AI can be an incredible tool, but somewhere along the way I feel like content started feeling less human. Now we got AI-generated thumbnails, scripts, images… Everything designed to grab attention, but not necessarily build trust. In this video, I talk about why my team at Full Battery Media has started pulling back from overly generated AI content and going back to something much simpler: authentic storytelling. We were seeing our AI-generated thumbnails become increasingly overcomplicated and unnatural. When we simplified them using real images, basic designs, Canva templates and even screenshots. That’s when we actually started seeing better results.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00AI sucks. I mean, not all of it, but a lot of it sucks. AI generated thumbnails really suck. And we've been trying to push back against them in my company. I feel like we're getting spammed. We're getting spammed by AI content. We're getting spammed by AI scripts. We're getting spammed by AI generated images. And they're there just to capture your attention. But like right now, lately, we've been noticing that the AI, like, thumbnail generation that we've been using is just kind of like going off the rails. A month or two ago, it was giving us these nice graphics, but lately, it started to look like the AI is going down this mad acid trip where it just is trying to put everything into every image.
SPEAKER_00And I had to tell my team, enough's enough. Stop using it. Well, they were the ones who convinced me. After we saw also that the results for like search were actually better when we kept things more simple. When we kind of toned back off of the AI spam and leaned into making things look simple and nice. We started going back to using Canva and some templates, and uh it was working. But you know, one of the things that I'm wondering about is why are major creators using this everywhere? Is it just because it's easy?
SPEAKER_00Is it because it's saving money and you don't have to pay for a graphic artist to make something nice? I mean, I'm all for saving money, but like at the expense of what? Expense of really talented people putting time and energy into making you something good, I'd prefer that any day of the week. Because I mean, to me, it feels more human, it feels more honest. One of the things that we're starting to do is we're taking a little film camera. I'm giving this to my daughter, and when we go out on shoots and places, we will take a picture like that, and we use that as part of our uh art, the art that's going up onto the images.
SPEAKER_00And I don't know if this is the right thing, but I do think that in a day and age where we're gonna be seeing more and more fake content, we were sitting down for dinner today, and my father-in-law had to keep asking my daughter and her cousins, is this video real? Think about that. Think about a world that we live in that we can't really tell what's real or fake anymore, and where we start to have things that influence us to a degree that I don't necessarily think it's good. So, what can we do?
SPEAKER_00A thumbnail doesn't need to be surreal. Videos don't need to be crazy. Keep it simple. Um, keep the images basic. And think about this. I heard person, place, and thing. Who's the person in the video? You use that one for me. That right there is my thumbnail image. Sean place, he's in this room talking about thumbnails and thing. We're gonna have thumbnails. So we're gonna put a picture of a thumbnail right there. And that's it. You have a basic but good thing, and you say what it's all about, and people have an understanding and desire to come watch it.
SPEAKER_00There was a great book early on in social media called Trust Agents, and it was by these guys, and they talked about how the most powerful thing you can do with social content is to gain people's trust. But if you want trust, you have to give people a reason to trust you. What is the value that you're providing? I don't know if I have the right answers. I don't know if what I'm telling you today is gonna make your channel blow up. But I do know that what I'm telling you today is gonna make your channel much more authentic, much more real, and much more relatable to most of the people out there.
SPEAKER_00And I don't know you guys, but to me that seems like a great thing. So what should we do? I think we should start with strong, real images. Use screenshots, use pictures, take a freaking camera with you and take some photos of the scene. I started going back to my old uh handy cam. I love this little thing. I got a little Sony handicam that I love shooting on all the time. And it is probably one of my favorite cameras to use. It's just little, simple, quick. Throw it up, hook it up, pop it out, have some fun.
SPEAKER_00The other thing that I like to do with my thumbnails is keep the text short and easy to read. And right now we are finishing up peeling back the layers of the AI generated stuff. I mean, certainly AI can be great. It can make some very beautiful graphics for you and help put them on there, but yeah, I was noticing some weird things like it kept making me look older, kept increasing the lines of my face, and really messing with the videos, and doing these dramatic things where it would kind of like accentuate features. I didn't like it. So start with real images, start with easy-to-read graphics, and try to use the AI when it actually improves what you're working on.
SPEAKER_00If the AI can actually make something better, use it to repair an image, use it to take something and make it more high definition. Uh, maybe you got a screenshot that's not so clear. Ask it to clean it up. But try to keep from overprocessing it, from making it feel unreal, unnatural. You know, I've been seeing a lot of major creators and they are leaning heavily into this. And I just think it's a bad idea. And maybe I'm wrong, but I do know that from the channels that I use for my family, we have noticed results around real content.
SPEAKER_00Real stuff, real people doing real things. Will it work for you? Maybe, maybe not, but I think it's worth a try. Get out there and make some real stuff. Go low tech, get an old handycam, take some film photos, have fun, man. Content doesn't need to be the way everyone else is doing it, doesn't need to be the most flashy, the most fancy, the most streamlined. Stop using fucking filters, man. You don't really need them. I I hate it right now. I hate all the AI filters that try to make everything look so smooth.
SPEAKER_00Man, one of the things growing up as a film photographer is the beauty of the imperfection. I look old sometimes, and that's okay. I'm happy with who I am, and I'm happy showing you who I am. Hope you guys have a beautiful day and can appreciate the realness of who you are because you are beautiful just the way you are. And the greatest content shares that wherever we're at. Hope you guys have a beautiful day, and I'll see you next time.
What does it really take to create an experience people never forget? In this episode of the Full Battery Media Podcast, I sit down with Andrew Fastman, Senior Vice President and Practice Area Leader at Huitt-Zollars,...
What if the biggest thing holding you back from building a successful personal brand isn't your talent, your equipment, or even the algorithm, but your fear of getting started? In this episode of the Full Battery Media...
Why do so many brands spend thousands on beautiful content that nobody actually remembers? In this episode, I sit down with Dan Holz, co-founder of Fieldborn Creative, to talk about what separates forgettable marketing...
In this episode, I sit down with Sara Currie, a longtime video editor and former MrBeast editor who now runs her own post-production company helping creators and brands make better content. We get into what actually...
What’s the best camera for travel vlogging and capturing everyday memories? After four days exploring Tokyo and Tokyo Disneyland with my daughter, I’m sharing the cameras I actually used, why I brought them, and how...