Critical Conversations: Wolfgang Streeck The latest episode of Critical Conversations, featuring Wolfgang Streeck, is now unlocked for all subscribers and visitors to Independence Captured. Wolfgang is one of the world’s leading sociologists and political economists. He is renowned for his writing on capitalism, democracy, globalisation, and the changing nature of the modern state. Streeck examines how economic institutions shape political life, and how tensions between capitalism and democracy have intensified since the late twentieth century. We discuss the following themes: * How are the contradictions between capitalism and democracy deepening? * Is representative democracy capable of disciplining capital, or has economic power become too detached from any semblance of democratic control? * How is intensifying geopolitical competition reshaping national politics? * Established political parties continue to lose support: is this a symptom of democratic renewal or exhaustion? * What is the future of Europe in a multipolar world? Streeck is a Senior Research Associate and Emeritus Director at the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Societies in Cologne. He is a Member of the Berlin Brandenburg Academy of Sciences, a Corresponding Fellow of the British Academy and an Honorary Member of the Society for the Advancement of Socio-Economics. His books include: * Re-Forming Capitalism: Institutional Change in the German Political Economy * Buying Time: The Delayed Crisis of Democratic Capitalism * How Will Capitalism End? Essays on a Failing System * Critical Encounters: Capitalism, Democracy, Ideas * Taking Back Control? States and State Systems After Globalism This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit jonathonshafi.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01In this episode of Critical Conversations, I speak to Wolfgang Streich. Wolfgang is a Professor of Sociology at the Max Planck Institute. He has written extensively on the tension between democracy and capitalism and about the nature of the political crisis unfolding within the system since 2008. His approach was recently utilised as a framework through which to understand the churn in British Prime Ministers in a recent Independence Captured article,
SPEAKER_01The Meaning of Starmer's Resignation. I began by asking Wolfgang to set out the key coordinates that got us to this place.
SPEAKER_00We have to look at the historical trajectory. What we see today is understood only if we see it as the outcome of a longer process. Now originally, when the modern capitalist way of life originated, the modern state which rose together with capitalism was a liberal state.
SPEAKER_00It consisted of a sovereign state, a free market, And the Combinations Act or the Loire de Le Chatelier in France, which made it illegal to set up any intermediary organizations between the individual citizen and the state. In that sort of liberal regime, capitalism thrived, but it also generated opposition.
SPEAKER_00And by the end of the 19th century, There were in all modern capitalist societies movements for an additional kind of democracy, not just liberal, but social. Not just based on individual rights, but based on collective rights. Not just a channel of electoral democracy, but in addition to it, and in competition with it, a channel for collective.
SPEAKER_00Namely, trade unions with a freedom of collective bargaining and setting standards for the labor market and for social policy independent from the state. Yes? Now, the formula, the peace formula, you could say the capitalist democratic peace formula of the first half of the 20th century. Was that there was liberal democracy with this interjection,
SPEAKER_00interspersed additional element, always in conflict with the market as well as with the state. But expressing the special interests of workers and trade unions. In conflict, perhaps, or very often in conflict, With a policy of the state which catered to property owners and capitalist entrepreneurs.
SPEAKER_00And the market where a particular kind of democracy prevails. One dollar, one vote. Whereas in a democracy as we wanted, it would be one vote. One person, one vote. And these two systems were always in conflict, as you can easily see. Now, if you look at today,
SPEAKER_00then let's look at the 1950s, 1960s. In all these countries, parliamentary democracy had learned to accommodate social democracy. There were basically two camps in a society. A conservative camp with a little more attention to capital and a social democratic camp with a little more attention to trade unions and workers.
SPEAKER_00And these two camps sort of fought each other or battled with each other under certain rules. And they understood that for some period the Social Democrats will rule, for another period the Liberal Democrats will rule. They recognized election outcomes and so on. There were two programs in this society. One was more equality, more security, less Less dictatorship of employers over workers.
SPEAKER_00That was the one problem. The other problem was more achievement being profits, more benefits for investors, and so on. Now, what we need to understand, to get back to your initial question, Is that today, these two camps do no longer exist. Because in the 1980s and 1990s, in the neoliberal regime,
SPEAKER_00the social democratic element of the capitalist democratic polity sort of broke away. Unions have no power anymore. Labor converted into new labor. That is some sort of Thatcherism with a human face. Yes? We no longer, when we go to vote, we no longer decide on in what way do we want to live.
