This episode we're getting into what's known generally as the troubled teen industry. There are many facilities and programs within this term, but today we will be looking into the treatment program known as Teen Challenge. Teen Challenge is often described as a place where faith and recovery meet - a program helping struggling teens find a new path. But depending on who you talk to, the story can sound very different. I am joined today by Lynn Green, a former student of these facilities before she began researching them, which is now an essential aspect of her work. She has a unique experience and story that we explore and are able to dive deeper into the philosophy of this particular treatment facility. Tik Tok: @lynn_green1 Instagram: @lynn.m.green Disclaimer: Some of what we discuss may be triggering for some, so be sure to be aware of that. There are things we will say that may not equate to the same experience for every person. Even the way every facility and affiliate of Teen Challenge is run can vary a bit. We understand that our critique of Teen Challenge does not speak for all treatment programs within the troubled teen industry, and there are programs that are doing some very helpful work. All views expressed are their own. Attributions: ON8FDNIHEAKJ8GXS
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
they can do a lot of damage. And a lot of people in that place are in that kind of power dynamic where they may have some good life experience to offer and maybe even some good advice. But when they're in a place being in a position to give treatment, it's an entirely different qualification that I would go as far to argue that none of them are really qualified to be doing. Welcome
back to Grub and Grace. I'm your host, Mark Flower. I'm joined today by Lynn Green. We are going to be talking about the troubled teen industry, and she is a former student of these type of facilities. And that's where she began researching them as well, which is an essential aspect of her work. Lynn, thank you so much for jumping on with us. Thanks. I'm just really excited to talk about it. Yeah, and I should actually give a disclaimer up front about what some of what we will be discussing might be triggering for some. So be sure to be aware of that. And although
we have plenty of critique and concern about this industry, there are things that we will say that may not equate to the same experience for every person. So even the way that every facility and affiliate of Teen Challenge, and that's who we'll be talking about specifically today. is run can vary quite a bit. So we want to address things that like a 10 ,000 foot bird's eye view of everything and then dive deeper into certain aspects of this troubled teen industry. And then we want to do it through the lens of
Teen Challenge because that's where the experiences are held within this conversation and just all the nuances that come with that. So Teen Challenge is often described as a place where faith and recovery meet. program helping struggling teens find a new path. But depending on who you talk to, the story can sound very different. So before we get into the experiences and controversies, let's start with the basics. What exactly is Teen Challenge and where does it fit into the bigger picture and bigger world sometimes called the troubled teen industry? Teen Challenge, I
think, can best be described as an intersection between two pretty well -known aspects of the troubled teen industry, which is a therapeutic boarding school and then a Christian. rehabilitation program. It's kind of a mix of both of those things. It originally started in New York in around the 1960s or late 50s for young men around the age of like 17, 18. Eventually, it expanded to over 100 adult facilities across the United States. And along the way, about 30 adolescent
facilities also popped up. The way that it functions is very unique to the troubled teen industry. It's a national corporation and a national office that functions as basically a franchise. So people can fulfill certain criteria in their own independent licensing structure and be able to classify themselves as a teen challenge, even if people from the national office have never technically been there to see it for themselves. There are, like I said,
about 30 facilities. Some only have girls, some only have boys, and some of them are co -ed. But the troubled teen industry as a whole is a multi -billion dollar industry that thrives on... Behavioral change, behavior modification programs, boarding school programs, wilderness therapy programs is a really big conversation that's been happening in the last couple of years. And Teen Challenge has some murmurs along the way, but it's not one of the bigger topics in
this conversation, which really does surprise me even now because it arguably is one of the largest contributors to this issue. Yeah. and like teen challenge is such an interesting thing i mean i've looked into a little bit more over the over the years i have some connection to it but just yeah the trouble teen industry at large it's it's kind of a headache it's there there's way too much that you could talk to on the on the subject and not enough that's really
getting out there that's you know for like public discourse that you're hearing that most people are hearing about It's only like the select few people that look into things like me, you know, people that have experienced it like you and that are continuing to look into it. And it's just like a lot of it just goes goes over my head. And it's just like there's just too much. So I'm hoping that we can at least dig into some of it today. Yeah, me too. It is a really big topic. And honestly, it seems like. So many people
have some kind of experience in the troubled teen industry, like either their parents had considered it at one point or they had a friend that got sent to one or maybe a sibling. It really does kind of touch everybody and everywhere. It's kind of like the drug epidemic itself, I think, and just like the mental illness epidemic. It doesn't really have like a face to it, if that makes sense. Like it really can be anyone at any time. especially as we'll kind of get into later with programs like teen challenge
around yeah so if if you haven't grown up in like the evangelical space i should just say like um you may not have heard about teen challenge specifically for me i grew up where i would be in in churches where they would have like guest speakers come from teen challenge so i heard about them very early on in my life and they would come and they would sing or they would give testimonies in church And especially since my listener base is mostly kind of in this like deconstructing Christian asking big questions
space. I assume that you, you, my listeners might actually have heard of Teen Challenge, but if you haven't, this is kind of the space that they, that they take in. I kind of want to dig a little bit deeper as far as like, like leadership around this. So people that you might've seen come to these churches and speak and give, you know, testimonies or just messages talking kind of, hyping up Teen Challenge as this treatment facility program that would be helpful for your children. So Lynn, have you seen it? Like, are there any
leadership or like figureheads that stand out to you within Teen Challenge? There's definitely some. The original founder, I don't think he is alive anymore, if I'm correct. David Wilkerson, I think, passed. I don't think he is. I can't remember if it was like 20 or 10 years ago or something, but I'm pretty certain he's not alive anymore. They definitely they had copies of like his book. I think he wrote multiple books. The one that I remember reading in like our library,
there was the cross and the switchblade, which is like a dramatized version of his life story, basically, and like how he started Teen Challenge. That was the main one. But mainly our figureheads were kind of our administration and our directors at our facility. Those are like. the people if that makes sense i think every facility is kind of like that in its own way like your own executive director and like administrative staff really like run the show and the national or even because
this is kind of the other complicated thing that they do is that they have like a national office that's like a non -profit and then they have like region offices so like Oklahoma is one for example I think there's like a couple of states and like Ohio and Indiana that's like a Midwest one so like and then all of those offices have their own executive directors so if something Frankly, if something bad happens, then those executive directors will come in. But, you know, if everything is kind of going smoothly, you
never really see them. And even if they are stepping in, you still never kind of really see them, at least as a kid, because the and we'll get into this a lot more later. But the adolescent and the adult programs are worlds different. So like where there may be more transparency and even like idolization of certain figures in the adult programs. At that level, like the state or interstate level in the adolescent programs, it is pretty like concentrated. It's pretty like cut off from the wider system and like world.
