The end of a trilogy. Brett J. Gilbert joins me to cap off a wonderful set of episodes. As one of founders of the Cambridge design group that both Trevor Benjamin and David Thompson from the last two episodes are a part of, it was such a great time going back to the beginning. The oddly constructed chronology of this episode kind of does the same, so join the end of this current “Collabstraction” journey. Brett's board game website. Beginning of the End (0:00) A little bit of introductory talk. A little bit of trilogy talk. Cambridge. Collaboration. Curator. (14:55) Brett discusses how the group came to be and how it’s changed throughout the years. There’s some other collaboration talk and one question that showed up in the other two episodes. Restrictions and Distillations (49:43) The ethos of Brett’s designs was clear from the beginning of the episode, but we discuss it a little bit further here with the specifically small project, “Good Little Games,” and in other capacities as well. Beginning at the End (1:03:36) For some reason I forwent asking about Brett’s gaming background early in the episode, but it worked out well here. There’s some additional talk about abstraction and complexity in this section. Wrap-up Questions (1:20:59) ---------------------------------------------------------- Contact, follow, and support information: vodthepod@gmail.com Twitter Instagram General feedback form - (your thoughts are appreciated!) Buy Me a Coffee
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Intertextual cardboard experience We've got a trilogy three episodes three intros and zero chapter sound effects This will be the shortest intro yet though as this is the perfect ending to this mini series So let's get on with the show Hello and welcome to intertextual cardboard experience very excited to have our serene 19th guest today in designer Brett J. Gilbert. How
are you doing today? I am very well. Thanks for having me. Yeah. So we just chatted for a second before coming on and just giving a little bit of context. This is kind of now the third episode in a trilogy. And previous guests to start off that trilogy were Trevor Benjamin and David Thompson. And when I had Trevor on, he mentioned that being
the 17th episode that he was a prime number. But we're prime as well with 19. So I think it's kind of meant to be that two of these three numbers are prime. So it's all meant to be. I mean, that is the maximum number of three consecutive digits that could be prime. Yeah. Yeah, that's the way it is. So yeah, I know. Well, if you start talking
about math, that's going to break my brain. I looked and I the next time there would be three numbers in a row and two of them would be prime would be 29 and 31. So that's that's a while's way but something to work towards. Yeah, something to work towards. But yeah, I guess it was a serendipitous that it worked out this way because Trevor mentioned it and this one is as well and it gets like it gets to bookend some thoughts but okay so the third in the trilogy the final act the third in the trilogy the final act and that actually
leads us pretty well to uh not not like a curveball question necessarily but any any medium what is your favorite trilogy so it could be movie series book anything oh boy okay um My favorite trilogy. That is not something I've given a lot of thought to. Things that come in threes. I mean, it would, man. I mean, here's the thing. I'm old enough to remember when Star Wars was
new. I am old enough to have gone to the cinema to see Star Wars in 19, well, it would have been early 78, I assume, when it was brand new. And, you know, it was like nothing, unlike anything else in the history of cinema. Well, certainly that I had seen. I mean, I was only seven. So I hadn't seen that. I hadn't been to the cinema very often. So I guess I can't think of any other trilogies that I've been particularly attached
to, I suppose. Not that I'm a huge Star Wars nerd, just to be clear, but I am of that age. I am of that age. Yeah, so it's an interesting thing too. So I think a lot of trilogies wind up being linked to like a genre. So, I mean, Star Wars being sci -fi, now there's three sets of trilogies for that, but, you know, sci -fi, fantasy, I think one of the bigger ones, which
I'm not into any of these a ton necessarily either, but, you know, Lord of the Rings is a big trilogy too. But I I like the Star Wars pick and honestly it was one of the ones that I had written down as kind of an honorable mention for myself just because I Didn't I didn't really have a set answer, but I I find myself watching a New hope or at least like starting to watch a new hope for various different reasons throughout the the years and I Don't know. It's a good film. I really like
that movie I mean, funnily enough though, and this was I hadn't really thought about until just now, I did actually rewatch A New Hope relatively recently. And it is kind of showing his age. I mean, it's pretty it is a bit ropey in places and incredibly slow. But that's just because, you know, cinema has moved on. I mean, it's still an absolute classic, of course, but it doesn't necessarily hold its own against, you know, I don't know what the younger generation make of
it now. They probably think it's an incredibly old hat. I could see that. I don't know. There is just definitely a level of humor and charm that it's well balanced, in my opinion. Oh, no, no, no. I take nothing right from my god knows. It's just at some point, you maybe have to stop watching the same things over and over and expect them to be just as good as they always were. What is it? Yeah. 40 plus years old it's it's
kind of crazy to think that yeah well when when I went to see it any I wouldn't have we wouldn't we weren't watching movies from 40 years ago that was pre -war I wouldn't have held anybody's attention at least not of the younger generation yeah that's true well very very fair thought and just kind of a another I don't I don't know if you technically would deem it a trilogy, but
pretty soon you have the third game coming out in the Mandala line. Indeed. Indeed. So I'll say once that comes out, it'll be one of my favorite trilogies too. That's very generous of you to say that, given that you've not played the game yet. No, I mean, we're certainly excited for that. And it's kind of it's, it's unexpected, perhaps that that one game has generated that kind of has turned itself into a line. But it's
been fun. Looking at, yeah, finding ways to reinterpret the ideas, I suppose, in it. And in some ways, the game, the third game flowers. is closer to the original idea we had for the game as a multiplayer game before it crystallized into a two player card game. So we started trying to make a multiplayer card game and it sort of failed. But we had to go on a long journey to return to it. I mean,
it's different from what it would have been had we made it originally. It's sort of interesting though that it's continuing to evolve. Oh, that's awesome. Yeah, so So yeah, just kind of, well, re -familiarize, or if anybody's hopping into this episode before listening to the previous ones, we actually, I mean, both episodes, I think we talked about Mandala and Patterns, because David talked about those two games being ones that he's played a ton lately as well. Indeed,
yeah, he's been very vocal about, I think. to his audience, of which he has quite a significant audience, about both games, which of course is fantastic, because I'm happy he enjoys them. Yeah, so, Mandala being the first game, and Patterns being the second with... You can correct me, but I think obviously the biggest similarity between the two would probably be the end -game scoring conditions, and trying to figure out
how you can maximize some of the higher points, like one through six is what you can score for each color. But also, I mean, I think just kind of the, if I'm not mistaken, one of three kind of options of things that you can do on your turn basically in order to manipulate cards in Ndala or little tokens in patterns. I mean, both games and and flowers is the same, very lean
in terms of rules. I mean, that's something which both Trevor and I strive for, I guess. And we were I think we got lucky with Mandala that to because it didn't arrive fully for it didn't just turn up. I think we had the idea for the card play before we had the idea for the for the scoring regime. And when we first thought of it, I think we weren't really sure that it was going to work. We didn't think it was that structure. We thought maybe that structure would be too limiting or not interesting enough, or
it would need more work. And it was sort of fascinating to see that actually a really simple structure attached to a really simple set of binary choice when you play cards essentially led to a really interesting strategic game in a way, it was richer than we expected it to be. You have to, you know, it's a little bit, it's sort of alchemy, isn't it? Like you put two things together and you realize it's, it's more than you expected. Awesome. Yeah, I think it's, I think, I mean, I'll probably
say it so many times. I mean, I love, love Mandala. My experience with patterns has definitely been less. I, well, I mean, it's newer and sometimes it just takes me a while to to get a new game into the circulation, but I like them both a lot. And I love, and I told Trevor that for me, if I were to drum up a top 10 list right now, that game is on it. So. Right. I mean, that's fantastic to hear. It's had a, it had a really good reception. Look, I did really well with
it. And it's had a good, I mean, hopefully it will continue to have a life as well. And I think following it up with patterns and with flowers. will just make all of the games hopefully continue to find an audience. So fingers crossed. But certainly we had a lot of fun developing each of the games and exploring sort of how to maintain some of the like preserve some of the DNA, I suppose, but still make something new. And fingers crossed for flowers that it you know, it's it's
lighter, it was designed to be lighter and more approachable, faster playing. And it It doesn't use all of the DNA. It has six colors, of course, because that was kind of hard -coded. And I don't know whether you've seen the images of the game yet, but it will be out soon. So there is a nice big cloth play mat, and there were three sort of areas that you play into, which are the flowers, instead of two. But it was an interesting game
to work on, because we kind of knew what we wanted it to be. But we weren't entirely sure what that was. So we kind of had a framework for it. We kind of knew when we were straying too far. It was like, oh, well, that's not going to work. That's outside of what we want it to be. And in the end, it came together quickly. But of course, it didn't come from nothing quickly. It came from a sequence of decisions. And patterns was part of that process as well. Yeah, that's super cool, too. I mean, especially because, I mean, as you mentioned at the onset that the
