Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Furthure

Furthure artwork

Exceptional Experiences with Psychedelics and Beyond with Dr. David Luke

Feb 13, 202651 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is one of the most fun and wide-ranging conversations I’ve had on Furthure in a while - and one of the weirder ones. Dr. David Luke, author of Otherworlds: Psychedelics and Exceptional Human Experience, investigates everything from how psychedelics may increase the odds of ESP-like experiences and paranormal beliefs to how people cope with existential distress after challenging psychedelic experiences. He has also been his own “guinea pig” for science, let’s just say, and isn’t afraid to tell us the tale. Even though studying the ESP phenomenon with psychedelics might seem a bit out there - maybe unicorn-dimension-level weird - there’s no denying that there are strong roots in the history of the field for studying this, with everyone from serious scientists in the 1950s to indigenous traditions entwined with it. We also get into the Challenging Experiences Project, which studies what can go wrong after psychedelic use. I loved this part of the conversation - we get into the nuances of how little is really known about what can go wrong after challenging psychedelic experiences. A little hint: it’s a lot more diverse than just psychosis or even run-of-the-mill depression. Understanding what can go wrong with psychedelics, and what people can do to help themselves afterward, is essential to the future of psychedelics integrating well (whatever that means) into society. I would also consider this a companion episode to Dr. Willoughby Britton’s episode on meditation-related side effects. If you enjoy this, be sure to check that out as well.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello, and welcome to the further podcast where we explore the far reaches of the human experience from missions to Mars to skydiving to blowing one's mind of psychoactive substances. These conversations offer insight into how these extreme experiences showcase the human spirit and just might teach us how to live our everyday lives a bit better. I'm your host, Haley Miranda -Rod. and I study the effects of psychedelics and other

out there experiences on people's minds and brains. So this is one of the most fun and wide -ranging conversations I've had on further in a while, and probably one of the weirder ones. Dr. David Luke, author of Other Worlds, Psychedelics and Exceptional Human Experiences, has quite the interesting research career. He investigates

everything from how psychedelics might increase the odds of ESP -like experiences and paranormal beliefs to how people cope with existential distress. stress after challenging experiences with psychedelics. He also has been, let's just say, his own guinea pig for science and isn't afraid to tell us that tale. Even though studying ESP -related phenomena and psychedelics might seem a bit out there, maybe even unicorn dimension level weirdness,

um... There's no denying that there are pretty strong historical roots in the history of psychedelics of people being intrigued by such phenomenon. So everybody from serious scientists in the 1950s to indigenous cultures worldwide or who use psychedelics are a bit entwined with it. We also get into a bit of the challenging experiences project which investigates how people cope with adverse effects after using psychedelics. I think this

part of the podcast is be best. We get into a lot of nuances about just how little is really known about what can go wrong after challenging experiences and it's great because there are a few people out there that are exploring what can go wrong with more nuance and just saying, oh hallucinogen persisting perceptual disorder or psychosis -like experiences. This is building from the ground up, a sort of taxonomy and also what people find helpful, which I think is extremely

important that people start to investigate. In a lot of ways, our discussion of the challenging experiences project kind of parallels some of the discussions I had with Dr. Willoughby Britton in our episode on meditation gone wrong, which looks at meditation related side effects. If you find this part of the discussion with Dr. David Luke interesting, be sure to check out that episode as well. And now let's turn to the actual conversation. So I am here with Dr. David

Luke, who has, I think, some of the most interesting areas of focus in psychedelic science. Definitely focusing on some weird and out there experiences. Dr. Luke is especially known for studying exceptional experiences. And a lot of these experiences are a bit outside, I guess, typical academic norms, you could say. Maybe you could tell us a bit about how you got interested in studying such weird phenomena and what exceptional experiences

are. Thank you, Hayley. Thanks for having me along. Yeah, I think I was always interested in weird experiences. I guess I had quite a few strange experiences as a kid. I had a very, very active dream life. You know, like I would just be off having cosmic battles. most nights and strange hypnagogic phenomena and body experiences. And so I was always drawn towards exploring that end of the spectrum of psychology, which led

me to also kind of treat my brain like a neurochemistry playset as a teenager and explore psychedelics, which led to me going away to study psychology at university. Although hopefully disappointed when I got to do a degree that you basically don't learn anything about this stuff about psychedelic experiences or exceptional experiences. And so I was kind of forced to go back and do a PhD and try and inject into the academy what I found to be missing. So exceptional experiences is

a kind of really broad heading for all of the weird and wonderful stuff you don't normally get in a psychology degree. So can be psychedelic experiences or paranormal or spiritual or anomalous experiences, unusual experiences which don't fit the norm, which I also include kind of neurodivergence in there as well. So things like aphantasia and synesthesia, which are not necessarily paranormal, spiritual or psychedelic, but at least they're not the kind of usual kind of everyday experience for most people. So it covers everything that

