Today’s guest is William Morgan, the co-founder of Restless Egg, a London-based incubator and accelerator designed specifically for a new class of “artist-founders” whose work synthesizes art, technology, and commercial product design. His thesis: The tech sector’s obsession with optimization can’t help us discover the genuinely novel forms of human experience that this intelligent substrate makes possible. If we want something truly better, we need to cultivate the taste and discernment to know which futures are worth living in - and radically expand our imagination regarding what human-machine relationships can actually look like. ✨ Become a founding member to access my online courses, including Jurassic Worlding and How To Live In The Future ✨ Browse and buy the books we mention on the show at Bookshop.org ✨ Stream and download my music at artist-owned (!) Subvert.fm ✨ Learn about Atlas Research Group, my new team building sovereign infrastructure for social coherence and collective intelligence. Chapters 00:00 Teaser: Taste & Sovereign Choice 02:46 Intro 06:41 Meet William Morgan 08:05 The Origins of The Avant-Garde 10:09 Taste and Abundance 12:12 Luxury Tech and Experience 15:57 Why Experiment? 20:21 Venture Models and Niches 25:20 The Sense Organs of Society 30:51 Rethinking Venture Incentives 38:54 Slop and Subculture Rebellion 47:13 Beyond “In” or “Out” 50:51 Founder Experiments Showcase 57:03 Scenius is Real Value Mentioned Restless Egg’s Half Dozen Newsletter Art Is Everything You Don’t Have To Do by Cory Doctorow The Usefulness of Useless Knowledge by Abraham Flexner This collective is radically rethinking what it means to make art by Thom Waite at Dazed Digital The Dimensions of Experience by Andrew P. Smith Mount Analogue by René Daumal The Nerves of Government by Karl Deutsch Why Software is Eating The World by Marc Andreessen Y Combinator’s Simple Agreement for Future Equity Common As Airby Lewis Hyde Standing by Wordsby Wendell Berry Right Story, Wrong Storyby Tyson Yunkaporta Fall by Neal Stephenson The Politics of Visionby Lydia Nochlin The Key to Science Fictionby Damien Walter Flora Weil Antithykera CCRU Luciana Parisi George Bataille Matthew David Segall This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.humansontheloop.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01The way you might think about taste is as a faculty of judgment that's been refined through a course of mature experience. So that someone has, through the course of their life, developed a habit of being able to render judgment on something. So that you are able to trust it when they say this thing is going to be cool or not cool or whatever. They know something about it before it actually happens. That's what it means to have taste is the ability to select from like a host of options what will happen.
SPEAKER_01And so when we talk about taste, it's not just about having versus not having, right? You don't need taste if I have a car and you don't, right? Taste is irrelevant because I simply have the thing. But if we both have cars, it's quite a bit more relevant than I have a Ferrari. But the way that that comes about is through some sort of abundance. That means we need to select from the abundance and we need a kind of development of a faculty that allows us to select. And so our whole thesis about the art
SPEAKER_01is looking for people who have spent their entire lives basically developing that faculty. And then the thesis is that those people at the present moment have the exact skill set that's necessary and that's at an People who have spent years identifying what in human-human relations or human-technical relations really stands out. What do people want to participate in? When you get the e-commerce revolution, the question Friction isn't like, what are the human relations?
SPEAKER_01What's the friction that we want to preserve? It's exactly the opposite. But now that that SaaS revolution has happened and we're in the agentic revolution, the question is increasingly, what are the forms of friction that we want to preserve? And what are the new economic categories that will be created around them? So this class of person has always been someone who identifies the highest value friction. We actually are not yet in a place where we can have a sovereign decision because the only decision seemingly available is refuse or let it rip.
SPEAKER_01And it's what we're all sort of sensing is that you have this forced choice of like, I'm in or I'm out. And that kind of feels horrible. And so in order to develop the capacities to have this sovereign choice over what future one wants to inhabit, we do need the development of different sensory capacities that give us more options.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to episode 37 of Humans On The Loop.
SPEAKER_00Today we're exploring how to make the most of a profound categorical shift. AI is rapidly receding into the background of the human environment, transforming into an omnipresent infrastructure that layers intelligence across every aspect of our physical and digital realities, and a nonspecific amplifier of human intention. And that's a serious constraint. Despite the radical nature of this evolution, our current deployment of new technology remains surprisingly uninspired.
SPEAKER_00Or maybe not so surprisingly. Trapped within a narrow commercial paradigm, the tech sector continuously optimizes existing tasks like proofreading emails while failing to discover the genuinely novel forms of human experience that this intelligent substrate makes possible. Or as William Morgan of Restless Egg puts it, why does everything in the near future either want to kill you or get you off? Using our new superpowers to merely do what we already do but better makes us passive consumers of desires and selves imposed by
SPEAKER_00the technopoly. If we are to avoid sleepwalking into a future defined entirely by market forces, we need to cultivate the taste and discernment to know which futures are worth living in and radically expand our imagination regarding what human-machine relationships could actually look like. William is today's guest, and he's committed to just that. He's the co-founder of Restless Egg, a London-based incubator and accelerator designed specifically for a new class of artist founders whose work synthesizes art,
SPEAKER_00technology, and commercial product design. He holds a PhD on the philosophy of AI from UC Berkeley, where his work explored the deep conceptual and socio-political frameworks of computation. This background directly informed his trajectory as a researcher on critical initiatives with organizations like Antithakera, where he co-developed research tracks exploring complex macroscale informational and cognitive systems. With Restless Egg, Morgan has moved decisively from theory to practice, promoting a new avant-garde who recognize their obligation to participate in
SPEAKER_00the unfolding relationship between technology and culture. As he writes in one of the articles we discuss in this episode, One unignorable conclusion about the AI revolution is that from now on, everything one does is training data. Furthermore, everything one might want to do is theoretically more possible now than ever before through additional compute, or so they say. At the same time, even those building AI in frontier labs don't know the full extent of what these machines can do, much less what they should be doing.