idea of having the game be multiplayer from the start so that idea was there and you're kind of working from there and then and then kind of brought it all the way back to this so I mean it certainly when we've worked on many games together and it's more often than not we get to a point of going maybe this is just two players we can't make multiplayer games they're really they're different beasts they're really hard in a two -player experience Playing two players rather is going to be very different from playing multiplayer even in a multiplayer game like the
head -to -head nature of it means that the game Feel of the game is going to be different and sometimes you just can't scale you just can't make the same experience work in both domains and It's sort of it's not quite a cop -out But at some point so let's just let's just focus on this being a two -player game and see whether we can make it work I mean the joy of working with a collaborator on two -player games is you don't actually need anybody else to play with. You have all the playtesters you need in the room. So it's like, well, let's, we'll play it
and we'll figure out if we like it, great. And sometimes certainly, we've tried to build big games, or we've taken a two play experience and speculated on whether we could expand it into a multiplayer game. And often, it's just lost what we enjoy about it. But flowers is an exception to that, I think that we we focused on making it on a multiplayer game, but we needed it to still work really well at two players. It wasn't a compromise. So at least we knew what we were trying to achieve. We knew what question we were
trying to answer with that design specifically. Oh, that's really neat. You mentioned nice for play testing. Nice for me because then I don't need to find too many people to game with either. I can just rope one other person into the experience and that makes it easy for me as well. So good stuff overall. But yeah, so we, I mean, honestly, just kind of in some of that introductory discussion, we've already started talking about some of the
things that we possibly could talk about the title, which I think I sent this to you in advance. Sometimes I have a title in advance, sometimes I don't. Kind of irrelevant. But this is going to be called Collab Restriction, a Collabstraction episode. Very good. Kind of just like Patterns, a Mandala game. Indeed. But also borrowing from
the previous two titles being Collabstraction. episodes and being able to talk about collaboration and abstraction and then in this case too, you mentioned it a little bit already how the games that you and Trevor make and you and like Matthew as well, we can talk about that moving forward a little bit too, you want to focus on making them lean and I think that some of your projects
and just in your design spaces that you're working in can lend to that type of conversation as well. But we'll get there. Did I? Okay. So my brain, usually by the end, I'm fuzzy. Did I mention that you mentioned you didn't listen to the previous two episodes? Did I say that already? I didn't want to study myself by muddying the waters. I would have a trilogy of ones to listen to after the fact. Super true. So once you listen back,
you'll be able to go through all of them. But a couple of questions primarily in the earlier collaboration section. And this first one here are kind of borrowed. Some borrowed, some repurposed. But to start it off, the Cambridge Design Group has been brought up a little bit. unless my understanding of it is off, it kind of seemed like the two
of, or the two original members and designers were both you and Matthew Dunstan. In a second, you can clarify if I'm completely off there. No, no, you're correct, you're correct. Okay, awesome. But, so then the question is, how has the experience with that group's growth, some movement of different members, and honestly, the tremendous amount of overall success and
published games and partnerships. How has that experience been for you? I mean, it's been the majority of my design career. I mean, it's been running for over 10 years now, I think. And it started small, certainly, but it started quite soon after My first game was published and it was just one of those little Accidental alignments because Matt had just come to Cambridge moved to Cambridge as a postgraduate student I was
already based in Cambridge, but I didn't know the community. I mean I begun to meet people elsewhere in the UK I mean, it's a really really good designer community in the UK and the playtest UK organisation that's run by Rob Harris which has now got chapters all over the country that had relatively recently started up and I've relatively recently met him and other people through him and I've been to Essen but it was all very new it was still at the beginning of my design career
so it happened at the perfect time I guess and in the perfect place it turned out because I mean if you're going to go anywhere in the UK and find you know a bunch of nerds then probably, probably Cambridge is a good place to start. I mean, I, in my pre history, I went to Cambridge as a student, I was a proper nerd. But it draws in people, you know, it's a center of, it's not surprising you would find those people there. But we got lucky, I think. And certainly I, Matt
reached out to me, because he's I had that time I had a blog. And I was, I can't remember where I was on. It was probably before I was on Twitter actually. And I talked about my games and I talked about how I'd entered games into competitions and I'd had my first game published and I must have mentioned I was based in Cambridge and he had just recently arrived in the UK in Cambridge for his postgraduate work. And he was going to Essen for the first time and I was going for Essen for the second time. So we actually met in Essen. And when we came back to Cambridge,
that's when we started meeting. But that was before it became a thing on the internet that drew other people in. And so it started very small. But eventually, we made the leap to add it to the Playtest UK meetup kind of schedule, as it were. And from then, you know, the rest is history, because that's how everybody else who has ever joined the group found us. And it has had a pretty big impact on all of our successes, I think, you know, and lots of people there have
games published like David Thompson, for example, who joined the group he was in based in the UK for I think maybe only four years in the end, but you know that a lot of us went to Essen together, we went to other cons together, we designed together, we played test together, and we did that every week. So although there were and continue to be really successful other meetups in the UK, we did, we were the most regular. There was a
monthly one in London. Initially, that was the beginning of it. But doing it every week made such a difference because it was like doing your homework. It was like, right, I'm going to have to meeting next Wednesday. It was always Wednesdays. It's now Tuesdays, but um best to get my next prototype ready because there'll be an opportunity to play um and some weeks we only had four or five people but that was every week and i lived around the corner so it was super convenient for me i mean i made sure it was super convenient for me um and but i think one week we had this
was several years into it we had like 18 people turn up which was almost everyone who could possibly have come at that time It was almost too many people at that point. I was like, crikey, what do we do with this? But it was always very informal and very productive and yeah, a real accident, I suppose, but a very happy one. Yeah, you mentioned at the tail end, but yeah, when you said that as many as 18 people showed up, I was wondering what the maximum, like how many people at most
had showed up to one of these meetups? How many that was almost too many for the venue. And they were I mean, I mean, it was a quiet night, it was a midweek. So I mean, they were happy for the trade, I think, but it was, and they were very, they knew they expected us, but we weren't big drinkers, necessarily. I mean, they also ran a lot, it was a restaurant. And so some people did eat and drink there. But I don't think we were hugely good for business. But we weren't, you know, I mean, they can't have been relying
on our business to keep them afloat. But when 18 people turned up, that was almost too many. We have other clients. We have to be able to seat people who are eating at our restaurant and paying the bills. You can't just have all the tables for your nerdy little play testing. But they were surprisingly generous and accommodating. So how many people would you say, on average,
come to the the weekly meetups nowadays? 2020? Well now it's so obviously COVID kind of knocked it on the head for weekly meetups and we're now back up to twice a month every two weeks and quite often I mean normally there's six six seven or eight people over the course of the evening and more than that again becomes a problem because we meet at a pub and we don't it's not as if you know They know when they do recognize us
coming and they have a nice table that we can sit out over there early enough, but we don't book anything So we don't really have an agreement with them But yeah, maybe 12 was maximum maybe last year towards I can't remember exactly but it's it's an I mean It's a good it's enough to have two or even maybe three groups playing something at the same time, which is fantastic It means we can get through a lot of games That's that's that's really cool having having your insight and experience of just kind of seeing it from
the beginning and, and obviously a lot of change. I mean, you mentioned some of the members moving and, and then obviously, you know, COVID shutting things down too. And then, and having it being back to bi -weekly since. So. No, I'm glad that it's back up and running and it didn't, and obviously it killed all of those kinds of meetups. And a lot of that, some of that moved online. people started using tabletop simulator. For example, I'd never used tabletop simulator before, so it was possible to play test with people, but
it's very different to do that. And returning to sort of in -person play testing is a real treat. Yeah, I can imagine. I still haven't learned how to use tabletop simulator. Well, you're not missing a great deal. I mean, it's a tool, a very inadequate tool, I suppose. It's way more than it needs to be for what I ever use it for.
