Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

H-Hour

H-Hour artwork

#265 “Relying on [independent journos] for the news is going to give you a stilted worldview.”

Jun 8, 20252 hr 49 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

H-Hour #265 Paul Tyson - News Editor, British Army veteran, journalist. Veteran journalist Paul Tyson joins the podcast to offer an in-depth look into his career and the changing landscape of news reporting. From his days in the military to covering significant global events, Paul shares his experiences and the challenges of reporting on complex issues like war, climate change, and natural disasters. He also discusses his current focus on Blast Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBIs), emphasizing the need for better diagnostic and treatment practices. This episode sheds light on the ethical considerations and responsibilities that come with being a journalist in today’s fast-paced media environment. https://x.com/Tyson585 Send us Fan Mail This episode is sponsored by Sin Eaters Guild - sineatersguild.co.uk Support the show Free H-Hour giveaways and exclusive access to guests. https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts H-Hour on Substack: https://hughkeir.substack.com H-Hour on WhatsApp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaWSj4p05MUbVlHmFu3y H-Hour on YouTube: https://youtube.com/@HHourPodcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome back. If you are rolling into the no, if you have just flicked on this episode and it's the first thing you've listened to on Hey Chour with Paul Tyson, then I suggest you go back to the episode before this, which is the icebreaker with Paul. It's about a 20 minutes long answering questions. Paul is answering questions submitted by Heychower patrons. Very, very good questions, and it serves as a very good lead-in and a run-in to this full podcast. If you don't want to do that, you can completely ignore me and continue listening now at your leisure.

SPEAKER_01If you want to submit questions for the guests in the future or have access to the live links, so at the time of this recording, right now, there are people watching this on a live link for patrons, then you should become, you should become a HOA patron. The links to those options are in the blurb of this episode, and uh it costs as little as£3.50 a month. Absolutely nothing. That is actually cheaper than a coffee these days, unless it's a Greg's coffee. Greg's is£2.60, everywhere else is like four or five pounds for a coffee. Greg's, I highly recommend. And if your local Greg sells corned beef pasties, then I suggest a corned beef pasty as well.

SPEAKER_01That was a digression and a half onto the podcast. Paul Tyson, welcome to Hey Shower. Pleasure to have you. Thank you. Nice to be here. And uh and so first first interview ever. Yeah. Well, the first interview on this side of the mic, not yeah. So you've been 30, 30 years nearly in media, news, and this is your first interview.

SPEAKER_00I find it hard to believe. No, it's I mean, it's not my not my job. My job's to be on the other side of the mic.

SPEAKER_01Maybe it is now. Maybe it is, maybe this is a career change coming up. Um, okay, can you give me a quick a quick give me give give listeners a quick outline of your career in media in general, credentials, shall we say, and also your military side?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I I uh so chronologically I joined the army straight from school, more or less, um in 1987, served through to the end of 93 uh with an infantry unit, Princess of Wells's Royal Regiment. Well, actually, I joined the Queen's Regiment and then amalgamated um as the Cold War came to an end, became the Princess of Wells' Royal Regiment, had an absolutely fantastic time, loved every minute of it. Um, and uh it sort of gave me an enormous amount of sort of background, useful, relevant background for what I went on to do, which was uh uh firstly I did a a sort of a I don't know what you call it, diploma, I suppose, a college course to do journalism when I left, and then got a job with a news agency and uh newspapers, then ships were freelance for newspapers, various different sort of Fleet Street newspapers, then went into regional television news and then on to national television news where I've worked for 24 years, I think, something like that.

SPEAKER_00A long time. So um, yeah, I've been in in the media of uh one sort or another for an awful lot longer than I was ever uh was ever in the army, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, um it sounds like a it sounds like an amazing experience though, to be honest. I mean, uh a lot of people will uh a lot of people who've been outside the military, never been in it, think, oh I did 20, did you do 20 or thir or 30 years in the military must have been amazing. And I'm listening to you talk about 20 to 30 years in media, you know, reporting, journalism. You're an editor now, right? And that that to me sounds like an amazing, amazing vocation as well, especially as you covered a lot of war, a lot of different wars as well, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean the the good the good thing, I mean I so look pitch for anyone in the in the forces or leaving the forces who who's vaguely interested in in the media, don't be put off. You know, it's a challenging job, it's hard to get into pay's not great, in fact, the pay stinks, generally speaking, uh no one gets rich from it, but it's just such a rewarding career. Uh that if you can ride the you know, if you can ride the the pain, if you can get in, then then I speak personally, it's an incredibly rewarding career.

SPEAKER_00It's got variety, it's got you know, you meet some incredibly inspiring, interesting people, uh, entertaining people. You work with incredibly dedicated, focused, uh, high-performing people all the time. Uh, and you you find yourself in incredible situations. You know, you cover amazing stories and and and you know, in my case, we've been lucky enough to sort of go around the world doing various things, everything from sort of climate change to war zones to earthquakes and what and whatever.

SPEAKER_00Uh, and it it it's there's there's never been a job I've not enjoyed. You know, I've never done a done a job I've not enjoyed. Sometimes in the office, you know, you can feel like one day slightly, slightly like the last one, but not often. Enormous amount of variety. And there's I would say that there's a few sort of ex-military in journalism broadly, but but not enough. I think there should be more. Um, you know, there's a guy, uh, you may have interviewed him, Johnny Ball, who who sort of advocates for getting more people into into politics. Yeah. Uh, and and I think that you know, journalism maybe needs that kind of that that for the same reasons, you know, it would be beneficial with I think for everyone.

SPEAKER_00And we we talked about diversity, right? It would be interesting if if there were more veterans sort of in in the media, and I not least because it's a incredibly rewarding job, and there are skill set crossovers, you know, there are things that I did in the army that led into what I do in journalism that that that you know made it easier for me to do certain things. Um, so you know, there are there are ex-military guys, there's a lot of X X-Signals guys used to be in satellites, uh, satellite engineering, there's less of that now as that as sort of technology changes. But um there's some very good uh for some reason always always ex-royal marines, but um camera operators, there's there's a guy at Sky, there's a guy at the BBC, there's a fleet street photographer I know who are all ex-royal marines.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, those there are veterans that I'm not I'm not by any means unique, but but certainly, you know, we need more. And uh yeah, if it's something if it's something you've considered, I can I I can only speak personally, but I've had an amazing career and I've absolutely loved it, and I would recommend it to anyone.

SPEAKER_01I recently had uh Nigel Elyon as well, who's another great example like yourself of uh going from the military into into journalism, and it does it does definitely seem to um tick some boxes in ex-military people's uh um what should we call it? Catalogue of satisfactory needs. Maslow's hierarchy of needs on there. Media definitely ticks some of those boxes for some people, I think, for sure. Uh um, but yeah, so do you think uh so uh you know, I I hammer on legacy media quite a lot.

SPEAKER_01Like why like I'm regularly disappointed, regularly disappointed right along by what I see or read in legacy media. Now but also there are amazing people like yourself, amazing people in legacy media doing amazing work, you know. Uh so I'm not you know, I'm not I'm not completely unaware of that, and I certainly don't think that uh every every legacy media platform provider, producer is out there to deceive people or you know, or tow a political line.

SPEAKER_01Um but it seems to me that it cannot be easy for from a morale perspective, motivation perspective, to be in legacy media now in whatever capacity, certainly if you're a journalist or a presenter. Um is that the case? Oh, you've done 30 years, right? So nearly nearly 30 years. How how is your how is you perceiving the changes over the last 10-15 years? Public perceptions of the media changes.

SPEAKER_01How does that influence people working in the industry?

SPEAKER_00I I not as much as I think you might you might imagine. I I think broadly I I think sort of, you know, there is a kind of thing if you go online and particularly certain platforms and certain certain kind of groups of online people where you'll sort of see relentless kind of criticism. Well, I mean, quite often nonsense criticism. I mean, there are some some valid criticisms also, but a lot of it a lot of it's demonstrably nonsense uh of the mainstream media, and there's a lot of kind of there's some sort of emotion behind that, like you know, they're all lying to us, uh, this sort of thing, the world is isn't round, or whatever it might be.

SPEAKER_00Um, why aren't the mainstream media covering this linked to something by NBC, linked to something by CNN? I see it all the time. I've done a few of those. I mean, it's it's like but but but they are you're literally linking to something from the what you would call the mainstream media. So there's a bit of that. There are some valid criticisms, though. You know, there's some genuine criticisms that I think the media uh me media needs to engage with in terms of you, you know, we we're largely based in London. The majority of the legacy media is based in London, and you see a slightly different world from London as you do from Lancashire, as as you know.

SPEAKER_00Uh, we're largely from professional backgrounds, lots of privately educated kind of people in the decision-making sort of sphere, if you like. So um that's not representative. Um, so so you know, I think there are problems that the media need to address. There are areas that the media needs to to evolve in terms of connecting with uh connecting with people more effectively. You know, there are valid criticisms. Um, but I think I think the kind of the the sort of emotion, the shoutiness, the kind of, you know, you you can tune it out.

SPEAKER_00You do occasionally get it when you, you know, you do occasionally get hostile reactions on the street, but it's it's quite rare. Mostly people are friendly, interested, courteous, and if people have an opinion, mostly they're they're very happy to discuss it with you, and I'm very happy to discuss it generally if I've got the time with anyone. So yeah, I don't I I've never found it personally, I've never found it a problem, and I don't find it. I think the media behaves a lot better now than it used to, uh uh, when I started in journalism, with the you know, where the tabloids were up to all sorts of all sorts of things that weren't particularly morally justified and so on.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, I think that there's always been some concerns about the media of one sort or another. Now they seem to be mostly politically loaded, most come from a particular worldview. Um but no, it's it's it's not hard at all. I mean, don't read the comments if you, you know, if if you if you don't want to uh if you don't want to see what people's views are, don't read the comments. And if you do read the comments, you know, understand that that's not necessarily a representative selection of people. So yeah, but not hard at all. Yeah, I love my job, I really enjoy it. I accept that there are some valid criticisms of of of what we all do, but but none of that affects me on a day-to-day basis.

SPEAKER_00And I don't think I think most of my colleagues would say the same, but I'd obviously not here as an avatar for them or a spokesperson.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, I mean from from my own perspective, what it seems one of the things that I it seems to me, and that disappoints me, but I think needs to needs to be stopped from can being allowed to continue or minimized, is that and I maybe this is my perception of it anyway, is that uh because of the way because of the way the rise of social media and because of uh the you know the the reduction of people's attention spans and how people are engaged online, what what engages them, what gets them engaging with a service, a platform, a product, a a a content provider, be that news, be that uh hashtag influencer, be that whatever, I um because of that change.

SPEAKER_01Um I think that uh legacy media uh creators, producers, what should we call them, legacy media platforms, right? I think that they are fighting a battle between hypothetically between when they're choosing to run stories, a battle between a news report or an event or a thing that sh that is that that is should be reported, public interest, actual relevant story that is important to society, on the one hand, and on the other hand, you've got how much attention a story could get because of the type of story it is.

SPEAKER_01So on the icebreaker, I think I can't remember if we were talking about on air or affair, um, but you know, you give the example of of uh years ago when you first joined, uh or in even in the 70s, you know, um a uh so a crime, if it was a black person on a white person crime, that would be worthy, they would knew that would get more attention than a white person on a white person crime. So that would be useful in terms of engagement. You would get not clicks back then, paper sales and all the rest of it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I'm not sure if it ever translated to paper styles, I don't really know. But I what I do know from personal experience is that there were some straight up racist practices back in the day. I'm not sure if that was commercially driven or whether that was just people being racist racist in in positions of power. But I I don't think any of that uh that's I don't think okay.

SPEAKER_01Let's I'll give an example, hypothetical example, right now. So there's this oh let's say it's two years ago, there's a story. Uh there's one story which is it's just uh I don't know, some the actual the actual event is uh some self-defense, violent crime, self-defense, violence involved. Uh it's a white person hitting a black person. This is totally hypothetical, but there can be examples like this, right? White person hitting a black person, uh, and so you've got that story, which is chose to be run as a story as a in in a the black victim narrative, when all of the facts and the information point to not a victim was actually self-defense on the white part, or you've got the any any situation where a police officer is stopping a black person for a supposed crime, then two or three years ago, sometimes even now, that would get fired up as a story with the skin colour highlighted in order to generate the wrong kind of attention to the story for the wrong reasons, right?

SPEAKER_00Not sure where you're going with this.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I I So choosing to run a story like that compared to another story, which is actually an important piece of news about the story.

SPEAKER_00I mean, mostly mostly it's not comparative, right? So if you if you have a newspaper, you cover uh I mean, I don't know, but but but if you've got four stories on a page and you've got 40 editorial pages, right, you don't really have to decide between one or the other. You can run both. So I'm not sure you know where where you run one, how you how you select what you decide is on your front page and what you decide is on page 13 or whatever, obviously you know, obviously uh uh uh has an influence. But I I'm not sure I'm not I'm not really sure what a question is.

SPEAKER_00I am I'm not explaining myself.

SPEAKER_01I I'm not explaining myself. I think I uh okay, I I think there's too much okay. I think that headlines have been put together and stories being put front and centre and and prioritized as like what people are most likely to see over other smaller stories, be that in print less in print, but searching on social media. Well, not social media, websites, you know, the first page of the BBC or name any other outlet. I think on those on those front pages, you are less likely to get things that are actually important as genuine pieces of news compared to something is going to get more likely to get interaction and clicks.

SPEAKER_00Um I'm not sure that's true. I think I mean there's a balance, right? So most most uh uh let's say newspapers are all commercial, they they exist as businesses, they need to make money. If they don't make money, they don't exist anymore. So uh and uh and some newspapers don't make money and are owned by people who are prepared to you know take a loss in order to be a newspaper owner in order to influence public opinion or or whatever it might be. But but you know, most of the the legacy media is is exist commercially, so um, so yeah, you if you if you own a newspaper, you need to sell papers.

SPEAKER_00I mean that's that's pretty straightforward, right? Uh we all uh so so the the the company I work for is a broadcaster, we're we're sort of regulated and we we we're public service broadcasters, so we have you know we don't have the the kind of freedom that a purely commercial operation would have, but we do, you know, again, we're a commercial operation, people need to watch us. If if our viewing figures goes down to nothing, our bosses will say it's this the best use of our airtime. The BBC have to justify the licence fees, so again, they you know, if people have to be watching them.

SPEAKER_00Um so there's a balance, isn't there? But I mean, there's lots and lots of stories that that are really important uh that we cover all the time that that are in absolutely in the public interest that don't get clicks, don't get likes, and that we're not doing for that reason. You know, I don't think I've ever approached a story thinking this is going to do really well online. That's just not what interests me. Uh, good example, Blast TBI, which we we were talking about before. It's not exactly uh, you know, it's not exactly clickbait. Uh it's pretty niche as an interest, right?

SPEAKER_00It's a fascinating story. Something is going badly wrong here. It needs to be, it's absolutely in the public interest that reporters get on board with this and that that that and I'm trying to do that, you know, and trying to try to highlight those issues. It's never it's never going to do well on YouTube or on it's not we're not doing it because loads of people are gonna say, well, this is amazing. Yeah, you know, it's public interest journalism. So so the answer to your question, I think, is we can do both, yeah, both those things.

SPEAKER_00I think we can be i i popular in terms of you know, people watching, people reading, people clicking, or whatever it may be, and and also uh uh also do serious uh uh sort of journalism that isn't uh doesn't have broad popularity. They're they're not mutually exclusive.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I yeah, I I think yeah, I think it's too.

SPEAKER_00I mean you don't select your guests on the basis of how many people are going to watch them on YouTube, right? You select your guests on the basis of how interesting they are to you personally, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but I've got an advantage. I'm able I'm able to do that because I'm not reliant on this production as my my survival, right?

SPEAKER_00No, you know But but I'm not directly, right? I mean, my my bosses are somewhere in the chain, right? Somewhere up there, somebody does obviously have to crunch the figures and somebody has to make those figures work, and and that's fine. But most journalists don't have that as a common thing. No, the journalists don't. We we come in and we do stories and we do the stories we want to do broadly, and we do the stories where we get choice. You know, we either doing the obvious sort of agenda type stories that are happening now that you wouldn't you need to report, or where we get a choice to look into things in a bit more detail, we do the things that interest us, that energize us, that we think need it need, you know, need to be exposed.

SPEAKER_00So I've got a privilege to have access, not sole unique access to me, you know, there's a whole process of getting things on air that involves an awful lot of people agreeing that this is a story it's worth telling. But I've got an access to a platform, a powerful platform that that most people don't have, right? So if I see something like Blast TBI, if I come across a story like that, you know, I feel it's a responsibility to to try and use that platform to try and make things better. Um, that's got nothing to do with clicks or views or anything else.

SPEAKER_00You know, the challenge for me is to persuade obviously my managers and the people who allocate the funding that this is worthwhile. But the the it's never the question's never been asked about whether how many people are going to click about that online, how many, you know, how that works commercially. The questions that are asked are, you know, what's it gonna cost, how does it fit in our budget, you know, how how will it fit against other things? Is this a you know, is this a good story essentially? Nobody's ever asks whether whether it's niche or not. You know, that's that's not that's not a factor.

SPEAKER_00It's not a daily sort of factor. Yeah, maybe it's not a good idea. It's not a factor in the kind of manager's offices somewhere, but that's not something that affects what we do uh in a daily basis.

SPEAKER_01Is not down at the journalist, right, or the reporter.

