Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

H-Hour

H-Hour artwork

“Your uniform doesn’t define you. What defines you is your values, your approach to life.”

Aug 10, 202523 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

H-Hour Icebreaker #268. In this engaging icebreaker episode, former Cold War submariner Marcus Peters discusses the ethical dilemmas in military orders, the day-to-day life of military personnel, and the robust training exercises they undergo. The conversation shifts to the challenges and support mechanisms for military personnel transitioning to civilian life, with a focus on various branches of the armed forces. Peters also shares personal reflections on wisdom gained with age, the emotional connection to military service, and debunks common myths about leaving the forces. This episode serves as a prelude to a full podcast with Marcus, offering an intimate glimpse into Peters' experiences and insights. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Free H-Hour giveaways and exclusive access to guests. https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts H-Hour on Substack: https://hughkeir.substack.com H-Hour on WhatsApp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaWSj4p05MUbVlHmFu3y H-Hour on YouTube: https://youtube.com/@HHourPodcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Okay, let's do it. Question number one, in no particular order. Okay, this is from Koch. Uh members of the members of the Soviet military, Vasil Arkipov and Stanislav Petrov refused to approve nuclear attacks at different times in the Cold War. Would most UK military personnel have done the same? Have you considered refusing an order? The context of this, Marcus was a submariner during the Cold War.

SPEAKER_00Okay, there you go.

SPEAKER_01It's a very interesting concept is when is a lawful order lawful? And I think when we were talking about stuff before, and I think there is within the rules of engagement, we are we have that ability to question an order, and I think what good officers always have done in my experience is when they have their plan, and you'll have known this in your world, it's that question about right, have I thought of everything?

SPEAKER_01It gives you that freedom to then input into that before a decision is made. I think that's on a day-to-day basis, that's how good leadership in the military works. When it comes down to the rules of engagement for nuclear deterrent, that's slightly different because your orders come from obviously Prime Minister in our case. Um, the sealed envelopes which are given to every captain on board a submarine. Um, in the event of loss of communication or in the event of a command order, those envelopes are all opened, those are the orders the captain has, and then the ship's company will undertake those orders.

SPEAKER_00Well, interestingly, during the early years of the cold war, which I've been learning about the cold war book, I've just been telling you about before we started recording. Absolutely uh the the US they the US president delegated down responsibility for use of nuclear weapons to the commander on the ground. And and I know that was the case in the Korean War, for example. Now you get the wrong kind of commander in place, things can go pear-shaped very, very quickly.

SPEAKER_01Yes, no, that if uh yeah, and there are films that look at that. I mean, there's the famous one with Gene Hackman and Denzel Washington, which if you you look at that the movie and that one, I can never remember what that one's called, but effectively that looks at where the loss of there's a loss of communication, yeah, loss of communication between command and the boat, and the captain decides we're gonna do this, and the first lieutenant says that's not a lawful order, no, and there's a mutiny on board and Crimson Tide Crimson Tide, yeah.

SPEAKER_01But um, yeah, and it and it it looks at that exact scenario. I think the one thing, you know, from my experience, we are drilled to the point that you don't actually think about the order, in the sense that you know, most deterrent boats will be going to war in exercise format two or three times a week, uh, all sorts of day and night. Because you don't actually think about it, it's why squaddies shoot at pop-up targets.

SPEAKER_01You don't actually, it's muscle memory, you pull the trigger when the target pops up. You don't think about the morality behind taking the shot.

SPEAKER_00Uh, I'm gonna disagree with that and we can talk about it in the podcast.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you can do, but it but it's it that's one of the things the military trying to do is that it's more about impacting that muscle memory than it is about really having long thoughts about what might happen. I mean, we're my view was always if the command came, you know, my loved ones are pretty much gone anyway.

SPEAKER_00Let's yeah, let's come back on to that on another podcast. All right, question two from Koch. Generally, members of which branch of the military are better at transitioning into civilian life, and which branch gives the best support for transitioning?