But I mean, it has its charms. I mean, you don't have to cut anything up or print anything out. And you can have as many components as you like, which is great. I mean, you can iterate, I suppose. Quicker than you could do in the flesh, but it's a different when you play test online It's very different from play testing in the real world All right. Well, I won't go out and try to learn how to use it effectively anytime soon. It's
It's on my computer. I have it but maybe maybe out of necessity someday I will but Okay, ah awesome So kind of moving on to some of your designs and collaborations, just kind of a clarification question first before getting to another specific question. But on BoardGameGeek, if you click
on your name, there are 60 games, some expansions that are under your credits. I'm familiar with a bunch of a bunch of your games, I clicked on most of the rest, but it appears as if the majority of your games are either co -designed with Matthew Dunstan, Trevor, some solo and then a couple kind of different collaborations or different groups too. Is that a fair enough breakdown or does that seem right or am I wrong? I mean, I think it's certainly true that the majority of
them came out of the collaboration or the long standing collaboration with Matt because we worked on a lots of games together. Some good, some bad, some indifferent. And, you know, we went to SN year after year and we built Alcapac Contacts and we pitched and repitched. And eventually when you ask enough people, some of them will say, yes, and not every game is your best work. I mean, it can't be. And also a lot of those games are now essentially seem like antiques
to me, like they're very old. And I'm not saying I didn't think they were good at the time, but you know, 2024 me, maybe has a different opinion. But it's, it's more about just turning up. I mean, that's just, I suppose that catalog is an example of that then like the scale of it is a direct result of that collaboration, because I don't think it would have been impossible to achieve that much and pitch that often and get
all of those things published on your own. Unless you had one line of games that was spawned 60 other versions of itself, it would be almost impossible to do it on your own. Clearly, there are some very successful A -list designers out there who have been just as dedicated and just as vastly more successful, mostly on their own. But that's the rarity, I think. It would be really hard to do that. So here's a follow -up question
that I didn't necessarily have but just kind of popped up. You mentioned that some of those earlier designs kind of feel like antiques to you, I think was the word. I mean, you could pick more than one, but which game or a couple of games from earlier in your design career do you... either feels most like the current version
of your design or matches up with 2024U and or is something that you would want to keep designing for. So either like a different version of it and get it out there again or an expansion or whatever that might be. Can I check? Can I bring up the list? I suppose I could check on... If I switch to... I can check online, can't I? On
my own website, which has all of my games listed online. So the question was, which is the most authentic to the current me, essentially? Yeah, I would say that's, that's what the question boils down to. If you can't tell, I just add a lot of random conditionals and follow up questions before. Here's the thing, I mean, I genuinely think my first published game DiVenaro, which was a little bit of a, you know, alchemy of its
own came out of nowhere, won a contest got picked up by Asmodeus was, you know, got got into the recommended list for the Spiel des Jahres. I mean, it's kind of crazy to think that that was my first published game. And I think it was that's that holds up, because it's sort of classical and very lean. So I think that one continues to be something that I'm proud of. And indeed, it will have a second. Well, it's going to have an edition in Japan, actually, a new edition
in Japan. A Japanese publishers picked it up. I mean, it's the same game, although we did look at a couple of modest tiny little adjustments. So I suppose in that sense, it's still live. It hasn't disappeared. Whereas I don't think many of my early games really deserve a second edition. I mean, the thing is, they're not disconnected from. the later games, they're all part of that journey, aren't they? And some of them are more connected than others, some of them containing them the seeds of maybe what was expressed later.
But I mean, that was a solo thing that I worked on solo. And it was, you know, my first was my launch pad, I suppose. And it's such a and it did really well. I think I just got really lucky that I had I had an actually good idea at just the right time. I remember play testing it for the first first time, this is before play test was possibly before I even knew play test was a thing. Maybe it was before play test existed as sort of an organization. I have been introduced to some other UK designers through a sort of
an online contact. And I went to a sort of an informal private gathering of some designers who knew each other already. And I was invited into their little world. And I took The first prototype of that game but I've only just designed it like it was just a little thing that popped into my head literally the week before and It wasn't terrible You know, it was already quite good. It already worked It already had a shape to it and a kind of a life to it and a kind of
a a sense of what it was It wasn't done completely there was Yeah, there was more kind of there was some work to do to finesse it But I didn't really know what I was doing. I didn't have a lot of experience. But I did. There were and there have continued to be design contests. And so at that stage, I was trying to create things to submit to design contests because that seemed like a really good discipline. And this was a project that was a really good candidate for
those kind of smaller was a smaller game. It felt like it was decent. Decent enough, at least, to enter into a contest, and the rest is history. It won that contest, which was really surprising. especially given it was a Spanish contest and all the other contestants, I think, or other entrants were Spanish. So I beat out all of the Spanish designers to win this contest in Spain. And it was picked up and then published. So it
was all, you know, it was a perfect introduction. I got really lucky fundamentally, just to be clear, I was just super lucky. and you know this is more than 10 years ago what is this 12 13 years ago and there weren't nearly as many game designers out there trying to make a name for themselves i mean you know the hobby is completely transformed in that time so um i still think it's i still think it's good but a lot of the other ones not so much i'm honest a lot so much okay But I mean, you already mentioned it, too.
You said that they are still a part of like that full journey. And the things that you are working on have obviously led to where you are and whether it's just kind of, you know, sharing some DNA with earlier games or learning from some of the design choices or just, you know, kind of figuring out and going. Oh, for sure. No, I mean, you I think you have to develop your own kind of voice, don't you? I mean, that's that I think I've detected that. I mean, it becomes hard, in some ways, it becomes harder and harder to
create things you're happy with, because you're more critical, perhaps, of your own work, which I think is a necessary, you know, there's a necessary talent to develop. If you don't know anything, you'll settle for it, you'll set, you don't know that it's wrong, or you don't know it's, you know, you don't know that it's been done before, you don't know that you don't have a framework to put it into. So Every game is part of that, and you can bring it to bear on new design decisions.
