Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Future Learning Design Podcast

Future Learning Design Podcast artwork

Educating Otherwise - A Conversation with Sarah Winkler-Reid, Mariya Ivancheva and Tim Ingold

Nov 21, 202644 minAudioSeason 1, Episode 262
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This week's episode is a follow up to episode 249 on ‘Education Through the Anthropological Lens’. I wanted to highlight a fantastic new book just out called ‘Educating Otherwise: Contexts, Interventions and Radical Possibilities of Anthropological Learning’, edited by Sarah Winkler-Reid, Caroline Gatt, Tim Ingold, Elsayed E. Abdelhamid, Soumhya Venkatesan, Simone Dennis, Mariya Ivancheva, Cris Shore, Cynthia Sear and Andrew Dawson. It builds on similar themes, but it goes deeper into the fundamental question of how the practices and approaches to learning used in anthropology might help us to do education differently. But simultaneously doing education otherwise might also help to do anthropology differently, particularly in the way it is taught in schools and universities. The five themes (studios) that structure the book are: Anthropology as education; Decolonizing the academy; Student-academic collaborations; Anthropology and the university; Anthropology across disciplines As you will hear, the book is just one small aspect of a much larger process involving many collaborators. And it represents a different approach to both writing and publishing. But in this conversation I was lucky enough to chat to Sarah Winkler-Reid, Mariya Ivancheva and Tim Ingold. Sarah Winkler-Reid is a senior lecturer in Social Anthropology at Newcastle University. Her research explores education, labour and ethics in contemporary Britain. She has examined this through a focus on young people’s daily lives in school, and now through a focus on construction and urban development in the North East of England. She is the author of Individually Ourselves: Personhood, Ethics, and Everyday Life at School (Berghahn Books 2023). Mariya Ivancheva is a senior lecturer at the Strathclyde Institute of Education. She is a sociologist and anthropologist of education and labour. Her work focuses on the casualization and digitalization of academic work, and the role of universities in processes of social change. She is the author of The Alternative University: Lessons from Bolivarian Venezuela (Stanford University Press, 2023). Tim Ingold, CBE, is Emeritus Professor of social anthropology at the University of Aberdeen, and a Fellow of the British Academy and the Royal Society of Edinburgh. He has published extensively on themes of human ecology, environmental relations, art, architecture and education. Full access to the book: https://www.berghahnbooks.com/title/Winkler-ReidEducating

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

So the effect of that is actually to cut off the transmission process from the life process, as though education is about transmitting the resources, informational material that people need to live. It's not about life itself. And this, I think, has been utterly disastrous. Hi, everyone. Thanks for joining me on the podcast. My name is Tim Logan and the podcast is produced by Good Impact Labs. This week's episode is a follow

up to a recent episode we did in August of our education and anthropology. I wanted to highlight a fantastic new book just out called Educating Otherwise Contexts, Interventions and Radical Possibilities of Anthropological Learning edited by Sarah Winkler Reed, Caroline GAT, Tim Ingold and other Co editors. The book builds on the themes discussed in the previous episode, but it goes deeper into the fundamental question of how the practices and approaches to learning used in anthropology might help us to do education differently.

But simultaneously doing education otherwise in this way might also help us to do anthropology differently, particularly in the way it's taught in schools and universities. As you'll hear, the book is just one small aspect of a much larger process involving many collaborators, and it represents a different approach to both writing and publishing. But in this conversation, I was lucky enough to chat with Sarah Winkler Reed, Maria Ivancheva, and Tim Ingold. I'll let them introduce themselves in a moment, but you'll find they're full of BIOS and links to the Open Access book and much more in the show

notes. Just fastly huge gratitude to all of you for taking the time out of your busy schedules to have a conversation, an incredibly important book and obviously making the connections between education and anthropology, which we've done a bit previously on podcast. But I think it to me, it goes a lot further than that because it's a real kind of invocation to everyone who cares about education and anthropology, of course. But I think really thinking about how could we shift

education? And I know you've been working on this, all of you, and Tim particularly for a long, long time, advocating for these of changes. So perhaps, Sarah, starting with you, would you just be able to just introduce the concept of the book, where did it come from, and give it a framing? So I'm Sarah Wickley Read and I'm one of the Co editors of this volume, which has been a long time in the making. In 2022 we started a conference but we wanted to do something really different. So a conference supported by the Association of Social Anthropologists of the UKASA. And when we got together, when

