Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

In Tune with Tradition - Perspectives on Session Etiquette in Irish Traditional Music

In Tune with Tradition - Perspectives on Session Etiquette in Irish Traditional Music artwork

The Harp in Irish Music Sessions

Oct 17, 202655 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of In Tune with Tradition, Tara chats with harper Janet Harbison at the Donegal Harp Summer School in Dungloe. Janet has spent a lifetime around the Irish harp, but this conversation is as much about belonging as it is about the belonging of the instrument. Tara and Janet talk about sessions as social life and practice, the difference between a harper and a harpist, learning the core session repertoire and why Janet now describes herself as a teacher of social musicianship. Along the way, Janet traces a musical life through Dublin, Belfast and Donegal, and reflects on the musicians, teachers, students and sessions that shaped how she thinks about traditional music. “Where there was traditional music, there was my tribe.” Adverts: Irish Memory Orchestra concert featuring Tara Connaghan on Sat. 9th January 2027 Mentioned in this episode: Irish Memory Orchestra 15th Anniversary concert Irish Memory Orchestra 15th anniversary concert Sat. 9th January, 7pm Visit www.irishmemoryorchestra.com for tickets and information

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

I knew that where there was traditional music there was my tribe and I would just get stuck in and it was a night of joy and friendship and it is it's all for the camaraderie and it is for the business of finding where you belong and I feel that about the music and nobody's ever a stranger with Irish music everywhere, no matter where. Welcome to In Tune with Tradition, Perspectives on Session Etiquette in Irish traditional music.

If you've ever come away from a session wondering what just happened? Whether you should have joined in, why one session feels completely different from another, or how everybody else seems to get what is going on. Well you're in the right place. I'm Tara Connaghan and on this podcast we talk about the things musicians are rarely actually taught about Irish traditional music sessions. How to read the room, how to recognise different kinds of sessions, how to understand the signals being given, and how to make better decisions about when and how to contribute.

Basically, we're trying to make sense of some of the uncertainty around Irish music sessions. I really hope you enjoy. Janet Harbison I am thrilled to be here with you. Uh you're in Donegal at the moment, doing a harp summer school. You are a longtime professional harper and you're gonna tell me the difference in a minute between a harper and a harpist. but originally from Dublin and you've lived in County Down in Belfast and you now live in England, but sometimes in Dublin.

Yeah, I I'm a bit of a wandering mongrel, um, but definitely bog Irish to the core. Uh yeah, I married an Englishman, fell madly in lust at some point along the way, and uh he was married before, had a son, and we now have grandchildren and this is the most brilliant craic Um and I miss them to bits because they're at home having fun without me and it's really annoying. Did you get them to play the harp yet? no, but they're close, I'll tell you. And I have the most darling photograph of the five year old grandchild.

I'm grandma, right. Um but I didn't do the parent thing in the middle, you know, I didn't have children, I was too busy in the I was travelling. I mean it often happens with musicians. You know, the biological clock passes us by somewhere. Yeah, me too. And uh 'cause we're too wedded to what we're doing. We're having way too much fun to be serious about doing things like having babies. Anyway, sure look um it meant that I was always a musician, it never changed, even though along the way I must have been gathering up bits and bobs. Oh, I'll have that for the bottom drawer. And I'll have that for the babies and I'll do this and I'll do that and everything.

So I ended up with a trunk full of junk. And now I've got the grandchildren to to lavish them on. And I have a bright purple little harp for um little Amelia to play now. Um but anyway, that's just one of the the fun things of life, and I was awful lucky, uh, even though I wasn't lucky enough to I would love to have been married to an Irishman, and I felt like dumping him a few times so. that I could come home. But I I've got myself a van now, so I'm the old lady of the van and a proper itinerant harpy now, so I can I can go anywhere and nobody has to make a bed for me.

I can sleep in the van and I'm happy out. Oh yeah. yeah. We can compare notes. Anyway, um I always start with the question, what does an Irish music session mean to you? Well it was my social life. It was my practice time, my social life. My all my friends were were musicians and it was what gave us a buzz and what we did for enjoyment. And there was always something else.

I might have been gigging at weddings or playing in the castle. Somebody made a joke about me recently. I was a Bunratty bunny. It's a long time since I felt like a bunny. But um there was always something where There was a bit of money in it and so you did what you had to do for the money, whether you had to look like an eejit as well. You it went with the job. But then, you know, there was always the lucky times where you'd have time to yourself and you'd be off at a Fleadh You'd and I mean I was very lucky coming up. I had very, very solid friends.

I mean, people that would be probably known to you, but people like Mícheál Ó hAlmhain who lived up the road and round the corner in Dublin. And uh when Comhaltas moved to Monkstown, we pretty much lived in Comhaltas a couple of nights a week. And then we were always away out of the Fleadhs and because Seosaimhín Ní Bheaglaoich was also one of our little trio of musketeers and we went everywhere together for a number of years and she's from of course West Dingle and my brothers and my mother lived in Caherdaniel South Kerry So I was always kind of moving around the the the back end of

Ireland where there was always plenty of music and sessions and I've been um kind of in Donegal for ever since kind of nineteen. eighty six was the first summer school I ran in Glencolumcille thanks to Father James McDyer. And you know, ever since then Donegal is kind of my spiritual go to place. And this is where we are now and look at the sun shining. That's it. It must be 'cause you're here. 'Cause it wasn't like that God is smiling. And I actually met you in Glencolumcille years ago before the the because I I play the fiddle um and there's the Glencolumcille Fiddle Week, but I think before the