falls down the cracks in usual psychology and it also points to and illuminates some interesting dimensions of consciousness which I think have been woefully ignored. So you were just a kid having strange dreams basically. And you're like, I need to go study psychology to understand what the heck is going on here. And that led you down quite a rabbit hole. And one thing that I appreciate about your work is it's not just psychedelic experiences. You use psychedelics as a lens to

study other things like psi phenomena and near -death experiences. So the interesting thing about psychedelics is They are a very reliable way of inducing these kinds of exceptional experiences. Exceptional experiences tend to occur more with psychedelics than any other kind of access route due to their potency. But I think the kinds of experiences you can access through these substances you can access through any other means of altered states of consciousness, pretty much the most

phenomena. And so like more broadly, it's the study of altered states, which includes psychedelics and these kinds of experiences. ESP and psychedelics, like that's something that kind of I think gets sanitized out of more medicalized discussions of like, oh, this could be a treatment for depression, addiction and what have you. But it seems that in indigenous cultures at least, that that was one of sort of the main ways that people were examining psychedelics being useful. Using things

like ayahuasca to be able to tell what somebody was sick with, for example, right? Yes. So I think this is an interesting thing. You know, psychedelics as they used by indigenous people are just part of an armory of techniques for accessing our states of consciousness. So in lots of indigenous cultures that engage in what we might call shamanism, it's a practice by whereby you go into an altered state of consciousness to transcend time and space and bring back useful information for your community. So it's very

pragmatic, magical, spiritual practice. And psychedelics are just one means of going into those states to transcend time and space. It's not something we have kind of continued with in the kind of the global north particularly. So like the anthropologist Charles Loughlin talks about how we have, you can separate the world into monophasic and polyphasic cultures. So monophasic cultures are those cultures like in Euro America that only really value and engage with the ordinary waking state of consciousness,

like one phase of consciousness. Everything else is denigrated. It's like, oh, that's just hallucination. really pay attention to that. So dreams aren't really... paid attention to psychedelic drugs are frowned upon, other altered states practices are frowned upon, or at least they were. And you know, you get some special dispensation to have coffee to make you function and work harder. And maybe you can have a few beers on the weekend as a way of relaxing. But you know, we don't really value the drunken state is any way important to our kind of civic responsibilities. Whereas

in polyphasic cultures, you know, the information coming from altered states such as dreams or psychedelic experiences are very much valued and engaged with at least on a level with ordinary waking consciousness, if not more so. And there are means of accessing information like it's a system of epistemology, the way in which we obtain knowledge. part of the world. It's generally through observation and science and education and logic and philosophy. Whereas in a lot of

indigenous cultures, their epistemology derives through altered states, through engaging with the natural world. through kind of shamanic practices. Like if you want to understand what the medicinal properties of a plant are, you may drink ayahuasca and dieta and diet with that plant and then come to know the plant in a relational way, on a subjective way and understand what its healing properties are. So these are two very different worldviews and epistemologies and ontologies that we have

where one is accepted that altostates are good and useful and the other is where they are denigrated. hated and denied. So I guess that kind of explains why for a period of time you went to Mexico to try to learn more about shamanism in a more polyphasic cultural setting, it sounds like. Maybe you could tell us a bit about what you got out of that experience. Well, I've got a fine collection of Mexican shirts. As you can see, that was one of the most important things for me. I also got

to learn a little bit about what is the nature of shamanism and these very different ways of interacting and seeing the world. northern global people, I was very naive to what these realities entail. But I would say that as a general rule bull who live within a magical spiritual kind of culture, which engages with shamanism, live in a kind of permanent magical reality, which is at odds with our kind of cultural reality

in the global north. And that is, you know, it is possible to transcend time and space and obtain information from those states of consciousness. They do so to communicate and mediate with what we might call the spirits of nature, but the rest of the ecological world. and to negotiate and discover animals to go and hunt or ways of healing or to divine the future or to find lost

objects or to negotiate spiritual contracts. And that's a lot for somebody from the global North to get their head around in any kind of open way without either just denigrating it, denying it or on the opposite side of it, you know, kind of elevating it in a kind of way, which, yeah, puts it on a pedestal. So it's just another mode of being, I think, that we probably also engaged with in our history, you know, our

ancestors would almost certainly have been animists, but it's something that's been kind of ironed out of the Global North's kind of working ontology. Yeah, I can see how it would be easy to either idealize it or just be like, oh, there must be some other explanation to whatever you're witnessing just because it is such a different worldview. But were there any specific instances you can think of that you encountered where you were just so surprised at how people interacted, I

