Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Informed Dissent

Informed Dissent artwork

When private speech becomes public execution

Feb 9, 202657 minAudio

Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke and Dr. Mark McDonald - We witness the collapse of privacy, civility, and medical ethics as private speech is turned into public punishment. Media mobs destroy lives while institutions abandon evidence-based medicine. We defend the moral line between words and crimes, resist ideological medicine, and insist physicians protect the vulnerable with reason and restraint...

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Informed dissent, the intersection of healthcare and politics with Dr. Jeff Barkey, board certified primary care physician. And Dr. Mark McDonald, board certified child adolescent and adult psychiatrist. Hey Mark, great to be with you. Another exciting episode of Informed Descent, the intersection of healthcare and politics. Looks like you're choking on some chips there. You know, I'm eating my favorite chips. They're um they're called Massa or Mesa, M ASA.

That means porn in Spanish. Yeah. And they had a sale recently, because they're really expensive at Mother's Market. They're like 14 bucks for a bag. Pretty expensive chip, but they're made with um no seed oil. They're made with um tallow. They're quite delicious and healthy. And then they had a 50% off sale if you buy six bags or more. So of course I bought like a whole case of them. They have different flavors. They have this carbonera. I'm not pronouncing it right, but it tastes like Doritos, but it's only, but it's healthy, so it's my favorite.

Here, have you had these before? Massa. No, I have not. I'm holding it up to the camera. You know, people are listening, not watching, but anyways, it's a good, it's good product. You know, our our introduction is the is the uh intersection of healthcare and politics. I don't know about you, but I'm kind of sick of politics. I'm completely disgusted with it, and uh, I don't even want to read the paper anymore or listen to news. Um because here it is. There's the reason, very simply. I am tired of focusing on fighting what I hate, and I want to start focusing on pursuing what I love.

Yeah, I like that. I think we should all do more of that. You know, I spend some a lot of fair amount of time on social media. I post almost every day, a morning message and so forth. So I am on Instagram quite a bit, and I've been noticing, and it's really bothersome to me. And I'm not sure exactly why. And I need my resident psychiatrist to figure this out. Speaking of psychiatry, there's a really good show, Apple. I don't know if you've seen it, it's called Shrinking. It's with Harrison Ford, and he's a psychiatrist.

He runs a small psychiatric office. There's another psychiatrist in there, two of them. And it's the interaction of them with their patients and their family and so forth. And uh later in season one, I think they're on season two now. Harrison Ford develops Parkinson's disease, falls in love with his physician who's treating him from Parkinson's disease, and they have a little thing together. And the beginning of season two, they're sitting in the Kerrison Ford is sitting in the doctor's Parkinson's doctor's waiting room, and sitting next to him is Michael J.

Fox. Michael J. Fox, of course, is the famous actor who has pretty advanced Parkinson's disease, but he's making an appearance now as a Parkinson's patient because he is one, and what that's like, and him and Harrison Ford going through the diagnosis of Parkinson's disease. So it's kind of interesting. Was the woman that he falls in love with 40 years younger than him, like his actual wife? Uh, I don't think she's 40 years younger. She's a bit younger, but I don't think it's dramatic. Because he's got to be over 80 at this point. Yeah, he's yeah, he's up there.

I don't know, I don't know how old he is. Yeah, I didn't know his wife, his actual wife was 40 years younger. Interesting. Yeah, I used to see them at uh Whole Foods in Brentwood when I lived there about 15 years ago. Oh, very he married uh I she used to be called Allie McMeal because she was anorexic. Uh, what's her actual name? Allie Ally. I forgot her name now. She was like 24 years old when he married her. But anyways, I started with the I need a psychiatrist because Calista Flockhart. Oh, yeah.

Oh, yeah. She's married, he's married to her. As far as I know, he's still married to her. Oh, interesting. I didn't know that. Yeah. Huh. Uh, I'm scrolling on Instagram and this whole Epstein thing. The FBI releases a ton of Epstein files, millions of pages and so forth. And quite frankly, I don't really care all that much. Um, but what was really bothersome to me is listen, we're all sinful fallen people. We all do stupid stuff. Men say stupid things, especially when in the company of other men.

Um, there's a social media physician influencer who I follow. I don't agree with everything, but he's really, really smart. I'm gonna say his name once, and then I'm not gonna say it again, just so people know who he is. It's Peter Atia. He wrote a book. I have it, it's a really good book called Outlived. It's a good writer, he's a brilliant man, he's a good thinker. I don't agree with everything. And he's on the Epstein list. So he's not only on it, but he said some really cruel and rude things, especially now that we know who Epstein was.

And it's not so much what he said that I care about, I actually don't. It's the piling on of so many people, hypercritical of what he did. And I don't know why they do that. I don't know why people care all that much about beating up this fallen now social media influencer on social media on Instagram and the and the like. And it's listen, I don't I don't know him personally. I think he's bright.