You can reflect on aspects of older games that you've worked on. But very few of them necessarily deserve to be gone back to. They are steps on the journey, but you don't need to return to them. Also, you can't. in a way, you can't spend your time reflecting on poor decisions, perhaps, or the lack of clarity you brought to the design
or some aspect of it that you in the end weren't happy with. It's done. Somebody published it. It has an audience. Some boxes got sold, maybe not as many as you or the publisher would have liked. Now it's on to the next thing. I do think it's super cool though that you told the story of Divinair and how successful that was right away between winning that competition, getting picked up, and then being recommended by the
Spiel de Jarre jury as well. It's neat that right from the get -go that you had that intuition for your designs in general. And it worked, you know, I think that's, that's just like a cool, fun bit. I mean, it's kind of surprising to reflect on it a little bit, because I couldn't have expected it to have been so successful. And once it had been published, and once it had been on the recommended
list, then it was a great calling card when we did go to Essen, and we met with publishers, because it already had, it was already out there, and they might have even seen it, indeed, the very first pitch meeting that Matt and I went to when we went to Essen to pitch our first game. I think it was the year after we met and we went back to Essen. We had one game that we co -designed and we pitched it to like 13 publishers because we'd talked to everybody we knew in the UK and
got as many contacts as we could. The very first meeting we had was with Wolfgang at Cosmos. And this was, you know, brand new. I had not met with any publishers before in that setting. And the first thing he said was, my friend really likes your game. My friend, Michael Rannick, who's another, he's a German game designer who obviously Wolfgang knows very well, was he sort of went out of his way to point out how he really liked it. So that was a really good start. And
as I say, a great calling card that was already out there in the world. Yeah, it was the best possible kind of beginning, I suppose. That's fantastical. I mean, I'm glad that it did work out in that way and it's just, you know, and has led to all the other future designs then too, because then I get to play them. So. But indeed, but not all of them. Well, not not all. I mean, I wouldn't recommend you playing all of them, even if you could play boxes. Just construct
the good ones. You know, I'll do that. Don't worry. And then I'll. OK, cool. So, OK, here here's where we get the fully recycled question. So three three episodes in this trilogy and the third time it's being asked. And it's regarding your role within your collaborative partnerships. And you have to come up with a title that you
would give yourself that best fits your role. So I'll tell you what technically Trevor and I worked towards his title or his name for his role, and that is the Grim Reaper. Oh, my word. OK. That wasn't the kind of taxonomy I was expecting. But go on. And then for David, he came up with the title Middleman. Really? Well, in the context
of abstraction. So he was kind of thinking about his role, like when he Would you know do design work or when he does design work with with Trevor that he's a little bit more into you know historical or setting less abstract games, but then some of the other people that he'll work with are more into the You know like heavier History or
less abstract so he that's kind of what he oh he sees himself sort of somewhere in the middle of that spectrum. Yes Okay, so that I understand that's a reasonable way to put it. What was Trevor talking about when he, well, and you collectively described him as the Grim Reaper. Okay, so I'll spoil you some of the parts of that episode. Well, he mentioned that, you know, kind of, you know, different partnerships will yield kind
of like different or he'll take on different roles. Um, so there's a funny bit when I was talking to Trevor where he says something along the lines of that he tells, uh, David when he's working with him, that him, David is getting a, a worst version of you as a co -designer. Something like that. I mean, the words might not be a hundred percent, but. Okay. But the, the Grim Reaper then came about was, uh, kind
of, I think specifically Specifically when working with David, but then also kind of like the two of your focus in what we mentioned in terms of like, you know, leanness in just like chopping things out, trying to get like a rule book shorter or trying to, you know, take a like a mechanism and seeing where it could be streamlined, things like that. Oh, and he and that he considers that's the group. That's the role of Grim Reaper is
Well, I am away with this enormous side. Yeah, yeah, I technically I technically like came up with that name, but I as envisioning him with the rule book, just like like you said with that. I mean, I'm certainly when I'm working with him, we're both attempting to do that. I think we're both classicists. We both seeking like the simplest version of whatever idea we might be exploring.
I mean, I always think of my role as being more of an editor, I suppose, or closer to a developer in a way, because I think most of the ideas, most of the seed ideas for games that I've collaborated on have come from the other member of that collaboration. the actual genesis of a game, unless it's come from outside of us and we've sort of essentially been commissioned to think about something or publishers asked us a question. I don't think
I'm very good at that. That's really hard, just to be clear, and I don't think I'm very good at it. I mean, it has happened. I have had original thoughts. But of course, part of the skill is... is knowing what to do with that when you've had an idea, isn't it? And I think that's why collaboration is so powerful, because you don't want all members of that collaboration to be stepping on each other's toes, you do want complementary skills. And I think Trevor does, and so it's true, Matt
was constantly having ideas, he couldn't contain himself. It was like, I've got four ideas, let's pick one to work on. I saw you last week, you didn't have four ideas then. I can't quite comprehend that. the fecundity of that kind of just inspiration, and they're not all brilliant, but everything's got to start somewhere. And Trevor's definitely better at that. But I think our working how we work together is more experimental now, like it's we can put something very limited or unclear
on the table between us, and we can work out, or we can work together to figure out what it could become. But I think I am more of an editor. And I think sometimes that gets in the way of just the sheer kind of the creativity of it. Because if you're not too careful, you start thinking too far ahead to the number of components or the box size or something about the audience or something about the rules, even before you kind of know what you've got. Because certainly, I think one of the first things I do when I'm
working on an idea is to write the rules down. Because in writing the rules down, that helps me to clarify the idea in my head. And so it's always bewildering to me that other designers don't write the rules down until the end. So what do you mean? How could you possibly remember all of the elements of this idea? And what if you forgot some of them? And how can you know what it's going to look like on the page if you don't actually try and put it on the page? Because it's no good having an idea if you can't communicate
it. It has to be translatable to an audience through a rules set. You're not going to be in the room with them. And so by writing rules down, for me, that's normally the first step. I mean, not the very first step, but that's the first step when I feel like I've got a handle on it, I guess. And I suppose that's where being an editor literally comes in, because you have to describe everything in words. And you have to find a form of words that Reflect the gameplay
and that's a really important step because and I did I mean I used to work in publishing and I used to be an editor of sorts I was more of a project manager, but I did do copy editing and that was a really useful skill actually to to develop because it's really helpful when working on rule sets now I don't I used to think I was quite good at writing rule sets and maybe I'm at least Maybe I'm better than most, but I don't know that I'm as good as I think I am. And actually,
because certainly when Trevor and I work together, I always write the rules, probably because I kind of enjoy writing the rules. And one of us has to do it and might as well be me. But I think when he works with David, Trevor writes the rules. So it's interesting. You have to find your place, don't you? But when I say editor, that's part of it, literal text editor. You have to choose,
I suppose. Design is curation, isn't it? Design is choice. And a seed of an idea could literally be anything. It could go in tons of directions. And you have to choose one of them. And I think maybe when I worked with Matt, that was most of what my contribution was, was choosing. I think it's a bit different with Trevor now. I mean, I think it's all very muddy anyway. But I think we're a bit more experimental. We try and see where an idea takes us. I mean, all of
those, every single choice, every single moment you decide to go left instead of right is making a choice. But I mean, we're doing it together. Like, it's happening in real time. It's not just Trevor says something and I go, it should be this. Right, let's make it like that. It doesn't happen. That's no good. But if one of them is a grim reaper and one of them is a middleman, I mean, being an editor, that sounds, that's really dull, isn't it? I mean, that's admin.