So we would have like. We would have like conferences with the adult facilities, like the men's facility and the women's facility where we would all do like worship conferences together like once a year or something. But other than like the adults actually would come and do testimonies, too, and they would like share their stories. But other than that, we were kept like pretty separate in that way. I don't know if any of that makes sense or not. Yeah, I mean, it makes as much sense as possible. I mean, there's a lot of different
facets. It's kind of like a spider's web in a way. Yeah. You did mention David Wilkerson. I looked it up. He died in 2011. So it's been a little bit since he's passed away. But how big of a presence does he have? Because you mentioned the crossing the switchblade. I've heard about that book. I know the name has been thrown around in my family before. How big is he a presence within the treatment, like the programs that they have? I mean, I would basically say that
like, I think his word and his like original message is kind of on par with the Bible, if that makes sense, in like a lot of ways. Like the idea of like restoration and like the first step in the process to like healing your addiction or whatever is accepting Jesus as your savior or whatever that looks like. Like it's about at the same level. So like the. program structure
the courses that we would do like the mentoring kind of system i assume that he kind of had a hand in designing all of that and all of that was held to pretty high standard like it doesn't change um and it's used for you know discipline and stuff like we'll get into probably but he like yeah his book was a pretty big present we have multiple copies of it in the library i read it multiple times just because also it was like one of the only interesting books because it
had like fight scenes or whatever in it and we would watch i think there was a movie at one point too that i think i remember watching so like we learned the story like inside and out like all of it but i think especially the further we get away from his passing he just kind of becomes like oh what's the What's the one guys for the Mormons? Joseph Smith. Joseph Smith. Yeah. He kind of becomes like that in a way, like this mythologized figure, if that makes
sense. Yeah, I can see that. So I'm glad you mentioned like the discipline punishment sort of thing, because at this point, we're going to progressively keep getting heavier and heavier into this. So I wanted to ask about Rachel Aviv's article in The New York Times. She likened these programs, the troubled teen industry, to a shadow penal system for struggling kids. Does that description resonate with Teen Challenge at all? Yeah, it really does. Because I think Teen Challenge was
a center focus of that article. In fact, I know a few people that were quoted in that article and did interviews with her discussing it. And I remember in that article was a conversation about a girl that was... coerced in some way around her abortion decision or pregnancy decision. I can't remember what the exact details are, so I won't say it because I don't want to say the wrong thing because I don't remember it. But in certain ways, it was about the larger troubled teen industry, but it also did have a really heavy focus on Teen Challenge. And I
do think that that is a really key distinction because it's kind of like a chameleon in a way. It's whatever... it wants to be like for some parents it's a place for their kids just kind of get away and reset like maybe rethink their life choices just get time away from bad influences whatever for other kids it's a threat it's like a discipline it's like you do this bad thing
one more time you're gonna go here You know, for other kids, it's my child's addicted to what God knows what substances and I don't know. Nothing works to get them off. Like that's how it's a chameleon, like shape shifts into whatever that kind of specific family needs in that way. And so but the system itself stays the same and the system itself is built on a discipline and punishment and rewards and hierarchy. And that internal aspect never really changes. Yeah, and I'll give
some background. You mentioned the woman that was, I figured her age was when she was in the program. But so during the article, it said that sometimes participants would be told that they would have to start the program over again, like in the case of Emma Burris is her name, where after being found out that she was pregnant, Teen Challenge denied, sorry, got a cold and all that. Teen Challenge denied her abortion, forced her to give birth during treatment, and she gave the baby up for adoption. A few days
later, the directors told Emma that she needed to start the program over again. And then one of the staff members, Katie Prince, who was there then, said that the reasoning was that she hadn't been able to do the program appropriately when she was pregnant. So now she needed to redo the entire thing, which is just... bonkers ridiculous um i but it completely fits into my experience and what i know because i can think of every single like um we didn't have access to our health
care a car or a phone even so it makes perfect sense to me why they could just kind of make that medical decision on her behalf and we she had no no choice but to just sit with it and I what my interpretation is that they meant by her not being able to do the program right was that they probably couldn't discipline her in the same way that they normally would and take away the same privileges that they normally would because she was pregnant. And so like her having
to start over that process is also having to like go through the system the same way everybody else is like. I don't know if that makes sense, but like. It fits in through the filter of like what I was told at Teen Challenge and what I experienced there. And having to start levels or the entire program over was a very valid threat. They really could do that at any time. And we knew that they could. And like I had seen. girls fully graduate and leave the program and then come back like a year later and have to start
the program like halfway and and do it all over again or completely start over and do it over again you know i it's funny that you mentioned the having to graduate and then come back there was someone else that that was on another platform that talked about their experience and they they said that they saw kids that were in their later years of high school, having to go through the program. And because they were in the program, they would have missed their graduation. So they got an education program while they were in treatment.
But after getting out of the treatment, they found that their education they got within the treatment wasn't recognized by the state's idea of what an education should entail. So they essentially had to get their GED after they graduated within the treatment program, which is crazy i mean you go you go through all these years of schooling and get through high school and whatnot and then you spend like a year and a half in treatment in their long programs and then and then get out to realize that your entire schooling system is all for nothing you have to go back and get
an additional degree just to have that high school um degree yeah it's it's crazy yeah that that happened to a few people that i know like either in some way they found out that Like they weren't qualified for graduation. Or I knew one girl who they gave her like they gave her a GED test. She passed and they never validated the results. So she never had a valid GED, even though she
knew that or she thought that she passed and everything. Yeah, even with me, because I missed I went to Teen Challenge about halfway through my freshman year of high school. So I was 14. And I went into their online school system that they had there and I was there for 15 months. But hey, I'm just horrible online school. I can't do it now, even in college. But I also only finished about a freshman year worth of coursework because I had to start over my freshman year entirely.
And I came back as a sophomore and I ended up graduating a year late from high school, like just as a whole. So like in itself, like kind of the troubled teen industry as a whole is very disruptive to a child's education process and to their progression as like a normal education. And like because I can't even imagine like getting and having to stop like algebra or something like really foundational and then going into something entirely different and having to come back. Because for mine, I remember I took like.
civics or something like that and like i didn't even need that it wasn't even like a necessary thing for me to take so there was a lot of experiences like that and some actually facilities they go to public high school too in kansas city it's closed now but like an outpatient program sort of thing But that's the thing is it's still inpatient because they live there. So they live there, but they go to a public high school. And so it was really, really weird and like disruptive because I knew one person that was in that facility
and they described it as just like like it basically wasn't like being in a teen challenge at all because they were in that one. And then they came to ours and ours was like worlds different because we were in the middle of nowhere with computers for our school and nothing else but Teen Challenge all the time. So it was. The complete opposite of that. That's what I mean when I say like every teen challenge can be very, very different, but a lot of them have like the same kind of foundation. And I can see like two sides of this. I can see a side where it's like, you know, if
someone really needs treatment, if someone is really deep into something, you know, substance use disorder or something that where they just really need help, like they're not able to really get out of it in any other easy way. I can understand them pulling them out of an education system in order to treat that because then they'd have the rest of their life where they can flourish and get by without having something to rely on and have a crutch like that. On the other hand, we're going to dig into some stuff that's going to make what we just brought up a little bonkers
and crazy for some of the people that go through the program that aren't necessarily having a substance use disorder or anything like that. So that's actually kind of bringing me to the next one. So what kind of behaviors or struggles typically lead teens into teen challenge? And I'm aware that it's not always substance use disorder. So maybe you can kind of touch on that. Yeah, kind of going back to what I said earlier about like calling it a chameleon. It definitely can be used for people that are going through that. But, you know, one of the main factors
that we know in the very little that we know about addiction and. Substance use disorder is that often it's motivated by external factors and external trauma that happens to the individual. And so a lot of the adolescents that I knew at that time and that I've talked to since I would some of them I would qualify more so as just kind of teens going through active trauma and kind of using substances as a coping mechanism or as an outlet or in like exhibiting addictive.
patterns and addictive tendencies but don't necessarily have that grip on them if that makes sense like the big issue in there that is affecting them is the trauma is the outward things for others it definitely extended farther into like heavy addictive substance use like the big ones like heroin meth those things and for those individuals like And I'll get into that in a second. But like for others, it was a behavior modification.
