Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Grub & Grace

Grub & Grace artwork

BSE: Once An Addict, Always An Addict & J-O-Y

Apr 23, 202617 minAudio

In this episode, we examine two common ideologies often promoted in religious rehab and recovery spaces: “Once an addict, always an addict” and “J-O-Y: Jesus first, others second, yourself last.” While these ideas are frequently presented as spiritually grounded wisdom, we explore how they can become harmful when used as the foundation for addiction treatment. We discuss how “once an addict, always an addict” may reinforce shame, hopelessness, and a fixed identity around addiction rather than recovery, and how the J-O-Y framework can encourage chronic self-neglect, poor boundaries, and the belief that personal needs are inherently less important than everyone else’s. This episode looks at why these teachings persist, why many people find comfort in them, and how even well-intentioned beliefs can create damaging outcomes when applied uncritically in recovery settings.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Drug and alcohol substance abuse impacts many people. In 2017, Pew Research published stats stating that nearly half of all Americans directly know someone who has a substance use disorder, an SUD. A peer -reviewed study published in 2019 stated that 73 % of addiction treatment programs in the US include a spiritually based element. as embodied in the 12 -step programs and fellowships initially popularized by Alcoholics Anonymous,

the vast majority of which emphasize reliance on God or a higher power to stay sober. Seeing as how religion and spirituality plays such a large part in the majority of rehab treatment programs here in America, I would like to discuss some common ideologies utilized as a foundation for methods within many of these religious facilities. More specifically, I would like to touch on the concept of once an addict, always an addict, as well as the joy model, J -O -Y. Jesus first,

others second, yourself last. Where cognitive behavioral therapy, CBD, is especially effective and a research -backed model, many religious rehab programs decide to go with non -science -backed methods instead. So, this is where we're at. Once an addict, always an addict, shortened to O -A -A -A, is an idea that implies that if you were once addicted to meth, food, alcohol, or sex, that you will always be addicted. It

implies that there is no way of changing your state. This idea that anyone is powerless over any substance or external additive force, let alone forever though, is simply not supported by research. So let's break this down. It perpetuates a feeling of shame. The O -A -A -A label comes with a lot of negative weight. Laziness, powerlessness, hopelessness, loser, untrustworthy. Given that

stance, they will be less likely to seek help for their problematic drinking, drug use, or porn use for fear of being labeled or shamed by those they love. An addiction expert, Dr. John Kelly, said that People who feel more stigmatized are less likely to seek treatment, even if they have the same level of addiction severity, and that they're also more likely to drop out of a treatment if they feel stigmatized and ashamed.

Dr. Kelly also found through a study that physicians and clinical psychologists exposed to the term substance abuser in a vignette. were more likely to blame a hypothetical patient for his or her condition than were those exposed to the phrase having a substance use disorder. Clinicians in the first group were also more likely to say that punishment was required as opposed to treatment. Howard Koh, a professor in Harvard's Chan School of Public Health, talks about the words we choose

and how they impact care. Words matter. The words we use convey what's normal and frame how clinicians, health professionals, and society at large view a problem, says Ko. If we don't choose our words carefully, we perpetuate bias, cloud understanding, and end up distancing ourselves from the people we want to help. Once an addict, always an addict, keeps individuals feeling powerless and small.

The term addict alone can contribute to destructive cycles. A 2019 study by Robert Ashford shows how using substance use disorder, SUD, rather than addict, contributes to a better success rate. If you have this idea that you'll always be an addict, even if you are able to stop using substances, you will always live with a shadow over your shoulder for the rest of your life. And if you do happen to slip up, then the guilt

and shame will consume you, easily spiraling you down the hole again. If you live by the logic of O -A -A -A, then you must be reliant on something, like your reliance of faith in God's redeeming grace, regardless of how fragile that may be. Recovery is not a linear process. Instances of slip -ups or relapse are often used as proof that the addiction is as strong as ever, but

in fact, they are great learning opportunities, much like mistakes are in any other field. Relapse, though, is a sign that they have been trying, not that you are doomed or damaged. It also might mean the current treatment method they are using isn't a good fit. They should keep searching for one that actually does. Recovery doesn't look the same for everyone. The more we try to shove people in the same recovery box, the fewer people we will actually help. When we measure

