What happens when a profession outgrows the structures designed to represent it? Megan traces the evolution of ASHA’s governance from its 150-member Legislative Council to today’s smaller Board of Directors, and compares that history with APTA’s still-active House of Delegates. She talks with former ASHA Legislative Council member Sherry Sancibrian and APTA House Speaker Bill McGeehy about the messy reality of trying to govern a large profession. The episode also examines grassroots organizing and social media, including Megan’s own experience becoming an informal voice for thousands of SLPs. If large representative bodies can become painfully slow, but small governing bodies can’t possibly hold the full complexity of a profession, what might representative governance look like now? Thank you to this episode's guests: Sherry Sancibrian, MS, CCC-SLP, BCS-CL, F-ASHA Bill McGehee, PT, PhD Sources: Rodgers, T. (2020). Reframed Thinking on ASHA Governance. Moore, M. (2007). New Governance Structure Adopted: Legislative Council Also Approves Preferred Practice Patterns in Audiology. ASHA Archives: Early Conventions ASHA, 2013: Ad Hoc Committee on Committee, Board and Council Structure Review. Final Report: Review and Evaluation of ASHA’s Current Committee, Board, and Council Structures and Processes and Recommendations for Enhancing These Structures and Processes Malone, R. (1999). The first 75 years: An oral history of the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. October 2022 ASHA Board of Directors Report February 2023 ASHA Board of Directors Report July 2023 ASHA Board of Directors Report Physical therapy: APTA House of Delegates Occupational therapy: AOTA Representative Assembly Nursing: ANA Membership Assembly Psychology: APA Council of Representatives Medicine: AMA House of Delegates Dentistry: ADA House of Delegates Physician associates: AAPA House of Delegates Respiratory therapy: AARC House of Delegates Nutrition and dietetics: AND House of Delegates Connect: Contact Megan: therapyinsights.com/insideslp PACT Survey: pactsurvey.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Megan BergHi, everyone, and welcome back to Inside SLP. This series is about how our profession came to be and where it's heading. Most of us work inside a system we were never formally taught to see. This podcast is about slowing down enough to understand that system with clarity, calm, and context. I'm Megan Berg. Let's look inside. Quick note before we get started. If you haven't listened to season one, this is a really good time to go back. That's where we get into things like why no one joined ASHA when it first started, why Florida SLP's doubled their dues in the nineteen sixties, Why ASHA was once sued by one of its own members. What McDonald's has to do with SLP advocacy and a number of other strange but influential little corners of this profession's history.
There are 20 episodes. They're about ten minutes each and together they lay a lot of the groundwork for where we're going today. We're gonna talk about grassroots movements, antitrust law, certification, board reports, bylaws, 150 people in a room arguing about things, why those 150 people eventually voted to stop doing that, and an unreasonable amount of nonprofit governance. So if any of that sounds like something you'd like a little bit more context for, start with season one episode one. Otherwise, welcome back.
Let's get into it. In 2023, I helped build a grassroots movement. It started with some pretty basic questions about the relationship between ASHA membership and the certificate of clinical competence. Why did they seem tied together? What exactly were we paying for?
And what choices did SLP's actually have? It grew incredibly quickly. Within a few months, over a quarter of the profession was following us on Instagram and Facebook. And about four months in, I walked away from the movement. It was one of the hardest decisions I've ever made. I also don't regret it. I talked in season one about some of the reasons I left, but working on season two has made me realize how little I understood at the time about what we had built and about the position I had put myself in within it. Because I had no idea what I was doing. No idea. I was learning about certification and nonprofit organizations and antitrust law and lobbying and professional associations while simultaneously trying to explain those things to tens of thousands of people.
Everything was happening incredibly fast and I couldn't learn fast enough to both understand what was happening and responsibly inform other people about it. I knew that at the time. I also knew I was becoming increasingly uncomfortable with the story developing around us. There were the people doing something wrong and then there were the people fighting them. And I had ended up being cast as one of the heroes and I didn't want that role. But there were other things I could feel going wrong that I didn't really have language for yet. I was beginning to understand what a blunt instrument social media is. It rewards certainty. It rewards simple stories. It rewards heroes and villains.
And I was finding myself wanting to slow down and hold more nuance in a space that really wasn't built for that. The experience was surreal. People I deeply respected thought what we were doing was important. SLP's, audiologists, ASHA fellows with decades of experience, people who had worked inside ASHA, people who understood parts of this system far better than I did and there were tens of thousands of people watching. But social media doesn't just give you an audience.
It gives you an incentive to keep the audience. And keeping people's attention requires something new. Another revelation, another problem, another thing to be angry about. I could feel the danger in that. If your role becomes finding what's wrong, eventually, you have to keep finding things that are wrong. But even as I became increasingly uncomfortable with my role in the movement, I hadn't stopped believing that the original questions mattered. I still wanted to know why certification and membership were structured the way they were. I still wanted to understand what we were paying for. I still thought SLP should be able to ask basic questions about the institutions operating within their profession without first becoming experts in nonprofit governance. What I was becoming less comfortable with was my role in answering those questions.
