070 - Generator Live: Nino Batista on AI, Retouching, and What Makes Art Actually Matter
1 hr 44 minAudio
Can AI replace the human element that makes photography and retouching valuable, or are we measuring the wrong thing entirely? Nino Batista is a photographer, retoucher, and educator whose work spans commercial photography and fine art. He's known for his technical expertise in retouching and his thoughtful approach to how technology shapes creative industries. After watching AI infiltrate photography and retouching over the past few years, Nino has developed a clear perspective on what actually matters when machines can generate images in minutes. This is a Generator Live episode recorded in real time. I brought Nino on to talk about the Evoto controversy, AI's impact on photography and retouching, and what happens when your entire career can be replaced by a prompt. We get into the uncomfortable truth about dismissible work, why workflow efficiency matters more than tools, and how the human story behind an image creates value that AI simply cannot replicate. The conversation moves through ethics, client relationships, and how Nino's own values have shifted over 17 years in the industry. What You'll Learn Why art created by humans carries inherent meaning that AI-generated content cannot replicate. Nino explains how knowing a person created something adds layers of interest and value, even when the final product looks similar. What it means when your photography or retouching work can be replaced by AI overnight. He gets blunt about dismissible work and what that reveals about the industry's actual priorities. How the story behind an image matters as much as the final product. Nino breaks down why we subconsciously ask different questions about human-made work versus AI-generated content. Why retouchers need to prioritize workflow efficiency over expensive tools. He shares his approach to creating Photoshop actions that save hours while maintaining quality and teaching clients how everything works. What photographers miss by treating retouching as an afterthought instead of recognizing it as its own art form. We discuss how the retouching community contributes to photography but often gets overlooked. How to think about AI as a recalibration moment rather than an existential threat. Nino describes moving from terror to a more grounded understanding of what technology can and cannot do. Why speed and efficiency in content creation matter more than perfection. I share how switching to live recording eliminated editing time and let me focus on delivering value instead of post-production. What supply and demand reveal about the photography industry's actual needs. Nino explains why clients choosing faster AI solutions over slower human work tells us something important about what we were making. How hand-stitched leather and artisan craftsmanship parallel the value of human-made art. He uses this analogy to explain why provenance and process matter beyond just the end result. Why workflow optimization should come before tool acquisition. We both emphasize understanding your own process first, then finding tools that support it, rather than chasing every new technology. How Nino's values evolved over 17 years from focusing on end results to prioritizing authenticity and personal pride. He shares why drawing clear boundaries around your work matters more now than ever before. What happens when photographers treat clients as content instead of individuals. We discuss the tension between maintaining artistic vision and meeting client demands for perfect, AI-generated results. Why high-end retouchers might transition into AI workflow consultants. Nino explores how understanding both craft and technology positions photographers to help others navigate ethical implications of AI tools. How the tactile and emotional aspects of live performance and physical media cannot be replicated digitally. We talk about why attending live shows and holding album covers creates connections that streaming never will. What clients actually care about when it comes to your process. Nino explains why most clients view photography as magic and don't care about technical details, which changes how we should talk about our work. Guest Resources Nino Batista Photographer, retoucher, and educator specializing in commercial and fine art photography Website: ninobatista.com Listen & Subscribe Never miss an episode. Subscribe to Generator on your favorite podcast app: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube Enjoyed this episode? Leave a 5-star review on Apple Podcasts to help others discover these conversations. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/generator/id1668192673 Connect with Generator Website: generatorpodcast.com Instagram: @generatorpodcast TikTok: @generatorpodcast YouTube: @generatorpodcast Host: Matt Stagliano - Stonetree Creative, Maine Generator is a podcast about the creative process, personal growth, and what it means to build something meaningful. Hosted by portrait photographer Matt Stagliano. Keywords AI in photography, photography retouching, Nino Batista photographer, AI-generated images, Evoto controversy, retouching workflow, human element in art, photography industry AI, commercial photography, fine art photography, Photoshop actions, creative workflow efficiency, AI replacement photography, retoucher perspective, meaningful photography, photography ethics, authenticity in art, AI workflow consulting, client relationships photography, artistic boundaries, human craftsmanship
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey, my friends. Welcome back to Generator live. It is 7pm here on the East Coast. We're covered by ice and snow. Tonight is going to be an interesting episode. So you've heard me talking about Evoto Gate a couple of weeks ago coming out of Imaging. You've heard me talk about almost weekly, how AI has infiltrated the photography industry. Seems that way. It seems like there's been some sort of focus solely on AI and
what that means for all of us. And I wanted to talk tonight specifically about that. I wanted to talk about photography retouching, how AI is affecting all of that. And there really is no better person to bring on, in my opinion, than my friend Nino Batista. How are you, sir? Welcome to. Welcome again to Generator. Absolutely, Nan. It's great to be here again, obviously, and one hell of a topic.
So this will be fun. But yeah, you know, I appreciate it, man. Good to be here. We've had a lot of conversations and this always seems to come up. This always seems to come up in one way, shape or form. And, you know, thinking about. I had a great conversation with Kelly Robitau recently and we were talking about, you know, she's like you, photographer and retoucher, and had a lot of thoughts. Dennis Dunbar, right, great friend of yours, guy that has done
probably more in retouching than most of us will ever know. Pratik talks about this all the time. And I love getting the retoucher's perspective because as photographers, we're so egocentric. We think the world revolves around those of us that are taking pictures. And then retouching seems to be that it's the art that we all need, but for some reason it doesn't get as much attention. And I think with Evoto, right, since we started there, coming out,
having that whole debacle with coming out with an AI headshot generator, it just sparked the debate again. And so, you know, without getting too far into it, I really would love to hear from you what your entire take on this is, and then we can dive into specific subjects and we'll just kind of follow things along. But I really did want to talk to you about this and I think you're the right person to give me the no BS answers on everything. I mean, yeah, I appreciate that and I have a lot of opinions
on it because it's something that has made me do a lot of thinking in the last couple years. Right. Like anyone should do a lot of thinking. And at first it was concerning, and then it was really concerning, and then it was Terrifying. And then, and I've kind of scaled back on, on the sort of existential horror about it. I'm not trying to claim offhand, let me just be clear. I'm not saying that AI is not a concerning tech. And of course when we say AI, Matt, we have to also know that we're talking about a wide open ended concept that goes well beyond
retouching your headshot. Right? So we're talking about something larger than that and this is a debate and something that should be, that people should be aware of is what I'm saying. Right. We can't, we can't just pretend that this technology is just another iPhone. It's, there's something there. We have to pay attention. Now with that said, what I started to realize is that, and I start to realize, but really what I came to terms with was as an artist, as an artist, tactically, your art shouldn't be
invalidated by another function of some kind or another person or computer or anything that makes manufactured art. We've been making manufactured art for a long time, we've been making manufactured music for a long time, et cetera. And that's not to say that it isn't frustrating, but if your career was entirely, or rather if your photography career, you retouching career, whatever it is, if it can be replaced overnight by AI, that is not your fault per se.
But it's very telling about what you were doing. It's very telling about what the industry wants. Because remember, at the end of the day we have to think about supply and demand, right? So if AI is doing things faster and acceptable and the clients are paying for it, that's the end of it, right? So if you're completely replaced because you were making, lack of a better term, dismissible consumables, and I don't mean to be a jerk about it, but I'm just going to say that because it's true though. If you were making generic sort of ads, I was a graphic designer for years. If you're making sort of generic ads and just needed a photo
of a beer bottle, as long as it was adequate, it worked and you got the ad. If someone can do that in seven minutes versus your seven hours and they need it for advertising, that's a no brainer, right? So it's, that's horrible because people are losing jobs, there's no question. So what I decided was since I don't do that really anymore, I decided that as an artist, someone who's trying to make images for the sake of the Images that. That's where I was going to focus. I was going to focus my analysis and sort of interpretation
of what AI does to us culturally from the lens of an artist, right. Whatever that is. Even as a musician, right. Play guitar and whatnot. Because AI is definitely intruding on that space as well. So as an artist, what I discovered in myself was, how do I. How do I start this? Art is more than the final product, right? It is the final product, there's no question about it. But art, no matter what it is, it draws you in.
There's something about that personal experience that, you know, was created by a human. And because it was created by a human, there's an extra layer of interest there. Even if it's fleeting and brief, it's still an extra layer of interest. It could be very profound. It could be photojournalism. There's a whole story into the image, Right, right. That's obvious, but there's still some human element, right? So, for example, if I venture out to some one of these locations that I love to go to, you know, Southwest Desert or something like that, or I end up finally going out to Zion or something, right? And I go with a model and I put her on a cliffside and I use
a 400 millimeter lens and I take a shot and it's beautiful. And, you know, she's on the edge of a precipice of some kind, and it's really dramatic and sky was cooperating and I love the work and it's beautiful. Now, if I show that to you, Matt, the first thing you're going to think is, how the hell would you do that? Right? Was there any danger involved? Subconsciously, you got to, how did she get up there? Right. Is any of this faked? Was there a helicopter involved? You know, those are questions that would come to mind which add interest to the image, right? Hopefully, sure.
If I rendered all of that in GPT or whatever the hell you'd be like, that's pretty. And that's the end of that conversation, right? Even if it looked nearly identical, if you said, is this real? No, it's AI, suddenly its meaning gets deflated 100%. Not. Not the quality, the meaning, right. When we say meaning, we. This is where I want to really harp on tonight. And I'm getting off my little soapbox in a minute. But this is my whole point that I'm circling.
When we say meaning, we tend to, I think, anyway, we tend to look for something really profound. Again, the photo generalism angle is really Obvious. You have a shot of a. Of a war zone. You have a shot of a protest, someone getting killed even. You have these. These images that tell deep, profound stories. You know, these legendary shots that get the whatever the hell awards they, I can't remember. Yeah, those tell stories. That's obvious. But there's other stories. There's stories for the sake of the art. There's stories for the sake of the moment. There's stories for the sake of the.
