Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Intertextual Experience: A Board Game Podcast

Intertextual Experience: A Board Game Podcast artwork

#17 - Trevor Benjamin: Collabstraction

Apr 8, 20241 hr 47 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

A wonderful collaborative discussion here with a designer that only designs in collaborations, Trevor Benjamin. Designer of one of my favorite games of all time in Mandala, everything that has Trevor in the design credits is guaranteed to be a fantastic game. Speaking of fantastic, I think this episode is quite fantastic too, so thank you for tuning in. Trevor on BGG and Twitter. Introductory Questions [Time stamps coming! - weird technical hang-up - should be set by 4/9] What got Trevor into board games and how that has inspired his designs The conversation goes on about Go and other abstract games, cooperative games, and intuitive/simple designs (I’m not sure if those words capture that part the best, so check it out to hear how this brief description almost matches that discussion). Cambridge - “Family” (56:30) What really sticks out in this section is how close Trevor is to his co-designers. Through discussing how these partnerships came to be and have turned into lifelong friendships, it makes sense why the games created between Trevor and Brett/David/Roger/Matthew click so well. Collab-specific Questions (1:16:00) What title best fits Trevor in his design partnerships. A question brought to you by “Indeed” (not sponsored) Wrap-up Questions (1:32:38) Trevor discusses a masterpiece of modern television and games to look out for from him this year. ---------------------------------------------------------- Contact, follow, and support information: vodthepod@gmail.com Twitter Instagram General feedback form - (your thoughts are appreciated!) Buy Me a Coffee

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Intertextual cardboard experience All right before we get rolling today I just want to have a very very quick set of notes for us. So first things first I think I May have had my biggest journalistic blunder I'm not sure journalistic is the the best one for for this but uh nonetheless there

was there was something that i got woefully wrong i won't spoil it you'll hear it but i was looking at so many different designs from trevor and people that he co -designed with that i think i colab -ceptioned myself so when you hear it you'll you can be embarrassed for me as much as i'm embarrassed for myself But another quick thing is that just with the way that the conversation

went, it was just very like flowy and kind of incorporated a lot of the different topics and the way that it was all set up together. I'll still have some timestamps to break up different parts if you want to go back into the show notes and find a part per usual, but there isn't going to be a sound effect. That said I'm going to throw a little something fun extra at the end too. So a hopefully Hopefully you are sticking

around for the whole episode in general It's a really really good one and then you can get to that part at the end and maybe have a laugh too But nonetheless kept this under a couple minutes. So like I said Blunder my part No sound effects chapters, something fun at the end. Fantastic episode. Thank you. Hello and welcome to Intertextual Cardboard Experience. Today we have our supreme

17th guest, Trevor Benjamin, designer of some of my absolute favorite games. How are you doing today, Trevor? Very good. Happy to be here. I'm happy to be a prime number in your list. That makes me happy. Yeah, awesome. I've been putting so much thought into the words. I haven't even thought about the numbers. But 17 is good for that. It is prime. Yep. That would be quite embarrassing

if I messed that up. Well, I was just kind of reaffirming it, even though I didn't even think about it. Anyway, happy to be here. Thanks, right. So I'm going to be putting my cards on the table early here. I've actually thought about this conversation that we're going to have for some time now. I do that. for some of my episodes. But I've been thinking about this interview because

I've been playing and enjoying your games for a while. And because I had and have what I think is a perfect title for this episode in Collabstraction. Yeah, very good. Nice. And then when I kind of checked initially on Board Game Geek and then with you and you confirmed that all of your projects are indeed co -designs. I, from the get -go, thought that that was super fascinating and that

there was so much that I could ask that was based on that. But I was still kind of struggling with the overall arc of the episode, which is why I didn't reach out. And that's just kind of like my process. I wanted to make sense in my head before I can ask somebody to talk. But yeah, so here we are and I am ready. Good. All right. I'm ready. I'm ready. Co -labs tractions. Co -labs tractions. We'll see where this goes. But

the first question I have for you is about your gaming career before design. You know, what sort of early memories of gaming do you have and what types of games did you play? Oh, I mean, so I think, I mean, you can't... meet a game designer who doesn't tell the class, you know, mention the classic games from from their childhood. But I mean, I mean, I mean, I think like, not just designers, but everybody. I mean, I have a lot of early fond memories of playing games,

but certainly I have always been and continue to be an omni gamer. And so, you know, I spend as much time playing sort of classic games, classic card games, classic abstract strategy games, like mass marketing games, as I do playing, you know, big H hobby games. But, and so, and that's sort of always been the case. And I mean, given

the abstraction of it. So like, I should just mention, yeah, like one of the games that I sort of fell in love with as a kid, me and my brother just stumbled upon it in a shop somewhere. What was go, so we bought, it was a little, you know, it was a terrible production. It was like, you know, it's not like a beautiful, it wasn't a beautiful wooden board with like, you know, like slate and, and pearls pieces. It was just like,

you know, trash cardboard with little plastic bits. But, you know, we had absolutely no idea, like, You know, we read the rules and were like, this seems simple enough. We had no idea what it was, but eventually, you know, we got it. It clicked. And, you know, I've loved it ever since. And, you know, like I said, a lot of classic card games, you know, like I have played as many games of hearts as I have of, you know, pick

your favorite modern hobby game. Um, and so I think like, you know, but also, you know, the, the big ones, like I played, you know, Dungeons and Dragons, I played tabletop, um, uh, sort of, um, Dungeon Crawlers, like HeroQuest, I played Magic the Gathering, I got really deep into Magic the Gathering, like again, no big surprise, lots of people. Um, and, and yeah, and then, and then, and then, you know, 20 years ago or so I discovered the sort of... the German storm of games and

that and then you know that sort of took over and but again it's always been there together with the with the other types of games and I think that's um yeah I mean that's enough of a rambling about my past so basically I played lots of games like lots of games still do I have a huge appreciation for games which um are instantly accessible like none of the games I have made to be clear have reached this level of thing but something like a Jenga or a Doppel like these

mass market games where it's just like you instantly like the product just tells you what it is you have to do like it just instantly shows you how to engage with it and you might have to learn one or two things but then it's unforgettable, which is just, I mean, to me, that's like, perfection, right, like being able to design to make a game like that. Obviously, you can't do everything

with a game like that, you can't tell you can't tell the same sorts of stories, you can't immerse people in worlds, but you know, you can you can do like, you know, to be able to make it an engaging experience that you know, you can pull out with anyone and it's instantly accessible. And it's just immediately obvious what it is, but it's just fun like that. I mean, to me, that's like, it's for me, the epitome of, or like, that's like my, my, my dream to be able to create a

game like that. Oh, that's, that's a really interesting thought. And yeah, yeah. Kind of, kind of, you know, seeing, seeing the game in its physical form, like you said, and Just kind of having some some instinct like this is what it is. Yep But yeah, I mean, okay, I don't want to die like no. No, I like that a lot. I don't want to dive into you know so obviously in chunks, but my thought here then as a follow -up is You know,

you mentioned that like a lot of your games Aren't like that. Obviously you have to read the rules in order to see how you're interfacing with it. But have you yet have you made any sort of efforts in designing in that space? Because I think it is a different type of design than what most people are making these days. Yep. Yeah, no, absolutely. So it's something that, so going to the collaborations bit, so I work with a few

different partners. And certainly one of the major design partners that I have is a guy, Brett Gilbert. And he and I have been increasingly trying to play around in the sort of, you know, more mass marketing space, right? Where we're like, you know, like we both just, you know, that's our dream to make a Django or to make a daubel or something like that. And certainly

we are trying. But it's one of these things where we've had some limited successes. Nothing has been published yet, but we've made it. We're getting into the rooms with some of the big more mass -market people, and we're increasingly getting closer in our designs, I think, about trying to just hone things down and create that sort of thing but it is a very very very different

beast than even creating something which to a hobby gamer is quite you know um simple or abstract like some of the other games i've met like mandala or great planes or like those what most people would say oh you know it's trivial there's just no rules like it's simple it's whatever words you want to use but it's still that's like miles away from what something like, you know, I mean,

yeah, we can talk there. There are there are there are changes potentially happening in some aspect. Like, there's ways in which sort of the casual side of the hobby market and the and the more complex side of the hobby of the mass market are sort of maybe coming closer together. But certainly when you're talking about a game like Dabler or Jenga, like it's still light years away, right? It's not to say I don't dislike

games with more complexity in terms of the rules or the interface. Yeah, I just very much appreciate games that have the minimum interface Necessary the minimum amount of rules necessary to deliver the type of experiences trying to deliver I guess I just don't like like every time I can cut a sentence or a paragraph out of rules. I'm a happy boy and And yeah, I think that's something that

