Join the H-Hour Patron Community at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** In this H-Hour Icebreaker, I welcome back Bags Simmons after roughly 18 months since his last appearance on the show. Answering questions submitted by H-Hour Patrons, Bags explains that the British didn’t deploy tanks to Afghanistan, but used heavily protected armoured vehicles like Mastiff/Cougar variants, describing restricted visibility, the need to get out and speak with locals, and the major IED risk posed by predictable routes - especially canals - plus his fear of drowning if a vehicle rolled due to welded front doors and heavy rear exits. He argues the Afghanistan campaign’s aims shifted from al-Qaeda to the Taliban, lacked coherent long-term strategy, and misunderstood Afghanistan’s tribal “donut” dynamic and the Durand Line, concluding there wasn’t a clear “win” and the withdrawal was rushed on a US timeline, leaving allies behind despite strong on-the-ground performance. He also discusses pledging allegiance to the Crown and his views on the Royal Family, praising the Queen’s 70-year reign and saying Charles has transitioned well while criticizing controversies around Prince Harry and Prince Andrew, before previewing the full podcast. Send us Fan Mail Support the show Free H-Hour giveaways and exclusive access to guests. https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts H-Hour on Substack: https://hughkeir.substack.com H-Hour on WhatsApp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaWSj4p05MUbVlHmFu3y H-Hour on YouTube: https://youtube.com/@HHourPodcast
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome back to H Hour. Welcome. H Hour. I got told this should be the intro now for the pocket. I got told earlier by a patron that I say genre, strangely. Well part that's I just said genre, bags simmons in the studio. We're going to come on, we can discuss that in a minute, Bags. But for now, you need to be aware that if you've if you're new to H Hour and you've come here because you know bags, you want to listen to Bags, you want to see bags talk and hear what we've got to discuss, be aware that this is the uh this is the H hour icebreaker. This is gonna be 10 to 20 minutes of me uh asking bags questions, which were submitted by Hour patrons.
SPEAKER_00Uh they've also got the option to watch the live link here, depending on the level of patronage, and they get advanced viewing of the guest list. If you would like to do so and support the podcast and get access to do that and submit questions in advance and be watching the live link and chuck questions in there and observations, uh, which I see during the podcast, and sometimes I bring them up in discussion with the guest, then you can become a patron by following the links in the blurb of this episode. It costs about a fiver a month, depending on where you are in the world.
SPEAKER_00Five pounds in the UK, absolutely buckshi, as we would say in the fredge. Nothing, very little. Please do so and support the podcast, support the Hue, and um support HL. On to the icebreaker, followed by which is going to be the full podcast with Bags. So let it roll through. Anyway, Bags Simmons, welcome back. Long time to see you. Well, it is a long time. How long has it been about two years since we did the last TV and film episode? I think. No. I think it is. It wasn't last year, was it? No, it can't be two years.
SPEAKER_00Year and a half. Me, you and I reckon it oh god.
SPEAKER_01You mean the and the Brock. I reckon it's probably 18 months. Yeah, God, probably 18 months, because I've been away a lot. So yeah.
SPEAKER_00There you go. Craigy. There you go, yeah, but year and a half then. That's terrifying. Uh but before we get into what's been going down for the last year and a half, let's look at the questions from the patrons. Okay, we've got entirely from the patrons, none of them from you. None of these are from me, no. Okay, cool. So uh we've got six questions in here of varying subjects. Okay. Good question number. Not very good on sport, so I'll eliminate those questions.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Uh oh, this is this is a bit like a sport. Okay, cool. Uh, what is what's it like fighting the Taliban in a tank?
SPEAKER_01That's the question. Uh I wouldn't know because the British never deployed tanks to Afghanistan. So uh instead we had massive armoured vehicles. Um, very well protected. They were based on a South African vehicle that was then taken by the Yanks and up armored. The Mastiff. And that was a that was a family of vehicles. They had all different variants. Um, that then got bought by the Yanks and turned into something called the Cougar.
