Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

General Practice Clinical Sessions Podcast

General Practice Clinical Sessions Podcast artwork

Knee Osteoarthritis and Surgical Interventions - Primary Care Masterclass Podcast

Dec 29, 202520 minAudio

Knee Osteoarthritis and Surgical Interventions with Dr Jonathan Negus This podcast explores the various facets of knee surgery, including robotic techniques, prehabilitation, and rehabilitation strategies. Dr Jonathan Negus shares insights drawn from nearly two decades of practice as well as emerging technologies that promise to improve patient outcomes. A key aim of the lecture is to clarify the surgical role in treating knee issues, particularly osteoarthritis, which is commonly accompanied by various degrees of degeneration in knee tissues. In discussing patient demographics, the lecture notes a trend toward younger patients with knee arthritis, often resulting from increased physical activity leading to injuries. Typically, those over 60 are considered for arthroplasty, yet the speaker emphasizes the importance of assessing functional limitations rather than solely relying on imaging reports, such as X-rays or MRIs, to dictate treatment. The speaker explains that many patients present with MRI findings that indicate meniscal tears or other conditions but often overlook underlying osteoarthritis, further complicating their situation. Thus, a more symptom-focused treatment approach is advocated, emphasizing the significance of patient function and quality of life beyond mere radiographic appearances. The discussion extends to patient expectations, particularly the desire for immediate pain relief and improved function, which guides decision-making in surgical referrals. The speaker emphasizes the need for a thorough assessment, including understanding a patient's level of pain related to activities and the impact of comorbidities, such as BMI on surgical outcomes. Assessments focus less on radiographic severity and more on how these factors influence overall function and lifestyle, particularly during preoperative evaluations. Further, the speaker addresses rehabilitation's critical role post-surgery, detailing strategies that involve strengthening exercises, education on weight management, and the use of adjuncts like braces and injections. While discussing various treatments like corticosteroids, hyaluronic acid, and PRP, the speaker notes their varied efficacy and expense, stressing a more cautious application. Nerve ablation procedures are introduced as a viable pain management option for certain patients, expanding the range of non-surgical interventions available. Towards the end of the lecture, robotic surgery is highlighted, showcasing how advanced technologies allow for precision in knee reconstruction. The speaker explains that robotics enable more accurate alignment and surgical outcomes, thereby enhancing recovery times and reducing revision rates in joint replacement contexts. The importance of early referrals for surgical consultations, not just for surgery itself but also for education on lifestyle modifications and nonsurgical treatments, is reinforced. In summary, the lecture emphasizes a comprehensive approach to knee osteoarthritis and surgery, integrating patient-centered care principles, high-quality diagnostics, and advanced surgical techniques to optimize outcomes and improve quality of life for patients facing knee issues. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Access thousands of premium conference podcasts and 'full video' podcasts including synchronised PowerPoint slides at https://www.armchairmedical.tv/podcasts General Practitioners: Earn your full year's worth of CPD including Educational Activities, Reviewing Performance and Measuring Outcomes CPD Hours. Discover more at https://www.armchairmedical.tv/podcasts Press play. You’re at the conference. In every episode of ArmchairMedical Conference Podcasts, we bring Australia’s leading medical conference education straight to your headphones. No travel. No full days away from clinic. No disruption to your life. Each episode features real conference lectures, captured live and carefully curated into short, practical, evidence-based podcasts designed for busy general practitioners. Whether you’re commuting, exercising, or moving through the gaps of your day, this is conference-quality learning that fits real GP life. If you value staying at the leading edge of medicine, but don’t have the time to attend every conference, this is the smart way to do it. 🎧 Press play. You’re at the conference. About ArmchairMedical Conference Podcasts ArmchairMedical Conference Podcasts transform Australia’s best medical conferences into on-demand audio education for GPs. Learn from leading clinicians and experts, anytime and anywhere, in a format designed to work with - not against - your day. Enjoying the episode? ⭐ Rate this episode ➕ Follow the podcast 💬 Share it with a colleague who’d value conference learning without the time away Disclaimer: Content is for health professionals and general educational purposes only. It is not medical advice or a substitute for independent clinical judgement. Always consult current guidelines, product information and local protocols. Views expressed are those of the presenters and not necessarily ArmchairMedical. ArmchairMedical accepts no responsibility or liability for any loss or harm resulting from reliance on the information provided. Visit https://www.armchairmedical.tv/podcasts for more information.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Right, back to me. So yeah, originally from the UK, if there's still an accent, I'm not sure anymore. But I've been here nearly 20 years and currently based in around St. Leonard's and more recently up here at Macquarie. Interest in robotic surgery, also prehab and rehab, do a lot of work with my patients on pre-optimization with physical therapy and with their rehab and looking at the outcomes that go with that. Uh trying to not overlap too much especially with sort of rasvan with the hip

