Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Informed Dissent

Informed Dissent artwork

When medicine loses trust, patients and society suffer

Feb 2, 202658 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke and Dr. Mark McDonald - Trust in medicine and public institutions is unraveling as bureaucracy, money, and ideology replace evidence and transparency. From board certification to pharmaceutical influence and informed consent, patients pay the price. Rebuilding trust requires honesty, accountability, and restoring cultural balance that allows families, children, and society to thrive...

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Informed dissent, the intersection of health care and politics with Dr. Jeff Barkey, board certified primary care physician. And Dr. Mark McDonald, board certified child adolescent and adult psychiatrist. Mark, great to be with you. Another episode of Informed Descent. Hello. So, you know, we've been doing this for a long time, and we will periodically get questions from listeners. We don't always answer. We don't really have a I don't know, a platform or venue just to answer questions.

But I thought it would be fun to go through some of the questions, and you and I can answer the questions from the listeners. Sound good. This will be uh QA hour with uh Jeff and Mark. All right, here's question number one. You ready? Ready? Mark, you're often introduced as being board certified. What does that mean? And are you actually seeing patients? It has nothing to do with me feeling bored when I'm with my patients.

It uh it's actually a designation, which not every physician has or actually even is required to have, and is simply an additional certification of competency in your specialty within your medical domain, which for me is both psychiatry, adult psychiatry, and child and adolescent psychiatry. So I have two board certifications.

You're double boarded. That's right. Board squared. I am you can be board cubed too if you get a board certification in pediatrics. Uh, so there's so in psychiatry, there's pediatrics, child adolescent, and then adult. Yes. And there's two or three programs in the United States that allow you to do three training paths that set you up for the potential to do board certification in those three fields. But the only people who do it are oh well, geriatric is not within that domain.

So it's not part of the triple path. But the triple path is really only set up for people who are so highly overachieving and perfectionistic that they outnerd the nerds. For somebody that wants to see a psychiatrist for whatever ails them and they think they need psychiatric help, is it important to find a psychiatrist that's board certified? 20 years ago, I would have said yes because board certification was the sign of a seriously minded professional who pursued knowledge and wisdom to be better than just a baseline physician.

But today I would say no, because I know a lot of colleagues who have given up their board certifications and their later years in their career after learning that the American board of psychiatry and neurogy, which controls the board certification process out of their office in Chicago, is thoroughly corrupted. It is just nothing more now than a money making machine that you must pay a bribe into every year so that at the end of the 10 year period, you can receive your re-up of your board certification while reading uh ostensibly educational materials that are restricted within a certain list on their website where you take tests and answer questions to show that you uh absorb the material on subjects like the need to be approving of transgender surgeries for children and the necessity to incorporate diversity, equity, and inclusion uh into your therapeutic practice and other such nonsense.

Why why do you continue to maintain your certification? There are a few reasons why you need board certification. One would be if you're an employee. So if you're employed by a hospital and you need to have, let's say, admitting privileges, often hospitals require board certification for that purpose. Also, if you are an academic physician that needs to have the board certification on your resume to be able to write books or speak with authority, that's a second reason. And really the third reason is just to show to patients that you're a serious doctor.

Now, none of those really apply to me, but I also pursue a somewhat um esoteric subspecialty in my profession, which is I work as a medical legal expert providing my opinions to attorneys. And when you work in the legal domain in medicine, uh, many attorneys feel that the board certification allows you to assert yourself as a stronger voice of expertise in the field, and you take on and hold greater weight uh when you render your opinions.

So it then becomes professionally uh quite useful for somebody who's working in that field. But were I simply to be seeing patients on my own in a private practice, like uh, for example, what you're doing, uh, I don't really think that it's necessary. And I don't think that it is uh in any way helping to improve clinical care or clinical outcomes. I agree. There is a relatively new new, I think it's maybe 10 years, called the National Board of Physicians and Surgeons, and it's an alternative to the traditional board certification.

In family practice, there's a board certification as well. And for years, I would get certified and recertified, and the recertification process is expensive, it's onerous, and it's been a while now, so I don't remember all the details, but part of it was an all-day test in one of those testing centers. And I remember the first time I showed up there, I had snacks and I had a cup of coffee, and you know, I'm the kind of guy when I'm doing work, I've got my cup of coffee and snacks I'm eating and whatever little ADD, and I want to sit at a chair for hours and hours.

And I got in there and it's quite secure. You have to check in, you have to show ID, you have to show ID for this, but not to vote or get into the country, but that's another story. And then I didn't read all the details about um the process of this test. And so when I got there with a backpack and all my stuff, they said, Oh, I'm sorry, sir, but you can't bring your backpack. I'm like, okay, cool. I don't really need the backpack. I've got a thermos full of coffee and a bag full of snacks. No, I'm sorry, sir. You're not allowed to drink or eat in the testing center at all.