I mean, you brought up another - Back office stuff, isn't it? You said curator. Curator. That is better, actually. That's a good point. and that was oh i quite like that i'll take that okay yeah i was gonna say i was i was gonna ask you i'm like are you gonna settle on editor or i mean you did bring up curator and i feel like it that's a much better word isn't it that's so much because it's yeah it's much more uh romantic kind of term for it um but all designers of design as i say the act of designing something is making
a choice even if if you're curating from your own You've come up with a set of options yourself in your own head. You have to pick one of them. You can't do everything. At least that would be my view. But that is a skill, certainly. That is a skill. And curating rules, perhaps, is another element of the work that has to be done to crystallize a Madeira into something that can actually be made. Yeah. One of the things that I was thinking
about when you're talking about your approach to the design process and where you want the rules to exist and when you want them to exist, and obviously them changing throughout that process too, was that you're probably not going to have any games on crowdfunding where you make this big splashy page and then there's a little link that's going to say rule book coming later or something like that. No, I mean, I know I that's
not my style I Would be I would be scared to death if somehow that was set up. It's like shit. I don't know what it's gonna be I mean, it's sort of yeah incomprehensible to me that you could sell a board game like that but it it's which vector you do you choose I suppose you can still you know, you can come at it from very different ways and most of those kind of games are very theme -led only and I mean, Trevor can speak for himself, but I don't think either I
or Trevor exactly theme first designers at the best of times. And obviously, David very much is because he's interesting in histories and sort of the historicity of the games he makes is so important to him. And so important to the players as well. But that's not Trevor and I don't operate like that. That's always second, or completely absent, I suppose, which is, you know, that's That's fine, but that's why typically our games are classified as abstracts, because
they don't really have or need a theme. They are constructs. I mean, they often a good theme or a very light theme can help. The presentation is important and the language used to describe the game is important and helps players to play. And curiously enough, Mandala was never conceived of. it didn't start out as a thematic game. I think we found the, well, I say we found, Trevor
absolutely came up with the idea for the Mandala theme and the name of it. And it really does fit the mechanism. Like there's a way of marrying those two things up. And some people look at Mandala and see it as thematic, as if that was our intent. which I'm sorry to say to those people it was not and some people look at it and go all this language they've come up with that's just in the way like what the hell is that that's just a waste of time I don't this is a field and it's a mountain and here's a river it's like
you know get over yourselves it's just colored cards and I can see both sides I love that there are people who embrace the theme or at least the narrative of the game, the theme is a bit strong for what it is. But I also get where people are coming from when they say, well, you must be kidding. Of course it's got no theme. Look at it. It's a tea towel with colored cards on it. How can that have a theme? And that's fair. Both of those judgments are fair. But that's
not where we started. OK. Cool. Well, you gave me an idea, and I think I'm going to touch on it later, later. But I kind of wanted to get to a little bit of the line of questioning regarding some of your design goals and philosophies by way of your site. And I know that, as you mentioned,
That it's What did I I'm not even sure what I put the The word down but that You know, it's kind of like archived it exists, but I'm talking about good little games And and the oh sorry that it's legacy I actually didn't scroll to the right part, but you know, it is in the past, but it was also where pray another day had its start, had its beginning as well. Indeed. But
before kind of talking about that a little bit, my question then is, you know, what inspired that site as a project and the games that you designed there? And, you know, despite kind of being done working for games specifically, you know, for good little games, you know, what takeaways then do you have from the experience or experiment or whatever you want to call it? It's quite some
time ago, actually. And the original, like the micro game So I designed the game called, which is on the site, called The Other Hat Trick. But that was, again, really early in my design career. And it was designed to be a micro game, as in, what's the minimum number of cards? It was going to be a card game. What's the minimum of cards I would need to make a game? it happened to be 17 for that game and that's very close to you
know that the notion of a micro game didn't quite exist in the way that it now exists and obviously it's been embraced and expanded upon enormously and it's a big field now and that's great uh print and play is bigger than it used to be much much bigger than it used to be so maybe we're slightly ahead of the curve and we didn't exactly capitalize on that as well as we could have done but it when it it sort of morphed into Genuinely, I can't really quite remember what inspired me to reach out to other designers to say, well,
look, I've got a print and play game that I want to kind of get out there. What about you? And try and define a limit to the number of cards. So it's like, well, it has to be a micro game. It's got to fit on like two or three sheets. What can you do? And some of the other games were inspired by that question. or they were games that other designers who I'd met had already come up with, but they didn't have an outlet for. And it was only later that Matt and I picked it up and started working on the good little blank games, which came out in a row. But it
was always an experiment, I suppose. And it's interesting to, well, some of the good little ones were, how do you take How do you shrink an idea down? There's already a catalog of games in this genre. How do you build a game with very few components, very few cards, and very few generic components that still capture some of the spirit of those larger games? So it was more of an intellectual exercise in a way to see what
could be done. It was quite a lot of work, each individual one. And some of them are definitely better than others. And I enjoyed making the artwork for them. It was very basic, but I kind of enjoyed the creation of them as a process. And you're right, the prayer of the day, which has done really well so far, and hopefully will continue to do really well, is a product of that experiment. And had we not... had that not happened, then Praying of the Day wouldn't have happened either. So even though it's unlike the other
games in that list, and it itself was inspired by a game that is not on Good Little Games, which Matt and I worked on a simple sort of rock, paper, scissors, buffing game called Hawks and Doves, which we came up with. And Praying of the Day is a distillation of that in a way. further distillation of something which was already pretty distilled. So it's all steps on a journey, etc. But I mean, I'm, I think we took it as far as we could at
the time. And then it sort of lost, we moved on to other things. I mean, you have a roving eye. You've got it's, it was, it was interesting at the time. And if people continue to play the games, great, but it's, it's as you say, it's a legacy now. Well, some of what you responded to there, I mean, I'm not saying that you can't be the curator, but you could also be the distiller.