SPEAKER_00Thus, the question becomes, Why is it this way and not that? As players in this, the rigorous game of living, it is your job, your responsibility, your opportunity to design what might fill in the blank before it is filled in for us." Right now, maybe nothing is more important than the nurture novel forms of interactability that expand rather than restrict what it means to be human, which is precisely what Restless Egg is up to
SPEAKER_00and, incidentally, what we're doing at Atlas Research Group. So, William and I have a lot in common, and this conversation took us into some very fun places. I'm excited to share it with you. If it excites you too, please take a moment to subscribe and leave a comment, because this show is still hyper-niche, and I respond to them all. Thanks for listening.
SPEAKER_00You had just said you were telling your coach that your life is a series of mistakes. And I think that the inability to get out ahead of our present is actually something that shows up in a lot of your work that I wanted to... Definitely. We can do that. Are we starting? Yes, let's do it. Okay.
SPEAKER_01All right. I'll let you start us off however you like.
SPEAKER_00I was telling you that it might be months before this episode comes out that you have that option that gives you the ability to talk about things that are very far away but it also means that when this drops you might look back on this and be like wow I was so wrong about that and that's just that playing with time I wanted to touch on at some point you're writing on the avant-garde and on the creation of new experience classes and all of that.
SPEAKER_00So there is this theme here of trying to get out ahead of ourselves, like trying to think the unthought and the unthinkable stuff that, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a great question. And before I launch in, let me just say thanks for having me on. And, you know, it's been a true privilege to listen to your podcasts over the years. And I remember it being the sort of main track of On To Get There. And so, yeah, truly a privilege to be on. As far as like the kind of avant-garde sensibility of seeing the future, looking around corners, I think it's very much what we're trying to do and a spirit that we're trying to cultivate.
SPEAKER_01And it has a little bit of taking a cue from venture, from startups, from philosophies. You Can Build Commercial Scale Products Based On That Admixture Of Ideas Just A Little Bit Of Background On That Collision Of Things I was an academic before doing Restless Egg and the way I see us fitting into a certain academic trajectory is like you have the CCRU
SPEAKER_01where my PhD advisor Luciana Parisi came out of and they're doing this David Morgan of experiments trying to put that into practice. So I would say that Strelka and Antikythera are two examples of that, but there's a host of other ones and they're innumerable. But I think that Restless A follows in that trajectory.
SPEAKER_01If like, for example, Antikythera was kind of like, can we use that combination of philosophy and technology to build prototypes and develop plans in the form of those video essays that we did and design briefs? Then the question of Restless A is, can you go one step further and actually build companies, successful, scalable companies and commercial products based on that same collision. And so to get back to your question, the avant-garde spirit, it's not just about forecasting or projecting. It is about capturing something that's outside.
SPEAKER_01And this really comes into the taste conversation that's been like, Maybe at this point it will have died when this episode comes out, but it'll probably be with us in some sort of zombified form. But the way you might think about taste is as a faculty of judgment that's been refined through a course of mature experience. So that someone has, through the course of their life, their work, their career, their personal experience, developed a habit of being able to render judgment on something and so that you are able to trust it when they say this thing is going to be cool
SPEAKER_01or not cool or whatever. They know something about it before it actually happens. That's what it means to have taste is the ability to select from a host of options what will happen. And so when we talk about taste, it's not just about like having versus not having, right? You don't need taste if I have a car and you don't, right? Taste is irrelevant because I simply have the thing. But if we both have cars, it's quite a bit more relevant than I have a Ferrari. But the way that that comes about is through some sort of abundance.
SPEAKER_01That means we need to select from the abundance and we need a kind of development of a faculty that allows us to select. And so our whole thesis about the The Artist Founder is looking for people who have spent their entire lives basically developing that faculty. And then the thesis is that those people at the present moment have the exact skill set that's necessary and that's at advantage. When you get the e-commerce revolution
SPEAKER_01The question isn't like, what are the human relations? What's the friction that we want to preserve? It's exactly the opposite. But now that that SaaS revolution has happened, and we're in the agentic revolution, the question is increasingly, what are the forms of friction that we want to preserve? And what are the new economic categories that will be created around them? So this class of person has always been someone who identifies the highest value frictions.
SPEAKER_00I want to back up just a little bit. Sure. Yeah, we definitely hit the ground like Sonic the Hedgehog. This idea that you unpacked in your piece on taste and AI as a luxury technology, I liked how the way that you said... I do not mean luxury in the sense of premium branding. I mean luxury in the sense that something luxurious exceeds one's basic needs, goes beyond utility. That you're talking about these new experience classes, or you're talking about things that are actually basic human functions.
SPEAKER_00It's like ritual, pleasure, spectacle, intimacy. Useless Beauty. You've got the Abraham Flexner, The Usefulness of Useless Knowledge. This was like a founding paper, the Advanced Studies at Princeton. And this is a conversation I got into with philosopher Matthew David Segal, where he was trying to make the case that philosophy is intrinsically valuable, not extrinsically valuable. The useful friction that I identified there is that there are two levels, right?
SPEAKER_00Play does not feel useful to a child or maybe to an adult that wishes their kid would go off and work in the mines already and get on with it. But play is useful to the species In terms of fine-tuning whatever learning cannot be transmitted through genetic inheritance, right? These things, like all of this stuff that we're calling luxury is from another level incredibly important, like ritual in the cohesion of human society.
SPEAKER_00or in aesthetic experience as a driver for self-determination of the decision of what we want to pursue. So there's one thing. And then the other thing is that I love that the entire operation of Restless Egg is couched in this incubation metaphor. I've just been reading Andrew P. Smith's The Dimensions of Experience, where he's talking about how evolution from the inside and how... The first complex animals did not have a lot of competition.