we were thinking about how we were going to do an online conference, we sort of wanted to take out principles of what we feel is kind of can be the issue with education in general, this kind of transmission model of education, which I'm sure we'll talk about. And conferences often are like that as well. So people bring their finished products to the conference and sort of exchange them like a marketplace. And we wanted this to be much more like a conversation. So we settled on five what we could studios and we called them studios because we wanted to

emphasize the conversation, the collaboration, the practice. And each studio went lasted a month. So it would have an introduction session, some kind of conclusion session and then some sessions in between and how those studios worked different from topic to topic. Each studio had two Co conveners and they became the Co editors of that section of the book. So in 2022, we had that in the end, over nine months, to have all of these ongoing conversations about education and anthropology, thinking about

it outside education institutions, inside education institutions, thinking particularly about political education in its higher education context and having an opportunity to explore these things. We thought criticism is really important, but so is offering alternatives. And I think one of the things that was great about the conference that's come through into this volume is that people are doing all of these kind of alternative practices of education and often they're happening little pockets. They might be happening in

little pockets inside higher education or inside other education institutions or outside, and we have a lot less opportunity to share them than we do our research. So we wanted an opportunity for people to be able to share what they were doing and how they were doing things differently, as well as thinking about the conditions of education. And that's how the book developed. Really it's these two things are intention 1 is how education can perpetuate hierarchy and exclusion and prejudice, and

also how it can address it and how people might be doing these kind of alternative practices of education educating otherwise all about the place. Amazing. Thank you. And could you just say a little bit about anthropology in that, because I'm in the first studio, I guess the first of the five sections in the book is called Anthropology as Education, which is a great title for the section, makes me want to dive immediately in. But there's something there for people who are non anthropologists or less familiar with anthropology. What's the connection there? Like why not sociology as

education? Or why not biology as education? So as anthropologists, we kind of have as our heart at the center, hopefully learning alongside people and having first hand experience of what's going on. And then, you know, we do that and an important part of the anthropological training is to do field work and to have that first time experience. And then we have the kind of classroom where sometimes that can get separated and we go back to a kind of more conventional mode of education where the

teacher is teaching and transmitting their information, their knowledge to the students. And the students are seen as these passive recipients. And so when we're thinking about the relationship between and education, what we wanted to think about is how can we put our money where our mouth is and not just think about, you know, how do we really respect difference and not just put people into the boxes that we've decided, but really kind of allow these things to open up and be explored through education.

And so seeing those two things as very kind of intertwined rather than just doing how things have always been done. Yeah, I know. I love that. It's almost like, yeah, you stop being an anthropologist when you go into teaching mode, right? You go out and do the anthropology, but then you just go into transmission mode when you're back in the in a classroom. And that's one of the funny things is that for a lot of anthropologists, teaching takes up a lot of our working time being part of our day. And it's a really important, it's a thing that's very important to us and very meaningful. And yet somehow it's not getting

the recognition it deserves on these kind of disciplinary scales. So that was the other kind of motivation really for this conference and this volume is taking what we're doing in our daily practice and really giving it this platform and allowing the different voices of people who are involved and using different formats to express that. So in this book there's about 27 different contributions and some of them are little snippet, postcard type contributions, some of them are short form

essays, some of them are longer chapters. We've got an ethnographic fiction, we've got visual responses, audio responses. So we also wanted to move beyond chapter, chapter, chapter to something a bit more creative. Amazing and a beautiful YouTube video of a spider with some lovely music and lots of amazing contributions. Now it's really rich. Tim maybe coming over to you. I'm sure you've got nothing to say to any of these topics given that these have been rather present for you for quite a while. So I just wonder if there's anything there you wanted to pick up on or otherwise.

I I definitely have a question I'd love to ask. I'd be happy to pick up on all the things that Sarah said. I agree entirely. I mean, my, my frustration has been with that sub discipline known as the anthropology of education, which has always been rather marginal within the discipline compared with other fields. And frustrating because anthropologists have tended to treat education just as the subject of ethnographic enquiry rather than actually something that they're doing. And it felt to me very much that that anthropology is itself a

form of education. It's an educational practice that's going on both in the field and in the classroom. But in order to show how that's the case, we need to challenge some presumptions, both in anthropology and in education about what anthropology and education are are both about. And in the educational case, it's obviously challenging the presumption, the transmission model, the idea that education is simply transmitting a body of knowledge that has already been formulated and specified to these recipients, the students.

