Do you and your partner have the same definition of love? Are you sure? We've found that the Heart partner and the Head partner see love in very different ways. Hearts are feeling it. Heads are managing it. Find out why that matters so much as Randy and Beverly talk about how love is defined. Send us Fan Mail Heart Versus Head is a podcast about relationship styles and how those relationship styles influence communication in the most important relationships. The hosts - Randy Hampton and Beverly Craddock - are a married couple who are sought-after relationship coaches, award-winning authors and regular people who (like everyone in relationships) are just trying to stay connected through all the noise of life in the modern world. You can learn more about the couple and their work at HeartAndHeadCoaching.com, where you'll learn to fight better and connect again. Or check out their relationship books: Heart Versus Head: How to Communicate and Connect When Nothing Else Works (2026) and The Couples Rulebook (2019).
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Heart vs. Head, a podcast that helps couples communicate and fight better. Here are your hosts, Randy Hampton and Beverly Craddock.
SPEAKER_01Hey everybody, it's Randy and Beverly. Welcome to the podcast Heart vs. Head. A quick disclaimer. Beverly is on cold medicine. Hey, Beverly.
SPEAKER_02Hi.
SPEAKER_01Sorry, she's getting over a cold. Just kind of recovering from it. The cold medicine makes her a little bit funny. More hearty. Well, welcome to the podcast. Enough about all of that. We are Randy and Beverly, a married couple. We've been married for about 16 years now. We work as relationship communication coaches in Honolulu, Hawaii, with uh tons and tons and tons of clients, actually, clients all around the world. Uh help people communicate better. We take everything from kind of a heart and head perspective.
SPEAKER_01In our relationship, I'm a head. And I look at things, I make decisions in the relationship from a very black and white perspective, kind of right, wrong. Beverly's a heart, and that just means she cares about everybody, darn it. Um, and so you take everybody into account when you make decisions. And because we make decisions differently, we've found that that's where most couples run into conflict. That's what we're here to talk about, uh, how to how to get out of some of that conflict. Today we're going to talk about some definitions, and it's really important that you have the same definition for some of these things.
SPEAKER_01What are we trying to define today, Beverly? What's the magic word of the day?
SPEAKER_02It's a song. It's what is love?
SPEAKER_01What is what is love? What baby don't hurt me. What is love? All right, we're gonna talk about love on the podcast today. And gosh, it's such a big topic, and surely everybody agrees on what love is, but let's talk about it from a heart and head perspective. You're the heart, Beverly. You're far more equipped to deal with love than I probably could ever claim to be. Tell us what is love. Where do we start on this topic?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so a heart is gonna look at love as more a feeling base. So we define love by what happens kind of inside of us, the emotion of love. And it's it's hard for hearts to describe it. I know uh Randy and I had this issue come up when we were writing the couple's rule book. We talked about what is love, and that was where I first learned, and this was well into our marriage several years, that we defined love differently.
SPEAKER_01Completely differently.
SPEAKER_02And the first thing I had to do was I had to go and text everybody that I loved and ask them, what is love, to find this for me.
SPEAKER_01Help me out here.
SPEAKER_02I I think the guy I married's broken. Right. And luckily, most people were hearts, and so they confirmed.
SPEAKER_01I was crazy.
SPEAKER_02Right. They're like, oh gosh, I don't know. I just I just feel it. You know, it's like that spark, that connection. You know, sometimes it's partly chemistry. When it's right, you know it. And all of that just made sense. It makes sense to me, to them. And it's it's just this emotion that is is our guiding light. Guiding light. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Well, that that's lovely for us. That's spectacular. Yay. Um, you know, good, yeah, good, good for you that that you do that. Um, heads do it completely differently. So as I as we were talking earlier today, and and Beverly's like, oh, how do you define love? And as hard as I try as a head, as as a thinker, uh as hard as I try to understand love, it always ends up in an action.