guess, with that more magical realm or way of thinking? I mean, always surprised. I mean, my time working with the Borradica in Mexico, they're otherwise known as the Huicholis, but that's not what they call themselves. And they have a really interesting tradition in that their use of peyote, which is psychedelic cactuses, is core to their whole cultural identity and their annual calendar and their way of life. So I guess while you were there in Mexico, you

probably encountered a lot of instances where people were interacting with that sort of more magical worldview in a way that was kind of shocking or surprising to you. What were some of the more weird, to you at least, instances that you encountered. I guess one of the kind of wildest things I saw or experienced was that the Warradica, like many indigenous people around the world, professed to have some control over local weather systems,

which is something that lots of rainmakers do around the world. And one time we had this encounter where it was the first time we were going to go on their sacred pilgrimage and I think it was the first time they'd taken any gringos on the pilgrimage. It's like a thousand kilometer round trip to go and harvest the peyote. And we rocked up on the edge of their territory. with this one Marakami, that's what they call their shamans. And we met with a whole bunch of other Marakamis from their ceremonial group. And they came in one pickup truck and we came

the other way in a pickup truck and we all got out. And we were just about to kind of introduce ourselves and say hello. And they immediately got to arguing with the Marakami we were with. And so there was like five or six of these shamans all arguing. And we were just stood there like lemons going, okay. This is a bit awkward. And then like this huge dust devil got up in the field behind them. They like they had their backs to it. And we could see this thing, you know, like a tornado, like not a tornado, but a very, very big dust devil and a couple of hundred feet

high, 30, 40 foot across. And it was sucking up all the dried maize leaves in the field. and started coming towards us. And myself and my kind of gringo buddies were all stood there going, wow, what's going on here? And it was moving in a direct line towards us and getting closer and closer. These guys were still arguing and at some point it was, it was going to hit us. And I was like, I kind of interrupted them and said, Hey guys, like, you know, look behind you. And they saw it and they were completely unfazed. Like one of them, two of them did this kind of

gesture with their arms. One had their arms crossed and kind of shoved. the dust devil with his arms and the other one just pushed it with his hands. And the whole thing changed direction suddenly in the direction in which they were kind of gesturing with their hands. And it went round us in an arc. We watched the whole thing kind of bend around us on his direction and then continued on this kind of the trajectory that it had previous to being seemingly shoved. So it looked like they, for all intents and purposes, just pushed a ginormous dust devil out of the way. or a bit

gobsmacked to say the least. We're like, did you see that? I saw that. Meanwhile, the interesting thing is they did this gesture with their hands and then immediately got back to arguing. They didn't even pay the dust devil any attention. aren't more important. We were all just completely gobsmacked. That was at the start of the trip. We'd literally just met them. We were like, well, if that happens now, what's going to happen on the rest of this journey? That was the most exotic

phenomenon we saw. I think maybe perhaps they were just showing off or something. I don't know. For all intents and purposes, it looked very much like ... They just manipulated this weather phenomena in a way in which we have no concept of. Now it could just have been some kind of coincidence or, you know, trick of the light, but I doubt it. So, you know, stuff like that kind of gives you some sense in which when they talk about their magical reality, they aren't

saying it flippantly or in any kind of illusionary way. They genuinely believe in this and you begin to have the inclination that what they're saying might actually be real. It leads you to question your own take on consensus reality. Or maybe they were just trying to get you very entranced with their magical skills and do a little show for you basically. But how did their experiences... and I guess use of peyote relate to this whole

ability to change the weather or whatnot? Did there seem to be a relationship between their magical abilities, I guess you could say, and their use of psychedelics? Or were those separate things? Yeah, it's all very much embedded in a deeper core magico -spiritual practice at which, you know, peyote is at the center in that this is how they form their deep connection with nature. Everything is sacred in the natural world and

they utilize peyote as a means of training and negotiation in this shamanic world. It's an ecological epistemology where they're very much engaging with the natural world and everything is sacred and sanctified. They'll train to be a Murakami, a shaman for 12 years, which includes all kinds of ordeals and a lot of time, all of the time is spent in nature. So, and they work very elementally,

like they're most important. Praxis is around kind of the elements, the four elements as they break it down, earth, air, fire and water. And they primarily work with fire. That's their central. deity, if you like, and the most important element. So it's a kind of elemental and ecological kind of animism, which means for them, they can engage with and negotiate with all the forces and species of the natural world through their use of peyote.

