going to throw the game that you see in some semi -coops. That doesn't come up. So it's a brilliant game about the Spanish Civil War. Yeah, it's definitely, I mean, I'm sure probably some of the other interviews that I'd mentioned, I'd heard you talking about it, and I know that. Well, you were just on the board game geek podcast with Candice Harris, and I'm not sure if you talked about it there, but I know that Candice has talked about it a couple of times as well. So yeah, yeah, I didn't. I

didn't talk about it only because we were discussing our I think it was like our favorite historical games for new people into historically and something like that. And I specifically stayed away from any game that I thought might be considered a war game. I was trying to go with non -war themed historical games. But if it was there for the taking, it would have been on top of my list. That's just me blending all the words and audio that I hear all the time. But no, that's really

good stuff. That's actually kind of I'll kind of skip ahead, but that's a good segue, because you mentioned that both of those games were by first -time designers. This is a chance for me to be wrong. But if I'm not mistaken, your first design was the For What Remains series? Kind of. It depends on the way you look at it. It certainly was my first design that I worked on, but it didn't get published until much later. And that's always the tricky bit. I think, technically,

my first published game was a game called Armageddon that I designed with Chris Marling. It was published by Queen. I think it came out in 2016. But it was designed after games like For What Remains and Undaunted and Switch and Signal and many other games. So it's just the interesting thing with the publication schedule. Oftentimes, what you design is not what gets published first.

And you talked, you know, obviously when you talked to Trevor, I can't, I don't think you guys actually discussed this, but you know, Warchest and Undaunted share a lot of DNA, right? And in Undaunted, Warchest was specifically an effort, an intentional effort to turn Undaunted into sort of this minimalist sort of abstract kind of game. And what's interesting is Undaunted was designed first, but Warchest was published first. So people will often invert that, they'll kind of associate the two, but assume that Undaunted was inspired by the design from More Chest. But

it's opposite way. So yeah, so you're working on Undaunted and then wanted to make it that a little bit more minimalist. That's very interesting too, yeah, because I mean, you know, unless people... would specifically have that knowledge. I mean, it would make sense in terms of like, I played this game first, then I played this one. So right. Right. Absolutely. No war chest was very much Trevor had the idea. He said, Hey, what happens if we take undaunted and we just strip it to its absolute core and take out the the randomness

of combat and that kind of stuff. So, yeah, it was definitely an intentional, you know, intent to share the DNA, but push it in a new direction for sure. Yeah, I know there's a chance I knew it. Chance I did it. But nonetheless, I think that's really interesting Yeah, and I you know, I promised myself I wasn't gonna call him out. I should be calling him the Grim Reaper But hey,

I mean that that would be like a perfect anecdote of a time where he was like undaunted too much That's funny, but okay, so you said that For what remains was one of your the first designs that you were working on and the reason I was kind of thinking about that is well a I mean, I've played most your games and I love them all and I was just taking a look at your your site

and it was just like a little blurb on the about site that you have in it and mentioned that your interest in playing and designing games exploded when you started working on for What Remains. So then one of my questions was then, you know, kind of what about that process or working on that game did kind of spark that passion or that explosion for you? Yeah. So it's interesting.

That game is very different than everything else I've worked on because of where it went and where it came from. So I grew up as a role -playing game guy. I did not play like, you know, hobby board games. We know them. And so that was really true. Like I really, I just played RPGs up until probably my thirties. And now I had played a few things. So I had played like Blood Bowl, if you know it right. So the games workshop board

game that uses some of the inspiration from Warhammer type stuff. And before Mage Knight, the board game, there was Mage Knight, the clicks game. So like little skirmishy fighting guys that predated hero clicks of people if people know what that is. And so there were very few things that you would call like tabletop games outside of the role playing game space that were so popular. that you could find them at the stores you would go to to buy comics and RPGs and stuff. But I

have this vague recollection of going into a store to buy probably RPG stuff and seeing it probably was Twilight Imperium and thinking like, what is that? I don't have a clue what that is, but it looks kind of cool, but I just don't know what it is. And so I really didn't know that the world of board games even existed, but I had I had grown up on Japanese RPGs and stuff like that. So games like Final Fantasy Tactics,

video games like that. Or I was talking to a friend today about the game Fallout Tactics. So I didn't play Fallout 1 and 2, I played Fallout Tactics. So there was this whole genre of video games that were like tactical turn -based games. And like I said, Blood Bowl and Hero Clicks and of course D &D. And so I had all these little inspirations. And so I started working on a game and that game would eventually many years later become for what remains. But this was in a time where I didn't, like I said, I didn't really know that board games existed. So at the time

I had no concept of this mashup that you see everywhere now of like this hybrid of board games and miniature skirmish games. And so that's kind of what I was working on. And then the real magic was when I got married and started having kids. And I decided that RPGs took up too much time because I was always the DM. So I was always spending all my time like prepping. I was prepping for the campaign that nobody would ever see the material that I was that guy. And so I was like, oh, this is taking away too much time. I can't spend this much time on gaming. And so I'll just

and so long story short, I basically found my way to board games in an attempt to reduce the amount of time I was spending in the hobby, which of course, massive backfire. completely backfired. But what happened was, you know, I saw that, you know, I was introduced and really the first type of board games I was introduced to is what we would call a merit trash or thematic games. So obviously, there was a pair, you know, there was there was this tie to what I had been working on, and it was eye opening. I was like, Oh, okay.

And so many years later, evolutions introduction to euros and war games and hybrids and all that kind of stuff. the game that would eventually become For What Remains was informed by all that discovery. And so, yeah, I mean, eventually it adopted what most people would consider some war game concepts, right? And so that's the game that was eventually published. But yeah, it dated back to, the design dated back to the mid -2000s before I even knew what board games were. So

it was a very long, strange evolution of a design. for sure yeah that's that's neat so i mean just kind of like you said having having all these things that you are like you know partaking in all these board game adjacent kind of quote unquote activities and and having this design you know kicking around for so long and then then it does kind of just seem like an explosion because then after that you know the number of games that that you're designing and published or getting published every year is just Increasing and increasing

so yeah Well, I tell people because a lot of people ask they're like, how do you you know? How are you able to work and it's not like kinesia numbers, right? Of course because no human can achieve that he's he's like a robot but But you know, it's usually like I give myself a goal of having four games published a year. That's my goal and And I always tell people that the way I'm able to do that is basically you'll note that almost everything I design now is a co -design. And so I really don't actually do any of the work. I just pay people to put my name on it

and take credit. So I don't have to actually do anything. I just do my name on everything. And I get half the royalties, which means I get like $1 .50 every year. So it's great. Oh, man. I haven't really designed anything outside of... you know, kicking around ideas and stuff like that. But maybe I'll just start paying people to design my games. I can. But you and I would have a problem. That means we can collaborate, right? One of us would actually have to do something. So we would have an issue. It'd be it'd be some

sort of like weird, weird metagame. And people would like just some experimental piece of art. The game is like you're two players and you're waiting for the first one to make the move and actually do the task. A different. a different type of semi -coop game. Well, I don't know. Maybe once I get really, I don't know, is esoteric the right word? Sometimes I say things and I don't know if it's right, but once I'm feeling

that, I'll... We'll put it out there, all right? It exists. It's just not on BGG. You haven't heard of it. That's right. Oh, that's awesome. So you mentioned that you played a lot of role playing games. Was there one that you played the most? Yeah, I definitely grew up on D &D. Now, I mean, I played a lot of other things. So I'm I'm 45 to give people like a sort of a sense of the time I grew up. So I grew up. It

