Join the H-Hour Patron Community at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** For H-Hour #279 I welcome back “Bags,” a former Royal Tank Regiment officer and military advisor for film, TV, and theatre, where we discuss reviving TV/film episodes - starting with a tank-film theme - and how cavalry and tank regiments evolved from WWI to today. Bags discusses his ongoing advisory role on Rogue Heroes (including season three’s production challenges, schedule compression, and historical-accuracy debates), the mixed military reaction to season one, and his views on the portrayal of Paddy Mayne while balancing authenticity against storytelling, budget, and time. The conversation ranges through theater work at the Globe, the appeal of live performance and improvisation, ticket pricing and ways to find cheaper seats, and how streaming has reshaped pay - especially the loss of residuals and disputes like Scarlett Johansson’s - alongside Netflix’s “second screening” influence and attention spans. We trade film recommendations and reflections and then address patron questions about how much productions act on military advice and whether media shapes public perceptions of war. The episode ends with a discussion of UK defence readiness, reliance on allies, and Bags’ new role at a British engineering firm building UGVs (uncrewed ground vehicles), plus thoughts on future instability, potential reserve service, and legacy prosecutions related to Northern Ireland. Send us Fan Mail This episode is sponsored by Sin Eaters Guild - sineatersguild.co.uk Support the show Free H-Hour giveaways and exclusive access to guests. https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts H-Hour on Substack: https://hughkeir.substack.com H-Hour on WhatsApp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaWSj4p05MUbVlHmFu3y H-Hour on YouTube: https://youtube.com/@HHourPodcast
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to Hey Chour. Uh, this episode is being streamed live to Hey Chour patrons. They have also had advanced viewing of the guest list, the Lucky Devils, and they've also been able to submit questions for the guests, which were answered by the guest today, Bag Simmons, on the icebreaker. A few of which have uh we couldn't fit into that 20-minute sort of approximate limit we have. So I'll ask them at the end of this podcast. If you want the opportunity to support the podcast, support me, and to get access to the guest list, watch live links of the of the podcast and submit questions in advance.
SPEAKER_01Become a patron of the podcast. It costs as little as five pounds a month. It's absolutely nothing. It's literally leaper, cheaper than the cost of a coffee these days. It's depressing to say that. And a shitty coffee at that. On that note, Greg's coffee is pretty cheap. That is not a fiver, and uh and it tastes very, very good. I do not work for Greg's, they're not commissioning me, they're not a sponsor. I just realized it recently and I thought, huh. Uh, in addition to corned beef pasties, if your local Greg's sell corned beef pasties and you've always been and you've always been put off by it, have a corned beef pasty.
SPEAKER_01It will change corn beef pasty, not cornish pasty, it will change your life. You can take it up a level by making your own home, dead easy. Get some uh get some get some uh dough. You can get rolls of dough pre-made from Tesco's or Asda, like pre-made, don't have to do anything, no flour, no water. Get those, get a tin of corned beef, put it inside, but 20 minutes and you have on your own corned beef pasty. I don't work for Tesco's or Asda either, nor am I a producer of dough.
SPEAKER_00Yet.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back, Bax. Thank you for having me. It's good to see you, mate. It's good to see you. It's been so fucking long. Um it's been so long. The uh the the TV and film episodes, I was loving those. Are you still up for doing those in VT? You are starting to still make it. Let's do those again. We'd love to, yeah. Um, and get the get brought the uh Brock Brock Nor Dorfner in. The Brock Meister. The Brock Meister.
SPEAKER_00There's a film that's on Amazon Prime that we need to watch. It's about a tank. It's a Russian tank. Um Tank. No, he's not. It's Russian Tank. It's called Tank. It's Russian, it's dubbed. I don't know, I don't know if it's called Tank, but it's it's a tank film about tanks. Uh it's probably called Tank in Russian, which I don't know what tank in Russian is. Amazon fine. Hold on. Okay. I'm gonna type it into the chat, yeah. Yeah, uh, I'm gonna speak it. Amazon fine Russian film called Tank.
SPEAKER_01Okay. The tank. Oh, sorry, the tank hang on. The tank. The tank, also known as The Tiger, is a 2025-2026 German-produced war film. Is it about Russian Russian? I've just been corrected, not Russian, now streaming on Amazon Prime that follows a German Tiger Tank crew on a dangerous 1943 mission behind Soviet lines. So it's in Russia. Directed by Dennis Ganzel, is described as a dark, psychological, and intense drama focusing on the crew's descent into a heart of darkness.
SPEAKER_01Watch the official trailer for the tank to get a glimpse of the intense gritty war scene. Should we watch the trailer? I don't know if the audio will come through. I can't see it anywhere. I can show you it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'll show you. Will this will everybody at home be able to see it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00See, it makes sense it's called Dash Tiger, because it's it looks like a target on camera.
SPEAKER_01That's fine. Okay, so my screen share has limitations.
SPEAKER_00Anyway, I will watch it. I'll watch it. Well no, I think I think we should watch it together as uh or do you want to watch it and then come together and do a part?
SPEAKER_01With the film?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, we can do that.
SPEAKER_01We could do a themed TV and film episode on tank films. Agreed. Hard agree. For those who haven't watched any of the numerous times that Bags has appeared on this podcast, Bags is in fact a former officer of the Royal Tank Regiment. I mean, you said both of those with a sneer. Well, I knew you said member. He is a member. I have been called worse, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Bags is a tanky. So um we can uh we can watch, we could do a tank to further fill up. Nothing would give me more joys. Uh Brock van Dorf now. Uh Queen's Royal Hussars. Oh he was a hussar. Hang on a minute, but aren't they kind of armor people as well? They are. Tank people. Okay, do you want to go down this route?
SPEAKER_00So, World War One, trench warfare, yeah, stalemate.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Uh they needed something to invention of machine guns meant that the traditional tactics didn't work. Therefore, soldiers dug trenches to protect themselves. So World War I turned into trench warfare. In order to break the trench deadlock, the British started to create uh the world's first tank. And um it was originally conceived as a land ship, so uh at the power of a battleship on land, so something that could cross land. So they basically took a battleship and a tractor and wanged the two together and made a tank.
SPEAKER_00Wanged. Wanged, wanged. It's a look it up.
SPEAKER_01So they really describe that that process to the engineers who actually did it at the same time. Yes, exactly.
SPEAKER_00They were wanging. Yep. Um wanged the two together to create the first tank. Uh and um it was able to cross no man's land, cross trenches, and it helped break the stalemate in World War One. Um, they created the Heavy Branch Machine Corps, which was a code name. So the Machine Gun Corps existed. The heavy branch machine gun corps was a code name for the tank corps that after World War I became the tank corps. Uh in the 30s became the tank regiment.
SPEAKER_00And then between World War I and World War II, most of the cavalry regiments converted over to tanks. Not all of them. Famously, the uh Scots Greys, I think, were the last ones who didn't convert onto tanks until World War II, probably midway through, I think 1942, the Scots Greys decided actually horses didn't survive well against machine gun fire, but everybody else did it before then. Um so yes, so nowadays you have various different branches of the armoured corps, some who work in tanks, some who work in light armor, um, and you have the cavalry and you have the original tankies.
SPEAKER_00But the cavalry look down on the tankies because they see us as new, we've only been around for 110 years. Uh, and the tankies look down on the cavalry as uh people who came late to tanks, so that's it, really. Any questions?
SPEAKER_01Not no, I don't. Uh we've got a problem with liveling. I just need to yeah, one second. I just need to tell I just need to tell some. That's fine. Shall I entertain myself? Any uh tell some more tank friends? Let someone know, check the post.
SPEAKER_00And we've spoken about the beret before, but the RTR were the first people to have the beret. They took it off the French in World War I. And the British Army didn't adopt the beret whole scale until World War II. You love quite like that, too. Because you're not a crap out then by definition. Can't be. Can't be a crap out. The old definition. It was the RTR, then it was the SAS, then it was the command line. Then it was the powers. Then it was the powers like fourth in line. Trust me, you can be a crap out. If it weren't for the tankies, you powers would be wearing you you'd be wearing pink tent hats.
SPEAKER_00Absolute screamer.
SPEAKER_01Oh mate, what's going down in Bagsworld? Uh, are we allowed to mention about the um one second? Oh yeah. Yeah, okay. So we can mention about you getting engaged and yes. Thank you very much. Also, obviously a previous uh podcast. Yeah, yeah, yeah. She's been well done, right? That's not how we met. Was it a romantic was it a telkus through the telcas through the proposal?
SPEAKER_00So I'd been in I'd I realise she took me to Burr Island, which is if you've never been to Burr Island's amazing place, it's off the coast of Devon, and it's an island that you can only Devon.
SPEAKER_01Oh, Devon, okay.
SPEAKER_00You can only reach it at low tide, and at high tide, there's a tractor that takes you across with well, it wang together. It probably was wanged together, yeah. Um and this place was where Agatha Christie wrote all of her books, and there's the island has got one pub and it's got a hotel on it, which is like a 1930s Art Deco hotel. Anyway, Jess has done a couple of events there, and alongside uh being paid for it, they give her free nights.
SPEAKER_00So it was her birthday a couple of years ago, and she took me down to the island. We went to see the otters as well. There's an otter sanctuary on the mainland not too far away. I think we went to to Buckfastley to see Buckfast Abbey, yeah, just did did a like a long weekend, took her to the range, we did some shooting. Um, you know, standard romantic guns. Standard romantic ranges, exactly. Buckfast and guns.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, and it was then that I realized that you know that she was she was who I wanted to spend the rest of my life with. So I I then then wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. This is last year. Uh year before last, I think. Before my 40th. So I can't even remember how old I am now. Oh, okay. It was it was it was 18 months, two years ago. Okay, maybe a little bit more than that. Anyway, realised that that that that was where um where things would go.
SPEAKER_00So um I decided to get a ring made. And so I sat down with my aunt, who's a jewelry designer, very cool lady, um, and had a chat with her about it, and she gave me a lot of guidance. And over the course of four or five months, we would meet up every so often, and she would show me some designs based on some thoughts that I had had, based on things that Jess liked, places that we'd been that we liked, and uh she created us this incredible ring.
SPEAKER_00So Jess had a job where she was going to go to Norway. Was it Norway? No, Finland. And so I thought I can I can go out and see her and I can do it then. Um that got pushed to the end of the year, and I'd got the ring by this point, and it was burning a bit of a hole in my pocket. And uh she got a job at the Royal Shakespeare Company um in Stratford upon Avon uh over the summer. Uh and uh she was that's a lovely area up there.
SPEAKER_00It's really nice. She was uh understudying for Rose Leslie. For anybody who's a Game of Thrones fan, she's in Game of Thrones? Rose Rose Leslie, married to um Kit Harrington. She's the ginger one. I can't.
SPEAKER_01Oh, Rose. Sorry, there's two ginger ones. There's the main ginger one. Yeah. I remember Rose Leslie. Sophie Turner. Sophie Turner's the other one, yeah. Yeah, Rose Leslie's gorgeous. Yeah, so she just was under studying for Rose Leslie. Isn't Rose Leslie the one with the proper Northern accent in it?
SPEAKER_00No, she oh, she has a proper Northern accent in Game of Thrones, I believe. I think I've never seen it. But no, she's really posh in Rose. She's a great one. Um so Jess was under studying for Rose at the Royal Shakespeare Company, and in uh theatre, what you have is you have rehearsals, which is normally done in a space, a rehearsal space. You then move to the theatre and you do the tech rehearsals, which is done in the theatre itself. Um, you then have um like a soft week, I can't remember what it's called, but you have dress rehearsals basically.
SPEAKER_00People come and pay to see it, but they pay a lot less, and then you have the opening night or pr press night. So press night is when everything's up and running. So I was in Malta filming and I'd taken the ring out with me, and I flew back, jumped in the van, drove up to Stratford-upon Avon, and I was going to propose to her that night when um, because it was the press night, it was a big party. Anyway, uh, everybody ends up coming back to her little flat in um Stratford-Pon Ponaven, and we had a bit of an after party, and we drank the litre of Japanese whiskey that I had bought.
SPEAKER_00Oh uh God, and it all got a bit a bit leary. Anyway, Jess loves Ferrero Roche, she's like an absolute fiend. I'll buy her like a little 12-pack and she will scoff through that pretty damn quickly. Um, I once saw her with one in each cheek as she was unwrapping the third one to pop into her mouth. She bloody loves them. So I bought as I was going through duty free, there was a massive industrial, you know, tub of the thing.