But they weren't tripping at the time. I don't think they're living a trip, basically. Well, later on, you went on to investigate whether a different mescaline containing cactus, San Pedro, could increase ESP abilities and you ended up using yourself as a guinea pig. Why were you looking at San Pedro? Yeah, actually this was before I connected with the Borradica and I was in South America in Ecuador. I'd previously been

doing some research on extrasensory perception with ayahuasca, but that was problematic for various reasons. And while I was in Ecuador, I figured it would be more sense to work with San Pedro, which is just a bit easier to manage in many ways than ayahuasca. And I certainly get on with it better. I'd attempted to do an experiment with people taking San Pedro and they were going to engage in a precognition task, a kind of computerized randomized precognition task, which was pretty, pretty fail safe. You

know, the results of which could only be due to like probability, which we controlled or the possibility of some kind of precognition. However, when I'd attempted to recruit people to take part in this experiment, the currendiro, the shaman, the healer I was working with, refused to let me bring my laptop into his ceremony. And I was running out of time. So I figured instead of getting 20 people to do a trial each of my task, the cognition task whilst they're on San Pedro cactus, I would do all 20 trials myself

under the influence of San Pedro, which fortunately, you know, the mescaline lasts about 12 hours. So you've got plenty of time to run 20 trials of a precognition experiment. And that was quite illuminating in that, you know, the design is such that you can't cheat it. Like, you know, the, the targets aren't even chosen until the future. And so it's got a safe design. So you can be both a participant and experimenter without compromising the experiment because because you actually have to use precognition to do well

at the task. I got a significant result, which was great. It's a kind of proof of process. I wouldn't say it's necessarily evidential, but it shows that the study design is feasible. a lot about the potential medium and process through which this could work in that, you know, I had to basically, I would set the intention to try and identify the future target. which would be one of four one minute video clips, which I didn't

know which one would be the target or what the video clips were. And so I'd like try and visualize this video clip and I would get some wild mental imagery and I'd write it down if I could actually put it into words. And then I would see the four one minute video clips and I would rate them according to how similar they were to my mescaline vision. And then the computer would then randomly select the target using a random number generator and we'd see whether or not I was correct or not. And through this process, you could see that there was kind of thematic elements. Like

I never actually fully saw any one of those video clips in its entirety in my vision, but there were very much kind of themes and elements which corresponded to the actual targets. And often in quite surprising ways. Sometimes they were quite spot on. Like one was like the sands of time, desert dunes, and there was a scene of a side wind. going across the desert, which I chose as the target and the random number generator also selected afterwards. So, but then there

was other elements whereby there was like a, you know, these were random pools of all one minute video clips, which had been selected by another researcher to be as heterogeneous as possible. That is they, to be as different from each other as possible so that it was easier to determine, you know, like which video clip was most like your visual mentations. If they're all really similar, it's harder to discern any differences between them. And yet on this one trial, I'd had a vision of a broken limb. That's

what I'd written down, a broken limb. And then it turned out... Then when I watched the four video clips, although they were all very, very different in content and theme and style, three of them had broken limbs in them, right? Which led me to have some difficulty discerning what the target might be. But weirdly, you know, my bemescalined mind had picked up on a theme that was apparent in this pool of four video clips that I had no idea was there because I hadn't even seen the videos. So Sometimes it was doing

things in weird ways which wouldn't necessarily translate into a statistically significant result. So that tells you something about the nature of this process if it is indeed real. It's definitely fascinating and it sounds like a fine experiment to put yourself through being the guinea pig for. It's interesting because even though, you know, in modern research this ESP stuff doesn't seem to be a focus, it seems like in the 1950s and 60s a lot of sort of the founders of psychedelic

research were somewhat into it. Like apparently Groff was guessing correctly on a remote viewing task several times in a row and like got freaked out or something and had to stop. And there are, I think, other instances as well. Maybe you could tell us a bit about those. Yeah, Groff famously did do, he did extremely well on this, I think it was a telepathy task or a precognition task. And yeah, he had to stop basically because he was he was doing so well, it kind of weirded him out. And there are similar stories like that.

I think it was John Smithies and Duncan Blewett. Smithies worked with Humphrey Osmond, who coined the term psychedelic. And Humphrey Osmond was also interested in this research and they run an ESP experiment on mescaline, which freaked out their research assistant because they were so successful that they had again had to stop the experiment because it was like too uncanny and it was making people quite nervous. And so, you know, a lot of these early psychedelic pioneers often had their own paranormal -like experiences

or psy -like experiences. Albert Hoffman on his first LSD trip basically had a kind of out of body experience or something akin to a near -death experience and felt like he'd left his body and he was looking down on his body and thought he might have died and that kind of freaked him out. Gordon Wasson as well, the first time they encountered a Mazatec Corundiro, who ran the first ever account of a Westerner gringo engaging in a mushroom ceremony. The Corundiro Donarulio

told him all these things about his son back home in the States that he didn't know about. And when they got back to the States after their research trip in Mexico, they found out it was all true. So you pretty much all of the big pioneers of psychedelic research. in the fifties and sixties had their own encounters with psi phenomena and were engaged with it. Even Walter Panke, we did the first Good Friday, the Good Friday experiment ran his own psilocybin ESP experiments as well.

