General Contractor Career: Real Pay, Markups, and How a Woman Built a Renovation Business
23 minAudio
How much do general contractors make, and how do they price a renovation? On this episode of How Much Can I Make?, Nina Simon tells how she went from teaching French to running Renaissance Renovations, her own general contracting company in New York City. It started when the toilet in her Lower East Side apartment broke in half, she had to fix it and never looked back. Over more than 40 years she became one of the few women owning a construction business in NYC. She explains what a general contractor actually does, how it differs from a project manager, and what it’s like to be the boss in a male-dominated trade. and why working under an experienced crew is a good way to break into the trades. Nina's website: https://www.renaissance-renovations.com/ Explore more business & entrepreneurship ideas ➡️ Send us Fan Mail Trying to figure out what career might actually fit you? Take my QUICK CAREER QUIZ and see your matches, NO EMAIL, NO HASSLE, just 5 questions ➡️ Visit howmuchcanimake.info Music credit: Kate Pierson & Monica Nation About the host: Mirav Ozeri has always been drawn to storytelling and journalism, especially the stories of everyday people. A former CBS Producer and a documentaries filmmaker. During her years at CBS, Mirav developed a television pilot built around a simple idea: giving people an honest look at what different careers are really like. Although the pilot was never picked up, the concept stayed with her. Years later, she brought it back as How Much Can I Make?, a podcast that explores real jobs, real stories, and the many paths people take to build a career.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Whenever I'd be presented with a project or a task or a situation, I would always ask, okay, what's the next step? That makes people engage in a different way. It instantly taught me how to make a team.
Mirav Ozeri - HostWelcome back to How Much Can I Make? The podcast about jobs and careers. My guest today has a great story. Nina Simon was teaching French when the toilet in her New York City apartment broke in half. Fixing it was the first step towards a career she never saw coming. For more than 40 years, Nina has worked in New York construction, first as a carpenter and then as a general contractor running her own company under the name Renaissance Renovations.
Mirav Ozeri - HostShe tells how she became the boss, what it takes to run a renovation project in a big city, and how she makes money doing it. Let's turn to Nina. First of all, thanks Nina for doing it. I really appreciate it.
SPEAKER_01Okay, my pleasure.
Mirav Ozeri - HostIt is very unusual to see a woman as a contractor, especially having their own business as a contractor. So why won't you walk me at the beginning? How did you get into it? How did you start?
SPEAKER_01I was a carpenter first, and I had an an apartment on Avenue C and 7th Street on the Lower East Side. I moved into the apartment in 77, and I was teaching French in New Jersey in a private school. Literally, when I walked in the apartment, the door slammed behind me, the toilet broke in half like a soft boiled egg. And that was my first plumbing job. Water was everywhere. It was shh so I had to figure it out. I didn't I must have had a pair of pliers.
SPEAKER_01I hope I did. I don't think I can do it with my hands. And then little by little I gutted that apartment and I started renovating it. Each time I took a wall down, I said, Oh, that's how they build a wall. I learned by demolition, I learned by doing, I learned by reading instructions on the back of materials.
Mirav Ozeri - HostReverse engineering the house. Yeah. The apartment.
SPEAKER_01And it took a long time because I was working, teaching, and at a certain point I started to do things in my apartment. People would come in and see and say, Oh, it's very nice, can you do that for me? I'm like, sure. Five dollars an hour, that's what I was charging. And I would make whatever it is they wanted while I'm also working on my own place. So my own place was in a state of disrepair for a long time. And then I had it's a it was a a very hippy-dippy school I was teaching in.
SPEAKER_01So I had the idea that I was gonna teach a class teaching young girls, high school age girls, to do construction. Oh, what year was that? That ha had to be in the s late seventies. Yeah, go on. And I would take these girls with their fingernails to my apartment and I would give them a hammer and uh instructions and we'd say maybe three or four girls at a time. We'd rip something out. I'm gonna rip out this window. So we rip out the window together, and they get this thrill and the powerful feeling of being able to do this.
SPEAKER_01I knew that we weren't going to put the new window in. I knew it was like to motivate me. So once I had a huge hole in the wall, I had to put the window in, and I did. So that was really the very early And any of those girls end up doing their own carpentry? Not those, but un later in 1980, I had an all-women crew, and some of those women went on to work in the trades. I wanted to have an all-woman crew because that suited my politics.
