Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Grounded & Growing

Grounded & Growing artwork

Is Hell Eternal? - Getting Greek

Feb 28, 202328 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

We need to deal with some of the key words used in Scripture to describe hell. If we believe that God inspired the very words of Scripture, we must be concerned with the specific meanings of those words. Three Greek words most stubbornly resist Conditional Immortality, and thus must be redefined by Conditional Immortality proponents to make room for their viewpoint. Support the show A production of The Sword and Trumpet Ministries. To learn more about The Sword & Trumpet Ministries, visit the Sword & Trumpet Website. For more theological content, visit theologicaltouchpoints.com.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Welcome to the Theological Touchpoints podcast. I'm Julian. The focus for this episode is touchpoints at the intersection of biblical theology and everyday life. This is part five of our series on Hell. We are talking about Hell generally, but we're particularly interacting with the conditional immortality view of Hell. Today, as promised, we're going to be discussing some of the key Greek terms that affect our understanding of Hell Particularly. We're going to look at how the definitions of these terms are readjusted by conditional immortality advocates to make room for their understanding of Hell, that being that Hell is not a place of eternal conscious torment, but rather is a place where the wicked are destroyed, where they are annihilated.

Speaker 1They cease to exist in the judgment, they go to Hell and their souls cease to exist, eternally cease to exist. If you want more details on their views, take a listen to some of the earlier episodes in this series. We are going to be getting into some of the Greek words here in a bit. Before we get there, thinking about our understanding of Hell and earlier on in the series, i laid out the different views of Hell, being the traditional view of Hell, the annihilationism view of Hell and the universalism view of Hell, traditional view being eternal conscious torment, conditional immortality being, or annihilationism being, that they cease to exist, and universalism being that eventually all will be saved and Hell will be uninhabited because all the souls eventually will be saved out of it The view that the church has typically held.

Speaker 1I've called it traditional view, and I've called it that because it's been the majority view throughout all of church history. But the more I think about this issue, the more I'm convinced that it's not sufficient to reject conditional immortality just because it is not the historical view of the church. The fact that the church is not traditionally accepted conditional immortality is a good supporting argument, but it must not be our only argument. There are a number of views on other doctrinal issues that have been held throughout church history that we have good reason to disagree with.

Speaker 1For example, sacramentalism, which believes that grace is received through the sacraments rather than, as the Bible describes it, grace being received through faith. Sacramentalism can be traced at least as far back as Augustine, if not earlier than that, and it has plagued the church for two millennia and it still does. Many Bible believing born again Christians believe in sacramentalism, and I believe that understanding of the sacraments, or what we would typically call the ordinances, is incorrect Confusion about infant baptism is another example Those who think it's necessary to baptize infants where the history of that is primarily, if not exclusively, connected to state church connections and not necessarily connected to scripture.

Speaker 1And yet large segments of the Christian movement have believed for many years, for centuries, that it's necessary and good and essential to baptize infants, and that too can be traced at least as far back as Augustine. So just because a belief has been held traditionally by our movement or by a significant number of Christians does not necessarily mean that that view is correct. Now, the consensus is typically correct, the majority view is typically correct, and as a rule, the more Christians you have looking at an issue and studying scripture, the better chance you have of properly understanding, properly interpreting and properly applying scripture.

Speaker 1So the consensus is typically correct, but not always So. More to the point, it's insufficient for us to attempt to wage the doctrinal war against conditional immortality by merely deferring to tradition. The question must always be what has God said? We bow to the authority of God's word. Our argument must ultimately rest not on tradition, not on orthodoxy, but on scripture. So in the end it's what the Bible says that matters.

Speaker 1That doesn't mean that tradition is necessarily a bad thing. Tradition can be helpful in its place. The value of tradition has a lot to do with how it is used relative to scripture. Tradition is a good thing when it supports scripture. Many traditional beliefs and practices can be traced directly or indirectly to scripture, and tradition is helpful in maintaining the faith once for all delivered to the saints, and it is good when it helps preserve that faith. Tradition is a good thing when it supports scripture.

Speaker 1Tradition is tolerable when it exists independent of scripture. Many traditions are amoral, neither connected directly to scripture nor contradicting it. These traditions are not wrong so long as they do not distort the gospel or cause us to disobey scripture. While tradition is good when it supports scripture and it is tolerable when it neither agrees nor disagrees with scripture, tradition is unacceptable when it contradicts scripture, and so I wonder a bit when we defend certain of our applications being the traditional practice when they actually disagree with what the Bible requires of us.

