Have you ever asked big theological questions about faith and God that you felt weren't acceptable in your immediate community to share? Have you ever felt that your faith tradition hasn't been living up to your vision of how it should be? You're not alone, and neither should it be that way. For us, Theology Beer Camp has been a space that allowed us to be us, and created a space to express yourself free of judgement and shame. Join us as we quest through Theology Beer Camp in St. Paul, MN, 2025.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
As of the release of this episode, it's only been a couple weeks since attending an event called Theology Beer Camp. Think of it as a space to nerd out on biblical and theological matters while enjoying communion with like -minded individuals over a beer or two. But this ain't your typical church -faring event. Every person is welcome with no judgments or conditions, whether you're straight, gay, trans, a believer, an unbeliever.
Even amongst the speakers, there are a diversity of people and ideas represented. In two and a half days, I felt like I was in church community more than I had my entire life. No strings attached, no shame, just an allowance to express yourself for who God made you to be. And all while hearing some of the brightest minds in their respective fields, like John Dominic Crossan, It was so
fun rubbing shoulders with these big names in the world of theology and biblical scholarship. If you're currently questioning whether the faith tradition that you've known all your life isn't quite living up to the expectations that you hold it to, Then consider checking out Theology Beer Camp in 2026 next fall. They have already announced that it will be taking place in Kansas City. In this episode, I invite Pastor Will Rose
and Ryan Doze to talk about our experience at the camp. The theme this year was Monty Python, so if you're familiar with that comedy style, I must ask. What is the average wind speed velocity of an unladen swallow? Or perhaps you could just tell me your favorite color or something. I should give you an explicit warning as we do use some choice language throughout the episode. So if you have children around, perhaps this might not be the best episode for them. And now I present
you, without intermissions, my conversation with Will Rose and Ryan Doze. Mark, where are we? I believe it looks like Theology Beer Camp 2025. Oh, man. We're still on the quest or have we
quested it? I believe we're still on the quest. I think there's still things going on. At the time of recording, we are questing. When you listen to this, the jury is still out there whether we achieved our quest or not, but we are questing at the moment. We are questing. Oh my gosh, that's good. Yeah. Mark, who do we have with us? I've been on your show, but our friend Ryan here. Oh, you have been. I have been on the show. Who do we have here? Ryan, introduce yourself and
tell us your favorite person named Will. Who's your favorite person named Will? I have an answer for this. Okay. All right. You're not going to like it. So my name is Ryan Doze. I am a podcaster because look at me. And I've had the privilege of doing God Pod stuff at Beer Camp a few years. Helped lead a few panels. And Will and I are friends. But my favorite Will. Okay, here we go. I low -key love Will Poulter. The actor.
Hey, I'll take backseat to Will Poulter any day. He is so stinking handsome. And on one of my favorite shows of all time, The Bear. Like when he shows up on The Bear. Will Poulter's on The Bear? Will Poulter is on The Bear. And an incredible, like deep into the seasons and good stuff. Look him up. I'm thinking we're the Millers, Will Poulter. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. He's kidding. He's like, you guys were getting paid? Yeah. Yeah. So Ryan is the leader and podcaster of Across the Bifrost, the Mighty Thor podcast that I am
co -host on when I have time. And we met through. Geek Stage and Thor. You're like co -host emeritus at this point. Co -host emeritus. And yeah, so we geeked out on comics and Thor and met so many years ago way back when, the before times. And then we've been a part of Beer Camp and curating the Geek Stage that's now the Pop God Stage, Pop Culture Stage. And here we are. And Mark, we met, I met in Denver last year. And I've done a few episodes and stuff. So Mark, thank you
for having us on here. Let's record at beer camp. And yeah. Well, I just got to say, thank you for joining us again, Will. And then Ryan, I just got to say, you are not the Messiah. You're a very naughty boy. Believe it or not, not the first time I've heard that. So for context, the theme of this Theology Beer Camp is Money Python, or just Money Python in general. So we decided to play a little game here. Quest for the Holy Stein. Since it's Beer Camp, we have a stein.