SPEAKER_01Right, best support at the moment, I think, is Royal Marines, as we we were talking about that, and I'm not a Royal Marine, but my son is. Um, but having seen that first hand, I think that is really interesting what they're trying to do because there is certainly in the UK military, I mean, you know, 16,000 a year is the average number that leave every year for a variety of reasons. The bit that are actually forgotten about and are the most vulnerable is often the medical discharge.

SPEAKER_01So you imagine you didn't want to leave and suddenly you suck down the rabbit hole. What does that look like? Uh, and some of them, you know, you imagine being, you know, a corporal sergeant, you know, that sort of 12-year mark, you're married, you're in quarters, maybe your wife's not working, you've got a young family, and suddenly med discharge, and within what, 60 days, you're looking at maybe losing your accommodation and that type of thing. So there's there's those, but also what about the young squaddies, matlows, and you know, boot necks and the like who don't complete training?

SPEAKER_01There's those that you know, I want to go in and I want to serve, but the the service says you're not for us or you're injured, need to go out and come back in two years. Well, if you've given up a perfectly good job and you're 17, 18 years of age, and your absolute mission in life was to do and be a para, for example, and suddenly you fail for whatever reason and you're out, what do you do? Where's the support network for that? So there is a lot of vulnerability, and that's where I think that the charity space does come in.

SPEAKER_01MOD are getting better, certainly with OpCourage and Opnova and all those sort of support networks that are coming through. But I think the ones that are sometimes easier to transition are some of the RAF, because they tend to go into technology-based or logistic-based roles, like for like, you know, they'll come off aircraft and they'll transition to other aircraft or the aircraft industry, they'll move into logistics, which are quite easily transitional. If you're a sniper, what's your skill set?

SPEAKER_01And if you're a sniper that's been med discharged, what's your skill set? How do you define that? How do you reinvent your narrative? And that's the harder thing. So I think some of the technical roles across all three services, but RAF, from my experience, tend to be slightly easier.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Uh okay, a question now from David, who's the editor editor of the podcast. Uh, you started in submarines, led big teams in energy, and now you are mentoring. What keeps pulling you back to support others?

SPEAKER_01I think it's the community and the like-minded people. You know, one of the things I'm I'm very clear on now that I wasn't, was your uniform doesn't define you. You know, what defines you is your values, your approach to life, and actually what people confuse when they're leaving the military is but the uniform was that, and it's not the uniform was a mechanism for you to serve, to care about the world, to care about others, to lead others, to mentor others.

SPEAKER_01It was just a mechanism, that's all it was. You would have done it anyway, but you just saw it more of that. You know, the uniform became a tool. Um, and I think I came full circle about 10 years ago when I realized that actually I should stop being this is gonna sound terrible, but I almost ashamed of my service, and because there was an element of you know failure in when I left and I didn't complete my mission in my head. Um, and a lot of people feel like that.

SPEAKER_01But it took a lot of people, particularly a friend of mine who was a US Marine, to really get me to see actually, you're not, you know, you're not something that to be ashamed of. Actually, you have served, you have stood up when others wouldn't. And I think that's what you find the commonality in all. It doesn't matter whether you're an RAF logistics that served four years or you've done 32 years and you're a lieutenant colonel. We all have that servitude and we all have similar values. Some of us might be pirate reprobates and thieves, but you know, underneath all of that, you still care.

SPEAKER_01And it's why you can get into a room with somebody you've never served with, completely different. You can have the crack, you can find common ground, you can find values, and and I say 98% of the people that I ever come across in the community. You if it was a school football team, you'd want them on your team. As opposed to a lot of civilians, you wouldn't you'd have to spend a fair bit of time with them to understand that, whereas you know, you don't in our community, so I think that's the key thing.

SPEAKER_00Uh okay. Um great advice as well, by the way. That the the uniform is not what defines you, and so many people need to be need to learn that lesson. Yeah. Uh what is again from David, what is one myth about leaving the forces you find yourself busting over and over with your mentees?