Of the beauty of the eroticism of something. There's some story element that's in there because there's a human or because it was made by human. And what we're seeing, my mind, is a reprioritization of and kind of a recalibration of what we see art as. We forget the human element, especially when we're scrolling on our phones and it's just, next, next, next, next, next, next image. Next image. Well, for a time, that was all made by people, for the most part.
And I'm not saying it's all valid. I'm not saying it's all great. I'm saying that we're going to have to go backwards now and recalibrate to the importance of something human, Right? We even say, like, if you say I bought a car and you say a bunch of robots made, it could be a nice car. But as soon as they say and stitch leather, you imagine some Italian artisan stitching your leather and your car, and there's value there. It, whatever, that might just be marketing, but still there's value there. So. And I don't just mean service people stitching leather.
I mean, in general making art, there's a human element. And that human element. It's not to say that things won't change and haven't already changed. I'm not being naive, but the human element cannot be replaced because there's no history. Humans have experience. Humans have a timeline Humans can remember six months ago. It could be art you made during a dark period of your life. It could be art you made after you got divorced. It could be art you made while you were terminally ill. It could be art you made while visiting somebody you've never seen since then. Who knows what the story is, but an AI is like an adult that was
born yesterday who knows everything but knows nothing. And that's awesome for the end result, but little or zero to the meaning. There's my soapbox for the start things on. I think it's a great place to start, especially for, you know, even when I learned from you years ago, there's so much more than the technical aspect of photography or retouching doesn't matter. There's so much more in the connection with the subject, right?
And it could be a hired subject, it could be, if you're doing retail photography, someone that comes in off the street, right? But there's a connection with the subject that creates trust in the artist, right? And I think back to when artists had patrons, right? And I'm not talking Patreon, I'm talking actual patrons, right? That. That just basically, the artist didn't make any money, so they found some rich dude who just said, you know what? I believe in you as an artist, and I'm going to give you a whole bunch of money. Because they believed that the artist was going to be able to tell
stories or produce work that was exceptional in their eyes above anything else that was out there. And it's that trust that allows the artist to portray an emotional truth, right? And the emotional truth is what I see as being lost, right? AI can create flawless, you know, beautiful images, technically pristine images that many artists cannot do.
But because they are flawless, they're also a bit soulless. So the. The idea of human imperfection is the thing that you just can't replace, right? And that's why Ricardo Montalban talked about Corinthian leather in a car, right? Because there was this emotional connection in the marketing that was just kind of like, yes, y. Yeah, you can have any car. We got Corinthian leather. And no one knew what the hell Corinthian leather was. But they were like, still does, but no one.
No one does, but they want it, right? And this is the thing. Yes. Things can be produced that are flawless and perfect, but when I look at it, I go, wow, that's. That's technically beautiful, but I don't see the depth, I don't see the flaws. The flaws build that trust in me that this came from a human, right? How many things are we seeing now, especially this day and age, where what you see, instead of falling into the story, you go, oh,
this. This has got to be AI. This has got to be AI. He's got. Oh, look, he's got six fingers. Or look in the background, the clock is spinning backwards, whatever it is, right? I'm. I look for that little Sora in the bottom of every video. I'm like, when is that going to. What is that going to crop up? Yeah, because it's so good now. And we've been so already inundated with all of these images and, and videos, which are getting remarkable by the way, that I'm, I'm feel like we're losing trust.
So fast forward a little bit and everything that you were saying about, you know, creating a product that is a unique to the artist and being a little bit imperfect. I think the connection that I found and that I've been trying to sell for many years is printed products. Right. Because the digital aspect will get you so far. I think when artists, photographers start adding in printed products now, it almost becomes accepted that there is going
to be a little bit of retouching on it and that's okay. But the client still respects the photographer, that they've learned the craft to do the retouching, whether it's digital or not. And then they're creating a physical piece and there's this trust between the client and the photographer that this is the transaction. Right. When that trust is gone and people are just saying, well, you're just going to run this through some AI program, make it perfect, they're already disinvesting, uninvesting, I don't know what the
proper prefix for that is, but they become less interested in the product and now it's just pure. Surely a transaction like, hey, you have the camera, I don't take the picture, press the button monkey and. And that's it. So before I run off at the mouth too much, the emotional truth and the trust is what I find are like the last bastions of hope for those of us in these industries that we have to be able to talk to our clients about that.
We have to be able to infuse that in our art in a way that people see it and they believe us. Not that we're trying sell them some Corinthian leather, but they believe what it is that we're giving them. Trust. Yeah, trust and, and truth is really where I'm getting at. That's correct. And as we know, clients in general, not just photography clients, but anyone who hires an artist, they don't always know what they want. And they are very end result oriented. You know, even a record label wants a pop song, they're not particularly
interested in how it's created. Really at the end of the day especially, I mean, there's variables, of course. So if a client comes to you and says, I need a beautiful headshot, if you take a snapshot to your phone and run it through AI and they think they look beautiful, technically you've succeeded. Yeah. So, you know, what are you supposed to do? Argue with that? Necessarily, you know, because a headshot client might not care about your truth and beauty soliloquy at all. They just might be like, I want to look halfway decent on my LinkedIn, you know, and so it's just like all.
We had this conversation recently with my, my son actually, because he's into cars and stuff. It's an engineering question, but it can be applied to so much more. When you engineer anything, when you're creating anything, what can be done is not as relevant and not as important as what's the point? What's the purpose? Where are our parameters? How are we defining what this thing is supposed to do? Right, because if your mission is fast car and everything else is relevant, you engineer a fast car that's going to be inefficient, impractical, incredibly dangerous, and go 450 miles an hour and almost certainly kill you because you're not considering something
other than fast car. So when you're thinking about making something, even as an artist, what's the intent that should drive you as to what you want to do? Right, so me, again, I'm coming from the artist standpoint, which people can criticize my work if they want, they have for years, whatever, but I'm going to model myself from the fine art perspective, making art for the hell of it, making art for the sake of the art, and then seeing what I can do to make a career out of it. Right? That's the fine art business model, for lack of a better term. Now with that said, that my purpose is art for art's sake and
hopefully it lands. Sounds simple enough, but as we know, that's very, very difficult. I don't know what I would do if someone wanted me to do headshots for them and they just said, can you run it through AI? I've heard conflicting ideas. I've heard people say, hey, you don't respect me as an artist. And I get that. That makes sense. You should say that there's some clients who are never going to care. They just want the end result. Now, again, end result oriented art, even in music, been around for decades.
You know, people aren't always looking for the profile. Most people even aren't looking for the profound. They're not looking for the big deep storyline or anything like that. So for me, for me, I think that the truth element is a big aspect of it. But if you're talking about a client who's paying you to do something, that has already changed and will continue to change, and that's honestly concerning for me, because, how do I put this?
It's inevitable. Yeah. What we're, what we're seeing, it's not going to stop. It will taper, it will level out. It has to. But some aspects of industries are going to be replaced. Now, saying that tech has helped destroy jobs for decades is not a consolation prize for anyone, but it really has been happening for a long time. It's just that AI has a terrifying efficiency, doesn't it? That's. And that's it. That's the concern right there. Yeah. The, you know, just going back to I have to pop a Ricolo.
I don't know, I've been trying to get over this head cold sinus thing, so forgive me, I gotta blow those Swedish horns and have a Ricola. So one of the things that popped to my mind while you were talking about that, about, you know, the hypothetical scenario, someone wants to come to you and they just say, hey, I don't care how you do it, just get me a good headshot from LinkedIn. I almost want to think like, I'm not making art anymore, I'm making content. And if I'm treating my clients like content instead of the human
that wants to be seen, then is that my burden or is it theirs? Right. And I'm, I'm really, you know, kind of torn on this because if it's their decision, I'm in a service industry where I'm supposed to be serving you with what it is that you want photographically. If instead I think of it as like, you just want to be content and you're not respecting my art, then that's just my ego taking over.
Right. So it just, it triggered in my mind the whole like content versus art thing. Right. So so many of us make art that we have to turn into content, but now is AI forcing us to think about our clients as content and creating that? The other thing you mentioned about the efficiency is that this is another place where I'm a little bit torn because AI invariably gives you more time to focus on making that connection with people.
If you have a limited amount of time and you only have an hour in a session, let's say you want to spend as much time with the client as possible, get to know them, really draw out what it is that you're trying to create, whether it's commission piece or whether it's something that you're doing yourself. So when time is of the essence, using an AI tool in your workflow I think can be totally justified. Right. Because you're trying to maximize that time, because of the efficiency, though, it becomes very easy to lean on that tool, and
suddenly you are. You're relying on it. And what I'm getting at is this. And I want to talk about this from your aspect, not as a photographer, but as a retoucher. As. As people start to utilize AI tools more, do you feel like they're giving up or avoiding learning the craft of retouching itself? And do you think that's inherently a good or a bad thing
for retouching? Well, my answer is annoyingly pedantic. It depends. And we have to start with defining what retouching even is. And we have to start saying to ourselves, for example, let's look at Capture One, right? Capture One now has a face retouch for a few months now, and that's cool. Well, I didn't get a card to vote as to what that retouch should look like. Someone decided that. So now Capture One does retouching as defined by Capture
One. That's it. There was no meeting. I didn't get invited. There was no discussion. This is just what Capture One does, right? So what that made me think was what we're seeing is a forced uniformity because the tools do what they do. Even a boto does what it does, right? But some of the best artists. Let's just talk about portraiture for a minute. Some of the best artists, their style is definitive. Their style doesn't look like Capture One did something.