Like they had just been sneaking out a lot. They were like having inappropriate, unhealthy relationships, maybe like gang affiliation, like whatever it might be, risky behaviors. And I think that's kind of what the foundation of Teen Challenge kind of was, which in itself is a little bit iffy in my opinion. But then I think somewhere along the way, it kind of continued extending in ways that it was never really meant to. Because in my facility, there were also individuals that
were kind of both diagnosed and undiagnosed highly autistic and had meltdowns and reactions to an unaccepting environment to their condition. In fact, an oppressive environment to their condition, I would go as far to say. Or there were individuals that kind of, I would argue, just simply weren't fitting into the social and cultural expectations of their family, which often were really heavily evangelical and Christian motivated, like they were experiencing same -sex attraction. At one
point, I knew a girl that was in that facility because she read romance novels. And that was it. Like that was the only reason that she was there and next to girls who did like very heavy substances. And so in that way, it's it's this weird expansion where I don't think it is. It's so difficult. I don't even know what to classify it right now, because that's that's honestly like what my research is, is like really trying to heavily define and like narrow down what this is and like what what we can functionally label
it as. But I wouldn't. necessarily call it treatment and I wouldn't really call it rehab either, because even those that were going through like really heavy substance abuse withdrawal weren't given the proper medical care and medical intervention to go through that process. And in fact, were put in kind of unsafe positions to do so. There is like this expectation where by the time you get to a teen challenge, you're supposed to be kind of detoxed at that point. And so when that's not the case or if, God forbid, a student lies
and their parent doesn't even know that they're detoxing, they're in a very medically unsafe situation. And there is, I think, the higher philosophy of teen challenge as a whole and like the adult programs especially is that it's meant for. Addiction in a way that it's meant for people in which nothing else is working, like medical rehab isn't working. You've been to jail and it's not, you know, making you change like, OK, substitute that for Jesus, substitute the drug
use for Jesus, substitute the. reckless criminal behavior for communal work and a work life balance and like gaining an education and work skills. That's what the adult program philosophy is meant to be, is like building that structure for you and substituting that core thing that's gripping your life with a faith relationship, which in itself, I won't label that as bad. I think that's a very kind of different thing in itself. My problem is that when you try and translate that.
very specific and narrow idea of treatment onto a very general population of children who are going through varying degrees of either active trauma to mental illness to honestly just normal troubles and tribulations and adolescent you know years so i wouldn't i wouldn't label it treatment i i would label it as like a almost maybe for some, but for others, it's like a suspension in time. It's just like a place to put them until
they figure out their, I don't know if I can curse on here, but like to figure out the shit basically. Okay. Cause I do kind of curse a lot, especially when I get really get going, but like, it's just kind of a place to put them to figure out their shit. It feels like, like I said, every facility is different, but at least my facility, it seems like they're just accepting like. of varying degrees of issues. Like I got my hands on their intake paperwork a little while back and on a list of like risky behaviors that you could put, there was like bedwetting as a, as
a thing as like a red flag behavior that somehow equates to like needing a teen challenge placement. If anything, it signals something is very different than involves social services. Like it's. It's very hard to define. And that's what makes Teen Challenge, in a way, function so well. It truly can be kind of anything it wants to be. It's so interesting that bedwetting can be that. It's almost like, can you even classify this as a rehab facility then, like you were describing?
You don't even know how to really label what this is. It's labeled as a rehab facility. That's how they advertise it. But when you look at all the factors that go into it, is it really a rehab facility? you know it goes into things like like i know a term that's that's thrown around quite often in those circles like evangelical spaces is gender dysphoria which is extremely damaging to to say that someone is is you know going through this transformation of understanding their body
and who they are and to classify it as like this disease that this um this illness that that's you know wracking their brain and um I've talked to numerous people where that is extremely damaging to the psyche and to the ego and everything like that. And so it's, you know, it more reflects on the parents and the culture that are allowing their children to be put into places like this, you know, this discomfort that they have. instead of actually addressing it in other healthier
ways it's like they just push it off to this facility that says like we can we can take care of this we can fix your child in a way um i don't know it's just it's just very damaging yeah i mean that's even like i guess the best case scenario in a way because at the worst case it's you know like for my family specifically i was I was in an active like risk situation. Like if I was not placed somewhere, I was putting myself in very dangerous situations. And so my parents
were just like, we just don't know what to do. And that in itself, I think is also very predatory because if it isn't offering like a proposed solution in like a vain way, in the cultural way, it's offering a solution to parents who are in very desperate and honestly, very. culturally shameful situations nobody wants to admit that their child is going through these things or doing these making these decisions and putting themselves in these situations and so parents
have a very hard time feeling able to reach out when they need help and they find out about this one specific resource that might be a solution and they don't have options to look elsewhere and look at other things It makes sense why Teen Challenge has been able to somewhat flourish in that way, especially as we've seen just drug use change so much in this country, like over the last 20, 30 years. Yeah, definitely. So that's the history and the outside view, how the program presents itself and how it is developed. But
of course, brochures and mission statements are one thing. Actually living there is another thing. So let's talk about what day -to -day life inside Teen Challenge has looked like for the people who went through it. So what does a typical day inside Teen Challenge look like? Like the rules, the routines, the discipline, the living conditions? So yeah, I can speak very well for my Teen Challenge. It was... We had boys and girls at the facility, but we lived separately. We didn't see or interact
with each other ever. There was very, very heavy gender separation. And outside of that, every single minute of our day was scheduled and structured by other people. So we would get up at like 6 or 6 .30. immediately have to get dressed and do chores and then go to breakfast and then school and then lunch and then school. And then I think free time and or discipline time in which you're writing sentences and then dinner. And then we
had to do Bible study basically and nightly devotionals. And then we would. go to bed. And that was every single night. And then on Fridays and Saturdays, if you didn't have any active disciplines, you could watch a movie, have snacks and do stuff like that. But if you did have a discipline, you would have to go in another room and write your sentences while everybody else watched the movie in the other room. Every single, it is very hard to encapsulate like just how highly controlled our lives were. So like our clothes,
for example, every single thing we wore was in uniform. Either it was like black or gray for chilling clothes or polo and jeans for school. Our disciplines were, like I said, writing sentences. For some girls, it would involve being on something called D -level, in which they have to wear different clothes than everybody else. They have a different diet than everybody else. They aren't allowed to sit on furniture. They aren't allowed any free time whatsoever. So even if they don't have
sentences to write, they just have to sit in a room and read their Bible, basically, because they're not allowed to have free time. And back in my day, some of them would wear orange jumpsuits if they were runaways. But now I believe that they've changed it. So now it's like a highlighter yellow shirt in khakis. But every single... They're differentiating people based on what they did. Yes, and that's always a factor. So every single person, either... So you either are on D level.
