I invited Mike Maeshiro to have a conversation about creating safe spaces for those who hold trauma from religious institutions and churches. I learned a lot through this conversation as we talked about mourning with those who mourn (Romans 12:15), being slow to speaking and quick to listening, as well as what it looks like to put in the hard work of creating a safe space for those grieving or mourning. Join us as we dig deep into this space. You can find more information about Mike through his website https://www.mikemaeshiro.com/ as well as through social media. Instagram: @mikemaeshiro Youtube: @mikemaeshiro3965 Facebook: Mike Maeshiro X: @MikeMaeshiro Tik Tok: @mikemaeshiro All ideas and viewpoints presented should be taken as opinion. Be sure to give us a 5-star rating on Apple podcast and leave us a shining review. Also be sure to like and follow us on social media on Facebook, Instagram, and X. grubandgrace.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to Grub and Grace. We're not all heroes, we're crepes. I am Mark Flower, and I will be having a conversation with my revered guest, Mike Mayashiro. We will be discussing how we can make room and safe spaces for those who are carrying religious trauma, to grieve properly, and how to allow ourselves to get out of our own echo chambers to hear other voices. I learned a lot from this conversation, and my hope for you is that you'll be able to take something away as well. So, take along as we dig in.
Welcome to Grub and Grace. I am Mark Flower. I am here with my revered guest, Mike Mayashiro, and I hope I'm pronouncing that right. You are actually. Alright, cool. Cool. Right on. I looked up some videos, so I was hoping that I would get my crick on the first try. So, Mike Mayashiro is the founder of NUMA, an organization that supports people recovering from religious toxicity. Mike is gay and advocate for the LGBTQ plus community and a queer theology enthusiast. Mike is a former instructor at Bethel School of Supernatural Ministry, best known for his class, Discerning of Spirits.
He now teaches in emotional health and redemption, a redemptive deconstruction. He is a consultant and coach for gay men recovering from evangelicalism. He also has a team of coaches who work with people whose faith is evolving. He is a social media influencer and thought leader. Mike loves Japanese food, movies, and playing volleyball and has a depth of useless knowledge about the X-Men, which I love. Anything comics. I mean, so it's a part of this podcast. I want to dig deep into some more like the nerdy topics like comics, movies, all that kind of stuff.
Even just like books. So there's one book I'm going to be talking with. Do you know, do you know, Geek, systematic ecology podcast? No. They're friends with like Tripp Fuller. They live over on the East Coast over there. But I got to meet Will and some of the guys over there and I was talking about this book and they're like, we should have you on for like a Christmas episode. That would be amazing. And so I love all this like nerdy stuff that that it just, it just brings so much joy and like kind of a dark, dull world. Yeah, totally. Love that. That's awesome.
Let's see. Did I miss anything? I mean, that's quite a full resume. Oh, it's a very long intro and you nailed all of it. It's too long. I was hoping I'd be able to say things like evangelicalism because I went to school with evangelical, but I was hoping at least I'd get that word down because it's been part of my life for so long. Right. Mark, thanks for having me on. I'm honored to be here. Yeah, I'm really glad you're here. I've just been looking forward to this for so long.
Let's jump into it then. I sent you the questions before. I'm sure you were able to look over them. I mean, I based these questions off of what you do and it's best to my knowledge, based enough of your website and what I know of you from social media. So I'll just jump into it. So can you explain what religious harm and trauma is and how it manifests in individuals? Yeah, so I mean, that's a it's kind of a big question because I mean, firstly, I want to say it manifests in lots of different ways, right?
People experience trauma in lots of unique specific paths in their minds, right? And their bodies. So the loose umbrella like explanation I would give is basically for many of us who have experienced religious trauma, we were raised in very indoctrinated spaces, typically in an evangelical church where we were taught at ages that we were too young to be able to even critically think through what we were being told pretty like awful things about the world,
God, people, ourselves, especially if you're queer. But even if you're straight, like there's still so much about evangelical theology that is terrifying, that is dehumanizing, that is, you know, like fostering a sense of self-hatred and like low self-worth. And so when you actually like metabolize the beliefs that and there are so many that we could list, right, just hell, sin, Jesus dying on the cross for your sins because you are unworthy of
God's love. Like there are so many things we could look at that, you know, if you actually like ingest this and believe it and practice it and internalize it, it starts to produce a lot of really negative effects in your life and in your body. And so that shows up in lots of different ways for people. But ultimately it's, you know, like you are stunted at being able to flourish and thrive as an adult, as a full-fledged person because these beliefs have limited your capacity to consider otherwise and have, you know, arrested your energies and attention on things that in a
lot of ways aren't even real and then have prevented you from being able to apply yourself in other ways, being open to and like consider of things that would cause you to grow and nourish you. Anyway, so that this is actually not a short answer, but like it's like that, you know what I mean? And it just goes in so many directions and has so many layers of impact. And we all have our different ways that we've coped those of us who have at least survived and left the institution. But anyway, I'll stop talking. That's my answer. No, no, I actually really like that. And maybe to further expand on that, like what are some common experiences that kind
of manifests some of these traumas? I know you kind of went over it a little bit with that answer. Yeah. Well, maybe I'll try and speak from my own experience. Mine is very obviously specifically more toward the queer journey, but as a gay man in evangelicalism, some of the cognitive like fallout that I had to live was the dissonance, the cognitive dissonance of constantly trying to reinforce a narrative and an experience that wasn't mine and trying to somehow alter or change, deny, fantasize about an experience
that I actually wasn't having in order to meet up to the standards that were being imposed on me from everyone all around me. And of course, the theology. So like that in and of itself is draining. It's exhausting. It just requires a lot of energy. It's unfulfilling. It creates this like rift within yourself. My ability to trust myself was like ruptured for a long time. Like I couldn't trust that what I experienced, what I felt, what I wanted was like valid.