Brett certainly You know every time we chop it down from under 700 words to under 600 words. We have like a little celebration. And David Thompson, who's my other main collaborator, like we make the Undaunted series, which is obviously, you know, again, a step up from Doppel and Jenga. But the whole thing is it's still, like most war gamers would say, these are lights. fluffy

games compared to, you know, like the, you know, what, what traditionally people see as war games. So I think we both like, you know, all the people that work have an appreciation for, for sort of simplification and abstraction where we can. Yeah. Yeah. I think, I think like, you know, you're hitting on a good kind of hallmark of, of your designs and both co -design pairs that you just mentioned. And that's, and that's kind of, you know, bridging Being being in that in -between space or even yeah, even if it is still

kind of relatively light for you know, like a war game or light for a Modern or game in general like that You know doing doing the most you can with the least within those design spaces. Yeah Yeah, I think that definitely comes across. I think I think you mentioned, you know with like mandala and Great Plains I think you know Great Plains is probably the one to me that sticks out the most. You're just putting out a piece,

putting out a piece. Maybe some initial stickiness for somebody learning that and wondering about the special powers. Could I do this or could I do that? That's really about it though. That's interesting. Another thing, backtracking a little bit, I have never played Go. I actually don't really know too much about Go. I know that, you

know, some, some Knizia games, especially through the desert, people say that it has goal -like elements. Do you, do you feel like the, a goal with a Great Plains or at least some inspiration? Ford is from Go? And this is just me asking because I have no idea. No, no. I mean, it's good. It's a good question. And I mean, the answer is absolutely yes. So and one day, I mean, it's probably a bit late now, but I had always wanted to write

sort of a design diary for Great Plains. Maybe I will one day. And yeah, no, definitely. Like, I mean that. Well, it's always tricky because design diaries always look like anything, like any piece of writing, you're always looking back and creating a history, right? It's always a much cleaner history than the reality. Like, you know, you create this beautiful narrative of intent and things follow naturally from that intent. But certainly, like, the game was heavily inspired by Go and obviously games like Through

the Desert and lots of other sort of modern games that have themselves traced back to go. And I think a lot of what, I actually don't know too, I mean, just to be, I mean, I'll put, I'll say it upfront, you know, Rainer Knizia, the designer of Through the Desert and 750 other games, like literally 700, he is my, you know, unabashedly my favorite game designer. I mean, I absolutely

just love his work. And so whenever anyone compares any of my games to his, it's the happiest I can be. Anyway, enough of that. But basically, so definitely the Great Plains and some of the other games that I've made over the years have been sort of inspired by Go and some of these other

Go -like games. And I mean, Go is a weird one. It really is a weird one. It's one of these things where I don't know if I can recommend it. Would I recommend it to people to play? I think it really depends on the sort of person you are and the amount of time and effort you're willing to put into it because it is not a game that shows itself um quickly like the there's it's

very very simple rules but you you learn the rules you look at this big board and you're like I have no idea how to play and I have no idea I have no like where do I go like what what am I trying to do like it just because the rules there are very very few rules but they're all about capturing pieces but ultimately it's not a game of capturing pieces it's a game of building up area it's like an area influence game or area you know sort of an area influence game but the rules don't say that like it's that's just what

emerges from the rules and Yeah, and it's all symmetric to start with. And you're like, I don't know what to do. And you can play anywhere. And like, it's just it's it's really it takes time to get it like and and it's brutal because it's an abstract strategy game. And if you play with someone who is better than you, they just win like end of story. There's no there's no if ands

or buts like, you know, it's just like, no, they're going to beat you. So, um, you know, when, when, when I remember reading some, um, cause back when I was a kid and had time reading like go strategy books, um, back in the days of books and they were like, um, you know, it was like, lose your first 50 games of go as quickly as you can. So you can learn to enjoy it. Just, I mean, that's basically what you have to do. Um, but, but this is where lots of, um, you know,

the sort of modern ilk. I say modern through the deserts, like 25 years old or whatever it is. We're getting, I'm getting old. But like, you know, there's these games that have been influenced by it. You know, I think in many ways they make the thing, some of the things that the beauty of Go, they make it more palatable and immediate. And, and then also try to, in

not very clever ways, hide the fact that it's an abstract game by giving you, you know, a couple pretty pictures to look at and some little camels or a little, uh, or whatever. What is it? What did I, I can't even remember what you have in Green Plains. They're foxes and snakes. Foxes and snakes. Yes, exactly. Exactly. Um, to try to lure you in, but ultimately what the If you get any enjoyment out of the game, you're getting the enjoyment of that type of pure abstract strategy

game. Yeah, that's really cool. So I had a few thoughts. I think the experience that I can link to the most is I started looking into the GIF series games. I have two. I've only played one. So I have Devon and Tsar. Right. And so I played, you know, I learned Devon physically played it

a couple times like that. And then I went, it's on board game arena. So then I started playing and it was one of those games where there are not that many people who are playing it, so the people who are, who the people are playing it a lot. Yeah, they'll stomp you. They'll stomp you. I'm like, oh, this is going to be a really clever play. I'm going to, you know, jump this, this huge gap and I'm going to go and, you know, leave their people stranded or their little tokens around people and their little chips stranded. And then, and then, you know, they saw that like five turns ago and then I lose, man. All right.

I mean, it's funny that I make these abstract games and I talk about Go, but I don't really spend a lot of time... I'm not a competitive player and I don't spend a lot of time playing... like a few will like the pure abstracts like the seamless abstracts because like that like I mean like the gift series I played a few and then thoroughly I have enjoyed them definitely

um and like I don't play that much go anymore um just because it's it's such an ask to find people to play with yeah but um but what what I was gonna say is that um what I find really interesting is um when If you can find someone, like if you take one of these more modern abstracts, right, if you can find someone who hasn't played the game before, right, and someone that you

enjoy playing two -player games with and, you know, enjoy the sort of, you know, some competition and exploring things together, then I think it's like, I always enjoyed that experience of learning a sort of abstract game with someone and and going through that. And the other interesting thing is that sometimes when I watch people play games like that or, you know, Great Plains or whatever, is that like they don't, not everyone approaches it like a, you know, sort of high

level abstract strategy player. They just sort of like bung pieces out and see what happens, right? And I mean, and that's what I love about it, like, is that these games can be played in that way. Like, a perfect example is, do you know the game Hey, That's My Fish? Yes, yes. Like that's my one of my favorite all time favorite games. I love it. I love it. I mean, the only negative thing about the game is that it takes longer to set up than it does to play. Like,

like that's that's lit. But I mean, it's just beautiful. And like I, you know, I have kids and it was one of the first games I played with my kids because you can play it at the level of just just I'll just go for the threes. I'll just go for the big fish tiles. And like, that's it. And you can play it that way and or you just play randomly and like the game runs and the rules are simple and like, you know, it's clear what you're doing. But. It also has on top of

that. A whole different game which is around, you know, controlling areas and blocking people off. And then there's the balance and then it becomes the balance between those two things. And so, you know, you get. Depth. with multiple layers of sort of playing the game, right? And I think that's, I mean, to me, when a game can do that, I think that's fantastic. And I mean,

in some ways, I think it goes a bad example of that, however, I will say. So when I lived in China and in Taiwan for a while teaching English, And I taught some kids in Taiwan who were like, you know, sort of kindergarten age, and, you know, it was a big deal there. And so like, they played a lot of Go. And just watching them play,

they played it as a speed game. Like it was just bang, bang, bang, bang, bang. And just like, like, you know, it was just, they played it. Yeah, they didn't, they didn't deliberate, they didn't think they just bong, bong, bong, bong, bong, take some pieces off bong, bong, bong. And, and, you know, and they thoroughly enjoyed it. And obviously, in, you know, in deep in their brains, they were learning the patterns just through trial and error. And I'm sure that over time, if they if they continue to play, who knows

if they did, that they would that that sort of foundational play, like play would lead to them. sort of grokking more of the emergent strategy of the game. But, you know, they were able to play it at that very superficial level of just make groups of things and let's see what happens. A lot of good stuff in your thoughts there. And it's kind of funny because I'm thinking about, you know, my experience. So with Great Plains,

yeah, I mean, obviously I think when it comes to any type of game, I'm going to be competitive for the sake of playing or agreeing to that competitive whatever. But I'm not going to overthink it. And sometimes if the competitiveness matches with, I want to... you know, pick up a bird tile so I can fly over in this part and then push

your snake into a mountain because I think it's going to be funny. Well, that's what I'm going to prioritize. And if it works out, that's awesome. Or, you know, in Devon, I'm going to try to make these super stacks and see how far I can jump on the board. You know, it's fun. Like, I mean, that's part of it too. So. Yeah. Yeah. No, absolutely. Absolutely. The games offer you lots of different ways of experiencing them and playing with them.

