Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heart Versus Head

Heart Versus Head artwork

Are You Rowing in the Same Direction

Jul 15, 202616 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Are you both Hearts? Are you both Heads? Do you think it would be easier if you were with someone more like you? In this episode, Randy and Beverly talk about the importance of balance when it comes to relationship dynamics. In all disagreements, someone is going to be in Heart mode and someone is going to be in Head mode. If you're both doing it the same, you will end up going in circles (and slamming into the riverbank quite a bit). It's time to get your boat moving in the right direction... together. Send us Fan Mail Heart Versus Head is a podcast about relationship styles and how those relationship styles influence communication in the most important relationships. The hosts - Randy Hampton and Beverly Craddock - are a married couple who are sought-after relationship coaches, award-winning authors and regular people who (like everyone in relationships) are just trying to stay connected through all the noise of life in the modern world. You can learn more about the couple and their work at HeartAndHeadCoaching.com, where you'll learn to fight better and connect again. Or check out their relationship books: Heart Versus Head: How to Communicate and Connect When Nothing Else Works (2026) and The Couples Rulebook (2019).

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Heart vs. Head, a podcast that helps couples communicate and fight better. Here are your hosts, Randy Hampton and Beverly Craddock.

SPEAKER_02Hey everybody, it's Randy and Beverly. Welcome to the Heart versus Head Podcast. Great to have you along. Uh having having fun doing this. This week we're going to be talking about something very interesting. We're going to talk about what if you and your partner are the same relationship style. What is it when two hearts or two heads get into a relationship? What goes on in that dynamic? We will uh talk about that because we were asked about it. Before we get to that, we take a look at things from a heart versus head perspective.

SPEAKER_02So in every relationship, one partner's going to be in heart mode, one partner's going to be in head mode. Heads, I'm the head in Beverly's and my relationship. Heads are the partners that look at things very black and white, very right, wrong, fact-based to make decisions. Hearts, meanwhile, are making decisions by deciding how other people feel about those decisions and how they feel themselves about the decisions. So they take everybody's feelings into account to make decisions. This difference in decision-making styles leads to differences in communication, leads to differences in the way that we do things, leads to differences in a whole bunch of stuff in our relationship, and it causes conflict.

SPEAKER_02We are relationship coaches, heart and head coaching. We are based out of Honolulu, Hawaii. We have been doing this for a, well, a darn long time, and we've learned a little bit about relationships. And we started this podcast about a year and a half ago in order to get people to think about these things, think about their relationship differently, and maybe make some difference out there in the world for people to be in more comfortable relationships. This week on the podcast, we ran into somebody that we know, and as they were kind of walking away with their partner, one of them turned around and said, Hey, what if there's two heads in a relationship?

SPEAKER_02What if what if they're both heads? And I I think it's probably because in that relationship, I would tell you those those people are are probably two heads. One of the things we notice, especially here in Hawaii, is in cultural differences, you often see more of that kind of that crossover, that switch, where you get more female heads, more male hearts. In some cultures, Western culture tends to be, uh, at least in the past, more heads are male and hearts are female.

SPEAKER_02And that's all switching around too now in Western culture. So, anyways, that's a long introduction. Friend of ours said, what if there's two heads in a relationship?

SPEAKER_00Right. And I think we're also going to address uh two hearts in a relationship as well. So the head-to-head in partnership is can be great. I mean, they're let's talk about the good things, right? Uh they can have uh predictability, they are very efficient, dependable, intellectually maybe stimulating, solving problems, respecting one another, avoiding uh drama. However, that can also lead to conflict, right?

SPEAKER_00So a lot of times feelings aren't discussed, they're assumed, perhaps. One person is looking at the other and just assuming my partner is angry and and or maybe they're just quiet because they're just thinking of something when maybe they really do have an issue. So a lot of times each partner is is dealing with their own stuff internally, and that that may feel very unseen.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that happens a lot in relationships where people maybe meet at work or meet at things where they're gonna be around people that are that are similar to them, and so you get you know, two heads or two hearts that'll that'll kind of bump into each other based on commonalities, and they go, wow, this person really gets me. They like the same things I like, they're into that. I remember in in my first marriage, and I was married to my first wife for 19 years. We were both definitely heads, and the relationship was uh, I think for for many years, very stable and very efficient.

SPEAKER_02It's like a machine when it's when it's two heads in a relationship, and everything runs along good until it doesn't, until that conflict comes up. In that situation, two heads in conflict, somebody's somebody's gonna adjust out on that to create that balance, they're gonna go into heart mode. And so you end up with still that heart versus head dynamic, but now you've got somebody kind of operating out of a style that's maybe not their their base style.