SPEAKER_00I was like, brilliant. I'll hide it at the bottom, give that to her, and she'll get through that in an afternoon, and the ring will be at the bottom. And uh so I didn't give it to her that night because there were loads of people there, and I didn't want somebody else to find it because that would be really awkward. Didn't want to do it in front of loads of people. So I gave it to her the next day when we were both incredibly hungover. Uh it was all the way at the bottom, and I reckon there must have been about 50 Frera Roche in there. She had one and went, they're a bit stale, and put the lid back on and left them.
SPEAKER_00Oh my god. And I'd been I'd sought advice from various people, and they said, look, don't overplan the proposal because the other person will do everything in their power unknowingly to unhinge the entire thing. A friend of mine called Sam, he was going to propose to his uh girlfriend. They were going for a week in in it in Italy, and on the the Sunday, he had the whole day planned, um, everything, all these events, and he was going to propose to her at the end.
SPEAKER_00On the Saturday, she proposed to him first. Oh my god. So all of this was exactly don't overplan it. So anyway, she was in the theatre that night. She has to be, even though she's the understudy, she has to be there, ready to go. So while she was at the theatre, I took it out of the box and shuffled it up to the very top. So all she had to do was take out the top one, and there it was. So lo and behold, at about 10 o'clock at night, she comes back in and I put them by the front door, and she went, ah, took the one off the top.
SPEAKER_00As she was putting it into her mouth, went, Oh, there's another box in it, then put the lid back on and went into the kitchen.
SPEAKER_01Oh, so is the ring in a box?
SPEAKER_00The ring's in a box. She saw the box. She saw the box and didn't twitch. So I was like, Oh, why don't you have a look at what the box is? Anyway, she then came back to it, looked at the box, and while she was because it was in a bigger box, she opened the big box and there was a ring box on the inside. And she said, Is this what I think it is? As I got down onto one knee, and then that's how I proposed. So incredibly hungover at the end of a long day. Well, congratulations, mate.
SPEAKER_01She is a good woman. She is, she's very good. Yeah, too good. She's a great woman. I got I got by good, I said good in a way that I meant great, like good, like a good, good woman. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Talented individual. She is. But the good beautiful individual. The great thing was, I was I was I was due to go back to London the next morning. Um, but the the staff at the RSC managed to get me tickets to see the show the next day, and Jess had to go on for the matinee. So Jess was on stage as the lead and they let her wear the ring. Because the ring is is a it was a very 1920s play, and uh the ring was a very 1920s style ring, and so she had this massive rock on her finger, bouncing light off.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was wonderful. So I got to see her perform wearing the ring. He's wonderful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, congratulations, mate. Happy both. Happy for you both. Happy for you both. She must be busy at the minute, is she? Very, yeah.
SPEAKER_00She's um she is doing a film. Can I say no, I can't. She's doing she's doing a film next week. She's been doing two or three games this week. Yeah, she's she seems to love doing the game voice. She loves the game voiceovers. She loves the game over. That's why she got into acting in the first place, was doing the voices. She was watching Ice Age and seeing Do you want to explain what tweet what Jeff does? Um predominantly she does voiceover, but she her love is theatre as well.
SPEAKER_00Um but she has a real she is she was she was raised in Wales. She's fucking Welsh, but she's got an Irish passport. She's more in Welsh. She when she's when she's um when she's tired or drunk, she does get a little bit Welsh and says things like toothbrush and saucepan um and heard. Uh, but she is a little bit Welsh. Um she uh has an incredible talent for voices, so she often gets brought in to do characters in games where the original person in like the like they're doing a game of a TV show or something, the original actor um isn't doing the games, they bring her in to mimic their voice.
SPEAKER_00She's incredible at doing that. She used to be able to unlock iPhones when they were voice by mimicking somebody's voice. Yeah, she's really good at it. Uh really good at it. Yeah. Um, but obviously, obviously, Apple have upgraded their tech since. Yeah, but no, she's and she l loves it. She loves she loves theatre as well. Um, so yeah, she's got a lot of good things in the pipeline. I can't say what any of them are because I'll be breaking every NDA under the sun.
SPEAKER_00But yeah.
SPEAKER_01So since we last spoke, I think you banged out Rogue Hero season two. Rogue Hero season two.
SPEAKER_00Season three, yeah. So season two was out on TV this time last year. Season three we filmed um end of last year. So we finished filming about a month and a half ago. Um, yeah, finished in December. Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01What was that like?
SPEAKER_00It was Did it get easier as the seasons went on?
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00Where were they? Where was it shot? It should do this. Was shot mostly in the UK with a little bit in Belgium. So um it should get easier, but um it was it was greenlit very last moment, and trying to get all the actors back was quite hard because a lot of them have become quite famous now, and so trying to organise all their schedules to make sure we could have everybody in the same place at the same time, plus the period that we were doing in season three is supposed to be the summer, so us going into the winter was making things difficult.
SPEAKER_00Um, a lot of it was filmed in in woodland, and obviously when it gets to autumn, the leaves start to fall off. So there was a lot of technical challenges trying to make it um trying to make it work. So it was and it was shot on a shorter schedule than both season one and season two, so it's got shorter each time the schedule. Um so this time, so season one was pretty much one unit shot the whole thing. So uh season two we had two.
SPEAKER_00Um I think one of them shot uh probably about 20 to 25 percent of the time. So and then season uh three second unit shot 50% of the time, so you're doing more in less time, so it yeah, it got it got um, yeah. I I think it would the schedule was more punishing for sure. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I remember when I remember when the first series got I loved love love, I've only seen the first series, and the only reason I say that is because I don't watch a lot of TV, but I don't and I deliberately try and stay, I don't want to be consumed by things. There's very little things I'll I'll put my time into it. I watched the first series because uh you were involved with it, and like as you know very much, fucking loved it. Oh in fact, I went and watched the first episode at your place. No, uh yeah, yes, it was. Yeah, we did uh we did a screening at BBC brilliant brilliant series. Yeah, however, I remember there being a mixed reaction from certain quarters of the military community in the UK uh to that first series.
SPEAKER_01Because very precious about the history, obviously. This is a dramatized programme, right? How did that did that change as the second and third series came about? Um was that was I did I explain that fairly about season one?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So so the the criticisms came from a number of different Most people loved it, and what was what was what was brilliant was you had people from all over the spectrum enjoying it. So um I think it was Anthony Beaver, the the historian, Sir Anthony Beaver. I think it was him, it was a very prominent historian, I think it was him, um saying that he thought it was great. At the same time, um is it Caitlin Moran, Kathleen Moran, feminist writer?
SPEAKER_00She said, I can't think of a TV show that I would be less likely to enjoy, that I enjoyed more. She loved it too. So if you're catching those two ends of the spectrum, then you'll it's it's sort of a dream for any production company to be able to get that spread of people. And a lot of people were saying things like, My wife or my partner usually hates watching these things, but really enjoyed it. So it did a good job of capturing everybody. There are a lot of there are a lot of people that got annoyed by very minor things, and some of them were also quite wrong.
SPEAKER_00So um there are a couple of people that were getting annoyed about them wearing sunglasses in the desert. Okay, British, British forces didn't wear sunglasses in the desert, blah, blah, blah, blah. And then you present them with the history and the pictures, like, right, here's David Sterling, 1941, wearing sunglasses in the desert. You know, them saying, Oh, they didn't have aviators in the 1940s, it's like, okay, here are the aviators invented in 1937 or whatever it was. Here are is David Sterling wearing a pair of aviators, like you're a fucking spotter.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so there, so there are there were a lot of people who were just getting really irate about things that were they were wrong. And then there were it was BBC, BBC budget. So BBC budget is not huge, and people um there was a tank in one scene that was quite clearly um an M60 mocked up to look like a German tank. It didn't look that much like a German tank, but it was supposed to be a German tank. A lot of people go, well, that's the wrong tank. It's like, we know it's the wrong tank, but for budgetary reasons, we shot on that tank for half a day in the middle of the Sahara, you know, hundreds of miles from anywhere.
SPEAKER_00If you think that the BBC is going to pay millions of pounds to get a World War II German tank into the desert to do that, then you're barking that's your taxpayers' cash being paid. You know, it's not that's not how it works. And there's a convoy of trucks opening sequence, there's a massive convoy of trucks. The first 10 of those trucks are World War II trucks, genuine World War II trucks. The further back you go, the more modern they get because they're in the background, they're blurred, and there's people going, That's a that's a modern truck. It's like stop looking at the background, enjoy the story.
SPEAKER_00But you know, some people just just want to complain. So there was that, and then there would be the other concern, which we've talked about before, was people were um annoyed at the portrayal of um a paddy main, so they don't feel that that's sort of representative of who the real guy was, which you know. I mean, I know we discussed that before when after that first series.
SPEAKER_01About Paddy Main's portrayal in there, what are your thoughts on it changed at all?
SPEAKER_00Not really, no. I think um I mean there are very many different versions of him, depending on who you talk to and what books you read. And he was an immensely complex man, which is quite clear, and I think certain parts of the TV show represent certain parts of him, but definitely not all of him as a whole. And the one thing I've been uh been trying to get them to show more of is his leadership, his actual genuine, innate leadership, which he clearly had in spades.
SPEAKER_00So there have been there have been moments where I've tried to tweak things a little bit more. As an advisor, your power to change things is quite limited. You can only advise and say, I think it should be this, I think it should be that.
SPEAKER_01And you've got to have really good reason to do it, especially when it comes to things like changing a character. Exactly. And and that's been written.
SPEAKER_00That's been written by somebody who who is an exceptionally good writer and understands a character and what makes people want to watch something. So he's not the writer isn't writing something that's going to um be historically pure. He's writing something that's going to make good TV. That's that's his number one aim. That's the production's number one aim. My aim is to within the bounds of what they want to do, is try and get them to be more accurate where I can. But sometimes you you can't.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes budget, time, story, you can't. And so you do the very best that you can, but you know, you can't always win. So you've got to keep your powder dry, you've got to pick your moments and and have a really good reason to say, I think this is incorrect, and here's why. And some of those I've won, some of them I haven't. That's just part of the job. But um, I yeah, I I there's a lot of people that still still quite hung up on on the actor's height, as if you know, the height, the height changes who he is, but you know, it's he's a a character, he's playing somebody, it's more about how he behaves and acts, but you know, there will always be people that won't be happy with that.
SPEAKER_00But it's not for it's not for them, it's for the majority of people, and a lot of people really enjoy it, a lot of people don't. Um, I personally preferred season one to see season two. My great uncle died in the SAS in World War II, and the events of his death are are in the show. He was um in season one in city in two. Oh, there's a big incident in episode four um where I think it's the biggest loss of life the SAS have had in a single day, and they lost, I think, uh I can't remember now, 20 somewhere in the high in the medium twenties, 22 25 blokes killed in one day, and he was one of those blokes.
SPEAKER_00Um, so I've got a very personal connection with season two, but I prefer season one. But most people do, but it's a necessity because season one is all very boy's own adventure, commando, a comic style. This is all a lot of fun by the necessity of what they're doing, but it touches on the darkness. There are there are situations where it's not all fun and games, where things get really dark, and season two goes a step further beyond that, things are getting darker, and people are struggling with that.
SPEAKER_00Season three goes even further beyond that. It's less of jolly hockey sticks, isn't this fun? Operating behind uh enemy lines to this is what warfare is like, this is what men are forced to do. So it is it's a journey, and yes, people preferred the first one because it was more fun, but that's necessity of the story that it's going to get darker and darker and darker. And season four, if it does happen, and I and I hope it does, season four will be going into things like Baberg and Belsen. So the SES were one of the first people to find one of those camps, and it's horrific.
SPEAKER_00And so these things by necessity, if you're going to tell that story, have got to get darker. And so, yeah, we'll see how people like three. I think three is is really good. I think it's really good. I think it I think it'll be better than two. Um, not that two was bad, but I think I think people will then start to connect the docs, the dots, and see where that story is going. Because it's about what war does to people. So, yeah, we'll see how it goes. Interesting.
SPEAKER_01What's the uh what's your favourite production to have worked on?
SPEAKER_00Roke Rose is is awesome. Is awesome because um depending on the production, like the the the most difficult productions are where you get brought on for one day midway through, and you can't really change anything. The ship is going at pace, and you can't do much to affect change. Um I've had some really fun jobs where I've been not been asked to be on set, but been asked to help write the script, so write the dialogue.
SPEAKER_00So we've got these army blokes doing this thing. What how would they talk? What would they say? And I've been given a chance to write things. But Rogue Heroes is all-encompassing. I'm involved from the very start. As soon as the scripts are produced by the writer, they get sent to uh the producers, the directors, and then me next. And we're pouring over the scripts and going over the details, and so from front to back, so it's being cut together at the moment. So at some point, I'll go into the studio and see the cuts and see what's been done with the story. And there's no other show that I get to do that be involved from the start to the end.