I get as much satisfaction out of just trying to do bonkers things or just experiment and play in the system that the game provides, the options that it provides, and just see what happens. you know, there are people, there are some people in my life, like whenever I play with my brother or whatever, like, you know, we will, we'll just, we'll go, we'll click back into competitive childhood mode. And it's like, I'm going to thrash you and like, that's all that matters. You know what

I mean? So like, but when I'm playing, you know, I mean, my kids are getting older now, but when I was playing with, you know, when I'm playing or playing with a four year old, like probably shouldn't be trying to thrash them if you ever want to play a game with them again. and and yeah I mean it's it's it's anyway that's that's but yeah it's it's it's good to hear that um you know that you're you know that you're yeah

anyway that's that's enough of that yeah yeah no I kind of have one one more you know gaming gaming you know preference type of question and things that you play kind of up until uh today so you know and and there's a reason why i'm asking this one too so obviously you know co -op games have been around for a bit i think people probably will say that you know pandemic is is one or the one or a one that really made

that genre a bit more popular so you said you're an omni gamer uh but Do you or have you played a lot of co -op games? Is that something that you're interested in? No, it's funny you mention that. So like, I, when I'm just playing games and there's more than three people or two or like, when you get to larger group games, like I play a huge amount of collaborative games or

co -op games like probably just one is the game that I have played probably the sort of new I mean it's like whatever is four or five years games probably the new game I played the most of um and then like the mind have you played the mind yeah I mean like I to me that's just that's just brilliant I love I absolutely love that game. So I really, really like those sort of collaborative, cooperative sort of party games.

I'm doing air quotes as though people can hear. I'm doing air quotes. I love those sorts of games. And I have played my fair share of sort of more of the sort of strategy type cooperative games like Pandemic. Although I probably tend to prefer them less to the sort of more socially type cooperative ones where it's about it's not about sort of solving a puzzle together. It's about exploring

each other, if you will, like doing something together, whether it's, you know, trying to provide clues to each other play guessing games together or like in the minds trying to I don't even know what the hell how you describe that it's it's it's getting it getting in sync yeah exactly getting in sync and then and then running a marathon together it's just it's incredible um so yeah like I'm certainly Yeah. And I mean, another good example is I said I played, I don't do it

that much now, but I did play a lot of Dungeons and Dragons and sort of role playing games when I was a kid. And I know it's not technically a cooperative because there's a game master, blah, blah, blah. But the point of the game is to have this collaborative, cooperative experience of co -creating the fun, right? Rather than trying to... you know, optimize a particular strategy or whatever you're doing. Yeah. Yeah. That's,

yeah, that's, that makes like, like a ton of sense. And I, and you mentioned, you know, Dungeons and Dragons and, and as of 2024 this year, I have my, my first and most uh, limited experience with like a mini session that I was a part of and it was, it was really great. I had a good time, but I think, yeah, I can't imagine how that experience would have been if it was, if it wasn't, you know, uh, a collaborative effort.

If you weren't trying to get the most out of like interactions with each other and yeah. And I think this one, you know, we definitely had it with the the Dungeon Master built in some, you know, combat maybe after, at the end of a session or every other, but it wasn't even, you know, all combat oriented. So it was a lot of exploration and stuff too. So it was cool. Yeah. It wasn't, I didn't really need to dive into the manual super heavily or anything. And yeah,

it was a good onboarding experience, but. That's cool. Yeah. I mean, there's, I mean, I, I just wish I had more time in my life because I mean there's this obviously there's we're in the middle of this massive explosion of role -playing games like indie role -playing games and there's all of I mean it's it's just an incredible time I think um and I would love to love love love love to have more time to to experience some of them um and yeah and I think a lot a lot of Like there's

still plenty of crunchy sort of role playing games out there where, you know, they have a big fat manual and, you know, like look up charts for this, that, and the other and huge, like, you know, huge character creation processes. But there's for every one of those, there's 10, which are just like, you know, one page of rules. And, you know, it's just like, get on with it. And the things, the things done in 60 minutes and it's done. like, it's a one shot thing. And,

you know, I think that's something that I'd love to have more time to experience. And just, it's just a really different and creative time, I think, in that in that world. And it's one other sort of type of game to mention that I've sort of, again, in this sort of, again, not technically cooperative, but the sort of hidden traitor games, like I you know, I like a lot of people discovered werewolf or mafia or whatever you want to call

it. I think it was I was in university, and we just fell no high school. And we fell in love with it and started playing it a lot. And then, you know, obviously, there's been it's a whole sub genre of hobby games now. And Again, it's that idea of it's a social game where it's about experiencing each other and getting into each

other's heads rather than trying to focus on the game, the table, the bits, the strategies or social strategies, if anything. It's just a different type of experience. I definitely love these sorts of games. And it's funny, I mean, again, I've tried my hand at designing a few of them mostly with Brett Gilbert. Nothing

has sort of hit yet, but we're trying. But I think it's... for whatever reason when I go to the, when I tap the well of game design, it's just like the abstract sort of stratist. Like basically, you know, it's either like my game design, like my muse either gives me some sort of area control positional thing or a sort of auction -y bidding game with cards. Those are

the two things that my muse gives me. But, you know, I keep, you know, it's funny because although I thoroughly love both those types of games, I love playing other types of games. I just, it's, yeah, I find it, I guess just, it's less natural. I have to force myself to say, okay. If I were to make a hidden trader game, how would I do it? And so far nothing has hit, but you never know. Yeah, I don't know. I wonder, I mean,

I wonder too, if it's kind of like a matter for you that those are the types of games that you're, you know, gravitating towards playing most having these, you know, more social kind of, kind of bigger experiences. I mean, obviously, you know, just one is going to thrive at more than three. I'm just going to throw out like a hypothetical number. And if it's, you know, because, and,

you know, speaking of kind of like a game that has some of those elements of simplicity and rich experience that comes from that simplicity, like in, in just one in the mind to, you know, if If you're just holding yourself to like too high of a standard when you're thinking about that process, right? I mean, I mean, I mean like, no, it's a fair point. It's a fair point. Yeah, it's a fair point. Um, yeah, no, I think you

may, you may well be right. I mean, you know, you can't, and especially with when your first, you know, your first delve into something, you know, like, I mean, okay, let's be fair though. The, the mind was one of. Wolfgang Barsch's first games. And so, you know, he just like the year that that game came out, like, he also had, oh, God, there was like, he had like two or three games nominated for the various Spiel des Jahres awards in the same year. It was like, it's like he had like one game before that. So, but But

the point is that it's a modern classic, just one is again a modern classic. Maybe I should just be willing to make something that's a bit less. I'm not even saying a bit less. That was all for me to say that I believe in you. Oh, thank you. Oh, thank you. Oh, thank you. That was the point. I wasn't going to say, hey, here's a classic you can't do, but. No, no, but I mean,

it's it's it's yeah. And like I said, so Brett and I have tried to do a few party games like those sort of like these collaborative sort of whatever you want to call them, party games or whatever. And yeah, we've no we've got we've got some. some ideas and some things and we've pitched some things, but yeah, just nothing is hit yet. And I mean, I'll be brutally honest, even if something comes, I gotta be careful. But even if anything of the ilk that we have, the things that we have now, none of them are

at that level. I mean, I hold both those games on a pedestal. So, you know, but, you know, I'm only... Whatever, I am 43. I've still got some time. I've still got some time. Yes, like I said, I think, again, just reiterating, it's you holding them on a pedestal, which is only hurting, not you. OK, all right. That's it. So OK, here, I asked that question about the games that you're

interested or the co -op linked games because it was kind of a transition point into You know some of the collaborative things that that you work on and the people that you work with too But I mean a lot of that stuff has kind of naturally, you know come out already so You know, I guess a follow -up question before I even get into some of those a little bit is I I also wonder you know Especially the games that i'm most familiar

with Of yours. I mean i've played a lot of great planes. I've played a lot of um mandala i've just got my first couple games in of patterns and that was fun i i like that one as well and you know war chest and um obviously the undaunted series is one that i think i have well i basically have all the undaunted stuff but i just haven't played it Ton a couple times like that too, obviously.