SPEAKER_01It was terrible, it was a terrible idea. I don't want to work on that closet today. I just don't feel like it. I'm like, we don't care what you feel like. Work on the closet.
Mirav Ozeri - HostBut I got the job done. So you were a carpenter as a result of that for a few years. On what kind of projects did you work?
SPEAKER_01I did bookcases and doors and I did sheetrocking.
Mirav Ozeri - HostWhere did you have all your saws and all that equipment?
SPEAKER_01In my apartment. It was it was then I stuck became the building manager. Okay. This was a a building with twenty-four apartments. It was not a co-op. It was we called it a de facto co-op.
Mirav Ozeri - HostOkay.
SPEAKER_01Which means an illegal co-op. Oh, okay. Because it w it was the late 70s. Squatters? We weren't quite squatters, but we didn't do it according to the books. We made our own thing. It was Avenue C and 7th Street. Nobody even knew that was part of the city. At a certain point, the lady next door to me, who happened to also have been a girlfriend of mine, wanted to renovate her apartment, soup to nuts, complete gut. She asked me to do it. So I couldn't do it and keep my teaching job.
SPEAKER_01It was just too much. At the same time, this there was the energy crisis. So at that time, the the tea the principal of the school said, We're only going to teach about energy. I taught French in women's studies. I'm like, you want me to teach about women's energy? You want me to give a poem of energy in French? Or what is it that you want me to do? He said, just make up a curriculum and submit it to me. I said, I have a better idea. Lay me off. He laid me off. I got$79 unemployment insurance.
SPEAKER_01Was that a week or a month? I don't remember. And that was that. That was the crossroads that life presented me. And I stepped on that path and I never looked back.
Mirav Ozeri - HostVery good. So that friend of yours that you renovated her apartment was your actually first job. That's right. As a carpenter, you're not sure.
SPEAKER_01As a soup as a soup to nuts renovation.
Mirav Ozeri - HostSo did you hire a crew?
SPEAKER_01What the A lot of it I did myself, but I did have to hire a plumber and an electrician, because those are skills I don't have.
Mirav Ozeri - HostSo besides of doing the work, you were the general contractor.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
Mirav Ozeri - HostWhat does a general contractor actually do?
SPEAKER_01What does an orchestra conductor do? He tells the violins when to come in, he tells them to whether they should be forte or pianissimo. That's what a contractor does. Organizes the whole thing, he has everything in her mind, and just manages everything, s works the schedule, interfaces with the client.
Mirav Ozeri - HostSo what is the difference between a project manager and a general contractor?
SPEAKER_01That's a great question. I do a lot of project management because a lot of time unless it's a really big job, there's overlap. But a project manager really should be there every day. The contractor doesn't have to be there every day, although I often am. Supplies come in, has to check the order, make sure that this one that everybody is where they need to be and they're guiding the tradesman. The tile guy has to do this before the plumber can do that. All of that stuff has to be managed. But to be honest, I do all of that.
SPEAKER_01I do that. I can maybe delegate to the project manager to call the plumber, but mostly I do it.
Mirav Ozeri - HostAnd so at the beginning you were just doing small things like your friends and I. At what point you decided this is it's a business?
SPEAKER_01To be honest, when my father died, my father was a very talented guy, but he was he was a real loser. He was a drunk. He was smart, but he made a bad marriage and choosing my mother and yeah, I just w it was violence, it was drinking, it was it was a messy place to grow up. It isn't that I consciously said I can't do better than him. I it was in my DNA to know that I could go to a certain point, but I couldn't be more successful than my father because I couldn't hurt his ego even more than it was hurt on a daily basis.
SPEAKER_01So he took pills to go to sleep, he took pills to wake up. It was a mess, yeah. Once he died, I hired a business coach and I said, I need you to teach me about business because I don't know how to make a living. I know how to do my work, but I don't know how to do a spreadsheet. I need help. I need a father. And so this guy, he was younger than me, he said but he basically just praised me. He said he showed me concrete things and he gave me good ideas, which I still use, but simple ideas.
Mirav Ozeri - HostLike what, for example?
SPEAKER_01For example, whenever I'd be presented with a project or a task or a situation, I would always ask, okay, what's the next step? Simple. That sentence that makes people engage in a different way than just telling them what to do. You draw them in, what's the next step? Oh, Nina, you should do this and that. Okay. And it instantly taught me how to make a team. Oh, instant by by doing that. And I always encourage my guys, we're a team.