recovery success as an absence of relapse, we're setting people up for failure. According to the National Institute on Drug Abuse, relapse rates among recovering alcoholics are between 50 to 90 % in the first four years after rehab. For recovering drug addicts, rates are between 40 and 60%. And those are the people who actually complete the program. Not everyone has the same goal of abstinence though. Abstinence can be

a barrier preventing folks from seeking help if they just want to gain control of their intake. It should never be a requirement. Abstinence will quite likely come once the client has worked through their traumas. triggers, and unhealthy coping mechanisms, even if total abstinence is the only way. It still should never be an upfront requirement, as studies have shown that can be a barrier in getting adequate treatment in the first place. If people accept the idea of once

an addict, always an addict, they may expect to keep struggling with addiction, which can make that outcome more likely. Admitting that you are powerless over your addiction can, in turn, become self -fulfilling and exacerbate any negative self -talk among those who struggle. These self -fulfillments would be calling things like experimenter bias, expectancy effect, and confirmation bias. Addiction is not a lifelong

characteristic. Believing addiction will last forever places a huge emotional and psychological burden on recovered addicts. Addiction is a spectrum disorder like depression and every person is different. In fact, according to the National Institute on Alcoholism and Alcohol Abuse, 75 % of alcoholics recover without treatment. Recovery may actually improve resiliency to new addictions.

According to a JMA study, people who recover from an SUD have less than half the risk of developing a new SUD. This proves that recovering from one substance does not typically lead to drug substitution, but actually reduces the likelihood of developing a new SUD. Simply overcoming the physical dependence doesn't necessarily mean a person is fully recovered. It doesn't mean their quality of life has improved. There are many more variables that should be

accounted for, like daily functioning, criminal involvement, and social integration. What happens throughout their journey to recovery is that they gain a recovery toolbox that helps them navigate life's challenges and stresses in a much healthier way. The model of OAAA, once an addict, always an addict, is at best a well -intended remedy for SUDs, and at worst, a destructive mechanism that keeps individuals locked in and

may or may not be well -intentioned. Well -intentions are never a good model to base anything off of. especially when it comes to recovery for people who may be in their most vulnerable time of their lives. The common model for recovery that I've heard in religious treatment facilities is the J -O -Y model, joy. It's Jesus first, others second, yourself last. This idea is loosely derived from biblical principles, particularly the command

to love God and love your neighbor as yourself. However, Some interpretations argue that the Bible does not explicitly mandate this order as a strict rule, emphasizing instead the importance of loving others in a balanced way, similar to how you love yourself. There is a false equivalency though, between a term that is defined as a deep and immense happiness, joy, with a phrase that arguably views taking care of your own needs

as sinful. J -O -Y carries an intonation of shame and a message of the sinfulness of selfishness, something that to question it is likened to questioning the sacredness of motherhood or the divinity of Jesus Christ himself. When it comes to recovery, attempts to take care of oneself is often branded as nothing more than unrepentant narcissism. This leads to unhappiness and pain being treated by forgetting about your own needs and giving

ourselves totally to the needs of others. In the Bible, when Elijah fled from Jezebel in 1 Kings chapter 19 and sank into a suicidal depression, the Lord didn't rebuke him for his lack of faith or his lack of dedication. In fact, God didn't attempt to treat his depression with a spiritual solution at all. He sent an angel with food and told Elijah to eat and sleep. And when he woke up, well, to eat and sleep again. Jesus took

out time from serving others to rest and to be alone. He knew the value of having boundaries, that if you give until the cup is dry, you'll soon have nothing left to give at all. The JOY principle is based on a faulty model of Christians without cracks, super beings who have no needs of their own and thus are free to give unstintingly of themselves to others. It's not only a faulty view of what it means to be a Christian, but also on a faulty view of God as well. Hebrews

4 tells us that Jesus, our high priest, sympathizes with our weaknesses because he lived in a human body too. Psalm 103 says that God has compassion on us just as a father has compassion on his children because he knows our frame and knows that we are but dust. Can one really separate loving God from loving people? Is it possible to love God without loving others? In Matthew 22, 36 -40, Jesus says that the greatest commandment

of the law is to love the Lord your God. And then he equals loving your neighbor as you love yourself as the whole basis for what the law rests upon. This isn't love your neighbor better than or less than yourself, but equal to. If someone hates themselves, won't they hate their fellow man? Part of understanding how to best love and care for others is learning how to best love and care for ourselves. Lastly, about J