Right. And that's like a really debilitating place to live from, especially when it's like touching something as deep and as profound as how you give and receive love and then experience intimacy. So for me, it was a lot of like lying to myself and everyone else and then not being able to tell, like be clear about what I even am experiencing and what's true about me. I remember there were a few years there where I was like, I might be straight. Like I genuinely wondered if I could be straight, like that I wasn't gay because I was so sexually
repressed that the lack of mess ups made me think maybe my sexuality was changing. Maybe I was becoming less gay and maybe that meant I was actually then leaning more toward being straight, which was of course not true. I was repressed. And so anyway, like for me, that was a very specific and distinct like cognitive experience of this religious trauma. It made me very afraid of the leaders in my life, which is strange because I was also a leader in that world and I was very celebrated and had a platform and was just enjoyed a lot of privilege
and like favors, what they would have called it, right? And promotion in the spaces that I was in. And all the while I was doing all of that with a noose around my neck. And so I just constantly was ready for the ball to drop, the hammer to drop. I don't know, something was supposed to drop on me, right? Which eventually it did, right? Thankfully it was a choice I made, but that was constantly just like looming over me. So any kind of choice I made in the public space just like inched the threat closer to me, right?
And that's just like really unhealthy to be living under the constant threat of everything's going to be taken away from you. You're going to be rejected and outcast from the world that you know. Anyway, it's a lot of that. I can go into a lot more details, but that's the gist. Right on. Like hearing your story online on like I looked it up on YouTube, your coming out story. Like a lot of the what you said is just so good to hear, so refreshing to hear this other narrative.
Like me growing up in a primarily Christian community, you don't necessarily hear too many stories like yours. And I'm just really glad that you have come out and been very vocal about your story and about other people's struggles. Even listening to your story, there's a couple of things that I felt like I kind of resonated with in certain ways. You had mentioned that you never really got along with the other boys too much.
You felt like you connected more with the other girls, which I feel like I can kind of resonate a little with that. Like I noticed at kind of younger age that there was a lot of like grandstanding, their masculinity, and primarily my male friends within the church were very like, you know, this is how you need to be masculine. And then you get like Super Bowl or football season. And it's almost like watching football and knowing how to talk about football became
this model for how to become a man. And everything else kind of rotated around that. And I just kind of saw this hypocrisy along with everything with that. And I just didn't feel like I could really connect with a lot of my other male friends just because I wasn't into that myself. And I felt like I actually connected a lot with my female friends a lot more because of that. I felt like it was just there's just more that I could actually talk to about.
That said, like, I don't have the same story as you. I am a white heterosexual male. There were times in my life where I actually was trying to be honest with myself and asking, like, am I gay? Like, nothing ever came to that. I never had any feelings toward anyone of the same sex. But I at least, you know, was able to be open to a realization of that, where I think a lot of people that are in the heterosexual lifestyle might be masking it and hiding it
and burying it down in the deep. They can. I do. I do a lot of friends that are at least some friends that I feel like that is the case. And it's kind of tough to see. Yeah, totally. Very tough for sure. Sorry, I just like I'm interviewing you and I'm like, you know, talking way too much, but I just really want to share. Yeah, totally. Thanks for sharing it. Here, I'll go to the next one here. How can we create spaces that allow for the voices of those who have been victimized by
the church and religious organizations to be heard? That's a good question. Listen, my answer, the first thing that comes up for me, I don't even want to say it because it just I know I feel like it's difficult to hear and it's because it requires work. But I think this is like probably more important than some of the things that would come later. If we want to create space and platform voices of people who are within marginalized communities, I think that one of the most important things we can do, you can do, whoever I'm talking to,
if you're somebody who's enjoying privilege and you have access to space that could amplify these other experiences and their voices, I think one of the most important things you can do is to start doing the work yourself of becoming aware of your own privilege, of the ways that you are currently benefiting from systems that you might not be conscious of that favor and prioritize people who look and sound and come from places that you do. Become aware of that. Do the work, go through the process of grief because I think any ethical, moral person who
actually starts waking up to the landscape and what's been going on for a long time and it's still happening, the victims that this creates, the oppression that's still actively happening in the world today, I think that there's a necessary grieving process where you get to acknowledge the harm that's been done that a lot of us have been complicit with unknowingly a lot of times and just letting that pierce our souls as humans and just recognizing this should never have happened let alone it definitely shouldn't still be happening and so I necessarily have to
get in the way of this stuff because I'm aware of it now because I see it. So I think that awareness piece is so important. I don't think giving people the A plus B equals C, do this, do this, do this is helpful until that internal work is done. When that conscience piece comes into play and the empathy kicks in and the human being can actually identify with what that might be like, as much as their imagination and capacity for empathy can take them to, have that experience first. I think we need to be pierced, I think is the word I would use, because there's all of this,
we have all these protections in place to help us just survive and get through society that may or may not even be relevant to this conversation right away but those protections harden us and keep us insulated and allow us to keep moving forward without getting just utterly obliterated by everything that's wrong with the world and so some of that needs to be penetrated. We have to get past some of those walls that we've built up in ourselves to survive in order to recognize that some other people are actually like in such worse positions and are in worse identities in our
culture based on how society treats them. So I think that awareness is key, is essential. Become aware, become informed, wake up and realize what has been and is still going on, be affected by that, let that change what you see, how you feel, what you're aware of and then as that has its own effect in you then you get to get more practical and then you start looking at like what are, okay I would look at my social media, am I following a bunch of straight white people? If so, why is that?
