Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Formation with John Ortberg

Formation with John Ortberg artwork

009. Everything You Need to Know About the Next Generation ft. Kara Powell

Aug 5, 20261 hr 21 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

About the Guest Kara Powell leads the Fuller Youth Institute as its Executive Director, where for more than twenty years her team has tracked how young people are changing across three generational cohorts, from Millennials to Gen Z to Gen Alpha. She holds a PhD in Practical Theology and has helped shape some of the most widely used research on the next generation. AMA Opportunity Leave us a review for a chance to ask John a question on an upcoming episode. To enter, follow the podcast, leave your review, take a screenshot of it, and email it over with your question to editors@formationpodcast.com. One question per person, screenshot required. What This Conversation Explores What has mostly stayed the same about young people across two decades of research, and what's vastly different What Gen Alpha needs from adults, and how their faith formation is taking shape Whether the data points to a genuine revival among young people, or something more nuanced Screen time and what it’s doing to our kids Whether teens today take fewer risks than past generations What kind of intergenerational relationships Gen Alpha is actually looking for and how they’re a benefit to all How to have more formative conversations with the young people in your life (and the scripts to get you there) What it's like to study faith formation for a living, and how it has shaped Kara's own spiritual life Whether some of the anxiety adults feel about this generation is really about the adults' own viewpoints How Kara is being formed personally Resources Mentioned Fuller Youth Institute: fulleryouthinstitute.org/subscribe The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt Growing Young - Fuller Youth Institute Future Focused Church - Fuller Youth Institute Free Gen Alpha report - fulleryouthinstitute.org Like Dew Your Youth by Eugene Peterson Chap Clark - the 5-to-1 ratio Dallas Willard Dietrich Bonhoeffer - the "chief sinner" idea Dave Wang, Fuller Theological Seminary About Formation Formation is a podcast that explores the science and soul of spiritual formation. Each episode brings together the ancient wisdom of the contemplative tradition and the best of modern research. John Ortberg sits down with some of the most rigorous and honest thinkers working at the intersection of faith and human flourishing for extended, unhurried conversations about how we are being shaped. New episodes every other week, wherever you listen to podcasts. Connect with Formation formationpodcast.com @formationjohn Formation is produced by Become New, a community dedicated to helping you grow spiritually, one day at a time. Subscribe for daily teaching from John Ortberg at becomenew.com/subscribe. Would you do us a favor? Make sure you're following the podcast. (It helps the show reach more people.)

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00And so I pulled my little black Toyota into a parking spot, and I was like, God, what are you doing? And I felt like the Holy Spirit said to me, I've never heard God speak audibly, but I felt like the Holy Spirit said to me, I'm breaking your heart for the needs of young people.

SPEAKER_04Kara Powell is a researcher, an author, an academic leader.

SPEAKER_00We are just now doing a new research project on Gen Alpha. We've surveyed about 3,000 of them, and we've asked them, what do you most want in an adult you trust? And what do you most want in the faith community? And at the top of the list is we want.

SPEAKER_04I don't even know that I would have articulated this, but a part of what I'm feeling is I'm not cool.

SPEAKER_00For young people, warm is the new cool.

SPEAKER_04Where does that come from?

SPEAKER_00Overall, if you look at the data at trust, we are a country that is not trusting others. That's true across generations. Trusting institutions and religious institutions. Sadly, we've earned that lack of trust. But what if they're doing something wrong? I do that.

SPEAKER_04Really, what's behind judging wherever it comes from is a sense of superiority and a lack of humility.

SPEAKER_00We did a survey of 600 senior pastors. Some of the most depressing research that we've done.

SPEAKER_04Unfortunately, a lot of folks don't talk much about parenthood as a spiritual discipline.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I told my girls a week ago what I would most redo as a parent is I.

SPEAKER_04Anybody who's watching us right now, if we do a good job in this conversation, what will they carry away?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. You know, your intro was very kind, but I think what I really love to say about myself is I love young people and I'm passionate about young people. So what I would want folks to take away from this is to know how to listen without judgment to the young people they care about most. That's it.

