Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Interplace

Interplace artwork

From Microsoft to the Surveillance State

Feb 23, 202627 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Hello Interactors, Watching all the transnational love at the Olympics has been inspiring. We’re all forced to think about nationalities, borders, ethnicities, and all the flavors of behavioral geography it entails. After all, these athletes are all there representing their so-called “homeland.” And in the case of Alysa Liu, her father’s escape from his. Between the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre and the fall of the Berlin wall, “homeland” took on new meaning for many immigrants. This all took me back to that time and the start of my own journey at Microsoft at the dawn of a new global reality. HOMELAND HATCHED HERE With all the focus on Olympics and immigration recently, I’ve found myself reflecting on my days at Microsoft in the 90s. As the company was growing (really fast), teams were filling up with people recruited from around the world. There were new accents in meetings, new holidays to celebrate, and yummy new foods and funny new words being introduced. This thickening of transnational ties made Redmond feel as connected the rest of the world as the globalized software we were building. By 2000 users around the world could switch between over 60 languages in Windows and Office. In behavioral geography terms, working on the product and using the product made “here” feel more connected to “elsewhere.” This influx of new talent was all enabled by the Immigration Act of 1990. Signed by George H. W. Bush, it increased and stabilized legal pathways for highly skilled immigrants. This continued with Clinton era decisions to expand H-1B visa allocations that fed the tech hiring boom. I took full advantage of this allotment recruiting and hiring interaction designers and user researchers from around the world. In the same decade the federal government expanded access to the United States, it also tightened security. Terrorism threats, especially after the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, spooked everyone. Despite this threat, there was more domestic initiated terrorism than outside foreign attacks. The decade saw deadly incidents like the Oklahoma City bombing in 1995 by radicalized by white supremacist anti-government terrorists, which killed 168 and injured hundreds, making it the deadliest terrorist attack in U.S. history before 9/11. A year later, the Atlanta Olympic bombing and related bombings by anti-government Christian extremists caused multiple deaths and injuries. Clinic bombings and shootings by anti-abortion extremists began in 1994 with the Brookline clinic shootings and continued through the 1998 Birmingham clinic bombing. These inspired more arsons, bombings, and shootings tied to white supremacist, anti-abortion, and other extreme ideologies. Still, haven been shocked by Islamist extremists in 1993 (and growing Islamic jihadist plots outside the U.S.) the federal government adopted new security language centered on protecting the “homeland” from outside incursions. In 1998, Clinton signed Presidential Decision Directive 62, titled “Protection Against Unconventional Threats to the Homeland and Americans Overseas,” a serious counterterrorism document whose title quietly normalized the term homeland inside executive governance. But there was at least one critical voice. Steven Simon, Clinton’s senior director for counterterrorism on the National Security Council, didn’t think “Defense of the Homeland” belonged in a presidential directive. Simon’s retrospective argument is that “homeland” did more than name a policy, it brought a territorial logic of legitimacy that the American constitution had historically resisted. He recalls the phrase “Defense of the Homeland” felt “faintly illiberal, even un-American.” The United States historically grounded constitutional legitimacy in civic and legal abstractions (people, union, republic, human rights) rather than blood rights or rights to soil. Membership was to be mediated by institutions, employment, and law rather than ancestry. “Homeland” serves as a powerful cue that suggests a mental model of ‘home’ and expands it to encompass a nation. This model is accompanied by a set of spatial inferences that evoke familiarity, appeal, and even an intuitive sense. However, it also creates a sense of a confined interior that can be breached by someone from outside. This is rooted in place attachment that can be defined as an affective bond between people and places - an emotional tie that can anchor identity and responsibility. But attachment is not the same thing as ownership. Research on collective psychological ownership shows how groups can come to experience a territory as “ours.” This creates a sense of ownership that can be linked to a perceived determination right. Here, the ingroup is entitled to decide what happens in that place while sometimes feeding a desire to exclude outsiders. When the word “homeland” was placed at the center of statecraft it primed public reasoning from attachment of place through care, stewardship, and shared fate toward property ownership through control, gatekeeping, and exclusion. It turns belonging into something closer to a property claim. What makes the 1990s especially instructive from a geography perspective is that “access” itself was being administered through institutions that are intensely spatial: consulates, ports of entry, employer locations, housing markets, and the micro-geographies of office life. The H-1B expansions was not simply generosity, but a form of managed throughput in a system designed to meet labor demand. And it was paired with political assurances about enforcement and domestic worker protections. Mid-decade legal reforms strengthened enforcement by authorities in significant ways. Mechanisms for faster removals and stricter interior enforcement reinforced the idea that the state could act more decisively within the national space. The federal government found ways to expand legal channels that served economic objectives while also building a governance style increasingly comfortable with interior control. “Homeland” helped supply the conceptual bridge that made that socioeconomic coexistence feel coherent. It continues to encourage a politics of boundary maintenance that determines who counts as inside, what kinds of movement are legible as normal, and which bodies are perpetually “out of place.” If the defended object is a republic, the default language justification is legal and civic. If the defended object is a homeland, the language jurisdiction becomes territorial and affective. That shift changes what restrictions, surveillance practices, and membership tests become thinkable and tolerable over time. HOMELAND’S HOHFELDIAN HARNESS If “homeland” structures a place of belonging, then “rights” are the legal grammar that tells us what may be done in that place. The trouble is that “rights” are often treated as moral abstract objects floating above context. Legally, they are structured relations among people, institutions, and things. But “rights” can take on a variety of meanings. Wesley Hohfeld, the Yale law professor who pioneered analytical jurisprudence in the early 20th century, argued that many legal disputes persist because the word “right” is used ambiguously. He distinguished four basic “incidents” for rights: claim, privilege (liberty), power, and immunity. Each is paired with a position correlating to another party: duty, no-claim (no-right), liability, and disability. When the police pull you over for speeding you hold a privilege to drive at or below the speed limit (say, 40 mph). The state has no-right to demand you stop for going exactly 40 mph. But if you’re clocked at 50 mph, the officer enforces your no-right to exceed the limit which correlates to the state’s claim-right. You have a duty to comply by pulling over. If the officer then has power to issue a ticket, you face a liability to have your dri… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit interplace.io