Maybe I should interrogate that a little bit and not defend myself, hopefully some of that work has like gotten us to a place where we are emotionally resilient and ethically like accountable to recognizing like I have some spots here that I'm, I maybe can't see and so I'm going to take responsibility for that and I'm going to do like an inventory check like if 90% of my, the following, the people that I follow on social media, that I platform, that I listen to are straight white people like maybe that says something and I need to do something about that so then a solution to that
could be actively to go start finding voices that don't fit that mold so go listen to queer people, go listen to people of color, go listen to black women, right? Like go find other voices that are saying something very different from anything you've ever experienced before and lean in and let them upset you, let them offend you, let them freak you out, let them make you really angry, let them make you feel misunderstood, mischaracterized, right? And then instead of like attacking or getting mad at the person who's provoking that within you, interrogate that experience, okay what are you afraid of? Why are you angry? Why are you getting defensive here? Do they have a point? Is
there something valid here that you need to look at, right? And then lean into that growth. So if we're itemizing this one, do the internal work. Two, check yourself in terms of like who you're still actively like subscribing to, like having, giving access to like influencing you. And then three, if you have any whatever kind of sphere of influence you possess, start pulling people other than you know the privileged world that you're part of like into that space. Like you build connections with people who are different from you, get to know them,
right? You get to hear their stories and experience them as people and then like invite them into your space. And you know like so I guess in this context Mark like doing what you're doing, right? Like you're having this gay guy get in here to talk about you know all this stuff. Like I feel like it's like that, right? Like whatever ways that we have avenues of impacting our environment, like let's use the platforms and the privilege that we're enjoying and let's like share that with people who don't have access to that, who can't work hard enough to get that. Let's start like pulling them into it and letting them like have an effect, you know?
Can I just apply to everything? It's like that's I mean just like you said, this is what I'm doing with my podcast. This is the whole idea of this podcast is the best conversation comes with sitting around a table around food and what comes with food is healing and reconciliation because so I just recently had a talk with Andrew Camp from the Biggest Table podcast but we were talking about with the holidays coming up. How can we navigate some of these tough and difficult conversations and where these holidays can be really difficult with having these discussions with people,
the table itself, the you know around food. It's almost like the food distracts you from the heart of the conversation from like these heated emotions and allows you to focus more on your food so that when you're talking with people around the table you can kind of try to navigate that a little bit more safely and you know there's a lot more complexity and nuance to it but yeah you really need to broaden your scope and bring people on so that you can have different voices and have different perspectives. It's just so important with life and
getting a nice like overall picture of everything so you're not stuck in your bubble, you're not stuck in your own little spaces. You get out in the world and you experience it and you experience people, you experience you know the love that people can give you and that you can give them as well so I just think it's so beautiful what how you phrase everything I just love it. Thanks agreed yeah yeah all that we love it. Okay and let's see in your experience what are some of the long-term effects of spiritual or religious trauma on individuals and how does it affect their relationships, mental health
and spiritual beliefs moving forward? I know you've seen a lot of this because you actually have some healing groups that you do so I kind of want to hear your response. Healing groups nice yeah totally so long-term effects of this stuff on people let's start with relationships because that's like a pretty big that's a pretty big one so in evangelicalism you're not just taught theology right of course that's a big part of it but what comes with that is a hierarchy right like you are invited into, invite is the wrong word, you are trained, I'm gonna use this word, you are
trained, I'm gonna use this word I'm not being dramatic, you are literally indoctrinated into a hierarchical structure that centers and prioritizes typically the pastor right and the pastor is typically in I mean literally every church I was ever a part of before I walked away the pastor was a straight white a cisgender man so that says something right like every spiritual authority figure at every church I was ever a part of and that's not true for every evangelical church but
it was true for a lot of them right and every single one that I've been part of that's what we saw as the example the ideal and there's a lot of messaging that's being given out there that's subconscious and cultural right but it is like reinforced and so anyway when you have that conditioning and then as a queer person you know that that position is a threat to your humanity that if they found out about you you're out you're going to be seen as a heathen a sinner a devil worshiper you know someone who's not going to inherit the kingdom like whatever
that's terrifying right so so I mean I've met so many gay people after I came out who were raised in the church who have walked away who have zero interest in going back they still consider themselves Christian in terms of like a label right as far as like their beliefs are concerned but they would never go back to a church they don't read the bible anymore they don't even pray because they feel like the iteration of Christianity they knew that was the only form of spirituality they were ever taught to practice it was taken from them because they no
longer fit the mold of the evangelical church they were raised in and so they just become orphaned they become like disenfranchised spiritual vagabonds right and so they're out then they instead just give themselves to whatever else they can find that fills a deep longing for meaning and connection and so to me like that's one very specific like pipeline of the effect that religious trauma I'm not sure what the umbrella question right now is anymore but that has that effect
