Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heat! Camera! Action!

Heat! Camera! Action! artwork

33 Duncan Clark on rewilding a 1000-acre farm and using Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) to help

Nov 4, 202644 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In the walled garden at Braxted Hall Estate, Duncan Clark talks about 30 years of rewilding of the family farm, and how it is beginning to connect up with other efforts across the landscapes of Essex. He describes developing multiple strands of business, including as a wedding venue. Farming has benefitted hugely from public support for the transition to sustainability and nature restoration. Now the new mechanism of Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) is bringing money from developers to the land: developers must offset nature losses by creating more, either nearby or further away on farms. Braxted Hall is being transformed by Duncan’s vision for a different kind of landscape. Maybe one day, he says, there will be a rewilded landscape from Clacton on the coast to the ancient forest at Epping on the outskirts of London. He says, the more you build nature, the more you recover. Duncan celebrates the work of the North Essex Farm cluster (40 farmers on 20,000 hectares), a recent example of the creation of social capital to increase trust, reciprocity and collective action by farmers. Facilitated by Emma and Joe Gray at Great Priory Farm, it is spreading ideas about regenerative agriculture too - you can have the food, and you can have the nature and carbon sequestration. Duncan is proud that when he was told to grub up his 20 years of nature recovery, he didn’t. His hero is Somali-born writer and activist Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Duncan says about nature and people, “I’m a great lover of harmony.” His recommendation, “treat thy neighbour like thyself.” For more on Braxted Hall, see https://www.braxtedpark.co.uk My new book will be supporting this podcast, and will be published in March 2027 by Unbreaking/5m. It’s called "Bamboo and Butterfly: Transformation and Story for Climate and Nature Recovery."

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Brexit Hall Estate in the centre of Essex. And we're going to be talking about rewilding and biodiversity net gain and the range of regenerative approaches that you've been taking on the estate here. So you started as uh trained as a business in business, business schools in Cambridge and in Columbia, and then made the journey into land management and the whole regenerative nature recovery bit. Tell us a little bit about that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I was 17 years working for Brown Brothers Harriman, which is America's oldest privately owned bank, formed in 1818, and I did that for 17 years. I ran their London office. And in 2001, they and I uh I and they went our our separate ways. They actually uh closed the business that I was running, so that uh that was uh I was needing to find another job.

SPEAKER_00And the job that waved at me was the one here. Um and to use an analogy, uh when I looked, uh came back and I put my head in the estate office. My father was an ex-industrialist living at home, uh, but he he wasn't uh an active manager, and frankly, the the water was going above nostril level. And where we're sitting uh was uh a symbol of it. The War Garden uh was in a shocking state.

SPEAKER_00Uh it was like um the Somme, and it was bare and sad and was very much a symbol. Um and frankly, there was much less coming in than there was going out. We were in five businesses, um the farm, a thousand-acre farm, golf, um, a chute, we had some properties, the name uh most importantly of the offices that we have here, 10,000 uh uh square foot of Old Plessy space.

SPEAKER_00That was the family company that uh owned Braxid until my father bought Braxett from Plessy in 1962. And um we had a very small um event business um which uh happened once a month, um twelve times a year in the main house. My father loathed it because he he slept on top of the disco. Uh so we only allowed uh twelve a year. Oh god. So that's what I came to and um it it it was a problem.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was a problem. It needed a problem. So the first thing we did was to rebuild the offices, and that took a couple of years from 2002 to four or so. Uh that hardly, frankly, moved the needle, um, and uh we borrowed a hell of a lot of money to do it, um, but uh the return on investment there was uh not sufficient to take the water level down. And so um with a uh lovely dolp of naivety, I um I went and bought uh this 35 by 15 meter marquee and I put it in the wall garden on our old tennis court.

SPEAKER_00Uh it took us about nine months to build it from scratch to what you see today, and um we overnight went into the wedding business in a big way.

SPEAKER_01And um that was the kind of early phase of of people kind of going to locations and kind of having designed things in a system. It's a relatively recent phenomenon.

SPEAKER_00Relatively recent. I mean, uh the there were some neighbours um who had done it quite a lot, a lot longer than us. Um and and Essex is an incredible place for weddings. I mean, I don't know, there are 250 wedding venues, so it's highly competitive. Uh but we sort of overnight, new new kid on the block, uh, we went up to about a hundred events. That was the beginning of the turnaround to get the water uh down to a point where we could breathe.