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello, Interactors. Watching all the transnational love at the Olympics has been inspiring. We're all forced to think about nationalities, borders, ethnicities, and all the flavors of behavioral geography it entails. After all, these athletes are all there representing their so-called homeland. In the case of Alyssa Lu, her father's escaped from his. Between the 1989 Tiananmen Square massacre and the fall of the

Berlin Wall,

SPEAKER_00homeland took on new meaning for many immigrants. This all took me back to that time and the start of my own journey at Microsoft at the dawn of a new global reality. From Microsoft to the surveillance state, the 1990s dream of global access turns towards the modern reality of territorial

SPEAKER_00control. Homeland Hatched Here With all the focus on Olympics and immigration recently, I found myself reflecting on my days at Microsoft in the 90s. As the company was growing really fast,

SPEAKER_00teams were filling up with people recruited from around the world. There were new accents and meetings, new holidays to celebrate, and yummy new foods and funny new words being introduced. This thickening of transnational ties made Redmond feel as connected to the rest of the world as the globalized software we were building. By 2000, users around the world could switch between over 60 languages in Windows and Office. In behavioral geography terms,

working on the product and using the product made here feel more connected to

SPEAKER_00elsewhere. This influx of new talent was all enabled by the Immigration Act of 1990. Signed by George H.W. Bush, it increased and stabilized legal pathways for highly skilled immigrants. This continued with Clinton-era decisions to expand H-1B visa allocations that fed the tech hiring boom. I took full advantage of this allotment, recruiting and hiring interaction designers and user researchers from around the world.