You would rather think of it as an exploratory activity in which teachers and students together explore a field without any predetermined outcomes. And then to see too, that we can see anthropology too, in that kind of way, that even if we go to the field there, the anthropologist is the one who's who's doing most of the learning. But again, it's an exploratory activity that you're carrying on with other people. And what I really wanted to try and do was to break down the boundary between the Academy and

the field, meaning everything outside the Academy. As you said, there's a tendency for anthropologists to go and do their stuff in the field, being anthropologists. Then they come back to the university and immediately move into the standard educational model and say, well, I've done my research here it is here results. I'm going to tell you all about it. And that that reproduces that boundary between the, the Academy where you have one kind of conversation with students and the world out there where you have another kind of conversation with people in in the field. And and it's that boundary that I think we need to try and break

down. Interesting. And I mean, it's almost that kind of learning disposition when you're in the field is also partly that's where it becomes or can historically has become an extractive move because it's it's all for the benefit of the anthropologist. And therefore there's a huge amount of very precious learning being held by that person, which they may not necessarily always treat with the care that it deserves. That is true. So I mean the, the old style as you, you go out, you extract your data, bring it back to the

university, analyse it, produce books results and then teach students. So the extractive model of research is combined with the transmission model of education. So, so we needed a breakdown in the interests of decolonisation, we needed to breakdown both of these. And the point is that you that it's transformative for both. I mean, the critique of education is also a critique of anthropology. It's not just critiquing education saying, look, we're anthropologists for critiquing education. We must be critiquing anthropology as well. And, and I'd like to see it as

in terms of conversations we have. We have a conversation with people in the field. We have a conversation with colleagues in conferences, in books. We write in what we read. We have a conversation with students and all those conversations can feed into one another. And a crucial point, like Sarah already said, is that for most of us working in universities as anthropologists, the vast majority of our time is spent with students or in student related matters. In a rather small proportion actually out in the field doing any research.

And somehow we're socialised into this idea that we're only really doing anthropology when we're out there, that that this teaching is just sort of necessary thing. You know, we have to do it. And we complain because you had to spend so much time teaching that we don't have enough time for our research. So there's this idea that somehow what you do with students is residual and it's not itself contributing anything to the field. And I think that's been really, really bad. I mean, back in the bad old days, we used to consider that the people among whom we worked were not, they were contributing

data material, but not themselves contributing to the formation of anthropological knowledge. And we had a great revolution and actually allowed the people who we talked to in the field as as collaborators who are working with us in this whole thing. But we still treated the students as there's a lot of people that that we have to sort of talk about anthropology with, but but they're not actually contributing anything. And so it turned the important to make that next step, which is to recognise that it's not only

the people we collaborate with in the field or colleagues that we collaborate with the students too, and that those conversations are absolutely transformative in terms of the development of anthropology, but they've not been recognised. Yeah, beautiful. Yeah. And I mean, it's a shift in self perception that we talk about a lot in relation to educational changes in all sorts of ways. Seeing yourself more as a Co learner and a guide and a support rather than, as you said, this kind of transmitter, the font of all knowledge transmitting, which is a broken.

I mean, it's it's it's a very limited basis for that now, I think now based on what we know about cognition. But just maybe, Sarah, if I could just come back to you, because I mean, you've, you've also done your field work in schools, right, As I understand, and that's interesting. Then when it you then take your anthropological gaze and approaches into a school setting. I mean, big question, I know, but what observations or you know, what experiences have you had that come to mind in that role? Yeah, so my PhD field work within a high school in London, and that was the kind of first

part of my research career really was focusing on education, but more on all the things that happen away from adult eyes that aren't formal education. And you know, what I write in this introduction is that young people are amazing, incredible learners and educators. They're constantly educating each other and learning how to become particular kinds of people. And very difficult part of that is policing each other and shaping each other and evaluating each other in these

ways. But it's very effective in terms of them learning how to be particular kinds of people. What's a lot less effective and a lot more hit and miss is the formal business of schooling. And in the high school that I did my research and, you know, there was a huge spectrum from people who are very invested to not invested at all and actively resistant. And I think that is another example of how humans are incredible learners and yet the formal business of education is often very ineffective. So there's this disjunct between how from the moment they're