SPEAKER_01When they say to me, I'm just a it's this phrase that just irritates the shit out of me.

SPEAKER_00I mean it's valid if they're a boot neck.

SPEAKER_01What leather is that?

SPEAKER_00Joking, I can't help it.

SPEAKER_01You're gonna get so much hate. Right. I am the dad though that I did when my son joined the Marines. I put a pack of 24 Coronel crayons in his bag. Oh, did you? And he phoned me and said, What's that for? I said, Well, in case you get hungry, obviously. Um, but you know, this this phrase just irritates the crap out of me. Um, and I'll give you a great example. I was at a careers fair last year um at Catterick, and this young corporal comes up to me, he's done six, seven years, and uh he said, you know, what do you do?

SPEAKER_01He stood there in his MTP, got his Army Air Corps stuff on, and uh he said, Oh, I'm just an Apache technician. And I went, So let me let me just rephrase that then. You are a mechanical electric electronics technician on the world's most advanced attack helicopter. He went, Well, if you put it that way, well, what other way is there to put it? Yeah, and it's that just a you know, I I've got to go.

SPEAKER_00That's not even dressing it up, that's exactly what he does. Exactly. Exactly what he does.

SPEAKER_01A Marine recently he said, I'm just a driver. And when we pulled that apart, he was you know, he got responsible for 16 people, a budget of about two million quid, his kit was worth about 30 million, he was doing logistics and resource planning, all of that. Yeah, but he's just a marine driver, yeah, yeah, yeah. And I think that's the big thing that irritates me.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Um, okay, we're back on to Coke's questions. So, question number three from Coke. Uh, what are the he does bounce around? Okay, what are the positives and negatives of growing old?

SPEAKER_01Uh one of the positives is you and this is when you hit 50, right? So a guy said to me last year, he said, Are you over 50? Now I said, Yes. He said, Right, now you can officially use a word in the English language called wisdom. He said, because you can't use it until you're 50 because you haven't lived enough and screwed up enough to be able to use it. And he said, and it's demonstratable by if you go to the Russian steppes or the Brazilian rainforest, there are elders and they're not 26-year-old IT graduates, right?

SPEAKER_01So you can use the word wisdom, so that's a positive, all right. And also, I think people give you a bit of a pass when you're a grumpy bastard as well, because he's just he's just old and grumpy. The downside is you can't do the things that you want to do anymore. You you know, you I work hard in the gym, but it it's harder now, and you know, it's just you've blinked, and when did that happen? Uh I was talking to a guy recently where he's just had a child, and I said, you know, buy a camera, buy the best camera you can ever buy, take pictures every day, take video every day.

SPEAKER_01Because that first five years feels like 15, the next five years feels like 10, and the next five years between 10 and 15 feels like three months. Yeah, it just accelerates. It's like this mad time acceleration that just happens.

SPEAKER_00Well, there is a there is a part two and three to this question, and I'm chuckling because I've just read the rest a bit, right? So, all right, so I'm gonna give the read the other three lines about this question. So to continue what Koch said, how different did you become in the and just sorry, he posted this without knowing who you were seeing a photo or anything. So he said, How different did you become in each decade of life given the given given the time of your service, i.e. 1980s, 1990s, I must respectfully conclude you were elderly.

SPEAKER_01Everything is in context. I'm younger than my dad.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, exactly. Elderly relative to what maybe the gog.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but but that it's quite interesting, isn't it? Because it particularly if you watch an old war movie when you know you look at a Sean Connery in like the you know, I don't know, bridge too far. It's probably my age, but in real life, he would have probably been you know 30 at the best, you know, in the war. I mean, it's quite mad how you look at life. Um, I think I'm in a good place now in this decade because there is a bit of you know, the kids are on a good path, they're all adults now, and you know, I've got money in the bank, I'm not a millionaire, I've still got a mortgage, but the pressures are slightly different, and you start thinking about the next part of your, you know, when would you retire, what would you do with that, all that sort of fun stuff.