especially and so there's that but then let's step outside of the queer experience and just like the people that I work with and that I interact on a regular basis just around the theology and deconstructing I mean women are so negatively impacted by evangelical theology right like the patriarchy that's just so pervasive in that purity culture especially targets women dehumanizes women like separates them from their own bodies and it just there's so many harmful
messages around like your body I mean the truth is everybody in evangelicals is like you know everybody in evangelicalism is taught that your body doesn't belong to you but that especially has like practical consequence on women right because when it's in a patriarchal structure maybe our bodies don't belong to us any of us but when you are a woman and you marry a man all of a sudden the man is the head of that household so maybe neither of your bodies belong to you but he has authority over what's decided in that space anyway so there's a huge discrepancy between
how this kind of thinking and belief system affects people of different genders right and then of course when it comes to the period of culture side it dramatically impacts our relationship with our sexuality not just your sexual orientation but also your sex drive your sexual appetite your sexual expression your sexual desire your sexual education right like so much of that is distorted denied avoided kept from you there's this weird secret that's like enshrined enshrouded with like
the threat of sin and depravity and deception that's also an intrinsic part of your humanity and it only gets to be acceptable when you enter a cisgender heterosexual monogamous marriage and so that obviously has its effect in so many ways I mean so many people have been devastated by purity culture I'm still unpacking some of the effects that that had on me because I was in it for 30 years years right I've walked away I it doesn't just go it doesn't just turn off you know I mean I still have to like do work at recognizing ways that I'm still repressing
myself ways that I still fear sexual interaction because of you know the threats that always came from the purity culture side of this and then of course there's the whole psychological torment of like you're gonna go to hell if you don't fill in the blank and then there's all this these contradictions in the I'm sorry I'm just gonna mark stop me when we're good because I could keep going and going I'm gonna maybe I'll land the plane on this one maybe two more okay the hell thing like go for it there's all this contradicting ideology within evangelical theology that says
like you're going to hell if you don't accept Jesus into your heart and you can only be saved through the grace of God right by accepting the sacrifice of Jesus but also they don't say this explicitly but it is absolutely reinforced and practiced in the culture accepting Jesus into your heart is not enough you have to go to church you have to tithe you have to not cuss you have to not have sex outside of marriage you have to not cheat on your spouse you have to there's a lot of other things you have to do in order to remain acceptable within the community which then your you know salvation gets conflated with that so if your church community rejects you then now
obviously of course you're also going excuse me you're going to hell you're deceived right and that's like very very damaging to people's psyches you know what I mean like so many people have been dejected from their church communities and it has ravaged their lives it has so like deteriorated their like willingness to trust people to belong to organize religion again to open the bible to hear the name Jesus to hear somebody talk about God said to me or it's God's will like that does that phraseology there's so much christianese it just is cringy
and it's actually a trigger for a lot of us because of how people who speak like that treated us and like all of the coded messaging that was not honest or clear or forthright that there were absolutely protocols and like um there's a word I want I can't think of it there's a uh there are protocols that you had to follow and that you know some of them were kind of like you know the
same space it like is a mind job right so the hell is like this giant club just being held over people to get them to comply the last thing I want to throw in here is like also by the way oh I don't want to say this because it's like not fun but the notion that you need to die and Jesus needs to replace you I at this point now actually find to be incredibly toxic which is so ironic because I when I was a teacher and a preacher like that was the message right and it was such a beautiful hopeful redemptive life-giving message and now I look at this thing outside of the system and I
like this idea is so damaging because what's built into that idea of like you know Christ in you the hope of glory that you die Jesus shows up Jesus takes over Jesus replaces you that idea in and of itself carries an inherent message that you're bad your uniqueness your identity the things that uniquely like culminate the the person we think you are are bad and the goal here is to eradicate who you are and to replace you with we'll use the name Jesus but actually what we're doing in
evangelical spaces we're trying to replace you with a straight white Christian man we want you to be more like that and we're going to continue to prop up example after example of what you're supposed to look like and be like and value and protect and when you continue to just fail to be this it's because of sin you know it's because there's something wrong with you that and then so and then so Jesus is weaponized the theology in and of itself I'm like this has been such a predatory toxic parasite that has ruined people's lives I'm not trying to be dramatic anyway I'll stop there
Mark I could keep going there are so many things like this but you know I know you could I know you could I've heard I've heard you you know talking about this stuff on social media and I've listened to your videos so I know very well that you could go on and I if we had all the time in the world I would just let you go on for an entire day so and I would post everything about it so but but it's everything you're saying it's you wonder I mean people wonder why deconstruction is such a big thing right now people wonder why people are leaving the church when you look at the PRRI I think it's the public research of something institute they came out with results last for last