And then of course, prohibition happened and parapsychologists like not wanting to tarnish their reputation very quickly moved away from psychedelics. which was seen as more taboo than parapsychology, although that now has kind of completely flipped. It's definitely interesting how there seems to be this line studying or at least considering parapsychology in indigenous cultures in the 50s and 60s with your previous work. there does seem to be something going on

where at least people are experiencing things like clairvoyance, like, you know, being able to predict videos and whatnot. But even though they're having that experience, maybe it's not really, you know, they're developing some sort of paranormal capabilities, but it just feels like it. And I guess it's possible that, I don't know, I spend a lot of time comparing psychosis and psychedelics and that's kind of my lens and in some ways a lot of these experiences sound a little bit psychotic like, a little bit like

maybe somebody has some aberrant salience where they're assigning meaning to small things and making big symbols out of these tiny coincidences. How would you push back against that? sort of guess interpretation that this is just a kind of a psychotic like thinking that people are having during these experiences. Yeah. It's interesting. And I think, you know, there is an overlap because of course in, in states of psychosis, everything becomes meaningful. We have a massive increase

in what we might call apophenia in kind of like super high gain sensitivity on our pattern recognition and thereby making associations and things and finding synchronicities and coincidences and everything. It's hard to draw the line. Sometimes the point is that, is that a symptom of psychosis? At what point is that? There's genuinely something unusual happening. There are other ways in which we can discern whether or not it's psychosis or not, but it may be partly a matter of degree

and partly qualitative. Nevertheless, lots of people who are not psychotic have these experiences and they're very common actually with psychedelics. Something like half of all people have taken psychedelics have had a telepathic experience according to some of my survey research, less so with precognition. And of course it tends to increase people's belief in psi, in extrasensory perception and other paranormal like phenomena. Having taken psychedelics, you know, people change

their worldview around the nature of these things, but not all those people are psychotic, far from it. Whether or not they're genuine or not is a very different question. We can only really discern that through controlled experimental research, but there's a long history of parapsychological research going back about 140 years predating the study of psychology really as a discipline. That's amassed a great deal of evidence to quite strongly suggest that, you know, psi phenomena

is genuine, albeit very, very subtle and almost entirely unconscious. So it's very difficult to pin down and establish experimentally. But if you look at the mass of studies that have been conducted and meta -analyses, they're extremely significant. So it seems like a latent or unconscious and therefore largely ignored and unidentified possibility that we can genuinely transcend time

and space and access information from beyond these spatial time coordinates, right? But it's not an everyday phenomena and people like shamans actively utilize this, right? At least that's what they profess to do. So it's a fine thin line in many ways because that way psychosis also lies. I wouldn't say having a psych experience makes you psychotic, but people with psychosis may be professing to have. you know, certainly a high degree of coincidences and also occasionally

they have symptoms of, you know, thought transference that, you know, people are reading their minds as CIA's beaming thoughts into their brain directly and all this kind of stuff. But the kinds of experiences that people are having are a bit more contained and prosaic than that. You know, it's not kind of like everything is associative and meaningful like you would have with psychosis, but people are having kind of quite discrete, very meaningful experiences, which may be passed off as a coincidence, or they could be explored for their potential for a genuine trans cerebral

kind of phenomena. It depends on which way you want to look at it. Yeah, there's definitely quite a history of people, I think, interpreting adverse events, especially related to psychedelics, through the lens of them being somehow psychosis -like, even though I think oftentimes the reality is a bit more complicated. Recently, a paper that you were on came out that was exploring how people responded to ontological shock and existential distress. after using psychedelics

and that paper to me was quite fascinating because it covered how their often are like worldview shifts and people can think that they're going crazy or whatever and become very kind of obsessed with understanding these different metaphysical like frameworks. Yeah. It's not really psychosis like per se. Yeah. I think, and I think ontological shock is, I think ontological shock is often part and parcel of, of profound psychedelic experiences. Unless your prior worldview already has room

for a mystical kind of experience within it. frame, then if you have a full blown psychedelic slash mystical experience, it is going to throw up some challenges to your reality and worldview. You know, often people describe having these experiences as going beyond what they imagined was even possible to experience. And so for many people, I think the ontological shock is well integrated and incorporated into their life. often leads to people taking a more spiritual

orientation or shifting their metaphysical beliefs. But often as well, this can often be a challenge and can lead to extended difficulties and of course people fearing for their sanity. So in the Challenging Psychedelic Experience Project, You know, we've been particularly exploring people who have difficulties longer than a day. And sometimes these can last for weeks, months or years. And they comprise lots of different symptoms, but one of the recurring symptoms that is most prevalent and also The longest lasting and also

