Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Hazard Ratio: Benjamin Ryan Podcast

Hazard Ratio: Benjamin Ryan Podcast artwork

LEAKED: Trans-Care Training Videos By Beleaguered Top Gender-Clinic Doctor, Part 1

Mar 12, 202554 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

I have obtained 12 hours of videos of top pediatric-gender-clinic physician Dr. Johanna Olson-Kennedy and her colleagues, including her husband, providing training to mental-health providers on how to treat minors who have gender dysphoria or otherwise identify as transgender or nonbinary. This is the first of 12 installments I will post during the coming weeks of these videos. Subscribe to receive them as I publish them: Update: Here is part 2: And Part 3: A 19-year veteran of the pediatric gender medicine field and one of its leading physician-researchers and advocates, Dr. Olson-Kennedy is the medical director of the gender clinic at Children’s Hospital Los Angeles. According to figures she provided during this particular video, annual referrals to her clinic surged from just 25 in 2010 to 436 in 2022 - following a similar pattern seen in clinics throughout the Western world. The past six months have been challenging for Dr. Olson-Kennedy, to say the least. Dr. Olson-Kennedy is the principal investigator on a National Institutes of Health grant for a long-running research project concerning pediatric gender-transition treatment, one that has received over $10 million to date. In October, The New York Times reported that she has withheld null findings from a study of puberty blockers funded by this grant, doing so for political reasons. The grant is now the subject of a probe by congressional Republicans. In November, however, she asserted in a sworn deposition in a civil case that the Times had mischaracterized her words. In December, Dr. Olson-Kennedy was sued by a former patient, Clementine Breen, who reported that the gender doctor prescribed her puberty blockers at age 12 - on her first appointment, without a psychological assessment - and testosterone at age 13, and then referred her to receive a double mastectomy at age 14. Ms. Breen, now 20, has since detransitioned, reverting to presenting and identifying as a woman. The Trump administration has unleashed an onslaught against the field of pediatric gender medicine, seeking to wipe it off the map. In recent weeks, the NIH has been canceling research grants related to transgender people, including those conducted with animal models. There is currently a preliminary injunction in place to block the president’s executive order that would freeze federal funds to hospitals that provide gender-transition interventions to those under age 19. Prior to the injunction, Dr. Olson-Kennedy’s clinic had “paused” new cross-sex hormone treatments for youth, only to lift the pause a couple of weeks later. It remains unclear whether the grant for which Dr. Olson-Kennedy is the top investigator has been canceled. But it is no longer listed on the NIH site where active grants are described. I reached out to Dr. Olson-Kennedy and her co-principal investigators on the grant to ask about its status. I did not hear back. Dr. Olson-Kennedy is also newly the president of USPATH, the U.S. branch of the medical-activist group the World Professional Association for Transgender Health. WPATH, which despite is name is largely a U.S.-based organization, has been besieged by damaging publicity over the past year, in particular after internal documents subpoenaed by Alabama’s attorney general revealed that its leadership was aware that the evidence behind pediatric gender medicine was weak and sought to paper over this fact. Prior to the October Times article, Dr. Olson-Kennedy was perhaps best known by the general public for a previous leaked video in which she was giving a training in 2018 to mental health care providers on how to write referral letters for minors seeking gender-transition surgeries. In the video, she expresses exasperation with what she sees as hand wringing over whether natal girls will later regret having their breast removed during adolescence. (At least 1,000 such surgeries have been conducted annually in recent years.) She says: “What we do know is that adolescents actually have the capacity to make a reasonable, logical decision. And here’s the other thing about chest surgery. If you want breasts at a later point in your life, you can go and get them!” Ms. Breen recently reported that she was undergoing reconstructive surgery to provide herself with new breasts. However, it is very unlikely she will ever be able to breastfeed should she have children. 12 hours of leaked Olson-Kennedy training videos The 12-hour training in what is known as the gender-affirming care method for minors who identify as trans or nonbinary took place in late April 2024 - a few weeks after Britain published the Cass Review, which found that this medical field is based on “remarkably weak evidence.” The training was led by Dr. Olson-Kennedy; her husband, Aydin Olson-Kennedy, who has a doctorate in social work and is a transgender man; and licensed clinical social worker Darlene Tando. I obtained the videos a few months ago. The training videos are a window into not just the methods of these individuals, but their overall attitudes about gender dysphoria and transgender and nonbinary identification in children. A prevailing attitude they share is one of indignation and irritation with a medical system that demands that children betray a substantial level of distress before they are granted gender-transition medications. Overall, these three favor less gatekeeping and less pathologizing of the mental states and internal lives of the children in their care. If a gender-incongruent child arrives in their care absent any particular distress about their identification as the opposite sex, they believe that that child should be granted the opportunity to medically transition by taking puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones if the family wishes. I have edited the videos to snip or crop out images that would identify the participants in the training, whether because of Zoom-chat questions that pop up in the right-hand corner of the screen, or moments when a matrix of the participants is visible. You can watch the video at the beginning of this Substack. Otherwise, I wrote a summary below: Video number 1: Johanna Olson-Kennedy on the gender basics Dr. Olson-Kennedy opens the video by charting the recent shift in transgender visibility in popular media, which she says has improved dramatically in recent years. Previously, transgender people were frequently presented as sex workers, according to at GLAAD analysis. But these days, TV has benefited from the likes of Jazz Jennings and shows like Transparent and Pose that center on the transgender experience, Dr. Olson-Kennedy says. Having stories about youth in the media in particular, she says, has influenced the seeking of gender-transition treatment by young people. She expresses concern that the trans kids whose stories have been told in the media are generally white. This is reflective, she says, of the disproportionately white patient population at gender clinics in the U.S. and Europe. “It is important for all of us to think about what those barriers to care are for other communities and work really hard to dismantle those barriers.” This remark speaks to a common dichotomy among advocates in this medical field: They will at once characterize the number of children receiving these treatments as low (as Dr. Olson-Kennedy does a bit later in the video), emphasizing that the political firestorm over this population is disproportionate to its size, while also decrying how few kids are receiving the treatment. Since 2021, Dr. Olson-Kennedy says, we’ve seen a “problematic” visibility of trans youth as states have moved to ban these treatments. She shows a Google search she conducted of “transgender youth care” the night before. “All of these six headlines, and there’s many more,” she says, “are negative, and they speak to moves being made to ban access to care.” Dr. Olson-Kennedy generally avoids using the words “child,” “children” or “kids.” This is apparently qui… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit benryan.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Today's agenda, I'm going to be talking about the, giving kind of an introduction so folks are grounded and then talking about the history around gender care. So I really, I think these are probably in the first five questions, but I would love it if folks could put in the chat your professional discipline, how long you have been working with transgender and non-binary