Everyone got a stein when we got here. So we've got a few Money Python quotes that we need to work into the conversation naturally. And that was the first. one that I chose. Nice. You are not the Messiah. He's a very naughty boy. I agree with that. We also have our coconuts here as well. That's what we wrote in on. Yes, that's what we wrote in on. I don't remember you wearing those. Yes. Why do you think they got here? These right here? It's natural for us to do that. Ryan did that earlier with those same coconuts. I did do it. And one of our other friends, Sarah,
was like, hey! And I was like, oh, no. No. Not allowed. Keep it on, man. So, Will, you came up with a creative little topic that we can kind of talk on, talking about the curiosity of what kind of sparked our imagination through this whole, everybody talking on the panels and everything going on at the College of Beer Camp. Maybe you could just explain kind of your idea of what you were thinking with that. Yeah, I think we're
basically at Trip Fuller Con convention. Into the Fullerverse. Into the Fullerverse. We're into the Fullerverse at this point. Yeah, we're going to go to a gig. I like that. Look at what we're doing. And over a course of many years, we also called him the Podfather because he was one of the original people to really do some podcasting. And he has a whole origin story of getting into theology and reading books and talking to authors. We don't necessarily have to read the books, but hear the conversations around it. And so he's doing it for many, many years.
And over the years, it's grown. Fan base has grown. The listenership has grown. The hunger for community in a safe and brave and courageous space to ask big questions that often churches don't allow for or are afraid of or get defensive about, Tripp provides that space. And so Beer Camp has grown over the years, and here we are. And so he has everything from, yes, beer and steins and humor and skits and laughter, but also some of the... most intelligent minds you can think of around theology and philosophy. And, and they do, um, what's the word I'm looking
for? Keynoting. TED Talks. Why did I jump in? I know. Thanks for clarifying that. Thanks for nothing. Thanks for nothing. But no, like keynotes and conversations and speakers who speak to that and then break off into workshops and smaller conversations. So you have anything from a room of 500 people listening to an amazing speaker to a breakout workshop where there's 10 or 20 or 30 or 40 people or someone sitting in the
corner talking to their favorite podcast. or having a beer and asking them questions. And so the beauty of this space, it is a brave and safe and courageous space to ask those questions that everybody wrestles with, and I love it. So this year, this is my church hosted in 2022. And so it's cool to provide that space for others and open the church doors where people, some people haven't walked in a church in a long time or felt comfortable, but yet we opened our doors. And along the way, we had the venues that did the same. Last year, we had St. Mark's, and now
we have Awaken Community, which is doing the same. And it's a really cool space. So my question was, what stands out this year? You know, you've been to a few. You've been to two now. Is there a speaker? Is there a topic or something this go around that you kind of resonate with or kind of stands out? Real fast for me, Philip Clayton doing that. cosmic big picture to small picture about the groaning of the universe, interweaving science and theology. I geek out hard on that. And he did that beautifully. And it was, I know it was so good. So to hear him, I've heard him
before and read some of his books, but not do it live. And to see that live was actually incredible. So do you mind if I go? Yeah, no, this is your dog and pony show. Go ahead. So I, because this is, I swear to God, this is, Sorry. I swear this is not a flex, but this year I was just busier doing more stuff. I love doing all the fun things. I haven't sat in on many panels this year, but
there was, we're talking about this year specifically. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Then I will stow that story away. Cause I'm still reeling from Robert Jones and Diana Butler's thing from two years ago. Right. Ridiculous. This year, though, I love listening to John Dominic Crossan. And our other mutual friend, Josh Patterson, has had to explain to me who he is. Because here's the thing. That
name gets thrown around and people are like, oh, my gosh. If I could only be near him. Yeah. Breathe the same air. And I'm like, I don't know who this old man is. When he explains stuff with this kind of folksy charm and humor, he's like a Jim Henson's Muppet come to life. And I mean that in a good way. We're laughing because we resonate with what you're saying. He's so cartoony, but then brilliant. And I don't understand. One