the most challenging typically is ontological shock. We find it in upwards of half of all people expressing extended difficulties following psychedelic experiences. And that is that they have a kind of cognitive dissonance between their prior worldview. and the worldview that their psychedelic experience presents at face value. And that can be challenging for people to negotiate and integrate. It threatens what we call their ontological security, a sense

in which you kind of understand the world and how it works and reality. And then suddenly this experience comes along and it kind of throws all your prior beliefs about the nature of reality into disarray. And that can be very destabilizing. So yeah, that paper was focusing on that particular phenomenon. phenomena and ways in which people found useful in helping them cope or stabilize their experience to lead towards a kind of more whole integration. Yeah, it's definitely important work because I feel like understanding what goes

wrong with psychedelics when things do go wrong is really under categorized at this point and anything that sort of builds what can go wrong from the bottom up. Doing qualitative interviews with people that are in depth can really, I think, facilitate a better understanding. Any sort of patterns in the sorts of people maybe prone to having ontological shock or existential distress, did any patterns emerge? Any specific sorts of experience that seemed more risky than others?

Well, it's hard to kind of extrapolate because it's a relatively small sample. because it is qualitative. So it's more about the depth of the lived experience and what they were going through and what they found useful in coping rather than identifying. trends in particular. So it's kind of more like the themes that emerge rather than, okay, this kind of personality leads to this kind of difficulty. But the kinds of things that come up are crisis, despair, confusion,

questioning one's identity, grief over the loss of you know, your previous self is like often seen as a bit of a one way street in that, you know, you, you can't necessarily unsee what you've seen or experienced and that's changing your reality permanently, you know, fears of psychosis or paranoia and so on. So the roadmap is kind of what's interesting in this is this is coming from psychedelic experiences, but there's, there's people have already mapped this kind of trajectory

out with exceptional experiences more generally, and it tends to follow. a similar kind of path, if you like. There's this deep period of questioning and confusion that follows these ontologically challenging experiences or exceptional experiences, which can lead to various pitfalls and challenges such as you may end up kind of joining a cult. falling into guru worship and handing over your entire bank account or personal self -aggrandizement, narcissism, spiritual bypassing, believing that

you're psychotic. So there's many potential risks in having one of these really kind of worldview destabilizing experiences. But then there's also a kind of pathway through into growth and maybe in a similar way into which we see like post -traumatic growth. as well. There's a period of destabilization, but then there is a movement towards feeling more whole and integrated and largely coming out the other side, a bigger and better person, if you like, more experienced

and more whole. Yeah, I wonder if other cultures where sort of magical frameworks are more embedded and accepted in their society. If they have... a way to make sense of rapid ontological changes. I don't know if they would be prone to experiencing such a thing or not. Did the people that you who are around in Mexico, did they have a framework? Did any other shamanistic sort of traditions that you're aware of have a pathway forward for

people who are somehow distressed by their vague experiences, I guess you could say? Interestingly, I mean, it's not like we've had like, have studied it directly, but I do think they already have a cultural cosmology, an ontology, which is accepting immediately of those experiences. So I think there's less of a kind of ontological shock. And this is just my kind of interpretation in that, you know, it already fits within their cultural framework to have these kinds of experiences

and it not. just to be psychosis. It's like, oh, you, you know, you had some kind of spiritual attack or, you know, whatever it might be. And yet the way of dealing with it is, is, is, is different as well. So like, you know, for instance, I've been in ceremonies where for all intents and purposes, somebody looked like they were possessed and had to be kind of held down. This was gringos, right? And the shaman's going, yeah, don't worry about it. You know, this happens all the time and just tie them up and wait for them to come back. And, and basically if you

want to be a shaman, yes, I just tied them up till they come back. And, you know, if you want to be a shaman, you're going to have to go through that. That's actually part of the journey. Like this is like, this isn't anything bad. This is just like a natural step in the process. Like we see it all the time. It's no big deal, you know? So they've got kind of a bit more of a relaxed approach to this kind of. these kinds of experiences of phenomena and a home for them as well in which they hithered or pathologized,

right? Which I do think probably makes a big difference. So going back to, I guess, Westerners' experiences, what were some of the things that helped people make sense of ontological shock or existential distress? Yeah. So there's, you know, there's a variety of different coping practices. I think one of the biggest ones we found certainly from our survey data, not necessarily the interviews is kind of psycho education. Like, you know, some people would turn to therapists and things like that and they didn't necessarily find that

the most helpful. And that could be just a sign of the times in that most therapists are probably A, not familiar with psychedelic experiences and B, not familiar with the weirder end of the psychedelic experience spectrum. of those kinds of ontologically challenging experiences, like feeling like you've been possessed or whatever, right? So classic CBT, for instance, doesn't really have a space for dealing with that kind of experience. So on the whole, people tended not to say that therapy was not the kind of go

-to route of helping to integrate these experiences. It was about typically like finding other people or resources where people have gone through similar processes and come out the other side and they weren't psychotic or stabilizing their experiencing and grounding themselves through maybe spending time in nature, changing their diet. doing yoga or some kind of bodywork practice. So often these kinds of things were seen to be useful. Yeah.