SPEAKER_00They were this avant-garde of multicellularity exploring a space that was not already crowded. And so they were able to try all of these different body plans without the pressure of competition. So however we might see competition as like a persistent force in evolution, There are these transitional periods where there is no competition because we don't have the abundance of this thing. So I don't know, I'm just connecting the stuff that you're talking about here to...
SPEAKER_00more general principles in thinking about this stuff. And the last piece I'll say is that I like that you said, from the perspective of ordinary people, the AI build-out does not feel luxurious at all. Most people's experience of AI so far is layoffs, price pressures, degraded trust, slop, and ambient social coercion. And you're calling for People To Think Otherwise. But one of the more interesting things to me that I've been ringing the bell about from very early on when AI was not so obviously useful was
SPEAKER_00that productivity might be the wrong frame through which to understand this, that all of this utilitarian thinking is a byproduct of something that's extremely weird and explosively generative. And the relationship between these two things continues to be an item of perverse interest. So yeah, I'd just love to hear you.
SPEAKER_01It's such a good set of questions. So I think you're exactly right. And I think the sort of like avant-garde is like a really excellent example. I'll come to that in just a second. But just to give a very sort of concrete first answer, the different use cases of AI feel like a luxury at this moment. But as you say, they are very beneficial. We should really hope that we have this kind of luxurious experimentation with different forms of AI,
SPEAKER_01because the current path of just the sort of agent to agent replacement of the SaaS economy is just one outcome of this fundamental technological revolution. So if you believe that artificial intelligence does have this kind of like underlying strangeness, or even if you don't, if you acknowledge that it is a fundamental technology, Then you can imagine all of these different use cases. So we can think about other fundamental technologies, like if you want to say electricity, airplanes,
SPEAKER_01the train, like with the airplane, you not only get flight as this is fundamental technology, you also get shipping, you get transcontinental travel, you get skydiving, you get all of these different things, right? And we're essentially just doubling down on one outcome from artificial intelligence. And so as a society at the most general level, we really do want people at this moment to be experimenting in a like broad, horizontal sense with the different use cases of AI,
SPEAKER_01whether that's like new forms of experience that might not be productive in themselves, they're quite societally productive because they ask what this technology means and it allows people to actually have a democratic say over what artificial intelligence looks like. Right now, Now, imagine a different future where there's a proliferation of
SPEAKER_01of let's say startups and products that offer you new experiences through AI that aren't like agentics for X business, Y business, that sort of thing, but are more like here we're leveraging AI for a new type of musical experience or we're deploying it in like a new type of robotic intimacy or for entertainment or something like this. This basically allows a kind of democratic luxury of people to decide what they want the AI future to look like. And so to go back to your multicellular example,
SPEAKER_01I think that's exactly like it's almost a one to one map is that like, we are sort of developing these societal technical appendages. And it's like we have to explore the morpho space of what we create. The Problem That I See And What I Think The Sort Of Traditional Venture Environment Is Missing And That Which I Wrote About In That Piece Is That So Much Funding And So Much Founder Energy Is Going To That's fine. That is certainly one use case and I don't mean to cast doubt on a productivity
SPEAKER_01That I think is certainly in the offing. That's not the point. The point is to develop these other use cases to provide a sort of, as I say, democratic optionality, but it is a luxury to even experiment with them. So the point is that we're doing luxurious experimentation, the technologies are themselves luxurious, and it should feel like a luxury in the sense that these are different ways of doing life that we are experimenting with, which We Then Have A Choice Of Which Way We Want To Grow Into Like I Think The Idea That
SPEAKER_01The AI Future Is Set In Stone As This Agent To Agent Economy Or Is Determined Is Totally Wrong I Think This Is What Some Of The Like Singularity P-Doom Discussion Misses Out On Is That It'S Not A Binary Yes No Future The Future Has So Many Different Shapes And Contours To It And We Only Get To Explore Those By In The Present Developing All Of These Different Options
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's interesting. I was reading the piece on Restless Egg at Dazed Digital, and there's a point in there where you say, and maybe we're getting ahead of ourselves here, because I think we do need to establish a little bit more in the work on the avant-garde and the role of the avant-garde in this. But regardless, it's on my mind. You say at some point that though some people might find it strange encouraging this in the form of venture-backed,
SPEAKER_00scalable startups, some people might, however days put it, they might feel like the bile come up in hearing this, that you're holding out some hope This might model another way of thinking for Silicon Valley, or as you put it in your piece on Do AI Products Need an Avant-Garde? Rather than slouching towards a future of ubiquitous intelligence interaction that is designed from and germinated within the incentive structure of the present, a future that is worthy of the name is genuinely different from the present.
SPEAKER_00rather than a repetition of the same only in a different moment of time. And so like Restless Egg is not just about incubating these projects that want to do this, but is itself that kind of a project that is trying to explore more of the morphospace of the way that we think about technology and business itself. It's funny because in arguing for... The necessity at this moment of an avant-garde,
SPEAKER_00you compare it to when the term first emerges, it arose alongside the Industrial Revolution. I mean, this piece is actually quite eloquent. You mentioned the work of art as material object exists to make the kernel of what the avant-gardist perceives communicable. It gives their vision form around which thought can gather and communication can begin. and then also that it makes foreseen futures legible for the first time. And you cite René Dumas' Mount Analogue, the door to the invisible must be visible.