I had become a knower, an informer, someone thousands of people were looking to for an explanation of what was happening and what they should think about it. And I started wondering what happens when you become so aligned with the identity of being an authority that you lose the ability to be wrong. Because if I couldn't be wrong, I couldn't learn and I wanted to learn. I wanted to put down this giant ball of moral outrage I was carrying and have a more grounded conversation. But the movement had a momentum of its own.
I felt like I was standing center stage under a spotlight with thousands of people watching but no actual audience in front of me. Instead, I was hearing voices from somewhere out in the dark. Louder. Sit down. Say it again. Shut up. You're so brave. You don't speak for me. And mixed in with all of that were people's stories, their experiences, their anger, their trust, criticism, their expectations of what we were supposed to do with all of it. Some of those perspectives contradicted each other, sometimes completely and I couldn't hold all of that.
I don't think anyone can. Everything started to feel distorted, loud, ungrounded. And because we didn't have much of a structure of our own, we defaulted to the structure social media handed us. I knew we needed something else, but I didn't understand governance. I didn't know what a good structure would actually look like or what problems it would need to solve. I just knew that an enormous amount depended on two people. What we posted, what we investigated, what we thought was important, what we ignored, who we talked to, how we interpreted what they said, how angry we were, how tired we were, whether we'd had lunch. What happens when one of those people has a really bad day? What happens when one of them desperately needs a vacation? What happens when the two people disagree?
What happens when one of them is wrong? What happens when both of them are wrong? And what happens when thousands of people are looking to those two people to explain what's happening in their profession? At the time, I thought the problem was figuring out how to do that responsibly. How do we make sure we're accurate? How do we slow things down? How do we bring in other perspectives? How do we put some guardrails around ourselves? Which are all fine questions, but I don't think that I had reached the uncomfortable question. Why should thousands of people trust two people on Instagram to do this at all?
I've learned a lot in the years since then and some of what I've learned has made me look back at that period of my life and think, what was I doing? Again, I still agree with the questions we raised at the very beginning. I'm not reevaluating that part. What I understand differently now is the position I had put myself in while asking them. I had stepped into an enormous amount of informal power without understanding very much about how power gets distributed, constrained, challenged, or held accountable.
And walking away from that in no way meant that I'd figured any of this out. I just knew I didn't want that role anymore. I didn't yet understand the larger problem and I'm still trying to understand it now. And I think that's part of why I've become so interested in governance. Because it's not just about discussing who has power, but also trying to figure out what we build around people who have power knowing that they're people.
People get things wrong. People have blind spots. People get defensive. People surround themselves with people who agree with them. People have bad days. People need vacations. And good intentions don't make any of us immune to any of that. So what exactly am I trying to do with these episodes? I'm trying to make room for a conversation that I think this profession has been trying to have for a long time. I saw it happen in 2023.
We asked some pretty basic questions and the response was enormous. Thousands of SLP's wanted to talk about certification, membership, representation, money, who gets to make decisions for this profession and what happens when we disagree with those decisions. The appetite for the conversation was not the problem. We just didn't have a particularly good place to have it. So we had it on Instagram and Facebook and comment sections and DMs and 10 slide carousels designed to be consumed between everything else happening in someone's day.
Those spaces can surface a question. I'm not sure they're very good at helping us stay with one. And that's what I want to try to do differently here. In this podcast, in conversations at state conferences, through the pact project, I want to make some room for us to stay with these questions long enough to understand what we're actually asking. Not because I figured out how this profession should be governed. I definitely haven't. The more I've learned about governance, the less convinced I am that anyone has figured that out. And I'm not trying to build another movement around my answer. I'm trying to create enough space for us to have the conversation before we decide what the answer is. So as we get into this, we don't have to fix anything.
We don't have to take up arms. We don't have to demand action or write letters or follow anything on social media. We don't even have to agree with each other. We just have to sit in the messiness of it for longer than we think we should. That's what I'm here to do. Do. Thanks for being here with me. I want to rewind a little bit because we're about to dig into the weeds of nonprofit membership organization governance, which let's be real, is not a super fun topic that lights us up. That is until we care about something enough to want to utilize governance structure for voice and change. I think we all have moments in our career when we think to ourselves, that's not right.
This isn't right. This needs to be stopped or this needs to change. For some of us that's caseload caps, for some it's reimbursement rates or scope creep or supervision quality or productivity requirements. For me, it was an $8,000 certification product that popped into the SLP scene in 2022. When I saw the initial marketing for the certification it said introducing the first ever medical SLP certification program without the two plus year commitment and $60,000 student debt.
And in my opinion, the marketing was misleading. It made it sound like someone could become a medical SLP without grad school and people had questions. A lot of questions. They questioned whether the certification was necessary. They questioned the cost. They questioned the lack of outside accreditation. They questioned the fact that it was being offered by a private company rather than a nonprofit volunteer board oversight. They questioned the amount of hands on training involved and there was a much more professionally existential question at play as well. What happens if a privately sold certification like this becomes normalized? Would hospital eventually start listing it as a preferred qualification?