Glencolumcille Fiddle Week, before I knew that existed. Yeah. Um myself and my sister, maybe it was my sister went to you and I had made a harp as part of my Leaving Cert Very good. And I think I brought it up or something. God, I hope I didn't tell you it was rubbish or anything. Oh that would be terrible. no it's not too bad. Lost for a good ten or fifteen years and then was found again, we found it again. So it's it's in it's in perfect condition. Um just needs a few strings, I should

Well you know, I'll never forget F Father James, um he wrote to me out of the blue and I was very busy being Mrs. Amazing, you know, all over the place. And um he says he's a priest in West Donegal and before he dies he wants to see the harp in the hands of Donegal children and he is a grand little place for me to come and stay when I would come over and I thought, Gee, but this fella's He he needs he needs an AlkaSeltzer or something, you know. He needs something to keep in mind. So, um anyway, I I kind of forgot a bit I forgot and I don't think I ever answered that first letter, although I found it recently, which is amazing.

and I didn't answer back because I had a busy life going on and I was, you know, kind of employed in the Ulsterfolk and Transport Museum. I was a music curator and I was flying around the place and recording music and you know, from fiddlers from Donegal 'cause I was looking after The cultural traditions, you know, in the nine counties of Ulster. They were happy to tolerate me to consider it a nine county province. So I was quite liberal in how I manage my time. But between everything, anyway, this strange priest, whom I hadn't ever heard of about, he wrote to me saying he wanted this thing done.

So the next thing is m I get a second letter in December and he says, Would you bloody hurry up? Because I've just had a heart attack, and I really mean to see this, right? And I thought, holy smokes, what what the oh right? And I felt morally obliged about to do something because this fellow was an imminent danger of going to heaven with a curse and with leaving me a curse. So we arranged for me to come up to Glencolumcille And it was the last day of January in nineteen eighty-six. And

I was in my Morris Minor, my great old Morris Minor, knew all of the AA boys in Ireland because I was always breaking down in potholes or in ditches or whatever. But anyway, this particular day it had snowed and what should have been a relatively straightforward, I can't remember, was a five or six hours. It took me about ten hours to get there. And I got to Glencolumcille and I I was supposed to go to the Parish Hall, which was in the kind of folk museum thing that Father McDyer had put together. I'd told him that I why don't you put a little concert together so I can make a few bob and pay for my petrol because I was a student at the time.

So I arrive at Glencolumcille and I see, you know, I'm ten minutes late. The concert's already started and I'm thinking, my God, they're going to think I'm a complete looper in those days, of course, no mobile phones to say I'm on the way. But anyway I arrived in and I see there's only two sets of footprints in the snow and I thought, my God, what kind of a concert am I going to be giving tonight? And it was just the parish priest and his his housekeeper. He said, he forgot to mention it last Week and I thought, what? I've just come all the way from Belfast in a storm of snow and ditches, and I had already run into one or two ditches other people had to help me out of.

And um anyway, we ended up being the best of craic because it was in Carrick and he invited me into the house. He was a teetotaler himself, but he gave me a pint glass which he'd filled with sherry. And I tell you by the time I was halfway through the pine glass, that we were the best of bosom buddies, you know. So he was cooking up ideas as to how I was going to come and service the children and make them all into brilliant harp players. And I thought, Jeepers, you know, he's got a lot of expectations.

Also, he was desperate to introduce me to Jarleth, the man that runs the fishing processing factory and he was looking for a wife apparently. So Father McDyer decided I was going to be part of life in Glencolumcille whether I liked it or not. And I I did like it. Um but in the end it was we ran the first summer school 1986 and it was a perfect, it was a God-given place for me because in Northern Ireland I was generating a bit of interest and I still had students from where I'd been living in Cork and Dublin and around the place, and it was a safe place in Northern Ireland.

Where people didn't have to go over the border to get there from the south. But people could come over the border from the north and not feel that they were in in Van Diemen's Land, you know. So um and we were remote enough at the time, and Father McDyer was just an amazing motivator, you know, because he he allowed me to stand up on the altar and we raised a bit of money to buy some harps, and that's how we got started, you know. And yeah, we never looked back, except that of course the last few. They're kind of troubled because the accommodation we usually use was given over to the refugees and that they're entitled and welcome to have it.

But the only thing is it meant that I was homeless then, you know, so I ended up in Dungloe here two years ago and happy out. Delighted. Uh and this is where I come now in the summers, and I run, you know, three or four weeks of summer schools, and I take eight people only a week, because that's as many people as fit in the kitchen here, you know. But it means that I get to have fun with a lot of students that are maybe adults, you know, because most of the young ones are liking to teach teenagers and they'll go and do spectacular things on stages.

And I'm looking after some of the oldies. But you at the same time it's lovely to be welcomed and they're great and it gives me an opportunity to connect with them because they're all turning into mommies now, my students and some of them have kind of abandoned the harp because they've got good jobs or they're teachers or their civil servants or something, but they'll come back to it. When the kids are of an age and they're looking for their harping granny again, you know, I'll be able to advise at least. yeah. no, that's funny because you mentioned Father McDyer and he was actually from Glenties where I'm from.