So yeah, I'm getting I have quite quite the catalog of You very much all behind me and some spot but you know, I think I Think you know war chest Does play up to four? I've only played it, you know head -to -head. Yeah, and and there might be some Here, correct me if I'm wrong. OK, this is just me not even thinking about it too much because I haven't played it much. But Undaunted

is primarily one versus one. Yeah, that's right. Does the new one that's coming out, does that open it up a little bit? So I mean, yeah, it's predominantly a one versus one game. I mean, that's how it started. That's how it was designed. There was an expansion. a few years back that introduced solo play, which just to be clear, David Thompson and I didn't design. That was designed by a couple other designers, both named

Davids, which is just horribly confusing. And we also introduced a two versus two play, which is similar to what War Chest has. And the new, undaunted, the Callisto, the spacey one, sci -fi one, will have two versus two and solo in it as well. But I mean, yeah, it's basically, I shouldn't say this. If the publishers listen,

they'll beat me down. But no, I mean, it's designed first and foremost as a head versus head game, right? And the two versus two play is... You know, essentially it's a, you know, it's a team game. You split up your forces into two and play, play that way. And I mean, it's, I mean, I actually really quite enjoy it. And David Thompson says that, you know, for him it's his favorite way of playing them. But yeah, I think like it's ultimately one side versus another. And, you

know, the, the, the overwhelming amount of, you know, that's, that's where it's, you know, sort of been optimized. Yeah, okay. So yeah, I think just again because now now my questions which I had all set up They're all swirling and they've all no no no, I'm sorry. I'm not all changed Okay, I think I think for the better too because You you already mentioned that you have Kind

of kind of the two types of designs that you're drawn towards or the ones that you can you know fall back on and iterate and and work with are the the ones that deal with you know some positional abstract like feeling and then the other kind of card bidding and then obviously and daunted like the deck building and and hand management stuff then to Like I guess I guess like linking

that to what your your your some of like your goals and making something you know bigger and and more social and and kind of like naturally um being like a like a big hidden role like a like a werewolf or something like that yeah like if there are any any kind of things that are like conflicting within your head kind of based on like where you you naturally fall towards and that's not a question i'll just Yeah. Oh,

yeah, that's it. That's interesting. Well, one thing that I think for the types of the sort of social games that we talked about, like the just one in the mind and the werewolf, like these things, they tend not to have sort of a shared Space right like your 10 not to be looking down

at something right your most of the focus is looking at the other players or I guess in just one it's. staring into the mid distance or staring at a thing. But like, essentially, you're trying to get into the heads of the other people. And that's what it is that you're focused on. And obviously, when you play any strategy game, you're trying to get into the head of the other player, but it's always mediated through this sort of like, shared board or whatever. Right. And so

yeah, I think convincing myself to move away from that crutch of there always being some shared thing that we're all looking down at. I guess I struggle to do that naturally. I want there to be something in the middle of the play area. you know, that we're like, and that's what I want that I mean, I love these games that don't

have that, but that's just where my brain goes. And so yeah, and I mean, I guess, like, even with it with a game, like a card game or traditional card game, whether it's a trick taking game, or a, you know, like a ladder type shedding game, right, like, you know, I played lots and lots of games like that and love them. It's still, it's still, you know, you're looking at a hand and you're putting things into a shared space

to bid for something or to try to win a trick or whatever. So it's still very much us all looking down at the table at something. And that's where the interaction sort of happens rather than, um, then looking, you know, I mean, I guess something like poker is kind of, you know, I mean, it still has that You know, you still have your hidden information, you have the shared stuff, like I guess I'm talking about like, um, Texas Hold 'em or whatever, and there's the shared stuff in the middle. But so much of the game is looking

at the other players because of that hidden information and how critical that is to the game, right? I don't know. Yeah, it's an interesting thing because I do like, yeah, hand of cards and a shared space are just the cruxes of the game of where I come from. And I mean, I'll just take a tiny tangent to say that like, I'm still like, that's the space I'm the happiest in and what I struggle with and I say struggle, but I'm not

really, because I'm not that interested. There's a whole world of games out there now, and no offence to them, and no offence to the people who like them, where they just do away with even that and just say, everyone look down in front of you at a little personal board and just play there. while other people play with their little puzzles in front of them and we'll do that for an hour. At the end, we'll see who built the best puzzle or built their puzzle the fastest or whatever. I have experimented with some of

those games. I made some and I can enjoy them. I don't like the term multiplayer salt here, but those sorts of experiences where it's much more, I'm solving a puzzle. and you were solving a puzzle, and we might occasionally fight a bit over the puzzle pieces. Like, you know, it's like, oh, I wanted that puzzle piece. It's like, oh, sorry, I didn't even notice. But you, you know, sorry, I took it. Like, those sorts of

games, like, you know, take and make games. They're sometimes called now. I mean, it's such a huge chunk of modern gaming are games like that. And again, I have no disrespect to the people who like them more. Like, it's just, it's just that's not like, to me, that's the, like, I'm, yeah, the games I enjoy the most with my friends and family are the ones that are the furthest away from that possible. But the ones where my brain

is the happiness. in terms of designing games is in between those two types of extremes, you know, where we're interacting, but we're interacting in a shared space where there's still like, you know, sort of strategy and, you know, you know what I mean, like those more traditional senses of strategy rather than just purely sort of like social dynamics. I think it's interesting that you brought up poker. and the shared space and

reading other people, because I do get a bit of that in Mandala. Oh, cool. Nice. Good. I mean, I don't think it's a poker -like game, but I do think there is a lot of the... I don't know, there is a lot that's on the table, but there is also a lot that's above the table, too. And that wondering, that intrigue, and how much... I mean, like you're playing with the cards and you're bidding with cards instead of like playing

with the cards and bidding with chips. So yeah. Yeah. Yep. Yep. Okay. No, good. I mean, yeah, I can see that. And I think that is a nice feature of auction games, right? Like auction games sort of have that, you know, like you know, there is that aspect of, you know, how much will they go for? And certainly in a game like Mandala,

where you have sort of a restriction on what you can bid with that there, you have that elements, like you said, of that sort of like, you know, like the, you know, do you have, can you bid more for this? Like, do you have those three red cards in your hands? And, you know, those moments when you're like, oh, yes, I do. Like those are, those are, those are like the, I mean, obviously not to the same degree, but it's like the moment of like, oh, yes, I did have the seven

of clubs straight flush. Like, you know, that, that sort of thing. So yeah. I mean, I guess I hadn't. Yeah. I mean, nice observation. I hadn't really made that connection, but it's good. Yeah. And then that one. Okay. I'm, I'm just going to start gushing because I've, I've never, you know, formally made. a top 10 list of my favorite games, but, and I don't really, I mean, I've played a lot of games at this point in time, but you know, every time I think about a top