In the same decade the federal government expanded access to the United States,

SPEAKER_00it also tightened security. Terrorism threats, especially after the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, spooked everyone. Despite this threat, there was more domestic-initiated terrorism than outside foreign attacks. The decade saw deadly incidents like the Oklahoma City bombing in 1995 by radicalized white supremacist anti-government terrorists, which killed 168 and injured hundreds, making it the deadliest terrorist attack in U.S.

SPEAKER_00history before 9-11. A year later, the Atlanta Olympic bombing and related bombings by anti-government Christian extremists caused multiple deaths and injuries. Clinic bombings and shootings by anti-abortion extremists began in 1994 with the Brookline Clinic shootings and continued through 1998's Birmingham Clinic bombing. These inspired more arsons, bombings, and shootings tied to white supremacist, anti-abortion, and other extreme ideologies.

SPEAKER_00Still, having been shocked by Islamist extremists in 1993 and growing Islamic jihadist plots outside the U.S., the federal government adopted new security language centered on protecting the homeland from outside incursions. In 1998, Clinton signed the Presidential Decision Directive 62, titled Protection Against Unconventional Threats to the Homeland and Americans Overseas.

a serious counterterrorism document whose title quietly normalized the term

SPEAKER_00homeland inside executive governance. But there was at least one critical voice. Stephen Simon, Clinton's senior director for counterterrorism on the National Security Council, didn't think defense of the homeland belonged in a presidential directive. Simon's retrospective argument is that homeland did more than name a policy. It brought a territorial logic of legitimacy that the American Constitution had historically resisted.

He recalls the phrase, defense of the homeland, felt faintly illiberal, even un-American. The United States historically grounded constitutional legitimacy in civic and

SPEAKER_00legal abstractions, people, union, republic, human rights, rather than a blood rights or rights to soil. Membership was to be mediated by institutions, employment, and law, rather than ancestry. Homeland serves as a powerful cue that suggests a mental model of home and expands it to encompass a nation. This model is accompanied by a set of spatial inferences that evoke familiarity,

SPEAKER_00appeal, and even an intuitive sense. However, it also creates a sense of a confined interior that can be breached by someone from outside. This is rooted in place attachment that can be defined as an affective bond between people and places, an emotional tie that can anchor identity and responsibility. But attachment is not the same thing as ownership. Research on collective psychological ownership shows how groups

can come to

SPEAKER_00experience a territory as ours. This creates a sense of ownership that can be linked to a perceived determination right. Here, the in-group is entitled to decide what happens in that place, while sometimes feeding a desire to exclude outsiders. When the word homeland was placed at the center of statecraft, it primed public reasoning from attachment of place through care, stewardship, and shared fate,

SPEAKER_00toward property ownership through control, gatekeeping, and exclusion. It turned belonging into something closer to a property claim. What makes the 1990s especially instructive from a geography perspective is that access itself was being administered through institutions that are intensely spatial. Consulates, ports of entry, employer locations, housing markets, and the microgeographies of office life.

SPEAKER_00The H-1B expansions was not simply generosity, but a form of managed throughput in a system designed to meet labor demand. and it was paired with political assurances about enforcement and domestic worker protections. Mid-decade legal reforms strengthened enforcement by authorities in significant ways. Mechanisms for faster removals and stricter interior enforcements reinforced the idea that the state could act more decisively within the national space.

The federal government found ways to expand legal channels that served economic

SPEAKER_00objectives, while also building a governance style increasingly comfortable with interior control. Homeland helped supply the conceptual bridge that made that socio-economic coexistence feel coherent. It continues to encourage a politics of boundary maintenance that determines who counts as inside, what kinds of movement are legible as normal, and which bodies are perpetually out of place.

If the defended object is a republic, the default language justification is legal and civic.

SPEAKER_00If the defendant object is a homeland, the language jurisdiction becomes territorial and affective. That shift changes what restrictions, surveillance practices, and membership tests become thinkable and tolerable over time.