of my things, Will knows this. Mark, we've talked about this many times. I don't know half. of half of what they're talking about no of course not and i'm not like i'm not gonna stand there and be like oh yes yeah like i i'm inherently curious and inquisitive but when he talks i'm just like you are just a dude who thought about stuff for a long time and has like what diana said something the opening night or the opening morning friday of like that we're seeing she
points to john and says we're seeing someone who has lived There was so much ebbs and flows and seasons of passion, seasons of drought, you know, all this stuff. And it was just nice. It was really, really nice to see an old man speak with so much whimsy and care that his disposition is what I go out of thinking. Yeah. If we could all be that in 80 years, that'd be incredible. That's why I think he gets along with Tripp so well is because they have that same kind of,
I don't mind being funny and loose and whimsical, but also brilliant. And across his 90 years, we don't know how much more time we have with him. He looks great. He doesn't need a walker or wheelchair. He's zipping around all over the place. And it's almost like if he ran to the door or something happened, it would be like, oh, it's just a flesh wound. I think that's kind of what he would say. I forgot we were playing a game. And so I think that's the way it would be. You slut. That was well -placed. But no,
I hear you. It is like some of these giants in scholarship and New Testament scholarship are... It's an honor to be a part of them, but also to be in this kind of space, which feels often like a high school youth group lock -in meets. uh, theology conference meets open bar. Yeah. The craziest wedding you've ever been to. Yeah. Good stuff. How about you? Like what's, what's standing out? I was going to say, I just, I just had to, you know, interrupt your program to annoy
you and make things generally more irritating because, um, thank you. Thank you. That sounds a lot like beer camp. Um, no, uh, no, like, like, like you were talking, we were talking about earlier, Ryan, that, that, you were talking about that these people like you don't know half of half of what they're talking about and that we just feel like a big dumb bag of nails and your words and i it was perfect it was like i resonated with that so much i did tell you that yesterday like on my podcast here i i talk about a lot
of smart things but i'm pulling from so many other people that talk about the smart things and i just adapt that into my dialogue of what i do i i feel like I'm just like a blank canvas, pulling all this stuff in, even when I'm researching and whatnot, and even when I talk about it on my episodes. But then I come here and I feel like I don't know jack shit. Mark. This is probably the first time. I'll probably have to do a disclaimer. Just a flesh wound. A verbal flesh wound. A verbal
flesh wound. A verbal flesh wound. It's just one. I've never heard that in traffic before. That needs to be a Grub and Grace t -shirt. Oh. Verbal flesh wound. Verbal flesh wound. Welcome to verbal flesh wound. I mean, I just had Brian Rucker on a previous episode here and he gave a little panel and it's just like, you know, great to hear him talk and talk about, you know, the concept of hell and how that, you know, shapes our life in general. And then you get like John Dominic Cross talking about, you know, the groaning
of the universe. And even just, you know, the scientific, you know, bringing stuff into that. And I mean, I don't even know specifically what to bring up on all that. It's just like, everything they talk about is blowing my mind. I'm going to have to watch some replays because it's just like, I can't retain everything, especially with like a beard. These podcasts are not listening at 2 .5 with, you know, no way. You got to slow it down. You ever tried to listen to Trip at 2 .5? No. It is dizzying. Yeah. So I need to ask, Mark, is this the first beer camp you've traveled for? Yes. Because the last one, correct
me if I'm wrong, but the last one was at your home church, home area? It's at my home church. It's the church that we call our home. So I remember my first beer camp, and I was definitely out of my element. I knew Will. I knew a few people, kind of. But I felt like I was being hit with a fire hose. Being the ambitious, you know, like, I just want to sound smart. I know I'm not going to be the smartest guy in the room, but if I
can crack the top 10, that'd be awesome. I tried to be that guy for my first beer camp. I got demolished. Yeah. Like my GED was powerless against all of this. And I went home kind of disappointed almost because I was looking at it like a church conference. It's like a Craig Groeschel men's conference. And I was disappointed. So in comparison to last year's beer camp, your first beer camp, to this one, what has been the biggest difference?