SPEAKER_01I can't remember what the original one was called, the South Africans, but anyway. I see some Cougar videos. Not those videos. They're the ones you've switched to VPN on for. And our sponsor for this month is no, uh, and um, but then but so so fighting in any armored vehicle is difficult because your vision is restricted. So fighting the kind of environments we were doing in Afghan was particularly difficult when you really wanted to get out and talk to the locals.
SPEAKER_01So very early on, we realized after we got over the initial shock of not everybody is trying to kill us, we then had to work out how it was how we would posture ourselves so we didn't just drive around sitting in our armoured box and cause problems. So it was you had to be you had to be a lot more thoughtful about what the local population thought of you. So getting out, talking to them, chatting to them, taking an interpreter out with you.
SPEAKER_01Um when it got into firefights, you were incredibly well protected. So um one operation I did on Herrick 13 with Smudge, uh, your friend and my friend. There's a picture of a Mastiff on screen right now. Is there?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um smudge hid behind the Mastiff as we drove across a field. So once I was being hit by PKM fire. Yeah, black smudge. Okay, one side being smashed with PKM fire, uh, and and uh the FSG hiding behind the other side of things. Well I didn't know at the time because we were going a little bit fast. Smudge was get him to tell you the story because he's trying to catch up and he's like falling out the back of the vehicle. Um, so in so in that case, we were very well protected.
SPEAKER_01The difficulty we had because um the vehicle was so big is it made us very vulnerable to IEDs because um there are only certain routes we could really go down. Um, and a lot of them were close to canals. And the Taliban had realized, or whoever we were fighting, be it the Taliban or not, but that's a much longer story. They realized that actually the only way to get to reach the vehicle was to tip it into a canal. They'd tried massive devices which had turned vehicles over.
SPEAKER_00We had a couple of vehicles turned over near canals, but but they were trying to tip us in because that was the only way to yeah, just for context, people that like a lot of the major routes in the area that we were operating at the time, uh where we as in the battle group that bags and I were attached to, three-power battle group attached to fucking bags were attached, I was three-powered three-powered battle group. Uh the main supply routes, the main roads ran parallel to canals right next to the major massive. What was that canal called?
SPEAKER_01The neb. The neb. Uh, which was short for the Nari, a Buja Canal or something like that. I'm not sure. Somebody will correct me. Uh, yeah, the Neb Canal. The the the my my biggest concern throughout the tour was the what the Americans had done to the cougar was they'd welded up the front doors. So the only way out was the gunner's hatch on top or the back doors. And if um it rolled into a canal upside down, there was no way you were getting out the hatch. And the back doors had bar armour on them, they were two very heavy doors.
SPEAKER_01Um, and so it would have it would have been probably been impossible to get anybody out had it gone into a canal. So we did devise a couple of systems, like quick ratchet straps, so a crew from the vehicle behind could jump into the canal, hook onto the back doors, and rip them open. Luckily, we never had to use them, but it was as a commander, it was my biggest fear that we were going to get drowned because that's a nasty way to go. Oh, yeah, nasty way to go. But yeah, so so fighting in a tank against the Taliban, no idea. Uh, but fighting in an armored vehicle actually, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I've heard that drowning is the best way to go. I mean, not if you've been blown up.
SPEAKER_01No, are you thinking of that film? Are you thinking of The Prestige? I don't know. Because there's a film called The Prestige, Christopher Nolan film, brilliant film if you haven't seen it. Um, a character in that Michael Cain talks about drowning being the best way to go. Um, and at the end he says, No, it's a lie, it's not, it's awful.
SPEAKER_00I don't think I've seen the prestige.
SPEAKER_01You need to watch it. It's Christopher Nolan directing. It is Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman, Michael Kane, Hugh Jackman. What's it about? Magicians, but it's brilliant. Um, David Bowie's in it playing Nikola Tesla. It's really good.
SPEAKER_00I don't think I've seen it. Really, really, really good.
SPEAKER_01You should refrain from banging the table. Sorry, I get excited about films. Um, if you haven't seen The Prestige, watch it, it's brilliant.