born, humans learn amazing, incredible, all sorts of things. And then we put them into these educational contexts, which are often focused on this decontextualized form of learning. And it just doesn't work very well. And when we get to higher education and we're thinking, thinking about it, we're often as lecturers might be feeling a bit demoralized by that and thinking, you know, I'm teaching the students this, but somehow it's not coming through and thinking actually that might be about the way we're teaching and how we're conceiving them, you

know, how learning happens and what education is about. Absolutely. And I mean, when it gets acknowledged, it's in some kind of categorization, like the hidden curriculum. It's, you know, often it we just pretend it's not even there. But this rich life that young people have in an institutional context, absolutely. It's usually disciplined or the space of stopping them doing things that rather than actually actively encouraging them to explore, right? Just to add to that, yeah, That,

you know, it often becomes blamed on the students, the young people, that they're somehow deficient or deficit, you know. So when I took that research and I did a project where I'm based now on the northeast of England called Girlkind, it was about just creating spaces where girls can be valued for their own experience and their own expertise. And that felt so simple, but actually the experience was so profound because young people and the girls often, you know, they're very devalued for what they know and what they experience.

Yeah, fascinating. So much, yeah, so much learning, Maria, just based on your contribution to the book. And you were really talking about the kind of institutional spaces that we're, you know, are the framing for all of this learning that's happening. But they really often constrain what can happen, what can be said or the kinds of things that are valued, the incentive structures, etcetera. Very much a topic of this podcast in terms of what different kinds of institutional forms might create a more generative space for these kinds of rich learning environments

we're talking about. Perhaps. Yeah. Could you just reflect on some of the things that, because you were focusing specifically on the university, I think as the institutional form, But yeah, what were your observations? So yeah, first I'm Maria Ivancheva. I am an anthropologist and sociologist already bringing one more discipline in and I'm based at the School of Education here in Scotland, which also means that I'm working with colleagues from quite few different disciplines on the field of education. My specialism is in higher education in the sense of

research that's done on the higher education setting in anthropology very often is out ethnographic itself. And it's just a few of us, including Clichor with whom we collaborated in our studio for anthropology and the university that actually do research in the university setting. And because of that, we very often have to reach out of our disciplinary field and go into other disciplines where a lot of the debates are perhaps much more advanced or interesting

without necessarily forgetting that anthropology has a lot of to contribute through a kind of theoretical lens and field work kind of immersion that is very different in other fields. So what we did in our studio was to think about first, who else do we learn from and how do other disciplines in the social sciences address the university as a field of study? What do we study, what do we learn, What do we have to understand? Because these days, increasingly

in anthropology we're faced with having to engage our knowledge in research based activism very often to resist redundancies, precarity, and a lot of us who have come through that trajectory know how difficult it is and how little. Often ethnographic data on its own is taken into consideration because it is a long form, long term immersive field work that nobody has the time or funding for, or very few people do, and because policymakers don't like reading ethnography, they like

stories, they like vignettes from time to time, maybe some snippets of quotes, but not real ethnographic writing. So what do we do? And so we also were speaking about studying the university, which often is much messier, kind of boundary versus resisting. So what are the projects that we see around us that are worth thinking from everyday Resistance in our teaching classroom engagement and to really, you know, a few people are collective taking institutions, countries, you

know, through trade union or other forms of opposition against what is happening in the sector, which is quite scary these days, especially in the UK. So we did that studio. But that makes me also think, within the broader framework of the book, what's the difference perhaps? Is that the way our work with Chris and others working on the institution, the way that Sarah has worked on the school? So really taking that as a context of deep learning and really understanding what's going on, it is an important vantage point.

Is also to understand a bit how anthropology functions and where it is complicit with some of the process that are happening and some of the tensions. And one of the tensions that I can feel partly is the discipline. You know, what does the discipline mean? On the one hand, we're trying to keep boundaries, to keep people in and out, to show distinction, to show who deserves to be in and who doesn't. And that feels very different from when you're in and out. I'm a person that was the president of the European Association of Social Anthropology, but I've never gotten an interview at an

anthropology department in my 20 years of academic career. So it is kind of interesting distinction of who is considered in and out, but also the kind of year he internally, once you are in, you know, how we treat our students. Are they disciples? You know, master's in disciples in the Morhigarian old school sense. And if they aren't, are we just facilitators of knowledge? And knowledge is porous and information is fluid and it's everywhere. And what are the difficulties with both approaches? One approach is, of course, structuring your body into vertical area in which you

receive orders and adhere to them, and then that makes you more compliant. But at the same time, the new approach, which a lot of universities try to kind of introduce, is to completely flatten education to information. And then everybody can curate an online forum in a MOOC that thousands of people can subscribe to and you don't need expertise, you don't need the level of intellectual integrity, ethical integrity that education within a specific discipline requires.