He was indeed. Nice we have another link. Yep. Uh no, you mentioned also when you're mentioned about the session, how much it meant to you. I noticed you mentioned was an awful lot. So do you still play sessions? God yeah. Good it's my life blood, really, because I was never good at practising. I mean I don't kind of practice as such. And no, I I depend on a session for a whole lot of things. I mean it is my social life and when I came up here to Dungloe, for instance, I knew there was a Comhaltas branch out in Meanacross and I knew that the librarian uh Fiona was in

contact with them, so the first thing I did cheeky me, you know, I said, Where are the Sessions going on, you know, where do people play? What pubs do they play in? And because I would slink in modestly and then maybe suggest that, you know, um, would you mind if I could come and join you for a few tunes? And um, you know, I would slink in as modestly as I possibly could. I loved listening to Mairéad Ní Mhaonaigh's podcast and hearing what the proper etiquette should be. But you know, um she's absolutely bang on, you know, you don't go thundering in. And so the first time I'd go in, I'd leave the harp in the car because

It's very hard to get in and not let on you've got a bloody big, you know, galloof and instrument there, you Yeah. So, um I wouldn't I would leave it in the car. But I might also take the harp out and leave the bag harp 'cause they there's an awful lot of muck and mu you know, silliness about. Yeah. And it would be tuned before I'd get in. So the idea is to make the least amount of trouble for yourself and but it is important that you get a chair where you're not jammed up against the table and people don't mind

you know, that your elbows are not in their way and their drones or their fiddle is not going to poke you in the eye, you know, so it is about just getting comfortable y because I didn't know people in North Donegal at all. I I would know people down in Glenties, Ardara and Glencolumcille but sometimes the northern part of Donegal is a bit strange. But actually I know Hugh Gallagher, Hughie as in Hudaí Beags, and 'cause he was on secondment or I met him when I was in Belfast in the early years. So when I discovered that Hughie's place was

Bunbeag, and the first time I had come up this part of the country, I came up to Bunbeag. And I was totally blown away by the school up there, the music school. And I just thought this is phenomenal. I mean, I was absolutely in love with this part of the country. And yet I'd never ventured north to any meaningfulness. I'd have been on the road all right, but it was because I was heading from Letterkenny down to Glencolumcille and I just thought, jeepers this is this is fantastic. Of course, once I'd gone to the session in Hudaís that's it. You know, I'm up there at least every Friday night that I'm here. year if not Mondays as well.

So there is and I mean in my much younger years I'd have been up around Ranafast and all of that, you know. totally yeah yeah and I have friends all over the place up there. And for the years that I was in Belfast well 18 years Belfast, four years in Derry, I mean this is my hunting ground, this is my social networking base, you know, I mean There was never really sessions in Belfast. I would go out to session in Bangor once a week to Diana and Nigel Boullier and that was a whole other different set and we were very much about, you know, the Scottish connection

and we were always going over to Dumfries and so on. But but I knew that where there was traditional music, there was my tribe. And I would just get stuck in and it was a night of joy and friendship. And it is it's all for the camaraderie and it is for the business of finding where you belong. And I feel that about the music and nobody's ever a stranger with Irish music everywhere, no matter where. And I mean I used to do a lot of trips and around the universe and whether it was America or Europe, even, and there would always be a session or Irish musician somewhere, there'd

be an Irish pub and you'd go in and you'd ask, you know, what's the night the musicians come by? And even if you didn't know the people in there, you'd know people that they know. You'd all there'd always be connections. And that's the one thing about being Irish. It's not about looking You know, what do you do for a living and how much money have you in the bank? No, you just don't want to know that. That just doesn't need to happen. But what you do know is, where do you come from? Oh, do you know this fellow? And do you know I I knew this so-and-so, and I know your cousins, you know. So you can't go far.

We're always a yeah. One person removed from everybody almost. And if you're a proper mongrel like me with connections all over the place, my mother was from Wexford, my father was Cookstown Tyrone. I was born in Dublin, but I was kind of raised between Hollywood North Down and Dublin. But we always holidayed in South Kerry, which was where my dad, as a young fellow, was he was a musician as well. He played piano and there was another fellow um he played accordion and the two of them were the summertime dance band in Waterville, County Kerry. And my dad played a bit of concertine as well, but he was always around musicians.

Classical music was the thing that was considered to be the proper music that what you learned in college and did your grades. But traditional music was the activity of every other day, you know. Did you find that classical music was, you know, the prim and proper but where the heart lay and where the like They're you you know the way you've got uh subjects in school, history and geography, and they seem to kind of cover lots of things like dates and times and places and things. And they're very different subjects, vaguely related.

Well, for me it was like I was in two different worlds. So classical music was one whole completely world, very entirely separate to anything I would do in traditional music, mainly because you would be you would be foreshortened for the prejudices between them. And you know, like my classical music friends, colleagues, students, co competitors, they would kinda look down their noses a bit at the fact that you're playing an Irish harp and you're not looking to go forward to the proper harp. Like when are you going to get a proper grown up harp? And I thought, no, I have no aspirations to that.

I'm perfectly happy. Thank you very much. I'm playing an Irish harp. I have no interest in the orchestral harp. And you know, y there was prejudice the other way round as well. When I was in Trinity doing my first music degree because of course it was ordained I was going to be a musician. Um but I went and I did music in Trinity because I didn't want to be a school teacher. I wanted to kind of explore music in the world and I wanted to um I loved hearing about what was happening down in Cork with Mícheál Ó Súilleabháin and Aloys Fleischmann was the

professor there at the time and I had met him in the library in Trinity and I just wanted to do what his students were doing. But I had already signed up in Trinity. I was a small bit stuck. I needed to finish in Trinity first. And it seemed like Professor Brian Boydell was the big cheese and I just thought, right, well look, he knows that I have a love for traditional music and hopefully, you know, we'll find my way in there. But anyway, I gave my first student recital with the harp and I thought, yeah, I can play the piano. But I thought all my fellow students could do with a bit of harp music because they wouldn't have known what it was about.