Would SLP start feeling like they needed to spend $8,000 just to compete for medical jobs? These were legitimate questions about where the profession might be headed and people were talking about them publicly. The person selling the certification wasn't happy about that. Several SLP business owners received cease and desist letters from an attorney demanding that they stop making certain public statements about the certification. I didn't receive one but I know many of the people who did.
And suddenly there were two conversations happening. One was about the certification itself and the other was, wait, are SLP's allowed to publicly debate the merits of a professional credential being marketed to SLP's without worrying that they're going to get a letter from an attorney? And that second question really bothered me. So I did what I thought you were supposed to do when something happening in your profession concerned you. I went to the professional association and I wasn't the only one.
The issue appears in Ash's July 2022 board report under the heading Member Feedback in Response to Medical SLP Certification. So I know these questions made it into the board's formal reporting process. They clarified that the company offering certification was separate from another company owned by the same person that had an ASHA corporate partnership. And ASHA pointed members toward resources explaining the difference between certifications and certificate programs. I remember opening that board report and thinking, wait, that's the response?
I had this mix of confusion, irritation and frustration because from where I was standing none of that answered the question we were asking. We weren't confused about the difference between a certification and a certificate program. We were asking what happens when anyone can begin selling a credential to SLP that presents itself as a professional certification. What standards should apply? Who decides? What happens if employers begin treating it as meaningful? What role does our professional association have in any of that? Where does the profession itself have that conversation? And I couldn't find the answer. That fall, I happened to be speaking at a conference in Deadwood, South Dakota.
ASHA's president at the time, Judy Rich, was there. So I walked up to her and talked to her about what was happening. Judy followed up afterward. She contacted ASHA's staff and sent me the information she received. And eventually, ASHA's CEO, Vicki Deal Williams joined the email conversation. And she told me something that shifted the way that I view my professional association. She wrote, ASHA will not comment or weigh in at all on any other certification program and she explained why. ASHA's position was that because it is itself a credentialing body commenting on another certification program could expose it to restraint of trade and antitrust concerns. And I remember having this moment of, oh, because I had been approaching ASHA as my professional association. I thought I was asking the organization representing SLP's to help us navigate something happening within our profession.
But ASHA wasn't only operating in that role. ASHA also sells a certification. And I started wondering what happens when the obligations of those two roles don't perfectly align. And this is where the whole thing started to shift for me because up until this point, I don't think I had ever really thought about the CCC as a certification. I knew that's what the C stood for, obviously, but that wasn't how I understood it.
The CCC was just what you got. Graduate school taught us how to get it. Supervisors told us we needed it, employers asked for it, you finished your clinical fellowship, got your CCC, put the letters after your name and paid to maintain them for the rest of your career. In the culture of our profession, the CCC felt much closer to a license than a product. But it isn't a license. Your state license is what gives you the legal authority to practice. The CCC is a voluntary professional certification issued by ASHA And I think this is the point where the categories I've been using started to get a little blurry. Because I've been looking at this private company certification as a product. Of course, it was a product. They created credential, they established the requirements, they set the price and they were asking SLP's to pay for it.
The CCC has a very different history. It has decades of professional recognition behind it. Employers and institutions have built requirements around it, it carries substantially more weight within the profession. But it is also a voluntary professional certification. ASHA establishes the requirements for earning it, ASHA establishes the requirements for maintaining it and ASHA charges an annual fee to keep it current. And then I started wondering why am I paying every year to maintain my CCC? I didn't know the answer and then there was the slightly ridiculous financial irony because I had been appalled by the idea of an $8,000 certification but at today's certification only fee maintaining the CCC for a thirty five year career would cost $7,735 and with ASHA membership it would be $8,750. Now obviously these are not equivalent products But what actually makes a professional certification meaningful? Is it the organization issuing it? The standards behind it?
The evidence supporting those standards? Whether employers require it? Whether the profession recognizes it? What should a certification be allowed to imply about someone's competence, who gets to decide and if we disagree about any of that, where do we even have that conversation? This is the path that ultimately led me to start deeply examining the CCC and before I go any further I want to acknowledge that this part of the story is very easy to flatten into the conclusion that SLP simply don't want to pay their ASHA dues.
And sure, nobody particularly enjoys paying dues but that oversimplifies a more nuanced question that underlies the entire professional culture. Because our certification fees the same as membership dues? I understood that professional associations cost money to operate. Advocacy costs money. Government relations cost money. Professional staff cost money. Research, practice resources, ethics infrastructure, continuing education, publications, conferences, all of it costs money. And I don't think a National Professional Association should somehow provide all of those things for free. There's also a completely reasonable argument that professional associations only work when professionals collectively support them. If everybody says, well, I don't personally use that service so I shouldn't have to pay for it.
Eventually, you don't have much of a professional association. I understood that argument. But it still didn't answer the question I was asking because ASHA wasn't only my professional association. It was also the organization maintaining my professional certification and those two financial relationships were extraordinarily difficult for me to separate. I had earned the CCC after completing graduate school, my clinical training, the Praxis and my clinical fellowship. And then, every year afterward, I had to continue paying ASHA to maintain that certification. So, I had what I thought was a pretty basic question. What am I paying for? What does it cost to maintain a professional certification once I've earned it? And what is the relationship between paying to maintain that certification and paying to belong to the professional association?