young people,

SPEAKER_00And the most important thing that you hope to learn from these many, many hours that you're going to spend with us, that information really helps guide us in how we deliver this material. Many of you think I heard Kathy reference have been here and listened to our training in the past. And I'm hoping that some of you have not. So this material is new as well. All right, let's get started.

So I am the medical director of the Center for Trans Youth Health and Development

SPEAKER_00at Children's Hospital Los Angeles. I have been providing many services, including medical services for trans and non-binary children, adolescents, and young adults. And I've been doing that work for the past 18 years. So I want to talk a little bit about how visibility has changed over the 18 years that I have been doing this work. So many of you probably are old enough to remember when what

was in the media were

SPEAKER_00pretty significantly awful representations of the community. So GLAAD did this study. For folks who don't know, GLAAD is the organization that is responsible for thinking about representation of the LGBTQ plus community in media. And they looked at 134 episodes of television where a trans character was brought on just to be a guest. And what they found was that the most common profession for a

trans character was a sex worker.

SPEAKER_00And so this is kind of the visibility. And this, of course, just to be clear, I love Priscilla, Queen of the Desert, but I think there were very, very clear and very primarily negative representations of the community. For the first probably 15 years that I was doing this work, what we saw was a shift in what was being demonstrated in the media.

SPEAKER_00So you have not just more positive stories, but also stories about youth. And this is really important when we think about how the care and the seeking of care has changed related to media visibility. We have also seen people's court cases, for example, Gavin Grimm, who sued his school district to be able to use the correct bathroom.

SPEAKER_00And then we also have seen gratefully, an uptick in trans individuals, actors and actresses playing trans characters in pretty mainstream media. And all of this has been really helpful for visibility. But I do want to point something out that I think is really important. The three kiddos on the left that you see all have something in common besides

SPEAKER_00being trans kids. They are all white. And I think that this is an issue that we face across the country and probably in Western Europe as well, that there is a disproportionate compared to population numbers of people accessing early care, including pre-blockers that are white. And so it is important for all of us to think about what those

barriers to care are

SPEAKER_00for other communities and work really hard to dismantle those barriers. But over the past three years, we've seen a different kind of visibility. And that visibility is also really problematic. So as you all know, if you're working in this space, these are actually from a Google search I did last night. because I like to stay current with this information.

SPEAKER_00And you can see that all of these six headlines, and there's many more, are negative, and they speak to moves being made to ban access to care around this country and also internationally, particularly in Europe. This is a little bit about my own clinic and reflected by many clinics around the country. Although we have the largest youth clinic in the United States,

these numbers are smaller but a similar trend that we have seen across the US and

SPEAKER_00also in Western Europe. So here in this graph, you can see this is the numbers of youth who are referred over to our clinic. And I think that numbers are really important, and they're often used against care providers, parents, and most importantly, community members, that in the largest number clinic in the country, we are still not seeing thousands and thousands of people every year.