SPEAKER_01It always ends up in an action that I or someone else is taking. So I love Beverly and because I care for her and I take care of her and I rub her back, and or Beverly loves me because she puts up with me and she's sweet to me, and all of those things. And but it's always an action. There's always a list. Yeah, that that that always ends at somebody's doing something. And it it really does in that way confirm that that you know, head and harder how people are looking at this, because that's absolutely true in like every couple, they come in and and if you push enough on the head to to try to understand what they're experiencing and and how they define it, you realize that we as heads have become so distant from our emotions that we're not really capable of defining even the the good ones because we don't let ourselves feel all that stuff.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, for for heads, then it's very external, observer, observable. Uh, it can be seen, measured, or maintained. And that may look like in their actions, maybe they show up in a certain way, or maybe they're more consistent, maybe they're loyal in that way, or more responsible. So it definitely has value. I know sometimes when when when I first learned that Randy defined it with a list, I think I went into a deep dark depression for two weeks.
SPEAKER_01It it was a it was a little while where it was kind of stunning that that we see it differently. I think the only thing that really kind of pulled her out of the depression is the depression turned into really Beverly kind of feeling sorry for me that I couldn't experience it when she realized this wasn't a choice. I wasn't going, gee, I hope I I don't get to feel things big and wonderful like love. It's like a disability. It was like a survival mechanism for I don't want to feel all the bad stuff, so I've quelled that all down.
SPEAKER_01So really, I think where Beverly came out of that was when she kind of took on a little bit of compassion, and that's something that we talk to couples about is you have to understand your partner and the fact that they're not broken, they're they're they're experiencing love the way they're experiencing love. But unless you talk about what love is, you don't even get into these conversations to understand it. But then when you do get into the conversations, they start to get really deep into maybe what's wrong in your relationship or what's challenging you.
SPEAKER_01Because when you sit down and go, okay, wait a second, what is love? And you realize the person across from you has a different definition of that, that's a fundamental problem. The that you have to go, okay, you you don't have to agree, you don't have to do it the same way, but you darn well better understand it because when you sit down to talk about things, if if as the head partner you want your partner to be happy and you're like, but I do love you, I do love you, and they're the heart partner think, but yeah, I need you to love me, and you know, heads are like, I don't know what that means.
SPEAKER_01If you can't understand this part of it, if you can't understand that definition part of it, you're not gonna get there. You can't achieve what your partner really is is looking for. And so it it really benefits you to have this conversation, to understand their definition, to understand what they're doing, how they're kind of expecting you to come at it. It'll give you some answers.
SPEAKER_02For hearts, there there are strengths and weaknesses. The the strengths would be that we do experience deep connection, intimacy, passion, that bonding, having that ability to empathize. And it feels very alive, very meaningful, but on the downside, it it can feel somewhat unstable. It can be very intense, and it can also be very frustrating because if we're not with somebody that speaks kind of that language, then we we feel very frustrated, uh rejected sometimes.
SPEAKER_02Whereas, like a head, the the pro side of that is it's very stable, has long-term viability, there's very clear boundaries, there are uh standards involved, and they're really less likely to be swept into the emotion of the day. They, on the other hand, the negative side, it feels very transactional or like a checklist, which is kind of the way I took it in the beginning. It might look really good on paper, but it doesn't feel as fulfilling.
SPEAKER_01Well, and I think that that gets back to where we come at it. I think we're as heads looking for a level of, you know, stability and a level of long-term security. And so maybe those wonderful emotions, because emotions for us have always felt fleeting. Maybe the brain just thinks, oh, if I if I don't let the emotion be so big, it it can last. If I don't let it get crazy in our head, if I don't let the emotion get too big, I can keep this emotion.
SPEAKER_01I can feel this love.
SPEAKER_02Sustain it, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it may, it may just be that I can make it last for a lifetime? A lifetime, which is which is what we're which is what we're looking for.
SPEAKER_02You kind of bowed that, yeah. Right.
SPEAKER_01It certainly can't last a lifetime, but for us at that level of woo, because we just don't we don't sustain emotions that way. We're we're not built to do it that way.
SPEAKER_02Right. And I also can't make this list. I mean, I do things for Randy, and there are actionable items of showing love, but that isn't to me what what love is. The takeaway is that the most grounded definition of love is really a combination of both. It's that felt emotional connection, that attraction, and it's also those demonstrated actions with consistency and respect. So what's interesting is heart and head, as we've said in multiple podcasts, we make a great couple because we have the kind of the yin and the yang.