SPEAKER_00And in amongst all of that, um at one point um in about 1994, my father and I took the decision to try and stem the losses um that we had on the farm because our our farmland is terrible. It's a mosaic of uh the worst kind of Essex clay and gravel, but in no particular order. So it's uh, you know, one field will have uh five reasonably large pockets of gravel, not big enough to excavate it, but big enough to make real trouble.

SPEAKER_00And so we set aside the whole farm 100% in 94.

SPEAKER_01Uh and uh by set aside, that means put it in, allowed, allowed nature to put it in the fire.

SPEAKER_00Well, you you you planted, you you stopped farming and you um uh you we we planted a lot of grass and um we uh hived off certain areas and and they became scrub uh almost by accident. We did that for 10 years, and you were paid by the taxpayer not to farm. And then we went into the countryside stewardship scheme for another 10 years. So now we haven't farmed for 20 years, and we get to 2014. In 2014, we all those schemes ended.

SPEAKER_00Um we weren't making a lot of money, but we weren't losing, nor did we care about rainfall or uh the price of uh fertilizer or the price of grain. It was uh happy times really, but we were forced back into farming in oath in 2014, and this is the key point. Um I was advised to grub up all of this welded area, and let's put it back under the plow, and some some little voice in the back of my mind said, no, don't.

SPEAKER_00So we kept about 50 to 75 acres of what was now rewelding. But it's rewelding, I want to make this point very clear, it was rewelding by accident, but it was a miracle what had happened that what nature will do if you leave it. Yes, and um lovely James Canton and I both came up with this phrase um uh independently, but we called it benign neglect. Um and and um as a result uh right now we have uh about a thousand uh about 950 acres of wheat, barley, oil seed rape, but alongside it are these little pockets of rewelded scrub, and you know, we now this is 30 years now because we went back into farming ten years ago.

SPEAKER_00So we've now got these little bits uh where out of the scrub came the oaks, and um I I happily take people to to to to go and look at that. Um quite astonishing to think that there's some wheat uh and there's these this this this nature regen, and these oaks are now sort of 25-30 feet tall, and they're they're 30 years old, and we didn't plant a single one of them.

SPEAKER_00It was all done by Jays, field mice, squirrels, etc. Yeah, so nature did the hard work for you. They did it really did, and it's astonishing how uh it will recover. So along comes BNG, and um it's a natural for us. And uh when people say what's it going to look like, I say, Well, I've done one earlier, um that's exactly what it's gonna look like in 30 years. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So tell us a tell us a bit about the biodiversity net gain, the BNG, which is something that that was uh picked up in the Environment Act 2021, um, and it's just now playing into practical application. So it's money from developers largely, or people who want to do stuff but need to pay for the nature that they've had to damage or use up by investing in it elsewhere. That's essentially what it is.

SPEAKER_00So if you if you take a very simple example of uh uh a hundred house site outside, let's say Colchester, and in building it you destroy a X amount of nature, the the law now says that um you must replace X and add 10%. Yeah. So in theory, the more you build, the more nature you restore. It should be adding up against that baseline, should be.

SPEAKER_00And um that can be done on site and off-site. Now, uh if you look at our uh rewilding, it's blackthorn, bramble, scrub. This is does not sit easily with a neat housing estate where um uh push chairs are pushing through to the playground. Kitchen to play and get it. And and turtle doves, you know, they don't like streetlights or noise.

SPEAKER_00And so uh you're not gonna you'll get a certain amount of uh nature, but not you're not gonna get the full Monty. And what we what we deal with uh at Braxit on the offs is the off-site credits that um um developers will buy. Um and uh offsite you you get this this really raw uh natural regeneration. And and we are going to be offering five different landscapes.

SPEAKER_00The the biggest one is uh grassland and pasture, the next one is scrub, yeah, the next one is woodland, uh, the next one is hedges, putting in a lot more hedges, uh, and and then we're doing some in-field tree planting and uh we are recreating uh some ponds.

SPEAKER_01I was gonna say ponds, right, so it's part of the the pond project in Essex, the ghost ponds just trying to bring them back again.