10, I have Mandala in that top 10. Oh, that's brilliant. Thanks so much. And it's something, it is a special game. I love it so much. Yeah. It sort of took Brett and I bit by surprise. I mean, we liked it. And we knew that there was something there. But I don't think, I mean, I guess this is true for a lot of things, like, I don't think we expected it to have this sort

of, you know, not again, not that it's like, it's not, you know, it's not, it's not top 50 top 100. games but it's like you know like it's done well and it's been like the people who like it seem to really like it and I don't but I don't think we've we expected it to have that sort of um you know that reception and so yeah thank you very much we're very we're you know it's great and and also I at some level I don't think this is this horrible thing to say but I don't

think we necessarily saw a lot of the nuance and the depth of it in the same way. Like, you know, it wasn't all designed in, if you will, which is a horrible thing to admit, but I'm here, Scoop, admit it. Like, I think, I think, you know, certainly as we, you know, as we played it, we saw, you know, we saw some of that, but

like, I don't think we, it's just sort of, kind of just sort of fell in some ways fell together. So we were combining a couple different elements from other games that we've been working on and we're exploring it. But it was like, yeah, it just sort of licked how we managed to, you know, I mean, again, I just go back to what I said earlier on is that like, I mean, yes, there is

intent in design, of course there is, and everyone, you know, is trying to create something. But anyone, any designer who doesn't tell you that there's some just serendipity and some magic that just happens, like, by chance, by rubbing two things together in the right way, is either far, far better than me or is lying. So one of the two. One of the two. I'll offer up a third option. It's just that you're really good at what you do. And some of those things that you

maybe, I don't know, not saying like took for granted or whatever, were just things that you inherently hadn't thought and baked into those different game ideas that you mashed around to start with in the first place. Right. Yeah. Well, I'll take it. Thanks. Thanks, Ryan. I mean, I think for me, from an outsider looking in, that's legitimately how I see it too. You can think of it like a sport almost, not every time. Think

basketball, where Luka Donchich makes this fantastic 70 foot pass. Like on, on a dime, it doesn't overthink it. It's just, you know, years of practice and years of doing it have manifested to that point. So, yeah, I mean, there's, there's definitely a huge element of that in, again, not to compare myself, but just like, just, you know, like, I, you know, I still have lots of terrible ideas.

And, um, I have, thankfully again, we can go back to the. collaborations, things I have partners, design partners who over the years we've learned to quite bluntly and constructively and lovingly tell each other when we have terrible ideas. We still have our fair share of terrible ideas, but the number of terrible ideas to good ideas, well, I don't know if that's true, but it's certainly like the process of finding the good ideas. and

separating them from the bad ideas is now a hell of a lot faster than it used to be, right? Like it used to be, you know, basically like stabbing in the dark and just like, Oh, what if I took that building and you know, whatever, whatever, and smash it together and see what happens. Like most of the time it was terrible. Just like most, you know, most ideas are terrible, but it's But it's sort of, yeah, you build up an intuition about things and, you know, you build up a process

for weeding through the bad stuff faster and these sorts of things. So yeah, there's definitely something there for sure. That's awesome. So, okay, so kind of kind of backtracking a little bit, you brought up Brett Gilbert, you brought up David Thompson and kind of Interestingly enough between our initial communication and setting up this In this talk and actually talking now.

I listened to David Thompson's interview on the board game geek podcast with oh, yeah, Candice Harris and He talked about a little bit very briefly about you know some of the initial kind of design group that you all had in in Cambridge and And who, so I guess who else was, was a part of that. And I don't really have a ton of knowledge on your group outside of like seeing names on boxes, I guess. So any, any, any story, any insight,

any history there? Yeah, sure. No, absolutely. So it's, yeah, it was, it's a weird thing because obviously for us, it was just, you know, Okay, before I get to the retrospect, okay. So basically the facts are that there is in the UK, like in lots of places, there's sort of, you know, various types of groups that meet up to play test each

other's games, you know, to come and try out like this whole game design thing, right? you know, you bring in your idea for a game or you bring in your prototype for a game and other people try it and you know, you see how things go. And so there was a like one of these game design meetup groups that that Brett Gilbert and Matthew Dunstan who is another key member

of this. He's an Australian game designer. He was living in Cambridge at the time. And so they basically, yeah, they set up a group. It was the two of them to begin with. They would just show up to a pub once a week and, you know, design games. And then slowly they started, you know, you know, this is sort of 15 years ago, that sort of time scale. They, you know, advertised it. online and a variety of people started coming

and they made connections and then around when was it 2013 -2014 that's when I came in and David Thompson came in very very shortly after and then there was Again, there's been quite a few people who've sort of come into it over the years. And so around that time, there was another guy called Chris Marling, who David has designed a couple of games with. Matthew Dunstan designed a couple of games with. And then there was other

waves of people coming in. And another big name there is Dave Neal, who's done a lot of narrative games. He's done You know, he did a new version of Sherlock Holmes consulting detectives. He's done lots of Sherlock Holmes games for lots of other narrative games. He's done three or four or five different games with Matt Dunstan. He's done a game with David Thompson that's coming out this year. So yeah, like those are probably

the sort of core people, but then there's lots of other people who have come and some have gone. It's this weird thing where a lot of the original group has sort of moved off, you know, moved away because Cambridge is one of these cities where, you know, it's obviously a big university, but also a lot of, so you have a lot of influx of non -British people coming in for a variety of different reasons and then leaving. And so

that's sort of what it is. And so it was, you know, it's We were just really, really fortunate that Matt and Brett set this thing up and that through serendipity, a bunch of people came in who like, and like, I mean, that was my first exploration of properly doing game design. I mean, I always had ideas for games. I had always had, you know, I tried my hand at it again, sometimes

on my own, sometimes with other friends, but we didn't really know. what it is that you do to make a game. It was very much in that I, you know, I very much had that idea that it's just like, you have to have the right idea and it all has to just work. And then you just vomit into the world and it's done. Like that was the sort of idea I had of game design, which is of course foolish because it never works that way. It's a iterative process, just like anything else. And so, you know, I managed to learn that

from these people who feel like, no, you have to make something and it'll be bad and we'll see if there's anything good in it. And then, you know, you pick those bits and you make them better and throw away the bits that are bad. And then also that's just, and that's just the design process, but there's the whole business side of it as well. Like you have to go out and meet the publishers and make the contacts and go to the conventions and blah, blah, blah. And so it was great to have a couple people who'd had, when we arrived on the scene, who'd had

some experience and success with that. But a lot of it has just been, you know, a group of people sort of growing together and helping each other out. And from that, you know, I've made both sort of hopefully lifelong game design partners, but also lifelong friends like, you know, I mean, David Thompson's one of my best friends, Brett. lives up the road from me and you know he comes over all the time and he knows my family and

you know like so we're you know we're we're friends like and i think that's um i mean obviously that doesn't isn't always going to happen in a collaborative partnership you know but i think like to me that's a big part of what it is like i don't a i don't want to design games my own because i just i don't I mean, ultimately this is still sort of a, it's not, it's not a hobby exactly. It's sort of a jobby, right? Like it's, you know, I have,

I have, I still have a proper job. And this is on the side. I mean, it's more than, than, than just a hobby, but, but I still want to enjoy it. I don't want it to feel like work. And, you know, I wouldn't want to spend this time. working with someone who I don't like, you know, or like I work with them because I have to, you know, so like, so anyway, I'm rambling now. Let's get back to so basically that that's the situation

with Cambridge is that it was it was the Cambridge meetup group, right is that Matt and Brett set up this thing. Variety of people came in, they've come and gone. But, you know, obviously there's still partnerships that have continued after people have left. So Matt Dunston has gone back to Australia now, and him and Brett still make a lot of games together. He still has other collaborations with people that he met while he was here, like

in ink, both in the UK and collaborations he has with some other European designers, some Aussie designers like him and Phil Harder -Walking make some stuff together and then other people. So yeah, it's not that big a community of designers when you think about it. I mean, I think you can do a six degrees of Kevin Bacon type thing and quite easily hit pretty much anyone within two or three links. Well, a couple things. First

off, if this podcast and these interviews aren't a vessel for rambling, then I'm not doing it right. Okay, so that's thing one. And thing two, I think it was probably on Twitter or social media in some degree, but it had a lot of the collaborations in those circles, kind of like you mentioned. Oh, yes. Yeah. So it's like that. And I'm pulling for sports. I don't know why my brain's on sports, but it's almost like a

Belichick coaching tree or a Popovich coaching tree or something like that, where you got the Brett and Matthew coaching design tree. Yeah, well, this is it. No, that's exactly it. Yeah, so David Thompson recently put out a a visio, like showing the like, you know, and I mean, there have been also some trios, which is kind of cool, we're like, you know, again, not none have come out yet. But like, there's been collaborations

in trios, although, yeah, designing with two and three is, it's a different thing from those like, it's Yeah, it's an interesting one. So I've done a few myself, and I've just been talking to other people as well. I mean, it works. It works. But it almost then becomes like you have to divvy up the labor a bit more. Anyway, that's a whole second thing. And obviously, when you go to the bigger, there's game companies out

there that have much bigger teams, like Fantasy Flight Games. you know, much bigger groups of people, for example, working on a game than sort of the more, I don't know, you wanna call it, I mean, it's not, you know, indie or whatever you wanna call it, design groups, right? Well, that's funny too, because I mean, I think when my questions was, and you said it's a whole nother

thing, and I have to imagine it is, but I did. kind of have a question regarding that chief differentiation between designing with one other person and designing with two, because, you know, I think, well, you mentioned that you have Sniper Elite, and that was with David and Roger Tankersley, correct? Okay, so yeah, interesting. Again, don't feel bad, don't feel bad, because it's even the... I love your checking. So... Sniper Elite was

