Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Gone Cold - Texas True Crime

Gone Cold - Texas True Crime artwork

Lecia McGee Part Two: A History of Violence

Sep 20, 202628 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Decades after the murder of 17-year-old Lecia McGee went cold, advances in forensic testing gave investigators an opportunity to take another look at the evidence that remained. Testing on a cigarette butt recovered from Lecia’s car produced a male DNA profile. That profile eventually matched a Fort Worth man already serving a prison sentence for a violent attack; a man who, as a teenager, had been questioned in the initial investigation. The discovery led detectives into the man’s extensive history of violence. Years after Lecia’s murder, he deliberately struck a woman with his truck as she was speed walking in her neighborhood, leaving her critically injured before attempting to force her into his vehicle. He fled after a failed attempt to abduct her, but was eventually arrested and put back behind bars. Investigators also examined an earlier crime spree involving burglaries, armed robberies, stolen vehicles, and gunfire. Perhaps most significant was his history before Lecia was killed. While living only a short distance from her family, he had already been involved in increasingly serious crimes. Shortly before Lecia’s death, he abducted a young woman after playing Good Samaritan. Luckily, she escaped before he could do his worst. After hearing about Lecia’s murder, someone familiar with that incident contacted homicide detectives and pointed out possible similarities between the two cases. Police questioned the teenager and his family, but the lead was never fully pursued. Decades later, the DNA match brought investigators back to him. He denied knowing Lecia well or ever being inside her car, despite his DNA being found there. Detectives believed the accumulated circumstances were significant, but prosecutors concluded the available evidence was not enough to bring a murder charge. With key physical evidence gone and no additional DNA linking him directly to the killing, Lecia’s case remains unsolved. Part two of two. If you have any information about the murder of Lecia Ann McGee, please contact the Fort Worth Police Cold Case Unit at 817-392-4307. You can support gone cold and listen to the show ad-free at https://patreon.com/gonecoldpodcast Find us at https://www.gonecold.com For Gone Cold merch, visit https://gonecold.dashery.com Follow gone cold on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, TikTok, YouTube, and X. Search @gonecoldpodcast at all or just click https://linknbio.com/gonecoldpodcast #JusticeForLeciaMcGee #FortWorth #FTW #TarrantCounty #Texas #TX #TexasTrueCrime #ColdCase #TrueCrimePodcast #Podcast #Unsolved #MissingPerson #Missing #Murder #UnsolvedMurder #UnsolvedMysteries #Homicide #CrimeStories #PodcastRecommendations #CrimeJunkie #MysteryPodcast #MissingTrio #FortWorthMissingTrio #CarlaWalker Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/gone-cold-texas-true-crime--3203003/support.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Gone Cold podcasts may contain violent or graphic subject matter. Listener discretion is advised. On the early morning of January 23, 1978, 17-year-old Leisha Ann McGee was reported missing to the Fort Worth police. She'd been at the home of a couple friends the night before, but didn't return to her house after leaving there at about 12.30 a.m. Leisha's family searched everywhere they could think of and when they couldn't find her,

Speaker 1they began to panic, fearing the worst. At around 5.30 that evening, those fears were realized when Leisha's car was found, the interior covered in blood. Leisha McGee was discovered deceased in the trunk of her prized 1968 Chevy Impala. She had been stabbed multiple times, and her throat was slashed. During the initial investigations, Detectives never got any closer to finding Leisha's killer than they'd been on day one, and

Speaker 1then the case file sat collecting dust at Fort Worth Police Headquarters. For more than 30 years, the case was essentially cold, with virtually no new leads and certainly no big breaks. In 2009, however, one finally came. Detective Jose Hernandez picked up Leisha's case that year. hoping fresh eyes might catch something investigators had missed over the decades. Now, the police had access to forensic technologies they hadn't even