Are those the same relationship? If they're not, why are structured so closely together? These weren't gotcha questions. I wasn't trying to prove that ASHA was bad or that professional associations shouldn't cost money. I genuinely wanted answers and I don't think an SLP should have to understand the internal machinery of her professional association before she's allowed to ask a basic question about her relationship with it. I didn't understand nonprofit governance. I didn't understand all of the legal constraints ASHA was operating under. I didn't understand how its board worked. I didn't understand its history. But I understood the question I was asking.
What am I paying for? I didn't need to understand the entire institution to ask that. Understanding the institution's answer was its responsibility, not a prerequisite for asking the question. So I tried to ask and I tried to ask in the ways we are told members should ask. We organized a letter writing campaign. Hundreds of SLP submitted messages through ASHA's InTouch system and our instructions were explicit. Be kind. These are volunteers. They're not our enemies. Assume there are things happening inside the organization that we don't understand.
Ask questions. Don't attack people. I submitted questions myself. I wrote emails. I communicated directly with the SLP member at large on the board. I attended opportunities for member communication. I listened to the ASHA CEO live chats. I watched the comments and questions coming into those live conversations. I read the board reports. Every time someone pointed me toward another mechanism, I tried the mechanism. And I wasn't alone. This wasn't one disgruntled SLP repeatedly emailing Asha because she was mad about her dues. The grassroots movement exploded within weeks. Thousands of SLP's were paying attention. Hundreds were willing to sit down, write to their professional association, identify themselves and ask questions membership cost, transparency.
I knew ASHA had a process for this. I had seen it play out with the medical SLP certification issue. In touch forms were summarized monthly. The forms and a cumulative summary of the messages were provided to the board. ASHA said member feedback was reviewed at every board meeting. So I read the board reports as they came out. And in October, there it was. The speech language pathology subcommittee had discussed the InTouch report form submitted to the board of directors for July through mid October. But the report didn't say what we had written about. It didn't summarize the questions.
It didn't acknowledge that hundreds of SLP's had been asking about the same thing. It just said that the forms had been discussed. And I think that was what was so difficult for me to understand. I wasn't looking for a particular answer. I wasn't expecting to open a board report and see Megan Berg has made some excellent points and we have decided to do everything she says. I didn't even need them to agree with us. I wanted some acknowledgement that the conversation was happening. Even a paragraph saying, we've received a significant number of questions from members about the relationship between certification membership. Here's what members are asking. We're aware of it.
That would have been something. Instead, I had this strange experience of knowing that the messages had arrived, knowing that someone had summarized them, knowing that the board had received them, and then watching them disappear from the public record. It felt like trying to talk to someone who won't look at you. They're talking to everyone around you. They're just behaving as though you're not there. And then in the next board report, there was an entire section about member satisfaction. 98% SLP retention, healthy growth, ways ASHA was acting on member feedback to increase satisfaction. And I remember reading that and feeling completely bewildered because we were member feedback. We were trying extraordinarily hard to tell them something and I couldn't even find a public acknowledgment of what we were saying. Eventually, some of that frustration spilled onto Ash's social media accounts.
People started leaving comments on their posts and these comments weren't always as measured as the letters had been. People were frustrated. Some were angry. And then, Asha turned off comments. I remember that feeling too. Okay. So not here either. We tried the mechanism Asha gave us for member feedback. When people started trying to have the conversation publicly, that space closed too. And again, I wasn't expecting Asha's Instagram account to become some kind of public forum where every angry comment had to stay up forever.
I just couldn't figure out where the conversation was supposed to happen. Recently, I was talking about all of this with someone who had served extensively as an ASHA volunteer. We talked for more than an hour. At one point, she very sincerely said, you should write a letter to the board. And I laughed and I kind of wanted to cry. Not because she was being dismissive, she wasn't that way at all. I think she genuinely believed she was pointing me toward the mechanism. But do you know that feeling when you've been dealing with a chronic problem for years and someone looks at you with complete sincerity and says, have you tried copper bracelets? It was that. Because of course I'd written the board.
We had been writing the board. We'd used the in touch form. We talked to board members. We'd shown up to member events. We'd asked questions. We tried being loud. We tried being polite. We tried working through formal channels. We tried organizing outside of them. The problem wasn't that nobody had told us where the contact form was. The problem was that I still didn't understand what happened after we pressed submit. So all of this is how I became obsessed with governance. Because eventually, as I talked about in the last episode, I learned that ASHA used to have something that looked a lot like the place I had been searching for, the legislative council. This body was made up of about a 150 representatives from across the country who didn't just communicate with Ash's governing body. They were part of the governing body.
And in 2007, they voted themselves out of existence. But why? The explanation I kept encountering in the historical record was some version of efficiency and effectiveness. And my immediate reaction was efficiency? Of course, it was inefficient. There were a 150 people in the room. Wasn't that sort of the point? To me, this made about as much sense as congress deciding it was too large inefficient, voting itself out of existence, and handing over authority to the president and cabinet. I thought, maybe this is what we had lost. So I started looking for the people who were actually there.