Well, I mean, they're very similar things. Yes. As I say, when Trevor and I work on games, we're both looking to try and make those kind of decisions. to really take something simple and make it even not simpler, but just more presented with the greatest amount of clarity, I suppose, that you can. And often that will be with the fewest rules and the fewest components, because rules and components are in the way. The rules are the
least interesting part of any game, and they're the thing which people stumble over all the time. So if you can remove rules, You are making the game more accessible by definition to more people. And that has, I mean, that in my mind has to be the object. So that's, you know, that's the dream. The best game would be the game with no rules whatsoever, that everybody can play instantaneously and know and understand. But of course, there has to be some structure. But how little can you genuinely get away with? I mean, you look
at some really successful games. And they're very, very lean. I mean, possibly Trevor brought up the same example, such as like Double or Just One or The Mind. These are games which almost are barely there, rules -wise. And you can explain them in, what, 10 seconds. And everybody can understand them. And they're not for everyone. And not everyone will enjoy them in the same way. But absolutely everyone can understand them. And that's why something like Double sells, what
is it, 17 million units a year. And it's genius. It's actually very subtle, like the way it's designed is incredible. It's just one idea. And it's a really good one. And so it totally deserves its success. But if you could if you could wake up one morning into the fever dream, and have an idea with that kind of clarity, with that kind of precision, with that kind of accessibility, with that kind of universality, you'd be done. You probably could retire then. Well, you certainly
could retire if you were getting double money. I mean, somebody somewhere gets a really big check every month. And they did for them. They deserve it. But that is what I would hope is still ahead of me. You have to assume your best ideas ahead of you. And I don't know what that idea will be. I haven't had it yet. But when I have it, hopefully I'll know what to do with it. Yeah, it's funny because you mentioned Trevor bringing up some of those things and then then
it kind of came up a little bit Talking to David as well, but I'll just I'll just cap it. I'll let you I'll let you experience that on your own and and you you have my My like stamp of of belief like I I believe that is coming and I'm looking forward to it all at the same time. I believe it too, or you have to believe it, otherwise you'd start, wouldn't you? But I believe it too, and I hope it's coming. But who knows what shape it will take? And if I could have
that idea with somebody else and share it with Trevor, then that would be great because it would be, you know, we're constantly seeking ideas that we think can match that those kind of levels. They're just really hard to do. You can't really work your way towards them from a larger idea. You can't start with something more complex, really large, and whittle it down to something that pure. That's unlikely. It's more likely to be either emerge fully formed ex nihilo. It's
just like wait literally from a fever dream and say, oh my god, that's it, isn't it? That's it, write it down before I forget it. Or it will be a little, it will be a an aside, it'll be like a little spark while you're discussing something else, while you're working on a different project, some other element of it will just sort of float off and go, oh, wow, that is a thing. That's a whole thing. Unexpectedly, you'll discover it rather than create it, I think. That's the process. Fingers crossed. Fingers crossed. But
again, you don't even need me to cross my fingers because I believe so. Okay, I mean, it's kind of, I mean, it is interesting, though, because, I mean, obviously, you know, kind of due to sharing that that very similar goal and kind of design philosophy with Trevor is nice, because, you know, then working on your games, you have like a very similar vision for the games that you're
working on and then, you know, like hopeful future games then too, but I don't know. I mean, this is not necessarily a question for you, but it's just like a thought kicking around in my head. I don't think that most, I don't know. I don't want to say most. I think there's a lot of designers who aren't necessarily doing That or trying to necessarily. Oh, I mean, there's there's obviously
there's like a spectrum for abstraction There's a there's a spectrum for for like complexity. I Mean if you look at the majority of games that are published in the hobby space It's kind of clear that the majority of designers designing them aren't seeking that because that's not what the majority of games in the hobby space do, it's not the audience they're serving. And that's fine. I mean, I'm, you know, that's, it's a different objective, the kind of products and the way they're
sold and the way they're marketed, and the audience to whom they are marketed to, you know, they're expecting, they have very different expectations, in terms of complexity and component count and cost. And I know sort of, yeah, sort of kind of the scale of them. are designed to be large. And that that, you know, they clearly do very well and sell a lot of copies. And people really, really enjoy those products, possibly in lots
of different ways. So people buying kind of games with miniatures in them. Maybe they're just buying them for the miniatures. Great. They bought toy and games of toys. Enjoy the bit of it that you like. Nothing wrong with that. But they do rather stand opposed to the kind of things that I am interested in myself. And I'm more I find myself further and further away a greater greater distance from those kind of games. Even a middleweight euro is more is like an order of magnitude more complex than I could really care about. Now,
I might understand them like I get them. And I have designed them or worked with other people to design them at least. And that's fine. But I then they don't excite me. They're not for me. I'm not their audience. They're not for me. Maybe they never were, but they definitely aren't anymore. And so all of that, which is a big slice of the hobby, just is not my thing. Just don't
try and sell them. I wouldn't play them and I wouldn't enjoy them. And if I did play them, as I said, I wouldn't enjoy them. I'd just sit in a corner being grumpy about them and sort of resenting. the complexity that they present to me and the hoops I have to jump through to even get any one thing done. They're not for me. And they are designed with a different outcome in mind. And I think that's good. I mean, it's
good for any designer to sort of realise with greater and greater clarity what it is that they truly want to create. And that's hard. And that's why it gets harder. Because there are fewer and fewer things that you want to do essentially, or it's a narrower focus, still an enormous space that you could potentially design into, but your focus is, is clearer. And, you know, you're not you're less and less distracted by things you probably shouldn't have been doing in the first place. And you're hopefully like a harder judge
of your own creations. Okay, I'm kind of going to backtrack a little bit because I guess I know a question that that I'll ask a decent amount is, is my asking my guests about, you know, their gaming, you know, background and experiences and things like that. And I technically never did that here. But so following up to that thought, you You mentioned that you both design in and
enjoy playing games that are similar to the ones that you design, just lean and to the point. What would you say the most, again, quote unquote, kind of like complex What would you say is the most complex game that you have played? relatively recently or Or just have had played and enjoy it's like what's where where does it get on on
that scale for you? Let me think I did I mean this is a completely random bit of Euro game kind of Nonsense in a way. There was, some friends of mine had a copy of the game called, oh boy, it's based on a book. Oh my word, hold on, I'm gonna look it up, sorry. Get it right, otherwise
I will, I'll be just talking and maybe I'll have a clue what I'm talking about, hold on. Can't even search for it because I can't remember what it's called. Oh boy. No, hold on. My mind is blank. My mind is blank. What am I doing? How many? Oh, it's got two hours. There you go. Must have two hours. I can't see. This is my... Come on. There. Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell. So this is a... That was a book from probably
a decade ago now. And Osprey, who published Undaunted, amongst many other fine... fine games, produced a board game. It's like five years old. It's Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell, colon, a board game of English magic. Now, this is not the kind of game I would ever normally put on the table or expect to enjoy. My friends had a copy. They hadn't played it. We played it. It took forever. I mean, it took them vastly longer than it should have been, about three or four hours. It should have taken, it says 90 minutes. It's incredible.
I mean, and it's a Euro game. essentially, like it's cubes and contracts. But it had, like, we enjoyed it. We definitely enjoyed it. But I think that was because we were willing ourselves to enjoy it. Like, we had to get through the rules, we had to understand it, we had to kind of decode it. And we did all get to the end of it and go, well, that took way longer than it should have done. wasn't as satisfactory as, you know, it was quite hard work to get anything done and even what we did do didn't seem very successful. But we did enjoy it because there was lots of
there was lots of story in it. It's based on a book and it was sort of redolent of this sort of Victoriana. And that's all was all fun. I mean, enjoyed the experience of play. But it wasn't very rewarding as a game. And I would certainly not wish to play it again. But actually. And as a Euro, it's not even that complicated. I mean, barely Midway is sort of light to Midway from a Euro perspective. What you were doing wasn't very complicated. Thank God. We just maybe we were just bad at it or we didn't understand it because we sort of wandered around Europe
and visited various. Every card was either a person or an event in the sort of society of sort of upper middle class society of Europe at the time. And we sort of wandered about. presenting, meeting people and presenting ourselves at various functions and all the whilst being magicians, like actual magicians. The proposal in the book is that magic literally exists, but it's been hidden away and it's now being rediscovered. And we enjoyed it. So, and that's played it quite
recently, but I wouldn't play it again. And it's within it exactly the quality of lots of other euros, which I wouldn't want to play either. and it took way too long like we could have played you know we could have sat and played pray another day for four hours and had like 17 games of it I mean not 17 rounds I mean 17 entire games of it and probably had much more fun and so that's
that's one of the benefits of simpler games they're just quicker you know they just deliver And even if they're not very good, it's like, oh, oh, now I get it. I can go back into it, and I can do it again. And they're not demanding too much. They're not asking too much. I don't want to play games which are smarter than I am that sit there kind of wagging their finger at me and tell me, oh, well, you didn't do that properly, did you? So calm down. I'll decide. I'll decide whether I'm enjoying it, and I'll decide what I think is the right way to play. Some games
are very didactic like that, and they have a very specific way that they must be played to kind of flourish. And you have rule sets, which go, well, here are the rules, but there's little sort of literally a man. Well, it's like, it's not is it has little speech bubbles. And he's sort of telling you what you should do in his game. So you better do this. But do this, because otherwise you won't work very well. It's okay. Why have you designed a game that you need to tell me how to play? Like, why can't I just experience
it? I don't like that's all of that's too much um uh and that was just it was but at least this the doctor not dr norrell mr norrell um the game it had a sort of a life to it I guess like the actual story was the story the world of the story was quite richly drawn and there was something to be enjoyed in that and you could have played it you could have gone really into it I suppose and played it much more like a role playing game and there's fun in that. There's a joy in that
as well. But if I have to tediously collect resources to satisfy contracts, to score points, and then still do poorly, just to get to the good bit, that's too much work. Sorry. I don't know about that. It's not a particularly good example. I don't think it's a particularly good example of games in that space. But it was, we did enjoy it. Okay, so I'm gonna, like I said, I'm going, I'm going backtracking. This is the least chronologically
sensible placement for this question, but I'm curious now. So what, what were some, you know, I mean, how would you kind of describe, you know, I think a lot of people who, you know, play and design games later in life had experiences earlier in life. That's not necessarily all the case, but What would you say were the types of games that you remember playing when younger? And also, how did you decide that you wanted to get into
designing games based on some of the things that you were doing or playing when you did? Well, I mean, we certainly played games as children, both amongst ourselves and with grownups. you know, sort of in a family setting. That was something we did quite regularly. So there was a tradition of that in our family, you know, when we got together at Christmas, once a larger family gathering, sometimes we'd play cards for money. I mean,
a very small amount of money, but the idea of playing cards as a group, you know, maybe like eight, nine, 10 people was always something we did. So that kind of using, yeah, games in that kind of social setting was very common, I guess. I mean, certainly I can fondly remember some games we had as kids that we played a lot of. I mean, there's a Sorry, for example, which is a classic Milton Bradley game. I don't know what
it's still probably for sale. Maybe. I don't know. I mean, it was originally designed in the 30s or 40s. I think it was kind of ahead of its time. It's Ludo, but with a deck of cards and sort of like tricksy little moves. We played that all the time. Remember enjoying that a lot. We played Monopoly. I mean, you know, that's because people played Monopoly. That's something people used to do, even though it's not a kid's game. Like it's a really grim kind of game to play with children. I don't know why. I don't.