SPEAKER_01That bit in the middle is when you've got all the craziness with the kids, you know, from sort of 30 to 45. Um, I feel there's a lot of pressure there to provide for family, pressure to be successful. Um often you lean into that and you actually don't find joy, which is mad because you've got you know, my kids are the most important thing to me. Pardon Mrs. Peters, you know, but you know, they are my world, but you actually lean into work, and I I jokingly said to somebody on a LinkedIn post recently, I gave the best years of my kids' life to a corporate environment, but I did it because to give them better than I had, which I didn't have a lot growing up, you know, to give them better opportunities in life because I fought my opportunities in life.

SPEAKER_01Um, so I think as you get that wise wisdom, you then look at life slightly differently. I think there's also that bit in the middle from leaving the service until I was probably 45, where I just ran away, hid everything, nobody understood what I did. Afghanistan and Iraq came along, and they were the hot wars, they were visible, and that you know, they were media they forgot about us. The Cold War didn't have a defined end.

SPEAKER_01You know, we did what was asked of us, and suddenly a wall falls down in Germany, and like, oh, you're not needed anymore, let's make a load of your redundance, let's just you know cancel all the orders on the new kit, or you know, just run everything into the ground, and there was a real like there was no end to it, you know, there was no natural end. I'm not saying that the pullout of Afghanistan was right, and and for a lot of the Afghan vets I know was very, very painful, particularly when the Taliban took back in charge, but there was a clear media coverage end point, and it was a finite game that you were playing, and the military is a finite game.

SPEAKER_01Unfortunately, life is an infinite game, and and that screwed my with my head for a very, very long time. And I was I suppose ashamed of what I did. I couldn't talk to people about what I did for secrecy reasons, people didn't understand it. One problem with the Navy is it's not like a lot of units where you're with a lot of people in, you know, you if you're in, I don't know, Joker Company and 4-2 commando, you know those guys and you'll move around the commando sphere, but it's a small family.

SPEAKER_01With us, you know, I I'd serve with you, and then three months into getting to know you, you'd be drafted somewhere else, or you'd be going on a promotion course. So you were having like three to six months at times rotations with people, you didn't get very, very close bonds. Whereas if you're on the aircraft carriers and that, you tend to be carriers only or small ships only. You you tended to knock into the same people a lot. So when you leave, where's your community?

SPEAKER_00Um okay, last last question for the icebreakers. Uh, we have got some left, but we're hitting the time limit, so we'll come on to them at the end of the actual podcast. This one again is from Coco. X RSM22 SAS Peter Ratcliffe said that when the captain of HMS Sheffield, Sam Salt, came on to the ship Hermes after his ship was hitting the Falklands, he looked defeated and sat head down in silence.

SPEAKER_00Not a single Royal Navy officer came to the captain to offer condolences and they ignored him. Ratcliffe recalled reading a captain who lost his ship could expect no mercy from the Admiralty. Does this behaviour match what you'd expect? And why did they ignore him? Now, I you would like to know as well. The Navy is a peculiar place. Submariners, submarine service, even more so. Even more so.

SPEAKER_01Well, you you you do realise we don't parade on Remembrance Sunday.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01So we parade a week before Submarine Service parade a week before at our own cenotaph, which is down on embankment, which is the submarine memorial. And the reason for that is is because after the first world war, when we started to do the cenotaph thing, the admiralty went, Well, we can't have those dirty pirates marching. They don't play war like cricket. War should be done in a certain way, it's underhand, it's not the way things are done. So the admiralty, that's why the submarine world started itself.

SPEAKER_01It's why that we see ourselves as pirates, reprobates, and thieves. It's why when a submarine, like when Conqueror sunk the Belgrano, she came back, she flew the Jolly Roger.

SPEAKER_00Funny.

SPEAKER_01Because it was almost like two fingers to the Admiralty that, and we are seen very differently. Um, when you you sort of, you know, the number of times that you you you'd go around, they go, Oh, submariners.