Speaker 1We should not defend a position merely because it is a Mennonite position. If it is both biblical and Mennonite, certainly we must defend it, but if we have drifted from scripture, we dare not defend ourselves in our error. Traditions that interfere with biblical applications or contradicts biblical teachings are unacceptable in the Church of Christ. So again, tradition is good when it supports scripture. It is tolerable when it exists independent of scripture, but it is unacceptable when it causes us to disobey scripture.

Speaker 1This is helpful in looking at many of the issues we face as conservative Mennonites And it is helpful in analyzing conditional immortality. A knee-jerk reaction that dismisses this idea just because it's new or just because it's the minority position is not sufficient And if we take that line of argument we may end up knocking the props out from under ourselves on other issues, such as the typical Mennonite, the typical Anabaptist understanding of non-resistance and the separation of church and state and the freedom of Christians to exercise their faith independent of civil constraints, and we could look at some other distinctives of Mennonitism or distinctives of Anabaptism that put us in the minority position.

Speaker 1Does that mean we're wrong? I hope not, but our question needs to be is it what the Bible clearly says? And unless we can appeal to scripture, we'd better not spend too much time or energy defending mere tradition, defending dead tradition, especially if that gets in the way of faithfulness to scripture. So a knee-jerk reaction that dismisses conditional immortality just because it's new, in my opinion, is not sufficient. It's not good enough to say, well, we've never believed that That's helpful to bring in, but that can't be our entire argument.

Speaker 1The only right response is to dive into scripture to see what God actually says According to truth. By tradition alone is a cop-out, a failure to appeal to the one and only absolute authority Christ has given to his church the written word of God. So as we go forward in this episode, we're going to be looking at some of those words, some of the key terms that God has included in his inspired written word, and some of the words, especially, that are redefined by conditional immortality advocates in order to make room for their understanding, for their definition of hell.

Speaker 1So we do need to deal with some of the keywords used in scripture to describe hell. This will get a bit more technical, but I encourage you to stick it out. If we believe that God inspired the very words of scripture, we must be concerned with the specific meanings of those words. Much of the conditional immortality framework depends on subtle redefinitions of language. There are three Greek words that most stubbornly resist conditional immortality and thus must be redefined by its proponents to make room for their alternate viewpoint.

Speaker 1These are Apolomy, asbestos and Aeonios. Apolomy is usually translated destruction. Asbestos means unquenchable and is used especially in Mark when it speaks of unquenchable fire or the fire that cannot be quenched. Aeonios is the most significant of the three. It's the word translated eternal and everlasting. It's the standard word for eternity throughout the New Testament, used both of eternal life and eternal judgment. Given that we are talking about the eternality of hell, our understanding of this word is crucial.

Speaker 1But each in its order. Let's first look at Apolomy. This is the word translated destroy in Matthew 10, 28. Do not fear those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul, but rather fear him who is able to destroy both body and soul in hell. This is perhaps the central text of the Annihilationist framework. If Apolami always meant cease to exist, this text would be nearly irrefutable. But the word, as most Greek words, has several nuances of meaning.

Speaker 1It can also mean ruin or render useless. Walter Bauer's lexicon says of this verse while destroy is sometimes taken to mean annihilation, it does not necessarily have to imply that here. Thayer's lexicon says that in this context, apolami means to devote or give over to eternal misery. All this to say that the word translated destroy here in Matthew 10, 28 does not necessarily imply end of existence or total destruction, but rather ruin or render useless.

Speaker 1Since interpretations other than destruction are acceptable and are in keeping with other scriptures that indicate eternal conscious torment in hell, it seems better to take this in light of the other texts and not the other way around. So the destruction spoken of here is a commitment to absolute ruin, the eternal misery in hell. So Apolami, as used here in Matthew 10, 28, means destruction or to be destroyed. But the idea communicated here is not cease to exist, no longer exist, end of life, annihilation, but is rather cease to be useful or to be burned away until there's nothing good left.

Speaker 1Again, not nothing left, it's the committing the sinner to judgment wherein everything that person worked for, everything that person lived for, is destroyed. So Apolami is used by conditional immortality advocates to say the Bible teaches that God will destroy the soul and body in hell. Since there are other acceptable ways of understanding this other than simply to say this is eternal destruction, ceasing to exist, we do well to take this in light of other texts in the New Testament that are abundantly clear as speaking of eternal, unending torment for the sinner and for those God judges.

