Do Pigeons Navigate with Their Livers? A New Study Sparks Debate
1 hr 40 minAudio
Do pigeons navigate with their livers? A surprising study proposes that iron-rich immune cells help homing pigeons sense Earth's magnetic field. But other researchers argue that the mechanism does not hold up. Lester Nare and Krishna Choudhary unpack the experiments, the physics and the scientific debate. Jump to 36:19 for the pigeon deep dive. We explore macrophages, magnetite, quantum biology, classic magnetic-coil experiments, and why changing an animal's behavior does not automatically prove how its compass works. First, we examine what the midterms mean for science: how Congress funds research, the difference between authorizing programs and appropriating money, and why committee assignments matter for NASA, the NSF, national labs and university research. What experiment would convince you that the liver really is part of a pigeon's compass? And what science stories should we cover before the end of the year? CHAPTERS 00:00 Science funding and a compass in the liver? 00:23 Hello Internet 01:46 What the midterms mean for science 03:05 How midterm elections work 05:01 Why federal research funding matters 07:37 Chris Pappas and research funding 11:02 Melissa Bean and the national labs 15:23 James Talarico and university research 16:34 Scott Wiener and California research 18:13 Andy Barr and Julia Letlow 20:01 What Congress can actually do 27:46 Committees, appropriations and oversight 36:19 Do pigeons navigate with their livers? 43:51 The classic magnetic-coil experiment 52:53 Macrophages, iron and red blood cells 54:30 The radical-pair hypothesis 1:04:23 Could the inner ear detect magnetic fields? 1:07:04 The liver study: testing the hypothesis 1:15:56 Tracking pigeons in sunny and cloudy weather 1:19:17 The rebuttals: evidence vs. mechanism 1:22:39 Thermal noise and the physics problem 1:25:29 Head coils and competing explanations 1:36:29 What comes next? 1:37:23 Wrap-up and your episode suggestions 1:39:44 Outro RESEARCH & FURTHER READING Homing pigeon navigation relies on superparamagnetic macrophages under overcast conditions (Science, 2026): https://doi.org/10.1126/science.ady2486 A macrophage-based magnetoreceptor is not tenable (Winklhofer et al., Science eLetter): https://zenodo.org/records/21893910 Iron-rich cells in the pigeon beak are macrophages, not magnetosensitive neurons (Nature, 2012): https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11046 Walcott & Green's magnetic-coil experiment (Science, 1974): https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4815725/ How Senate committee assignments work: https://www.senate.gov/about/origins-foundations/committee-system/committee-assignments.htm EDITORIAL NOTES The liver-based magnetic compass is a contested hypothesis, not an established explanation of pigeon navigation. We distinguish the study's observations from its proposed mechanism and discuss alternative explanations. Political context reflects our November 12, 2026 recording. On-screen clarifications: 09:20 The roughly $9 billion NASA science figure was a budget request, not an enacted appropriation. 29:59 Committee chairs represent the majority party; ranking members lead the minority on that committee. 32:29 Congress ended Superconducting Super Collider funding in 1993; President Clinton had urged continued funding. 44:04 The historical coil experiment was published in 1974 by Charles Walcott and Robert P. Green. 52:53 Mature mammalian red blood cells lack nuclei; bird red blood cells retain them. 54:30 The 2012 beak study challenged a specific proposed receptor, not every iron-based sensing mechanism. 1:03:39 Bats are not blind. 1:04:23 David Keays is affiliated with LMU Munich and the IMP in Vienna. WATCH & LISTEN Watch, listen and explore the research: https://ffppod.com Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/@FromFirstPrinciplesPod?sub_confirmation=1 Support the show: https://ffppod.com/donate Contact: https://ffppod.com/contact Follow @FFPPod on Instagram, TikTok, X and Facebook. Breaking down science news so it makes sense to curious people everywhere. #Pigeons #Magnetoreception #SciencePodcast
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
But the real sugar daddy for this is the federal government. And I know this is something in your own research that you're aware of and have experienced directly. 100%. That's really weird already because first, why are these birds using their liver to navigate? Where are the haters? The haters came out quick. The rebuttals are swift, okay? Hello, Internet. This is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury.
There is so much going on in the news right now. We are both returning back here in studio after some international travel. We're going to cover two stories today. Starting with a post-midterm election breakdown with a wave of new members coming into both the House and Senate next year. What will it mean for the ongoing battle as it relates to research funding and the mandate for federal agencies around deciding what U.S. research and development looks like?
And we will end with a deep dive on a research paper that was on the cover of Science Magazine early this year about how birds use their livers to navigate when they fly. There's also a lot of drama around this story, which we will touch on briefly. But as always, we are going to talk about the science from the ground up today because this is from First Principles.
Welcome back. Thank you. Thank you. Yeah, it's been... America has changed a little, hasn't it? I was in Australia actually watching the elections in real time because over there, like the mornings over there is around the evenings here, right? And so the results were coming in while I was at my desk. It's pretty funny. So there's been so much discussion both about the elections, about other crazy stuff and nonsense happening. happening in the U.S. right now.
But the reason we wanted to briefly do a quick post-midterm elections breakdown is the decisions that are being made by those in Congress does impact the resources available to American scientists, from university grants to our national lab ecosystem. And some of the people that are now heading to Washington, given this was a wave election, meaning there's a variety of new people that are taking place of incumbents, uh and trying to take a look at their record for supporting the kind of research we talk a lot about on the show was going to be a fruitful exercise and it's also an opportunity just to kind of talk about how the work that we love and support actually gets done which requires money and funding so before we get to the the who uh
is going to now be headed to Washington, D.C. I want to briefly talk about what the midterms actually are. So Congress is the part of government that approves federal spending and passes laws. We have three branches of government. And within Congress, there are two chambers, the House of Representatives and the Senate. Sometimes these get mixed up when people say Congress and the Senate. Congress is both chambers, and it's the House and Senate. Every two years when those elections happen halfway through a four year presidential term, it's a midterm.
So all 435 voting seats in the House of Representatives are up for election every two years. Senators serve six year terms and those seats come up in three groups. So roughly a third were up for election in 2024. A different third just had their election in 2026 in the midterm. And then the remaining third will be up in 2028 alongside the next presidential election. And that's the good old pigeonhole principle, right?
If you've got 100 things – That six years, but every two years, so it's got to be a third. Very nice. So the members that were elected this November will be joining the 120th Congress in January. Yep. And... that's when the work will continue. And together, they'll make these decisions about federal spending and priorities for the next two years. And those spending decisions are going to matter for all the reasons we just discussed, particularly as it relates to what we're interested in, which is fundamental research, also known as basic research, which is fundamental.
Not very basic. This is work aimed at understanding how the world around us works, how cells function, how materials behave, how our stars form. The immediate goal is to gain knowledge even when we don't yet have a practical use for it. And in many cases, this can take years even just to do that, those fundamental steps. And this requires researchers, equipment, professionals. facilities, all of which requires funding. So this is the connection between why we want to talk about Congress as it relates to this show where we really focus on papers.
And the last note I want to make here is around the scale of federal funding as it relates to this basic research. According to the National Science Foundation's estimates in 2024, the federal government provided about 40% of the total funding for basic research in the U.S., more than any other That picture changes a little bit when you look at research and development as a whole, which includes the broader categories of applied research and which solves for practical problems and development work, which is actually translating it into the end products.
The private sector provides about 75 percent of the funding for that larger, broader category. And they do put some significant money into basic research. But the real sugar daddy for this is the federal government. And I know this is something in your own research that you're aware of and have experienced directly. 100%. I mean, when it comes to grants, the federal government, whether it's the NIH or the NSF, the DOD, these guys are the real bread providers of a lot of the basic fundamental research that we know and love that we cover on this show all the time.
All of this is what contributes to all the scientific and technological progress, particularly in the U.S. that we've seen. And the research, depending on this federal funding, means who these people are going in to make these decisions matters, especially because currently – There are ongoing battles around the scale of federal funding for basic research versus applied research, as well as the authorities on who gets to decide the mandates of the federal agencies, which have had historical ways in which the rules operated that are coming under challenge currently.
Yeah. We're going to sort of look at a few different ways to think about this issue. We're going to talk about the who first with some of these new members coming in. Then we're going to actually look briefly at what does Congress actually do as it relates to science funding and how does that process work? occur. So our first member we're going to discuss today is going to be Chris Pappas, a Democrat moving to the Senate for New Hampshire. He's a small business owner who's worked in his family's restaurant business and served in the House since 2019.
So he's making the transition from the House to the Senate. During that time, he supported specific funding requests for two Pappas joined a bipartisan group of House members to provide at least $10 billion to the National Science Foundation or the NSF for fiscal year 2022. The NSF specifically supports research across science and engineering, including work at universities where researchers are investigating some of these fundamental questions and training the next generation of scientists, which is a very important thing.
aspect, which in interviews we've done on the show is something that almost every interviewee has brought up in their own experience. And we've talked about in terms of your own lineage, as you went through your own undergrad and postdoc programs. Yep. Yeah. I mean, you know, it's not very much appreciated that in order to actually do the as well as have the equipment and buy the reagents and pay for the telescope and all that other kind of stuff, right?