SPEAKER_00Ghost ponds uh sitting in fields where they used to drink um the plough horses, um zombie ponds, which are ponds in the age of woodlands which have got overshaded by uh uh trees, lots of uh leaf mould sitting in the bottom, and rank and smelly and and stagnant. What you do is you you you get in there, you take a lot of the old stuff out, you cut some trees down, let the light in, and um uh they they come back.

SPEAKER_00The the the ghost ponds uh again they they literally sit in the middle of a field. They were filled in during the war when we were um uh digging for Britons it were and growing every square inch under under the you know, trying to grow more wheat. Um and there they they sit wet in the winter, and they're the obvious place, and there's this lovely guy, Andrew Hull, who who will dig away, and he he knows when he's hitting the old um uh um seed bed, uh, and he stops, and then that that those seeds have laid dormant for a hundred years, and then they suddenly come to life once they've got the light and the water.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and so so we'll be doing uh a lot of those. Uh and the other point I'd like to make is that having taken uh public money for 20 years via set-aside and countryside stewardship, uh it's this is not public money. This is uh the developer um complying uh with his obligations by law. Um and it's a much more comfortable place for me.

SPEAKER_00This is a private transaction, um, and and some good comes up out of it. So um that's an important point to make. BNG is not being funded by the taxpayer, it's being funded by the developers. Yes.

SPEAKER_01But it's still creating in the broadest sense. I mean, it's on your land here, but it's creating a kind of public asset of nature because there's going to be more of it. And when the the plans for the local nature recovery strategy come into fruition, the idea is to join up nature across the whole of a county. All counties, hopefully, in due course with 48 of them, these local nature recovery strategies. And so the bit you're doing here is creating a natural capital asset that will link up with other things if we want to put it in those kind of topics.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely, and and the more um joining between them, I mean we are conscious of within our bit joining it all up. So that you have, in theory, uh a corridor that uh uh a field mouse could run along. Yes, or door mouse or whatever. Or door mouse. And and uh um i if I have a neighbour who's doing the same, then we we we like to think about you know how do we join each other and and on the t'other side.

SPEAKER_00And and of course, there's um Mike Wadham of the Big Green Internet who who has identified that the ancient woodland goes from sort of Clacton to Epping, we are slap bang in the middle of that. Okay, and there's a reason for that we won't go into, but um um it it's it it it's sort of associated with the very, very poor quality of our land. People of uh good farmers left it well alone and there it became woodland. Um and and the same reason we had such a bad time farming is the same reason that we're slapbang in that ancient woodland corridor.

SPEAKER_00So he is the ultimate sort of linker of great scale.

SPEAKER_01So you can imagine a uh a linear woodland, a long connected habitat going from Clacton all the way to Effing. Yes, and why not?

SPEAKER_00And that's that's that's his vision, and it's called the big green internet. Um and uh and he's terribly interesting about it, but as I say, we're slapbang in the middle of it. And and the reason we have so much ancient woodland is our land is so poor that in the uh in the 19th century um the farmers that came down from Scotland and said, Well, you know, I I've got you you know much better land nearer the sea or nearer Cogershore. But uh this this hill is is this horrid sort of mixture of gravel and clay, and um let's leave it alone.

SPEAKER_01The ice sheets delivered a long time ago.

SPEAKER_00He says it was a big glacier and it just pushed up and then stopped along this ridge that goes all the way, uh, from Clacton all the way to.

SPEAKER_01And you can imagine if people want to look at pictures, I've seen them, of the terminal moraine at glaciers, for example, in Iceland, where they've been melting and retreating in just the last few years. They've great kind of towering hills at the end of them, um, you know, 50 meters of of um of shale and sand and gravel, and that's your lot. There's no organic matter in there at all.

SPEAKER_00And and relatively we are high. I mean, um I know it's not saying much because we're in Essex, but we do have the second highest spot in Essex. Right. Right on the edge, uh, which is where this radio mast is that you can see from all points of the compass. And the views up there on the Grange Road uh that we look down, we you know, we can look 10 miles.

SPEAKER_01So we're you're at that stage of of having this kind of dual approach of more than 20 years, 25 plus years of natural regeneration um on parts of the of the estate. And and now with the biodiversity net gain um beginning to flow or about to flow?