SPEAKER_00Well, it's down at the journalists, yeah. I mean the guys who the guys who sort of sort are a running order in television or the the layout in newspapers are journalists too, you know. Ultimately the editor has the ultimate say on what your lead story is, what your back page is, what the you know, in in newspapers, and similarly, you know, our editor has ultimate responsibility, but they're overwhelmingly, if not exclusively, journalists by background. You know, they've done time doing other things and work their way out to be the editors, some some more quickly than others.

SPEAKER_01Maybe maybe my perception of it is completely wrong then. Uh maybe and the reason I can't a reason I've been thinking that apart from just from what I think I see when I'm looking at things on online. I mean, I rarely buy a a newspaper anymore. Um, but one of the reasons is is because I think well, not I think I know that you know, new newspaper sales have gone down and and and t television views or whatever's on TV have gone down. Uh gone down being the the polite way to put it, you know.

SPEAKER_01And uh and so for legacy media, I think that they've moved slower than the speed of you know people's attention. Social media has m has has progressed. So that they've they found like a big a big a big drop in revenue and are chasing the tails to try and pick that revenue back up in in in a way that only the only way that it appears it can be done these days, which is through, you know, which is through trying to get engagement on social media through posts going out.

SPEAKER_00I mean I speak personally, I don't feel under any pressure to drive revenue up through clicks. I I feel pressure to do the story of the day or the stories of the day as well as we can uh and to do those things that are that take more time and more investment to do the things I I want to do that interest me and engage me, I think are important. So I I don't feel that pressure personally. Uh is there a pressure, you know, will News at 10 ever have 17 million viewers again as they once did under Trevor McDonald? No, those days have gone. But that democratisation of the media is a good thing, right?

SPEAKER_00I view it as a positive because people have an incre have an incredible amount of choice about what they consume. How people use that, obviously, you know, there's there's bad things for that as well as good things, but broadly it's positive. And what it it allows to happen is so previously, if you wanted to set up a to buy a professional quality uh uh television camera, sound recording equipment, and uh, you know, and then somehow to be able to broadcast that 20 years ago, that was a substantial investment that was totally beyond what any normal individual can do could do, right?

SPEAKER_00And now here we are in a a studio that that has cost I don't know, but a recent hundreds of thousands. Hundreds of thousands of people. Hundreds of thousands, honestly. But you can you can set up now as a camera operator, filmmaker, documentary, documentarian for the kind of money that that you know that an average small business might invest in a startup, right? It's not totally beyond your reach. So that that kind of democratizes the media, right? That allows people like yourselves to have a space to have a platform, right, of your own that you control and that you use however you want to use it.

SPEAKER_00And I think that's great. Now, whether people engage with it, the extent to which people engage with it, how responsible these, you know, a lot of new media channels are in the sense that they're not regulated in any way, that there's no requirement for fact-checking or whatever. All there are problems with that, but I think people, but you know, people aren't stupid. The public aren't stupid. I think people can generally, right, people can make their own mind up about what is kind of regulated, what is fact-checked, what what isn't. There is a problem, I think, you know, where people get into an echo chamber politically of seeking their own political views, wanting them reflected back to them, and therefore not exposing themselves to alternative views.

SPEAKER_00That that's a problem that exists for sure. Um, but I I think broadly the kind of spread of new media, the democratisation of media, the ability of of anyone to get into the media, if you like, to have to put put things out, to to explore things, to ask questions, to create content. I think that's fantastic. I think that's great. Why should it be the preserve of a a kind of small number of people who happen to go through sort of training and interviews and get into a particular job? We fulfil different roles. What you do is different from what I do, do you know what I mean?

SPEAKER_00And we do them in different ways. But the public has a choice. You could watch ITV news for weeks without seeing anything relevant to veterans' affairs or to the military on it, just because that's not a standard kind of part of our agenda. But now you've got the option, rather than waiting for something to come up that interests you. Now I can go onto the HAR podcast and fill my boots. And that that's fantastic. So I don't think it's yeah, it obviously commercially it's a challenge, plainly. That's that that's true from that point of view. But I don't think it's changed what we do fundamentally.

SPEAKER_00We all have our own social media output now, we all have you know a a presence, legacy media all has a presence online somewhere, so so it's changed to that extent. But in terms of changing what we do editorially, I I I don't detect that. I don't think that is the case. Um are we conscious of uh let me revise that? Do we see things online that we think oh, that would be good on tele, too. Yeah, we do. You know, there's sort of viral videos might make it to our end finally, or something like that.

SPEAKER_00So there is an influence, there is a sort of crossover, no question. But I don't think it fundamentally changes our journalism. Uh yeah, I I'd not that's not something I would recognise.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I it's refreshing to hear you talk like that, and it's definitely I mean, it's definitely I mean you're changing the way I think about things, it's making me feel a bit better because I've been so I've been so miserable about it over the last few years. Um but one of the reasons I think I've been miserable about the quality of legacy media is it's actually something you touched on. You touched on an icebreaker and you touched on it again just now. And I think that is again because of the because of the way things have moved so quickly over the last 15 10, 15 years.

SPEAKER_01That not only has legacy media been impacted, everything's been impacted, but individuals have been impacted, and many, many people I know you're saying people aren't stupid. No, but I think many, many people are now uh uh unintentionally, whoever is ignorant, unintentionally ignorant of things because they've been caught in an echo chamber. And that and and that that is because that is evident in you know, people who, for example, will only ever watch the BBC for their news, right?

SPEAKER_01Or their radio channels. You know, my dad my dad is almost exclusively BBC everything 24 hours a day, almost exclusively. Uh, but he's of a different generation. Um, then you've got other people these days who are, you know, there are people who are exclusively Andrew Goddamn Tate, there are people who are exclusively Russell Brand, there are people who are exclusively Joe Rogan, you know, not that Joe Rogan's a news person, but he's a podcaster. They're exclusive, they just done these these one channels where they've there's something they've they've got something from it at one point for some reason, something's resonated for some reason, and that's all they consume.

SPEAKER_01And uh and Andrew Andrew Tate is very clever with this, uh, in that and this is not me saying I like Andrew Tate, I do not like that individual, but very clever, and and uh in that and this is he you know he will say some things which are very positive, common good messages, bog standard, like uh uh no-brainer, you know, look at yourself, well-being, attitude, motivation, all this stuff, right? Majority of what he says is nonsense and like horrendous the and who he is.

SPEAKER_01I don't like the person, what he does, but these little snippets of actual pieces of good advice you hear from somewhere else, they get hooks into people, and all of a sudden people think he's the Messiah. Russell Brand does some great independent. I mean, who would have thought how many other years ago that Russell Brand would be an independent journalist right now, which I suppose he is, but he does some amazing stuff. But that's not the same, everything that comes out of his mouth is like 100% true and accurate. Some of what he says is pretty wild, you know, and I'm not even talking about the comedy stuff. And the same goes for the legacy media platforms.

SPEAKER_01So it the ignorance of the public is is is a problem as well. And that's I was influenced by by it too. But I mean, that's why, right? That's why we like it. I don't like legacy media, but I don't stay away from it. I deliberately will consume it because sometimes I get good information from it. Other times I want to see what the layer land is, who's saying what about what? From I mean, the three main ones I'll go to is uh for Al Jazeera, GB News, Sky News, BBC. You know? Um, because you you you've got you've got to have these variety of sources.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think there's there's I mean that's that that's a good point. I think there would, you know, you it helps if you're a bit media literate. I'm not you don't need to do like media studies or anything to know that that that having more than one source of information is probably healthy, generally speaking. Um so yeah, I mean the answer to that echo chamber problem is for is is for people, you know, that that there are a variety of media out there and you you you can consume them. But uh all I'd say is there is a difference between we sort of say independent journalist.

SPEAKER_00I'm not not sure I would categorize Russell Brown first and foremost as an independent journalist or or Andrew Tate, but but perhaps I think perhaps that takes us into sort of semantics, but yeah, yeah. You know, we would regard ourselves as did they take that off of me? Sorry? Take that lanyard off of me. Oh, cool. I just I've just noticed it, sorry. Sorry, sorry. So uh yeah, yeah. I mean ultimately I think people who rely on if you're relying on those sorts of people for the news, then then I think that's um you know that's gonna give you a slightly sort of uh uh stilted sort of worldview, but that's that's you know, people of people, it's for there's a freedom to choose there.

SPEAKER_00I don't think that's fundamentally a bad thing. Um you know I think people have always been able to do that. Lots of people have never read a newspaper, you know. That's kind of fair enough. If you don't want it, you don't want it. We don't have to force that onto people. And if you if you want to be in the public sphere, you want to be engaged with the world around you, then obviously the more you read and the more you consume in terms of the media, the better informed you'll be, and the more valid your opinions will be, the more likely you are to be listened to. But I don't think you can't make people, you know, if people want an echo chamber if that's where they feel comfortable, if they just want their own political views reflected back to them and they want the facts to fit their view, uh, and they don't want to talk about facts that don't fit their view.

SPEAKER_00That that's kind of a freedom that people have, right?

SPEAKER_01I think this is kind of I know, but if I could if I you know if there was one lesson they could teach to everyone now and clip my fingers, it would be that you don't want an echo chamber, you don't want you no one should want an echo chamber in any circumstance whatsoever, I don't think.

SPEAKER_00At all. I don't see any benefit to it. You know, I think most intelligent people like to challenge themselves intellectually just naturally, and I'm not saying intelligent people as in people with degrees, I mean just normal people who have an interest in the world around them, right? You know, are are up for challenging themselves, and you only have to sit in a pub with with with a group of young people and listen to the conversations to understand that people people are still interested in the world around them. They do still discuss politics with a small P, not just party politics, they do discuss world affairs. Though those things do matter to people, and and generally speaking, so that whether or not that translates into huge fitting viewing figures for ITV News or BBC kind of doesn't matter so much, you know.

SPEAKER_00Yeah people now can A, they consume our content in different ways online and and and so on, as well as as well as on on sort of terrestrial broadcast. Um, and the same for the for the newspapers, you know, newspaper articles fly online as well, uh, even if the viewing figures for actual the hard copy is down. Uh and B, they can there's this democratisation, they can also watch the HR, they can also watch whatever else it is they want. I I think that you know the movement's been really quick because technology's enabled it. Uh and but I don't I don't think it's bad.

SPEAKER_00I think it's a good thing. I think the way the media's going is a good thing. Yes, it has problems, yes, it has challenges. There have always been problems, they've always been challenges. Do you know what I mean? That's uh that the way everything's going, I think, is is an absolute positive. I'm a I'm always an optimist with uh I mean with most things in life, but certainly with the media, I you know, if our viewing figures get to such a point where I you know get sacked and have me back on and I might sing a different tune. But I, you know, I think the media's in a really healthy place, personally. Really? Yeah, absolutely. Really? Yeah, yeah. But as a consumer, you can find whatever you want to find.

SPEAKER_00Now, if you wallow in it, an echo chamber in it, okay, that but that's on you. Well, but if I want something just from a point of view of research now, if I'm looking at, let's say, for instance, Blast TBI, right? That we've we've spoken about before, I can find incredible content from Australia, some of which is ABC, the big broadcaster there, their health correspondents been doing really, really powerful work on that. But also, there are uh veterans there, people who are afflicted by this, who are putting research online, blogging on it, creating communities, right?

SPEAKER_00This didn't exist even 15 years ago. This was not possible. Now I can connect to these guys in Australia and talk about what's happening there, learn from them about what's happening there, and and have a whole new kind of whole new sort of information stream that's available to me. Same in the United States, Sweden, Canada, you know, and I can connect to all of these people and all of these communities and all of these discussions, and and you know, I can take what's useful to me and leave what what isn't. But that's that's a capacity that didn't exist 15 years ago.

SPEAKER_00It just wasn't there. And now, now that people are using social media, they're using blogging, they're using podcasts, they're using, you know, all this stuff that's available to us now. Uh, and there's an incredible amount of fantastic content out there, and it's not all a preserved now of the legacy media, but but that's good for us too, right? Because we can use that and turn that into hang on a sec, these guys here are doing something that we should be doing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I agree with that. Sorry, when you were saying, when you were saying media's uh legacy media isn't in a healthy state, I I was I was thinking you meant in terms of financial health and business model health.

SPEAKER_00No, as a I'm talking journalistically. So so from a business point of view, uh yeah, I mean it's a challenging time. But I mean, when I started journalism, I went to a college in so I think I think I'm one of the only people ever to actually find a job from the resettlement, you know, the resettlement computer thing you used to have. Yeah. So you go on this, do this psychometric thing that you wouldn't.

SPEAKER_01Is it the career transition partnership back then, was it?

SPEAKER_00I can't remember what they called it, but you went to a board shot and you sat in front of a computer that was like the size of a house and it and you sort of typed in, you know, your favourite colour or whatever, and it said, um, and it said, you be a good teacher. I can't remember what the other thing, psychologist or something. There was a sort of little list of jobs that it thought I'd be good at, and a journalist was one of them. And then you could go on the yeah, you had to go to a different computer to find out what courses might be available for these things and what the requirements were and whether you needed a degree and whatever. And it turned out you didn't need a degree to go into journalism, and so I that which most of the others did, and so I sort of you know typed this in, and there was a college course.

SPEAKER_01You could bring your crowns with you.

SPEAKER_00You could bring your crown, exactly. And and so so that's kind of how I ended up in in journalism. So um I had thought about it before, it wasn't like totally new to me, but but it was, you know, that was so so that got me into college. So I went to college, and the first day, the sort of senior lecturer, the first thing he said was sort of, you know, ladies and gentlemen, you you you're joining a dying industry. Uh, you know, newspapers of these newspaper titles, you know.

SPEAKER_01What year was this?

SPEAKER_00Uh this was in '93. Or ninety four, ninety four. No, ninety three. So you're joining a dying industry, reading figures are down, it's terminal decline. Uh of all all these newspapers, only one or two will be in business in in five years' time. I think he said he might have said I'll be generous to him and say ten years' time. So uh all of those titles are still going, except today, newspaper closed. The standards gone on, you know, there are there have been changes, but nearly all of those newspaper titles are still with us. So I'm not saying they're thriving necessarily.

SPEAKER_00I'm not saying the business model is that they're they're all cracking open champagne every time the reading figures come through, but they're all still with us, and that's 30 years on. So so you can exaggerate the kind of you can catastrophise about you know where the legacy media is heading a bit, because it still has a really valuable role in the ecosystem to have something that is, you know, fact-checked, that is in the case of broadcasters, regulated, uh, you know, that everything has to be verified, that it has to be balanced, has to be fair, has to be accurate, and all that sort of stuff. There's a place for that.

SPEAKER_00I'm not saying that's the only thing people should be consuming. We were talking earlier, the more people consume, the better. But within that sort of ecosystem, there's an absolute place for straight, fact-checked news. And I think there always will be. And the newspapers, you know, I think people like younger people far less like to read newspapers. But you know, I I still read newspapers, even not even so much for the news sometimes. Crosswords, sports. You know, there's something about sitting in the garden with a a newspaper that is is better than sitting there on your phone for me.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but that that is you know, that is maybe that's a generational thing.

SPEAKER_01That's exactly what it is. That's exactly what it is. You know, go and try and put a newspaper into someone's hand these days. I mean, it's hard to get it's hard to get young people to read books, you know, voluntarily. Yeah, no, I said at school, you know. Um uh, but so all right, so so question then. So if newspaper sales and viewing figures have dropped off, right? Uh and they were both a source of you know, the main source of revenue for legacy media platforms, then where has that revenue been picked up?

SPEAKER_00But I mean, I the answer is I don't know. I'm a journalist, so I'm not a I don't have you know any responsibility, thank goodness, for the the kind of business side of things. But you know, ITV is advertiser funded, advertising goes up and down, not just with VM figures, with other other factors as well. Um, but when things go down, we make efficiencies like any other business. And when things go up, we we we try and expand our our offering and our operation, you know. So and I think with with newspapers the same thing. Sort of advertising's, you know, it newspapers are no longer the only place you can advertise.

SPEAKER_00So, but I I don't it doesn't I don't think it's like uh you know I wouldn't over-catastrophise it. I think where there's been a real problem where there is a real change that's noticeable is in local newspapers. I think if you look at local newspapers now, that obviously classifieds used to pay for those essentially, and and much of that business has gone online, and that is I think that's a lot harder uh for the local so they're nearly all owned by two or three big groups now, which wasn't the case. They used to be fiercely independent and you know, right around the country with these really small three, four, ten person operations doing incredible work of covering their patch, their local area.

SPEAKER_00And I now now you you might have one guy who covers all of a whole London borough or a whole county or whatever. So plainly there is a guy, or I mean guy in a gender neutral sense, but so plainly there is you know that local new the quality of local newspaper journalism has definitely taken a hit. They've definitely commercial, you know, they've taken a massive commercial hit, and the quality of journalism has suffered as a result. I don't think there's any question about that. I would say uh at sort of national newspaper network news level, not dramatic, you know.

SPEAKER_00I don't think it's dramatically journalism's any different than it was when I joined.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00People like to look back at a golden era of journalism when we would sort of, you know, fly across the world and spend three weeks, five weeks on a story and only file once and have you know expense accounts that you know the journalism was no better then. Do you know what I mean? It wasn't. What we can we can do incredible things now. We can bring you things from like anywhere in the world live almost that we couldn't do back then. We have, you know, there's some things might have been better about this, but some things are better about that. There was never a kind of golden age where everything was perfect, it didn't exist, you know.