-O -Y. The idea of placing God, others, and yourself in a hierarchical order can aid in slowly disintegrating a sense of self and erodes at our ability to doubt the fallibility of man's judgments. It's what creates a world where those in powerful positions are able to get away with abuse or fraud so easily, while those victimized by abuse or cast as outsiders can be so quickly pushed to the side. Why would we allow a tactic so often

used in cults such as the Moonies, the Branch Davidians, Heaven's Gate, the Children of God, or Synanon to impact our lives, particularly one that is loosely based on the Word of God? By removing the sense of self in individuals, they can be easily susceptible to manipulative schemes. A 2020 article by the Stanford Report explores Stanford anthropologist Tanya Lerman's book about the intersection of religion and science.

She found that religion can, in fact, provide positive mental health outcomes, not solely because of religion, but rather how it's represented. The article says, Research has repeatedly shown that people of faith report feeling better and healthier. One of the most striking findings in social epidemiology, Lerman notes, is that religious involvement with God is better for your body in terms of immune functions and reducing

loneliness. One explanation for this, Lerman writes, is that for those who with an intense faith God becomes a social relationship. MRI results indicate that in terms of brain function, talking to God resembles conversing with a friend. But the nature of that relationship is also key in terms of health. The more that God is seen as judgmental and negative, the more mental health symptoms are reported. In contrast, people who

represent their relationship with God as being loving and satisfying pray more and report fewer mental health symptoms. The data suggests that when it's a good relationship, it's better for the body, Lerman said. If the way a person experiences God can measurably shape their mental and physical health, then the implications are difficult to ignore. The image of God we internalize becomes the lens through which we understand our worth,

our limits, our needs, and that lens is not neutral. When faith encourages connection, compassion, and mutual care, it nurtures well -being. But when it distorts those values into self -neglect, quiet suffering, or chronic unworthiness, it begins to mirror the very harm it claims to heal. It is not belief itself that restores us, but the nature of the relationship that belief creates.

And if that relationship is rooted in fear, shame, or diminishment, if your connection to God is conditional, then we should question what exactly is being formed in the name of healing. At some point, we have to ask what kind of healing demands that you stay broken in your identity or disappear in your personhood, because that's what these models do. They keep you small, dependent, and easy to control. But real healing, doesn't come

from shrinking yourself. It comes from learning to exist fully, honestly, and perfectly with agency. And if you're religious, feeling the unconditional love of God. And if that kind of wholeness challenges the system, then maybe it's the system that needs saving, not you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ashtiname of Muhammad w/ Mark Wayne of the Colonial Outcasts podcast

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 56 minAudio

    Two white Christians, who love Muslims, breakdown myths and misconceptions that many Americans (and more specifically Christians) have about Islam and Muslims. Mark Wayne of the Colonial Outcasts podcast joins in the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Business of Immigration and ICE | Enchantments of Mammon Ep. 8

    Oct 5, 20261 hrAudio

    Capitalism has a long and ugly history of scapegoating and exploiting immigrants. From British capitalists exploiting Irish people to the United States’ deeply systemic and oppressive tactics, immigrants have, for a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Exploiting Women in the Patriarchal Capitalist Machine | Enchantments of Mammon Ep. 7

    Sep 14, 202635 minAudio

    This is part 7 of the Enchantments of Mammon series. Capitalism needs a permanent source of unpaid labor. Childbearing, child raising, cooking, cleaning, caregiving, emotional support. The invisible work that keeps...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Racism of For-Profit Capitalist Exploitation | Enchantments of Mammon Ep. 6

    Sep 7, 202625 minAudio

    Marx’s analysis does not specifically take into account the history of the exploitation of women and non-white people. We will be digging into some of the ways that racism, sexism, and xenophobia play into the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Prosperity Gospel of Capitalism | Enchantments of Mammon Ep. 5

    Aug 31, 202618 minAudio

    Spiritual maturity and financial security are often married within the church business model. How do we identify patterns of abuse and work toward a more sustainable future? Let's get into it in today's episode of part...

    Credit the people on this episode