Sherry Sansibrian served on the legislative council representing Texas.
Sherry SancibrianYou know, it was set up kind of like the House of Representatives where it was population based. So Texas, New York, and California got the biggest group, so we had six people. So that part was great too because we were six people representing all over Texas and we were generally people who were involved in our state association too, so we kind of knew a lot through that. But that meant there were 150 people who got together twice a year and there were proposals, you know, there was a lot of work up front to do and review, and then we'd get there and decide whether we were gonna vote on something or, you know, the... All the different things that came before us.
Was a lot of fun. You got to know people from other states because we were all lined up at tables and, you know, you got to to hear the problems and it was also, I don't know, it was sort of affirming to hear that little states and big states still had some of the same problems in common, you know, it wasn't just this part of the country or the size of your state that determined it. I think that part was great. What wasn't so great was that it just feels like when we moved into that twenty first century, everything just sped up. You know, making needed to happen faster.
We're using electronic tools to communicate and we were just starting to get used to doing that. But then when you get 150 people in one place and lots of people have an opinion, yay or nay, how we're gonna vote on a proposal coming to us, it was slow, slow. And so because we only met twice a year and the business of the council really happened in those meetings, it just meant that a proposal that came to the council could easily take a year to get through the process, if not more. And there was also a feeling that there wasn't distributed representation so that audiology had a voice, people who worked in hospitals had a voice, people who worked in schools had a voice. There was no makeup of your council members that required that so many represented each discipline or work setting.
And so that was kind of another issue that had been brought up multiple times that you could easily have had six people who all came from the same kind of setting and did essentially the same job. So we represented our states, think, maybe geographically better than we did by work setting and profession.
Megan BergOkay. Fair. A 150 people meeting twice a year. Everybody has opinions. Not everyone is represented. Something comes up March and maybe by next March you figured out what to think about it. This is not exactly an agile organizational structure. I was beginning to understand that representative governance was one, not an easy thing to pull off, two, not always actually representative, and three, not just inefficient but sometimes debilitatingly slow. But I also saw how having some kind of structure was beneficial and yet the people actually sitting in that system overwhelmingly voted to get rid of it.
Sherry SancibrianSo that's why I said it was kind of a bittersweet time to vote ourselves out of existence because I think people who were on the LC believed in the work, we enjoyed it, we enjoyed hearing all the issues coming before ASHA and representing our state, but the problems became too much. So early in... Well, guess it was early in 2006 that the LC decided that we wanted to entertain a new model and so they put together a work group to just investigate different ways of managing an association because it's... With the size, you know, it just had grown so much and and the things that had to be taken care of had also grown. So that group led by Ray Kent studied, think, more than 20 different models for managing a large association before they landed on the current one that was presented to the team.
And I think Ray Kent was a great choice because he's a scientist, he's presented the data, He was very calm, you know, gave a presentation that made people feel comfortable with such a big change, as comfortable as we could be. So then March 2007, we took a vote and voted the LC out of existence. So it was strange. We all got together and had a a giant picture of the 150 of us at that that last official meeting.
Megan BergAnd I keep highlighting this point because I think it's important. The legislative council wasn't just a very large focus group or advisory body. It actually participated in governing the association. Under the new model that governing authority would move to a much smaller board of directors. But this wasn't the entire plan because ASHA also created two large advisory councils one for audiology and one for speech language pathology. It seemed like the goal was to make the governing body smaller and faster while preserving a large distributed structure that could keep the board connected to what was happening across the professions. At least, that's how Sherry remembers understanding it.
Sherry SancibrianIt does mean that Ashley can be more agile. We we had become just kind of a lumbering giant that couldn't keep up with things that came down from the federal government or just, you know, changes that happen all the time. And it just felt like there were more of those changes and more frequent changes and so I think that part was good. The advisory councils set up by Audiology and Speech Language Pathology, I think, you know, each one has like 53 members so that they can represent not only their part of the country but their work setting but also within their profession. So that was one way to ensure that both speech pathology and audiology were represented.
Megan BergThe advisory councils lasted another decade or so. Then in 2018, ASHA undertook another review of its governance structure and recommended sun sunsetting them. So 2007, the Legislative Council is dissolved. Then 2020, the Advisory Councils are dissolved. They were replaced by a committee of ambassadors still geographically distributed, but they were focused on advocacy and outreach rather than gathering information and advising the board.
So there were still ways for information to move through the organization. There were still state associations, committees, volunteers, surveys, and the in touch form. But the governing authority that had once been distributed across roughly 150 elected representatives now rests with the board of directors, a group of 17 people, give or take, through the years.
Sherry SancibrianBut... And the pace is just so rapid that I think having a more streamlined governmental body makes a lot of sense. And let me just be honest, I'm not sure that when we had the legislative council that people always felt connected. I think as a legislative counselor it was your job to go back and report out. And I know at least, like, at our state association meeting, we would have meetings where people could come and ask what was happening and, you know, hey. I have this problem. I was actually doing anything about it. So that was kind of a duty from LC. I don't know that there's that kind
Megan Bergof conduit anymore. Conduit. I had spent a long time trying to figure out how a concern becomes something the organization actually grapples with. I knew how to send information toward Asha in touch forms, emails, letters, questions at member events, SLP member at large. Apparently, I could have added carrier pigeon, but what I couldn't see was the rest of the route and Sherry had been inside the old route and now she was outside of it.