I go, are you kidding me? I've got to sit there for two hours or three hours at a time without a cup of coffee. You can bring a clear plastic bottle of water. That's the only thing allowed. I'm like, are you friggin' kidding me? And the test, um, the testing was literally, it would be a three-hour block of time where it was on a computer. You would answer question after question after question for three hours. I can barely stay awake watching a three-hour movie, let alone sitting there.

Now, this was years ago. And I remember after I did that, I said, I will never do this again. It's a complete waste of my time. It is painful that I would have to do this. And the questions that you have to answer are completely meaningless, irrelevant to the actual practice of medicine. Some of the questions were so detailed, like in pediatrics, because I take care of kids. You know, you've got a uh eight-year-old kid who comes into the office, he had these two vaccines, uh, went away for a period of time, he came back and got this vaccine.

Uh, what is the proper schedule to get them caught up on vaccinations? Something like that. Mike, are you frigging kidding me? First of all, if such a patient actually came into my office, I could easily pull up the CDC schedule on my computer. They have a catch-up module so you can figure this out. I'd lay it down on a piece of paper with a pen, I'd circle the ones where he is and so forth. You think I'm gonna memorize something like that? So it was things like that that made me realize that it's ridiculous.

And then they had this process called uh MOC, maintenance of certification. So it wasn't enough that every I think it was 10 years, might have been six. Was it enough that every six or 10 years you had to go to one of these testing stations and take an onerous painful test? But along the way, they had this maintenance of certification. Of course, you had to pay for it. And it was things like you had to pull chart records for the last 20 patients that you saw for hypertension. Then you have to answer their questions to make sure that based on what they think is important, you asked your hypertensive patients or hypercholesterol patients or diabetics and so forth.

You have to pay for it. It's very expensive. There are numerous studies that showed there is zero correlation between maintenance of certification, the board certifying test, and quality and quality care as a physician. And finally, I said, forget it. I'm not doing this ever again. Right about the same time, my partner, business partner, took the same test for whatever reason. He didn't pass it by a few points. And together we decided we are not doing this, and we discovered this other board certification route, National Board of Physicians and Surgeons.

It is accepted now by almost every hospital of the country. It is not an onerous thing. You have to prove CME as you should. You pay them a small fee. There's none of this nonsense maintenance maintenance of certification. And that is the certifying body through which I am now certified. And what do they require you to do? Uh, it's basically CME. Um, and uh You you need to provide them information about your clinical practice. Um, and you pay a small fee, and that's basically it.

And CME is uh continuing medical education, continuing medical education. That's right. Credits that you receive for taking classes. And it's like, you know, we're we're both uh licensed in this in the great communist state of California. Well, California takes it even farther. We are under the umbrella of the um of the medical board of California, medical board of California is our licensing board. Interestingly, of course, the president of the medical board of California is not a physician. Uh, he is an attorney, but whatever.

And they have requirements, the medical board, you have to take certain classes. You have to take classes like I think there's a transgender class that we're supposed to take to maintain our license. You're gonna dress up for that one. You do have to, yes, it's and it's not even on Halloween. So I think for the most part, I agree with you, Mark, that the traditional American Board of Physicians specialties, that's the organization under which all are all the typical specialties that you can think of. Uh, is corrupt. The certifying uh process in no way ensures that uh the physician who is so so-called board certified is certified to do anything other than to pay a large fee and pass the process by which they they deem necessary.

So I think more and more physicians are opting out of board certification and are looking at other organizations like the National Board of Physicians and Surgeons. Makes a lot of sense. Yeah, for sure. Okay, question for Barkey. You talk a lot about holistic health. Have you always been holistically oriented? And if not, when did this begin? Is that before or after you gave up your pension for uh eating Smarties and chicklets?

Oh, and good and plenty. Let me forget that one. Skittles. I love Skittles. And I love good and plenty. Good and plenty isn't hot tamales, I think are the superior candy. And by the way, I've got a mason jar full of both in my drawer at my office. I do not recommend this for anybody, but from time to time, I will have a few of those uh as a little bit of a treat. But really, for me, the wake up call came during COVID and even before COVID. Um, when I realized that much of what I learned in medical school was bullshit.

And I can give you multiple examples. You and I were both taught in medical school. We're about the same age. I think you're a little bit younger, but same concept. We were taught, for example, vaccines are safe and effective, and there is no correlation between vaccines and chronic illness or autism. This was drummed into our head over and over and over and over again, almost to the point that we just didn't even think about it, at least in my practice as a primary care doctor. Kids would come in for their well child check. The well child check is um is basically the schedule by which you would follow the CDC guidelines for the vaccine schedule for children.

And we didn't think anything of it. You'd see a newborn, and we'd have them come in at two months, four months, eight months, 12, 15, 18, and so forth, correlating with the childhood vaccine schedule. No informed consent. I hadn't read a package insert. I wouldn't even know how to read those things, nothing. So there's vaccines, there's the cholesterol myth that uh saturated fat causes elevated cholesterol, which causes cardiovascular disease. You need to stop eating saturated fat, and you need to treat the cholesterol with some sort of a statin.