SPEAKER_00So and it's interesting to look back at if you look back on old archive news reports and so on, you know, some of them were fantastic, like some of them are now, some of them are awful, as some of them are now. You know, I don't think the the the kind of I don't think it's particularly healthy to always be looking back at something that was better than it is now. I don't I genuinely don't think that. I think some of the journalists we have working for us now are every bit as good as the kind of legends of the past. Every bit as good.

SPEAKER_01Um are there any uh so from a on an independent journalism uh topic? Who would you are there independent journalists that you would recommend to you know follow alongside the legacy media platforms? Is there anyone that that pops up?

SPEAKER_00It doesn't feel right to do that because they're because it's a personal, you know, there's people I follow, and then I don't follow for a while. So no, not really I'd I'd yeah, I'd kind of rather not do that. Yeah. There are there are I generally mostly I would say I consume legacy media. Generally speaking, I will go where I come across independent journalists, it's through rabbit holes, it's through being interested in a subject, so it's topic specific. So you know, Veterans Affairs, you the same people that the same people that you know are the people that I would consume from time to time.

SPEAKER_00But I I I'm not sure I'd recommend them. I like you know I kind of use them specifically to for a thing. There's not much that I would just listen to for pleasure, it's mostly because I'm interested in in a thing. Uh so I follow some sports podcasts, but but I do them because I'm interested in a particular football team and I follow them and I consume that content that's related to that. So you know, I could say I like this podcast or I like that, but I ultimately they're not I'm just following them because they're subject specific.

SPEAKER_00Do you know what I mean? Yeah, yeah, yeah. And that's the great thing about independent journalism in that sense, about about the democratisation of the media, is I can now find like 15 different channels on my football team and you know, podcasts and YouTube channels and all sorts, just on and it's not even a big football team. It's like you you know, that was you just couldn't do that 15 years ago. Some of it's garbage, obviously. But you can kind of pick and choose. So I think that's that's good that's great.

SPEAKER_01Can I ask you a question? So one thing that surprised me, uh, you may have been able to explain this, maybe uh either specifically about this story or using another as an example. But it is the Kirstama uh the three Ukrainians in the arson story. Oh yeah yeah yeah. Right. Yeah. One of the things that has really surprised me is the w I see this as being major, major story that for some reason I I think should or in alternate circumstances will be getting covered on a daily basis until we find out what it was all about.

SPEAKER_01You know, Prime Minister security breaches, Prime Minister three three people, not one, Ukrainians as well. Um and they've been charged. I am not sure. I'm not sure.

SPEAKER_00But I think that so one of the reasons that and this is a thing that we're independent media, if you like, or where people generally are, I think, and maybe maybe maybe maybe this is actually an issue for us that we we're we don't do enough good enough a job of of explaining why we're not covering certain things. But generally speaking, when somebody is is arrested, and very certainly when they're charged uh with an offence, there's very little we can say about that until the court case, and that's governed by the Contempt of Court Act, which you learn all about in journalism school, and essentially it's to safeguard the trial to make sure that the jury aren't influenced by media coverage.

SPEAKER_00So, up until the point where proceedings are active, you can say what you like. I mean, there are other things that kick in, there are other restrictions on our freedom of speech, like libel and so on and so forth, but you can there's no restriction legally on us commenting on things. Once proceedings are active, and there's a sort of slight grey area over whether that's arrest or charge, but we generally generally speaking, once somebody's charged, there's a real limit, a strict limit to what we can discuss about the case. So and that's for a very good reason.

SPEAKER_00I I mean, obviously, as a journalist, one doesn't like any restrictions on freedom of speech to to but to an extent you also have to recognise that some of those restrictions are there for a very good reason. And if a jury's already made their mind up about whether whether someone's guilty or not because they've been reading about it online or in the Sun or in the mail or on ITV News or whatever, every day up until the trial, then that's that obviously means they're not getting a fair trial. So that's the reason why these things don't get reported in real time. Come the trial, I can absolutely guarantee you will report that.

SPEAKER_00You know, and so will the rest of the media because you think it's more it's more likely that this is a contemptible, potentially a contempt. 100% contemporal thing. It's just not something we can do. And and and a really good example of that is is is probably one of the most uh famous of the uh independent journalists if you if you credit him with that type was uh Tommy Robinson, who who went to jail for precisely that, right? And and he knew what he was doing. He's been released as well, hasn't he? He's just been released, yeah. And but he he he knew about the contemporary court and but but obviously felt that that that was something he wanted to push and test.

SPEAKER_00And and you know, maybe maybe uh it's right for him to do that. But the bottom line is that you know we there's a reason we're not not reporting on this grooming trial because we don't think it's newsworthy. It's just w there's a limit to what we can do. If there are reporting restrictions in place, if there's contempt of court issues, that means we can't report them. And there are we challenge those, we do challenge reporting restrictions, we do challenge these things in court all the time, but there is a genuinely good reason for society why people should be able to have a fair trial if they're accused of serious offences.

SPEAKER_01Those restrictions would not be uh applicable on independent journalists, then would they?

SPEAKER_00Well, technically, yeah. I mean they are a protection. Technically speaking, yes. So so as as Tommy Robinson found out, yeah, absolutely. If there's a court order that says you can't report the identity of this person, that's a court order for everybody. So they're applicable for everybody. We obviously have lawyers who who you know will will advise, and we we have a kind of infrastructure that makes it easier for us to observe those things. You know, sometimes people don't know about that, might be commenting, let's say, about this trial that you mentioned, and you know, you might you might fall foul of those things.

SPEAKER_00But but but technically speaking, you're every bit as you know, we're journalists are just citizens. We don't have any, there's no rights that we have, and there's no responsibilities that we have that you don't, basically. So if if if we're talking about the details of that trial that you happen to know about for whatever reason right now, and those people have been charged, there's a danger that that that could be viewed as content. Yeah. The bar's quite high. You have to seriously prejudice the the outcome of the trial, but it's it's nobody wants to have a trial abandoned potentially guilty people walk free because of your reporting.

SPEAKER_00That will be A will be reputationally bad, B, ethically wrong, uh, and C, you can get fined and imprisoned for it. So um, so yeah, we tend to take contempt to court very seriously.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um what are the are there what what are the standard or are there standard processes in place for a uh for a journalist to hit minimum requirements for due diligence when when due diligence of stories, sources given information before a story is submitted for publication.

SPEAKER_00Are there any standards? Is there any bar there for you? Yeah, I mean they vary. So it varies with what you're doing. So if if what you're doing carries a risk, then then the lawyers will go through it with a tooth comb. So if I'm going to say, you know, Hugh Kierr runs a terrorist organisation not anymore. Not anymore.

SPEAKER_01I left I left three parameters.

SPEAKER_00But you know, if I'm if that's the story I'm gonna go with, plainly there's a risk that you will sue me for liable and that my uh company will have to pay a large amount of money to you because of my lack of diligence. So where where we're talking about something like that, like original journalism or or you know that that kind of uh that kind of thing, it's pretty rigorous. And it's pretty rigorous for everyone, and and it's pretty rigorous for an obvious reason, which is that there's a a reputational problem, which actually, if you're someone like the BBC, someone like ITV News, the reputational damage is probably worse than the actual payout.

SPEAKER_00Um so there's a lot of diligence there, everything goes through the lawyers. Um your sources need to be you need to explain who your sources are, you need to explain where they come from, how you know them. There's a whole there's a whole series of questions that the lawyers will want to know. If you're reporting on let's say day-to-day politics, if let's, you know, politician A says this, we'll normally report that politician A says this, we'll then go to politician B and say politician A just said this, you know, politician B always say that's absolute nonsense, that's completely true.

SPEAKER_00If it's something that and I think we're getting better at this of fact-checking politician A, but it's hard in real time. Uh, and also politics is politics has sort of moved and shifted a bit in terms of their kind of willingness to state things that are just blatantly not true, and and so um so we're probably we're slowly getting a bit more rigorous in terms of challenging those things as they come, rather than just reporting them and then reporting a rebuttal. I think we're we're we're probably getting getting better at now, I would say actually challenging in the first place.

SPEAKER_00But so for so it depends on the story. The level of kind of rigour that goes into uh to examining stuff depends very much on the story. But nothing goes through, nothing goes on air that isn't checked by a lawyer in terms of BBC, ITV News, Channel 4, whatever. Everything goes through the lawyers that's contentious or potentially contentious. So we literally have in-house lawyers all the time who every day for every broadcast will check anything legal, any court reports, anything with potential for libel, potential for privacy breaches, potential for contempt of court, uh anything that might get us in trouble is rigorously checked.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think what but one of the one of the one of the issues of that is I think it's too easy to be able to publish something which is published as a fact and is incorrect and later corrected via, for example, an apology or correction on a website, like the BBC has it, you know. I think all the I think all of the well, they must do all the platforms have a way of doing it. Uh a page where they have a list of corrections that they've had to make.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and listen, no one's nothing's perfect, does it? No one's perfect. And and if you look at if you take a newspaper, if you look at the amount of content in that newspaper, and then you remind yourself that this was all done from scratch today, in a day, and sent to the printers, and printed, and distributed, right? This is happening at speed. All of this is happening at speed. So uh ITV News and BPC put out three different programs a day as from scratch, as well as those three different programs a day.

SPEAKER_00There's kind of online content, there's live streaming on various platforms, there's social media content and so on. An incredible amount of work that's happening at pace and judgment calls being made at pace and quickly. So, you know, do mistakes happen? Yeah, of course, they always have, and and they always will. Uh, and it's right that they should be corrected. Some mistakes are more egregious than others. Some mistakes are a function of changing expectations in society, changing laws. So, if you look at privacy, for instance, back when I started in journalism, privacy didn't exist.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there wasn't such a thing. You could go up to people's doorsteps with a camera rolling if you thought they were bad guys and ask some questions, you could film people through their windows. Uh, we didn't, I wouldn't say we made a habit of that, certainly not at ITV News, but I mean, there weren't it was all about what you thought was the right thing to do. There wasn't a law, there was no legal underpinning for that. And then obviously the Max Mosley case was a big breakthrough in in terms of privacy, and now privacy is a big thing. You know, the helicopter, the news helicopters, you know, if you're filming somebody in their garden inadvertently, you're following a motorcade, let's say, and you're then potentially that's an issue.

SPEAKER_00So the law changes, society's expectation changes. So some things are not, it's not like they're mistakes necessary, it's like an evolution in the way things in the way the media works, if you like. So some of it's that, and some of it is just honest to goodness, human error. You know, one of the things that absolutely infuriates me the most about our job is, you know, ask to mistake mistakes on maps and things like that. And and and you know, sorry. You know, when people put the wrong wrong names on maps and things like that and on in graphics and so on.

SPEAKER_00And I mean it's really infuriating and it's embarrassing when that happens. And but no, nobody wants had to this is a of people working at pace and making mis making a genuine kind of good faith mistake. I don't think it's a symptom of any deep malaise. You could argue that you know, perhaps the people who once used to fact-check those things are no longer there because we're all leaner and we're all slimmer. There's probably some some truth in that.

SPEAKER_01Um there's a good movie actually on that, uh, on Netflix at the minute. I'm just looking for the name of it. It's got Kieran Knightley in it. Uh, Netflix journalist, one second, and there's a good example of that. And you'll probably laugh. I'm I imagine you've experienced something like this with someone else doing it. Uh wait a second, what is it called? Not blackdoors. Oh, what the heck is it? I can't remember what it's called. Uh but in the film there's a leak, and the they get hold of a story, they they not leak, they but they publish this story, and in the story they there's an email that they put from a spy.

SPEAKER_01I can't remember what it is. In fact, it's based on the true story. It's based on the true story. I'm sure it's based on Iraq War, dubbed weapons of mass destruction. Hang on a minute. Hang on a minute. Uh WMDs. Anyway, in it, the person who is about who is checking the story for grammar and punctuation runs the story through a spell checker, which then changes the spelling of this email, which was leaked to them, from American spelling to British spelling, and then when it's published, it's called up. That's that's not true.

SPEAKER_01That's that's bullshit. It wouldn't be spelt like that. It's spelled in America. This is invented, this is made up, and it it it makes out it means that the public think the whole story's yeah, I'll tell you.

SPEAKER_00That sounds like a good example. It's you know, it's it's a good faith error, it's a sloppy error. You know, and we do you know, obviously, we none of us have none of us sorry set out to make mistakes on purpose, but they do happen. And you don't have to look, you can see them because they nowadays they go online straight away and they bounce around on on X or on Twitter, and you know, mistakes are amplified in a way that they weren't previously now. So um, you know, particularly funny sort of maps where you've got the wrong country name in the wrong country and so on. That that's you know, which we I can't remember us doing, but it does happen.

SPEAKER_00Official secrets. Official secrets.

SPEAKER_01This is 2019. Okay, a British drama. I'd highly recommend it, directed by Gavin Hood, based on the case of whistleblower Catherine Gunn, who exposed an illegal spying operation by American and British intelligence services to gauge sentiment of and potentially blackmail UN diplomats tasked to vote on a resolution regarding the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Yeah, it's a really good film. But it's basically a spell check mistake in the in the in well, I can't remember which which uh organization it is who published the story.

SPEAKER_01Uh anyway, anyway, sorry, yeah.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, I mean, in terms of it being too easy to make mistakes, I mean it's too easy to make mistakes driving, it's too easy to make, you know, these are things that are happening at pace, and and I could I the only thing I'd accept probably is that, you know, like you say, the guy whose job it is to check things probably used to be three people who would probably check, you know, and maybe they would would have been very experienced and therefore quite expensive people. Now though, now that we kind of everything's leaner, tighter, cheaper, mistakes are more likely to creep in in that sense. Perhaps that's true.

SPEAKER_00Um I'm not sure whether that's empirical, you know, whether if you sort of did on air mistakes for a year at this particular broadcaster in pick a year and then did it for this year, whether there would actually be a difference. There might be. Um there might be, I don't know. Um, but I don't think I think few of those mistakes are major. You know, I can't remember. You know, and and it's right that if you make a mistake, you should correct yourself. And it's right that if that mistake has I mean, most mistakes are kind of innocent spelling mistakes, whatever. But I think where you where you make a mistake that has implications for people, you should correct that.

SPEAKER_00You know, I think that's entirely responsible.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um so can we come up with the subject of blast TBIs? Is that all right? Never seen someone so happy about TBI. Uh yeah, you mentioned the icebreaker, you mentioned it earlier on, and so and you know I've done a few interviews on this, I've got a real keen interest in it, and a lot of my listeners and viewers have as well, um, for various reasons. You know, some are directly impacted by either themselves or by a family member. Uh and so how how have you ended up covering blast TBIs as a as a story in general?

SPEAKER_00So there's a friend of mine who I I say friend, it's a guy I interviewed, I met and interviews through another story, basically, something totally unrelated. Um, it was about three power in Afghanistan, actually. There's a project I did a few years ago, and we've sort of stayed in touch. And this guy has been saying to me, you need to do something on Blast TBI, you need to be looking at this. I'm I'm not sure I'll mention his name publicly. You may, he may not, he may not want me to do so, but he's a really fantastic guy and really kind of inquiring, intelligent sort of individual uh uh with excellent service record and just just just a good good person.

SPEAKER_00And he's been sort of you know gently sort of prodding me a bit to do it. And obviously, you get quite a lot of that when you were children while you're doing this, you should have a look at that. And it it assumes that you've got all the time in the world to do that, which I don't, you know. You have uh I have a sort of my job's quite all-consuming, so they're carving out time to do stuff that isn't agenda stuff, is is perfectly possible, but it's not easy. So I sort of said I put him off a bit, put him off a bit, and then said I at some point I said sort of look, I'll do a reading day on it. I'll I'll I'll let me I will have a look at this.

SPEAKER_00And I did a reading day on it, and I just couldn't believe what I was reading. He sent me a load of stuff, I think including your your um uh Mandy Bostwick, you did, didn't you? You didn't it like part of amongst other things.

SPEAKER_01Episode 99, folks, if you want to be able to do it.

SPEAKER_00There you go. So well that was an eye-opener for me when I first started talking to her, and it was like Well, I think she's been one of the she's she I think she was she probably watches what happens in the media now and thinks I've been saying this for a decade, you know, which i in in fairness to her, she she she she she she has. So and that amongst other things, uh so I've went through that and then I thought, well, this this can't this it can't be true, or it can't be it can't be well.

SPEAKER_01What was the thing that was shocking you?

SPEAKER_00The shocking thing so it didn't shock me at all that primary blast waves can cause brain damage in the sense of like being involved in an IED or whatever. Uh it was quite interesting because it tied in with rugby. I don't know if you've read Sam Peters's book, Concussion, but it's really fascinating. If you're into rugby at all, yeah, you must read it. It's fantastic. He's a book, he's called Sam Peters, he's a journalist of the Daily Mail. He pretty much led the campaign in terms of publicity, in terms of journalism rather than science, uh, to kind of recognise and and gain awareness of of the fact of the problem of repeat concussions in rugby.

SPEAKER_00Peterson. Sorry? Sam Peterson. Sam Peterson, is it? Sorry. No, Sam Peters, I think. Okay. Yeah.

unknownGo on.

SPEAKER_00The book's called Concussion.

SPEAKER_01Oh, it's mood of the book. Okay, right. Okay, right.