I follow him, I learn from him. His career is gonna get close to destroyed. He's repped a bunch of companies and so forth, and they're all slowly dropping him because he said stupid, cruel stuff. Said where and what format and in what venue. Email, email. He had email, he had back and forth emails with Epstein. Oh, well, that's irrelevant. And that was one of privately, so it's irrelevant. And one of his lines was he's talking to Epstein about uh uh a female body part is uh is low carbs.

He mentions a female body part and he's mentions you know, this body part is low carbs. You know, whatever. I mean, and then uh this influencer on Twitter. If you're listening, check it out. He has this long tweet or X X account, whatever. This long response, and he says what I said was stupid, I'm embarrassed, I should never have said it. I'm ashamed, it was wrong. I did nothing criminal, I did not know about you know all of Epstein's whatever.

I was never on the island, I was never on the so he's defending himself, of course. And then the pylon is the part that just so bothersome to me. It's like leave the guy alone. He's got a wife, he's got kids. Leave him the hell alone to figure out his life, and he made a mistake. He's acknowledging it to what depth. I don't know. It's between him and his creator and his wife and his kids. Leave the guy the heck alone. And I just the number of people that are piling on against this guy saying really mean and cruel things that they would never have said to his face, never have said had they not found out about this relationship.

He whatever relationship he had. It's just I don't know why people do that. Why do people need to do that? I don't think he made any mistakes except that he put it in writing. I remember Dennis Prager bringing this up frequently, and I completely on his side here. What people say privately is not only is it irrelevant, it's no one else's business. And the moment that you erase the distinction between public and private speech, you don't have a civilization anymore. You have a Soviet Union and a gulag. Right.

And I don't want to live in a gulag. I want to live in a place where people can say whatever the hell they want, whatever shit they want, as rude and nasty and crude and socially, politically inappropriate as they want at any time that they want with anyone that they wish in private. Period. I don't think there should be absolutely any restrictions or repercussions or conditions on what people say and communicate in their private world. Absolutely none. And the moment that that is is violated in any way, it's all over.

It's completely over. We don't have a society anymore. We don't have any freedom. We have nothing. All we have is that's the way it is. That's the way it is right now. I mean, and that's the anything you say that you think is private, whether it's a text to a friend or whoever, whether it's an email that you send, you can pretend and think that WhatsApp is somehow encrypted and private, uh, etc. There really is no privacy anymore because hackers and the like can somehow get these, get this information.

And I get it, you know, Epstein was a bad man and he did terrible things, and I'm I'm not sure he actually killed himself. But now all these emails that he sent and received to a whole range of people are now coming out. And granted, if there's evidence of criminal behavior that they participated in his pedophilia network on Epstein Island, that's one thing, but it's you know, the first time Trump ran for president, you may remember that the Billy Bush tape that came out where he said some you know locker room trash to Billy Bush, thinking it was in private.

Somebody recorded it, and then later it came out with the sole purpose of this as ruining his election uh campaign. Of course, it didn't. And I think many, if not all women listened to that and said, listen, men talk this way in private, and it's locker room talk. I'm not defending the speech. Um, but it was private. And when we go over that line of private and public, like we are now doing everywhere, especially on social media, it's very, very challenging.

And especially, you know, people now become so guarded with everything they say. Um, and uh it it makes communication, especially with people you care about much more difficult. If you were able to just upload the contents of everyone's diary and publish it on the internet, what would that do? That's kind of what's going on now. Kind of what's that movie where they predetermined that you're gonna be a criminal and they you know, and they come after you, the Tom Cruise movie.

Yeah, I can't remember what it was called. Um it's kind of like that, maybe rendition, maybe I don't remember. Maybe not, I don't know. But that's the word that comes to mind. But I know in the movie or what I'm interested in, and I can't quite figure out why do people get such it seems like joy out of bringing down and being hypercritical about somebody who has now fallen from grace. Well, I think it has to do with envy, which is the desire to destroy something that someone else has that you don't have, because these people will never do it to someone who's unknown.

They wouldn't derive any pleasure out of it. Same words, same context, different person. They only do it to people who've achieved more than they have. Yeah, I suppose, and there's just a level of glee that seems to be going around with people just shitting all over this guy now. And oh, I knew he was a bad person, la la la, look what he's done. You can't trust him. If he said this, you can't trust him on anything that he's done, and just on and on and on. And you know, Jesus, what did Jesus say on the on the cross?

He he who is not sinned, throw the first stone. I mean, listen, we're all we're all sinners, we all have a sinful nature about us, and we all do stupid stuff, all of us, whoever you are, and then to pile on as if you're holier than thou, you know, all these people that I don't know a lot of them that are piling on, but some I do. And you know, I I almost want to reach out and say, if I went through all your private emails and your text messages and your WhatsApp, what would I find?

Wouldn't I find stuff that you were embarrassed by? And if I made that public and then people piled on because you're a well-known person in the social media influencer stage. I mean, it just it's not it's cruel, it's not right, it's certainly not Christian. Um, and it it makes me think less of them that they would purposely try to destroy a man uh that is fallen and sinful just like the rest of us.