because there's a lot of similarities and also with um bernie's going to talk a bit about sort of patient demographics and, um so we'll try and stay away from that been involved in a few different things. So goal for me today is trying to support your decision making really on how patients come to us clarify the role of surgery within the knee and then share a few new insights on new technologies and what their implications are hopefully that will bring up a few questions you

all know about osteoarthritis a condition that affects all the tissues within the knee I think that trying to get a key from each slide and the key for me on this is that and we'll get to imaging shortly is that often people will come to me now with an MRI and they'll say I've been sent in because I've got a meniscal tear and I will say well that's true but you're 70 and the rest of your knee is worn out and the meniscal tear is part of the arthritis process, and i think it's a really important message and that's why when we'll get to the imaging slides why we prefer just to get an x-ray

because often the mri adds a lot of complication in terms of explaining to the patient what's going on with their knee commonly medial more than telephemeral more than lateral that's just what we see and i'm sure you're the same and a bit like hips with lack of internal rotation really that reduced range of motion and stiffness is probably one of the more common signs effusions is very variable some people with terrifically bad arthritis have no effusions other people with fairly mild arthritis have very swollen knees.

So typically we're looking at over 50s it's um you know we're seeing younger and younger patients now more active population um more knee injuries at a younger age leading to that post-traumatic arthritis but generally for arthroplasty we tend to be considering people over 60 more commonly obviously there are exceptions in terms of assessment factors i mean for me the functional impacts the most critical we take pain histories that's very very important but you know there's pain in and of itself and there's pain that stops you doing the things you want to do I mean sleeping is one of those obviously and just getting around

and doing activities of daily living but I think our population now has a higher expectation than just walking to the shops or, getting on public transport which a lot of our questionnaires are based on a lot of people still want to play golf you know they want to go walking on the on the beach or go walking around the park for a couple of kilometers every day and that's important for their physical and mental health so we have to look at how important the loss of function is to them. Comorbidities, I think, are going to be discussed along with BMI.

We take BMI into consideration, but really, in terms of knee surgery, it's really only the very morbidly obese that has a significant effect on outcomes afterwards. It leads to a little bit more sweat and a few more harsh words in the operating theater sometimes, but it doesn't affect outcomes. Functional loss greater than radiographic severity. I think Razvan explained that very well. We don't treat the x-rays. I try and say to patients, they say, oh, both my knees, which is worse? And you say, well, they've both got arthritis. So now we've made the decision that you've got that disease.

Now we're going to look at function and pain and say, which one is worse, which one needs treating? It doesn't really matter which looks worse on the x-ray. In terms of things to ask, knowing where it is, sometimes it gives you a good clue. I'd never heard of the movie theater sign until I did a bit of a search, but I thought it was quite a nice little description. I often talk to people about if they're sitting in a car for a long period of time, but if they're sitting in a movie, an hour, two hours, do they get stiff and do they need to move their knee? That's normally patellofemoral.

If they're weight-bearing or doing any impact activities and have pain on the inside of their knee, it's medial, it all makes sense. But what's nice about that is if they have that medial pain and they're tender medially and their x-ray shows medial arthritis, it's really reassuring for us to go, if you do an operation that addresses that medial compartment or along with other compartments, you're more likely to get a good result. If they have just purely medial arthritis and the pain is all over the knee and you just address the medial side you're going to get less of a good result so just just putting the matching up the the symptoms to the imaging can be

