Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Grub & Grace

Grub & Grace artwork

Deweaponize the Bible w Ryan Canty

Jan 13, 202553 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Ryan Canty joins me to deweaponize the Bible and show you that there is a larger story behind the words regularly used to demonize and dehumanize marginalized peoples from behind the pulpit. Ryan is promoting his book called "Deweaponize" which is out now. It is a very accessible read for anyone interested in learning more about the topics discussed in our episode. Get it for yourself or as a gift for the loved one in your family that may benefit from a little flexibility in their theological world view. All ideas and viewpoints presented should be taken as opinion. Be sure to give us a 5-star rating on Apple podcast and leave us a shining review. Also be sure to like and follow us on social media on Facebook, Instagram, and X. grubandgrace.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Grub and Grace, where we believe the best conversation happens around the table. I am your host, Mark Flower, and I will be sitting down with authors, pastors, and others who are passionate about topics such as faith, religion, pop culture, politics, as well as personal testimonies, all while allowing an open and safe space for good faith dialogue. We don't always have to agree, but we're always willing to listen without demonizing or shutting the other down.

We believe that we can learn from one another through active listening as we navigate faith and life. Our goal is to enter into every conversation with the intention to learn while leaving our pride and our ego at the door. So, pull up a chair and stay a while. Welcome to Grub and Grace. I am Mark Flower and I'm here with my guest, Ryan Canty, who's written a fantastic book, by the way.

It's called Deweaponize. If you are in the deconstruction space or just having questions at all about, you know, what the church teaches you about what the Bible says, you have to get this book. This is a fantastic book. Ryan, thank you for allowing me the chance to read this because this is just, I don't know, I feel like you gave me so much to talk about in the deconstruction space and just the biblical space. But if you don't mind, tell my viewers a little bit about yourself.

Sure. So, I'm not a theologian by trade. I'm a software engineer. So, I kind of approach, I have done approaching theology by going about it very methodically. And so, when I was where I was raised in more of a strict Calvinistic background and then I went to school in Calvary Chapel, Calvary Chapel Junior High School, and then went to a Baptist University. So, I'm very familiar with kind of both the hardline Calvinist and more of the evangelical Baptist side of American evangelicalism.

And when I kind of started having this crisis of faith, it pushed me towards diving a lot deeper into theology than I think most people probably would. So, I ended up learning Greek, Hebrew, reading tons of books from early church fathers, rabbis, etc., theologians from all types of the spectrum. So, yeah, that's a little bit about me. The book is very much of a passion project.

It was, I wrote effectively the book that I wish I would have had when I was first kind of coming out of fundamentalist Christianity. Something that respected the Bible and respected some of the beliefs that I had and didn't hand wave over it. I think a lot of books either are incredibly solid theological resources that take a lot of time and effort and energy to get through, and they only touch on one or two little things, or they're really high level, cover a large sloth of doctrines and concepts in the Bible.

And they kind of hand wave over some things that I've always been curious about, like what did Paul actually mean when he said X? So, I try to do the best that I can to answer most of these through the lens of a more Christ-like interpretation is what I try to do for. And you do it in such a digestible way too. So, like you were saying, a lot of theologians, they devote an entire book based on just one subject, whether it be homosexuality, which you have a good chunk of a chapter on that, you have, what other chapters may be.

You have very nice, nicely organized and nice bits for people to digest that it's not overwhelming, but you give a lot of evidence to your logic and reasoning for what you say in the book. And I find that very helpful because like you were saying, when you're coming out of that fundamental space or you start even asking questions just in general, it's that type of book that you wish you had so that you can get, even if it's just your introduction to these topics

and something that pushes you forward into wanting to learn more. I mean, you can find other books by like P. Dens, Brian McLaren, Ili Dillio, all those other authors. I feel like your book is just such a good beginning point for a lot of people. Thank you. Yeah, that's exactly what I was trying to shoot for. Because I think one of the things that a couple of things that kind of I was trying to dismantle in that book is the idea that for one, there is a single interpretation, right? My interpretation may not be right, right?

Like this is my point of view. This is my theological biases that are coming into my reading of the Bible. Now, I've spent a lot of time and energy trying to understand to the best of my knowledge what the original authors meant and what they intended. But at the end of the day, how you apply what they intended into our regular lives today is a matter of interpretation. It's a matter of discussion. And that's why there were councils upon councils to decide any kind of application within the church.