It looks like them, whether it's polished or raw or whatever, you know? And so as a retoucher, I think if a tool helps you achieve your vision in some way, whether it's a benefit in speed and efficiency or a benefit in technique that you can go from, then great. But if you're forced, if you're conforming, hard conforming, because this is what capture what does now. So this is now what I do, right? Okay, that's fine. But as an artist, as someone like me who likes to retouch my way,
I don't want to rely on that. You know, I don't want to. Because it's not just that it works, quote unquote, it's how do we define it? That's like saying that I need to add guitar to the song, and that's the only requirement. Guitar. What? There's so many variables there. So when you say we're touching, we've compartmentalized that into one thing, as if it's hard to find and it isn't. And so that's, again, pedantic. As hell. Because I know a lot of people are like, I just want my clients to not have, like, blemishes. Shut up, Nino. I know.
I'm sorry. Because retouching is not just getting rid of blemishes, though, is it? It's finalizing. Right. So that finalizing, I think, is, is more the, the, the personal aspect than the skin cleanup or whatever. Skin cleanup does have some fundamental things that, yes, that we can all agree are at least somewhat fundamental. But vision varies wildly. You know, I mean, techniques are techniques, but your vision is, is, is the open point there. So that's why I'm like, I think that if we, how do I say it? If we say, for example, I've never used a voto, but if we say,
well, I don't need to do that anymore. Evoto does. Right, okay. Evoto does what Evoto does. And now that's what you do. And I know that's splitting hairs, but as an artist who wants to, ideally, if you want to make something that's definitively you, are you conforming unwillingly at the altar of efficiency, or are you finding a way to leverage it differently? There's just too many questions. So I can't say that we're not going to need, quote, unquote, need retouching.
I can't say I'm going to stop it. I'm going to, I, I, I think it's all, it's like, it's like painting, for example. Oil painting. Right. Let's say you, you, you, you prep your canvas. Right. And it might be a method to prep your canvas. Well, you can have an assistant do that if you do it every single time. Right, right. But if you prep your canvas differently per painting, that's part of the art. Right. So again, heavy, heavy on the pentictics here. I know on the pedantry, as it were, but that's how I have to start the conversation about. Well, you know, what do you mean by retouching?
What is your, what do you, what are we talking about? So before I even get into that, I did want to say, oh, I'm going to get rid of the placeholders. So Anna Hill is a portrait photographer here in the Northeast. She's amazing. She's a wonderful content creator. And she's just stopped by to say hi, Anna, thank you for joining us. Enjoy the conversation, because we're going to, we're going to be here for a little bit. So I want to get back to what you were saying in all of that.
To me, it Comes down to values. What is it that you, as a photographer or lead toucher have as your core set of values? And I don't hear enough people talking about this. Insofar as we all have our style of art, we kind of know the genres and what we do, but I rarely hear people talking about values outside of the money conversation.
Yeah, yeah. So talk to me a little bit about. Because you were just, you know, and the. The pedantry is fine. Where do your values start with your art? And have those changed over time as you've adapted different things in the industry? Capture one, you know, whatever. AI. How have your values changed if they have. So I think that I've been. By the way, I figured out that this year is my 17th year officially
in this. Yeah, yikes. Anyway, but I say, I think officially because I grew up with photography. That's another story for, I think, another interview that we did, but officially 17 years. So my point is, in that time, I feel like I have found or continue to look for truth and authenticity more than I did 10, 12, 15 years ago. I think when I started, I was very end result oriented. Like any beginner, I was trying to figure out just how to do this shit.
And then. And then came in result oriented and then came with. That worked. I want to do more of that because I want better feedback and I want this and I want that and, you know, and then now I'm starting to get into that. Not last week, but in recent years, I'm into that mode where I'm like, I want to do something that just feels more authentic. I want to feel something that. That makes me feel like I'm proud of this. I'm glad I put this together, whatever together may be. So I feel like I've. I've advanced in that in that regard. For lack of a better term. I don't want to say advanced like I've gotten better.
I've just changed my mindset into that. So I guess I. What I will say about every artist that they have to do is whether you're a service provider or not, there's some element of drawing a line in the sand and then sticking to it. That is part of your entire mystique as an artist. That's your whole thing. Where is your line in the sand? Where is your boundary? Where is your value? Like you said. Right. And then you stick to it. You stick to it stubbornly. And that's what makes you an artist. You're not supposed to conform. You're not supposed to cooperate. You're not supposed to make sense. You find your line in the sand and you say, you know, like, Bandcamp
recently said, no AI music on their platform. You know, okay, cool line in the sand. I'm here for it. You know, that's part of being an artist. That's part of trying to define what you're trying, what you're doing. So for me, I think that it's just a matter of courage, really. You know, like, I'm not going to conform to AI what if it comes against me? What if it comes against you? You're still a person. You still have images that are still stories. Like, for example, look at something as mundane as the backgrounds of our little video feeds here, right? I don't know what's happening behind you, but it's not AI and it
draws interest. There's a question. What is that thing back there? What is that other thing? Sometimes there's a guitar. Matt, where's the guitar? Today, these little simple human, like, questions that make us connect with one another, even the simplest ways are completely devoid in AI they're just. They're not there. And to get too far and say that AI is going to go away at night, but we're gonna. We're gonna see more interest and more excitement about authentic
experiences on the Internet, because we're already. We're inundated by plastic experiences from humans, I might add, but also from AI Slop, as the term goes. So I think authenticity is due for a comeback. How's that? And I'm not being naive, I'm not being silly. I understand what we're facing here. I totally get what we're facing. But I think authenticity is going to be valuable. So the question is, are you going to stay the course and be courageous and continue on despite.
Because artists have done that for years, or are you going to either conform or die trying? I don't know. I think it's an issue of being courageous and like I said, drawing a line, sand, and thinking, this is what I do, this is what I don't do, at least for this season on work, Right. I'm not trying to simplify it. I think that it comes down to that. I think so. As the tools become more accessible, more consumer friendly, right? And this is kind of the thing that Evoto did, was they said, all
right, photographers, we hear from you. We know what it is that you're what you're looking for. And. But we're a software company. We're not photographers. We're out to make money. So we're making these tools, and I have zero issue with that, by the way, but we're making these tools and we want to make them accessible to as many people as possible because we're in the business of making money as people get access to the tools, just like it was with ChatGPT, where suddenly everybody has access
to it and it's the greatest, coolest thing. Right. But as everybody starts to use it, what does it do? It learns. And it just basically makes every answer this milquetoast, homogenized version of whatever the answer should be. There's no real thought in it. Right. It's pattern recognition. So when we talk about the experience of photography, I'd like to believe in the heart of hearts that, like you're saying you
draw your line in the sand as the artist, the experience that you provide perhaps, is that line. People are going to find these tools and they're going to use them, and there's no way that we can push back against that ocean. But I believe that over a period of time, people just get bored with it. You know why? Because they're producing, everybody's producing the same candy cane Christmas picture that, you know, every white woman put out
on the Internet a month and a half ago, and it was the same exact picture. Now that in our world is no different from Everybody running a 40 over 40 campaign and, you know, basically doing the same thing. However, I think as people get bored with seeing the same image that Sally has, that Jane has, that Mary has, that suddenly they're going to be like, I'm not really going to use these.
I want something that's me. I want to feel the power that's me. Guys are going to say, yeah, great, I can look super buff. But when I take off my shirt at night, I don't look super buff. So I know it's fake. And they want to get back to that reality. Yeah. The question becomes, can we wait out that period as artists or, you know, if we have our line in the sand and we believe in the humanity of the photography, how.
How do we weather that storm? When we rely on this for financials to keep a roof over our head, how do we weather that storm? Even if we do take a stance against AI or at least advise and educate our clients, that right, you're going to get something pretty generic. Well, to me, it's twofold. For one, one of the things on our side is it's horrifying efficiency. So we're gonna see things progress faster and faster the way they have I'm thinking about AI in 2022 versus now.
That's four years. And it's night and day difference, right? So I think that ridiculous efficiency is gonna peak at some point. I mean, how much more realistic can videos get? How much more realistic can a photo rendering get? Get before doesn't fucking matter anymore, right? You know, and so that people are going to do exactly what you're going to say, which just suggested I should say they're going to be tired of the same old. They're going to be tired of the. Of the convention. They're going to be tired of the manufacture. They're going to be really obvious when it's manufactured.
It's going to like, that looks cool, whatever, you know. You know, it even plays out, if I may, it even plays out in the very quietly dark backbone, financial and technological backbone of the Internet known as pornography. That even works out there. Because what happens is that now you can have all this AI pornography so you can create all kinds of ridiculous images and images that are morally questionable. Let's just call it that.
And video content as well. But what happens even on something, even on the subject that's something that's as base level as human urges and sexual urges for evolutionary kind of things in humans, eventually that kind of generic AI redundancy, someone's going to be like, yeah, but no, but I'm hot for that person. I'm not hot for the invented person. I'm hot for her. I will spend money there, right? So even at the base level, reptilian brain, human urges of masturbation,
we're going to see AI slip because people want that real experience. Now some people won't. Some people will be like the. Will be Wally and happily. But the vast majority of us are going to want a authentic experience of some form, right? And when some, I think most people are not going to read, are not even going to fully realize that they're tired of the AI storm. They're tired of the. I mean, they can. They're tired of being tricked. That's a whole nother subject, you know, content that's designed to deceive. But if you're. If the deception is not.
The deception is intentional and it's clear, what is it worth? A deception is very valuable. We can call it valuable, it's immoral, but it's valuable because it elicits a response, right? So that's a deception. That's one use in AI AI that's openly. A deception like this is not real. Okay, what is this Value. And certainly it won't have a long term value. You know what I mean? I put stuff in GPT. I put stuff into Sora and once I see it and I go, that's ridiculous. That's a tricycle on an F1 track.