SPEAKER_00In these moments, and I know I'm hammering on this point, but the utility is actually in exploration. So I've been thinking about this a lot with when everything becomes training data and software has already eaten the world and Therefore, all of the industrially legible human labor can be reproduced at diminishing marginal cost, then it shifts to an economic regime where
SPEAKER_00the real high value contributions are not whatever is standardized to the factory floor, but whatever hasn't been already. Right and so like over the last few decades we can feel this shift from like secondary education readying people for a stable workforce to more you know like colleges preparing people for entrepreneurship or teaching people How To Ready Themselves For Lifelong Learning And So When We Talk About There's
SPEAKER_00A Risk In When We Talk About The Production Of New Experiences There's Like A Residue Of This That Is Still Thinking Of It In Terms Of The Experience Economy Like The Way That We Can Make All Of This Stuff Compatible With Consumer Lifestyle Capitalism In Service Of The Self-Actualization Of Consumers And Industrial Institutions But The Tendency That I Think You And I Both See Here Is The Weight Is Shifting To The Other Foot
SPEAKER_00where we are being called to explore this space so strongly in part because, again, if we want to get into multicellularity, this analogy I find is really deep, that a bacterial cell, 99% of its genome is producing proteins and only 1% of it is a reservoir of proteins adaptive potential or is involved in regulatory functions.
SPEAKER_00But 99% of your genome and mine is junk DNA that is involved in the regulation, the maintenance, and basically creating optionality for a cell. We see the same thing In That Transition Where It's Like The Part Of The Cell That Is Preoccupied With Productivity Is Extremely Concentrated In A Very Small Region Of Its Genome And Everything Else Is
SPEAKER_00engaged in what you might call sense-making. So yeah, that's a huge ball of stuff, but I'm curious where you take that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, let me, I'll pick a couple of key bits and then feel free to steer me into the directions that you like. The first bit about sense organs, I think this is absolutely crucial. So this comes a little bit from my philosophical background studying cybernetics. And I think the person I'm thinking about here most closely is Carl Deutsch, the political scientist, first cybernetic political scientist who wrote this book. I think it was in like 69 called The Nerves of Government, where he was like, can you do political science in a cybernetic lens?
SPEAKER_01He asked this question and thought, what are the sense organs of a body politic? If you think of the Habesian diagram of the Leviathan made up of all these people, quite literally, what are computationally inflected sovereign sense organs? He comes up with this really in-depth understanding of how a political organism takes in information and reads it. He basically says that you can measure a given polity's openness or closure
SPEAKER_01to new information and then you can determine how much it can change its orientation or positioning based on how open or closed it is at a given moment. So this is really interesting to me because the executive functioning that allows a society to steer itself can be closed out. So he gives this really cool example about how Soviet chess prodigies were taught. And he says, is that if these guys ever sensed that they were losing in a game of chess, the goal might not always be to develop some sort
SPEAKER_01of come-from-behind victory strategy, but that oftentimes a better tactic to employ would be to attack their enemy's communication system and sort of almost move randomly so that the opponent doesn't know what's happening. Exactly This, that you're trying to frustrate the ability of the other player to explore the space or have their communication system open to explore the space. I would say that this is actually not totally dissimilar to what is happening now.
SPEAKER_01with AI and the current conversation that's happening around it. I think the sort of executive decision-making about what AI investments are being made, both by venture, by what's happening at the level of geopolitical conversation, by the center of gravity of conversations that happen in and around Silicon Valley and have to do with X-Risk, for example. But in general, the way that the conversation is unfolding is It's almost like our communication systems are under threat. And so they're quite closed to free exploration to develop these things.
SPEAKER_01And so I really like the way that you said it, we're called to explore the space. That's really nice. Kind of like the semi-theological kind of inflection that you give it. And I think it's right, especially because if we say that we are in a moment of conversational closure or politico-economic closure about what AI could be, it's why, despite everybody being like, we have this fundamental technology, things still appear to be relatively the same.
SPEAKER_01This is actually kind of a thing that strikes me personally is you hear these pronouncements of how everything is so different about these technologies. And it's like, yes, and my day-to-day life remains relatively similar. That to me is always like a little bit weird. And it goes back to something you referenced, the Andreessen software eats the world bit and the like You'll remember that Andreessen is on the side of bits,
SPEAKER_01the software age of the world hypothesis, and Thiel is like, where is all the change at the level of atoms? We've over-invested in software, but all the buildings and infrastructure are still the same. And so I think Andreessen even did a recent podcast where he was like, I've switched sides on this. I think Theo was right. I think the Adams question is fundamental. And I think that is something coming up right now, especially something I've written about is How artificial intelligence is increasingly best thought of as an infrastructural technology,
SPEAKER_01as something that will be threaded throughout the built environment. And so one of the questions is not just how does it work in terms of agentic workflows, but how do we want to access it? What is the interaction space? In what ways does it interact with our lives and does it come into our lives? And so I think that question is very combined with the novelty question and the closure question and how to create a kind of openness that can interrupt a kind of monoculture that exists right now. I mean, at the beginning, we were talking
SPEAKER_01I think as a society, we may look back and be like, why did I do that? Why did we not focus on these new domains of experience sooner? Why did we let them lag? Because I think the built environment, the physical, the infrastructural, I think they keep us from experiencing the awesome.
SPEAKER_01I mean in the awe-inspiring sense power of these new technologies. They become a kind of limit. And so that's part of what we're trying to do. I don't mean to say that we're necessarily doing all hardware, but I think hardware is in again. And I think that it provides an opportunity to break the monoculture when you have these different ways of interacting with physical space of physical reality. And I'll just say one last bit about that. Which is something we touched on earlier and we're wanting to bring into the conversation, which is that there's a model of doing venture that predominates and has
SPEAKER_01since Y Combinator switched from convertible notes to inventing the safe. I think it was in 2003 that they invented the safe, the simple agreement for future equity. Basically, the idea behind it was that the convertible note comes along with all of these sort of economic concerns that founders and investors need to worry about having to do with debt and Interest Rates and so on and so forth. And the SAFE by being an equity agreement that only converts later on means that you don't have to worry about that.