SPEAKER_04Say that one more time.

SPEAKER_00How to listen without judgment to the young people they care about most.

SPEAKER_04So I I think in our conversation, Kara, uh, we will circle around that and unpack what does that look like? How do we do that? How do we know if we're doing it? Why does it matter so much in this moment? I actually want to start with I was thinking about this, um, your call.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Uh we work in kind of adjacent fields, and as a pastor, there's this thing called a call. Yeah. It plays out real differently with different people. I grew up in Baptist circles where I was supposed to have one experience I did not.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04And uh, but I thought I I'd love to hear because you occupy such a unique and interesting role. Yeah. What was it in your journey? Yeah. Did you wake up one morning knowing this is what I want to do? How how did that journey happen for you?

SPEAKER_00Well, definitely not waking up one morning and knowing what God was calling me to. It was a process. So in 11th grade, I ran for student body president and lost. And you're laughing, but it was traumatic for me.

SPEAKER_04I ran for student body president and lost also.

SPEAKER_00I lost even earlier than we're part of the club of people who have run for public office and then lost. And that's just, you know, publicly embarrassing.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But my youth pastor and his wife, I was very close to them. And my youth pastor said at that point, I think God's calling you to youth ministry. And my parents are both attorneys, and I had seen the good. Yeah, they met at law school. Wow. And I had seen the good that they had done as attorneys. So I thought, no, I'm going to go be an attorney and change the world that way.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_00But through a weird fluke in 12th grade, I ended up volunteering at our church to get credit from school. And, you know, the very first job I did.

SPEAKER_04Volunteered at church to get credit from academic credit.

SPEAKER_00Yes, I got I needed to pick up an elective and I was able to work this. So the first thing I did was clean the youth kitchen. Uh that was, I still remember those smells from the youth kitchen. And then I worked on uh the weekly bulletin, which we used to use copy machines and remember clip art books and white out and tape.

SPEAKER_04For people who don't know, bulletin was this like printed out thing at church that you would learn everything on. For some reason, churches call them a bulletin. I don't know what.

SPEAKER_00Yes, yes. And a copy machine is something that makes copies. We don't even use that all that much anymore. Um but uh and and I and in the process of spending more time at church, I did feel like, well, maybe God is calling me to youth ministry. A couple obstacles though. Number one, I had never seen a woman doing full-time youth ministry. I was in a denomination that was egalitarian, very pro-women, but I just never seen a woman doing it full-time. Well, God solved that problem because while at a youth ministry event, I met a youth pastor who, as I was washing my hands in the bathroom, said, Do you think God's calling you to youth ministry?

SPEAKER_00This stranger says, Do you think God's calling you to youth ministry? In the bathroom. In the bathroom. Yes. At Solana Beach Presbyterian Church in San Diego. Wow. Uh, because I grew up in San Diego. Okay.

SPEAKER_04So all of a sudden, here's where where a woman named Roberta Heston is was the lead pastor.

SPEAKER_00Exactly, exactly. Yeah, absolutely. So all of a sudden, God provided this woman, this full-time woman who I met with multiple times over the years. But then the last thing that was missing is I really wanted a sense that God was calling me to youth ministry. It wasn't just what I liked, it wasn't just what other people saw in me. Um, so I I I went to Stanford undergrad, and just last week, I was, because I was in the Bay Area, I was driving on El Camino Real, you know it, I do, uh, by the Stanford Shopping Center.

SPEAKER_00And what happened on October 11th, 1988, when I was a sophomore in college, is I was driving into the Stanford shopping mall to get a birthday gift for my mom, and all of a sudden I started crying. And I'm not someone who just bursts into tears for no reason, uh, especially not then, still not now. And so I pulled my little black Toyota into a parking spot and I was like, God, what are you doing? And I felt like the Holy Spirit said to me, I've never heard God speak audibly, but I felt like the Holy Spirit said to me, I'm breaking your heart for the needs of young people.

SPEAKER_04Not just I'm calling you to, I'm not sure.