What did you learn over the course of the year leading up to this that maybe helped you come into this one with a different attitude? Something like that. I think it helped that I made... Like I grew my network through everyone like you guys and through everyone that I met last time. I think it helped humble me because I was very similar to you. Like I went in, I wouldn't necessarily say that I was trying to be the smartest one in the room. None of us was dumb in this setting.
No, of course not. You got to come up with something, right? But yeah, it was like a fire hose. Like you get just sprayed in the face and it's humbling. To be around so many people like that. But I think more so than that, I think the biggest kind of shock with it all for me was that coming out of this fundamentalist circle, Bible literalism, and not that I really adhere to it, I was a part of that community. That was my whole life growing up, was growing up in the church and being a
part of that system. You know, right around COVID, like kind of starting to question things and whatnot, I didn't really have a community of people that I could really talk to honestly about this kind of stuff. And so it was more internalized. So when I found this group and, you know, I started listening to like New Evangelicals and then opened up to like Homebrew Christianity, like Trip Fuller. Across the Bifrost. And it opened up to you guys. Relationality. Yeah. So it opened up all this stuff. But then actually attending my first beer
camp. It was just, it felt refreshing. Yeah. It was just nice to find this community of people, even if it was just for a weekend. You found your people. It set my heart ablaze in a way. I think he's going to preach. Here we go. My heart is strangely warm. Hallelujah. It's one of the grossest. Thanks, Wesley. Like, I get it. Thanks, Wesley. I get it. As a Lutheran minister who Martin Luther said some really shitty things,
at least you have Wesley who said, at least my heart was strangely warm. That was John, right? Yeah. Someone just said to me, like, John. you're going to need to cool it. That's right. No, it's warm. We're all uncomfortable. It's like warm brownies. It's like warm gooey brownies. My heart is fresh out the oven. So, Mark, would you say that... So you're trying to clarify him right now? You're going to repeat what you just said. That when you were in this former conservative, biblically literal, which, by the way, I'm from
that experience too. Would you say that you were able to see the violence inherent in the system and say, help, help, I'm being repressed? I'd say if you can't see the shit on, then it must be a king, right? Oh! Oh! Oh! I waited so long to say my quote, and Mark was just like, and counter. Well, speaking of us recording this, speaking of we're recording this on No King's Day, and, you know, this being a safe space,
I think strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government. Wouldn't you guys agree? On No King's Day. Really, this is political science. Really? We're doing poli -sci now. We're not doing open and relational theology. We're doing poli -sci. Poli -sci according to the question of the high grill. Poli -sci. Oh, my God. I sure hope my listener base is picking up all these. They're smart. They're smart. I know you are. Verbal flesh wounds. Oh, my gosh. Fun. Wowzers. Wowzers. Yeah. I mean, everything,
everything going on. I mean, we're all talking about like social justice. There's a lot of social justice talk going on. And I think it's very. apt to be talking about it, especially with the No Kings protest going on right now and everything going on in our socio -political sphere and everything. And a lot of people are afraid and a lot of people are scared. And I think a lot of the stuff that people talking at the Theology Beer Camp here has been a message of hope, a message of what things could be and how we can come together and support each other and support those who are oppressed, marginalized, and pushed aside.