And so if you ran away, you wear the yellow shirt. If you just did something bad, like really bad, then you get a blue shirt. But that constantly visibly classifies you. And like I said, you're not allowed to sit on the furniture. So sometimes I'll see photos from Teen Challenge and I'll look and I'll see a girl sitting on the floor wearing blue. And I know that that girl's on D level for something. And for others, we all had wristbands that were color coded on which level we were, because that's the other really
big part about this program is there's five levels. And when you enter, you're an entry for a couple of weeks, and then you have to apply and get accepted for levels one through five. And with each level, you get new disciplines, or sorry, not disciplines, you get new privileges. So you would have the wristbands that would visibly classify what level you were at. And then different levels were allowed, like different makeup and stuff like that. So like on my eyeliner right now, you wouldn't be able to get to like level five. So that would immediately like classify
me as like higher in the hierarchy. And then I'm trying to think of just like any other general stuff that kind of applies to everything. Like I said, just every single aspect of our day was highly, highly controlled, even down to like the words we were allowed to speak and when we spoke them. Like we would be on this term called word fast in which you're just not allowed to talk like you're on word fast when you're doing schoolwork in the classroom or you're on word fast in your room, especially if no staff are
present, then you are not allowed to talk. Our showers are timed. We only got 12 minute showers unless you were a room leader in which you got a 15 minute shower. Like every single, every single moment of your day is no longer in your own hands and in your control. You know, it's really funny that you mentioned this negative vocabulary where they, they remove certain words that you can say, you know, can or cannot say, is there any vocabulary that they, they encouraged or pushed like specific things that you, that
they wanted you to say? um other than just like kind of general faith terminology like I don't know, like wanting to pray for people in that way, I would say there was a really big list of words that we couldn't say and stuff we couldn't talk about. But really, any conversation about like faith or anything was very highly encouraged or like, oh, my God, like if you were staying up having a really good conversation with this one girl past bedtime and a staff member came
around and was like, hey, you guys need to go to bed. And you looked at that staff member was like. Actually, we're praying and we're having a really good prayer session right now. That staff, if they're feeling nice, may just be like, all right, fine. You have like 10 more minutes and then you have to go to bed. So like in that way, it was very highly rewarded. But like any kind of talking about like drugs or outside, not outside more so like previous life was not allowed. But talking about like boys was especially not allowed. Stuff like that. Gaming the system
by the rules they set up. Basically, yeah. So I know you do a lot of research and interviews of people that have been through the programs and whatnot. What surprised you most about some of the other survivor accounts? I think, honestly, just how much people don't remember. You know, upon like a lot of self -reflection on like talking and getting a lot of really close with other people who went through this at that time, I kind of realized that I was a watcher in a lot
of ways. I was just kind of always sitting and watching other people and kind of what was going on and just taking everything in. It was definitely a trauma response at the time. And so I have a very good and like pretty distinct account still, even to this day of like what the daily structure was like, very specific situation. And I get memory gaps for sure, but not like extensive ones. And a lot of people I interviewed now are in such kind of a highly traumatized state that like they can remember somewhat specific
situations, but even kind of asking them like basic questions about like, oh, what was the discipline you got for saying that or something? Or even just like, are you? I don't know, like asking them to kind of pinpoint specific details like I just did to you just now, I think is very difficult for some people. Just because I think a lot of us kind of had to go into an autopilot state to like kind of get through it. And so
I think the brain shuts off in a lot of ways when it does that. And so for some people, it's very hard or even just like upsetting to try and remember that stuff. which is really something that you really only see from very highly traumatized people. I think in the beginning of my research process, I was very much still kind of in a denial space about how highly traumatizing it was. And I, again, coping mechanisms. But once I kind
of really got into the research and started talking to people and realized like how hard it was to ask people to recount stuff from this time, it made me realize like just how upsetting it was for a lot of people. Yeah, for sure. It's kind of funny that you mentioned like, you know, saying, oh, we're having a really good prayer session or being encouraged to have like faith -based vocabulary. Americans United, they had an article going off of the New York Times article by Rachel
Aviv. And they essentially said that Teen Challenge has been described as essentially an extended Bible study rooted in Pentecostal theology. How does religion actually show up in daily treatment then? It is like the only treatment. I think that's why I had such a hard time classifying it as treatment earlier, because really any and all treatment goals are lost in this process and they're replaced with faith based goals. Instead of I'm entering treatment because I'm
having outbursts, because I have like maybe a personality disorder, it becomes. We want to see you be a leader in Christ and really step into your life in Christ, basically. All of life is wrapped around that singular mission and goal. It is everything. We end every single day with Bible study. We're in church multiple times a week, in worship multiple times a week. All advice
and mentorship that we're given is being given through this lens of Pentecostal theology. All the books and media we're allowed to consume has to go through that same filter. So it becomes everything in that way. So the program emphasizes Jesus first, others second, yourself last, which is the joy model, J -O -Y. And there's a number of problems with this. You know, it's essentially
a false equivalency between a term that is defined as a deep and immense happiness with a phrase that is arguably views taking care of your own needs as sinful. There is an annotation of shame and a message of the sinful as selfishness. Something to that question. It is likened to questioning the sacredness of motherhood or the divinity of Jesus Christ. What impact can that hierarchy have on teens already struggling with identity or self -worth? I think it makes you a very people
pleasing kind of person. I think it's honestly so fascinating to think about what this exact same model can have on a fully developed or at least moderately developed mind versus a developing mind. Like on a developed mind, the idea of. put something else first and yourself second, I guess isn't entirely bad, I guess, especially if you've been leading your life making very self -serving decisions or hurting people that
you love, especially or not showing up for other people in that way. But when you're a child, you're still trying to form that foundation of identity in the first place before you can dictate whether or not you're using or leading by that identity in a way that feels right, if that makes sense. And so when you're asking a teenager to basically add this new foundation of help other people. Because for ours, for example, for the kids, it was like lead by example. Like that
was kind of our version of the others first thing. It was like be a leader, show the other girls what an upper level is supposed to be kind of thing. And so when you're asking somebody to like make that a core foundation of who they are and where they find joy and validation from who they are, it makes them into very people pleasing people. identities um leaving that and i think that that really really hurts people down the road because i think it makes it hard
for them to assert boundaries and stick with them i think it makes it difficult for them to honestly see like other people's actions towards them is harmful. I feel like it kind of makes them makes people filter through a lens of like, what did I do? Or what did I not do right to have this happen to me, which I think is already very commonplace within the church, especially with like the victim blaming narratives that can be in the church sometimes. And so when you mix that in with some of the other, like very
problematic stuff that can happen in these facilities, it just kind of primes people. to, like I said, be very people -pleasing and be very outwardly validation -seeking in a way that's really unhealthy, I think. Yeah, it's almost like an inward -facing dagger that makes you focus on the self as opposed to systemic power asymmetries that are at play that have caused whatever it is that is going on. And I think it makes it hard for people to...
reach out for help in that way too like even after they leave I think it just like in that way makes it very difficult to even see them and maybe being worthy of help yes I think that that's like somewhat easy to like attain especially as you develop like oh this thing was wrong but i think being able to reasonably see other people being able to give you that help in a way that feels like it will do what you want it to do i think is really challenged when you're building everything off of what can i do for other people
or how do i make everything else around me okay Speaking of ways to make it difficult to kind of crawl out of this. So Teen Challenge often frames addiction as lifelong and only manageable through continual submission to Christ. This model is once an addict, always an addict. How does that compare with modern addiction science? I think it's really harmful in a lot of ways. Like I said earlier, a lot of what... We still know really very little about addiction. You
know, there's kind of there's the external and internal and both of them are kind of separate fields that aren't really talking to each other, in my opinion. But I think one of the biggest things that we do know is that, A, it is chemically motivated at a certain point. Like once your brain gets hooked on to something, it rewires the way your brain works and receives things in a way that is debilitating. And when it is not that severe, it's often motivated by trauma
and an outlet for feeling bad or wanting to escape from the bad things that are happening to you. And so. the biggest message that i remember from our teen challenge at least was this and the idea that you know we're inherently broken people like we're sinners and we're the only thing that can fix it is jesus and so when you intertwine this idea of like A, you were born a sinner, you'll die a sinner, and now you formed an addiction
and that's unescapable. I think it just makes you feel like this very, very inherently broken and irredeemable person. Yeah. And this once an addict, always an addict model kind of implies that if you were once addicted to meth, food, alcohol or sex, that you will always be addicted. It implies that there is no way of changing your state. The idea that anyone is powerless over any substance or external addictive force, let alone forever, is simply not supported by research.