SPEAKER_02We have the the opposites, and what is key when it comes to defining love is to understand in the ways that we are opposite, so that we're not always having missed expectations or or needs left on the table. Basically, the imbalance would be where I have a lot of emotion and feeling, but I'm not showing any actions or perhaps not really sharing that respect or appreciation to Randy.
SPEAKER_02On the opposite side, perhaps he's doing all these things on the list, but doesn't show me with any of those vulnerable moments of feeling and connection.
SPEAKER_01The heart partner becomes frustrated that they're not getting the emotional connection with the head partner. A lot of times it'll turn to, you know, triggering anger. It'll it'll turn to anger because the heart is desperate to find a reaction, to find an emotional reaction from their partner. And they seem to be able to trigger one. The problem is it's anger and they're trying to trigger love, but if they can't trigger love, anger might be kind of the next best thing because our brain looks at anger as what's called an approach emotion.
SPEAKER_01Basically, when people are angry, they they fight and argue and try to work things out. Um, we always think of anger as running away and it really isn't in the brain. It's why anger is not actually a bad emotion, is it's trying to get you to work something out. It's it's just when anger becomes unstable and turns towards violence, it's a it's a useless emotion at that point. But that's not the purpose of anger. The purpose of anger is actually to work things out. So sometimes hearts will be frustrated that nobody's feeling anything and they they go, okay, I'll make you feel something, and then suddenly there's there's anger there.
SPEAKER_01So it can work both ways.
SPEAKER_02So a lot of the the problems that we see with couples when they come in, the feeling heart-based partner will say, they're a robot, they're cold, where's the passion? And the head sits over there in their own corner and says, Well, nothing I ever do is enough. You're never satisfied. So it's one person saying, I don't feel you, the other one's saying, I'm showing you. They're each in their own truth from their own perspective, but yet they both feel rejected just for different reasons.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01How many times have have I, as a head, you know, you go, Oh, I'm doing everything I can. What more do you need from me? And that's just a sign that I've got a list in my head and I'm doing the things on the list, and and it's not accomplishing. But you see, by talking about these things, by sitting down and having the definition of love and understanding the that maybe your head partner's got a list, my instant reaction to that is wouldn't it be cool to know what's on the list? Hearts ask them. You know, ask what's on that list.
SPEAKER_01What are you doing? Uh so that you can understand how your partner's delivering love. They may be doing a ton of things, you're just not tracking it. And when you can you can go, oh wait, they're they're trying to show their love that way. Oh, okay. I understand that now. Now you can see some love in that action. We've talked on the program before about um how how I love to cook, and Beverly looked at cooking as just another chore, and so it was never a big deal to her that I was cooking.
SPEAKER_01It was just a chore to get out of the way. But I was doing it out of love, and so we had a little bit of a uh misunderstanding maybe about why, where that comes from. But if you don't talk about love and the things that you do for the for your partner, you really don't get there. We were writing a book at the time, so we we kind of had that conversation and it taught us to have these conversations.
SPEAKER_02I wanted to give one more example. So we had a phone client recently, and they had done the first session, gained a lot of tips and and and hands-on strategies. And then when we got on the phone, we were doing a follow-up second session. It was so interesting because the heart partner was sitting there saying, Oh my gosh, it's been a horrible week. We we didn't have any chemistry, there was no closeness. I just feel like we're drifting apart. And the head partner was just stunned and said, Oh my gosh, we we had the best week ever.
SPEAKER_02We got so much done. We were week ever consistent, we were reliable, we both were putting in effort, and they were oblivious that the week didn't go well for their partner. So I think you can start to see where just this definition is gonna create a whole lot of issues in the relationship. Again, we're saying that both people are right, the head and the heart. You're both right, your perception is right. So, what we want is to allow for both in the relationship.