SPEAKER_00If homeland structures a place of belonging, then rights are the legal grammar that tells us what may be done in that place. The trouble is that rights are often treated as moral, abstract objects floating above context. Legally, they are structured relations among people, institutions, and things. But rights can take on a variety of meanings. Wesley Hofeld,

the law professor who pioneered analytical jurisprudence in the early 20th century, argued that many legal disputes persist because the word right is used ambiguously.

SPEAKER_00He distinguished four basic incidents for rights, claim, privilege or liberty, power and immunity. Each is paired with a position correlating to another party, duty, no claim or no right, liability and disability. When the police pull you over for speeding, you hold a privilege to drive at or below the speed limit, say 40 miles per hour.

The state has no right to demand you stop for going exactly 40 miles per hour.

SPEAKER_00But if you're clocked at 50 miles per hour, the officer enforces your no right to exceed the limit, which correlates to the state's claim right. you have a duty to comply by pulling over. If the officer then has power to issue a ticket, you face a liability to have your driving privilege altered, i.e. fined. But you also enjoy immunity from arbitrary arrest without probable cause.

SPEAKER_00Let's apply that to Homeland Security. If a politician says we must defend the homeland, it can mean at least four different things legally. 1. Claim rights. Citizens can demand that the government protect them, i.e., from attacks. Officials have the duty to act. Think TSA screening or border control. 2. Privileges. Federal agents get freedoms to act without legal blocks.

SPEAKER_00such as stopping and questioning people in so-called high-risk zones, while bystanders have no right to interfere. 3. Powers Federal agencies hold authority to change your legal status. For example, they can label you a watchless risk, i.e., you become a liability. This can then lead to a loss of liberties like travel bans, detentions, or asset freezes.

SPEAKER_004. Immunities Federal officials or programs shield themselves from lawsuits via qualified immunity or classified data rules, effectively blocking citizens' ability to sue. Forget whether these are legitimate or illegitimate. Hofield's point is they are different forms of rights, and each has distinct costs. Once homeland is the object, the system tends to grow powers and privileges,

SPEAKER_00capacity for overt or covert operations, and to seek immunities, resistance to challenge, often at the expense of others' claim rights and liberties. Rights are not only relational, but they are also often spatially conditional. The same person can move through zones of legality, experiencing different practical rights, Consider border checkpoints, airports, perimeters of government buildings, protest cities,

SPEAKER_00or regions declared emergency zones. Government institutions operationalize these spaces as behavioral geographies, which determines who gets stopped, where scrutiny concentrates, and which movements count as suspicious. The state looks past the abstract bearer of unalienable liberties and due process to see only a physical entity whose movements through space dissolve their constitutional immunities into a series of observable,

SPEAKER_00trackable traces. Those traces become inputs to enforcement. This is what makes surveillance so powerful. Homeland governance is especially trace-hungry because it imagines safety as a property of space that must be continuously maintained. But these traces are behavioral cues and human behavior is never neutral. They are interpreted through normalized cultural and institutional schemas about

SPEAKER_00who belongs in which places. Place attachment and territorial belonging can become gatekeeping mechanisms. Empirical work on homeland-place attachment links it to identity processes and self-categorization. Related work suggests that collective psychological ownership, this place is ours, can predict exclusionary attitudes towards immigrants and outsiders. In legal terms,

these social attitudes can translate into pressure to expand state powers and

SPEAKER_00narrow outsiders' claim rights. A vocabulary rooted in republic tends to emphasize rights as universal claims against the state. This is where we get due process, equal protection, and rights to speech and assembly. A homeland vocabulary tends to emphasize rights as status to permissions, tied to membership and territory. Here we find rights of citizens, rights at the border,

SPEAKER_00rights in, quote, emergencies, and rights conditioned on lawful presence. The shift makes some restrictions feel like a kind of protecting of the home. Hence the unaffable phrase, Get off my lawn. Homeland Hierarchies Humbled

If the homeland is framed as a place of belonging and rights are the grammar of

SPEAKER_00that place, then the current crisis of American democracy boils down to a dispute over the nature of equality. This tension is best understood through the long-standing constitutional debate between anti-classification and anti-subordination, which dates back to the Reconstruction era. Anticlassification, often called the colorblind or status-blind approach, holds that the state's duty is to simply avoid explicit

categories in its laws.