was funny. You know, I distinctly remember when I started playing D &D. my brother, who's a year older than I, we started on, we had the second edition, advanced under the dragon's books, core books, but the first edition Forgotten Realms module, and we didn't know that there was a difference between them. And they're really, to be honest, there's not that much of a difference. But it was funny, like, as a kid looking back, how much you didn't care about things like what actual

rule set you were playing with and things right you just it's like oh it's just a game and it doesn't matter that there's slightly different rules and and all that stuff like you just it doesn't register um but that was that was the sort of time period i was growing up now um there were other plenty of other games that that you know like there was a system called palladium which had a lot of warts and stuff but it was very it had a lot of really interesting lore and And it was a Marvel game, you know, role -playing game at that period. So I bounced around, but D &D was always the one that I would basically

stick with. And I basically played Dungeons & Dragons almost nonstop from, like I said, that sort of first slash second edition AD &D through fourth edition. And then I had dabbled in fifth edition with my kids a little bit. and I love it. It's great. It's just not something I do nearly as much as I used to. But yeah, the kids and I have tried it and we loved it. Nice. Kind of a little bit of a connection to the aforementioned

in the episode before this with Trevor. And he mentioned that he wishes that he had more time because there's been so many different Types of role -playing games lately things that are you know, new systems like longer shorter? Everywhere kind of in between has there been anything lately that you have been able to get into whether it is Like a different system or just like one of their the shorter kind of one -off types or yeah

Well, you know, it's what's interesting with my kids were a little younger. So I have three kids They're now this effectively 15 13 and 10, but when they were really young um so my girls when they were probably like seven and five or so we played a lot of the my little pony game that's what they grew up on the my little pony role -playing game which is funny because i mean that's what they they were interested in at the time so that's why i got it um was a very easy system to run but of course it puts me in the unenviable position of like running kids through

a campaign setting that I basically know nothing about, they know everything about, I'm expected to be the danger master, but we play that. Here's the funny thing about my kids, so we don't really play a whole lot of anything now much, except for my 13 year old daughter, she'll play anything with me, but we don't play a lot of RPGs, but I would love to pick up something off the shelf, especially some of the quicker, you know, lighter stuff and just play that because it's just so much easier to pick up and play. But they were

very much, what's the word, inspired, I guess, by Stranger Things. So they just want to play D &D because they know D &D, right? That's the brand, right? So it's been very effective in that. And so that's what they want to play when we're able to play. So we really haven't. I did play a game called Carolina Deathcrawl by Jason Morningstar, I believe. There's a Night Witches, very appropriate, and there's a Night Witches RPG that I would love to play at some point.

I think it would be awesome if Liz and I could play it together, potentially with Jason, who was the designer of that one. That would be really cool if I could pick one to do. But I haven't actually played anything myself, other than just one or two one -shots every once in a while. Nice, yeah. I was just curious because, you know... the the you mentioned that you Kind of pick games to save a little bit of time that backfired and I was just curious Where where where that was

on your kind of like current radar and what you're doing. So, yeah Nice, okay, so I I kind of skipped ahead past a I don't know. It was meant to be a transition or introductory type of thought but It's been brought up a couple times, and last episode I was extremely fortunate to talk to one of your frequent co -designers in Trevor Benjamin, and I titled that episode Co -abstraction.

And then today's episode is going to be called Co -abstraction 2, the Co -abstractioning. Yes, yes. It sounds very intense. There are some examples of sequels that are better than the original. So I'm going to tell the Grim Reaper that the next time I see him. Well, here's the question, though. So the implication of the title is that we're going to talk about some similar things, but not, and also kind of that idea of sequels

and iterations, too. Yeah, of course. Sure. Of course. So I get to start you off on a difficult question and you kind of almost hit it on the head, but I don't even have an answer. Most of the time, if I think of a question, I have some idea of what I would pick. But do you have any example of a movie or show that kind of mid -series or, yeah, mid -series, whether it was a show from season to season or from movie to movie,

where the actor or a particular character was swapped out and they wound up being more well known or played that role better. Well so I mean I can certainly there are examples of that having happened but I can't think of any absolute major ones where like oh this is much better except now this isn't directly answering your question

because this is not like mid series, but if we include reboots, then Battlestar Galactica has a lot of examples where like Starbuck was infinite. I mean, nothing against Dirk Benedict. I think it was the actor's name, but like the new Starbuck is Starbuck, right? So I think in reboots, we can come up with a lot of examples. In mid series, I mean, I would struggle to think of anything that's like a substantive example of that. That's

a good question, though. Yeah, you were you were like right on it right away. You had that thought like I came up with a question and I had nothing I I thought you were gonna ask I thought you're gonna ask You know a series that sort of evolved such that that it got better as it went on or something like that Right, and I will just quickly note for for people listening that might be interested I I watched the expanse, but I did not watch it like all at once. And when I first started,

I did not have not read the books. So I should I should admit, say that this is from a guy who has not read the books. But I just wasn't into the show that much. And I don't watch a ton of TV. So it took me a long time. But I did kind of like push through the seasons eventually until we got to like season five and six. And, whoa, boy, they're really good, really good. So, you know. If we can talk about the series in this and of course, there's Star Trek Next Generation. There's so many examples of like, you know, it's a show that takes a season or two to get its

footing under it. But yeah. Yeah, that's funny. I've heard a good number of people speak highly of The Expanse, but I don't know if I don't necessarily know if they have that same sentiment or if they thought it was good from the beginning, though. Yeah, I'm not sure. A lot of people like that from the beginning, especially if they like the book. It was this it was sort of like the focus of the show, especially when it hit season five, that really it got a little bit more into like sort of the military, political stuff and a little

less about the the whatever you call it, the MacGuffin of the of the show with the photo molecule that was sort of the underpinning of the concept that I didn't care as much about. So but that so that sort of like focus, it shifted and I was always on board for that. Nice yeah, I I definitely I mean I go through kind of kind of like you know peaks and and valleys for most most of my hobbies whether it's you know board

games or video games or shows or movies, but that's why I Created this podcast so I can bring up random stuff whenever I feel like it so you can do whatever you want I can Exactly and and just giving it a name like intertextual cardboard experience just gives it like the easiest catch all of all time. Awesome. Okay. Well, I've got a not too many questions, kind of like a couple

more collaboration questions and then a little bit more open -ended one. So you brought up the title or the name that Trevor and I worked towards for him that could best define his particular role in a collaborative team, partnership group, trio at most, or what have you. And that was the Grim Reaper. So your task is to come up with yours. Oh, boy. I should have expected this.

I should have been prepared. So, okay, let's talk a little bit since, you know, we're talking about collaboration, right? So sort of an extension of last episode and let's talk about, let's put some context to my collaboration. So obviously Trevor talked a lot about me and a lot about Brett, right? And I think this is true. We're the only two people he has published games with. He's worked with other people, but in terms of published games, I think we're the only two. For me, I've worked with a lot of other people. many of which I only have like, say, one or two

games with. But there are, so Trevor's the person I've worked with the most. And then a person, probably the person I've worked with the second most at this point now is Roger Tankersley, right? So we worked alongside Trevor on Resist and Witchcraft, and we've got some other things cooking. But Roger and I also worked on a game called Sniper Elite. And we have another game with a publisher that's on the way, et cetera. So Roger's probably the second person. that I've worked with the most. And then Liz and I don't even have a game

out together, but we've been working a lot together. And one thing that is true about all three of those relationships that's different than some of my other design partnerships is with all three of them, it's a little bit not sure whatsoever, but Roger and Liz especially, I was friends with before we designed anything, like very good friends with them. And so our collaborations come from a place of friendship first, collaborative game design second. And so that was a lot of background

material to get my point here. So my point is this. Let's just say there's a hypothetical spectrum, where one end of the spectrum is minimalism and abstraction. And then on the other end of the spectrum is like, willingness to have more complexity or more just stuff in the game or Chrome, whatever you want to call it, whatever word you want to call it, and less concern about minimalism. And so I would put Brett on the far end of the abstraction.