SPEAKER_01So it becomes really easy for founders and investors to make early stage deals. Okay, so we have the SAFE. That becomes the industry standard. And then we get the venture industry always hoping or working towards the next financing route. And so the idea and what's taken shape in the sort of SaaS venture world is that you're constantly raising an additional round, you're scaling, you're going for an infinite TAM, you want to capture the entire market. This is one model.
SPEAKER_01And I don't mean to say This Model Doesn't Work It Obviously Has Had Enormous Success But What We're Talking About Is These Sort Of New Experiments That Are Not About Changing The Infinite Tam They're About More Carving Open We're adding a shared earnings agreement.
SPEAKER_01And so the reason we have that is to say that traditionally, if you want to have a small or medium-sized business, you're out of alignment with your venture investor because you might not be trying to raise another rat. You're at loggerheads in terms of they want you to We think that given the founder class that we're supporting, this kind of avant-garde niche founder who knows their audience, has like a needful audience that is like They're responsive to them at the level of culture.
SPEAKER_01They have yield distribution through their creative practices and so on and so forth. Let's say they want to build one of these businesses that's generating cash flow, that's commercially successful. We as investors want to be aligned with that and say, we don't need you to raise another round. So this shared earnings agreement says that we can be in alignment with you as you produce revenue. And we think that that's the way that we can economically Support Founders Who Want To Produce This Kind Of Impact So Like All
SPEAKER_00Of This I'm Holding It Together In A Superposition With This Article I've Been Writing With My Colleague Simon Quornby At Atlas Research He Did Accounting At Amazon And He's Been I'm thinking a lot about financial innovation. And this piece is on how over the last 200 years, despite the efforts of all of these prominent economists, we have confused profit and rent. We're like rent is a is a permanent positional claim on something.
SPEAKER_00If you go back to, for instance, Lewis Hyde's really fabulous history of intellectual property law, Common as Error, and he talks about how all of the original Patent and IP stuff going all the way back to 1474 and like certainly as it was devised in the early United States set a 14-year term exclusivity because it was considered the natural lifespan within
SPEAKER_00which somebody could train two generations of apprentices and Before Releasing The Idea Back Into The Commons And That The Understanding Was That This Balanced Public Enrichment With Private Opportunity That The Real Innovation Does Not Happen Within An Enclosure That It Has To Be Put Out Into The World At Some Point And That What Has Happened Is You See These Papers By Like Johan Chu And James Evans On Slowed Canonical Innovation In The Sciences
SPEAKER_00And It's Like The larger a domain becomes, the more financialized it becomes in the sense that we're used to operating, over the course of our lifetimes anyway, the more everyone's attention is focused in one way. So to tie everything you said to this piece on rent and IP and on enclosure and commonsing to the stuff we were just talking about a moment ago, like the cognitive closure of a society. I see this all as related to like model collapse.
SPEAKER_00Like if you don't have a constant influx of new data or new experience and you're increasingly overfit on You're Training. Or the way that Wendell Berry puts it in Standing By Words is that there's been an imbalance between internal and external accounting, and that the more we focus on productivity, the more we lose sight of all of the community and the ecology that's substantiating all of this. And so I think the reason we are being called to
SPEAKER_00the avant-garde is maybe less theological than that. It's more like a Thomas Kuhn, the anomaly becomes so burdensome at some point that you have to look beyond your framework and that we're at this point where we are turning our attention back out. It's actually, there is this sort of opportunistic thing still in play here where, for instance, there's enormous wealth waiting for the people who figure out how to scale the bioremediation of plastic and radiation and these kinds of things.
SPEAKER_00How do we close the metabolic loop by opening the theoretical loop that we've been stuck in. So it's just like the ecological frame Simon is working on is the positional claim on perpetual value extraction through rent. is equivalent to immortalism. It's like the value in a particular idea is enriched by these sort of phases
SPEAKER_00of exclusivity and incubation and then the release into the commons where we're able to leverage innovation as a collective enterprise and that there's a cyclicity to all of this that we see in all complex adaptive living systems that we've Ignored But The Last Citation I'll Stack On This Is Like Tyson Young Caporta Saying There's Human Law And There's The Law Of The Land There's The First Law And Eventually If Human Law Is Out Of Alignment With
SPEAKER_00The Law Of The Land The Law Of The Land Has The Final Say And So I See This idea of financial structures reward companies that are not necessarily supposed to scale as an adaptation to our increasing awareness, ecosystems are not made entirely out of whales and elephants. We can actually see that the economy needs to be able to afford as many different kinds of activity as possible in order to close
SPEAKER_00as many metabolic loops as possible in order to actually I think it's doing, which is to continue to explore this morpho space and maximize entropy production, minimize available free energy. There's actually so much more profit and so much more creativity in us all not collapsing on this traditional approach.
SPEAKER_01So it's funny because I don't normally speak about what we're doing in terms of the sort of ecological health of a society, but I think you're exactly right, that if you limit what A Technological Revolution Can Do To Like One Set Of Use Cases It Is Really Quite Unhealthy For A Society I Mean The Thinker Sort Of Lurking Behind So Much Of This Is Bataille I Think I Reference Once In That Piece But Like The The Famous Accord Share Framework Is That Like If You Have This Surplus Of Energy
SPEAKER_01And You Don't Expend It You Get Militaristic Outcomes And You Know I Think Anybody Who's Gone Down The Bataille Rabbit Hole Has Probably Been Like I Wish He Could Be A Little Bit More Clear Instead Of The Sort Of Like Mad Raving Librarian That He Was And Sort Of Operating At The Level Of Vibes Which Cool But I never thought I would come back around to Bataille for dealing with the stuff that we're dealing with right now. But I do think the sort of general economic lens to think about artificial intelligence and that we're having this buildup in the energy going
SPEAKER_01towards these productive use cases, I do think there's like a decent argument that someone could write about an inherent connection between that and the shortening of the kill chain. I mean, people are writing about that already. I won't say a ton more about that, but I will say that I think expanding the options of what artificial intelligence is for, expending energy on developing those options and giving people the ability to invest in those and become attached to those is fundamental to the health of a society.