SPEAKER_00No, I'm breaking your heart for the needs of young people. So I went up into the foothills and prayed for a couple more hours. And that night I went out to frozen yogurt with some friends from college and said, I think God called me to youth ministry. Wow. So my journey was really a process of youth pastor and his wife investing in me, meeting a woman, doing it, which was really key. And then finally, this you know, supernatural Holy Spirit moment. So yeah, I love telling that story, John. So thank you for asking me.

SPEAKER_04What's very striking to me as you tell that is that the word that would come is breaking your heart. Yeah. How did you understand that? That doesn't sound like, oh, goody, I get to have my heart broken.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_04Well how how did you how did you interpret that?

SPEAKER_00Well, uh, the passage that was really prominent, and as a mission and theology faculty member at Fuller Seminary, I should know the reference, but I'm a little loose here. I think it's uh Luke 9, 36, something like that, where Jesus had compassion because he saw the crowd were like sheep without a shepherd. Yes. And my understanding is that the Greek word there is like so moved, even internally and physically. And I was looking at that passage about that time, and that's kind of how it all connected for me.

SPEAKER_00That like how I feel about young people, it's visceral. And still today, you know, when I drive by a high school, when I drive by a college, I just want to stop and talk to young people. So I love young people and I love adults who work with young people, and I love talking about young people. So I well, how do we get to do that today?

SPEAKER_04So uh to talk with, be with, work with young people is one thing, yeah. But then uh part of where that's led for you is to research and to lead research, which is uh a little different thing than hands-on involvement connection. You are at the forefront of that as much as anybody that I know. How did that happen? From I want uh a heart for young people to I want to find out yeah what are the best minds, what is the best data, what is the best research, how did that shift happen?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I love education. And uh so I got my MDiv and I got my PhD in practical theology and I was teaching full time at Azusek Pacific University in Los Angeles.

SPEAKER_04I don't think I knew you taught anything.

SPEAKER_00I did, I did. That's where I that was my first academic role. Yeah. And then Fuller was getting ready to start this new research center that was gonna listen to the needs of the church and the world and then do research to respond to those needs and then translate that research into practical resources, which A is basically the practical theology methodology that I'd been studying in my PhD program. And B, I thought, oh my gosh, you know, this center is gonna stand with one foot in the life of real life, young people, families, churches, and one foot in the world of world-class research.

SPEAKER_00Like that's where I want to stand.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So a friend of mine who was a faculty member on at the time said, like, Kara, I think you should apply for this role. And that was like 22 years ago. Um, so and I I just love the idea of listening to what the church and world need, doing really good research, and then turning that research into a practical tool. Wow.

SPEAKER_04So wow, perfect fit.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I yeah, I kind of think so. So yeah, thank you.

SPEAKER_04I want to come back to your initial statement. If there's one thing that you'd want anybody who's listening to you to come away with, yeah, it is that young people want to be listened to, they want to be understood, but without being judged. Where does that come from? Why is that so important?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I think developmentally, you know, this is not the first generation of teenagers and young adults to feel that way, to want to be listened to. But I think we as adults, uh, we've been especially critical of young people now and in the recent past. You know, there was a lot of criticism about Gen Z, millennials, you know, how lazy entitled they were, etc. So I think young people feel like adults and even the church has been finger pointing at them.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, they want adults who are not going to judge them but journey with them.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And we are just now doing a new research project on Gen Alpha. So, you know, after Gen Z comes Gen Alpha, which we're defining as those born 2010 and later. So think 16-year-olds and younger. And we've surveyed about 3,000 of them and we've asked them what do you most want in an adult you trust? And what do you most want in the faith community? And at the top of the list is we want adults who will listen without judging. We want adults who are a safe place for us.

SPEAKER_00So I think young people feel so judged in so many other spheres that they're just hungry for that uh in general. And what a great opportunity for the church. I mean, we have the chance to, I would say, earn back young people's trust by how we listen to them.