SPEAKER_00So I've got I've and I've got a bit more of a voice than I have on other productions. Um, and yeah, I think I think that is there's always little jobs that are really good fun. But my favourite job is that because the cast are brilliant, the crew are fantastic, and it's like being with family again. It's like another six months with family. So um, yeah, I think I think that's definitely my favorite one. But there is there's days when you have to kick yourself and think, I'm being paid to do this, I'm being paid to, you know, drive jeeps around the desert, or I'm being paid to fire guns in a London tower block, you know, whatever it might be.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's the variety, but yeah, there's there's I I really enjoy doing theatre as well. Theatre is a completely different beast. Oh, you've applies on theatre stuff, yeah. I didn't realise. What have you worked on there? Um so um recently we've been doing a few productions at the globe. Um, we've been doing Romeo and Juliet that was set in the 1800s in the US, which was set in a cowboy sort of western town. So it was all with cowboy guns. It was really good. I have to say, I've Roman Juliet is one of those productions that's uh done to death a little bit, and I've myself I've done two different versions of it.
SPEAKER_00I've done one set in the 1930s in fascist Italy, which was really good because it was a different take on things, but this one had another level of stuff, and it was done really well, and it was probably the best version of Roman and Juliet I've seen. Really good fun. Um, so there was that, and they were using cowboy revolvers, so it's all about you know how they would use those, and there's gunfights in that. Um then um Midsummer Night's Dream Again at the Globe, but again with a bit of a spin on it, and um there's a there's a gun in involved in that, which you wouldn't expect if you know the play.
SPEAKER_00Um, so there's things like that. Uh yeah, a lot of Shakespeare, bizarrely, a lot of like modern day adaptations of Shakespeare. Uh, Richard III is always a popular one for the army. There's lots of stuff involved in that.
SPEAKER_00Um, The Henry's, there's lots of stuff involved in that. Um, but it's it's different, it's fundamentally different because you are doing it live. Film and TV, you can stop, you can pause, you can set things up. Uh, you only have to get it to work once. Whereas theatre, you've got to get it to work every single time. It's got to be reliable, it has to be safe, it has to work for everybody, not just for one camera. You're working, and it's just a very different way of thinking. It's a very different way of of operating.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, theatre. I've become when I was my dad worked in um my dad worked my well, you know, my dad's side of the family in terms of TV and film and media and theatre and shit. Uh my dad worked in the in the Welsh National Opera backstage, it's a yeah, I think he ended up as a gaffer. Um, and so it's always kind of interested me, but I never really got into watching theatre or stage shows or even musicals until really over the last few years.
SPEAKER_01Um, and it never ceases to amaze me when a game is something starts. Normally I'm mainly shocked in the in a musical uh because of the choreography, yeah. And I think how I it I also just you know, stage shows like how the the ability to remember this stuff, this is such a long thing that they're doing. They can't pause and go, What was my line? Yeah, they have to remember it and do all the actions and have enthusiasm doing it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I when I say enthusiasm, I mean acting in the way you need to act. It's extreme, it takes a lot of energy, right? Day in, day out for multiple shows a day sometimes, obviously, multiple shows a week, day in, day out. Um, remember it all and nail it without skipping a beat. Well, very rarely making a mistake, or or making a mistake and the crowd not noticing. You're glossing straight over it, like improvising how you adapt. Amazing.
SPEAKER_00One of my favourite ones was doing one of the Romeo and Juliet's um, there was there's a scene where where Romeo and his friends go to the ball, uh, and that's where he first meets Juliet. And um he goes off to find her, and you have the famous speech on the balcony, um, Romeo, Romeo, where of four arc are Romeo, etc. etc. Uh, and his two mates are off chatting to one side, and they have an entire scene where they're talking backwards and forwards, drunk, about Romeo and what he's up to, the fact he's gone to met a girl, blah, blah, blah, blah.
SPEAKER_00It's just two blokes chatting. Um, this one version of Shakespeare that I worked on. Um, there was a woman who was playing one of the blokes' parts because Shakespeare is famous for women's parts being played by blokes. So this was an in version of that, and and she was like the lariest bloke you could possibly played like this proper, proper lad. Um in this scene, and this was only like a couple of weeks into the run, so they hadn't really got into this the throw of things.
SPEAKER_00The other bloke forgot to come on. It's a two-person scene, and the other bloke completely forgot to uh come on. Oh my god. So she was there on her own, so she decided to do the whole scene herself as though she's talking to herself pissed. And nobody knows the audience didn't notice. I was sat there watching in the audience next to the director, and we both and she was fantastic. She did both the lines word perfect, and it worked like a drunk person debating with themselves, brilliant, all improvised.
SPEAKER_00Um, so yeah, it's in and that's the thing you have with the thing that you don't have with film and TV is a live audience to react to. So you have each show is different, each show is different because you'll do something different, but the audience is different as well, and they make up a part of it. How they react to things changes the performance, and so it's unique. Every you'll never see that same player again. The next time it's done, it'll be subtly different, and so it there's an excitement with theatre that it could go wrong, and it's really, really interesting what happens when it does go wrong and how people react to it.
SPEAKER_00Some people react well to stress, some folk don't.
SPEAKER_01There's a um there's a comment in the in the in the live chat, and it says there's a very funny play called Goes Wrong. Yeah, yeah. Uh have you seen it? I have, I know some of the people.
SPEAKER_00So the play that goes wrong is is is a farce, and it is um it's like an Agatha Christie murder mystery style play. And it's being the conceit is it's being put on by an amateur dramatics uh company, and um everything that can go wrong does like the the scenery falls apart, people people are in the wrong place for the wrong cues, and it just descends into madness. It's really funny. It's like it's it's chaos, it's utter chaos, but it's controlled, and it's all these these stunts and the uh go and see it, it's so much fun.
SPEAKER_00Um, the the team that do it do a number of different shows. They started with the play goes wrong, they've they've they've got um the Peter Pan Goes Wrong, they've got Bank Robbery Goes Wrong, they've got all different plays, and they're all farces, they're all basically this amateur production company trying to put on these plays and it going badly. They've they've got a couple of shows on iPlayer as well, which is where they do um I think it's called the show that goes wrong on BBC iPlayer. Go and watch them because they're funny, they're about half an hour long, and they're these these these stage places.
SPEAKER_00The stuff they do is magnificent. Well, one of my favourite ones. Um, the conceit is they've got a really long boardroom set that they don't have space to build, so somebody's built it at 90 degrees. So it's so the so when you when you're watching it, they've it's and it's like people passing big people drinks and they're like throwing it and it's going down the table because obviously they turned the camera, and everyone's hair is out here. There's another one where the set is divided into two.
SPEAKER_00There's two parts to the set, the sets break and come back to get together, and what goes wrong is the wrong half of the set gets put together. So you've got a doctor's surgery on one side that's linked up with a flat on the opposite side, so nothing's in the right place. It's they're very, very smart because each one in the way that they go wrong is all very unique, it's really, really worth a watch. Really good time.
SPEAKER_01I saw like the most recent thing I've been to watch is um MJ the Musical. Have you been to see this? No, I'm not a musical fan. Neither am I bucks. Yeah, neither am I. But MJ the Musical, yeah. If someone had offered me, if I'd walk out of there and someone phoned me and said, Hugh, I've got a spare ticket for MJ the Musical tomorrow night, do you want it? I would have I I would have gone, yeah. Oh really? 100%. I would have gone back to watch it the next day. Oh, once you'd seen it. But why did you go to see it in the first place? Uh tickets through um work, basically.
SPEAKER_01Oh, right, yeah. Yeah, tickets through work, went and see it. And within the first 90 seconds, I was already going, holy shit, this is special. Yeah. Because there was it was the like the complexity of the choreography, the number of the dancers on stage, and all and everything else that goes into putting sort of on live production like that. Yeah, and it will last for about I think it lasts for about an hour and a half. There's a break in the middle, maybe a bit longer than that. The pace facts was just unreal.
SPEAKER_01How are they remembering this entire the dancers? This entire sequence. Yeah, no one is fucking it up. Yeah, you know, no one's tripping over, no one's getting each other's way, and it was actually really enjoyable.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, I'm a fan of Michael Jackson music, so live stuff is brilliant because it the it and it's it's having a bit of a resurgence, it was struggling a lot in the build-up to lockdown and with lockdown. But because film and TV is sort of struggling with streaming, streaming has meant that people can access it whenever they like. So somebody going to see a film in the cinema is becoming more of an event. You've got to persuade people to get off their butts to go and do it.
SPEAKER_00Whereas theatre, you cannot get the theatre experience at home. You've got to go out to see it. So theatre is having a bit of a resurgence at the moment. But I I I recommend to people, you know, go and find something that you think you might like and go and watch it.
SPEAKER_01I I think if yeah, I think but I think if you've not been very radical, go see anything. It really doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_00Go see the play that goes wrong. If you like comedy, if you like fast, go see things like that. Because there are some amazing plays.
SPEAKER_01Do you remember uh Grant Kilburn or if he didn't give it your play? Did you mean Grant? I did, yeah. He's he did 222 a ghost story. Well, he did it. At that time he was um understudy for lead. Uh but now he's on it again now as the lead.
SPEAKER_00Is he picking a big role? Yeah, yeah. Which which one is he playing? Because there's two there's this for the people that haven't seen it, really good play. Two male parts, two female parts. Um you're asking me now. Grant. There's the there's the husband and wife. It's all set in one London flat, one sort of house. Really good play. Really good play.
SPEAKER_01Uh Ben.
SPEAKER_00Explain Ben, whoever Ben is. I can't remember if I think Ben's the friend. I can't remember. But it's really good play. Really good play. Four four hander, these four people in a flat. It's really good. Yeah, it's really good for our glad.
SPEAKER_01He's a mega guy.
SPEAKER_00He's a mega guy.
SPEAKER_01Uh what does he think? Okay, what do you think of so another question to Chan? Yeah. What do you think of what do you think of theatre ticket costs? Ooh, yeah. They can exclude younger, poorer audiences. Anything else? Entirely agree.
SPEAKER_00One of one of the things, yeah, so theatre tickets can be incredibly expensive, especially for big shows like sort of the the Hamilton style stuff, that is, you know, you're talking hundred plus ticket. Hamilton. Yeah. Hamilton is about the it's a musical based on the ascendancy of um Alexander Hamilton, who was one of the not founding fathers, but one of the group of people that um fought for American independence and set up the banking system and everything like that.
SPEAKER_00Fascinating figure, but a really interesting way to learn a bit about US US um history post-um war of independence, which a lot of Brits we don't really care about because it's it's you know, when those lot you know cut away and ran. But it's it is it's quite an accessible way to get into it. It's quite a dry subject, but the this is like rap and dance, it's really quite cool. Um, you can watch it online. I think it's on Disney Plus. Okay. And the guy that choreographed it's called Lin Manuel Miranda, who does a lot of the songs for Disney now.
SPEAKER_00So a lot of things like Lin Manuel Miranda. Does it sound like For who? For Disney. Lots of the Disney films now. He does lots of songs for them. So yeah. You will have heard his stuff even if you don't. Ticket costs on the cost. Yeah, 50 ticket costs. Can be very expensive, but normally for those big West End shows that are very popular, which are tourist attractions. So um Hamilton, um, you know, all the all the big ones, the ones that you will have heard of. But there are so many other plays that are happening in smaller theatres that are much more accessible.
SPEAKER_00They're also and often often much more intimate.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know.
SPEAKER_00Much more. I mean, I'm I'm not a fan of a big theatre. I really like something small intimate. And you can so there's there's a the there's a theatre called the Nonmar Warehouse, which is called the Warehouse, but it's actually quite small. And it's it's um uh a very unusual theatre, but some theatres have got standing seats. You stand at the back and you get them for 10 quid. You can go and watch a play for 10 quid. So, yes, I do think a lot of tickets are very expensive, and the problem is that it's not the performers, it's not the creative people who are performing that get that money.
SPEAKER_00That money is all going on rent, it's all going to the very expensive people that produce the show. So, you know, it's it's never getting to the people who are on stage. So, the for instance, Jess doing stage work, the amount that she gets paid for two hours of voice work is the same as she gets paid for a week in theatre. That's the sort of level of the disparity in the pay there. Theatre is very low paid. Um, but you can definitely get good price tickets to go and see stuff.
SPEAKER_00One of the ways you can do it is go up to the boxer office about half an hour before the show starts, and what they'll normally have is returns. So people that can't attend the show have sent the tickets back in and they'll sell them off at a song. I went to see uh The Book of Mormon, which is a brilliant show. That's good, yeah. I again is one of those big shows that would normally cost you another 100 quid a ticket. We got like third row seats for 25 quid because we went into the box office just before it began and go, Do you have some seats?