useful in terms of knowing what to do or whether you're more likely to get a good result mechanical symptoms of locking and catching now commonly associated with either loose bodies or meniscal tears but that can also be arthritis one because arthritis they have loose bodies and meniscal tears but also just the quality of the cartilage is very poor and therefore they can um they end up uh with a lot of those mechanical symptoms as well on examination they said we're going to see the antalgic gait that we've already touched on the effusion the stiffness tenderness over the the joint line they're all things we find out i don't think

they affect too much in what we do um but they're just important to note in terms of ongoing management and red flags obviously. So imaging, really, I mean, this is one of the key things. It's so simple, but I still get a lot of people referred to me with a first line imaging being an MRI and that's fine. I don't mind, but it just is a pain for the patients, costs money, costs time, and it's probably more difficult for you guys. So plain x-rays are absolutely fine. The important one is the Rosenberg, which is a view that actually goes, it's not an AP, it's a PA, comes from behind with the knee slightly bent.

And the reason for that is that it shows the cartilage around the back of the knee when the knee is flexed and sometimes if i've done this right um in extension the medial compartment there doesn't look too bad but in the rosenberg you're down to bone on bone and if you didn't do a rosenberg you might see the ap and go well you've got mild arthritis so your pain is is not explainable but actually the rosenberg shows it is and often these people have got more pain on stairs or activities where they're bending their knee more when they're standing they say it's not too bad i'm going downstairs i get pain it feels a bit wobbly so it's

just important to get those views but with a set of x-rays we'll be able to manage most people you refer in so why an MRI well an MRI for me is someone who's of an appropriate age where they've got pain and you may have seen them and you think oh they're going to have arthritis you get a full set of x-rays and their x-rays are normal then you don't have a diagnosis then it's reasonable to get an MRI. And then this example I'll put an arrow on there so you can see that's a radial tear of the posterior horn of the meniscus this often happens quite quickly and then they get this bone bruising pattern um can i do it on both just back

there so this sort of whiteness in the bone underneath, um over here and that's just the bone has gone from having a structural support with the meniscus to a sudden tear no support and it gets very painful very quickly and they struggle to walk so that can often explain pain when the x-ray looks relatively normal so mris can be useful, but essentially there should be second line when the when mri should be second line when the x-ray is shown to be fairly normal and out of it's not doesn't fit with the clinical findings.

So what do the patients want? Well, they want to know what's going on. They want to have a diagnosis. They want to be out of pain, which might involve interventions. And then they want to improve their function. I think that's really important. So rehab and exercise therapy following knee surgeries, especially knee replacement, I think is critical, especially if we're trying to get them back to a higher level of function. So when to refer? Well, persistent symptoms if we've trialed non-operative care. Again, I think RASVAN's highlighted very well that it's not first line is to

make sure that we treat non-operatively and optimize them to see whether we can avoid the surgery. However, if the symptoms continue despite all the varying treatments, then we need to consider it. Functional decline that is affecting them, limitations on work or sport. Um recurrent effusions more to explain why just try and work out there's not anything else going on um and severe radiographic OA of course if it's if it's severe the likelihood

is they're going to be heading towards some sort of surgery so it's worth considering considering the options and starting the education process but I think the earlier referral leads to better education and planning so I like to see people early because um I'm very happy to then place people into a physical therapy program and give them the advice on what they can do advise them on weight loss advise them on strength and if i focus more on strength and weight loss actually i think i always talk about power to weight ratio so the problem one of the problems of weight loss again without touching too much on bernie's

is if you lose weight and lose weight rapidly you lose muscle if you lose muscle around the knee you get knee pain it's it's simple so i'd rather they get stronger first and again that's part of the education process i find if i see people earlier. So as you can see there's some of the kit we have but it's it's you know we will we'll measure strength and function in order to get a really good idea of where people are in their journey. Oh that didn't work well um we also have questionnaires um uh we can do uh we

can ask standardized questionnaires in order to get a uh an idea of where they are along with the more functional assessments and obviously look at satisfaction expectation along the way, so educate first line treatments education is key weight loss um around about three to four times your body weight goes through your knee as you walk is around about seven to eight times your body weight when you run so when people say when i run it hurts and you go well if you're carrying 10 or 15 k's extra you're putting another 70 to 90 k's through your knee than you should be so it's going