And I think whatever Peter Peter said or didn't say and did and didn't do, it's between him and his family. And I'm I'm not gonna participate in the piling on. I just don't like it. I don't think that there should be any equivocation or that's not the right word, any uh any equalizing between somebody's words and somebody's actions. I don't actually see the reason why uh private speech, whatever it is, is considered uh a character flaw.

Your actions are the only thing that determine who you are, not your words, certainly not in private, because they don't have any effect on the public sphere. Yeah, for sure. Many many stories over time. Sorry, go ahead, Mark. Well, there's there's now reports that are quite credible going back 50, 80, 100 years of presidents that we held in high esteem. I believe Lyndon Johnson is one of them who made what would be considered today, and I guess even at the time, really, quite pointed derogatory racist comments about blacks, for example.

Yeah, and this guy opened up this enormous trough of money that was directed at poor blacks, and he was then revered by blacks and whites for being such a generous president. No, I don't think that the policy of rewarding people with um social welfare is a good policy decision. That's a separate issue, of course. But certainly he was he was lauded for that, despite uh all of his what we called racist commentary. Same thing with John F.

Kennedy, who is considered this pillar and iconic moral uh pure man who loved America and his family, and it's now known that he was having sex orgies in the White House with prostitutes on a regular basis, a modern day Hugh Hefner. Sure. And none of that came out, and then none of that was well. Well, hang on, it did come out, and the media knew about it, but remained silent because they didn't want to tear down this, you know, this pillar of American society and you know, this incredible family, and so they remained silent.

Of course, they don't remain silent now about almost anything that anybody does, and I'm not saying what JFK did was appropriate, it wasn't, but what people care about in a I mean, I care about a lot of things, but at the end of the day, it's his behavior and his actions, the as a president, the bills he signs, the leadership he displays, and so forth, and what he does in his bedroom while I don't agree with it, maybe reprehensible, um, is not something that ultimately we should be judging him on, at least, you know, after the fact.

Well, this whole thing just just exposes the I mean, it's basically a combination of envy, hypocrisy, and a complete disappearance of distinctions among Americans today who for various reasons have some sort of psychological problem and desire to go after people and cause them injury, and it's not healthy, it doesn't represent um a good behavior, it's not just and it's not offering any kind of uh redemption or fairness to an injured party because there aren't any victims here.

You know, if you don't have a victim, you don't have a crime, and I think it's really it's a problem to go after people in the way that the Soviet Union did. You know, you show me the man, I'll show you the crime. That's kind of the position that they're taking. They're not looking for a crime, they're looking for a reason to attack someone that they dislike, and that may be a small distinction, but I think it's a critical one. Because as you said, if if there hasn't been any injury and no crime, every single person, every single person could be publicly convicted in the social sphere of some sort of soft crime, but that doesn't make them a bad person, it doesn't make them a criminal, it just makes them human.

And if we want to go after everyone and adopt a scorched earth policy, we're gonna have no people left, or we're gonna have people who are just simply really, really good at putting on a great show and not saying anything that can ever be recorded, and then doing behind the scenes pretty nasty things that they're never gonna get caught for. And I don't want to live in a country like that. Sort of reminds me of the work I did with for the medical board for a while, medical board of California, the medical board is the for those listen listening is the licensing board for all physicians in California, and they have a investigative body when there's complaints, they investigate doctors and so on and so forth.

So for a while I worked for the medical board as an uh as an expert reviewer. So if a primary care doctor was being reviewed or investigated, they were they're required to hire a like specialty physician to review their records to evaluate whatever the complaint is. And I remember I would do this, it was pretty easy work and you know, paid decent and whatever, and it was kind of fun. But I would have this thick chart, and back then it wasn't electronic, it was actual paper charts, but nonetheless, and the complaint could be about X, whatever that might be.

But I was asked to review the entirety of the medical record surrounding the time that a particular patient was seen, and to point out any deviations from the standard of care that I could find. So if a patient came in and vital signs weren't taken and there wasn't a blood pressure and a temperature and so forth, I would write that down as a minor deviation from the standard of care. If a prescription was written, but certainly it wasn't written a certain way, on and on and on. You could look through any physician's medical record with a fine-tooth comb and find deficiencies in it because we're not perfect people, and so these physicians that were being investigated for crime X often got criticized for crime Y and Z that had nothing to do with the original complaint because as you're looking through the record, there's just tons of little nitpicky stuff and an occasional a big thing, even though there was no harm to the patient.

And that's what we're seeing now. So I don't, you know, I don't, as far as I know, this physician social media influencer didn't harm a single person, as far as I know, and it could be different, I don't know, did not participate in Epstein's pedophile malfeasance. He exchanged a handful of emails, some of which were written in a way that, you know, I would not write it. And he said some words that were kind of, you know, gross and you know, what

Whatever beneath his statute as a thought leader and influencer, you know, for sure. But we should we're supposed to what? Ruin his career now because he did that and just skewer him on social media, make networks and advertisers drop him because of this. That's that's literally as we speak, his career is crumbling because everybody and their mother is now hypercritical and taking joy from the fact that their you know vaunted leader, this social media influencer that rose to fame and and and riches is now being you know fallen, and people are celebrating it like they're like a like a friggin' Roman Coliseum watching the gladiator get eaten by the lion.