Beaten cars. And then you delete it. This entire rendered video. 15 seconds of a tricycle on circuit of the Americas beating F1 cards. The most vivid, realistic, absurd thing you've ever heard. Deleted in five seconds. Because the moment passed. Right. If I rendered all of that 3D animation, it would be a month long project at the least. And I would route it around and people would ask me how I did it. And I probably have behind the scenes video of how I rendered the tricycle. And there's. There's something.
There is what I'm saying. So I already double value AI. Not in principle, but because where did it came from? It came from the ether. And. And it's. It's worth about as much as the ether. It didn't come from anybody. No one made it. You know what I mean? No one. And how do I put this? This T shirt was manufactured. There's not an artisan making this Fender T shirt. This is. This was mass manufactured and I bought it for $29, whatever the hell at the guitar store. And I like it because it's Fender. And there's no emotional investment here other than Fender.
Right. That. I'm not worried about this as a piece of art. There's a place for manufactured things. But as, as artists, we can't be replaced. If I may be so old now. I'm gonna, I'm just gonna. I'm gonna butt in there for a second. Just specifically with the Fender piece. Right. Some graphic artists at some point put that logo together. It's now become part of Americana. Right. And. Absolutely. And so while the T shirt itself is mass produced, the logo
is the artwork. Right. And that is what has transcended everything. People know Fender, they know Gibson, they know Taylor. Right. Because of the look and feel of that brand. Yeah. And. And I just keep thinking that our art, our style, our approach is our brand. And that becomes recognizable only over a period of time. That's it. Right? That's it. Cool. And that's.
We also go backwards in time too, because everything that we do today was drawn from everything that came before. Everything I do now, everything I say now came from experiences I've had for 34 years. Let's go with that. Talk about age right now. Everything, everything that happens to this moment is A product, at the very least a product of everything that came before it as a human because of time, right? Time moves linearly, blah, blah, blah. We can get into like ontological and epistemological discussion
of time, but either way, point is that because of that, again, an AI is a grown ass adult with a million skills, born yesterday, right. And can only pretend to understand memory, can only pretend to understand experience. Can, can, can fake it really well, don't get me wrong. But when you realize, oh, you actually weren't there in 1997, you weren't there in 2011, at that moment talking about that experience and what is that?
What is that? It's something, but it's not, it's not a human experience. So replacing not entirely. This is the thing that Nikki's getting to. So Nikki Lister joined us. She says hi, but she says, you know, I completely agree. It's not emotionally attached to us. There's no real connection in the art that's produced and what we see outside of basic dopamine hit, hey, this made chemicals
in my brain go giggity, giggity and then I'm done. Right. One other comment that came in Artemis. I don't know if you know Artemis. Artemis is a phenomenal photographer in Pennsylvania. Loving this discussion. Gotta run. We'll have to watch replay. Perfect. I think, you know, when it comes to that emotional connection. Again, I'll keep coming back to this because it's one of the things that I, I know I center around. I know you have very strong opinions and you center a lot of
your work around that human connection. Right. And that, that beautiful imperfection in things, even though you create, you know, flawless images, but that's based on craft and skill and time and experience over a period of time. 34 years. So four years. 34 years. So like, you know, you, you, you're focused there. A lot of newbies aren't, right? We're fortunate that we've been in this game decade, multiple
decades. Right. And so 10 years ago we had to learn retouching, we had to learn the craft at whatever point it was. Is it the same as doing the craft of tintypes or film photography? No. And there were guys that were my age started going, hey, you're using digital, right? So that, that element is always going to be there. I got trolled the other day for talking about AI and someone said, you know, something about paint brushes that AI is going
to, you know, the same, doing the same thing, that. How was the last time you saw somebody paint something And I'm like, there are museums full of that stuff. So I don't think painting is going anywhere. So I don't think photography is going anywhere. It's just, what is it going to be considered as an art? Right. I see a painter and I go, you're a wizard. I see someone play the piano at a classical level. They're purely inhuman to me. I don't know what planet they came from. Their fingers do things I could never conceive of learning.
But that doesn't mean that, because I can go to Spotify, that classical pianists are irrelevant now. Right? Right. I go to those concerts and I sit in a. In a chamber hall and I listen to just phenomenal music that came out of someone's head and then performed by someone that has spent hours, hours, thousands, thousands of hours perfecting their craft. And it means something to me.
It moves me to tears. In the past. If we're just looking for what gives me a boner, what gives me quick dopamine hits, we're not even considering what it is that we're looking at. We're hoping that the funny little pixels on the screen will make some little chemical in my head, make me feel good. And so I don't think the newer, the newer crew of photography people that are just getting into this now.
They. Haven'T had to fight the battle of the old Internet. They haven't had to use floppy disk. Right. So they're growing up with AI. And this is the thing I think that people get wrapped around the axle about is that new photographers are not real photographers. New retouchers are not real retouchers because they don't know the craft well. They're using all that they know. So I can't denigrate them for doing that or using the tools that they're using. But what I can say is the newbies are going to do new level
stuff. The OGs are going to do OG level stuff. I think we're going to see a collapse in the middle. Right? The people that were kind of good, but, you know, they're not charging $200 an hour for retouching and they're not including it in their packages because it's just cheap and easy like newbies would. So that middle, where someone's charging 50, 100 bucks an hour, why would someone pay that if they know that, you know,
if they know they can get it either super cheap or if they value it, they're going to go to someone that really knows the craft. As people talk about the industry collapsing? I don't think it's going to collapse. I think there's a level of adaptation that we have to get to. I don't know what that looks like yet. Where do you see, on both sides, photography and retouching. Since you have your foot in both ponds, where do you see significant change happening and where is that change really not going to be
that big of a deal? Well, the first obvious, most obvious change is efficiency. The efficiency we're going to see. We're going to see utility things done very quickly. You know, we already are. So, you know, if, if, if I think the next step, for example, I mentioned capture one in their. In their face retouch, right? The next step will be to open, capture one or the new update and then train it, if you will, and say, this is how I like my editing to be done. And I don't even want you to finish it. I just want you to get started. This is the kind of things I want you to do for me.
And then that has more use suddenly because it's not just conforming to one thing. That's not like you said, everything kind of squished into a medium gray of this is acceptable. So this is what we're doing now, you know. No, there's more nuance than that. And if you're new, you don't know any better. You just know that a face went from blemishes to none and you think win, right? So that's the first thing. Efficiency. Mad, crazy, stupid efficiency. But second thing is that sort of leveraging in a customized way
in a way that's more tailored to you. Because if, if you came from the world of airbrush retouching, which goes back decades, many decades, not just airbrushing, but all kinds of chemicals and paints and everything in the dark room, all kinds of things. You know, spray painting, literally spray painting an airbrush with large positives and then you reshoot them. And, you know, it was a big process. It was a big problem. Digital, right? Digital comes and it's slow and clunky, so it's cool, but not an immediate threat, right?
And then it starts advancing in the 90s, becomes a threat and destroys. Manual retouching. It just absolutely obliterated it because it became efficient, you know, and once it came, once it hit the same caliber in terms of quality, because, you know, 1992, 1 1, whatever they call you, 1111 megabyte image was huge. So that was not useful for people. But once it became useful and then ownership of course, became ubiquitous and regular old school type of retouching, unless
you're choosing to do it, is gone and it got replaced. And AI is doing that now. However, the difference, in my mind, the difference is how will we leverage the technology in a way that allows us to still express something, that allows us to still be who we want to be. And even if we don't know the answer yet, can we customize the tool? Because right now AI is ask, receive, right? You know, and I understand there's ways of training models and there's open source things and then you can train it on you and
train it on your work and that we're seeing that, that's what I'm talking about. But just because you trained on your body of work and then you output something as AI, that I'm not going to perceive that work as the same as your photographs. I'm just not because of that history that's absent. It's cool tech, but I'm not going to view it the same. You might have a cool vision, you might have a pretty image that again hits the dopamine, but there's not going to be a story there. So I think we're going to customize the tools, if you will, being able to leverage them in ways that help us efficiently help
us accomplish something, which we kind of already doing. Every time you go to subject selection on Photoshop, guess what? That's AI making a choice and avoiding you making a pen tool mask that takes an hour. So we've been doing that for a while, right? So is that corruption? No. If you don't use a pen tool to mask out the subjects, you're not a real artist. Right? Where, where is everybody's threshold? Right, that's, that's a question that we have to ask. But at the end of the day, of every damn day, what are you, what is your vision? What are you doing? And I want to circle back real quick when I say this because when
we say meaning again, I want to repeat this. It's very important that make this clear. When we say art should have meaning, we tend to immediately jump to profound, serious, you know, in depth, poignant. We don't. We think about serious songs, deep love songs, and we think about politically charged things and we think about socially aware concepts and things. And that's all valid. But there's meaning, human meaning in art that's just pretty because a human did it, a human wanted to do it.