SPEAKER_00So that's a must-read if you're interested at all in in in this sort of sphere. So that so it the idea that sort of blasts obviously cause brain damage and that you know you get tertiary effects and shrapnel or whatever, that that's kind of not surprising at all. What was surprising was the not the acute kind of traumatic brain injury thing from IEDs, although that is underreported and and and comes with an awful lot of challenges in terms of treatment and and diagnosis and so on. But the fact that repeated exposure to blast can cause serious neurological damage down the line that may not be symptomatic until many years later, that was a mate, that was like a really and so then I kind of started reading some of the papers on it or the abstracts and the and so on.

SPEAKER_00I'm not not scientifically trained, but I've you know started trying to find counterviews. And where's the other side of this argument? Where's the science that's uh this disappears to be true, you know, at least as far as the science takes us, there's a lot we don't know, right? So I think the idea that our own weapons that the blast overpressure from our own weapon systems are causing brain damage, and that that brain damage is kind of cumulative in a way that's not entirely understood, but that at some point that can come become symptomatic years down the line, perhaps long after you've left the military, perhaps when you're in a health system where you're going to see a GP who has no idea what you're talking about, uh, and that this is frequently being diagnosed, therefore, as something else adjustment disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, anxiety, whatever it might be.

SPEAKER_00That was amazing to me. And then you think, well, this must be quite niche. How big is this? I mean, what's the scale of this? And the answer is we don't know, but I think it's far bigger than than than anyone's admitting at the moment officially. Uh and I and I think, I mean, I say we don't know. I mean, I d we don't know. It's not just journalists that don't know. I generally don't think the MOD know. I think I think that's it it is an unknown. But there's an interesting comparison between the American figures, uh, where they've got over 400,000 diagnosed cases amongst their serving service personnel, and and the UK figures, which are a fraction of that.

SPEAKER_00Um and that's been rationalized by people saying that you know that the in the United States TBI is overdiagnosed in order so that people qualify for veterans healthcare, which you know, lifelong healthcare, which is not as we have a obviously a different system with the NHS. And so that doctors are saying, Well, you know, we're gonna give you this so that you have a code that allows you to access healthcare. The other that's that will be that's said a lot by people linked to the MOD or by some some sort of there there's a it's a something that you hear from time to time.

SPEAKER_00But the alternative is there's there's another possibility, right? And the other possibility is that we're underdiagnosing it because I'm going to my GP and saying I've got these symptoms. These symptoms overlap with PTSD, with adjustment disorder, with depression. The GP doesn't recognise them, sends me to a psychiatrist, I get a mental health diagnosis, and what I've got is not a psychiatric condition. You know, you know from talking to many and so on. What I've got is a physical injury sustained either in an off combat or potentially having never been deployed operationally, potentially this could be sustained by exposure to mortars, shoulder fired anti-tank weapons, sniper rifles of the heavier caliber sniper rifles, all the things that we know cause blast over pressure over a a certain amount to a damaging amount.

SPEAKER_00So that to me was staggering. I found that amazing. And and so that. Obviously hooked me in as a journalist, right? Why don't I know about this? Why haven't I heard about this? Um, and the other thing that was a that really kind of got me set on it was speaking to Kate England. Have you come across Kate England?

SPEAKER_01Kate England's been on the podcast. Kate Eng's been on the podcast. And um glad to call her a friend, and her husband James, actually, yeah.

SPEAKER_00So I think I said before that one of the great things about my job is meeting some of the people you meet who are just inspiring and inspirational people who are against all the odds doing incredible things. And you know, she's one of those people that's not only holding together a family, caring for James full-time, but also campaigning on this. She's like absolute expertise on it is incredible, but also just the energy to keep campaigning, keep fighting, not take no for an answer. So, you know, she's so I thought having spoken to her, I was just right, uh, this is the story I want to come at.

SPEAKER_00This is something I want to do. So so I've been slowly, bit by bit, working on it ever since. And it's it's it's a fascinating intellectually, and B, it's like, why isn't something being done?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean it thing is, it makes when I interviewed Mandy there, it sounded like it was the same penny, it was a you know, it was a penny drop, it was a shock moment, but also like a penny drop moment into how you know one of those things you go, oh my god, actually, yeah, it makes total sense. You know, if you think about so if you think about uh boxes and what uh a Parkinson's disease is an example, or or an other psychological issue that they get, or or physiological issue that they get, because of repeated blows to the head.

SPEAKER_01Now, those repeated blows to the head, sorry, those illnesses aren't caused by the glove hitting the skin of the face, those illnesses are caused by the shockwave going through the head, you know, and and it's the same with you know for for for people who are ignorant to this, not not not I don't mean ignorant in a negative way, I mean ignorant is because you just never experienced it. You know, when you're in the military, even just firing a normal, you know, a small caliber weapon, you shoot those things, you've got a you've got basically a small explosion happening right next to your head in the barrel, and you know, you get a you get a you get a blast wave come out the end of the barrel, uh, and has a certain shape profile depending on the weapon system that you're using.

SPEAKER_01And that you feel that in your head. It's literally the bigger the caliber you mentioned there, the bigger the calibre weapon or changes in the environment in which you're shooting the weapon, your your head feels like it's going to explode. You know, I you you see on TV uh like uh someone in a car, say the obvious one's in the car in a building, and they're firing a shotgun or a pistol in a vehicle, for example. And I always look at it and go, and you know, they'll carry on talking or something afterwards. The scene carries on. And I'm looking at it and thinking, he wouldn't be carrying on with that conversation, he wouldn't be carrying on.

SPEAKER_01For one, no one would be able to hear anything. And for two, one of you is probably say it's four people in the car, one of you is probably gonna be in excruciating pain, excruciating pain from that enclosed blast in there. It is it it is horrific. And uh and and and and so it doesn't surprise me that of people who are regularly firing weapons or being around explosions, because that's what they are, the explosions, are gonna have issues.

SPEAKER_00It's not even completely surprised me. I it surprised me. It's maybe my uh maybe that points to my kind of my ignorance anymore, perhaps more than anything else. But I was just uh I I I was just staggered by that.

SPEAKER_01It also doesn't surprise it surprised me, right? But what I'm not saying I wasn't surprised, I'm saying that it also made total sense when I sort of went, okay, actually it makes total sense, you know. Uh and the fact that this symptoms can be delayed onset for a long time also doesn't surprise me because from the conversation with Mandy, and then I had follow-on conversations with Mark Gordon, we went a lot more scientific on it. Uh Mark Gordon, American doctor, yeah, you know, I've mentioned him to you, who's who's on the on the US side is you know, is doing the equivalent of what Mandy's doing, you know, flying the flag, pushing it forward, but also he's on the science side, research and testing and development of of uh treatments, preventions and treatments of blast TBIs.

SPEAKER_01Um uh he was you know, the way he explained it to me is it's it's it's not uh so much a physical impact, you know. A lot of the bla a lot of the TBIs, so blast TBIs, you would you would struggle to find physical evidence of it, but you wouldn't struggle to find physiologic like neuro physic neurophysiological evidence of it. You know, you're more likely to find uh hormone imbalances in the brain because of it. And so when as the evidence of it, you know, the hormones are not being produced in a way that is normal because of because of the experience of the blast.

SPEAKER_01Now, over time, as we get older, um obviously our bodies change and the way our hormone balances change.

SPEAKER_00I think we're there's a kind of breakthrough that we're close to, I think, which is that the Boston, the Department of Defence uh uh scientists in Boston, Daniel Pearl and McKee, uh, think they've identified a pattern. I'm not sure if they've published on this yet. I don't think they have, but I think they they Daniel Pearl has done some interviews with Daniel Pearl. Yeah, P-E-R-L. He's one of the sort of leading um neuropathologists in this field, or is working in this field. He's identified a pattern at autopsy that is specific to blast.

SPEAKER_00So previously, so there was always this issue of, but have they had concussions in the past? And if you're talking about soldiers, if you're talking about particular infantry and and teeth arms who are more vulnerable to this for obvious reasons, lots of rugby players, lots of boxers, lots of people who have a punch up on Friday night in a bar, lots of just active people who have head injuries anyway, right? So there was a kind of well, how do we differentiate between you know, how can we say this is blast?

SPEAKER_00Yes, we we accept that there's brain injury here, the the scan shows that, or the symptoms show that, or whatever, but that's if you're lucky enough to get beyond a psychiatric diagnosis. Then there's this kind of you know, but how do we how do we attribute it to blast? And I think what's happening now, and I'm I'm not the expert on this, I just ask the questions and and you know, trying to absorb as much knowledge as as I can, but I'm totally no scientific training, no scientific background, you know, zip. So I'm very far from an expert.

SPEAKER_00But I think what's happening now is that they've having they've identified a pattern at autopsy that is specific to blast. So I think that allows Oh really? Yeah, and so that's that there's a CT CTE related. No, it's not CTE. Okay, it's not CTE, it's separate from CTE. It's essentially so you remember that CTE, for instance, there was a large discussion about whether or not it it's caused by impact. And eventually it was agreed scientifically that there is no other cause for CTE.

SPEAKER_00You can't get CTE in any other way. Uh, and I think the science is heading in that way with blast, where it can be identified, or it will be possible to identify autopsy signatures of blast TBI that as distinct from blunt trauma or other things. That seems to be where it's going, to the best of my knowledge. Um, so that's a potential key, a potential breakthrough, a potential way forward. The other key, it seems to me, is neuroimaging has advanced now to an incredible degree where brain damage can be identified very, very, very specifically and very accurately.

SPEAKER_00What they can't do with neuroimaging at the moment is say specifically this is caused by blast. Um, but in a sense, you don't necessarily need to, right? If I've not had other head trauma, if I've not if I have a history of blast exposure and I don't have a history of other head trauma and I've got physical brain injury, one can make a working assumption, right? So I think neuroimaging is is is heading rapidly in the direction of it being able to be diagnostic, which it's not at the moment.

SPEAKER_00Um so you know, there is progress on this, there is movement on this, mostly from the States, but in fairness to the MOD, they they have invested money in it. There is a, you know, they are researching it. Um, but there's a lot of things that aren't happening. Uh uh, it seems to me, and you know, it's not my job to campaign on these things or to to sort of have opinions, but it it seems to me reasonable that what we know about it now, which is a quite a lot compared to let's say a decade ago, uh, the World College of GPs doctors have a leaflet that goes to all GPs and dealing with veterans, specific veterans' healthcare issues.

SPEAKER_00So we're more likely to have hearing loss, uh, joint problems, back problems. There are certain sort of health issues.

SPEAKER_01Because it's our age, Paul, or because it might be.

SPEAKER_00You know, I never carried I always tried not to carry too much weight, so I'm alright, my back's alright, but my hearing's shot. Um, so so there's this leaflet that goes to GPs with these sort of you know, and psychological problems, PTSD and so on that tries to help them to help to recognise problems that might be specific to veterans, and that's a good thing, right? No mention of TBI on this leaflet, nothing. Could be there, should be there. Um, NICE don't approve neuroimaging at the moment. Nice for the National Institute of Clinical Excellence, who approve treatments, drugs, medicines, and so on.

SPEAKER_00At the moment, they don't approve neuroimaging. Neuroimaging is at a level now where it can do incredible things. I I'm not sure why that's where we are in that process, whether that's something that's imminent or whether it's just something that's not even in progress, I don't know. Uh coroner's officers. Sad to say, but we know that there's a link between TBI, civilian TBI, normal TBI, road crash TBI, right? We know there's a link between that and higher higher rates of suicide. That's clear in the literature couldn't be clearer.

SPEAKER_00So does it not follow logically then that if we know veterans are at high risk of blast TBI, does it not follow logically that in some of those cases people take their own lives as a consequence or with DBI? And if that does follow logically, why aren't inquests dealing with that? So we've looked through uh I mean loads of inquest reports, a series of prevention and future death reports, but also press reporting of inquests. We've seen every red flag for TBI on some of these terribly sad cases, right?

SPEAKER_00Every red flag for TBI, and it's not just not been discussed. The families don't know about it, the coroner's offices aren't talking about it, so therefore, brain donation's not happening, and without brain donation at the moment, one can't say. So everything's about PTSD, and and the the the two, as you know, can co can coincide, they can occur together, uh, and whatever. So I'm not in any way belittling PTSD or any mental health health sort of thing. You know, nobody's suggesting that they're not real, real and pressing problems, but but here's something else, and why is that something else not being also looked at?

SPEAKER_00So, you know, there's a whole awareness thing that should be happening, and you know, partly that's to do with the media, but but the government could be doing this, right? I don't see why people we should be alert to this. GPs should know about this.

SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, it's this is this is I remember, you know, I remember when I was talking to Mandy, um, and that that sh you know Mandy, she gets very animated about this, and and right, so Marcus as well, to be fair. And I think it's what one of the one of the worst things about this, you you you touched on it there, is that there are so many people um that should be around today, would be around today, if if during the uh during the diagnosis and during the treatment of let's say PDSD, let's choose PDSD as an example, uh during that initial assess those initial assessments and when they were getting being looked at, been spoken to to work out what the problem was, is that so up until very recently, almost exclusively, that was only a conversation about this their psychiatric state, and the only things that were considered for treating them were psychiatric, psychological measures, you know, um, and and so and omitting and neglecting the neurophysiological side, you know.

SPEAKER_01Uh and there are people who who I know people now who've just had a this thankfully they're still here. You know, how they sit here, I don't know, because they've had a miserable existence for a long time, ex-military. Um, and they've done everything that all of the standard treatments that they can go through, CBT, the uh EMDR, all these things, medication, go round the houses, and nothing, nothing gets into a position where they're okay.

SPEAKER_01It's like nothing is working for them, you know. And and it again, back to that penny drop moment. It seems madness to me now, in hindsight, granted, that you wouldn't uh do uh assess both things, this psychological pro uh situation and the physiological situation. And and Mark Gordon's sorry, and Mark Gordon's uh and Mandy, what they both think is the correct approach here when someone presents with issues, let's again PDSD, whatever those symptoms of the PDS, yeah, whatever those symptoms of PDSD could be depression, anxiety, mood swings, you know, whatever, uh substance abuse, whatever.

SPEAKER_01Is that the first they they argue that the first thing that should the first thing that should be looked at is the neurophysiological side. What is the because that can be easily addressed, straight away easily addressed, right? It's not it's not a grey area. So that's and then see what the and then see what psychological so treat that first, get the hormones to where they think they should be, and then look at what psychological symptoms remain. So their argument is that that would address most of the issues. Most of these people would not have.

SPEAKER_00I think that's where we where we need to go, but but but there are there are a number of problems. One of the problems is we don't know much about it. There's so much we don't know about it, it's incredibly it's very heterogeneous as a condition. It being what? TBI, blast TBI. But but so so for T PTSD, to your point there, one of the diagnostic criteria for PTSD is that you rule out physical causes, that you've ruled out other causes. Oh, you mentioned this on the phone to me, actually, yeah. So you you in order to diagnose post-traumatic stress disorder, you should have already ruled out physical causes.

SPEAKER_00So the the problem comes in like how do you do that? Do you do that symptomatically? At the moment, you can only really do that symptomatically. So there are symptoms of TBI that aren't necessarily common to psychiatric disorders, sensitivity to light, sensitivity to noise, headaches, and so on. So there is a if you combine history, blast exposure, uh, and even that's hard to measure, right? Because it's all about the patient looking backwards at their own blast exposure, and that that's subjective. You know, a lot of us are like, oh, it was nothing. You know, it's a military thing, isn't it? To to to understate everything, to downplay everything.

SPEAKER_00Um, but to try to ascertain a sort of history of blast exposure, obviously, and then you try and and symptomatically, and that's at the moment, that's all they've got. So there's one guy I spoke to online who was referred to a psychiatrist. Psychiatrist went, I think somewhere else going on here, referred them to a uh neurologist who then scanned them. And although the scan's not diagnostic because then I haven't approved it, it's a useful tool, right? And and diagnose them with TBI.

SPEAKER_00One person um that I've spoken to. I think what happens normally is not that I think what happens normally is that people present and end up with a diagnosis of PTSD that doesn't respond to treatment in the way that it should, because PTSD is treatable largely and then it's C PTSD, and then they're like, Well you're comp you're too complex to we can't help you, you're too complex.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. Yeah, and then yeah.

SPEAKER_00And and that's what's the scale of this, right? What's the what A, what's the spectrum of it? You know, because we the people we speak to that we meet that we that we talk to tend to be at the far end because because it's so little known, you have to be right on the that end of the spectrum for it to be well, this must be TBI, right? But is there a sort of spectrum of symptoms concentration, balance, you know, memory short-term memory loss? Is there a could you just have a little bit of those things and be done?

SPEAKER_00Um probably, it seems likely. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Are there thousands of people affected by blast over pressure? Tens of thousands? Is that possible? Uh we don't know. Is it well is it possible? Yeah, it is possible. I mean we don't know, but it's certain it's got to be possible, right? So so yeah, that is uh A that as a piece of journalism that's fascinating. And B as a kind of public interest, from a public interest point of view, these these these are men and women who've whose damage directly relates to their service, right?

SPEAKER_00And are not being that that's something that every government every government claims that you know everyone likes to wrap themselves in veterans' welfare politically speaking, right? Every party. And in you know, in fairness, various governments have done you know good things for that, uh including this one. So it's they do it's not just words, but here's a problem that that it seems to me more needs to be done on. Um and as again, as a journalist, that's that's something that you know that's a duty.