That's like what's what's happening. And it's it's disgusting. I don't like it. I almost I don't know the man, and I don't agree with everything he says. I don't know the man, but I almost want to defend him because I think it's disgusting that his career should be ruined by private conversation he had, even if that private conversation was kind of gross and disgusting and beneath what he should be doing, because it could happen to any of us, and I don't like it. I'm actually very concerned and distrustful of people, especially men who never speak in a way that is the slight bit dirty, vulgar, or offensive, because it seems to me that people who are that concerned about censoring their thoughts and their language are probably expressing worse things in their behavior or their language in other places.

And so when I'm around people who are not afraid to at times deviate from what's considered to be clean and proper, it shows to me a certain ironically, perhaps, a certain degree of integrity. It's as if they're saying, look, I'm not pretending to be better than I am. This is just who I am. And provided that it doesn't cause any injury, meaning you're not saying things in front of children or at church, but you're at a bar, you're writing private email messages, and you're using crude language and you're telling dirty jokes.

To me, that's actually a sign of normalcy and sincerity. And people who never ever do that, it's like I said, especially men, I I actually don't trust those people. I find them to be uh suspicious. Yeah, I understand what you're saying. I mean, I can tell you in my own life, I make an effort to moderate uh my speech, my text, what I write, what I think. Um, I don't think it's I don't think it's I don't think it's good for me as a person or good for my soul to be throwing out F bombs all the time, saying rude and vulgar things.

I think how we how we talk to ourselves, how we speak to others and so forth affects us as well. But that being said, it's it's normal. I mean, you and I have hung out together multiple times. We've hung out with other guys, and it's it's it's kind of normal banter, and I guess maybe the further you are further along you are, at least me personally and in my spiritual walk. Uh, I I try to clean up some of that stuff along the way. Um, I just don't like people being prosecuted, persecuted for what they're doing, especially what they're doing in private, if it's causing nobody but themselves, perhaps harm.

Is it better now that when you go into an operating room as a medical student or as a surgeon or as a nurse that if the doctor who's operating gets angry and says, what the what is this shit over here? Get me that damn scalpel that he if he says that that he's gonna be suspended for two months and he's not gonna be able to operate because there was a wallflower uh that felt that she was under threat because his volume was loud and he was using abrasive language and that she has the power as a uh as a a part-time scrub tech to take down the career of a man who may have saved the lives of hundreds or thousands of people.

Are we in a better world now that that this man is now being um policed, thought policed and content policed and tone policed and word policed by by some random person in the room? I don't think so. I really don't, and I think there's a purpose for that because there's a there's a release of stress and also a presence of therapeutic benefit to dark humor, whether it's dark or in the case of perhaps in uh the military, it might be crude or or or objectionable, that's actually helpful.

And so when you take things out of context and you put in sort of a threat monitoring system, not only is it inappropriate and harmful to the individual, it actually takes away the possibility and the opportunity for people to heal through what will be considered dark or or crude language. And I think there's a benefit to that in a lot of cases, and we're losing it. Yeah, no, I totally understand. We'll talk a little bit more about this right after we come back from the break. We'll be right back.

For a powerful celebration of faith, freedom, and the American spirit. America Out Loud, the Wellness Company, and Clear invite you to join us for the 25010 Nashville event. You'll experience best in class speakers, extraordinary voices from across America, bring an inspired messages you won't forget. And on July 4th, get ready for the most spectacular by work show in the country. Lighten up the Nashville sky. 250 years of liberty in America and 10 years of America Out Loud News.

Standing strong for truth, justice, and the nation we all love. You can save now with Early Bird Price and America Outloud dot news forward slash Nashville, July 2nd, 3rd, and 4th. America Out Loud News. 25010 Nashville. In just two minutes per day, you could reclaim your health and cut your grocery bill in half with one simple convenient product. Our doctor formulated Green 85 juice formulas, powerful dose of ultra-concentrated essential nutrients, stops hunger in its tracks, and supplies your cells with what's missing in the grocery store food.

Go to ChemicalfreeBody.com forward slash out loud today, get nature's super multivitamin Green 85, empower your immune system, cut down on your grocery bill, and save 20% on your first order. Is there MRNA technology in your grocery store beef? You won't see it on the label, but it's there. 100% grass-fed, grass-finished, mRNA-free, hormone-free, and vaccine free. Wellness farms, order now at TWC.health backslash out loud and use code out loud to get your exclusive 20% off for AOL listeners.

You wouldn't go a day without brushing your teeth or washing your hands. What about washing your nose? I mean, your nose does filter the air you breathe, air loaded with bacteria, viruses, and irritants. Make nasal hygiene part of your routine with clear. No messy bottles to fill, no drowning sensation. Clear is a natural drug-free saline with the added benefit of xylitol, which blocks bacterial and viral adhesion. Available in stores and online at clear.com. That is X L-E-A-R. Have you been looking for a healthy snack for on the go?