We know now that that's BS. On and on and on. I mean, it wasn't long ago, Mark, 50 years ago, only 50 years ago, the majority, more than 50% of all physicians smoke cigarettes. We didn't just smoke cigarettes, by the way. We would often recommend smoking cigarettes to patients, for example, that suffered from depression or anxiety that for patients that had digestive issues. By the way, there is a role for nicotine for those things, but the cigarettes are the problem.

And it took over 20 years from the seminal study that definitively linked smoking and cardiovascular and pulmonary disease before all the three-letter agencies decided that they would abandon the idea that smoking was harmless at best, uh, or even helpful to some patients. So I have a whole talk that I give on this. What else 50 years ago did we do? Well, in psychiatry, we used to do lobotomies on patients that suffered from intractable depression or anxiety or whatever the psychiatric illness was, wasn't uncommon to do those types of things.

Electroconvulsive therapy, although there's a role for it, and it's making somewhat of a comeback. There are many things that we used to do. We used to recommend drugs that we now have found out are harmful, like uh, what's the drug we would give for women for morning sickness? Um, can't remember the name of it. Uh thalidomide. Yeah, thalidomide for morning sickness. Oops, it just caused, you know, arms and legs deformities. Uh, so it had to be pulled from the market. Of course, nobody got fired as a result of approving that thing.

No drug company got sued as a result of that. On and on and on and on. So over COVID, it really woke me up to start looking at everything that I did in medicine, realizing that there is a holistic path forward to almost everything that ails us, not a drug prescription treatment strategy for everything that ails us. You and I were both taught the disease model of medicine, which means if you have a symptom or a disease, we can find a prescription to treat that.

We were never taught to look at the root cause. Oh, in passing, it was discussed, but there was never any formality about how to get to the root cause of whatever it is that somebody has. And now watching TV, the NFL playoffs, for example, uh, almost every other commercial is some drug commercial. Drug commercial for a drug that you can't pronounce that most people has never heard of, treating an illness that's very rare that almost everybody doesn't have. So Sky Rizzy, it's like, what? For whatever condition, I can't even remember, but I can remember the name of the drug.

And I did the math at the the other week during an NFL game. I don't remember the drug. Do pixant, Sky Rizzy, uh true truvada. I don't even remember, but I did the math and I looked at one of the drugs for whatever whatever it was uh being treated for ulcerative colitis or something. I said, Huh, I wonder how many people are watching this football game right now. I looked it up and it was like whatever it was, three or four million people at any particular game. I said, Oh, that's interesting. How many people in the United States have this disease that they're advertising for?

I don't know what it was, maybe 10,000 people in the country that had this disease. I'm like, that doesn't make any sense. Why would you spend so much money to advertise a drug that nobody's heard of? And by the way, probably couldn't even get even if they had the disease because it's so expensive and requires some sort of prior authorization system. Uh, and advertise for a disease that rare is a rare disease that hardly anybody's has. What's the deal? Why are they doing this? Well, as it turns out the reason why they're doing that, this has little to do with advertising to influence consumers.

What they're doing is they're advertising to influence the news desk because pharma spends a tremendous amount of money bolstering these networks in hopes of that their news desks won't be publishing negative pieces when they're sued, when they lose money, when they kill somebody, when they have to pull something from the market, they won't publish critical news pieces against the pharmaceutical company. So that's why you see all these pharmaceutical ads, not to influence the consumer, but to influence the news desk.

And I think the same is true with all the advertising and pharma support of all the medical journals, New England Journal of Medicine, Journal of the American Medical Association, uh, out of Great Britain, the Lancet, these things are heavily subsidized by pharma. Do you think that these journals are going to publish hyper-critical articles about the drugs and the vaccines and the companies themselves? Oh, hell no. Follow the money. And so when I started learning about all the corruption in healthcare, it made me realize that I need to needed to question almost everything I believed as it related to health care.

And then along the way, I also had a very holistic medical assistant nurse that I hired during COVID. Uh, and she also opened up my eyes to much of what I didn't see before. She asked me, have I ever read a package insert for the MMR vaccine that I'm about to walk into a room and give a kid? I'm like, uh, who reads those things? Nobody reads those things. So I started reading them, and I had to teach myself how to read them because they're not easy to read. They're written in small font, they're written very scientific y.

So a lot of the words I didn't even understand. I'd have to Google search the various words to understand what they meant, especially when you look at section 11, which is it's the it's titled description, and it's where the ingredients are in these vaccines. There's a lot of code words and numbers and letters there, and they don't make any sense to the average person. You have to look these things up. Like, for example, uh, I did a um in I did a morning message informed consent, which I do almost every Friday on the hepatitis A vaccine.

I had a patient who was going overseas and they wanted to know if they should get the hepatitis A vaccine. So that's a really good question. Let me look at the package insert, and we'll read it and research it together. And then you decide. Here's and here's what I found out under description. It has MRC MRC 5, MRC-5 under the ingredients. I'm like, what the hell is MRC five? If you're listening, look it up. Google search it, MRC 5. It's an aborted fetal cell line that was been propagated for many, many years.