So then we are against that force as well. So why we're trying to reform the colonize the year highest discipline because it has all these old school problems that we've mentioned. At the same time, we're against the bigger trend that is trying to make us all redundant very physically for us in the UK, because I myself was through a kind of redundancy list in which there was 30% chance that I lost my job. And a lot of, as we're speaking, hundreds plus universities in the UK are introducing huge

redundancy schemes, some compulsory, some voluntary, and getting creative programs like Edinburgh in the humanities and social sciences. So how do you do 1 sort of reform while it also renders you more and more invisible? And you can speak also about AI and where it answers this, because that's an even bigger topic. Sure. Absolutely no. Wow, thank you. I mean, that's fascinating. I think that is a real tension that I feel in all of this work around kind of reforming, transforming education is that tension that you've named between kind of the opening, the

flattening and the more inclusive, decolonizing, etcetera. And at the same time understanding or holding, you know, what is my role as an expert or as a as a holder of knowledge, whatever that even means, if we're going to even excavate, what do we mean by knowing or knowledge? So it's a really, yeah, I feel you. It's a really interesting tension. And that's, I think that's why often a lot of people resist, particularly educators resist that because they know how powerful the, the role of being the guide who really does know, you know, I mean, it's it,

there's a lot of tension, isn't there? I don't know, Tim, I wonder what you think about that in relation to kind of wayfinding And you know, are we all just bumping into each other wayfinding randomly together or or is there a role for someone who has some kind of a map for the wayfinding, I don't know. Well, one of the issues that we did have to contend with or, or allow for in, in this volume is that there's a way of thinking of education which is framed essentially by institutions, institutions of higher education, institutions of, of schools.

And there's a sense of education which is fundamental to life itself, but are both perfectly valid approaches. And we have both of them in the volume, but they raise different kinds of questions. And part of the problem is how to link those questions up. So speaking simply from my own work, I've wanted to think about education in that very broad sense. It's just the same way as you might talk about religious life or political life, their educational life. It's an aspect of the whole, the

whole thing. It's, it's the way actually the way in which a society or a community secures its continuity in time. And therefore it's something that any society everywhere in the world at any time in history, education has been going on because otherwise there would be no continuity. So then we're thinking about it in those very, very general terms, but obviously also we have to think about it in the terms of what is going on in primary schools, in secondary education, in higher education. And there's a sort of separate set of issues, but they're not

completely separate and they feed into one another. And, and maybe part of the problem that we're we're addressing is that they've been partitioned too much so that the professionals have been able to talk about education and educational institutions, forgetting what the whole point of it is, which is for social life to continue. Instead, they've narrowed it down, for example, to how to train kids into this brand new technocratic order that we're designed for them all, how to ensure that they have good employment prospects or how to overcome disadvantage and things

like that in a competitive society. So the, the professionals, the policy makers are all looking at that stuff and somehow losing track of what the point of the whole thing was in the 1st place, which is that life, social life should actually carry on across generations. So I mean, that's that's why my old work I've been found myself particularly looking at the way which we think about generations in this. Absolutely no. I mean, but it's interesting, isn't it? Because even in, I mean, I fully agree with you in the, the kind of that ongoing, the social continuity that you talk about

and the role of education in that. But even there, as you say that we partitioned it strongly. But even in our every aspect of our lives, there are people we will go to for guidance on life challenges, right? It's not that we're all just bumbling away trying to figure it out for ourselves as though no one's ever, you know, experienced this before. So even there we have elders, right? We have elders that we might go to too, but. The key transition that happened sort of historically with the advent of, of modernity in a broad sense, that is at the moment when particularly when

the state began to take over from the institutions of the family in the household for educating the young, things were really switched around. Because in the past and still in in indigenous societies, children would learn by following in the footsteps of their parents and grandparents. They'd figure out what to do by trying things out for themselves. They'd hear the stories and become storytellers themselves. They'd practice the crafts and become skilled craftspeople to themselves.