SPEAKER_01If something goes wrong, it's just another thing on our to-do list.
Mirav Ozeri - HostSo now you have your own company and you're working in New York City, which is I know is very hard to work as a contractor in New York City just because of the red tape.
SPEAKER_01You get used to it. There is red tape, but now sometimes I'll work with a designer or if I have a project manager, they have to deal with the management. Go get the get the list of paperwork, get and fill it out, get the insurance, certain get the stuff.
Mirav Ozeri - HostGive me an example of projects that uh you work in and who is in your crew.
SPEAKER_01So twenty years ago I started working with this stone guy doing some he did my countertops. Very talented guy. He was my exclusive stone guy. He wanted to learn how to be a contractor. He asked me very politely if he could shadow me for a day or whatever amount of time. Sure, shadow me. So we went to a look at a job in Yonkers, and the lady showed us the house, needed this and that and the other thing. I gave her a bunch of ideas, and she's listening, and then she turns to him and says, What do you think?
SPEAKER_01He got a little flustered because he's there being a shadow, and he's a very smart man, and he said, I think what she said is right. And and he then elaborated on what he repeated what I said, basically. And she turned to us both and said, I like his idea better.
Mirav Ozeri - HostSo this brings me to the question I'm dying to know. As a woman in this industry, what kind of difficulties, besides that difficulty, for example, that she would automatically turn to him, take his answer, what kind of struggle above the profession did you have to go through?
SPEAKER_01People are jerks. I'd go in, I'd have my overalls and my tools hanging from my buckles, and I'd go to the lumber yard. Same lumberyard I used every day. So I would be there maybe three times a week buying materials. And the guy turns to me and says, So Nina, what do you do for a living? I said, I'm a baker. What do you do? Or even now, when I don't do the physical labor anymore, people think I'm the designer, I'm the decorator.
SPEAKER_01Which means I can always go in the front door. I don't go in the service door.
Mirav Ozeri - HostIs the pay different for women than or men in this industry?
SPEAKER_01In your case, you're the boss. I'm the boss, so I decide who gets what. And by the virtue of the fact that the boss is a woman, they have to be respectful. So I've had guys who were jerks and were rude to me. And I and they were gone. And they were gone. Jerk. I'm your boss. You may think I don't belong here because I'm a woman, but you're fired. Take your stuff and get out. Cool. Now, how do you decide how to price a job? I work with my partner and I'll make a scope of work.
SPEAKER_01I make my the most beautiful spreadsheets. I learned Excel. I work with my guys, say, okay, how many days do you think this is gonna take? What kind of material we make? And we estimate it and we come up with a number. I usually add to that number because it's never right. If a customer changed their mind, or there's something happens and it's there there is a thing that God invented for us and it's called the change order.
Mirav Ozeri - HostYes.
SPEAKER_01So there a customer changes her mind, no problem, we can do that. It's gonna cost this much time and this much money. And they can decide.
Mirav Ozeri - HostWhat is usually is the markup of a contractor on a twenty. Twenty percent. Twenty percent. Of every material that you buy as well? Pretty much.
SPEAKER_01I don't charge a fee for myself. I just put in a blanket percentage and hope for the best.
Mirav Ozeri - HostBut they have to give you some sort of a deposit so you can hire people?
SPEAKER_01They give me a third down, a third when the roughing is done, and we're closing up the walls, 23% at substantial completion, and the final ten percent on completion. That's how it is. Okay. I hired a lawyer to write a contract for me. So I have this contract that nobody can understand. I can't even read this thing. It's all gobbledygook. And there are some customers who read it and say, I d it's too restrictive, I don't want to work for you. And what my lawyer told me was if anybody runs away from this contract that I've written for you, thank your lucky stars and say goodbye.
SPEAKER_01So I give 'em my contract, they say they ask questions, I answer them to the best of my ability, and if they don't want to work with me, they don't.
Mirav Ozeri - HostOkay, so t give me an example, what a beginning carpenter can make.
SPEAKER_01I think they should be able to make depending on their level of skill. Like the guys at home de that are at Home Depot and the ice is picking up, guys will charge two hundred dollars a day.
Mirav Ozeri - HostOkay.
SPEAKER_01Just for to be laborers. So that's the base.
Mirav Ozeri - HostOkay.