year so earlier this year they came out for last year results from 2023 from a decade before so that whole decade span they found that right now so that from from last year church attendance from people who go out to at least one one service or one thing in a church a week is down to 24% of all Americans go which is down seven percent from a decade ago which is pretty massive and you know
for everything that you said you can see why people are doing that this is basically the stats of people that have left the church altogether they've become either non-believers or agnostics or atheists or you know whatever category you want to put in that doesn't account for people deconstructing and leaving the church like you were talking about where they still consider themselves Christian and but they're just not actually going to an active church so that could even be way lower than what what those stats are even saying so it's you know I I'm just kind of
baffled by by people that are in the church that this cognitive distance like you said before said earlier that it's like the statistics are out there people are talking about this in you know you know in abundance right now and yet people are still deciding to close their ears and not want to listen to it because it doesn't fit into their mold of what they think a Christian should be and it's it's infuriating it's frustrating to um so yeah and it's so sad it's so sad I mean it's something to get we get angry about and then but when you listen to the victims of this
regularly you just like hear story after story after story of how people's lives have just specifically been ravaged by this stuff it's so sad and then to watch the people who are still perpetuating these things and the arrogance and the entitlement and the just void of compassion or awareness is just it's unbelievable anyway yeah yeah yeah and I just gotta say one last thing like you know even though it's infuriating and frustrating sometimes to um have to explain things over and over again or try to even get another perspective out there a lot of people are just
a lot of my friends are open to listening and I think that's where you got to show a lot of grace too because um there are people that just don't know any better and maybe they haven't they just don't like genuinely don't know another way than what they've been living and um even if you have to tell them you know over and over again and they just are very you know hard-headed about it um you know give it a little time be patient give them grace to be able to um hear you out and you know in time I mean you've seen how many people are deconstructing now like April Joy I mean she
she's very vocal now but she was deep into it I mean she she even sang it on the Jim Baker show so um she created a original song for the Jim Baker show so um I mean you see where people were and where they came from you know that there can be hope um in the end so um it's yes easy to to talk about the frustrations but it's almost like you have to yourself to kind of remember and remind yourself you know you know we were all there once so who have experienced religious
trauma did I already ask you that no no okay yeah how can we ensure that those who have experienced religious trauma feel supported and empowered yeah okay so I'm gonna let's I'm gonna be really practical mark um so like for example the thing we were just talking about um telling people to be patient with the evangelical bigots in their lives because look at where we were at one point right like I understand logically where that's coming from and there's truth to it right that's
true we're using April Joy as an example she was so deep into christian nationalism and you know like up there writing music and performing live unto this whole psychotic empire um I was in the same boat in my own way right in terms of like being a poster child for charismatic christianity and the things that I used to say publicly and that I was known for and whatever um and so right look at us right we were those people and now look at us look at what we're doing in the
world and what we believe and we're advocating for you know so totally there's truth to that however and I'll say this as a gay person who was coming out of the closet I had a lot of people when I was on my way out of when I was coming out people were telling me like hey be patient with these people who don't see you as a valid human right now because you used to believe these things and I would say in terms of being a marginalized person in that process people saying that to me was not helpful um that actually sorry I I just said that earlier so I'm sorry no it's great but that's what
I'm I wanted I'm using that as an example to be like when it comes to people who've been traumatized by this stuff and are currently actively trying to work through that while there might be truth to hey you know these people can and possibly could change we know people have changed there's truth to that um that doesn't mean the people they're dealing with are going to change um because we know a lot of people who never changed who don't unfortunately and I'm not trying to emphasize the negative side of this because there is hope and there are people who will change and that's awesome and we love that but we don't know that it's going to be their people and so
giving them false hope and we actually have no educated information around their context and the people they're talking about um that those people possibly could change we don't know that and even if they do change a year from now five years from now that doesn't change the impact those people's beliefs and practices right now are having on them in real time and so for me when I was in that position and people are telling me like hey be patient you know they can't they're not going to change overnight while there might be some form of truth to that response ultimately what I was experiencing on an emotional level was hey what you're feeling isn't valid and that's not what
they were trying to say to me but that's what I was hearing and experiencing as a traumatized individual trying to get out of the traumatizing contexts that I was in right so I would advise when it comes to this context of like how do we create safe space for people I'm like we we probably should be really aware of how the things we say and then our our rush to try and mitigate the harm we think people are going through and we naturally just want to help let's interrogate the things we think are helpful and recognize that maybe that might have been helpful for me but I'm not this kind of a person in the world it might not be helpful for them and so then getting really
