Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Hostage to the Devil

Hostage to the Devil artwork

Demonic Foes with Dr. Gallagher

Jul 24, 20241 hr 11 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail Psychiatrist Dr. Richard Gallagher speaks with Marty about his experiences working on cases described as demonic oppression and possession. Recorded in September 2018, the interview explores the experiences discussed in his book Demonic Foes. Episode links and sources: https://amzn.eu/d/06DzQcfz Music by Andrew Simon McAllister. Produced by Causeway Pictures and Scattered Images. Support the show MARTY STALKER PODCAST STORE CAUSEWAY PICTURES SEE HOSTAGE TO THE DEVIL DOCUMENTARY - UK / US / CAN IRISH GOTHIC: Apple Podcasts / Spotify Support the shows and browse official Causeway merchandise, including Irish Gothic, Unknown Skies and Hostage to the Devil designs, at the Causeway Producer Store: https://shop.causewaypictures.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01You are listening to the Hostage to the Devil podcast. Some listeners may find this content disturbing.

SPEAKER_02Tell me through your professional accreditation then and how long you've been working in the field of psychiatry.

SPEAKER_00I've been a psychiatrist for about 30 years. I've been involved in consulting on cases of possible demonic uh oppression or possession for about 25. My present position, I'm a professor of uh psychiatry at a medical college and also a psychoanalyst on the faculty of Columbia. Uh I trained at Yale. I was a classics major at Princeton, so I had a pretty good background to be going into this work.

SPEAKER_00Well, first of all, I never volunteered for anything, but I've had uh back 25 years ago, I had uh a couple of priests, especially a uh very prominent American exorcist who asked me to consult on a case. And like all these cases, it was an odd case. Uh and uh eventually my role was to confirm that this was not some kind of psychiatric condition.

SPEAKER_00Most people who think they're possessed or oppressed are suffering from a medical illness, and it's usually psychiatric. Um but then there are these cases, and I have seen scores and scores of cases, uh hundreds really, um, which would imply that it's not so rare, but it is rare. Uh, nevertheless, I've seen these cases, and they always have some element that clearly goes beyond the medical or the or the psychiatric.

SPEAKER_00And that that was my conclusion. It was the priest himself who made the official discernment, but I uh agreed with him that this particular woman who was oppressed, not possessed, oppressed, uh clearly had something in the range of the paranormal, and it could clearly not be um conceptualized as a uh psychiatric condition.

SPEAKER_02From a faith point of view, were you a Catholic all your life? And if so, was it strengthened by what you'd seen 25 years on, you know, or were you always a devout Catholic from day one?

SPEAKER_00Um I was baptized a Catholic and I was brought up Catholic. Like a lot of, you know, young men, uh I certainly questioned it. Uh and I would say that my involvement in this field, a pretty heavy involvement, uh done pro bono, but uh, you know, uh something I found of interest. Um it certainly it certainly strengthened my faith.

SPEAKER_02I wanted to put the purely scientific head on here with the next question. Obviously, there's a lot of signs that investigators and exodus look for in a case, you know. Can you give me a scientific explanation of the following? Like number one, um, a person in the room that's being exercised exhibits superhuman strength. How can science sort of um give an explanation for that?

SPEAKER_00Well, there are different psychiatric conditions. Uh, the one that's cited a lot, and you know, I'm a very experienced clinical psychiatrist, so you know, I've seen thousands and thousands of psychiatric patients, including hundreds who have mania. And people, for instance, who suffer from bipolar disorder and then have a manic episode, they may exhibit very high levels of uh strength. The signs of possession, including, you know, what's sometimes called supernatural or prenatural strength, go so far beyond the psychiatric that it becomes obvious you're dealing with something more.

SPEAKER_02And what about a person reacting aggressively to holy water and crucifixes and again you could have a suggestible person uh who knows that it's blessed or something.

SPEAKER_00But uh again, if if sometimes you do uh sort of a test to the person, uh uh they don't know whether it's holy water or not, and they have a very strong reaction. Having said this, a lot of people focus on the individual signs and the suggestive criteria classically in the Catholic tradition about discerning a possession or superhuman strength, um speaking in different languages.

SPEAKER_00Speaking in different languages, uh extreme aversion to sacred things, as well as the possession of hidden knowledge or knowledge from a distance. Um those signs are very suggestive and they're very important. But you always have to go on the totality of what's going on. For instance, you'll have those signs in a genuine possession, pretty pretty invariably, although there are a few exceptions, but you'll also have a context.

SPEAKER_00This is a person who may have been involved in Satanism, or at least heavily into the occult, or this may be a person who turns strongly to evil as several factors. Um and in addition, there will be such a difference between their presentation, you know, with or without the uh the paranormal signs, uh, that, in my opinion, um you normally can easily distinguish it from a psychiatric or medical disorder.

SPEAKER_00But you have to know all the facts. And a lot of times people, you know, hear one thing and and they they credit that. I mean, a very good example would be levitation. Uh now I've never seen levitation, but I've talked to about ten different priests, all of whom swore to me that they had a case of levitation during their exorcism. For instance, a woman I evaluated very closely, uh, I call her Julia.

SPEAKER_00I've written about her academically. Uh I had about eight people who were at her exorcism say that she levitated. Uh I had the wife of a gentleman who was a gangster, uh, had turned to evil. Uh, the woman I just referred to had turned to Satanism. So there was the context for their possession. But there's no question that these people, uh that some rare cases of possession, and even in possession it's rare, have levitated.

SPEAKER_00But other other people throughout history have also levitated. For instance, some of the great saints have levitated. Uh there are occultists throughout history who purportedly, and I believe it, have levitated. So you can never uh separate out one symptom and say that proves uh possession or oppression for that matter. You have to look at the totality. And that's what a lot of people unfortunately don't do.