And another thing is trying to dismantle this idea that there is a single orthodoxy or there is a single way of looking at things, not a single interpretation necessarily, but a single right interpretation and a single way that has been that way for all of Christianity. And that's just a falsehood, right? Like people have been thinking about and interpreting the Bible in so many different ways throughout the throughout the throughout Christians history, Christianity's history. And so I think it's really important to understand, like when you're in evangelical spaces, very frequently you'll get the idea,

well, this is just how Christians have always believed. The concept, one of the concepts being like the doctrine of biblical inerrancy is one of these concepts that they think, oh, yeah, well, of course, everybody believes that the Bible is inerrant. That takes a little bit of teasing apart. What does it mean that the Bible is inerrant? Does that mean scientifically and historically factually accurate? Does that mean that the authors weren't lying? Does that mean that the Bible was written down by God? Well, what does that mean? So you have to question a lot of these things and don't necessarily just go with the answers that people give you, but just start to question like, okay, wrestle with God.

Like, what does it mean that the Bible is inspired? There's nothing wrong with thinking that the Bible is inspired, but it has certain implications depending on how you imagine that to be. Like, if you imagine that the Bible in its current form, like in the ESV English translation of modern times, every single word on those pages is directive and meant to inform every action of your life, you're going to come away with a very different idea than an interpretation that imagines the Bible as a collection of stories that ancient people imagined God in different ways and try to wrestle with him and try to understand what his will is for their lives

and act out of that in their own cultural context. So those are kind of the main things that I wanted folks to kind of come away with. And as a result, using some practical examples. And so the book kind of goes through seven different kind of theological concepts, starting with, as we just mentioned, inerrancy, moving into creation versus evolution, which is a big one. It was kind of one of the historical points that started the inerrancy debate. Then we move into patriarchy. How does the man-woman relationship within a family structure kind of work?

I've been a supplementary in churches for a while, throughout most of my life, actually. And coming out of that with what is a Christ-like attitude of a husband toward a wife or wife toward a husband or parents toward children. And then going into, okay, well, what is the relationship between homosexuals? What is the relationship between any kind of queer relationships? Is that sinful? Is it not? What does the Bible actually say about it? Does it even address this issue? And then so going on past that, I talk about the idea of hell.

This is a concept that has evolved dramatically over the centuries, from early, early Jewish thought before Christ, and then during the Second Temple period, and then in Jesus's ministry and after. And then that thought kind of developed throughout Christianity to what we have an idea of hell as today. And we bring our own theological biases talking about that. And then we talk about the atonement, which is a big one in churches today where the question comes up, why did Christ have to die? Did he have to die?

What is the relationship between God the Father and Christ? Did God have to kill Jesus as a sacrifice for our sin? Is he not able to forgive us without a sacrifice? And so really honestly handling some of those difficult questions, then we kind of end with this idea of repentance and what salvation really means and what that would have meant to the early Christians. So again, these ideas are not things that I'm presenting the correct way, because again, there is not really one correct way.

There's multiple different ways of viewing this and interpreting this. And I do the best that I can to treat the text seriously and honestly and try to answer as many of these texts with different interpretations that point to a more Christ-like view. And one of the points you bring out the book is that we have 40,000 different denominations in the world. And that alone should tell people, okay, there shouldn't be one way of thinking this. There isn't one correct way to analyze and say that this is the absolute truth that the Bible says. And the practical examples you talk about, I love the practical examples you give.

So you give even examples to pop culture like Star Wars, Lord of the Rings. You even talk about the term sick and what that means and then terping it. So you talk about Star Wars, how George Lucas would, if he was asked in the 90s about Star Wars, it would of course be the original trilogy. And then if you were to die to that point, and they continue to make Star Wars, there's that whole debate. You bring that whole analogy to scripture.

This is to give a little context, this is the bit about whether or not we can accurately say that because in Timothy, Paul, the author, presumably Paul, says the word scriptures. Is he referring to his own scriptures? Is he referring to other books of the New Testament or is he mainly referring to the Old Testament and things along these lines? And whether or not Paul was the genuine author of the pastoral epistles, namely, for second Timothy and Titus.

Yeah. And thank you for going into that because I'm sure people listening to me, I'm just probably butchering with whatever you wrote in the book. But even going to like the word sick and if people like 500 years in the future look back and they look at the culture context of the word sick, they would think unhealthy and sickly and just someone that has some sort of illness. But what it really means is if you're talking about like going surfing and the waves are sick, it's more of this California bohemian term. And you wouldn't actually understand that. And you kind of bring that into, I think it's the theonetics, theonostics, I forget what the term was.

Theoponistos? Yes, that's how you pronounce it. I was struggling with that, I was reading it. I was like, how do you pronounce this word? But yeah, it's like these really, like I was saying, it's very lower shelf so that anybody can kind of pick this up and you bring these examples in to allow people to use their real life and real terms that they use on an everyday basis and pop culture to kind of illuminate the story of the Bible and the direction that you're taking it.

So I thought it was such a fascinating reading. Thank you so much. I appreciate that. You hit quite a bit of subjects that are considered taboo or even demonized, which we discuss, you know, homosexuality, the role of the men and women in the modern church, particularly those that adhere to fundamentalism or Christian nationalism. You even mentioned a book, If Someone Makes It This Far Without Throwing the Book in the Trash, which April Adjoy in her book actually did something similar to that. I haven't read that one yet, it's on my list.