And, you know, over and over again, that's true. And there's even research as far as like. using certain certain words as opposed to like um addict or if you're using like substance use disorder there's research showing that using substance use disorder around people that that have addictive i don't want to say addictive personalities because they feel like that's damaging too but um has some sort of addiction actually has a better success rate by using substance use disorder as opposed to addiction and Teen Challenge is
one of those that still uses addiction, whereas other models use substance use disorder. And we can talk about success statistics a little bit later. That'll come up a little bit later. I do want to talk about some of the testimonials and how central the testimonies of transformation inside the program are. What role do public confession and spiritual narratives play in shaping identity there? Teen Challenge model is built on the idea
of kind of like two identities, like your life before and... You know, during slash after finding Christ. And so a lot of it in the testimony, it plays a very large role in that. And especially for the kids, we were like we were filmed like our testimonies were filmed occasionally and put online or looked or used at like other conferences and stuff. So like our stories in that way were directly utilized for their own like narrative of what Teen Challenge can do in that way. And
secondarily, it's kind of like a it's almost like if you're picked to do a testimonial video when you're in the program, it feels like like the coolest thing. Ever like that person just got this awesome opportunity because that means that the program leadership really sees that you've stepped into this new identity of this born again person. And that like validates kind of this whole other thing that you've been working towards in that in that program. And so just being able to like. glorify or like promote your
testimony in that way is a huge way to signal like i've done the change you wanted me to do like even i did it i wrote like a this the spoken word thing where it's like the dramatized testimonies that people do And honestly, it's so funny now looking back on it because I just remember I wrote a poem initially and I looked at it and I was like, this is really good. And there's no way that they'll let me keep it if I don't talk about Jesus. And so I flipped the paper over and I wrote the first half of my testimony,
which was like the before part. And then a little bit about how I found Jesus and then like the rest of it. And so that was like. That was like foundational for me there. I remember because like every single conference we had after that, like after I'd wrote, written it and like submit it for like this arts competition thing, they had me promote and perform that testimony every chance that they could. In fact, when I had went back years later, it was two years later. But and I went to visit, they remember they asked
me if I still remembered it. And I told them that I didn't and I didn't bring any like writing with me. So I couldn't I didn't have anything to go off of. But like they're constantly looking for ways to utilize like our story and our faces in that way. Because again, it just it really shows that like their their goal worked. So hearing about these daily routines and expectations naturally raises some practical questions, like who's actually running these places? What kind of training do
staff have? And what systems, if any, are supposed to make sure teens are safe while they're there? So what do we know about who runs Teen Challenge Centers and their credentials or lack thereof? So a lot of the people that ran my Teen Challenge, at least, had some. credentials in psychology or in like theology based schools or degrees. But in our daily care staff, especially, we did not have really any people that had the right
qualifications to be kind of giving us the amount of care that would have been expected. And even in kind of the baseline idea of like being a treatment center or a therapeutic boarding school. We didn't have any licensed psychologists or psychiatrists, no kind of really formal standard medication management. A lot of times their goal was to wean us off any kind of medication that we were on. Even if it was like a necessary psychiatric
medication, they would prefer you to just like not have it. In terms of our daily care staff, a lot of them were hired. Some of them are like adult Teen Challenge graduates that had been working and graduated for 12 months that got hired at our facility. So they were kind of freshly out of like their own rehab program. Others had done like maybe some kind of like light kind of care, like a camp counselor or like a nanny,
like that kind of level of care experience. But nothing really higher than that. A lot of times, because I've interviewed a few former staff from my facility. And a lot of them did not know what they were getting into at the time that they applied. Like they had heard of the adult Teen Challenge facilities or they had seen like the presentations at their church. And they decided to apply for it like while in, I don't know, Bible school or something. And realized very quickly that it was not at all what they thought
that it was going to be. Like this was a place for troubled girls, as they put it. There were situations like we can get into more of that later, most likely. But baseline is a lot of them have little to no experience. They're often very young. They're paid very little. They often live on site or in a very cheap rental nearby. So a lot of them are in a very vulnerable place, I think, to be working there. And they don't
really have any opportunities to even get credentials oftentimes. So going off with credentials and whatnot, how many staff are typically licensed by the state's mental health boards? Do you know any? I would say none. None? There was none at the time, at least when I was in the facility that I was in. Not a single person had an active license. I think there was one individual that had an expired license, but she hadn't renewed it in quite a while. I believe that. They have
now, but at least at the time they were not like actively practicing. And that was the closest that anybody ever was. They really do. And I'm sure that this is consistent among the adult programs as well. They really do pride themselves in their separation from like secular, as they would probably put it, like secular standards or requirements and stuff like that. And they really, really heighten like theological experience. If you have like so -and -so direct care experience,
but like you're a family member of like somebody that goes to the church that we attend or something like that, you know, then congrats, you might just have a job for a few months or something like that. I don't know if it's different now, but at least that was a lot of what the hiring looked like on that level. And then kind of like the middle level administrative staff were oftentimes like those people who were hired in with very little experience who had just stayed in there for years and years. And so they had like a decade's
worth of experience in this facility at this point. And so they just kind of stayed there. So what does it mean for like the teens in the program if treatment is delivered by unlicensed or religiously trained staff? Typically, it's. It depends. So in a couple of ways, I think you kind of know what you're getting into. Like biblical counseling is a really big thing there. Like they would be like, oh, we offer biblical counseling, but that's not. legally that's not psychiatric
treatment like that's something that's different that's like the same as life coaching basically that's just a term that people can say or put on themselves basically and so there is like a certain level of experience that comes with that you know if you spend 10 years of your life talking to and trying to motivate teenagers i assume you get some kind of experience and some skill talking to them in that point you know but in that way they don't If they believe something.
It has the potential to be filtered in such a harmful way by a teenager hearing it. Like a 40 -year -old woman growing up in church purity culture and then hearing a girl open up to her about whatever kind of experience she may have had and responding in any kind of way that is not validating that person and ready to carry them through whatever it is that they may need next from that moment. they can do a lot of damage.
And a lot of people in that place are in that kind of power dynamic where they may have some good life experience to offer and maybe even some good advice. But when they're in a place being in a position to give treatment, it's an entirely different qualification that I would go as far to argue that none of them are really qualified to be doing. Interesting. That would be my thought based on everything that I've seen and everything that you're saying, too. I probably
err on the side of caution of this probably isn't the best idea. Yeah. So I was going to ask you, like, are there any laws or regulations that Teen Challenge programs actually have to follow? Like, where do oversight gaps tend to appear? It's really interesting, honestly, because a lot of it traces back to the early 2000s from what I've been able to see. In Texas, in about 2008, there was a Teen Challenge facility that was under threat of being closed. And Bush was
governor of that state at the time. And so he stepped in and passed a law in Texas to allow it to stay open, which eventually kind of transformed into the, I think it's the Office of Faith -Based Initiatives or something like that, where a huge part of his campaign goals was to promote these Christian -based family value programs or whatever. One of them was like a prison fellowship program and another one was Teen Challenge. And so because of that, he basically carved out the laws to
be made for faith -based facilities to get separate accreditation through a company which oftentimes really sponsors places like Teen Challenge. And those standards... I do not have like in mind exact comparison of what they are the state ones, but I know that they are in nowhere near the same realm. And once you have that kind of licensing, it stays for a lot longer. There isn't like an
active regulatory process basically to check in on that place. And so. When the gaps are typically it's in this weird little space where like they are accredited by somebody, but that somebody is not the same person as social services or. The state of, you know, the state that I live in, for example, the state of Michigan coming in and evaluating what is basically your school or your medical treatment center and saying,
OK, this is good. This meets our standards. And if they ever get a call to social services or child services, they're going to say, OK, look back in our files. What's going on here? When they're the separate entity, they're the separate accreditation process. That bureaucracy gets a lot more muddy. And so when the call is made to child services, it may be like, OK, what is this place? But then you kind of see that it's not state regulated. There isn't any other calls or anything like that, something along those
lines. Or you just don't have the manpower or the people to go all the way out into like a really impoverished areas and like go and check out this facility and talk to every single kid. So you're just like, we don't have the time or the resources. It is what it is. And so the oversight really kind of stays that way. Unfortunately, I think until something big happens, until something bad happens, like in Florida, for example, a girl passed away in her facility. And that's
what eventually got that facility shut down. Not even actually, because they just dwindled in numbers until they decided to shut down. Even then, it takes a lot to like really step into these places and stop what they're doing or even assess what level it's at in terms of like harm that it may or may not be doing, because it's the entire thing in itself kind of just becomes like, well, it's another thing. It's like another entity's problem. So if abuse or malpractice
occurs, who has the authority to actually investigate this kind of stuff? Like, are there any regulatory bodies overseeing these programs like reporters? No, none of them are mandatory reporters in terms of like, like I at one point have had to be a mandatory reporter for certain jobs where I've had to take training and sign agreements saying that if somebody, you know, said something to me, I had a legal obligation to tell authorities or whatever it may be. And they do not have any of that as far as I'm concerned, because I think
the massive problem, and I do think it's the same problem that we kind of see in churches sometimes where it's, you know, that question is really for like, if it ever makes it out of that world in the first place, because a lot of things are like handled internally. And that's what makes it difficult to report abuse because The only like outside sources that you have are staff that are may or may not be willing to believe
you or take action to what you're saying. And if you try and tell your parents, there is the same risk because the other huge issue with these facilities is a really large narrative of to not believe what we're saying, that we're exaggerating how bad it is because we just want to go home or we just want to go to drugs again. And so there's just this era or aura of invalidation that makes it very hard to really report any kind of abuse. And when it really does get out,
a lot of times things are handled in such a way that it never makes it to formal authorities. Like staff members agree to leave or they get fired and the family agrees to not press charges. You know, things along those lines happen and agreements are made. And so it never makes it to the formal authorities. And maybe by the time it does, it's too late. Like they're not in that facility anymore. They don't live there anymore, whatever. So because it's such a separated world,
it's really, really difficult to get people to even listen in the first place. In the darkest of times, students have to take. What they feel is necessary, but really extreme measures just to get people to listen in the way of making actions that harm themselves or harm other people just to get somebody to listen like a police officer or an EMT. Because I've heard those, you know, I've heard those stories from students.