SPEAKER_04And uh I'm thinking about that topic of sensitivity to being judged.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Um is there something around um being young and generational differences that feeds into that? Or is that just a reflection of the fact that as sinful people we are so judgmental and people in power can be most judgmental and people who are young don't have it?

SPEAKER_00Uh yes and yes. I mean, I I think it's it's everything that you've just said, but I think as the pace of change and cultural change accelerates, yeah, it gets harder for us as adults to keep up with youth culture, which I think makes us even more makes me more prone to be judgmental because I don't understand it. It feels even more foreign, even more distant for me.

SPEAKER_04Well, and I wonder, even too, because I'm older than you, and part of what I'm aware of, I was talking with our team yesterday about stuff that they're watching, and I'm not watching what they're watching. Yeah. And so I don't even know that I would have articulated this or at the time, but a part of what I'm feeling is I'm not cool. Yeah. Oh, yeah. And cool is such a thing, and it's kind of like the older you get, the less cool you are. Yeah. So judging becomes a way to deal with my sense of inadequacy and not being a good idea.

SPEAKER_00My insecurity, totally. Oh, yeah. I mean, my kids are 20, 23, and 25, and they would say, just the way that I say cool reveals that I'm not cool. Like, you know, in fact, somewhere they're kind of cringing just because I've now said it here with you. So, so yeah, absolutely. We cut become aware of our lack of coolness. Uh, and I think that can make us more insecure, more prone to withdraw or to judge. But, you know, we had a senior pastor tell us during the course of our research with some previous research, that for young people, warm is the new cool.

SPEAKER_04Oh, that's beautiful. Isn't that good? Because temperature-wise, it looks the opposite.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. And and any of us can be warm. You know, for for people who are watching or listening to this who are cool, awesome. They can just keep being their cool selves. But for the rest of us, we don't have to try to be cool. In fact, when we try, young people pick that up. What they want is they want us to be real, they want us to be warm, they want us to listen, they want us to care. Now, I will say, sometimes young people don't always show that. You know, it's not like the nearest young person at our church or our grandchild or our niece-nephew is saying, Oh, please build a relationship with me verbally.

SPEAKER_00So sometimes we have to push through what can look like apathy or even caution from young people, but fundamentally, young people they want, they want that warmth.

SPEAKER_04I I was listening not too long ago to a talk that Dallas Willard did, and he was talking about the concept of cool.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_04And where does that come from? Why is this so central? And he actually went back to the fall. And that after the fall, one of the consequences was now you will work, you will labor by the sweat of your brow. Yeah. And so sweat is a symptom of fallenness, inadequacy. So we all want to look like no sweat.

SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_04But I'm cool because sweat is an indication that I'm fallen, I'm inadequate, I'm wrong. But actually, that's the truth about me.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Oh, oh, that's really profound, John. You know, as we were talking, I was thinking about a dad whose teenage daughter told him, you know, you don't need to come uh to my games anymore. She played soccer, you don't need to come to my games anymore. I don't want you to come. And he listened to her because it seemed like she was pushing away. So he didn't come. And she admitted to him some years later, you know, I really wish you had showed up. Wow. I really wish you had come.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00So it, you know, I need to remember that as a parent, you, as a parent, grandparent, it's we are just building relationships with young people in our neighborhood, in our church. Again, they're not always going to have the welcome mat out. Um, you know, there's a season where as a parent you show up at your kids' school and they give you kind of the head nod. You know, you don't even get a hello. If you're lucky, you get a head nod. Yep. Um, yeah, but and that can happen when they're not even our kids, but showing up, being consistent, being uh, you know, kind of a steady force in their life.

SPEAKER_04No, you know, we have grandkids and we're already experiencing at a certain age when they're little and you come up, it's like, oh my god, you're gonna be the grandest day of my life. Totally. And then at a certain age, and it comes sooner than I would have thought. Yeah. If we're alone, there can still be that very warm response. But if there's other peers around, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Right, exactly. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. I'm thinking uh about a church that we've been working with uh that we always recommend with listening. That's not just true with individual relationships, but churches, you know, as you want to engage teenagers, young adults, have you actually listened to them? So there was this church that said, okay, we really want to better engage our teenagers. It was a church of about two, three hundred uh near Fuller in Los Angeles. And so the associate pastor and one of the deacons, they did a couple focus groups with teenagers.