SPEAKER_00In a social democratic and later socialist way or in a capitalist market-driven way. We do not have that choice anymore. If that is the case, then politics becomes sort of, you can say, Like a loose cannon. All sorts of things can happen. This guy Farage comes and promises any possible idiocy that he can invent.
SPEAKER_00Then someone else comes, claiming they are the descendants of the Social Democratic Party, but there is nothing social democratic in them anymore. And so you have these strange sort of battles between different public figures, different public images, different role players. One is a woman, the other is a man.
SPEAKER_00One is married, one is not married. One has a feminist thing, the other has an anti-feminist thing, and so on. But it's totally sort of devoid. Of any practical linkage to the way in which people live their lives. And therefore, the bizarrest things can happen. In the United States, this guy Trump can become president. It doesn't matter much what he does.
SPEAKER_00But for the normal people, this thing is a spectacle, nothing else. And in all our societies, if you look around, you see that politics is about image-making. It is about spin-doctoring. It is about a kind of public entertainment, so that people in the evening can watch some ongoing news, what some idiot had said in the House of Commons.
SPEAKER_00None of this touches the base. And then you see that in this period, the problems in our societies have continuously been growing, regardless of who was in government, because they have lost touch with all these things.
SPEAKER_01One of the ways that we think about the current crisis in UK politics and this churn of Prime Ministers is that we look back and say, after World War II, you have what we might refer to As a compromise between labour and capital in some sense. In the mid to late 1970s, capital abandons that settlement and we have the neoliberal phase in capitalist development. We have to be aware.
SPEAKER_00That we're living at a time when another world order is sort of decomposing and breaking down. Neoliberalism was a global thing. It was allegedly a big, big, big, big capitalist economy all over the world without a state. But in fact, it was the rule of one state, namely the United States. Sort of making that
SPEAKER_00economic regime appear like it was a free market, but in fact, it was something for the enrichment of big American firms. And think about it in those, I say this about almost three decades. 1990, when the Soviet Union disappeared. Twenty a few years ago when we saw that things were sort of breaking up.
SPEAKER_00The United States were believing, the US believed that they were the world, so to speak. And we watched sort of Americanism spread all over the world under the name of neoliberalism. What do I mean? An enormous increase in the number of billionaires and billionaires. An enormous increase in inequality in all these societies. An absolutely ongoing warfare.
SPEAKER_00There was not a single day since the end of the Soviet Union that the United States were not involved in some sort of war somewhere. A complete dissolution of international law when it came to the United States engaging in the so-called War on Terror. The ongoing devastation around Israel in the Middle East.
SPEAKER_00Up to a point, in this regime there was one thing that sort of was the seed of its demise. Which was that these two countries, Russia and China, had been included in this free trade regime. And they sort of prospered as a result. And the United States were watching this. They suddenly recognized that as these were becoming bigger and bigger,
SPEAKER_00The Russians by selling oil to everyone, the Chinese by being this absolutely ingenious culture of engineering and commercial things. Now, as they saw this growing, they understood that There was a limit to neoliberalism which would be reached where the hegemony of the United States could no longer be sustained
SPEAKER_00over these two potentially rivaling countries. And now, if you look at, let's say, the 2020s, last five, six, seven years, nothing is so... So interesting as the use that the United States made of sanctions. This world, in spite of the presence of the World Trade Organization,
SPEAKER_00the United States don't give a damn if it comes to this thing. They impose sanctions all over the place. Now we're at a time where this whole sort of global Pseudo-state-free, American-governed global economy is fragmented. And the United States are struggling to maintain their hegemony,
SPEAKER_00but they know that for this they would have to go to war with China, and the Chinese No small fry. So now we see a regrouping of the world economy. And countries are looking for where would be a trade bloc in which they can prosper, where they would not be under the surveillance or the vesselage of
SPEAKER_00the United States. And then you get this Canadian Prime Minister who talks about these intermediate size countries working together. You see that the Americans are attacking the Russians or provoking the Russians to attack the Ukrainians in order to basically the policy of the European Union now at least
SPEAKER_01of their
SPEAKER_00Foreign policy representatives is, let's slice up Russia into three or four states. Like the slicing up of Germany after 1945. That would solve the Russian problem as it solved the German problem, at least for a while. And in this world, this is a world where we do not know the rules, how it would function.
SPEAKER_00And predictions are extremely difficult to make. As you see in this madman Trump, who has new ideas every day. What the United States would do, how the world would be organized, and so on. Compared to him, this Chinese party chief is a model of sanity. But madness In these areas is not just an individual thing.