Speaker 1So, apolami, first. The second word we want to look at is asbestos, and yes, this is the word used to name that familiar substance that was used extensively in building materials in the 20th century. The substance gained the name asbestos in the 1600s when it was used to make an incompostible fabric, a fabric that couldn't be burned. It's a bit of a misnomer, actually, since the first century meaning of the Greek word was inextinguishable, something that could not be put out, rather than incompostible, which is unable to be burned, and that's how it was used when it was applied to the substance we know as asbestos.

Speaker 1The meaning of the word in the first century, when it was used in the gospel to speak of unquenchable fire, simply meant fire that could not be put out inextinguishable, unable to be put out. Asbestos is formed from two parts ah being not the negating ah, as in ah moral, like I used earlier. Not moral versus moral, ah, meaning not, and asbestos, which comes from a Greek word meaning to quench. Thus, asbestos means something that is not quenchable.

Speaker 1Asbestos is used four times in the gospels, all four in reference to hell. Matthew 312 and Luke 317 both record Jesus using asbestos pire, which means unquenchable fire to describe the judgment of the wicked. Mark 9 uses the phrase twice, both times saying that hell, gehenna, which we've looked at previously is a fire that shall never be quenched. The wording literally is pireho asbestos fire that cannot be put out. If this means the fires of hell will never go out, it definitely means hell itself is eternal and indicates that the sufferings of hell are likely eternal as well.

Speaker 1Edward Fudge, who we talked about in the last episode, one of the foremost scholars promoting conditional immortality, he disagrees and he defines asbestos differently. He says it doesn't mean that this is an unquenchable fire, but rather it is an irresistible fire. He says the fires of hell cannot be put out or resisted. In this sense he believes the judgment of hell is inescapable for the wicked. Not that the fire will continue eternally, but is that what this means?

Speaker 1I believe it's incorrect to define asbestos as irresistible rather than unquenchable. The sense given in Mark, chapter 9 is the correct understanding when it's translated in the New King James the fire that shall never be quenched. Never be quenched indicates an eternally enduring flame, not an unstoppable flame, but one that never dies. This understanding is further enforced when we notice the companion phrase in Mark 9 when he talks about, their worm does not die.

Speaker 1If their worm does not die, then it follows. The fire spoken of will burn eternally as well. Asbestos is best understood as unending fire, not irresistible fire. So that's the first two words. Hopefully that at least gets your mind into the language a little bit. And then the third word we need to look at we'll spend a little more time on this The third Greek word that is used in the New Testament and shapes our understanding of what hell is is aeonios. It is the most significant of the three words we're looking at in this podcast and it occurs a lot more times.

Speaker 1It occurs 71 times in the New Testament and is usually translated either eternal or everlasting 67 of the 71 times it is translated either eternal or everlasting. In its most essential definition, it means time out of mind or beyond the boundaries of time. So time that cannot be measured, cannot be quantified or cannot be capped or understood according to our way of looking at time as being something exists from one point to another fixed point.

Speaker 1Aeonios is used three ways of time without end, so something that begins at a point and continues without ever ending. It's also used of time without beginning something that something that existed from before creation and exists up until a fixed point or third of time, without beginning or end. When Romans 1626 describes God as the everlasting God, it has this third meaning in mind time without beginning or end.

Speaker 1Aeonios, theos, is the language there in Romans 1626. God who has no beginning and no end. He is the one who always was and always will be, from eternity past. He has existed. He will exist until eternity future. That's the third meaning. Aeonios is used with the second meaning and second Timothy 1-9, when the Apostle Paul speaks of the grace which was given to us in Christ Jesus from before time began. Aeonios here being used of salvation, which was planned by God before the foundation of the world and given to us in Christ from before time began.

Speaker 1So this is eternally past, fixed in the mind of God from eternity past, looking forward to a definite point in time and space and history where we would experience and receive the grace given to us in Christ. God fixed his salvation plan before he framed the worlds. So again, aeonios means time out of mind, time without boundary, either without a boundary marking its end or without a boundary marking its beginning.