SPEAKER_00What do you think of the military withdrawal of Afghanistan? And could we have won? How long is this icebreaker?
SPEAKER_01Uh long enough. So, in short, I think it was a little bit flawed from the outset. So, the original reason why we went to Afghanistan was because of Al-Qaeda flying planes into the Twin Towers. The USA um uh calling on NATO um and invoking Article 5, only country ever to do it, uh, got us all involved. Um, and overnight we went from fighting al-Qaeda to fighting the Taliban.
SPEAKER_01And people used those two terms synonymously, and it's not really true. And in the end, this is why I said in the first one, we're not really fighting the Taliban, we were fighting local people that were paid by the Taliban or funded by the Taliban local groups of militia rather than the Taliban themselves. Sometimes sometimes, but not all the time. Um, so I think the whole Afghanistan campaign, for it to have worked, would have taken 40, 50, 60 years.
SPEAKER_01The way that Afghanistan has always been is like a donut. The center of the donut is where you've got Kabul, and the center of the donut is the bit that was westernized in the middle of the 20th century, and then you've got the outside of the donut, which is all the tribes, um, which do not identify with Afghanistan as a concept because they pre-exist Afghanistan, and they are the way the border was drawn between Pakistan and Afghanistan, it's called the Durand Line.
SPEAKER_01The British just drew a line on a map which went right through a couple of tribes, the Pashtun tribe being the largest, went right through that tribe. So you've got the Pashtun tribe who consider themselves Pashtun, not Afghanistan, uh not Pakistan, they are Pashtun. So nobody had ever got Afghanistan to operate as a country. When the Russians came in in the 70s and the 80s, they took over the middle bit, but again struggled with the outside bit of the donut, and this is where all the warlords sprung up.
SPEAKER_01So the British again, the British and the Americans and NATO when they came in in the early 2000s, took over the middle bit, but again, Helmand is outside of that. So I think there was a fundamental problem with what we were trying to do. Bearing in mind, we'd been in Northern Ireland, peace in Northern Ireland took 40, 50 years, and it's a tenuous piece. Whereas we thought we could get it done in 10 years. In fact, how long were we there for?
SPEAKER_0120 years? By the end of it, 2001 to 2021? Yeah, it was it was it was 20 years bang on the money. So um one of the issues I found is every operational tour I did was the the aim, the strategy wasn't really there. The tactics and what we were doing for that six months was there, but the overarching strategies wasn't really there. Eventually it morphed into building up the Afghan army and the Afghan police so they could take over when we left.
SPEAKER_01But that was a fundamental misunderstanding in how Afghanistan operates. And I remember about six months before Kabul fell, I remember listening to the story of a young chap who was uh Mujahideen during the first time when the Taliban took over. And he was in a fort up in the hills, there was a valley below, and one day they had a dispatch rider come from the next fort and said, Right, the Taliban are on their way, they're gonna be here in a week.
SPEAKER_01Prepare. Next day, another guy arrives and says, The Taliban are here, they're gonna be here in five days. I was like, the other guy said a week. Anyway, next day, another guy arrives, Taliban are gonna be here tomorrow tomorrow. And the question that everyone was asked is how are they moving so quickly? How are they defeating all these other warlords and forts along the way? Um, and then the next day that they arrived. And apparently the Taliban had the priests out front in white robes, holding the Quran with all the fighters behind them that they gathered on the way.
SPEAKER_01Because they hadn't been fighting anybody, they'd been gathering people, and they were saying, You're Afghans, we're Afghans, let's join together and run the country, rather than letting other people do it as we have done for the last hundred odd years. Let's join together. You're Afghans, we're Afghans, let's go. And everyone went, Yeah, cool. So I listened to this and then had an inkling about what was going to happen. So soon as the Afghan National Army and the Afghan National Police started to melt away, people people were saying, How are they able to fight them so easily?