Roger and David, but Roger and David and I have done Resist, which is a little solo game, and then Witchcraft, which is a follow -up to that, and we're working on other things now, too. But yeah, trios are weird, because when there's two, obviously... when you're designing a game, there's always stuff going, it's always rumbling around the back of your head. But when it comes to like, doing the design work, there's only the two people,

right? So you meet up, you say, you know, this is the idea I had, or this is the work that I've been doing on this based on the last time we met or whatever did it did it with treehouse, you have this awkwardness where it's like, If you talk to one of the other two people and the other person isn't there, you kind of feel like you're cheating. Right. And so it's a weird one. It's a weird one. And especially where with David and Roger and I, because David and I meet. like three times a week at least right because we

have you know like undaunted to do right like that's just like it's basically we're always working on an undaunted game and other things right we have other projects that are basically like so we're always meeting and then Roger and David like work together and they do their own game a couple of their own game designs like Snape Elite and so they talk together sometimes and so it's like sometimes it makes it a bit awkward where it's like Okay, so we've already had this discussion, but then we have to have it officially with the trio because, you know,

and so that just makes the communication a bit interesting. And I'm sure that as you scale up to even more people, that becomes an even bigger problem to solve. And then you're just talking about these are not problems inherent to board game design. This is just... collaborative projects, right? Like, how do you manage communication amongst the people? How do you manage, um, making sure that everyone feels like they're involved

in every step, but also that some people are responsible for some things and other people are responsible for other things and all that stuff. And, um, yeah, it's an interesting one. So like with, I mean, I'll just quickly mention. So with Roger and David and I, we have very, like with a couple of games we've done so far. it's like, you know, we, we sort of settle into roles. It became quite clear, right? Like, Roger does the theme and a lot of the history stuff.

David did the sort of the main sort of mechanical conceptualization of the game and sort of And he does most of the marketing and managing with the publisher and this sort of thing. And then I do more development and I write the rules and a lot of that's more editorial side of things. So we have much quite clearly defined roles. I mean, obviously, we're all involved at every

step, but that's the way it works. and even in a duo you fall into roles and that differs depending on who you're working with and David and you know he he we've he's talked about this publicly as well and I mean obviously I talked to him at all times like you know the role he takes on when he's worked on a game with um Roger is very different than the role he takes when he when when him and I worked together the role

I take on is very different when I'm working with Brett than with him and So you just sort of like, you learn these things and it's, um, I haven't had as much experience working with lots of different people. So David has, and he, you know, it makes sense. Like he said that, you know, it's always, it takes a while to get to find that footing when you're working with new person. It's like, okay, are you going to do this bit? Am I going to do that bit? Like, and especially, especially if it's someone, if it's someone who you're already have a relationship

with. then you already have some of those basic, you know, sort of communication, empathy pathways built up and you can manage it. But when it's someone who like, you know, you may know their name or have no something about them. But like, I mean, so David mentions a good example of working with Jeff Engelstein, who obviously is a big name. And but David, you know, had to figure out how to work with him. Right. Like, because it's just a totally different person and totally

different way of working and so it's fun I mean it's fun but um but yeah like I've I've been fortunate or I don't know maybe it's not fortunate enough that whatever whatever it is maybe not so that I all the designs I've done have been people that I have a relationship with yeah and and you mentioned it before too when you're talking about uh working with you know Brett and how you know obviously you know you're spending all

this time on something that you want to be doing and and you have that friendship so you have well you had a relationship and then it's obviously grown so that i don't know it's just it's a very unique opportunity yes yes oh that's all i had just very special yeah well no and and like even before I got into these design partnerships, like when I was fumbling around in the noughties,

like with game design, in a couple cases, it was like, it was with other friends. I mean, I say from back home, my old friends from Canada. And it was a way for us to have something, a reason to meet up regularly. and do you know try to do something so it was like i'm just a joint project collaborative project just just like some people meet up to play a sport or they meet up to you know go fishing or they meet up

to you know whatever like it was just it was a reason for for meeting up with someone and do you know and you know and i think that's something really nice like a lot of game design i mean if you actually look I think sort of the big, well, like a lot of the game design partnerships, the long ongoing ones, when you sort of listen to the podcasts or meet the people or we find out that a lot of the time, that's what it is. It's like, yeah, we've been friends for a long

time. And then, you know, whereas with me and Brett and me and David, it was we all intentionally wanted to do game design and met up and then through that formed the friendships. But, you know, I think it's, I can't imagine that there are many people working in hobby games who have a long time partnership with someone and don't get on well with them because it's like, Christ,

there's a hell of a lot easier ways to, you know, like to spend your time and make money than the designing board games. Like, God. We're gonna meet from 9 p .m. to midnight five times a week and I hate this person. Exactly, exactly. I mean, I wouldn't want to be in that situation anywhere, but I'd better have a boss who's telling me to do this and I'd better be making six figures

if this is how I'm gonna be spending my evenings. Oh, that's great. Okay, well, I mean, honestly, in terms of the collaboration questions, I mean, there's a lot of things that I had written in various spots that you've answered to different degrees and a lot of questions I didn't even know that I had that you wound up answering too. So thank you for doing my job. You're very welcome. But you kind of mentioned when you're talking

about falling into a role Within like the design group whether it's a like a duo partnership or or with a couple other people And you said that a lot of your work, you know, obviously all parts together But you mentioned that you are in the you know the development and the like rules and refine and then and that part of it is Your role, but I have a I had a question here, which is

kind of like that but I I want you to give yourself a title with this as well, all right? So this was what I wrote. So I said, if you were to give a brief title to the role you feel within the design team. So for example, I wrote the wild card or the visionary. I don't know why they came to my head and I wasn't necessarily presuming that's what you were going to pick, but they felt pretty bold. So that's why I picked them. But you have to give yourself a similar title.

Right. Well, it's interesting. So I'll let me think I'll pick the David one, I think, because it does it does differ, right? Like with Brett and me and Brett, like he's definitely has a better of the sort of developer editorial, like for for the games he and I work on, he writes every single rule set because he's like, he's exceptionally good at it. And he just he whittles away all the crap. And so I basically with David,

David, I sometimes joke with David, I say, David, you get the you get a bad version of Brett when you work with me. But whereas with, yeah, OK, let me think. So if I had OK, so for David, if I had to give a title, a title. Oh, that's a good one. You put me on the spot here. Okay,

let me think, let me think. So if I mean, I don't want to be, I don't want to put a negative spin on it, but yeah, like it's, there's two things that David always says about me. One is that, On the one hand, I'm always trying to cut out rules, right? I'm like, so it's like the, but we can't do that. Or like, but then we have to

do this. And it's like, like that, that sort of thing. So I mean, I guess it could be Mr. No, we can't do that. It doesn't sound very good. But the other thing is that I really try to chase fun, like, I want it, like, I don't want to settle for something which is just okay. And I think

with David, like, there are like a lot of the times not that not that he does not that he's willing to just push crap out. But like, but like, I think there's been quite a few times in our over the years where like he would have accepted something that I'm just like, no. It's not good enough. It's not good enough. It's not good enough. It's not good enough. It's not. And I can't always articulate why, you know,

I don't think it's good enough. But I'm like, if this just isn't, it's not fun enough or it's too clunky or, you know, it's, yeah, it's basically just not good. It's just not good enough. Like, we're better than this. You know, it's like, we're better than this. you know, we, you know, especially now it's like, I just, I'm like, I don't want to just put a crappy game out there. Like, you know, like it's one of these things where if I relied on this for my, you know, to

pay my bills and these sorts of things, I'd probably have a different opinion. But it's just like, you know, I don't want to, I don't want to put a subpar thing out there there's lots of games that like there's thousands and thousands of games coming out every year and again i'm not saying that all my games are perfect or anything like that but it's just like i don't want to put something out there that i feel that is not fully baked and something that i'm not happy to stand behind right um and so yeah it's the

we're not done, mister we're not done yet or something. We can't do that and it's not done yet or one of those two things. So I guess that's sort of a quality control type role of both in sense of the quality being is it as refined and simple as it can be but also is it as good as it can be. Yeah, well you gave me a couple so