And that's the kind of choices that. these kids are being forced to make because they feel that that's a necessary choice in that moment they feel like that's the only way out so i think it's honestly kind of heinous that the larger invested investigative authorities aren't looking at this thing that's having so many of these kids making these actions and saying what is going on that's making these kids you know do these things And I've also heard from numerous
sources that they almost gatekeep information in a way that they don't actually keep any records whatsoever or a very minimal amount of records. So that way. if if anybody if any like agency does come at him and say hey we need to see these records because this happened we need to look into it further like oops we don't have them we don't know where they are yeah they might just slap them on with like a you know a fine or something like that and that just may be be it um but i don't know if you've heard anything about that too Yeah, they I think they're only
legally required to keep records for like five years and then they can just like shred them after that. So it's really just it's a matter of if you can get your hands on them. But I have known of a lot of people who've reached out to them trying to get their records and just heard nothing back. And so there's not really any way to like have anybody enforce that for you because. What are you going to do? Like if you're a 17 year old, 19 year old kid, you don't have a lawyer that can come in and like say on your behalf
to do something. Yeah, people have tried to request them that I know of and they just hear nothing back. So a lot of the times they don't. It's just like a wall or in the worst cases, too, like they I've also heard they erase their camera footage like once every two weeks. So that makes it even more difficult to get your hands on things like that. So. Even then, it can make it really difficult for kids to report stuff and actually have and they're making it difficult for them to even have the tools to look back into what
they're saying, too. So from an ethical standpoint, consent, autonomy, informed treatment, what stands out as most or outstands out most about the Teen Challenge model? I would probably say consent and autonomy. Probably autonomy first, because these kids really are stripped of every single facet of like being able to make choices for themselves from like what they're allowed to wear and getting dressed in the morning and like
in a way that's what Teen Challenge wants. But that can be incredibly damaging if it's in any way, to be honest. And, like, a lot of kids don't even really understand why they're there in the first place or they aren't told, like, sometimes they aren't told the full extent of what the program is going to be just to, like, get them there calmly. And then they tell them what's actually happening and they, like, freak out. Like, it's those are probably the biggest red
flags, I think. Like, it's just not the entire process, I think, is inherently. Unconsensual. So when you have programs working with vulnerable young people, especially in pretty controlled environments, oversight really matters, as we can see. So in this next part, we're going to talk about some of the more serious concerns that former participants and staff have raised, including allegations of harm and coercion connected to Teen Challenge. Former participants describe
obedience, structures, isolation, confession, and spiritual authority. Which of these patterns appear in Teen Challenge? I would probably say every one of them, but in different ways. I think obedience is definitely one of the biggest ones in the way that Every single aspect of it. So like the word fast thing that I spoke of earlier, like if you talk when you're not supposed to, that's a discipline. And disciplines are the sentences that you have to write, which are like three to four sentence paragraphs that have to,
they range from like 20 for the least, 20 to 15 maybe, to like in the hundreds. I even saw them get into like the thousands a couple of times for some people. That is like a central part is anything you do wrong, you get a discipline for like every single way that you can advance through that program is filtered through whether or not you are being compliant with what they want and not are you actually getting better? And are you getting help for the things that
brought you here in the first place? And in the same vein, I think that isolation is also a really big part of it because. These kids are really cut off from everything. Like they're cut off from all their friends. They can only talk to their parents for 40 minutes out of an entire week over the phone. They can only see them once a month. They are living in this very rural area. Oftentimes they're completely cut off from the outside world. I think that's definitely what
I remember the most. And I know that a lot of other kids remember the same thing. A lot of... It differs for people. It differs if they grew up evangelical or if they didn't, honestly. If they did, they kind of knew how to fit into the structure because oftentimes that was intertwined with having like strict parents and strict childhoods where they have like similar. discipline structures and like obedient expectations whereas kids who grew up in like a secular environment who were
just kind of wild children before they got there they found it very jarring like it was a really long adjustment period for them and so that is the biggest difference like in my research especially is like the way that kids or adults now describe it is that if they grew up like homeschooled or something for example they would just kind of be like yeah i don't know like what I was there for or like it was pretty because I would ask them like what stands out to you the most from your time there like that first couple of
months and they'll just be like you know maybe Just the fact that it was kind of like home, like it didn't take much for them to settle in, whereas the other kids that grew up just doing whatever they wanted or whatever that looked like, they would remember just hearing all of the rules and all of the structure and like the new routine that they would have to get used to. And they just remember how overwhelming it was. So that really is like the biggest difference for them, too. So Robert Lifton in his book,
Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism, identified eight criteria of what he called thought reform, popularly known as brainwashing. So these eight criteria, I wouldn't say that every single one of them really nails down on Teen Challenge. And of course, like we stated, every single Teen Challenge facility is run differently, slightly differently. So it's really hard to nail down an umbrella of Teen Challenge that falls under this whole thing. But these eight are milieu control, mystical manipulation, demand for purity,
confession, sacred science, loading the language, doctrine over person, and dispensing of existence. I could go over this further if you want to. I don't know if you wanted to dig into any of this kind of stuff at all. I don't know. if i've actually heard that one before because like some of them sound familiar but i don't know what other ones mean like the loaded language i've definitely heard before but like the mythical one i don't think i've heard so i'll go through them number one milu control so the leader or inner circle has complete control of information
how and where it is communicated disseminated and consumed resulting in nearly complete isolation from the outside world People learn to trust only the publications and news that comes from the group itself. The rest is considered fake. Eventually, people internalize the group mindset, becoming their own mental police. I'm sure you've seen that take place over. Yeah, because it's so interesting, too, because like I went there in 2017 and 2018. So like really the start of
like what we know of, you know, the last 10 years of being like. very, a highly political era. So, and I'm, again, I'm a sociologist and like everything is political as well, but like. It's so fascinating because when I think about it now, like I remember the fact that I don't remember anything that happened in like the first year of Trump's presidency, basically. And then 2018, I was still kind of in it. And then 2019, as I was getting out and readjusting to life again,
basically, COVID happened. And so and then everything else after as we know it. And so I'm. I honestly can't even imagine what it was like in that facility once COVID happened, especially. But I can imagine that it was filtered through a certain realm of. like giving information and or misinformation in that way because like there's a joke that i make with my friends that like if anything happened in 2017 i don't know about it basically like if they show me something funny on their
phone or like a meme or something there are so many times where it just doesn't click for me like i just i have no reaction they're like you don't know that and i'm like when when was it made and i told them to google it and it says oh my god every single time it says 2017 or 2018 i'm like that is why i don't know it i did not have a phone i did not have a computer like i'd had nothing and so like any news i got would have been given to me by my parents and i do trust my parents as news sources somewhat you