Sherry SancibrianSo we started with the councils and that I thought made a lot of sense because I wasn't part of it anymore. I'm not really sure why the councils didn't really work. Because the model was that we'd have the board of directors, and they would get their input about what's really happening out there from the councils. But I don't know what happened with that part. That part all made sense to me. I do feel like there are times that maybe just because I'm not as involved anymore, I I don't always feel like I know, you know, what... What's happening. The board of directors does put out information. You have to work to keep up with it, I think. And, for me, it's just, you know, when you're involved, you see how ASHA works and you see how your concerns can be brought forward.
Now that I don't have involvement at that level, I also understand why people feel so distant from the management of the association. We just don't feel as connected, and I don't know if that's just something that happens with our size. They they have methods for you to communicate directly with the board, but they may... A lot of people, I'm sure, do feel like their voices aren't really heard. And I don't know what model would let a 150,000 people be heard.
If I need something, I still know enough people, but I don't have a problem contacting someone at Ashley directly. But if I couldn't do that, I'm not really sure that I would feel hurt unless somebody actually answers my in touch message. And I know that sometimes that doesn't happen, and I'm sure they get a lot of them. But there seems like there just needs to be a way for more two way communication.
Megan BergAnd that was such an interesting thing to hear from someone who had actually governed inside this organization because she knows how it works. She knows people. She knows where to go. And even she could understand why someone without those relationships might send something through the official mechanism and wonder, did that go anywhere? At this point, I wanted to know whether this was just an ASHA problem. I wanted to see if another rehabilitation had figured out what we had lost. So I talked to Bill McGeehee. Bill is a physical therapist. He's on the board of directors of the American Physical Therapy Association and he's also the speaker of APTA's House of Delegates. Yes, physical therapy still has one.
So does occupational therapy, nursing, psychology, medicine, dentistry, physician associates, respiratory therapy, nutrition and dietetics. They don't all give these bodies the same authority. They don't all choose representatives the same way. Some call them house of delegates, some call them representative assemblies, but the basic idea is remarkably common. A professional association can have a board of directors and still maintain a large representative body through which members or constituent groups participate in the governance of the profession.
And I was extremely excited about this for approximately seven minutes because Bill immediately started explaining why representative assemblies are also a giant bureaucratic challenge.
Bill McGeheeSo you have this group of 400... They're voting and nonvoting delegates. So it's a group of about 450 people in this room for two days. Right? From all across the country, diversity of practice settings. Right? To me, as the leader of this group and the chair, I believe we should take advantage of that in a very strategic way. And a lot of times, we don't spend our time strategically. Because if someone gets their idea in time and meets the requirements for what it takes to get a motion forward, the house will discuss whatever anybody wants it to discuss. So it just takes one delegation, really.
And even... You don't even have to have the support of your entire delegation to bring it forward. You could do it as an individual. So one of the things that I've been working towards, and we're getting there, but we're still not there, is we don't have a... There's not a lot of strategy around what the house of delegates is gonna discuss in any given year. It's whatever people wanna talk about. And I think that that is not the best use of 450 people's time. Now some people could say, and it's a fair argument, well, look. I pay my dues. I'm part of a 100,000 people, and I should be able to get our representative assembly to talk about whatever I wanted to talk about.
So, there is that. And... But I just think that we should, it would be better use of the house's time, and it would be a better use of the money spent and better for our organization and our members if we were more strategic. And I've been talking a lot about over my last six years is we should be about the quality of motions that we're talking about, not the quantity. And so...
But, you know, anytime that you talk about that, someone has to define what those priorities are. Right? And, anytime you do that, you'll have people who think those are the wrong priorities. And so some people really value that. I'm just sort of speaking as a member of the board of directors, and we spend a little over $1,000,000 on the on-site house with delegates and 450 people's use of time, I think we could do a better job of being strategic.
Megan BergSo APTA is still wrestling with essentially the same trade off. Representation costs money. Deliberation takes time. Large groups are inefficient and the more open you make the mechanism, the harder it becomes to decide what deserves the group's attention. Bill has spent years trying to make APTA's house more strategic. But then he told me a story that made me understand what the cumbersome structure was actually buying them.
Bill McGeheeWell, I'll do one from this past year that sort of came from a small group of members in a in a state. They were very interested in APTA coming out with a position statement and some resources to help clinicians who were working with patients use... Who used psilocybin for therapy. Mushrooms. Right? It was brought forward by a a state chapter delegation. About two months before the house of delegates is gonna discuss motions, they are all posted on a community, and all members can see them. The motion came forward. It was discussed, and, the house vote didn't adopt it. It was, it didn't get enough votes to pass.