SPEAKER_02Well, I was chancing Matt Baglou in Rome, he he talked about his own experiences working with psychiatrists and obviously observing some of these exorcisms taking place. One of the things that a lot of scientists that he spoke to in psychiatrists really couldn't get their head around was this um knowledge of hidden things about somebody in the room or themselves. You know, can you give me your own personal experiences on this about how someone's had hidden knowledge about yourself and no?

SPEAKER_00This is clearly in the realm of paranormal that the possessed and sometimes the oppressed individuals would have this hidden knowledge, knowledge of faraway things. Uh some people say knowledge of the future, which is not true. Spirits and uh the church teaches both angels and devils and demons do not know the future. Only God knows the future. But they can have pretty good guesses about the future.

SPEAKER_00But their knowledge, which is called in Latin lettra, uh and usually translated as hidden knowledge, uh, it's absolutely a um a sign that you're dealing with something uh paranormal. And and psychics can tap into that realm too, uh, perhaps in unsavory ways. Uh the Satanist woman that I referred to, uh, for instance, knew all kinds of things.

SPEAKER_00Um she knew how my mother died, which was ovarian cancer. But she didn't know just how my mother died. She knew how about ten other people's parents had died. Now, unless she was, you know, I mean, you have to use your common sense, uh, unless people think she was researching hospital records and stuff, it it staggers the mind to believe that she didn't know that through hidden knowledge.

SPEAKER_00A more dramatic example of her hidden knowledge was she told me once that she had something which the parapsychologist called remote viewing. She could see things at a distance. And and she clearly believed it was not some ability of the human mind, but that it was conveyed to her by demonic uh intelligence.

SPEAKER_00And she said to me once, and I decided to challenge her on it, she said, Well, I can see the exorcist. I said, What are you talking about? You can see the exorcist right now. She says, Yes. Now I had the guy's cell phone. Uh the the chief exorcist on her case, whom she was talking about, um, was a good friend of mine. So I said, Well, you know, describe, describe what he's doing now.

SPEAKER_00She says, he's walking along the beach near his house, and he sang his brevery. And I said, What is he dressed in? She said he has a blue windbreaker and he has khaki pants on. I call her by the pseudonym Julia, of course I would never reveal anybody's name. And I said to Julia, I said, Well, listen. I was tempted to say Miss SmartyPants.

SPEAKER_00I said, Listen, uh, Julia, I'm gonna call him. So I called him. Uh he called himself by a pseudonym, uh Father A. So I said, Father A, um, who was also one of the founding members of the International Association of Exorcists, by the way, it's very little known. I said, Father A, uh, you know, what are you doing at the moment? And he said, Well, I'm usually at home, but I decided to, you know, take a walk uh along the beach.

SPEAKER_00And I said, What are you doing? I said, I'm saying the divine office, I'm saying my prayers. And I said, and what are you dressed in? So he said, Rich, I know what's going on. So I said, What? He said, You're talking to Julia, right? And I said, Yes, just answer the question. He said, Well, I have a windbreaker on, and I have my khakis on. He was actually an ex-military guy. And uh I said, What color is the windbreaker?

SPEAKER_00And he said, blue. And he said to me, I'll bet you she told you all that, right? She's amazing, isn't she? I told you she was amazing. And it was. It was it was by far the most dramatic case of possession that I've ever encountered. And that even these two experienced exorcists who work with her, it was, in their view, the most flamboyant possession they ever witnessed. And they were incredibly experienced.

SPEAKER_02It's great. Okay. Let's get back into the mind of the skeptic then. The science uh the science are in general terms, can you list what professional skeptics or scientists, psychiatrists believe the demonic symptoms to be, you know, gin generic terms, you know, uh multiple personalities sort of? Can you just sort of list um if someone was to watch this now and go, oh no, it's all it's all baloney, it's it's it's gotta be multiple personalities. Can you just sort of list the the the possible um examples of what a skeptical scientist would be?

SPEAKER_00Well, first of all, skeptical people, in my opinion, um have never seen a genuine case. So they just assume there must be some other explanation, and in modern times, and there are other alternative theories too, but in modern times most um skeptics kind of put it in the realm of mental pathology. So they may say, well, this is a psychotic individual who only thinks demons are talking to them or giving them knowledge, and that they have good guesses.

SPEAKER_00Uh or they are severely personality disordered people, like sociopaths or individuals who suffer from borderline personality who have a sense of evil inside. Or they may be suggestible or histrionic people who are misled into thinking that, including a subset of the suggestible, which is multiple personality, which is more technically called dissociative identity disorder.

SPEAKER_00Now, I can say unequivocally, I mean, I'm a very experienced psychiatrist. I know schizophrenics who think they're attacked by demons. I know people with multiple personality. I've seen over a hundred multiple personality cases in my life. It's often thought to be, by the way, an atrogenic diagnosis or a diagnosis that is stimulated by people's reading about other cases. So it's it remains a controversial diagnosis.

SPEAKER_00I'm not saying that there isn't legitimate phenomenology captured by that term, but it's a little bit of a dicey diagnosis to begin with. In any case, when you look at these cases, whether they're psychotic patients, patients with a strong sense of evil inside, or suggestible and dissociative individuals who may be diagnosed as multiple personalities, if you really get to know the case, they are in no way comparable to possessed cases, if you know all the facts.

SPEAKER_00A lot of people don't know all the facts, or they just assume that, well, you know, that must be the explanation of what people are mistaking for a possession. And I say to people, you know, how many psychiatric patients do you know who levitate, who speak foreign languages, you know, who can tell you how ten people they know, how they died, who can see a priest at a distance. That's what possessed and oppressed people can.