know like i trust them as reasonable people as we all trust each other as reasonable people sometimes in that way but like in the in the same way like it was an entire mental process to have to readjust to life after that place like having a phone again was an entire adjustment in itself being able to like because when you're in that program too like you aren't even allowed to like look at boys and like it's so dumb but like they make you like turn your head against
the wall and put your head down basically if a boy is even walking by and we had to call them the others and they had to call us the others and just all of the separation and so like even coming out of it and having to like not feel anxiety like looking in a boy's direction in that way was a whole adjustment in itself like I think brainwashing is such a weird and funny word in that way, because like I think it describes I think overall we kind of use it to describe
the way in which people can take over your mental process and your mental thinking and in any way and not just like with language and stuff, but like the way you interpret situations and the way your body reacts to things as well. And so it it is a helpful term, but it's like also it's almost like not. physical enough for me if that makes sense because like it's so everything about it is embodied like just your the way you interpret situations is it's an entire way of life that
is just like inescapable for however much time you're there and so i think a lot of people feel like they were brainwashed coming out of it because they feel like they have to undo all of this mental work that was put on to them oh for sure I'm going to skip ahead a little bit to the next section because I feel like we actually covered quite a bit of this already. And my time will be coming up in the next half hour here. So I want to tackle some of this other stuff before that time comes up. I want to make sure we get
to some of this. So at this point, listeners might be wondering if these kinds of programs have been reported over the years, how has Team Challenge maintained such a positive reputation and continued to grow? To explore that, let's look at the bigger picture. Funding, influence, and the success stories the organization shares about itself. So Teen Challenge has grown into a large international organization. What do we know about its funding streams and influential supporters? What can you say on this? A lot of it is really hard to track because they do label
themselves as a non -profit. A lot of their funding, though, from what I do know, comes from, like, grassroots funding in that way. All of these businesses are kind of independently funded to open as Teen Challenge facilities, similarly to like any franchise business. And then they're sustained through maybe some input by like the original owners, but also probably a large amount of like personal private donation by like church
members or affiliated churches or organizations that see what they're doing on the outside and think that it's, you know, great work. And even in some cases. state funding as well because the faith -based initiatives office like i mentioned does have some allocated for federal funding that i do believe teen challenge got for a couple of years i don't know if they still are with all the federal changes honestly it goes for say i don't think that one's probably been touched so they might still be getting some federal funding depending on the facility and i will say my family
paid three thousand dollars a month for when i was there and i was there for 15 months so that was basically my college fund like it was i i was i had some family members step in to help me my parents my family pay for it a lot of girls did that this facility encourages some parents to take out loans to be able to fund their stay at these facilities but like these parents paid 3 000 a month for their kids. I
think with inflation, it's about $4 ,500, $5 ,000 a month now. And there's about 30 kids in every facility. So it is like hundreds of thousands of dollars, which I'm sure a good amount of it does really go to funding a place, especially if it is. You know, like a facility kind of like mine, where it is like a school building and then a house and then staff housing all on the same campus. It does take a good amount of money to be able to fund that. But like we get all
that tuition plus donations, plus private funding, plus maybe some state funding. It's a lot of money from a lot of places. Yeah. And they have a lot of powerful people that are pushing for these. money sources that are coming through, whether it be through government or through other sources. You mentioned a couple of them. You mentioned George Bush Sr. with his Office of Faith -Based Initiatives in 2000s. Of course,
Billy Graham has been a big advocate for it. Ronald Reagan, George W. Bush, John Ashcraft, James Dobson, John P. Walters. He was the former White House drug czar. So a lot of those names, like a lot of my listeners will at least know the names. I've heard them before. Technical difficulties, camera's going out, but at least you guys can hear me. So maybe I'll just keep that in there and just run with it. I think you were talking, you got past Bush Sr. and some
other people. All right, well, I'll just kind of, no, you know, I'll just keep it in there. We'll just let technology be its thing. Teen Challenge often cites an 80 % success rate. What's behind that number and how might confirmation bias or selective follow -up shape it? I love my university because my University of Michigan email gives me access to so many different things. And they have that original study that Teen Challenge cites in the University of Michigan library,
and I've read it. And in that study, In the very end, in the results section, it says that it's not generalizable to all Teen Challenge locations and that that study is riddled with confirmation bias because they surveyed Teen Challenge facilities. And so they surveyed people who were like actively in that facility, voluntarily participating in that program, or they were surveying staff who had been in that program. And so it's riddled with bias all throughout and it's not generalizable
to everything. facility, let alone the adolescent facilities like they do. I know that there is a couple. I have my own research that I'm trying to publish that is a more long term focused look at Teen Challenge and what an actual output would look like years like years past. And I'll have some problems with my own study the same way. And, you know, it's all about a conversation.
But Teen Challenge is everything that you're not supposed to do when you're given a piece of research in that way, because it was also funded by Teen Challenge as well. Yeah, there's always red flags when a research study is funded by the very research center that it's trying to report for. You always need third party so that you don't have some sort of bias that's burned into the data that you come out of it with. You know, it's probable that the group cooked the figures fuzzy mouth. I would assume
something like that. It just feels very kind of iffy. There's a few ways I could come up with these numbers as they are widely different from any other rehab treatment program. The primary term for selectively choosing data to support a specific viewpoint while ignoring contrary evidence is cherry picking. This behavior is a key component of confirmation bias, psychological tendency to seek, interpret, and recall information that confirms preexisting beliefs. Other terms that may apply to this are selective exposure, which is actively seeking out sources or data
that confirm. or conform to prior beliefs while avoiding contradictory information. It could also be suppressed evidence or card stacking, which is deliberately omitting relevant data that contradicts a desired conclusion. And it could also be selective perception, which is screening and noticing only information that aligns with one's attitudes. These behaviors are often driven by our desire to validate existing opinions rather than searching for an objective truth. and are more common when dealing with emotionally charged or deeply held beliefs. Wow.
But that's, I mean, that's a whole lot just to kind of take in as far as like terminology and whatnot. But when you start looking at this 80 % number and then you start looking at other treatment facilities and their success rates. it it just seems a little bit off and especially with like you know on top of what you said with your what you found with research and reading their research and then doing your own yeah just something seems a little off with that yeah i mean none of it is generalizable either it's
what makes it so difficult is like every single Because my research is mainly qualitative. So a lot of it is like in -depth interviews that I do with people. And every single person is so vastly different and has a different set of circumstances that they are born into and given access to. So it's really more so dependent on that than it is Teen Challenge. Because I know some people who are relatively well adjusted and doing very well, but they don't attribute any of that success directly to Teen Challenge.