Okay? So that would be an issue where, I guess, if that was your... To me, the process worked, so I don't consider it a failure. But if if that's your issue and it didn't pass, then you might consider it a fail. But, look, you had an opportunity to bring this forward. You make your case. People discuss it. They debate it on the floor of the house, and then ultimately, the representatives, vote.
Megan BergSo the people who brought that proposal forward didn't get what they wanted. What they got was a conduit. Concern, representative, proposal, public discussion, debate, vote, decision. You can lose, but you know you lost and everybody else knows what was considered. The disagreement leaves a record. There was another idea I had become very attached to. I kept describing these representative bodies as something like congress or the house. A board over here, a representative body over there, checks and balances, and Bill very politely ruined that too.
Bill McGeheeIf you look at the the association, right, the association is governed by a board of directors. Right? They have ultimate responsibility and accountability for the success or failure of the organization and for the prudent and judicious use of the resources of that organization. For many years, there was sort of this false analogy that somehow the board of director... It was like our federal government.
We had the board of directors was the executive branch, and the house of delegates was the legislative branch. Right? And it was a check and balance. Well, there isn't any check and bound... The check and balance is the the house delegates elects the board members. The the the board, by law, has the ultimate authority to run the organization and the fiduciary responsibility to do so. It's it's... It would be rare. I mean, I I think even in this new sort of something's recommended that the board would ignore it. Right?
Because you got a, you know, group of people telling you you should do this. But there may be some things that the board says, look. You asked us to do this, but the cost is, you know, out of the question. We just... We cannot do it. We don't have the resources. Or look. The environment that we exist in right now, this is not the best time to do this.
Megan BergOkay. So nonprofit representatives are not like the federal government. That goes against nonprofit law. So now my beautiful theory had several holes in it. Large representative bodies are inefficient. Small governing bodies can't possibly know everything happening across an enormous profession. Advisory bodies can distribute input without distributing authority. And social media can make participation incredibly easy while giving the people who accumulate attention no formal constituency, no defined authority, and very little accountability at all. Cool. We're doing great.
So let's go back to where this episode started. That insane four month period of my life where the SLP internet exploded. We didn't hold an election. Nobody appointed me to anything. Nobody said, Tens of thousands of speech language pathologists would now like you to explain exactly what ASHA is, what the CCC is, why they pay for it and whether any of this is actually required. I asked a question. Other people had the same question and suddenly there were tens of thousands of us converging online. And whether I understood it at the time or not, somebody still had to decide what that group was saying. What mattered, what we were asking for, what Ash's response meant, what should happen next. That is representational work except we were doing it informally on social media with no structure of our own.
The structure we did have was an algorithm that counted likes and comments, rewarded whatever kept people's attention, and seemed to have about a twenty four hour memory. There were no constituencies, no elections, no rules for deliberation, no process for resolving disagreement, no way to know whether the loudest voices represented anyone beyond the people who happen to be online that day. I asked Sherry what she thought about grassroots organizations now going to Washington with their own messages, potentially different from ASHA's or from state associations. Her answer was not great, more representation.
Sherry SancibrianYou know for me just the years that, I've been involved in advocacy, that is the nightmare that when the people who have the power to make change hear too many different stories from within the profession, you'll end up with a solution that makes nobody happy. And so I... That is a really scary thing that people are becoming fragmented, and the message is not consistent. I think they barely hear our message anyway. And when they're getting different messages and parts of it being the same and parts different, that's really not helpful.
Megan BergAnd I think that can be a real problem. If multiple groups show up in Washington claiming to represent the same profession and they're all saying different things, eventually, you've just made a fire in the kitchen. Here is the tension that's uncomfortable to sit with. The obvious solution is to consolidate. Fewer voices, clearer channels, let the organization gather information from its members, figure out what matters, and advocate from there.
And ASHA does gather a lot of information. Surveys, committees, task forces, reports. Some of the reports I found while researching this project are incredibly thoughtful and well done. They identify problems years before those problems become the thing that everyone is talking about. What I'm less sure about is what happens when the information has been gathered and the report has been written. How does an issue keep moving? Who keeps asking about it? Who decides it needs more attention? Reimbursement is one example. Clinical training is another.
These are enormous, complicated issues that have been studied for years, often by committees and working groups with considerable expertise. But those groups don't necessarily have governing authority. And I do not expect a handful of volunteer board members serving rotating terms to somehow absorb all of that work, decide what rises to the level of action, and keep every unresolved issue moving forward. Which brought me back to something Sherry had told me earlier. When she voted to eliminate the Legislative Council in 2007, she wasn't voting to eliminate broad representation from ASHA's structure.
The advisory councils were supposed to preserve that connection between the professions and the much smaller board of directors. So I asked her how she would have voted had she had a crystal ball. Do you think that if the LC had known that the advisory councils would be dissolved fairly quickly, that the vote would have been the same? It's hard to say.
Sherry SancibrianThink the advisory councils felt like an important piece of the plan. So it would have given me pause for sure because for the very reason you decided, a board of 13 or 15 or 18 people, whatever it is under any model, just can't know all the nuances of different professions. I mean, we've got two professions, multiple work settings, issues that may be state or regional. There's so much to keep up with that I thought we were counting on the advisory council to kind of have their finger on the pulse of their state at least and their profession in their state and feed that back to the board. So I would have been worried about not having a mechanism to collect information from the states.