SPEAKER_00Antisubordination, by contrast, insists that the law must actively dismantle structured group hierarchies and the caste-like systems they produce. When the state embraces a homeland logic, it leans heavily on anti-classification to mask a deeper reality of spatial subordination. In what we might call the theater of defense, agencies like the Department of Homeland Security and

Immigration and Customs Enforcement increasingly rely on anti-classification principles to justify

SPEAKER_00aggressive interior crackdowns. They frame enforcement as a territorial necessity by protecting the sanctity of the soil itself and A workplace raid or roving patrol, in this view, does not target any specific group. Instead, it simply maintains the integrity of the homeland. This reflects what law professor Bradley Earhart and others have described as the anti-classification turn, where formal attempts to embody equality end up legitimizing

structural inequality.

SPEAKER_00Put differently, the state exercises Ohefeldian power to alter individuals' legal status based on their geographic location or, quote, lawful presence. At the same time, it shields itself from legal challenge by insisting that the law applies equally to everyone who is, quote, out of place. This claim of territorial neutrality is a dangerous legal fiction. As scholars Solon Barocas and Andrew Selps have shown in their

work on algorithmic

SPEAKER_00systems, attempts at neutral criteria often replicate entrenched biases. Triggers like proximity to a border or behavioral traces in a transit hub do not produce blind justice. They enable targeted scrutiny at the erosion of immunity for those whose identities fail to match the, quote, belonging model of the homeland. The state circumvents its Hofeldian disability,

avoiding the creation of second-class statuses by pretending to manage space rather

SPEAKER_00than discriminate against persons. The shift from a civic republic to a territorial homeland is the primary driver of democratic backsliding. Political scientist Jacob Grumbach captured this dynamic in his 2022 paper, Laboratories of Democratic Backsliding. Analyzing 51 indicators of electoral democracy across the United States from 2000 to 2018, Grumbach developed the State Democracy Index.

His findings reveal how American federalism has morphed from laboratories of

SPEAKER_00democracy into sites of subnational authoritarianism. States with low scores on the index, often under unified Republican control, have pioneered police powers that insulate partisan dominance. We see this in the rise of state-level immigration enforcement units, the criminalization of movement for marginalized groups, and the expansion of the, quote, right to exclude. These states are not just enforcing the law.

They are forging what Yale legal scholar Owen Fiss would recognize as a new caste system.

SPEAKER_00By fixating on defending state soil against infiltrators, legislators dismantle the public rights of the Reconstruction Era, the right to participate in community life without indignity. Today's backsliding policies transform the nation's interior into a permanent enforcement zone. They reject the Enlightenment ideals of America, rooted in beliefs like liberty, equality, democracy, individual rights, and the rule of law.

SPEAKER_00To fully understand constitutional history, we best acknowledge that the America's Universalist creedal definition wasn't solely European. David Graeber and David Wingrove's The Dawn of Everything shows how Enlightenment values of liberty and equality arose from intellectual exchanges with indigenous North American thinkers. Condéronc, a Huron statesman, traveled to Europe in the late 17th century and debated French aristocrats.

His critiques were published and circulated widely among European intellectuals,

SPEAKER_00including Voltaire, Diderot, and Rousseau. Graeber and Wingro point out that before the widely popular publication of these dialogues in 1703, the concept of equality as a primary political value was almost entirely absent from European philosophy. By the time Rousseau wrote his Discourse on the Origin and Basis of Inequality Among Men in 1754, it was the central question of the age.

Kendi Aron criticized European society's subservience to kings and obsession with property. He contrasted it with the consensual governance and individual agency of the

SPEAKER_00Haudenosaunee Confederacy embodied in their great law of peace, a political order prioritizing the public right to exist without state-sanctioned indignity. The writers of the U.S. Constitution codified a republic of unalienable rights, synthesizing indigenous-slash-European-inspired liberty with the Hofeldian disabilities that legally restrain the state from territorial monarchy. Backsliding erases this profound philosophical endeavor.

