Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Heart Versus Head

Heart Versus Head artwork

Finding Your Way Home From Quiet Quitting

Sep 16, 202622 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Have you ever felt like giving up on your relationship without actually leaving the relationship? Do you have those days where you think, "why try if my partner won't try?" In this episode, Randy and Beverly talk about the trend of "quiet quitting" in marriage. Oprah Winfrey brought it up in her podcast recently and her guests focused on the growing number of (mostly) women in their 40s who stay in a marriage but become emotionally detached from their partner. Instead of giving up, learn how you can both change your perspective and get back to focusing on building an amazing home with your partner - safe, strong and filled with connection. #HeartVersusHead #QuietQuitting #Oprah #WhyTry #CouplesGoals Send us Fan Mail Heart Versus Head is a podcast about relationship styles and how those relationship styles influence communication in the most important relationships. The hosts - Randy Hampton and Beverly Craddock - are a married couple who are sought-after relationship coaches, award-winning authors and regular people who (like everyone in relationships) are just trying to stay connected through all the noise of life in the modern world. You can learn more about the couple and their work at HeartAndHeadCoaching.com, where you'll learn to fight better and connect again. Or check out their relationship books: Heart Versus Head: How to Communicate and Connect When Nothing Else Works (2026) and The Couples Rulebook (2019).

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Heart vs. Head, a podcast that helps couples communicate and fight better. Here are your hosts, Randy Hampton and Beverly Craddock.

SPEAKER_02Hey everybody, it's Randy and Beverly. Welcome to the Heart versus Head Podcast. We're gonna have some fun today. Beverly, what are we talking about today?

SPEAKER_00We're talking about something I heard on the Oprah podcast. It actually aired back in August, but I just happened to catch it over the weekend. And it's a got regarding this trend out there where women over 40 mostly is the cat is the age group who have emotionally detached from their marriages, but yet they're remaining married and not really going through divorces. So the divorce rate is kind of leveling off in that age group. And what they're saying is this is quiet quitting.

SPEAKER_02People are quiet quitting on their marriages. And we're gonna dive into that from a different perspective. For those of you that are new to the podcast, Beverly and I are relationship coaches out of Honolulu, Hawaii. We have worked with thousands of couples. We are not doctors, not psychologists, not psychiatrists. We are actually social scientists who take a very, very different look at relationships because we lean on not gender, not men and women, but we lean on heart and head in relationships.

SPEAKER_02In your relationship, one of you is going to be in head mode. One of you takes on a role of making decisions very logically, very specifically, black, white, right, wrong, do it this way, very structured, very direct communicators. That person's the head partner. That's me and Beverly's and my relationship. And then there's the heart partner. Beverly's the heart and our relationship. And heart partners really are making their decisions based on how everybody feels. We make decisions differently in our relationships.

SPEAKER_02This is not gender-based. Now, and uh we'll talk about that some more as we talk about this quiet quitting in relationship concept, but realize we're gonna come at this from a different angle. We're gonna come at this from heart versus head and try to help you understand what may be going on if your relationship feels a lot like some of these relationships, certainly that Oprah was talking about and that we're going to talk about today. So we'll see if we can't maybe do it from a different angle and really give you a more useful way to mitigate this if this feels like what's happening in your relationship.

SPEAKER_02Quiet quitting, if you're not familiar with the term, it came around kind of pandemic time frame, maybe even a little bit earlier than that, where people started doing the bare minimum in their jobs. Don't expect them to do anything beyond exactly what's in that job description, and they don't really care. They don't put any passion into it, they don't put any effort except for the bare minimum effort. Quiet quitting. They're not quitting, but they're not really doing physically they're there. And this is apparently what's going on in relationship.

SPEAKER_00So one of the reasons this podcast really resonated with me is that I'm gonna take a quick step back for new listeners. Randy and I got married, a second marriage for each of us that was in 2010. We got married and then shortly thereafter moved to Hawaii and we ran this uh relationship coaching business. So as we were seeing hundreds of couples, we were starting to notice that they were saying a lot of the same things we were saying.

SPEAKER_00And so when we tried to look for resources and as social scientists, as we tried to provide more explanation for these clients, there was really nothing out there that talked about how we make decisions. It was all gender-based. And Randy and I were noticing, especially in Hawaii, that we see a lot of same-sex marriages and they are struggling with the same things. So we knew that this was not a gender-based issue.