It doesn't have to have some deep story or deep message, but a Human did it. There's value. And I'm not trying to get too crazy spiritual on you. It's just that when you compare it to the AI slob and the endless amounts of it, one person going somewhere to take a picture is an experience that AI cannot do. And that's important to me. I'll go outside the realm of photography for a second. But since we're here on YouTube, one of the things that I look forward to at the end of every year is inevitably someone
will release a humans are incredible video. Right? And you see these people that are cliff diving and, you know, they're BASE jumping and they're doing all this stuff, and it's just really cool. You're like, how'd you learn to do that? Right? You have squirrel suit flying. Like, how do you get into that? Right, right. And I see that and I get super excited by it because I know those are real humans. Now at the end of this year, is there going to be someone on a tricycle, on an F1 track? You know, and I'm going to look at it and be like, I'm so jaded
now, and I've become so callous to what is real and what is not. That unless I'm there looking at it in person, it becomes very difficult for me to default to, wow, that's really cool. Right. Because I've lost the trust in it. But let me get back to something you said a minute ago about, you know, training it on bad data. And I keep thinking about where retouchers fit in. And what I keep thinking about is, yes, people can move sliders and they can do blemish moving or, you know, even easier liquefy
on someone's waste by using these sliders. Right? But they're working within the confines of whatever the software company gave them. The value in real retouching is that you know what contrast can or cannot do. This is one of your latest videos about what contrast really is. I've talked to Renee Robin about compositing, Right. I don't do much compositing, but she's like, compositing is easy,
but everything lives in the shadows. If you don't get the shadows right, it doesn't portray truth or it doesn't. It doesn't even allow you to suspend your belief, to believe in the art if you don't get the shadows right. Because your brain is just like. That doesn't look right. Yeah. So do you think there's a place. For. Real retouchers to work as AI workflow consultants to help people if they're going to be developing prompts or they're going
to be using this, hey, here are the things you really need to look out for. Or do you feel like that is, you know, just three months where retouchers do that and the software companies pick up on it and they just kind of work that into the software. Do you think there's a place for that? Like high level of knowledge? Especially people that grew up on tools that don't necessarily have the background of knowledge of what this software is actually doing. Right. Using an action or using a preset tool is great if you know
what it's doing. And then you can season that recipe to your taste by tweaking, you know, this slider or that slider or this panel. But if you have no idea, you're at the mercy of the software company as to what they think. And this goes back to the beginning of the conversation where you're talking about that. Do you think there's a place for the, the high end retoucher to elevate themselves up into a more valuable consultancy role? That's actually a very fascinating question because the
idea of being a consultant on the matter is something I haven't spent a lot of time thinking about. It's actually really cool. Yeah, that would be obviously a temporary thing because AI's slope is extreme, right. So it learns so fast. You know, this is not something you can set up, but what we do see in the world of AI, all kinds of AI technologies that we have consultants, if you will, or how do we put this? Every, every AI organization has an entire like ethics board,
you know, and, and, and if you're OpenAI, you kind of need an ethics board, you know. But will we be able to consult on the tech from an ethical standpoint? Not just on principle, not just AI is going to take over, you know, T800s, blah blah blah. Not just that, not just end times, but what are we doing with our work. Right. And I think that's going to be a topic that should be discussed. I'm not saying it's going to be a professional position, I don't know. But it's something that should be taught. Maybe it should, something that should be part of curriculum,
maybe give a workshop. We should talk about that. So look, we have to talk about the elephant in the room, AI. Let's talk about the ethical element. What is the ethical element? The ethical element to me is where you draw your line in the sand, right? What does that mean for You. And how do you navigate your career in that boundary? Because that's all that matters. You can do whatever you want. You can go hella AI and you can say zero AI draw your line to sand, navigate your career and then what? And so that's kind of your own ethical boundary.
Right. I think deception is of course, where, where everything draws the line. If you're, if you're saying these are photographs and they're not, you're not winning anybody's favor. You're going to make enemies except for marketing companies. Other artists are going to absolutely condemn you. If you're saying something is what it isn't. That's been true forever. Right. We've seen people stealing photos from others, let alone making AI website. So deception is always asset threshold. I think 99.99% of people can't go past the deception aspect. No, but where you leverage it, where you draw that proverbial line
of sand, that's, that's interesting. That's an interesting metric that we're seeing evolve. You know, we've seen people who don't retouch. Right. Who are photographers and fashion magazines who swear they don't retouch. Right. That's a principled decision. Right. Less of an art decision. It's kind of an art decision, but it's an art decision made on principles that are important to that person. Does that limit them? In some ways, yes. Is that controversial to some people also, yes. However, their courage, you can't deny the courage for drawing
the line in the sand AI is no different. So I'm not trying to simplify and I don't claim to know because this changes every quarter. But right now I'm strongly of the idea that we have to make some choices and run with them and be courageous about it. You brought up ethics, value principles. Does the retouching workflow matter to the end client?
Do you think they care? Right. So we're at a point now where the consumer level tools are okay, but quite honestly, unless you're in the industry or peripherally attached to it, you just don't even think about it. Right. People that I talk to here in town, they, they don't care. They don't care about the process of what I do to create the image. They just say, wow, your stuff looks like art. And I'm like, I think that's a compliment. I'm going to leave it there. But like, whatever.
But I don't think they're considering the aspects of the principles or the ethics in what we really debate about internally. And so I wonder if this is much ado about nothing when it comes to the relationship between the artist and the client. But it is certainly something that we have to talk about, we have to deal with. I've just, there is no difference in this to me between
film going to digital, digital going to hologram, like whatever it is. And I think, you know, if you have built in color profiles in Lightroom or capture one and you don't know how to change that to enact your own vision, you're really not any different than the end consumer who can just find an off the shelf Kmart tool and do their, and
do their art. Right? I'm an artist. I picture, you know, Ralph Wiggum in that. So. I just, I keep expanding the conversation because I come down to what am I concerned about? I'm concerned about things like we're not adapting fast enough to think about how we stay ahead of the technology. Do we consult, do we create an ethics board at the PPA level, you
know, and really come out as subject matter experts on a topic that is not necessarily something that we can change at the person by person level, but changing the conversation and how we think about it. Do you think that that is even worth it to have that conversation? Or do you think that everybody knows the playing field? The companies know what they want to do, they're injecting AI and stuff because some bean counter told them that it's going
to save on the bottom line. Do you think it's even worth having deeper conversations like this about how we change our own profession? Or do you think we just make it more of an individual choice and come back to the line in the sand, the principles, the values on a per person level. What do you think about that? Yeah, no, that's. Let me answer that in pieces. The first part is the clients don't care. They haven't cared about how you retouch in the beginning.
They don't care. And just because of social media, everybody knows that AI is a thing. And I'm sure the average client's asking, hey, did you use AI on this? Because it looks cool, right? They don't care. As far as they're concerned, what you were doing 10 years ago in Photoshop is AI, right? Oh, magic. It might as well be magic, right? So the client doesn't care. So if you're looking at the ethics question, then you're the client is not entirely relevant. Now it's a very, very different story with some kind of. If there's an Element of truth to it.
If it's a headshot that's supposed to look pretty, that's cool. But if it's supposed to be, I don't know, a wedding shot and you completely render a new background, that strikes me as unethical. I feel like something's wrong there. This is an art shot when it's. Supposed to be requested by the client. Hey, it was a rainy day. Put a sunny sky behind us. Yeah, right. And they can just live that lie. Totally. Yeah, totally. For whatever they want. Right. So again, it's a service and art. Now, from strictly from the art standpoint, then, you know, there's
no client involved there. So that's where you have to draw your line. Stand, like I said, and go, what am I going to do with this? But again, if you look at it, there's something sobering there. Thinking about the client perspective that 10 years ago what you were doing in Photoshop is as good as AI is today. They didn't know the difference. They don't know how Photoshopping works because they use it as a verb and they just assume that magic happens. Right. If you're good at it. And then now with AI, they just assume. Oh, you ran that through GPT, right? Yeah, that's what I did. I ran your modeling photos through GPT.
No, but they don't know. They don't care. And that's a very, again, sobering reminder of what, of what the tech can be seen as. Now, we in the industry, we're in the middle of it, we're in the trenches. We're gonna see all the tech come and go. There's people who didn't like mirrorless, there's people who didn't like digital, there's people who didn't like this, and that is people who still don't like medium format. There's people, you know, it gets exhausting after a while. But there's a big, big but here. And that AI's, again, its efficiency in what it does and efficiency
and how it evolves is not to be understated. That is, I think what scares people is that if there's an ethical dilemma at all, an ethical obligation, responsibility, it's in, I guess, teaching. Yeah, that's the word. But ensuring that people as a whole, in any way that you can, don't lose sight of humanity, from anything from music to, especially
in the arts. But in general, yeah, we're seeing that because of the deception angle. Right? We're seeing a lot of that. Right. We need to be Real careful on the deception angle. Videos and photos of things that depict things that did not happen. They are tricking people. That is dangerous for reasons I don't need to go into. But deception aside, we have to help, hopefully remind. I'm just going to use this term normies, non artists. We're going to help normies try hopefully to remember that there's
value in human effort. There's value in a human hand doing something. There's value in a human voice speaking and saying something that came from their experience, that they can modify your future experience from there. Ideas converge, efforts converge, and things continue to evolve in a very, very human way that literally cannot be replaced. At least not wholesale. And not overnight, not in our lifetime, but before. We are consciousness that are uploaded into a substrate of conscious,
of mass consciousness. And we're now in this extra, you know, a thousand years from now, we're a whole different story. That's cool, but I don't want to be there, right? So right now my concern is reminding people of their own humanity. Not so much you need to respect artists, you need to respect yourself. Because if you understand your own humanity, you'll see it in others. That's theory, anyway. I love that. You know, it got me thinking about how much commercial work you do. And this is more video than it is, than it is photography.
But when Jaguar came out with. I think it was Jaguar. No, it was Coke. Coca Cola came out with. Jaguar was just kind of like, they just missed the mark on so many levels. Coca Cola did a. A video at Christmas, like a Christmas commercial, and they produced it. And it's, you know, this train going down the tracks or it was like 18 wheelers or something like that in every shot, because it was produced in those seven to eight second VO videos, is that there was a mistake in every single shot.