SPEAKER_01And then you add on from based on their level of skill. They all have a daily rate. There's a guys at 200, guys at 250, there's guys at 300, there's guys at 500, the really skilled ones who lay the tile. Wow, they're 500 a day? They can get good money. Wow. Because it's very It's a skillful job. Real and it there's a lot of math. You want the center line, you want the tiles to end the same on e left and right. So you have to start in the middle and work out, and they're sitting there with pencil and paper and measuring, and they'll take a d a whole day to lay out the job before they even touch a tile.
SPEAKER_01That's real skill. And I'll look at them and I'll go, God bless you, and get out of the way. Who is in your crew? So I have my partner.
Mirav Ozeri - HostYes.
SPEAKER_01And he has his company.
Mirav Ozeri - HostSo the partner is the guy that you trained that you the chair is.
SPEAKER_01He's now my partner, that's right. And he's and we get along we get along beautifully. I'm I was I'm going to visit his family in Columbia next week, and we're just gr great friends.
Mirav Ozeri - HostOkay. So is your partner ever since then or when wow.
SPEAKER_01He's my partner, and he's he's respectful and he's he loves me and I love him, and it's it's great. We get along great. So he has his guys, he's got a t he's got tile guys, he's got and since he came to me to expand his business, he now has those professionals in his crew. Okay. And so I don't have my own crew, I have him. Yeah, you have him. That's good. At another point in time I had multiple crews. But it was actually after the pandemic.
SPEAKER_01And when the pandemic happened and the city shut down, I got an invoice from my insurance carrier that said, Your premium is due forty thousand dollars. I'm like, hello, I'm not working. I'm not paying forty thousand dollars for insurance that I'm not I'm to sit in my living room. I don't need that. So my insurance lapsed. And he, because he has a big company and he has trucks and he has machines and he has da-da, he didn't lapse his insurance. So I said, Okay, I'll work with you.
SPEAKER_01So I work under his insurance and it's all completely legal.
Mirav Ozeri - HostI was gonna ask you, how much did it cost? What kind of insurance? You have to have liability, you have to have uh scalm.
SPEAKER_01You and you have to have they want you to have insurance on your truck, they want you to have insurance on your uh your own vehicle, they want you to have in your left hand should have insurance on your right hand.
Mirav Ozeri - HostThey just it's uh how much money you have to pay a year for you for all those insurances, you think?
SPEAKER_01Sixty I charge every client. There's a line item in my estimate that is insurance.
Mirav Ozeri - HostOkay.
SPEAKER_01It's usually twenty five hundred dollars per job. Give me an example of the kind of jobs you do now. Um let's see. Right now I'm finishing up this lovely lady. It's a gut renovation, small apartment, a one-bedroom apartment. And it's got it was a gut. We're gonna be at substantial completion next week.
Mirav Ozeri - HostOkay, you get 23%.
SPEAKER_01I'll get my 23%. I'm like, can you hook up the cooktop already? I can't build her until the cooktop is working. I have a bunch of bids out, for example. I have a a lay a repeat customer, I did her bathroom, I did built-in radiators. She wants some more radiators. The designer I work with is moving in with her boyfriend and blah blah and she wants her apartment picked up. So the budget, the range of the budgets of projects that you work on. A big job for me will be combining two apartments.
SPEAKER_01That's my favorite thing to do. How many of those do I get a year? Maybe one, maybe two, if I'm lucky. I get a lot of bathrooms. To do a gut bathroom, it is about forty thousand dollars, something like that. To rip it out, to get them change all the plumbing pipes, g getting a new sh getting a shut off from the super, putting in new valves, and there's all kinds of requirements, it has to have a check valve, has to have this, it has to have that. I need to know all that.
SPEAKER_01I need to m make sure that's all done, because if it's not done, they're gonna shut me down.
Mirav Ozeri - HostYou mentioned before that you love doing de combining apartments. So do you need to work with an engineer and an architect to break a wall, to break a door?
SPEAKER_01Need drawings. That's a job that has to be filed with the city, and you have to make sure you're not knocking down any load-bearing walls, you need to do the plumbing, you know the electrical, you need inspections.
Mirav Ozeri - HostIt's so the preparation for a job like two apart combining two apartments, how long of a preparation? Just the paperwork with a city.
SPEAKER_01Oh my god, it could take three months. And you go back and forth and back and forth, and they say, Yes, you can do that, and then they say, Oh no, we didn't realize you were doing that. Now you can't do that, you can do this, you can do the other thing.