And I was I remember playing the Belfast Hornpipe, which is not exactly your hardest core dance tune, but I could do pretty frilly things. And impress my classical friends with the with the Belfast Hornpipe, And um so I gave my student recital and I thought they should be intrigued and like, what is all this Irish music about? This has got to be interesting. But no, the first thing they called me said, here's diddley-eye. here's diddley-eye. Jesus, Janet, you know, and I I absolutely recoiled.

And I was ever so regretful that I'd played it because I had brought this attitude down on me. And I was always then from that point on fighting to just be treated ordinarily. And it was an immediate dismissal. And one of my class colleagues is a very eminent person in music education now and he still hasn't opened his heart to Irish music and I kind of I regret that but you know everybody has their own path but I immediately found that there were times that I wouldn't be raising my head above the parapet and delighting my audiences and the fact that I feel much more of a traditional musician

because I'm not a straight jacketed musician and the reason I orientated more to the traditional is because I love to improvise if you like it's not the right word but to play traditional, where you've got a great tune, everybody else is playing the tune, they're all doing something different with it. They're all using the same ideas of ornamentation, variation, whatever, and then you've got the accompaniment, the left hand dimension with the harp, which just adds another element of adventurousness, if you like, to music. But I was never somebody that could play something fixed.

I was looking to do it different because you'd be feeling different. There'll be days you feel perky and days that you feel like, my God, it's hard to get out of bed. And you know, when you get the good days, if there isn't anything you couldn't do, you'd be flying at doing rolls and cuts and God knows everything all over the place, you know, and I just loved that Flexibility, the creative flexibility. And I love classical music too. I mean there's lots of fabulous music and I still have my father's piano, but to be truthful I haven't played it in well over twenty years.

I would maybe tune it once every ten years. I I tune the harp a lot more often, let's say. Um But it's um I love the creative nature. It's so I really do feel at home with trad music 'cause I've grown up with it and it was never something that I got beaten over the head with, you know, when I'd be playing wrong notes on the piano now. There was a particular teacher who would have rolled up newspapers, bam and also trying to get a nice word of encouragement from my father. I had to work very, very hard to get his approval for anything I was doing with classical music because it was never quite good enough.

He was a very fine musician and I was always quite terrifiable and you know I would die of nervousness and of course you know I'd get the shakes and I'd be sick and you know I would find getting very very uh agitated with the pressure to play everything perfectly the way I'm supposed to play it whereas I can relax in traditional music. At what point did your dad give you the you're you've arrived? never really gave me that. He died young. Okay. And that's one of the the old sadnesses, you know.

My mum lived much longer and she only died in two thousand seven. But I knew her obviously well because we had a lot of time together, you know, 'cause I was nineteen now when Dad died. The younger ones in the family were ten, eleven And so life was in crisis at the time. But we were just on the brink of him getting excited about what I was doing. I'd won a few competitions in the Feis Cheoil at this point. But I was spending most of my time desperate to get Daddy's love and approval with getting the music that meant so much to him right.

And that was the grades. I had done all the grades and I'd finished them. But he was he was a taskmaster to gain approval from. But I never had that terror of doing it all wrong. with traditional music because it was much more relaxed, it was much more interactive. And it didn't matter that you played bum notes. It didn't matter that the people you were playing with weren't the winners. Um and it just was a whole other place, which is actually a s an escape for me. And I mean I adored my father, he was a very dynamic musician, and he loved traditional music.

I mean, he was part of that social circle with Éamon De Buitléar and Seán Ó Riada of course known to us as John Reedy, um Paddy Moloney. They were regular people who wafted through our sitting room 'cause Dad would bring them back after parties, and they were all part of the same set. They had a Sunday morning session out in Mount Pleasant and Dad used to go over there and he'd disappear on Sundays and just play music and he and Éamon de Buitléar would be the boon chuckers on the piano if you know if there was piano needed. And he he played a bit of music on the concertina.

I'm not sure he was that good. But at the same time he loved to be around and when he got into business, because my mother was a high maintenance lady, he had to earn some decent money. And this was all kind of um pastime for everybody. Nobody was professional at that time. But this is before the chieftains kind of became The chieftains and dad would have them all out for the office parties. And that was really where the band started forming around some of these events in Dublin where the boys discovered that they could make some money on this. But Dad was committed because we were already, you know, high-maintenance children at home.

so he kind of got stuck, but he was always around the music, and people were always around him. He was very social. And I was always trying to play. It was very interesting because um John Reedy's or Sean Ó Riada's um attitude to the harp was that it was very drawing room, lady centred, Irish colleen reeking of touristic caricature. And I know that that disappointed him terribly, but that was what I got taught in school. I went to Sion Hill, of course, the Harp Farm.

And we had a wonderful teacher, Máirín Ferriter, and we were all being trained up for Jury's cabaret. But what it was is we were all singers, or they were all singers 'cause I wasn't a a good singer. And essentially we had been taught how to use chords. And that was brilliant because when I was with my traditional friends, instead of playing the whistle or I because I play a bit of flute as well, but um I just literally transformed the boom chucks from what you would do on the piano as a céilí piano player, which I'd hear my dad doing all the time.

And I just transferred that to the harp. It was convenient because either somebody else was playing the piano at the same time, or there wasn't a piano available, or the piano was out of tune, you know. And I just kind of got into it from the back door. I got taught it to delight the touristic audiences that would come around in the summer times and that was nice, it was okay. And you know, we would be hauled out during the school concerts and we went on little tours to convents around the country. But then, you know, as a teenager I was finding my own way.