Speaker 1dreamed of in 1978, including DNA testing. But there was a problem. According to Leisha's sister Lori, much of the evidence had been lost. A Monopoly board game that had been in the trunk of Leisha's car and contained fingerprints was gone. the clothes Leisha wore and the green coat found in the back seat, all covered in blood, were presumably destroyed by mistake. Nevertheless, Detective Hernandez began requesting DNA

Speaker 1testing in June of 2009 on the physical evidence that still existed, including a Marlboro cigarette butt taken from the rear door ashtray of the 1968 Impala. From that item, Two DNA profiles were obtained, one belonging to a female and one a male. After securing samples from Leisha's sisters, the female DNA profile was compared and found to match the slain teenager. The other, the male DNA profile, was

Speaker 1a mystery at first. Then, after three months, Detective Hernandez got a hit. The male DNA on the cigarette butt came back as a match to a 48-year-old Fort Worth man who was serving a 50-year sentence at the Allred Unit of the Texas Department of Corrections in Wichita Falls, a man with an extremely violent past named Robin DeWayne Carter.

Speaker 1At a little before 4.30 p.m. on Saturday, June 17, 1995, 30-year-old Melanie Gable, a fifth-grade teacher at Lively Elementary in Irving, was speedwalking in her Colleyville neighborhood. Colleyville is a middle-to-upper-middle-class suburb just northeast of Fort Worth, and in 1995, it was undergoing major development. but there was still plenty of empty land and small wooded areas in the city. Colleyville's

Speaker 1crime rate at the time, particularly the violent crime rate, was low. The subdivisions and everything in between were considered safe. As Melanie walked down Maplewood Trail, she passed a red pickup truck parked on the street. An eerie feeling rushed over her, but not only because the truck was parked in an awkward way. As she walked past, the man sitting in the vehicle, who she later described as creepy,

Speaker 1made eye contact. She looked away fast, Melanie later said, but she could feel the strange man staring at her as she walked on. Melanie looked back, and he was. She described it as a very sick stare. Because of the feeling she got from the stranger, she had glanced quickly at the truck's license plate when she looked back. As she continued down the street, Melanie repeated the license plate number over and over in her head. A few

Speaker 1minutes later, the red pickup drove past and eventually disappeared from sight. She felt an immediate sense of relief. She was just being paranoid, thinking the man was up to something, Melanie said to herself. He was probably just picking someone up or doing something else completely normal. but Melanie's initial instincts were right. Moments later, she heard a vehicle driving at a high speed behind her. She quickly stepped off

Speaker 1the street and onto the grass, looking over her shoulder as she did. It was the red truck, and it was only about five feet away and moving fast, too fast for Melanie to react. The truck sped onto the curb as she turned around and slammed into her. The vehicle took her 20 feet from the site of the impact before the driver slammed on the brakes, sending Melanie flying. She hit the concrete street and her head split open.

Speaker 1Melanie's legs were already both broken from the impact of the pickup truck's bumper. Exited the vehicle and walked up to her, smiling. She was still conscious, but she couldn't go anywhere. At first, Melanie thought he was going to help her, that his smile was warm and one of concern for her. But that only lasted for a split second. Aw, does it hurt? The man asked her, facetiously and cruelly.

Speaker 1Melanie tried to pull herself up, but even if the man hadn't quickly grabbed her, it would have been a futile attempt at an escape. One of her arms, like her legs, was broken. She had the serious head wound. One of her vertebra was crushed. and her liver lacerated. Still, Melanie struggled with the man while she screamed for help. Regardless, he was able to drag her to his truck. He opened the door and tried to push her in, telling her,

Speaker 1You're my evidence. I ain't leaving you here. But she continued fighting him. Melanie, however, was beginning to lose consciousness. She looked at the bone protruding from her arm. and knew she had little fight left. She screamed one last time for help. A neighbor who had heard Melanie being hit, and then her screams, suddenly showed up at the scene. Luckily, she was enough to startle the man. He fled, leaving