So the idea was that you would follow on in the wake in the footsteps of those who've gone before you. So the ancestors are always ahead. They're not in the past. The ancestors are ahead and you are following them. And what happened with what we vaguely call maternity, I know it's very rough already, is that we were told no, we should turn around in the other direction. The ancestors are behind. What you need to do is to prepare for the new society that we're designing for you, which means putting the past behind and heading instead towards the

future. So there's a kind of about turn, and much of our present educational system is rooted in an idea. Not that education is there to secure the continuity of life by following those who went before you, but that education is the engine of social progress. And in social progress, then, every generation is supposed to either stand on the shoulders of the previous one or condemn the previous one to irrelevance because it's a new one now.

So instead of thinking in terms of this notion of a continuity of following your ancestors, who are the people who gave you the guidance and whose guidance you're following, you get to this idea that each generation is a new stage in the development of society as a whole towards ever higher levels of of attainment and achievement. Yeah, thank you. It's interesting, isn't it?

Because I mean, your, your layers, it, it just feels like another instance of our obsession with separating, like we separate one generation from the next in your stratum rather than your rope, which I think is a beautifully, I mean, a very powerful analogy. But these are continuing together and they they are in dialogue with each other, the generations at the same time. So, yeah, no, it's beautiful. But I mean, Sarah, I wonder, I mean, this is part of the tension, isn't it? Is that everything that Tim has just beautifully described, I personally fully agree with. And those institutions do exist now.

And that's where our young people are. And that's, you know, they're the institutions that you all are working in as well and researching. And it's an interesting tension that, isn't it? Because almost what you were talking about, the young people doing all this informal learning, all of that stuff that Tim was just describing about social continuity is existing within these strange institutional spaces that seem obsessed with a whole different kind of logic. And I'd say I don't know whether do you see any connections there? Yeah. So just when I was talking about my research in school, one of the things I would start with is just how weird school is in

terms of like separating young people out into one year age groupings. And so much of the intensity of what happens and the period intensity is this, you know, that you've got people in together day after day for six hours and six hours a day within this narrow age range. And it creates particular kind of dynamic. But in terms of the volume, you know, this, we've back to, you know, one of our aims when we started the conference and moved into the volume is just to have different ways of exploring education and different openings.

And like I said at the start, I think, you know, we wanted to have both a real interrogation of the current conditions of education and higher education, all the issues and problems that we're facing now. And also to give light to these little kind of regenerative spaces where even if it's, you know, on a small scale, people are doing things differently and people are trying to do things differently. And Mario and Chris Studio was divided into two for exactly that reason that they had. You know, the first half was

people looking at the conditions and and the second-half of people looking at alternatives. And I think that, you know, exemplifies what we were trying to do in the book is to have both. I was saying Maria did. Was there anything you wanted to add to that? Yeah, I guess to some part of what team was speaking about, you know, which is also what we have to take into consideration and how much a lot of what's happening now is a matter of historical development of what public universities were and

used to be for and have moved on to be private. I was worried about and other public systems which which can be quite similar in some ways. So there are a few trade-offs that have happened and very central one is the kind of if you want New Deal or post war kind of welfare state where higher education is specific was given to broader classes that before were never part of higher education. In order to partly pacify, partly discipline within

whatever the new state settlement was after the war, and partly to start structuring experiences towards a kind of widening, more complex field of work. And now the problem with that is that there were a couple of things going on, and part was the kind of insistence on connection between the world of work and the university and the university becoming one of the biggest employers in many cities, for instance, in big countries and so forth.

So let's not forget that. And that that has now LED us to almost the opposite end. Whereas it started as a progressive project that acknowledges the value, the value of education for broader group than the aristocracy, landed Gentry in the bourgeoisie, let's say, you know, broadly defined. We're now at the place where on the one hand there is mass success, but there is also that's become a successful project that is now biting back.

It's kind of, it's so successful that it's, it's now being commercialized that we're charging enormous fees to all the, you know, different constituencies of students. And, and basically the lower you are on the class and, or the food chain, the more you pay into, into education in some way because of loans, because of how much repayment comes into that. So there is that to take into account when speaking about also, you know, building in the generation intergenerational dynamic. Of course, what is very

difficult right now is for someone like myself, for instance, who is a critical Marxist to speak against employability on the one hand, while on the other, I'm teaching students coming from the Global South in programs that are cash cow programs. Basically. You know, we if we have to be honest about that and some of our students already call them as they are, you know, and and try to make my program so that students can get work once they graduate because they have a two years visa after graduation that