In fact, I remember playing it and finding it very upsetting. So I don't know why I was necessarily forced to play it, but it was on the table. We played But we had done kids' games, I suppose. We had physical elements, or you'd span a little spinning top, or you were playing doctors. There was a ton of cheap games, I suppose. And we made the best of them. That's what we had. We didn't have very many, so we played them over and over.
But to answer your second question, or the second part of it, the thing we did, which I think led on to becoming a game designer is we changed the rules. We house ruled it. We did more than house rule it. I mean, everybody house rules. And that is essentially one step, but very, you know, it's a sliding slope. So the thin end of the wedge of becoming a designer is to actually decide, I don't like that bit. We're going to do it like this. That's design. That's exactly that's the same process. But we took it further, I think. And it didn't occur to us that we shouldn't
do that. We didn't feel I don't remember, it didn't feel very transgressive to change the rules like that. We had a copy, and this was later when we were a bit older, I suppose. We had, there was a game called Super Cluedo Challenge. I think it was called Super Cluedo Challenge. And it was a version of Cluedo, but with more people and more weapons on played on a bigger board. And it had a different system for decoding the You still asked questions, but there was
another system laid on top. And you just ran around this board. And it could take a long time to play. And what typically happened was you played for two hours, and then everybody would come to the same conclusion at once. Because if you kept meticulous notes about everything that happened and every question and every answer, you could all basically come to the same conclusion at once. But even that game wasn't the game that was in the box. I think we played it once, but based on the rules in the box. And then we instantly transformed into something that was sort of a hybrid between regular Cluedo, which we'd never
had, and this new version. And we wrote, my sister wrote, hand wrote the rules out. And that was the game we played. We always played by those rules and not by the rules in the box. And they were quite different. I mean, they had similar aspects, but we somehow decided instantly that it should be like this. And that's what we played. So nobody else in the history of the world has played the game like we used to play. And we played it all the time. And we kept in the most
absurd part of it that we really enjoyed, which is the sort of insane little mini game that happened every now and again. So there was sort of a garden path around that manor. And every now and again, for no reason whatsoever, you were just randomly all have to run to a garden ornament by rolling dice. Not real time. You would take turns to roll dice, and you had to drop down tools, drop what you were doing, and run off to the sundial.
And the first person to the sundial would be able to ask a question or get to look under one of the little, you know, discover something about the mystery, and hence move the game forward. But these little mini games could last five, 10 minutes, because if you landed next to somebody, It was just a roll and move. If you had it next to them, you could push them back to any other part of the board. So in theory, that little mini game could have lasted indefinitely. So you would have thought a classicist designer might have looked at that and gone, well, let's get rid of that. But that was the bit we really
liked. So that's the genesis of being a game designer, isn't it? It's going, oh, I quite like that bit. Let's make a game that does that more. and take out the bit I don't like, because it doesn't work for us. And that's the beauty of a board game. It's all exposed to engineering. You can do with it what you will. You have the components and the cards and the dice and the pieces and whatever it is. You don't have to do what the rules tell you. That's just a convention.
You can do whatever you like. And fantastic, isn't it? That's not how a lot of people view them. I think a lot of gamers want to know that they are playing games correctly, in quotes, reflecting the designer's vision. But you don't have to, is the point. And so anybody can become a game designer. And house ruling is obviously something that people are very familiar with, even in a very modest way, even if it's a very slim little change. But once you've taken those
steps enough times, you've made a new game. Nice well I I'm I'm looking forward to one of your future game designs having Weird racing mini games Okay, I've got I have typically in my interviews I do have a couple wrap -up questions and and those ones will go Little quick, but I had one
one final thing that was kind of like in the scope and and I feel like my scope for this one and where we've gone is just It's been all over the place because of me and my organization, but you you mentioned how You know for the most part when when you're thinking about a game design that you're thinking about, you know, like the Mechanics or the feel first as opposed to like the theme or the the setting so the one kind of like final question regarding abstraction
or setting would be, what do you feel is the one game where you perhaps led most with theme or had the world in the setting in your mind as a focal point for what it was that the game was doing? It's a good question. Not many of them. I mean, as in, they were driven by my inspiration,
I guess, I mean, working with other people mean, you know, ideas are brought to you, and they might have with or around them an idea of theme. And it's like, Oh, great, that sounds like a good enough theme. Let's let's work with that. I mean, it's I don't know. I mean, I don't know that I'm just looking at the catalog on screen to try and think of one that was really taken forward by a specific setting. And that was somehow
part of it. I mean, outside of ones which were specifically commissioned within a preset framework. I'm not sure any of them were really, not in the way that you mean. I mean, for example, Matt and I designed a football game for Cosmos, which is the most bizarre and unlikely thing you could possibly imagine, because neither of us are football fans. And obviously, it had to be a football game. So in some sense, it had to reflect aspects
of football, at least the aspects we understood. It had to have a ball, it had to have goals, it had to have players on the pitch. But that was designed to a brief, rather than having, yeah, rather than bringing, yeah, rather than the creativity being, oh, I want to make a game about this, and that this being a story rather than about a mechanism or an experience even. So I don't know that any really fit that category, if I'm honest, outside of the ones that were
commissioned. Which is, well, there you are. The answer is none. I suppose. Hey, you know what? That's an acceptable answer. Oh, buddy. OK, awesome. OK, so like I said, I kind of end on a couple of wrap up questions. And part of
the the podcast or the way that I have it set up is I want to be able to talk about anything. We started our conversation with movie trilogies. So that was probably the least board game related thing that we discussed. But like I said, we can talk about whatever we want. And in this case, I am curious about a text. So literally anything. Could be a game book show movie song
What have you that's been stuck on your mind for one reason or another? You mean now at any point in my life like right right now. Yes Like what's what's something that that you've recently, you know consumed that I really liked that I Mean just like everybody else I'd sit and binge watch things on Netflix and Disney, and they kind of wash over you and fill your time. And
some of them are good and some of them are less good. But I mean, the most recent one I consumed, the most good media that I can see recently that I particularly enjoyed and was Ripley on Netflix. Have you seen Ripley? I have not. So it's a series, it's an eight hour limited series, as they call it on Netflix, just to warn you that, you know, it's not like seven seasons worth of it. And it's finished based on the talented Mr. Ripley book by a thriller by Patricia Highsmith. So it's like a 50s. It was a series of books with
this particular character in it. And there was a film in the 90s, late 90s. But this is a new interpretation of it. I mean, it's the same story. And it's, it's shot in black and white. And It is very stylized and quite mannered. But it is a psychological thriller. So I mean, it's it's stuff happens. And Ripley, Tom Ripley, the sort of the is an antihero because he's the he's the