And then when Comhaltas came to Monkstown that was the end of it. That was the end of it. I just was down in Comhaltas. I just kind of moved in really. Yeah. Um I'm just uh thinking back to my own dad who died about eleven years ago. Okay. but when I was about maybe nineteen, twenty, you know, from maybe about sixteen onwards, when I really got interested in Irish music, you know, there was that kind of encouragement, but you you the I I noticed a wee mistake there, Tara. You know, it was a little bit until maybe around twenty twenty-one.

That was when he actually said, That was really good, Tara. Oh so isn't that such an important moment? And I would imagine a year later you would have got probably the same dad I well I feel my mum's presence 'cause she still finds my car keys every time I lose them. But I wish I had that closeness with my father. but when we started finding that conversation, he was already terminally ill. And that was the tragedy of it. But you know, I'm hoping that he's

Happy. I I don't think he'll be too sad because he was very politically motivated as well, and that's what motivated my work in Northern Ireland, because when I found that the harp could be useful in the time of the troubles where we could, you know, do something where we could have children from both communities, you know, playing together, that was actually what was the core value of what I brought to my life, enriching my life was being the useful, you know, because that worked. That worked. Was that the um the Belfast Harp Orchestra?

Yeah. I remember some of the students, some of the girls musicians were over in Glencolmcille and they were teaching yeah. And I mean I am so proud. I didn't, like I say, have babies myself, but I have harp students all over the place that are my nurtured outgoings, you know, and um you know, a lot of the most dynamic and creative and super harp players that are out there now came through my stable and while you know people don't talk about their teachers an awful lot these days, my cheeks glow

when I hear them play, you know, and I love that they're so well regarded, you know, because um my life was always about kind of creating the world I would have loved. I would love to have been one of my own students. Which is I suppose a bit mad, isn't it? That's the best kind of teacher though? Well, you know, I I mean I didn't get it right all the time, you know, and my students taught me way more than I ever taught them. And I when I produced my first book, which was way back in two thousand four.

in the preface or the forward, I apologised to all my students because I experimented on them, you know, and I mean they taught me how to help them get it right. But I didn't get it right. Because there was a whole lot of things I didn't get right in beginning. You know, I really hadn't drawn the line between what's formal and what's informal music because when my students started coming to me, there was a pressure on me and on them, which I passed on to them, um, is to get a good quality of harping right so that we could represent the music of the seventeen nineties, you know, because seventeen ninety eight uh or seventeen ninety-two Belfast

Harpers’ Assembly and it all started with the Linenhall Bicentry in nineteen eighty eight, which was seventeen eighty eight when they formed and it was their, I suppose, cultural life in Belfast at that time with the kind of the emergence of the um United Irishmen and the harp being adopted as the emblem of their movement, which is all about the repeal of the last of the penal laws and the Catholic question. So it was quite a big and a an important time for the political responsibilities of the leadership in the community in Northern Ireland, which was a Presbyterian leadership at

the time, because the Presbyterians had been very prosperous and they were looking to get relief from the last of the the ridiculous penal laws, the very suppressive laws. and in all of the effort of that they were inspired by the French Revolution, liberty, egality, fraternity. And that inspired the basis for the Belfast Harpers’ Assembly. And I was inspired by that story. For me, that was a heroic story. And the fact that people were collaborating and that was led by Presbyterians who would have thunk it, you know, who would have thought it.

And here's me, an Irish Catholic coming north. But with a name like Harbison, I've got a planter background. You know, and the Harbisons came over with the Ulster Scots. Hmm and they had been granted land in Ballanderry around the Loch Neagh area and there was farming land and you know, there's kind of family history. They were there from about seventeen thirties or some, even though the plantation was from a hundred years previously, they were later arrivals, from what I gather and from what I

can find out, which is not an awful lot actually, because they were just farmers, you know, they weren't Hoipoloi or important people. I and there were there was kind of poets among them and some of them were orange as well. But then there was somebody dared to marry a Catholic and then the family split and they were originally Harbinson. But the Harbinson stayed Harbinson but the Catholic lot they dropped the Catholic lot they dropped the N in the middle and became Harbison as opposed to Harbinson.

So the story goes anyway, and I ended up Harbison. But um that was a pretty exotic name in Dublin 'cause most of the family are still north or the Harbisons are still north. But anyway, going back there, having an Irish Catholic nationalist background with an Ulster planter name opened doors that would be a surprise. And I was always a bit of a floater between the churches. For a long time I wasn't a paying up member of any one of them, and my first husband was a Presbyterian and the two of us thought, right, we're gonna fix all this ourselves.

You know, let sex, drugs and rock and roll r rock the state and um we were young and carefree, but the troubles kind of caught up with us in a big way and um the pressures were gigantic and um so unfortunately all of that came apart because of the troubles thing. Um the way it it worked and it was a very difficult time, especially for my husband. He he was in the fire service, saw a lot of things shouldn't no human should carry with them and it was I had a a life of grandeur and I was on the media and I was even doing the the Sunday morning news programmes.

It only did it once I told you you know, where you talk about what's on in the newspapers and I thought, my god, I'm a celebrity. And at home it was a very, very different story. Anyway, it is what it is. And he found somebody else that gave him comfort and he started having babies with her. So that was okay, just had to had to move on. And I picked up husband number two who was Protestant. And I thought, well, here I am, a Catholic. I've married a Presbyterian, now marrying a Protestant. I'm gonna have a right one way or the other.