SPEAKER_00Uh, I've never met a psychiatrist. I've probably treated or consulted in my life, because I've been a very busy psychiatrist my whole life. I'm a professor of psychiatry. I probably evaluated directly about 25,000 cases. None of these patients had those paranormal powers. In fact, nobody who came into my office as a psychiatric patient did I ever think was possessed. The reason I can talk about these cases, and I've seen many, many cases, but it's because they've been referred to me actually from all over the world, but especially from all over the United States.

SPEAKER_00And so I'm seeing these rare bunch of people, and they meet the criteria of the Roman ritual for these paranormal or preternatural powers. Medical cases don't, psychiatric cases don't. It's a very distinct, it's they're two separate distinct groups. Although you have to have an open mind and you have to know all the facts. The skeptics do not seem to have encountered those cases.

SPEAKER_00Or if they do, they they just try to explain away symptoms which cannot be explained away as psychiatric or medical.

SPEAKER_02You mentioned it before. Can we talk about the, and you mentioned it quite a lot in your articles? Can you talk about the Julia case from start to finish then?

SPEAKER_00Just Julia, and of course, I always use a pseudonym, was a uh unfortunate woman, tragic case, of a woman who at a young age had turned to Satanism. She was a member of a satanic cult, uh, and she literally uh worshipped Satan. And she had a kind of uh diabolic philosophy of life, which she would expound. In the course of this, not surprisingly, because this is one of the reasons someone would get possessed, uh I try not to freak out the public because I say, you know, this is not just all of a sudden going to happen to anybody.

SPEAKER_00You know, there there are reasons that possessions happen. And uh she became possessed, and despite the fact that she was still in the cult, the satanic cult, uh, and and we had brief encounters with some other people in the cult who hated what I was doing, but especially hated what the exorcists were trying to do with Julia and made threats.

SPEAKER_00Um despite her remaining in the cult, she wanted to be relieved of the possession, which is kind of a contradiction in terms. You know, people sometimes think exorcism is a magic ceremony. The prayers are important, but the inner spiritual battle, the need to struggle and turn to our Lord is just as important a part of the successful liberation.

SPEAKER_00So she had a clear possession, and she had the whole nine yards. I mean, she had clear hidden knowledge, um telling me uh how my mother died, telling other people how they died, uh their parents died, uh, seeing people from a distance. I recounted the story of the Exorcist, but she could do that with other people too. Uh during the Exorcisms, she spoke multiple uh foreign languages, which, you know, she was a she was a savvy enough woman in her own satanic way, but she was not an educated person.

SPEAKER_00There's no way she knew those languages. Um exhibiting all kinds of you know weird phenomena during the exorcisms. And again, none of this unprecedented, but in its totality fairly flamboyant. For instance, you know, at times during an exorcism the room became very cold. That's been reported in other cases. At other times the room became stifling hot so that everybody would sweat. Uh the exorcist, again, the same uh man I referred to before, who was incredibly experienced, said, I feel like I was at the gates of hell.

SPEAKER_00Um and and this is a woman, this is one of those cases, and I've heard about directly, of course, read about many more, but directly uh uh spoken to priests and family members uh about this phenomena. Uh she levitated for about a half an hour during her last exorcism. So uh to be clear, she was sitting in a chair, she was being held down, and for about a half an hour she rose from the chair.

SPEAKER_00Now, eight people, observers, told me they saw this, they had to hold her down, else they felt she would have ascended further. Again, it staggers the imagination to believe. That eight good-hearted, salt of the earth people are just going to make up this story about me, especially in the context of this dramatic satanic uh possession.

SPEAKER_00So these are the kinds of things that not only prove she was possessed, but uh were constantly witnessed by multiple people, including myself and uh certain of the paranormal uh features. So people always ask me, well, what happened to Julia? Well, it wasn't surprising, since she refused to leave the cult, that she was never delivered. Um I think it was a tragic case because I think she was basically afraid to leave the cult.

SPEAKER_00I think she was afraid that she would be harmed. Uh in addition, the cult had been her world. You know, she said to me at one point, um, one of the reasons I'm in the cult is because I love the powers I have. Another reason is the sex. And she said, uh every anybody who doesn't think satanic uh cults are full of sex doesn't know what they're talking about. Um be that as it may, she was afraid to leave the cult.

SPEAKER_00It was a kind of substitute family for her, and she never wound up doing that. And not surprisingly, she was not delivered. And eventually eventually, you know, uh we were told, she told me, that she was dying.

SPEAKER_02Was there a was there a time when um when you were on the phone dexist and you had the demonic voice come through?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I was trying, you know, I was a busy professional and and I I was never able to attend one of her series of exorcisms. She had about eight. And uh one night the assistant exorcist, she needed two exorcists, the assistant exorcist said to me, Well, why don't you come to so-and-so uh you know parish at this particular time? And um while I was talking on the phone with him, this was these were landlines, um a voice came in over the phone saying, I told you, you effing priest, leave her alone.

SPEAKER_00She's ours. Which sounded exactly like the voice that came out of her at a time when she was sitting in the backseat of a car while uh I was going through the evaluation process with her. Um and so I said to the exorcist, you know, gosh, did you hear that? And he said, yes. He said, in an incredibly dramatic possession such as this of a Satanist, uh, you can these things can happen.

SPEAKER_00Now, she wasn't just a Satanist, she was the high priestess of a satanic group. I don't want to go into detail, she was also a breeder for the group. So she had attained a very high status, and I'm sure the demonic world did not want to let her go.

SPEAKER_02Obviously, keep you can keep names out of this, but um, how do you become involved with the International Association of Exorcists and what was that experience like to be involved in the R.