I was trying to come up with like a title based on On like the initial thing when you said you're kind of like chopping out rules and refining So in that regard kind of like a like a grim reaper or like a yeah That's good. That's good. I like it. I like yeah, I see this is I'm not I'm not the theme guy I'll tell you that Yeah, if it's any like any of the theme The pizzazz comes from David or other people. And with Brett and I, we just were horrible. Because we're often

scrambling to try to find something to make sense of these rules that we've written. And it's just like, what makes sense of this? Nothing. But yeah, Grim Reaper's good. That's good. Thank you. I'll take that. We'll stick with that for now. But the other part, it doesn't necessarily fit with your part two. So I was trying to come up with both at the same time, and it just wasn't working in my head. But we'll say, based on overall, we'll just say the Grim Reaper. That's nice. No, it's good. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I like it. I like it. OK, so here, it's kind of like where

we are at in our conversation. You know, I had some specific abstract questions, but honestly, you know, the way that you talked about, you know, your inspiration early on and go, and I feel like some of the conversation is just not necessarily knock those questions out, but thinking about like the scope of the interview. I'm going to have one more collaboration type question and then get you to the wrap up questions too.

so I don't have to keep you up until midnight again. It's all good. Don't worry. Here's the final collaboration question. This is a structural note. Sometimes some of my episodes I will... We try to have a particular format or part of it be a format So like initially with this one and and it wasn't gonna work I could tell early on that it was gonna be like a complete failure.

I wanted to like I wanted to have all these questions be kind of in in the vein or feel like interview questions, right and then and then you know how sometimes like a job interview question a lot of them are about you know teamwork and this and that but yeah I feel like I ran out of real estate with that that format really early but I wanted to keep one though and this is yeah this is so I got it from I was just kind of poking around on typical teamwork based interview questions

and I got this one from Indeed so I'm not not sponsored just crediting the the source I guess but the the question is it's actually It is a question. It says, share an example of a team project that failed. Oh, God. All right. I have to be careful. All right. Without getting too specific because I don't want to offend the people

involved. So I'm going to twist a little bit. So here, the team is not the design team per se. Well, it is a design team, but basically the way that David and I work, I'll take David, but it applies to other people too, is like, you know, obviously the creation of a game is always a team effort, which extends beyond the

design team. you know, and you have to find, I mean, unless you want to do the whole thing yourself, but even then will be a team effort is you're always going to eventually have to work with a publisher and work with them. And the nature of those relationships can vary drastically, radically. And that's a whole, whole other discussion. But generally speaking with David and I, um, we prefer to sort of effectively do and manage

all of the design bit, right? And even like occasionally sort of for the fine level of development there's some like the publishers involved but generally speaking we just say like, here's the game. like play it see what you think if you have any feedback we'll go back and we'll incorporate you know make some changes or push back or whatever it is but essentially like it's us doing the design and that and most of the development right like i mean in development and by development here i'm talking about like the gameplay aspects of

it right obviously when it comes to things like art and production whatever like that's a much like that has to be a team effort but on the design part. Now, that being said, we've had a couple of experiences where we worked with a publisher who really wants to get involved in the design process. And yeah, a few times

that has failed. And the interesting thing is not that I don't think that model can work. It's just that I think for that sort of model to work, the external designers, so David and I, for example, you have to be doing this as a full -time job because you have to be willing to spend lots of time in meetings or meet with the publisher

two or three times a week. or two or three times a week in order to like you know work on the design together and it's just like that doesn't work when you're also juggling almost a full -time job in my case or a full -time job in David's case and managing like the rest of your life your family your kids like all these things and so it just it doesn't like that sort of model just doesn't work for someone who's doing this in the way that we're doing it so that's an example

where Having gone through that now, we're a bit more cautious when we first make contact with a new publisher to try to feel out what it is they're actually want and expect from the process of making a game together. Not to say that you can't make changes to the game, that's fine, but if you want to make changes to the game,

like you can make changes to the game, but we can't then spend hours going back and forth about like, you know what I mean? And, and if you want to overhaul the whole thing, like either you can do that and then it's yours and you know, fine. Or, or we, you don't do it, but like, it can't be that we're involved in every step of the way. And like, it's just because then, you know, it just, yeah. It just becomes too big

a time commitment for something which is ultimately a jobby. So that's an example of, I guess, I mean, you can view as a failure, right? In the sense that a project was started and it did not complete in the way that all parties involved in that project were expecting it to complete. I mean, I certainly from my perspective view

it as a like, I learned something from it, like all good failures, I've learned something from it to learn but like there are different ways of working. And you just have to know going into something what it is that how you want to work or how you can work like it's not even it's not again, like I said, it's not like I would have wouldn't enjoy working on that sort of thing. It's just I can't commit to that sort of thing, right? So I think that's, you know, know what

it is that you're getting into. Try to get that as clear as you can up front and then work under those constraints. Well, we can definitely blame Indeed for the word fail in there. Yeah. And obviously, you know, understanding that all life experiences are going to have, you know, those learning elements to them too. And, you know, I also kind of, you know, I'm thinking, you know,

with the way that you do collaborate with, you know, for the example that you said, you know, David and for like a lot of people who aren't designers, you know, like myself or who haven't designed even many games or just have done it in different ways and you know, there are definitely, I mean, so many different, you know, publishers and processes out there that, that it's, that not, not everything is going to be a fit. And

I guess much, much like, like a, like a job interview too, like you, obviously you want, if you're interviewing for a job, presumably you want the job, presumably you want to get paid, but you also have to make sure that it is a good fit. So figuring out. Like how that is and and especially with another person like syncing up your schedule with them trying to figure out how that's gonna balance with with other people who are wanting to like design and develop differently than the way that you would imagine to like Makes makes

sense to me without having experienced it obviously Yeah, but it's I again I there's nothing I don't there's anything unique to game design here. That's this is just any sort of collaborative project is that you have to know like either know going in or be able to work out quite quickly how this is going to go and basically be willing to either adapt or know when you can't adapt

and and and you know be grown up enough to just say sorry this isn't working like you know this doesn't this isn't what I was expecting, or this doesn't fit with, you know, the way I have to work for reasons x, y, z, or enjoy working for x, y, and z. Like, so it's just, you know, I guess sort of, yeah, that's just the nature of humans being humans. The nature of collaboration in general. Exactly. Bring in at home. Okay,

cool. So for my wrap up, wrap up section, I have a couple of questions and with the title of the show being Intertextual Cardboard Experience, I'd like to open it up to something that has been stuck on your mind, a text, so this could be anything, book, show, movie, board game, video game, song, something that you recently consumed in some way, and it's stuck on your mind. Okay, let's have a think. Oh, here's a good one. And

it connects to games. So there is this very weird sort of reality slash game showy thing called The Traitors. Do you know this? I do not. It's on not Netflix. So it's originally British. And there is now a Traitors. USA and the traitors, Australia, because of course that's the way these things work. And essentially, essentially, they've

taken a game like Werewolf, very similar to Werewolf, and turned it into a multi episode TV show. It's not great TV, but it's interesting to see someone try to take, you know, this thing from our little weird little hobby and making it big. and um more you know and and yeah so basically i mean the basic schtick is yeah it's basically the werewolf it's basically werewolf but like so

the first bit of every episode they have um a way to like build up the prize pot right so they they go on some thing and they go do some activity and it's like oh go find bags of gold in the woods and the the more bags of gold you have the more you build up your pot And then they have the round table where they all, you know, come in and accuse each other and then vote when the people gets killed and then the traitors secretly go off and murder someone and, you know, and eventually whittles it down until the end,

final episode where if there's any traitors left, they split the money and if all the traitors are gone, then the faithful split it. So it's basically, like I said, werewolf. But yeah, this is really interesting. I mean, both for the obvious reason that it's just nice to see something from our world making it into pop culture, but also just to see how much, like, how the stakes that

people put into is, I mean, like, people get really, really upset. Some of the people get really, really upset. And I get it because ultimately, you know, these games, like, ultimately lying, bluffing, even if it was if it's within the magic circle of a game or a game show or whatever, like, you know, these are real relationships that you're building, even if they're, you know, sort of shallow TV relationships, they're still relationships like these people are, you know,