It's not appreciated that you need to pay for the personnel. However little, grad students don't get paid a lot, but it still amounts to a lot when you consider the amount of research that needs to be done at the scale of the entire country. 100%. So that was the first thing he supported, Chris Pappas, in 2021. Then in 2024, he signed another congressional request, this time seeking $9 billion for NASA's Science Mission Directorate for fiscal year 2025. So that's part of NASA's responsibility for the scientific investigations of NASA.
Earth, the sun, and our solar system in the wider universe. And that specific funding request was associated with expanded funding for two space telescopes, Hubble and Chandra. Which the Hubble Space Telescope, as we can see here from this beautiful illustration, its goal is to observe visible light, ultraviolet light, and near-infrared light. And it's still going. And it's still going. Even though James Webb is up there doing its thing. The Hubble team at the Space Telescope Institute is still churning out papers.
Which is incredible. Yeah. And the other space telescope that was a part of this 2024 $9 billion appropriation was the Chandra X-ray Observatory. Detects X-rays allowing us to investigate extremely hot gases, the remains of exploded stars, and matter heating up around black water. The last piece from this bill was also the request supporting Dragonfly, which is going to be sent to Saturn's moon Titan. And so, again, this is making the connection between money directly to these end products.
So, you know, on the funding piece, Chris Pappas has a strong background, but he also – backed research legislation in his votes. In June 2021, he voted for both the National Science Foundation for the Future Act and the Department of Energy Science for the Future Act, supporting expansion of the research programs in these agencies. Our next up is Melissa Bean. A Democrat returning to the House from Illinois in February 2008, being joined a bipartisan group of Illinois representatives and submitting a statement to the House Budget Committee.
They were seeking support for the Department of Energy's Office of Science, which funds those major research facilities, including Fermilab and Argonne National Lab, both of which – Yes. Yeah, this is where the last two quarks were discovered.
The top quark, which is the most massive quark, was discovered in Fermilab. It's a legendary place that now is in dire needs of funding. I have some friends who work at Fermilab, and they were telling me that the funding constraints at Fermilab right now have gotten to the point where people need to take... mandatory time off and things like that. And it's kind of going under the radar, but like everybody in the particle physics community and the physics community at large knows that like this laboratory, which is kind of a bastion, like a temple of American physics is, is in dire need of funding.
In addition to the discovery of the last two quarks, research at Fermilab is widespread but also includes studying neutrinos and all of these fundamental particles that help scientists understand the underlying nature of reality, which has so many downstream implications. The other lab institution in Illinois that she supported was Argonne, which supports research across several fields. What's interesting is one of its major facilities is the advanced photon source, which produces powerful X-ray beams.
And they use them to study structures and properties of biological molecules as well as understanding how materials function. Yeah. In part of her work, she described – and this is literally what you were just talking about – the consequences of inadequate funding. Oh, yeah. There you go. At this time, back in the day, Fermilab had to place employees on furlough. This was over a decade ago. And so this is a recurring issue because funding and appropriations happen on an annual cycle. Sometimes it could be multi-year, but that's also –
it gets complicated. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And Argon was forced to reduce its operation capacity of the advanced photon source by 20 to 25%, which is not insignificant. So what this means is now this major scientific instrument that's given to researchers, you're decreasing the ability for science to access one of our great tools. And it's kind of a waste of money in the sense that like, You've already paid so much to make this thing, this X-ray photon source, right? And now when there's just a lot of downtime, it's like, you know, what are we doing?
So at that time, the delegation that Representative Bean was working with and leading, they asked to make room for at least $4.7 billion for the Office of Science in fiscal year 2009. That request also supported expanding and making that research program broader in both of those lab institutions. So she's another one who supported research legislation in her historical votes.
Another interesting thing in her resume was in December of 2010, she voted for the final House agreement on America Competes Reauthorization Act. This was authorized support for research and science education specifically, including funding levels for the NSF, the same Department of Energy Office of Science, and the National Institute of Standards and Technology, or NACA. Now, this was authorizing the increased funding, which is a separate request than actually appropriating the funding, which we'll talk about in an upcoming segment.
So she's returning with a strong history of support for some of these research institutions. Our next up in the list, Democrat entering the Senate from Texas. James Tallarico or yeah also known as uh Talafrico Talafrico which I don't know if it had the intended effect I like I like him I'm not gonna lie I like James Tallarico he's uh I've been following him for a while and uh this is a long time coming so part of a congratulations a new class of democrats in the south
One example of his support was for the Texas University Fund, which created a lasting source of funding for university research. So in May 2023, Tallarico voted for two measures behind that fund, and Texas voters approved the constitutional measure that November, which resulted in an endowment worth approximately $3.9 billion. Wow. About $3 billion was new funding combined with money from an existing research fund.
And an endowment works a little bit differently from a budget that gets spent in a single year. So the money invested in distributions can provide a variety of different financial support. Our next up of new members entering Congress after the midterms is Scott Weiner, a Democrat entering the House from the great state of California. He's an attorney who has served in the California State Senate and who worked on legislation that created a new source of state funding that was specific to,
for scientific research. The clearest example of this is Senate Bill 895, which Governor Newsom signed in September of 2026. And that legislation puts a $7.5 billion research bond before California voters in March of 2028. So now what's the difference between a research bond and the endowment that James Salarico put with the University of Texas system? So a bond allows the state to borrow money and then repay it over time rather than money already existing in a pool, whether it's through donations or through tax revenue, and then distributing it.
So in this case, the proposed borrowing incurring debt would support specifically scientific research across the UC system. So while this legislation has been signed, the $7.5 billion has not yet been approved. by the voters now we do have two republicans moving from the house to the senate that have also uh have specific examples of supporting research alongside votes against some of the legislation we discussed the first of the two is andy barr of kentucky who will be succeeding mitch mcconnell's senate seat which he's held for a very very long time and andy barr who's coming in
in terms of his history as it relates to supporting science, signed the April 2021 request for at least $10 billion for the NSF in fiscal year 2022. He also voted for both the NSF and Department of Energy research bills, but was opposed to the Chips and Science Act in 2022. Okay. Okay. The other Republican entering the Senate in this cycle is Julia Letlow of Louisiana, who has supported a specific university research project alongside her Senate colleague, Bill Cassidy, who's also a Republican.
She was the congressional requester for $3.5 million for semiconductor research and workforce development at Louisiana Tech that was included in fiscal year 2024 appropriations package. However, she has a mixed voting record historically where she voted for the Department of Energy Research Bill in 2021 but against the NSF bill as well as the CHIPS and Science Act. So a little bit of a mixed bag for both Republicans who are going to be making their way into the Senate.
So these are some of the people. that are going to be entering the new 120th Congress in January with some record of supporting science research either at the state and or the federal level. And so some of their past action can give us a sense of their priorities. Now let's look at what can they actually do in the House and Senate that shapes research funding for the work of scientific institutions.
Congress has three main jobs, authorization, appropriations, and oversight. First, authorization establishes what agencies and programs are supposed to do. They can initiate a research initiative, they can change an agency's responsibility, and they can set out funding levels for that work. But authorizing a funding level doesn't commit Congress to providing that money.
So you can authorize $10 billion for the NSF, but you still need to separately actually write the check. And these can happen in two separate steps. So that actual process of giving the money happens through appropriations. While the provided money, which is the provided money agencies can actually spend. So you have a use case, like I just mentioned, where you can authorize $10 billion for a research program and then only appropriate six or nothing at all. Wow.
And the Chips and Science Act gives us an example of that distinction. The law provided appropriations, actual money for the semiconductor industry, but only authorized the broader research expansion for the federal science programs. So when we hear that Congress – has authorized billions for research, we still need to ask how much money it actually has appropriated. For a university team for applying for an NSF grant, like we've talked about, those are decisions that help them understand what programs are available and how much research the agency can support, which then dictates the type of work that they do.
So what's interesting is Congress authorizes these agencies on what their mandate is, but they generally don't review an individual team's proposal. That happens through the agency with input from expert reviewers and program staff. Although there is currently an ongoing battle that is trying to change that paradigm that would then allow political appointees to have individual input and control over –
how a large bundle of money that's appropriated for an agency is individually granted to specific programs, which is a massive departure from how this has historically been done. Yeah, and I mean, before historically, the peer reviewers, which were other scientists and other experts in the field of whatever grant proposal was being deliberated on, they would have some kind of final say, right, on like, you know, because presumably the experts are the ones in charge and know what type of scientific question is worth the money and what is not.
And what you're saying here is that like in very recent times, within the last administration actually, so probably within the last two years. Yes, and especially this year in particular. Yeah. So this year in particular, just before the midterms, the Trump administration put out like a type of memo. Right. Which is how they wanted the White House Office of Management and Budget to change how they administered grant funding, among other things. Yeah. And this is what you mean by the contamination of political activities into fundamental science grants and funding.
And it also touches on the tension between the authorities of the legislative branch, Congress, who has the power of the purse, versus the executive branch, which is meant to faithfully execute the laws passed by Congress. And part of what the executive branch is trying to do is say we get to decide the national priorities of the country at any given time, which means that we as the administrators of the money should have more –
at the political level versus the agency level control over what happens, uh, which is in part, uh, overriding the constitutional authority of the Congress in appropriating the money that the, and what that money should be spent for in terms of the government responsibility. So there's a constitutional issue here and there's also just some operational day to day aspects of, of this battle, which is why the midterms, kind of mattered as it related to upcoming budget votes over the next two, four, six-year cycle.