SPEAKER_00Again, everything I've done, uh, you know, I've been asked to do. So I was asked by two American priests who were at the time there weren't that many American exorcists. So these guys would travel all over the country. Sometimes I would go with them, and that's why I saw so many cases. Uh now there are many more exorcists, and they're usually confined to their diocese. So an individual exorcist even would see much less cases than these two gentlemen with me were accustomed to evaluating.

SPEAKER_00So they, uh, especially Father A was very instrumental in getting together with a group of exorcists around the world, which included Father Gabriela Morth from Rome, in founding this organization. And uh since I work so closely with them, they said, Well, you know, Rich, why don't you come over to the meetings? And uh a few years later, for a brief period of time, I was on the uh governing board as a scientific advisor.

SPEAKER_00Um this is with a um uh a later president who was a wonderful priest named Father Giancarlo uh Gramolazzo. Um and I've just been, at this point, I'm the longest standing American participant. I've just continued to go to their biennial meetings. Uh the organization, and I don't like to mention too many priests' names because uh most of them, you know, I'm very discreet in in revealing any names, but uh the people I've mentioned are kind of public about it, and the present uh president is a very able uh scholarly man and a very experienced exorcist named Francesco Bomanti.

SPEAKER_00And uh he has contributed to uh the growth of the organization, which now includes four or five hundred priests.

SPEAKER_02Where are you now with regards to your work next to them? Are you still involved? Are you delegating all cases to colleagues, or what where are you actually now 25 years on?

SPEAKER_00I'm uh I'm as busy as I've ever been in evaluating cases. And uh I I try to respond, I can't respond to all cases. Uh, but at this point I get calls and emails from all over the world.

SPEAKER_02Um this might be hard to answer. Well, if I give it a sort of percentage or maybe a ratio, how how many of the the demonic possession and oppression cases that were deferred to you were actually legit legitimate cases, some of percentage point view. It's very quite hard to answer.

SPEAKER_00You can't really talk about percentages uh easily because uh it depends on who's referring you the cases. Uh for instance, I've mentioned that I've evaluated as a professional, having nothing to do with this field, about 25,000 cases, psychiatric cases. None of them were possessed. On the other hand, of the cases that I'm referred from knowledgeable clergy, and I've worked with clergy of many different faiths.

SPEAKER_00I mean, certainly Catholic but Protestant, uh Hindu practitioners, Imams, rabbis. Uh I prefer to get referrals from clergy because then I I expect that there'll be some kind of spiritual follow-up and support. Plus, because they're referred by clergy, uh, they've been screened a bit. So of those cases referred by clergy, the percentage who have something diabolic, either possession or much more commonly oppression, is actually fairly high because they've already been screened.

SPEAKER_00So as a whole, I mean, you know, given how many people I know in this field and that I've attended the international meeting, of course, I've heard of hundreds of possessions and probably a couple of thousand oppressions. Myself, I've evaluated. I mean, these are people that I've evaluated in person. Uh I've certainly evaluated over a I mean, I've kind of stopped counting over a hundred cases of of clear-cut possession and at least several hundred cases of clear-cut oppression.

SPEAKER_00That can give the feeling that, oh that can give the impression that uh I'm seeing these people everywhere. And and that's misleading. First of all, I've been in this field for a long time, so that's the main reason I've seen these cases referred from legitimate sources. Uh but I would have to conclude that these are still very rare phenomena. They're rare phenomena which I've seen just because I've been so involved in the field, not because they're common.

SPEAKER_00I mean, your average psychiatrist may never see a case of this in their whole life, and probably wouldn't. In part because, too, uh, a lot of these people don't want to go to a psychiatrist because they just think they're going to be ruled crazy. When Julia first talked to me, uh, and she was required to talk to me by the priest, and she had been evaluated by several other mental health people as well, all of whom thought she was possessed, not just me.

SPEAKER_00And she said to me, Well, uh, Dr. Gallagher, uh, you know, I I'm always reluctant to go to a psychiatrist because I think that you guys are just gonna say I'm crazy and put me in a hospital. And I said, Well, unless I thought you were dangerous, I wouldn't put you into a hospital. But that's a typical reaction of someone who's suffering from a possession or a oppression. In other words, they think that uh they're just gonna be deemed crazy.

SPEAKER_02Are you seeing a rise in cases, demonic cases in the USA and globally as well?

SPEAKER_00Am I seeing a rise? It's a very good question. Um, because of all the publicity about it, uh I mean, even a movie like yours, uh, as well as all the films and shows about the paranormal, going back to the original Exorcist movie, which was stimulated and has continued to stimulate a lot of interest in this field, I think there are more people now who think they're attacked by demons.

SPEAKER_00There is also an opinion among a lot of people I respect that in the Western world, because in other areas of the world Christianity is growing, but in the Western world, where there's somewhat of a decline in traditional practice of Christianity and of Catholicism, um people have turned more to the occult. And that may have stimulated an increase in cases.

SPEAKER_00But these are hard, you know, I try to be scholarly about what I do, and these are hard statistics to come by. Uh so the impression is that uh there are more cases of possession and oppression. Uh I think it would be, you know, I'm trying to speak as a fairly scientifically ground person. Uh and I value science and mainstream science very highly. Uh I think it would be hard to prove that, but that seems to be the impression of an awful lot of people.

SPEAKER_02Um from the cases that were legit legitimate, what what are the common reasons for people being afflicted then? Is it messing with Ouija boards, mainly Satanism? You know, keeping it.

SPEAKER_00I don't think using a Ouija board or reading Harry Potter is automatically going to make somebody uh uh demonically attacked. But I would say a serious interest in occult forces um where the person kind of turns to that in a serious way for guidance uh is is a dangerous thing to do.