SPEAKER_00Let's say the madness of the situation attracts the people that are correspondingly mad enough to move into this world, you understand?
SPEAKER_01One of the questions that I wanted to ask was about how the geopolitical changes and shifts will reflect back into domestic politics. There are a whole number of ways in which this will happen, but the United States has been going around and methodically dismantling the architecture which it developed after 1945, the global institutions and so on and so forth. And it seems to me that we're moving into a multipolar world that paves the way for
SPEAKER_01the United States, the UK, for Europe and so on. To say that in the name of pragmatism in this new world order, democracy must go into a further retreat. That the formality of democracy will remain in terms of elections and so on. But it having any real meaning or function will steadily decrease. Do you agree that the global changes will have a domestic impact on politics? And second, in that context, is representative democracy going to be capable of disciplining capital
SPEAKER_01and bringing it under some kind of democratic control at all?
SPEAKER_00Jonathan, another three lectures. Yes. Yes. But let me say that we are learning something. What I am learning is that talking about democracy in a state or in a given society is impossible without understanding the location of that society in the global system. We knew this somehow, but we didn't put enough emphasis on it.
SPEAKER_00And because then secondly, we sort of, even we were smart people, but we were sort of believing the kind of rhetoric that we heard emerging in the United States or in our elites. That democracy is a virtue that is conceded by the ruling classes because of value. The reason why there was democracy in the world until 1990,
SPEAKER_00and only in the Western world, was that there was enough power vested in the citizenry and in the working class that the ruling classes, Had to make concessions. And one concession was that within the constraints of liberal constitutions, guarantee of property rights and so on, within those constraints,
SPEAKER_00it should be possible for the people To choose between two alternative governments, the ones I mentioned, one slightly more conservative, the other slightly more socialist. So this very, very important possibility for people to change their government, to throw the rascals out and vote others in, was a concession.
SPEAKER_00Because otherwise these societies would have fallen apart. Now with the dismantlement of socialism and social democracy, that concession is no longer really necessary. And you see that in the political system, there is no alternative anymore. You throw the one rascals out and the other rascals come in. They don't make a difference.
SPEAKER_00They make slight, tiny differences, but it is no longer about the way of life. That would sort of move people deeply enough to vote for, in Germany, Willy Brandt, As a sort of emigree who had fought Hitler and Kurt Georg Kiesinger, who was the chancellor at the time, who had been a press officer in Ribbentrop's Foreign Office.
SPEAKER_00There you saw a difference, dammit, and you could vote for one. Well, where is the difference today? Now, in that world, In that world, the question of what are the possibilities for democracy, that question has to be answered in a different way. So representative party political democracy works where you have classes That want
SPEAKER_00to be represented and can be satisfied out of the resources that the collaboration between capital and labor generates in a growing economy. Now we don't have that. And then the question is, in what corners of the world will it be possible for people to take control of their own lives? And force their government to defend them,
SPEAKER_00taking that control against others, against a new hegemon or this sort of thing. In other words, in my view, we have to remember histories of direct democracy, of distributed ownership of resources, On the continent often called syndicalism. Of cooperatives rather than capitalist firms.
SPEAKER_00Of community banking rather than Wall Street banking. And these things where people actually no longer Have to beg some government to do something for them, give us some regional policy, this or that, where they can themselves
SPEAKER_01do their thing.
SPEAKER_00Then you suddenly see that in this history of sort of parliamentary socialism, we forgot something that was very much alive in the 19th century. That was cooperative socialism, Owen, and so on. Now then, the big task today would be to figure out how this kind of democracy could look like today, where people
SPEAKER_00take control back. My latest book, taking back control, question mark, you know? And of course, in a sort of tongue-in-cheek way, I use the Brexit conservative slogan to tell people that there is something to this idea. Because in our world, sort of redistribution through parliamentary democracy has become extremely
SPEAKER_00Let's say improbable. Improbable. We are talking to a world of spin doctors. And in fact, the way the media are organized today, see in this older democratic world, let's say after 1945, political parties had their own newspapers. And they had circles where people came together to discuss their lives and their possibilities.
SPEAKER_00In the 1970s and 1980s, all of this dissolved. And now we're dependent on these ridiculous American social media platforms. Well, you can't say a decent sentence because any sentence that is decent is at the same time too long.
SPEAKER_01Because Trump's social media posts and so on, in a sense, are playing the role of the spectacle. They are dramatising politics because there is no politics underneath it. There's nothing substantive. There is this assumption that as the world becomes more multipolar, more unstable, as Europe can rely less on the United States for example, there is an assumption that this will bring Europe closer together.