And then I would put Trevor next. And I'll remove myself for a moment. And then I would put Roger and Liz probably further on the direction of complexity. I think I would fall in the middle of those people on that spectrum. And so I'll give myself the title of middleman. OK. I like that. That makes sense. Trevor is funny because Trevor had a very similar response. And he talked

about the same thing. Your roles change depending on your design partnership. And certainly, he goes from being the person who's less minimalistic and less abstract with his partnership with Brett, and then he takes on that role with me, and I have the exact same sort of dynamic when I work with him versus when I work with Roger versus when I work with Liz. In each case, I take on different roles sometimes as the roles that he would normally take on, just depending on the relationship and the dynamic. Okay. Okay. Well,

that's fantastic. the the the story behind it or not the story just like the explanation makes a ton of sense and I like the name you came to it uh really quickly but honestly this I don't know what sparked this question in my head but you kind of you kind of put the you handful designers on on that spectrum and I don't yeah like I said I don't know why I came up this question but it's here so what What type of game do you feel

like you would be least likely to design? This is a part one of a part two. Yeah. Well, I would never design the kind of game I don't want to play. So we can talk about the kind of games I don't like. Because I would never design that, right? So I mean, like the kind of game I would be least likely to design would be like a take that kind of game, which I can't deal with. I don't mind games that have randomness or uncertainty.

A lot of games that have output randomness with dice rolling and stuff, that's fine. What I don't like are games that have, for example, a quote unquote adventure game where you're going around and you do something and you draw from a deck of cards and you do a thing that's very impactful to you that you had zero agency over, right? So anything like that... is a very big like turn off to me. But I would just say like any sort of like take that kind of game is not my wheelhouse. I would never design something like that. Well,

then, OK, so then you get a follow up before the other follow up. And that's that what's a type of game that you do like that, at least at this point in time, you don't feel like you've designed in that space or really haven't thought about designing yet. Yeah. So. I absolutely wish I had the ability to design games like, have you played Prey Another Day? Do you know this game? So, I did just see the picture very recently

and it's funny because I'd heard it on, I think it was brought up briefly on the Shut Up and Sit Down podcast. From what I recall, I didn't get I'm not sure how much they talked about it. It seemed like they were positive on it from that podcast, but I just didn't get a ton of sense. So I didn't look into it a ton more. But then after I saw your picture, I went on to the site that I buy games from. And it was currently

out of stock. Yeah, of course. I would say it's similar to the Canizia School of Design. So it was designed by Brett, who we've already talked about, Trevor's often partner. And Brett's other, I mean, you talked about this. You talked about the Cambridge cabal and how incestuous we all are. But it was Brett and Matt Dunstan who worked on it. And so it's an extremely simple, dirt simple game. You know, I won't I won't go into

detail here, but it's like a five, 10 minute game. It you know, the second I introduced my kids and my wife, who doesn't really play games to it, we played like eight times in a row. They took it. I was sick, unfortunately, and I missed our favorite vacation of the year is called Weekend Werewolf, where we go to this castle in like the hills of Ohio and play a weekend long game of Werewolf, like 60 people. So I was sick and missed it, unfortunately, but they took that game and they introduced it to my people. Then I took it to a historical game convention and

taught this not historical game to a bunch of people. So anyway, the point is the point is I'm not capable of making those kind of games. Right. So and what I mean by that is like these extremely minimal, smart, you know, games like a kinesia style or whatever. I've tried. It's just not my thing. I have to have I have to start from a place of like a game that's about an event or about a concept about an experience and then

just build from that I can't have this clever like oh I'm gonna have a deck of you know cards one to five and we're gonna go down the list it's super abstract just I don't have that capability so I would I would absolutely love to when Brett and Trevor finally get their mass market game published and they're rolling in their millions of dollars and stuff and I'm you know their games on sale at Target Walmart and I'm at home working on my hyper -historical military war game or something that's going to sell 12 copies, I'll

just lament the fact that I don't have those skills. Or you could just pay them to put your name on it. Yes, that's right. I do have those skills. At least I have the skills to get my name on the box. That's funny. Okay. Well, man, that's all good stuff. And honestly, yeah, knocked out. all my, that wasn't something I'd been thinking before, but it just popped up and that's neat. Yeah. So the long and short of, I definitely

have that game on, on my radar and I hope to play it very soon too. Well, and you know, I mean, you, you talk to Trevor about it, but like similarly his games with Brett, Mandala patterns, I'm sure flowers when it comes out. Um, I mean, they're brilliant. They're brilliant. And I feel so bad. I have an entire shelf. I don't you might be able to make it out. It's right there. Yeah. So the people listening have no idea what I'm talking about, but I'm pointing to my shelf and I have a shelf dedicated to games that Brett and Matt are Trevor and Brett have designed.

And for some reason, I don't know why I have like every one of the games they've ever made, except I didn't have Mandala. And I got it and I played it once with my daughter, the only person in the world to play games with me. And We liked it. It was fine. We played it once and then something happened We put it up and we didn't play it and like literally a year later or something we have this weekly thing where she and I will go to the coffee shop together and play games and We we usually play similar things for a while and

I was like I want to play something different And so I picked it up and we took it and we played and I was like and I never do this I was like we're just gonna learn it from the rule book And so we did. We learned it from the rulebook at the coffee shop and we played it. And I think we wound up playing like four games of it, maybe five games of it that day. And then I immediately went and bought patterns. And we've been playing. I think that was very late last year or early this year. And we played Mandala and patterns other than pray another day. Those were by far the games we played the most. And that was the

only reason I bring that up is because I think it falls into that camp. I would struggle to design a game like that because nothing against Mandala and patterns. but they're not exactly steeped in the historical or thematic underpin. It's a very abstract kind of game. Yeah, I have a follow -up thought to Mandala. And I've kind of been thinking about my conversation with Trevor, just having it, listening back to it a couple

of times. And coincidentally enough, I don't know when but honestly it was probably within the last couple or few weeks at most but mandala was released on board game arena okay and i mean i usually will play a few games maybe a handful most at once on board game arena asynchronously and well first off i would i would never play that game asynchronously i think i'd go crazy

but um Occasionally, especially if I see or if I click to start a game and I have 10, 15 minutes, it's a pretty fast game. I just wanted to try it out because I love that game and I wanted to just play it more. And it was good. Implementation was good. It was fun. I had a good time. But some of the things that I was talking about that I felt when playing it, just some of that a good

bit of that above the board tension definitely didn't like exist. You know, just kind of, you know, that feel of, it kind of got more into just like, you know, clicking, clicking, clicking, and playing what I thought would work the best, but it just didn't have like, oh, I really hope they don't go there with this. You can't see the cards in your hands. There's just, I mean, I like board game arena. I'll play games on board game arena, but I don't know. Yeah, I'm getting

at it, but no that's a really that's a really interesting observation And I think we we played my daughter and I actually played patterns last this past week When we were we need that we did our our little weekly coffee shop date And and it's a similar thing because when we were playing patterns the first game we played It was kind of a slow, thinky game. And then the next game, I was just like, I was just doing like lightning fast moves. And that wouldn't translate in BGA, right? But you could do it in real life. And like, for some reason, the way in which the players

are playing the game, there's like this weird circular feedback between the players and the way they're playing it together. That that you know, you just know that would never translate to the to BGA, right? You it doesn't make a difference how you're approaching it. And so yeah, certainly I don't play a lot on BGA I think it's cool that exists. I don't really play a lot online at all But but you do miss a lot right obviously Yeah, yeah, and that's I mean that's probably why I

play most of my games asynchronously with you know friends just so we can hop on and send a message once a day play a turn or whatever and it's nice yeah, I not my preferred way either, but glad it exists. And I know I'll keep playing games of like Mandala on it, but once I get to play against someone else and really kind of like think into that game with them, it has, like you said, kind of that flow -ish feel and those different feedback loops, as you mentioned.