SPEAKER_00Um it doesn't usually lead to possession. It may it may contribute to an amount of people who are oppressed, as we call it. The people who get possessed are usually people who have very seriously turned to the occult, to evil, sometimes per se. Uh and and, you know, for instance, in the example of Julia to outright Satanism, that's the most common reason that people uh get possessed.

SPEAKER_00Although I have to emphasize, too, that uh because this is something that confuses people, you can be evil. You could be a serial killer, and and that person is not automatically and probably not usually at all possessed. So you can be evil without being possessed. There are some rare cases or rarer cases where people are possessed, they feel because they're under some kind of a curse, or sometimes people have almost voluntarily, as a kind of penance or substitute sacrifice, have invited the devil to attack them instead of doing something else.

SPEAKER_00Uh those cases are rare, but I I I believe that those are credible cases too, and avenues for possession. But the main reason people get possessed is they've turned to evil, they've turned to serious occultism, and uh even Satanism. The church is is very careful about screening people. And um the criteria are very strict. I mean, we talked a little bit before about the criteria.

SPEAKER_00It's not just the criteria, it's the overall pattern, it's the context, it's the reasons. If you take all these things into account, it's a very careful discernment that goes into why one would get diagnosed that in anticipation of the help that they're getting. For instance, it's almost impossible in America and in most of the developed world for a bishop to authorize a formal major exorcism without a very serious medical and psychiatric evaluation first.

SPEAKER_00And it is, it's a genuine from uh from a doctor's point of view, as I am. Uh it's a definite syndrome. It's not something that we just intuit or it's not something that willy-nilly we just have a sense about. I mean, you have to fill, you have to fulfill definite criteria. And and this is this is one of the reasons why the Catholic Church diagnoses it rarely and is careful to make sure that people who don't meet the criteria and who may well therefore be judged as suffering from a psychiatric or a medical disorder, uh, that these people receive the proper medical help.

SPEAKER_00I mean, people with psychiatric problems, and and there are many, for instance, schizophrenics who may think they're attacked by demons, these people need medical help and they respond to medical help. Whereas the possessed individual doesn't respond to medication or medical help, and they require uh something like an exorcism or at least serious spiritual help. A person with a spiritual problem requires a spiritual remedy.

SPEAKER_02So the priest exorcists that you've worked with 25 years, do they do you find that they have a sort of a common personality, like a common attribute to being in this field, this ministry? Do you feel like they have to have certain skills themselves and also certain per a certain personality to do what they do?

SPEAKER_00I think exorcists have a wide variety of personalities. What they have in common is they tend to be uh serious-minded, intelligent, uh, and generally holy men. Uh they're not supposed to be hysterical or jump to conclusions. They're supposed to be very discreet, and a lot of this is laid out in the uh in the ritual. Um the most important characteristic is that they be well trained and that they not jump to conclusions and that they don't rush into making a diagnosis.

SPEAKER_00So most of them, you know, are again sensible people. They will use medical input. Um they will not rush into dealing with a case until they're really sure of the whole story. Um so they tend to be wholly sensible people in my experience. Uh there may be exceptions, but those are those are the people that I work with. Uh if I have any questions about the um spiritual practitioner, I won't work with that person.

SPEAKER_02So let's talk about Father Maliki Martin then.

SPEAKER_00Talking about that experience and how many times you've met him or well I only met a I only met Father Martin a couple of times. Uh it was in the context of uh uh of of cases that I would be with one of the priests that I knew and worked with, and uh that person would uh bring in Father Martin to consult. Uh I found him erudite, I found him knowledgeable, uh I thought he was a bit of a character.

SPEAKER_00Uh maybe I should leave it at that. Uh but I I I I did feel that um he certainly was very sincere in in trying to help people. I had read his book. Uh I thought it was a little over-dramatic and a little stereotyped.

SPEAKER_00Each of the cases that he wrote about seemed to be fashioned in a literary way to prove an ideological point. And I believe Father Martin in his writings came off as a little over-dramatic and apocalyptic. Had a very dark view of where the world was going, which is which is not an unusual thing in religious history.

SPEAKER_00I mean, there have been many areas of history where, you know, the world's gonna end, the world's going to hell in a handbasket. Um, whatever one thinks of the state of Western society, uh I think his his view of um the level of demonic activity um was a little hyperbolic, and I think he emphasized the tremendous price, emotional and otherwise, that a uh an exorcist would um have to pay.

SPEAKER_00And I think it was a little unfortunate. I know many exorcists. I mean, uh I go to meetings with hundreds of them. Many are very delightful, happy, jovial people. They're not superficial people, but I think Father Martin's emphasis that sort of every exorcist was going to uh have a tragic life or something, uh was a little melodramor melodramatic.

SPEAKER_00And and I I do think uh as a character, uh I think he was both very knowledgeable uh but there was a little bit of blarney in some of what he would say too at times. That's my personal opinion. I'm I'm not I'm not criticizing him, you understand. I think he was a good man. Uh he undoubtedly had a complicated life, and uh he was personally very gracious to me.

SPEAKER_00Uh so nothing in what I've said should be taken as a serious criticism. Uh, but he was a human being, uh, with perhaps uh some some gifts and some flaws too.

SPEAKER_02Right. It's common knowledge that Father Martin used a lot of media um from the seventies onwards to help broadcast his message about a lot uh various topics, um, including the demonic. Do you believe?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think he was a singular character. Um at a time where uh there wasn't much knowledge of this whole field. Um but I've known uh scores of exorcists, I know scores of exorcists, and many of them are incredibly intelligent, wise, um, experienced exorcists, uh, and they're prudent too.