SPEAKER_01But I wonder if this is misconceived and that if in fact is likely to create and generate More intense competition between European states. And I think that Europe's in a very weak position at this moment in history. And that its leverage will probably have to be developed through becoming actively a site of competition between American and Chinese capital in order to perform some kind of agency.
SPEAKER_01I just wondered if you had any thoughts about what you think The future of the European Union might look like in that way, in that context.
SPEAKER_00See, until the Russian attack on Ukraine, the European Union was sort of in a process of slow disintegration. All of these major projects had failed, like euro bonds, like recovery from... The pandemic, all of these things.
SPEAKER_00And then this sort of failure reflected the failure of the nation states in this presumably global economy to do something for themselves and their citizens. So, as I said, these 30 years of neoliberalism were a time of increasing inequality, of increasing poverty. In Germany, the fastest growing sector were the food banks.
SPEAKER_00Yes, in the richest country in Europe. And interestingly, in 1970, there was not a single food bank. You didn't know what it was. Now you look at the rate of growth as recorded in our statistics. Since the 1970s, our per capita income seems to have doubled. But the number of food banks has multiplied by 100. Yes?
SPEAKER_00So then, in this present situation, we, the European Union and its member states, were quite happy at what they considered the last possibility to reintegrate both Europe and the National Society, which was to pick a real enemy. What you now see is a very conscious strategy of militarization in Brussels of
SPEAKER_00the European Union, where Frau von der Leyen, who is the big shot there, desperately tries to turn the European Union into a European NATO with her in the command stand. And as yet she doesn't have much money, but now the excuse for
SPEAKER_00claiming taxation authority, taxing authority for the European Union is we have to fight Putin. Putin comes up. And the nation states, look at something like Germany. The education system is going down the river. The railways are no longer working. And it's a long, long, long list of dysfunctions.
SPEAKER_00If you're not German, you don't believe it because you think Germany is this wonderful place. No, it's like disintegrating society. In addition, in all of our societies, We have an enormous amount of discontent in the population, always expressed in these 30% of people who vote for Le Pen, your guy, what's his name, Farage, Germany, AfD, Italy, and so on and so on.
SPEAKER_00And they have been desperately seeking. For a way of healing these rifts and what I would say restoring discipline in their societies, which is ending any of these claims for benefits and forcing people to agree to the welfare state being cut in favor of the warfare state. So there are,
SPEAKER_00in all of our societies and in Brussels, there is suddenly the idea among the political elites. Would it not be interesting to find out whether the democratic state can be turned into a garrison state? Yes? And in Germany, they are about to restore compulsory military service. I predict it will be a fight. Because it presupposes
SPEAKER_00the restoration of a nationalist identification that goes so far that you follow your leaders into your own death. I always say military is not a joke. It is about killing and dying. Now, if you're a big colonial power like Britain was for a long time, you have your troops from all over the world who do the killing and dying for you,
SPEAKER_00including the scratch cards or whatever. That is, today, you have to get your own people to agree to this thing. And then they may begin to ask very specific questions. Why should we do this? What is our interest in this? And then all these questions about military propaganda, war propaganda, they all come up.
SPEAKER_00In final remark on this, since you started with the European Union, the problem of the European Union is That while clearly the Brussels gang wants to be the supreme commander of the European army, nobody will want to die for Frau von der Leyen. And now the question becomes, who is going to command the European Army?
SPEAKER_00There are candidates. One candidate is Britain, because Britain stands out of the European Union. They aren't affected by the nasty details. But they still have a good relationship to the Americans. And they can sort of be like the field commander. Or the French, who have a seat on the Security Council.
SPEAKER_00They have nuclear arms, unlike the Germans, who have nothing of this. The French always dream of Western Europe being a third global power. For this, they have to get the Germans on board. The Germans are now dumb enough in order to integrate their society and their polity with this enemy Putin to build up what they themselves say the
SPEAKER_00by far biggest conventional army in Europe. What for? What for? And the French are waiting for this because they want to take command. Of the German Conventional Army and back it up presumably with their nuclear arms. I'm saying all this to make clear how uncertain the present situation is. How many different things are sort of working together to create this enormous uncertainty.
SPEAKER_00And the question who does what to who when The Germans, essentially, if they, I think, could do what they want to do, they would understand that their interest is in some sort of rapprochement with the Russians and a sort of pacified Eurasian world from Lisbon to Vladivostok. As Yeltsin has called it, or Putin in his first year.