And it was very, very clear that the marketing department, the art department of Coca Cola used AI to create this. So there was big backlash. And people were like, come on, Coca Cola, you own half the planet. Like, really, you couldn't pay someone to do this, right? There are plenty of animators out there. You couldn't do that, right? What are you seeing with your commercial clients at a. At an emotional level? Do you feel like you're. You're retaining clients because you've built a relationship
with them over the years, that you are really catering to what they need? Or do you feel like there are companies that are really moving towards the efficiency angle and just get it out fast? Because we know content's only Going to live for 3,5 seconds at a time. What are you seeing when you're having conversations with magazines, when you're having conversations with your commercial clients? What are they feeling? How do they look at all of this? I mean, it varies a lot, right? Yeah, but one thing that because of what I do, and I've always
presented it, at least in last few years, I always presented that what I do is an artistic endeavor, not so much. I'm not trying to advertise a soda, so I don't. I don't ever work in that space. I can imagine that's a whole different animal. But in my side of things, I think I succeeded okay, in selling the human element enough that people want. That they want the human element, you know, like, even I don't do it anymore, but even when I put together sets for men's magazines or whatever, you know, the girl is the point, you know?
And I'm certain that we're going to see. We haven't already AI pictorials and Playboy and things like that. And that's fine. But think about it. That goes right back to what we were already talking about. Not necessarily pornography angle, but the humanity angle is like, who is this person? He does not exist. And that's just not as interesting, is it? No. And I'm seeing this. I just saw a thing last night. I don't know if you've heard about this controversy or seen it. There's an artist, apparently a musical artist, named Sienna Rose. I do not know the her music.
I don't know anything about it. But there's the question, is it AI generated or not? Because the producer on many of these records is a guy out of Europe, Finland, Norway, Denmark, something like that that is unapologetically creating AI music. And so the question becomes, are we looking at purely AI video? She's gotten like 2.6 million streams or something ridiculous, right? Like Taylor Swift numbers on each record that comes out.
Is that something that we're just going to continue to see over and over and over and it becomes indistinguishable and our thirst for consuming just stuff. I just need to listen to something that we're not even caring that this stuff happens. Like, I think, yeah. Where do you go with that? Honestly, that won't change because people have been listening to disposable music for a long time. Oh, sure, yeah. You go into an office at 3:15, it is 2005, and you walk into an
office at 3:15pm the same fucking song will be playing because the radio Station has a schedule, right? Okay. Now, that might be human, but I'm going to tell you a story, and this will give you the answer. I want to bring your attention to this cd, happens to be sitting next to me. All right? This is a band from Tokyo called Nikaku. And Nikaku is a Prague instrumental band. This is bass melting, complicated music. Let me tell you a quick story about this. So I discovered this on pandora or something 15 years ago.
And I was like, what? And so I looked it up in the 2005 Internet, 2008 Internet, and I found who they were, and they had a MySpace page with their tracks and all that. I was going to say, I fired up Netscape, right? And I fired up Netscape and I found the CDD for sale. Yeah, I bought it, right? And it took, like, I don't know, three weeks to get here from Japan. And I was very, very, very excited. Now, in subsequent moves in the last 10 to 15 years, I lost my CD. And you might think, what's this?
Well, every year, roughly in the last 12 years, I have looked for this album, but this band has disbanded. And the. The. The guy who ran it all, well, I cannot pronounce his name. I'm sorry. He had a defunct Facebook page that he hasn't posted in five years. And I kept doing searches, and I kept doing searches, just hoping, hoping, searching, hoping, hoping, hoping. One day, a buddy of mine, and I was talking back and forth, and we were talking about Prague music, and I said, man, this nightoku, you know, and you go online, you can't find this album anywhere. It's not on Spotify, you can't find it on YouTube.
You can find some live shows. But one day I did a search just because I remember, I said, what the hell? This was in November. I did a search, and there was this record was on Discogs, which is a reputable website, yo, sure. And I was like, long story short, it took five weeks and it cost me $65. And I bought a CD of a defunct progressive rock band, instrumental, started by a bass player and a flute player, because I needed it.
Yeah. And I got it. And the first thing I discovered, that this effort and this band was so removed from modern technology that when the CD came in, it occurred to me, I don't own a CD player anymore. So I was like, wait. So luckily my shitbox car has a CD in it. So this comes with me every run now, and I need to go to Amazon and order a stupid CD reader or something.
But my point is, I'm not like everyone, and I get that. But if you're moved by art and you're passionate about art, you will get the art and you will appreciate the art, right? It means something to you. And this band meant something to me because they. They pushed the boundaries of what I considered was possible in music and the arrangements, the composition and overall mood and. And all this. And by the way, this. All this text back here, you see? Can you see all that text? Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's. That's. That's one song title. That's the name of the song. So, you know, I like that kind of bizarreness and pushing the boundaries
of things. And so my point is, if this stupid CD took a decade of re hunting and $65 in 5 weeks from Tokyo, why is that? That because I made it? Or is that because there's something about the humans that made it that moved me? Right? Maybe not everybody will spend a decade looking for a $65 CD, but somewhere between that and people who don't give a shit about what they listen to, there's a lot of us, and there's a lot of people, I think, who will. Who will continue to make that effort for that human experience. That's why live shows are where all musicians make money now.
End of story. They don't sell records. Major musicians, you know what I mean? Everything is streaming. So then interpersonal experience. Someone mentioned once, but let me make sure I didn't break one, okay? No, I think I'm good. Someone mentioned the other day, they were talking about a. A big band. Jazz, Right, Big band. You know, like. Yeah, big. Whatever. Count Basie style. Sure, exactly. And someone said, they're listening to the tracks. And they said, cool. And this old dude was like, you know what's missing, though, if I'm honest?
What's that? He said, you can't. You can't feel the sound waves in the air moving from the horns in your face when you have that many horns. That guy beating the. Out of a drum and the bass player slapping the shit out of it because he wants to be able to be heard. And that physical feeling of the air being moved by the horns is part of it. And that's true. That's so true. And not everyone gets to experience that. Concerts are loud, sure. But that personal element, that physical element, that visceral
element, you're never gonna be able to take that away from us. You can't. You know what I mean? And yeah, we have. We have fake bands, you know, Gorillas comes to mind and things like that. But those at least have a human. But that was more of an art project than anything. It was, it was a performance piece is what it was. That's still human, right? If someone types in a prompt and runs a concert, no one's gonna care. No one's gonna care. You know, I just saw a buddy ofmine on questionable.com. he just joined. He's a big hip hop head and it's funny that he just joined because I was just thinking in the, in the analogies you were making.
I remember growing up in Boston and I grew up on hip hop. I was the white kid down at the park, right? I just grew up in this world. And I remember going to. There was a place in Cambridge, Mass. Called the Middle East, a very famous kind of like rock club. And they have a lounge downstairs. And there was a certain night, it was like Wednesday nights or something like that, that they would have live hip hop. It was almost like an open mic night, right? And I remember rolling in there one night and Guru from Gangstar
was in there because he was kind of like a Boston dude, right? So Guru was in there and drunk, but just rhyming. And it was right around the time where Gangstar was really starting to blow up. Moment of truth had come out and it was just like Gurus at, you know, downstairs lodge. There were probably like 15 of us, right? But it was that. It was that feeling of you're there witnessing something that was pure to the culture of hip hop. You saw freestyles, you had the certain funk in the room, right?
And there's just like weed smoke everywhere. And it was just this wonderful moment that you don't get even listening to a gangstar CD or record or streaming or whatnot. You don't get that same feeling that you're in the presence of something happening, something magical that's not going to happen again. And I've seen enough Prague rock shows and I've seen enough concerts that you just don't get that same feeling, right? Even someone like me who DJ'd forever, whether it was scratch DJing
or electronica, there's nothing like seeing a real DJ, DMC style, scratch DJs performing their craft versus a European guy dancing, jumping up and down and eventually twisting a fader. Because everything is so synced up and pre recorded, it just doesn't have the same emotion. No matter what the speakers do, no matter what the sphere makes you look at, it just doesn't replace that human element that you're
experiencing. Something very rarely Have I listened to a record, vinyl, cd, whatever it is, lime wire, download that. I felt that same feeling that I got from watching a street performer in Harvard Square. Right, that's exactly right. So when it comes to photography and retouching, and we're talking about the humanity of that, this is. This is kind of the hill that I die on, is why I asked the question earlier. Do we just have to wait this out a little bit while people realize,
yeah, that experience is missing? Yeah, I can have the shiny new thing, but I like the dirty old shit box car, Right. Because I know exactly where to kick it to make it stop, you know, cranking or whatever. So, yeah, it's that experiential thing that is irreplaceable. And I'd love to hear more photographers talking about that experience. Outside of the platitudes of, oh, you're on a journey and you're gonna get this great experience, like truly the experience
of understanding what it's like and goes into the craft of photography. I think that might be the thing that saves us. And retouching. Right. So it's not about just moving sliders, it's about understanding what you're looking at and how do you draw more out? How do you draw more or direct the viewer's eye where you want to go. Right. I think, I think that teaching people, again, normies, teaching them what art is, it's not something that hasn't been going on for decades. It has been going on for decades. Right.
Whether it's performance, I always like Warhol. Warhol is brilliant for performance. Warhol basically is like, I'm going to make these things and you're going to buy them for a lot of money because I'm me. The performance is him fucking you, and the performance is his presence. The performance is Warhol basically said, I'm gonna exploit everything and you're gonna love me for it. And I mean, is there another one like him, really? Not really. And so that's fine. That's how Warhol did it.
He chose to be notorious. Okay, well, I don't wanna be notorious. I'd rather be beloved. And that's kind of what I go for. So authenticity is my. My focus. You know, if it's not authentic, it doesn't sit well with me. That's my line in the sand. That's. That's my line in the sand. It's not authentic. And of course, I have a threshold because someone could argue that it's not authentic to modify photo at all. And then my Counter is it's not authentic to even take the photo. At what point do we take a human experience to the base level,
sort of simian level experience of only interacting in person? We can take a photo that's technology that didn't used to exist, right? We can modify the photo. We. Everyone has a different. A different threshold is what I'm. What I'm saying. So. I think about that threshold. What makes art art, what makes people gravitate towards a certain artist, or what makes people dismiss a certain artist. And I don't think we can get caught up in that.