SPEAKER_00And I'll talk more about numbers later, but you can see a clear shift starting in 2015, where the numbers of young people who are being referred over to our clinic go up, and there's a shift in ratio. And really critical to remember that we see adolescents and young adults And the emergence of more individuals who identify on the trans masculine spectrum, so people who are registered female at birth,

and an increase in the numbers of people with non-binary gender identities,

SPEAKER_00gender identity labels. I think all of us probably know this, but language is really critical. It's really important. The terminology that we use is dynamic. Youth are primarily the ones creating the terminology. And so it is important for people to check in and be updated about the language that's being used. Labels may mean something different to different individuals,

SPEAKER_00and I always tell people to err on the side of asking. And that also applies to utilizing specific body part language, because for some people... They may not be triggered by using anatomic names for body parts and organs, but other people might be. And so I check in with my young people and ask them what feels the most comfortable for them.

I do want to give us some language so that we can kind of be grounded together as we work through this information today and then over the next three days of the seminar.

SPEAKER_00So I created this gender abacus many, many years ago. And the primary reason that I did this is that I had a lot of parents who like many, many people, were conflating gender identity and gender expression. And so I have a physical version of this in my office that has 10 beads and 20 spaces, but I also created a digital app so that people could help

explain to me where they

SPEAKER_00were situated, but also explain to their parents. And I'm going to preface this by saying I actually don't think that female and male are the ends, like some kind of linear relationship to each other. I'm going to talk about this more when I talk about non-binary folks. But I think for the purposes of non-community members, this is the way that people think about and understand gender.

SPEAKER_00I'm going to go through each of these things. So our designated sex at birth or registered sex at birth is really what happens when somebody is born. So I've been in a lot of births. That was part of my training. And if somebody has not gotten chromosomal information, when a baby comes out, if said baby has a penis and testes, they are labeled or registered as male.

SPEAKER_00If they do not, they are registered as female. Okay. I could do a whole hour just on that. Sometimes people have information even before birth through an ultrasound or karyotyping. I just want to draw people's attention to the last pair of chromosomes in humans. We have 23 pairs of chromosomes, 23 pairs, but sometimes there's more than two.

SPEAKER_00I think that's important to talk about for another time. The last set of chromosomes are the XX, XY, and wide variations of those. And those are primarily what guides the fetus into developing the physical secondary and primary sex characteristics. And again, not going to spend a lot of time talking about the intersex community or

SPEAKER_00differences in sex development or sex characteristics, because that would take me another several hours. There is overlap in the intersex community with the trans community. And I'll talk about that where it's relevant. But I think that's what I'm going to include about that. What about gender identity? So I think that this is a really important nuance that a gender identity is both a label and an experience.

SPEAKER_00So it's an internal basic sense. of being male, female, both, neither, or something else entirely, especially as it is experienced in self-awareness and behavior. And this is one of the hardest things about this work, is that gender identity is something that each individual has and carries inside of them and is not assumed just by looking at somebody.

People label their gender identity in many, many different kinds of ways.

SPEAKER_00And I'll talk about that tomorrow as well. So it is true, and I think this is important, that the majority of people, for example, who are registered male at birth, identify as male. And the majority of people who are registered female at birth identify as female. But over the next several hours, we're going to talk about situations where that is not the case.

SPEAKER_00What about gender expression? I think about gender expression as the way a person communicates their gender to those around them. And it doesn't just include clothing and hair and name. There are also many, many different ways across cultures where people perform gender in a way that is stereotypical for men and women. And so there are,

in addition to these kind of cues that we give about our gender to the world, there are also ways that we perform our gender that give people around us cues. And this is kind of baked into the way that we learn about gender from the time

SPEAKER_00we're really small. And I'm going to talk about that in a minute. So synthetic hormones were... And early 1930s. But before that, you know, trans people have existed since people. But before that, really the way that people kind of did their gender or, you know, were able to live in a gender that felt authentic to them was through clothing and

SPEAKER_00their occupation. Right. So I love this quote from Emmanuel Herman. Clothing is the unconscious language of the spirit and clearly expresses itself all the more when the tongue is condemned to silence. Why is that important? Because people were not able to freely talk about their experience of their gender. So in order to feel more comfortable, people would adopt clothing that felt most appropriate for them.

