Ever wonder why Thanksgiving is a "turkey" holiday? Us too! The answer is part science, part history, and surprisingly part politics. #STEAMpodcast SOURCES: Cunningham, John M.. "Why Do We Eat Turkey on Thanksgiving?". Encyclopedia Britannica, 24 Nov. 2025, https://www.britannica.com/story/why-do-we-eat-turkey-on-thanksgiving. Accessed 14 November 2026. Gunther, Kaitlyn. "Why Do We Eat Turkey On Thanksgiving?" (2021, October 15).https://food52.com/story/24719-why-do-we-eat-turkey-on-thanksgiving Smithsonian Staff. "Thanksgiving: From Local Harvests to National Holiday". (1998, March). https://www.si.edu/spotlight/thanksgiving/history U.S. Turkey production rebounds as demand stays strong. (2026, November 10). https://minnesotaagconnection.com/news/us-turkey-production-rebounds-as-demand-stays-strong Stuck in your van too? Give us a follow for more educational resources. Youtube: Hello From The Van! Instagram/Facebook @HelloFromTheVan HelloFromTheVan.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Mimi FaatzI went to Costco this week and saw a host of wonderful things, amongst which was a lady trying to pass a bad check. Haven't seen that in a hot minute. And turkeys are on sale. And that got me thinking, why are we eating turkey at Thanksgiving? Why is that? That's the question we're answering today on Hello from the Van. Alrighty, here we go. Turkey. Thanksgiving. What's the correlation?
Mimi FaatzAs a child of the 80s, I distinctly remember learning in grade school that we have turkey at Thanksgiving because the pilgrims had turkey at the first Thanksgiving. Now, is that true? Well, it's a possibility. Let me explain. Let's set the scene. It's the early 1600s in the eastern United States. Pilgrims of different denominations and Indians of different tribes are all holding what we now refer to as a harvest festival.
Mimi FaatzBasically, it's fall and everyone is celebrating different versions of the harvest. This is what historians know. Scientists know that in New England, wild turkeys were present. Here's the cross section of science and history. The historians say yes, there was fowl or birds present for the meal. They did eat birds at the original harvest festivals or Thanksgivings, as we call them. Do we know if they were exactly turkeys? No. In short, yes, there were birds served at these harvest festivals.
Mimi FaatzThere were many different harvest festivals happening, some with the Indian tribes and some with the pilgrims, some with a mix of both. This is all well and good, but where do we get Thanksgiving and a day of Thanksgiving? 150 years later, in 1789, Elias Boudineau of New Jersey, he was a member of the House of Representatives, he made a motion that a day of Thanksgiving be held to thank God for giving the American people the opportunity to create a constitution to preserve their hard-won freedoms.
Mimi FaatzThis, of course, was approved, and then President George Washington, yeah, on October 3rd, 1789, proclaimed that the people of the United States observe a day of public Thanksgiving and prayer on Thursday, the 26th of November. But this was like a one-time thing, right? It wasn't like uh this is now a national holiday. It took subsequent presidents of the United States, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison. They also proclaimed this same holiday like, hey, let's do it.
Mimi FaatzAnd it just became an unofficial tradition. But it was sporadic. It wasn't happening every year. It actually took a woman with a lot of sway and a pen to solve the turkey problem. Her name was Sarah Hale. She was an editor of a ladies magazine. And remember Goti's Ladies Book from an earlier episode where we talked about the Queen and the Christmas trees? Yeah, she was the editor of that magazine. She began to lobby for Thanksgiving using her pen and her magazine.
Mimi FaatzShe started to write articles and think pieces saying, We need a day of Thanksgiving. We need a Thanksgiving holiday. She wasn't just writing editorial or think pieces, she also was very, very clever. She published stories of Thanksgiving, ways that it brought people together. She also wrote recipes. She then started writing letter after letter after letter to governors, senators, and presidents. She did this for 36 years.
