Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

H-Hour

H-Hour artwork

“Marines have a higher standard of fitness when it comes to close combat and training”. H-Hour Icebreaker – Chris Shirley

Nov 2, 202524 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

For H-Hour perks, join the H-Hour Discord guild: https://discord.com/invite/KCb54MQNxd and follow H-Hour Hugh on X: https://x.com/HughKeir ****** In this H-Hour Icebreaker, Chris Shirley returns as a guest, answering questions submitted by H-Hour patrons. The topics range from the performance of marines in combat compared to other infantry units, to respect for figures like Bear Grylls within the military community. Additional discussions include the UK's digital ID for veterans and its privacy concerns, the impact of reviewing historic special forces actions on mental health, and strategies for maintaining focus during challenging physical endeavors. Shirley shares personal stories from ocean rowing to ultra marathons, highlighting the importance of positive role models and maintaining elements of military life post-service. The episode concludes with light-hearted banter and hints at future exclusive content for patrons. Chris Shirley is a former Royal Marines officer and also former Royal Military Police. Chris is also the founder of Hiatus Designs. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Free H-Hour giveaways and exclusive access to guests. https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts H-Hour on Substack: https://hughkeir.substack.com H-Hour on WhatsApp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaWSj4p05MUbVlHmFu3y H-Hour on YouTube: https://youtube.com/@HHourPodcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome back to Hey Chower. If you are if you are this is being recorded obviously recorded live it's been streamed live to Platinum Patrons. The questions you're about to hear me ask the guest have been submitted by Platinum Patrons. If you would like to submit questions for future guests and get access to the live stream to watch the episodes being recorded live, become, you guessed it, a platinum patron. Go to substack.hucare.com or patreon.com forward slash hk podcasts.

SPEAKER_01The links are in the blurb. Sign up, become a platinum patron, and you will be able to do this for future guests. You'll also be able to recommend guests and um you'll also be able to jump on the occasional uh Zoom call with past guests for exclusive QA's, of which Chris is going to join one of those, aren't you, Chris? Yes, you are. Yes, Chris is going to do one. Yes, yes. Uh so excellent. Let's get into the icebreaker with Chris Shelley. Chris, welcome back to Hey Chour, my friend. It has been a long time coming.

SPEAKER_00It really has. A few things have happened since uh we saw. A few things have happened. A few things have happened, a few things have happened.

SPEAKER_01Okay, let's get the questions up one second. Uh first, cool, hang on, we've got main pod questions here. Hang on a minute. Hang on a minute. We're just a we've got a we've got a variety. Right. Okay, question one from Coke. Uh did m these are in random order of topic, right? Uh one part A. Did Marines perform much better in combat compared to other infantry?

SPEAKER_01Are we laughing at?

SPEAKER_00So okay, so the question is do marines perform better in combat than other forms of infantry? Yes. Uh can you are you also ask ask them questions? Are they can they qual can they say what kind of combat is it like No.

SPEAKER_01Just general combat.

SPEAKER_00Okay, okay. Okay. So um well in combat, yeah.

SPEAKER_01But he's asking a Marines are better warfighters, basically, than other other than other infantries, it's a contentious question because one of the com one of the core values is humility.

SPEAKER_00So I've got to find a way to say it diplomatically without uh just saying it. Okay, so Marines have a higher higher standard of fitness when it comes to um obviously you know close combat and training. Um they get a bit more investment in much like the parachute regiment, get more investment into equipment, deployment, training, bigger, bigger budgets, that's what I understand. So you could assert from that that Marines are better under the bit sponsored. Okay, okay. Uh I mean the Marines certainly attracted me over your regular um generic line infantry.

SPEAKER_00So yes, I'm gonna I'm gonna go out and approach the one and say yes.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Okay. Jesus. This isn't House of Commons, right?

SPEAKER_00You can tell he's an officer, he danced around the topic before even like confronting them.

SPEAKER_01Um okay, if yes, this is the part B. If yes, is there a moral obligation to ensure other infantry units are trained to Royal Marine standards so that they're less at risk in combat?

SPEAKER_00That's a complex one, isn't it? Because there is there a more moral obligation, well, clearly if if you're suggesting there's a um Marines are used or elite infantry are used for other jobs, other tasks than your general infantry, then no, I guess not, because your general infantry aren't going to be used for those specialist infantry roles. So I'd say not. Um unless I've misinterpreted the question. But yeah, I think you misinterpreted.