SPEAKER_00Um we've started um and uh we've sold some units. We we we are we are committing 200 acres of the of the thousand, um the the least um amenable land um we are committing to the BNG Habitat Bank. Uh we have right now planted all of our hedges, all of our infield trees, and the next step is this summer we planted the spring wheat on what is going to be the grassland, and this harvest, what we will do we are putting no inputs into that spring wheat, so it has the effect of nutrient stripping.

SPEAKER_00By growing, it strips the nutrients out. We will harvest it, we will feed that grain to pigs, we will bale up the straw and we'll use those big bales to demark the scrub areas which are going to just be let go, benign neglect again. Then in spring 27 we will drill another spring crop, um, this time under sowed with grass.

SPEAKER_00And in uh harvest 27, again, no inputs, so more nutrient stripping. Uh you obviously have a much weaker, thinner barley crop, but again, you'll you'll feed what you can to to um um my contractors' pigs, will bail up some more straw, more demarcation of the scrub areas. But because you've planted planted the grass, uh by the time you harvest, the grass will be coming up.

SPEAKER_01Right, and this is a kind of a grass mix, not not the your traditional um it won't be boring, no, it won't be tough old ryegrass.

SPEAKER_00It'll be it'll be a mix that has been approved by the ecologist uh for um um um um wildlife. Um and so by that stage we will have, because we're gonna plant our woods this winter, we'll be done because we'll have planted all the grassland, we will have planted all the trees, we will have demarked the scrub areas and just let nature start doing, and that will take 20 years, and uh we will have done all of our infield trees, and that's what we promised to do.

SPEAKER_00So then it just becomes um uh a matter of uh looking after it, and that's going to be the key because you know we put these hedges into the ground uh in January, February this year. We had eight inches of rain. We were so happy because it was so wet and we thought this couldn't be better. We're already having to water them. I mean, um we've had no rain for six weeks, the the the clay has gone cement like bone dry.

SPEAKER_00And the important thing is to, you know, to have a setup whereby you are not, I mean, ours is gonna be self-policing. We're gonna invite a lot of scrutiny from the buyers of these credits, and we'll we'll come to that. But it's sort of going to be self-policing. Can you imagine uh how it would be if all of my buyers and my credits were invited back to Brexit to find dead trees, dead hedges? Yeah. Can't let it happen. No. Cannot let it happen. So we are going to, I hope, be the a shining example of, you know, maintenance, and even though it's costing me money now to go out there with a water browser and a man watering all of these trees and hedges, got to be done.

SPEAKER_00Uh, I fear that there are a lot of um big, big BNG exploiters, normally driven by private equity, um, and rather like the water companies, um, you know, um, I fear there's gonna be a lot of bad press about BNG as a lot of these companies take their money and and don't then maintain what they've left. And I think you're gonna see some bad stories. We are gonna be at the opposite. We are going to um really cherish um the nature, make it work, and then invite back the buyers of our credits and their clients.

SPEAKER_00So a uh a buyer of a house in uh for ABC developments in Colchester will be invited back once a quarter to inspect um the actual BNG credit, be it a hedge, a tree, uh a bit of grassland, a bit of scrub, that we're going to invite them back on open days to to inspect it all because, in a way, you know, by buying their house they've helped nature.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_00You've done this. Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_01I think that's a lovely part of thinking about public engagement with this, because as you said, this is a kind of uh at one level, this is a kind of transaction that that links up developers with with land um owners and land managers. Um the public central in all of that because they're going to be in houses. The nature is for the wider good because it will be connected up broadly, but to make people feel a kind of Ownership, even of saying, Well, that's that's where we've contributed to increasing nature.

SPEAKER_01We've done we've done our bit, we're doing our bit.

SPEAKER_00Yes, I think that's I think BNG is at the moment, developers view it as the enemy. It's yet another cost, and you know, they they've got a lot of costs, let's face it, and they're there a lot of them have stopped building because of the costs. But um our view is that if you're going to have to do it, and hopefully you will have to do it, because it's a it's it's a good idea, more you build, the more you recover nature, then turn it at least into something that you can be proud of and maybe use it uh as an asset.