Speaker 1his victim broken and bleeding on the street. Though the entire assault seemed to have lasted a long time, in reality, only moments had passed. The red pickup truck was traced after the victim was able to give police the license plate number, along with a description of the man. And only two days after the attack, a 35-year-old remodeling contractor named Robin DeWayne Carter was arrested at a construction site

Speaker 1in Colleyville, where he was working. Bail was denied as prosecutors sought an indictment. On August 8, 1995, a grand jury indicted him on an aggravated assault with serious bodily injury charge. Melanie Gable spent the next several months recovering from her injuries and was most often confined to a wheelchair during that time. After five surgeries and a considerable stint at physical therapy, she was able to return to

Speaker 1Lively Elementary to teach, but only part-time and with the aid of a cane. Meanwhile, Carter's family took to the press defending him, insisting he hadn't intentionally run over Melanie. One family member told a Fort Worth Star-Telegram reporter that his brother's crime was drinking and driving, and he had only fled to avoid a parole revocation. When Carter ran Melanie down, he'd only been out of prison for a

Speaker 1few months since February 13, 1995. He had served seven of a 20-year sentence for a crime spree in 1987, in which he pleaded guilty to several counts of aggravated robbery. Robin Duane Carter's trial was set to begin on April 8, 1996, but minutes before jury selection was to begin, he accepted a plea deal with the Tarrant County DA because it reduced the charges significantly. At sentencing, he rambled to the court.

Speaker 1begging Melanie, who was present, for forgiveness, and insisted he wasn't a bad person. He told the judge he'd been drinking that day, saying he'd consumed at least 18 beers. But then Carter lied. He said he'd only gotten out of the truck to help Melanie out. accidentally hitting her, but fled after remembering his parole. When it was time for his victim to speak, she told Carter she forgave him, but she'd do everything in her power to make sure

Speaker 1he served his full sentence. Carter had proven, Melanie said, that he was incapable of living outside prison walls without hurting others. Taking into consideration his past criminality, the judge sentenced him to 50 years in prison. Robin Duane Carter, who,

Speaker 1in cold blood, ran over a Colleyville school teacher and attempted to kidnap her afterward, had prior run-ins with the law that weren't insignificant. On Saturday, March 21, 1987, police stations from Benbrook to Fort Worth were receiving multiple calls from different, unconnected people about a man taking their vehicles at gunpoint. Luckily, police put two and two together, and quickly figured out they were looking for the same man

Speaker 1for all the crimes, a man who became known briefly as the Man in the Red Shirt, as witness descriptions trickled in. The man's real name was Robin Carter. At about 4 p.m. that day, 25-year-old Carter burglarized two cars and one building on the 5300 block of West Vickery in Fort Worth, beginning his elaborate crime spree for the evenings. About 300 feet away from the scene of the burglaries,

Speaker 1Carter approached a child on his bicycle, pointed a pistol to the boy's head, and demanded his bike. He rode about four blocks away, approached a man getting in his vehicle, and stole it at gunpoint. Carter made it just a couple miles away. Police later discovered the stolen car on the 4500 block of Greenbrook Place abandoned. A few blocks from there, Carter stole another vehicle from a home on Spring Hill Road, drove the car a few miles away

Speaker 1to the 6000 block of Camp Bowie, abandoned it, and made off with yet another car. But this time he was choosy, having inspected a different vehicle before deciding to take it, his fourth stolen car. He abandoned that one about 10 miles away in Morningside, a neighborhood south of downtown Fort Worth. There, he stole a fifth vehicle and drove it to a gas station at 1701 South Freeway, having traveled about a mile, where he threatened the clerk

Speaker 1at gunpoint before stealing a sixth car. From the gas station, Carter drove a couple blocks to the 2100 block of Jennings Avenue, where he began stealing a man's pickup truck. This time, he had bitten off more than he could chew. The owner, who was packing heat himself, caught the spree criminal in the act of stealing his vehicle. As Carter sped off in the pickup, the men exchanged gunfire. The owner hopped in the car Carter had just abandoned and