SPEAKER_00There's an amazing book. Recommends. Somebody's not muted. Is this a comment to me or... There's an amazing book called Not Straight Out of Germany. And that book really talks about kind of the origin of the gay rights movement and talks about trans folks and trans experience. The way that trans folks were talked about in 1910 was very

different than the way

SPEAKER_00that we talk about trans experience now. But there are all these great photos about people trying to live authentically. Highly recommend. So it is also true that for people registered male at birth, they identify as male and they want to express their generation in the way that the society thinks you should. You get a lot of messages about this from a very early time.

So, for example, if you do a Google search for boys toys, this is what you see.

SPEAKER_00you know, construction equipment, tanks. If you do a search for girls' toys, you get stoves and babies, right? So there's a lot of very clear and kind of consistent messaging about how to do your gender in a way that is going to be okay and acceptable to the society, right? Here's another thing about clothing, right?

SPEAKER_00The girls just love me. So it's only going to be heterosexuality, but it's also sort of giving this kind of idea about what it means to be a boy. Mama ain't raising no fool, right? And then here's, you know, this is what you get when you look for girls' clothes, right? And Props to this, at least there's reasonable shoe wear. So we have assumptions in our society that cause us to gender

people based on these social cues.

SPEAKER_00I want to give you some examples. Here is a bag. It is presumably for carrying personal articles. And here is a bag, presumably for carrying personal articles. Here is a coat. presumably to keep you warm. Here is a coat, presumably to keep you warm. Even if you covered up these people's heads, you can see also not a comfortable shoe wear on the left side.

SPEAKER_00If you covered up these people's heads and their hair, you probably would gender the person on the left female and the person on the right male. In my work, I do a lot of work that's not related to medical intervention, but I do also a lot of work that is related to changing somebody's physicality or phenotype so that they can feel more comfortable.

SPEAKER_00But I think there are things that we... you wouldn't necessarily think about if you weren't doing this work, that are physiologic differences in skeletons and in features that are XY chromosomes or registered male or XX chromosomes or variations of these. So in people with XY chromosomes, they generally tend to have a more forward-facing brow, which means that their eyes are set back further.

And you can see also that not all, but a lot of people with XY chromosomes have Adam's apples.

SPEAKER_00Not everyone. And there are some XX individuals who have Adam's apples, but predominantly this is something that you see in men or people who've taken testosterone. There's also a longer length between the bottom of the lip and the bottom of the chin. So if you compare the left and the right side, obviously these are just two examples, but in general, this tends to be true. And then my last domain on the abacus is sexual and romantic attraction.

And I put this in again because there's a lot of conflation with sexual and

SPEAKER_00romantic attraction and gender identity. So the majority, while there are a lot more LGB folks than there are trans folks so far, There is still a majority of people who identify as heterosexual. So if they're registered male at birth, they have a male gender identity. They want to express that in a masculine way and then generally

have sexual and

SPEAKER_00romantic attraction to women. Or they're registered female at birth. They identify as women or girls. They want to express their gender in a more feminine way. And they are attracted to boys and men. Okay. That's not what we're talking about for the next 14 hours. It's probably 13 now. Okay. We are talking about people who are registered one sex at birth because primarily their genital anatomy or their chromosomes,

and they identify as something other than what would be expected in the majority of people.

SPEAKER_00So they're registered female at birth, they identify as male or somewhere along the masculine spectrum. Or people who are registered male at birth, but they identify somewhere along the female spectrum or trans feminine spectrum. And of course, every variation, including those that line up in the middle or half and half or anything else, but they are not cisgender.

SPEAKER_00And I'll talk about that right now. So for a very long time, the way that we talked about trans experience was really problematic and it created a hierarchy that made cisgender experience preferential. So This word, cisgender, actually comes from chemistry. So a molecule that has two atoms on the same side or are

adjacent to each other is

SPEAKER_00called a cis molecule. So in people, we're talking about people registered female who identify as girls or women, right? or people who are registered male and identify as boys or men. Okay, a trans molecule is a molecule that has atoms on a cross or opposite sides. And so in the case of people, we're talking about someone registered male at birth who

identifies as a girl or

SPEAKER_00woman or somewhere on the trans feminine spectrum. or non-binary, or somebody registered female at birth who identifies it as male or along the transmasculine spectrum or non-binary. I know that there is a lot of, even within the community, feelings about the way that we talk about the community. I, for the most part, Talk about trans experience to mean non-cisgender.

SPEAKER_00I umbrella everybody under the trans umbrella. And I know that doesn't sit right for everybody. And I just want you all to know that I am not excluding non-binary or agender people in that umbrella. All right. So what is gender? Is gender our chromosomes? Is it our reproductive tract or genitals? What about our role of rearing or socially constructed definition?