But all the energy and protein bars are just too sweet and full of sugar preservatives and mystery ingredients. Well, not all energy bars are soft and sugary. Bear bars are a crunchy savy bar made from just six simple natural ingredients made with veggies, nuts, and seeds, bear bars are plant-based, organic, gluten-free, contain six grams of protein, and are low-temp dried for a unique crunch. To learn more, just visit barebar.com forward slash out loud and get the exclusive discount just for America Out Loud Listeners. That's B-E-A-R-B-A-R.com forward slash out loud.

Well, I challenge you to find a broad array of great voices, a deeper bench of experience or a more dedicated collection of passionate patriots than here on America Outloud. Now is our time, my fellow Americans, America Outloud. Liberty and justice for all. Okay, we are back with Dr. Mark McDonald and Dr.

Jeff Barkey, informed dissent. The intersection of, I don't know, what is the intersection? Healthcare and politics, the healthcare. Healthcare and the damn politics. Healthcare, the intersection of just crazy and crazy. Healthcare is crazy. Politics is corrupt as hell. I don't know who to believe anymore. Maybe we need to change our podcast name. But I I agree with you. I mean, in the work environment, you do need to be a little bit careful uh how you how and what you say to people, for sure. Uh, but I think there's a there's a role for appropriate anger, and I think we've gone way overboard with political correctness and political sensitivity.

Where you can't say anybody to anything, you can't compliment a woman on her, you know, nice looking outfit anymore. You can't, you can't, you just can't do that. And I don't know, I don't think society is better as a result of these politically correct rules that we put in place. Well, I think one of the big problems that is coming out from all of these um envious, spiteful, hateful attacks is the hyperfeminization of our social culture right now.

Women are designed to search for emotional comfort and a sense of equality and justice and perceived fairness. That's that's what motivates them. That's why HR departments pursue that and why it's why they're all run by women. Um men are driven for other things. They're driven to achieve, to produce, they're driven for not fairness, they're driven for justice.

Uh, they're driven for um quality and success and competition. And when you're driven for those things, people are going to fall by the wayside. People are going to be injured physically and emotionally, and there's going to be losers, and uh people are going to be unhappy. Yeah. And that's that's just part of the game. And if you remove all of that from the game, now essentially all you have is a bunch of people sitting around talking about their feelings and trying to make everybody feel good about themselves, and nothing gets done.

And that's that's what happens when you just allow the feminine to take over. You you wind up with a collapse of society, everything gets too soft. And uh, I just think we become too soft. In many ways, I think you're right. Speaking of too soft, let me let me get your thoughts on this. This was from uh yesterday from the Washington Post. First major medical group opposes gender transition surgeries for youth. The American Society of Plastic Surgeons said doctors should delay gender related surgeries until age 19, citing quote, insufficient evidence, close quote, that benefits outweigh risks.

I hesitate to call that a breakthrough. Uh it's uh it's I wouldn't even call it a step in the right direction. It may be a big toe placed in the right direction, small toe, maybe a small toe that's been severed, dipping in lukewarm water. Yeah. I mean, if if we have to take this as a sign of um moral courage, I think we have a long way to go.

Uh, but I I do have to say that relative to the uniform unequivocal chorus of slice those breasts off now, which is what I've been hearing up until yesterday. I I suppose that that does represent uh relatively speaking, um, a tidal shift. Yeah, I was on a I was on a radio show today, the Andrea K show out of San Diego. She's on the Salem Radio Network. I do a recurrent piece with her, and she asked about this, and you know, I I had a little bit of a flippant comment.

I said, you know, remember that surfer, Bethany Hamilton. Do you do you remember who she was, Mark? Didn't she get a shark bite? Like she lost her arm? Yeah, she lost an arm. I remember that. She's quite beautiful woman, and she lost her arm literally up to her shoulder. That's right. I remember she recovered and continued to surf, and now she's famous and infamous, and I imagine making some money or doing whatever because of what happened and her bravery continuing on and so forth. So I said, you know, kind of matter of fact, kidding, not kidding.

Well, you know, I'm I'm so amazed by what she did that I'm gonna go see an orthopedist and ask them to remove my left arm, because I'd like to experience what she did of having to live with only one arm uh and being able to achieve these various things. So I'd like my left arm to be removed, even though my left arm is perfectly healthy. Now, of course, any normal person with a half a brain would think I would be out of my F in mind to even consider something like that.

And any doctor that would perform such a surgery should be put in prison or at minimum lose their license. However, when we talk about gender transition, and we use terms to uh make it seem as if there's just a you know, a nothing burger going on, and surgeons that do this and and they should be in prison as well, they call it top surgery or bottom surgery. When they mutilate sometimes children, that's not happening anymore, but even adults, to remove a female's breasts through major surgery and to recreate a penis where there used to be a vagina, so-called bottom surgery.

I think it's the equivalent of somebody asking that a perfectly healthy limb or body part be removed just because that's what I want to do, and I'm an adult and I should be able to do anything with my body. So the whatever this uh medical outlet is, plastic surgery, Society of America, whatever the hell they are, you know, I agree with you. You know, okay, maybe directionally it's better than it was before this announcement, but the reality is like duh delay surgery until they're 19.