SPEAKER_00You know, our houses um have help recreate the nature, and you can go and kick the tyres. And I think um, you know, the the developers who get out there and do that earlier are gonna have an advantage over those who are sort of grumpy about it all. And I think um if um uh John and Mary coming out of London to Colchester can feel, oh, you know, we we not only in theory can feel, but we can go and look at it and go and listen to the recordings of a turtle love and go and look at a rare moth and uh go and look at the the the new woods and scrub, um, then I I'm sure that's going to have a really good feel-good effect.

SPEAKER_00Oh, I think it'll be good.

SPEAKER_01And I think it's sort of it's more than just feeling good. I think it's um uh it's got this potential to give people a sense of agency, like they're involved in something. Um, at a distance, fine, that's okay. Um, but the Amazon's at a distance, and you know the gorillas are at a distance, and people still want to feel part of kind of looking after nature and habitats in other parts of the world, so it applies here as well. But people will feel that if they can do that, they may be able to do something else as well, and that actually is kind of of wider interest.

SPEAKER_01You change the view of the public in general.

SPEAKER_00Well, I've always worried about the growing chasm between town and country, uh, and this is um certainly something that helps bridge that. Um, and I love sharing it. I mean, the other day I took um um a couple of officials from Molden and Brainfree District Council, and we went up to the the sort of epicentre of our our re-rewilding, and there was not one but two nightingales singing to each other.

SPEAKER_00Yes, and um perfect, I mean it really it really was um wonderful. Um I couldn't have arranged it better, frankly.

SPEAKER_01Have you had nightingales before or is that quite new?

SPEAKER_00No, that's new. Um the nightingales reappeared here about five years ago.

SPEAKER_01They come into the black thoughts.

SPEAKER_00I mean, obviously we had them years ago. Yeah. Um turtle dove, um we've uh had more recently, but uh in the last two or three years they have become really very rare. Instead of five pairs, one or two. Um we're hoping this year we we start. And certainly when we start the the the BNG Habitat Bank becomes more established, I I'd be very surprised if we didn't get them because the sort of um landscape that we're going to uh uh be uh developing is is just perfect for them.

SPEAKER_00Yes, exactly.

SPEAKER_01Well let's talk about the um uh you've described the kind of setting up of the process, but you're also looking forward. You've got filmmakers coming in to help record, um you want to measure and count stuff so you know you've got a story to tell to say, well, look, this is what's happening over here and over there. Um but you're looking forward not just a couple of years, you're looking forward 30 years.

SPEAKER_00A minimum 30, because that that's the obligation you sign up to.

SPEAKER_01So what what do you think it looks like as we head into that space? More of what you've already created over the first 25-30 years, but you're talking about uh for parts of the estate, uh you know, more than a half a hundred years of of uh regeneration, that's going to be uh fantastically interesting.

SPEAKER_00Yes, and and and again it's the the contrast between um a big field of wheat, which is uh very monoculture, to lots of smaller fields of grass, scrub, woodland, uh, and all that that brings. Um and it a totally different landscape. Totally different landscape and um uh in theory much, much more nature.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Much more uh many more invertebrates, moths, birds, bird song, um, strange grasses, flora and fauna, you know, I it would be otters in the we won't have otters up there. No, no, no, right. We on on the Blackwater we we have an otter down at the near my house. Uh uh we're not on the river, but the the the mill is, and they often see the otter. Uh I love the otters coming back.

SPEAKER_01Yes, yeah, fantastic. So sometimes you do you also need those iconic things. Um I mean, strangely we often value rarer things more because they're rare, but you can see why. But the turtle dove is a is a good example. Um they're under threat, there are very few around. If you end up with some, then people are going to feel good about that, and they're going to want to come and see them, or at least hear about them, or watch a clip of film of here are the turtle doves feeding on this particular thing. Yes, it's a it's a good sign.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It's rather like a lichen on a tree. And we're we're very lucky to have Simon Lister who chairs the uh the the local native partnership partnership, local native partnership.

SPEAKER_00And I think he was very, very um important in in getting s um proper compensation for um Jo uh Joe and Emma because it is a big commitment and and they shouldn't uh they should be paid. They're not paid a lot, but they're they're they're they are uh proper uh properly resourced. So with them plus the tailwind of Essex, um I think we are unusual.

SPEAKER_00Um and they are incredible. They they they are brilliant at first of all preaching what they've done. They and they are leaders of sustainable farming. Uh, but also they're brilliant at putting people together, and and I think they've got a massive amount of respect amongst the farming community. Um my own contribution is I I very quick to point out I'm not a farmer, I'm a landowner, it's two different things. Um and uh uh uh once I've said that people relax.