SPEAKER_00Is it a legal designation? Is it all of these things? Okay. So I think that for folks who pay attention to some of the legal stuff that is happening right now, kind of hear all of these things. And really, I think or have come to believe after the years of work that I've done is that mostly gender is like an onion. It has all of these layers and

SPEAKER_00And it's whether you're a trans person or a cis person. And, you know, sometimes gender makes us cry. And sometimes we cut it up and put it in spaghetti sauce and it's delicious. So gender is really multi-layered. And we're going to talk about it, think about it as such. important to remember that we start this process of gendering or assuming somebody's gender very early,

SPEAKER_00right? So sometimes we get an ultrasound when somebody is in utero or we get a karyotype for whatever reason. And it is really still common that people start to create stories, future stories about their unborn child, right? In 2007, this practice of gender reveal parties began. And so these were parties to celebrate even a child who was not yet born.

SPEAKER_00That's sort of a story about their gender. So guns are glitter. What's in the oven? A sweet little cupcake or a handsome stud muffin. I think like all of these things tell us about how people are thinking about and creating stories related to the gender of their unborn child. And these gender reveal parties are often very gendered. So they preclude us from thinking about, even in cisgender kids,

SPEAKER_00that these qualities of people can go beyond. I mean, they can be things, not necessarily guns, but they can be things that we would like all young people and then adolescents and adults to think about as part of their personality. So what happens after that? What happens after that is, you know, if you have a person without a penis, you put him in a room like this. Or if you have a person with a penis, you put him in a room like this.

SPEAKER_00These cues that are in people's rooms, and I see this less and less now than I did when I started this work, but these cues give babies and children messages about how to perform their gender. This is a ubiquitous situation. I did a search relatively recently. If you look for back to school supplies, you can see on the left, you know, back to school supplies for girls,

SPEAKER_00although I do appreciate the trans colored backpack. But in this set of things, you can see, you know, makeup and, you know, nail stuff and earrings and chapstick or erasers or whatever those things are. And on the right side, you know, you see backpack and food. I think this is really important. So on the back to school supplies for girls, there's no food.

SPEAKER_00And I think that is its own message. Most people don't really think about this unless you do this work or you're part of the community, right? It's really overwhelmingly pervasive. I can tell you that I've looked in a lot of people's ears and you don't need... you know, skull screws if you have testes or XY chromosomes. And you certainly don't need pink earplugs if you identify as female.

Here's, you know, bounce fabric softener for men and those who smell them. And then it also is true that, you know, girls don't need a specific kind of tape.

SPEAKER_00Our fine motor skills are intact. And so it's important that people recognize how much this happens. And this is going back to this issue around food and the sort of policing and expectations around the bodies of women, you know, the bro nuts snack like a man. Yeah. If you think this is only for children and adults, look at this. This is, you know, a thing for a three to 18 month old for a sweet baby girl.

SPEAKER_00And it's a ring rattle. And this one is for a busy baby boy. It's a saw and it has a mirror in it. So when we think about how and why people come to understand their gender, to understand the gender cues that they are getting from a very early age. There's also, you know, this product, Minoxidil, which is for hair loss, is not different. It's the same concentration.

SPEAKER_00It smells the same, by the way, terrible. But the only difference is that the price on the women's one is higher. And so there are all kinds of things happening. This is all wrapped up with putting people into an environment that we feel like represents their gender, and we wrap it all up with constant reminders about gender expectations from media. So all of this assumes that your gender is aligned with your

primary or secondary

SPEAKER_00sex characteristics and by default your chromosomes. And that particular way of thinking is called gender essentialism. Gender equals genitals. Well, what's wrong with that? Well, it erases trans experience and trans people. It creates kind of a chronic environment that's skeptical and now increasingly hostile that creates a scenario whereby individuals have to prove their gender

SPEAKER_00before they can be affirmed either socially, legally, and certainly medically. It establishes and continues to support a hierarchy that privileges cisgender people, and it results in barriers to accessing necessary care. Gendering in this way is traumatic for all of us. all humans, whether you're trans or cisgender, right?

And so you can see that these experiences that are happening right now across the country where youth care is being banned is adding to the traumatic load that young

SPEAKER_00mom said, well, my kid likes to wear dresses and play with dolls. And this four-year-old kind of leapt up and put their hand over their mom's mouth and said, don't tell the doctor. And in that moment, what I realized is that this young person had already started carrying their gender, about not even their gender necessarily. It doesn't even matter if this kid is a girl or a boy or

non-binary or something else entirely.

SPEAKER_00What this kid had, what was clear and obvious, was gotten messages about the things they like to wear and the things they like to play with were not okay. And that message creates shame for people. And that was really an important thing that I recognized for even in a child who's four years old. was a social construct and that, you know, you could raise anybody in any gender and that's where they

would kind of stay.