Cool. So the other kind of question that I'm taking and iterating, changing a little bit. I wasn't, when I asked about the kind of collaborative failure, I wasn't trying to get any tea or hot goss or anything like that. So I took that question and I tweaked it though, all right? So just to

be clear, the mean when when you asked Trevor last time, right? Yes. Yeah. OK. And it was funny because I knew exactly what he was talking about. I was like, oh, that's a very, very real specific example that I know all about. I was part of that. So it means it means something very specific to you and something very general, but also providing a lesson. to to everybody and yeah just on on like he he said at the end of it in a very profound way that it just applies to all all collaborative

elements like you just kind of got to be all on board with each other and that's very true but so i took that question and i'm tweaking it to what's the the the I have the word funniest, but I guess you could replace that word with something else. What's the funniest moment that came from a collaborative miscommunication? Oh, man. Oh, no. Let's think about this for a second.

Oh, man. I was ill prepared for this. Oh, I don't know. I can't think of any funny. Especially. Yeah, I'm failing you. I'm sorry. No, I like

I said, I knew when I put the word funniest I don't know like you it I guess it doesn't have to be like ha ha humor. Yeah Maybe it may be like just some some like series of You know, like unfortunate things that happen that that weren't like catastrophic. I That yeah, you can look back on and laugh at I guess. Oh Goodness, what could that be? What could that be? Um Well, I mean, so, okay. But first of all, I'm trying

to decide whether or not I should go back to Trevor's example and expand on a couple of things. Because I think there's some interesting, like, so people who didn't listen to it, you should go back to listen to that. Make sure you listen to that first, right? But I think what's interesting is Trevor gave an example of quote unquote failure. But the game went on to exist and was fine. Our part of the design didn't get completed. And one thing that I think is really important to come away from that is it's important to know

what you want to do when you're designing a game, what you want your role to be, and be true to that. And that was, you know how you always hear this such a cliche saying about, oh, You'll hear this like when people are making movies together and then like one person will leave or whatever. They're like, oh, we left over creative differences. And you're like, oh, yeah, right. They like had a like a fight and somebody left or whatever. Somebody got fired basically. And they're saving face. In this case, it really legitimately was

like everybody's a good intentioned person. Everybody's awesome. We just were coming from different perspectives. We genuinely did have creative differences. And eventually we were like, oh, this isn't this isn't going to work out. Everybody's awesome. We leave them great terms. And the project went on to succeed. It's just that we didn't continue with them. So I think it's important to understand that there is a time where you should stay true to yourself more than anything else and say,

this is probably the time that we should step away. So. That's not the answer to your question, though. So I'm going to this isn't really funny. I'll just tell a little story about about me and the Grim Reaper. And it's like our origin story. Right. So so like Trevor talked about, we're all from the Cambridge School of Design or whatever we call ourselves. And I think that I think the very first thing we started really working on was probably what it would eventually become undaunted. But. Also early on. I came

to the design meetup. And so what would happen is, like, I think it was every Tuesday night or something, we would all meet in Cambridge at a pub, and we would all bring our own stuff. And you have this dance that designers do at playtest meetups where, like, everybody really wants to play their game, but you also have to play everybody else's game, right? Like, that's the price of admission. And so I wanted to make a game about American football, like, basically like management, right? So like a game that simulates like, not like playing football, but like managing

the players and like super quick, like game resolution maybe, but really I wanted to have like players that would age from season to season and get better and then get worse and you have to pay them and all that kind of stuff. That's what I wanted to make. And I came to it with that idea and Trevor's like, Oh, let's work on this together. And that game eventually became what was published as Ork Olympics, which is like one of our other I think it was our first design together that was published. And so what happened was, over time, it evolved into this completely

different game, very different theme, et cetera, et cetera. And certainly, if we were working on it now, neither one of us would ever let that game have been published in the state it was. It's fine. It's OK. It's an OK game. But it's not great. It's an example, I think, of two people getting to know each other. And I told you, I was friends with Liz first, and I was friends with Roger first, and I knew all about them. And Trevor and I didn't. We got to know each other through designing. And that game represents a time in our relationship where we were getting

to know each other. You don't have the right word is not trust. But we couldn't be probably as open as we might. could have been or should have been when we were giving each other feedback and being honest about what's really important to me in this design and what's not important to me in this design and where you're willing to compromise and stuff. And so I think in the end, you wind up having a game that's probably, it is our worst game, right, that we've made.

And it's also, I mean, I'm not saying, obviously we were just getting started, so it's all forgivable and stuff. But in terms of a game where there was a series of what everyone would call that, unfortunate incidents or whatever. I would just say it's a game that was made of its time and place. And it's funny to look back on now and sort of smile at what it was originally conceived as, what it eventually became, and just how it represents the early part of our relationship. Nice. So I've seen that game just on your VGG

page. Do you feel like it has any similar DNA to any of your other games or is it just oh That's a good question um I think it's probably kind of its own thing I think it really is you know it doesn't share. It's kind of this weird auction Drafting game which doesn't really fit anywhere at least anything I've worked on and I don't think anything Trevor does he has either I don't really think it shares much DNA with anything

else probably for the best No, it's not bad. I shouldn't mess with it. But no, I think it does kind of stand. And I don't mean this in any way disrespectful. I think Armageddon sits in a similar place. And I think Chris Marling would attest to that, that it was very early for both of us. And there's a lot of regrets we have about that game. Not as much on the design, but on the relationship and the way that the development for that game unfolded and us not

being active in that and kind of not being happy with where it got to and stuff. And so I don't dwell on what could have been and wanting to go back and change games and that kind of stuff. But certainly when you look back at some games, you do wish that things had played out slightly different in some cases. Yeah. I mean, that's really interesting. I mean, I think part of kind of my... Well, having these conversations is... Just fun for me in the first place, but it's

really nice just getting to learn and hopefully having other people I get to hear I mean You know you mentioned it a couple other people that I've talked to mention it about like When the design happens as opposed to the publication of the game like that's one thing that I Mean, I would assume most people would think that there's some time period but to the point where like the the release could get so flip -flop that Well, people think that the one inspires the other and just kind of how, you know, especially

with you working on a lot of collaborations and, and how the collaborations between designers and the collaborations between designers and, you know, publishers and artists and all these other things and how, you know, how different that can be just from like time to time and just in time of your life as well. Like I think. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, like. people, most people get the game and and their reactions are to the game. But there's obviously a whole bunch of

stories that are wrapped up into it, especially, you know, the more people you get involved. So, yeah, I mean, yeah. So so every game was made by people and every one of those people that helped make that game had some sort of relationship along the way. Right. And I would I would guess that if you were to do like a deconstruction of a game, And it was a very good game. And you looked at and you did this deconstruction. The relationships between the people who made the

game were probably strong. And there was probably close bonds. We approach undaunted designs now very differently than we did when we first started. We're much more intentional at the very beginning of a new undaunted to bring in when we started on the most recent one. In the virtual chat, or whatever it was, myself and Trevor, it was the entire development team, so three people. It was the artist, it was the graphic designer, and it was the author who... For example, in