SPEAKER_01Uh okay. So he's basically saying is there a moral obligation to bring other units up to the same standard as Royal Marines to ensure they are less at risk during war?

SPEAKER_00No, because they're not going to be used for the same things. So Marines are Marines like Parachute Regiment of a specialised infantry for specialise for a certain demands of a certain role, so therefore there's no moral obligation to bring the infantry up to the side of the Royal Marines because they've got different focuses and different tasks. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Good answer. Uh we've got Okay. Okay, so this is part of Part B as well. James Williams, ex-Marie, who is an ex-Marine and SRR, said on Ryan Forrest's YouTube stream, apparently Taliban would see a marked difference in the combat fighting capabilities when the Marines and the Paras were there compared to the wider army. I I'm aware of that. Are you aware of that? I'm is from ICOM shadow, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I didn't serve in Afghanistan, so I I can only go off obviously what I know from other people. Um, but incidentally, I think uh James Williams was in the um commando documentary, which was one of the inspirations that got me into join the corps instantly. I remember he's got uh a line it he goes, the the ethos of the commandos, so yeah, I'm yeah, aware of him.

SPEAKER_01So he said apparently that he heard uh there's a there's a quote from the iCOM, the Taliban chatter, saying the Marines are here now, so let's switch on, or the equivalent in Pashtun. Yeah, yeah, interesting.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, um I think the IRA used to do the same thing as well. There was they they noticed they marked difference in you know whether Marines or Paris were there versus um your your general infantry.

SPEAKER_01So okay, question two from Coke. Do you and most mar and most Marines lack respect for bear grills and his military record? He heard an ex-Marine say most Marines don't have time for him. And the part we'll come on to the part B in a minute because it references me, but go on. Okay. So yeah.

SPEAKER_00No, I don't I think you could you could generalize. I mean, there's right now there's like between four and six thousand serving Marines. There's like what tens of thousands ex-marines. So if you were generalizing across the whole core, it'd be very hard to you know, you'd have to have a very confident um uh you know guesstimate that that was what the whole core thought. I I don't think it is, no, because obviously Bear Bear was a um he was obviously uh 2-1 SAS. Um, you know, they've got a very different selection process, which is is long and and difficult. The core has got a very different you know selection process and different focus.

SPEAKER_00Um no, I don't think I don't think it's fair to say to say that, and also Bear is he's an honor honorary um colonel in the in the marine, so I've worked I've worked with Bear a few times and yeah, I think he's a he's a nice bloke.

SPEAKER_01Um you've worked with Bear, have you?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Coke doesn't care, mate. Coke throws the Coke throws the like he throws his question, he doesn't care about your feelings, he doesn't care about awkwardness. It's only for the covers at the uh end normally it's me being targeted. Like, for example, you know, the two the two be two question two part B is when I asked Hugh, uh apparently I said he wasn't a good supp soldier who deployed. Uh oh no, no, he asked me. So he wasn't a good soldier who deployed, and I said no, but he serves a purpose, I suppose.

SPEAKER_01I said I saw this question ahead of time, and I I I we had a I had a conversation with Coco about this. I didn't say this, right? So I don't know what what Bear Gris has done operationally. I don't I don't know. I've got no idea. I so I couldn't comment on it.

SPEAKER_00I mean he he um he broke broke his back in Africa um parachuting uh skydiving parachuting. Um I don't know if it is on operations or if it's training, but it's okay. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01No, so I don't know what his deployment record is, so I can't comment on it. Yes. Um moving swiftly. All right, part C. Oh, hang on, this is another part of the same thing. Chris Ryan has criticized Bear. Claiming he's lied about his service. I never heard that. Have you ever heard that? No, I haven't heard that either. Okay. Moving Swift Click.

SPEAKER_01Uh we've got more questions here. So these are from David, the podcast editor. Okay. Uh whose whose uh black magic camera you were admiring earlier on. Yeah, yeah, there's a nice big kit. Yeah. Um I'm amazed I haven't broken it yet. Um, so question number from David. The UK is rolling out digital ID for veterans. What's your take on it? Is it a useful innovation or is it something that raises concerns about privacy and purpose?