And so we've talked about how Congress – two of the three aspects of how Congress wields that power, authorizations and appropriations. What are the federal agencies and their mandates? And here's the money for them to go do that job. Their third tool is oversight, which is then saying – looking at and examining how are these agencies executing on their mandate with the money that they were given to do that mandate this is something that people see all the time on tv which is these hearings as an example where they'll bring in leaders from different federal agencies federal agencies span well beyond the scientific agencies we've talked about this will be the pentagon this can be
different finance-related agencies. It's a massive labyrinth. But the focus here is so that members can ask, in the context of science research programs, why a research program has changed, how grants are being awarded, whether an agency is following the law. And that would then inform future upcoming legislation that might impact that agency. Now, that's for both the House and the Senate.
The Senate has also an additional role in deciding who leads these institutions. For positions that require Senate confirmation, which can be leaders of some of these federal agencies, the president nominates somebody and then senators decide whether to approve that appointment of who is going to be head of X agency. An example is the new gentleman at NASA who had gone through this process. So – These are the responsibilities that Congress operates alongside the executive branch.
And for supporting science for the members we talked about that will be joining, that can mean a variety of concrete things, right? Helping establish research programs, securing the funding for it, and then holding leadership accountable for how it operates – given the amount of new political influence that's happening in these agencies. So we've talked about the who. We've talked about the what. What can members of Congress do that impact basic science research? Now I just want to briefly touch on the how.
So how does this detailed work actually happen? Congress divides much of all these groupings of people into committees, which are smaller groups of members of the House or members of the Senate who focus on particular subjects. Within those committees of jurisdiction, there can also be subcommittees that take responsibility for even individuals. narrow areas. These groups examine proposals, hear from agency leaders, and work on the legislation before it gets to a full floor Senate or House vote, which is what's required for it to then become law.
So for science, it helps to distinguish the committees that shape research policy, because sometimes when people talk about the House or the Senate, they're the image can just be, oh, it's, you know, 100 or 400 plus people all in a room arguing about anything and anything at any given time. And it's a little bit more narrow than that. So in the house, the Science, Space, and Technology Committee has the responsibility for civilian research. That includes the NSF, NASA, and the National Institute of Standards and Technology, NIST, which NIST works on measurement and standards for all bunch of technology.
The committee... also covers Department of Energy research and laboratories. In the Senate, those responsibilities are divided differently. The Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee covers agencies including the NSF, NASA, and NIST. The Energy and Natural Resource Committee has responsibilities involving the Department of Energy, Science, and National Laboratories. These committees can work on all of these research programs and how these agencies carry them out.
Now, that's on some of the authorization aspects. For appropriations, the funding bills go through appropriations committees. And there's an appropriations committee in both the House and the Senate, each of which are divided into subcommittees covering different parts of federal spending. And so these appropriations committees, they're the ones that actually decide where the money is going. When you say secure the bag, you want someone on an appropriations committee. Okay. So like the appropriations committee is like one of the most important and powerful committees.
And it's a highly lucrative position to want to be in. You want to be on the appropriations committee. Yeah. That's absolutely right. In both chambers, funding for NSF, NASA, and NIST go through the Commerce, Justice, Science, and Related Agencies subcommittee. Department of Energy science funding goes through the Energy and Water Development subcommittee. So for an agency like the NSF, there are multiple groups that have a role on all of these aspects for this.
So this is why when you hear these ongoing battles about party leadership or committee leadership, each party will have, if it's the party with the majority, the majority leader or ranking member, and then you'll have the minority leader who drive... the priorities and the process for what gets discussed at that first stage before we get to a full floor vote.
So those leadership positions in these committees and subcommittees are a big driver for what gets oxygen when it comes to ultimately the decisions around authorization and appropriations happening. members in the House and senators change the dynamics of the discussions that are happening in these committees as it relates to where does the future of basic applied and development science go in terms of congressional priorities, especially when we have huge financial tensions in the U.S. right now that,
and the American people are personally feeling. That's right. There's issues around how corporations, which are also drivers of research and development funding, are spending money and that wanting to be a priority for the American public. And so our science research appropriations in what is potentially the beginning of an era of austerity, are they going to be able to get oxygen with so many other competing issues? Yeah, I think that's... You bring up a good point.
It is... It's not trivial that just because we have Democrats in charge, science funding is going to go up. And so... science is a bipartisan effort. Historically. Historically. But what that means is it's bipartisan support and also bipartisan not support. I don't know what the word is. For example, Ronald Reagan was the one who tried to fund the superconducting supercollider in Texas.
Bill Clinton, a Democrat, is the one who stopped the funding. Right? And sure, you could say that's 30, 40 years ago. Well, you know, the nuance is still there. And it's going to come down to, like, what are the priorities, as you said? I mean, a big thing that's out there right now is health care for all, which is, I think, a great thing. But, like, at the same time, does health care for all also mean heightened funding for fundamental science that will make health care cheaper and better in the future?
Right. That's not so trivial. And it's a little bit nuanced because if you're going to look at this sort of Medicare for all, health care for all, Trump care for all, whatever you're looking for, a big part of that conversation is we don't have the money to pay for it. We're not going to litigate that argument because I think there's. Yeah, yeah. That's not for this podcast. But I think your point is important, which is. Part of what funding the basic research in science could do is actually lower the cost. Yeah. But that's not going to be a part of the discussion.
If I were a betting man. Exactly. It's not going to be how it's viewed. Yeah. Because it's already viewed as such an expensive thing to accomplish. And so there are real nuances here. And so as we go into... season three next year, one of the things I'm looking forward to doing, building on the work that we've been able to get educated on and implement from a triple AS is funding historical data sets and tracking, which you can check out on our website at FFP.com is more closely looking at the legislative and appropriations process, because we know many of you as listeners are working,
researchers are postdocs and are being impacted by the yo-yo nature of this process. And it's a little bit, it's not as covered on other major networks in terms of what's actually happening. So, you know, hopefully we can provide some more clarity there as we move forward. And this was a good starting point to create a baseline of what is actually happening and what are we talking about? And the midterm craziness gave us an opportunity to talk some policy from
So with that, we are going to take a quick, quick shill break because we got to keep the lights on on the pod. So for those of you joining us for the first time, welcome to the best science show on the planet. The two of us here run this as a love letter to the research community. The best way you can support the show is with a like, share, a comment, bring it to Journal Club. If you are listening to the podcast, a five-star on Spotify or Apple is greatly helpful in us reaching more people.
For those of you who are Apple podcast listeners, congratulations. You now have video. After months of back and forth, video is now available online. on any podcast platform that enables it, including Apple Podcasts. We did see some transition issues for our Spotify listeners for a few hours in the day we made the transition over. So if you are a Spotify listener, videos are available in back, and it's one of the best ways to watch the show because as we will see in our upcoming deep dive podcast,
We like to look at figures and visualize some of these deeply complex topics. And with that, we are going to transition into our deep dive for today, which is going to be about a controversial research paper on the cover of Science about how birds use their livers to navigate while flying. So I first encountered this story because it was on the cover of Science, the journal Science, in May 2026.
And it piqued my interest because the headline is there on the cover. It's very weird. It says, liver macrophages guide pigeons on cloudy days. That's really weird already because first, why are these birds using their liver to navigate, right? Navigation means sensory stuff. Like you got to like look where you're going and figure out where you're going. That means the senses, which is usually in the head for birds and mammals and things like that. And also it's a brain thing, okay? The liver is nowhere in the calculation for me when people say sensory mechanisms.
Yeah. The other, when you look at the story in great detail, you go into the story and the authors are claiming that the liver in these pigeons is sensitive to the Earth's magnetic field. Wow. That's not on the cover. Wow. Okay? But the magnetic field part is there on the Max Planck website, the Max Planck Institute for Animal Behavior. Wow. And that is absolutely wild. Yeah. Why is the liver sensitive to a magnetic field and it can sense the Earth's magnetic field, which is an extremely weak magnetic field, by the way.
And, I mean, I had heard about magnetoreception before, which is the idea of animals being receptive to the Earth's magnetic field and using that to navigate, but not in the liver. That's weird. The story came out in May, and I was tempted to do a whole episode on it right when it came out in May. I mean, it was on the cover of Science and everything. It was all over the news. And at the same time, my skepticism was also triggered because I was like... I hadn't even read the paper, but I'm like, the liver and the Earth's magnetic field, there's a lot going on.
I don't know enough about this, but I know enough to be like, I'm going to wait it out. I don't believe you. I don't, yeah. It's like, maybe, yeah, like... I'm going to wait it out and see what people say. And Science is also one of these journals that doesn't publish peer review, right? So I can't like – like in Nature, I can't like go in and see all the – The back and forth. All the back and forth between the reviewers to see what happened. Right. So I really wanted to give it some more time. And the wider community delivered because since its publication, there has been a lot of press.