Stalingrad, there's a lot of text that was written to accompany that, and that was written by an author they brought in. So before we ever actually started the first any design work, we all came together and talked about the project, right? And now, of course, you don't always have that opportunity. And of course, this is a game that's built on a system that's been very successful, and et cetera, et cetera. So you want to make sure it's as good as possible. But the point is, I think that that game, people will never know. But I think that that game will benefit

from the deliberate relationships that have been built up over time to try to make it the best possible game it can be. Yeah. Now, that's awesome. And just kind of along along those lines too. I mean, I mean you Trevor talked about it. You're talking about it how you know, you're designing with Liz and Roger who you'd been friends with and now Trevor has been a fantastic friend for all the time since you started designing together

too and You know, I think I mean it It seems obvious but Like I would assume that there aren't, especially in the board gaming designing space, too many collaborations that are going to be linked to just relationships that aren't the greatest. Yeah. Yeah, I think, I mean, so to be full disclosure, I've worked on, I've experienced

the range. And the range being everything from literally my best friends in the world, Trevor, Roger, Liz, et cetera, that I also design with, to collaborations with people who I would consider friends or acquaintances that I have a really good relationship. So like Jeff Engelstein and I are working on a game right now. Jeff and I know each other. We don't have the same relationship that I have with everybody else, but it's certainly a positive, good relationship. It's just much more It's not like business -like, but you know

what I mean. It's just a different positive, but different relationship. I've had experiences where I worked together with a person, and we would maybe even build a game out of it. But you're like, I don't know that I necessarily need to go back and work with that person again. And then you have like, that did not work out. We're not doing that again. You know, I mean, it can run the gamut. Right. And I would just say I'm very blessed that I've had way more of those friendly, positive experiences. But I mean, occasionally you do. And you do have not such

great, you know, experiences. And the thing is, it's not it's not that anybody's there's a bad person in that. It's just that you're going to eventually come along when you work with enough people. You're going to come along and you're like, well, there wasn't as much synergy there. Right. And I think it's important to recognize that and say, especially when it's not your job, right? If it's your job, there's a difference. Like, if I'm trying to put food on the plates of my children, then there's a different driver than if it's something I'm doing as a sort of

whatever, jobby, as Trevor called it. So yeah, anyway, that was a tangent. But the point is, those relationships can run the spectrum, for sure, and they have. Oh, and it's nice now, too, especially with some of the newer design partners that you've had, too. Like you mentioned, Jeff and Liz, and designing more with Liz already, with Night Witches still coming out soon, and

then all those other games that you're already working on. So just being able to now kind of have that That group so no matter what your if your goals to kind of get you know like about four games out a year or whatever I mean you're having like those four people that you design with that's it's gonna happen. So yeah. Yeah, absolutely Yeah, and one one thing I would mention that I don't want to get lost in the shuffle about about collaborations and I don't think Trevor mentioned this I want to mention it is

For me personally, and I think this is probably true for other people too. Um having a design partner is a really, really, really good way to hold yourself accountable. So when I meet with any of them, Roger, Liz, Trevor, whoever, we will come together and especially with the three of them, I've worked the same way with all three of them. When we do, we do almost all of our design work together. We don't do this thing where we'll come together and talk a little

bit and then go away and do a bunch of independent design work and then come back together and compare. We don't do that much. When Trevor, Roger, and I work together, Trevor talked about this. A three -person dynamic is different. And so we do a little bit more of that then. But typically with co -designs, with the three of them, we'll come together. We'll do all of our design work together. And the only thing we'll do independently when we go away is like, action oriented, task oriented things that aren't design work. So like Liz will write the rules and I'll make stuff

for tabletop simulator or whatever. I think that's super important. But the other thing we also do is we always set the next meeting schedule and the tasks for the next meeting. And I can't screw that up. I can't not do that because I'm letting somebody else down, not just myself. And that's very different between that and like I have a few things that I'm working on that are like, you know, what I would call like my indulgent designs, right? So things that I would like to be working on, but they are so far down

the list that I've seldom have time. And the reason that they're not getting done is because I don't have to, I'm not being held accountable by my partnership with anybody else to get them done. So I just wanted to flag that as another practical benefit of co -designs is that accountability. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense too. So I mean, not not necessarily in a negative way either, but you mentioned that maybe some of your kind of like solo, more indulgent things that you

have been working on may get bumped down, just so you can not let your partners down. Do you feel like, I mean, outside of that, what sort of Kind of what has the change been and what has been your approach in some of your solo design? So, I mean, we talked about for what remains and you've done the valiant defense series, which for games or for games of our fifth one's coming

out, but the fifth one won't be designed by me. It's been designed differently in the system. Yeah. So, yeah. So, so a bunch of those games that, you know, Yeah, I guess back back to the kind of the question is like what what sort of? Changes have you seen in your soul design based on just? Designing more in general designing with other people more what what has that brought

about I used to say that This was probably about three or four years ago I used to say when people would talk to me about designs that you know I basically do co -designs when it's when it's a multiplayer game And a lot of my solo designs were solo games. There's a lot of obvious practical reasons for that. But that slowly changed in the Valiant Defense series that you mentioned as part of that evolution. So the first game in that series was called Castle Litter, and

then there was a game called Pavlov's House. In the third game, it's called Soldiers and Postmen's Uniforms. There's a co -designer listed for Michael Cochman. And so Michael was actually the person who had reached out and proposed the topic. He's from Poland and the game is set in Poland during World War II. And Michael is a gamer. But he also, you know, he's there, he lives there. I actually went, my wife and I actually traveled to Gdańsk at the time when the game was set,

Danzig. And we met with Michael and he and I did a bunch of research in person together there. And so he served essentially as like a cultural or historical consultant, if you will, is probably the most accurate way to describe his role in the game. But I felt, but I mean, I always ran all the design stuff by him, but I felt like his work, he deserved co -design credits. And a similar thing happened with a game I designed, a solo game I designed called By Stealth and

Sea, with another designer, Nicola Sagini. And so, It was during that time period where I had these positive interactions with people doing this sort of like hybrid historical research slash consulting slash co -design work with me. And I was like, you know, even with my solitary designs, I'm enjoying this way more collaborating with people. And so it just sort of like organically evolved over time that I realized like even with

my solo designs, I would prefer to just work with other people. to the point now where I don't know, truthfully, if I'll ever do another game that I would list myself on the box as the only designer. Maybe, maybe some day, I won't say never, right? But all of those games, even the train game I made, Switch and Signal, which is listed, it is a code, I mean, it is a solo design, but it dated back to like 2014, right? Before

I was really... even collaborating with people. And so I just don't think, I don't think I have enough time in the day now to work on stuff by myself. I think I would always work with somebody else on it. Oh, that's, that's really cool too. I mean, like, like you said, it just seems like it was that, that evolution to kind of picking up more people who were interested in the history that, that matched the Valiant Defense series. Yeah. That's really neat. Okay, well, so you

talked about it a little bit before, kind of thinking about collaboration and abstraction a little bit. And you mentioned that on the spectrum, the kind of like mandala or pray another day, that's. that's not where you can get to. So on, I guess, the opposite end, you brought up the word Chrome before, and I mean, I'm not, I'm definitely not the most historical -based gamer.