SPEAKER_00So we dug a bit deeper. We started writing our first relationship book, The Couples Rule Book, put it out on Amazon early 2019. What was interesting in that book is when we put our own relationship under a microscope to really examine what was going on, I was secretly feeling as though Randy and I were becoming more detached. And I didn't understand it. From my perspective, I could only look at my past relationships.

SPEAKER_00First husband, we were two hearts for a very long time until his alcoholism pushed me into a head mode. Head mode meaning I had to step up, worry about the future, be the responsible one, take care of the kids, and so forth. Single mom mode. Yes, eventually divorced and truly was single mom. So I looked back at that relationship, and because we were two hearts for several years, I assumed that Randy was just like me, another heart.

SPEAKER_00That's that's a very human thing to do. We make assumptions about our partner and their values and the their beliefs and perceptions, the way they look at relationships and connection.

SPEAKER_02Early in relationships, we're kind of all operating in heart mode. We're putting all that energy into building a connection with a person. So we do start out in heart mode, and I was very much in heart mode coming off of my divorce because I'd become the heart partner in my first marriage. So I was in heart mode. Beverly was desperately seeking somebody that could be, and here we were. I checked all those boxes until I didn't.

SPEAKER_00Right. And that is something that it took a while because again, married 2010, going through those uh honeymoon phase years, and then moving to Hawaii was kind of more of that honeymoon phase. It it's hard not to just be two lovers in love in Hawaii. So it took quite a while for us to reach that point where Randy went back to his natural way, which was head mode. And I just felt, where'd you go? I just felt kind of abandoned, not so much rejected at that point, but it was something was wrong, and I didn't know what it was.

SPEAKER_00At the same time, we're noticing it in other couples, and and we start to write the book. There's a point in the book writing where we realize this breakthrough that hearts and heads make decisions differently. And this was it. This was the nugget in in all of the relationships we'd seen, in our own relationship. And we started having these very vulnerable and real conversations with one another. And when I realized that Randy was not doing the relationship the same way I was, that he was ahead, I did not understand that.

SPEAKER_00Like most people, this is a different concept. And it really shut me down for a while. So the quiet quitting is something that I feel I experienced not as a logical choice. This was just something that I just tunneled into. And I was there for a while, I think a couple of months as we're writing the book. What I realize now is that most people, most uh in Oprah's podcast, she talks about how these women just feel this disconnect and they're seeking that connection from their partner.

SPEAKER_00It's gone because the children, the job, all the things that we find ourselves so busy with that we just don't have that time or priority in that relationship. And so when that happens, that disconnect is there, we don't know what to do as the heart. And we keep asking and we we start complaining and we start telling our partner, you know, you're not listening, or are am I even important to you? And then the head is feeling this criticism.

SPEAKER_02Right. And it all begins to sound a lot like criticism to a head partner, and I think that that criticism kind of shuts the the head partner down. Maybe we're both kind of quiet quitting at that point where the heart partner is tired of asking for connection, and the head partner is tired of feeling like they suck. Because that's that's what it feels like. The you know, I'm not good enough providing your needs, you're always unhappy.

SPEAKER_02It feels like I can't do this, I can't do this, I can't do this, I suck. We turn it into criticism as a head. Now we're stuck because we're both quiet, quitting on the relationship. We're both out and we both stopped asking.

SPEAKER_00Right. And so the irony of it all is when both partners shut down, it actually can run smoothly from a physical standpoint. The bills are getting paid, the the children's needs are taken care of. When we're no longer fighting because we both shut down, now things are are happening. And and what's interesting is a lot of times the head will say, Oh, okay, great. At least she's not complaining. She's not bitching about it anymore.

SPEAKER_02I'm okay. When the head partner stops hearing the complaining, their brain tells them that everything is good. They they've now made their partner, quote, happy, and that's not actually what's happening. They've just worn their partner out. But because heads are so unemotionally connected, there we're not connected to our emotions in the same way that a heart is. We don't feel that disconnect, and so we don't see it that way.

SPEAKER_02And so when your partner gives up, a lot of relationships seem to settle into this period of time where one partner's given up and the other partner doesn't even have to pay attention because they're sitting there, the heads going, Oh, they're happy now. I don't have to, I don't have to even work as hard. And it's that kind of that moment where the heart gives up that the head ends up giving up. And so nobody's getting what they want at that point.