You mentioned a moment ago about, you know, not retouching, right? And. And I. I split my. My photography in the studio down the middle, where I have my unfiltered stuff. You can choose an unfiltered session. You're getting all black and white, you're getting no retouching whatsoever. And you walk out the door with digital images. But I'm giving you a printed book because I. You're going to get the prints of this because I want that to be part of the experience. You want something physical.
The other side. I do a lot of personal branding and headshots. When people come in, you know, you kind of get to know them. Turn this way, turn that way. Snap, done, right? And it's fine for what it is, but I then have to go in and retouch. And I'm still someone that's kind of old school. I'm using a Voto, but I have no problem going back to just doing the old school, you know, retouching. I think we put a lot of emphasis on that. I think we have to be the stewards of almost explaining to
people why I'm doing the things that I'm doing in the way that I'm doing them. And it's not necessarily a fast process and it's certainly not a cheap process because there is this craft, right? We go back to the Corinthian leather, right? I want to sit there with my needle and thread and I want to sew you a picture, right? And it's because I enjoy it. And I believe that the end product, you are going to have a
deeper connection when you see it on your wall, when you look at it on your phone when you die and your wife uses it at the funeral home, there's going to be a deeper connection to that image than there would be otherwise. And it behooves us to explain that to the people that we're working with, whether it's commercial real estate Headshots. I think if we're drawing the line in the sand that we are either anti AI or this was AI with an asterisk.
Right. I use it as a tool to make it more efficient and pass the value on to you, the consumer. I'm okay with that. But if we don't step up and actually explain some of this, then we're the ones that are causing our own demise. We are devaluing what it is that we do. We're letting the market dictate our value for us rather than us standing up and saying, no, this isn't how it is. Yeah. What are your thoughts there?
Well, I think I can. We have to teach, right? We have to teach the audiences. And this is why historically, in any art, extreme skill gets the attention. Right? With the power singers, the shredder guitarists, the people jumping off cliffs. And extreme skill gets attention because people can immediately relate to that and say, I can't do that. Right. You know, and so therefore, there's a huge separation and ipso facto, they are impressed. Yeah, but are we always going for impressing or are we trying to
make some other kind of impact to them? Are we trying to make some kind of emotional impact in some manner? Again, it doesn't have to be profound. It can be. We don't all have to be raised against the machine. Sometimes we can just be Ed Sheeran, you know what I mean? As long as we're impacting people. But are we trying to impress? Now we're in a social media economy socially. Right. So culturally, that's what we're in, and we have been for a while, and I think we might be on the way out, but that's another discussion. We're used to the likes, we're used to the virality, we're used
to the shares, and we still. But it's still dominated by that. So impressive is the metric that gets the most attention. Yeah, but that's why we have the singing shows and the Voice and the other ones. And there's some amazing talent on there, don't get me wrong. But while someone is there belting out, you know, Irene Cara or something, covering, they're killing it. And Amy is like, I'm thinking, are you guys hearing that studio band back there? Those guys are amazing. But I wouldn't care.
You know, the funny thing is, you're right. No one cares. But I love, you know, this is why I love my own autism, because I'm like, did you just hear the fill that that drummer put in? Because, you know, he's bored as hell, and he's just gonna rip. Or the bassist just does something funky. You're like. You make that funky face. You know, I. I love that aspect of when you're in tune to whatever your hobby is, whatever you pay attention to. Right. You're gonna see more of it, of course. And I like finding those little moments. All right, one more. One more comment while we're here.
Unquestionable dot com. We're talking about hip hop. One of my favorite local artists here In Foger, North Dakota, is Duro. He has an album entitled 98 Warhol, and it's one of the most creative artists I know, shockingly. Right. So that just. I thought that was great tagging on to the. Tagging on to that Warhol conversation. But, you know, it's funny you were mentioning that. You know, you were. You were. You're big. You grew up on hip hop back in the day, you know, 30 years ago, not. Not 40. We're not talking about a long time. Anyway, I was at the gym with my kid.
Right now, these TVs that always play and we always joke about all they do is stream sort of popular hip hop right now. And there's some in the mix that's not bad, but for the most part, it's all pretty formulaic. And it's like any popular music, right? Yeah. So the other day we went in there, and it was nothing but, like, a real EDM pop. Just the whole damn afternoon, I didn't know any of the artists, but my kid. And I look at you. I was like, well, at least it's a vibe. Right? Right. I don't know where Tribe Called Quest drops scenario. And I'm like.
So I'm, like, flowing along with every bar, and my kid's, like, looking at him. And then I'm just. I'm like. I'm thrilled because Jim never plays anything I give a about. And then suddenly it's over. It's right back to a 300 pop for another 30 minutes. And I was like, all right, we did that. Yeah. There was definitely a worker there trying at this and hijacked the playlist for a second, for sure. Right. Right in the video. I don't know if you remember the video. Oh, yeah. But it's very. It's interesting. It was fun. My kid was like. And I was like, oh, that's so trippy.
So I. In hearing that song in the context of this place that normally plays modern stuff, it really stuck out. And that goes right back to the cd. That moment of Tribe turning on in the gym was a moment I'll remember for a long time because of course it was with the opposite of what's normally played. It's, you know, you don't usually hear old school hip hop there, blah, blah, blah. I had a moment with my kid telling him about Tribe again because I have speech to him about it before and, and those are the moments,
those are the real moments. And why wouldn't the gym just funnel a bunch of AI music? It's just background. Why wouldn't they, Right. Say they won't. The music discussion is fascinating to me and I know we kind of gotten this a while ago, we stuck with it. But I have down in my living room, I don't know, probably thousand vinyl records. And it was like it's a fraction of what I used to have when I was DJing. But I was going through it last night because there's this poster behind me that I just kind of want to put in a different area in
my house. And so I've got a bunch of record frames and going to put some records up and, and put them back here. And so I'm going through because I knew after DJing for so many years, you don't. As you're flipping through your, your crate of vinyl, you know the labels, right? You know exactly which label it is. You don't have to think about it. You just get the label, you throw it on the turntable, you're done. But I remember a lot of album covers that most Deaf Tribe Called Quest, right?
There's Dark side of the Moon, right. Legendary album cover. Asia from Steely Dan. Right. So I'm going through all these records and I'm like, I want to put something back here that not only represents me but also represents the experiences that I've had in life. And I don't think that. And I was saying it's not that I'm playing the music here, it's that I'm using the artwork that meant something to me and it
gave me this kind of renewed hope in what it is that we do. Right. And, and about it being longer lasting and impactful. Right. You get a Notorious B.I.G. the ready to Die album cover is iconic. Herbie Hancock's headhunters, iconic mountain cover. Right. Legendary cover. So these are the things that I look and I could put on the wall and have a conversation about. Yeah.
And I liken that to the types of photography that we do and the printed product and the end product, whether it's a Magazine, whether it's a piece on the wall, is that it invites not only a story about the subject, but it invites a story about the artist. I don't know the photographers or the graphic designers that did most of those album covers, but some of them, when you dig into it, have the most amazing stories about how they got that shot or why they developed things the way they develop how much acid
they were on when they were thinking about the concepts. Whatever it was, there's something there that invites more discussion. When it comes to AI, there is nothing outside of divisive conversation. Right? It just devolves into. That's the avatar that we're using to fight. Instead of discussing the concept, discussing the artist, discussing the reasoning behind it. Why are you naked in that photo? You know, like, whatever it might be, I want art to foster that
discussion. And I don't think that anything AI is fostering a discussion that is positive. It's always like, ugh, there's the slop, or that's not real, or they couldn't have gotten somebody real for that. You know what I mean? So I think therein lies one of these little pieces that we can talk about about the longevity, about the. The sudden experiential memory that we have about where we were
when we heard Scenario for the first time. And Busta Rhymes goes off on some other level of hip hop that no one's ever heard before. And there's a dungeon dragon in there, right? Dungeon dragon. And so I think, you know, as we look to other art forms to influence perhaps how we navigate this space, music is, I think, the closest parallel that I have, even beyond painting, because the visual art there, music has always had the visual and the auditory element
to it that I just find, you know, I just find to be so much stronger. So I'm looking there and kind of watching, you know, and I think. I think that the story element that we're talking about, like you mentioned some album covers, you don't know the history of the. Who made it or why or when. The story element is there, whether you know the story or not. Totally. And that's fascinating. In fact, looking at album covers and sitting with the. With the liner notes, and this is. We're not old enough to remember doing this, of course, but. No, no, no, absolutely not.
Because our high school was late 90s or early 2001 anyway. So my point is, when you look at this, anything at all, and like. Like this image here, the Naikaku did not use AI for I. I've looked at it multiple times. It's kind of grainy and it's someone laying on the ground, and I'm not sure why they're laying on the ground, but I've looked at it a lot and it reminds me of looking at old album covers. I don't know the story and it's likely I never will. But there is one, and that's fascinating. And that's because there's a human again, that experiential element. Someone did it. There was a reason behind it.
Who did it? Why? I. I don't know, but somebody did. As opposed to AI made this. Like for example, the graphic you put up earlier when you started this conversation with me about AI and Ritucci, that was created by AI you can tell it was created by AI. Right. Let me get to. Has that feel to it. Right. And I could recognize that immediately already. And that image will disappear after this conversation and if it's never used again, no one will care. That was the purpose of it, though. It was a quick visual to illustrate.
It's no different than another title graphic in any TV broadcast. So in that regard, sweet. You didn't slave over an hour making that piece. You knocked it out in minutes. Right. So in that regard, it's fine. But if you're going to make actual art that you want someone to remember, you want someone to track down your CD a decade later, it's got to come from you, it's got to come from people. And that's what I mean. You know, this music is not socially profound. First of all, there's no lyrics, so you can interpret however you want. And second of all, it is very inaccessible and complicated and it's not ever going to be popular.