SPEAKER_00So if if you're willing to take a risk, you can actually get some really good seats. There are um tickets for troops and that sometimes have discounted seats as well. Um, there are ways to get cheaper seats. Um, a lot of theatres will now do um very they'll do a certain number of accessible seats, so at a very low price, that get given out to people who who don't go to the theatre much or can't afford it. But yeah, I do agree that some of them are extortionate, but it is so the Michael Jackson one, for instance, if you go and look how much that is, I bet you that's sort of I think it was maybe 75 quid.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, 75 quid plus, which is a lot. Um I got a reduced rate, yes, I'm sure you did.
SPEAKER_01I am paying 70 quid for theatre tickets, sorry.
SPEAKER_00But there are there are ways of means I'm very fortunate because I work in theatre, I often get what's called comps. So um uh there was there was a theatre. Comp starling comps. Comps. So I I get free tickets to go and see shows that I've worked on. Um and you're normally going to see see them during the dress rehearsals or during the matinees or during you know quiet days where they've got spare seats. But yeah, the there are ways to get them, but yeah, I do understand, and I think I think I think the modelling of how theatres make their money needs to be looked at because not the money's not going to the performers, it's being hoovered up by people at the top or paid on rent and things because these massive London places have to pay taxes as well.
SPEAKER_01Well, it wants to stop. Uh yeah, I mean like but that's why I can see why the the costs would be expensive, right? Or the low pay there, because you you the amount of money you generate is limited on how many people how many bums on seats. Yeah, exactly. Unlike a film that you can sell and sell and sell and sell. Has anyone tried selling the like a stream or a video production of a live play?
SPEAKER_00Yes. So there are there's something it doesn't work. No, no, it does to an extent. There's something called called MT Live. So the National Theatre will often either stream some of their shows live or they have a streaming service where you can watch them. Similarly to watching Hamilton on Disney Plus, you can go and sit down and watch a recording of a show. So Hamilton on Disney Plus is a recording of the show. It is, yes.
SPEAKER_02Oh why don't they all do that?
SPEAKER_00Because um the big shows want to get people bums on seats, whereas um selling it to streaming, they'll never get as much as they get with bums on seats. So um they'll often do it for plays that have been and gone. So um uh one of the plays I worked on called Good, which is an exceptional play with David Tennant. Again, it's a three-hander, it's all about the Holocaust. Um, or rather, it's all about the three-hander, a three-hander, and then there are three actors in it playing all the parts. So David Tennant plays one part throughout, and then there is a uh a male performer and a female performer, both of them are excellent.
SPEAKER_01And everyone anyone else in the play is basically extras.
SPEAKER_00No, they these people play all the uh other parts. Okay, so there's only three people in the play until the very end, which I will not spoil, but it um it is you know, it it doesn't involve any, it's not a huge cast. Um Good is on BBC iPlayer, and I'm I'm not sure how or why it is, but it's on B BBC iPlayer. I urge you to go and watch that because that's a brilliant play. Um yeah, it's it's again, it's that same thing with cinema.
SPEAKER_00It's how are they making their money? Are they making more money through people um coming and sitting and watching it live, or are they making more money by selling it to a streaming site? And chances are if you're selling it to a streaming site, you're you're gonna do it at a lower cost, you're gonna make less, but more people will see it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but I'm I'm just thinking. It's a more guaranteed. The additional exposure you get in doing that will generate more bums on seats and more value for the bum for the seats.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it could do it could do, but this plays don't tend to run for that long, plays will tend to run for a few months, maybe even six weeks. But um big plays like you see on the West End, like the Michael Jackson play, may run for years and years and years. So Book of Mormon's been going 10 plus years. I don't know. Lame is went for 20 years. There's a play called the The Mousetrap that's been running continually for 60 plus years, you know. There's there's and people go and see that all the time.
SPEAKER_00Um yeah, I I'm always fascinated by the funding model and how these things work and who gets what chunk of the pie. Because um part of the problem with streaming is that the money is kept at the executive level, and not a lot of the creative people get the cash, which is another conversation for another time because that's a big one. That's a big one. We can go into it if you like, depending on how much time you've got.
SPEAKER_00So um before streaming, the creative, so the people that write it, the people that that act and perform in things, would get something called resit residuals. So residuals were take something like Friends, for instance. Every time Friends was repeated on channel four, the people that wrote it, the actors, the directors, depending on what kind of deal they had, what kind of contract they had, would get a residual a payment. And it was never, it didn't have to be much, but it was enough to keep them afloat.
SPEAKER_00Because actors don't act all the time and they won't have gaps, but all the residuals be enough to sort of pay them like drip feed cash into their bank account. Um and the BBC still does it, but a lot of it was based on viewing numbers. So they'd say, right, if we got this number of people watching it, you'd get paid this much. If we had more than that, you'd get paid that much, and it would be a tiered payment, depending on how many people watched it. And the figures, the viewing figures were collated, and they were they were very easy to say, right, this is how many people, or the number of households that watched it.
SPEAKER_00With the advent of streaming, a couple of things happened. The main one was companies like Netflix were extremely reluctant to give out the data of how many people were watching their things. They still don't do it nowadays. They still don't do it. The reason why they don't do it is because it affects their share price. If you say, if it's like if if it was known publicly that a show uh that the you know they paid millions for only you know a couple of hundred people watched, then it would negatively affect their share price quite quickly.
SPEAKER_00So and also because it isn't it isn't like like how do you how do you how do you pay somebody based on if so do you if somebody's watched the whole thing, if somebody started watching something, you know, where do you where do you say right that is one watch things, yeah. It makes it much more complex. Anyway, at the start of this, actors' contracts uh there's a big thing in the US called SAGAFRA.
SPEAKER_00Uh Sagafra contracts are renegotiated every sort of I think it's every five or six six years. So they happened back in 2024, but before that was 2018 when streaming didn't exist really, it had just started, so Netflix was the only thing on the block. So there was no negotiation for streaming rights within those uh contracts. Now streaming is the dominant thing, and so streaming got away with not paying residuals for a long time, but everybody everybody got to the point where they were like, We're not happy with this, we are now unable to keep going with our jobs because we're not getting any residual payments because everything we do ends up on street streaming.
SPEAKER_00One of the first big court cases was Scarlet Johansson and the Black Widow movie, the first one that came out in 2020 just as lockdown was starting to hit. Um her a lot of her payment was tied up on what we call the back end. So, depending on how many bums on seats that film gets, she'll get a percentage of that. Um Disney decided to release it straight onto streaming, which of course reduced the number of people that got the bums on seats.
SPEAKER_00And her deal had nothing to do with streaming in there because streaming deals didn't exist yet. So she sued them because it it massively negatively affected how much cash she got for that film. And she said, Look, I don't need the money, I'm not doing this for that, I'm doing this because if I don't, nobody else will, and this needs to be for the people coming up, this needs to be stopped now. So how performers and actors and creatives get paid is a real problem because at the moment, what tends to happen is the money is being kept at studio level.
SPEAKER_00The studios are now being run by business people, and they always have been to to an extent, but the money is now held at a much higher level. If you look at at any film on Netflix and look at the number of executives that are listed, they're all getting some money off the back end of it, which reduces how much everybody else is being paid. So it's um it's a tricky industry because of that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it's been changing so fast, yeah, so fast.
SPEAKER_00And AI will change it more.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And and the only people that can keep up without changing a capitalise in the big roundhouse changing are the people at the top who are they've become film studios have turned into tech companies because that's essentially what they are, they're providing the tech platform that allows you to watch them.
SPEAKER_00Um yeah, it's it's um uh the industry in the short time I've been in, I've been in it for 10 years now. It's all manner of changes, and I think we're gonna see some more in the next five years as well.
SPEAKER_01I was talking to the previous guest, Freddie, about um about what he thought about where basically how how the the length of films will be or is being impacted by streaming uh and people's attention spans. And I mentioned to him um about did you see the thing about Matt Damon saying that you know, why is that right and not being reminded to people because people are not paying attention viewing at home on their phones?
SPEAKER_01It's absolutely true. I do the same thing as well. I get totally distracted, and it it it it it's very rare for me to get myself to sit there and pay all my attention to one thing if I'm on my own for a couple of hours. Yeah if I'm with someone watching something. It's easier because they go away you do it. Well, yeah, but also I don't want to have it out because I don't want to get told that. Exactly. Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00And I feel like a dick because I'm not spending quality time. So Netflix developed something a couple of years ago called second street uh second screening. So second screening was was um a strategy that meant that none of their shows could be that complicated because what they were seeing was people were looking down at their phones, scrolling, scrolling, scrolling, looking back and being lost. So they said, right, we need shows to be simpler, we need people that so they started designing TV shows, Netflix, second screening. Netflix started it, but I I expect other people were doing it as well.
SPEAKER_00But basically dumbing down shows so that people couldn't would watch them but not get lost if they were looking at their phone, which is another reason why theatre is brilliant, is because you are immersed, you are in that world, phones off for two hours, you sit there and you watch. And another reason why people go don't go and see films is they don't want to be cut off for two hours. I can't think of anything I would like more than being switched off from my phone for some time. It's great. Um, but yeah, so this this this was their tactic. I don't know if it still is, but things, things like what Matt Damon was saying, reiterate that is that they don't want things to be super complicated.
SPEAKER_00Or they have a certainly they have a the majority of their stuff, they have a tier where they want it to be easy watching, they don't want it to be challenging. They this is why you have recaps at the start of things now. Like this is what happened last episode, which you have just watched. We know you've just watched it because we just binged it, but you probably weren't paying attention, and there's an important plot point that you'll need to know for this one, otherwise you will be lost. I hate them because the minute you start watching an episode, you know that whatever they show you is going to be important for the one you're about to watch.
SPEAKER_00So I always skip them or put my fingers in my ears and la la la my way until it actually starts because otherwise it's like hint hint, pay attention.
SPEAKER_01One of the toughest films I've tried to get a grip on uh and understand was tennis. Oh fuck, I knew you're right. So I understand now why you can't get a grip on it, right? And I watched it, I've seen this film three times. First time I was in the cinema drunk, the second time I was at home half drunk. Yeah. The third time, I was like, right, right. I like stop drinking that right, focus, watch it. And I was like, what the fuck?
SPEAKER_01And I'm the film's entertaining. Yeah, I understand the plot, yeah. But where it breaks me is I'm trying I'm literally trying to understand it scientifically. Yeah. I'm trying to I'm trying to go right. I how does this work with the time and spit?
SPEAKER_00I need to watch it again because I because I went to see it with Jess during lockdown, uh, because it was one of the few films that was released during lockdown. I went to see it with Jess. We'd had a few drinks, so I wasn't pissed, but I was I was I was lubricated, let's say. Uh Jess walked out of it about a quarter of the way through because she's like, I can't understand a word they're saying. I can't as and she got she got really angry. And when I met up with her afterwards, she went on a 20-minute rant about.
SPEAKER_01I think my problem is, I think the problem uh the problem is you can't, it's not possible to logically make the science work of the film.
SPEAKER_00I don't know, I kind of agree with you. I think there's there's there's a couple of different ways to watch it. Way number one is just let it wash over you. Don't try and stop and think and work it out. And any other science fiction film, you really want to do that. You want to understand how the world works, especially with time, anything like Looper, any anything like Back to the Future, you were sort of working out, oh, that's how it works. If he does that, that happens. Whereas whereas this one, you you everything was going at such a pace and with so little explanation that you literally couldn't.
SPEAKER_00So your options were let it wash over you and just take it at face for value and enjoy it, or pause it and go, right, fetch me a whiteboard. I need to draw this through. But yeah, I I watched it and I uh was trying to follow it, and I got to the halfway point and thought, I'm just gonna have to watch this. I can't work it out as I go because I'm missing things. The dialogue was so hard to understand, and I and apparently that was intentional, but it was so difficult to understand.
SPEAKER_00I need to watch it again, but there are certain bits that I think there it was, it was one of those things that visually was very cool. There was a bit where he's fighting himself as he's going forward, and he fights himself going backwards, and I was trying to work out how that would possibly work, and it just it just makes your brain hurt, and I it wasn't an enjoyable experience until I just went let go, just watch it, and then it was quite fun and cool. But I like things to make sense, and so it it it it did annoy me, it confused me.
SPEAKER_00I need to see it again, I need to see it and be able to pause it.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, it's yeah, I think I'd miss so much effort trying to understand it because I enjoyed the film, yeah, and I love Kenneth Brenner and like I like Robert Patterson, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's I again I'd never seen him in anything really up until that point. Um Twilight, I accidentally watched about six seconds of Twilight. No, no, no. I was I was going through the channel. Yeah, yeah. I was acting I was flicking through the channels and um accidentally caught like literally six seconds, and it's the bit where he walks out into the sunlight and goes, This is why we don't go out into the sunlight. Now, me being a fan of all films and and books, know that vampires don't go out into sunlight because they burst into flames.