Somebody's gotta, you know, save my soul. And um so I married an Englishman, um, cathedral organist, and he's he's on the staff of St. Paul's in London. So he's he's a mighty musician. And I was intrigued by this because I love big music, and an organ is you know, a cathedral organ. Church music is fantastic. So I'm quite gregarious really. I'm as much an itinerant bog woman in my musical tastes, because I love rock music as well. So I mean, w when Finton Vallely came out with his first compendium, somebody had put me down I was described as a fusion musician.

I thought, God Jeepers and I thought I could play a decent jig and reel, you know. But you know, it is what it is. Sam, you mentioned Harper versus Harpist. Yeah. What is the difference now? Can you tell me? yeah, well now it's all very grey. It's a bit like being a brilliant classical violinist and saying, I'm a fiddler. Okay. Or um, you know, it's this kind of thing. Uh the IST ending, harpist, is the classical version. And the you know, the instruments of the orchestra all turned from being fluters to flautists and from harpers to harpists.

And if there was a pipes in the orchestra, there would be a pipist. So And I don't know when it's started, but I mean, I've always been around traditional music with a harp. I did do six months of lessons on a proper harp, really to figure out what it was that I was doing that was offending some of the people that I'd go into these competitions and somebody say, My hand position's all wrong, my thumb isn't right and I thought, jeepers I mean, you know, the music's coming out all right. However, you know, there was quite a bit of criticism thrown at you, you know, and

And I kind of thought, well, if I could just have a notion what it is that you think is what I should be doing. And so I went for lessons in the college of music in Dublin, um, with Caitríona Yeats and I learned how they do it in classical music. And the elbows had to be up and, you know, you had to do and, you know, we spent kind of the first four months learning the scale and the arpeggios. And I just I just did it 'cause I felt maybe I should do it because maybe I would learn something. And in the end, uh Caitríona got a job in Sweden.

She went off to a big, big job in Sweden. And Mercedes Garvey, lovely, lovely lady, took on and finished her classes for the end of the year. And Mercedes said to me one day, I remember playing a tune, I can't remember. Was it think it was the mountains, the Kid on the Mountain, because she'd asked me to play something I wanted to play rather than all the stuff I didn't want to play. And she said, Why are you doing this? Why are you coming to lessons to learn classical harp? I said, Because I never Had proper lessons on instrumental playing. I learned how to accompany myself singing in school.

But beyond that, and I had all of these people telling me my hands were on, and um Mercedes said, Don't you be minding them. Your playing is grand. Sure, hadn't I been touring the States with Comhaltas at the time, I'd won the championship. Other l lots of my friends, lots of my colleagues, thought what I was doing was fine. And Mícheál, my lovely redneck Irish friend, From up the road and around the corner, uh, who is still working away and playing away and teaching all the kids on Inishmaan and Inisheer And uh Mícheál was never backward about

coming forward and telling me what's rough and what's not. And he didn't like the way I was playing rolls you know, five-note rolls. And you know, so he was very, very critical and he would say what needed done. And I learned a lot from him because he was hearing with a strong traditional ear. And I was only hearing with what I was hearing. And, you know, even in the sessions now in Dublin, I had fabulous people around me. Maura Glackin. You know, we we we get territorial about where you sit in the session and the same people will sit beside you every week, you know, because they like sitting beside you.

And I like sitting between Simon Coyle, who is a wonderful fiddle player based in Dublin, a Dublin man, and uh Maura Glackin sat the other side of me. So I was surrounded by great musicians and they would give me new tunes and they would say, Yeah, d try that a different way. Don't be trying to do it the way the fiddle does it. Do it the way it's gonna work for you in the harp. And you know, when I would be struggling with a bit of a tune. And everybody shaped me. All of them were my teachers, which was a very different experience to the classical thing. So I was quite happy to be a harper as opposed to a harpist.

Could you maybe show us so you have the heart beside you, so I'd love to just the difference between the rolls that maybe Mícheál have showed you and the one that you were doing beforehand. uh I mean that would be a kind of five note roll and and he wanted me to do the cut and tip roll as opposed to the triplet roll, so

I'd have to now try and get my head around what I'm doing, you know. I'm I'm taking the shortcut there because I'm doing a a treble. triplet roll you know it's kind of making a stronger differentiation between the the triplet roll and the the cut and tip roll, you know. And I mean the the treble which is a very harpy thing to do is so easy to do and it impresses everybody.

Whereas it's darn hard work to do the cut and tip roll. And when I was teaching on the TTCT I was the harp teacher for the first lot of years. And Mícheál Ó hAlmhain Was always saying that all the harpers had to be playing. There was no compromise. They all had to play the cut-and-tip roll, the proper roll, none of this triplet rubbish. And he doesn't realise how much technical skill is needed to do that. And it isn't easy. And we have three times the work of anybody else to do anyway, because we have to figure out what to do with the left hand.

So we need to arrange, and then we're going to be, you know, we're going to be doing kind of boon chucks as well. So when we're playing in the sessions. we're doing the accompaniment thing. So you still have to So you're you're still doing something. Now, that's pretty, you know And then you've got all the young ones doing. Um You know, they're doing the kind of the slap guitar bass type thing, you know. But getting your head into deciding what you're going to do with the left hand that's not going to overwhelm what's happening in the right.

That's going to be just enough to complement the tune and not make um a dog's dinner. Is the repertoire you or the other harpers play in sessions, is it slightly different or is it do you kinda try to stick with what has been played in the sessions anyway or? yeah. I mean, I'm probably well known for having gripes and, you know, Janet's rant and all of that. Because one of the things that I find that harp players don't do enough of, and that's learn the basic tunes, is to the core tunes that connect everybody.