And more so, I know people that are completely debilitated by their trauma from Teen Challenge directly. So it varies on from person to person and a lot of it. And that's the whole thing itself, too, is that. Because we were all children and this was such an unconsensual process and such a jarring process and a life altering process for so many people with so much control. It is
more effectively labeled as trauma rather than like a rehab experience or like a treatment experience, because like that is the only way. that it can be functionally labeled for these people because it's not how it is for an adult where that person is voluntarily choosing that process to a certain extent. Yeah. I want to define a term here before I ask you this next question. So I want to define feedback loop. That's defined as a process where the output of a system is circled back and used
as input, allowing the system to adjust, self -correct, or amplify its future actions. So my question is, how does reliance on testimonies create a feedback loop where positive outcomes are visible, but negative ones disappear? I think it honestly, it comes to a question of just how the culture of Teen Challenge functions and is effective. And that culture is built on an invalidation of negative experiences from adolescence to adulthood,
like it is the same. A justification of them being on a mission that nobody else understands and that the secular world just doesn't understand and that we're bad for thinking that they're bad, basically. And then, like I said, some testimonies are filmed and put in conferences or whatever, or there's photos on their website of people and their families, even though they don't agree
with it now and they don't want those pictures up now. It really is. I'm really happy that the conversation is changing because it was put on. us to change the conversation because if people like me weren't talking to people like you and people i know weren't putting their own videos out on like tiktok and facebook because like we have been saying things for years but it just feels like the conversation is finally opening up to us i think and this is and people are just
listening that's the that's the only difference but like we've been saying these things for years but if we didn't step forward and say this teen challenge would have been the only thing putting out information. And as far as they say, everything is great. And so it's, again, it's put on us to put something else out there if we feel different because we were never given a chance or an opportunity to really voice any, just like how I worry in my own study that I'm overemphasizing negative
experiences because I, may not have enough people who are neutral or positive about their experience they have so much concentration of good experience put out there that it's honestly impossible that all of that has existed with no negative experiences or negative testimonies to be in there with it like just it's it's such a nuanced topic and that's what's so the internet loves nuance but it certainly does exactly but like it's so frustrating
sometimes because i just as much as teen challenge has a capacity to do amazing work and do good i also think it has equal capacity to facilitate harm and Do really bad things like it has capacity for both. And I think that's because it's been given this really broad scope and given this really general mission. And there is not enough individualism put into every program or enough oversight. And there is no adherence to secular
normative state standards so they can function in isolation and they can just. They can keep doing what they're doing and have nobody stepping in to tell them that they're doing something wrong. And when somebody does, it's because we're wrong, because we're secular, because we're not in that world with them, because we don't understand things like that. And so for survivors to hear that like they don't understand or like we don't
know what we're talking about with our own experience. is incredibly invalidating. And so it takes a lot for survivors to look at all that and still decide that they're going to come out and speak anyways. There's been a lot more people over the years, like you said, recently that have been coming out and speaking. But behind all the statistics and public narratives are real people whose lives were shaped by these programs, sometimes in complicated ways, they're still sorting through. So as we start to wrap up, I want to focus on survivors. What support looks
like? How people make sense of experiences like this? And what changes might better protect teens going forward? So how can listeners support people who went through Teen Challenge or other similar programs? What kinds of validation or care are most helpful? I think that it's... I think it varies for every person, but I think that a lot of people just want some kind of validation in their experience. I think that it's easy to get validation from strangers about this experience
because it's kind of unique in that way where when you say it to people and you give no context or you just say like, yeah, I was in this place or I experienced this and I was like 16. Like that's a tough sentence to hear from. like a somewhat disconnected person in any context. But when you are close to those people and you really know those people, you're in a different position where I would argue that you kind of
have a duty to say that even if it's hard to hear and your experience doesn't match what they're saying to you, that you still believe them and that you still care for them because It can be really hard. And what I really hate about this industry is that it puts families in a position where now they have to go through the process of unworking. All of this trauma and these narratives that were put into them as a family to not believe
each other or to not validate each other's experiences. Like my parents can have an experience of being afraid and wanting what was best for me, just like I can have an experience of I was hurt by a decision that they made, even though I know that it was coming from a good place. It's conversations like those. that are so important and even if you're not in it having those conversations like guiding people along that way for whatever they need that's where the healing really has to come
from in my opinion because the troubled teen industry in a lot of ways does kind of fundamentally break families in the same way that divorce can break families or the foster care system can break families or other life events can break families that they then have to heal from the troubled teen industry does the exact same thing in almost every single case, in my opinion. Yeah. So what is Teen Challenge Persistence? Tell us
about gaps in youth mental health care and addiction treatment. What reforms would actually protect young people? I think that the legal system is a really good way to go. I think that any time Anybody is in a place of like social work or health care or really any scenario where they're going to be coming in contact with children in that way. And or they're in a position to pass legislation that can protect children. I think
it's really important for people to take time to educate themselves about this industry. And especially in the case of like social work or even teachers, especially in schools, like anywhere where kids are, basically. anywhere kids are this industry has a place that they can seep in like if people aren't looking for it one of their students in their classrooms can be there one week and gone the next and you don't know
where they are all you hear is that they're at some boarding school and nobody looks or bats an eye at that I think like those moments are the real gaps where kids just kind of fall through and the system stops looking. And it's those gaps that need to be filled by people or by legislation. Well, there you have it. Teen Challenge sits in a complicated space. Part ministry, part recovery program, part youth intervention system. And
like many institutions built around helping vulnerable people, experiences can vary a lot depending on who you ask. What matters most is making room for honest stories, careful scrutiny, and better safeguards for young people these programs aim to serve. If this conversation connects with you or your own experiences, you're not alone. And your perspective is part of this larger story, too. One of the best things that we can do is learn history and understand the systemic structures of past harmful institutions so you can better
identify potentially harmful structures in the present and be able to identify pathways that lead to harmful situations in the future. So Lynn, if people want to hear more from you, where can they find more information? OK, my TikTok that I post videos talking about this industry and stuff on is Lynn underscore green one. It's L -Y -N -N underscore G -R -E -N one. And my Instagram is Lynn dot M dot green. It's L -Y
-N -N dot M dot G -R -E -N. Very cool. Yeah. You know, I started. following you after I saw you on someone else's platform. And I was just inspired by what you said and kind of shook at the same time. So that's what got me talking to you. No, I'm really glad that I was able to talk about this. And I'm, yeah, I'm really thankful for every single chance I've been able to. Yeah. And I encourage anybody to do the same. Like
if you're listening to this, watching this. even just a clip on social media. There are people, if you've gone through something like this and it's been traumatizing, there are people that are willing to listen and know where you're coming from and will validate you and you'll be heard. You use both of us as as a means to do that. If you feel necessary to reach out to somebody, I would suggest Lynn over me. But I think I have some capacity of understanding as well. So but there are plenty of other people. There's lots
of other resources. And like I said, you are not alone. And I think Lynn, you would probably agree with that, too. Yeah, definitely. I really, really appreciate this. Thank you so much. Yeah. No, thanks for coming on. I think it's a topic that needs to be talked about more. Yeah, me too. I'm really excited to hopefully I'll have many more chances to talk about it. Yeah, definitely. All right, Lynn. Thanks for coming on.
Two white Christians, who love Muslims, breakdown myths and misconceptions that many Americans (and more specifically Christians) have about Islam and Muslims. Mark Wayne of the Colonial Outcasts podcast joins in the...
Capitalism has a long and ugly history of scapegoating and exploiting immigrants. From British capitalists exploiting Irish people to the United States’ deeply systemic and oppressive tactics, immigrants have, for a...
This is part 7 of the Enchantments of Mammon series. Capitalism needs a permanent source of unpaid labor. Childbearing, child raising, cooking, cleaning, caregiving, emotional support. The invisible work that keeps...
Marx’s analysis does not specifically take into account the history of the exploitation of women and non-white people. We will be digging into some of the ways that racism, sexism, and xenophobia play into the...
Spiritual maturity and financial security are often married within the church business model. How do we identify patterns of abuse and work toward a more sustainable future? Let's get into it in today's episode of part...