And then right in the ingredients, it says this vaccine may contain trace remnants of the MRC five cell line. Now, regardless of what you feel about abortion and whether it's okay to do this or not okay, isn't the point. The point is patients should know when they make then make their own decision. In addition, this particular vaccine uses aluminum as an adjuvant. And it also has a neomycin antibiotic in the syringe, and it's got polysorbate AD. Now, I don't really care about these things necessarily, but what I care about is that patients understand what they're injecting in their body.

In addition, as you read the package insert for hepatitis A, there is not a single placebo controlled study that was ever done for this vaccination. All the studies for hepatitis A were done against either older versions of the same vaccine or against other vaccines as comparisons. And then what they use is efficacy studies, is not vaccinate a whole bunch of people and follow them over time and see who gets hepatitis A and who doesn't. They do the vaccinations, then they measure antibody response in the blood.

And if the antibody response is high enough, they conclude this stuff must be good and must be protective. Not to mention that the vaccine companies are immune from all liability. So it's this information that I think it's critical that every patient know. Then only then are they in a position to make a decision like this patient did. I'm going to Europe. It wasn't Europe. It was um uh they were going to uh the Philippines.

Yeah, they were going to the Philippines for some uh business purpose. He had business over there, and they wanted to get a hepatitis A vaccine. Like, sure, go get it, but only after you know this information. So it's sort of like, you know, we report, you decide. I can't remember what uh station says that. Um, but that's the information. I'm just reporting, I'm just educating, and the patients can decide. So that's that's my perspective on answering a very long uh answer to the question uh how did I become holistic?

So it's that information, that knowledge that I learned, learning about vaccines and other things that makes me question just about everything I do to research first to see if there is a holistic path forward, not just the drug path forward. Most people are still really uninformed about this. I was at a farmer's market today here in Los Angeles, the Marvista Farmers Market, passed by uh food stand, guys screaming at me from behind the counter. You got to try our vegan muffin.

And you gotta try our vegan cheese, potato, Spanish tostada. And uh, we've got to try. So anyway, I tried the products and I said, just curious. Um why did you take out the eggs and the meat and all of that? Right rather than the fact that you, you know, you love animals and you think it's a sin to kill them. And you know what the woman said? She said, Oh, it's for health reasons. And I said, What specifically? She said, Well, all these animal products, they they increase your cholesterol and they cause heart attacks.

Yeah. And I said, Well, look, all religion and ideology aside of the vegan movement about the animal rights. That isn't true. Cholesterol actually has no correlation with risks of heart attacks and strokes in general. And she got very, very indignant. And she said, I've done all of my research. I read, and I know that you're wrong, and we have to agree to disagree. Thank you very much. Did you taste one of them at least?

I had all of the samples. Yeah. Were they good? They were actually all quite good. Yeah. And I said, My compliments to your ability to make something that has essentially no nutritional value tastes so good. Yeah, I mean, listen, I respect somebody who's a vegetarian because they feel bad about killing animals. I get it. And if you've ever been to a uh a cow slaughterhouse, it's it's quite gruesome. Uh, and I would understand after seeing that that maybe you wouldn't want to eat cows or whatever.

I respect that. But to do so for health reasons, I think is misguided. As a matter of fact, I think arguably uh it's much, much harder to be a healthy vegan than it is to you know be a carnivore, if you will. I told her, well, you know, RFK Jr. has done a lot of research too, and he just pronounced that we should invert the food pyramid. And then she finishes my sentence and she says, and eat more meat. And I said, eat more high quality protein. Yeah. And then she says, No, he said you've got to eat more meat.

And I told her basically what you just said. Yeah. Which is, you know, your vegan diet is actually making it harder, not easier, for you to be healthy. And then she leered at me and turned bright red in the face, and I grabbed a sample and ran away. Mark, we're going to take a quick break and we when we come back. You wrote a sub stack, not actually Substack, but people know what Substack is. It's your own site called DissidentMD about New Year's resolutions. And when we come back, uh, a listener wants to know what, if any, were your new New Year's resolutions, since you thought it was a pretty good idea to make some.

We'll be back in just a second. Let's get real. Let's get loud on America Out Loud Talk News. Yes, this is Dr. Peter McCullough, and I'm personally inviting you to join me in Nashville on July 2nd, 3rd, and 4th for a historic experience in 2026. America Out Loud News 250 slash 10, Nashville, along with Clear and the Wellness Company. We're celebrating two big milestones: 250 years of America and 10 years of America Outloud News. I'm calling all patriots to this historic weekend with inspiring entertainment.

Incredible fireworks, and nationally recognized speakers who proudly stand for freedom. I would love to see you there because your presence matters and you are family. Now's the time to get together and we can exchange ideas, answer your questions, and enjoy fellowship. Join us and register now at America Outloud dot news forward slash Nashville. That's America Outloud.news forward slash Nashville. We'll see you there. You wouldn't go a day without brushing your teeth or washing your hands.