And there has also been a lot of clapbacks from other scientists in the field. So I'm glad I waited. We love a clapback. Yeah, there's been a lot. In this segment, I want to talk about this story in some detail because, first of all, Magneto Reception – is amazing, right? The idea that you can even sense the Earth's magnetic field reliably is kind of crazy. And second, it's a great reminder of how dynamic cutting-edge science is. We've done stories like this in the past. The favorite one is probably the
hexagonal diamond story where you had this back and forth you had all of this lore of people saying it's not possible then someone's actually made it all of the back and forth between the reviewers to actually get it right in this case we don't have reviewers but we do have rebuttals um so it's it's going to be kind of a wild ride so first let's go over some history as always this actually dates back to the time of ancient egypt and greece This is, you know, usually when we say let's go through some history, it's like the past 200 years.
Now we're going like 4,000 years, okay? Going in the way back, Michelle. Way back, the Epic of Gilgamesh. This is the great Sumerian epic, the first like big work of fiction that humanity is known for. The Epic of Gilgamesh. It's a story that involves a great flood. And during that, there's a dove that is used to see if the flood is over. So the dove would like go out. and scout it out and then come back to the boat or whatever. This is the same motif that is then used later on in the story of Noah in the Bible, where the story goes that Noah sent out a pigeon to check if the flood was over, and when the pigeon came back with a branch of an olive tree, Noah knew that the floodwaters were residing and he could post up somewhere.
Pigeons then became used for navigation because it turns out, you know, they can go out and come back to their home. So ancient Rome in its heyday had something like 5,000 pigeons. The ancient Greeks actually used carrier pigeons to release the results of the Olympic Games back in the day and send messages during battle. And obviously you also have Hannibal and Chinggis Khan. These guys all used pigeons to... relay messages from one to another you know who else used pigeons who uh pigeon man from hey arnold the classic nickelodeon cartoon dude who was the man who had all the pigeons uh you know and arnold befriended and it was complicated but it just made me think of you know me with my classic 90s references that's a good one pigeon man along with genghis khan and hannibal yeah users of pigeons for uh communication and navigation
Exactly. All the way into the modern era, in fact. World War I, homing pigeons were used extensively in battle because they were so reliable. And this is before the two-way radios and the long-distance sort of radio frequency communication of World War II. But back then, the homing pigeons were so reliable because they had this uncanny ability to fly back from unknown territory. They were carried in tanks, in ships, in seaplanes. They were pretty ubiquitous.
And what was miraculous was you could displace them hundreds of kilometers into unfamiliar territory, and they would find their way back. Okay? How did they even do this? I'm very curious. It's really quite strange and quite miraculous, right? Now, from all of the research that we've done, we definitely know that it's multisensory, right? It involves visual landmarks, probably some type of smell, like olfactory maps. But also, they can do this in windy days.
So the olfaction kind of goes away. There's no smell on windy days because you don't know where the smell is coming from. And they can do it on cloudy days, so they can't tell where the sun is. At that point, they probably use the magnetic field of the Earth. This is called magnetoreception, and it serves as a kind of sixth sense. It's the same way that, you know, Boy Scouts use the compass to tell which way is north. And then from there, maybe you can tell on a map where you need to head to.
The central biology mystery here is there's a widespread consensus, right, that migratory species sense the Earth's magnetic field. Fine. But how? How does that actually happen, right? House way. Yeah, like, what is the anatomical location? And what is the biophysical mechanism? There's some biology happening, but it's clearly also a giant physics problem in some sense because you're trying to sense a magnetic field that is extremely tiny.
And that is where this latest paper sort of fits in. Okay? So there's a rich scientific history about just investigating magnetoreception in the first place. And it's going to be important because a lot of these players are going to come in Okay, so it's important to understand how we even got to this spot. The modern scientific hunt for the biological compass, probably you'll say it begins in the 1960s and the 1970s with behavioral biologists William Keaton and Charles Walcott.
These guys from the University of Frankfurt, they published this paper and it establishes that these birds are indeed using the magnetic field. So this is the paper that shows once and for all, definitely, they are using the magnetic field. It's not showing how, but it's saying certainly it is. Here's the experiment that they do. They design a tiny battery-operated Helmholtz coil, which is just like two tiny solenoids. And these solenoids have parallel wire loops that can create a nearly uniform magnetic field in between them.
And you can strap this to the heads of pigeons... and give them a fake magnetic field, right? You can, back then in 1960s and 70s, battery technology was just good enough where you could power this thing, have it kind of remote on a pigeon, and then have the pigeon fly, turn it on and off wirelessly. And you can see how that affects navigation. That's clever. Right? And the result was pretty stark. When they released these coil-wearing pigeons on sunny days, the birds flew home perfectly, whether this thing was on or off.
On cloudy days, if it was off, they would fly home perfectly. But if it was on, that fake magnetic field would overpower the Earth's magnetic field, and they would just, like, start scattering around randomly, right? So this is the dual navigation paradigm that is established in this paper. It means that, you know... Birds use the sun when they can see it, but when they can't see it, they switch to these specialized backup magnetic compasses that they have somewhere in their body.
That's such a good setup because it immediately establishes this contact. It's a beautiful, simple experiment, right? Very, very well done. Yeah, because it's like, I mean, the thing being on or off, that doesn't change the mass of the apparatus, right? So you can't say like, oh, when it's on, like it's heavier. It's really not, right? You're just... cycling current through the thing on sunny days it doesn't matter if it's on or off it's only on cloudy days that it matters if it's on or off and if it's on the local magnetic field is just messing with the global magnetic field and intuitively very simply you can see that okay this yeah this makes sense yeah exactly and you know there are challenges in studying now the question being what's going on yes where is it right right
With magnetoreception, you're trying to sense the Earth's magnetic field. This is a sense that is very different from the other senses. For example, with light. Light does not go through my body. I need a specialized sensor like my eye that is mostly transparent, right? Because then the photons can go through. They'll go through my eye. They'll go through the... the, you know, the jello in between my lens and the retina. And clearly the retina has some photoreceptors that will sense the photons.
But I don't have eyes all over my body. That would be a little weird. That would be a little weird because, well, it would also be useless because none of the photons would like get through. There's no eyes inside my body because it's dark inside my body, right? The eyes sort of stop at my skin or the photons stop at my skin, right? Similarly to Again, the skin is like a high impedance sound barrier. If I'm talking into my hand and I put a microphone at the center of my hand, you're going to get very muffled noise because the sound is going to hit the skin.
It's going to hit the bone. It's going to hit all this sort of stuff and get bent and get diminished. That's why our ear canal is just a giant hole that funnels the sound in into an eardrum that is sort of our sensor. Part of the point you're bringing up here is we have specialized tools to receive the type of signal that can actually make it functional. Yeah. And it's like kind of obvious where it is. Yeah. Because of the physics of the thing you are trying to sense. That makes sense. The magnetic field is different because the magnetic field penetrates.
Okay? You put a magnetometer inside... And it will sense the Earth's magnetic field just as well as if you put a magnetometer on the surface of my skin. You see what I'm saying? Yes. So the organ to sense the magnetic field could be literally anywhere. Which is uniquely different than photons and sound for the reasons we just discussed. Exactly, right? The physics is different, which means that like in some sense you have a bit more freedom in putting the organ wherever you kind of want. It could be anywhere. Right? Which is kind of the idea here where it's like, oh, it could be in the liver.
Well, maybe. Yeah, it could be. Maybe. Yeah. So let's see. What are the hypotheses before we get to the liver? Yeah. Right? Yes. What are the big hypotheses? The first one that people came up with is kind of a nice classical explanation. They said, okay, look at a compass, right? A compass responds to the aggregate magnetic field by just like there's like a torque on the thing because like it's There's a tiny magnet on the compass itself, and that magnet wants to align with the Earth's magnetic field. So you get a little torque, and the compass begins to align with whatever the magnetic field lines are over there.
So what if you had something like a compass in these animals? You had a little... thingy that was tiny bit magnetic and it would start rotating with the Earth's magnetic field and it would cause these forces and if I could sense those forces then I could sense which way the magnetic field is. And that's the first hypothesis. It's called a magnetite hypothesis. Now, it was known that there were certain bacteria that navigate using chains of magnetite, which is basically iron, oxygen, iron, oxygen.
The iron is the thing that is ferromagnetic. And so that thing is, you know, it's naturally occurring as a ferromagnetic mineral. And the logic is that, like, if the bacteria can do it, right, then surely birds can do it, right? Birds are a higher evolved form. So it kind of makes sense. And the bacteria, in this sense, they're not actually sensing the magnetic field. What they're doing is using these crystals that move around and exert forces.
They sense those forces to tell which way the magnetic field is, right? So it's a kind of indirect sensor in some sense. But at the same time, I mean, they are, in fact, just like straight up, they know which way the magnetic field is by looking at this thing, right? Now, anatomical studies reported... finding bilateral patches of magnetite-rich nerve endings in the upper beak of birds. Okay? So this is the paper that came out, and it showed that it works in total darkness, right?
You can have these anatomical receptors. You can have these magnetite patches on your beak, and... And then if you orient with the magnetic field, you're going to feel a little tingle. And if you orient perpendicular to the magnetic field, you're going to feel an opposite type of tingle. Right? That feels very reasonable. Feels right. Yeah, it feels right. It's nice. It's classical. The location on the beak too, it's like, you know, it's... Yeah, it's where the sort of distance to the brain where it's processing and it's where they're going.