SPEAKER_00Let's let's play the drum, let's see what we can see where we can put pressure on here uh to effect change in a positive way. Because it's not just about the really interesting thing as well, not interesting, but again, one of those penny drop things was people suffering from this without having been deployed operationally, even. So I'm not sure if you're familiar with the guy in Maine, Robert Card, is shot. It's one of the sort of many spree killings in America that have become so kind of almost normalized that we we kind of don't remember one from the other, uh, which is horrific.

SPEAKER_00Um, but this guy shot, I don't recall, 16 or 18 people dead, uh, injured another large number of people. He was in the National Guard, the sort of the reserves for many years, 20 years or something. Never deployed, never went to Iraq, never went to Afghanistan, never had an operational tour. But he was a grenade instructor, and that was his job with his local National Guard. So he was on the grenade range day in, day out, subject to repeated low-level blasts over a very long period of time. So when the campaigners uh on this in the States heard about that, they uh requested that his brain be submitted for autopsy.

SPEAKER_00So his brain went to the experts at Boston, and guess what? Serious brain damage, physical brain damage. Um never deployed. So that's very worrying. So is there a whole not only is there an issue with suicide, but the answer is almost certainly yes, right? There's also an issue here with the criminal justice system. And you know, we've I know you've spoken in the past about you know veterans in the criminal justice system and the problems with that. Well are we looking at are we looking at that as well potentially?

SPEAKER_00And again, the answer is probably gonna be yes, right?

SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, exactly. One what you know, one of the one of the common things with uh um spoken about with regards to CTE, with regards to TBI, on the US side, and different different uh things I listen to over there is the link between sort of uh high-level athletes who are in contact sports and exhibit extremely erratic behavior, you know, uh similar to that which we see with PTSD victims.

SPEAKER_01Now, um Martin Gordon will say, if you speak to Mark, have you spoken to Mark? No, I can I'll link you up with him if you want. He's a he's an em like and he loves talking, and he's he's a piece of brilliant source of information, right? Um you know, cutting edge stuff on on this subject. Martin Gordon will say it to you that there is no such thing as PTSD. That's what he was saying. That's a very well but you know, so what do you say? What he will say is so so you know, we I that Pete we use PTSD as the we we would say, oh he's got PTSD, or she's got PTSD, that and we say that as the illness.

SPEAKER_01Now, the way so what Mark's point is, he would say that there is no such thing as PTSD, as that's the illness. Uh, and what he means by that is this is my interpretation of it, is that and how I come and this is what I think now as well, right? I so when I hear someone's got PTSD, immediately what I think is okay, I view that term as that is a description of it's a description of a common set of symptoms, one or more from a bank of these symptoms, right?

SPEAKER_01And also, and also the cause of those symptoms, the mechanism of injury and the cause of the symptoms. I don't think PTSD is an illness per se. I think there's a good description of common symptoms. So what the what the mechanism of injury is.

SPEAKER_00I think there's two separate things there, right? And I'm not an expert, and sorry to cut across you there. I think it's two separate questions. One is you know, is there such a thing as PTSD independent of physical damage? I think the answer to that has to be yes, that there is, and I've spoken to quite a few people about that because there's some science to that, right? Yeah. That that that does suggest that that the two are so inextricably linked, that one doesn't exist without the other, or some suggestions of that. So what are intrinsic in PTSD and physical damage? But we have PTSD is common in survivors of domestic violence, in survivors of sexual assault and violence, and so on, in in circumstances where there's no actual physical damage, headphones on it yeah, but they're those are but the cause of that though, Paul.

SPEAKER_01The cause of that is is not psychological, it's a neurophysiological cause, it's a neuroendocological endocrine issue. Okay, and and again, this is this is from Mark Gordon and other people's research on it.

SPEAKER_00That's an area I'm not familiar with. So let me just explain it.

SPEAKER_01Let me just explain for you for one second, then I I thought it's well we probably did spoke about this before, but we maybe I didn't. So there's a great documentary called um, I think it's called Quiet Explosions. I think it's called Made in America, right? And it's about it's all about TBI. Now, I don't know where you can get it. I think it's on Vimeo. I highly recommend anyone that can go and get it, and if he has to pay for it, pay for it. I strongly suggest if you've got any interest in this. Long story short, in this in the documentary, it covers maybe five or six different people, subjects who are who are suffering from PDSD like symptoms.

SPEAKER_01Put PDSD, right? Or I mean there's a couple on there who are football, American football players, they're suffering from symptoms. If they were soldiers or sailors or airmen, you'd call it PDSD, yeah, right? But they're not, so it doesn't get called PTSD. So five or six of them. Now uh most of them have had head trauma or been around weapons, shooting, whatever. Okay, you go, okay, yeah, makes sense. These are TBIs, that maybe been mislabelled as PTSD. I get it. Uh apart from the football player, which is obviously repeated uh concussion to the head.

SPEAKER_01One of the people on there is a is a uh uh US Navy, a female US Navy. Never been around uh prolonged exposure to weapons. Like the last time she used weapons was when she was in training. The role she was in the Navy never touched them, was never around any artillery, uh I'd say artillery on ship, anything like this, nothing, never repeated blows to the head. Her symptoms are exactly the same, and her and her neurophysiological condition is exactly the same as the others who have had the fit have been exposed physically, yeah, exactly the same.

SPEAKER_01And the reason I say about the so uh someone who gets PTSD from a near-death experience, for example, or uh a rape or something like this, where there's no head trauma, is because the the br the the the brain goes into the fight or flight mode, it has a and these people it has a an extreme reaction, uh, which is a normal reaction, you know, fight or flight, all the hormones kick in that go, you need to survive here. But they the the the changes don't so normally what would happen is you get out of that life-threatened situation, you you know, you you deal with it emotionally, and then your neuroendrocological system resets itself back to normal.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01In the the US Navy lady, for example, in her case, it doesn't, right? Then and the the the neuroendorcological system stays in the state that is the same is this is in the same state as what the people who had the physical interaction. It's the same thing. So Ram's saying it's not PDS no, I'm sorry, not PDSD, it's not psychological. It is a it is a physiological created condition which manifests itself as a visibly psychologist.

SPEAKER_00That's beyond my knowledge. Uh I'm not that's not something I've come across, and obviously I've I think I've spoken to seven or eight I am also not an expert. Leading new neurologists on this in this uh six six actually neurologists who are in this sphere, and it's quite a small world. Yeah. Uh you know, TBI research is not uh it's not a there's not like millions of medics who are who who are into this sort of things in in this this space. So um so that's not something that's not something I've I've come across or investigated. I I it's not something I have any knowledge of.

SPEAKER_00But I think that there is another there is the other interesting thing is is you know whether whether you know TBI can be a cause of PTSD. Uh I know Mandy feels that very strongly that it that it is a cause of PTSD. I think it's the primary. And and and and I think that's that's uh uh uh again, that's not there's there's there's scientific studies that suggest that. It's I don't think it's by any means broadly accepted amongst people in that space. But is it possible? I think it's possible. I don't think you can at this stage with the knowledge we have, I don't think you can rule it out.

SPEAKER_00I think it's a possible cause of PTSD. I think you can say that is something that that is is is I need to connect your book. But I m my view is like as a journalist, right? I'm going with there's a danger, right, that you get you get that kind of do they call it confirmation bias, or you know, where if you look hard enough for something, you find it everywhere. And there's a danger if you get wrapped up uh uh too closely in a in a in a sort of subject, you frame everything around that subject, and you're in danger of going beyond what the science allows you to do.

SPEAKER_00And I'm really conscious that that that that you know the the things that are kind of agreed on by the leading scientists here that they that there is consensus on are so shocking anyway that there's enough to deal with with that alone. And and it's but you're you're absolutely right, there are possibilities beyond that, right? There are possibilities beyond that, it's no question, but I'm not going there because I'm already. What do you mean? What do you mean? So, in terms of things that are not scientific, so scientifically, there is no dispute about certain things.

SPEAKER_00There is no dispute that blast over blast overpressure over a certain PSI causes brain damage, right? Everyone's agreed on that. Everyone's agreed that repetitive blast exposure over a certain PSI, that either that form of damage can have an effect cumulatively over time that is causes serious neurological effects, right? The type of damage, the symptoms are broadly agreed on. Um so uh it's agreed that sort of major concussions, particularly when they're repeated, can cause long-term neurological effects.

SPEAKER_00So there's all these sorts of things that are there's no real dispute over these things. Um so that's kind of where I'm happy because all the leading neurologists agree with these things, even them, even the Ministry of Defence. Uh they don't they don't say no, this isn't true, they dispute the scale of it or they question the scale of it. They say, you know, well, we don't know, we're investigating. Um one of the interesting things. But so but moving into stuff like a a whether TBI causes PTSD, there are some scientific studies that suggest that's possible, but it's by no means is a consensus.

SPEAKER_00I mean, it's not a consensus. Okay, so a question of it. The other point you made as well is is you know, that's not that's not generally accepted. That doesn't mean it's wrong. But again, we were talking about mainstream media in your words, right? And and being responsible and so on. Well, that's you know, I'm I'm taking a very conservative small C view about what we look at and what we report. But that that doesn't mean the other things are wrong.

SPEAKER_01It just means that that's what are the uh just I'm trying to just a question in your research. Questioning your research. So from what you research, what are the what are the common symptoms, psychological symptoms of TBI?

SPEAKER_00Well, this is there's a there's some kind of some quite good stuff. There's some graphics on this on I don't want them. I don't want to like it the whole list, but just well, yeah, yeah. I mean I'd struggle to do the whole list to be honest, but as as I understand it, there are sort of symptoms that are common to PTSD.

SPEAKER_01TBI I'm talking about.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there are symptoms that are that overlap. There are symptoms that are more associated with TBI than with PTSD. Examples would be sensitivity to light and noise, uh dizziness, um, short-term memory loss, headaches, but migraine type headaches. Um, those are sorts of symptoms where you would think, uh, you might think red flag TBI here, if you were a medic, as far as I understand it.

SPEAKER_00Then there are things that are specific to PTSD, like flashbacks. You don't, you know, from TBI, you don't get flashbacks for if TBI is your only problem, for instance. You know, that immediate sense of being somewhere else or being in a place that's dangerous as well.

SPEAKER_01The thing is with the flashbacks, the thing is with the flashbacks and PTSD, right? Is that people think flashbacks are common to PTSD. Flashbacks, flashbacks are pretty they're not a common thing amongst people who suffer from PTSD. They're just an obvious one that people are.

SPEAKER_00But it's it's just all of these things, right, are a spectrum. You can have one symptom and not the other. You can have uh a constellation of these, you know, there's a complex kind of constellation, if you like, of different symptoms, some of which are you know commonly associated with TBI in civilians or in other spheres of life, some of which are more so it's not a kind of simple checklist of like tick, tick, tick, or you know, or you've only got one of those, therefore you're not, you're not, you know, you're not afflicted. That that's it it's not that simple. Um I mean, even the the sort of leading neurologist, we interviewed the the a sort of professor of neurology uh uh and uh experimental neuropathology at uh Oxford, which is a fantastic job title, a guy called Gabriel De Luca.

SPEAKER_00Um we interviewed him for for one of our reports on this, and and you know, he he really stressed that you know this is incredibly complex. And that that we the thing he said that sort of stuck with me as a as a kind of really good explanation is that you know we've got into this way of looking at the world where you have the mind, you know, the conscious mind and the brain, and we separate them as if they're yeah, as if they're two different things, and then the body, and of course, of course, uh you know, everything that that that goes on is a series of electrical impulses through the brain.

SPEAKER_00That is your that is your mind sort of thing. We it's not right to separate them. We need to think of them more holistically, and and that and that neurologists, neuropathologists, psychiatrists, neuropsychiatrists need to be you know joining up on this because all of them have expertise in a particular sphere, and that that that you know that the way through this is is for all these disciplines to kind of work more closely together. Yeah, these um the So I thought it was really interesting. Sorry, one other thing it that the same guy said to me that that it was a you know another is this analogy with smoking that you know we know it does you harm, but it's cumulatively over time, you know, you don't have a cigarette when you're 12 at school or whatever and then die from it.

SPEAKER_00You bit by bit by bit by bit. Suddenly, when you're 50, you get stroke, arsac, lung cancer diagnosis or whatever it is. And similarly with smoking, we didn't know everything about it before we acted. Right? We banned smoking, we banned cigarette sales to children long before we knew what the pathological, exactly what all the pathological links were between smoking and lung cancer, for instance. What we knew was there was a huge statistical association between smokers and health problems in later life. We knew that. What we didn't know is exactly how cigarettes cause this type of cancer, right?

SPEAKER_00But we didn't need to know every single thing about it to act. We acted and we banned smoking. And since then we've done more and more and more to to marginalise smoking and so on, right? But the same thing, it seems to me, applies here, right? We don't know everything about this, a lot we don't know about it, but what we do know is it exists, we do know it's a problem, we do know it's almost certain to be at some scale. So my question as a journalist would be why aren't we acting?

SPEAKER_01Why aren't we acting acting? Yeah. Why aren't we doing things?

SPEAKER_00I yeah, I I mean specific things like for instance, uh you know, nice urgently looking at looking at brain scans as a diagnostic tool, like GPs referring to the Royal College of GPs making sure that that TBI is something that GPs know about, those sorts of things, awareness things, they're not they don't cost anything.

SPEAKER_01No, they don't. I agree. I mean the thing is yeah, the the subject can be complex, but I think where it comes to coming back to the treatment or identification of the pro the core, you know, the the cause of a uh of someone being mentally sub, you know, mentally compromised in whatever way. We're gonna look at this again. Let's use the PDSD example, or someone presents with obvious symptoms that look like the PDSD, right?

SPEAKER_01Now yes psychology is complicated, uh yes, it's difficult to get to the root cause analysis uh the root cause of things. Um, but the the argument the the the suggestion and the frustration from Mark and from both Mandy and many other people know is that their frustration is that it is it it is a no-brainer, not pun intended, it's a no-brainer, it is pertinently obvious to them and I think and and to me after speaking to them, obviously, so I'm in that echo chamber that if someone presents with a psychological issue depression, anxiety, whatever, that the the first thing that should be done, apart from immediate care and you know, these people are suicidal.

SPEAKER_01Remember, the the the first thing, one of the very first things should be done, is to uh test their neuroendocronological level, their brain hormones, to see where those are at. You test those, you measure them against the common baseline across the population. We have that baseline, you have a baseline of what it should be. And it there's fluctuations in different people, different hormones, what it should be, what the baseline is, but generally we know where what the what the uh what the range they should each one should each hormone should be in. You test those, you see where the deficiencies lie, and let's say one or two areas need to be increased or decreased.

SPEAKER_01Then you try and then through treatment and this so supplementation is uh one way one way of doing it, literally taking medication on a daily basis, natural medication, which not uh yeah, non-harmful, should we say very few side effects to get your hormones back to a baseline where they should be, you take those, you get the hormones to where they should be as close as you can, as best you can, and then you see what psychological symptoms remain, and then you treat the psychological symptoms because the assumption is based on their research and experience with treating veterans here in the UK and in the USA is that when you treat the hormones first, the neuroendocnologically and neuroendocnological system first, it reduces the psychological symptoms.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely does. What's also interesting about this is that and what and when you speak to Mark, he he will I think I mentioned it to you as well. What's interesting about this is when you accept that to be the case, and if you believe this to be the case based on the the evidence, it means not only can you put in more effective treatment for people suffering from PTSD, okay, life-changing treatment, which is relatively cheap and relatively quick.

SPEAKER_01Uh you can also put in protocols within the military, which Mark Gordon is doing now. I know he's doing it informally with people uh on the Welsh border, special forces in that area of the world, and he's also doing it with special forces special forces units in the USA. You can preemptively supplement, so literally adjust your diet, take on additional supplementation uh to bolster the hormones in the brain that they know are most commonly affected by blast, by, by uh, by repeated exposure to the blast.

SPEAKER_01And in doing so, even when you're a special forces or any soldier, say Larry Emmanuel who's going to go into battle or do it, or even just training, you know, whatever, and you shoot, you know, going to be in these environments. Uh, it goes the same for sports. So, contact sports, American football players, rugby players, boxing, you can you can basically up-armour the brain to be less likely to uh to uh be subject to a TBI from what you're doing, or at the very minimum, less likely to have real bad symptoms from a TBI you may or may not get anyway.

SPEAKER_01You can literally supplement to protect yourself, which which should be so and I know you said the MOD are looking into this. I'd be interested to see exactly how they're looking into it because they're probably worried about I they have to be worried about um you know lawsuits and things like this because they hear probably got in the minute.

SPEAKER_00Well, one of the big things that that they're doing in the States as well as the UK is looking at biomarker, looking for biomarkers as a diagnostic. So large numbers of diseases or dysfunctions or whatever create reactions which are measurable in in the body, chemicals or whatever. So i is it possible that glass TBI could create unique biomarkers that can be measured or can be, you know, with a blood test or a urine test or whatever it might be.

SPEAKER_00So something cheap, simple, something that can be scaled up very quickly, and something that's portable that can be taken out into Afghanistan or you know, wherever it's needed. So that's an area of research. Uh in terms of hormones and the neuroendocrine system, it's quite complex. There's a lot of the what I've read, as far as I've read, which which is I I go back to a lot, I'm not an expert, I just ask the questions, and uh you know, I uh I've read fairly widely honestly of trying to do a piece on it. Is is there's it's a slightly mixed picture.