SPEAKER_00Um but I my I I offer myself as someone that um uh kind of knows about BNG having done it, yeah. And if anybody else is interested, I I'm kind of their go-to guy on the board.

SPEAKER_01Um, how how are farmers who are members of the cluster? If you're looking at it, you're on the board and you can see uh what the benefits of this facilitation and leadership come from, from Emma and Joe and others. Um farmers now feeling as though they're part of a bigger project, that they of course individual farmers are focusing on your bit of land because you've got to make that work in whatever way, but to feel as though you're part of a larger collective enterprise strikes me as beneficial.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely, and also, you know, for instance, I don't know, uh a new FWAG scheme to put in new ponds. Yeah, um it's complicated and it is quite intimidating, and they uh incredibly helpful of steering the members to places where that they can get help doing that sort of thing. They're very good at sort of pointing out where the available finance for various investment projects can come from. Um and uh they're very good at you know sharing sharing key information.

SPEAKER_00Who's good at digging ponds? Uh you know, people are some farmers are quite frightened by the idea of not putting on as much fertilizer. And you know, well, we've done it, and here's here's you know, let me talk talk you through uh the outcome. Yeah. And and then sitting down with the and it it's listen, I think with all these things in the wedding. Well, change is hard.

SPEAKER_01I mean, transformation is hard, especially if you I mean in every part of our lives, and if you've got a way of doing something, and as you were describing earlier, if that way has kind of put you underwater over time, financially underwater, then something's not quite working. But even then it's quite hard to work out what to do. Um, and farming um is subject to all sorts of external shocks and stresses, markets, climate, all sorts of other things, policy, sudden policy changes. And in the face of all that, it's kind of not surprising that it's quite difficult to work out what the plan is.

SPEAKER_01But if someone else has has done something, well not the plan, but the parts, you've got you know lots of potential approaches, you could go this way or this way. But if someone says, Oh, it's quite, you know, it's fun, it's quite easy. That's quite convincing. That's more convincing than a hundred reports.

SPEAKER_00If another farmer Absolutely, I mean you know, imagine the shock when you know you you eventually have got yourself into a position of applying for SFI and suddenly the government withdraws it. Um, you know, you become, you your instinct is to rush back into your shell. Um the the wedding business is uh is a classic uh uh analogy. Um during um there were 260 wedding venues in Essex, and when uh lockdown happened, uh we became the arch enemy.

SPEAKER_00We were super spreaders, and it it we were we had no friends at all. And let me tell you, at that point, the collective association of wedding venue owners that I arranged, uh the National Wedding Venue Support Group, um it had instant buy-in because everyone, you know, at that point of maximum fear, you you you want to be with people. Yes. Like-minded problems. Yes. Um, and it's the same with the phone cluster, you know, it it the the there are lots and lots of bad days, and it's nice to be with people who are experiencing the same thing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and also have got ideas as to what works, and not necessarily saying that everybody should do the same thing, but to say, well, here are a range of things. I mean, if you've got how many members of the cluster? 25-ish?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it's the it's the hectare of the acreage, which is it's enormous. Yeah, exactly. I mean, I think it's one of the more successful clusters in the world.

SPEAKER_01It's covering a lot of land, it's got a good number of people. Um, and um I kind of like the idea that that through that uh nobody's saying everybody should do the same regimented thing. You can say, look, here are the principles, here are the ideas of it, here are the sources of income, a new one with BNG. Um you choose what you want to do.

SPEAKER_00Yes, and if you are a tenant farmer and you don't own your land, you're less inclined to do BNG and make yourself redundant than you are if you are if you own the land, obviously.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00So it's not for everyone. Yeah, but um uh equally um they'll be fascinated in Joan Emma's message and how to reduce, how to keep your agricultural margins high by putting in less artificial. Exactly. You know, that that we're we're all interested in that. And again, that's good for nature.

SPEAKER_01And when the prices are going up like this because of changes in fossil fuel prices or constraints on fertilizers, if you're not using them, you're kind of smiling.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think Clarkson is saying uh uh cheerful Charlie Ireland has advised him not to plant any crops uh this year at all, because the um price of wheat is so low and the the price of the inputs is so high you just lose money. Yeah, yeah. So right.