SPEAKER_01I think we're actually pretty close to starting to see that in terms of like an inflection point in slop. So I think probably eight to 12 months from when we are recording, I think the slopification that consumers feel is probably headed towards a worse place, at least the way that they are fed content. And we may even get some of the brief tangent. There's this Neil Stevenson book called Fall. It is like Paradise Lost retelling of About Consciousness Upload.
SPEAKER_01But in the first half of the book, he describes a nuclear bomb that goes off in Moab, only it hasn't really gone off. It's been like a sort of digital fake. And what happens as a result of it is the truthiness of the internet fractures as a result. And so online space just all becomes 8chan, and there is no more internet anymore as a source of communication. That's obviously a dramatic outcome, but I do think we're closing in on a moment where people realize that
SPEAKER_01the slopification, homogenous, this is for everyone kind of tendency that we've produced in products so far. is being rebelled against. We already see it in the rise of youth subcultures and the pursuit of subcultures as a way of identifying oneself, as a way of doing individualization. I think that more people will be talking about how The Premium On Frictional Human Relations Is Kate. I was having a conversation with one of our founders, Flora Wheel, who does Nephela, about this.
SPEAKER_01And one of the things that she and I spoke about was this sort of tautological frame that Human Relations Are Unique To Humans So It's This Idea That Like I Think A Lot Of People Are Threatened By The Fact That Artificial Intelligence Can Do What We Do And I Think That Most Attempts To Say Humans Are Unique Because AI Can't Do X Y And Z Or Sort Of A Losing Train This Kind Of Like Receding Yardstick Of What Human Is Like They Couldn't Play Chess They Couldn't Hold Conversations Etc
SPEAKER_01Etc So I Wouldn't Put Too Much Steak In That But you can make the total logical argument that human relations are fundamental to being human and that's not at all diminished by the fact that you can also have a relationship with an AI model. And so this kind of like anomaly that you're talking about, this burdensome anomaly that becomes an imperative to think is like, Okay, well, what are the ways that we can develop technologies that actually lead to what one section of the community calls human flourishing,
SPEAKER_01experimentation, new use cases for AI? I think this sort of like optimistic, I mean, I wouldn't call it necessarily techno-optimistic kind of pursuit because that has a whole set of baggages, but more optimistic about the future as a catalyst for change. I think if you want to invest in that, Then you can ask the question of what human makes it out of the near future. Okay, let me bracket on that and say one last thing about the rent comment that you made. And it's not exactly addressed to what you said, but I think it's related.
SPEAKER_01I think that the ethos and mission of Restless Egg is to intervene at the level of sustainable financial models for this genre of person. I've spoken about this before, but it's worth restating is that the origin of Restless Egg is really in this community of people, and then realizing that the financial institutions that existed to support them were being hollowed out by external factors, were small grants that couldn't sustain them,
SPEAKER_01forced them to compete against each other, and the timelines of them are really short, such that by the time you're halfway through a residency, you're already applying for the next residency. This is not to say like the art world can't produce great things. I just think that it produces great things for some people, but I think it doesn't produce great things for the whole host of people that are in it. I think that's a pretty uncontroversial statement, at least in terms of financial outcomes. And so we basically created Restless A as a way of supplementing
SPEAKER_01the existing financial incentives for that genre of person. What our idea was, what our hypothesis was, is that the innovation that was happening that's not functioning.
SPEAKER_01And The Model Of Scaling That Exists Today Is That The Product And The Company Are Commensurate With The Size And Speed Of Society And That You Have An Attention Scarce Environment And So To Affect Change You Do Have To Acknowledge Some Of Those Things You Have To Acknowledge Those Things And Participate To A Degree But Also Innovate Within So That That's The Restless Egg Ethos On That Front But Last Comment On This Thing Is That I Think For Us
SPEAKER_01The IP Model Was Something We Were Skeptical About In That We Didn't Want To Enter Into Pitch Battles With Founders Over Who Owned IP So Restless Egg Takes No IP It Has No Interest In Owning Any Of The IP Of The Founders The Equity Model For Us Had The Advantage Of Borrowing That Kind Of Alignment Thinking That Exists In Silicon Valley I think bringing in these different themes, these sort of tactics for innovation,
SPEAKER_01Incentivizing People And Developing New Forms Of Experimentation That's What We Do But I'll End This By Saying That Like Everyone Who Comes Through The Incubator Knows And Is Fully Aware That Commercial Success Is A Necessary, if not sufficient condition of what we're trying to do, both from the restless egg side of allowing this to be sustainable for other artist founders to come in and for scaling the ideas such that the founders can go beyond the reliance on grants or external funding
SPEAKER_01and can have their impact in a way that's self-sustaining.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm just thinking about, again, in the piece on Dazed Digital, you speak to another thing that I've been writing about, which is that we've been given a false binary between either you participate in institutionally owned collective intelligence, or you go to the opposite extreme and you go dark. You exit from the future entirely. And in so doing, we cut off our nose to spite our face because you talk in a few of these pieces
SPEAKER_00about the importance of, as Lydia Noshlin in The Politics of Vision talking about alienation as crucial to the avant-garde. Similarly, Damien Walter talks about cognitive estrangement as a feature of science fiction. You're creating, as a science fiction author, a novum that acts as like a seed crystal, like one thing, one variable you want to change that makes the world a very different place, and then the world builds around that change. You can feel that in what Noshlin is saying about the alienation of the avant-garde,
SPEAKER_00that like knowing that something can be different is what inspires that kind of curiosity. Again, it's the call or whatever. But a lot of people are responding to the cognitive estrangement of the world that's being given to them. As you say, someone has either designed the future for us, or it's outside of our reach, or it's too grandiose or ineffable to even begin to describe. And the response is to shrink away and not to participate in that. And so where I see this thing like, well, it has to be viable.