SPEAKER_00Anybody can do this. Any adult listening or watching can do this. You know, what do you like about our church? When do you feel closest to the adults in our church? When do you feel like you really belong? And what the young people said was we love it when people from our church show up at our events, when they show up at our soccer game, when they show up at our play.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00Um, that's what we love. And so the pastor and the deacon, they came up with something really wild and creative. They created a Google Doc. Wow, new technology, so sophisticated. Yeah, I know. You heard it here first. A Google Doc that parents and stepparents and caregivers and kids themselves could enter their events in so that youth ministry volunteers, you know, it's part-time youth pastor, three or four volunteers, could show up at an event. Well, that went so well. Adults, these volunteers started showing up that the pastor and the deacon thought, well, why don't we do this church wide?

SPEAKER_00So every Sunday there's a slide in the announcements that reveals it, you know, that indicates what young people are doing, who's got a game, who's got a play, who's got a Girl Scout event, whatever it might be. Now, think about what it means to be a young person in that worship service and you're seeing yourself and your friends and just young people highlighted like that. I mean, what do you feel about? Okay, I belong here. This is my home. But then also, adults are spontaneously showing up at kids' events and even becoming, you know, when you mentioned Ron Ronnie of it, as you said, talking about being a grandparent.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_00Because especially senior adults, there is a special tenderness between senior adults and young people. So the pastor who was telling us this story uh about his church, he had he had gone to uh a 16-year-old soccer game, and he's standing on the sidelines talking to her parents, and he looks down the sidelines, and there's an 81-year-old sitting in his lawn chair, just there to cheer her on.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00Now, you know, I'm not suggesting that's a magic silver bullet for every church, but I love that idea of okay, we listened to young people and we heard what they said, and then we figured out how we could do what they said. And in this case, it was showing up literally.

SPEAKER_04As simple as showing up, exactly.

SPEAKER_00And and the senior adults, I mean, they they want more to do, they want opportunities to want and need connection, exactly, uh, although sometimes push it away because it's often more effort.

SPEAKER_04Totally. But then when it's given, it's like, oh yeah, that's what life is about. Absolutely. I matter to somebody.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Hence the popularity of Theo of Golden, if you've read that novel. Okay, yeah. I mean, how anybody can make a difference, and especially people who are senior adults. There's there's some amazing opportunities.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Is there a reason why showing up uh to listen without judging is particularly important in this moment? Yeah. Let me unpack that a little bit more. You were talking about uh research with millennials, uh, Gen Z, Gen Alpha. I'll have you say a little bit more about how we carve generations up. Yeah, yeah. And why does that matter? Folks will sometimes lose track of that. Yeah. But you've been doing research now for a couple of decades. Yeah. And a big question is um, how do things change?

SPEAKER_04Yeah. You know, how do cohorts differ from each other?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_04And then uh how how do they remain the same?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_04And uh so say a word about that. What the generate how the generations get sliced up, uh, and what shifts and what changes stays the same, and is just showing up, listening without judging for some reason particularly important now.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, great question. So, you know, generational cohorts, they're a little arbitrary. You know, but researchers kind of look at trends, and it's not like somebody born December 31st of one year is so different than somebody born January 1st of the next year, et cetera. But as we've looked at how others are grouping it, we've landed on 2010 as the delineation between Gen Z and Gen Alpha. Now, let's start with what's different. Okay, you asked about what's different and what's the same. Okay, here's what's different. Think about what this cohort of young people, your grandkids, are navigating post-pandemic.

SPEAKER_00So many mental health struggles. You know, we've never had a cohort of young people who has navigated stress and anxiety and depression like this. Um, you know, I don't know a family with teenage girls who's not navigating mental health challenges. Yeah. Like the research tells me they exist, but I can't name one. And teenage boys are just a half step behind.