SPEAKER_00In as much as it it's it's almost certain that there is a connection between blast, it's almost certain that you know there is some connection between uh uh pituitary dysfunction, the pituitary clone, which sort of regulates hormones, and blast that that you know that that there is a relationship there. But it it's not universally accepted that that so some of the science in the United States, which is fascinating, says suggesting that 40% of combat infantrymen, for instance, have uh lowered uh testosterone, for instance.

SPEAKER_00Uh testosterone and and growth hormone are the two main ones that they seem seem to crop up in the world.

SPEAKER_01Oh, I didn't know about the growth hormone.

SPEAKER_00Okay, they that seems to be just from my reading of the literature, I'm totally not uh I go back to it. I'm like, you know, scrape through my O's and A's, and that's me. So but but just from sort of trying to get across the science as coming out of the states. Now that's disputed because measuring hormones, I know this is somebody who had a pituitary tumor, so I I'm reasonably uh I'm familiar from the kind of operating what's it called, the user end of with endocrinology rather than rather than the science. If you like, is that they measure it, they like to measure your levels repeatedly over a period of time, over quite a long period of time.

SPEAKER_00So where the science snapshots a population and says this is true, that's not considered brilliant science because you're not following it up over a period of time. It's not ideal. And the other thing is that there are that there's a kind of series of tests that they like to do. Not all the science in the States has done is it's not as rigorous as perhaps it might be. If you really wanted to like, you know, if you wanted to, if you were funded to end-to-end research this, because the a lot of the point about research that we don't really consider, right, as non-scientists, is that if your funding is X, right, your research will allow you to do Y, because that's what you're funded for.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And if your funding is like much bigger, you can do much more. So for instance, there's uh the advanced study that's happening at the moment in the UK, which is like it looking at a whole series of long-term health outcomes from people who've been caught up in IEDs and such like, uh is potentially really interesting in terms of TBI, right? We don't know what their conclusions are yet. But what what I I'm told, and I don't know this 100%, but I believe from having read their you know what they've put online and and and what I'm told that they're not specifically looking at hormones at testosterone and growth hormone about the pychuriotry, the neuroendocrine system.

SPEAKER_00That seems to be like a massively wasted opportunity, right? To because this is fairly thorough, fairly well researched cohort study over a long period of time. So it's in terms of science, it's good science. So you know, it would be a shame. If it were doing that, it would be that would be that would help to answer all of these questions, right? This study doesn't appear, as far as I could see, the study isn't doing that, and I think that's a real shame. And that's how it and that's presumably because it's not funded to do that. Part of the point, but I do think that some of the some of the sort of headlines about the neuroendocrine stuff don't bear an awful lot of scrutiny.

SPEAKER_00That's not to say that what you're talking about is not true. That's totally not what I'm saying. It's not to say that that that there's not a relationship between between blast, between TBI, and between neuroendocrine problems. There I'm pretty sure there is, uh, but I think it's complex. And I think j I just speaking as a journalist, you know, i in terms of what I would report, y it's it's difficult. Yeah. There's there's a there's a sort of there are things that everyone agrees on and there's an awful lot that everyone doesn't.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but what the problem the problem is on this topic, right? I d I So I'm the brain's complex, science is complex, but what I don't agree with is is how overcomplicated the is being is being made out uh about this the protocol of treat the hormones first, see what remains after. That is not that's not a complicated situation because we know the range should be so ideally like you were saying ideally we would know an individual's baseline of hormone levels.

SPEAKER_00But I think there are some issues again. I'll be corrected by by I'll be corrected if I'm wrong because I I'm a layman here, but yeah, I think if you treat, for instance, if you take testosterone supplements, your brain adj adjusts to having those supplements, and therefore it doesn't produce so that's so for instance I had very low testosterone as a result of a high-turfy tumor and very low, and um and it was monitored over a period of time, and my endocrinologist who is who who was excellent was like, Look, we we can give we we can we can kind of help in terms of short term, right?

SPEAKER_00We can give you testosterone supplements. The danger with that is that your brain then adjusts what's required to that and then you're stuck with that flow.

SPEAKER_01That is not the that is not the pro so from Mark's so for Mark's side, that is not the protocol. So it is not so though in that supplementation I'm talking about, it is not giving you the hormones I say wrongly, it's it's not this diet. What I meant by natural is it takes weeks. I think I think it takes because I I did a program of of his the supplements, and uh I if I recall it was three three weeks, I think it was. You take them on a daily basis, and over that three weeks, it it basically is triggering your body to gradually in by understood, yeah, itself produce the hormones it should be producing, right?

SPEAKER_01Now, going back to the point I wanted to make just now, one of the problems with this area of research and this this proposition that hey, actually TBI, you know, tbi is maybe the real cause of what PTSD is, and we should be treated in a different way, or we should be yeah, assessing people in a different way, we should be monitoring this in a different way. One of the main problems with this is the the massive resistance against people like Manley, people like uh Mark, and people like you spoken to on the subject from uh places like Imperial, places which are uh places which are heavily invested in the in psychiatry and and you know what I think that's I think that's changing now.

SPEAKER_00I think that's changing because I think it's changing slowly.

SPEAKER_01It's definitely changed since I spoke to Mandy, but not the way it should be going. I think Mandy, uh sorry for people listening, I spoke to Mandy in 2018 or 2019, that's how long ago that interview was.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Episode 99.

SPEAKER_01Episode 99, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um it seems to me that so science can move slowly. We know it can, we can move very slow. So if you look at there are incredible breakthroughs that you'll read about in the newspaper in terms of, let's say, CAR T therapy for you know stem cell engineering and so on, right? You go to the hospital, and no, this is a trial for the next six years, and then it has to be approved, and then it's not it's not gonna be mainstream medicine for a long time. So medicine generally moves slowly, science moves slowly. It can move an awful lot more quickly, as we found out during COVID, if the funding's there.

SPEAKER_00So there is a there is a kind of question about how much money's going into this, is it enough? Are there you know, other scientists getting all the support they need to to answer these questions, and so on and so forth? Um, but I think we're kind of in the modern age of needing everything to be instant. I think we sometimes get frustrated with how slowly these things work, and sometimes we're right to be frustrated with how uh with how these things go. But sometimes there are genuine intractables, genuine problems, genuine disagreements in the scientific community about what should be done. So, so there is that.

SPEAKER_00I also think, you know, nobody's saying no, this isn't true. I think 10 years ago people would have scoffed at this, and I'm sure Mandy suffered from that, right? And I'm sure the other the other people you reference have suffered from that, and and maybe still do to some extent, but but I don't nobody's saying this isn't the case. There is a an agreement between the leading neurologists in this field that that this exists, that this is a problem. Uh, and so so that's that's a huge leap in in terms of you know, it nobody's saying it doesn't exist, nobody's saying it's not a problem.

SPEAKER_00Where there are there are arguments about the scale, so the in the US they appear to have a problem this big, and in the UK it appears to be that big, and yet our armies are the same, we're doctrinally very similar, our weapon systems are very similar. There's no very few fundamental differences between the US and the UK in terms of blast exposure. You can argue, and it it is argued, and I've seen it argued, that US tours of Iraq and Afghanistan were longer, and therefore there's more intense blast exposure over a particular measurable time.

SPEAKER_00Um, but I'm not sure how much that stands up. You might get US servicemen within eight people might do one tour, UK servicemen might do four tours. I'm not sure how robust that is. And the other point is that it's not taking into account training. So if you're training, if you're a mortar operator and you're firing 81 millimeter mortars, 120 millimeter mortars, it kind of doesn't matter if you're in Afghanistan or if you're in Iowa or if you're in Sunnybridge. You're right, the blast exposure's the same. So you might be putting more rounds down the range in in a combat situation in Afghanistan, true, because there are less restrictions on you know money and training budgets and so on, but you can go through an awful lot of ammo in training as as I know because I did.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, those are those arguments are there, but I uh about sort of scale, about how big a problem it is, and that's it, and about something wanting a kind of perfect diagnostic system, and that's kind of what we hope the MOD are working towards at and we hope that's happening at pace. So I don't think there's like a resistance in that, but you know, if you're if you're having an appalling time in your life, and some of the people are afflicted with this really are, and if that is directly attributable to your service, and I think that's pretty much demonstrable, right, in a lot of these cases, if you've had TBI, you've been exposed to blast.

SPEAKER_00If the pattern of damage, once we get to the point of view of being able to say this isn't rugby, right, which we're not at yet, but once we get there, and I think it will happen, then of course, right, yes, there is a possibility of legal action that follows that. And that's that's does that inform thinking in the MOD? Probably. Probably, I don't know. Yeah, I hope it doesn't inform, but you know, we were talking about journalists earlier on and the guys in the the guys in the top office and what I do. I hope it doesn't inform their scientists. I'm pretty sure it doesn't, you know. Most people are most people are on that's not gonna be top of their mind.

SPEAKER_00But is there somebody in the MOD going, oh my god, if this is true, it's gonna cost me cost us billions. Where's that money gonna come from? Yeah, it may be possible, isn't it?

SPEAKER_01Um Yeah, that's how I say it's likely.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that's not that that won't stop the science, right? That's not gonna stop the science evolving. That's not gonna stop these incredibly dedicated, incredibly intelligent, incredibly motivated guys that I've been speaking to with expertise in neuroimaging, neuropathology, neurology, you know, this is their life, this is what they do, and they're incredibly, incredibly good at it. The science is gonna carry on.

SPEAKER_01So but what it does do, what it does do is it slows down progress, right? Now, if the MOD were, you know, if the danger if the MOD were playing a long game and the sensible game, yeah, right. Let's, you know, I would suggest that they would be that I would suggest that they would have done the mathematics, done the calculations. I don't mean actual calculations, I mean done the logic and gone, hmm. It's highly probable that this is going to be, we're gonna be opened up yours to a bunch of cases of you know, m money, you know, compensation claims like exactly what we're seeing now with hearing claims, which you're going back 20 odd years, you can go back and claim on this stuff.

SPEAKER_01That they're looking at that in the face now. Um I think they think I I'd say they think that's probably reality. They don't know the scale of it, but the longer it drags on, the worse that probably become for them, right? Now, the earlier they get to the earlier they can push to a resolution on what exactly the cause is and how they can prevent things, the earlier they can put protocols in place to lessen the financial burden on them in the future for the soldiers, sailors, men and women of today who could be getting impacted, who would literally join up today, right?

SPEAKER_01Well, this is this is exactly this is so I look, I don't know. And on that, sorry, and on that, the longer it drags on, the longer people have who are out of the military have an absolute miserable time.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and the more people unnecessarily top themselves and could be totally that's a really important point. I think so. Firstly, it it's not my job to guess what the MOD think, you know. What what what the MOD say to me is what I report, or what they, you know, and I don't want to have an oppositional relationship with the MOD based on me conjecturing what might be happening in the corridors of power. That's just not how responsible journalism works, right? They they they put their position, we report their position, that's that. So I've no idea.

SPEAKER_00They might be working at this at pace as hard as they possibly can, blah, blah, blah. The lawsuit might be the furthest thing from their mind, for all I know. I don't know. Uh, and I and I it doesn't it's not necessarily helpful to speculate. What is happening, what you can make as a valid comparison is what's happening in the United States. I don't know if you saw 60 Minutes recently with um uh a a guy called Larkin who was uh unbelievable military CV, was Navy SEAL and then CIA and then everything else, and um it was involved in Washington as a very senior sort of security guy.

SPEAKER_00His son became a Navy SEAL, uh was afflicted with TBI, blast TBI, and took his own life. And uh he did this amazing interview, incredibly powerful interview uh with 60 minutes, and he's been speaking to obviously because of the contacts he has, the connection he has, and the res kind of respect in which he's held has has sort of helped make changes in the sort of you know, special forces community there, certainly the Navy Salesforce, where they are looking at how many rounds you can fire from particular weapon systems without time to recover between them, where they're you know measuring blast.

SPEAKER_00They're making practical measures to reduce blast exposure for a percent to a proportion of US forces. Come back to this thing about smoking, right? We may not know everything about it, but if we accept that blast causes damage and repeated exposures to blast can potentially cause you know, then why not take those? Why not take those measures? You know, why not take this measure? They could be temporary measures. If we find out that there's a cure or that there's a new helmet design or that there's a thing, you know, if we find out there's a a door we can walk through that makes this uh that solves this simply, well then you know, go back to go back to firing sort of 1584 millimeter anti-tank weapons in a day or however many 120 millimeter mortar rounds you want to bang out.

SPEAKER_00But in the meantime, does it not make sense to put those restrictions in place? Uh and and the Americans are working towards that, not as quickly as some people feel they should be, but that is at least tangible something that's happening. Could that happen in the UK? I don't see why not, but that's a question for the MOD, we will ask them. Um, but but at least but there is something practical happening, and I think it's difficult if you're in like an alliance like NATO, like the five five eyes and all that kind of stuff. If you're in if one partner is doing something quite radical like that, uh the others will you know, journalists in Australia are sort of saying, Well, what are we doing?

SPEAKER_00Journalists in Canada, well, what about you guys? And that's happening. You know, that is happening.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, um the other thing, they that the MOD, I mean, I think if they've got any ounce of sense about them or or or real intent to get to this, to get to a not a resolution, but progress this as fast as practically possible. You know, I suggest that is immediately starting to monitor a percentage of people who are joining up now. I say monitor, as in assess assess either baseline.

SPEAKER_01They join you exactly baseless, you baseline those, you baseline the those the the brain, you baseline the hormone levels and whatever else I think is necessary to do. You baseline those and you take snapshots throughout, you know, you check, check, check, check, check, either after certain incidents, certain types of training, certain events on on tour, and you know, periodically every six months every year or whatever. You know, and you and you and you do that because that because they will they will thing is they will decide to do that at some point. That's an obvious step that an obvious step to take.

SPEAKER_01That will happen at some point, right? Why did why it doesn't start happening now, it it is beyond me. It's just a total, you know, it's uh anyway. Uh I I find it I find it I'm I find it very frustrating, but but you know, one of the things that you're highlighting with your research that you're doing on it and the story that you're doing on it is is how far forward we've come, even just since 2018, since I interviewed Mandy to where we are now, you know, the fact that you and your organization are doing this is a is a really big thing, it's a really positive step, you know.

SPEAKER_01So I'm gonna try and chill out.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, look, I mean it's a responsibility for us from my point of view, it's what we're for, right? It's what we exist to do. You know, it's public public interest journalism, it just just is. And the frustration for me is we can't go quicker, we can't do more, you know, the the the the everything takes takes time, and there is very good reasons for that, people's availability and so on and so forth. So there's you know, there's interviews that we'd like to do that where people don't want to talk to us, and that's like yeah, you know, that's how the world works. And so, for instance, I've spoken to uh a number of families of people who've lost loved ones to suicide, and that's really difficult, right?

SPEAKER_00Because in some cases they've campaigned about mental health. Where do you even start with sort of putting something else under the table there five years afterwards, ten years after? Is it even fair to do that? Is it even ethical to sit down with a mother of somebody who died by suicide and to suggest that maybe something else was at play there that nobody even mentioned to you before?

SPEAKER_01Is that it's a harsh, it's a harsh reality.

SPEAKER_00It's not easy to do so. We've gone a bit of a way down that path, uh, but it's really awkward and it's really there's a there are lines beyond which you know, and so everyone needs time to we present the topic as a some something that may if it's not interesting to you, don't do it, and so on. And people tend to have a discussion with average family family members and decide that you know what, we don't want to get involved with this. It's not something we want to and the burden of sharing something so horrific, right? In public to millions of people is tough.

SPEAKER_00You know, would would I do that? Yeah, I think that's a good way to look at it. Is what would I do if my son, God forbid, my daughter, God forbid. I don't think I'd leave the house. You know what I mean? So you have to kind of you have to be patient. There is one family who have spoken to us and they're and are fantastic, and their courage is like you know, every moving. Uh and we will broadcast that piece as soon as it's ready. Um but it's it's it's it can't happen quickly, everything takes time. So so you know, we are working on it, we're committed to it, I'm committed to it personally.

SPEAKER_00It's a fascinating apart from anything else, just intellectually, it's fascinating. Um and yeah, and like you say, people are suffering, you know. So and more so there are people who are suffering who I think uh what they've got is what they've got, right? But there's that knowing you're not alone, knowing this isn't just me, knowing knowing what you're dealing with, I think is really important. So there's a guy we've spoken to. I'm not gonna go into too much detail because we haven't broadcast this yet, but and I've mentioned this to Kate as well before about like what why does it why do you want a diagnosis of what why do you want to have a scan that might tell you you've got serious brain damage?

SPEAKER_00I mean, is it not better to have PTSD as a diagnosis? And it's that, you know, because it's like what you're what you're seeking is appalling news, right? It's terrible news that you've then got to deal with. And and the people we have asked that question to is that it's it's better to know. Whatever it is, it's better to know. Then you know what you're dealing with, and you can have, you know, and this is true in civilian life and car crashes and whatever, you know, you can have a meaningful positive, you know. It's not like it's not not ground for despair, you know.

SPEAKER_00You can find that there are a whole series of therapies that are interesting, some work for some people, not not all of them are kind of mainstream licensed type medicine, but there's a lot of there is a lot of things that some people find comfort from. Yeah, people have routines, have physical exercise, all this other stuff. Just not the end of the world, you know, that diagnosis, but it is important to people to know, you know, is it just me? Is it my brain or is it is it physical damage?

SPEAKER_01And for 99.9% of people knowing and understanding what the condition is, even if you can't change that, is a a method of relief in itself. Seems that way. You know, method of relief in itself, for sure.