What about washing your nose? I mean, your nose does filter the air you breathe, air loaded with bacteria, viruses, and irritants. Make nasal hygiene part of your routine with clear. No messy bottles to fill, no drowning sensation. Clear is a natural drug-free saline with the added benefit of xylitol, which blocks bacterial and viral adhesion. Available in stores and online at clear.com. That is XLEAR.com. Filling off since COVID? Try the wellness company Spike Detox Trio, packed with natok kinase, bromaline, and turmeric to help boost your immune system and fight off harmful spike proteins.

Bounce back with energy and clarity. Go to TWC.health forward slash out loud and use promo code Outloud for 20% off your first order. Struggling with your health, energy, and constantly feeling hungry. Want to save money on the rising cost of groceries and dramatically improve your health? Go to chemicalfree body.com forward slash out loud today. Get nature's super multivitamin, doctor formulated green 85 juice formula, empower your immune system, cut your grocery bill, and save 20% on your first order.

Been more threatening. Well, the America most of us have grown up with. And Marxism. America Rotlaw.news is the antidote to these poison is America Outloud dot news is that place to awaken your heart, soul, and mind to the outloud truth.

All right, we are back with informed dissent, and we are answering listeners' questions during this episode. Kind of fun. So Mark, you wrote a uh dissident MD substack like article. This was uh early January about New Year's resolutions. And you said they were a pretty good thing to do, requires discipline, uh, patience, uh, etc. Uh, what were yours? If any, what were your new years resolutions? And have you have you changed your mind since you wrote that article? No, I haven't.

I've actually reinforced my decision as I spend more time uh out and about here in Los Angeles with uh the indigenous crazy people, which is that I'm going to spend at least two months abroad in 2026. Two months. Yeah. Two months total or two months at a time. Two months in total in at least four week blocks. Oh wow. Okay. And where do you plan to go? Central and eastern Europe, probably.

Okay. Uh you were in the Middle East not long ago. And he I was any desire to go back to Lebanon. I would love to go back to Lebanon. Unfortunately, there isn't any work available there right now, which would have been an easy way for me to get back. But I'm still considering that. Yeah, well, if when you go and if you travel, let me know. I can't, I can't get away for four weeks, but I might go join you for uh a week or thereabouts, it might be fun to go see the crazies in other countries for a while.

The uh the Central and Eastern European nations are, although not perfect and certainly have unfortunately chosen to allow a bit of uh poisoning of their culture, since uh they're not completely isolated from the West, and and nor should they be. And it's hard to uh keep yourself completely clean culturally without being completely cut off from the world at large. But I do believe that they are at least 15 or 20 years behind where we are in terms of the degradation of their culture, and by that I just mean the uh the disappearance of rational common sense, the loss of Judeo-Christian values, the connection to church, the uh prioritization of family, children, and community, and equally importantly, if not more so, the devaluation of full-time chronic employment by women.

This is something that the West has taken on as an almost theological belief, a scriptural prophecy, which I think has done more to really destroy uh every foundation of Western civilization than just about any other societal decision. And you don't see that in these countries, and I think that that is is largely what has allowed them to maintain uh their uh their cultural roots, their sanity, their their health, and the ability for them to uh to sort of propagate the species, which is ultimately what we have to do, and we're not doing it anymore in the United States.

Yeah, for sure. And you've you've written about this a number of times that you think we have in the equal rights movement as it relates specifically uh to women have has done more harm than good. Fortunately, the ERA, the act itself was shut down, uh largely due to the efforts of Phyllis Schlafley. Uh, but the movement in general has done more to harm women and and men than really any other post-war movement. It's a Marxist movement uh at its core, and it denies the differences between men and women, and it actually supplants the needs of women with a political agenda, which has nothing to do with what women actually need.

And it's hurt children. Yes, it's it's largely hurt children because children thrive in two-parent households, and they don't thrive in single parent households, and single parent households have increased, certainly within the white population, mainly because of this uh fallacy that women can raise children independent of men, uh, which they can't.

Uh the breakup of the family in non-white houses. Well, they can, just not nearly as effectively. Well, when I say they can and they can't, I don't mean that the child dies, but you can't you can't uh raise a child to the child's potential if you don't have two parents. There's going to be an injury. And you know, some injuries through divorce are unavoidable because of the loss of the parent. But when you tell women that it's really no different raising a child by yourself than it is with a man or father, a husband, that's a lie.

Meaning if a if a woman, a single woman purposefully decides to have a baby independent of marriage and a family, uh, that's a that's not a good thing for the for the woman, and it's not a good thing for the child. No, it's not because the child requires for potentially reaching full development, the presence of a father and a mother, and to necessarily deny the child by choice that option, not because the father died or because there was a unfortunate divorce that was unavoidable, but by choice, that's not just a tragedy, that's an act of narcissism.

Self-it's it's incredibly selfish. I that's why I'm opposed to the gay couple uh using the medical science of uh you know insemination and surrogacy to have children. Um I don't support that. Um, I think that it's incredibly selfish and narcissistic for gay men and gay women to deprive their child of the opposite sex parent simply because they want to have a child.

Um I do think that they should not be banned from adopting children, but I don't think that they should choose to bring children into the world when they know that that mother or the father will never be known to that child. Yeah, Dennis, I know has talked about this a lot in the past that there is something unique and important what a man and a woman brings into a child's life, important and very different. And when you have two men or two women, you deprive that child of that difference.

It's right. It's it's an important distinction to say it's not that a child needs two parents. That's not the point. A child needs a male and a female parent, a mother and a father. It's not the number of parents that the child has that makes the parenting good. It's the fact that there are two separate opposite sex parents that makes the parenting good. Yes. Okay, from a listener. Mark, you often are very critical, it seems purposefully against women.

Do you think we should repeal the amendment that gave women the vote? Oh, wow. What a what a what a targeted, a targeted question. Send hate mail directly to Mark McDonald. Well, this this has been this was actually one of the favorite um uh arguments that Charlie Crook would take up on college campuses. No, you know what's funny, and serious seriously, uh you know, I I read all your articles, they come to my email. I'm a subscriber. Uh, you're an excellent uh writer and very insightful and bright.

I do feel that you sometimes purposefully write in a way that is inflammatory for the purpose of being inflammatory, not just to uh impart your wisdom and knowledge. Well, I'm I'm not uh I'm not on statins, so that might be why everything is so inflamed. Maybe, yeah, that could be it. Yeah, we need to put we need to give you more fish oil.

I love fish oil, by the way. I think that if you just look at the results of what's happened when women have been given the vote, they're uniformly negative. Uh and this is pretty much um not just not it's it's really not disprovable. Uh women make decisions largely speaking based on emotion, not on reason. And for that reason, women can be more easily controlled politically through propaganda and manipulation. And you could even argue, and and many women actually have argued this, including uh self-described feminists, that another way to describe or define woke culture is the weaponization of the feminine.

In other words, women are naturally inclined to want to protect the groups that they perceive to be weak. And of course, the ultimate weak group is infants, babies, children, and that's good and that's natural. But what happens if for political reasons or power or financial reasons, vulnerable groups are defined for women, meaning not for their on their behalf, but they're defined in place of women's decision making for the purposes of those who make those categories and distinctions for themselves.

So for example, let's say the vulnerable are now illegal immigrants or transgenders, or black and brown people, or the environment and those who love the environment. Now, what if what if all of those groups now supplant the truly vulnerable and the one vulnerable group that all women really should be focusing their attention on, which are babies and children and infants. Well, now you have the opportunity to weaponize women's natural instincts for caring and caretaking to the detriment of themselves and society, because it supersedes their reason and their ability to see through all the bullshit.

And that's why you see today, most activist groups, including the anti-Kings protests, including the eco-environmental activist protest, including the anti-ICE protests, are largely speaking middle-aged white women. That's the problem with giving political power to women. And these women vote. Well, listen, there are there are examples of heroic female politicians that have made a huge difference on the world stage.

You know, Margaret Thatcher, for example, comes to mind. Well, the fact that there are people, women who have done amazing political acts does not deny the valid the validity of my argument in the same way that there are undoubtedly amazing examples of heroic female police officers on the streets and female soldiers to the argument that on the whole female soldiers who are fighting in combat create more problems and more harm than they do good.

And besides Hillary Clinton, what a wonderful politician and women. Nancy Pelosi, Kamala Harris, the best. Maxine Waters, Karen Bass. Do you do you think the tide is changing back to more traditional roles for both men and women? I don't see examples of the tide turning for the majority of the population.

I only see it in very specific subgroups, demographically and geographically. And it seems that these um these differences are politically segregated as well. In conservative circles, there are much more traditional families, traditional families. Uh, the man works, the woman's primary role is taking care of the children. I mean, there are there are exceptions to men staying at home and women working. That's not common, but there are exceptions.

Uh, versus left of center where you have this mix-up of roles. I have a friend who just started dating again. She's in her 50s, and she's been setting her dating app profiles to different zip codes. LA, South Texas, South Florida, and she's sending me screenshots of the profiles of men that pop up in the different zip codes and lining them up side by side to show me the distinctions between one and the other.

And they are stark. The men that she's seeing pop up in her profile in Texas and Florida are largely men who are in shape, wearing traditional masculine clothing, playing golf, going to the gym, working full-time, using complete sentences without jargon, being respectful and polite, focusing on not themselves, but their family, friends, and community and what they're doing for the outside world.

The men in Los Angeles that are popping up are men with bleached white mohawk hair with pastel plaid vests on and pink t-shirts, man jewelry, man buns, skinny gen chains, skinny jeans. So you you wrote an article about this uh about the loss of masculinity. Uh, the articles entitled The Masculinity Crisis and the Origins.