Reclaiming the Republic means honoring the indigenous critique that a nation's

SPEAKER_00legitimacy rests on its people's freedom, not its fences. We seem to be moving from a governance by the governed to protecting an end group. In Hofeldian terms, the state expands its privileges while shrinking the claim rights of the vulnerable to move and exist safely. This leads to spatial subordination, managed through audiophorization, a concept from social theorist Zygmunt Bauman's 1989,

SPEAKER_00Modernity and the Holocaust. Bauman, a Polish-Jewish survivor who escaped the Nazi's grip on his early life, drew audiophora from Greek for matters outside moral evaluation. Modern bureaucracies make horrific actions morally neutral by framing them as technical duties, enabling atrocities like the Holocaust without personal ethical torment. As territorial belonging takes precedence,

SPEAKER_00non-belongers are excluded from moral and legal obligations. They become non-spaces, or human waste, in the eyes of ICE and DHS. This betrays anti-subordination, the core and conscience of America's civil rights tradition, as Yale constitutional scholars Jack Balkan and Riva Siegel called it. A democracy can't endure if it permanently relegates any group to legal impossibility.

SPEAKER_00In the homeland, immigrants may live, work, and raise families for decades, yet remain mere traces to expunge. Weaponized place attachment turns affective bonds into property claims. This empowers the state to cleanse those deemed to be out of place. Rights become status permissions, not universal ideals. If immunity from search depends on territorial status, the Republic of Laws has yielded to a Heimat,

a term the Nazis usurped for their blood and soil homeland that they then bloodied

SPEAKER_00and soiled. Reversing this demands confronting the linguistic and legal architecture that rendered it conceivable. It's time to rethink the homeland frame and its anti-classification crutch. A truer and fairer republic would commit to anti-subordination, and the state would be disabled from wielding space for hierarchy. A person's immunity from arbitrary power should be closer to an inalienable right

to be secure in one's person that holds firm beyond checkpoints or workplace doors

SPEAKER_00or your front door. Stephen Simon was right to feel uneasy with Clinton's wording. Homeland planted a seed that sprouted into hedgerows of exceptional powers and curtailed liberties. Are we going to cling to a homeland secured by fear and exclusion forever unstable, or finally become a republic revered for securing universal law and rights? As long as our rights remain geographically conditional,

we all dwell in liabilities. Reclaiming the Republic and our reforms within it may require transforming the Constitution from a Hofeldian map of perimeters into a boundless plane of human

SPEAKER_00dignity it aspires to be.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Where ‘The Cloud’ Touches the Ground

    Oct 30, 202625 minAudio

    Hello Interactors, I can’t, with certainty, explain my lapse in Interplace posts. I blame the shear bewilderment, ambiguity, angst, and collective anguish, anger, and exhaustion of all that surrounds the increasing...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Regreening Ruses and Radiant Ruin

    Aug 2, 202624 minAudio

    Hello Interactors, I’ve long been a fan of “regreening” cities, imagining replacing bits of asphalt and concrete with trees, plants, mini-parks, and green roofs to cool them down. In many cases these are indeed good...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Burning Both Ends

    Jul 18, 202621 minAudio

    Hello Interactors, As Canadian and Alaskan wildfire smoke drifts across North American borders, it’s easy to resort to feelings and language of crisis in the demand for urgent, immediate control. But fires are not new...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Burning Through 250 Years

    Jul 3, 202622 minAudio

    Hello Interactors, Welcome to summer where Interplace turns its attention to physical geography and the environment. It’s already a crazy El Niño - thanks in large part to global warming - and the United States is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Living Through Tulsa's Time

    Jun 19, 202625 minAudio

    Hello Interactors, A couple weeks ago, I found myself in Tulsa for the first time. I left pleasantly surprised. There’s a lot of private money flowing into this town, but the city is filled with sorted stories about...

    Credit the people on this episode