SPEAKER_02So, what we need to do is understand one another, having this conversation, talking about it, and really diving deep, you know, really understanding how that list works in the in the head and and and what the heart is is really talking about. A lot of times I tell hearts, it's your job to really help them understand, explain it in such a way, you know, show them, be the be the love that you're looking for. Because when you bring connection to your head partner, they will meet you there.
SPEAKER_02And so many times a heart is like, well, no, they should already know, and they should, they should approach me first, or or or I feel rejected, so now I'm not gonna do it. And and that's just never gonna work. You're not gonna get back together. We're not gonna solve this if we just sit in our opposite locations. Another thing would be to, again, have more understanding and empathy for one another and be careful that your words don't sound like criticism.
SPEAKER_02If the heart partner is saying, you know, I feel like you don't care, or if they say, Well, well, so what? You did all these things for me, you know, you didn't sit and hold my hand. You know, those things can be very critical. And and the problem with that is that when we do that and when we push for more, the head feels criticized and pulls away more. And so the heart is pushing harder, wanting more. This is usually that anger stage. The head partner shuts shuts down more. So now it's no longer about love at all. It's just everybody being defensive and protecting.
SPEAKER_01Ultimately, for heads, ask the question. Try to understand. Talk to your partner, ask them, what is love? How do you define it? What is it that that you get? What are the things that you see that I do where you do feel loved? What are the things that I do where you don't feel loved? What are the things that I could do differently to increase the amount of love you feel? Ask some questions. Just come at it with, hey, I wanna I wanna be that that person. I want to be, I want to be that partner for you.
SPEAKER_01And it can really make a big difference for you.
SPEAKER_02What we always tell couples is heads need respect and appreciation. So respect the list, respect all the things that they are doing. It is valuable, it is their way of showing love, and also make sure that you are asking for what you need, making sure that you're sending emotional signals, having that eye contact, watching your tone, perhaps reaching out, touching, you know, their arm, their leg, or something. A lot of these ways of physically being with your partner is a great connection, and it's a great way to ask kind of for what you need without even using words.
SPEAKER_02Nonverbally, you're letting your partner know that you are looking for some of that connection right now. Neither one of us is doing it wrong, that we each love each other, but in a different way, a way that we don't quite maybe understand yet, but yet that doesn't mean that we don't love one another. It just means that we need to reach a deeper level of understanding and to have these conversations so that when we do that, we become kind of bilingual.
SPEAKER_02We can speak our love language, but also the one of our partner, which makes it that we're both fluent in that feeling of love and also fluent in showing that love.
SPEAKER_01Fluent in head and heart is a good place to get to. That is the podcast. And I'll give you this final note. If you're having trouble defining love, take a moment, get your partner with you, hold their hand or give them a hug, or or do something and and hang on to that for about 20 seconds and just really feel that. And maybe that's a start on having a conversation about what love is.
SPEAKER_01See, heads, it's it's there. You can feel it. Just let yourself. It's uh and hearts let 'em and let them be safe in doing that. And be patient. It'll change everything. That's the podcast for today. Thanks for tuning in, everybody. Heart vs. Head. Uh, we will talk to you next time. Aloha.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to Heart vs. Head. You can learn more at Heartandhead Coaching dot com and check out new podcast episodes every Wednesday. If you have a question for Randy and Beverly, send an email to info at Heart and Head Coaching.com.
Hearts love to spend time with the people they love. Heads enjoy that - but also get stressed out if they're constantly thinking they need to fix things for the people they love. This can mean that when Hearts push in...
Are you dating? Or back in the dating game? Are you having trouble deciding what you want in a partner or finding someone who checks all the boxes and doesn't have any 'red flags'? Science can help. New research is...
Marriage is boring. That's the gist of a recent Reddit post we saw where a Heart partner was complaining about her Head partner and the loss of spark in the relationship. He was, she said, a great husband, dad, provider...
No... this isn't about the Festivus episode of Seinfeld. This episode is about an article in The Atlantic that shared how some couples only hash out their disagreements at scheduled quarterly or even yearly meetings...
Have you ever been in a wonderful new relationship and everybody around you minimizes it or warns you that the wonderful will surely end? What if that isn't necessarily true. In this episode, Randy and Beverly talk...