SPEAKER_00And uh I I would say that there are many exorcists uh who um yeah certainly certainly are as knowledgeable as as as Father Martin, who I've been told was primarily an assisting exorcist. Um But there there are many, many uh exorcists who have a lot of experience and and I've worked with some of them, and so although I was exposed to some of Father Martin's ideas early on, uh uh I I I've certainly learned just as much from from many subsequent exorcists that I've known and became friends with.

SPEAKER_02He had a well-known fear of the rise of Satanism in the USA and apparently documented an 800% rise in the late 1970s. I don't know where he got his statistics from, but do you believe personally there is a rise in Satanism and and more people become involved in the occult in America?

SPEAKER_00Do you think there is a problem, a map like a real problem here, or do you think it's uh Well, as I said, in in the Western world as a uh strong adherence to maybe traditional Christianity diminishes, it's going to be filled with something else. And so it may be filled with agnosticism, or it may be filled with, you know, new age or occult beliefs. There probably has been a rise in that. Um again, there is also, and I'll speak as a psychiatrist, who's who has studied memory and recovered memories and this sort of thing.

SPEAKER_00Uh there also at times has been an exaggerated hysteria about uh Satanism. I mean, I've heard many false stories about Satanists or people who feel they've been cursed by Satanists or abused by Satanists. This is not to trivialize the true demonic practitioners out there, but I think it would be very hard to prove that you know they're lurking around every corner.

SPEAKER_00Uh somebody told me once, and I don't know if this is true, that Father Martin once claimed, and this may not be true because there were always a lot of rumors about his life, uh, some of which I I think are uh not true, uh, although I don't know if they all are, um, that Father Martin supposedly said that half the people languishing in mental institutions are suffering from demonic problems.

SPEAKER_00I I I think that's not only mistaken, I think that's uh a very imprudent thing to say. Um so he could exaggerate things. That doesn't that doesn't um discount uh the good work that he at times undoubtedly did.

SPEAKER_02You talked before about working with different denominations and different religions, and you know, are there correlations between all the faiths and different faiths? Is it are we fighting the same enemy here?

SPEAKER_00You know, in my opinion, there there is no, and I am a Catholic, there's no question that historical Christianity uh has had the best understanding of the diabolic realm. And just as a student of history, uh there is no figure in history who had the tremendous ability to control the demonic world and drive out demons from people who are possessed is Jesus Christ.

SPEAKER_00And again, as as a Christian, I believe that uh in many ways uh beneath every um authentic spirituality of other religions as well, um people who work to liberate people from evil spirits are operating wittingly or not under the the power and authority of Jesus Christ.

SPEAKER_00So uh yeah, I'm a I'm pretty committed as a Christian to that idea. That doesn't mean to say that other faith traditions, Muslim tradition, for instance, or some of the Far Eastern religions, have had successful liberation of people from uh from uh demonic bondage through their prayers.

SPEAKER_00Um I think there's a lot of good in a lot of religions, and there are people in those religions who are uh noble souls who are tapping into the grace of God as we would see it in the Christian tradition. Um of them also, though, are very confused about the nature of what they're really dealing with. An awful lot of um uh religious uh spiritual people outside of the Christian orbit, for instance, tend to believe in possession by dead souls.

SPEAKER_00And in fact, throughout history, that was probably just as common a belief that dead souls were possessing people. And uh you go back in in ancient literature and you'll see that belief just as prominent as that evil spirits are possessing people. Um I think the the Christian tradition has understood better that demons can present themselves in all different sorts of forms.

SPEAKER_00And demons, evil spirits, um are constantly trying to confuse people. So that other faith traditions I think are in danger of having mistaken ideas about what they are doing. And undoubtedly Christian um spiritual practitioners, even historically, in my opinion, uh, have had much more success at driving out demons than other religions.

SPEAKER_00A good example of what I was um alluding to, I had a woman who suffered from oppression, and she came to me, and she was clearly a non-psychotic, lovely, lovely person. Uh there are some denominations within Christianity which assume that because a person is uh in some way attacked by diabolic forces, and I'm primarily talking here about oppressions, they must they must be some kind of sinner.

SPEAKER_00That's a dangerous idea, because we know that even great saints in history uh, as well as good people, can get attacked. Uh though, again, it doesn't happen out of the blue, it usually happens for some reason. So this woman comes to me, clearly non-psychotic, clearly not a psychiatric case, and she claimed that she was being communicated to by at first she said angels.

SPEAKER_00And so I said to her, Well, what do you think? She says, Well, these angels tell me they have a special mission for me. And I don't I uh I'm just a humble mother of a family, and I don't believe that you know our Lord has some special mission for me, that he would send angels to uh uh give me that mission. So I said, Well, that's that's probably sensible and humble of you.

SPEAKER_00Uh why don't you uh because she had already consulted other doctors and priests who were trying to help her, and and the other doctors were a little mystified what was going on, but they certainly didn't regard her as psychotic. And I said, Why don't you see what happens and come back and talk to me? She came back and talked to me a year later, and she said, Well, these spirits now say they are dead souls. And I said, Well, what do you believe about that? And she says, Well, I don't think that's true Christian belief, so I'm a little skeptical.

SPEAKER_00And again, I had I said, Well, I admire that you have some uh good sense in this area. Let's see what happens. She came back to me a week later, uh a few weeks later, and and she said, They finally, Dr. Gallagher, have revealed who they are. And I said, Who are they? Uh she said, Well, they've finally been forced to confess, as I as I work with priest in this area, what she was doing, uh, that they're evil spirits. And I I found that a very telling story.

SPEAKER_00Uh and it's not the only time I've heard that from people. So these evil spirits will often pretend they're dead souls. I mean, this is this is whom mediums, for instance, are often thinking that they're in touch with. Or they may present themselves as messengers of God, um, angels, whatever. And um I think that's a very good illustration of that truth.