Mimi Faatz36 years of constant writing and publishing to get Thanksgiving to be an official American holiday. Now, during the Civil War, President Lincoln, especially after the Battle of Gettysburg, needed some goodwill. And a great way to do that is to give the people a holiday. So on October 3rd, 1863, President Lincoln proclaimed that November 26th would be the National Thanksgiving Day to be observed on the fourth Thursday of November every year. Since Lincoln, it has changed twice, and this is why.
Mimi FaatzFranklin Delanore Roosevelt, in order to give Depression merchants more selling days before Christmas, said, hey, let's do it the third Thursday instead of the fourth Thursday. This was in 1939 and 1940. This, of course, led to an uproar. People were mad because they had already scheduled Thanksgiving football games for the fourth Thursday. And here comes President Roosevelt saying, no, no, let's do it on the third so that these people can sell you some more stuff. People were mad. Give the people football, all right? Roosevelt's scheduling debacle of 1939 and 1940 was one of the few things where Congress has actually come together in, well, a timely manner.
Mimi FaatzBecause by 1941, a joint congressional resolution officially set the fourth Thursday of November as a national holiday for Thanksgiving. Basically, it didn't matter where you were on the political spectrum, everyone agreed Thanksgiving stays where it is and the president shouldn't touch it. So that gets us to Thanksgiving on the fourth Thursday of every November. But where did the turkeys come in? Well, it was a practical solution to a fall harvest problem. During times of food scarcity during the 18th and 19th century, there was one thing that was very, very plentiful: turkeys.
Mimi FaatzSpecifically, wild turkeys. One historian has estimated that there were at least 10 million turkeys in America at the time of European contact. Turkeys were plentiful and easy to harvest in the fall, as that's when they're active. Also, if you had a family farm at this time, there were almost always turkeys available for slaughter. If you think from a purely practical point of view, live cows and hens are useful and they're kind of their own built-in food storage while they're alive.
Mimi FaatzHowever, turkeys were raised for their meat and could be readily killed in the fall. The other great thing about a turkey, they're big enough to feed a large family. So we've got the turkeys in place, but how did they become solidified with Thanksgiving? Well, it goes back to Sarah Hale again. In her 1827 novel, Northwood, she wrote an entire chapter describing a New England Thanksgiving, and she wanted to make it as appealing as possible.
Mimi FaatzIn her description, she said that there was a roast turkey, quote, placed at the head of the table, close quote. She was also campaigning at the same time for Thanksgiving as a national holiday. So she wrote this book to kind of prop up her propaganda of Thanksgiving. And the book said turkey was the centerpiece of Thanksgiving. So naturally, all the people who she had bent their ear to hear about all of this thought, oh well, okay, I guess turkey is a Thanksgiving food. And if you're wondering just how much turkey is consumed in the United States every November, according to the United States Department of Agriculture, 198.5 million turkeys were raised in the United States in 2026.
Mimi FaatzThat is an estimated 5.13 billion pounds of turkey. 2026 has also seen an increase in demand for turkey throughout the year due to the fact that you can get it for normally under 99 cents a pound. For all the grocery shopping parents out there, you know that finding a protein under a dollar a pound these days is kind of hard to do. As the economy changes, Turkey remains the center of our Thanksgiving feasts.
Mimi FaatzThere's more to it, but for now, I'm Mimi Fotz, and this has been Hello from the Van.
What happens when we experience a burn? How do you help a burn when it happens?? That's what we're exploring this week on Hello From the Van! Sources: Hunter, Carin. "Systemic Response to Burns." Physiopedia. 6 Jul...
Ever wonder what's happening inside your body when you get scared? This week we take a family-friendly approach to the science and function of fear! SOURCES: Adolphs R. The biology of fear. Curr Biol. 2013 Jan...
Ever wonder where the words Monday, Tuesday, etc come from?? Us too! In this episode we break down the science of etymology, and the history of the English days of the week. SOURCES: Almaden, S. A. (2026, July 21)....
It's fall time here in the US and in some regions the leaves are changing to fantastic yellows, golds, and reds. This week we answer the question, "Why do leaves change color?" and explore the growth cycle of trees....
Last week it was dogs and this week, we're talking about cats! You'd think after 10,000 years of domestication we'd know more about them, but so much of their feline world remains a mystery. Find out some of what we...