It's a good one too. Then they are at least open to these concepts. So the question is, what kind of criticisms have you received from the book so far? Frankly, not too many. I think that it's still new enough and I'm not quite popular enough in the conservative spaces to really have had enough of an impact that conservative folks who are reading it for the purpose of antagonizing would have actually bothered reading it.

I've received some feedback from folks around just genuine questions about homosexuality, around atonement and things along these lines, mostly from friends and family, that I think are really valid. I think it's been great to have conversations with those folks around what are these, is this heresy, is this something that we can talk about, is this something we can have an open dialogue around? I think it's been really constructive in a lot of respects.

So far I haven't had any hate mail or death threats or anything like that. I'm glad you haven't gotten any death threats. Please do not send them death threats because that does not help anybody. Nope. Has anyone started using your book as part of a group study or anything like that? Funny you should mention that. Yeah, I'm actually working right now on... I'm an ordained elder in the PC USA at my church and so I'm going to be pitching the idea of using my book or maybe some other books in that same vein to address some of these cultural issues within our time.

I think I led a Bible study at that church around Peter Enz's book, How the Bible Actually Works, which was really, really good. A lot of great questions. He addressed a lot of similar topics, but from more of a biblical critical perspective and kind of more high level of how to answer these questions. He didn't really dive into a specific alternative interpretation. And so I might try to bring in my book for that. I think you probably noticed that there's quite a few discussion questions at the end.

My next goal, my next project is going to be to write up a bunch of PowerPoint or Google slides and make them publicly available and share them. So that if you want to use the book as a Bible study tool for your church, then you can do so. So stay up to date on that and I should hopefully be done with that in the next couple of months. So we shall see. Well, that'd be really cool to have that resource out there. And like you said, I did notice the little questions at the end and I just thought you it was a cool inclusion to have that not only just for the reader to self reflect,

but and even just kind of have like a almost sort of summary of the chapter in a way. But like, you know, they have that resource as like, you know, possible study tool. So I thought it was just really cool that you included that that into the book as part of each chapter. Yeah. So I love the flow of how you laid out the chapters in the book, starting with breaking down inherent inerrancy and misinterpretations as to lay out the groundwork so that the reader can better understand the later concepts you present. What stood out to you while research researching and writing as the biggest concepts that moved or shaped your understanding of faith?

Oh, biggest concepts that moved or shaped. I think. The idea that the Bible is not meant to be read as a scientific or historical textbook, I think, was one of the biggest turning points for my faith in gave me permission to. Use kind of the cultural context and the ways in which the ancient Near Eastern person would have read this and thought about this in in ways that were more constructive and a little bit more.

I don't want to say mystical necessarily, but more open to interpretation. Rabbis use the term, use the analogy that the Torah is like a multifaceted gem, right? Like the more you turn it, like you see different light in different ways. It's the same gem, but you just see it in different ways. And I really like that analogy, and it allowed me, I think, the permission to to view the Bible in that way. The book that I think was the most influential kind of catalyst in that was Speed Ends' book, The Bible Tells Me So.

Highly recommend that to anybody. I think that one was a really good book to introduce folks to this concept that just because the Bible says something doesn't mean it's necessarily historically accurate. And it also doesn't mean that the author intended it to be historically accurate, because it's one thing to say that they were wrong or they were lying. It's a whole other thing to say they weren't intending to tell the truth in the way that post-Enlightenment modern thinkers think of it.

They were telling their national story in a way that made sense to them, right? They were telling their, like a great example to if folks have heard the Baymoth podcast with Marty Solomon, he does a really good job of going through kind of the Bible in more of an eastern thinking way, like an ancient near-eastern kind of way of thinking, where it's more inductive reasoning, not deductive. He uses this idea of not viewing the Bible as a set of bullet points.

Like we typically do in America or the Western world. We typically transfer information as in like this bullet point, this bullet point, this bullet point. Whereas the ancient near-eastern person would tell a story and like Jesus, right, you would tell a parable. And out of that parable, he would assume or want you to question it and wonder, what am I getting out of this? He doesn't give you the answer. He gives you the question so that you can ponder and ask more questions and come to your own realizations and come to your own conclusions about what he was trying to get at.

So parables shouldn't be viewed as, well, what's the interpretation of this parable? What is the interpretation? Like what is a interpretation, right? Like there's many. And I think that when you start thinking about it that way, you can read things like Genesis significantly differently. There's a fantastic book, if you're ever curious about this, called The Beast that Crouches at the Door by Rabbi David Foreman. And he does a really good job of describing the story of Adam and Eve and the story of Cain and Abel from more of a interpretation of like a story, like an allegory, right?