Speaker 1gave chase, but the car ran out of gas after only four blocks. Carter barely escaped from the stolen truck's owner, and he'd been shot twice. He only made it to Magnolia and Fifth about a mile away, before he crashed the truck, colliding with another vehicle. Carter then fled on foot, but he left a literal trail of blood and witnesses that allowed police to track him to an apartment nearby. After a witness told police which one he'd gone into,

Speaker 1he was found hiding underneath a pile of clothes in the closet there. After committing about a dozen major crimes, As he was being treated at John Peter Smith Hospital, he blamed the entire ordeal on bad dope, which wasn't necessarily unbelievable. He'd pay for his actions regardless. He also told a judge that it was all bad dope, but Carter was eventually sentenced to 20 years in prison anyway. He served less than nine. Obviously, he wasn't rehabilitated, as

Speaker 1is evident by his horrific attack in 1995 on Melanie Gable in Colleyville. But Robin DeWayne Carter's history with crime and violence began long before that, and there is more than just DNA on a Marlboro cigarette butt and a violent criminal background that made him a suspect in the January 1978 murder of Leisha Ann McGee. On Tuesday, January 24, 1978, the day after Leisha McGee was slain, Robin Carter appeared

Speaker 1before District Judge Scott Moore at juvenile court. His history of offenses as a teenager are, of course, sealed. However, many who grew up in the Greenbrier and surrounding neighborhoods are all too familiar with his activities, which usually consisted of breaking and entering, car theft, and vandalism. His criminal career began as early as when he was 13. The case he was in court for the day after Leisha's

Speaker 1murder is known. Carter had abducted a woman on Saturday, December 3, 1977, at a Fort Worth service station on Crowley Road, just off Interstate 20, a 24-year-old student from Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. stopped to fill up her tank. The woman's Chevy Nova was overheating, too, and noticing the steam coming off the vehicle's engine was a 16-year-old Robin Carter.

Speaker 1Carter offered to help the woman, and she accepted. As he filled the car's radiator with water, he made small talk. He asked her where she was headed, and when she told him, he said he needed a ride to somewhere near there. She agreed to give Carter a lift. He'd helped her after all, but the woman's returned favor quickly turned into a nightmare. After they had traveled only a short distance, the teenager wrapped a rag around the woman's neck.

Speaker 1Carter told her to keep driving. The woman realized that she was in a life-or-death situation. If she didn't find an area where there was a lot of people soon, she knew it could be her life. Bravely defying Carter's attempts to control her, the woman slipped one hand between the rag and her throat, preventing him from choking her, and veered suddenly into a Dairy Queen parking lot, purposely smashing into a brick column. She honked the horn frantically

Speaker 1while opening the car door, attempting to flee. The woman was halfway out of the car when Carter floored it, and she flew from the vehicle. A Tarrant County District Attorney investigator heard the commotion from his home nearby and was able to act quickly enough to follow him. He radioed the Fort Worth police as he pursued the teenager, and they were able to take over the pursuit in no time. Once the cops were after him, Carter presumably panicked and crashed the Chevy Nova on the grounds of

Speaker 1the very seminary in which the woman he abducted was a student. A chase on foot ensued but was short-lived. Officers detained Carter. He was held at the Tarrant County Juvenile Center for a couple weeks until he was finally released on December 16th to the custody of his parents. Carter's appearance in court on January 24th, 1978 was a rescheduled date due to the weather and was supposed to

Speaker 1have taken place the previous Friday. He was given probation even though he was no stranger to the system. At 16, Carter was already a repeat offender who was constantly slapped on the wrist, even as his offenses were escalating. When a Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary security guard heard of Leisha Ann McGee's slaying, weeks after it happened, he phoned Fort Worth Homicide Detectives. he told them all about Robin DeWayne