Speaker 1Something that begins at a certain point and continues eternally, or something that has been from eternity past. Or third is sometimes used of something that has no beginning and no end. Aeonios is used most frequently with the meaning of time without end. So, coming into our discussion of hell and eternal life and eternal judgment, aeonios is used most often in the New Testament in this context, used of eternal life, everlasting life. It's also used of everlasting judgment, everlasting destruction, eternal fire and eternal condemnation, all four of those being phrases the New Testament uses to refer to hell, everlasting judgment, everlasting destruction, eternal fire and eternal condemnation.

Speaker 1The word is used interchangeably throughout this inoptic Gospels to speak both of eternal life and eternal judgment. So just the fact that the same word is used to describe the duration of both heaven and hell should lead us to conclude that they are parallel in extent. This is especially apparent in Matthew 5, 46. The unrighteous will go away into everlasting punishment, but the righteous into eternal life. Here, everlasting punishment, colasus Aeonios, is contrasted with eternal life, zoe Aeonios.

Speaker 1Why should we understand the judgment to eventually end while believing that life will continue for all eternity? That's what conditional immortality proponents do with this. They say that heaven and hell are asymmetrical. Those who experience life experience eternal life in heaven. Those who experience this everlasting judgment experience a different kind of eternal, different kind of everlasting judgment, and they would say it's not directly a parallel. But scripture multiple times sets them up in direct contrast to each other, indicating that the kind of eternity that is experienced by believers in heaven is akin to the eternity that is experienced by unbelievers in hell, and that being time without end.

Speaker 1Why should we understand the judgment to eventually end while believing that life will continue for all eternity? There's no reason to understand them differently, unless we are determined to fit this text into an annihilationist framework. Edward Fudge attempts to skirt the issue by shifting the definition of Aeonios. Rather than meaning time out of mind, he defines it as meaning that which pertains to the age to come. By defining it this way, he removes any connotation of time measurement and uses the term in a generic next life sense.

Speaker 1By his definition, aeonios describes the things of the next age. If we think about a word like heavenly and what we would think of when we hear heavenly things having to do with heaven, then another time, another place, other than our current experience. He says Aeonios describes the things of the next age rather than describing the duration of those things. So he uses it as a characteristic rather than a time-bound measurement. But this does not fit with Aeonios.

Speaker 1Aeonios is not just a general reference to a future age. Aeonios is a unit, it is a measure of time, time without end. It is a unit, not just a characteristic. Aeonios, when used of heaven and hell, means that which continues unendingly. It does not simply mean future things, but it means eternal, unending, everlasting things. Fudge defines Aeonios as meaning that which has unending results.

Speaker 1By this definition, phrases like everlasting destruction are interpreted as total destruction or destruction from which there is no recovery. So let's just step back a little bit and think about this. Typically, christians reading the text to talk about eternal life and eternal judgment, everlasting judgment have understood that to mean something that is going to begin and is going to continue eternally, without end. Edward Fudge says No, that's not what this term means at all.

Speaker 1It just is a way of referring to the next life, the future life, and he further defines it as he talks about when scripture says everlasting destruction. He says this is not a destruction that's going to be experienced eternally, but rather a destruction that can never be escaped or never be returned from eternally. It's a total destruction or destruction from which there is no recovery. So he says, the effects of destruction continue eternally, the wicked are judged, they are cast into hell and they will never again exist.

Speaker 1That's Edward Fudge's way of explaining what Aeonios means. Can the language bear that treatment? I would answer that with an absolute no. Aeonios speaks of that which continues unendingly. Everlasting judgment should not be understood as irreversible destruction, but rather as ongoing, unending destruction. It does not mean just that the effects are unending, but rather that the punishment itself is meted unendingly.

Speaker 1So conditional immortality is made plausible by some light-footed redefinitions of key Greek words. But those redefinitions only make sense if we're already committed to that framework. But even if we take the above redefinitions proposed by Fudge, we run into interpretive issues throughout Scripture, as I've attempted to show in previous episodes, where annihilation only makes sense if we come into Scripture looking for an alternate explanation, looking for a different view of hell than that which the Church has always believed.

Speaker 1Those who would like to harmonize the ideas of annihilation, the ideas of conditional immortality, with Scripture, find a way to adjust their understanding, adjust their definition of some of these key Greek words to make them fit. But these adjustments actually depart from what the Greek word means, with the way it was used and the way it was commonly understood. All the Greek aside, i also see a bigger problem with annihilationism, and that is that no Scripture asserts that man ceases to exist in the judgment.