Like it shows very clearly that this story is not meant to be taken literally. And you look in the ancient historical records of what stories came before Genesis, things like Gilgamesh, things like the Anuma Elish. And I talk about a few of these in the book, but these stories predate Genesis. And it's one thing to say, oh, well, Genesis just like ripped him off. Well, that's too simplistic. And I think a lot of atheists tend to look at these things and say, oh, here's a gotcha for you stupid Christians.

Like these stories came before, so your book is just a lying whatever. But reality is, is that they're very different, but there's a lot of similarities because A, they lived in the same region and time, give or take. B, there was a lot of cultural transition going on where Israel was in the land of Babylon or in or like exiled to Babylon, right? And this is around the time when they start writing down a lot of their, a lot of their stories and a lot of their traditions.

So it's pretty clear that a lot of these Babylonian epics like the Epic of Gilgamesh would influence the stories of Israel, right? Gilgamesh has this character called Utnapishtim, who's a Noah figure, like very, very clearly. And if you listen to Gilgamesh, it's not super long. I listen to it. So most of the things I listen to on audiobooks, if you read Gilgamesh, not super long. It has audiobook versions of it. It only takes a couple hours.

And in it, you'll hear the story of Utnapishtim, who is this character who deceived the gods and built an ark when the gods were annoyed with humanity and wanted to flood the world, right? And he builds this ark, has like animals of like two by two, mostly like agrarian animals, like cattle and goats and things like this. He builds this big square boat, very detailed about the dimensions, just like in the story of Noah.

And then he lands on a mountain, sends out, I think it was a raven or something. It's very, very similar, right? And so the idea that Genesis wasn't influenced by this book that was like, with a story that was about a thousand years earlier, I think, if I'm not mistaken, is kind of ridiculous. It was in the same time, significantly earlier, why wouldn't they have been influenced by this story that was able to stand the test of time? But when you look at it from a perspective that they knew about it, they chose to appropriate it and then added their own theology on top of it to show how good their God was, right?

And it brings up the idea that, well, God was still destroying people, but at the same time, ancient people didn't think that was bad, right? Their idea of their God was that they destroyed not everybody, but the wicked or the unjust, right? And that was their oppressors at the time. It wasn't that God was able to be deceived like the gods of Enlil and Aon, these Babylonian gods. But Yahweh was able to see ahead, understand that there was wickedness, there was righteousness.

Noah was the righteous, and he was going to save Noah and destroy wickedness, right? And the wicked people or whatever it may be. So, I mean, these are not meant to be literal historical accounts, and you can get more out of understanding and accepting that there exist other accounts prior and trying to think about and rationalize why it is that they chose these accounts to describe their kind of national identity and who they were and who their God was and things along those lines.

Yeah, and to bring your kind of method of analogies and all this, it's like modern day stories. You get books, movies, TV shows where you see influence from past media. Like you get, was it Orwell's 1984? You get like, you know, like Margaret Atwood's, you know, like, and then you get like Shakespeare. And you see a lot of their themes that they had written about before in their literature showing up in present day literature or present day film.

Or, you know, you got Mr. Rogers and then my kid watches like Super Simple Songs. So you see a lot of influence from Mr. Rogers in Super Simple Songs. I'm kind of visualizing this as you're saying all this and as I read the book too. But yeah, it's like kind of that pull what you can and kind of make your story your own sort of thing. And not only that, but I think there was also this element of subversion to it, right? I recently at my church, the music director brought up a song that I'd never heard before.

I'm not really super into listening to Christian music on my own, so I didn't really hadn't heard this one before. Audrey Assad does this fantastic song called Your Peace Will Make Us One. And she uses the music from the Battle Hymn of the Republic, which is that song about where the grapes of wrath and all of these things. But she uses the same similar like cadence and music and language and kind of converts it to being about peace and God being nurturing.

And it's a fantastic song, not only just in the lyrics that she chose, but the kind of the subversion of this really awful theology song of the Battle Hymn of the Republic. If you haven't heard it or listened to the lyrics, I highly recommend you go look at that and then look at Audrey Assad's song next to it, because it's a really interesting kind of subversive text and song. And it does the exact same kind of a thing that I think that the authors of Genesis were doing with some of these Babylonian myths.

So there were two or three concepts that people would be able to walk away after finishing your book. What would your hope be that they would be able to pull out of it? Just like one or two or three concepts. Yeah, that's a good thought. I think that the I mentioned a couple of these already that the one is that I would want them to understand that there's not just a single interpretation or single way of looking at the Bible. Like if they can walk away with that as being like it, I think that would be a win.

Realistically, I also would like them to have a framework for interpreting the Bible and reading the Bible and applying it to their lives that has Christ as the cornerstone. Christ is the central point. I think a lot of evangelicals in the vein of John Calvin and Martin Luther and others focus so heavily on Paul and Paul's epistles that they kind of miss the historical Jesus as part of that. Or they focus so much on revelation and rapture and all of these kinds of things.