SPEAKER_00So they did work on gender development. And what they found was that by the age of two, children become conscious of the physical differences between boys and girls. And primarily, this means genital anatomy. Before their third birthday or around their third birthday, most children are easily able to label themselves according to what they've learned about gender as a boy or a girl. And by age four, most children have a stable sense of their gender identity,

SPEAKER_00knowing that, for example, if they put on different clothes or, you know, carry a handbag or whatever kids are doing, that their gender identity is the same. It doesn't change. From birth, as I showed you some examples before, children quickly learned that a lot of their lives has to deal with the concepts of masculinity and femininity, right? Again, these hangers on the right are labeled as boys' hangers,

SPEAKER_00I guess because they're blue, right? And then there's girls batteries below that. And so these are clearly things that young people are going to be exposed to at even a very young age. If young people have parents that are very interested in guiding them into doing things that are stereotypically thought to be assumed with gender, they will give covert and overt messages of disapproval for not

complying with

SPEAKER_00those norms. And so it is these kinds of messages that solidify the understanding of children about gender roles. I am going to tell you why all of this matters in a minute. Children obviously internalize parental messages because a lot of times their parents are the most important person to them in their life. And they they will look to adult people that share a gender

that they are assumed

SPEAKER_00to have for role differences. What about peers? So, you know, whether or not a child is cisgender or trans, they're going to like certain things. But as they explore those things, whether or not their peers approve of those choices is going to be crucial and whether or not they will continue to demonstrate an interest in those things. Not if they will continue to have an interest in those things,

SPEAKER_00but whether they will continue to do them. And this is important because the interests that a person has are innate. You're just interested in something or something makes you happy. But the behavior related to that is mutable based on the messages you're getting from people around you. I had a kid once who came in and... And this kid who is registered male at birth said,

SPEAKER_00I asked this kid, what's your favorite color? And this kid said orange. And the mom said, no, it's not. It's pink. But a bunch of my in this kid, I think, was about six. Right. So first time in kindergarten where there's peers around who had said your color, your favorite color can't be pink because you're a boy. And so this kid had sort of shifted and said, my favorite color is orange. Gender identity for trans and gender diverse children is

happening in a cis

SPEAKER_00normative environment. And this is why I'm showing all of this stuff, because I think it's really important to understand that figuring out that your gender is not what it's assumed to be is a puzzle. And it's different for each young person because And it's impacted by multiple aspects of someone's life. And I know that Darlene is going to talk about this later. But I think of this as young people trying to swim upstream in a downstream world.

SPEAKER_00So if you are a cisgender person... Everything is created in your world, in your environment that supports your cisgender situation. Right. So you're just swimming along. You don't really have to ask this question or think about it. But for trans and non-binary young people, they are swimming upstream and trying to figure out what's going on with their gender. Right. And because of that, you know, people are going to understand their gender at different times,

SPEAKER_00right? Some people are going to talk about their gender when they're five or three, and some people are going to do it at 13, and some people are going to do it at 30, and some people are going to do it at 50 or 70. And so when you're When you're hearing information about, well, this kid did none of this when, you know, my teenager did none of this when they were young. Think about this slide and about what that young person needed

to do to put their

SPEAKER_00gender puzzle together in order to get somebody's attention around it. So I want to talk about this kid. I asked this kid's mom to write a little kind of summary of her experience of her child at three years old. This kid's story was profiled about 12 years ago on public TV, so it's out and available.

SPEAKER_00But this is what this mom said. At age three, Jay started acting out, and this mom is gendering this kid according to registered sex at birth. He would have tantrums when I would drag him into the barbershop for his bi-monthly haircut. They were on a military base. Shopping for clothes, he would excitedly head toward the girls department, only to end up in tears as I redirected him to the boys. Putting his uniform on each morning for school,

he would untuck his shirt and modify it to the best of his ability to match the

SPEAKER_00girls uniforms. During the night, he would wake up and tear the paper from his walls, pull down his drapes from the windows, strip the bed of its sheets, and basically destroy his room. My baby was cracking and I had no idea where the pressure was coming from. So the story of this kid is that this went on for a couple years. And at this kid's five-year well visit, the mom was explaining these things to the doctor, the pediatrician,

SPEAKER_00about her child. And the doctor said, is it possible that your child has what was then labeled gender identity disorder, but is now called gender dysphoria? Yeah. And the mom was like, what are you talking about? And she took this kid home and said, do you want to live as a girl? And this kid said, yes, I am a girl. And so this young person underwent a social transition and

SPEAKER_00And I'll share a picture of her in a minute. What happens when a kid does not fit into their anticipated box? Some of you may have seen this video before, but I think it's incredible. And I give such great props to this mom who put this story into a very understandable experience of what she went through as her child tried to tell her about her experience.