How about forbid any physician from doing this surgery because it's batshit crazy to do that to somebody with a legit mental health illness. We wouldn't do that. Or what if we took somebody who was anorexic to the point of, you know, no longer having periods and skinny and osteoporosis, and we encourage them to continue because they just wanted to be skinny as an adult person and they have a right to be as skinny as they want.

We would never do that. We would get them help. So I don't, I mean, it's it's ridiculous that the plastic surgery society or anybody else would make such a statement as if waiting until they're 19 suddenly now they're in a position to have body parts, healthy body parts removed, and somehow that's okay. That's that's not okay. We we should not allow that to happen any more so than we should allow a healthy body part to be removed because of some fetish or desire to look like Bethany Hamilton.

This whole argument about age boils down to one straw man argument or red herring in this whole debate about transgender medical procedures, which is this whether or not these mutilations are justified, moral and ethical, boils down to a question of patient consent.

And I I completely disagree with the whole premise of that argument. The basis of medical care has before consent is even entered into the conversation, it has to do with beneficence, it has to do with offering something good and a value to the patient, which is not determined by the patient, it's determined by the physician and the medical community and medicine as a profession. And if what's being offered is harmful to the patient, it doesn't matter if the patient wants it, it's irrelevant.

Well, it definitionally, somebody that wants such a thing can't be mentally healthy. And how can a mentally ill person give consent anyways? If the patient wanted the doctor to rape her, is that somehow now consensual sex and that's okay? It makes no sense. It's illogical. If the patient wants the doctor, well, this is another reason why I think euthanasia is unethical and immoral. Uh, because it doesn't benefit the patient to be dead. No, you can argue that palliative care and reducing pain is of benefit, even if it allows the patient a more speedy death.

That's certainly a valid logical uh and and moral argument to make, but you can't argue that a doctor who is supposed to reduce uh illness and suffering can somehow achieve that by killing the patient. It's not possible, even if the patient wants to die, because people who want to die are definitionally mentally ill. It indicates that there's a problem in their psyche by definition. Same thing with patients who want to have body parts removed that are not diseased or or or injured.

Same thing with a person who sees her nose is too big and thinks that it should be shaved off. These are people who have psychiatric illnesses. It's not up to them to decide how the doctor treats them. It's up to the ethics of the profession and the morals of society to make that decision. And if we're not willing to say it's unethical and immoral to do that, despite whatever degree of patient consent is offered at whatever age, 17, 20, or 78, then I think we've lost our way. And I don't think these medical associations are ethical associations anymore, as long as they stand by this.

I was in a deposition recently uh on a case, and wasn't related to any of my patients. It was just an evaluation of uh a third party, and I was asked to offer my opinion. And I I was asked, Dr. McDonald, uh, are you a member of the American Medical Association, the American Psychiatric Association, the American Association of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, et cetera, et cetera. And I said, no, no, no, and no. In fact, I'm not a member of any of these associations.

And the attorney said, Oh, well, were you fired from them? Uh, did you revoke your? I said, I haven't been a member of these since I was a resident, or even maybe a medical student, actually. And he said, Well, well, well, why not? I said, Because they're not ethical organizations. And he just paused for about 10 seconds. He didn't know what to say. He said, Well, what do you mean? Don't they establish standard of care? I said, No, they establish political standards of care. And I'm not interested in politics. Well, what do you mean? And I gave him the example, as you did about their positions on mutilating children in many cases.

Yeah. I said, I'm I'm not, I don't support the genital uh mutilation and chemical castration of children. And any organization that does is not one that I want to belong to. Do you have any other questions, counsel? And he just sat there silently bewildered. Well, I don't know if that is the I said, you can Google it right now. Shall we go offline? Shall we go off the record and Google this information? And then you can go back on the record and you can read it back to me. I'm happy to do that with you. And he said, Oh, well, let's just move on. I said, Yeah, good idea. Let's just move on. You don't know what the hell you're talking about, you moron. No, he's just trying to discredit you.

Exactly. And I shoved the shit right back into his face and made him swallow it. Have you had patients as a as a psychiatrist that have wanted to transition male to female, female to male? Uh, I had one patient who came to me on referral as a medication patient, not as a therapy patient. This was about five or six years ago. This is before 2020. And she was very excited because she said she wanted to get some medication for her mood, but her mood was a lot better recently.

So maybe she doesn't really need it. Oh, really? Why is that? What happened? I had a huge discovery. It was amazing. Really? What was your discovery? Well, with the work of my therapist who supports sex positive and gender-affirming communities. She helped me discover that I, it's the girl speaking, that I'm actually a boy in a girl's body. And now I'm looking for hormone treatments and going to move for sex change operations.

And I looked at her and I said, you know, I'm I'm really glad that you're feeling better emotionally. But I would strongly urge you to wait for a number of years. She was a teenager until you're well into adulthood, before you do anything hormonally or surgically to your body, because you will very likely learn something even more important in the coming years. And I can't tell you what that is, but I strongly strongly suspect that it's going to differ with the position that you're taking right now.