allows them to pay back enormous debt that their families, communities have taken in order to allow for this, you know, next step in the massification, which kind of opens UK higher education beyond the original community. Now again, trade off. So where is it that I can insist on education should be critical and not for the consumption of the labor market, which I believe in to a certain extent. I have a degree in philosophy as first degree from a university in Bulgaria. I don't think anyone ever

thought that that would translate into any employability options, you know. So where where is the kind of point of resistance and where is the point of recognising how the world works right now? And not not being naive about it, but also not allowing it to completely kind of pour the rug under our legs and really change the terms of engagement from us as a community. And that's a very, that's a very tricky place to be. Yeah, it is. Yeah, Thank you. Yeah, I mean, incredibly tricky, isn't it? It's like these path

dependencies that we've created and it's really difficult to to get off them. But maybe on the plus side, with AI now, philosophers are highly demanded. I think their employability just shut up significantly. Well, there was a recent article that said that if you want to survive in the age of AI, you have to study anthropology. Really. There you go. Yeah, I'm not exactly sure that is the case, but that's an it's an interesting. I mean, a previous round of that same argument was that anthropologies are very highly demanded by the World Bank. Is that really the type of work

that we want to educate our students to be part of? I don't know, like it's, it's kind of it's another one of these. Another example, right is another example of the traps. Exactly. I mean, it's yeah, they turn into marketing lines to get more students. Quite interesting. Just if I may, I was sorry that Andrew couldn't join us because I was very taken by his chapter in part five of the book around the metaphors that we live by. And I just maybe if I could in his absence, wonder if I could ask you, having heard you, Tim, talk about this, in some ways, this idea of kind of the journey

as a metaphor and these kinds of these different ways that we think about some of this work metaphorically. And I mean, to me, it's a personal thing, but it feels like the dominant mechanistic metaphors built into education are incredibly constraining in the way that we think about biological ourselves as biological organisms doing cognitive work. We're obsessed with kind of, you know, software and hardware. And, you know, this legacy issue of the brain is a computer, right? So I do feel I, I'd really like that chapter because I do feel

like the metaphors that we use in our everyday language feel so important in the creation of what's possible to think and know and, and do. So just in. Yeah. I don't know whether you are familiar with his chapter. I can't remember the chapter, but I know the issue and it I I'm not sure that I talk about it in terms of metaphors. I'm not a fan of Lakoff and Johnson myself. So we can have another argument about coming with anthropology, which is not relevant right now, but, but I have been concerned with the very extraordinary

parallels between the way in which the mainstream science thinks about evolution, in biological evolution, the way in which mainstream psychology thinks about learning, and the way in which educationalists, again in the mainstream, think about education. 100%. And basically the theoretical structure of the argument, the conceptual structure is virtually the same in each case. And it's almost sometimes explicitly carried over from one domain to the other, from evolutionary biology to educational psychology to

educational policy itself. And the thing that it that all of these, you call them metaphors, but let's say all of these constructions have in common, is that they distinguish between life that is lived or education that is undergone within each generation and a transmission across generations in biological evolution. This is the opposition between ontogeny and phylogeny, right? That life is lived within a generation. That's development. That's ontogenetic development. Then there's a transmission of

information between generations that's genetic, or that's through through social what what psychologists call social learning or what educationalists call transmission. So the effect of that is actually to cut off the transmission process from the life process, as though education is about transmitting the resources, informational material that people need to live. It's not about life itself. And this I think has been utterly disastrous in in all three, in all three fields.

So what what we need instead then is, is a rethinking across all three fields, something I've been trying to do in the sense that in evolutionary biology to to put the emphasis on developmental systems, developmental processes, same in psychology, same in education. So that we should see all of these basically as, as developmental processes, systems within which people live, grow, life cycles are undergone. And then through this development, we not only create

ourselves continually, but create the conditions under which other people grow. That's history. And so so it really requires a pretty fundamental paradigm shift. Agreed. I wonder if you're also tracking the cognition first biology stuff that's coming out now. I mean, there's some really I've done an episode on it recently and it's completely fascinating. Maybe to come if we can just wrap up coming back to you, Sarah, in relation to your hope for the book and collectively,

of course, feel free everyone, but just I wonder if you, it sounds like a really interesting process, the whole evolution of the ideas and the book itself and the approach. But yeah, where would you like it to go now? Have you, have you had discussions about that or is it, I don't know whether that's something that's still alive in, in terms of the project? So I think the in some way the book is a product F and partly maybe a bit of a victim of the academia nowadays, you know, so we. Whereas it's a great achievement and it's a great collection and

and really a legacy of a long, somewhat painful process. It also came four years after the conference. It has taken a lot of revisions. There was a change of press in the meantime, coming from a more commercial press into Birkhan, which is kind of a family business and has Open Access options, which was great. But it's been really trying to resist some of the pulls of of academia nowadays. A lot of people have moved in institutions.