SPEAKER_02We see so many couples that come in and they can identify the points where each of them gave up. Uh if you want to go back and listen, there's a there's an episode from last season called The Moment, which talks about these moments where we let our partner down, or they let us down, and we make a decision in our head that this is how it's going to be. And the problem is so often those decisions that we make are based on a misperception. The heart believes the head doesn't want to connect, the heart believes the head is not doing this because they don't want to, and and that's the damage is it's not that way in the mind of a head.

SPEAKER_02I wasn't being disconnected because I did not love Beverly. I was being disconnected because I thought I had to manage everything else so that Beverly could be happy, or I could be happy.

SPEAKER_00Right. And well, we're gonna get to the solution here in a minute, but I want to also point out so the heart also usually is still loving the head. This this is part of why there's not a divorce, is we we get along, maybe we're best friends, maybe there's you know great intimacy. There are a lot of other pluses. We don't want to leave the kids without a family unit. But whatever that is, they're they're not divorcing, and the heart is finding their needs met in other ways.

SPEAKER_00I mean, we live now in this culture where mental health is big and getting a coach, perhaps. And so these hearts are out getting their needs met in other ways, getting fulfilled, which is great. We shouldn't rely on our partner for all of our needs. However, what ends up happening over time is the relationship becomes, as Oprah's uh podcast says, becomes roommates with history. And I think that's where a lot of listeners might identify is has my relationship become this feeling of roommates with history?

SPEAKER_00And then what I want people to realize is the solution isn't as hard as we all might think it is. We might look at this and say, well, if we're two different people, if this is your premise of heart versus head, we we make decisions differently, we look at this differently. Gosh, aren't we married to the wrong person? Uh, we we shouldn't have to change who they are in order to be happy. But honestly, the solution isn't that difficult.

SPEAKER_02And before we get to the solutions, I want to point out one of the challenges of this. And I think we saw it in Hawaii probably before a lot of people saw it in other places. And we've created uh at a societal level, we've created a global economy where you need two working people to afford a darn home. And what that has built is an inability for people oftentimes to feel like they have an escape or that they can even make it on their own.

SPEAKER_02We become financially codependent in our relationships, and that's much more common for people in their 40s because the the housing prices have gotten so high recent 20, 30 years, they can't do what their parents did, can't afford a home. And so they may have to stay in these relationships, and I think that builds resentment and builds more anger and frustration about the situation they're in because they feel trapped.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I would say though, on the on the podcast, and and I I know that you didn't catch the whole thing, is that the 50s and 60s, what they were saying on the podcast is they had no choice financially because there really was that one bread earner, the main bread earner, and they weren't it. And so they did feel trapped and stuck and resentful in their relationships because they would have divorced and and went out to to find uh another way to get their needs met.

SPEAKER_00But whether it has financial or not, I mean, they they are saying that if you stay with the premise that they truly love their person, they just aren't getting their needs met. Because I find that to be the most interesting part of this is that they're choosing to stay. I know financially it could be devastating. I've watched couples here in Hawaii, as Randy said, uh, try to um, you know, coexist in one house because of the financial situation, which is very difficult to do.

SPEAKER_00However, this idea that they love each other, they're just they don't know how to find their way back to get their need met. And that is exactly heart versus head. This is where we wrote another book, Heart versus Head, and that book is a very short read. It gets right to the point. We do this podcast, we're trying to help couples to understand this disconnect because it is not insurmountable. Couples call all the time is this relationship fixable? It is if your mind is open and you're willing to understand that you are different people, you look at this differently.

SPEAKER_00We can help you to communicate to one another. So now you're on the same page.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, no relationship is unredeemable as long as those partners both wanna work on it and want to make it work. So let's talk about solutions when you're experiencing this kind of this quiet quitting in your relationship. Where do we go?

SPEAKER_00The head will usually come in and say, make the heart stop complaining. And the heart is saying, Well, if the head met my needs, then I wouldn't complain. The head needs to work harder. Those approaches are never going to work. This is where we stay stuck. We're we're pointing the finger at the other person, and that's never going to work. So, what we need to do is we need to explain it correctly. We need to ask the right questions. The heart needs to sit down with the head and explain what makes us feel loved and connected.

SPEAKER_00And the head needs to explain to the heart what makes them feel respected and appreciated.