SPEAKER_00No, they sparkle in that world. They sparkle. That's why they don't go out into the spark off bump. And that was literally it, that was the sixth second bit I caught. So I and and the Harry Potter film as well. I didn't have any interest in him at all as an actor. Then when I saw Tenet, I was like, oh, actually, he's really good. And then I saw him in The Lighthouse as well. Oh a film. Yeah, what a film. Willing DeFoe, one of my favourite actors. Yeah, yeah. Great film.
SPEAKER_01Um, yeah, go on.
SPEAKER_00And then he was really good in um The Batman. I thought he one of the things that you never get from Batman is how is he functioning as a human being? Because he's up all night, and that one he wasn't. You could show, you could see in the way his performance was that bloke was on was on the edge the entire time. He was I need to watch it again once, and I wasn't really paying attention.
SPEAKER_01I remember it being different.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's he's unable to function during the day because he's up at night, and that's what you don't really get from the other films. So, yeah, yeah. The ending I didn't like so much, but but but I thought his performance was brilliant.
SPEAKER_01I've been so a couple of months back, for some reason, I was after I was after watching something, watching something like a bit melancholy, and I went to revisit a couple of films I'd watched before and kind of half remembered and think, Oh, yeah, that's the kind of film I'm after, and got it catastrophically wrong twice. And and once oh, I tell you another story actually in a minute about another story, let me write this down. Let me write this down for one second. So the first one I revisited um was um a Robert Patterson movie called High Life.
SPEAKER_01You ever heard of it? No, no, not many people have. It's a sci-fi movie. Uh Robert, it's Robert Patterson on a on a spaceship, an experiment, a spaceship doing experiments on humans, right? Yeah, they're all convex, they're all like bad people on there. And they're going into space on a long journey mission. They got there's no hope of coming back, kind of thing.
SPEAKER_00It's extremely dark. I I have heard of it. I can remember the visual watch.
SPEAKER_01I can remember seeing pictures of it. When I first watched that, I watched it in uh as a as a as a a bunch of other sci-fi movies that have been recommended to me as like uh not really well known. Uh alongside the platform, I watched the platform. You've seen that great film. Okay, yeah. So High Life is an intro, like it's a good film, but it's dark, like real dark. It's sort of you know questions morality and the and the stuff that's been done. And I love sci-fi movies. Yeah. On the subject of which um coming out soon is Project Hail Mary.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Have you read the book? No, I think I've recently finished the book. Have you? Superb.
SPEAKER_00Now I I know a lot of people who had read the book were really uh miffed at the trailer because the trailer gives away something that happens quite. Really? I don't know. I'm not gonna say it just in case. But yeah, um in Ron Gosling is one of those actors I will watch doing absolutely anything. He's really good. He really fun. I wouldn't let him do actually anything.
SPEAKER_01God damn it. Drive is one of my favourite films. I love Drive. So good. Drive end of Drive. Anyway, do you mention a second film on the seller story I'm gonna tell you? So that was run. I started watching High Life again and I thought, oh god, this is no, this is too dark. Not what I was after. This is like I wanted Melancholy, not yeah. Okay. Then I went to another of my favourite actors to rewatch one of his films, Casey Affleck. Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_00And I put on Manchester by the Sea. Oh god. Have you seen it?
SPEAKER_01Oh my god.
SPEAKER_00You were really in a dark mood, weren't you?
SPEAKER_01Oh my god. Brilliant film, absolute torture all the way through. I don't mean someone getting tortured. I mean it is oh it is so depressing. Yeah. It's it's not dark. It's depending on I know what you mean. Sometimes you're in that mood. Sometimes you really want to be Oh man. You want to watch this all the way through because it's so good. And you go, oh my god.
SPEAKER_00Can I give you a recommendation for a film? Um, The Ballad of Wallace Island. Okay. The Ballad of Wallace Island. It's a British film, independent film. Um written by two guys, Tom Basden and Tim Key. If you've heard anything they've done, it is one of the it's like it's a British independent film. Okay, and it's just so so so good.
SPEAKER_01Wallace Island. Okay, well, yeah. So my little anecdotes, you mentioned Drive, right? Yeah, yeah. Now my missus not someone who's sit down and spend a lot of time watching films, and I do like doing that, and so and she does enjoy it, she's just not somebody she'd do often. So I've been trying to introduce her to you know my extensive film knowledge. Sometimes I miss sell things. She is someone who she likes happy, romantic, yeah, not like violent, gritty stuff.
SPEAKER_01Gritty stuff. So how did how did you sell drive to her? Is this where we're going with this? A rom, a romantic film, like a ro it's a romance, love story. I mean I literally said love story. I mean an element of it kind of is. But you asked her, it is a they don't even kiss. The relationship.
SPEAKER_00They don't even kiss bags. But the relationship between them is beautiful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but also it's extremely violent.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, one of one of my favourite scenes in that is when they're in the lift. The love story story. Yeah, when they're in the lift and and he it's done in slow-mo and he moves towards her and he slides his hand on her waist and then it goes violent. Yeah. Oh, hang on. What's she talking about? They do kiss. They do kiss. They do kiss, yeah. And then the violence happens, yeah. And then he just becomes like absolutely yeah. Ultraviolet takes that guy out of town. And it but it's that it's that switch from one to the other, and it's just it's such it's that sort of as he moves her out of the way, it's that sort of protection and then off goes for him.
SPEAKER_00Okay, the second one.
SPEAKER_01The hammer. The hammer hammer, yeah. The hammer. The second one, mate. Which I sold, and in my defense, and so drive, I deliberately misled her. Yeah, right. Yeah, yeah. Because I love that film. Yeah. This one, I misremembered it. I hadn't seen it for a long time. And I sold it as an uplifting film. Yeah. And this is Shawshank Redemption.
SPEAKER_00Right. Now, I I know what you mean because the ending is very Hollywood, very uplifting. But bags, the only uplifting bit of that entire film is the last 10 seconds.
SPEAKER_01The last 60 10 seconds.
SPEAKER_00And I I think I think that's the worst bit of the film. I think the film should have stopped with him on the bus. Morgwood Freeman being on the bus. Maybe. Because then it's like, what's gonna happen? You don't know. And and yeah, I think I think that ruins it.
SPEAKER_01And I'm sat there with her watching this film. And within the first minute, I think it's within the first minute, there is the violent death of a man at the hands of a of a prison guard who beats this helpless, fat, like frightened guy to death on a screen. Yeah, right. Then she's once after that, there is a gang rip. Yeah. And that repeats throughout the film.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. You've got the better, it doesn't get any better. That's the set of the film. But when that started, I was like, oh god, it's the dumbest thing. But it's a film, it's a film about hope. Oh my god, mate. Yeah, but then you've got people hanging themselves. Yeah, yeah. You've got the prison warden laying, you've got extort in the prisons. Yeah, you've got um, you've got uh what else have you got? The guy being shot. The what? The guy being shot. The guy being shot?
SPEAKER_00When there's when there's hope and that hope hits.
SPEAKER_01The guy being shot, yeah. It is it is oh god, it goes horrific all the way through. Horrified through.
SPEAKER_00But it's got it's got those, it's got those glimmers that there are those moments that are glimmers of hope.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but then immediately after the hit dash exactly what was going on.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, what is it? Great film, yeah. Great film. Originally when it came out was um was not a success. It was only a success later on on tape and DVD, yeah. But when it came out was not a financial success. No. And um I think it was based on a short story by Stephen King. I think it was, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Didn't know that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I didn't know that. What's happening in Bags World anyway? What is going on in Bags World? We've spoken about Jess World, we've spoken about TV and film world. Well, what's happening in Bagsworld?
SPEAKER_00So for the past sorry, for the past um 18 months or so, I've been in between the film work because film what film work goes from you know periods where you're absolutely maxed out to periods when you're doing nothing. I've been doing a little bit of work in the defence sector, which has been you don't have to do this big reveal if you don't want to. Well, no, I've I have I have started a um a new job, uh, which I wasn't intending I didn't seek out.
SPEAKER_00I wasn't intending on starting a new career, but I was offered a prison guard. But no, I was offered I was offered I was offered a job, I was offered two jobs actually, and I had a very difficult choice about which which one if if on either of them to take. But I have accepted a job with uh with uh a British engineering firm um called DCE who make uh UGVs, uh for those of people who've never heard the term UGV before, it's uh uncrewed ground vehicles.
SPEAKER_00So if you imagine drones for the land, um so these things are basically baby tanks, uh, and they are incredibly mobile, uh, they can carry a lot of weight, you can put whatever you like on the top of them, you can control them remotely, and they are brilliant. And the military, I think, at the moment is in a very similar to position to where it was in the 1930s, the fact that technologically it has sort of fallen behind, and other reasons as well why it might be why we might be in a 1930s situation, right?
SPEAKER_00Technologically, between World War I and World War II, the British, despite inventing tanks in the first place, sort of kind of fell behind with tank warfare. And so when World War II started, the British tanks were not very good. Um, they were designed for a different kind of warfare. And uh I think we're in a similar situation at the moment with uh drones and UGVs, in the fact that not a lot of money in the UK has been spent on developing a UK solution.
SPEAKER_00So over the last 20 years, the British forces have gotten smaller, less well funded, and so we've had to rely on getting our technological solutions from other nations. And if anything, the last uh year or two have shown that the traditional um traditional uh what would you call it? Sort of power sharing and technol technology sharing and information sharing that has happened throughout the West can no longer be relied on as it has been.
SPEAKER_00And if the UK doesn't speed up its homegrown tech, it might fall behind. So that's you know, the last last sort of 18 months have shown me that we've been sort of sat back crossing our fingers that things are gonna get better, and and really they haven't. So it's sort of I think it's about time. And people are realising this that we need to spend a bit more on defence, potentially. If we're gonna compete at the level that we've tried to over the last sixty years, um, we need to spend a bit more, otherwise we're gonna get left behind, or at least spend better, perhaps.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. What do you think?
SPEAKER_01Uh I agree that we should be less reliant on the relationships and allegiances and power sharing, information sharing, technology sharing that we've had for the last uh the benefit of for the last since the second world war. They've become less reliable, certainly. It's become less reliable, but but our reliance on it has not become less. You know, I because we don't have another option yet. Um yeah, but we've we've made that bed for ourselves, right?
SPEAKER_01By not investing inward on it, you know, and uh and also the the the as obvious obvious it should be obvious to everyone given the just the news every day that lasts what or nearly ten years now. Geopolitical uh stability and it is is probably the lowest level. It's been since the mid 70s, maybe.
SPEAKER_0170s maybe not being as old as you, Hugh. No, in fact, we work this out.
SPEAKER_00You you and I were. I'm born in the 80s, mate. Yeah. When when were you born in 1980? Well, let's just say the eighties. 81. 81. 84, yeah. So I I you're 84. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, I forgot about that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So um I I think you're right. I mean, but it's all it's difficult because we live in an area, sorry, because we live in an era now where we get so much more information that we than we ever have done before, there is a tendency to think that things are much worse than they ever have been. But that's because we're more aware of things. But I think you're right. I think I think we are in a very unstable position at the moment, simply because it after after World War II, the two power blocks that came about was NATO in the West and Russia and the the um a communist sector.
SPEAKER_00And that was what the Cold War was was all about. It was those two sides that were too big to ever go to war fronting off against each other. Before World War II, the world was a lot more fractured and broken down into a lot smaller pockets. Um that sort of changed in the lead up to World War I and post-World War I as well.
SPEAKER_01I don't think that's necessarily true. Well, it what were the US doing in the 1930s? Oh, but the US is the US. When you look at the when you look at Europe and this side of the pond, you had the British Empire and the Ottoman Empire. Yeah, it wasn't as it was just a different set of bigger.
SPEAKER_00There were a lot of small, there was the Austro-Hungarian Empire, there was lots of little empires, there were lots of little groups of people teaming up because of common interests at the time, but those were constantly changing, constantly evolving one in, one out. But I think we've in in a similar way that our political system has always really been a two and a half party kind of system, but really a two-party system. What we're now seeing is that fracturing into lots of smaller parties, and we're seeing that globally.
SPEAKER_00So we're seeing two big blocks, which was NATO and Russia, now starting to collapse. And I think what you're gonna have coming out of it, and you know, smarter people have said a lot more on this, but I think you're gonna end up with at least four blocks. You you're gonna end up with America being north and south as one block. Um, you're gonna come out with Europe, you're gonna come out with Russia, and you're gonna come out with China. That's basically the four main blocks. There will be other blocks as well, and Australia will probably lump in with with Europe, because that's ideologically where they are aligned.