Speaker 1Carter's bungled kidnapping and the chase afterward, the month prior to Leisha's killing. He remembered clearly how the story's ending began when Carter crashed on the seminary's campus. Detectives were certainly intrigued by the story. The abduction and Leisha's murder had potential similarities, it seemed. In March of 1978, following what was perhaps their only lead, Detectives visited the home where Carter lived with his parents and brothers on Cameron Street,

Speaker 1just two blocks away from where Leisha lived on Hodgson. Detectives asked to speak with Robin, but he wasn't home. They told his parents, Betty and George, that they wanted to bring the 16-year-old in for questioning and to take a polygraph test, since the case he'd been caught red-handed for made him at least a person of interest in Leisha's murder. contradicting the fact that both he and his wife were home and Robin was not. George told the homicide detectives that his son wasn't allowed to leave the

Speaker 1home without one of them going along with him since the kidnapping in December. Police, for whatever reason, seemed to have not picked up on that. Robin's father went on to tell the detectives that on the night of Leisha's murder, The family ate dinner at a relative's house, and when they returned home, George continued, he and his son played cards until shortly after midnight, at which time they both went to bed. The alibi, or the attempt at an alibi,

Speaker 1didn't necessarily place Robin Carter at home when Leisha was killed. As detectives were speaking with the parents, Robin arrived home, and they got the opportunity to ask him if he'd be willing to take a polygraph examination. At first, he agreed, telling them he had nothing to hide, but he quickly rescinded. Detectives told the teenager to talk to his parents and reconsider his decision, and that they'd check back later to see if he'd changed his mind. The Fort Worth police

Speaker 1never followed up the Robin DeWayne Carter lead during the initial investigations, or in the reinvestigations over the many years after, for that matter. Not until his DNA profile matched the cigarette butt found in the backseat ashtray of Leisha's car. It wasn't just that Robin DeWayne Carter's DNA was on

Speaker 1the Marlboro cigarette butt found in the backseat ashtray of Leisha McGee's car. It's also that the Chevy Impala had been detailed that day, meaning the ashtrays had been cleaned, along with the fact that Carter had insisted, both in the initial investigation and in the 2009 reinvestigation, that he didn't socialize with Leisha at all and that he'd never been in her car. He was, however, willing to plead guilty to Leisha's slaying through a deal. Carter told Fort

Speaker 1Worth homicide detectives that he would accept a 30-year sentence for killing her if the time ran concurrently with the time he was already serving, the 50 years for his abhorrent attack on Melanie Gable in 1995. It certainly wasn't a confession. Rather, Carter seemed to have been making the offer just to get detectives off his back. Still, why would he risk his chance at parole if he hadn't killed Leisha? The Tarrant County District Attorney, anyway, wouldn't bite.

Speaker 1The DNA on the cigarette butt wasn't enough to try and convict him, or even negotiate a plea deal. And it's really all they had. Since the clothing Leisha was wearing when she was killed had been accidentally and carelessly destroyed in 1988 by the Fort Worth police, testing on those items wasn't an option. And testing on two rings Leisha wore, as well as bloodied material removed and stored from the car's seats, provided no further DNA evidence other

Speaker 1than that of the slain teenager herself. Fort Worth homicide detectives working the Long Colt case in 2009 disagreed with the Tarrant County District Attorney, suggesting that a jury of 12 would easily find Robin DeWayne Carter guilty of Leisha's murder. There was his criminal history and a disturbing story about a discovery his father once made. Carter and his brothers were all in seemingly constant trouble with the law, much

Speaker 1of the time involving drugs and violence. In 1988, at age 31, Robbins' brother Tony Ray Carter died while serving time in a Texas prison for aggravated robbery and aggravated assault. Brother George Michael Carter was in and out of prison for various crimes before finally receiving a lengthy sentence for multiple DWIs. His brother Pat Allen Carter was the victim of a hit-and-run auto accident, which left him severely brain-damaged.