Mirav Ozeri - HostHow many projects can you juggle in the same time?
SPEAKER_01So I can do four or five. I don't always have four or five. And with this lady that's just finishing, she had three she gave me three apartments to do in three different addresses. So that was like three jobs. It was all for her, but that was so great.
Mirav Ozeri - HostWhat's the biggest challenge of being a contractor in New York City and also being a woman contractor?
SPEAKER_01So the the negative of being a woman contractor, the negative meaning the unpleasantness that people are jerks sometimes. So they're jerks whether you're a woman carpenter or a woman contractor or an astronaut.
Mirav Ozeri - HostRight. And what is the biggest challenge as the just as the profession of a contractor?
SPEAKER_01Management. The city, the inspectors. It's getting worse and worse. The whole gas thing, for example. A few buildings blew up with gas lines. Now, if a client comes to me and says, I want to move my gas line, I'm like, redesign your kitchen and leave your gas where it is. The architect doesn't understand. You need to leave the stove exactly where it is. Maybe you can move it 18 inches. That's it. So it's the city regulations that are really bust our chops.
SPEAKER_01And what is the biggest reward? Oh, it's to see a job and see it when it comes together. You envision it and you and then it comes together and it's a beautiful thing. And when the client is happy, I live to make the clients happy.
Mirav Ozeri - HostSo you see it through the painting and the colors and the furniture, you come at the end with a cake and telling them.
SPEAKER_01I don't care about the furniture. As the contractor, as the the one who where the buck stops here, I can walk into the apartment from the front door to the back of the third bedroom and back and see things that my guys haven't seen by standing there all day. Because my eyes are fresh, my eyes are critical, and I'm there representing the client. Even when I bad mouth still representing them. So and how do you get your clients?
SPEAKER_01Is it word of mouth? Only word of mouth. I've never, ever advertised. I have a website, everybody tells me it's terrible. How did you pick up the name Renaissance? So I was a French teacher, so I was a French major. I dropped out of a master's program in French literature to become a carpenter many years ago. And that was a big change. That was a rebirth, Renaissance. I rebirthed myself when I started Renaissance. Of course, I didn't realize at that time that nobody but nobody knows how to spell Renaissance.
Mirav Ozeri - HostIf somebody wants to get into the business of contracting, what do they need to do first?
SPEAKER_01I think they should learn something first. A lot of guys just go in, got my hand on a hammer, I'm a contractor. No, you're a jerk with a hammer in your hand. You're not you need to learn. So I went to school, I went to Parsons for interior design. They taught me about layout and lighting and things like in color. To see color is huge. You need to learn that. You don't just have it innately. So I think the first thing to do is to get some knowledge. It's a great way to earn a living.
SPEAKER_01It's really yeah, you're productive, you it's just a great way to earn a living. You have to keep in shape because you have to carry equipment, you have to What I say is I want to I don't carry anything, I point. But I say I started my own company because I didn't want someone stupider than me telling me what to do. I want to be the boss. And it's really quite pleasant. Excellent. Just like you're the boss.
Mirav Ozeri - HostExcellent. All right. Thank you. This is it for today. If this is not the right career for you, maybe there's a better one waiting. Take the five question career quiz on my website. How much can I make that info? And learn about careers that fit the lifestyle you want. No email, no registration, just five questions. And don't forget to give us a like, it really helps. Thanks. I'll see you next week.
A dance can look effortless. Making a living from it takes grit, creativity, and sometimes a one-way ticket with no guarantees. New York-based choreographer and director Mandie Rapoza takes us behind the scenes of a...
Could your next job be managing AI agents? At 19, Laurits Wehding is already doing it, without a university degree or coding skills. Joining me from Sweden, Strawberry’s founding operator shares how he landed the role,...
We talk with book doula Michelle Fiordaliso about what it really takes to bring a book to life, from finding your voice to choosing a publishing path. We also get honest about author income, ghostwriting rates, AI in...
“Save until it slightly hurts” sounds harsh, but it might be the most realistic wealth-building advice you’ll hear all year. We sit down with Donna Stephens, a seasoned financial advisor who also brings an attorney’s...
Everyone’s talking about the jobs AI might replace. But what about the jobs it’s creating? In this episode I talk with Meg Columbia Walsh about where the new AI career opportunities are, what kinds of jobs are already...