Or if they're more puritanical, they focus so much on Old Testament and laws and how can those apply? And it's fascinating to see that if your focus is on any one of those things, you will naturally try to make the rest of the Bible fit into that frame. If your focus is on the law, you're going to take bits of the New Testament and try to make it kind of apply to that. If your focus is on Paul and what Paul is saying, then you're going to take a very systematic theology approach to the rest of the Bible and try to kind of make everything fit. But if you take Christ's approach and if you look at the Bible from a Jesus-centric lens and really immerse yourself in the Gospels

and see how Jesus handled the scripture, like read the Old Testament scripture that Jesus is quoting. Read them in their contexts. How is he handling it? Is he using everything in context or is he kind of picking and choosing bits with the primary point of talking about love, talking about freedom, talking about who God actually is? I think you see a lot of this subversion of how the first century rabbis at the time had interpreted the Old Testament and the Torah and the prophets

and have missed a lot of things. Very similar to the Reformation in Catholicism, right? Like how the Pope and the Roman Catholic Church at the time had interpreted the Bible and things along these lines. Martin Luther came in and tried to adjust things and try to reform the church. I think coming away with this idea that Christianity is in large part always undergoing deconstruction. It's always undergoing Reformation, right? Deconstruction is not a scary term. It should not be a scary term. It's been made a scary term because it sounds a little bit like destruct

and that's not at all what it's meant to be, right? We're constantly trying to reevaluate and reform how we think and why we come to the conclusions that we have. So I think the two big things is one, understanding that there's more than one way to kind of look at the Bible and that it hasn't always been like that. And two, to come away with the idea that if we read the Bible with Jesus at the center, we're going to come away with a much more positive

and a much more constructive way of interpreting the Bible. I think those are two really good things to pull away. Kind of like what you were saying, I want to kind of go back to talking about like if you're in certain camps that you focus more on like the Old Testament or the Gospels of Paul or John, I think it was Paul. And that's one of the main things that allowed me to start asking questions and kind of start this process of like, you know, what's the truth of the Bible?

What's being told versus, you know, actually digging in the scripture myself and doing my own work instead of allowing someone else to tell me is a lot. Almost every single church that I've been to, I didn't really hear too much of Jesus's teachings. It was always Paul. It was always Old Testament. And it still was until until recently. I found actually the church that the LGBT camp was. We just started turning that one and that one. Yeah, it's it's actually been really refreshing because they do a lot of Jesus's actual teachings.

You know, once I started asking questions, I started learning about like the red letter Christians and you know, where they focus very heavily on the red letters, which are Jesus's, you know, words from the Bible. There's a lot of interpretation as far as if that actually was Jesus's words or if it was manufactured by the writers. But but they do focus a lot more on that and and they do go into other scriptures. But it's very heavy, more or less more heavily on on Jesus teachings. I think you're absolutely right there. I think that it's so important to have a an anchor within the Bible, because realistically, you can approach the Bible from a critical perspective and just view each of these things as very disparate stories, because they are.

Realistically, the Bible is not a book. It's a library. And we can't treat it as a book because it doesn't it has some like overarching themes for sure. But it wasn't designed to be a single book. Certain books were certainly chose chosen to to compose the canon that we know today. And most of those were chosen because they fit some overarching narrative. But at the end of the day, you read the Old Testament in the Torah, you read even within the Torah, the differences between like the Levitical laws and the Deuteronomical laws.

And then you go jump ahead to like the major and minor prophets and how they viewed sacrifice as an example, how they viewed justice, how they viewed land, how they viewed God and the people and things along these lines. And then you jump ahead to the Second Temple period. If you don't have a book that has the Apocrypha, highly recommend it. There's some really, really good stuff in there. Second, third Maccabees, you got the dragon. Exactly. But I think some of those were later Christian editions. I think the ones that are really interesting are the ones that were in the Septuagint, because something that historically speaking, the Bible that was most commonly used in the time of Jesus was the Septuagint.

It was the Greek translation of the Old Testament, and it included a couple of books that were in the Bible for a very long time, actually until like, I'm going to say like the late 1800s is when they actually took those out of the Bible. So it wasn't just Protestantism. It was like in the Bible for a very, very long time. And it was funny enough, I think, if I recall correctly, the reason that they took it out was because it cost too much to print and no one was actually like reading anything out of them. So they just decided, yeah, we'll just scrap those. It's fine.

It's not part of a liturgical calendar, so we'll just scrap it. But it just kind of became a precedent. But you can see this kind of evolution and these differences in thought, and that's all great. It's fantastic to read the Bible as like it's overarching storyline. But if you are going to do the quest of taking the Bible and applying it to your life and to understanding and to reading something and applying it to how am I supposed to interact with other people with God in my life,

you need to find some kind of anchor in doing so. And I think that, like I said, so many people try to find this anchor in Paul because he speaks in a very educated way. He speaks very linearly, which appeals to post-Enlightenment thinkers. He doesn't speak very parabolically like Jesus did. And so you don't have to really chew on a lot of what he says much. Like you can read a couple of his verses out of context and kind of get the gist of what he was saying. With Jesus, any one of his parables, you can read it in a bunch of different ways. And some of his sayings are really challenging and really hard to think about.