SPEAKER_01Six years ago, I gave birth to my first and only child. A boy. When he was two years old, my son began insisting on wearing only pink clothes. Preferably ones with lots of sparkles and ruffles on them.

When he turned three, he begged me to buy him some dresses and let him grow his hair long.

SPEAKER_01That made the grandparents a little nervous, but we went with it.

SPEAKER_02Why is she a fairy and she's a princess?

SPEAKER_01That's the difference.

SPEAKER_02And also, they can't fly and they can't.

SPEAKER_01And then one day in a conversation that I kind of knew was coming, but it still knocked the wind out of me. My child told me that he was actually a girl, not a boy. He looked me in the eyes and told me something had gone wrong in my tummy. that made him come out as a boy instead of a girl. He wanted me to put him back. He begged me to put him back, to fix this mistake.

SPEAKER_01He was three years old. I spent the following year resisting, trying to present alternatives. I told my child over and over again that he could continue to be a boy and play with all the Barbies he wanted and wear whatever he liked. Dresses, skirts, all the sparkles money could buy. But my child said no.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely not. She was a girl. What are your favorite things to play with? My princess things. Your princess things? Why do you like princesses so much?

SPEAKER_02I just can't do them.

SPEAKER_01Do you think it's okay for boys to like princesses?

SPEAKER_02But I'm a girl.

SPEAKER_01After 12 long months of making both myself and my child miserable, I finally let my little boy go. Goodbye.

SPEAKER_02Now let's do it. We switched to female pronouns and told our family and friends that she was a girl now.

SPEAKER_01She wanted a new name, a girl name. At first, she picked Rainbow. I was relieved when she changed her mind and named herself after her aunt. So now I have a girl. A daughter.

SPEAKER_02Actually, I need to hear about how spaceships fly. A really happy daughter.

SPEAKER_01I adore my daughter. But sometimes I look at photos of my baby boy and I miss him so much. This probably sounds crazy, but sometimes I wonder where he is. It's like he was a dream I had one night and then morning came and I woke up and he was gone. And now there's this little girl in his place telling me that

the boy was just a dream.

SPEAKER_01Just someone I imagined. As far as she is concerned, there never was a boy. Can you explain that to me one more time? What's the difference between you and Holly?

SPEAKER_02She's a girl with a penis and she's a girl with a vagina.

SPEAKER_01You're a girl with a penis and she's a girl with a vagina? Yes. So now that I have a daughter instead of a son, what does this actually mean for her and for me as her mother? Other than letting her wear pretty dresses and using different pronouns,

SPEAKER_01what has actually changed? What does this newly minted girl need to know? What do I need to teach her how to be a girl?

SPEAKER_02Girl alien does all the work.

SPEAKER_01Do I even know how to be a girl? And if a girl can be a senator or an astronaut or a plumber, if a girl can wear pants and have short hair, if a girl can even have a penis, what is a girl anyway? Who gets to decide if you're a boy or a girl? Me!

SPEAKER_00Okay, so I really appreciate Marlo Mack for putting her own experience into this type of little cartoon so that people can kind of see what she went through as a parent. If you want to see more, she has many, many of these that talk about her child growing up and There's some with her child in them, and now her kid is a teenager. But I do think there's one with her daughter giving advice to

other trans kids in the country.

SPEAKER_00It's really quite amazing. So I really do want to be clear that not everybody who has this experience in childhood is going to continue to identify as a different gender in adolescence and adulthood. I do think that is important. There are lots of people who are designated male or registered male at birth who like to wear dresses and play with dolls. But I think that this child's assertion about her gender is a

really important

SPEAKER_00factor in her continuing to assert a female gender identity. There are diagnostic criteria for gender dysphoria in childhood. I don't spend a lot of time on this because you can all read them and go through and check these things off for people. I know that Aiden is gonna spend a lot of time talking about gender dysphoria outside of the diagnostic criteria. And in some ways,

whether people meet these diagnostic criteria in childhood is not super relevant for me as a medical provider because there are no medical interventions for people

SPEAKER_00who are not yet in puberty. But there is this definition and there's some issues with it. So this incongruence between one's experienced or expressed gender and their assigned gender of at least six months duration. And then as manifested by six of the following things. So a strong desire to be of the other gender or an insistence that he or she is the other gender or some alternative gender. In people who are assigned male at birth,

SPEAKER_00a strong preference for cross-dressing or simulating female attire, or in assigned girls, a preference for wearing only typical masculine clothing and a strong resistance to the wearing of typical feminine clothing. I really cannot stress this enough that the trajectories of development for trans masculine and trans feminine people are vastly different. And it has to do with the patriarchy.