SPEAKER_02We talked about the demonologist on television that you've seen, and investigators, you know, and we're all in search of that sort. We call it the golden nuggets of evidence, that one piece of evidence recorded on camera or audio, that's gonna totally shift and convince the masses of non-believers in the world. Do you believe we will ever convince the masses of non-believers that this is real?

SPEAKER_00Well, probably not. Uh I don't I don't believe that uh one's gonna get definitive evidence. Uh these phenomena, uh, which have been written about by anthropologists, they've been written about uh by different scholars, uh probably the best historian of uh states of possession was an agnostic named uh Dr. Osterreich in Germany about a hundred years ago. And um the presence or the nature, uh, the scientific reality of these things is uh is probably always gonna be disputed.

SPEAKER_00And that's in part because people think that evil spirits are gonna perform for the camera. I mean, most experts in this area, and I certainly agree, uh they recognize that these evil spirits as fallen angels are probably far more intelligent than we are.

SPEAKER_00In fact, they look down on human beings, there's no doubt in my mind, you know. We're kind of monkeys to them. And uh they're very shrewd and they're very interested in confusing people, so they're not going to just perform for the camera like an exhibitionist Hollywood actor and make it easy for people to capture uh their reality uh for posterity on YouTube or something.

SPEAKER_00Uh quite the contrary, they they they want to cause a commotion and confuse people. Uh and they've been trying to confuse people for millennia, even in the pre-Christian era. So uh no, I don't think that we're gonna get this definitive proof. Even if you had a fairly definitive proof of something, and people have tried, other people would say probably, well, the tape was doctored, or the film was mistaken, or blah, blah, blah, or they staged this for the camera.

SPEAKER_00Uh so I think it's quite naive for people to think that we're gonna get some kind of uh unequivocal evidence. Now, we may get evidence, but it's certainly not gonna convince everybody.

SPEAKER_02I'm sure you've been heavily criticized by fellow psychiatrists and professors in your field. You know, I'm just gonna just gonna spout off a few quotes here from the Skeptical Inquirer 2016, you know, very fitting. Uh quote, his grasp of science is troubling, his approach to explaining human behavior has the potential to damage the profession and contribute to harmful mental health practices. You know, why why do you feel why why do you think you've faced such I mean you've come out publicly in a lot of articles, but why do you think you've faced such harsh criticism?

SPEAKER_00Well, I wouldn't say that I uh am criticized by my fellow professionals. I would say that there are some people who are committed to a kind of dogmatic materialism who question what I'm saying. And they question it, and sometimes they get vitriolic and, in my opinion, adolescent and immature about their criticism, uh, because uh to recognize the reality of this uh spirit these spiritual phenomena completely upsets their apicot.

SPEAKER_00Now, as a matter of fact, in my profession, uh I've never been overtly criticized. I I think I've raised a few eyebrows in certain quarters, but I've also worked with other Catholic doctors, and uh in fact, my my past academic chairman who was a past president of the American Psychiatric Association, he not only believed what I'm writing about, but he claimed that he had had a case himself when he was younger.

SPEAKER_00So the other thing is this is a uh tolerant country. Uh we believe in religious uh uh freedom and we believe in in pluralism. And um so as opposed to, for instance, in Europe, I think there's much more openness to uh the realm of the demonic, even among physicians and certainly among the general public. People sometimes will say to me, um, how does it feel to be out of the mainstream?

SPEAKER_00And I say, well, what are you talking about? In America, 70% of Americans believe in the devil. Uh over half in one survey believe that demons actually can attack people. So, just who's out of the mainstream here? You know, it's not me. You get some uh doctrinaire people who are very committed to a kind of bland sterile materialism.

SPEAKER_00But look, not only in America, but most people throughout history have believed in spiritual realities. As a matter of fact, most people in history undoubtedly have believed in some kind of uh spirits attacking human beings. Now, if you have spirits who attack human beings, however you think about them, those are evil spirits. I mean, let's not let's not play with semantics here. So uh the the the in recorded history, the vast majority of human beings have probably always believed in evil spirits.

SPEAKER_00So uh I'm hardly out of the mainstream. And and quite frankly, uh most of any kind of criticism of me is usually this anonymous online stuff by people who uh really have little idea what they're talking about. One supporter of mine uh wrote a comment um and he was more acerbic than I tend to be. He said, Dr. Gallagher, you've obviously disturbed the antill.

SPEAKER_00But that's that's that's kind of the perspective I would have, that the people who actually are hostile to what I would say usually have their own axe to grind, and uh they they've had zero effect on me.

SPEAKER_02You've mentioned before that you you you you're clearly you're not anti-scientific, you believe in science, but you've had that you've just had that rare opportunity to study these things in detail. Can you talk talk more talk more about this?

SPEAKER_00Well, look, uh science, as we understand the modern term, um has made enormous contributions to human well welfare, uh, engineering, um, cosmology, our understanding of the universe. I mean, I believe in the Big Bang. I believe in evolution. Uh, when I was in grammar school, I went to a Catholic grammar school, the nuns used to say there's nothing anti-Catholic about beliefs in evolution.

SPEAKER_00Um, so of course, as a physician, I value science very, very strongly. Now, that doesn't mean that a society can't have a very strong commitment to science as well as religious beliefs. And if you have religious beliefs, you believe in a realm that can't be nailed down by the usual principles of what we call science.

SPEAKER_00When people say science, they're really referring to what's called methodological naturalism. That's the fancy term meaning, you know, science in the modern sense advances by doing experiments and um having double-blind studies and this sort of thing. Well, you can't subject evil spirits to that any more than you could subject, you know, God or angels to that. Um these realms of knowledge are confused if people think that science disproves evil spirits.