Speaker 1If we are people bound to the book, if we are those who have willingly submitted ourselves to God, as he's revealed himself in his word, then it is not enough for us to simply find room for a doctrine within Scripture. We must have chapter and verse, we must have something in the authoritative written word of God that clearly teaches us a certain truth, and no Scripture asserts that man ceases to exist in the judgment. No text of Scripture distinguishes for us between the eternal fires of hell and the eternal experience of the sinner.

Speaker 1By that I mean that if annihilationism were what God expected us to conclude from his word, he would have spelled out for us that, though hell itself is eternal, those who are cast into it cease to exist. No text argues that for us. Yes, we can argue on the basis of what destroy means or what death means, but we still don't have a single text that tells us sinners will be thrown into the eternal fires of hell wherein their souls will cease to exist.

Speaker 1And hell is not a minor theme in Scripture. Hell is a significant idea in Scripture. In fact, jesus talks more about hell than he does about heaven. So it seems that God would be careful to spell out for us exactly what we need to know. I believe he has. And what is not spelled out is the central claim of annihilationism that sinners are eternally destroyed, that sinners are annihilated in hell. Annihilationism injects ideas into Scripture rather than deducing them from Scripture.

Speaker 1The question becomes how can I fit this into Scripture or can I fit this into Scripture? rather than the question which represents true faith, true belief, true submission to God? the question what is most clear in Scripture? If we claim to be biblical Christians, our pursuit of truth must be defined by the latter question What is most clear? Not the question of how can I make this fit or can I make this fit, can I make room for this in Scripture? That's not the question and that's not the point.

Speaker 1The question is not can we harmonize this with Scripture? The question must be if we're seeking to understand the truth as God has chosen to reveal it, the question must be what is most clear in the Word of God. What has God most clearly laid out for us? We must not fit Scripture into our own claims. We submit all of our ideas to the truth of the Word of God. Our obligation as believers is not to define the truth. God defines it. We submit to it. Yes, we should engage in developing systems of truth and defining biblical truth, but ultimately the Bible determines what is and is not true.

Speaker 1In interpreting Scripture, our first obligation is to believe what is clearly taught. Subservient to this is our fitting those truths into a reasonable framework. We accept it before we seek to understand it. When we reject the truth until we understand it, we elevate human reason over the clear teaching of God's Word. The Christian who claims to be submitted to Christ, the Christian who claims to be submitted to God, will submit himself to the Word of God and will seek to understand God as he has most clearly revealed himself, to receive that truth, no matter how difficult submitting to and believing the Word of God.

Speaker 1Thank you for joining us for this episode of the Theological Touchpoints podcast. This podcast is a production of Sword and Trumpet Ministries. For more information, visit wwwswordandtrumpetorgcom or wwwtheologicaltouchpointscom. If you have thoughts or questions, you can contact us at wwwpodcastattheologicaltouchpointscom. Now may the God of peace himself sanctify you completely, and may your whole spirit, soul and body be preserved blameless at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ. He who calls you is faithful, who also will do it.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Does Church Matter? Wrap Up Discussion | with Julian, Nolan, and Bryce

    Oct 21, 202652 minAudio

    In this episode Julian is joined by Nolan Martin and Bryce Wenger to review and recap our recent series Why Does Church Matter? Support the show A production of The Sword and Trumpet Ministries. To learn more about The...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. When Leaders Fail | with Merle Burkholder

    Sep 23, 202658 minAudio

    In our final interview we talk with Merle Burkholder, a pastoral mentor from Ontario, about how Christians should respond when their leaders fail. We think about what contributes to leadership failure, how leaders can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Pastors and Preaching | with Todd Neuschwander

    Sep 9, 20261 hr 26 minAudio

    Todd Neuschwander, pastor of Living Water Mennonite Church, joins us to talk about pastors. We discuss what a pastor does, who is qualified to pastor, and why preaching supports his work as a spiritual shepherd. Toward...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How Should We Worship? | with Wendell Nisly

    Aug 26, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    In this episode we talk with Wendell Nisly, pastor of King's Table Church in Harrisonburg, VA and artistic director of Oasis Choral, about Christian worship. We discuss why Christians gather to worship God, how our...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Building Healthy Church Relationships | with Rick Bauman

    Aug 12, 202658 minAudio

    Join us as we talk with Rick Bauman, pastor of Woodlawn Mennonite Fellowship and mentor with Servant Institute, about building healthy church relationships. We discuss how we can care for each other, ways we can...

    Credit the people on this episode