Even though we're living in a very scary time within this region of the world, it's nice to be able to have this community of like -minded people that are talking about these subjects and not just being silent and therefore complicit in what's happening and what's actually being implemented within our current empire and system right now. Yeah, I think people attend Theology of Spirit Camp, one, because they're fans of Tripp and what he does, but also to gather people like them, to reconnect with people that maybe
saw before, but also just to find their people. And Tripp's cultivated an online community of learning and growing, and it's his spiritual community that he helps curate. And yeah, it's really smart, but he also has... He's a youth pastor at heart, so he wants to bring people together. And creating this space for that, I think, is really important. They can do all those things on top of each other. And so, yeah. Well, I couldn't agree with you more. I think there's this imagery that I associate with beer camp
now. Because one of the things we do at beer camp a lot is a lot of beers get poured out. A lot of beers. There's a constant pouring, pouring in, pouring out, pouring in, pouring out. And I think it's a pretty good metaphor. for what beer camp does. Cause almost all year we are constantly pouring out energy into our own families, our own relationships, our own communities, if we have them. And then because some of us, like what Mark was saying, like some of us have kind of. either voluntary or involuntary. We've adopted
this outcast status from an established church, a former church, things like that. And what we do is we spend so much time in our year pouring out, pouring out, pouring out, pouring out to good things, and then pouring out to things like, how in the world do I keep up with the news? You're never going to be able to. That's 24 hours, and eventually you have to sleep. So you're keeping up, you're keeping up, you're pouring out, you're pouring out. Beer camp is... My I've told Will this so many times, Mark, it is the one time
a year I get to be with my friends and be completely myself and without even intentionally doing anything. We are filling each other back up with the energy and the effort and the spirit we need the rest of the year. Will and I never, ever plan. Be like, hey, I'm calling for my hour -long discipleship talk. My accountability partner. Yes. You signed
up for April 11th at 3 p .m. Yeah, because here's the truth. I'm not a religious studies guy or whatever. That doesn't work. I spent 20 -plus years trying to make it work. It didn't work. Instead, friendship worked. Care worked. Empathy worked. Will has talked me through some of the, and sorry, this is not like the Will Rose spotlight hour, but it should be. Will has helped me through so many difficult areas of life, and never once
was I like, gee, pastor, do you got an easy answer for my very complicated problem? Why, yes. Here's the Hallmark greeting card version. Or read this book. You'll be good. Yeah. Read. Will knows. I don't read. You read comics. Come on. You read. You read every day. I read. As long as it's got pictures, I'll read it. Which is what Kim tells me all the time. Pictures. Words with pictures. I'm just saying like that constant pouring out. Yeah. That's a good analogy. It is. Really good.
It is how I've just. It's a good visualization for beer camp. So we're all pouring out at all times. Okay, yeah. All right, I'm going to keep going with this metaphor. So Trip provides us with kegs. Are you about to grab those? Are you about to grab your coconuts? Are you about to grab your coconuts? All right, there. Since Mark did it, I wanted to do it. I know, you were like, I need to do this. This looks fun. So Trip not only, to go with this metaphor even further, he provides beer. He provides kegs. He has sponsors
and people. We have one called the Holy Hop Grenade, a theology beer can. Holy Hop Grenade. A theology beer can. This might be backfired a little bit. You know, here it is. I'm going to pour it out. But I think, you know, they provide a lot, a lot of beer. But also, he also has a bottle share. So he invites people to bring what they brought with them from their homes, their favorite beer to the table. So he's not only saying, let's do craft beer together. What are we going to? Homebrew Christianity. How are we going to homebrew our faith and pull together all the ingredients
around? Bring your own spice of life. Bring your own spice of life. And it could be like a black porter. It could be wine. It could be a truly. It could be something. Could it be an IPA? It could be the best beer ever, which is an IPA for maybe. Since there's like a ton of white guys here. There needs to be some hoppy stuff. Come on, man. Everything else is boring. But we bring the bottle share. So we bring what we bring here as well. It's not just him providing. for you and let me tell you how to do religion right or whatever. You're not being told what to do. Not being told. You're being invited to
bring your favorite stuff to the table too. I think that's beautiful. I think it's also important to bring out your dad too. That wasn't on the card. I'm not dead yet. I'm not dead yet. Be quiet back there. I'm not dead yet. But I'm not dead. But I'm not dead. Bring out your dead. But I'm not dead. That's a good one. Good one. Super fun, guys. This is great. And yeah, I mean. And we're anticipating where it'll be next time.