SPEAKER_04Um teenage boys are always a half step behind. Yeah, that's true.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a given, maybe in a lot of cases at least. Uh and then you know what's happening with young people with technology?

SPEAKER_04Yes.

SPEAKER_00And all that they're exposed to, you know, it that causes them in some ways to uh uh be. Be older and more mature, and in other ways, maybe be less mature. So, you know, one of the lines that we have at the Full Youth Institute is 14 is the new 24, but 28 is the new 18. Which think about the young people you know, right? Those 14-year-olds are really sophisticated. Yes. And thanks to technology, know so much. But then those 28-year-olds are often kind of developmentally behind.

SPEAKER_00And so, you know, it's taking them a little bit longer to pass some of the traditional markers of adulthood. So, you know, and then think about our world. I'll just add one more characteristic of what's different. Our world is so fractured today, you know, in the church, outside of the church, there's just so much divisiveness and so many polarities these days. And so in comes a new generation. Um, what's constant, you know, you asked me what I would want folks to get out of this podcast. Somebody asked me uh a couple years ago, Kara, summarize all your research in one sentence.

SPEAKER_00I mean, that's like me saying, John, summarize all your sermons in one sentence.

SPEAKER_04Love the Lord, you got with all your heart, soul mind, love your neighbors yourself. So they've been done.

SPEAKER_00Great, great, awesome. Well, well, you could do that uh at the drop of a hat, which is wonderful. So I kind of looked and thought for a few seconds, and I said, adolescent faith formation boils down to caring, trusted, Jesus-centered adults accompanying young people in life and faith.

SPEAKER_04Oh, you know, you gotta say that again.

SPEAKER_00Okay, yeah, and and I vetted it with our team. You know, I maybe tweaked it a little bit, added an adjective, perhaps, but but uh what I said two years ago, the team aligns with so adolescent faith formation boils down to caring, trusted, Jesus-centered adults, accompanying young people in life and faith. I'll just highlight a couple words there. Accompany. Um, we are doing a lot of exciting work with Catholics these days, especially through the 10 by 10 collaboration.

SPEAKER_00And that is one of their favorite words for mentoring.

SPEAKER_04Interesting.

SPEAKER_00And just journeying in life together. But they use it quite a bit for adults, uh walking with young people and the idea of accompanying. There's a beautiful mutuality there that we hope adults lean into.

SPEAKER_04I I just picture there's that story in Luke after the resurrection of the Emmaus Road. Yeah, yeah. And a couple of the disciples are just crestfallen and they're on the road to Emmaus, and then they don't recognize him yet, but Jesus is walking with them. Yeah, and just accompanying them, yeah, and just walking together and talking.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_04And then they see the presence of God.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I want to loop back to something related to that, but uh accompanying, um, and then if I can just point out trusted. You know, overall, if you look at the data at trust, we are a country that is not trusting others. That's true across generations.

SPEAKER_04Trust in institutions down at almost everything.

SPEAKER_00Exactly, and religious institutions and young people especially are distrustful. And sadly, we've earned that lack of trust. They look at the church as unloving, hypocritical, judgmental. And sadly, there's a lot of evidence that supports those theories. Um, so that's why uh a trusted, caring, Jesus-centered adult who will accompany young people can mean so much. And you know, the data on trust, this is so encouraging to me.

SPEAKER_00Um, the data on trust, it's not about heroic gestures. It's not. The best data on trust, it's everyday acts of showing up at a soccer game. At it's it's asking a young person, hey, how can I be praying for you? And then looping back 48 hours later and saying, Hey, I was praying for that science test. Yeah, you know, how's it going? The consistency and everyday small acts of showing you care. That's how this generation builds trust.

SPEAKER_04Wow. Wow. So uh uh you wanted to loop back to that Emmaus deal.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So um we had a gathering at Fuller a few months ago, uh, thanks to a number of foundations who came together for a project that we called Rise, uh, resourcing the integration of spiritual and emotional health. So the H is silent. So we call it RISE. And we had uh 30, 40 practitioners, researchers gathered. Um, and the talk that was the most impactful to me was Dave Wang.