SPEAKER_00Ooh, quick good question. Um, I mean, we're not the first country to bring up digital IDs. Um, obviously, Estonia being the classic example, they've had digital IDs for 20 years now.

SPEAKER_01Oh, um just context. You live in Estonia, so you understand it there. Right, okay.

SPEAKER_00I hope you don't mind me just uh no, that's that's not weird. Um is it a well, I think you know, anything digital these days does pose a risk. Um I mean, more so than like a physical ID card. Uh you know, it'd be kind of hard to quantify like whether what's the riskier thing carrying around a physical ID card which can then be doctored, you know. If you lost it, it can be doctored, it then becomes a um uh you know like a data loss out data loss um incident versus you know uh cybersecurity in the age of AI is like a much bigger, thornier beast to tackle.

SPEAKER_00So I you can I don't think we can really compare the two. They're like apples and pears, aren't they? They're yeah, I wouldn't even I didn't know enough about cybersecurity to go down down that line and say what which will be better or which would be more riskier.

SPEAKER_01Well, there's I mean, on I I I sp I spoke quite a bit on this on the last podcast with Adnan Sawa. Um it was a similar question asked there. Um but so I won't I won't go back over why I'm very much against it. But since then I found out that on a on a cyber security front, um even at the development level there's problems. So they have the contractor that they have used to develop the first because it's I mean it's not even beaten, it's out, it's in it's pr it's in production now, right?

SPEAKER_01It's as in it's it's live now, right? Uh was the contract was in Romania, so and it was farmed out today, and um and the history of the contractor is not great from a security perspective. Um and I I mean I think they decided on that when they went through the procurement process. That this kind of thing I think this would have to be done like on-prem UK mainland development. The the the the minimal risk of uh of um data uh access issues um and uh and you know and and and basic security considerations would would tell me that okay.

SPEAKER_01I I'd rather spend more money on development main mainland UK involving very uh not shipping it off elsewhere, yeah. Uh as opposed to paying less and cheaper for overseas contractors.

SPEAKER_00I guess it depends on wh which element of it was was um done, but I don't think in NATO uh Romania is a NATO country, um an EU country as well, so there'll be a there'll be a due diligence checks obviously from mod before it gets it can get outsourced to that. I know I know um but it there's a there's like a such a long stringent process to it that it's you know it can just be kind of like giving out willy-nilly because there's obviously all kinds of security implications around that. Um yeah, I I'm I'm sure there there's there's some thought gone into it because yeah.

SPEAKER_00Oh probably. Yeah, and checking, you know, and due diligence, obviously. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Okay, question number two. Um with the ongoing review of historic special forces actions, how do you think that impacts the morale and mental health of those who served under high stakes conditions? On that note, at the point we're recording this, people, Soldier F uh has just had his case um where he's been found not guilty in in court, hasn't he? For the Northern Island allegations, which is yesterday morning, I think.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so how do you think it impacts um morale and mental health of so of those who've served under high states conditions?

SPEAKER_00I mean there's there's definitely two elements to it, isn't there? There's the there's the um the kind of what we call the eye of Sauron on you, isn't there? You know, if you're if you're always operating um wondering if you're going to be brought up in a dock, that's gonna have an effect on you. But then also obviously when you're when you're deployed on operations, um you obviously got to work under the Geneva Convention, and and there's always that you know that always always that understanding that you you you deploy and you you operate um you know with kind of a high ethical standard, isn't there?

SPEAKER_00So I mean undoubtedly it will it will have a an impact on you know we've we've got mates in in SF. Um it would definitely have an effect. Um and I guess it's just it's just down to the leadership to make sure that you know operations are conducted um you know in line with you know UK UK policy, Geneva Convention, all that sort of stuff as it is. Um you know, I I think we we're probably becoming more aware of it these days, you know, given obviously the things like soldier F uh trial in the in the media and it's more more things um get put into the public space than I think ever before, you know, especially pre pre-Iraq and pre-Afghan era, you know, it was uh it was obviously Falkland and and Northern Ireland, um and we're now in a kind of a new era where you know any everyone's got a everyone can be an ev an expert witness and everyone can give evidence because they've got a phone in their pocket and they can transmit information quickly and with agility.

SPEAKER_01Okay, question three from David again. Uh you've taken on everything from ocean rows to ultramarathons. When things get mentally tough, what do you lean on to stay focused and keep going? Good question. Um pull that mic in to you a bit. Okay, sure. Um pull it here, you relax and pull it pull it here.