SPEAKER_02And it it does create conflict and happens with, as Beverly said, when two hearts are in a relationship too. And I know that was probably a lot of the case in in your first marriage, Beverly, because it it sounds like you and and your first husband, your ex were both hearts, and so at some point somebody goes into head mode in that relationship. It relationships seek balance, that's what they're there for, and they kind of do that.

SPEAKER_00So Randy jumped over to hearts and and two hearts together. We'll talk about the positives again, excelling at empathy, uh, emotional support, making one another feel cared for, seen, all the very qualities that do create closeness, but yet there are challenges. So one of the things that can happen is conversations can be very repetitive and long, a lot of words, because each is seeking that deeper understanding before they're ready to move forward.

SPEAKER_00So, for example, my first husband later in life when he had a challenge with alcoholism, a lot of times that solution was just so difficult because it was this constant uh wanting to protect one another from disappointment and you know absorbing each other's stress and just that personal responsibility is so hard to separate from our shared responsibility. So it was very difficult as his partner. And I finally, when I divorced and moved on with my life, I felt such a relief to be out from under all of that pressure, all of that weight.

SPEAKER_00Really, when you look at relationships and and the the two hearts, the two heads, they they do have challenges and likely one person will go opposite as as Randy says. And I also can I I want to throw one thing in. I had a listener a couple weeks ago say, Oh, well, your your first husband was just crap. It was just really bad, it was horrible, and and that's not my partner and I. And and I had to back up a little bit and say, whoa, whoa, whoa.

SPEAKER_00I I have said on the podcast that he was alcoholic, which anyone who's ever dealt with any addiction issues understands that that is a very complicated relationship.

SPEAKER_02However, it wasn't all that he was.

SPEAKER_00No, no, no. Yeah. In fact, we we dated for seven years, uh, fantastic dating, loved every minute of it, had uh two children together, that 13 years of marriage, uh up until the the drinking thing, which showed up about the last four or five years. So really about uh 20 great years and then four that really sucked.

SPEAKER_02It is interesting the way I think I I look at this, because you in that relationship really, because as it closes out and the alcohol issues come up, you ended up in head mode. In my first marriage, where we were both heads, I ended up being the one in heart mode. And so if we step back, and this is where I think people get confused, because everybody, when they first kind of start looking at heart and head, they they say, Oh, wait, you know, I'm this, and that doesn't make sense, and we're both this, or you know, I'm more this, and sometimes heads want to be more in touch or emotionally aware, and they go, Well, you know, I've got heart qualities as well, or I can do that sometimes.

SPEAKER_02These things are all true. Think of it this way: there are naturally born hearts and kind of what I would call a natural head. Heads aren't born, every child is is a heart until they experience something and decide to do it differently in their brain. But hearts are kind of hearts are born and then heads are are created, and and that's a natural head, kind of created by life to make their decisions differently. So there's natural in the relationship style, and then there is relational hearts and heads.

SPEAKER_02And this is what occurs when two heads get together and and one is just by the the natural forces of creating balance becomes a heart. That is a relational heart. So that that person has made a change to accommodate the balance, and as long as you're aware of it, this can be incredibly strong in a relationship. But there are also not only are there natural hearts and heads, relational hearts and heads, there's also stressed hearts and heads.

SPEAKER_02So hearts under stress will move into head mode, heads under stress will go into heart mode, and so all of these things can affect when you look out there at my partner is this and I am this. All these things can be affected situationally, relationally, and then naturally. So it it you gotta be aware of things. And I think the way Beverly and I talk about it is when you're in the conflict, recognize who's taking on that role in that moment because it can switch back and forth or or or be a little bit more hidden.

SPEAKER_02But if you get down to the level of every argument, somebody's gonna be in heart mode, somebody's gonna be in head mode in that particular moment. It's most likely the person that's generally in heart mode is gonna be in heart mode, and the person that's generally in head mode is gonna be in head mode, but there are shifts that occur based on stress or or balance in the relationship and those kind of things. So it's tricky to watch. What else do we need to talk about, Beverly, with this?

SPEAKER_00So I always like to give a metaphor. Um, and I also want to say that two heads will view each other as critical when they get stressed. Two hearts will view it as overly emotional and feeling each other's emotions. If one's anxious, the other's anxious. If one withdraws, the other one feels abandoned. So then feelings become layered. But really, the head and the heart together, if you were to think of maybe a river and maybe the head is teaching the relationship how to move forward.