What causes a guy in LA to wear a man bun, dress in skinny jeans, pastel colors, and basically loses man card. What causes that to occur? Well, putting aside all of the health arguments like estrogen in the water, loss of testosterone, et cetera, putting all that aside, just looking at it from the societal perspective. Uh, I think it's the result of decades now of intensifying education/slash indoctrination, K through 12 in universities that decries all expressions and forms of masculinity as inherently toxic and misogynistic.

So they've been taught that. I believe that it's entirely environmental. And as well as what is changed of the nuclear family. Well, the nuclear family is no longer valued. So this guy that dressed the way I just described is likely to have been raised by a dominant uh mother and a passive father. Very much so, if not a single parent like a single mother.

Or maybe even two gay men. And then you have an educational system that reinforces that. And then you have all these endocrine disrupting chemicals that don't help things, uh, lower testosterone, lower sperm count, uh, more toxic food, more vaccinations, more drugs as opposed to holistic solutions, uh, more SSRI medications, uh, because they're anxious or depressed or what have you.

So it's multifactorial, not just a simple, not just a single thing. Correct. And don't forget the additional factor, which is female dominance of all institutions. When did woke take over? Woke took over around the same time that our institutions became dominated by women. Corporations, HR, all women dominant, universities, faculty, all dominant, populations of students in professional schools, law, business, medicine, female dominant, education, health.

The public health director of LA County is a woman. Most of the people that run the city schools, women, most therapists now and social workers and psychiatrists, women. I think I think most new students to medical schools are women as well. It crossed over about two or three years ago to the 51 plus percent range. So you have female dominance in all different domains, and what happens in what comes with female dominance? What comes is not critical thinking, conflicts for the sake of resolution to a better end, aggressive fighting for better achievement and outcome.

What comes through is negotiation, compromise, protecting people's feelings, comfort, not the pursuit of truth, but the pursuit of equity, the idea that protecting the weak is more important than fostering the success of the strong. All of these are female qualities and female virtues that when put into practice in institutions negate the masculine outcomes of strength, success, productivity, and the pursuit of truth.

Those are not what women want, and that's not what they desire. And that's not what we get. We get the opposite. And that's why we have weak men. Not many, not many women in the construction industry. There are very few, and the only ones that I know of are basically lesbians. Not too many women truck drivers. Just a few lesbians. Special forces in the military, not very many women. Zero, because they're not allowed. That's the one uh domain of the military where no women are allowed to serve.

Yeah, is that true? Yep. No women Navy SEALs. Zero. They're not, they're not allowed. No women airborne uh army airborne or marine recon. No, only in administrative capacity. Interesting. And imagine now what would have happened with the recent snatch of the Venezuelan president illegitimately elected uh Nicholas Maduro had we had a integrated special forces fighting force, we probably would have lost half of the staff and half of the fighters on the ground in Caracas.

Send hate mail directly to Dr. Mark McDonald. How do we how do we reverse some of these changes? Do you think? I don't think there's a solution, actually. Um it's started decades ago in the 1960s, so it's been 50, 60 years in the making, and it's now multi-generational, and the newest largest voting block in the next election is going to be those who were brought up entirely under the woke culture doctrine and the indoctrination who believe all of the lies that they were indoctrinated with over the last uh 20, 25 years.

So they're going to be in the majority and they're going to be making our political decisions. And there really isn't going to be much that any of us that are over the age of 40 can do about it anymore. So I'm not hopeful, and I don't see really anything changing on the political front, certainly not in states like California or in large urban centers until and unless the younger generation begins to demand that truth be prioritized over feelings.

And we don't have many examples of that occurring throughout the United States, only in pockets. And that's ultimately why we're failing. And any country in the world that you see failing, other than obvious Gestapo states like you know, North Korea, um, are also failing for that reason. Um, I'm not talking about tribal outliers in Africa. I'm talking about first world countries. Their primary source of failure uh is that they don't pursue truth anymore. They don't pursue productivity, they pursue um some very confused uh goal of making people feel better and making things equitable, whatever that means.

And that is a feminine quality, it is not a masculine one. Men do not seek equity, men do not seek uh feeling uh feeling. Of evenness. Men seek uh growth, success, productivity, and winning. And uh, and we're not doing that. Um, I think it's actually going to have to come from the women, honestly. Um, men are not going to be able to win this battle because they'll be pushed back as as you know, misogynists. Well, it's the it's the mostly women that are fighting the battle, for example, to get men out of women's sports.

You and I met with uh and had an opportunity to speak alongside Riley Gaines, uh, who is an outspoken advocate uh to prevent men from competing against women. They are the ones that are doing this, not not the men. That's right. And that's that's a counterattack against those who were largely pushing for allow men to take over women's sports, which ironically was also women. Now, the people who were moving into the men's sports, or the women's sports, rather, that were men, are of course men.

So they are the ones that are entering into the sports, but the supporters of them and those that were pushing it were largely women. All of the transgender activism is all driven by women. So it was really uh an internal pushback by also by women to fight back against other women. So it was like an internycene battle, because when men start to jump in and say we need to protect women, then they're accused of being toxic. So it's it's a lot harder for that that cry to be um to be levied against women who are saying we're just trying to keep ourselves safe.