SPEAKER_00So it'll be NATO without the states, and maybe a couple other countries will break off as well. But you're gonna have it's not gonna be a two-party game, it's gonna be smaller groups. That's that's where I see it going. But going back to what we were saying before, it means we can no longer rely on those previous partnerships as we have done. We've got to be a lot more resilient at home, and so hopefully we do that before it's too late.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, you said something uh earlier on, which was uh just a few moments ago, which was yeah, more information being presented, so it it kind of things may look worse than what they are. Yeah, but but maybe, but but you could also say that it gives you the ability to make a much better judgment of what is really going on. Yeah. You know, um I was talking to someone earlier uh and just probably about two weeks ago, for about two weeks, I I was like in a bad place I was in like genuinely a bad place in terms of how secure I felt the world to be and thinking about my children's future, yeah.
SPEAKER_01My future as well, but my children's in particular, right? Uh because it seems so unstable at the minute, yeah, and things seem so disconnected and and and all but also I I I do believe so when we look at America and the way America behaving at the minute, which isn't great for most other countries, like really, if we're generalizing, right? But it is one of the things it is, is in um it is with America's interests in mind.
SPEAKER_01Not the only thing, you know, Trump is Trump, and people are people, and they have their own interests as well, right? But but I do believe that most countries at the minute should be putting themselves first above these bigger allegiances that don't seem to have been working very well. The EU, for example, I I don't think that works very well, and that is and that is being evidenced by its its gradual decline in its stability over the last 20 years. I think, this is what I think.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and I think we you know Britain should we should put our ourselves first above all else, like I think Germany should, like I think America should, like I think everyone should, within reason, all right, within reason. Um, but the conflict is that that also leads to conflict, that also leads to instability. But and which way is the best way to go about it? But I literally had, and it was after a couple of conversations with my youngest about different things, politics and stuff like that, and which she's starting to think about and talk about. Uh, and I realized that I think the second half of our lives, like the age we are, uh oh you're younger, you're younger, yeah, you're younger.
SPEAKER_01Um we're in, I think the next 30 or 40 years, bags, is gonna is gonna be worse than anything that's happened since the second world war. I I genuinely do in the Western world. I genuinely do. You know, uh I know some people who who are close to me and and are perhaps better informed than me who fully expect to be in a trench within the next five years. Fully expect it to be in the trench within the next five years. That is extreme end, yeah. Right? I expect us to be at war next 10-15.
SPEAKER_01When I say us, I mean Britain. Uh, I generally do, whether that's internal or that's fighting externally, I don't know. I just know there is fucking crazy times coming.
SPEAKER_00I think we're very lucky in the fact that we are an island. And I was thinking about this. It sort of struck me about a year ago. Britain's always been an island, its borders haven't changed because they can't change. They are they are by necessity, they are the borders of the art the uh the island that we're in. The only thing we have done is join England, Ireland, Scotland, and Wales together successfully, in some uh cases less so in uh others. But that's we've when we've been invaded, we've been taken over.
SPEAKER_00Nobody's been taking chunks out of our border. Nobody's been trying to push into a region and take that. Nobody's been cutting off East Anglia from you know the rest of the UK. So we we've got like a little fortress, like a little island that is incredibly difficult to get to.
SPEAKER_01Not as difficult as it used to be.
SPEAKER_00No, not as difficult as it's just. Especially when you're talking about unmanned vehicles. Yeah, yeah. But it's still, in order to do it, you've got to take it all. You can't just take a chunk of it, like a border that moves, like the Donbass or or anything like that. And we're in a position where we're not really in Europe, we're sort of slightly outside of it. So we're in a very lucky position where we can we can do what we like and we can isolate ourselves. Not saying that's the best way to go, but we could do that if that's what was required.
SPEAKER_00And the rest of the world can sort of sort of uh sort of hack it out. And um interesting, I was watching 28 years later uh last week. I've never seen it. I've seen 28 Days Later, I've never seen the 28 Days Later is brilliant, groundbreaking at the time, but it's it unlike most really good horror, groundbreaking, but then it sort of pales into insignificance because most other things have copied and done what it's done again and again and again. So the original seems weak, if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_00So Psycho, if you go back and watch Psycho, Psycho was a groundbreaking film, groundbreaking film, mostly because um before then, I think we've talked about this before. Psycho? Psycho's 50s, I think. Yeah, before we've spoken about this before. Before Psycho, people would just turn up and sit down in the dinner and watch a film from the midway point and would wait for it to come back round again. Psycho was the first film where where Alfred Hitchcock went, no, it's gonna have a start time. And if you're not there at the start time, you're not gonna get in.
SPEAKER_00You've got to watch the whole film. Oh, I didn't know that. But if you watch Psycho now, there's some bits that are a bit laughable because every horror film you've seen since has copied, aped it, improved on it, based itself up on it. So 28 Days Later was the first zombie film that had running zombies. Everything before that zombies was sh slow and shambling. So 28 Days Later was very different, but now lots of zombie films are like that. Um 28 years, sorry, 28 weeks later, which was the sequel that came out a couple of years after, has an amazing opening sequence that is genuinely terrifying.
SPEAKER_00And like I watched just that start sequence a couple of nights ago, and it put me on edge straight away. I'll have to watch it so good. I'll have to watch it. That first bit is brilliant. The rest of it goes into sort of generic sort of action film. Um 28 years later, there's two films, 28 years later, and then there's 28 years later, the Bone Temple. 28 years later, I've seen, and is much more like 28 Days Later to begin with, and then it goes off and does things, but it's much more like that to begin with, and then Bone Temple I've not seen, but apparently that's really good.
SPEAKER_00Um, but again, what it reminded me of is is that in in those films, the UK gets a cut off from the rest of the world, it gets isolated and left alone, and there are pros and cons to that. I think everything goes in a pendulum, and we've had globalization over the last you know 200 years where the world has gotten smaller due to sort of things like planes and everything else like that. It's been easier to get to places, and therefore the world has gotten smaller, and these bigger conglomerations have appeared.
SPEAKER_00And now I think we're gonna go the other way. The pendulum is gonna swing against that, and we're gonna the world's gonna get larger again, so it's gonna be more difficult to go around around the world, I think. There we go.
SPEAKER_01Um we're seeing it change over. Uh are you and he says he says, Are you and Ben going to be part of the UK military fighting you reservists raised to 65 by Al Cairns? Well, it's opt-in for us because we're already out. We can opt into that.
SPEAKER_00So a couple of interesting things on this. I have seriously considered rejoining the reserves. Um, because when I left the regular army, I transferred to the reserves. Um did it for a bit. Um but um I I've had that same sort of feeling that I need to be doing my bit. Same thing that made me join up in the first place. Um what I would be doing as a As an an older, fatter man, I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Um, but fully prepared to sort of you keep it look it. I know luckily I gave you the option there. I gave you the option there to save yourself. No, I wish I did. Um, I just don't. I I hate fizz, always have. That's why I'm a tanky. I like to be driven everywhere. Oh my god. Um, no, I I I I would seriously consider rejoining. Um, but also um the thing I'm now doing with UGVs is sort of ticking that box for me as well.
SPEAKER_00It's it's making sure that I'm doing my part. Um I don't know what what uh a British army looks like in the next 10 years. If we do get involved in a wide-scale conflict, I think at the moment we're completely unprepared for it. We've given away a lot of our kit. We are in between a lot of pro programs where we've given up or mothballed a bit of kit and we don't have the next thing yet. Things like Ajax versus C VRT, Challenger 2, you know, we don't have enough of those.
SPEAKER_00We've given some away. Challenger 3 is not ready yet. Guns, we've given away all of our guns, all the AS90s are gone, and we've got a couple of um a couple of archers, which I know are a stop gun. The technical term gun being big gun. Yeah. Um even the SA80, the SA80 is is reaching the end of its lifespan. They're chosen the replacement of them.
SPEAKER_00Not yet, no. Project Greyburn is the replacement for it. They haven't picked it yet. It's likely going to be an M4 style platform, but then um the options they're looking at are built in the States or in Germany. It's like do again go back to the resilience aspect of it. Do we want to be reliant on another nation for our arms? The Enfield factory, you know, close to where I live now, the Enfield factory shut down in the 90s. Is it time that the UK started building guns again? We've we've we've we've outsourced all of this stuff to other nations.
SPEAKER_00The army's outsourced a lot of the stuff that it does because it just doesn't have the manpower. The army used to to build all its houses, the engineers used to build the houses, the army used to have all of its chefs. Um you know, all of these things the army used to have that's gotten rid of over the last 20 years and in cuts and it's cut it back and back and back and back to the bare bones. We've got a division on paper. We're supposed to have two, we used to have three. It's like we are not a proper fighting force at the moment.
SPEAKER_00This is a real 1938 moment where it's like, do we want to go to war? Let's avoid going to war unless we absolutely have to. Oh bugger, we absolutely have to, and we're slightly on the back foot.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, it is interesting times.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm not, I'm not, uh, I'm not confident we're gonna have a uh stable remainder of our lives. I am in I it it it I find it interesting to see what's gonna unfold, but I you know what would you what job would you like to do if you if you joined up again now in the reserves, what job would you like to do?
SPEAKER_00Presumably you wouldn't want to be a para again. I'd go back in the red, you'd be a sniper again. 100%. You go back to be a sniper, yeah. Yeah, yeah. So sniper rather than a regular Tom.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no. Yeah, no. I mean, I I mean well, if I could choose a role I'd be sniper. If I could choose a you know a ranks different question, uh different question. No, no, not my my hearing. I mean, right now I wouldn't I can't drive my hearing. Uh but the I think that would go out the window because they would lower the thresholds or what would be appealing. You know, I can have a conversation with you here, no problem. Um they will make they would make exceptions, yeah, you know. Um the other thing was so I was considering this.
SPEAKER_00I went to I went to Estonia um the first two weeks in January, which was eye-opening because wasn't that far away from the Russian border, and the Estonian outlook on things is very different, and I think that'll be where Britain has to get to soon. Um but as I was there, I was thinking about this idea of rejoining the reserves in a capacity, um, and I got an email from Glasgow saying we'd like you to select your next job in the reserves.
SPEAKER_00I was like, the fuck? I haven't I haven't been in the reserves for a decade. Like, what the hell? And I and I was I was like, I thought I'd left the reserves. Turns out I didn't. Technically, I'm still in the reserves somewhere, which is a bit of a shock to me. So I may not have a choice. I may be but the the UGV stuff I think is going to be really key. So I'm really glad to now be sort of moving into an area that's gonna make a difference. So the company I work for, DCE, their motto is keeping people out of harm's way. So basically putting UGVs in to do the jobs that are dangerous and the soldiers would have to do and making it easier.
SPEAKER_00That's and I think is a really good aim. So yeah, I'm I'm I'm sort of happier now that I've got something where I'm doing doing a bit.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, sounds exciting, mate. Sounds sounds excited. Right, bags. We have got loads of questions to get through, so I want to get onto those now. Okay, so rapid fire.
SPEAKER_00Give me, give me, give me how long I've got to answer them as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Uh let me I like these, they've been some really good ones. So thank you to everybody that's sent them in because they've been really uh thought-provoking.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So looking at the questions again. Oh, okay. There's one in the in the chat which just came in, which is Has Ben ever seen a film called Man Bites Dog, a Belgian black comedy?
SPEAKER_00Oh, somebody recommended it to me. I can't remember who it was. Man Bites Dog. It's supposed to be really good, and I can't remember what it's about, but I've been recommended it. So um, I haven't seen it, would like to because the planet's brilliant. Oh, okay. I've written that down as well.
SPEAKER_01Uh let's look. So uh to what extent does the creative industry listen to your advice? Um the whole industry. When you're talking about the industry, yeah.
SPEAKER_00So listen to it, yes, 95% of the time. Act on it, acting on it, less. And it's because um it depends what the goal is, and there are many people involved in a production, many people with input, and many people have a different view on what's important and what's not, or what they're trying to achieve. So my approach to giving advice, I always explain this like a golf caddy.
SPEAKER_00Okay, your game of golf. If you wanna if you want to hit every hole with the putter and just go up and down and have a great game, that's entirely up to you. I'll advise you for this shot, it's probably better to use that one, but it's entirely up to you if you take my advice or not. And the worst advisors, the people that come into this uh cold get really angry and stamp their feet when people don't take advice. That's the wrong way to play it because you're not being helpful. Um, the best way to do it is sort of take a step back and understand what the production's trying to achieve.
SPEAKER_00So a theatrical production doesn't have to be a hundred percent realistic. It will skip certain things, it'll combine certain things, it'll gloss over certain things, or it may use situations that are slightly unrealistic in order to tell the better story. Now, to some people, that won't be a better story because they want to see things 100% accurate, or some people it causes cognitive dissonance where they go, that wouldn't happen because of this and this and this.