SPEAKER_00This injunction to make these projects commercially viable, I see as related to this third way that is not like just give all of your data to the big tech companies or refuse to participate in the commons governed collective intelligence. That is possible if we had the architecture for it. That it's like, if you really want to navigate these futures, we're going to have to develop the affordances to engage
SPEAKER_00in sovereign collective intelligence. And so these two issues are very tightly related to me. So I think the point that I would make is that we actually are not yet
SPEAKER_01We Can Have A Sovereign Decision Because The Only Decision Seemingly Available Is Refuse Or Let It Rip And So That's The Closure I'm Talking About And I Think We're Agreeing On This And It's What We're All Sort Of Sensing Is That You Have This Forced Choice Of Like I'm In Or I'm Out And That Kind Of Feels Horrible And So In Order To Develop The Capacities To Have This Sovereign Choice Over What Future One Wants To Inhabit We do need the development of different sensory capacities that give us more options.
SPEAKER_01I think it's right to say that probably the only choice right now is like, are you in or are you out? Because that's the only choice we've been afforded. And so part of the Restless Egg mission is to try and break The Stranglehold On This. So from where we are, we're doing that kind of cognitive estrangement on the financial side. But I think this puts us into a sort of nice relationship with the founders because I hope that they can see that we're embodying the same estrangement that they are themselves doing,
SPEAKER_01especially in running the accelerator, not just the traditional venture, like investing side of things. Maybe I use this opportunity to speak a little bit about some of the founders and what they're developing in terms of alternatives to the refuse or let it rip. And maybe just before I do, I can say that this is exactly What I Mean When I Talk About Luxury Technology And The Current Batch Is That Right Now It's Refuse Or Let It Rip But The Idea Of A Luxury Technology Is
SPEAKER_01The Luxury Of Choice That Decision Calculus To More Than These Two Options So A Couple Of Examples Self Engineering Founded By Jack Self Is Developing A New Information Hygiene Well I Don't Think He Would Call It That I think he would say it is a cultural intelligence engine. But in this discourse that you and I are having, which is more philosophical, I would say that what he is doing is thinking of a informational hygiene relationship to the feed and how
SPEAKER_01the feed represents my point of view or what the algorithm says my point of view ought to be. But it really constrains that to my point of view, like always scroll the feed as myself. That's very strange. What if you scroll from a different perspective? That is a different kind of sense organ that is like, can I participate in the sensory affordances of, let's say, as a first instance, someone else's algorithm? Obviously, that has There's these two Berlin-based artists who I'm always fond of bringing up
SPEAKER_01in conversations about exactly this called Brad and Salvador developing Lovebot, which is the new robotic intimacy project that's developed specifically through Sextech products. Super cool, super interesting idea. And I think what they offer is that the relationship between AI and intimacy isn't like love it or hate it. It's much more flexible. I think that has enormous implications for how we think about robotics entering our spaces.
SPEAKER_01And I think that we will need those conversations rather than just it's the humanoid assistant or the like smart home Disney house that wants to kill you. I think you and I have spoken about this before, but if not, we've certainly had separate conversations about it, about how the sci-fi imaginaries that we had from the golden age need to be replenished. And it's easy to say that, but you also need some like fundamental innovation to replenish this. So in a lot of ways, I think that what we're doing is part of that feedback cycle
SPEAKER_01of allowing new imaginations and new technologies to be developed on top of them. The most lizard-brained example of this in the portfolio is robot dogfighting. That one tends to stand out and grab people's attention for obvious reasons. Really cool group of founders, Ben, Edwin, and Sharna. Their thinking is like, What is combat sport for the AI era? What is the new relationship that AI promises for entertainment?
SPEAKER_01And what I think is maybe the more philosophical aspect, I'm not asking them to forward this kind of thinking, but if we're adopting that battalion framework of the accursed share, Right now you've got all this defense tech energy that's happening in Silicon Valley. And it's like, you build all those weapons. They don't just sit on the shelf. But if we could have this kind of new entertainment product, it's a much better outcome for where those things go than being used against people. I can go on about all the different founders. I mean, I'd love to champion all of them.
SPEAKER_00That's the origin of sport, right? It's like we've got to do something with all of this energy so that we don't just go to war. And that gets back to the evolutionary utility of play. But I actually do, because you mentioned Sextech founders exploring robots entering our spaces, which I thought was hilariously on the nose. I want to end here because at least ostensibly this show is helping people do the avant-garde thing and estrange themselves in good ways, right? So you asked this question about why does everything in the near future either want
SPEAKER_00to kill you or get you off that I thought was brilliantly parsimonious. And I just want to say this is your chance, I guess, to speculate what all of this that we're talking about now do you think is going to open up for us? Like, what do you actually see and what do you actually want in the future? What is that? What does that world actually feel like and look like? And just to give you a prompt to go off of, I've been hinting at this for the entire conversation, that I think that we can look at the last hundred years or so as a world
SPEAKER_00Where The Most Luxurious Thing Is To Engage In The Pursuit Of Self-Actualization And Everyone Else Is Just Trying To Get By And That Maybe What The Next Economy Offers Is That Self-Actualization Is Actually Like The Low Rung But That The Economic Pressure Is On Self-Transformation On Continual Learning On Discovery It turns out that the lowest rungs of the economy are going to be the people
SPEAKER_00that consider themselves fixed, that there is an essential or authentic self to satisfy. And we can already see this. It's like if you have a legible job category you're searching for on LinkedIn, by the time you find it, there's already 100 people who have applied. And those islands are drying up. And it feels like the movement of history is into a world where people are freed from having to settle into something legible because,
SPEAKER_00again, the real value is in contextually assisted mass parallel search of an expanding adjacency. So that vibe is going to be scary to a lot of people because it means you don't get to rest on your laurels. But it's going to be exciting for a lot of people who felt like they were never able to bring their full self to work. So that kind of stuff, I'd love to hear Yeah, I think I might disappoint you.