It's a book that's quite uneven in some way. So it's not like the standard collection that has equal chapters by, you know, everybody involved. So whereas that makes it quite curious and interesting, it makes the responsibility of, you know, who is to take the project for, oh, it's also taken a few maternity leaves, including Sara and my own, you know, in the meantime. Thank you. But that means, you know, so then the responsibility of who is to take the legacy forward is quite diffuse, perhaps. And we really tried, even if

Sarah appears as the coordinating editor, that was because traditional publication doesn't really allow for more than one or two names to appear on the cover. And whereas she did most of the really coordination work. So let's give her the due credit for that. That makes it more diffuse in terms of, you know, what's this editorial collective. We never came to the same place physically and some of us have never met face to face until today's are and me in such way. So it is a kind of it's an

interesting thing to think about. Where do we go next? So I think this invitation from you today was great because it allows us to bring together some of these threads from the book that otherwise sound dispersed. And there is a as one of the authors from our studio who actually left academia after a very painful redundancy process at the University of Leicester, David Harvey wrote it's great to see the book out in the wild. Let's see what life it will have now. So there there is a bit of a wishful, you know, let it carry on, but at least, you know, in

terms of teaching with bits and pieces a bit and it entering debates in different sections of anthropology, that would be enough of an achievement, I imagine. Fantastic. Thank you, Sarah. Yeah, I mean, I I totally agree. It was, you know, it's it's had this very long life and hopefully it will take on something different as it now it's OWL and hopefully, yes, these short form pieces can be used and it can be used in teaching and it can, you know, rather than kind of a long capture that you're expecting people to read.

So I think that was definitely one of the hopes we had for these kinds of different format. But yeah, it's interesting to think about what we would do next with it. Yeah, great. Well, I mean, if this can be at all useful in getting it out into the world, then I'm very happy. It's interesting to note how how conventional the the processes even to publishing are that keep us in certain particular lanes, right. But I thank you, thank you so much for taking the time. I know you're busy and and for the book, it's really wonderful and really happy to support putting it out.

Thank you for inviting us on. Thank you. Push it out for all you can because it has represented new kind of publishing and I think it's important in that respect too. Absolutely. We hope you've enjoyed this episode. Please feel free to continue the dialogues with our guests, with us at Good Impact Labs, on our blog or on social media, or. Within your own networks.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Are Peacebuilding and Education Inseparable? A Conversation with Amir Bergen and Kanstantsin Tsiarokhin

    Nov 8, 202642 minAudio

    I got the chance this week to talk to two amazing young people who have created a friendship, and a space of possibility for learning and peacebuilding that, in other worlds, might have seen them fighting against each...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Many Paths, Not One: The Rise of Experimental Education in Taiwan - A Conversation with Tang Guang-Hua

    Oct 24, 20264 minAudio

    How did Taiwan become one of the world’s most interesting places for educational and societal innovation? In January 2025, Manda Scott interviewed Audrey Tang, Taiwan’s youngest ever Minister of State and its first...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. A Chance to Solve Their Own Problems - A Conversation with Prof. Jal Mehta

    Oct 10, 202641 minAudio

    It's all too easy to come up with scripted and pre-packaged solutions to educational challenges that are complex, deeply human and relational. My guest this week has been a powerful voice globally for a long time,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Collaboration as an Essential Practice - A Conversation with Rich Watkins

    Oct 3, 202656 minAudio

    When was the last time that you achieved something totally on your own with no reliance on others? My guess is not ever, not really. One of the things we humans have always been really good at, despite our relative...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Diverse Intelligences in Natural, Artificial and Hybrid Systems - A Conversation with Prof. Sheila Macrine and Dr. Jennifer Fugate

    Sep 26, 202644 minAudio

    We all take lots of different roles in our personal and professional lives, but one of the roles that I find most exciting (and aspire to myself) is being a convener and connector, bringing people together for...

    Credit the people on this episode