I could see how a therapist who really wasn't all that familiar with psychedelics would be startled by somebody coming to the session being like, I felt like I got possessed when I did an ayahuasca ceremony. How do I make sense of this? Like, yeah. Of course, that's going to be not necessarily the ideal environment. There's this whole history of psychedelics and psychosis being the main concern that people have, even though that could be a concern, but it's not

necessarily the main adverse effect that people are most prone to. So a therapist hearing that somebody is having a challenging time, they might just think, are they becoming psychotic? and I could see how that could be difficult. Going forward, what do you think needs to happen for people to be more informed about how to handle challenging experiences? Yeah, I think we just need a better literacy generally around exceptional experiences and challenging experiences and metaphysical

challenges too, you know, ontological shock, etc. which I don't think is necessarily there in most kind of generic types of psychotherapy. Perhaps existential psychology or therapy may be better suited or transpersonal. Psychotherapy are probably more able to engage with this kind of phenomena. But as a general rule, I think people aren't very familiar with the range of exceptional experiences that people may have and just a kind of understanding of those. More

broadly, I mean, these aren't always the stuff that comes up. You know, often people's challenges are of an intrapersonal nature, right? They may be rather than transpersonal, you know, maybe kind of dealing with childhood trauma that they were unaware of or this kind of stuff. You know, also we get a lot of these kind of more transpersonal kind of challenges. And so I think there is a need for better education around this. I think it really needs to be embedded in kind of sitter guide therapist training for people wanting to work with psychedelics. So they at least have

a working awareness of it. And it requires a kind of metaphysical neutrality as well, you know, an openness on behalf of the therapists or sitters and guides in that, you know, you're not automatically prejudging and having a sense of self -awareness and enough of a container that you're not projecting your own metaphysical worldviews onto your client as well as all your kind of cultural, social and interpersonal ones as well. So it just adds another level to the onion of things that therapists need to be kind

of aware of when they're dealing with people having challenging psychedelic experiences, I would say. Yeah, it's definitely true. I mean, I guess psychedelics have long had an association with more like woo woo out there things. So that these side effects can also be a bit out there. to me does not seem that weird. Another thing that people frequently do, I find, is that they compare psychedelic experiences to other extreme experiences. So there's this whole thing about

comparing 5 -MeO DMT to near -death experiences that you've also written a bit about. Maybe you could tell us about that as well? Yeah, so this has kind of been an ongoing research project and interest, particularly of my ex -PhD student, Pascal Michael. who's kind of the expert on this, but there is a sense in which there is a large degree of similarity between near -death experiences and psychedelic experiences, particularly with things like DMT and fibemia, and not just in

the acute phenomenology, like the experiences themselves have a great deal. deal of resemblance and also some mismatches, but also the outcomes in that we see similar things emerging from people who have near -death experiences as we do from good or successful psychedelic experiences like a change in worldview, often a spiritual reorientation. enhanced kind of empathy and re -evaluation of one's moral compass, deeper connection to nature,

all of these kinds of things. So in a way, near -death experiences are a kind of prototype spontaneous phenomena that psychedelic experiences and psychedelic -assisted psychotherapy kind of emulate in a way. They are spontaneous. spiritual mystical like experiences, which have typically profound and positive outcomes, but maybe quite challenging, not least because you have to usually come very close to death to have one. There's also some

mismatches. Not an easy prerequisite. No, no, don't try this one at home. In many ways, like having a profound psychedelic experience is like you can go to the brink of death and at least psychologically and come back without any genuine risk of death or a very minimal risk of death. You know, ayahuasca translates as the vine of the dead. It's like you can have an experience of dying without actually dying. in a metaphorical way, right? And in some sense, you may be having a kind of mini death, like an ego death experience,

if we can use that term quite loosely, because it's not well defined what we mean by ego death. But there are matches and mismatches. Like when we drill down into the phenomenology on the surface of it, yes, DMT experiences look very similar to near death experiences. And if you give people having high dose DMT, the near death experience scale, which is a psychometric measure to, you know, try and identify or log the kind of near -death experience, you find that they tend to score in a way which looks fairly identical with

people having cardiac arrest induced near death experiences, right? But then they're also mismatched. That's just on a kind of on paper kind of inspection. So myself and Pascal and my other colleague, Oliver, looked at this more in depth of the phenomenology, right? And you'll see that, okay, so on DMT, you'll have lots of geometric patterns and top ticks, this kind of stuff, which are very rare in near death experiences. You'll also have encounter experiences, which people have in near death. But the encounters may be far weirder with DMT,