to hurt so it is important to bear in mind but obviously physiotherapy and strengthening, is key as well basic analgesia has all been touched on weight loss there are various different, modalities as we know and again i won't go through that. When people say they've done physio i think it's really important just to question what that involved there's obviously unsupervised at home or in the gym there is there's there's physio where they're they're actually given exercises and monitored um versus

just being put on a bike or or given a sheet of exercises and they haven't done them and then there's exercise physiologists more long-term looking at long-term function so it's important for us to get a history of what they've actually done so when they say it has or hasn't worked we actually know whether it's like being given a tablet and not taking it it's um you have to you have to actually um do it in order to see a result. In terms of other adjuncts, this particular brace, for example, is a medial unloader brace. So in the younger patient, this can be useful. It acts like a spring on the inside of the knee and just actually pushes the joint surface apart.

So when they're walking, it takes a little bit of the impact out of the knee and it can give people a fair amount of time. And I find this quite useful in people who've got active jobs, like builders or in construction, especially if they're just trying to see out the last few years of their, of their company or their work um it can be a useful thing but like all these things i think it's about a thousand dollars so it's not it's it's got to be it's got to be considered carefully but it can work very very well it can also be used prior to an osteotomy operation to see

whether the osteotomy may work it does a similar thing um injections have been touched upon obviously corticosteroid has been a number of discussions i don't tend to use it in me very much at all purely because it's so short term i will use it if someone has a big effusion that is i'm struggling to to get under control and i want to get them back in the gym and get them get them strong, or very occasionally i'll use it if someone's got a big cruise or something coming up and you're just trying to give them a band-aid to go away with but other than that because it rarely lasts beyond three months in the knee in my

experience i just don't find it to be particularly useful. Um prp and hyaluronic acid are two that i get asked about a lot and they have variable evidence and i think the evidence for every year it seems to go in favor of one and the other and it comes back um essentially they're both quite expensive i think prp tends to be about 300 a time and you need two or three for a course hyaluronic acid is five six hundred dollars a shot depending but you have one so I tend to tell the patients it's about 60% effective in

those it works it works well but in those other people it does absolutely nothing at all so if you're willing to spend the money you can trial it if there's no other option but really only for those people for whom they're maybe the younger people are really trying to avoid a knee replacement you can give it a go. But the evidence isn't great. It's one of those things we use when we really don't have many other options. Stem cells, the evidence is poor, as in it's good evidence that it is poor effect. I tell patients it just doesn't work at the minute.

Nerve ablation is a procedure that's getting more popularity in the knee. It's a day case procedure that takes around about 20 minutes. Needles are placed in four or five anatomical locations around the knee with the patient sedated or with general anesthetic and then i put a probe down into the needle and it does a two and a half minute burn at each site and it just it just takes the geniculate nerves so it gives the patient good pain relief it's effective in about 80 85 percent of people so who's this for well, insurance weight period is just i get a number of people who come in they go

i've just found out that i'm not i'm covered for knee reconstruction not knee replacement i've got to wait a year, but the their insurance level does cover ablation so it can actually give them really good pain relief for that time while they're waiting um it can be good in the insufficiency fractures and it could be good for people who have got other comorbidities maybe like the 94 year old where you're you're looking at going i really don't want to do a big knee replacement on this person, um i had a lady who had um she had terminal cancer she had a life expectancy of 12 months but she had terrific pain from a very

valgus knee so we did it she got great pain relief but she came in even after all the education but my knee's still bent and I was like I put needles around your knee I was not going to straighten it out but uh she got good pain relief so it can be a. Non-replacement surgery, you know, the days of doing a clean out for arthritis have gone. Patients come in, can you just do a clean up and a tidy up? And we just know that if you go into an arthroscopy and take away all the little

bits of cartilage and little bits of torn meniscus, they'll just be back. They'll just be back very shortly. The knee's failing, so cleaning it up just doesn't work. And you're subjecting that person to unnecessary surgery and risk, as well as the fact that every time we operate on a knee, we weaken their quads. So they've just got more work to do to get their strength back and the strength is really key for them osteotomy um there's just some slides from the the way that a lot of osteotomies can be done now which is all planned on computer like most things and specialized jigs made in order to, cut a wedge of bone in the tibia or the femur and readjust the alignment so