But for me, it meant the world and it made me move mountains and spend copious amounts of money for ancient technology. Right. That means something that's powerful and you can be that as long as you don't compromise yourself. Someone will think about that photo you took in 2017 and talk about it in 2036. Yeah. And you can tell them the story and you can tell them why that happened. I have image. I have an image of a girl that I found. I was looking through a hard drive the other day and I looked at the image and I go, I remember her in Ohio.
What happened? Oh, I shot her on Saturday. She was dead on Monday. And there's a memory. Yeah. A dark one, a profound one. Right. Still, a. That photo now has that memory. I don't have any emotional connection to her. It was a Workshop model that I met for a couple hours. So I don't miss her, because I can't. I don't know her. But there's a story there that is a dark story. And we love. We love drama, we love death, we love, you know, we love explosions,
we love war, we love all the pathos of life. Those are easy to call the human experience, but there's subtle things too, and we. We need to not lose sight of that, because it matters. Every little thing that you do matters. And it's just, you know, modern. Like I said, this. This economy, this cultural economy that we're in, of disposable content that we've been in for a while, likes to make you believe that those little things don't matter and that they do, they always will. And we are going to level out. But are you going to be part of the casualties when it levels
out, or are you going to be on top? And I think just remaining authentic to yourself is at least the best chance you have. You know, if your work is shit, I don't know what to tell you there. But if you stay authentic, at least you give yourself a chance. That's. That's how I see it. And that's. That's how I'm moving forward with myself. I am not scared of AI replacing me, per se, because how about this? If AI can replace me, then it should.
That's a. What's a strong statement? Yeah. You know, I'd like to think that my work is worth more than that. I know it is, because I've seen you. I've seen what you do. I know your clients, what you do absolutely matters. And I'm gonna. I'm gonna kind of leave this here now. But before I go, I do wanna give you a chance to talk a little bit about some of the things that you're doing. Not with that graphic, but with this one. So you've got a couple of different websites, ninobatista.com
and then NBP retouch tools. I know that you've this year been shifting a lot of things around and you're creating a metric ton of value in your tutorials and the tools that are coming out. Talk about some of the stuff you got going on and where can people find all of this? I mean, I've got the QR codes, but is there any other place they should go? Workshops, you're showing up to conferences, anything like that? Yeah, so a couple things. One thing, the main shift that I did when it comes to my, My, My
education Aspect is that I used to offer an annual tutorial retouching collection that you could purchase and you know you have pre purchase price, save some money and you get a whole download of a bunch of videos. Right. I used to do that annually and this year I did it. And then after I did it and I sold some pre sales and all that, it also hit me. I was like, wait a minute. One way that I've adapted is I've taken all these individual videos that I usually put in the collection and they're all basically for sale a la carte. Nothing new for others, but it's new for me. And that has worked because people can look at that and go, oh,
that tutorial is $20. It's an hour or so, it's capture one and it's a studio shot. That's what I do. Cool. And they buy that and they can pick and choose. If they buy a couple, they get a discount. That is an adaptation that I've done as opposed to a big collection for 299 or something like that. Again, others have done it, I haven't some learning to adapt. That's what I want to mention there. And then the workshops. I was not going to do any workshops this year. Not on principle and not on bitterness, just a different bogus.
And I was going to stay home for a while and a couple of things came up. And so I will be in San Juan, Puerto Rico in May and I'm booked in Orlando for a class that I have to do there too. And that is in September. So that's it. And as far as I'm concerned, that's all I'm doing this year in terms of in person workshops. And there's a lot of reasons behind that. I'm just focusing on the directions. But if I do things the way I want, 2027 will be a very busy travel year. Very busy. That's 2026. I'm just kind of. I'm just kind of chilling out now. As for nbp, the retouch tools, those are heavily focused on Photoshop
actions now. And you want to talk about educating your audience, Matt, People are like actions, bro. I bought a set of actions from this person. 2013. It's all bullshit. And I'm like, well, give mine a chance because this isn't a bunch of dumb color presets that don't look like anything in another bleach bypass preset. Nonsense. This is. These are functional tools. And there's a video, video, multiple videos teaching you how each One works. So I feel like I'm pushing the boundaries of what actions can do, but they're supposed to be purposeful, not blind you with science
nonsense. They're useful. So I challenge anyone who thinks actions are useless to go check out mvp, because I think. I think I've done some. Some pretty cool stuff there. And I. I don't want to be. I don't want to sound any kind of way, but I say I've done because I done. Those are actions that I made. Most of them are what I call evolutions of zombie actions. Functions that I made because I knew I needed something to do this function regularly. And then eventually I was like, I need to clean that up and make it useful for someone else. And then they turn into tools, right? So that's. That's how it's happened.
Because you see my zombie actions, I know what they do, but no one else would. So I had to make them functional for people. And that's what I've done over the years. I had these cool collections, so that. That's the two things there. I have to teach my customers that actions are very powerful. And what's really cool about actions is they're not expensive to produce, they're lightweight development. I can update them quickly. So when Adobe decides to shit on everything, I can fix them and then push them out, as opposed to regular development, which is slower and more costly. And then my tutorials, again, they're not. I make up a tutorial.
I'm like, oh, this shot that I'm going to edit today, let's bust the microphone out. We're going to record this one because I think this is going to be a cool lesson. 47 minutes later, I have it recorded. 90 minutes later, it's for sale on my website. I can keep making new, fresh, educational content and keep them moving quickly. And so that's what I'm trying to do now is stay adaptable, current and constantly renewing, if you will. That's kind of what my new philosophy, as opposed to putting together a bulk of content once a year, you know what? I have an AI prompt that I can send you that'll be able to create
all those actions for you. We'll just kind of wrap this up there, I think. You know, one of the things that I do love about your actions is not only do I see you make them, but you explain literally every facet of what the action is doing and how you as the purchaser, as the customer, can modify it. Like, if something goes wrong, if something goes Wrong with your car. You've got a built in mechanic that can show you exactly what belt is squeaking right. And I just really like the, the intentionality that you put into
educating the clients and your customers about what it is that the action's doing, how to modify it, how to tweak it, how it was created, all of that because it's not a mysterious science but what you are doing is taking years of knowledge and making it the most efficient process possible. And I really like that. Just while we're here, a couple of comments came in Unquestionable is talking about his name is Ishan. By the way, if AI can replace you, it should standing out, pivoting, adapting to technology.
Crafty, artsy creatives will stay as such believe that a thousand percent. And you mentioned you were you were going to Puerto Rico. We, we have a mutual friend down there, his name's Billy Thorpe. Really interesting character. I should put him in touch with you. He moved down there and he now makes a living as an Amazon influencer. He will make a video about a pen and he's made 4,000 videos on Amazon and he makes well over six figures doing what he's doing. And it's great. He fell into it during COVID and he's just living life.
He moved out to Puerto Rico this year Then the last comment that Ishan had is I've been making scripts for Adobe Illustrator projects when I need similarly I should post those. Great idea. I think one of the things that I really liked about what you were just saying because it's been my approach to content creation and doing this the same exact way. It's the reason I went to a live format rather than prerecorded and then post processing and posting it, you know, a week later
because it was just taking too much time. We'll record this conversation. It will be immediately available on YouTube. I will then take this and cut it into shorts and spread that out. But the thing is I don't have to now go through and edit anything on this video. It's done in real time. And what I'm finding as I talk to more and more content creators, it's about that speed in efficiency in your workflow.
It's not about the tools, it's not about AI. It's not about anything other than knowing your own workflow, your own process, so that you can deliver more value to your followers, your customers, your clients, whatever it is. And I think people don't spend enough time on making their own workflow work for them. Regardless of the tools, understand what it is that you want to do, understand the life that you want to live and how you
want to find harmony between those two things. So, dude, this has been an incredible conversation as always. We always have a great conversation. Oh, I was a blast. Always a blast. Are you going to be heading out to wppi? I saw you there last year. You're not going to be heading out this year. Okay. No, there's a lot of people that are not going out there this year. So I was just curious. It's a last minute addition for me. I didn't know if I'd be able to see out there and no, I. I generally have no desire to go to Las Vegas again, but I have
no business purpose in WPPI this year either, so. All right, man. All right. Again, for everybody watching, you know, batista.com start there. It'll link off to everything else. Do yourself a favor, check out the work, check out the tools and the actions and just, you know, support real art. I can't say enough good things about having these types of conversations. I think they're important. And if you're watching this and you're hearing what I'm saying,
it's resonating in any way, shape or form, have the same conversation with your friends, no matter what art you're producing, because these are the types of things that we have to figure out on the fly. And if we don't talk about it, we are going to all get swept up in some wave of unemployment which I'm really hoping doesn't happen. So. All right, my friend, hold on one second while I shut everything down and then I will see you when I see you. All right. Thank you, sir. Appreciate everything, man. It was a good time. Thanks, man.
Michele Quigley makes the costume by hand, builds the set, lights it, and then photographs it. The result looks like an oil painting that has been hanging somewhere for two hundred years. Michele is an international...
This is my first show back in about a month and a half, so of course things went wrong. I've got a metal roof and about halfway through the recording the sky opened up over Maine. I had Power EQ running in real time...
Most of us got into creative work wanting to do everything, then spent years drowning in all of it. Sean McCormick did the opposite on purpose. Sean spent years as a public school special education teacher before he...
"As soon as your age has a six in the front in Germany, it's very difficult to find another corporate job." That's where Jörg Kampers starts his story. He spent 35 years inside companies like Commodore, Dell, and...
Most photographers will tell you the same thing if you ask them honestly. The shooting is the part they love. Everything else is overhead. Ashley Siegert heard that enough times that she built an entire company around...