SPEAKER_01And the reason is that I could say some things about cybernetic human enhancements and new forms of governance and the atoms Looking Different and all of these sci-fi imaginaries or whatever we might call them, bringing those into more reality. And I sort of feel these days that that is the job of a past version of my That Would Have Been What My Academic Self Would Have Wanted To Do And Love To Do
SPEAKER_01And Now When You Say What Do I Want I Have A Much Clear Answer That Actually Feels A Lot Better So What Do I Want To See In The Future I Want to have this community of potential artist founders, people who consider themselves avant-garde creators or thinkers or experimenters, have more opportunities to attain the kind of funding that will allow them to Begin, scale, fully pursue their self-estrangement, in our case, in the form of products.
SPEAKER_01My job mission now is to be an opener of doors for that kind of person and to try and build an institution that facilitates that. So in that, I think my sort of academic role responsibility is to develop questions. And to the luxury technology point, I think of as a question. I have some answers, but my best answers are, here's what the founders are working on. And it's like, I'm developing a question and a format for helping them to develop answers.
SPEAKER_01And so I think the hope is more experiments, more products, more options, healthier society. But I can tell you like maybe the healthier society is sort of down the road. I go back to that conversation I was referencing with Flora and something she said to me that really stuck out was that it's not possible to experience the true joy of freedom alone. And I was kind of like, Oh, damn, that's powerful.
SPEAKER_01And I had to think about that for a while. And it rings true with a lot of what we've been doing at Restless Egg and what Restless Egg is about. Because for me, a big problem that I ended up having with the Academy was that it felt like oftentimes, who was I doing it for? You know, if somebody was driving home and their car broke down, nobody was calling me being like, hey, my car broke down. Can you give me a quick lecture on cybernetics? And It felt badly to not be of service to anyone.
SPEAKER_01And so I think that the point of Restless Egg is to leave the community of people better than we found it and to sort of bet on that the unique thing to humans is human relationality. And so I'll just say that the last bit, if you've read the newsletter, you see that I'm obsessed with this Brian Eno term, seniors, It's the best It's the best It's so good and so simple But if you haven't come across it Xenius just means the genius of the collective Rather than the individual genius who emerges from it And so if there's a kind
SPEAKER_01of what do I want final word It would be like do it for the Xenius
SPEAKER_00Honestly, I think your best future and my best future are the same thing. I'm talking about maybe what it looks like at one level, and you're talking about how it actually happens and your place in the underlying mechanism. Once again, we vibe hard every time we speak, and thank you for taking the time to do this. But more importantly, thank you for being the kind of person who wants this future.
SPEAKER_01I appreciate it and I think what I would say to that is that I'm not sure it's some sort of like inbuilt thing I feel that I have been given a great privilege of being around these incredible people and That has allowed me to find a lane and lean into it. If there's one piece of advice amidst the oncoming AI wave, it's that the Silicon Valley people like to talk about broadening the surface area
SPEAKER_01of experience, increasing is your amount of luck. I would say in the specific domain of human relation, broadening the surface area of that and doing cool experiments with people and just continuing to... Part of being avant-garde in the least elitist way is that anybody can try to be avant-garde. It's kind of like If you say you're trying to be avant-garde, you are. So I would encourage anyone who is considering the artist-founder pathway
SPEAKER_01or even looking for a way into this. It's like double down on the human relation side, see what's friction-y in there, where creativity, taste, culture, whatever spark and where you feel them brushing up against estrangement, then follow that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, which means I guess, thanks for listening, but this is a parasocial relationship. Go find the real people that you can be weird with right now and run more experiments. Hell yeah. Thanks, man.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. It's a pleasure.
SPEAKER_00Thanks again for listening. Humans On The Loop is a labor of love. If you want more of this in the world, consider becoming a member at michaelgarfield.substack.com. You can also support the show with tax-deductible donations at every.org slash humansontheloop and then maybe I can finally hire an editor to spend more time on writing and research. More writing and conversations are on the way including the first in a series
SPEAKER_00of extremely heady dialogues with my friend Cognitive Neuroscientist Adam Saffron of Tufts University on the current state of scientific exploration into world models, human, machine, and otherwise. Until then, stay tuned and remember the words of René Dumas, The door to the invisible must be visible.
With AI on everyone’s mind, we have to ask: what does it mean to think? When does the brain actually create predictive models and rely on mental representations - and when is it really just a matter of inputs and...
For Part Two in our Continual Learning mini-series, Dr. Nadav Amir of The University of Ottowa joins me and guest co-host Dr. Adam Safron of Tufts University for a trialogue on the fundamental role of goals in...
What does it actually mean for a machine to “understand” the world? Are today’s auto-regressive LLMs truly reasoning, or is statistical text prediction fundamentally distinct from genuine deliberative agency and causal...
✨ Become a founding member to access my online courses, including Jurassic Worlding and How To Live In The Future ✨ Browse and buy the books we mention on the show at Bookshop.org ✨ Stream and download my music at...
✨ Become a founding member to access my online courses, including Jurassic Worlding and How To Live In The Future ✨ Browse and buy all of the books we discuss on the show at Bookshop.org ✨ Stream and download my music...