SPEAKER_01Think about something else. Um carbon as well. I mean we we we could have talked a bit about the the carbon being captured in the soil. So um, if you're doing direct drilling and not turning over the soil, then the carbon is being kept and accumulated over time. So there's another benefit being done through the natural regeneration but also the regenerative farm methods. You're turning the land into a store for carbon. And over time, if that carries on over time, um then actually the quality of the soil will be better.

SPEAKER_01So if you do want to farm, continue to farm bits, it's gonna be a better margin and better yields as well. Let's come to the end with a couple of kind of questions about um uh your recommendations and your thoughts for for the audience. First of all, um I I mean we've talked a lot about the intent that you've had for this change, and you know, in order to address climate and nature recovery, we've got to want to do it in the first place, and creating people's sense of agency for that is is critical.

SPEAKER_01Um something you're really proud of. I mean it might be the whole project, um, but but is there a kind of one part of this that you would point to or the kind of the the approach that you've been able to take here over the Yeah, I I guess I'm proud of learning the lesson because uh as I said, this was slightly done by accident, but once done, I realize how important it was.

SPEAKER_00And I'm I'm proud of the fact that then I ran with it in a big way. I mean, 200 or 20% of your land to put into it. Uh, and possibly more, if it if it goes well, possibly more. Um and okay, it's come my way. I mean, it's now quite fashionable to have done it, and that's not why we did it. It's just that we we find ourselves. So I guess I'm proud of the fact that when they said grub it up, I didn't. Yes, exactly.

SPEAKER_00If you see what I mean, it wasn't that. It was a key moment. Yeah. Um and uh I'm not a uh a naturalist, I'm not an ecologist, but I do realize how valuable um uh it is what we're doing, and I I'm proud of the fact that we are now uh putting together one of the largest habitat banks in Essex.

SPEAKER_01Yes, exactly. Um yeah, no So the estate has this wonderful wall around a large part of it, you know, beautiful um old wall. How how long is that wall? It's four and a half miles. Yeah, okay, that's interesting.

SPEAKER_00And it was it was uh seven kilometers. And it was um everything inside it uh is parkland. Yeah, and so we are we have a totally separate strategy inside the wall. That is parkland restoration.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00So that is much more manicured, much more sort of reptin look and feel. Yeah. It's not appropriate to put rewilding in inside uh um a Grade Two star listed park. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um that's effectively then surrounded in various ways by all the work that you've described. Exactly, exactly. Um an interesting way of looking at this is that the first, the longest surviving written story um uh was um the epic of Gilgamesh. Um uh and this is from 5,000 years ago in Uruk. And Uruk, uh the walls were eight kilometres around. So it's almost exactly the same size as the original Uruk.

SPEAKER_01And Gilgamesh, the story of Gilgamesh is he falls in a hole. You know, he's a terrible king, he's a he's really bad and a tyrant, and then he goes on this big journey and all things go wrong, and eventually he comes back and he converts Uruk into a blue-green paradise. He converts it into brings water in, creates orchards, meeting places for people, the birds and the animals come and it becomes a kind of wild and cultivated and very flat, politically flat city, famous for that.

SPEAKER_01So within the walls, Uruk became, in a sense, a sort of kind of paradise. An erasis, yeah. And I think that's quite a nice tale because he he had to go on a journey to get to that point. I'm not saying you're the same as Gilgamesh, it's the the the footnote for the story is is he who saw the deep, and it's something about how you kind of soar into something and see the opportunities beyond the obvious. Um that's the first written story, the Epic of Gilgamesh. And and there it was, Uruk was the blue-green paradise.

SPEAKER_01And I think there's something similar. I'm making a stretch from Mesopotamia to to Essex, but the point is rather similar, which is um you know, the you can only start with what you can control, but if you and you can manage, but if you can do something with that, everything can change. It really can.

SPEAKER_00Yes, and I guess my my whole was um I uh the the what I uh started with, which is the water level, you know, and and getting that water level down. I'm sort of digging myself out of that hole. Yeah. Um, and that is what we've done up to a point. I mean, um the the uh pandemic, let me tell you, I went straight underwater again. Yes. And so we're we're we're not quite out of it yet.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01I suppose the thing about the pandemic is that a lot of people were suffering the similar thing. It didn't make it more easy, but you're part of a broader society.