It seems sensory, right? It's like, yeah, all of our stuff's around here. It's like it makes sense, right? And it's kind of an intuitive model for a physicist. It's the same thing as a compass. You have a compass on your beak and you just like sort of orient this way and figure out which way it is. And it's widely accepted. Okay. Until 2012. Ooh. 2012, it's always a nature paper. In this case, it's a letter from nature. Okay. This is by David Keyes. He publishes this particular paper.
Great name. Look at the end. The clusters of iron-rich cells in the upper beak of pigeons are macrophages, not magnetosensitive neurons. Okay? Just straight up, not what you thought it was. Okay. Okay? Macrophages are these, you know, they're parts of the immune system that are kind of like the trash collectors of the immune system. They're the Pac-Man cells that just, like, eat up debris and all sorts of stuff. And what they found kind of shattered the consensus because what they found was that the same...
beak strips of magnetite material that was previously thought to be these neurons that would sense the magnetic field. No, it turns out it was just these particular immune cells. The reason why they are magnetically sensitive is because they have a lot of iron. But the reason why they have a lot of iron is because that's kind of the job of a macrophage. You eat up all of the dead red blood cells. Red blood cells don't actually live all that long because red blood cells don't have nuclei, right? The cell nucleus is gone as they squeeze out of the bone marrow.
And so they only last for, like, I think for human beings it's on the order of, like, months, maybe even less. Once those red blood cells die, they have a bunch of hemoglobin in them, which is a lot of iron. These macrophages, when they eat that, they're going to accumulate a bunch of iron. And so, yeah. It's so good because this is why I love science. The clapbacks are so – you can't debate that. Yeah, yeah. And I mean he shows with multiple staining techniques that these iron-rich deposits are macrophages.
They're not neurons. So the immune system becoming a sensory thing – Harder leap than the initial construction, which was clean and felt easy. Yeah, exactly. And at the time, you know, neurobiologists considered these macrophages to just be the immune system's garbage trucks. They're incapable of the kind of rapid, organized sensory signaling to the brain that is required to sense things and navigate with that sensation. Right? We're going to come back to this because if you remember the title of this paper that we are referring to is about macrophages.
Right? So it is kind of a nice like full circle that are we coming back to macrophages being important? It was a clap back, but it might be a clap back back, but stay tuned. But stay tuned. Let's see. So clearly the magnetite hypothesis is not really going to work, right? They're in fact macrophages. They're not neurons. Classical mechanics and classical electrodynamics might not be everything. Okay. So what do you do? You invoke quantum. The quantum. Yeah, yeah.
So they went marvel with this. Okay. And the original idea was actually proposed in 1978 by a physicist, Klaus Schulten. The idea is to use radical pair quantum mechanism. We're going to target a specific protein that is found in the eye, in the retina of these birds. It's called cryptochrome 4A. Here's how it actually works. So you've got this protein, Cryptochrome 4A, and it's going to house a molecule called FAD, which is Flavin Adenine Dinucleotide.
This is a ubiquitous molecule that is found all over cellular metabolism. It's part of the cellular respiration cycle and the mitochondria, all sorts of stuff. It's found everywhere. It's kind of like an analog of ATP in some sense because it can store energy and then give it back and things like that. Here's what's going to happen. A blue light photon is going to enter the bird's eye and it is going to excite an electron in this FAD cofactor, this light-absorbing cofactor.
This photon strike is going to initiate a cascade of electron transfers. The electron is going to move around, and the process is going to result in a radical pair, which is two molecules, the FADH+, and the O2 molecule. Okay. Those two are going to each possess a single unpaired electron that's going to be separated by some physical difference. It's going to be separated by some physical distance because these are two separate molecules, obviously. But here's the thing.
They're bound by a shared origin. That's interesting. Right? Yeah. We have seen this before. In our quantum mechanics discussions, this is an entangled pair of particles. Which is so... But it's super radical. Yeah, it's radical in the sense that these are like radical pairs in chemistry is what they call it. But in this case, the idea is if I can make the entanglement live on for a while, I can use that to then sense the magnetic field. That is the idea. And so here's what's happening. These two electrons, they're created simultaneously from the same chemical bond.
This is good. And now their quantum spins are entangled. Yeah. You've got your Alice and Bob experiment again. But instead of like two people with little polarizing filters, your Alice and Bob are two molecules that each have an electron. They can exist in two distinct states. They can exist in the singlet state or the triplet state. Calling back to our quantum computing episode, where the singlet and the triplet were the 0 and the 1 of the qubit. In this case, the singlet and the triplet are these two states
Of the two electrons that are inside this cryptochrome 4 protein. This was in 1978? He had devised it in his head, right? Okay. And he said that this could be possible. That's quite nice. It's quite nice. I mean, singlets and triplets had been known for a while. And at the time, cryptochrome had just come out. And people had just started understanding the chemical reactions, right? I see. there's a chance that this could happen. Because what ends up happening is the singlets and the triplets have different angular momenta, right?
Because one of them, they're anti-parallel. The other one, they're parallel. So because of these different angular momentum, they're going to interact with the aggregate magnetic field in a different way. 100%. And... When they finally create some kind of signal cascade at the end, because at the end of the day, the whole thing has to like collapse in some sense. Like there's some other protein that is using the state of these singlet-triplet pairs to then create some kind of downstream... signaling cascade that then goes to the brain to mimic what it means to see something that's that's what vision is photons coming in a signaling cascade going to the brain that's telling us you know there's some light over there if all of that happens and there's a difference between how the singlet creates a signaling cascade and the triplet then all of a sudden you have a mechanism to see literally see
the magnetic field of the earth. Isn't that something? The intermediate state ultimately downstream collapses to a zero or one, which then functionally becomes the way in which you can see the magnetic field because of this sort of almost indirect effect. detection. Yeah. Because you're not detecting the magnetic field. No, you're detecting the singlet versus triplet. Which is impacted by its interaction with the magnetic field. Exactly. It's great. That's great. That's great, right? And there's actually a simulation of what the bird's retina would see if they actually...
Like, you know, went through it. And this is 40. Yeah, there you go. So this is a simulation of what the bird would, like, be looking at. Yeah. Right? And if it's heading in the north direction, then it would see a characteristic sort of symmetric arc of neural activation. Right? The white there is not necessarily light. It's some sensation that the bird is getting that those are the neurons that are activated. Right? And as the bird turns west or east, the pattern of neurons that are firing in the retina are going to change.
And so it's literally seeing the magnetic field of the earth. Right. And the bird's ability to recognize when I need to go home and what I'm getting in my neural signaling looks like the image of east, I make it home. Yeah. So it's not east to a bird, but it's this white band of... Which is so... Yeah. And perhaps it has learned that this pattern means north. Yeah, exactly. Because it knows that like it's noticed that every time the sun rises, the pattern is always this way.
You know what I mean? Like there could be innate learning that happens. Yep. That correlates this signal to the signal of direction. But you need to sense the signal in the first place. We're first – before we get anywhere else, we first need to be able to say I can detect the magnetic field. Yeah. And this is the mechanism to do so and then get some output. Then with that, there's a whole variety of other things. Exactly. Exactly. Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so this kind of makes sense. Yeah, yeah. And because there's a mechanism to it. And people have done experiments, which I'm not going to show here, but one of the experiments I'll just tell you is like they had like a radio frequency antenna that would mess with the singlet-triplet splitting, okay?
And they put birds in a wooden box. And when they put this antenna up, that would mess with their... Yep. Because the radio frequency itself is messing with the singlet-triplet oscillations that are then leading to this sensation of north versus south. It's a similar concept from the first experiment we talked about. Different methodology to interrupt the signal because the way in which it's absorbed is different. Yeah.
But the same idea of you just put a disturbance in the force. Yeah. to see does that impact their ability to navigate. Exactly. And one of the cool controls that they did at this time was, I told you that they're in a kind of wooden sort of cabin that these birds are interacting in, and they couldn't tell which way is north. Then the researchers put a Faraday cage around the cabin, and they grounded it. So now the magnetic field can go through, the Earth's giant magnetic field can go through, but radiofrequency pulses... get smeared out by the Faraday cage and they get grounded.
And all of a sudden now the birds could navigate again. Right? So it's pointing. It's pointing to this thing, but it's still not enough because we haven't, fully observed the singlet triplet splitting in these cryptochromes we haven't observed like that oscillation we haven't timed the thing it would be really nice if we could like just stick a cryptochrome here shine it with a blue light right like or even two photons um where the two photons add up to the energy of the blue light does that actually give you the same
kind of behavior. There's more stuff that you can do, right? So the jury is still out. And the other big problem with this CryptoChrome model is that... The limitation is you need blue light. You need a blue light photon to excite that radical pair. But birds can do this in darkness, in complete darkness. So how do you explain that? So how do you explain that, right? This could certainly be one of the mechanisms, and perhaps there are many. But we still haven't explained how bats have magnetoreception. They're straight up blind.