living in some place for a week, a month, whatever it is, a couple weeks or a month. And yeah, like people get pretty upset. Like there's lots of crying and I can't believe you did this to me sort of things. And it just brings me back to the experiences I had, you know, playing diplomacy. Have you ever played diplomacy? I have not played diplomacy. Like the diplomacy, the friendship wrecker or playing like, you know, werewolf and these sorts like, you know, I mean, you know,

eventually, you know, it's like, it's just incredible that games, even, you know, even if you're inside a met like a little magic circle, you can't it can't have such a, you know, it can the the effects like what happens inside the magic circle can leak into the real world. I mean, I guess obviously, it's different. It's it's especially the case when there's $100 ,000 on the line or whatever, right? Like, yeah. People aren't happy when they

lose at poker, you know? Yeah. Huh, that's funny. I can't say that I've ever heard of that one, so I've got it typed in, and if it's, you know, like you said, just a little bit of that slice. Yeah, it's not like I enjoyed watching it, but it's not it's not quality. Like it's not you know, I'm not I'm not heralding it as like some some masterpiece or anything. But it was just it was it's interesting to see. You know, like

rather than being a, you know, a competition about baking or cooking or, you know, basket weaving, it's like no. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. It's like quizzes like, no, no, it's a trader's game. Well, I'll make sure that I take your audio and just make it sound like you are promoting it as the highest quality of television. Yeah, please do. Please do. As long as I get some royalties. I'll reach out. OK, so the final final question,

you mentioned undaunted Clisto, and that's going to be a 2024 release. The next game in the Mandala series will be as well, and that's Flowers. Other things that are announceable to be on the lookout for from you? What else is coming this year? A War Chest expansion, the third War Chest expansion has just started shipping. I got my copies like

last week. So they should be coming out soon. So this is a, it's called, what's it called? Nightfall. Yes, War Chest Nightfall. So we're really, Dave and I are really happy because we weren't sure if War Chest was going to have any more life in it, but. AEG, the publisher, reached out, whatever it was, 18 months ago now, and said, we'll go on, let's do one more. They did this big Kickstarter where they were making,

it had some silly name, expansion, something. But it was basically a Kickstarter where they were selling expansions for like three or four of their games at the same time. expansion extravaganza extravaganza yeah that's it i was trying to blend the two but i guess they were smart they were smart enough to realize that they are unblendable so yeah that that has just come out and i don't know but great plains we have another game which

is a great plains type game so it's called great lakes which is Yeah, the same. So that will be coming out. But they announced it last year as a last year release, and it didn't happen. So maybe it'll come out this year. Or maybe they'll kick it to next year. I don't know. But yeah, I mean, that's enough. I'm trying to think if there is anything else coming out this year.

There's one of my favorite games of mine. I love it because it's nowhere near anything like Undaunted or Mandala. There's this little dice game that Britt and I made. It's called Snack Rabbits. It's coming out by Amigo, which is this big German... It's funny because it's a big German family game. company. They do Bonanza, which is obviously

a classic, and they had many, many, many, many, many other games. And so we were very, very happy to get a game with them. So it's this little, that's a little Dyson card game, but it's just a silly little sort of gambling game, essentially. It's all about managing risk and rolling dice and hoping. Um, but yeah, it's really like the, the, the artist that God is a, it's a children's artist and has really cute, um, uh, children's,

uh, like illustrator for books. And then like, they've got really cute pictures of rabbits and vegetables. That's just cute. So, um, that's, you know, what I'm very, very happy with. Like I just, um, like yeah it's the closest thing I think in my catalog to a Jenga or a it's not anywhere near there I gotta be careful I say it's a beautiful I love it but it's a game that like you can just pull out and play with a four -year -old or an adult and it's fun and it's

it's immediate and so like I'm very happy and proud of it so that's that's that's one I'll mention it doesn't unfortunately the English so that the German version was released um the very beginning of the year um there are plans for an English version but it hasn't come out yet so I don't know it'll be some time this year but anyway that's enough that about my games no that is fantastic I mean I I didn't Like see I mean I you said it was announced last year

But I didn't see about the the Great Lakes and I mean I was undoubtedly going to get that no matter what but being Being a good 30 miles from from Lake Michigan. I think ah Perfect. Yeah. Yeah, no definitely and yeah, like that's exciting with Clifsto and and snack rabbits and I know that I mean I remember seeing the the the war chest expansion site I mean I have the first two but I remember keeping tabs on it and still

missing it so I'll make sure that that I get that and it's a it's a hefty box now oh god yeah it's it's crazy it's um that's a lot of poetry yeah yeah we um um yeah it's we were really happy I'm uh I like words like I'm not undaunted is the one that we spend the most time on, but I mean, certainly, I love making it and it's a good game, but certainly War Chest is the one

that fits much more with my sort of sensibilities, obviously, because it, you know, has like, it's this abstract strategy game. But, but yeah, so I mean, yeah, it's so yeah, I was very happy to get the chance to play around in that world again. And I mean, hopefully, you know. maybe we'll get to do it again someday or maybe make a second edition or something at some point who knows who knows you know this this is this is the other funny thing is that i mean it ultimately it's not it's it it has to be it has to come

down to you know what what the publisher sees as as as as sort of a sensible thing to do so i guess we'll just we'll just have to see how it goes well no matter what uh if if it's designed and you're a part of that design, I am instantly intrigued. So I'm, I'm looking forward to all the 2024 and Beyond Releases. And I really appreciate you taking the time to talk to me about the collaborations

and the different like processes and games that you played. And I don't know, I think it came together so well, and I just had such a nice time. Oh, thanks, Ryan. It was great. It was Yeah, it was like, it's really nice to meet you and to chat. I mean, I don't do that many podcasts. So it was like, I mean, I don't know if you like David is doing like two a week. I don't know how he I don't know how how he manages, but I don't yeah, I don't do that many podcasts. It's

always it's always nice. And it's always nice to, yeah, to meet people who are enthusiastic about games and, you know, have something they want to like obviously if you're creating a podcast you're creating something so you haven't you know you there's you have a voice there's something you want to say and there's something you want or something that you want to bring or contribute so i'm you know i'm always happy to do it so thank you very much yeah well i appreciate it and yeah i think thing number one is just getting the stories and experiences of of people like yourself because without that i would just be

rambling which i've done before It's always better to ramble with someone else than to ramble on your own, for sure. Exactly. Well, again, thank you so much and have a great night. Cheers, Ryan.

Thank you so much for choosing to spend your time here. Any further support such as sharing the show with friends, following the pages socials in the episode description, writing a review, filling out the feedback form, or doing anything else you can think of is greatly appreciated. Keep playing, watching, reading, listening, experiencing.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. #49 - Eric Dietel: Good Conversation High Intertextuality

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    You are chasing the elusive high score-the ability to carve your initials (or some other inappropriate word or abbreviation) digitally into your favorite machine. The perfect combination of greasy, sticky, and fast...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. #48 - David Masnato: Pax @ PAX

    Sep 3, 20261 hr 36 minAudio

    From the slight burn of a slide that’s gotten too hot in the late afternoon sun to the sense of ecstasy (mixed with a slight tinge of panic) from getting a little higher on the swing than you’d ever gotten before-and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. #47 - Jeff Grisenthwaite: Board Game Are(ca)na

    Aug 13, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    As fate and coincidence would have it, designer Jeff Grisenthwaite and I had actually met and played games together once and then played games at different tables of a smaller meetup just months after that. It wasn’t...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. #46 - Amabel Holland: Episode of Six Video Essays

    Jul 24, 20261 hr 30 minAudio

    Back like it never left, Intertextual Experience welcomes Amabel Holland - designer, video essayist, author, and co-owner of Hollandspiele - for its forty-sixth episode. Amabel has been making my favorite board game...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. #45 - Taylor Reiner: The Quiz 2 – Trick-Taking Romanticism – Everything’s a Sequel – You Can’t End on a Toot for Me, I’m Gonna Toot on You

    Apr 2, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    Taylor Reiner. The Quiz 2. Since Taylor was on the show in September 2023, he’s been busy with designing, developing, making videos, and more. We get to explore some of the things Taylor has been working on through the...

    Credit the people on this episode