And so a lot of churches, I think, generally avoid that because Paul speaks in a much more post-Enlightenment way and like kind of Greek philosophy, frankly, way of thinking about it. Like he follows a lot of the same logic that Plato did. And so finding that anchor in Jesus will really help to frame how you're viewing the rest of the Bible. And that can be like kind of the thing that is your determining factor of, hey, the Old Testament says we should like stone people for X, Y, and Z. What does Jesus have to say about that?

Okay, cool. So now if I'm taking Jesus as the cornerstone, I don't necessarily reject that part of the Bible, but I read it in its context and realize this is not in line with what Jesus said. If Jesus, we believe, is the incarnation of God, is the full manifestation of the character of God in human form, and he is saying to love your neighbor as yourself, and this doesn't align with that. Maybe this thing back here was an ancient violent tribal people trying to reconcile how their God interacted with them at their cultural time and place.

And Jesus is taking that and saying, this is part of our narrative. This is part of our history. We don't disregard it, but at the same time, we don't necessarily live by it either. And so that's the whole point, I think, of the Spirit, of the Spirit of God coming to us and kind of being that conscience and being that guiding light. Whitehead called it kind of the lure, right? The lure of the divine that kind of lures us toward greater novelty, creativity. And I really like that analogy. And I think that that's kind of how I see the Spirit working.

And to further extrapolate that, you even go into some of this book that the problematic nature of Paul and writing that you get these like three different versions of Paul, and like it's different writing styles and different focuses on certain subjects and matters that are vastly different from each other. And it depends on what you focus more on as the preachers focus more on in churches that really shows kind of what they're trying to achieve or whatnot or try to give a cross to their congregation.

To kind of back up on that point and give a little bit more background. So we see these kind of distinctions of Paul where you have, and Marcus Borg and John Dominic Crossan discussed this in their book, The Last Paul, or The First Paul, I forget which one. The book about Paul. They kind of break this out into the radical Paul, who is the Paul that we normally think of as the Paul of Romans, the Paul of Philemon, the one that is liberative in how he discusses things.

And then we got to get into the Paul of Corinthians, or not sorry, of Corinthians is radical Paul. He's regular, like actual genuine Paul, supposedly. And then Colossians and Ephesians and Second Thessalonians Paul starts to get a little bit more conservative in the sense of he starts to back it up a little bit towards more of the general cultural norm of the Roman Empire. And then you see kind of a bigger shift in Paul in the Pastoral Epistles, which is for Second Timothy and Titus, where Paul is basically saying the exact opposite as radical Paul.

And so you got to kind of ask those questions thematically. Okay, who is this guy? Like, is he actually making these changes in his own thinking? That's kind of problematic. Or is it just a secondary author that is trying to apply the teachings of the original Paul in their cultural moment and they have their own biases and way of thinking about things. I think that it's yeah. Oh, sorry. I was going to say, and speaking of if he even wrote it at all, you even bring up in Titus specifically that Titus was written after Paul died.

Yeah, so it wasn't what yes Titus probably, but also it was first Timothy. So there's this thing in Timothy. So the general dating, the reason that I can kind of, this is at least something that I heard that I feel like could be, it makes a lot of sense to me. Where in First Timothy, you have this quote of, I want to say I have it in the book, but I don't remember it off the top of my head. I think it's like Luke 10 something, 10-7, where he talks about the laborer deserves their wage.

And it's a direct quote from Luke. And he refers to this as scripture, right? And so the author, if the author of First Timothy is referring to Luke as scripture, and we know from a lot of different like historical sources that Luke was probably one of the later gospels. One of the earlier gospels, which is Mark, was most likely written after the temple was destroyed in 70 CE. But Paul died in 65 CE. So the gospels were most likely written almost entirely after Paul died and everything was going by word of mouth at the time, or some other scripts and letters that we just haven't read yet or found.

And so if First Timothy was written or was referencing Luke as scripture, that means it must have been written after, or he must have been able to see that. So most likely, First Timothy was written after Paul had died, and therefore Second Timothy as well, at least. And by virtue of analysis of the kind of content that's in both First and Second Timothy, and the linguistic analysis of what kind of words were used at that period of time, it's very likely that First, Second Timothy, and Titus were all written probably decades after Paul died.

This is some of the best research that I've seen. There's these people that disagree, and I think the majority of the folks that disagree at this point that the pastoral epistles were not written by Paul. There's still a lot of debate on Colossians and Ephesians and I think Second Thessalonians. But the pastoral epistles, the majority of scholars are pretty certain that it wasn't Paul that wrote those, or at least it wasn't the same author that wrote Galatians and First Corinthians and Philemon and things along these lines, and Romans.