But they have magnetoreception, right? And to your point earlier, there's this idea that it might be a multisensory piece. So it's not saying that it has to be one monolithic individual thingy. Yeah. But there's still a little fuzziness here. Yeah, exactly. There's still room for more science to happen, right? Yeah. And the third one that I just want to briefly mention before we get into the liver macrophages of this episode, the third one is electromagnetic induction. This is by David Keyes. Again, same guy from— Back again.
Back again. He's back again. So the first thing he did was show that the magnetite materials won't work on the beak. The beak are just macrophages. And now he's back with his own little theory, okay? Okay. He's at the University of Munich in Vienna, and this theory relies on Faraday's law of induction. So this is, again, a classical mechanism, and it's inspired by aquatic animals because aquatic animals like eels and a lot of these things will literally shock you with an electric shock. They have organs. full of electricity.
Not the, you know, I mean, we can say we have electricity in our brain because of the neurons. No, this is like aggregate electricity that will like shock you, right? And that will like kill stuff that it can eat. So this clearly has, there's a lot of current going through. And by Faraday's law of induction, if you have a lot of current in a conductor and you move through a magnetic field, you will experience a force because current means that there's moving charges, moving charges to a magnetic field that will create a force. If you can sense that force, all of a sudden you can sense the magnetic field, right?
So in the similar fashion, Keyes' group postulated that probably the bird, as it flies and it moves its head around in the Earth's magnetic field, there are conductive biological fluids inside the loops of the inner ear that create a kind of Faraday coil, right? In the same sense that Michael Faraday was like, like moving a coil of wire and measuring a current, you could do that with the inner ear. That's interesting. And you could perhaps measure that Faraday effect and be sensitive.
And one of the modes of evidence that he used to support this was using light sheet microscopy to map brain activity In pigeons. And he showed that when you expose the pigeons to rotating magnetic fields, the vestibular nuclei, which is where the inner ear stuff comes into the brain, like the parts of the brain that are responding to the inner ear, they started responding to the rotating magnetic fields, right? So it's telling you that like the brain that lights up to the inner ear is lighting up to the rotating magnetic field, perhaps...
the rotating magnetic field is affecting the inner ear, which is causing this brain activity. Because we're seeing a reaction to the change of the external stimuli that's correlated, but not causation. Yeah, and this is all within the last decade. This is crazy. 2012 is when the magnetite hypothesis was disproven, and then people are after it. They sense blood in the water like the Navier Stokes. Yeah. I mean, this is a cool problem. This is very cool. People want to stake that claim and be like, I figured it out.
Because it's a big – it's like – it's so surprising. One of the reasons we go through history is because it's – the fact that we don't know this. Yeah. And it's like 3,000 – we've been using pigeons for 3,000 years. It's pretty crazy that we don't – Really know. Yeah. We know. Yeah. But like how, right? And so finally we get to the paper that we're going to talk about here, which is homing pigeon navigation relies on super paramagnetic macrophages under overcast conditions.
Paper out in science. And now we also understand why under overcast conditions. Matters. Matters. Yeah, exactly. We're going to get into what that super paramagnetic means. We know what macrophages mean. Yes. Let's try to understand that part, okay? The background here is this is an immunologist, an animal behaviorist. They merged iron-accumulating immune cell research with animal navigation tracking. Okay. So it's this multidisciplinary thing that's happening from the University of Vienna.
And a lot of the competitors are also European from continental Europe. They're all, it's like University of Munich, Frankfurt, Vienna. They're all, I bet they go to the same conferences. It's the Champions League of figuring out bird navigation. Yeah, exactly. It's so funny. So first step, let's just try to, these authors figured like, okay, let's just see where the magnetic response is happening in the blood. I'm sorry, in the bird. Okay. Okay. Like where in the body of these birds.
is a magnetically sensitive organ. Okay? Yeah. Kind of the same thing that they did with the beak, right? Where the beak had these magnetically sensitive parts. They're asking, is there anywhere else? One of the key results is they identified that the liver, in fact, has a lot of magnetically sensitive cells. Okay. Okay. Kind of makes sense because the macrophages there are doing the same thing. They're cleaning out the blood. Same thing we talked about in the beak. Same thing we talked about in the beak, right?
They also show this idea of super paramagnetism, which means that if they were to take the ferrous material that is in these macrophages, they were to distill it down, and then they were to ask, as I reduce the amount of temperature, can my magnetic material... remember which way is magnetic north. Okay. Okay? Let me talk about that in a little more detail. So, you know, like paperclips, they're not magnetic, but if I rub a paperclip with a magnet, it's going to become magnetic.
Classic grade school experiment. Yeah, yeah. But if you just leave it on the table after like 20 minutes, it's going to no longer become magnetic. In fact, if you heat it up with like a ray gun or something, put it out in the sun, it's going to take even less time to become magnetic. not magnetic. And that's because temperature has this effect of jiggling all of the atoms together. So even the tiny bits of iron that are in there that are aligned to create this magnetic field, because that's how magnetic fields happen, is like all of the iron atoms kind of align to create a gross magnetic field.
And so what you're doing with the paperclip and you're rubbing this magnet together is like the magnet is influencing the the atoms in the paperclip to align in some sense and create a gross magnetic field. But if you remove that external force, the temperature is going to make them jiggle and they're going to lose the memory of which way is magnetic north. But if you cool that thing down, The jiggling is going to go smaller and smaller, and it's going to jiggle less and less until the energy between adjacent spins that are aligned is going to be greater than the jiggling energy, right?
So at some low enough temperature, the jiggling is not enough to overcome the alignment energy of these atoms, right? Yes. And that's what they found here. That's called super paramagnetism, where below 12K, the thermal flipping freezes out. And you can actually get magnetic material at 12 Kelvin that... remembers sort of what it is. Okay? This is not an effect that they found anywhere else in any other kind of tissue.
The liver tissue had this. There was a finite threshold where it could actually stay magnetic. So I think what's interesting in comparing this back to the beak thing you talked about earlier is we've said that to detect the magnetic field, it is very weak. And so you need high sensitivity, something with high sensitivity. And with this... aspect of what's in the liver and its ability to maintain its alignment, even at low temperature, speak to this idea of the sensitivity piece? Or is it a different way to think about it? No, no, no.
So that's what the authors are arguing. Okay. The authors are arguing that in no other part of the body did we observe this super paramagnetic effect. The liver had enough of these magnetic ferrite materials to, in the macrophages and enough density of macrophages to actually create this aggregate effect where I can like now like remember which way the magnetic north is. But we are gonna come back to that because it begs the physics question, right? 12 Kelvin is awfully cold.
Right? So we are going to... That's actually one of the rebuttals that we're going to get to. Okay. It's a good point that you bring up. Okay, okay. Okay? So first we've established that the liver has a bunch of this magnetic material and it can remember the magnetic field in some sense, right? Now, if it's sensory, they're arguing that this thing is going to be involved somehow in sensory navigation, right? That means there needs to be a neuron involved because, look... You can say the liver senses the magnetic field, but the planning of where to fly to is happening in the brain.
Okay? That's a no-brainer in some sense. So we've got to get that signal from the liver to the brain somehow. So the next thing they said was how would that happen? And they did some anatomical mapping. This is a transmission electron microscope. And it's showing the macrophage in blue. And right next to it, do you see the little crescent there? That crescent is a neuron. It's stuck to that neuron. It's maybe two microns or less difference. Well, well, well.
Right? So it's right next to that neuron that's myelinated. Yes. That's taking signals to the brain. It's going to the vagus nerve, which is the nerve that goes down to the gut. And we already have a lot of literature that shows that the vagus nerve controls the brain in a very fundamental way, right? Like your gut health controls your brain health. Well, maybe this is a gut feeling that the birds have, right? Of like which way the... Did you write that in?
Yeah, I did. That was pretty good. I borrowed it from a news. It wasn't me. Anyways, but it's kind of good, right? Like, it's a gut feeling that is going to the brain, and that's telling the brain which way the magnetic field is pointing. So for that big missing gap, this is starting to get a little... Yeah, it's starting to get good. I mean, look, this thing was published in Science. You can't just... You've got to have... A good amount of evidence, right? But that one's okay. That one's a good one. We can communicate. Yeah, yeah.
We can get to the brain somehow. And the final one is really the one that got them into the journal itself and got them past peer review. The ultimate test for any sensory hypothesis is behavioral disruption, meaning you've got to mess with it somehow. And that has to mess with the downstream behavior. Yeah. Right? And you have to do this in a controlled way. The same way that the magnetic coils around the pigeon created this localized magnetic field that then messed with its navigation. Can we show the same thing, but this time now messing with the liver macrophages?
The gut feeling. Right? Yes, exactly. And the pharmacological tool they used was... Clodronate liposomes. So, clodronate liposomes act as a kind of Trojan horse, okay? They encapsulate this drug called clodronate. inside liposomes. Those liposomes are then eaten by macrophages, and the breakdown of that produces non-hydrolyzable ATP analogs, meaning ATP is like the cash currency of energy in our cell.
This is creating fake monopoly money in some sense. The cell gets really confused. It destroys the mitochondria, and it causes cell death. Sounds like the U.S. economy. Yeah, in some sense. If we just keep printing, that's how it goes. Being facetious. Being facetious. Clodronate kills macrophages. It doesn't kill other cell types. Which is good, right? Because now this is a way for us to kill the macrophages and see if this has some effect on the behavior.
Okay, here's what they do. They put an Internet of Things GPS tracking setup on 34 pigeons, and they track it over a 19-kilometer path that the pigeons have been trained to go back and forth in. Okay, so now let's see how these pigeons navigate with the control group, meaning the ones that don't have this macrophage-killing system. And the ones where we kill the macrophages, presumably we kill the magnetic sensing ability of these pigeons.
And presumably that's going to make their navigation worse. The first bit of evidence that I want to show. Wow. On the left-hand side is the control conditions in sunny weather. Yes. Okay. So these are pigeons where we've given them that drug. So the macrophages are dead. Wow. But because it's sunny, these pigeons can still navigate, right? Because of that dual hypothesis that we had talked about earlier, the first thing they do is just look for the sun.
And if they have the sun, they don't need to know where the magnetic field is, right? This is a key control because it actually shows you that killing the macrophages doesn't affect behavior in some sense, right? In a grand scheme. On the right-hand side, we've got overcast conditions. This is incredible. But now again... without the macrophages. And you can see a total disruption in their navigation ability. This is very in your face. Yeah. And another key control would be, well, what about overcast conditions, but with the magnetic sensing, right?
Right. Like, how big is the spread? Right. Because in this case, with what we're looking at here, we're saying overcast with no magnetoreception. Yes. But what about overcast with magnetoreception? Like, is it still that bad? No, it's not, right? On the left-hand side is the true control, which is overcast with... with magnetoreception, and it's almost identical to the right-hand side in the Sunny case. Yeah. Right? Right. Like, it's the... Sure, the Sunny case is a bit more just direct home. Accurate. But you can tell with the overcast conditions, and they have their macrophages intact, we're doing well.
Wow. Wow. Right? In the middle, it's complete random nonsense. We don't know where we're going. We don't know where we're going. Right? And so that is effectively the paper. They're showing that... These birds, they're healthy, they're motivated, they're fully capable of flight. That's what these controls are for. But specifically, they lack the backup magnetic compass that lets them navigate in these overcast conditions. And so these macrophage-depleted birds, they can't really navigate, as well as the ones that do have macrophages.
So that's the whole story. Liver macrophages, superparamagnetic, Overcast conditions. Okay. Right. That's the whole story. Makes total sense. Makes total sense. Pretty nice. I, as someone who's now going through the story for the first time, we went through the history. This feels pretty good. Feels pretty good. Cover of science. Look. A really nice cover, by the way. The cover looked good. Looked good, right?
Lots of wild press. It's in the Scientific American. It's in CBS News. Where are the haters? The haters came out quick. The rebuttals are swift, okay? I'm going to go through them one by one. There's really two big ones that I want to go through. The most devastating critique, I have to say, probably originates from a coalition of leading biophysicists, chemists, and sensory biologists. They publish a rebuttal on their website, and their argument is...
is not to dispute the biological data. They're not saying that the experiments are wrong. They're saying that it's probably physically impossible, that the mechanism that you are using attributing this effect to is really what the cause of it is. Now, before we get into the exact arguments here, I want to just linger on the authors, okay? Okay. These authors are legends of the field that we have talked about just previously. Yes. Keyes. He's the famous guy who...
did the myth-busting of the macrophage-related errors, right? He said that, well, the beaks are actually macrophages. So he's kind of seeing his own work come full circle and be like, well, the macrophages are actually the point. So clearly, you know, there's some personal, like, no, I was right that time. You're using my own argument against me, blah, blah, blah. He's also the guy who is behind the inner ear mechanism, right? Yeah. There's also PJ Horae and Henrik Moritzson.
These two are arguably the world's leading champions of the radical pair mechanism. Aha. Okay, so they've got skin in the game too because they think it's the thing in the retina with the quantum entanglement stuff. Right. They've gotten famous with that. Singlet and triplet flipping. Yeah, yeah. So, so, so they're the quantum guy. Yeah. They're the quantum guys. And so they're coming together and they're like, okay, all right, let's see what, let's see what's up. The enemy of my enemy is my friend. Yeah. Yeah. It's like the two of them have competing theories, but they're, they're teaming up just to take this person down.
This is so good. It's so funny, dude. So this is their contention. Their contention is that ferritin, which is the protein of... in these macrophages that is giving the ferritin like from ferrous like iron this is the protein that gives these macrophages the ability to actually sense the magnetic field It contains ferrihydrite, which is anti-ferromagnetic, and that has a very tiny magnetic moment. A magnetic moment being how well do I respond to an aggregate magnetic field?
What is the torque that I experience that rotates me into aligning to the magnetic field? It's extremely tiny, this magnetic moment. And so one can calculate how much effect... there would be force something that is about the size of the Earth's magnetic field, which is at the level of tens of microtesla. And if that energy, if the energy of that mechanism, is greater than the thermal energy involved in living tissue, especially birds, birds are warm-blooded animals, when you calculated it out, the magnetic interaction energy in Earth's field...
is 30 times smaller than the thermal noise at body temperature. Right. Right? These guys were talking about 12 Kelvin. The body is at 300 Kelvin. Right? This goes back to... So the jiggling that we're talking about... is way larger than any of these ferromagnetic materials in these proteins as they respond to the Earth's magnetic field. It's a pebble of sand on a beach, and we're saying that the pebble of sand is, you know, a driving...
detectable thing exactly you're not detecting a single pebble no no when there's like a breeze and there's ocean waves and all this other stuff right yeah coming through that that's the main argument and that's a it's a physics-based argument right at physiological temperatures 300 kelvin if your thing only aligns below 12k your magnetic poles are going to flip in nanoseconds, which is nanoseconds is not something that is biologically tenable. It's too fast. It's just too fast to sense something that only lives for that long.
If you've got microseconds, perhaps, perhaps there's ways to amplify that signal that only lasts for microseconds, but nanoseconds is quite small, especially in a world where you're living at 300 Kelvin and your jiggling is... extremely energetic right you're bumping into stuff all the time in a warm-blooded animal so that's the main argument that that these guys put forth i think it's a pretty good argument to be honest and that's exactly why that that's the one that i was thinking about when i was like yeah like birds 300 kelvin like i'm also it's the same reason why i'm also skeptical about the the radical pairs yeah thing yeah okay because the quantum entanglement lasting long enough in an
It just doesn't add up to me. Like there's like unless someone shows me maybe someone can show me a back of envelope calculation about how the lifetime of like this T2 star in some sense in quantum computing language is going to last long enough for like proteins in my in a bird's eye to like sense that I don't see it. Anyways, it's all about... In biophysics, the biggest conundrum is always temperature, right? And the jiggling of stuff. Everything's jiggling. Everything is, all the time. Now, the next preprint that I want to talk about that is the rebuttal is this.
It's the reanalysis of classical experiments. This is published by Charles Walcott and Joseph Kirschvinik. Walcott is the same guy... who did the Helmholtz coil on the pigeons. So this is one of the OGs. He's at Cornell right now. One of the OGs that sort of established this entire scientific discipline of birds can definitely sense magnetic fields, right?
Now, remember, in that experiment, the Helmholtz coil is attached to the bird's head, and that is what is causing this confusion because the bird can no longer sense the aggregate global magnetic field. So in this paper, these two authors, they go back to that paper and they have the notes, right, about like how, powerful the current was, what was the size of the current, and now you can just do some of Maxwell's equations and calculate what is the fringe field at the liver, right? And that's the next sort of figure that they have.
They're calculating if my coil is here... And the magnetic field is kind of leaking out because most of it's going to be confined to within the two coils. Right. But if some of it is leaking out, how powerful is the magnetic field at the liver, right? Their point being that we've shown that when we have this device here interrupting the bird's ability to detect the magnetic field, the leakage is not going to make it the distance to the liver, which is the thing you're saying is… is the navigation component. And so it can't, both of these things can't be true.
Yes, exactly. The liver is far enough away that the leakage isn't going to reach there. Of course. And it's only going to be like, it's only going to alter the magnetic field there by 1.4%. But the effect that you're seeing is massive. Right. So it can't be that. Yeah. So that doesn't explain my experiment from 1974. Right. Right. Right. Right? Bud. It's the same guy being like, no, I did this. I love this because, again, it's – He still cares.
These communities are kind of these players who, even as they are part of the old guard, the OGs, They still want to let the new people know, like, hold on, young fella. I did this 50 years ago. Like, relax. Yeah. It's because you got on that fancy cover. Yeah. Like, you know, oh, you can do liposomes now and, like, kill macrophages. Like, so what, right? So... They also attacked the liver hypothesis for being purely from a purely neurobiological perspective because they said, okay, like let's focus on how the brain would process spatial data, right?
In order for the brain to interpret the compass heading, the compass has to be sort of fixed. Like if I'm in a car… and my compass is attached to the dash cam, then as my car moves, the compass is going to move with it, and then I can know the heading of the car. These macrophages move around in our body all the time. They are literally, one of their jobs is to move around and look for trash to eat. If you're moving around as macrophages all the time, that means your compass is rotating all the time. How do you possibly have a reliable signal from these little tiny compasses that is going to the brain?
Because you're saying you have all these distributed compasses with different headings. And at a given time, they have different headings, right? And so you're going to then compress it to some aggregate thingy based on hundreds of that million, whatever. No, it doesn't work. Too much compute. Yeah, yeah, it doesn't work. It's too much compute and it's moving around too fast. Like the direction is going to be changing. How do you keep track of, oh, like is this macrophage now also telling the brain? I was here when I made that... measurement but now I'm here and I'm making this measurement and then the brain is somehow competent you know that's a bit much that's also a good one it's a bit much right so that is sort of where we're at and and all of these authors they provide alternative explanations because at the end of the day you still have to explain why the cloudy day of uh cloud cloudronate yeah uh
Yeah, cause a macrophage killing caused the navigation to just... Yeah. Because that's a thing. And it was very pronounced. Yes. And it happened. And none of these rebuttals are saying that that didn't happen. They're not doubting the biological data. Right? They're not doubting the biological data. They're simply doubting the mechanism. Yeah. So they have to propose some kind of alternate mechanism, right? Yeah. So... One of the things that they're talking about is the acute systemic anemia. And this, I think, is probably the best alternative explanation out of the two that they've proposed.
Here's the idea. You're wiping out iron-recycling macrophages, right? You're killing a bunch of immune cells. Now, what that does is force... tissue to iron scavenge because now there's no longer like the macrophages in your liver that are recycling iron. Now your body is going to be like, give me any iron anywhere in the body because I need it to recycle it to create more red blood cells. Well, there could be another center in the
is doing the magnetic sensing, perhaps not in the liver. Maybe it's closer to the brain. Maybe it solves all of these other problems. But because now you have put the body in an iron-starved situation, the body's like, you know what? I don't need the magnetic stuff right now. I need red blood cells. So I'm going to scavenge any iron that's out there. That actually feels... as someone who was born borderline anemic, like, yeah. It's an off-target effect in some sense, right?
And so that basically... Right, it's off-target effect. You've basically destroyed a key cleanup mechanism within the body that impacts other functions. Yeah. And you've not yet... Yeah, because you're killing macrophages. You've not yet, like, in aggregate in the liver, right? Like... Okay. And effectively, the second... The second... Alternative explanation is basically that, which is like you're depleting systemic macrophages. That's going to trigger inflammation. and pain and selectively impair maybe these high cognitive load navigation systems.
Both basically effectively different mechanisms. Same idea. The first one is a bit more specific and that like, okay, it's like the fact that like I've starved you of iron and now the body's just like, I just want anything that has iron, even if that's my magnetic sensing mechanism. Cause in the hierarchy of order, it's probably, it's maybe lower than others. Yeah, exactly. From a survival perspective. Yeah. Like I need hemoglobin more than I need to like, get home quickly right right yeah no this this was this is kind of cool this is the the hexagonal diamond yeah paper and this liver macrophage paper are competing for the two best yeah clapback uh stories we've covered yeah it's it's it's really cool i mean this is a this is a good
People are trying new things, and it was risky for this group to publish that liver macrophages are involved in navigation. They've clearly identified a very stark effect. And so I still think as a science paper, it is extremely important because this gives you a huge amount of information. As you go into this field, even the authors that are doing the rebuttal, right? They've learned a lot from reading this paper because they've learned that liver macrophages have this huge effect on navigation, which I don't think if you would have asked them before this paper, they wouldn't have bet their money that killing liver macrophages would have had this huge effect.
But it's clearly a thing, and now this gives you another clue into some of the underlying mechanisms. On the other hand, it's also a kind of word of warning that correlation does not imply causation. Right. In animal behavior studies, this is especially important and notoriously hard, right? The paper itself is a bit more tame than the press came out, right? Sure. I mean, obviously, if you look at the science cover, even in itself, the science cover does not say anything about magnetoreception.
The science cover simply says, and I can read it, the science cover simply says, liver macrophages guide pigeons on cloudy days. Nothing about magnetoreception. Yeah, that's right. That's true. Liver macrophages are involved in navigation somehow. Right. Or at least the lack of liver macrophages impacts navigation ability in a bad way. Right. Right. Right. So – It's interesting. Correlation does not involve causation.
I think you bring up a good point, which is part of the reason we literally do this show, which is to get underneath the headline, which usually is not accurately describing, not in the journals, but in the news and press coverage, accurately describing what's actually happened. This is really great, though, because I think one of the things when there's a lot of the back and forth and rebuttals, especially when we can see the peer review file, is – It really, again, it illustrates that this is not a black box in terms of when we make conclusions that get these splashy paper titles.
And this was – that paper that got the cover is still a huge deal. Yeah. And it's clever. The liver macrophages have neurons. Yeah. It's a gut feeling. Yeah. I like that. Yeah. It's kind of clever. I mean, they have the steps, right? But as with all of these mechanisms, whether it's the radical pair mechanism or this liver mechanism or the inner ear mechanism, right? It's all still up for grabs because no one has shown a clean chain of this chemical does this, which folds this protein, which causes this signal cascade, which then connects to this neuron, which then goes to the navigation system.
We have done that for the eye. We have done that for the ear. The magnetoreception is kind of this final frontier of sensation in birds. I want to ask an unrelated question, but in terms of how to think about this, when you talk about making the mechanistic connection for internal body stuff in this context, because obviously with the eyes and ears, there's sort of these external sensors that are kind of easy to see. One of the things we talked about with birds and the magnetic field is it could be inside the body.
When we talk through our optogenetic story and the mechanism, the trail and the mechanistic process by which we activate the ion channels and we can know when we have the green light, this is exactly what's happening. And we can show one, two, three, four, and it's not up for debate, which is why it got a Nobel Prize. We're not at the optogenetic level of… Not at all. Of tracing the process. No. And I'm sure that optogenetics could be used somehow.
Like, it could, for example... I'm just going to make up an experiment now. But it could, like, falsify this one. Oh, interesting. For example, you could put the light-sensitive... channels, channel rhodopsin, on these macrophages, right? And then, like, when the bird is navigating through, like, a lab setting where there's an aggregate magnetic field, turn on the macrophages or turn them off on demand. Does that, like, visibly change the way the bird navigates?
That could be one. The fact that with optogenetics, right, you can turn on and off on command lets you ask these causation questions. Right. I love making these, drawing these connections. This will be a good story to see. With our hexagonal diamond, there was follow-up that happened pretty quickly afterwards. Yeah, this one, the original authors haven't followed up since then, right? So they might be working on a clap app. This was in May. The rebuttals came out June, July. So perhaps they're doing the necessary steps.
They are not pulling a Kendrick with an immediate clapback. But they're maybe pulling a Drake with dropping an album a year later. Yeah. Yeah. Fantastic deep dive research story on this episode. Again, we've talked on... some of the midterm breakdown, how the science research ecosystem that does some of the work we talked about in our story to actually gets funded to answer these kinds of questions. Uh, another fantastic story. We have both of us back in studio now after some travel again, for those of you who have listened to the end, what should we have as our, uh, comment call to action for those who made it through another two hour epic?
Um, Give us some ideas for end of year episodes, because we're winding down. It's the holiday season. The holiday season. Yeah, give us some ideas for what you would like to see as the end of year approaches. We have one episode that we are currently working on right now. It is celebrating the life and science of the great immunologist, right? tonegawa who um was chasing his second nobel prize with optogenetics um he unfortunately passed this year and i made a brief comment about him in the nobel prize episode not knowing that he had passed away and then someone in the comments suggested and like told us and i was like whoa like it totally flew under the radar for me um and actually just in news in general yeah which was very strange to me because um tonegawa is someone that um
He's a legend, and you guys will see why. But other than that, if you guys have other episodes, let us know. Thank you again all for joining us. If you want to take a look at any of the papers we covered in our second story, all of the research papers we cover on the show are available at ffppod.com. If you want to get our show in a bite-sized way, you can always check us out on social at FFPpod. My name is Lester Nare. Joined as always.
by my co-host and our resident PhD, Krishna Chowdhury. We do have two more interviews from our Golden Goose Awards trip to DC coming up over the next couple of weeks as we roll into the holiday season as well. So we will see you all next week.
How can a weather satellite see Ramadan, Christmas and a blackout? Dr. Miguel Román joins Krishna Choudhary to explain NASA's Black Marble: nightly maps of the lights on Earth, from a single band on the VIIRS...
Can sound destroy a tumor without an incision? Dr. Zhen Xu joins Krishna Choudhary to explain histotripsy: focused ultrasound that creates tiny bubbles to mechanically break apart tissue, without relying on heat. From a...
What happens when AI moves beyond the chatbot and into the laboratory? From Claude-designed proteins that bind scorpion toxins to robots that assemble optics experiments, we examine what AI can do for science and what...
Can light restore aspects of sight? Can recalling a cold experience change an animal's metabolism? And what can ghost particles and mirror-image molecules tell us about the universe? Lester Nare and Krishna Choudhary...
Why does life favor one molecular mirror image? The 2026 Nobel Prize in Chemistry honors Henri B. Kagan and Kenso Soai for nonlinear effects and autocatalysis in asymmetric organic synthesis. Lester Nare and Krishna...