clear from people in those spaces like what is helpful right and that I think in order for us to learn those things we're gonna have to lean in and really listen I had to learn that like I probably I don't know I was gonna say I might have I might have said something like that someone else coming out but I'm like I don't think I would have actually because I was living it out right like I because I had the experience um but like for example I'm not a trans person and I have such compassion and empathy for the trans community and everything that they're having to like continue to fight through even now I've done a lot of listening and a lot of the things
that guide and clarify and motivate me in terms of how I participate and show up in my attempts to be an ally to the trans community is things that I've learned from trans people from listen and not to people who have opinions about trans people right like that's those are two different kinds of sources right and so I think just getting really clear about how our responses how our advice how our quote-unquote support is actually like experienced by the marginalized people that
we're giving this to we need to do some work on just like getting them a clearer I'm sorry I have more filled out picture of how some of that translates to people who aren't us who aren't privileged in the ways that we are you know because I could say stuff to people who are in like more disenfranchised positions than I'm in and it can totally come across the same way and I don't want to have that kind of an effect on them so part of my answer another example would be like I've got a friend who's a gay okay I want to just try and keep this as anonymous as possible I've got a
friend who works at a church and he's gay and this last week we had a really shock at the recording of this Trump was elected this is our next president right and the pastor of this church who's a straight man was basically like trying to give hope to his congregation and like hurrah for what we're gonna do to move forward and whatever and my friend who's a gay person working there was like I don't I don't want to hurrah I don't want to jump into the next thing we're gonna do I'm not ready for that right and so he sent me this long text just like what he would want to say
to this person instead and ultimately the heart cry and I'm like yeah totally that's exactly how I'd feel he was like I don't want to jump into the next thing I want to hear this isn't okay this is awful this should not have happened this must be devastating we don't just hurry past this we need to validate and acknowledge the impact this has on people that this affects greater than other people right and the solution is not let's pretend like it's not happening or let's hurry to a solution the proper response to this is to not find a solution is instead to sit with the people
who are mourning and mourn with them right I mean this this is a biblical precedent right like mourn with those who mourn don't give them some like cheesy solution so you don't have to deal with the discomfort that comes from having to live in a world that targets and dehumanizes whole people groups right like anyway so there's a lot there to learn and so to me ultimately the priority in terms of if we're going to create safe space for people who are navigating marginalized identities we got to listen to them we've got to like lean in and let them tell us how they
experience our solutions and if our solutions are actually not helpful for them then we need to relabel those solutions as something else and we need to recognize that those solutions belong in other spaces not this one right and so like there's a cultural difference when a straight person shows up in a queer space they're a guest and guests have a different kind of demeanor and audacity in some ways than someone who's part of the culture right and so a guest should be showing up with some humility and like being slow to speak quick to listen right and like consider it of
what is being communicated and what is being expressed and then from there I think then that changes how we go about processing and then responding to people in these places so it's work right like I probably would not have had the I could not have said to you like hey Mark I don't think it's helpful to say that some people will change to give them give them space and patience like yeah I don't think that's helpful I won't say that to people now like I've got a lot of people who are deconstructing who come to me I would never say that to them because they don't need that that's not helpful what they're looking for emotionally whether they know to ask for it or not ultimately is please tell me I'm not alone please tell me I'm not the only one please tell me
that this isn't just happening to me right because we're we're looking for encouragement and hope not you know someone else's idea of what a solution looks like so I don't have to feel it anymore because the feelings don't just go away right anyway so to me that's like a big one and it's and I had to like spend a lot of time energy to learn because I used to be an evangelical leader I used to be a pastor right like I used to have all the answers for everyone all the time I wasn't allowed to say I don't know so learning how to say that to people in like theological or spiritual conversations was a big pill to swallow for me and it it was work and I finally got to a place where
I started like becoming comfortable with acknowledging like I don't know everything I know this might be a shock to you guys but I don't know everything right um but I had to start doing that to just be ethical in those conversations and like have the appropriate accountability right and it's also been so liberating uh because I was part of a hierarchical structure and I was like performing my role to keep this structure in place and the structure is actually harming a lot of people including me so I'm so glad I walked away from it I'm glad I finally was able to undo
those things and actually people don't need me to have all the answers they need the people around them to witness them you know to like validate and understand and like hold space for what they're experiencing it doesn't have to be correct it doesn't have to be accurate and so you can tell when the privileged person is entering the conversation when they're starting to try and tell people and police what they're allowed to say or what they're allowed to conclude or how they're allowed to move forward it's like oh you don't understand how to grieve you're you actually don't recognize you know and it just kind of comes off as like um maybe like a shallow