I have enough, and I like them a lot, but Chrome here, if I'm getting it wrong, meaning, you know, rules kind of created for a particular history or a detail. Yeah, that's exactly right. It is kind of a wargaming term. I think people might call it crunchy or rules grid or whatever. There's a lot of millions of terms for it. But basically, in the wargame parlance, a chrome rule or whatever

is a rule or rules or subsystem or whatever that exists essentially to usually simulate some sort of historical element in the game. So then thinking about that spectrum, which of your more historical base games do you feel is the chromiest? Oh, that's a good question. Oh, man. I can give some

examples of current, so this is really difficult, right? So let me indulge me for a moment and let's talk, let's just have a little tangent about from rules. So I think it's important that before you start a design, so the way I design historical games is I'll read all about the event. I'll take a bunch of notes. Usually there's like a six month research process before I start the design. So I'll research, I do a bunch of research, take a bunch of notes. I'll sketch out the sort of like conceptual model of what the game should

be like. And when I'm doing that, I'll take notes of like, okay, this has to exist in the game. This has to exist in the game. And I'll make the, okay, these things have to be there. They just have to. And then I'll start designing the game around that. And it's important at that point when I'm making those, this has to exist notes that I know who I'm designing the game for. What who's the audience for this game? So the reason that's important is if it's a game like an undaunted where it's for a broader hobby,

you know, broader audience, then it can't have those chrome rules. Like it just your my quote unquote chrome budget is really low. OK, if it's a solo war game in the valiant defense here is my quote unquote chrome budget just skyrockets because I have I'm dealing with. the vast majority of the audience is going to be solitaire war gamers. They are a lot more forgiving for that kind of stuff, right? So before I do anything, I know this is who I'm designing it for. This is my Chrome budget. This is what I can afford to include. Okay. So I'll answer your question.

I know it's probably like Pavlov's house or by stealth and see something like that. That's probably, but. I want to give a couple of examples and I want to walk through why you make those choices about whether you should or shouldn't include them. So the last game that I worked on in the Valiant Defense, and we should just real quick, the Valiant Defense series, this is a series of solo war games published by Danvers and Games. All the games share the common theme of you're a small group of people in a sort of like against

all odds, hopeless defense kind of situation. so that's that's what all of them and they're all real historical events and they're some of them are like so bizarre that if i told you what they were about and you you would be like that's that's not true that's not real um and i would like nope these are all true historical things so the most recent one is called lands earth ridge it's on the first day of the battle of the bulge and there's this group of like 20 us soldiers they're not even real like like a normal infantry unit they're like a like a scout unit

It's designed to do reconnaissance and they're pushed into a situation where they're forced to take a more conventional role to plug a gap in a line, blah, blah, blah. And a German unit of about 500 soldiers comes upon them and they hold the Americans hold that group of 500 soldiers off for basically a day. So 20 guys hold off 500. That's a really oversimplification. The Germans were at this point in the war not very well. trained and the officers were horrible,

et cetera, et cetera. But they did hold them off. OK. In the game, in the reality, those soldiers, those 20 American soldiers, had a few machine guns. They had a couple of different types of machine guns. They had a few different positions where they were. And those machine guns, those few machine guns, were the reason, ultimately, that the Americans were able to hold them off. They had to exist in the game, specifically. And it was important to, in this case, model

ammunition. Now, that's not something I've ever done in any other game. It's probably something I'll never do again. But I needed the idea of ammunition as a finite resource in order to model effectively the reality of the situation and to give that same sense of like, the stress of saying like, we only have so much, we can only hold out so long. So creating that system for that game, for that version of that game in that, you know, in the Divine Defense series was a

decision I made because it was so important. So it's not often that I would make a game that has individual machine guns and you're actually, you know, you're not tracking each individual round, but you know what I mean. There is a finite amount of ammunition that you have to track. So that's an example. I mean, there's there's others but but if I if you if you said I absolutely had to I would say probably Pavlov's house or by stealth and see has the most Chromey bits Okay Thanks. Yeah, I so from from the I Own those

four games that you designed in the Valiant defense series and I played three of them. So the only one I haven't played yet is Lancer at the ridge. Okay, okay now I Okay here so here's a follow -up question then to based on that because I know that You said this that you put in at least kind of a six month Period of research before you you start on it and then you also make a

companion guide. Is that the right? Yeah, that's right. For each of them. And how long does creating that take? Oh, goodness. A few months. Yeah. Yeah. When I'm probably for a Valiant Defense game or a game like that, like an actual historical game, not something like Undaunted, the set in historical period, but an actual historical game seeking to model a historical event or events.

I usually spend six months to a year researching it and then probably three -ish months working on the companion book. Nice. Yeah. Okay, well. We should, real quick, before we leave Valiant Defense, we could do, we should do an entire episode on Just Cast a Litter and Blow Everybody's Mind based on what it's about. Like, it's the most mind -blowing... thing that happened in World War II, I would submit. So that's just it. For people that are listening, just do me

a favor. Go Google Castle Itter. It's I -T -T -E -R. And read about the insanity of what happened. You'll be happy you did. Maybe. Oh, here. I mean, I know that I'm ill -equipped to talk about so many things when it comes to history. I am. I just. I don't know. I think. This is going to be like a minor tangent. I just feel like when it comes to. All right, people that are actually

like that know history might say that even this statement is wrong, but, you know, history. Has some level of. Trues to it, I mean, things happened obviously the way that it would get recorded. I mean, all those different things are going to impact like what people know about history. So, I don't know, I just feel if I ever tried to like, think about it or touch that, that I would wind up just failing so miserably. That's

why I stick to fiction. That's why I like to read. Well, I'll tell you one little secret about me and historical games that I work on, is that if you ever look at the historical... specifically historical games, but I've designed war games, etc. What you'll know, there's a common theme, you'll know they're all about these really obscure topics, right? Like, I don't ever do like strategic level popular topics of history and wargaming.

And that's because I don't want anybody to call me out and tell me like, I'm totally wrong. So I'm just like, I'll just pick something obscure that nobody knows anything about. And nobody, nobody, nobody will be able to call me out on it. So I mean, it's I'm not saying that. I don't believe that. But it's true. No, I mean, I mean, it's kind of true. Like, I'm not I'm not totally joking. Right. You know, I mean, it's a little bit it's it's it's fortuitous because I also really love digging into silly, like crazy, like

human torpedo writers. Like, how how insane is that? So I genuinely like it. But I mean, there is a little element of truth to like, you know, if I'm going to if I was to design a game about, you know, whatever. the eastern front in World War II. But Jesus, like, you know, half of the war game playing community knows more about it than I do. Right. So that's a that's an intimidating thing to get into. So, I mean, I say it in jest, but there is some truth to it. And it's it's just I mean, it is a really neat idea, too. I

mean, like you said, it's something that you're passionate about kind of digging to find these stories and and bring them to light. And, you know, me who will read you know, the rule book or the companion book and wants to read more about it. It's, it's just, I don't know. I'm, I'm a big fan of it as someone who is definitely will never, well, I'm not a self -proclaimed history buff by any point at, by any stretch of imagination. Maybe some point I'll be able to kick back and read, read more there. But I

say kick back. I don't know. I said that. I would, if I was reading that stuff, it would be the exact opposite. I'd be like, completely like at the edge of my seat, but nice. Okay. So here's kind of like a little bit, and it doesn't have to even leave the valiant defense series too much, but can kind of transition to like a final conversational topic before getting to, you know,

the end, but Having had played three of those games and having played some of your Undaunted games and and also knowing that undaunted came before War chest and also having war chest having expansions and stuff like that too so I guess the the the first question that I have is how how would you go about the process of thinking of iterations, I mean you You kind of talked

about with, I think it was Callisto or at least having that whole group there being very intentional from the start. So that's, you know, something that's going on now, but like the, the valiant defense series, you know, each game has, you know, the, they have so many differences to it, but they, there are still similar ways in which they play like through the deck and everything like that. I mean, you know what I mean? They're not that similar. They share a core system, for

sure. So I guess, at this point, especially with undaunted kind of always being on your mind, how has your approach to iteration changed? And at what point do you Think about you know expansions as opposed to iterations. I don't know if that's the best kind of like follow -up or dual question,