SPEAKER_00Funny enough, snipers, believe it or not, were also on land wars before obviously the sort of the birth of the sniper, I think, not the sniper, but marksmanship in a military, in a military context, I think it was the birth of that, was the Royal Navy. Yeah, yeah. Um, but where snipers on land are concerned, especially World War I, and also in the American Civil War, were looked down on by their own troops for much of the same reasons. That that's not gentlemanly conduct to hide and shoot people. No, no, no. They have to walk up to the line and then just point guns at each other and say no, fire.

SPEAKER_00Even in their own lines, they weren't liked at all, even though they're pretty good at what they did, you know.

SPEAKER_01And I can I can see that you know, it is my vessel. You know, a captain sees the ship and his people on that ship as his property and his family, and I can understand the loss of losing it. And and it's really weird, you know. Years later, from when I left, um, we were building a substation at Resith. Um, so the Resythe dockyard were building it on our behalf, and I I was going up doing inspections, and it was right in between the two aircraft carriers in build. But when I stood on the top deck of the substation in build and I looked out across, all of my old submarines are mothballed waiting to be turned into razor blades, and there is that little tear in your eye of that's my home.

SPEAKER_01It's a bit like you watching a forward operating base being demolished and knowing that people have lived and died for that. It was really emotional, and you can't quite connect it, you know. It's a bit like I don't know if you've ever been to the ABBA thing down in London, and you start whooping and cheering in a different way at avatars, and your brain goes, There's nobody there, why am I cheering? It's like it's just a rusty piece of metal. Why are you getting upset about it? But there is this emotional attachment to it because it it was everything to you, you know.

SPEAKER_01And certainly two of those boats saved my life. I shouldn't be here, you know. There were things that went on on that boat, I shouldn't be here for the people on that boat and that the the strength of the people who built it. I came out to my loved ones. So what were you on? I was on um resolution class, I was on Reserve Repulse. I did a an O-boat for a short while as well, and I did about a week on a frigate. I actually wanted frigates in Plymouth and ended up in submarines in Scotland, just how Ministry of Defence works, you know.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01Like you said, I wanted to be in the Catron Corps and you ended up in the Paris, you know.

SPEAKER_00That is the end of the icebreaker. Um, if you listen to this in your podcast app, it's gonna roll straight into the full podcast. And like I said at the start, uh um, yeah, if you want to submit questions for future subscribe for future beg future guests and watch or listen live, become a patron of the podcast. Patreon.com forward slash hk podcast, qk a dot substack.com. That's it. Cool next uh full podcast rolling in, coming in hot, coming in hot.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. “Ronin is a spy film, an action film, a samurai film in bits” - TV & Film chat with Bags and Alex

    Oct 11, 20262 hr 13 minAudio

    Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** British Army veterans Bags Simmons (Royal Tank Regiment, Bare Arms TV & Film) and Alex Brockdorff (Queen’s Royal Hussars, actor/director, A24’s Warfare) join...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Sniper & Combat Medic - "I'm 19, first kinetic experience, first mass casualty event"

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 57 minAudio

    H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts Chris Dodd joins H-Hour for an extended conversation about his years in the British Army and his experiences serving in Northern Ireland, Iraq and Afghanistan. A badged...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Former PWRR Sniper Chris Dodd “The person with the biggest stick is the winner”

    Sep 6, 202620 minAudio

    H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Chris Dodd answers questions submitted by H-Hour patrons in a Q&A format. Topics include whether all infantry should be trained to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. “At the end of the day, it’s their country and they won.” Levison Wood

    Aug 31, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** Levison Wood returns to H-Hour for his second appearance on the podcast, having first featured in 2019. This expansive conversation covers war, exploration,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. “The biggest danger of any expedition is getting in a car.” Explorer Levison Wood

    Aug 31, 202614 minAudio

    Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Levison Wood answers questions submitted by H-Hour platinum patrons in a short Q&A format. Wood discusses what it was like to...

    Credit the people on this episode