And I don't really know why it didn't work, especially now that we can use technology. I know money was always an issue and bringing the the LC together, a 150 people to come in for three days and, you know, travel and, hotel and all that was expensive. And it could be, you know, for a 100, people on an advisory council too, but once it could be done electronically, then it seems like money might not need to be such a big issue. So, yeah, it really would have made me wonder how that small board would be able to keep up with what's going on all across the country in so many work settings. I think that's a big chore.
Yeah. So...
Megan BergI wouldn't wanna be on that board.
Sherry SancibrianI think it's probably a pretty thankless job in a lot of ways because, know, somebody's unhappy all the time. And you're probably not doing it right if everybody's happy anyway. Right? So... But but it is a tough job and I don't know, you know, how they can keep up with everything because people also have to remember these people are volunteers that serve on the board. They have day jobs and families and lives, and you could study all day every day and not be up to date on everything that's happening in our professions.
Megan BergWhen I talked to Bill, I expected him to defend the House of Delegates as the obvious answer to ensuring that a profession is fairly represented. But he didn't. He was actually intrigued by Ash's story. He encouraged me to fully understand why they dissolved their legislative council and he openly wondered about the trade offs his own organization was making to keep theirs. Nobody has this figured out. There is no arrival point where an institution gets governance permanently right. There are no copper bracelets that can fix this. No easy solutions. A small board of directors can govern an organization more efficiently than a 150 people in a room. I think that's pretty clear.
What I'm less convinced of is that a small board can also carry the entire burden of representation. Maybe that's an unfair thing to ask of them in the first place. Like Sherry articulated, these are volunteers. They have jobs and families and lives. And as she put it, you could study all day every day and still not be up to date on everything happening across these professions. I agree. I don't think the problem can be reduced to whether individual board members are listening. We've built a structure that asks a very small group of people to somehow understand, and respond to this enormous profession? How does a concern move from one clinician in one setting in one part of the country into something the profession can actually consider? Who decides whether it deserves that consideration?
Where can other people disagree? Where does that disagreement become visible? And when a decision is made, how does everyone know what happened? Because if there isn't a clear place for that work to happen, it doesn't disappear. It just happens somewhere else like in Facebook groups, Reddit, Instagram carousels, influencers. It happens through whoever happens to have an audience at that particular moment. I know that because for a few months in 2023, one of those people was me. And it took removing myself from that position of power to actually see how problematic it was. I sometimes wonder if stepping onto the ash of board of directors can feel a little like walking into a social media viral moment. Suddenly, an enormous amount of the profession gets condensed onto your shoulders.
The complaints, the disagreements, the things people think Asha has gotten wrong, the things they desperately want someone to understand. Some of it arrives through formal channels like the in touch form. Some of it finds you at conferences. Some of it comes through email or through a colleague of a colleague who knows how to reach you. What do any of us do with all of that? Broad representative governance can be slow and frustrating and political and wildly imperfect, but it does give disagreement standing. You don't necessarily have to know the right person. You don't have to get appointed to the right committee. You don't have to accumulate enough followers that someone finally pays attention, and you don't have to win. You have somewhere to bring the disagreement.
Somewhere you can come back to later and say, we're still hearing this. We need to talk about it again. And the responsibility for doing all of that doesn't land on 17 people. I don't know what that kind of representative governance should look like for ASHA in 2026. I don't know if it should look anything like the legislative council. Maybe there are models we haven't tried yet that take advantage of everything we've learned about participation, technology, elections, deliberation, and the limitations of the structures that came before. But I don't think the fact that representative governance is messy is a reason to stop experimenting with it. Because we're never going to build a profession where everybody agrees about what's right. Can we build a system of governance capable of holding the complexity of this profession without collapsing under its weight or simplifying it until it no longer represents the people inside it? I'm Megan Berg.
This is Inside SLP. I want to thank Sherry Sansibrian and Bill McGeehy for generously taking the time to have these conversations with me and being willing to record them so we can all learn from their perspectives and experience. Thank you. If you'd like to learn more about my research into the structure of the profession with my colleague, sociologist doctor. Emily Eccle and our board of advisors, head to pactsurvey.com. That's pactsurvey.com.
What does it actually mean to “work within the system”? Megan traces the history of member voice and decision-making within ASHA, from Richard Adler’s 1990 address to the Legislative Council to the governance changes...
In this episode of Inside SLP, Megan looks beyond speech-language pathology to ask how professions decide where authority should live. From AOTA’s decision to separate certification from its professional association to...
For the first 20 episodes of Inside SLP, we explored the history of speech-language pathology and the systems that shape our profession today. We looked at how licensure, certification, clinical training, and...
For twenty episodes, we’ve been examining the architecture of a profession under strain, including its history, its blind spots, and the pressures it was never designed to hold. In this final episode, we step back from...
Anger can feel clarifying, but without context, it rarely leads anywhere new. In this episode, we step back from the outrage cycle to examine what’s sitting underneath it: systemic grief, misaligned training models, and...