SPEAKER_00Of course, it does nothing of the sort. And even the word science, uh, it comes from the Latin scientia. The word science really meant knowledge. And any uh respectable philosopher of knowledge is gonna say there are different ways we understand things. I mean, there's nothing unscientific about belief in devils and demons. Uh it just it has a different level of evidence.

SPEAKER_00Uh some of the evidence is uh and primarily historical evidence. When we study something that happened in history, we can't do an experiment on it. Doesn't mean we don't believe in the events of history. We just mean that the way of knowing things is different. Um biblical scholarship is a is a reasonable field to study. We're supposed to study it rigorously.

SPEAKER_00That doesn't mean it's anti-science. Uh John Paul II wrote a famous encyclical called Faith and Reason. Uh he didn't mean he meant that they're very compatible. You don't you don't throw out your reason for your faith, and um you're supposed to use your reason even in realms of uh complicated philosophical or theological study.

SPEAKER_00So, in my opinion, there there's no contradiction. And America is a good example of that. America is a religious country, but it's also a a country that turns to science. Now, if you turn away from science and just accept some kind of blind faith in things, well uh that that's not that's not the Christian ideal. It's certainly not the Catholic ideal.

SPEAKER_02You mentioned on the radio into that that this is not a field for the faint hearted. Can you talk more about this? You know, uh is is is it dangerous to be To be dabbling in this um type of feel?

SPEAKER_00Um I d I don't really think it's a dangerous thing to get involved in. It it's a creepy thing. Uh uh and again, I'm certainly not setting myself up as some kind of paragon, uh, but you know, you should you should take care of uh you know your spiritual life. You should probably have people praying for you. Um but I believe strongly um uh I'm on the winning side. And uh so I don't I don't I don't fear what I get into.

SPEAKER_01Well you just answered my last question. Are we all doomed or are we on the winning side? I think you just answered it.

SPEAKER_00Well, I hope most of us are on the winning side. We leave that up to God to decide. I mean, there is clearly um at the heart of this whole subject is is the matter of free choice and free will. And and people can choose to try to follow God as they know him, best they can, uh, or they can reject it. And and certain people in history, of course, um Hitler, Stalin, whatever, have turned to evil criminals, uh cosmic uh uh uh terrorist, um gangsters.

SPEAKER_00Uh so human beings have free will, and I I I think it's eminently uh analogous and and sensible to think that if God created angels, as most religious people in history have always believed, that some of them could have also turned to evil and rebelled, and then they go to their own place. They have consciously rejected God and separated themselves from God.

SPEAKER_00Um I call them cosmic terrorists because they seem to get a certain satisfaction, or at least they have a strong inclination to attack human nature. Uh people have different theories about that. Uh myself, I believe that in a sense they are trying to attack human beings as the image of God and as creatures who can still turn to God, which they have separated themselves from and and reject and continue to reject.

SPEAKER_02Let's finish on the book.

SPEAKER_00Let's talk about a little bit briefly about the book, motivation behind writing it, um, when it's going to come out, you know, just a little bit of a like like everything else, like getting involved with the International Association of Exorcists, like doing consultations on cases, everything I've done, uh, and maybe I think it's more providential that way, has been because somebody has asked me to do something. So quite a few people asked me to write a book about my 25 years experience.

SPEAKER_00And I was a little hesitant. First of all, uh, you know, as a doctor, I I value confidentially tremendously. Uh so I certainly had to disguise all cases that I uh that I write about. But at the same time, I realized it would be kind of useless or uh silly to write a book if I wasn't very scrupulously accurate. So I tried to write a book at the request of many, many people, uh, and after some hesitation uh to share my experiences.

SPEAKER_00You know, there was a New Yorker writer who said, write what you know. Well, uh, willy-nilly, uh, without my really uh having any ambition to get involved in this field, which just sort of happened in my life, uh, I decided it would be worthwhile to share my experience and share my expertise in this area. So um I wrote a book. Probably will come out in early 2019.

SPEAKER_00It's going to be published by HarperCollins. Uh they seem to be very enthused about the book. And uh the title is Demonic Foes, F O E S. Demonic Foes A psychiatrist investigates diabolic possession in modern America. And um, I hope it does some good. Hope it does some good.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Inheriting the Warren legacy with Chris McKinnell

    Oct 30, 202652 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Most families keep their secrets locked away. For Chris McKinnell, the secrets came with the family name. Chris is the grandson of Ed and Lorraine Warren, the legendary paranormal investigators whose...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Malachi Martin: In the Shadows of the Vatican

    Dec 17, 20251 hr 12 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Robert Marro Jr. joins Marty to discuss his memoir, Malachi Martin: In the Shadows of the Vatican, and his friendship with Martin during the final decade of Martin’s life. The conversation covers...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. A Lifetime of Demonic Oppression

    Apr 13, 202553 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Cheryl joins Marty to describe a lifetime of experiences she attributes to demonic oppression, including disturbing incidents in her homes and her efforts to seek help through her Catholic diocese....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Chief Exorcist Archbishop Ronald Feyl Enright

    Feb 5, 20251 hr 21 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Marty speaks with Archbishop Ronald Feyl Enright about his work in the exorcism ministry, his approach to assessing reported possession cases and the development of his investigative process. The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. John Zaffis: Godfather of the Paranormal

    Jan 1, 202527 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail An uncut interview with paranormal investigator John Zaffis, recorded by Marty on 4 March 2015 during the US production of Hostage to the Devil. Zaffis discusses his work with Ed and Lorraine Warren,...

    Credit the people on this episode