SPEAKER_01How are they able to defeat them? And the answer was they weren't. They were joining them because it's Afghans with Afghans, and it was always gonna have to be an Afghan solution, as we'd seen in Northern Ireland. You can't eliminate everybody, you've got to leave it to them to do what they want to do with their country. So they were always gonna have to be part of the solution. And I think the strategy long term wasn't really there. So, um, what was the question again?
SPEAKER_01Well, the next question. What was the what was that one though? What was just remind me what that was. What do you think of the military withdrawal of Afghanistan? And could we have won? So I don't think we could have won. I don't think there is a winning. I think we could have done the withdrawal a lot better. Withdrawal was handled exceptionally quickly, and due to the US timeline, and there were a lot of people caught on the back foot. A lot of people were left behind that had entrusted their lives to us and had basically bought into the Western ideal of democracy, and then we kind of abandoned them.
SPEAKER_01We did. And there were a lot of people left on the tarmac, there are a lot of people that died, a lot of people who are still there hiding. And so I it was I'm not sure it could have gone much worse unless we had lost troops. And I mean the US did, I can't remember exactly how many they lost during that phase. I think it was 12.
SPEAKER_00I think it's important to call out, yeah, especially as obviously I'm tired I've got a a uh a bond with the with three power uh that will last forever. A positive that is on um You're talking about the the the strategy and the timelines of the withdrawal, right? Not specifically the actions and the performance of the battle group bonus on the ground doing it.
SPEAKER_01Again, the strategy wasn't there. So the the political strategy higher up was not there. The way it was handled on the ground, I thought was exceptional. Was always done the best that could ever be done. I don't think, and having done a tour with the paras with three um a para was actually incredibly impressed. I turned up being concerned I was gonna have six months being called a hat and being told to sit on my burger and watch. But I was very impressed with the the tactical and operational now that three para went about it.
SPEAKER_01Uh so no, I've no problems with that. It's the wider strategy above that that was the problem. And so I don't think we could have won unless by winning you mean either turning the entire place to glass, which that could be somebody's idea of a win, or um converting the entire a country into a westernized democracy, which would have taken generations to do, so 60 years plus. So I don't think there was a way to win.
SPEAKER_01I think the only option was to hand it back to the Afghans and to do with it what they wanted, but I don't think um I I yeah, the strategies just didn't seem to be there.
SPEAKER_00Okay. There are one, two, three, there are four more questions to go. I'll speed them up. We won't get through them all. We'll do one and then we'll go into the podcast. I'll ask the rest at the end of the podcast. Okay. They're quite complex questions. Uh yeah. Yeah. Um so I will ask you here a question, uh question from Koch again. Should the UK military have to pledge allegiance to the crown? Ooh.
SPEAKER_01That's an interesting one. That's a good question, that's a good question. Oh, that's a tough one. So the wider thing is what is the crown for? And I think it is incredibly important to have a figure head with the government to one side, and I think it's quite a good thing to pledge allegiance to the crown. Um, I think it gives everyone a common boss. Because I remember the Queen was always referred to as the boss, the big T, big B, the boss.
SPEAKER_01So um I don't think everybody should, but I think it's a good idea if people do, because having a figurehead to to rally behind is good.
SPEAKER_00Be it the regiment, be it the flagship, but I yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think I think I think people who rage against the crown, um, and I know they've been unpopular over the last few years, but people who rage against the crown maybe don't see the benefit that the crown brings. So I I would say I would say nobody has to, but I think it's a good idea if they do. Do you support the mil the royal family?
SPEAKER_00That's another question.
SPEAKER_01Again, another it's a similar one in that um I think the Queen was an incredible figurehead, and um Charles has done a very good job actually of taking over. But the wider crown has got some issues. Yeah, he hasn't he hasn't he hasn't like come in and completely trashed everything that she'd she had done and everything that she had to do.
SPEAKER_00He seems too ideologically steered and I not ideologically, not wrong, not ideologically. He seems too steered by um politics and I want to say industry, but politics mainly.