emotional development in the person um I have a lot of straight evangelicals in my world that I've since distanced myself from who used to exhibit a lot of that a lot of their responses to grief and pain and injustice were like shh but this is true therefore you can't feel that way and it's just so infuriating and painful to be met that way um so I guess my answer I mean there's so many answers but my ultimate one is like letting the listening be so significant that it
legitimately changes the way that we think the way that we hear and then it changes the way that we participate you know like that would like clean up um our phrases uh like I don't say you I don't say you guys anymore because not everyone is a guy or identifies as male right and I know the culturally colloquially there's you know like a glazing over but some people are actually sensitive to gendered terms and so I'm actually trying to de-gender when I address a group of people that's work I don't have to do it but it's changing because I've listened to people who are
trans and non-binary and the gender language actually impacts them in a way that I don't have to think about you know um I don't say blind spot anymore because that's an ableist term associating someone who's blind with someone who's an idiot and like that conflation is not appropriate so I'm like okay and so it just it's work right but like my listening has gotten significant enough that it's changing the way that I'm participating and I'm like that practice to me has probably been one of the most helpful um that set me up for success and being able to to show up for other marginalized people um so I don't know if that's practical I think it's radical
right but like then that would impact or filter how we follow through with lots of other things too you know what I mean I feel like I've gotten in the weeds on this no please I I still struggle with a lot of the like that last part you're talking about with like saying you guys anymore I I just did that like a few days ago and it was two it was two three women and I said um see you guys later and after I walked away I was like was there something better how I could have phrased that um I could have said see you all later or something like that um you know they may not have
been impacted the way you were talking about but um how would I know that you know without having a conversation with them so it's those things that like I'm still trying to figure out as I'm going to you know you're saying all this and I'm like I'm like yes yes yes and um you know there's two things that I do that uh like little scenarios will bring up an old habit or way of thinking about doing something or um acting and I'll do it that way but then I'll realize no like I'm
going to kind of decolonize that thought process I need to kind of you know destruct that that thought process and rethink about what how how I could do that better and how I could act better the next time I come across something like this and it's the thing that I'm constantly going through um even even some of the ingrained racism that I grew up with not that my parents were I wouldn't consider my parents racist and I still don't but there is this um kind of culture that they grew up in that they brought along with them subconsciously that impact area has reflected
onto my life and um I'm in the process of trying to decolonize a lot of that ingrained kind of racism that has been passed down so um and sexism uh you know homophobia that sort of thing so um I'm right with you I like you're talking I'm just like yes yes um you know it's it's a constant learning process and it's nice that you're saying like it's nice to be heard and to be understood that you know we're all on this journey together because it can be very lonely trying to figure
all this stuff out for sure yeah um I'll jump in this last one here um what resources or approaches do you recommend for individuals seeking to heal from religious trauma and how can advocates help guide people toward recovery and the freedom to redefine their spiritual journeys okay you know what it is not my fault that my answers are long-winded these are very layered questions this is your fault not mine you got to thank chat gpt for this yeah totally nice nice
um god I think my answer might be a little outdated for some people but I do think depending on your level of engagement with the theology that you're coming out of to me the reading is necessary um I don't know that listening and watching is enough you've got to take time and like process through the jaw and the tittle that got you jaw and tittle that's so anyway that god sorry that got you to where you were theologically to begin with right like you didn't just wake up one day and you were indoctrinated that was
years that was day after week after hour after month after year after sunday school class after youth group after church service after sermon after retreat after camp right like you had all of this stuff investing in you thinking in a very specific way and not thinking any other way that's not just going to change overnight right it's going to require some intentionality and some labor so my first answer and again I want to acknowledge this is probably not fun for people to hear but I'm like read the books and there are so many books you can read so that's overwhelming
I have a page on my website that's literally just deconstruction web resources right and it's not the end-all be-all but it's like some books that I found to be particularly helpful Brian McClaren's a new kind of Christianity to me it was a really soft helpful transitionary book to address the con the moral conscience of a an evangelical Christian confronting the problematic theology universal christ by Richard Rohr again to me was like another transitionary kind of book um more hitting the spirituality and the ethics behind our theology that I thought he did a great
job um you want to get more biblical uh Rob Bell and Pete Enns I think both did great jobs of making complex theological conversations a lot more like lower shelf and accessible but also like substantiating their work you know in the books so what is the bible by Rob Bell I thought was a really helpful practical book the bible tells me so by Pete Enns like anyway those are some really easy helpful immediate places I would refer people to if they're just starting to like ask the questions and look at some of this the other part I want to answer about that is um the reading you
know doing the work of like addressing the ideas themselves is really important the other thing I would say is this is an emotional journey um so get around some people who are on the journey with you or at least who are further along than you um who are doing the work too who are asking the questions too who have the courage and the audacity enough to say is this true is that right are we aware of the impact these beliefs these practices are practices are having on people like does that matter to us right people who are talking and thinking that way like get around people like