I mean you can go to so like I was playing the um Silver Spear there. But I mean, you know, just solid tunes like I was just thinking the Cat's Meow. I mean that's a fairly new one, but it's a great one and everybody plays it and thanks to Joannie Madden for that. But you know, all the regular tunes, whether it's the battering ram, you know, the saddle of pony, you know, all the Kesh jig Yeah, all the absolutely, totally. And even Miss McLeod's Reel that's what I taught them all here today. And yesterday I was doing what's the ocean?

over the ocean, yeah. I knew that as Portroe Jig that way back it's out on the ocean is what it's called now. But I think it's really important that everybody has that core of standard session tunes that are known universally. Instead of uh very often what happens in the workshops that's happening now is that to learn by rote, you know, where everything is actually given to you on a platter and you're told what ornaments to stick in, what bass notes to play, and you know, it'll get you a fast result. But it's not your music. It's the music of whoever arranged it for you.

And yet there's no acknowledgement of where the sources are coming from. And that's kind of plain not right. It's plain wrong. And it's just not being truthful and where people are playing tunes and they're going into the Fleadhs with these highly ornamented and highly polished arrangements, but they might be learning those same three tunes through the year. And it came under my conscience because I produced an awful lot of kids that did exactly that. And I just thought, jeepers they're going in and they're presenting themselves as traditional musicians, but everything has been put on a platter for them.

I haven't taught them what to do for themselves. And that's where I had this conscience thing. I thought, I need to change. I need to change my whole approach because it was too easy for me to fix everything for them. And so now I teach people how to do it. They might get a bit miffed with me because I won't give them a full set arrangement. I want them to find their own voice in the music. And I'm delighting in the fact that my students, um, all of them now do their own thing. They I taught them how to do it. But it might have been a hard task for them because it would have taken time.

Whereas a lot of young people go in for fixed arrangements, maybe even arrangements of some of the leading musicians, and it shouldn't be that they're only taught this. They should be taught how to do it for themselves as well. For me that's important. Do you find you may lose interest that way? Because I'm guessing that somebody that wants that really wants to Yeah, they really obviously want to learn the music and are so excited about the music that that's what motivates them to do that next step. absolutely.

But there's another um issue in music playing. I mean I'm teaching people to play in a session and I'm teaching them accompaniment skills, but that's not what they want. The parents are looking for them to win competitions. They're looking for competition ready arrangements. They want super tunes with lots of ornamentation and lots of funky basses. And that's not what I want to teach them. I want to teach them to get it into the community, to get to enjoy and experience the communal aspect of music. And to have the kind of friendships worldwide that I have enjoyed my lifelong.

And um there's a strange issue in teaching that music now because I make that a point of how I present myself as a teacher. I present myself as a teacher of social musicianship. I've done all the other things and all my students I've got I use a little boast for you, I've well over forty students who have All Ireland championship titles, and it's probably a bit more than that now. And all my students but two Who were related to me, little scallywigs, got A's in their leaving certs or A levels playing music.

And for me, I'm very proud of that. But that was me coaching them with fixed arrangements to tick the box for a very quick in and out exam or competition sitting. And I don't feel I taught them properly because I gave them what they demanded of me and I didn't stand my ground to insist. So I have lost a lot of students because the parents are looking for the competition ready players. Do you find that those who have won competitions are still playing or not? Mostly not.

Yes. You're absolutely right. Because they didn't have the breadth of tunes. Also, with the competitions, they're not looking for regular tunes. They're looking for kind of peripheral tunes or big tunes. You know, they're looking for the show off tunes like the Bucks of Oranmore and you know, the the Johnny Doherty tunes. They're looking for the big tunes. They're not looking for the two that gives them the connection with other musicians Exactly. And it's very interesting to watch all of that generation of players that I taught not able to teach that on because I failed in teaching that to them at that time.

Because at the time it wasn't expedient for me because we were having such a great time as the Belfast Harp Orchestra and we were flying around the universe doing stagey stuff and I was teaching them staged music. No, we would have had sessions behind the way and a number of my players Would have been players of concertinas or flutes or fiddles as well. But they tended to still favour the flutes and fiddles and concertinas when they were playing in the session. So it's not that many of them will stick with a harp. So I have to admit that that was my failing and I'm hoping that the generation I've started teaching now I can reverse that.

Anyway, sure look it's not like as if I've too many chapters ahead of me, but you know, we we'll do our best. well I plan on coming back to Dungloe for as many years as I have left. But I hit seventy in two weeks' time. I'm gonna be seventy. Thank you very much. I think we should play Happy Birthday. No Well, you know, if you can't play happy birthday, I'll beat you up. You know. So I mean, if I'm teaching them how to do it for themselves, the least they can do is play happy birthday. It's the three chord trick, I mean it's too damn easy, you know.