SPEAKER_00Good question. I don't I don't think I don't think there's there's anything really I I kind of rely upon. Well, probably fizz, actually. No, fizz. Fizz is fizz is a thing which you can kind of do anywhere. Um you know, and it kind of gives you away. I'll be specific on this then.

SPEAKER_01Okay. What about you did the Talescale whiskey challenge, right?

SPEAKER_00Uh not the Talascill Challenge, no. We did a we did a um um what's the word? A row across the Atlantic that was with a skipper, so it was a private chatter, that's the word. How long was that? Three months. Holy shit. I know that was our photo. Uh Portugal to French Guyana in South Africa.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so when that was super tough, the toughest times there, and you were like you were struggling to stay motivated. What there? How did you keep going? What mentally kept you going?

SPEAKER_00Um, I think probably like setting the it sound I've got to let these words out, even though they sound really cheesy, really Chad. Is kind of setting the example for other people, you know, and I realise that's one of those kind of throwaway comments where you're like, you know, you want to want to be a good example for others. Um, you know, for me it was um going out there and doing something big outside of the military, you know. So you've done you've obviously done time in the military, you can still do big expeditions, big things, you can still fit them into like a you know professional life.

SPEAKER_00Um, you know, Ferry's three months running across the Atlantic doesn't fit into your holiday entitlement every year, but you know, you can take a sabbatical and do big things, so you can still you can I guess you can still feel relevant, you can still feel um like you're able to kind of inspire other people.

SPEAKER_01I realize how cheap I don't think that's uh you know I don't cheap that sounds no, you know, it's the I think the I think we you drastically underestimate these days the importance of positive role models, act like positive role models, or um leading by doing, yeah, yeah, you know, of uh of of even just demonstrating doing the right thing, you know, put uh uh being how to be a positive contribution to society.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Be that the person who you know be that the person in an underground tube station who you see someone or you see like I don't know, where was I the other day? Uh it was in Liverpool street it was in uh Liverpool Street, Elizabeth's line. Yeah. And there was uh it was packed, people coming off the off the train, off the tube, walking through, it was really busy, about 20 yards ahead of me, not even that, must have been 10 yards ahead of me. There's a young lad and he had a he had a it was a metal, it was a glass bottle of something, it was uh of whatever the drink was.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and he and he finished it and he put it down, mate, in the middle of the walkway. In the middle of the walkway, and it's busy, just put it down, right? There's no bins down there, but you keep it in your hand, you've got something mental, and then we're down in the middle, mental, no shame whatsoever. Everyone's around him, right? I saw it, and it was a guy about five yards in front of me, he was right behind him, looked round and picked it up, didn't you know, picked it up off the floor, yeah, and just carried on to take it up to the bin. Now, he didn't go to the guy and go, You're a fucking ballad because you don't didn't want confrontation or whatever, but yeah, he picked he bent down, he picked that up, and I thought, that is mega, yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know, because I saw him do that, other people saw him do that, and what that means is other people who would probably walk around that bottle, they would just leave it, go on, not my problem, and carry on. The next time round, they're likely to do the right thing and pick that up, yeah. You know, or go a stage further and go and strangle the fucking. Do you know what I mean? So I think the importance of being a positive robber, it's really underestimated. Because once you understand as well that how important it is, it leads you to behave better.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it does, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know, so that is not what you're saying there is not a it's not a uh an what do you say a like a fluffy, airy fairy thing. You know, you you people see you going out out going out putting yourself out of your comfort zone, or people see you being unexpectedly put out of your comfort zone, and how you deal with that and overcome adversity, yeah, yeah, you know, and they go, pfft, and when they have hard times, they'll they'll be able to go through it better. Or if they are looking for the next thing, they'll go, you know what, I'm gonna do something really tough.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, because Chris Shirley did it. And he's not a ballot. Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I mean, just just for context, it was for Team Rubicon UK now React. So it was a it was a a charity fundraiser for the you know for the charity, but a personal, personal endeavour as well.