psychopath that you root for essentially. um not to give anything away like he's clearly the villain you're kind of on his side and you're kind of you're constantly wanting him to get away with it um so it was very gripping and uh if anybody's seen it hopefully they agree but i i particularly enjoyed that i suppose yeah it was very as i say it was very um Lean is not
the right word. That's completely incorrect. It's quite a rich story. But it was very precise, I suppose. It was very deliberate. And with the way it was shot and the way it was sort of acted and everything. So it was unlike a lot of the more mass -produced kind of corporatized stuff that obviously is also very enjoyable at times. So it was good to see something which had. an opinion, I suppose, you know, it was kind of had a very clear sense of what it was and what it was trying to do. And it was it was really, yeah, it was very bingeable. Awesome. Yeah, well,
obviously, when when you're talking, I, I typed it in. And I've been behind on a lot of things that I want to watch or what have you. But honestly, I don't really have in terms of shows, I don't have a huge back catalog of things that that we're pressing. So that one, I don't know, I'm going to add it to the list. It sounds really neat. Awesome. Perfect. Well, I'll, like I said, I'll add list spring, I've got like another kind
of crazy, busy month coming up. But then after that, I think I can, I can sink into a few more shows. So nonetheless, you'll get a report from me at some point in time. I mean, I don't know how well it's been received by the people. But I mean, it's, you know, it certainly it was it was very interesting. And unlike a lot of stuff that gets sort of churned out. You know, we live in a golden age of television, all of that is incredible amount of content, a little bit very polished. So it's it's it stood out, I suppose,
as being a little bit different. Nice. Well, I mean, yeah, like I said, from from your recommendation and from looking at it, I'm I'm excited to have that on my list. So Speaking of things to be excited about, we get the kind of final, final question. We've talked about Flowers, which you said is going to be releasing pretty soon. In talking with Trevor, he also mentioned that one of your co -designs, Snack Rabbits, is going
to be coming out as well. What else? should people be looking out for from you in 2024? Well, I mean, SnapRabbit's released in Germany a little while ago, but I don't know whether it's actually out in English or not yet. That's a good question that I can ask the publisher. So Matt and I have a game A couple of games coming out this year,
actually, which have been in the works for a while. So there's AliCat Games. This is a UK game publisher who published one of our games before. They published their game Chocolate Factory. They're publishing a game called Happy Home, which is a polyomino game, but it's got a little bit of a twist. and so it's not just about packing the you know it's not about space filling necessarily you got a little home and each piece is a piece of furniture and you're trying to design your perfect abode following certain rules and pot
plants and rugs and like couches and beds and i mean it's it's cute it's super cute and it's been in the works for a while so it's sort of coming soon so i think the publisher will have the first copies at the uk games expo which is at the very beginning end of May, the beginning of June. Separately, we have a game with Plan B, which has been for works for the most enormous length of time. Like, it's not quite a decade,
but I mean, it's a game that has we originally designed the very first version of seven years ago or something. It's crazy how long it's taken. And it's been through various... It's been in the same, well, it's been in a continuous sequence of hands because the game publishing industry is constantly churning and companies become other companies and people become, move to different companies. But it is coming. It is. So I think they will have it at Jane Connell. I'm not entirely sure. I've seen, I think I saw, well, I saw the
cover and sort of like the rule set, the final rule set. So that's kind of exciting because it'll be interesting to see. what it's become. Like it was it's it isn't quite the game I remember anymore. It's had a long, long life. And obviously, some of those years, some of that time was COVID. So that kind of changed perception of how long these things take. But it has been a long time in the works. It will be interesting to see how it is received. Because this weird thing that we designed essentially came up with the idea
of seven, eight years ago. And it's only now being realized. because that's a long time things the world has changed we as designers have changed certainly but the industry has changed like the audience has changed what they expect has changed so we'll be we'll be interesting to see how it comes out and we have other projects sort of slightly further out but it's you know there's always and some smaller projects too so maybe not for this year but for the next year trevor and i've been working on some smaller stuff so
and maybe even a fourth member of the Mandala trilogy. Maybe. Then it's not a trilogy anymore. Well, with no point did we establish it was going to be a trilogy. But then it can't be a part of my favorite trilogies. It may not happen. No, I want it to happen. I'm not telling you not to make it happen. We designed the game. Which would be a fourth member? and it's in the
hands of publishers so may and if it's It you know, and it's sort of we didn't there's no guarantee that it'll be published Well, I'll just hope it will be well I will say when it is it will be like the Phantom Menace. It will be like the prequel I Mean that to be fair the Phantom Menace has now been kind of reappraised isn't it? reflecting more kindly. I think so. We'll see. If it were
to be published, it wouldn't be until the middle to the end of next year. Don't count any of those chickens just yet. All right. Okay. Well, it's a future thing, but no matter what, any future thing, game that you mentioned and some of the other ones, and obviously the fact that you have these awesome collaborations and do a lot of work with your, just in designing in general, there's a lot to look out for from you. And I'm really excited about that. Great. Well, thank
you for saying nice things about Mandala. It's always nice to hear from people who enjoyed it. Yeah, I didn't talk about, yeah, there's a lot of things we could have talked about, too, in terms of other games that, like in Vandala Patterns, Great Plains, and all of them are just beyond enjoyable. So I'll say more nice things about more of your games. Great, thank you. And I do have a, this was actually a bit ago now, that
I... Found a copy that technically for me wound up being a pre -order. I know it exists already, but I I will have Pray another day in in my hands at some point in the future whenever it gets delivered to me. So great. I know I know I know a reprint is Scheduled for very in a the next couple of months. Okay. Yeah, hopefully we'll get a its release will continue and to expand That's awesome. Well Thank you so much for coming
on and talking about your games and the Cambridge Design Group and Star Wars and everything else. My pleasure. Thanks for having me. It's good to talk. All right. Thank you. Great. Intertextual Cardboard Experience, the most triadic podcast about board games and any other text that they connect to. Thank you so much for choosing to spend your time here. Any further support such as sharing the show with friends, following the
pages socials in the episode description, writing a review, filling out the feedback form, or doing anything else you can think of is greatly appreciated. Keep playing, watching, reading, listening, experiencing.
You are chasing the elusive high score-the ability to carve your initials (or some other inappropriate word or abbreviation) digitally into your favorite machine. The perfect combination of greasy, sticky, and fast...
From the slight burn of a slide that’s gotten too hot in the late afternoon sun to the sense of ecstasy (mixed with a slight tinge of panic) from getting a little higher on the swing than you’d ever gotten before-and...
As fate and coincidence would have it, designer Jeff Grisenthwaite and I had actually met and played games together once and then played games at different tables of a smaller meetup just months after that. It wasn’t...
Back like it never left, Intertextual Experience welcomes Amabel Holland - designer, video essayist, author, and co-owner of Hollandspiele - for its forty-sixth episode. Amabel has been making my favorite board game...
Taylor Reiner. The Quiz 2. Since Taylor was on the show in September 2023, he’s been busy with designing, developing, making videos, and more. We get to explore some of the things Taylor has been working on through the...