SPEAKER_00Chances are any production that I've ever been involved in that's been pointed out by numerous people numerous times. But it's that way, it is the way that it is because that's the way they they want it to be to tell the story. Um, there was one show I worked on um just doing script stuff where it was being converted from a US book to a UK story. So the original book was set in the US, US soldiers, blah blah blah.
SPEAKER_00They were setting it in the UK, um and therefore wanted to convert the plot into the UK. There were certain things that just didn't work in a UK plot, things about people owning guns, people with access to guns, anything like that. So I presented all of this and said, look, in reality, this is how it would work. And they would go, okay, that's great. We hear you, we understand we can't have that because it needs to work this way for the script, for the story.
SPEAKER_00So great. So how much do they listen? Usually 100%. I mean, you do the the occasional person that doesn't, but it's how much they can change or want to change depending on what they're trying to achieve. There are numerous conversations I have as where, you know, even the way that a soldier speaks, soldiers speak in TLAs all the time, three-letter acronyms, three-letter abbreviations. Sometimes that's really good, and they really want that for like chatter on the radio, stuff like that, make it feel authentic.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes, if it's a plot point, it's like, no, we need to spell it out, we can't use the acronym, we need to explain to the audience who won't know what the acronym is, what it actually is. So, radio chatter is one of those things that depending on who's doing it at what point of the story, can change from very authentic. Sometimes they go over the top. This is this is sometimes writers will go over the top, and everything will be a three-letter acronym. It's like, well, actually, three-letter acronyms are useful, but that's not how we speak 100% of the time. So sometimes you have to dial it back.
SPEAKER_00Um, you know, it's part of the job. You have to you have to have a broad back and accept that not everything you say is gonna. There was a historical advisor um on the radio who was saying, I would rather people make informed informed errors so they know they're making an error and there's a reason why, rather than an uninformed error. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, and the end result may be the same, but it's how you get there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, another question from Koch. Um uh Hugh said Tony Blair is a ninja. Do you agree? And what politicians do you like?
SPEAKER_00Do I agree that he's a ninja? Um, as in in what sense? As in wearing pajamas and healthy swords.
SPEAKER_01No, an extremely effective politician and parliamentarian.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I don't I can I can disassist. I don't like him as a person in the same vein, you know, there's lots of politicians that I don't like, there's lots of people I don't like, but they're very effective at what they do. Yeah. No, I think I think he was very effective at what he did. Um yeah, I d I wouldn't. There are certain things that he did poorly that have come back to bite him. Like going into Iraq were one of them.
SPEAKER_01Well he didn't do it poorly. It was an absolute decision that he did. So he he he made the decision that he wanted to go into Iraq to support the Americans, and then he decided that he needed to tell the public that that's what we needed to do to support his decision. It's like the opposite way around the democracy, which is what happened.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_01On false information, which he knew was false, and then went and did it. Yeah. So I would say that's I wouldn't say it was poor, you executed it perfectly.
SPEAKER_00He did what he thought was the right thing to do. But yeah, it's it's it's difficult, it's difficult for anybody to give somebody credit for stuff that they don't agree with. Yeah. So Trump, for instance, there are there are there are I do not like Trump or anything that Trump does, but the I can still give him cr credit, ticks in the boxes, for the the way that he does it can be very effective.
SPEAKER_00Whether or not I agree with how he does it, but I can recognise that how he does it works.
SPEAKER_01That is the attitude everyone should have. Yeah. When they are look when you you should have the uh you should have the ability to objectively judge anyone, regardless of whether they make you fucking skin crawl or not.
SPEAKER_00It's difficult to take a step back to the floor. It's difficult, yeah. But we we should be able to do it to that. Yeah, I think. I don't like how he does things, but I can't argue that they are I totally agree.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay, we've got questions from David. Uh here we go. Uh right. Um you've worked on some of the biggest productions in the UK. And what do you find is more difficult to choreograph? A firefight on set or a conversation with a director who thinks safety catch off is a character note. Ooh.
SPEAKER_00Now, it's it's rarely the just the director. So when you are talking about a character notes, it can be something that the actor might want to do. It can be something that the director wants, it can be something that the production wants, it can be something that the the writer wants. There's all sorts of creativity that goes into these things. It's not a single person. We have moved slightly away from what we call the the auteur-director. So the the big name directors that you know from the 70s, the 80s, and the 90s, the Steven Spielbergs, they are like the all-singing, all the dancing.
SPEAKER_00This is how it is. I've made that that choice. But there are so many more directors that are a piece of the machinery, they're not necessarily that driving force. So um it is in my experience, it's rarely a director saying they want to do that. Um, it could happen, but that's quite rare. But normally, I'd you'd need to understand their reasons why. So, for instance, if a character has a safety catch-off, I would want to know the reasons why.
SPEAKER_00Okay, talk me through the reasons why. Are you trying to show that this person is a bit slack? Are you trying to show that this a person is untrained? You know, what is what is it you're trying to portray? If you're trying to protect portray that this person is a professional, one of the key things I'd advise you to do is weapons handling correctly. And here's why. So read the question again, just so I've got I've got it.
SPEAKER_01Um reworded it slightly, but um uh uh so is it more difficult, what's more difficult with choreographs? Uh a firefight on set or a difficult conversation with a director who wants to, for example, have a safety catch off for a character as a character now.
SPEAKER_00I mean firefights on set are all about what looks good on the camera. So you're you have close-up shots, you have wide shots, and you are piecing together bits of the story and trying to make it logically work and geographically make sense with the ground that you've got. So it can be a bit of a technical um a technical beast, and you've really got to have the eye of a director and a a cameraman to understand lenses and how much you're actually seeing and what's important in that particular shot.
SPEAKER_00You've got to understand um story and how people viewing it were gonna tie it together. Um, and so it's that's more of a technical one. Whereas speaking to a creative individual and trying to explain to them why something works or should work in a particular way, that's more of a personal problem. So they're they're two very different things. To be a good advisor, you've got to be very good at the personal stuff in order to get the technical stuff done.
SPEAKER_00If you're just good with the technical stuff but not good with the personal stuff, you'll never achieve what you want to do technically because you'll be butting heads. So 90% of my job is relationships, is is is gently persuading people. It's like you could do that, but if you do that, this then happens, or this is a this is another way to do it. And it's having no ego because the industry is is uh filled with people who are very sensitive, some who aren't, but some who are.
SPEAKER_00And if you say to them that's wrong, then they'll immediately shut down. So if you say to an actor who's doing something that's wrong, boom, shut down. I remember a terrible day on set I had um introduced to an actress who's playing a corporal, and she her backstory was a particular thing, and she was talking to me, and I asked her what accent she was speaking in for the show, and she went, Oh, my own one. She had a very plummy posh accent.
SPEAKER_00And I and the reason why I asked her because we were trying to work out her backstory. So if she was a corporal with an accent like that, we could come from a different angle, you know. It it all these things weave into it. You know, there are people who are extremely posh who do end up as as uh as um junior NCOs, and there are people that just don't, and but it would it would serve a particular backstory. So I asked her, you know, what accent are you doing so I could tie it in? And she took that as huge offense that she was doing the wrong accent. And I was like, no, that's not what that's not what I meant at all.
SPEAKER_00I'm trying to trying to give substance to your backstory that would fit with that. So there's no right or wrong answers, but she took that as being wrong. So you've got to be really careful. You can't tell people that they're doing something wrong, something's wrong, something's incorrect. You've got to be much more sensitive to that. Whereas in the military, we're very used to being that's right, that's wrong. And so a lot of people approach it with that, which is completely the wrong way to do it. So I'd say I'd say both are very difficult different problems, but most people struggle with the personal side of things more than the technical.
SPEAKER_01Okay, makes sense. Follow-up question, follow-up question to that then from David. Do you ever worry that the public's understanding of war is being shaped more by Netflix, for example, than by reality?
SPEAKER_00Oh, I mean, it's always been the case. Everybody's understanding of war who's never been to war always comes from media, be it you know, newspapers, film, TV. Yeah, 100%. And I can say that for myself. I can distinctly remember uh being a teenager and being raised on a diet of World War II films and thinking, you know, war was all about bravery and about doing your bit, and then actually being in war and realizing it's far more complicated and far less straightforward than goodies versus baddies.
SPEAKER_00So um I'm not worried about it because it has always been thus. The media has always been used both for and against the argument about war being a good or a bad thing. And you know, propaganda has existed throughout. If you look at World War II films that were produced during World War II, about World War II, they were all very jingoistic, very up the hun, da-da-da-da. They were all very of a type. And and then you get into films about Vietnam in the 80s and the 90s, and actually they were very different in terms of they were very anti-government because Britain won World War II.
SPEAKER_00All of our World War II films are very uh very patriotic. Whereas if you look at German World War II films, they're very different. There's exceptional f films um in the 50s and 60s about World War I that was very, very tainted by what had happened in World War II. And so most people's understanding of the military and of warfare is going to come from films. I think if it's something you cannot fully understand or appreciate until you've lived through it.
SPEAKER_00So, my from my first tour to my third tour, my understanding of warfare and war in general and the war we were fighting changed completely. At the start of it, I was very like, we're going over there to fight the baddies, to stop bad things from from happening. By the end of it, totally different aspect. So I don't see how other people get an understanding of warfare without having gone to war or speaking to people, even so, as an older person, generally you have far more of a nuanced understanding of the world.
SPEAKER_00I'm not worried about it. I mean, what's the worst that could happen? I'm not sure. What I am worried about is more long term, and it's interesting that all these things, this destabilization is happening now. There's a theory that there's an 80-year turnover in terms of um people's attitude to war. I mean proper war. And it is because 80 years is about the lifespan of an individual.
SPEAKER_00We've now pretty much lost everybody who fought in World War II. There are very few World War II veterans left alive. And so the politicians and the soldiers are far more prepared. Pro-war than they would have been 20 years ago when those people were around. And it's that sort of 80-year span is the same or a similar theory as the four-generational one, which is the you've sure you've heard this before hard times create good men, good time good men create uh good times, good times create weak men, weak men create hard times.
SPEAKER_00It's that same four-generational cycle. And this is why I think the 1930s is a very interesting period of time. I remember as a kid learning about World War II and learning about what was happening in Germany and not understanding how people could get caught up in this, understanding how the Germans got swept up with this. And now I've got a far better understanding of how that can happen, if that makes sense. I've got a far more nuanced view on how people's behaviour and the um politics in the media of the day can shape things to move things in a certain way that ends up getting there.
SPEAKER_01Uh last question. How do you feel about the uh the decision to remove the conditional immunity for Northern Ireland legacy prosecutions?
SPEAKER_00I it's I don't know enough about it, but um I think it's got to be fair on the both sides. And the whole point of the peace process was to say, right, that's it, draw a line under it, everybody from both sides immune. All right. We understand why it happened, it shouldn't have happened, it did happen, everybody's immune. So I think it's a terrible idea to go back and go through that all again. It'll never be perfect.
SPEAKER_00Yes, there will have been people who have done bad stuff on both sides. There will have been people in the army who will have done stuff, isolated instance of people doing bad things. We all know these things happen. We're not going to say that the entire army has been 100% good 100% of the time, but we drew a line under it for the for peace. The idea was that is the line. People on both sides of the line have done but b bad stuff. So to go after one side and not the other, that seems poor form.
SPEAKER_01Uh it was never fair from the start, though, as my recollection. And that I think the there was immunity granted to terrorists or accused terrorists, but the immunity wasn't granted to British forces.
SPEAKER_00I again I don't know enough about it, but I I s I thought the idea was that it would be on both sides.
SPEAKER_01Okay, the Good Friday Agreement. Okay, yeah, the Good Friday Agreement of 1990. Obviously, we're going back to what it was then, did not grant blanket amnesty for crimes committed during the Troubles, but it included a structured early release programme for parallel paramilitary prisoners as a key component of the peace process. Under the agreement, both the UK and Irish governments committed to an accelerated release programme for approximately 400 prisoners affiliated with paramilitary groups, uh, provided their organizations maintained a complete and unequivocal ceasefire.
SPEAKER_01The Northern Ireland Sentences Act 1998 implemented this provision, blah blah blah. Um the eligibility required uh eligibility required that the offence was committed before April 10th. Prisoner was okay. Release okay. No amnesty was granted for unprosecuted crimes. Individuals not in prison were not automatically protected from future prosecution under the Good Friday Agreement itself. By July 2000, 428 prisoners had been released.
SPEAKER_01Um, but didn't the Conservatives introduce a protection though?
SPEAKER_00And again, I don't know enough. Well, let's check on it because it's an important subject. Yeah, I think I think if you're gonna draw a line under it, a line needs to be drawn under it. It won't be perfect, not everybody will be happy. There will be people who feel that they've got a raw end of that deal. But by war is chaos, there is no right and wrong. Well, the Northern wasn't a war. No, I know it wasn't, but warfare is complicated, and this is again going back to what I was like as a as a teenager versus how I am now.