Never saw her face dropped. She left the office, and I never saw her again. Yeah. And this is normative psychiatry now. This is normative now. And this was back in the 2015 to 2020 period. I don't know exactly what year, but it was definitely before 2020. What the hell happened to your uh to your profession? It got infected and invaded by ideologues, wokesters, and Marxists. And the language became corrupted, and the members directorship became infiltrated by people with not only bad ideology, but but complete absence of really sort of any intellectual rigor who decided that taking positions of power within psychiatric organizations would make them more significant because they would have more influence.

And so the people who pursued that influence and power were not driven by the desire to do good, but the desire to be influential, even if it meant victimizing young and defenseless patients. And the profession was hollowed out because the people who remained in it as members decided to say nothing and to let it fall. And now it's fallen so far that it is not survivable, it is not reformable. And there is, in my opinion, there is simply no reason or justification to even participate in any psychiatric organization or body in this country anymore.

There are still people going into the field of psychiatry, though, through residencies. There are, but they're all being taught, instructed, tested, promoted, or held back or suspended based upon ideological conformity with contemporary Marxist woker belief systems. So those who are either not going along with the plan, or if they are not, are unwilling to say so, they are not now part of the community.

The only people that get promoted and pass are those who accept what they're being told to do and say, uh, or those who reject it internally but agree to abide by it for the time being until they can get their medical license and get the hell out. Uh in other words, they're either uh corrupt uh or they're cowards. What percentage of people, what percentage of psychiatrists are like-minded to you? I only know of one or two in the city of Los Angeles now that I believe are publicly rational and follow ethical principles to a large degree.

And I only know of probably half a dozen in the rest of the country that I've been put in touch with who also feel the same way and are not afraid to talk about it or write about it. How many of them uh say the the quote unquote right thing in public just to prevent being targeted, but actually do the do the correct thing in their practice? Yeah. Um, I don't know. It's it's actually impossible to know because psychiatry is such a privileged occupation or specialty. Uh, nothing really leaves the the consulting room.

So what percentage of psychiatrists in anonymous surveys, assuming that they're telling the truth, would actually reject some of this nonsense. I don't know if that's kind of a survey has even been done. What uh what's a patient to do that believes what we believe that needs to see a psychiatrist? Well, unfortunately, I think the only thing you can do is do remote treatment now, because it's very unlikely that there's going to be anybody physically in your city that you could find.

The only people that you could find publicly would people that you'd have to search for that have made public statements of affirmation of ethical psychiatry, and there's not many of those left in the country, and they're probably not near you. So finding somebody that's local that you could see uh in person uh would require just I think a real stroke of luck in being able to uh through word of mouth, be able to to discover that that psychiatrist uh or or physician exists.

You certainly won't be able to find it by going on the web and searching in your city because those people are probably not posting or publicizing anything at all that would draw attention to them. Is there a mechanism to find a like-minded psychiatrist? Well, I think what you can do is see who has published books that would be in support of what I would consider ethical psychiatric positions who actually practice, but the the overlap of that is not very high. A lot of clinical psychiatrists don't publish books.

I mean, Miriam Grossman, uh, who published the transnation book against the genital mutilation and chemical crestration of of kids out of New York, I believe she still practices. We interviewed her. We did. I know when we interviewed her, she was you know, off the air. Uh, she was much more disclosing than on the air, on the air, she didn't want to talk about a lot of these controversial things that we were talking about.

It was probably because she hadn't published the book yet. That could be. And then there's a psychiatrist down in South Orange County, I can't remember his name. We interviewed him as well. I think you've, I think you know him. Um forgetting. Well, Aaron Cariotti out of UC Irvine, who was fired for challenging the forced injections of the faculty and staff and students in the UC system. Um, I believe is is practicing maybe one day a week, but most of his work is publishing and writing and speaking.

Do you see patients online? I see local patients remotely who have moved, like high school kids who are in college who go away, but I don't see patients, new patients who come to me from other areas and out of state. I only see and evaluate new patients in person. Yeah, it's a dilemma, and it's not unique to psychiatry. I'm often asked, where do I find a primary care doctor that's like-minded?

And there's actually a mechanism. I mean, this is what I tell people. It's work. You call your local compounding pharmacy. You can just Google search compounding pharmacy near me. You ask them if they dispense ivermectin for the treatment of COVID. If the answer is yes, then you say, could I please have the contact information for the doctors that are calling in and prescribing it? And chances are that those physicians are probably like-minded. And they may be clever. And they may be from different specialties, primary care, whatever there is.

But chances are that's a good place to start and go interview them and ask them some questions. Or I guess, you know, the other question I get is hey, I don't, I want my, I don't want my kid vaccinated. Where can I find a pediatrician? And you just need to make phone calls and ask the pediatric office. Do they and will they see kids where the parents don't want them vaccinated, and then you can choose accordingly. Uh, but I know here in Orange County, even in Orange County, even coastal Orange County, where it's, you know, it's pretty, it's pretty red politically.