we just take the alignment weight bearing alignment um away from the the damaged part of the knee and over into the non-damaged part of the knee, more for the younger, more active patients, and can be an alternative to joint replacement in those people. Talking about joint replacement well if we delay surgery we also want to pick the right people but if we leave things too long prolonged pain leads to prolonged functional loss muscle loss deconditioning,

can have significant mental health impacts and it can compromise outcomes post-surgery i think things have to get pretty bad to compromise the outcomes in terms of stiffness but if people start to get a progressive deformity that gets fixed that does actually lead to bigger procedures so, generally we tend to see people before that happens but there are some impacts to delaying surgery. From the point of view of replacement you've got partial or total. Partial can be medial, lateral or just patellofemoral.

By far and away the most common is the medial which is the one up there that's because medial arthritis is the most common. It's been done more, it's more reliable the others are a little bit more tricky and and just less reliable um so uh most most people instead of a lateral or a pteropheromal will just have a total but there's there's a around 15 something like that of of arthroplasty is um will be a unique unicompartmental medial. So can be a little it's a little less invasive little

faster recovery um and and the robotic technology that's come in has really helped us with this and has helped us to um to do it in a more precise way for people so we're getting i think starting to show some better results with that but still the majority is total knee replacement which is very reliable and again as raz van pointed out i'm quoting him a lot today um the uh the polyethylene the plastic liner that we had in we have in the knees much like the hips has improved so much that we just get the knees lasting that much longer now. So why robotics touching on robotics well it

allows us um it allows us greater precision and alignment and and an ability to balance up the knees so from a surgical point of view we we like it gives us more information and more ability to perform a reproducible operation there's some early data coming out about faster rehab and maybe some lower revision rates but essentially it's um surgically it gives us more options to do what we do better um and it's increasingly being used in centers of excellence this is just one of the screens that gives an idea of one of the platforms of this is prior to making any cuts in a knee so

we can virtually make cuts, put prostheses on, work out the gaps, adjust it all and then we go in and make a cut which is a little different to how it was done before. So what can you do? Well, encourage weight management and strengthening, optimize chronic health, educate patients, early imaging with weight-bearing x-rays, refer early for a discussion not just for surgery and discuss realistic expectations because surgery is a tool it's not a cure and it's part of a process of of of your health optimization um rehab and uh everything

that goes with that so our patients want to be out of pain to have better function i think you guys really are key to the early identification, and management um and i said if it can make your life easy just do x-rays that's all you need, and we'll be happy with that uh joint replacement now offers a more accurate delivery of the prosthesis it's not essential but it's definitely something that's becoming much more popular and used by more surgeons and the key is early referral to start the process basically to improve

the patient's function. Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Protecting the feet in people with diabetes Professor Stephen Twigg

    Sep 19, 202619 minAudio

    Protecting the feet in people with diabetes Professor Stephen Twigg Professor Stephen Twigg addresses the critical issue of preventing diabetes-related foot diseases, emphasizing the need for effective prevention...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Advances in prostate cancer diagnosis and treatment Dr Nick Mehan

    Sep 17, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Host: Michelle Odayan (My Health Academy) Guest Expert: Dr. Nicholas Mehan (Urological Surgeon specializing in prostate cancer, robotic surgery, and laser ablation) Episode Summary Dr. Nicholas Mehan provides an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. First Trimester & Screening Dr Jackie Chua

    Sep 16, 202633 minAudio

    First Trimester & Screening Host/Speaker: Dr. Jackie Chua (Director, Queensland Ultrasound for Women) Episode Summary: Early pregnancy scans involve far more than checking for a heartbeat. Dr. Jackie Chua breaks down...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Plant based diet in diabetes Vivien Yiu

    Sep 12, 202616 minAudio

    Plant based diet in diabetes Vivien Yiu In this podcast, Vivian Yiu explores the prevention and management of Type 2 diabetes through plant-based eating. She presents evidence-based strategies, emphasizing the benefits...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Gestational Weight Gain Why is it Important Dr Robyn Barnes

    Sep 5, 202617 minAudio

    Gestational Weight Gain Why is it Important Dr Robyn Barnes The podcast examines the importance of gestational weight gain in managing gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM), highlighting medical nutrition therapy (MNT) as...

    Credit the people on this episode