like, you know, self -transforming machine elves and jesters and octopoids, which don't tend to pop up in near -death experiences, ideally always kind of like deceased loved ones or kind of religious figures, which also pop up in DMT experiences, but not as often as they do with near -death experiences. So there's some matches and mismatches, you know, and so like, what can we conclude from that? Well, that DMT is in endogenous. So it could be triggered or part of the near death experience, but we don't think it fully explains

the near death experience because there are certainly other things going on and also neurochemically as well. DMT may be released in the human brain at the point of death or in a near death experience, but it's not the only thing. There's a whole near death experience cocktail. of really high levels of monoamine neurotransmitters, which are flooding the human brain, we think, in these experiences. So it can help us model the near

-death experience and perhaps understand it a little bit more and vice versa, the psychedelic experience, but it's not a one -to -one relationship, we don't think. Yeah, it's interesting how people seem to want to say psychedelics can model so many different things. One minute they're modeling mystical experiences or provoking them or provoking near -death experiences. Another researcher might be like, it's psychosis -like. So it's quite strange to me the range of phenomena that people

claim are possible with psychedelics. If you think of them as kind of neural amplifiers, right? in a way that is feasible, that they accentuate all kind of elements of the human experience, then yeah, in a way they can model psychotic experience, but in a limited way or near -death experience, you know, all models are ultimately wrong, but some are useful, right? And that degree of usefulness has its limitations, of course.

Yeah, I mean, it's great because they're never not weird. I think is one thing I really enjoy studying psychedelics. You can have a very controlled clinical trial and people are still going to be having odd experiences in some way. Well, I think that's everything I have for you today. Are there any other things that you think might be interesting to mention? I don't know, especially weird experiences that you've had or something. I mean, I could probably be here all day if I

was to talk about my own weird experiences. But what I will say is that having had my own weird experiences, it gives me a useful lens in which to frame the research and vice versa, you know, that the research also helps me frame my own weird experiences. So in the journey of studying this phenomenon of exceptional experiences, there's an old adage that in studying the transpersonal one has to be prepared to be transformed themselves

in the process of doing that work. And that I think it urges us to be reflexive and experiential and a bit more authentic and honest in our approach to studying these things in that we are also, our research is driven by our own personal proclivities. and reflects it and vice versa. So yeah, I'd like to say that. Just a shout out for the experiential strand in all of this work. It shouldn't be downplayed or undervalued. It's definitely tricky in this

field because I feel like a lot of people, if you mention your personal experiences, then they view everything as you being a bit biased. and maybe even fanatical, like you're, I don't know, a psychedelic evangelicalist or something like that. But I do think it can definitely inform interpreting other people's lived experiences. I feel like it has influenced some of my interpretations with qualitative work that I've done. So yeah,

I agree with you there. I'm delighted to hear that, Haley. Thank you. I really enjoyed our chat and happy to talk some more anytime. So I enjoyed that. Thanks so much. All right. Well, thank you. Alrighty. That's it for today's episode. If you enjoyed it, please consider sharing it with somebody who you think might also find it fascinating. And just remember to keep going further. Until next time, hope to see you tuning in and turning on. to the next episode of the

further optics.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Mapping the Jhanas & 5-MeO-DMT Spaces with Andrés Gómez-Emilsson, QRI Founder

    Nov 15, 20261 hr 46 minAudio

    What happens when a group of mathematicians, Silicon Valley psychonauts, and a monastery-trained meditation teacher spend 8 weeks together trying to map out some of the most extreme experiences of consciousness...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Psychedelics in the Wild with Daniel Kruger, PhD

    Sep 21, 20261 hrAudio

    Daniel Kruger, PhD, is an expert on the real-world impact of psychedelic use and community-based research. Although a lot of times people get blown away by psychedelic headlines about a trial for a specific condition,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Lexicons of the Ineffable: A Conversation with Josie Kins, PsychonautWiki Founder

    Jul 3, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    One of the most systematic and comprehensive systems of documenting the effects of psychedelics and other psychoactives wasn’t made in academia, but was crafted by some drug nerds with high trait-level systematizing and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Dissociatives Nervewing has known and (Ab)used

    May 14, 20262 hr 6 minAudio

    Nervewing may be the closest thing the field of psychonautics has seen to a Shulgin of dissociatives. Having cataloged an extensive repertoire of 253 unique substances ingested in their lifetime, including many...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Can Psychedelics Pass the Placebo Test? with Balázs Szigeti, PhD

    Apr 24, 202647 minAudio

    The structure of clinical trials is generally not the most interesting thing in the world. But for psychedelic science, going through the “gold standard” double-blind placebo-controlled paradigm is all but impossible-...

    Credit the people on this episode