but No, I think that's great. I think it's great. I mean certainly there is a difference right so war chest is a game with expansions Undaunted Valiant Defense etc is a game with Whatever you want to call that standalone sequels right whatever you want to call that that thing of their each game is different, but but shares a system There's pros and cons to both approaches, I think it's probably more interesting. The expansion thing, it is what it is, right? We're going to create

more content for the base game. It doesn't change the base game, et cetera. So that's kind of what it is. In the world of systems, and this is true of Valiant Defense, this is true of Undaunted, I would say the designer has a very difficult job of trying to walk the fine line between, there's a reason that you're making another game in the system, the first one must have been successful enough to, you know, for you to make a second one. Okay. So, you can't deviate too much from

the first one because obviously that's what people want, right? If they're buying Undaunted Normandy, or if they're buying Undaunted North Africa, maybe that's their first one, but probably... You know, they're coming from a place where they played a daunt to Normandy. And so clearly, you need to make something that is close enough to the first one that they enjoy it. But it needs to be different enough that there's a reason to own it. Slash, it needs to be different enough that Trevor and I don't lose our minds while

we're designing it. And that's it. I'm not like I say that, but I'm not joking. Like, so. So we are very, I'll just dive into Undaunted a little bit more rather than Dying at Defense as I walk through some of these examples. So you think about Undaunted Normandy, it's the first, fine. Undaunted North Africa, it was interesting because we designed it before Normandy was released. So Osprey said, hey, we believe in this game. We want you to design a sequel for it before the first one even comes out. So we had this

sort of unenviable task of designing a sequel. without having a clue how the game was going to be received, what people were going to like, dislike, et cetera. And the only guidance that Osprey gave us was just use different nationalities. OK, so we can do whatever we want, which is not necessarily always good. The sky's the limit. But we quickly settled on, well, you know, we're designing in 2018, I guess it was 19, something like that. And so it's like, well, people like

asymmetric stuff. So let's make the sides radically symmetric in terms of like what they're trying to achieve and et cetera, et cetera. So you're trying to say, let's stay within the system, but do that. And then, and then of course, reinforcements comes out and we know that people want solo. So we include solo and team and we give more of the same. And then, you know, it's Stalingrad comes out and it's like, Osprey told us they were like, we want you to make a legacy game. And when they said that they actually meant destructive legacy, because if you think about that timeframe, destructive legacy was like all the rage, right?

And so thank God, we were able to like walk that back and make it a resettable campaign. But some of it is organic. And so what I mean by that is Osprey says we want it to be destructive legacy. And so that we're like, OK, if we're in an undaunted world and we're in World War II, if you're going to have a legacy system with a unit size that that's small, that small number of people, it's going to have to be in a relatively static environment. So that leads you to Stalingrad. And so Stalingrad,

once you've made the decision, you're going to put it there. Stalingrad sort of constrains what's the art of the possible in terms of being in the game. And so all of these things kind of feed back on one another. And the design sort of is informed by the constraints. And then once you've made the decision on the design, it's just this loop. And then there's a deliberate decision sometimes. When we were done with Stalingrad, we wanted to do something very, very, very different.

Again, both for our sanity, for the design challenge of how far can we push the system for our sanity, because we needed to design something different at that point. And just, you know, to give the players something that felt different. So that's how Battle of Britain came about. So every one of them, I would say that like every discussion for every game is a. It's a game, it's a discussion that takes place in its time and place, it's informed by what's going on at that point in time. But there are some practical. issues. We need to move the game in a new direction. It

can't just feel like we're phoning it in with a reskin and doing the same old thing. But again, going back to the very first thing, it still, no matter what, has to still be undaunted, quote unquote, undaunted. It has to be that deck builder that has the tempo control and the integrated health and command cards and that kind of stuff, right? So it can never deviate too much from that. That was a long -winded answer. I hope I hit it. hit on it, but, you know, there is no one single thing. It's a lot of different pieces that goes into that decision. Yeah, no,

that answered everything and more. And if you couldn't tell by like the me trying to struggle with the words for the question in the first place, and you somehow answered a question that I didn't even ask in there perfectly. That's great. So this is just a you know maybe clarification for me and and uh potential audience as well but when when does do you know when klisto's

official release is fall fall 24 i don't think they have it i don't know if they have an actual an actual date um I hope, I've got my fingers crossed for people listening, I hope that it will be present in some form at Gen Con, potentially available for sale. That's my hope. But I think broad release will be, yeah, fall of 24. I think

every undaunted game for the past five years has been available around the summer, fall timeframe. And of course, it's convention season, right? That's when they're going to want it to release. Well, OK. You don't have to answer this one. I'm not trying to get insider information. So if you say pass, I'll be OK with it. But how many more undaunted games are you and Trevor

currently kicking around? Oh, man. Well, okay, so Callisto is done. We finished the design. So Osprey is awesome. Absolutely awesome to work with. And the reason they're awesome to work with is because they run an extremely tight schedule that they hold us to and they hold themselves to. And they're really the only publisher that I know of that is so vigilant about their schedule. And so Trevor and I usually have to finish about...

I don't know, a year and a half, two years before a game is going to come out, something like that. I don't know, give or take. And so what that means is we finished with Callisto a long time ago. Like we have not worked on Callisto from a design perspective in a long time. I mean, we've checked files and that kind of stuff, but as far as the actual design. So I'm going to get in trouble, man. I don't want you to get in trouble. I will say this. I will say this. We've worked on a couple since then. So we worked

on a couple since finishing Callisto. Okay, cool. Well, yeah, I mean, that's kind of the schedule that you're running. I mean, that makes sense. Yeah, and I will tell everybody that's listening, if If any undaunted don't come out after, if Callisto's the last one, it's because of this podcast. I got in trouble and they were all canceled. Yeah, then as small of a podcast as this is, that's gonna get canceled too. Everyone's gonna bring out their pitchforks and be like, this

is the guy who canceled undaunted. Well, okay, I mean... I'll try to save myself a little bit. I think people have to know that there's more. That's all I'm going to say. That's funny. Okay. Well, I think in terms of kind of integrating a lot of collaboration, ideas of abstraction at different times, and then you're like, really

great answer to the idea of SQLs or, you know, iteration systems and, you know, the process behind that as well. I mean, you've answered everything and then some. I had some follow -up questions that were random, worked or didn't work, but I learned a lot. And I have to leave you then with the two kind of wrap -up questions. which are, well, I'll get you with the first one. And the first one is the now ever present

penultimate question. And that's, what is a text that has been stuck on your mind? Any text? Oh, this is funny because I heard, I listened to Trevor struggle with this and then I didn't prepare an answer. This is amazing. Okay. Man. Okay,

let's talk about this. So I'm in a life group. So my church, we have what we call life groups, which are people that you go to church with and you get together with and you talk about whatever you're studying at the time, usually something biblical related. And whether you're religious or not, this is applicable. One of the things that I really took away from the recent life study I was reading about was the sense of people putting too much of themselves, like too much

of their identity in things, right? And when you're reading the book, the book suggests like you should be putting your identity and your faith with God. But independent of that, even if you're a secular person, The point of it is to not associate yourself too strongly with any one thing, because if something happens to that one thing, too much of yourself is crushed. So as I was reading that, I was like, man, that that makes sense on so many on so many levels, you know, whether you're a parent whose entire

world is about their children or or whatever it is. And I was recently talking to Liz about this very topic about a friend of ours who had put a lot of a lot of whatever you want to call it, eggs in one basket or whatever of their identity. And so that text, and I'm looking over, hoping that I see the authors, but I don't have the book handy. So I can't tell you even who the author was or the book. But just that thought, that thought resonated with me, this sense of