But it can be done. Um Janet, I would have to let you go because I know you are due to be somewhere else shortly. So I have stolen a tradition that other podcasts use and that they ask the last guest to leave a question for the next guest. right. So the question that has been left for you is have you ever given someone who's playing in the session the look mid-tune? yes. On what level of misdemeanor earns it? what a great question.

my god, you're gonna need another hour now for this one. that's brilliant. I I apparently I'm renowned for the look. Ha ha ha. 'Cause you know, when I'm with the orchestra I would be facing them and you know, there would be the look. I don't know if you've time, but I've got a great wee story. I had one of my she's about eleven or twelve year old, and we were playing for the Emperor of Japan in Áras an Uachtaráin right? So big posh concert and everything. And uh she obviously had been missing for one or two of the rehearsals and I could see her um, you know, kind of footering and playing rubbish and I was trying to give her the look

and her neighbours were getting her to look at me to see that she was getting the look, you know. And the next thing is I motioned in my face to Now I know your listeners can't see it, but essentially I'm saying fake it, right? fake it was what I was saying. But she didn't hear fake it, she thought I was saying right? And the face she had these beautiful big, big eyes, you know, and the eyes opened like big sauces, like what the is Janet saying she's telling me

But then the the last but sorry you can't say fake fake fake not fuck fake fake. ha ha. And then when she realized what I was saying, because I wanted her just to look like she knew what she was doing, and she realized, and then she started faffing with the the hands around the harp and pretending to figure it out, well, the wife of the emperor thought she was the most darling thing, and what an expert she was. She was playing the strings, not touching a string, but it didn't look like that from the audience. They thought she was playing, and she looked so confident and she had the big beaming smile across her face.

When she got over the shock of what she thought I was saying, um Um and so y that's the look how the look can work. So, you know, it's amazing how that you've just reminded me of that now. It's a long time since that happened. But uh I mean, you know. Otherwise you just have to grab the point and just give it up to the universe. There's occasionally you find people who might be new to a session coming in that just don't understand the etiquette and they might be desperate to kind of lead sets and

they're busy trying to jump in in the middle of it, or you know, it's it's it is a bit of an ego trip. Um or it's maybe that they're desperate for belonging, but the word that ends up in the end of the day is desperation, and um you just cajole them and make them feel welcome and they don't need to be stressed up or trying to meet an agenda. So it's not so much that they would get the look there might be a look, but it'd be a look of Don't worry, don't worry yourself. You know, you don't need to be desperate.

It's fine. Everybody's welcome, everybody's included. A session is a family. You're going to have brilliant people, you're going to have beginners. It doesn't matter. Everybody will be able to play something. Because what I do, and I love to say it, is that it's organic music. What we do is organic. It's not linear. You're not going to start at the beginning of the page and struggle through to the end. No. The idea is you play as many notes as you're able. at the pace that everybody's playing. And then you just add the extra notes as you get to be better at what you're doing.

And before you know it, you're flying it. Have you got a preference for how many harps would be you know, in a one session or even how many instruments would be? just as many as possible. Right. Yeah. I mean if you're putting a spectacle on. you know, it's great to put a bunch of harps on stage because that's how I created the orchestra, because I needed to find an audience for it. Nobody was going to come to a solo harp concert. You know, you you have to create spectacle and modern concert goers are looking for that spectacle.

So I did that with the orchestra. That's how we established our audience to start with. But there would have been beginners, intermediates and seniors, and the way I worked it was that it was a kind of a journey. Everybody came in at the beginner, and they might be ten or eleven or twelve, but then they would move up through. the orchestra and then they'd move out and they'd be corporate entertainers or or teachers or stage or studio performers, you know, and they all would have been in the business of the music. But please goodness I've produced some that would also feed into the social environment, the the social business of session playing.

Because that's where my heart is, because that's where the joy is. So how many in a session would you think would be kind of At least two. Yeah. Because you know, like playing on your own it's like talking to yourself in the mirror. There's only so much good you can get out of it. Okay. You know, so at least two. I'm a family fiddles, I love at least two fiddles. yeah, I don't mind. I mean I'll play with anybody. I remember in in Mairéad's podcast that you did with her you asked her uh what were the best instruments. I have a big thing. I love the uilleann pipes.

I've always orientated to uilleann piping, mainly because I love the tunes they play. I love the old piping tunes, especially the the kind of epic pieces, whether it's Allistrum's March or whatever. Love all of that colourful story music. And um but I'll go to a session anywhere. We might play a few tunes. Because I was actually wondering what kind of tunes will we play up so I could do it. you don't need to I I mean I do I know all of that stuff as well, but I'd be more than happy to play a few tune on.

Thanks for listening to In Tune with Tradition. If you enjoy this episode, please follow the podcast, leave a review or share it with someone who might find it useful. You can visit sessionetiquette.com or IrishmusicSessions.com to send me a question for a future guest, share a challenge or joy from your own session experience, or support the podcast. The In Tune with Tradition podcast is recorded and produced by me, Tara Connaghan and edited by Anita Alvarez Santos.

Until next time, stay in tune with tradition.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Irish music sessions are not a free-for-all

    Nov 9, 202635 minAudio

    Belfast flute player and uilleann piper Harry Bradley joins Tara to talk about why an Irish music session is not a free-for-all, even when it can look like one from the outside. Harry describes the session as a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nerves in Irish Music Sessions

    Oct 11, 202647 minAudio

    This episode Éamon Ó Ciosáin talks with Tara about nerves, listening and the things musicians gradually learn by actually spending time in Irish music sessions. Éamon speaks openly about going blank when asked to start...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. People First, Music Second

    Sep 18, 202644 minAudio

    This episode of In Tune with Tradition was recorded in person in Miltown Malbay during Willie Clancy Week 2025, (shortly after the podcast was officially launched), where Clare fiddle player, teacher and broadcaster...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Irish Music Sessions Are Strange Social Experiments!

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Fiddle player and teacher Jacqui Martin joins Tara Connaghan to talk about friendship, slow sessions, rhythm, seating, safe places to play and why Irish music sessions can feel like strange social experiments where...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Music is a biological necessity

    Aug 15, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    This episode explores how music can regulate the nervous system, build belonging, and help people feel safe in communal playing spaces. Tara Connaghan is joined by Louise Kelly, a consultant music therapist from the...

    Credit the people on this episode