SPEAKER_00The other thing is one other quick thing is like I'm slightly going going sort of totally off piste here, but you know, they have this sort of memorial wall, it's one of the families said to me, you know, they there's the I put the arboretum in um yeah.

SPEAKER_01Are you gonna say there's nothing there for suicide?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and if you die by suicide, there's the the you and I I kind of understand why that is. I get the I get the sort of reasons born on that. But if your suicide is a direct line from a physical injury sustained as a result of your service, is that not a totally different conversation that needs to be had?

SPEAKER_01You could say that, but then then the argument from the opposite side of the people who put their names on the wall is oh can you prove that? Prove it. I understand, I I get it.

SPEAKER_00But I mean I can you know but I think that's kind of where we're going, isn't it? I think we will be able to prove that oh sorry but that's a crate, isn't it?

SPEAKER_01That's a crate, look at that.

SPEAKER_00How do we do this?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, go grab it. I'm gonna know you need to answer it. That is a crate. Yeah, you're the professional. I know, it's a totally um I apologize humbly. Uh no, I know I I know exactly your point. I've I you know I there's at least one family that I of a uh one of my friends who uh sadly took his own life and uh I don't know if there's any other side of it, but that one family that stick in my mind.

SPEAKER_01I his mum said the same thing, you know, there's nowhere where can where can I go? Where where is he represented?

SPEAKER_00You know, and um I'm not attaching myself to either side in an argument, but it's an argument, right? It's a it's a serious discussion, you know.

SPEAKER_01These people have given everything and I believe there you know is a monument now somewhere, is it not? Not on the wall, but I think there is a monument a suicide monument, which I fuck the fact that we have that have to have that is just you know. I mean, well, I'm not gonna look for it. I was gonna look for it online there, but there should be a place in the Arboretum. Absolutely. Uh it maybe maybe the name doesn't go on the wall. I don't know. Uh whatever. I don't sorry, I mean whatever flippantly. I mean, I don't know. Um, but at the very least, I think there should be a place in the Arboretum for these people, you know, a a service person, um, you know, it takes their own life.

SPEAKER_00Uh yeah, but right, we can I make a can I make a blanket plug? Is that if you're we haven't finished yet watching this, I know, but it seemed like a good time to get it in. After I interrupted us with um with my cunning phone call. It's just that if if this is something you have knowledge of, interest in, genuine experience of something you want to say, get in touch with me, because I'm interested. And that may not be something I can help with, it may not be something that translates to anything practical, but the more people I speak to there is a capacity issue a bit.

SPEAKER_00I try and do bits in you know in chunks as and when I can, but but you know, the more people I speak to the better. So uh so if you're a kind of subscriber to Hugh, get in touch with you, you can get in touch with me. Or whoa, whoa, whoa. What's your email address? Or get me a bit really simple, ball.tyson at itn.co.uk or go to itv.com forward slash news, google TBI. My pieces will come up. My name's on there, my email's on there, and there's a there's a website specifically for this, which is investigations at itn.co.uk. So you can get in touch with me a number of ways.

SPEAKER_01I'm on the investigations, what?

SPEAKER_00Investigations at itn. Oh, that's the email address.uk, yeah, or my own, my name. The the problem with our email system is it's incredibly kind of secure, so lots of stuff goes to junk, clutter, quarantine, or whatever. Uh so the investigations one does come, doesn't nothing gets quarantined, it comes straight to me. So it's probably better than my personal one. Okay, so nothing will get missed, or you know, get in touch with me, whatever, Twitter, Facebook, uh however you like. But but you know, this is this is a sort of growing, building, evolving sort of thing as a piece of journalism.

SPEAKER_00And the more voices, the the more with the more I hear, the more I learn, and the more capacity we have to to to sort of fight this battle.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Anyway, right. We have got we've got a bunch of questions uh left over from the icebreaker and also new ones that were going into the uh live stream as we were talking. So we're gonna get through those now, if that's all right. Um

SPEAKER_00One area for the rest of your career, what would it be? Climate change. Climate change. So what's happened with climate change is it's become politicized. I'm not sure when that happened, and I'm certainly not sure why that happened, but it became a kind of we went from sort of, you know, a body of of of political opinion that didn't believe in climate change at all, didn't believe it existed. Then uh as the science became incontrovertible, people believed it existed, but didn't believe it was man-made. Uh, then that argument moved to so so now where we are is the argument is yeah, it does exist.

SPEAKER_00Yes, we accept it is man-made, uh, but we can't really do anything about it, or we shouldn't do anything about it because it will cost too much or make us uncompetitive. So there's this kind of interesting shift. And there was a time when all the parties, all the main parties were aligned on that, where the Conservatives, Labour, Liberals all broadly speaking, agreed with each other that this was a major crisis that we needed to do more on. And now that time seems to have gone, it seems to have become kind of a left-right political issue, which is nonsense. It's not, it's physics, it's just science. It's just there's nothing political about it, uh, really, or there shouldn't be.

SPEAKER_00Um, this is something where we should all be able to work together and to find solutions. And uh and it's just fascinating. The science of it is fascinating, it takes you to some beautiful places, uh, which is obviously irrelevant from a journalist's point of view, but personally speaking, it's lovely to go trekking on glaciers and and so on. Uh, and it affects all of us, and it affects all of our kids more, and it affects our grandchildren more, and there's there's simply no doubt about that. Uh, it it's probably the most important issue in the world today. So that if I could just do one thing thematically, uh it would be climate change.

SPEAKER_01Okay, biting my tongue, right? Uh okay. So, Coke in the chat when we were talking about blast traumatic injuries, he said uh you don't wear ear defenders when firing live weapons, question mark. Uh so well, what was your experience with wearing live uh wearing ear defence when you were serving? And I'll give mine. Yeah, yeah, so just for people listening, uh you they either Paul demonstrated you would just take them out yours and throw them away.

SPEAKER_00They they either fell out, which they did all the time, the little yellow things, right? Or you took them out because you needed to be able to communicate by voice with your section commander. I was a platoon commander in the infantry. You know, if I can't hear my section commander shouting and then me, then then comms become very difficult.

SPEAKER_01Um there's been a big evolution of in events so for Koch. There has, yeah, I've known that. Yeah, for Coke's uh benefit and people listening's benefit, there's been a big evolution in in protective equipment for hearing in the military over well, since uh you served, since I served uh to know. In fact, so when I joined, it was the same as you. We would get we would get issued like uh big over-the-ar, we call them ant blocks, over the ear, you know, over-the-head ear muff type ear defenders, which uh when worn under a helmet were extremely uncomfortable, uh, were not usable in conjunction with the radio systems we had at the time.

SPEAKER_01Uh, I'm assuming it was clansmen we were in with clansmen when I first joined. Uh, and and also to your point, it was very difficult to communicate to each other. So the ample box you wouldn't have. Then they they would issue as an alternative the yellow little yellow ear defense, little sponge things you put in your ears. They weren't great at preventing the kind of noise you get from weapon systems, but they were they weren't bad, but it was the same problem. Not compatible with radio systems, you couldn't hear people, you could it was like you couldn't hear anything.

SPEAKER_01You need to be able to communicate verbally, uh, when uh when you're in the military when there's loud noise going on, so those hearing protection wasn't wasn't good, so you would take them out. You would it wasn't that you take them out and you you had to take them out and be able to do your job. Uh uh so there you get been, so yeah, you'd fire weapons without hearing defence in, or you'd fire weapons with one hearing defence in one year and not in the other year. Uh and then fast forward to I'm trying to think what I got, issued them 2010 when I went out on the the third my final tour with three parts, the third Afghan tour I did.

SPEAKER_01That's when we finally got well our unit anyway, finally got what were known then as P hips. You ever hear of P hips? I've heard of them, yeah. Yeah, I've never I've not seen them or used them, I've heard of them. And uh P hips were you get a mold done of your inner ear, um, that mould will go off, and then maybe four to six weeks later, you get sent back. A little plastic box in there was a piece of plastic, soft plastic, basically, uh basically an in-ear ear defender that was perfectly molded to the shape of your ear, but also had a removable like cap in inside it, which you'd remove that and you could connect with an attachment, you could connect your radio to it, so it would keep out the blast, keep out the the noise, but you could hear your radio through it, and also as part of that radio system, had a microphone on there which would filter out the loud noise and fill so you could basically be next to someone with your hearing defense in, you could talk and hear that like airpods these days, you know, like if you can hear someone talking, but not loud noises, the same kind of thing.

SPEAKER_01We got issue doors 2010. But back when you and I joined, you know, and it was worse when you joined, you know, there's just uh non-existence, you had to take them out, everyone took them out, which is which it actually in itself is demonstrative of how different people's bodies are and people's heads are and brains and ears are that you know when I went through training and and all those years and was in before we got the P hips and on those tours, most people I say didn't get without without hearing injury. A big proportion did come away with a hearing injury, but most didn't.

SPEAKER_01Everyone's experiencing the same thing.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I'm in my mid-50s and I've got hearing aids, you know, no one in my family has hearing aids. My mother does she's in her 80s, but no, I've there's no family history about mid-50s and I've got hearing aids, so uh it's okay.

SPEAKER_01Um, all right, so uh let's look at these questions. How re I'm not sure I understand this question, I'm gonna skip past it. Okay. Which group of people tend to give unjustified negativity in comments? We're talking about in response to news here, such as left or right-leaning people. So are left-leaning people more likely to give negative comments or right-leaning people?

SPEAKER_00Oh, I'm I'm not sure. I'm tempted to say that you're gonna say right because you're left. No, no, not too. Well, I'm not really. I don't I don't regard myself that way. I I I think they're as bad as each other. I think it's the it's the kind of more the more sort of the further you lean one way or the other, the more likely you are to sort of have a worldview that is that journalists are here to lie to you and controlled by lizard men and such like. I don't think there's a I don't notice. I I might obviously somebody somewhere's done a research paper on this, right? I'm sure. But just from sort of personal experience point of view, I I've not seen any different.

SPEAKER_00In fact, weirdly, I I think they're really quite often it's hard to tell which way somebody leans politically from the they could be either equally from the comments you get. So it's quite sometimes it's you know, uh not not talking about the whole sort of it's not like I go and research people's worldviews online or anything, do you know what I mean? But sometimes the the the sort of far left if you if if you're allowed to call them that and the far right if you're allowed to call them that are so similar. Now, you know, politics isn't like a straight line, it's more like a horseshoe sort of thing, that that theory. And that they're so sort of similar that it's actually hard to tell from people's comments where where they where their political sort of leanings is sometimes, it seems to me.

SPEAKER_01What is the worst hate you've received and how did you feel about it?

SPEAKER_00I don't I don't really, I don't I'm quite sort of thick skinned. I don't really I mean people I I tend to think when people sort of react negatively to you, it's usually kind of understandable. You know, I've been threatened where we you know, a new big news story, a bomb or whatever, and you kind of you're immediately reacting to that and you're knocking on people's doors or whatever, people will tell you to to, you know, in no uncertain terms to go away or whatever, and and you know, you vultures and all that sort of stuff. You kind of understand that though, don't you? Yeah, it's a natural human sort of response.

SPEAKER_00I don't, it's not personal, you know. I never feel it personally. So I'll take it like when you're a journalist, you know, you get shot at from time to time because you're working with this particular, you're working with the Free Syrian army, or you're working with Assad forces, or you're working with the Libyan Revolution, or whoever it is you're with, right? Occasionally you're gonna get shot at or mortared, and whenever that's gonna happen. Uh, it's not personal to you. And I think I sort of take it the same way. It's not, you know, I don't take take it personally when when people take those sort of those views.

SPEAKER_00They have an opinion of what I am about and why I'm there, but it's not personal. It's I'm a I'm a kind of avatar for all journalists and and and in in that circumstance. So so I've never really been affected by it. There are certain topics I stay away from. I've I sort of did did I was I've been to Gaza, I don't know, four or five times. I'm not so we're gonna expand on that particularly, but I tweeted about that once and I was subjected to an enormous amount of online abuse. What did you tweet? Uh I we went to this recently, no, no, a long time ago.

SPEAKER_00This was I think it's 2014. And we went to a particular place, uh, like a UN school that had been smashed up in in I think it was in Rafah uh by a tank fire. And uh I was basically trying to look trying to find if a firing point and it wasn't one. Um you know, and I tweeted what we saw with pictures and whatever, and just because it was interesting. And uh suddenly I was kind of you know an agent of Hamas and a radical i Islamic general anti-terrorist and so yeah, and then but and then I sort of said, Well, look, you know, all I'm doing is tweeting myself.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm not drawing any conclusions from that, right? And then suddenly I was a Zionist kind of uh, you know, settler, but yeah, I mean it's like I can't be both. I mean you know, so there are some subjects that are just I know the internet will make you both. Well, no, that's that that's kind of what happened. So uh and there was an American, a kind of American, well-known American commentator. I won't say his name, but he was a well-respected kind of think tank type person who was could calling me a coward because I wasn't reporting that Hamas were on every doorstep and controlling all our movements, controlling everything we did.

SPEAKER_00And we weren't reporting it because it wasn't, it's not visible, it doesn't work like that. You know, it's it's not a kind of it's not like they come and take you to, you know, there are certain places you try to get to and they're like, no, you can't go there. Same as if you try and wander into Hereford or as you want to wander, you know, that's also true here, right? I'm I'm not I'm not making that as making sort of i i excuses, you know, they're an unpleasant organisation, nasty sort of you know, terrorist organisation, let's be, let's, let's call it call it what it is. But but you know, this idea that they're you know we're mouthpieces for unwitting mouthpieces from the control that was not the case.

SPEAKER_00We could go where you like, talk to who you want to like within certain limitations, and and I thought calling us cowards when at that time there's heavy bombing from the Israelis, I mean nothing compared to what's happening at the moment, but we'd you know rush out in the cars and go to a particular place and quickly film and quickly rush back at danger of our own lives. And this guy in Washington, I mean serious danger of our own lives, you know, and uh this guy in Washington's calling me a coward. I thought that's a that's a bit strong. So so yeah, there are you know, there are there are you get into that you can get into those sort of situations, but in in terms of hey, I I've never experienced something that I've regarded as personal to me, and I've I that might be because I'm quite thick skinned, but but uh yeah, it's you know it's I've I've not experienced that.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_01Uh what is the hardest part of journalism? What roles in journalism are the most difficult?

SPEAKER_00Um that's a very good question. That's a really good question. That I'm not I it would take me a really long time to answer uh answer properly. I uh oh it's subjective, right? So everyone were to tell you something different. Um you know, knowing stories are true and proving them, that's really frustrating. Knowing something's true, having one good source on something and needing another.

SPEAKER_00Well, because if a friend of mine might tell me that something's true, but they might oh their knowledge might be secondhand. So I'm not how can I get that through the lawyer that but you in that case you don't know it's true. Well, I'm sure it's true. Being sure, being certain that something is true. That's different. So for instance, uh you know, a friend of mine might have knowledge, direct knowledge of something, but it's where's the paperwork? Where's the you know, you need the bar is reasonably high on stuff that's not mainstream, and it's sometimes you just know this is happening, right? You know this is true. No, okay, I take your point, but you are certain that this is true, but there's just not enough to get it on air.

SPEAKER_00That's really frustrating. Doesn't happen often, but there are I've had that a couple of times where I've essentially had to give up on stuff because I just the bar's too high and I or the or my my ability to to to get to the stories too low, take it, take it whichever way you like. That's frustrating. In terms of the hardest types of story to cover, earthquakes. Wars are really easy.

SPEAKER_01Earthquakes are the hardest type of story to cover.

SPEAKER_00And I've only done a couple. There's there's guys at my there's guys at my where I work who've done like I don't know, 15 or whatever. There's guys who've done loads, so I don't want to, I don't want to big myself up here. I've only done a couple, but but if you if you go to a war, you're you're plugged into one side or the other, sometimes both. Weirdly, you can cross the front lines sometimes, but um, but you're kind of an army needs to have food, right? Needs to have water, it needs to have power. There's certain things that that any fighting force will have. And if you're a journalist and you're working with them, you just plug into all that, right? So the logistics are quite simple.

SPEAKER_00Whereas if you go to an earthquake, like water is suddenly everyone needs water, and yeah, we do travel with money, and lots of people don't have money, but if you've got that amount of water for your kids and someone's offering you loads of dollars, the dollars don't look like they did a week ago anymore. They're not that it's not that big a deal. If you've got to feed your kids and someone's offering you bits of paper, which for a week or two until normal order and aid starts to come and everything else is that's suddenly that's all those dollars are.

SPEAKER_00It's really difficult. So, you know, all the normal stuff that you rely on isn't necessarily there. So the hotels that you might stay in, well, they might be affected. So where do you stay? Do you take the risk of aftershocks, structural damage, parts of the world that where building regulations might be iffy anyway? Do you take the risk and stay in a hotel? If you do, is it based on what architectural knowledge? Normally it's well, yeah, there's a couple of cracks, but I think it'll be all right. Well, we've got no idea. Yeah, um, but or do you stay outside in tents and stuff?

SPEAKER_00And obviously, that degrades your ability to work, it separates you from you know, there's hygiene issues, it separates you from power supplies to charge all your kit. We have a phenomenal amount of kit that needs charging, and so uh food, you everyone need everyone's after food, everyone's after water, uh comms, you know, all the mobile towers go down. So earthquakes are really logistically speaking, earthquakes are incredibly challenging, and then you get you know, you might sort of get a team of guys to drive out to you from the capital with all the supplies you need, they get robbed en route, they turn up with nothing.