There are, I know doctors that refuse to see patients, refuse to see kids uh if their parents are not going to vaccinate them. And I, and even uh right in Long Beach, Long Beach Memorial. They have a whole pediatrics department. They will not see you if you don't want your kid vaccinated. I wonder how long this is going to last. I have so many patients now who are mothers who are going to get pregnant, are pregnant, or just had babies, who are not particularly out there.

You know, they're they're normal, sort of middle of the road. Sometimes I would even call them like liberal parents, but they're just very focused on natural health. They're not necessarily even that political. Right. And they're not interested in receiving the pediatric vaccination schedule. And at the very least, you know, they what they want is a culling of the majority of these vaccinations and whatever's left to be uh given later and with gap periods in between, so that the body has time to acclimate to the uh to the insult.

And this is actually now becoming, at least here in LA, I think fairly normal. It's not really considered to be extreme anymore. As I said, these are not activist parents. They're they're just kind of middle of the road people, and I'm hearing it more and more now. Yeah, I mean, for example, you have I think it's South Carolina, but I can't remember. There's uh several hundred uh cases of measles, and of course the media is all over it, and it's an outbreak and it's horrible, and the evil parents that don't get their kids vaccinated and on and on and on. And so parents are asking, listen, I'm not I'm not down with the whole vaccine schedule, but I'd like to get a measles vaccine.

The problem is there isn't a measles vaccine. It doesn't come as a standalone vaccine. It only comes as part of the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccination. And this is a big scam from the vaccine companies that they did this purposely to push vaccines that aren't necessarily needed, they come in combination that's never been studied in combination. Uh, and oh, by the way, they're immune from all liability, so they don't care anyways. And I I hope at least directionally it's changing at HHS.

The vaccine childhood vaccine schedule was was reduced from I think it was 17 to 11. It's like, okay, well, it's like, you know, the plastic surgery society that is saying wait till you're adult before you cut your breasts off. I guess directionally that's good, but I don't think the government should even be coming out with a vaccine schedule. I don't think they should publish a vaccine schedule. That should be between the doctor and the patient. Let them let them do the research, let them figure out what's going on, let them make a decision to vaccinate or not vaccinate.

But I don't think the government should be pushing a schedule. Hasn't worked. It's caused, I think, more harm than good. And until the vaccine companies stand behind the products that they put on the market, I think the government should say hard pass, we're not even going to come out with a schedule anymore. Well, when I look at places that I've traveled to where the people are physically and emotionally much healthier than Americans, it tends to be in places where the government is just not really doing much.

And the people themselves are taking charge of their lives and their health. Yeah. The more the government intrudes, uh, the less healthy the people are. I see that to be true largely around the world now. That's right. Yeah, that's right. So what country are you moving to? Well, I haven't decided yet, but I'm definitely going to start to spend um more time again in Central Europe. I I do think that uh some countries like Israel and Lebanon in the East and certainly in Central Europe, countries like Hungary and Poland and Slovenia and uh perhaps uh Slovakia.

Um they've they've not entirely, but I think they've they've they've largely dodged the biggest bullets that have landed square in the face of all the Anglophone countries, as well as all of the countries in Western Europe, yeah, which are just mired. There's there's no life really left to be pursued in those countries, unless you go out into the countryside into small towns. I understand that there's still some safe places, but sure. If you're looking at small, medium, large cities, I don't think there are any that um are really largely healthy and have freedom in the rest of the world.

This is the sort of first world world. You're not moving to Minnesota then. I wouldn't, I wouldn't move there just because of the weather. Yeah, but uh certainly certainly not with the politics. For sure. Well, Mark, we're just about out of time, and uh we'll have to continue this uh conversation and we'll see what happens in the world of politics and health care. Great to be with you until next time, we are out, informed dissent, the intersection of health care and politics.

You've been listening to Informed Descent with Dr. Jeff Barkey, board certified primary care physician, and Dr. Mark McDonald, board certified child, adolescent, and adult psychiatrist. Informed dissent, the intersection of health care and politics.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. High blood pressure care should go beyond the prescription

    Nov 16, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - High blood pressure care deserves more than another refill. Sleep, stress, exercise, and accurate home readings belong in the conversation alongside medication. A stronger...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. America’s Real Doctor Club puts patients first

    Nov 9, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - America’s Real Doctor Club promotes a return to medicine built on listening, informed consent, prevention, and personal values. As corporate demands and paperwork strain the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why your pet doesn’t need shots every year

    Nov 2, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - Does every veterinary treatment help your pet live better? Dr. Shawn Messonnier advocates individualized care that considers vaccination risk, nutrition, and quality of life. From...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Faith-based leadership for stronger families and teams

    Oct 26, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - The legacy children inherit begins with the promises parents keep today. David and Angelike Norrie connect Christian faith with intentional parenting, personal responsibility, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Russian plague fears: Evidence before panic

    Oct 19, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - Reports of a laboratory worker’s death in Russia raise questions about plague, transparency, and public fear. The author urges clear evidence, informed consent, and personal...

    Credit the people on this episode