SPEAKER_02And that's that's the big difference because our brains are doing it differently. We're looking for different rewards from our relationship. Heads are looking for that respect and appreciation because we see it as we're out there doing everything. We go to work, we we struggle, we we do all these things for our partner. So we need that respect and appreciation. And as Beverly said, hearts need that connection. And the interesting thing is when couples actually do have these conversations, they find a lot of success because ultimately the head partner wants to be successful and wants their their heart partner to be happy.

SPEAKER_02And if a divorce, yeah. Yeah, heads are super practical. If you give them a manual and go, here's the manual, do these things, they're generally pretty capable of doing those things. The trouble that most couples have is they can't get to the thing they actually need because hearts are afraid to ask for it or don't even know anymore or aren't connected to it. And so now they're fighting about crap.

SPEAKER_00And we just we communicate differently. This is what we teach clients is how to communicate to your partner. It's not that difficult. So there's a metaphor here. We always try to include something that helps with understanding the model. The metaphor would be the home, the the family home. And the head views their job as making it a home. And they're looking at paying the bills, keeping the roof over the head, keeping up with repairs, the the security of that home, the responsibility of toilets backed up.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. And the heart, their job is they want to make that house a home. And a home is where the heart is, where the connection is, where the memories are created. It's the life inside of that structure, that house. And so both are very much needed. What happens in relationships is we don't appreciate or recognize how we go about it differently, and that we need both and what each person is trying to do.

SPEAKER_00And once we step back, now the heart can have restored hope. We can feel safe in our relationship, we can know that our partner is understanding us, and the head can realize that we can't solve problems just by providing more solutions, that we need to also step back, see that our partner is hurting, take a moment, be vulnerable, be open, and when we do that, we connect. And that was what Randy and I found writing the book in that moment where I had pulled away, and I wasn't going to quit on this relationship.

SPEAKER_00We had worked too hard, I loved him so much, I was not going to quit. And I I stepped back into the relationship and Randy and I became scientists. We started really looking at it, breaking it down, and we found our way back to each other. And people ask to this day, 16 years, how do you do it? You work together, you're married, you're all these things. You don't you don't kill one another. People learned that during COVID. It's impossible to spend that much time together.

SPEAKER_00But we are truly happy, not because one had to become like the other, but because we understand the difference, we respect that, and we communicate on that level.

SPEAKER_02And we see it as a strength in our relationship, that we have the ability to disagree and analyze and break things down and come at it differently, because it ultimately is a strength in your relationship when you have both. Stop trying to make your partner into you, stop trying to make them think the way you do or feel the way you do, and be able to realize that you have a very strong relationship that can do amazing things because you have balance of heart and head.

SPEAKER_02If this resonates with you, don't forget to like, follow, or subscribe to this podcast.

SPEAKER_00Heart and head are the yin and yang of a relationship. They make great parents. We don't need to be the same person. And all of those people who actually divorce and they think, I'll just find someone else. I'm sorry, but you're gonna end right back where you started.

SPEAKER_02Right back in the same situation. It is a vicious cycle, and so many people are finding that out. That is the podcast for this week. We'll catch you next time at Heart Versus Head.

SPEAKER_01Thanks for listening to Heart vs. Head. You can learn more at Heart and Headcoaching.com and check out new podcast episodes every Wednesday. If you have a question for Randy and Beverly, send an email to info at Heart and Head Coaching.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Connection Versus Space Loop

    Nov 18, 202625 minAudio

    Hearts love to spend time with the people they love. Heads enjoy that - but also get stressed out if they're constantly thinking they need to fix things for the people they love. This can mean that when Hearts push in...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Who to Date

    Nov 11, 202614 minAudio

    Are you dating? Or back in the dating game? Are you having trouble deciding what you want in a partner or finding someone who checks all the boxes and doesn't have any 'red flags'? Science can help. New research is...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Marriage is Boring

    Nov 4, 202621 minAudio

    Marriage is boring. That's the gist of a recent Reddit post we saw where a Heart partner was complaining about her Head partner and the loss of spark in the relationship. He was, she said, a great husband, dad, provider...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Airing of the Grievances

    Oct 28, 202619 minAudio

    No... this isn't about the Festivus episode of Seinfeld. This episode is about an article in The Atlantic that shared how some couples only hash out their disagreements at scheduled quarterly or even yearly meetings...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. It's Just the Honeymoon Phase

    Oct 21, 202621 minAudio

    Have you ever been in a wonderful new relationship and everybody around you minimizes it or warns you that the wonderful will surely end? What if that isn't necessarily true. In this episode, Randy and Beverly talk...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode