Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

From The Green Notebook

From The Green Notebook artwork

(When) Do Leaders Matter? with Jared Diamond

Oct 9, 202658 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Jared Diamond, Pulitzer Prize-winning author of Guns, Germs, and Steel and Prophets, Coaches, and Kings, joins Joe to explore a fundamental question: When do leaders actually make a difference, and when are their successes or failures shaped by circumstances beyond their control? Joe and Diamond discuss how luck, timing, resources, and institutional advantages influence leadership outcomes. Drawing on examples from history, business, sports, and the military, Diamond challenges traditional ideas about great leaders and explains how natural experiments can help separate individual contributions from outside factors. They explore why coaches and CEOs may account for only a quarter of their organizations' success, how favorable conditions helped Genghis Khan build his empire, why Winston Churchill was the right leader at the right moment, and how even brilliant commanders like Erwin Rommel faced limitations they could not overcome. Joe and Diamond also discuss: The Hamlet Test and how to determine whether a leader was truly indispensable The strengths and limitations of using biographies to study leadership Why firing an underperforming coach may not improve a team's performance The role of luck and timing in Mark Zuckerberg's success How Seretse Khama, Botswana's founding president, chose to limit his own power for the greater good Why so few powerful political leaders voluntarily step down The importance of charisma and organizational ability in building religious movements What Diamond has learned about leadership across politics, business, sports, and religion How Diamond continues researching, writing, and learning at 89 years old Why keeping notebooks has been essential to his research and writing process since he was three years old Whether you're leading a military formation, running a business, coaching a team, or simply trying to understand what makes leaders effective, this conversation challenges how we assign credit and blame. It offers lessons on recognizing the influence of circumstances, questioning the stories we tell about successful leaders, and developing the humility to recognize that even the greatest leaders rarely succeed on their own. A Special Thanks to our Sponsors! Meet ROGER Bank - a modern, digital bank built for military members, by military members. With early payday, no fees, high-yield accounts, and real support, it’s banking that gets you. Funds are FDIC insured through Citizens Bank of Edmond, so you can bank with confidence and peace of mind. Meet Nightwing. Made to serve the mission. Hardwired to defend the nation. Against an ever-evolving threat landscape, Nightwing brings deep expertise and an unwavering commitment to U.S. national security. From cyberspace to orbit, Nightwing operates at the edge of complexity - delivering some of the world's most technically advanced capabilities to see what others don't, go where others won't, and achieve what others can't.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02So since the coach moves from team to team, you can see the effect of the coach as opposed to the effect of the team. And what you discover in the sports world also is that coaches account for about one quarter of team success and three quarters of team success on the average depends upon the general manager and the budget. Like Alabama has a big football budget and a great player. So did Bill Belichick make a difference? Well well Tom Brady was there going to hold Tom Brady goes off to Tampa Bay, and Bill Belichick no longer goes to goes to the Super Bowl.

SPEAKER_02So on the average, then coaches and CEOs account for about one quarter of success. In the military world, I'm just waiting for uh you or someone else to apply national experiments to the military world and see whether also Patton or Yamamoto or MacArthur accounted for about one quarter of the success of their countries and whether other factors accounted for three quarters.

SPEAKER_02For example, Rommel, great general, great German general in North Africa. Rommel ended up getting defeated. Why was he defeated? Yeah, he was a great, great general. But Britain had much more ability to funnel supplies into North Africa than did Rommel. And so, although Rommel was a great general, he was defeated by Britain's superior delivery power.

SPEAKER_04I'd like to introduce you to our newest partner, Roger Bank, a modern digital military bank built by military members for military members. Whether you're stationed stateside or overseas, Roger is designed to meet the unique needs of our men and women in uniform. I recently opened an account myself, and the process was incredibly smooth. It took less than 10 minutes from start to finish. Now, here's why I'm excited to partner with Roger. They offer high-yield checking and savings accounts, zero account fees, early payday, and automatic savings with Roundup Match.

SPEAKER_04Their military-ready direct deposit form is even auto-populated and signed by the CEO, saving you time and hassle. Plus, you get free global ATM access, real person customer support, and they even offer accounts for service members as young as 17. Funds are FDIC insured through Citizens Bank of Edmund. So you can bank with confidence and peace of mind. Visit Roger.bank to learn more. That's R O G E R dot Bank.

SPEAKER_04When do leaders actually make a difference? In this conversation, we challenge some of the stories we tell ourselves about great leaders. We talk about the role of luck, timing, circumstance, and resources in determining success, why firing a struggling coach may not actually improve a team, and how natural experiments can help us separate the impact of an individual leader from everything happening around them. We also discuss Winston Churchill, Genghis Khan, Rommel, CEOs, sports coaches, and Turetsi Kama of Botswana, I hope I said that name right, whose decision to give up rather than consolidate power offers a fascinating lesson in leadership and character.

SPEAKER_04And towards the end, Jared and I talk about something especially appropriate for the show, notebooks. At 89 years old, he's still researching, writing, and learning. And he explains why keeping notebooks has been essential to his work since he was three years old. So grab your green notebooks and please welcome to the show, Professor Jared Diamond.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. It's a pleasure to be with you.

SPEAKER_04Well, I I I want to start the question I have is the first question I have is the, you know, behind the title of the book, Prophets, Prophets, Coaches and Kings. And you write that you've been wrestling with this question since childhood of when do leaders make a difference? And um, and I think you grew up, you talk about it in the book. You grew up, your family grew up in the shadow of Hitler and World War II. And so I'm question I want to know is why has this question stayed with you your entire life?

SPEAKER_04And and why now to write this book?

SPEAKER_02Why this question stayed with me my entire life? My first response would be heaven's sakes, my my my wife's mother survived Auschwitz. My wife's father's father did not survive Auschwitz. The last of my family, my own family in Europe disappeared in the Holocaust. Um, I grew up in the shadow of Hitler. The question has been with me for a long time. My wife is still alive, and the photograph of her mother is on the desk behind me, Auschwitz Wever, and her father's father is photo photographers also there, Auschwitz non.

SPEAKER_02So those questions never go away.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Well, you know, you push back against two, you know, theories. One is the great man theory, which is, you know, there's extraordinary individuals in history, but then two, Tolstoy's uh, you know, quote about leaders, leaders not mattering. What what did you learn through this process of researching and writing this book?

SPEAKER_02What did I learn through this process? What I learned is that neither of those two extreme views is correct as a universal answer. Sometimes leaders make a difference and sometimes they don't. And so what my book is about is not about how to be a great leader. There are so many books about that. It's about the circumstances under which a leader can can make a difference. And I look at that question in politics and in business and in sports and in so many cases.

SPEAKER_02Argentina would have would have won the World Cup if the Argentine coach had read my book. The Argentine coach didn't read my book. He didn't didn't read that where coaches most make a difference is not in the heroic teaching his players to dribble and all that stuff, but in teaching his players not to commit penalties. But since the Argentine coach didn't teach that lesson, uh Argentina got all the yellow cards, Spain got no yellow cards, Argentina had one player set sent off.

SPEAKER_02It was zero-zero until then. And when that one player was set off sent off, Spain had 11 players against Argentina's 10 players and so it did not go to a penalty shootout, which Argentina would have won with their great goal. So there's a non-military uh example of what people can learn by reading Jared Diamond's book.

SPEAKER_04Well, let's let let's back it up a little bit. One of the interesting ideas that you put forward in the book is is something called the Hamlet Test. Could you explain that?

SPEAKER_02Sure. The the Hamlet test. Um leaders in some fields, military fields, political fields, um business fields, often claim they are the only person who could do it. Whatever. Um but so ask yourself, was Jeff Bezos the only person who could have found a online marketing of everything in the United States? Well, when Jeff Bezos was founding online Amazon, the population of scientists in the United States was 320 million Americans.

SPEAKER_02And you're trying to tell me that out of those 320 million, we can eliminate them one by one. And every single one of those 320 million, other than Jeff Bezos, couldn't have made a difference. The Hamlet test um looks at the unusual circumstances where one person can make a difference. Well, Shakespeare Hamlet is often regarded as the greatest greatest play in the English language. Could any if Shakespeare had died in childbirth, would we never have a great play like like Hamlet? Well, in this case, we know who were all the other Elizabethan playwrights at the time of Shakespeare.

SPEAKER_02There are about two dozen of them, and we've got their plays. We know all of them, not three and forty million, but all twenty-two of them. And we got their plays, and none of their plays is remotely as good as Hamlet. But Hamlet was not Shakespeare's first, it was his, I think, twenty-second play after Romeo and Julian and Julius Caesar. Shakespeare had already proved that he was a great playwright. So Shakespeare passed the Hamlet test. It's rare in the business world that you get a person who is the only person who could have done it.

SPEAKER_02If you like pomegranate juice as I do, when the pomegranate juice industry was founded in 2022, there were only, I think, 22 Americans growing growing pomegranates in California. And of those 22, 21 were small farmers who didn't have the money or the independence or the motivation to found the pomegranate juice industry. One, Linda Resnick, had lost the money and she was not a stock company. So she could do whatever she wanted. She had the medical motivation, and she founded the pomegranate juice industry, which required building a three-story press.

SPEAKER_02It's not like orange juice that you cut it open and squeeze it. To squeeze pomegranate, you need a three-story press to squeeze the so she was she's the only business person I can think of who found past the hamlet test. In the military sphere, was Rommel the only German general who could have temporarily reversed the battle in North Africa. Um okay, there were not 340 million German generals, but there were several dozen German generals.

SPEAKER_02Was Rommel the only one who could want to make more of a case for Rommel?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think it's very it's a very fascinating thing because I think what it does is it takes it it forces us to look at all the various factors, like going back to the pomegranate juice, which I actually love. Um, you know, you know, like like you said, like they had the the greatest amount of um, I guess, produced the greatest amount of pomegranates. They had the money, um, and and then they had the the drive, and no one else was doing it. And um and I think that's like really interesting, especially in the military sphere too, because I think a lot of times we attribute greatness or success um to people when there were other factors uh politically.

SPEAKER_04And and you kind of mentioned it, you know, when looking at at the you know, towards the end of the book, like we talk about the great military leaders during war too, but like also look at the industrial defense industrial complex that that we had built up during that time and the logistics that we had built up during that time. And it's just it's really interesting, I think, to kind of separate people from the factors at play to really narrow down to what works and what doesn't.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well what you offer such such such good examples, all right. So so at the Battle of Midway, Wayne McCluskey saw the Japanese destroyer Arashi when both sides were looking for the other's aircraft carriers. Wayne McCluskey, American pilot, figured out that the destroyer Rashi proceeding at full speed was probably heading for aircraft carriers. So he followed the Arashi, and lo and behold, there were the Kaga, the Akage, and the Soyu, and within five minutes he sank them.

SPEAKER_02But with Japan's limited industrial capacity, the loss of the four carriers to Japan at Midway, um, when the United States in the following two years built, what, 13 SS-class aircraft carriers and also had the atomic bomb? Was there any way that Japan could have won World War II? Um I think what could make a stronger case that Nazi Germany had a better chance for winning in Europe because it had much more industrial capacity than Japan.

SPEAKER_02But again, in the case of Japan, Japan, so the Pearl Harbor attack, Nagumo ordered two strikes. His pilots told him order a third strike and knock out the fuel tanks. If he had knocked out the fuel tanks on Hawaii, the American fleet would have had to retreat to the Pacific coast. And would we ever have been able to overcome the Japanese head start? One might say, well, we developed the atomic bomb and the Japanese couldn't. And yes, if we had lost our um the gas tanks, it would have taken longer, but the result would have been the same.

SPEAKER_02One can debate that back and forth.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, again, this is like very fascinating. And so two methods you use throughout the book, and I want to talk about each of those. The first one is biography. What are the strengths and what are the weaknesses of studying leaders when it comes to using biography, which is one of my favorites, by the way.

SPEAKER_02The strength of biography is that it's it's fascinating. It makes good reading. The weakness of biography is you can't prove anything. So there are biographies. Did Hitler make a difference? There are biographies of Hitler. Most biographers of Hitler consider that Hitler was a uniquely evil, uniquely talented, uniquely deceptive person who made a difference. But um the the um greatest British historian, A.J.P. Taylor, wrote his own biography.

SPEAKER_02He didn't discover new facts about Hitler. Biography were the same facts. And A.J.P. Hitler concluded A. A.J.P. Taylor concluded that Hitler was a normal German politician who did what any German politician would have done. Didn't discover new facts. That's the weakness of biography. Um the strength, the alternative is natural experiments. Um we we can't go around experimentally killing leaders. Um I can't uh kill Rommel and MacArthur as of January 1941.

SPEAKER_02But leaders do die natural deaths, and more often they don't die natural deaths, or they get assassinated and they don't get assassinated. We can compare what happens in a natural experiment, not with Jared Diamond going around killing people occasionally, but with people dying natural death, and we see what happens when 57 politicians after World War II died natural deaths of heart attacks and falling off a horse, and 220 didn't die natural. We can compare the results, and that's a natural experiment.

SPEAKER_02That's why I see power, unique power to the method of natural experiments.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, let's you you mentioned Argentina earlier, you know, talking in sports, and you talk about in the book that sports are uniquely uh it's a unique sphere because the rules are very straightforward, and there's a ton of data um that's available to sociologists to kind of look at and and run natural experiments on. So like I'm interested on one of the findings, um, that one of the questions you you looked into was, you know, did do firing coaches um make the difference?

SPEAKER_04And I thought it was very interesting that the um you know the results that you found.

SPEAKER_02That is an interesting story, and because you are speaking to me, a UCLA professor. UCLA is a flagrant example. Um the chancellor, the chancellor of the UCLA just fired our athletic director. The chancellor of the UCLA and our athletic director did not see fit to ask Jared Diamond whether to fire all their sports coaches. But UCLA, after John Wooden, greatest coach of any American college sport in 20th century, um after we hired John Wooden, we've hired we've had a string of other coaches, basketball coaches, and those basketball coaches have had records that any university would have been proud of.

SPEAKER_02They won 60, 70 percent of the game. But because they were not John Warden, we fired all those coaches. But what one what the people who look at coaches with losing records and that fire the coach, what they fail to do is is to compare what happens when you fire the coach with what happens when you don't fire the coach. And it turns out that if you don't fire the coach, the new coach has about the same record that you would have had if you had not fired the coach.

SPEAKER_02The result is that the UCLA Athletic Department is now$150 million in debt. Why? Because we fired all these basketball coaches. We had to buy out their contracts. That's$150 million debt that we're in. But each coach did as well as the previous coach because it turns out that coaches account for only about one quarter of success in sport. In Argentina or where so many coaches get fired. You can compare what happens when the coach gets fired with what happens when the coach doesn't get fired.

SPEAKER_02And it turns out that that it's like throwing dice. If you fire a dice thrower, because the dice thrower has thrown a one, the chances are five out of six that the next dice thrower, even if he's a comp he or she is a complete idiot, uh has got five choices to do better, two, three, four, five, six. Whereas uh a dice throw's thrown a one, the chances are five out of six that the next next coach will will do better. That's what we can learn from the sports world.

SPEAKER_02And it's why the business school professors who are interested in studying the outcome what CEOs do, uh their database nowadays is especially in sports, because the the the results in sports are so much so much clearer. The games are played every week, the coach is jumping up and down on the sidelines, you know what the coach does. Whereas the CEO who knows who knows what the CEO does and takes five years to report the results and then they may never get reported. Similarly, similarly in sports, the what we've learned about sports and about business has been disproportionately from business school professors analyzing football games.

SPEAKER_04It it's interesting. And it's you know, like reading your book, and then there's another great book called Captain Class, where um I think it was Sam Johnson is his name. I may have I may be getting the name wrong. I'm sure I am. Um, but you know, he analyzed like 1800 teams to like to figure out, you know, what traits or or what things need to be present for a team to actually have a dynasty to win over time. And so like reading these two books, I kind of realized that, you know, like we think that we're so much better than people who, you know, used to look to the stars or the sky for signs or like throw people off a ship because they felt like they were, you know, the reason the ship was getting battered by the storm.

SPEAKER_04But it seems like we haven't gotten much better with our judgment. We just look at different places, but it's these natural experiments and trying to piece apart the factors, I think is is a way that we could actually improve our decision making and our discernment as leaders.

SPEAKER_02That's right. In the past 30 years, social scientists have improved, almost perfected the method of natural experiments. Um so my career began as a laboratory scientist. I worked in the laboratory, I did gallbladders in potassium solutions or sodium solutions, they were controlled, and so I could uh uh uh settle whether gallbladder sodium transport was stimulated by potassium, because I could manipulate gallbladders.

SPEAKER_02When I got interested in New Guinea birds, so among scientists I'm best known for my work on ecology and evolution and goose birds, I could not run around in New Guinea exterminating bird populations. Instead, I had to look for natural experiments. I looked for mountains where the mountain mouse warbler was absent, and mountains where the mountain wasp mouse warbler is present, and I compare those mountains to see what happened to the lower mouse warbler. Well, social scientists, including several who won the Nobel Prize in Economics last year, have developed the method of natural experiments of comparing what happens when you don't do it purposely, but when it it it happens by chance, a natural experiment.

SPEAKER_02What happens when the president gets assassinated, with what happens when the president doesn't get assassinated. Um it happens in lots of cases. Um again dramatic Hitler. So um the assassination attempt by Klaus von Stauffenberg against Hitler. Klaus von Stauffenberg, uh German who was thoroughly disillusioned with Hitler. Klaus von Stauffenberg at Hitler's lair on July 21st, 1944.

SPEAKER_02He had a briefcase with a bomb in it, and he pushed the briefcase under the table next to Hitler. And the briefcase went off. And alas, Hitler leaned forward just at the moment the bomb went off. So Hitler got severely wounded. Four other Germans in Hitler's lair got killed, but Hitler survived. If Hitler had died July 21st, 1944, probably millions, maybe tens of millions of people would be alive today who would have been spared if Hitler had died on July 21st instead of committing suicide on early May.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, I I thought it was really fascinating. The, you know, like how much and it you kind of, I mean, you cover it throughout your book too, but like the role that luck and timing has, um, not only for the positive successes a leader has, but also like in the realm of blame too, the the mistakes, um, you know, like wrong person, wrong time. Um, you know, or the you know, maybe the right person the wrong time coming into a role and is not as successful as somebody coming down the road later and trying the same exact thing.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so an example in the we can talk about examples in the military world, but let's think of an example in in the business world, Mark Zuckerberg. All right, so so Mark Zuckerberg, um uh FaceTime, Meta, whatever he calls it now. So Mark Zuckerberg is especially successful in the social in the social media world. Why? Mark Zuckerberg was born in 1984, which meant that he was a Harvard sophomore in 2004. There had been social media founded before him, social media founded after him, but 2004 was the perfect year to found a social media because the power the internet had just just developed uh um uh uh special success before Mark Zuckerberg, they've been friendly, but didn't do do so well.

SPEAKER_02Now, did Mark Zuckerberg uh have the foresight to get himself born in 1984? No, he had the good luck to be born in 1984. And in 2004, he didn't know that this was the best time to found social media. It was simply that he was a sophomore at Harvard then, so he did what he did and founded social media. There is someone who was at the right place and right perfect place and perfect, but he didn't know about it. And for a military leader, the the biggest empire in land empire in world history was Genghis Khan, who established an empire all the way from China to Poland.

SPEAKER_02And but there were there were other um leaders on the steppes of Asia. Um there was Adela the Hun or Timor the Turk. Why did they not establish that huge land empire? Well, Genghis Khan, we now know only in the last decade, Genghis Khan had the good luck to be born at the wettest time in the steppes of Central Asia and Mongolia in the last 2,000 years. But a wet time of high rainfall means lots of rain, means lots of hay to feed sheep and goats to feed Mongol babies, but also hay to feed horses that Mongol soldiers could ride into battle.

SPEAKER_02And so if Genghis Khan had been born 10 years earlier, 200 miles further away, we wouldn't know about Genghis Khan. There's a military, yes, Genghis Khan was an outstanding tactician, tactician, but so many outstanding tacticians, Adela, were born at the wrong time and wrong place. Genghis Khan didn't know, but like Mark Zuckerberg, he was born precisely the right time and place.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, he's even, you know, thinking going back to World War II examples, you know, you you've got characters, and I say characters, but you have leaders like Patton and MacArthur. Um, and and actually, like even Churchill's a great example of this. Um, any other time period, um, they probably wouldn't have been successful. They probably wouldn't have done well. And we even see it, I think, in you know, going back to biography, like Winston Churchill's previous uh experiences, he was the crazy loud guy in parliament um that would never shut up.

SPEAKER_04And you know, guys were like um other politicians were rolling their eyes as Churchill would get up and give these speeches, but then World War II comes around and he's the right person at the right place in time to do his thing. And even like the egos of a guy like Patton and a guy like MacArthur, um, you know, World War II required uh, you know, them to be the way they were to be successful. Um so I anyways, I've just been thinking about that a lot, like the timing aspect of everything since reading this book.

SPEAKER_02You are you are so right. So so Winston Churchill, Winston Churchill was Chancellor of the Exchequer, basically Treasury Secretary, in 1929. And everybody agrees that he did a horrible job. And then after World War II, um, so he was voted out as prime minister at the end of World War II, but then he came back in, I think, 1951. He was peacetime prime minister. And everybody agrees that it was a terrible peacetime prime minister. His colleagues wanted to get rid of him and they finally got rid of him. But when Germany invaded France in May 1940, Churchill was a and Chamberlain was forced to resign.

SPEAKER_02Churchill was was called upon to become prime minister. And in his wonderful five, six-volume history of World War II, Churchill on the last page of Volume I says, I knew that my this was the moment to which my whole life had been pointing. Um, this was my opportunity to be wartime prime minister. It's not that Churchill engineered the opportunity. Churchill did not make Germany invade France. Germany did invade France. The result was that he became prime minister, but we immediately see that he made a difference because the British War Cabinet, the week of Dunkirk, met to decide what to do.

SPEAKER_02And in the War Cabinet, Lord Halifax, foreign minister, Lord Halifax proposed accepting an offer of Hitler whereby Britain would give Hitler incredible Gibraltar and Malta in return for Hitler promising not to invade Britain. And Halifax and the other members of the Ward Cabinet said, yeah, let's take this deal. Turtle said, no, no, no. And Turtle gradually, in the course of several days, convinced the cabinet not to do it. Well, Churchill made a difference, but he he got to it, he got to his situation.

SPEAKER_02He didn't engineer it. Um, he found himself at the right place at the right time. And in 1929, and I defeated one of them would have been at the wrong place at the wrong time. So Churchill's an example of someone who knew that he had the crucial opportunity, but he was not in a position to manufacture that opportunity.

SPEAKER_04And speaking of leaders, and Professor, you're gonna have to help me with this name because I'll probably mess it, I'll probably butcher it and embarrass myself. Um, but is it Zaritsi Kama? Is it how you say his name?

unknownYes.

SPEAKER_04Okay, so you know, like you have a really cool biography in the book of Taritsi, and and I had never heard of this guy before reading your book. And so, you know, he makes a decision that is almost counterintuitive to somebody with power by um, you know, opening like giving his the rights to the diamond mines to the state instead of holding on to it to try. So he was thinking of the greater good versus that that personal security.

SPEAKER_04So this is a little bit outside the context of the book, but I'm just curious of your thoughts on it. Is the willingness to restrain yourself one of the clearest tests of character in a powerful leader? Um, because again, he could have just taken the diamonds, he could have focused on profits, um, but but he didn't in the in the founding of Botswana.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, he's a great example. So he was the founding president of what had been the British colony of Bekwan, which was totally worthless to liberty. Britain had never invested money in Bekoanaland. Um, and then it becomes independent as Botswana. Um, it Botswana upon independence looks like the least promising country in the world because it it had had what 20 22 college graduates. Um but six months after independence, diamonds were discovered in Botswana.

SPEAKER_02If the diamonds had been discovered before independence, the British and the Beers of South Africa would have taken over the diamond mines, but the diamonds were discovered after independence, which meant that Botswana itself could decide what to do with the diamonds. There were about 20 chiefs, tribal chiefs in Botswana, and the diamonds were discovered on the land of Suretskama's tribe, which is the biggest tribe in Botswana. In any other African country, the chief on whose land was discovered the oil and diamonds and other stuff, took the diamonds and oil and other stuff for his tribe.

SPEAKER_02But Suretskama no, he said any underground resources are the property of the Botswana state. And that meant that the Botswana state with only one million people then became rich, they had all the diamond wealth to spread among only one million people. So his decision to make the diamonds national property, and similarly as the the most powerful tribal chief in Botswana, when Botswana became independent, it set up a two-house parliament like the British Parliament, with a parliament of chiefs and a parliament of everybody else.

SPEAKER_02Um the parliament of chiefs in other African countries, the chiefs assume tribal chiefs assume power for themselves and were corrupt. But Suretsi Kama said, No, the power of the chiefs, I'm gonna gut the power of the chiefs. He is the most powerful chief in Botswana, was the only person who could get away with gutting the power of the chiefs. And in addition, he had been educated at Oxford and he married a British woman.

SPEAKER_02So he was a master of both worlds, the European world and the African world. He wore a European suit, and in his jacket pocket was a bag of dried grasshoppers, traditional food, and he would offer the dried grasshoppers to his European visitors who refused it and to his African visitors who ate it along with him. So he was the master of both worlds. He there was a leader who made a difference.

SPEAKER_04From cyberspace to orbit, Nightwing operates at the edge of complexity, delivering advanced capabilities to see what others don't, go where others won't, and achieve what others can. Nightwing, solutions for every domain, resolutions to every thread. Check them out in the show notes or go to their website at nightwing.com. Yeah, and and again, going back to that decision, like it I feel like in just my my study of you know not doing natural experiments, but uh, you know, reading a lot of biographies is that when you gain power, there's a propensity to take all of it, not to restrain yourself at all.

SPEAKER_04And it seems like some of the examples in your book. Um, again, while you didn't specifically write about this, but that ability to restrain yourself uh and not just go all in on power will actually benefit whatever organization you're a part of in the long run.

SPEAKER_02Right. Um, so examples of that. Well, one of the surprises for me um in the book, um in in looking at at political leaders, um I assembled a table of the couple of dozen putting the most powerful political leaders since World War II, and I looked at what happened to them. And what surprised me was that out of those 24 leaders, um, there were only two who stepped down voluntarily.

SPEAKER_02Um Nelson Mandela of South Africa retired voluntarily, and Lee Kwan Yu of Singapore retired voluntarily. But all of the other major political leaders, like Hitler, they committed suicide, or like, or they were assassinated, or they were voted out of out of office, or they were pushed out of out of office, or they they got sick. What this means is that once a leader um uh has achieved power, most leaders who achieve power draw the conclusion that they are uniquely talented and they don't step down voluntarily.

SPEAKER_02Um out of out of 24, there were only there were only two who stepped down voluntarily. That surprised me.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's and as I'm like thinking about this because I'm I'm really interested and want to write about power um as I'm as I'm doing the research now for it. And one of the things that that I think um, you know, especially like what you just said, is that it will continue to pull us uh into thinking that we are indispensable because we have been successful. And the importance of like books like this and some of the other ones out there is to look at all the factors in play, at least from a philosophical perspective, to keep yourself humble.

SPEAKER_04Um, you know, timing, luck. Um, you mentioned a ton of factors in the book when we're talking about sports coaches, um, everything from startup players to the quality of the league to you know their ability to pick and choose. Anyways, just a lot of factors out there that I think are worth, you know, people who are successful in leadership positions is looking across the field uh to find that humility. Again, I know it's outside the scope of the book, but I think it's just an interesting point that that I I just an insight I had while reading this.

SPEAKER_02Absolutely. So in in the sports world or in in the business world of CEOs, um routinely say, I'm uniquely qualified to be head of this company, and this company is making profits of$100 billion. So you can, since the company is making$100 billion, you can pay me a lousy little salary of$2 billion. I deserve it because I'm uniquely qualified. Well, is the CEO really uniquely qualified? This is an area where business school professors analyzing the sports world and then analyzing the business world have ground out the numbers.

SPEAKER_02And it turns out that on the average, a CEO accounts for between 20 and 30 percent of company profits. And the other effects on company profits are the company itself. Procter Gamble has been a well-run company for 150 years, and CEO after CEO, Procter Gamble always turns a great profit. Another factor is the industry. There are industries where you can make the killing and others where you can't.

SPEAKER_02Public utilities, you can never make the killing because public utilities are tightly regulated by the government. But teenage t-shirts, um if you can figure out what the teeny poppers are going to like two weeks from now, you can make a killing. And and a friend of mine is the head of a teenage t-shirt company, and he's made lots of money because he's a genius for figuring out what the teenagers are going to like um two weeks from now. Similarly, in the sports world, yes, the coach has an effect, but you can look at how much of an effect by watching what happens when the coach uh moves from team to team.

SPEAKER_02In Argentina, um on the average, um on the average, a coach gets fired every year. And in Germany, football league, uh the average, coaches get fired often. So since the coach moves from team to team, you can see the effect of the coach as opposed to the effect of the team. And what you discover in the sports world also is that coaches account for about one quarter of team success. And three quarters of team success on the average depends upon the general manager and the budget, like Alabama has a big football budget and a great player.

SPEAKER_02So did Bill Belichick make a difference? Well, well, Tom Brady was there. He goes off to Bay, and Bill Belichick no longer goes to goes to the Super Bowl. Uh so on the average, then coaches and CEOs um account for about one quarter of success. In in the military world, I'm just waiting for uh you or someone else to apply national experiments to the military world and see whether also Patton or Yellamoto or MacArthur accounted for about one quarter of the success of their countries and whether other factors accounted for three quarters.

SPEAKER_02For example, Rommel, great general, great German general in North Africa. Rommel ended up getting defeated. Why was he defeated? Yeah, he was a great, great general, but Britain had much more ability to funnel supplies into North Africa than did Rommel. And so, although Rommel was a great general, he was defeated by Britain's superior delivery power.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, we've talked um it's fascinating. I don't know if it'll be me. I'm I'm still figuring out what I want to do when I grow up. Um, but you know, we we've talked about business, we've talked about military, we've talked about sport, um, and we've talked about government. You also talk about religious movement in this book. And so um, does create not only creating a movement, but also institutionalizing it, does that require fundamentally different types of leadership skills?

SPEAKER_02Sometimes here goes a paradigm and that's what the frustrated interview is out of the line. It depends. But it's but it's true. Um to be to found a new religion, um, you need at least two and possibly three abilities. You have to be charismatic. If you're not charismatic, you go nowhere founding a new religion. But also you have to be an outstanding organizer. If you're not an outstanding organizer, your religion goes nowhere. And then religions often face opposition, including violent opposition.

SPEAKER_02So sometimes you have to be a successful general in the case of the Mahdi of the Sudan, who set up an empire in the Sudan in the late 1800s. The Mahdi was incredibly charismatic, and he was a great organizer, and he was a great military leader. He assembled his tribesmen with sticks and stones, and he nevertheless defeated a British Egyptian army of 7,000 with machine guns.

SPEAKER_02So in the case of the 20th, the 19th century USA, it's interesting. There are four religions that are spread around the world in the last 200 years. The Mormon religion and the Seventh-day Adventists and the Jehovah's Witnesses and Christian scientists. Now, isn't it interesting that all four of those religions that spread around the world in the 19th century, they're all US religions.

SPEAKER_02Yes, they're charismatic leaders, but I've known charismatic New Guinea religious leaders, and the Mahdi was charismatic leader of the the Sudan. In order to have a religion that spreads around the world, you have to have not only charisma, you have to have economic power and you have to have military power. The United States in the 19th century was developing economic power and military power. So Joseph Smith, who founded the Mormon religion, yes, he was charismatic, but he was in the right place at the right time. And he was not the greatest.

SPEAKER_02It was Brigham Young who was the great organizer after Joseph Smith's death for the Mormon religion.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, the uh I again I like I'm still reflecting on the various lessons of this book. Um, was there anything that you believed about leadership before reading this book that changed once you started diving into the research?

SPEAKER_02When I got into the research, um, my my motivation was initially to study political leaders again because of my growing up in the world of Hitler. But but I realized that because I'm 89 and I have 39 year old sons. In order to be able to have a conversation with my 39 year old son, I have to be interested in NBA, NFL, and and and whatever, which I hadn't been interested in.

SPEAKER_02So from my sons I've learned about sports. And from my UCLA undergraduates I've learned about about sports. I didn't realize that the lessons about leadership from sports were so clear and that they were essentially the same lessons as one one learned from tech politics and business. I hadn't realized that the lessons that one learns from Hitler and Winston Churchill that similar similar lessons apply to to religion as well.

SPEAKER_02And so those were the book took me seven years to write but those were discoveries to see that similar lessons about leadership emerged not only in politics, which were what drove me into writing the book, but also in business and in sports where I've learned a lot from my sons and in the witchmen.

SPEAKER_04I I you you mentioned it and this is a question I've wanted to ask you uh since we started you said you're 89 years old and uh you're still writing books. Um I imagine I and I'm not sure you're still a professor at as a day job or emeritus or um but like yeah how are you how are you how do you find what factors and I guess like I'm asking you this which is probably the wrong person to ask but like what factors do you think there's in play in your life that's allowing you to still continue to do this thing at 89 years old um where there are people 11 12 years younger than you that are you know not doing this to the degree that you are several things.

SPEAKER_02One the luck of my genes um my my mother and father both lived into their 90s and they died preventable deaths. My my father's sister lived into age 102. So I'm lucky with with good genes. Another thing is that ever since I was in high school I'd work I've worked out I go to the gym three times a week um I come back and tell my sons today I did pet fly 48 reps at 90 pounds and I got my biceps curl up to 70 pounds.

SPEAKER_02And for my sons that's nothing. And for the other I work out at the UCLA gym and all these young 20 year olds they ask me how old I am and I so one thing that helps is that that I'm I I work out three times a week and I go on the exercise bike. And then I'm I'm I'm interested a lot in what what I do. I'm still working on New Guinea birds and I used to sing. I love the music of Bach I'm listening to Bach cantators and and I hope in the next five years to listen to all 200 Bach cantatas.

SPEAKER_02So I'm into really interested in life I have a wonderful wife and wonderful children and I don't want to screw up their lives by by dying on them. And then I'm fortunate good genes and then finally I work out diligently.

SPEAKER_04Do you think that writing and researching is something that just continues to keep you keep you sharp?

SPEAKER_02Yeah yeah so I I'm interested in lots of stuff on my desk now is uh a manuscript of a paper on the the birds of the Wandaman Mountains on the northwest coast of New Guinea. Now my guess is that you have not been seriously concerned about the birds of Wanda Mountains, but I am they're one of the 10 mountain ranges on the north coast of New Guinea. And so I'm comparing those ten mountain ranges to see what generalities one can arrive at understanding why some species are good colonists and others are not.

SPEAKER_02New Guinea birds are a good place to study that but it's a general question in biology why some species better colonists than than other colonists. And yes I'm writing about that and I'm interested about that and and I I hope to to live long enough to publish not only about the Montamin Mountains but I then I have to publish about the Bwanning Mountains and when I've done that I can then do a synthesis and compare the birds of Walthead, New Guinea Mountains, provided that I stay alive and do it.

SPEAKER_04Well you you've been writing now for over three dec I mean you've been publishing books for over three decades now. Another question I have again has nothing to do with you know this particular book but what lessons have you learned about writing um you know that that have vastly changed I guess since you you first started this process a long time ago for me writing has not changed.

SPEAKER_02My mother taught my mother was a school was a teacher she taught me to read when I was three years old and I began keeping notebooks from age three onwards. I I had notebooks where I where I listed generals and where I listed rivers of the world and where I listed birds and animals. So I've been making lists and keeping notebooks ever since I was three years old. I went to a secondary school a very good secondary school that required all of us to to write a composition every week.

SPEAKER_02And each week I would sit down with my mother eating peanut butter and wristcrackers while my mother corrected my compositions. So Mom taught me the difference between restrictive and non-restrictive relative clauses which which no young per person today except my Chinese graduate students knows anything about restrictive relative clauses. So I keep writing um I I do not do anything about AI. I I write myself um I used not to write on the computer until my wife and twin sons forced me to buy an iPhone and so I got I've got the iPhone um I behold the iPhone in this lower corner there's this little icon and a high school classmate of mine showed me Jared that icon I never knew what the icon was that icon is a dictator and so with my iPhone I can now dictate not only in English but also in Italian and German.

SPEAKER_02So my Italian and German cars every day I deal with Italian and German I push that that little icon so and so technology is good for something. Not a great deal but it's good for something and and my iPhone enables me um to do my correspondence in Italian and German. And also my iPhone enables me after I've written longhand the drafts of my books and papers I then dictated onto my my iPhone um and I sent it to my I made a great discovery in my iPhone the night before last so there are these there's these knobs on this side of the I didn't know what they were and and the night before last I discovered that if I I if I push the top knob that top knob increases the volume I've been frustrated for a long time I didn't have to increase the volume just by chance I discovered the night before last that's the volume control knob.

SPEAKER_04Yeah you're still you're still learning I I'm curious the the notebooks because you know the what this podcast is called From the Green Notebook and the notebook you know the the green government issue notebook has been a part uh was a part of my military career for two decades writing notes and and putting ideas down and I've been really big about when I read books like yours and and others I I take notes in a separate notebook when I have ideas about things to write I put them down in a notebook how has your notebooks contributed to your output over the years oh absolutely essential um to to write about anything um I need to develop a base of knowledge a fact base my books uh um my current book about leaders include one quarter is about CEOs in the business world well and one quarter is about sports my sons will be the first person to to tell you that their daddy doesn't know anything about sports except what we our sons told them that that that's true.

SPEAKER_02So I have to gather information from lots of people from from specialists in the area and so when I talk with a specialist I then dictate the notes what the specialist told me and then I organize those notes um and those notes are the starting point um for my book. One has to assemble one's knowledge base and then from the knowledge base find one's conclusions and develop one's conclusions.

SPEAKER_04Yeah and and I think that you know one of the things I at least I've learned and I'm sure you've learned the same lessons is that like when you you can walk around all day with ideas in your head um and you're gonna forget things, they're gonna be muddled but when you put them down on a paper piece of paper um it at least allows me to start looking at them objectively and actually start making connections that I couldn't have made if they were stuck in my head. Look for knowledge gaps um that I wouldn't have discovered if it was just stuck in my head. I mean there's just so many benefits.

SPEAKER_04So it's it's really neat to hear that this is something you've been doing since you were three.

SPEAKER_02You and I are in good in good company um Jeff Bezos and I believe Elon Musk are famous and notorious carry carrying around a notebook or and always writing things down in in the notebook. But it's not just in the business world. Beethoven the great composer Beethoven had his notebook and he scribbled things down in his in his notebook in Beethoven's notebook one can trace there's the there's what became the theme for the Ninth Symphony we've got an early version of it.

SPEAKER_02Beethoven in fact put the early version of it of that world's most famous theme into um his notebook and it became his choral fantasia in the Ninth Symphony but in the choral fantasia Beethoven started on the third we've got his notebook Beethoven put things down in his notebook Brahms probably did did also except Brahms burnt burnt all his notebook so yes keeping a notebook is a central for getting your ideas down and you and Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk and I and Beethoven all learned that lesson.

SPEAKER_04Ah great company well Professor Diamond thank you so much for your time today this is a really big deal for me. I remember being in high school walking into Barnes and Noble and seeing uh Gun Germs and Steel um you know like at the front display and and I've read your other books over the years. So um when I saw that you had published this book um I was really excited and really hoping that I'd get a chance to interview you uh for the show. So thank you so much for for making time today.

SPEAKER_02Thank you so much. And I have to it's I do lots of interviews. It is a great pleasure talking with you. Thank you.

SPEAKER_04Thank you so much. Well have have an amazing labor day and thanks for uh carving out an hour of your time for me.

SPEAKER_02Thank you so much. Over now bye-bye.

SPEAKER_04Bye thank you again for listening to another episode of From the Green Notebook podcast. If you enjoyed the show please give us five stars wherever you listen to podcasts it helps us gain visibility and the opportunity to help more people on their leadership journey. Also make sure you check out our website at www.fromthegreennotebook.com there you can listen to past episodes read leadership articles written by military leaders from around the world you can sign up for our monthly reading list email where you can learn about new books that are coming out and our Sunday reflection email that comes out every Sunday morning is really short.

SPEAKER_04It's a two minute read but I guarantee you it's going to start your week off on the right foot. Finally make sure you follow us on Twitter at FTG the notebook and you can find us on Instagram and Facebook by searching for From the Green Notebook. Again, thank you so much for coming on this journey with us. I am humbled by the opportunity to learn these lessons alongside you so please join us next week for another episode of From the Green Notebook where we're going to help you lead with the best version of yourself

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Welcome to the Chip Age: Understanding the Technology that Powers Our World with Rakesh Kumar

    Nov 20, 20261 hrAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Rakesh Kumar, author of The Chip Age, joins Joe to discuss the tiny pieces of technology that power nearly every aspect of our modern world, from smartphones and artificial intelligence to advanced...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Law of the Sublime with Robert Greene

    Nov 13, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Robert Greene, bestselling author of The 48 Laws of Power, Mastery, and The Laws of Human Nature, joins Joe to discuss his newest book, The Law of the Sublime, and how we can break free from the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What Is Strategy and Why Is It So Hard? with Dr. Eliot Cohen

    Oct 30, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Dr. Eliot Cohen, Professor Emeritus and former Dean at the School of Advanced International Studies at Johns Hopkins University, and author of The Strategist: How to Think About War and Politics, joins...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Building the Apple Store, Lessons from Steve Jobs, and Learning from Failure with Ron Johnson

    Oct 17, 202656 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Ron Johnson, former Apple executive and architect of the Apple Store, joins Joe to discuss his new book, Shop Different: How Retail Revealed Apple's Genius, and the leadership lessons he learned working...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Hidden Patterns Driving Your Relationships with Thais Gibson

    Oct 3, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Dr. Thais Gibson, founder of the Personal Development School and author of Learning Love, joins Joe to discuss attachment theory and how our early childhood experiences shape our relationship patterns,...

    Credit the people on this episode