Gotcha. Sorry, I kept looking down. I was trying to look up where you'd written that so I could back you up. Yeah, we'll go ahead and move on to the next little thing here. So, writing a book, so I was just going to wrap this all up with just the book in general and just writing. So, writing a book requires a different set of tools and is a much different experience from writing in other formats. The question is, as Deweaponize is your first book publication, what were the challenges and learning experiences that you pulled from it?

Oh man, so many, so many. I think that a couple of learning experiences that I would say is get feedback early and often from folks that you trust. Like find a group of people that you trust, tell them that you're writing this book, float ideas past them, and give them smaller chunks to read. It's a lot more challenging to get people to read an entire manuscript than it is to get them to read like chunks of a chapter. And it's a lot easier to iterate if you can get one chunk of a chapter at a time and then edit that and things along these lines. So I think it probably took a little bit longer to edit it once the entire manuscript was written and I started floating it around and things like this.

But yeah, I think that would probably be one of the bigger things. And also find some time that works for you. Like for me, I work the best probably early in the morning. So I was waking up before my kids woke up, spending like an hour or two, like 4am to get some writing in before the kids woke up and before my wife and I were getting them shuttled and ready to go. I think it's just a matter of finding your own time and trying to stay consistent. It's hard to stay consistent realistically and life happens. So have grace on yourself.

But find that time that works for you and try to stay as consistent as you can with that and just get feedback early and often. Because I think a lot of that too, feedback is going to help you to be motivated too. If you are saying something that really resonates with somebody and they give you that feedback that, oh my gosh, this really resonated with me, that'll be really motivating for you. Like hey, I'm actually onto something here. Maybe it's not even a person that you know in real life.

Maybe it's just you take one of the paragraphs that you're working on or a quote from your book that you're thinking about or something that summarizes a section and you post it on one of your socials that you have some amount of following on and see what people think. I think a lot of the feedback that I got that was positive was in Twitter threads before those ideas were expounded upon within the book.

So I was able to see kind of real time, hey, this actually resonates with people. This way of thinking, way of imagining how the Bible works, it works. It resonates with people. I was getting some positive feedback from scholars so I knew I wasn't going completely off the rails. And also making good relationships. You mentioned theology beer camp. That's a fantastic way to make relationships, especially in this space of writing with Christian authors and theologians and things like this.

Finding networking spots that you can go to and just learn from folks. Yeah, just whatever kind of book you're writing, find a group of people that are writing or thinking about similar things and make some genuine relationships and get their thoughts and feedback on stuff. Usually they're very amicable to help you out. Well, the thing that really resonated with me was finding the time to be able to do it. Doing a podcast is a little different than writing a book. It's a whole different undertaking. I kind of struggle still with finding that time to be able to do it.

And do it so that my mind is fresh too and that I can actually just sit down instead of just spacing out and sit in front of the monitor and just, what am I doing here? I can totally resonate, especially with kids. It's a whole different ballgame. So yeah, I totally get that. The second half of that, what is some advice that you could give someone who may want to get into writing? I guess, never mind. You just nailed that with a bark. Let's see. The very last one here. I thought this book was clear and accessible. It was an accessible success for you. Do you have any future projects lined up?

Book-wise, no. But yeah, I think my more near-term project is to build out some slide decks for the book to kind of go along with the book as a resource. And so I think not only just for my church, but for other folks that would have this. I think that there's a lot of churches and particularly mainline churches that are open to these ideas and these concepts, but they haven't just given it enough thought.

They see a lot of the problems of bad theology making its way into the public sphere through Christian nationalism and things like this. And they see the impacts of it, but they're not really sure where it came from, why people believe that way. I've talked to a lot of folks in my church and talking about some of the things that the churches that I used to go to believe. And they were like, why would you guys believe that stuff? But realistically, a lot of it is indoctrination. You get into these things from the time that you're very little, and this is all you ever hear. And if you never question it, then you're probably not going to find an alternative unless there's some catalyst, some sticking point.

And so I think making a lot of these mainline churches more aware of the issues that are going on in our time and the issues that future generations are going to have to deal with is I think going to be really helpful for the church as a whole and as an institution if they want to continue living in a Christ-like way and not bowing to the empire of our time, which I think that a large portion of American evangelicals has. It's bowing the knee to consumerism and to capitalism and to right-wing authoritarianism. And seeing that play out in real time is concerning, obviously. And it's one of these things that if I can in any way be a part of helping to reshape and allow the church to kind of repent of that.

I talk about this in the book a little bit, is the word metanoia literally means to change your mind, to turn your mind around. And if we can get the church to repent and to think differently about these concepts and these theologies that have been so harmful to so many people and to refocus their attention on Christ, I think that it can make a massive difference in our religious and political landscape. You mentioned the Marion of capitalism and consumerism. Just makes me think of a Christian Copademias book, Jesus and John Wayne.