What's going to be, you know, he tries to go around the country. And so if this is your first time listening to Grim Grace or Across the Bifrost or Systemic Ecology, if this is your first time or you haven't heard of Theology of Beer Camp, you know, find Trent Fuller and follow his website and his sub stack. where it's going to be next time, we'd love to meet you in person because that's what it is. It's cool to listen and follow and see what's up going on with his online classes, but also to see people in person. I mean, Will and I have been friends for going on five years
this year, which is a lot. I was 10 pounds lighter then. And I was weirdly not. There's some shirts from that year I can't fit into. Fantastic. I was just going to say, you and I are very good friends. We don't see each other all the time. We see each other once, maybe twice a year. Some
of my greatest friends live all the way across the country. Maryland, Tennessee, North Carolina, California. It's just crazy. I live in the middle of Nebraska. Canada. We have a friend in Canada. One of our co -hosts on Across the Bifrost is from Canada, and he would be ashamed. Canada sounds real nice about right now. He keeps inviting us. One day we're just going to show up with our podcast equipment. We're living with you for a year. I've asked him about the guest room.
His wife's going to be like, oh, God. Oh no. All these refugees. But I'm just saying it is a place where so many people from different walks of life, different stories that you may think. It's like, oh, I deconstructed from my evangelical church. Fantastic. But you are uniquely you even if some of the elements of your story sound like other people's. When you come here though, there is a common lexicon of pain. There is a common...
That was good. A common lexicon of pain. That's good. That's a big word. I wouldn't say that's a big old dumb bag of nails. Write that down. Okay, well, I'm going to continue to try and sound smart. But there is this... It's a common language. If someone says, I was hurt by the church, you know what they're not going to do? Well... You probably didn't pray enough or anything. Here, though, it is assumed that you mean what
you say and that your pain is validated. So when you come from these different places, it creates a common ground that you didn't even really realize was there. And so that's what I love about beer camp. It's one of the things I love about beer camp is that lexicon of pain. you can that's the name of my metal band that's it i'm gonna write that down but you know that being said you know it is kind of a love fest but also like we're challenged to and and so you don't go home
empty -handed you don't go empty -handed yeah yeah so hey do you hear that yeah I think the horse is here. The horse is getting ready to go. Here we go. We've got to roll back out. Off of Camelot. We're out. Time to head back out to some more workshops and humor and after parties and beer and connections. And so, Mark, thanks for what you do. Thanks for what you do, man. Thanks, buddy. Thanks, guys. Thank you for the invite. Yeah. Oh. We're out. You shall pass. You shall pass. What? It's the part of the movie
where Eric Idle is like, you must get through this castle of all these beautiful virgins. He's like, I can take them. I can take them. What is it, the troll? What is the password or whatever? What is your favorite color? Green. No, blue. Follow me if you dare. Look at the bones. All right, peace out. That was fun, dude. Hopefully you got some usable stuff in there. Hopefully.
That's it for today's episode of Grub and Grace. I hope you enjoyed my discussion with Will Rose and Ryan Doze about our experience and curiosity at Theology Beer Camp 2025. I want to give a big thank you to Will and Ryan for joining me on this episode. If you would like to find out where to listen to more of Will Rose, he shows up on numerous podcasts on the Anizow Podcast Network, but primarily Systematic Ecology and The Homily with Will Rose. You can find Ryan
on the podcast Across the Bifrost. If you like the content that we produce, consider rating and reviewing us on Apple Podcasts or Spotify or wherever else you listen to. It would really help the algorithm. And as always, until next time, stay curious, keep an open mind and celebrate the traditions that bring us all together.
Two white Christians, who love Muslims, breakdown myths and misconceptions that many Americans (and more specifically Christians) have about Islam and Muslims. Mark Wayne of the Colonial Outcasts podcast joins in the...
Capitalism has a long and ugly history of scapegoating and exploiting immigrants. From British capitalists exploiting Irish people to the United States’ deeply systemic and oppressive tactics, immigrants have, for a...
This is part 7 of the Enchantments of Mammon series. Capitalism needs a permanent source of unpaid labor. Childbearing, child raising, cooking, cleaning, caregiving, emotional support. The invisible work that keeps...
Marx’s analysis does not specifically take into account the history of the exploitation of women and non-white people. We will be digging into some of the ways that racism, sexism, and xenophobia play into the...
Spiritual maturity and financial security are often married within the church business model. How do we identify patterns of abuse and work toward a more sustainable future? Let's get into it in today's episode of part...