that and maybe not just once in a while like get around people so I'm not trying to just shamelessly plug here but like I have a couple of groups specifically dedicated toward hosting space for people who are deconstructing one of them is just dialoguing the other one is specifically a book club where we're reading these books I just mentioned and others together and every week we're chiming in on the last reading from the week and like pulling apart the ideas and how did it feel what are we thinking and what were the aha moments what did we hate well you know like just processing through it together and the goal is not to end up anywhere in particular the goal is to
be on the journey together and allow for the rational critical thinking process to have its effect on each individual and they get to land wherever they want but the goal is like let's let's decolonize let's detoxify let's confront harmful beliefs right so I think the other thing I would add to that question the answer to my answer to that question is get around other people don't do this alone it is terrifying it's intense some some beliefs maybe not that big of a deal right but when you get into like other things the afterlife salvation Jesus the rest of the world
Jesus the resurrection some of this stuff the bible like some of these things are bigger deals you know I mean they're more fundamental building blocks to people's realities so if you're going to start asking about some of those things and pulling at that thread which I think you should do I think ethically you should re-examine some of these you've been told about those things yes don't do it alone that's a lot you know what I mean and your mental health is going to be impacted by this so be with people who can simply be human with you that's how I'm going to answer the first part and I gotta throw out that there's other there's not just like groups which your groups
I've heard are fantastic honestly what you just described with like the book club and you were just going to have a dialogue I maybe considering maybe joining up for that too so but there are like outings like theology beer camp just happened a couple weeks ago there's that one in August I I was talking to Brian Rucker and he said that he didn't have a wild goose yeah yeah so there are get togethers that meet up around the country I'm not sure where the LGBT camps going to end up
for this next year but wild goose is in Alabama was it or North Carolina North Carolina I know it's kind of more on the east coast just like that I just couldn't remember where it was but yeah there are groups where you can do that and you can book these groups up so wild goose the LGBT camp I'm not sure more than that I'm sure you might might be able to think there but one more I'd mentioned is the post evangelical collective I don't know exactly how to plug into that world but that's another group of people who are you know yeah I would add that to the list but yeah and I can say
it's been very healing for me to be around people I mean I my journey so far most of my friends and connections aren't necessarily in the same sphere that I am they're very much you know locked into their their way of life going to church listen to the preacher that's their life they've got their beliefs already set their fundamental fundamentalisms of their basis of living is already set and sewn and and so I don't have too many people so when I went to theology beer camp I was like wow there's a whole community that of people that are asking these questions just like I'm asking so I can say
firsthand that you know I I love these kind of communities and I think someone should get plugged in especially stuff like what you have going on so thank you yeah I love that um well I that was the last question I I love this conversation I I seriously want to reach out to you again and have a conversation down the road as well trying some other topic or something like that but or we can talk about this again I mean this I feel like you you already have more you could probably say so but thank you so much for coming on the show I this has just been such a good day
for me so nice Mark I'm honored I appreciate that you're holding space for this you're asking these questions this is such important work and there are so many people who still you know need these conversations to be happening publicly so I love that you're hosting this and thanks for having me I'm honored to be part of it for sure all right well I'll talk to you later then okay that's it for today's episode of Grub and Grace I hope you enjoyed our conversation with Mike Mayashiro about advocating and allowing safe spaces for healing for those with religious trauma I want to give a
big thank you to Mike for joining us on this episode and I will make sure to put his links in the notes music is by Fleece Mob with the song everything you need graphics are by root and branch creative remember to visit our website at grubandgrace.com that's grub a and d grace.com as well as our socials on Facebook Instagram and X this week's recipe won't be happening I have fallen a little behind on updating the recipes on my website and as much as I want to share my food with you I found that it was a bit of an ambitious task to take on at this time
so in the future I hope to start up again but for now as it stands I won't be including that until next time stay curious keep an open mind and celebrate the traditions that bring us all together
Two white Christians, who love Muslims, breakdown myths and misconceptions that many Americans (and more specifically Christians) have about Islam and Muslims. Mark Wayne of the Colonial Outcasts podcast joins in the...
Capitalism has a long and ugly history of scapegoating and exploiting immigrants. From British capitalists exploiting Irish people to the United States’ deeply systemic and oppressive tactics, immigrants have, for a...
This is part 7 of the Enchantments of Mammon series. Capitalism needs a permanent source of unpaid labor. Childbearing, child raising, cooking, cleaning, caregiving, emotional support. The invisible work that keeps...
Marx’s analysis does not specifically take into account the history of the exploitation of women and non-white people. We will be digging into some of the ways that racism, sexism, and xenophobia play into the...
Spiritual maturity and financial security are often married within the church business model. How do we identify patterns of abuse and work toward a more sustainable future? Let's get into it in today's episode of part...