SPEAKER_00So, yeah, they're very challenging. Very challenging.

SPEAKER_01Questions from David now. So, how does your time as a soldier shape your work as a news edit editor today?

SPEAKER_00I I yeah, that's that's that's also a really good question. I think um being able to deal with large amounts of information, incomp knowing that information is incomplete, and being able to make judgments based on that information is something I do all the time. As a you know, if you're sort of logistically uh and editorially kind of making making judgments on what you do know whilst being aware that what you do know is incomplete, uh is something that you do uh uh a level in the army.

SPEAKER_00I mean, frankly, in the British Army, you're doing that from Lance Corporal up, really, aren't you, in some way or another? Any command responsibility, you're doing that. You know, it may get may get more complex. It might be sort of, you know, as you get to like half colonel or whatever, there are an awful lot more factors in play, but the the principles are same, right? And and so that's that's something be able to analyse and judge and just and just sometimes just make a decision knowing that that that might be right, wrong, but that's you're you're deciding with what you've got. That's valuable in journalism, that's valuable, I thought it's certainly valuable as a news editor.

SPEAKER_00Probably valuable in all walks of life, I would say, maybe confidence, having the confidence to communicate with people to come and talk to you, uh knowing that there's some tricky questions written on your laptop. Or but that that sort of you know, you need to have a certain amount of confidence, I think, in in journalism to to get by, you know, to talk to strangers essentially. You that takes I wouldn't have been able to do that prior to joining the army. I don't think I would have been able to go and knock on someone's door and said, Look, I'm investigating something that you're in some way key to or important to or have knowledge of, and you know, I would like you to invite me into your house and talk about something that might not even be to your advantage.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, that takes that so so you know, the army's great for building well, the services generally, I think, are great for building that kind of confidence, that sort of ability to sort of believe in yourself. I I had very little self-belief as a not very little, that's not true, but I was the the the forces really noticeably built my confidence and my belief in myself and my security and my own kind of being comfortable in my own skin and accepting my that I've got faults, but not letting them sort of defy me.

SPEAKER_00Does that make sense? Not letting not letting them over the things that I'm not good at. Not don't worry about the things you're not good at, you know, concentrate on things you are good at. And and the forces were brilliant for that. Brilliant for that. You know. Um so those that's the sort of top of my head.

SPEAKER_01No, good. Uh how has war reporting changed in the age of fake news and propaganda?

SPEAKER_00I did there's uh uh there's that old that's another great question. The yeah, I don't know I'm not sure I know the answer to that. I I mean there's this the old classic saying that the first casualty of war is truth. Uh you know, propaganda and war has been a s you know, they've been bedfellows since long before the information age. So um so in one sense uh uh nothing's changed. Um it's I mean there's a lot more to so for instance we rely uh in conflict zones it's not always possible to be everywhere.

SPEAKER_00We try where where money permits and where the situation allows, we try and be do our own eyewitness reporting because it's just the best way of saying what's going on is to go there, see it yourself and report it. Doesn't mean that people believe it anymore necessarily. You one still gets, you know, once will still get opinions or whatever, but but but if you can go somewhere, film it, show it, say this is what we saw, that's pretty that's kind of gold standard war reporting, right? Gold standard journalism, I would say. Where that's not possible, Gaza, no journalists allowed in, haven't been since the start of this situation.

SPEAKER_00So we rely on the journalists who are there already. The journalists who are there already are doing amazing work. Um and they work for us. We have our everyone has their own teams who've worked for them, worked before the situation worked for us, so so they're incredible guys, incredibly courageous, they do an incredible job, but they're constantly subject from to this kind of yeah, but they're all Hamas, aren't they? Yeah, but they're all partial because they live there and so on and so forth. Uh which is in in certainly in our case absolutely 100% not true. Uh, but there's no substitute for going there yourself and and with with your own kind of your own reporters that everybody knows and recognises.

SPEAKER_00So, in the circumstances like that, you you we we use it Gaza's actually better than a lot of places. We do have our own journalists there, and they've done amazing stuff and sent us some award-winning reports. But there are some places where we don't even have anyone, we don't have uh we're literally relying on social media friends, particularly in the early stages of stuff, or in in kind of places that are simply hard to get to, and then there's a whole you know, well, we can sort of verify this to that point. Do we run that? Do we, you know, and then it gets really difficult to make those judgments.

SPEAKER_00So has propaganda changed? I don't I don't think the principle's changed at all. What has changed is that people will propagandize, people will know that we will use social media footage, for instance, and so that gets propagandized and that gets manipulated, uh, and there's constantly sort of stuff that says it's this online and it's not, and there are ways to check that and there are ways to verify that. But if you're in a hurry and if you're not doing due diligence and you whack this on and you say this is this and it's that, then that's reputationally damaging, you know. And I've made that mistake actually.

SPEAKER_00I've used a piece of footage that was it was the place and it was the story, but it was a different date than uh than the date I said. So so it didn't actually have the effect of being misleading, but it was nonetheless not what we said it was, and that was my fault. I think it's the only time I've only done it once, uh, and it was obviously it was a good faith mistake. Uh, but it was a function of working quickly under pressure, under pressure of time. Checking, yes, but just not not checking enough, frankly.

SPEAKER_00And and you know, I sort of held my hands up and we you know, not I'm not sure that that was it was one of those things that doesn't mislead, so it wasn't so much of a problem as it could have been. But yeah, it's it's we it's something you have to be alert to. A good example is Syria where the you know the the um Uh chemical weapons attacks and so on. This whole thing about crisis actors, and then the all the footage was being questioned, and then there was footage that will was fake that wasn't related to that, and then the the idea to just throw enough mud, throw enough smoke, throw enough doubt, uh, and people will believe this has hadn't happened.

SPEAKER_00Oh, it did happen, it incontrovertibly did happen. And then and there's any huge bodies of evidence, including a report, which if you're interested, you should read from the the United Nations chemical weapons inspectors. But there was a whole debate about it, a discussion about it, not just online, but also in in you know in the legacy media and newspapers. And so, and that was uh that whole debate was a function of deliberate kind of throwing of smoke and trying to obscure that and trying to deflect that and trying to suggest that that what it yes, it looks like this, but actually it's that.

SPEAKER_00Uh and yeah, it's difficult, it's very difficult. And it it requires you you have to just slow down a bit and not be in a rush. We're very competitive, right? Animals, with we just are by nature of journalism, not not necessarily unhealthy, but but it is it it leaves us vulnerable to trying to get something on too quickly, trying to get something on before I want to get my story on before you gets his on. And you know, if you're not careful, you can make mistakes. So I think that the difference, I think the propaganda, the fact of it hasn't changed at all. I think the the ways in which it operates, you know, manipulating video, manipulating uh you know, clips online and so on, that that's changed, it's changed technically.

SPEAKER_00Uh does that is that a sensible answer? Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um, thank you. Uh right, two questions left. Uh uh my bladder is gonna burst. Uh have you ever had to choose between telling the full truth and protecting lives or relationships? So tell the full truth at the expense of lives or relationships, or don't tell the full truth to protect those lives or relationships.

SPEAKER_00I don't know. I've never been in that position. I'm quite glad. Glad to say I'm so you three people under the bus then. No, yes, I'm not sure. I just uh the situation's never arisen, I don't think. I mean, um I'm trying to think of a time when that's I mean I yeah, I'm not fundamentally I'm not an investigative journalist, so uh mostly I do news, so it's kind of that the situation doesn't arise really. Um generally speaking, uh I think it's it's true to say that that our sources we protect our sources, I think, and we'll people will go to jail for it, people have gone to jail for it.

SPEAKER_00And and you know, I think that's uh uh the problem the problem is if you don't, you know, the one type that if you don't, then no, who why would anyone talk to you confidentially again? You know, if if you're sort of if if you have doubts about my my A, my willingness to protect your identity if you're talking to me about something that requires that, uh B my ability to is the other point, is you know, my OPSEC and my my or ComSec or whatever you call it, you know, my ability to kind of make sure that your identity is disguised.

SPEAKER_00If you have doubts about that, why would you talk to us? And there's lots of people who don't, you know, there's lots of people who who will not engage, want to get a story out, and they'll go through sort of third party things, and you'll get half the stories and pizza stories. You're like, I can't work with that. Yeah, yeah. I need to sit down with this person and make my own judgments and check their bona fide, and people are I'm not gonna do that because I don't trust you enough, or I don't, or the consequences are so big that I'm not gonna take the risk or whatever. And so so them stories don't happen, but but but yeah, but broadly speaking, we we take it incredibly seriously.

SPEAKER_00Uh sources throwing people under the bus in terms of people who work with us, I'm that's I've never heard of that happening.

SPEAKER_01Um have you ever where is it? Have you ever faced pressure to censor or alter a story? And if so, how did you handle it?

SPEAKER_00Uh yeah, I mean, with there's constant pressure to alter stories. I'm not censor not so much. No, I wouldn't necessarily use that word, but I mean there's it's sort of balanced things. So here's an example, right? And these are not there's not a right or wrong here, but early in the reasonably early in the current conflict in Gaza, we might interview people in Gaza who might say this is a genocide. Is that acceptable? It's their words, it's their opinion, it's obviously their words and their opinion. It's obviously not yours. You're simply using that soundbite of them saying that.

SPEAKER_00Is that acceptable?

SPEAKER_01Are you saying is it acceptable to publish that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely.

SPEAKER_00Not everyone thinks that. Um, so that's a that was a live debate. It became more common to hear that word when the courts got involved because it is a legal term, right? It's a specific legal term with specific legal meanings, so it became more, you know, would we would we say that without a court having decided it? Never. But should people themselves express their opinion that this is a genocide, or should they be allowed to do that, or should we be censoring them? That was a live debate at one point uh uh in that conflict.

SPEAKER_00And and uh I think in the end in the end, I think we took the view that as long as it's very clear that this is their view, but but that was a that was an issue, that was a debate. I'll give you another example. Um, would you using the word terrorist, is that even helpful at all in any context anywhere? Right? It's a live debate, it's an argument that's been going on for as long as terrorism. I remember having this argument with the uh the IRA and uh, you know, when I was in Northern Ireland, is it you know, one person's terrorist, another person freedom fighter?

SPEAKER_00Those kind of discussions. That's a constant thing, you know. Do we decide that Hamas is a terrorist organization? Um was so so break that down a bit. Was the were the attacks of October 7th? Was it 7th? The attack that's part of was that a an act of terrorism? I think incontrovertibly, yes, I'm sure everyone would agree with that. I get I find it very hard to define it another way. Does that are all members of Hamas, like the Minister of Health or the Minister of the United States? Are they all terrorists?

SPEAKER_00And is that helpful to frame it in that way? That's a that's a more interesting discussion. I'm not I'm not gonna come down on a side on that. But so so in terms of is there pressure to to change what you what you know to change your reports or to modify your reports constantly, all the time. Those these arguments, these discussions, these judgment calls are like a kind of part of the job almost. They're they're constantly and they evolve and they and they change and and you know, and they're difficult, and there's no there's no right or wrong kind of answer. And either way, you'll get flak. Um you just have to pick what you think is the most reasonable uh reasonable way through, whether it's middle ground or whether it's you know, we're going to attach to using this particular form of words in this particular circumstance.

SPEAKER_00ISIS, then it was dash, and it was so-called ISIS, the whole kind of what you call them that doesn't glamorize them, but does because so certain there was a push from government. You might remember to call them dash because that was the Arab pejorative, but that never really took on because it just sounds weird. It doesn't sound like it sounds like a kind of cartoon character or something. So it never really took on in the media much. Um, but there was a whole discussion around that. With what about so-called Islamic State? Is that better than Islamic State? Does one valid validate them? And you know, it's a there's always pressure to change, there's always pressure to not say this or say that or use this form of words, but it's it's it's healthy press, it's not an unhealthy pressure, it's not like a censorship, it's not like a you can't say this because um, it's it's more about what's the best way to deal with this that doesn't attach value judgments to it, doesn't sort of attach ourselves to supporting one side or another, uh, but is is reasonable and is understandable by the public, you know, it has to make sense.

SPEAKER_00So those discussions are like I wouldn't say every day, but they're common. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Am I avoiding the question there? Is uh is that is that a reasonable answer?

SPEAKER_01No, no, yeah, no, no, it's fine. Yeah, it's absolutely fine.

SPEAKER_00Um in terms of censorship, if anyone said, Well, we don't want you to say this for whatever reason that that we don't that's something you know to be true, you've proven to your normal to you know, you've done your due diligence, you've proved it, you're gonna run it. Does anyone there say no you can't run it? Is there a kind of big, you know, yeah. What do they call it in the army? The long screwdriver? Is that the you know, when Westminster get involved and say you can't do that? So um uh there's no, I've never I've never come across that personally, never never happened. Um, to my knowledge, does it I can't say obviously that never happens because I I only can only speak to my own experience, but in my own experience, no.

SPEAKER_01Right, it's been a a real pleasure. I I was you know what I was what I was hoping to get from today was uh a you know behind the curtain conversation, first hand account of of um of commentary and perception and experience of all of the things that annoy me about legacy media and speak to someone who's who's in that it's it's been really useful for me, really has, and and uh I've definitely changed my opinion on the things somewhat. Maybe not an extreme change, but I'm definitely a little bit less cold to legacy media than I was before that we started the mics rolling.

SPEAKER_01Well done, you excellent. Um, but more importantly, uh what you're doing on the CBI research, mate, is you you know it's incredibly important, and uh and it is a huge amount of effort, and it uh and you know, in an ideal world, it will be getting it would be front and centre of every flipping newspaper and and news outlet ever all the time, every day until the situation improves, you know. But that's not the case, and so you know, this I I I would I would assume there are last parts of this at the moment which we which appear like a thankless task, but you know, but it's it's super important work and it's uh it will undoubtedly literally what you're doing will undoubtedly play a part in saving lives and improving lives.

SPEAKER_01So I thank you for what you're doing. Yeah, I we I really mean it. I really mean it.

SPEAKER_00That's good to be. I think I think if Kate said I think if one person and and I and I I feel this, if if one person feels they're not alone, yeah, then then it's then it's worth doing, it's worth all the work. And I think that's that's what we're for as a journalist, right? Isn't it? That's kind of what we should be for anyway. So yeah, exactly. So yeah, no.

SPEAKER_01So on that, uh yeah, you mentioned in the middle that uh so if people have got experience or want to contribute to what you're doing in terms of the TBI research, uh, or get in contact with you about it, it's investigations at itn.co.k investigations at itn.co.uk or Paul.com.

SPEAKER_00Or just find me on social. All right, cool.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, perfect. Uh anything else? Uh we need to plug? No, we'll go. I do want you to come back. We have not touched on any of your career. I want to hear the career from start to finish. I want to know all the wars you've been in, I want to know all the stories, I want to go from start to finish. We'll cover your military career, but we'll quickly go on to journalism career. If you're up for that. Yeah, yeah, no, 100%. I know hopefully. I reckon the questions will be easier for you as well.

SPEAKER_00I questions have all been really legitimate. Absolutely. Some of them have been fantastic, actually. Uh all questions should make you go like that before you answer them, I think. So uh no, it's been great. I've enjoyed it. It's been lovely to meet you again. And hopefully, I'll come back when we made a bit more progress on TBI and I can feel like I'm not at the start of something, feel like I'm halfway up a mountain rather than just looking at it from base camp. But um, yeah, be a pleasure. Good luck, everything. Thank you very much. Cheers, thank you.

SPEAKER_01That's it. If you enjoy this episode, why not become a Hey Chour patron? Patrons will get access to all of the episodes before anyone else, they get advanced viewing of the episodes, and you also get other perks and bonuses. All of the information is on charliecharlie1.com. Just hit the menu item, become a patron. It'll show you everything there, including access to the Heychhour Discord community and private patron only channels on there. So go to charliecharlie1.com and hit the menu item, become a patron.

SPEAKER_01Easy peasy. Thank you for being a supporter. Subscribe to the channel, and I will catch you on the next episode. Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. “Ronin is a spy film, an action film, a samurai film in bits” - TV & Film chat with Bags and Alex

    Oct 11, 20262 hr 13 minAudio

    Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** British Army veterans Bags Simmons (Royal Tank Regiment, Bare Arms TV & Film) and Alex Brockdorff (Queen’s Royal Hussars, actor/director, A24’s Warfare) join...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Sniper & Combat Medic - "I'm 19, first kinetic experience, first mass casualty event"

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 57 minAudio

    H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts Chris Dodd joins H-Hour for an extended conversation about his years in the British Army and his experiences serving in Northern Ireland, Iraq and Afghanistan. A badged...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Former PWRR Sniper Chris Dodd “The person with the biggest stick is the winner”

    Sep 6, 202620 minAudio

    H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Chris Dodd answers questions submitted by H-Hour patrons in a Q&A format. Topics include whether all infantry should be trained to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. “At the end of the day, it’s their country and they won.” Levison Wood

    Aug 31, 20261 hr 27 minAudio

    Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** Levison Wood returns to H-Hour for his second appearance on the podcast, having first featured in 2019. This expansive conversation covers war, exploration,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. “The biggest danger of any expedition is getting in a car.” Explorer Levison Wood

    Aug 31, 202614 minAudio

    Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Levison Wood answers questions submitted by H-Hour platinum patrons in a short Q&A format. Wood discusses what it was like to...

    Credit the people on this episode