SPEAKER_00The heart teaches the relationship why moving forward matters. So it's like the head has the map and the other remembers who is next to them. We each have both inside of us a head and a heart. However, over time we've developed one more strongly, just as Randy has said, a lot of factors in growing up. So lasting relationships are not built by changing who you are, they're built by borrowing the wisdom of the part that comes naturally.

SPEAKER_00So the head learns to pause before fixing, and the heart learns to breathe before emotion. And when both partners are using better regulation within themselves, then conflict stops feeling like two people pulling against one another. It becomes two people rowing the same boat, one watching the current and one watching the destination. Together, they arrive where neither could have reached it alone.

SPEAKER_02That makes a lot of sense. I think in the book Heart versus Head, which is uh available on Amazon if you want to read more into this or understand it a little bit better, Heart versus Head on Amazon. I think in the book we gave an example, and I I I maybe regret writing the example because it's a basketball example, and it's a basketball example from the 1980s, and so you know, many, many, many people were very, very young or not even alive then and and were old, I don't I say old late 50s. We're late 50s.

SPEAKER_02Okay, I'm old. And I think the basketball example is is useful, but let's put this in terms that people in 2026 can understand. If you have a World Cup team, everybody's soccer nuts right now at the World Cup in the United States and Canada and Mexico hosting. If you have a World Cup team and that World Cup team is made up of nothing but you know strikers and goal scorers, you're gonna score a lot of goals. But the reality is the other team's gonna score a lot of goals against you because you don't have people that play quality defense.

SPEAKER_02You want to build a good World Cup team, you have offense and defense, and this is important when you build your relationship. If you want to build a strong relationship, if you want to be in a relationship that raises amazing kids, if you want to be in a relationship that doesn't have all the stresses from work and life and all of those things blowing it up, find some balance in that relationship. Let that heart and head dynamic work naturally because you're more balanced.

SPEAKER_02You're playing with offense and you're playing with defense in a way that you have a strong team. And I think that that kind of gets to Beverly's point of everybody rowing in the same direction for different reasons. And you're right, we do get to that destination, and we probably couldn't get there if we were exactly the same. If if both of us are rowing on the right side of the boat, we are ultimately going in circles and the the current will smash us into either shore of the river. It's when we're we're able to kind of do that opposite thing, that dance, and we've talked about that before.

SPEAKER_02When we're able to do that well, then you get balance and you get where you need to go. What else do we need to add before we get out of here? That's all I have. That is all we have. I am notoriously happy in this relationship as the head partner. Beverly is is my crazy heart partner. I mean that in the the kindest way possible when I when I use the word crazy. I just I love her energy, I love her passion, I love I love her, and and it's awesome to be in balance like that. It does not mean we don't have conflict, we have conflict all the time, especially when we're stressed out.

SPEAKER_02And if you listen over the last few weeks, we've been stressed out about some stuff. Hey, do us a favor. If you're if you're listening to this podcast, if you go, hey, this hits home for me, this is this is interesting, I like this, hit the follow button and and follow this podcast for us. We encourage you to share it with your friends and your family. If it'll help other people have better relationships, if you know people that are struggling and they're like, I don't even know who this person is anymore, share it with them. We're we're here to we're here to help.

SPEAKER_02That is the podcast. Join us next week on Heart vs. Head. Aloha.

SPEAKER_01Thanks for listening to Heart versus Head. You can learn more at Heartandheadcoaching.com and check out new podcast episodes every Wednesday. If you have a question for Randy and Beverly, send an email to info at Heart and Head Coaching.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Connection Versus Space Loop

    Nov 18, 202625 minAudio

    Hearts love to spend time with the people they love. Heads enjoy that - but also get stressed out if they're constantly thinking they need to fix things for the people they love. This can mean that when Hearts push in...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Who to Date

    Nov 11, 202614 minAudio

    Are you dating? Or back in the dating game? Are you having trouble deciding what you want in a partner or finding someone who checks all the boxes and doesn't have any 'red flags'? Science can help. New research is...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Marriage is Boring

    Nov 4, 202621 minAudio

    Marriage is boring. That's the gist of a recent Reddit post we saw where a Heart partner was complaining about her Head partner and the loss of spark in the relationship. He was, she said, a great husband, dad, provider...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Airing of the Grievances

    Oct 28, 202619 minAudio

    No... this isn't about the Festivus episode of Seinfeld. This episode is about an article in The Atlantic that shared how some couples only hash out their disagreements at scheduled quarterly or even yearly meetings...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. It's Just the Honeymoon Phase

    Oct 21, 202621 minAudio

    Have you ever been in a wonderful new relationship and everybody around you minimizes it or warns you that the wonderful will surely end? What if that isn't necessarily true. In this episode, Randy and Beverly talk...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode