In this episode, we sit down with the ideas from Doubting Faithfully by Keith Long to explore what it means to deconstruct faith without abandoning it entirely. Instead of treating doubt as failure, we examine how it can be a sign of growth - a willingness to move beyond inherited certainty and into something more honest, even if it’s less comfortable. We also dig into the unsettling pull sometimes felt within high-control religious spaces - the sense that questioning could cost you everything, yet not questioning might cost you yourself. From there, we wrestle with what it means to hold tension: to entertain difficult ideas without immediately accepting or rejecting them. Why is that so hard? What systems, fears, or social pressures keep people from engaging deeply with their own beliefs? And how might learning to sit with uncertainty actually reflect a deeper kind of spiritual maturity? Ultimately, this conversation invites us to loosen our grip on needing to be right. What if being wrong isn’t something to fear, but something to learn from? What if faith isn’t about certainty, but about curiosity, humility, and the courage to keep going anyway? Pull up a chair - this is a space where doubt isn’t the end of faith, but part of how it becomes something real. Keith Long has been a Lutheran pastor for 14 years and is the author of three books, Doubting Faithfully: Confessions of a Skeptical Pastor, Growing Spirit Wise: A Heretic’s Guide to Resurrection and Eternal Life, and Moviemakers, a novella. Keith has also written for New Testament scholar Bart D. Ehrman's blog, studies expanded consciousness in his free time, and loves his home state of Minnesota where he resides with his family. His website is www.authorkeithlong.com and is currently developing a Lecture Series entitled "Jesus Beyond Christianity" 7 in-person and online presentations exploring pre-Christian culture and the future of religion. Attributions: ON8FDNIHEAKJ8GXS
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
People who are deconstructing and asking questions, it's because they want to have more dimension in their life and not less. For me, I've often kind of seen people with these fundamental beliefs, and I talk about it in the book, as like having their faith is like a house of cards. And they're realizing that we live in an increasingly windy world. And so they want to put up more walls because they want to protect that house of cards with everything that they can. And people who
are deconstructing are like, I don't think it is a house of cards. And if it is, I want to build something else that's going to, That's going to hold up better. Welcome to Grub and Grace, where we treat the table as a place for honest dialogue, spirited debate, and holy art of doubting faithfully. Here we untangle harmful theology, question the things we were told never to question, and still try to hold a little grace
for people we disagree with. Yes. even those people. Around this table, every voice matters, especially the ones empire would rather ignore. Because when people wrestle with faith together, instead of pretending certainty, we might actually build something better than the systems we inherited. I am Mark Flower, I'm your host for the show, and I'm joined today by someone I had the honor of meeting at Theology Beer Camp last fall in St. Paul. Keith Long has been a Lutheran pastor for 14 years and is the author of three books,
Doubting Faithfully, Confessions of a Skeptical Pastor, Growing Spirit Wise, A Heretic's Guide to Resurrection and Eternal Life, and Movie Makers, a novella. Keith has also written for New Testament scholar Bart D. Ehrman's blog. He studies expanded consciousness in his free time and loves his home state of Minnesota where he resides with his family. Thanks for joining us. Thank you. It's good to be here. Yeah, it's good to be here. It's good to have you on here. We did briefly meet at Theology Beer Camp. It was very briefly.
It was kind of funny because I think it was during lunchtime. They were handing out lunch, and I think you and a friend were eating lunch, and then I was just looking for somewhere just to eat a sandwich because I was running around. I think I was talking with so many people that I just was holding my sandwich in my hand and there happened to be a chair next to you. And I think I just pulled up and I was just like, hey, can I sit here? Yeah. And then it turns out we were both kind of looking for each other in a certain way. You know, you were just kind of getting the podcast started and I had some
books burning in my backpack. I was anxious to give away to people like you that, you know, I could maybe have further conversation with. So yeah, that all worked out pretty well. And here's that book right here, Doubting Faithfully. If you're just listening to the podcast, obviously you can't see the book, but it's called Doubting Faithfully, A Confession of a Skeptical Pastor, which I got a chance to read, and honestly, I loved it. It's a short read. It's only what, like, how many pages is it? It's just about 100 pages, yeah. Yeah, just under, it's like 80 pages.
It's really not that long, but you pack a good amount in there, though. And it's not like heavy and dense. It's like a lot of stories, but you bring a lot of kind of life and color to those stories, though, too. Yeah, well, that's kind of my pastoral vibe is, you know, when you're preaching, especially, like you got to... Don't be boring, right, and try not to be too heavy. So, yeah, I try to find ways to connect with, you know, I kind of keep, like, my high school friends in my mind, like, know that they're not
big readers, but if I can make it accessible for them, then I feel like it'll connect with pretty much anybody. So that's kind of what I keep in mind when I start, when I do writing projects is, you know, don't be boring, keep it. keep it short and keep it entertaining, you know. Yeah, I definitely got that impression from it. Well, especially in a book like this where it's, it can't, you know, it's a lot to grapple with. And so, you know, I wanted to, you know, I feel like I've read books like this
that go on longer than they maybe should. And so to me, it's most important. I love having conversation about this kind of thing. So I try to keep it conversational, too. Yeah, it's one of those things like, you know, growing up in the church and just kind of never questioning anything, just kind of accepting. you know you go to church on sunday and you know whatever the pastor preaches he must know what he's talking about and usually it's a heat they just kind of go with the flow and everybody is kind of in agreement like oh that was a good sermon you know clap their hands and um you know good worship
service you know rock band worship service and um and all that but then you know there's times in your life where things maybe just don't line up or It just kind of makes you think a little bit or someone comes in your life that, you know, makes you start questioning the little things by the things they say. And, you know, pebble after pebble, it just kind of creates this sense of, you know, is doubting okay for me? Especially in your instance where being a pastor and doubting after becoming a pastor, that was probably a
bigger... kind of hurdle to kind of get over, where you have this stigma of like, the pastor's got to know everything. And you address this in the book, you're like, pastor's got to know everything. And like, if I'm the one doubting, is anybody going to be willing to come to my church? Is anyone going to be willing to even listen to me when I say that I really don't have all the answers? And I thought it was just a different way of looking at it, because I've got my own story. But you know, everyone's got their own story. And I've never really heard much from another pastor talking about their
journey through asking these big questions. So yeah, it was very interesting. Well, thanks. Thanks for reading it in a way that's willing to put your, I mean, because you're kind of, you have to put yourself out there, like reading a book about doubt in faith. And yeah. And so I think it's just as much as the reader being vulnerable because you are engaging into somebody's vulnerability. And so I think there's the honesty kind of has to go both ways in something like this. So thanks for reading it. Yeah, of course.
So I'll jump into this first little segment here. So in your book, you talk about your journey through deconstruction and how the loss of your good friend was very influential to you along this path for binary constants, like God being a he. We're all being questioned. You miss the days when none of these things were conscious thought. You describe this time of your life almost in a 1984 -esque sort of way, feeling like you had to constantly look over your shoulder for thinking differently than your Christian community did, making you feel isolated and alone.
You prompted a question, had I ever felt God's presence or was that just something I conditioned myself to think? Which I love that line. I've heard similar sentiment, honestly, from many other of my friends that I have talked to about. their deconstruction journey so what was helpful for you as you navigated the big questions yeah so great question i i think for me it was above all you know being comfortable in my own skin and knowing that you know just having a lot of self -grace for that because Like you said, it
was isolating, and I didn't want to be beating myself up for having questions that you encouraged of congregation members and youth alike. It's okay to question. So that same grace that I extended to them, I extended to myself. It's okay to have these questions, especially with how much time I spend reading the Scriptures and studying and preparing. I'm just in it all the time. So for me, it was just kind of like, well, it's normal,
you know, to normalize it in a sense, to be like, is it really? Did this really happen? And kind of... Yeah, to wrestle with it in a way that wasn't, not shaming myself. You know, yeah, I did have to kind of be careful about who I talked about, who I talked to about that season of my life. At the time, I was just, yeah, I was kind of nervous. Like, I didn't want to derail somebody else's faith. I wanted to just own my own journey. But yeah, there are people that look to you to
be the strong rock. in the faith so but i also we constantly as pastors were like but we're people too uh we're not we're not gods we we're you know we're just we're just regular people who have gifts for for ministry so yeah so at first it was just basically just like it's fine dude just relax and just and gave myself a lot of that that grace um i i kind of told myself like it's it's It's humans that need the order and the structure in their lives and that God
alone is free. And so I kind of approached that section, even when I was questioning the existence of God, it was still just like, you know, but God, I don't, I don't, my God doesn't have like a clipboard going, oh, you know, like questions, faith, like you're out. And so I kind of gave myself just this structured freedom and flexibility to, to work with, with all the ingredients. and, you know, to set some aside if I needed to. And, you know, I would ask myself, like, what's good about this? And then also what might be short
-sighted or what might be causing harm? And so I kind of, that's kind of how I ordered that time. But I also found a lot of help from the Buddhists. And so I had, I don't know how I had gotten this book in my possession, but there's an American nun, quote her in Doubting Faithfully, I think at the end, payment showed her name. And the book is When Things Fall Apart. And so I like underline that whole book. It really spoke and resonated with me in the sense of like, she
really encourages getting kicked out of the nest and treating that as a good thing, as a way to really reflect on the learning that you're doing as you're in this instability moment. And what I really liked about what she said was not treating it as a means to an end. Because I had often heard that faith crises for... Christians was kind of like, oh, you have to doubt in order for your faith to get stronger. And she really
encouraged, instead of treating your doubt as a means to an end, treat it as the end in and of itself. It's okay to just sit with your uncertainty and not rush to have to solve it in order to be stronger. And so I'd say that self -grace and, again, some Buddhist thought was really helpful for me. Yeah, I did notice that quote. I was trying to look for it. I couldn't find it just off the cuff of my sleeve there. I do appreciate you using the word ingredients and
especially a podcast called Grubbing Grace. Sneak in there. There you go. Like I was mentioning, your journey through the deconstruction and losing a good friend at this time i i had lost someone close to me recently and it was it was one of those books that just like you know at that time in my life it really just kind of struck a little bit more with me some of your stories felt a little bit more personal and you know everybody goes through loss of life it's you know the death
rate of everyone is pretty close to 100 for every person so it's you know and there's people around that are they're gonna you know everybody dies at some point in their life so it's somebody you're gonna lose some somebody in your life you're gonna lose lots of people in your life and and to how do you deal with that and how do you work through that and i think along that question of you know doubting your your faith and not just doubting but like questioning and asking these big questions like you really you really add in this other layer of of kind of
grief and and working through that alongside with everything um and i feel like that can actually bring a lot of people to bringing this coming to this question you know front of and i definitely got that from you that that was a big part of you bringing you where you are right now is is the loss of your friend absolutely death is that great equalizer that puts us all on the same footing and makes us all experts of our own grief and I counsel people as a pastor, there's no
right way to do grief or there's no wrong way. You just have to lean into it and figure out what you need and then be free to do and handle that process as best you can. And I think that was kind of the eye -opener for me with the death of Carl. I had been countless bedsides of other people's family members, my own family members. But then losing someone that was considered religiously
other by the institution, yeah, that was just like total threw me out of that nest and made me ask some really big questions. It was the death of a lot of things at that time. Grief is a great catalyst. It sucks, but it's a great catalyst. You know, like reading your book made me kind of think, you know, like I'm at this point now and I wasn't always at this point. You know, I had to go through this kind of journey, so to say, to get where I'm at, you know, what
I believe and finding my own. um way to believe and way to see the world and everything and oftentimes that's like you know like what would i ask my younger self because like like tim whitaker you know he's talking about how he always likes to share about the the concept of like those in this like stuck in this evangelical kind of community very like narrow -minded of christianity is like the basement of fundamentalism and when you come out you see that there's all these other rooms of christian thought that you've never knew were
there but now you're seeing here like like what is this it's like a full house of of all these different rooms and um you know it just kind of makes you think like what would you say to your younger self so i'll reflect that back on you if you could question your past deconstructing self what would you say to him so I don't know. Let's see. I think for me, it really came back to not underestimating the fearful insecurity and closed -mindedness of those with orthodox
beliefs. That would be the one piece of advice, reflecting on that question that you sent me a week ago and just thinking about that. I wasn't naive. I knew that deconstructing as a pastor was a risk. And I definitely, that's where I, you know, there was hesitation, and yet I was just so fired up that I knew I had to publish, that it wouldn't just be good enough to just
put it as a blog or something. But, you know, I had this narrative, and I felt really good about it, and yet, you know, I knew, you know, things are going to change when I... publicize this right and so i think my advice is just it's not necessarily like i would do it any differently but i i definitely misjudged one of my relationships i sent the book to somebody and I just totally misjudged that person and it really backfired on me. And that relationship was kind of ruined
as a result of asking for their thoughts. They ended up being way more orthodox than I anticipated. And so that really, that stings, you know, like it's just getting kind of blindsided. And so I was, you know, that I think just understanding that people with... orthodox beliefs something like this does it's like throwing a punch you know and so i i just think that you know that resistance i didn't necessarily anticipate you know from from people that again i thought would
be totally cool with it i knew that there'd be resistance but then when you when you poke the bear like you're gonna get some wounds and i now i have the scars to prove it from doing that. And yeah, like I said, I knew what I was doing and I knew that it was going to be a risk. But yeah, I think just, you know, there are some relationships that ended up being strained as a result. And it's just kind of sad, you know, that it had to be because of me trying to be honest and more authentic and them taking it
as an affront or as me being, you know, somehow. trying to tear down their faith, which I wasn't intending to do that at all. But they then became like, they pitied me when they thought all these, again, those thoughts that a lot of people on the Orthodox world think of us deconstructing. You kind of mentioned this in a question later on about shallow thinking. And it's like, well, what can I do, you know? Yeah, so that's kind
of how I think is if I advice, it would just be, hey, make sure you align yourself with as many allies as possible because someone's going to come at you and you're going to feel, you know, there's going to be all the feels that go with that and to just make sure you've got a strong group of people around you that. that do have your back and do you know love what you're what you're trying to do yeah and that can be such a difficult thing like you're talking about like getting over that hump um and i think that's
honestly what keeps a lot of people in this kind of thinking mode of you know like like just just stay with the status quo don't don't rock the boat you know and i don't want any any heat on me sort of thing but you know i found out very quickly and i strained some relationships too after October 7th, 2023, when I started speaking out for and in support of the Palestinians and against the actions of Israel. And I strained many friendships by doing that. And it honestly
felt very lonely because I didn't really have any close friends that really saw Araya with me. Some people thought... you know like like oh you're sticking to your convictions cool but it wasn't anything more than that i had a lot of friends were very outspoken against what i was saying and were very much like you know israel haha and um and and then you know i i started coming out more as you know deconstructing myself and then i started this podcast and that's during more relationships um because of what i was saying on it and um so i i think doing that and kind
of getting over that hump of of no like getting criticism on yourself now now i see criticism as just you know i i'm able to brush it off a lot easier i don't take it personally just think there's still sometimes i take it personally but i'm able to kind of move past it a little bit more because i've kind of gotten over this hump i i realize what it is and i see the shallowness in a way i don't want to say that people's critiques are shallow but some of them were. And I think
those shallow critiques, I could see the flaws in their logic. And it allowed me to think that maybe having these large questions really helped me to get out of a shallow mindset of thinking for myself. And that's where I was. So definitely moving past that. And another thing I'll say is physicality of moving past boundaries too. Like in college, I would go and do some bridge jumping and getting over like a fear of height or anything like that and knowing that it'll
be okay once you hit that water and go in like that distance that time though that you're in the air you know it's scary for the moment but um but you know it'll pass and and you'll it'll it'll start to wear away So a common motif that you refer back to throughout your book is the idea of jumping off a ledge, which I'm well aware of that too. There is a French term called l 'appel de vide. My French isn't perfect. I took one French class in school. But in English, it translates to the call of the void, which is
a feeling that tends to be a brief, entirely out of character and often involves thoughts of leaping from a high place or driving headfirst into an oncoming vehicle. In a 2012 study, lead researcher Jennifer Hames concluded that somewhat paradoxically, the call of the void could well be a person's subconscious attempting to encourage a greater appreciation of what it feels like to be alive, as opposed to wanting to lure someone to their demise. When more and more people are deconstructing their faith, the tighter the church
attempts to hold people in. So how do you suppose this call of the void may free people from binary high control religion? Yeah. Fantastic question and totally resonate with that motif of the call to avoid. I think I even I think maybe my first chapter might be like stepping into the void. So, yeah, I that that just really resonates with me and kind of my intention behind this experiment, I guess, of publishing doubt within the institution.
It made me think of the quote. that Joseph Campbell has that says something similar to this, which is, he says, I don't believe people are looking for the meaning of life as much as they are looking for the experience of being alive. And so I think when you have a clear... purpose and intention of what what you want to do uh i mean this this goes for anything whether it's a workout program or a new job like you just get behind this purpose and you just go and so you know going back you
know talking about like the criticism that comes you know rob bell i heard rob bell speak at a two -day conference about over 10 years ago now. But the one thing that stayed with me was he said, when you get criticized, let it sting. Because it is personal, right? Anyone who says, don't take this personally and then tells you criticism, you're going to take it personally. But he says, let it sting, but then remember what you're trying to do and remind yourself of your intent and move on and then put it behind
you. And so I think my intent was to feel more alive. in my faith, to be more authentic as a follower of Jesus, as a leader, as a teacher. And my MO in doing that has always been, or maybe it hasn't always been, but I've found great success in being really honest and being willing to be vulnerable. And so that decision motivated this. And I was not really finding the safety that
I once had in religion. I started to realize I don't think there is a right way to believe. There's different ways to believe, some that are more helpful than others. But between feeling more alive, being more authentic, and taking that risk to be vulnerable, and realizing that the system that I was in really couldn't guarantee my safety. and then throw in Carl's virtuous atheism. And then it was kind of like, now we've
got a total kind of mess and chaos on our hands. You might as well just throw yourself behind your purpose and go for it. So I was tired of... of religion high control religion kind of suppressing who i wanted to be and who i who i saw myself as i was constantly throwing these masks on in order to to fit in with with people who were christian and from yeah hanging out with my friends and being in a really strict form of christianity that said i couldn't swear and i couldn't watch sex scenes and movies and i couldn't you know
all these no's that i kept getting it's just like well but i You know, so I was tired. I just, you know, you kind of just get to a point where you're like, enough, like enough with the rules. I want to try this out for how I see it. And so it's, you know, getting away from that, you have to make some of those, I think, just, you know, rules for yourself. Like, how do I want to live in this life? Do I want to go by what someone else tells me all the time? Or is it okay sometimes to make my own way and see what
happens? So, I don't know. That's... That's how I started to organize my thoughts around this. And I'm not perfect, and I know I didn't maybe do it exactly the way I should have, but I'm the one that has to sleep at night with how I carried myself. Yeah, I don't know. I guess I got to this point where I felt like I was screwed either way. If I stayed within the religion as is with these doubts, I hid myself from who I
really was. That was not great. And if I put myself out there as being vulnerable and having doubts about the faith like that also, it was like a win -lose. So I just decided I might as well just do things on my own terms where I have a sense of freedom and authenticity. even if it doesn't work out. And everybody comes across their own time when they decide they want to be themselves and just live authentically. You
tell a story in your introduction of the book about a boy whose parents are concerned because he was expressing these deep philosophical and atheistic attitudes even about all things God and the Bible. You express that his doubting, skeptical, and intellectual perspectives were in fact a sign of spiritual maturity which i love that you use that word that phrase spiritual maturity to express you know these sort of ideas so could you tell us like why you view the act
of asking questions as a sign of maturity and sign of that spiritual growth yeah so in christianity it just had started to become clear that like um like the school's system no uh it was it seemed like it was more about pursuing certainty rather than celebrating curiosity, and that Christianity didn't really seem all that interested in someone's spiritual, personal growth. It was more just like compliance with, like, this is the platter
of what you can choose from, and if it's not on the table, then that's not acceptable. And so someone who exhibits curiosity is now saying essentially that they're going to be courageous and make themselves vulnerable by asking a question and kind of going against the grain. And I see that as mature because that's... That's breaking free from the mindset that the universe revolves
around you and that there might actually be something else that you don't know. I mean, immaturity to me is like a baby or someone who's really young who they think everything revolves around them. Why would they extend themselves out beyond their little circle? Everything revolves around them. So someone who's willing to ask questions to me comes across as, courageous enough and they've got thick enough skin that they actually do see themselves not as necessarily the only,
you know, person in the room, but that there's other things that they want to learn and grow from. I just think that that's a sign of tremendous maturity, especially in the church where, you know, I mean, there's the catechism and Martin Luther is like, okay, you know, these are the things that everyone should believe and this is what everything means and memorize this. I mean, that's a lot of like some of our older members, like that was our confirmation was memorizing
the small catechism, standing up and reciting it or just memorizing scripture verses and, you know, call it good. And so I think having to actually critically think and wonder about something that indicates to me that you're willing to step beyond what is required, I guess, of you. And that's a big step. I mean, that's being very vulnerable, and I think that's a great sign that even if you're questioning what you're absolutely
not supposed to question, again, you want to know something. That's really cool. And I love those kids. I love engaging with those kids and adults that are like... I know I'm supposed to think this way, but it's not gelling with my personal experience. Okay, now we've got something to work with because now that you're doing the work of what I think Jesus wanted his disciples to do, which is you're starting to put the pieces together rather than just accepting somebody
handing you the completed puzzle. I want to flip this question a little bit. you know the church business is such a big business model it's like a multi -billion dollar business model per year and so when like you know you get like fundamentalists apologists and bible literalists like mike winger makes claims that those who deconstruct faith are shallow thinkers what would you say to people like that or you know institutions like that i would say that it is impossible to have a reasonable
conversation with people that are that close -minded. My experience has been people like Mike Winger. It's not far enough to say that they're the ones who are the shallow thinkers. That doesn't go far enough. They're just closed thinkers. They don't have depth. They don't want depth. People who are deconstructing and asking questions, it's because they want to have more dimension in their life and not less. And so when you engage with someone who's belittling and trying to essentially
make you look bad and get you down to their level, I mean, it's because they're not interested in growing. They feel afraid. by what you're saying. And for me, I've often kind of seen people with these fundamental beliefs, and I talk about it in the book, as like having their faith is like a house of cards. And they're realizing that we live in an increasingly windy world. And so they want to put up more walls because they want
to protect that house of cards with everything that they can. And people who are deconstructing are like, I don't think it is a house of cards. And if it is, I want to build something else that's going to hold up better. And so when you engage in those conversations with people who are attacking you and trying to make you look like you're the shallow thinker, it is an apples and oranges kind of situation. It's like, well, there's nothing really that I can say that, unless you show that you're open to what I'm having to say, I mean, I'm going to lower my expectations
for what's actually going to come out of that conversation. I don't know. I've just found that The true adventurers are those that are willing to, yeah, they want to use different materials in building their faith and to be a lot more, you know, kind of adventure sport minded from, you know, kite surfing or cave spelunking or, you know, name your adventure sport, scuba diving. I mean, it's about digging, going deeper, exploring, trying different things and seeing what sticks
and what you can do without. that don't get that they're just a desert dweller they just want to be in on the ground level and have no real intention of of of leaving beyond and you know it's unfortunate i just feel bad for them so you can plant seeds pray for rain you know i don't know but i i guess i I feel like you have to tread carefully and lower your expectations in engaging unless you just want to debate them. But then you're just going to go round and round
in circles and no one's going to feel good at the end of that. And no, there's not too many people that have ever come out of a debate that they've lost where they think, you know, oh, I've really changed my mind. Totally, yes. Yes, exactly. When you're so entrenched in something, facts don't really... change anything they just entrench you deeper um to be honest so it's it's one of those things like when you are talking to somebody if you actually do decide you want to talk to somebody that's so entrenched and closed -minded and saying you know i've got the
truth and no one else has got the truth and i'm going to fight everybody that thinks they do it's you have to come at it a different approach. You have to come out and, you know, plant those seeds of allowing them to think and don't expect any quick changes. It's something that's going to happen over time. You know, the more and more people that plant seeds, the faster that might take place. But yeah. You never go into it expecting that you're going to change someone's mind, especially when there's facts and such a closed -mind approach.
Yeah, and it goes both ways. I mean, we all get into our echo chambers. Whether you're deconstructing your faith or you're Orthodox, you tend to kind of go in looking for your people to cheer and say, yep, that's exactly what I believe. And so I do think it's good to have people in your life that don't. just echo back to you what your beliefs are. And hopefully you have a long enough relationship with that person where you can be honest with each other without it always becoming an argument and truly try to see something from
a different perspective. In my second book, I put in this kind of test called the open -closed assessment and kind of just always having in your own mind, like, what's my openness to change on this topic? Am I completely closed or am I like a seven or an eight where I'm more established but still open to changing my mind? And then either asking that of the other person that you're talking to, like how open are you actually to changing your mind on this topic? And for those
longstanding friendships. Those really that are trusting, you'll know, you'll either know what their number is already or they will be honest with you. And if they're feeling like, you know what, I really don't want to change my mind about this. Well, then, you know, what good is it going to be having this conversation? And so it goes both ways. It is important to still, and that's what I love about the church is that lots of different opinions and lots of different experiences that those opinions are based on. And so it really does come back to like hearing people's story and kind of getting a sense of like, oh, now.
Now I see why you're coming at it from this perspective. And then that can help your own perspective. I'm still deconstructing this side of me because I still get entrenched sometimes. I think later, like a day or two, I realize how close -minded I may have been during a conversation. But it's still one of those things I'm working on. And I think knowing that yourself, that you can do that yourself, you can be so close -minded. It helps with a little bit of understanding that in other people and seeing yourself in other people. I think that definitely helps in a journey
of understanding all that. So you place a number of quotes in your book, mainly at the chapter heads. And there is one that really stood out to me. It was from Aristotle. It reads, I think
it's primarily two things. I think it's the emotional attachment that People have put their beliefs on the container that they put their beliefs into. It has a lot of just emotion to it. So especially people who their faith helped them get through a really difficult time, that developed just a lot of emotional intensity to those beliefs. And so to question something that in the past was really helpful, that's a big leap for some.
for some Christians and other people of faith to make. And that's where, again, those conversations you get into, you're stepping into potentially emotional landmine field, and you don't realize, I just want to have a conversation about Jesus' death, and somebody has just this emotional attachment to that doctrine. And then you just step on a landmine, right? And so I think there's just a lot of that emotion that you have to regulate
for yourself and be cognizant of when it comes to that questioning journey. But it's just hard. I mean, it's for someone who has spent their whole life being conditioned in, and yeah, it is a conditioning in a lot of religious circles where that Christianity narrative. is looking for you to mentally assent, like, yes, this is the way it is. And then you keep reinforcing
that over and over, depending on who your preacher has been, who they want you to just keep echoing back, like, yep, you're right, that's exactly it. So that just develops lots of layers, right? So that conditioning can be really hard to just break out of just because. So I don't think the church necessarily intended to create critical thinkers either. They want you to believe these things because in doing so, then you're going to heaven or whatever has been promised through
these beliefs. So it's just a lot of sweat equity, I think. In general, people are pretty lazy when it comes to their Christian faith because that's, again, how the system was designed and how it was built. Jesus died for your sins. Believe and be saved. Bada bing. There you go. That's all you need to do. That's how it's been packaged and sold. And if you've got emotional belief, emotional equity and investment in that, that's going to be really hard to break out of. not
really interested in those kinds of things, then that's also going to be difficult. It's for people like us who say, yeah, but, you know, and I, you know, can I just ask a question about this? Or then, you know, we've clearly, we've broken through some of those emotional attachments or we've created new emotional attachments that say, it actually really makes me mad. And I don't want to be a mad person. I want to have peace. So I need to I need to focus on this thing that
makes me mad and come to a better resolve with that. And then there are some people who just get mad and they leave and they don't ever want to not be mad. Whenever it comes up, they're just pissed off and they don't want to go there and you just have to honor that and be like, okay. It's everyone kind of in between mad and super, you know. toxically positive. You know, you try to find that middle ground to say, you know, what do you actually think about this if you have to, like, give an explanation yourself?
And it's those people that I think are more ready to, you know, engage in this journey. And, you know, for everyone else, you just have to kind of, okay, like, got it. I will back up and allow you to do your thing. It's funny that you say toxic positivity because that's definitely who I used to be. I used to be in that toxic positivity. I'm glad I'm out of it. I mean, I still have my positive side, but I feel like I've moved definitely more into the realistic and just understanding
the nuance between so many things in life and just not wanting to just... Just be like, no, I'm just going to sit in this little category of what I want to be, where I want to be at, and I'll just sit there and just ignore the rest of the world. Yeah, I'm glad I moved on from that. Yeah, there's nothing wrong with being positive, but there's definitely something wrong with being too positive. Yeah. You say that you're eager to move on from Christian messaging that
lords Jesus' death or Jesus' death to bully or frighten people into believing. The example was needing Jesus to die for us to get something in return, which makes Jesus' death transactional. I've talked about this with the book Hellbent on another episode, but you mentioned that for true spiritual growth, healing, and the feeling of aliveness to occur. a person needs to be willing to question struggle and be wrong like be okay
with being wrong the thought of being wrong about something can be a difficult pill to swallow so would you say it is important to be okay with being wrong absolutely i mean you have to be okay with being wrong whenever you're in an exploring experimenting mode i mean scientists are wrong all the time whenever they're trying to prove their hypotheses It's the wrong which leads to their learning and growth. Yeah, it is a tough pill to swallow because there's a lot of power that's attached with being right and then therefore
a lot of powerlessness that's attached to being wrong. But from my standpoint, one of the things that draws me to Jesus continually is His humility and his willingness to be vulnerable, his willingness to draw that out of others. And so you can't, I feel like being willing to be wrong is just, it's about humility. That's your opportunity to be, to live out that Jesus -like humility
and authenticity is risking that you could just be. wrong sometimes it's sometimes you can laugh off being wrong and sometimes being wrong is deeply like hurtful and and again another one of jesus's tenants is forgiveness and grace and so those are opportunities to let your human side come out and and know that i screwed up and i need to forgive myself for that you know if you get forgiveness from from from the person
you hurt that's that's bonus but i mean it really comes down to can i forgive myself for this and so being wrong i think is a just a huge part of of this creating a new a new system a new faith building or whatever you want to call from what you've done with your deconstruction is is where's where's the humility in in doing this because if it if there isn't humility if it is if it's just now you're trying to create a a system that's just about right belief, well, then you're literally no better than the thing
you just deconstructed. You're just trying to do it your own way. So, yeah, I think it's a great way to be in a conversation, like we just talked about with your openness is, no, I could be wrong about this. I think that would help me to grow from it. And so I think it's more Christian than certainty. Because being wrong or being willing to be wrong, I think that demonstrates
the softness of the heart where certainty is more about rigidity and trying to establish this concrete has to be this way. So I think that we have that need to feel right and there's nothing wrong with wanting to be in that feeling either as long as I think you're leaving space for the possibility that... You might not be. I like that. Well, it's just about time here. Again, we were just talking about this book, Doubting Faithfully. Pastor Keith, thank you again for
entering my life and giving me this book. It was a great read, and I really enjoyed it, and I hope that other people are able to find it. Keith, where can people find this? So I self -published Doubting Faithfully through the Amazon platform. The only place you can get it is on Amazon. There's also an e -book of it. If you are anti -Amazon, just reach out to me. I've got hard copies. I'd be happy to send you a signed copy because I respect that. I just didn't know
what I was doing when I self -published, and Amazon was literally the only thing, even though I was kind of like, am I selling my soul to sell to Amazon? But it was so easy. So anyway, you can get it on Amazon. I keep my website. regularly updated, and so you can find my work there, which is authorkeithlong .com. I blog on there as well, and I post sermons occasionally, and I've got different links to things that I'm up to. So if you want to hear me preach, I've got a link
on the About page on my website about listening to sermons that I give here at my congregation. I'm doing some teaching. through Question Church, which is an experimental online community for the spiritually curious. And so that's once a month. You can check in through there. So yeah, that's pretty much how you can get a hold of me. Email address is in my books and on the website. I'd love to have conversation with people and answer questions and receive your criticism so I can grow from it. Now, I noticed you also said
that you are developing a lecture series. Do you want to talk about that at all? Yeah, so I love to teach. It's just in my bones, and obviously I've done that through writing, but I've developed a seven -part lecture series on the future of religion and spirituality. My hope is to just get out into churches and other communities, either online or in person. There are 50 -minute lectures with time for Q &A. The list of those
lectures is on my website under Presentations. presented at churches before. And yeah, I'm just, I find I'm a filmmaking major and my undergrad is in filmmaking. So visual image is important to me. So I put together PowerPoint presentations to go with these presentations. Again, open the dialogue and have more conversation. Yeah, it's the Jesus Beyond Christianity is the title of the lecture series. And like I said, you can find that on the website. Very cool. I might have to have you on in a future episode to talk
about expanded consciousness because obviously we don't have enough time right now, but I don't know much about it. But when you sent me that, I had to Google it and I was like, oh, so this is like a big thing. Yes. Maybe we can plan another talk. I would love to do that. Yeah, I'm actually, I don't know. Yeah, I'm contemplating going back to get more school and education around the topic of expanded consciousness. And even if I don't, I've read so much and listened to so many podcasts.
The science around non -local consciousness is growing, and I do feel like if people can tap their own personal journey, that learning about consciousness just gives you such a different perspective, especially about suffering and your own journey of faith. And I do feel like it's the future of the way we engage. religion and spirituality. And so, yeah, it's a deep passion
of mine, and I'd love to come back and talk about it and appoint people in direction of some resources that I've found really meaningful. Yeah, I'd love to talk more into that. Well, maybe we'll run into each other at Theology Beer Camp this year. It's in Kansas City. If anybody is wondering, you can get your tickets to it at homebrewedchristianity .com. I think that's just the web address for it. Or you can just Google Theology Beer Camp 2026. You should be able to find that. I'm still on the fence. I think you're thinking about going.
Ian McConnell, I just talked to, I think he's thinking about going too. So there'll be a number of people there. It's constantly growing every year. There's more and more people that go. So yeah, maybe we'll run into each other this coming year, a little later in the year. Yeah, it's a great way to meet people that are... doing this journey as well and they're a fun group and yeah you might run into somebody who then you end up on their podcast so um yeah there you go well keith it's it was a real pleasure talking to you today um yeah thanks again for coming on here yeah thanks mark thanks for what
you're doing and look forward to hearing more of your podcasts in the future i think you're doing a great job
Two white Christians, who love Muslims, breakdown myths and misconceptions that many Americans (and more specifically Christians) have about Islam and Muslims. Mark Wayne of the Colonial Outcasts podcast joins in the...
Capitalism has a long and ugly history of scapegoating and exploiting immigrants. From British capitalists exploiting Irish people to the United States’ deeply systemic and oppressive tactics, immigrants have, for a...
This is part 7 of the Enchantments of Mammon series. Capitalism needs a permanent source of unpaid labor. Childbearing, child raising, cooking, cleaning, caregiving, emotional support. The invisible work that keeps...
Marx’s analysis does not specifically take into account the history of the exploitation of women and non-white people. We will be digging into some of the ways that racism, sexism, and xenophobia play into the...
Spiritual maturity and financial security are often married within the church business model. How do we identify patterns of abuse and work toward a more sustainable future? Let's get into it in today's episode of part...