That's right. It's a fantastic one. Which everyone needs to read that one, I feel like. Yeah, absolutely. By capitalism, I want to be very clear on that too. Obviously, there's problems with certain socialist ideas, certain communist ideas. But problematic specifically in the Christian church has been capitalism within America because of this consumeristic idea that the church needs to reach all of these lost souls and do so by any means. And in doing so, they tend to be this kind of positive feedback loop. I'm not sure if folks are familiar with this term positive feedback loop. But if you've ever done any worship music at a church or sung in any capacity where you have a microphone and you have a speaker,

you put that microphone next to that speaker, you see this really high-pitched squeaky noise. It's called a positive feedback loop. There's nothing to cancel it out. And so it's really important for the Christian church to have this negative feedback loop. And the ancient Israelites had this with the prophets, right? It's a negative feedback loop that was constantly trying to course correct. But when the church is trying to always bring in more people in this unscalable type of a way, they tend to do resource tactics such as clickbait and saying the most obscene things and trying to push the marginalized folks away so that they can attract the most people that they can.

I think a lot of folks in the atheist camp will make the claim that, oh, this is all about money. And I'm like, yeah, that might be part of it. It might be that the church is really just greedy and wants all this money. But I think it goes a lot deeper than that. I think it's theological too. They're so convinced that they need to save all of these souls for Christ. They will do so in whatever Machiavellian way that they can. And I think that has roots in the capitalistic, consumeristic way in which America functions. And that's not a good thing. And I think it's important for us as Christians to recognize that and to call it out and to help the church course correct.

Ryan, so people listening might want to know where to find you. So are you on social media? Do you have a website or anything like that? Yeah, that's right. So I'm on Tov Theology, T-O-V Theology on Instagram and Blue Sky and threads currently. And I do have a blog, but it's not as active as it probably should be. Awesome. No, I'm so glad. Yeah. And I'll make sure to try to find out where your blog is at too. Great. It's tovtheology.com or blog.tovtheology.com.

Oh, very cool. Well, Ryan, I don't want to hold you up too much longer. I think we're right at that tail end of the time that we were talking about. So, but thank you so much for coming out and talking about this. Of course. I really appreciated the read. Like I said, it's it'll give me it's given me a lot of like verbiage and and different things to even look deeper into. So I thank you for that. And I do recommend anybody. I mean, we're recording this before Christmas. I'll see if I can get out for Christmas. But if not, everyone gets Amazon cards or some gift cards that you can spend on, you know, books and go find this book.

Seriously, I feel like it'll it'll broaden your scope as far as thinking about the Bible and and everything that goes along with that and religion and everything. So thank you again. Thank you. Yes. That's it for today's episode of Grub and Grace. I hope you enjoyed our discussion. Music is by Fleece Mom with the song, Everything You Need. Graphics and visuals by Root and Branch Creative. Remember to visit our website at grubandgrace.com. That's grub, A-N-D, grace.com, as well as our socials on Facebook, Instagram, and X.

If you like the content that we create and would like to support us, make sure to subscribe or follow wherever you can and leave us a review on Apple Podcasts. And as always, until next time, stay curious, keep an open mind, and celebrate the traditions that bring us all together.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ashtiname of Muhammad w/ Mark Wayne of the Colonial Outcasts podcast

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 56 minAudio

    Two white Christians, who love Muslims, breakdown myths and misconceptions that many Americans (and more specifically Christians) have about Islam and Muslims. Mark Wayne of the Colonial Outcasts podcast joins in the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Business of Immigration and ICE | Enchantments of Mammon Ep. 8

    Oct 5, 20261 hrAudio

    Capitalism has a long and ugly history of scapegoating and exploiting immigrants. From British capitalists exploiting Irish people to the United States’ deeply systemic and oppressive tactics, immigrants have, for a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Exploiting Women in the Patriarchal Capitalist Machine | Enchantments of Mammon Ep. 7

    Sep 14, 202635 minAudio

    This is part 7 of the Enchantments of Mammon series. Capitalism needs a permanent source of unpaid labor. Childbearing, child raising, cooking, cleaning, caregiving, emotional support. The invisible work that keeps...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Racism of For-Profit Capitalist Exploitation | Enchantments of Mammon Ep. 6

    Sep 7, 202625 minAudio

    Marx’s analysis does not specifically take into account the history of the exploitation of women and non-white people. We will be digging into some of the ways that racism, sexism, and xenophobia play into the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Prosperity Gospel of Capitalism | Enchantments of Mammon Ep. 5

    Aug 31, 202618 minAudio

    Spiritual maturity and financial security are often married within the church business model. How do we identify patterns of abuse and work toward a more sustainable future? Let's get into it in today's episode of part...

    Credit the people on this episode