So don't don't you can't call us misogynists. You can call us transphobic, of course, but you can't call a woman a misogynist for wanting to protect yourself. But but you can you can lance that charge at men. So I think it's really going to be women that are going to have to stand up and unify and push back against um what I see as sort of the nexus of the of the degradation, which is coming from the overtaking by the feminine of our society and the weaponization of that feminization in a really bad way.

Well, maybe in an unexpected way, this movement to get men out of women's sports will translate into other aspects. Well, women will take the charge to kind of write the ship of uh I think more universally defined male roles and women's roles in society. Well, if women could start to acknowledge that their strength lies in supporting men rather than trying to compete with them or replace them, then they will paradoxically elevate themselves and also elevate men.

Yeah. Well, some people will be angry at you saying a woman's role is to support men. They will say, I can do anything that a man can do and do it just as well, and I should have the right to do that. And they'll be wrong. Because there actually is nothing that women do better than men. There are things that they do that men don't do, which is give birth, but there isn't a single activity, there isn't a single subject or a single occupation that women perform better than men. Doesn't exist. Raise children. Well, that's just an extension of giving birth.

And I wouldn't even argue that in to some degree, uh, women are actually less good at raising children than men are. The majority of infanticide and child abuse is actually perpetrated by women, not by men. Traditionally, women have been in the classroom as teachers, grade school teachers. And they are traditionally the ones who have now over the last few generations, largely destroyed the ability of boys to develop normally because they have been thoroughly feminized and taught to be like little girls and sit still and be quiet and not go in rough play.

But not traditionally. Well, I think it was acknowledged decades ago, make say, say World War II and before that boys should be boys. It really was only after the 60s and 70s that uh women's voices in education um started to attack traditional understandings of biology and development and supplanted what was really based in reality and truth and feminized education. And I think that's really been to the detriment of boys.

So I don't think that currently uh the teachers today are doing a great job raising children in the classroom. And if you look at the teachers who were purple haired with rainbow flags teaching transgender nonsense with a bunch of metal in their face and using different pronouns, they're largely speaking women. Yeah, well, that's true. But the tradition, the tri, I mean, I know when I was when I was growing up, I had some great teachers.

I would say most of my you know, K through 12 teachers, there were exceptions were women. Uh, I don't remember any effort to cause problems. Uh, I I think they understood the traditional roles of men and women. And I think you're right that during the 60s, that all started to change. Yeah. Um, but there's a lot of men that aren't gonna want to be elementary school teachers, uh, no matter no matter what we do. And I think there's always gonna be a need for a more nurturing um person in the classroom to take care of the young kids as they grow up.

Well, I would grant women the option to be teachers, nurses, and nuns. Yeah, and you're right, nurses as well. Most most nurses traditionally, there are more male nurses now, but most nurses traditionally have been women, possibly and a lot of the male nurses are gay. They are, yeah. So, and also a lot of the male nurses are Filipino, and many of them are Filipino men who tend to be rather effeminate if they're not homosexual. So there is an effeminate quality to uh nursing, whether it's by men or women that seems to be very well received and does well with the patients.

So there are certain occupations that women can thrive in, but the bulk of where women work in, the bulk of the areas that women have infiltrated in the last few decades, has really been in corporate office towers and air-conditioned rooms. And a lot of the work that they're doing is unnecessary. And that's why I actually believe that one of the biggest changes that we might see, at least in the long term positively, not in the short term, it'll be a disaster. Send hate mail directly to Mark McDonald.

Mark, we are completely out of time. Uh thank you. Interesting conversation, and uh, I will see you next time on informed dissent. You've been listening to informed dissent with Dr. Jeff Barkey, board certified primary care physician, and Dr. Mark McDonald. Board certified child, adolescent, and adult psychiatrist. Informed dissent, the intersection of health care and politics.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. High blood pressure care should go beyond the prescription

    Nov 16, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - High blood pressure care deserves more than another refill. Sleep, stress, exercise, and accurate home readings belong in the conversation alongside medication. A stronger...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. America’s Real Doctor Club puts patients first

    Nov 9, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - America’s Real Doctor Club promotes a return to medicine built on listening, informed consent, prevention, and personal values. As corporate demands and paperwork strain the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why your pet doesn’t need shots every year

    Nov 2, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - Does every veterinary treatment help your pet live better? Dr. Shawn Messonnier advocates individualized care that considers vaccination risk, nutrition, and quality of life. From...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Faith-based leadership for stronger families and teams

    Oct 26, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - The legacy children inherit begins with the promises parents keep today. David and Angelike Norrie connect Christian faith with intentional parenting, personal responsibility, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Russian plague fears: Evidence before panic

    Oct 19, 202657 minAudio

    Informed Dissent with Dr. Jeff Barke - Reports of a laboratory worker’s death in Russia raise questions about plague, transparency, and public fear. The author urges clear evidence, informed consent, and personal...

    Credit the people on this episode