Speaker 1and which presented a predicament to detectives when George Carter, Robin's father, gave them some shocking news. He told them that his son Pat once spoke of seeing Robin with a bloody butcher knife around the time of Leisha's slaying. A knife had also disappeared from the kitchen of the Carter home around that time. Detective Manny Reyes did not believe George Carter's account of his son's whereabouts that he told detectives back in 1978, even though George had spent

Speaker 130 years in law enforcement as a reserve police officer beginning in 1982 and had connections with the Tarrant County Sheriff's Office going way back. Reyes believes that on the night of Leisha's death, she encountered Robin Carter at a convenience store at James Avenue and West Butler Street. where she was buying cigarettes. The theory is that Carter wanted a ride, and that the ride took a violent turn for whatever reason, perhaps no reason, resulting in Carter murdering Leisha.

Speaker 1Her mother Helen once told reporters, whoever killed Leisha must have been covered with blood. He couldn't have just walked away from the car and thumbed a ride back to town. The walk to Cameron Street, where Carter lived with his family, was only a little over a mile from where Leisha's body was found. Perhaps it was this night Carter's brother saw him with the bloody knife. But if he did murder Leisha McGee, Robin DeWayne Carter will likely never confess,

Speaker 1especially without the threat of a looming trial. But the Fort Worth Police Department's push, for one, didn't work out. Detectives working the case were worried that when Robin Carter's parole hearing came up in 2020, he would be let out. In June of 2020, a 59-year-old Robin Duane Carter was granted parole. In September of that year, he was released from the custody of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice

Speaker 1and into the custody of a sex offender rehabilitation program he had to complete before walking free. As a condition of his plea deal for the assault by truck on Melanie Gable in 1995, Carter was court-mandated to participate in the program, something not uncommon in Texas when kidnapping and attempted kidnapping charges are involved. In March of 2022, Carter finished the program after 18 months and was released on the streets of Houston. His last known location is Richmond, Texas,

Speaker 1a suburb of Houston located to the city's southwest in Fort Bend County. If you have any information about the murder of Leisha Ann McGee, please contact the Fort Worth Police Cold Case Unit at 817-392-4307. If you'd like to join Goncold's mission, To shine a light on unsolved homicides and missing persons cases, get the show ad-free, and have

Speaker 1access to bonus content, you can at patreon.com slash gonecoldpodcast. You can also support the show by leaving a 5-star rating and written review on Apple Podcasts or wherever else you listen. However you choose to support Gone Cold, we appreciate you. Thanks for listening, y'all.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Killing of Connie Jane Bibb

    Nov 16, 202630 minAudio

    In the fall of 1986, 28-year-old Connie Jane Bibb was entering her senior year at the University of Texas at Austin, where she was studying special education. A former Air Force communications specialist and devout...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Slaying of Debra Sue Reiding

    Nov 12, 202630 minAudio

    In December 1978, 18-year-old Debra Sue Wilt Reiding and her new husband, Robert, arrived in Austin, Texas, after leaving their small Montana hometown in search of warmer weather and better opportunities. Married just...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Murders of Phyllis Butto & Martha Read

    Nov 9, 202633 minAudio

    In 1975, Austin, Texas, was experiencing rapid growth and cultural change, bringing new challenges for a police department already struggling with an increasing number of violent crimes that seemed to have no witnesses,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Cash-Landrum Incident Part Three: Disinformation

    Nov 3, 202637 minAudio

    By 1983, Betty Cash, Vickie Landrum, and Vickie’s grandson Colby had spent more than two years seeking answers about their reported encounter. Their account had reached national television, attracted civilian...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Cash-Landrum Incident Part Two: That’s Incredible!

    Oct 29, 202623 minAudio

    In the months after their December 1980 encounter on a rural road in southeast Texas, Betty Cash, Vickie Landrum, and Vickie’s grandson Colby continued living with its effects. Medical appointments, persistent health...

    Credit the people on this episode