SPEAKER_01Last question before we have got a bunch more here, we haven't got time for them, the icebreaker. We'll do them at the end of the main podcast, the ones we haven't covered. But okay, question four. Oh, hang on. Do you know what? I might leave this to the podcast actually. We're gonna cover this in the podcast. It's about you, it's about your accident. Yeah, all right. Question five then from David. From Royal Marines Officer to BBC Risk Advisor. What helped you mentally manage the shift from a high-intensity military life into civilian work?

SPEAKER_01Can you repeat the question again, just one more time, just so I've got uh what helped you mentally manage the shift from high-intensity military work, Royal Marines and police into the civilian world?

SPEAKER_00The transition. Yeah, yeah, good question. Yeah, no, um again, kind of like fizz, you know, like j just doing the things which were the the staple of your everyday days in the military, you know. So that was like um you know, your your your your caveman fizz, I call it. Um I mean my my transition to the BBC was it is interesting because I end up I end up doing the first world record well whilst at the BBC and training for the the heavy marathon, um which was like so going out on a weekend um carrying a 45 kilo you know backpack um bergen to to go and get the conditioning in and and kind of help me develop the this the um the leg strength and then walking into you know BBC New Broadcasting House on the Monday morning, literally staggering, people looking at me weirdly going, What's wrong with you?

SPEAKER_00I'm like I just carried a you know 45 kilo bergen around uh I think Guildford you know for 10 miles and they look at me like why? I'm like because you know so you know so it's it's almost like that um doing you know, keeping elements of your old lifestyle, but then when you're going to Civvy Civia Street, you know, into a new role is that the change isn't gonna happen overnight, it's gonna be a gradual thing. So you keep retaining some of those things. Obviously, probably some of the you know the the core stuff should stay in the core, um, you know, you know, the banter and stuff, the uh the those conversations, but then you know good good things like fitness, um focus on um you know personal development is it should come with you into your new role as well.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, excellent fizz.

SPEAKER_01We've got one last comment strop question. I think this is a jokey one. Do you like Wallace and Gromit? I think I think he sees a likeness here. Me and Wallace. I think you've seen a likeness here. I'm looking at the screen. I'm looking at you and thinking, is there some kind of Wallace likeness?

SPEAKER_00I get uh I mean not bold, uh uh you know, maybe maybe maybe Dick Gyllen. Oh no, I say Dick Gillen Hall. Who's a guy in American Pie? The um Oh yeah. Who's the the kid? Not Stifler, the other one. The geeky one. That's that's what I get from time to time. But not Wallace is a new one.

SPEAKER_01Right, let's pause and get ready for the podcast pop out. Nice. Um, if you were listening to this in your podcast app, uh this is gonna roll straight into the next episode, which is episode 274 with Chris full podcast. Become a patron of the podcast. It supports me and it supports the podcast, and uh it makes me happy. Make you happy. Pay for me. Hashtag make you happy. Oh, am I my only my only fans this it's like a revenue stream, isn't it?

SPEAKER_01Isn't it revenue it's a revenue stream? It could be like specials. Me and the naked guest. You never said this in the brief. Pausing there, Jesus Christ.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. “Ronin is a spy film, an action film, a samurai film in bits” - TV & Film chat with Bags and Alex

    Oct 11, 20262 hr 13 minAudio

    Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** British Army veterans Bags Simmons (Royal Tank Regiment, Bare Arms TV & Film) and Alex Brockdorff (Queen’s Royal Hussars, actor/director, A24’s Warfare) join...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Sniper & Combat Medic - "I'm 19, first kinetic experience, first mass casualty event"

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 57 minAudio

    H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts Chris Dodd joins H-Hour for an extended conversation about his years in the British Army and his experiences serving in Northern Ireland, Iraq and Afghanistan. A badged...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Former PWRR Sniper Chris Dodd “The person with the biggest stick is the winner”

    Sep 6, 202620 minAudio

    H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Chris Dodd answers questions submitted by H-Hour patrons in a Q&A format. Topics include whether all infantry should be trained to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. “At the end of the day, it’s their country and they won.” Levison Wood

    Aug 31, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** Levison Wood returns to H-Hour for his second appearance on the podcast, having first featured in 2019. This expansive conversation covers war, exploration,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. “The biggest danger of any expedition is getting in a car.” Explorer Levison Wood

    Aug 31, 202614 minAudio

    Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Levison Wood answers questions submitted by H-Hour platinum patrons in a short Q&A format. Wood discusses what it was like to...

    Credit the people on this episode