SPEAKER_00Zone of peace. But this is not for the French, because the French couldn't govern this. And it is not for the Brits, because the Brits would be outside, and what the Brits always hated was the idea of a continental unifier, or some unified continent. They always wanted to balance between different, like in this case, Russia versus Russia. Western Europe, and so on and so on. The long thing is really where in this world,
SPEAKER_00and we're talking about Western Europe, where there can be a rejuvenation of democracy is very much dependent on the solution of the foreign policy quagmire that is now developing where we don't know. Where we belong and how we can achieve some sort of peace as the precondition for democracy where you can descend from the government. That's an important thing in a democracy.
SPEAKER_00And in a country that sees itself at war, there are very strict limitations on what you can say in public without getting into trouble. And it is beginning in Germany. It is beginning in Britain.
SPEAKER_01Earlier in the conversation, you said that the destination of all of the processes building up in global capitalism is not queer and is difficult to predict. And I think we can also see that there are fragmentation taking place, not just at the social base, but within the institutions and within the governing class and so on and so forth. So Here is where I would suggest there is some kind of hope because it's within
SPEAKER_01that kind of environment where it may be the case that the future is in some way up for grabs. That unlike the mid-1970s and 80s where you have this unified, cohesive turn towards neoliberalism, now we are seeing something quite different, far more differentiated. And therefore an opportunity perhaps. How do you assess the potential for some kind of democratic alternative to emerge
SPEAKER_01within this chaotic environment?
SPEAKER_00It is the question that I think we both share this hope that people will not in the long term tolerate being pushed around by some sort of desperate political and economic elite that has lost orientation and only wants to increase their capital. Yes, it is a hope.
SPEAKER_00As Abraham Lincoln said, you can fool some of the people all of the time and all of the people some of the time, but you can't fool all of the people all of the time. And people are or have this admirable instinct, you can say, to be suspicious if they are being pushed around too much.
SPEAKER_00Against that, this is the optimistic, against that if you look around how deeply capitalism has penetrated the everyday lives of people. Their dreams are being generated by Taylor Swift and the American entertainment industry. Their perception Life together is one of competition.
SPEAKER_00Big sports events with big money at the end. Two million pounds for winning Wimbledon, this sort of thing. And also today, I think it's already there in the UK, Which is you can buy a program for your mobile where you can any minute buy shares. Very tiny shares of shares, so to speak.
SPEAKER_00Three pounds on whatever company. And then you see how it goes down and up. And you sell and you buy and in the evening you can spend your entire day with it. And in the evening, you may tell everyone that you found a way without work, without working with others, how you can get rich simply by playing the stock exchange.
SPEAKER_00And I understand that hundreds of thousands of people are doing this. They are so much hooked on. The capitalist economy, that their way of life has become capitalist. I'm not saying that this can go on forever. But I'm saying that we're facing, if we're talking about today, we're facing a problem that is much more, much larger than just disappropriating or
SPEAKER_00Some sort of capitalist. You have to end a way of life. Self-exploitative, others exploitative, violent against nature, violent against others. So we are having a big problem. Sometimes I say that. Look at the transition from the pagan Roman Empire to the Christian Middle Ages.
SPEAKER_00It took about 500 years. Nobody knew where it was going, but it ended somewhere. It won't last 500 years this time, but it may last 100 years.
SPEAKER_01So much food for thought there. Thanks very much for all of your time that you've given to us this interview. It's been very interesting and I'm sure all of the listeners will take a lot from it. So with that, thanks very much to Wolfgang.
In this episode of Critical Conversations, the Independence Captured podcast, we are joined by Ewan Gibbs. Ewan is a Senior Lecturer in Economic and Social History at the University of Glasgow. He writes about energy,...
In this episode of Critical Conversations, the Independence Captured podcast, we are joined by Darren McGarvey. Darren is a Scottish author, broadcaster and social commentator known for his incisive work on poverty,...
In this episode of Critical Conversations, the Independence Captured podcast, we are joined by Dr Gregor Clunie and Dr Jenny Morrison to examine the deepening problems in Scottish higher education. Gregor is a Sociology...
Critical Conversations: Wolfgang Streeck In the second episode of Critical Conversations, we hear from Wolfgang Streeck, one of the world’s leading sociologists and political economists. He is renowned for his writing...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit jonathonshafi.substack.com Critical Conversations: Isobel Lindsay In the inaugural episode of Critical Conversations, we speak to Isobel Lindsay, a...