It has to do with misogyny and our feelings as a society about people that we

SPEAKER_00perceive to be men in women's clothing. OK, so look at the language in here. If you are designated male at birth and you want to wear stereotypical girls' clothing, here we call it cross-dressing. However, if you are designated female at birth, you have a strong preference for wearing typically masculine clothing, right? And what does that even mean?

SPEAKER_00Does that mean pants? Does that mean a sweatshirt, right? So you can just see that we still have, when we think about clothing, a much more stringent criteria for what we describe as male versus female clothing And even in these diagnostic criteria where we codify this feeling, more negative feeling about people who are registered male at birth. A strong preference for cross-gender roles in make-believe play

or fantasy play. A lot of times my kids will tell me about the avatars that they use and that their avatars maybe they are exploring some of their gender or questions about their

SPEAKER_00gender through their avatars. I think that's an important question. Back in the day when these criteria were first conceptualized, this was about like playing house and stuff like that. Then there are these things, a strong preference for the toys, games, or activities stereotypically used or engaged in by the other gender, a strong preference for playmates of the other gender. Again, for registered boys, a strong rejection of typically masculine toys,

SPEAKER_00games, and activities, and a strong avoidance of rough and tumble play. I mean, a lot of this stuff is kind of a vestigial tale from the way that we talked about gender back in the 1950s. And this criteria seven, a dislike, strong dislike of one's sexual anatomy. And, you know, reminding people that your sexual anatomy is not just your genitals,

right?

SPEAKER_00Your brain is actually the biggest sexual organ in your body. There are many, many issues and concerns with these criteria. Yeah. but I want you to know them because sometimes we need to make these diagnoses in order for people to get services. And then a strong desire for the primary and or secondary sex characteristics that match one's experienced gender. And when this diagnosis moved from gender identity disorder to

gender dysphoria, I think that there's an important movement that happened here that there is an

SPEAKER_00effort to de-pathologize the experience of being trans. from the distress that being, having a body that doesn't necessarily reflect your gender. And those are two different things. So this B criteria was added on. Again, for pre-pubertal children, these diagnostic criteria are not super useful. In these younger kids,

what we often see is or what parents will report as the first major conflict is

SPEAKER_00really around underwear. Parents have a lot of latitude for letting their children wear whatever they want. And this is especially true now, at least in California. But this is this sometimes causes problems in the family where kids will want different kinds of underwear. Props to these kids that make assertions about how they should use the bathroom. I like this one. This is like a registered girl at birth who's like,

SPEAKER_00no, I'm going to stand up to go to the bathroom, which is usually messy. This is something I commonly see. Somebody maybe starts out with longer hair and says, no, no, I want a haircut. And they get a haircut like this. And then they say, no, not really. I actually want a haircut like this. And so I call this so affectionately the ascending bob in little kids. For trans feminine kids, I see a lot of like moving into hyper feminine or hyper masculine spaces,

SPEAKER_00right? These hyper masculine expressions of how they want their clothing to look based on what they have learned as little babies up to childhood. Yeah.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. In WPATH's Own Videos, Doctors Describe Billing Gender-Transition Care Under Alternative Diagnoses

    Sep 12, 20261 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit benryan.substack.com When New York City’s Mt. Sinai Health System reached a settlement with the Justice Department last week to keep its pediatric gender...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Academic Activists Said The Telegraph and The Times Led a ‘Lynch Mob’ Against Jason Arday—Papers They Said They Don’t Read

    Aug 23, 202613 minAudio

    This Substack is meant as a video-based companion to the article I published Friday with The Washington Free Beacon about the organizing meeting on Tuesday of the UCU Solidarity Movement, an activist caucus within the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Why Are Academics Falsely Claiming Plagiarism Can’t Be the ‘Mere Overlap Of Sentences’ In the Wake of Jason Arday’s Death?

    Aug 21, 20264 minAudio

    Hazard Ratio is a reader-supported Substack. Consider backing my work and becoming a paid subscriber today. When I was in the 7th grade in 1991, my terrific social studies teacher, Mr. Corkran, taught us what plagiarism...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. British TV Show Gave Jason Arday Major Prizes For His Lies About Charity Fundraising

    Aug 10, 20262 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit benryan.substack.com Hazard Ratio is a reader-supported Substack. Consider backing my work and becoming a paid subscriber today. Jason Arday, who resigned...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 'More Hair, Less Hair, Larger Boobs, Less Boobs, No Boobs' How the 'Embodiment Goals' Premise Is Taking Over Youth Gender Medicine

    Jul 29, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Hazard Ratio is a reader-supported Substack. Consider backing my work and becoming a paid subscriber today, which will gain you access to all the WPATH conference videos I have published and will publish going forward....

    Credit the people on this episode