making sure that, you know, your sense of self should not be wrapped up and and material things, things that can just be taken away at a whim or whatever. So that was something that resonated with me. Yeah, that's a very good and profound thought. And then I was slightly jokingly thinking in my head, good thing nobody can see the room

that I'm currently sitting in. But no, in all sincerity, now that is like a very poignant thought and just being able to, you know, have different relationships, have different things that you care about to like really have a well -rounded identity. Yeah, exactly. I like that. Okay, so then the final question is, we've brought up I think in some capacity these three, but Calisto

sometime this year, the Nightfall expansion for War Chest. I think last episode Trevor said it was starting to get delivered. Yep, that's right. Which is awesome. And then Night Witches this year as well? No, so I think... I think Night Witches will probably like go to Kickstarter, so realistically, I mean who knows, but I think realistically Night Witches will go to Kickstarter this year and probably like ship next year. You

know, I know I think I don't make you know what when you talk to Liz I don't think this was public information So, you know tool is the artist for night witches and he's just starting on the art now So I think it's unrealistic to think that it could get art can be done and well, I don't think that's possible So yeah, I would think it'd be a 2025 release okay. Yeah, I I Could have probably looked I could have probably seen or see what my board game geek had to say about that. Well, nonetheless, so Clisto 24 and the Nightfall expansion out. Other things too, and

obviously, sometime soon, a Kickstarter for Nightwitches as well. But what other things should people be on the lookout for from you? So I'll mention two because two are... to have been publicly announced. So one is a game that's coming out later this year from another game from Osprey other than Callisto. It's called War Story Occupied France. This is a game that is being designed with Dave Neal. So. For astute listeners from

the last two episodes, you'll realize that Trevor and I work with a lot of people from Cambridge. So this is yet another person. So this is Dave Neil, who worked on Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, some of the unlocks, et cetera. So he's extremely well known for his narrative work. And Dave reached out to me and said, hey, what do you think about this idea of combining his Bailiwick, which is narrative games, with my thing, which are sort of like this hybrid cross, you know, between hobby and wargame space. And so what we game up with this was this game is

war story occupied France. And so it's sort of this like, I don't want I mean, I don't want to call it choose your own adventure, because it's not really that but it's sort of from cut from that same cloth. But imagine with a much more interesting combat resolution system when when combat is necessary in the game. And so I'm super happy, super excited with that, I think. I think it'll be available at Spiel. I think it's when Borsrock by France comes out. So I'll mention that. The other one, and we mentioned

Jeff Engelstein earlier. So the game I'm doing with Jeff is coming out from GMT. It's on their P500. For people that don't know, GMT and P500 is their pre -order system. It's called Cheng He. So it's about the Ming voyages. It probably will be 2025. It's in art right now. And the thing that I will say about Ming voyages, Cheng He and the Ming voyages, is I would like to start doing more non -war historical game design. So

Cheng He was the first one that I sort of dipped my toes in that is not, you know, a lot of people would say, a lot of people will say that nothing I've designed is a war game. There's a whole like grognard community that would say, I've never actually made a war game. And that's fine, I don't really care. But most of my games have at least have a war theme, right? Like that's the thing you're doing is some sort of conflict thing. But I would like to start doing more games that are like adjacent to that space that are more historical focused without that war theme. Not saying I'm leaving war games, but it's just something I would like to explore more. And so

so Junghub was is the first one to kind of visit that space. The game that Liz and I are just now starting to work on that started to design well. We've been working on it for a few months now, is another game that I would say fits in that space of war adjacent historical game, first and foremost. So hopefully it's not something that I feel super comfortable in quite yet, but I'm definitely interested in exploring it more. That's awesome. I don't know, I was like looking

behind at my collection, like I already had it, but you mentioned Zhang Ha and as soon as I heard about that, that was an instant P500 for me. I think it's like my very first P500 as well. Oh, thank you very much. Yeah, no, thank you for getting me introduced to that system and getting me in trouble. And speaking of trouble and thank you, like once this gets published and my podcast gets cancelled, for getting you in trouble. That's just gonna be it. We're going

down together. Yeah, all right. Well, I couldn't have asked for a better final guest. No, no, no, that's not true. You'll have a few more episodes before it all catches up to us and everything goes bad, so who knows? Who knows? It'll be the final guest, but we don't have much longer. Yeah, I know. Our time is short now. Well, no, thank you. Thank you so much for... coming on talking to me and having all these like really insightful thoughts that have me thinking and and per usual

by the end of the episode my my brain is broken to the point where I come up with questions that aren't questions and you still answer them nonetheless so I couldn't be much more appreciative. I couldn't be more appreciative, not much more. No, I appreciate it. This has been awesome. I really appreciate it. And I'm sad that I have to admit that I discovered your podcast when you reached out. Well, that's not true. Trevor had told me that he was on. And so I kind of knew about it. But I often lament,

like I'm a huge podcast consumer, huge podcast. I listen to podcasts all the time. And I always lament the fact that, and I don't know if you share the same frustration, podcasts are notoriously difficult to find. Like there's no way to like go and like, maybe there is and I don't know how to do it, but to just like go and look for how do I find a new podcast, right? Like you have to kind of know and be told about it. And so, so when I just quote unquote discovered you, you know, a few weeks back, I've been listening

to a ton of your stuff and I really appreciate what you're doing. So thanks for, for having me on. It was, it was really cool. Yeah, no, I, I don't know. I, I think my title sticks out, which is cool, but I, well, not to get too down, down that rabbit hole. I'm not like the biggest like media person in terms of like social media or things like that. So, you know, the, the best thing that I can do is have like really awesome guests on and, and have them save me every single

episode. And you can have me on too. No, it's been great. I've really enjoyed being able to go back. I mean, that's the one benefit of coming into it, 17, 18 now episodes in, is that I get 18 episodes to go back and listen to. So it's been really fun. Well, I appreciate all levels of support and you being here with me today. So thank you. Yeah, thanks for having me. Intertextual

Cardboard Experience, the most iterative podcast about board games and any other text that they connect to. Thank you so much for choosing to spend your time here. Any further support such as sharing the show with friends, following the pages socials in the episode description, writing a review, filling out the feedback form, or doing anything else you can think of is greatly appreciated. Keep playing, watching, reading. listening, experiencing.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. #49 - Eric Dietel: Good Conversation High Intertextuality

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    You are chasing the elusive high score-the ability to carve your initials (or some other inappropriate word or abbreviation) digitally into your favorite machine. The perfect combination of greasy, sticky, and fast...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. #48 - David Masnato: Pax @ PAX

    Sep 3, 20261 hr 36 minAudio

    From the slight burn of a slide that’s gotten too hot in the late afternoon sun to the sense of ecstasy (mixed with a slight tinge of panic) from getting a little higher on the swing than you’d ever gotten before-and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. #47 - Jeff Grisenthwaite: Board Game Are(ca)na

    Aug 13, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    As fate and coincidence would have it, designer Jeff Grisenthwaite and I had actually met and played games together once and then played games at different tables of a smaller meetup just months after that. It wasn’t...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. #46 - Amabel Holland: Episode of Six Video Essays

    Jul 24, 20261 hr 30 minAudio

    Back like it never left, Intertextual Experience welcomes Amabel Holland - designer, video essayist, author, and co-owner of Hollandspiele - for its forty-sixth episode. Amabel has been making my favorite board game...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. #45 - Taylor Reiner: The Quiz 2 – Trick-Taking Romanticism – Everything’s a Sequel – You Can’t End on a Toot for Me, I’m Gonna Toot on You

    Apr 2, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    Taylor Reiner. The Quiz 2. Since Taylor was on the show in September 2023, he’s been busy with designing, developing, making videos, and more. We get to explore some of the things Taylor has been working on through the...

    Credit the people on this episode