SPEAKER_01I don't know, it's difficult because he always was beforehand, and I think since he's become king, he's had to um become less outspoken. And uh how the queen spent uh you know uh the number of years she did on the thread. Was it was it was it 80 years? Was she on the throne for? I think so. It can't have been that long. No, she had a platinum jubilee. Which one's platinum? It can't have been 80 years. She came she came to the throne in 50 52. She reigned for 70 years, 214 days.
SPEAKER_01There we go, 70 years. That is incredible. It's a long old stint. So how she was able to do that for 70 years, no 6th of February 1952.
SPEAKER_00Today is the 6th of February.
SPEAKER_01I thought you were about to say it's 1952. I was like, what long live the queen? Long live the queen. So I I think she did an incredible job um keeping the nation together, but you know, I know that not everybody shares that view, but I think so.
SPEAKER_00Would it be 74 years today, would it be? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Anyway, so yeah, I I support the royal family. I don't not necessarily a fan of all the shenanigans, certainly with with Prince Harry, and definitely not with the artist formerly known as Prince Andrew. And the more that comes out about him, the the the the worse it the worse it seems. But the wider royal family and what they stand for.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Icebreaker done. We have got more questions. I will ask them to of you at the end of the podcast. Happy days. So let's take a pause, let's recharge our glasses. If you are listening to this for the first time, H hour for the first time, the next episode in your podcast app or on YouTube is gonna be the full the full podcast with bugs. And we are gonna get into what you've been up to for the last uh year and a half. Uh, we're probably, I'm gonna hypothesise, not hypothesis, I'm gonna guess. We're gonna talk about TV and film industry, we're gonna talk about defense, we're gonna talk about the state of the world right now.
SPEAKER_00Uh, we're gonna talk about maybe a little bit about politics and maybe a little bit about his military career, maybe. We'll see where we go with it. This is uh also this is not Bags' first time on a podcast. Multiple times, multiple times.
SPEAKER_01Fourth time on my own, third time.
SPEAKER_00Maybe fourth time on your own, and we've done the TV and film episodes, haven't we? Yeah, yeah, but they don't count. If you're a TV and film buff, um, I think a few people aren't. Uh, there are H hour TV and film episodes with myself, with Bags, and with our other friend Alex Von Brockdorf. Or Alex Brockdorf, he's dropped the Von, hasn't he? He dropped the Von last year. He's he's got his acting name, which I can't remember. Alex Brockdorf, is it not?
SPEAKER_01He dropped the Vaughn. I think he I think he went from I think he went from Von Brockdorf to Brock, and I think he then went back to Brockdorf. I don't know.
SPEAKER_00I'm gonna call him I'm gonna call him Brockdorfner.
SPEAKER_01But uh Brockdorfdorfner Brockdorfner. But uh but actors do this all the time. Actors have stage names that they use because they they need a name that's unique from other actors, yeah. That you can't have the same name. So um Michael Keaton. Yeah, do you know his real name? Alex von Brockdorf. No, another more famous actor that I've already mentioned Michael Cain. Michael Keaton's real name is Michael Cain. He couldn't use his real name because there was already Michael Cain. And Michael Cain's real name?
SPEAKER_01Maurice Micklewite.
SPEAKER_00Oh god. Anyway, anyway, right. Uh right. Let's get ready for poker.
Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** British Army veterans Bags Simmons (Royal Tank Regiment, Bare Arms TV & Film) and Alex Brockdorff (Queen’s Royal Hussars, actor/director, A24’s Warfare) join...
H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts Chris Dodd joins H-Hour for an extended conversation about his years in the British Army and his experiences serving in Northern Ireland, Iraq and Afghanistan. A badged...
H-Hour on Patreon: https://patreon.com/hkpodcasts In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Chris Dodd answers questions submitted by H-Hour patrons in a Q&A format. Topics include whether all infantry should be trained to the...
Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** Levison Wood returns to H-Hour for his second appearance on the podcast, having first featured in 2019. This expansive conversation covers war, exploration,...
Become a Patron of H-Hour at patreon.com/hkpodcasts ***** In this H-Hour Icebreaker episode, Levison Wood answers questions submitted by H-Hour platinum patrons in a short Q&A format. Wood discusses what it was like to...