SPEAKER_00There is no right or wrong, there is a lot of wrong, and that's about it. People can think they're doing things for the right reasons, but actually it's entirely subjective about whether you're right or wrong. So to to prosecute somebody because they were on the wrong side, it gets murky. So um so for instance, it doesn't happen so much now, but there was a spate of it in the 90s, early noughties.
SPEAKER_00Um German pensioners who had been involved in concentration camps at a very low l level, so were soldiers in concentration camps being arrested and tried for what they did back in 1940 when they were teenagers. That doesn't really achieve much. Is that person the same individual they were back then? No, ostensi, they would have evolved and changed and moved on. Is there any benefit to society for locking up a pensioner for something they did when they were 20?
SPEAKER_00It depends on the crime. It's it's it's a tricky one, and it comes down to the following orders thing. There's never gonna be a perfect solution, but I think going back over the past and raking over it again and again is unlikely to bring Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think we we're in an era where the situation like we've got now or in a stage where you it's very rare it's gonna happen again in the future. The reason I say that is because so the same with Northern Ireland, same with the example you just gave there. Back in the these times that we're talking about 40s, 50s, 60s, 70s, into the 80s, actual concrete evidence was not abundant. Yeah. I mean, recordings, film footage, like the investigative, the immediate investigative and analysis procedures and steps and quality information that was gathered was not great.
SPEAKER_01All these things evolved to a really great, great position now. So most of the time, what's being relied upon is especially with Northern Ireland, is memories, firsthand, sometimes secondhand accounts with things that went on 30 years ago, 20 years ago, and we know how the memory works. It's fucking terrible. It's fucking terrible for everyone.
SPEAKER_00You remember memories change, and people can tell the same story 25 times and it subtly changes the people. You don't realise this, you're not that becomes the truth. Whereas that wasn't what you said first time around. Have you ever done jury service?
SPEAKER_01No, I don't ever want to either.
SPEAKER_00If you if you do get the chance to do it, do it. I've done it twice. It's fascinating. But what is fascinating is witnesses and how because normally a court case will come maybe six, nine, twelve months after the event, and you'll have a witness statement that was taken at the time, and then we'll have the witness and their recollection of that nine months later, and it differs wildly because they would have told themselves or told other people that story numerous times, and it would have subtly, like very slightly, change over time.
SPEAKER_00And it's jury service is a fascinating thing to do, and I recommend anybody that does get selected for it do go and do it. Um but yeah, the the human brain and memory is a very pliable thing, and you and you can make people think they remember things that they don't, and vice versa. It's it's mad, absolutely mad.
SPEAKER_01And people can be and people can be um people can be influenced, given the wrong information or a misrepresentation of something that happened, and 20 years later remember that to be fact of what happened. Now, uh so I was just looking over this bill to go back onto this conversation. So, yeah, in 2023, where is that where has it gone? Uh yeah, in 2023, so uh the Northern Ireland Legacy and Reconciliation Act was passed, uh offering conditional immunity from prosecution to all individuals, including veterans of paramilitaries, who cooperated with a new truth recovery body, the ICRIR.
SPEAKER_01This act also halted inquests as civil claims related to the troubles.
SPEAKER_00I think this was what what Johnny Mercer was trying to achieve. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Right, which he drove for this, right? Now one of the good things that did was stop. I'm gonna refer to the Bloody Sunday inquiry here. And I'm not saying that bad things didn't go on that day. In all I wasn't there, in all likelihood, there was bad things went on by people that shouldn't have been doing it that day for a variety of reasons. I'm not gonna speculate on any of it. 1972 Bloody Sunday was, and you conduct investigations nearly 30 years later, when it started about nearly 30 years later, like a proper investigation nearly 30 years later.
SPEAKER_01Should there have been a proper investigation earlier on that wasn't like half-heartedly done, which was the case? Yeah, yeah, they should have. But doing an investigation 30 years later, and I'm just using Bloody Sunday because it's a it's a real good example, because the victim the families that are victims of Bloody Sunday were equally as fucked off that not much happened, right? Because a lot of these kids got thrown out because memory is you could completely understand why. Exactly. This is the problem with the historical stuff, right? And and so what's happened now is this 2023 bill has basically been reversed.
SPEAKER_01So Labour reversed the bill, but it opens the door up for those prosecutions to start again for veterans for historical stuff, which is problematic, it's so fucking old, and there's not any more evidence. Yeah, you're not gonna if new evidence comes about, right? And it's new eyewitness testimony, fuck off. Fuck all the way off. I mean honestly, whether that's prosecuting a terrorist or whether it's prosecuting British forces, fuck all the way off. Bullshit, not like not reliable, 100% not reliable, right? Um but reason to say it now, in 30 years' time, in such an investigation of things going on now, there is much more reliable evidence.
SPEAKER_01There's film footage for everything, there's audio footage for everything, there's digital records for everything, it's a different kettle of fish. Yeah, it's like we I don't think people understand that fact. They don't understand that. But what I don't want to see, oh sorry, so yeah, so what I don't want to see, you know, is like this, like I just said, investigations into this historical stuff where there's no new evidence, there's some maybe some new anecdotal shit that's come about, but nothing that is concrete. And by concrete, I mean DNA evidence found on the victim that is dead of a killer, or some ballistics evidence, which doesn't exist because it would have already been found, you know.
SPEAKER_00But no, anyway. I agree. I think it rakes over coals that have have died down, and I understand why people want to do it and why some families might want to have it done, but it's never going to bring the peace that everybody needs and wants.
SPEAKER_01Every single, every single historical prosecution that is brought around to do with Northern Ireland now is purely political reasons. There is no other reason that is brought around. If it's given any air, any any attention, it is for purely political reasons. That is it. Yeah. That is it. There was no other reason. I I like I that's what I think anyway.
SPEAKER_00It just doesn't make any sense. On the other side of it, you've also got things like Phil Shiner in the in the 20s. When did he first rear his head with Brian Wood and things like that? Phil Shiner.
SPEAKER_01But they just found out uh uh Starmer was involved. Don't know Starmer involved with Phil Shiner.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, Phil Shiner and public public interest lawyers, for those of you who don't know, there were a load of vexatious claims that came out of Iraq. Um, Brian Wood, MC, his story is one of those. Uh, and essentially, Phil Shiner went and rounded up a load of people that testified that the Brits had done awful things, and 99% of it turned out to not be true. And it was essentially him going and doing some no, go on, go on.
SPEAKER_01Listen to this.
SPEAKER_00Oh we've hit we've hit the mother load. Go on, he's just found something on the internet, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, let's just remind people who uh uh Phil Phil Shine.
SPEAKER_00Phil Shiner was the man with very tiny spectacles.
SPEAKER_01He always wore these is an absolute turd and was and is uh and was found to be um uh falsely uh so basically constructing false prosecutions of British military to do with Iraq uh alleged atrocities, basically. All right. Yes, this is an AI answer. So Okay, we'll take that with a answer. It's brave AI, it's not Chat GBT, it's not Grok, it's not uh it's it's brave, right?
SPEAKER_01And brave, but brave, anyway, right? Yes, so Kia Starmer was involved with Phil Shiner through the nature and extent of their collaboration, though the nature and extent of their collaboration has been the subject of significant controversy and scrutiny. This is given the sources here as well. Okay, legal collaboration. Starmer worked alongside Phil Shiner on multiple high-profile human cases, uh, on multiple profile human rights cases in the mid-2000s, including a 2007 case that led to the Ministry of Defence ordering inquiries into deaths in Iraq.
SPEAKER_01This case, Al-Skiny and others versus the Secretary of State for Defense triggered years of criminal investigations into British soldiers, some of whom were wrongly acclouved. So that was the Brian Wood one. That was the Brian Wood one. Starmer contributed a chapter to a 2008 book titled The Iraq War on International Law, compiled by China. Uh, in this work, Starmer argued that international human rights law should apply to British military operations in Iraq, and his stance critics say undermine military effectiveness. Starmer acted pro bono without payment as an intervener in these cases representing legal bodies such as the Law Society and human rights organizations.
SPEAKER_01He did not represent the Iraqi claimants directly, but his legal arguments were central to the cases. Phil Shiner was struck off as a solicitor in 2017 and later convicted of fraud and dishonesty in 2024 for fabricating evidence against British troops. He was described by former military leaders as the bane of our lives. Starmer's response, when questioned in Parliament about his links to China, Starmer avoided a direct answer, stating, as soon as there were any allegations of wrongdoing by Phil Shiner, I had absolutely nothing to do with him.
SPEAKER_01This response to criticism for being evasive. The Prime Minister's office maintains that Starmer's role was limited to providing technical lead legal analysis on points of law and that he did not represent claimants or work directly with Shiner's firm. Well, the evidence otherwise.
SPEAKER_00Well, no, that kind of again, there are a couple of ways to read that. I'm not a fan of Starmer in particular, but the way I read that is he China was fabricating evidence.
SPEAKER_01I see where you're going.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Starmer was providing technical advice saying if that is true, then they have broken the law. Because British troops are under UK law and under under other laws as well when they go abroad and fight. It's not like we've got free reign to do whatever we want. We are under humanitarian law. So therefore, what what it what it reads to me is Starmer was saying, yes, from what you've said, that breaks the law. But what it wasn't isn't saying is that Starmer was implicit in the lies that Phil Shiner was peddling.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So therefore, you know, do you do you blame him for it? And he says that as soon as he found out that Shiner was fabricating, he stepped away. I've got no way to prove if that's true or not. But it would seem that, you know, I take that in a slightly different way.
SPEAKER_01Uh I see the way you're saying, eh. Yeah, I agree. That's how that's how that's how it reads. Yeah. I totally agree. And then you've got the then you've got the then you can hypothesize on what is the character of someone like Phil Shiner like to be able to do that. And uh and um the character of his network and circle who support him could be crazy as well.
SPEAKER_00He was a lawyer. Starmer was a lawyer, they're all lawyers, and nobody nobody really likes the lawyers, you know. But my sister's a lawyer. Is she? Is she a good one? Yeah, she's a good one. Yeah, yeah, good one. What kind of lawyer is she?
SPEAKER_01She is serving.
SPEAKER_00She's a she's a military lawyer, yeah. Wow, yeah. So she's she's an army officer. Uh at the moment she's not army. Oh yeah. I'll say the more.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Anyway. Bags. It's been too long. Yeah. It has been an absolute pleasure, mate. Mate, we've talked about some brilliant stuff. Can we get a TV and film in the in the bag with uh um brock uh Brock Dorfner? Yeah, yeah. Brock Dorfner, Brock Meister. Brock Meister, yeah. Um good luck with DTE, mate. The DCE, yeah. Thank you very much. Yeah. Well, if you can come and have a look and come and have a play with a UT will. Yeah. I'll come and play with DTE for sure. Sure for uh for sure.
SPEAKER_01Um say a little JS for me. I will do. And so be been a pleasure.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for the questions. Good questions. Good what? Good questions. Yeah, good questions for the patrons.
SPEAKER_01Really good questions for the patrons.
SPEAKER_00Good questions for the patrons, really good, in-depth, difficult questions. I like it.
SPEAKER_01Anyway, we're done. Thank you for listening. Thank you for watching. Become a patron or uh or don't, whatever. If you don't, it makes me sad. Bye. That's it. If you enjoyed this episode, why not become a HeychAur patron? Patrons will get access to all of the episodes before anyone else, they get advanced viewing of the episodes, and you also get other perks and bonuses. All of the information is on charliecharlie1.com. Just hit the menu item, become a patron. It'll show you everything there, including access to the Heych Hour Discord community and private patron only channels on there.
SPEAKER_01So go to charliecharlie1.com and hit the menu item, become a patron. Easy peasy. Thank you for being a supporter. Subscribe to the channel, and I will catch you on the next episode. Thank you.
Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** British Army veterans Bags Simmons (Royal Tank Regiment, Bare Arms TV & Film) and Alex Brockdorff (Queen’s Royal Hussars, actor/director, A24’s Warfare) join...
H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts Chris Dodd joins H-Hour for an extended conversation about his years in the British Army and his experiences serving in Northern Ireland, Iraq and Afghanistan. A badged...
H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Chris Dodd answers questions submitted by H-Hour patrons in a Q&A format. Topics include whether all infantry should be trained to the...
Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** Levison Wood returns to H-Hour for his second appearance on the podcast, having first featured in 2019. This expansive conversation covers war, exploration,...
Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Levison Wood answers questions submitted by H-Hour platinum patrons in a short Q&A format. Wood discusses what it was like to...