SPEAKER_00What I learned there is that I am super dependent on the goodwill of the government and Joe Public. Yeah. And neither of them like me during the pandemic. Um anyways, we're we're we're getting there.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um the water is still above nostril level, but we're we're we're we're we we know our our hole has got a firm ground and the water is going down.

SPEAKER_01Puddled at the bottom, yeah, exactly. Um a hero or a heroine um in all of this. So maybe it's in rewilding, maybe it's in the the the changes that have happened. Would you name I mean this can be a can be a troubling term, heroine or hero, but quite often stories have them, um they go on a big journey and come back again.

SPEAKER_00Um I I'm uh a great lover of harmony, and um this whole BNG journey is there's a certain harmony connection there, but I think there's way too much aggression uh in the world. And my I've got this um wonderful uh writer, journalist, uh politician, activist, uh Ayaan Hershey Ali, who's a Somali-born Dutch politician, um very, very uh brilliant and incredibly brave woman, um suffered um FGM when she was six at the hands of her granny, and um has lobbied uh vigorously for uh equality of uh of human rights and uh particularly um you know against things like forced marriage or honour killings and stuff like this.

SPEAKER_00Um she's she uh I'm sure would be a great supporter of BNG, yeah.

SPEAKER_01And why not? Because people who if you uh I mean the point you're making is that that the big challenges we face in different parts of life transfer across elsewhere. The transformations are hard, but they require people to be brave and have courage and intent.

SPEAKER_00Yes, and she's extraordinarily brave uh and and is essentially uh uh harmonist, and and um uh you know we've got so many problems with extremism of one kind or another that um to have her bravely out there, particularly from from the the place she came from, uh in terms of her religion, her family, her nationality, um she is subject to no doubt huge threats, but carries on. And I I I strongly, every time I read her, um I strongly admire her balance and um you know um Essex man is quite an aggressive fellow, and we meet him from uh every day, and uh uh uh I often want to say, you know, harmony, harmony.

SPEAKER_00Let's calm down.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Well I was gonna finish with a with uh do you have a recommendation for for viewers and listeners? I mean perhaps that's it, you know.

SPEAKER_00Uh treat thy neighbour like thyself, I think is my my um strong code. I think it's the glue of life. Um so um uh uh if you if you follow that, I'm sure that's part of every single religion in the world. Um treat thy neighbour like thyself, uh we'd all be much, much better off.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Clark. Uh Brexit Hall of State, thank you so much indeed. It's been a real well pleasure. Really enjoyed it. Thank you, Justin.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 35 Amy Isham on how flow and interconnections are vital for our well-being and climate/nature action

    Nov 18, 202645 minAudio

    I’m on the beach at Mumbles with Amy Isham, positive and environmental psychologist from Swansea University. It’s early in the day and hot, records are being broken all over. Amy describes how action on the environment...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 34 Mark Nowers on bringing back the turtle dove and ghost ponds to farmed landscapes

    Nov 11, 202650 minAudio

    It’s early morning in late summer, and I’m with turtle dove expert Mark Nowers of the RSPB. We’re sitting in a wild field margin at Braxted Hall estate, location for wilding and nature recovery through Biodiversity Net...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 32 Susan Owens on the attentiveness and bravery of painter John Constable on his 250th anniversary

    Nov 4, 202648 minAudio

    We’re sitting on the banks of the River Stour in “Constable Country.” It’s the home territory of the painter 250 years after his birth. Susan Owens is acclaimed author, art historian and curator: her most recent book is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 31 Trailer 2 and Review (Series 1): Heat! Camera! Action!

    Nov 2, 202619 minAudio

    So - this is that sort of trailer that comes in part after the vehicle. Looking back as well as forward. Series 1: 40 shows to Dec 23rd this year. In all 20 women guests, 20 men Series 2 will begin around the end of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 30 Rob Hopkins on time travel to the future, and the great achievements of the Transition Movement

    Oct 28, 202659 minAudio

    We’re at the home of Rob Hopkins close to Totnes in south Devon, and we’re talking time travel. Rob is the co-founder of the Transition Movement, and we chat about the revelatory moment when he saw a T-shirt saying,...

    Credit the people on this episode