SPEAKER_00I don't know if you spent much time with him. Yeah, fuller faculty member. His opening line was the Christian faith is built on a trauma.

SPEAKER_04The Christian faith is built on a trauma.

SPEAKER_00The resurrection is or the crucifixion, excuse me. The crucifixion is inherently traumatic. And then he pointed out something from John 20 that I hadn't really grasped. Um and that was after the resurrection, Jesus still had scars. God could have erased those.

SPEAKER_04And you would kind of think heaven, perfect bodies, you know, there'd be no blemish. Exactly. There's no tears.

SPEAKER_00That would be the ideal.

SPEAKER_04The scars, the wounds stay.

SPEAKER_00But the resurrected Jesus had scars. And so I think that's part of why young people these days are so drawn to Jesus, not necessarily the church, but Jesus, because they feel wounded, because they know their scars, and the idea that Jesus is a savior who had scars. Um I got to share this with a young man who had been cutting.

SPEAKER_03Wow.

SPEAKER_00And he said, I have 50 scars on my body. And the idea that I could say to him, Jesus relates, Jesus had scars. So you know, there's a lot of talk about how young people are open, and we see that in our research. The Barner group has said that very well, that young people are really open to Jesus. And I think partly because this generation has gone through a lot of pain, they could relate to a savior who who brings together beauty, but also there's still signs of, I don't want to say brokenness, that's not quite right, but signs of wounds and healing.

SPEAKER_04So I was thinking, you know, when I was in high school, to the extent that I understood it, the strategy of youth ministry was try to get the jocks and the cheerleaders to go to your church. Yeah. And then everybody else will follow.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Has that changed?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a lot more splintered now. Uh I mean, you know, those who we used to call the the knee the nerds or the geeks, they don't care that much about the jocks and the cheerleaders. And the jocks might not care about the cheerleaders, and the student government group doesn't care about the drama kids, etc. So it's it's a whole lot more fractured, which means we need more diverse adults. Yes, right?

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_00We need more diverse adults because again, you don't have to be the one who connects with the jocks and the cheerleaders. You can be your dorky self and connect with kids who are insecure, et cetera.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And we just need a whole bunch of different adults caring about kids. In fact, part of what we would love to champion is it's not just your youth pastor who's a youth worker, everyone is a youth worker.

SPEAKER_04I I I remember part of the research that you did was looking at again, what I think about when I was growing up, churches would have a ratio of how many kids could be in a group per each adult. And you're thinking about that differently.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And this was the brilliance of Chap Clark when he was at Fuller, and he coined this idea of the five to one ratio. Uh, because in in every research project, no matter what question we start with, John, we always end up seeing the importance of intergenerational relationships. Again, caring, trusted, Jesus-centered adult. Whatever question we ask, you know, we're getting ready to do some new research on AI and we're looping back to caring, trusted, Jesus-centered adults. So Chap was seeing that in his research. And so he came up with this idea that we need to reverse the five to one ratio.

SPEAKER_00And what we mean by that is if I was to show up at your church or my church or any church and ask the youth pastor, the children's pastor, like, okay, what's what kind of ratio are you aiming for? And they probably want like one adult for every five kids. Um I got a retreat coming up, right? Whatever we're doing, one adult for every five kids. Well, what chap wisely said is what if we reverse that? And it's not one adult for five kids, it's five adults for each kid. Not five small group leaders, not five Bible study leaders, but five adults who are showing up at a soccer game, five adults who are remembering a young person's birthday, five adults who are just that safe place.

SPEAKER_00And uh five is a good number, but three is great, you know, whatever. And and you know, we say to parents and step parents, hey, you don't have to keep this a secret from your kid. Like, ask your kid, who would you like to get to know better? When your kids are young, who would you like to be, who would you like to babysit? This is what Dave and I did.

SPEAKER_04Oh, that's great. So any parent that's watching right now, absolutely just ask your kid, who do you want to babysit? Yeah, yeah, because I think about with our kids, that's a real quick indicator, like that person, don't want to be around that person.

SPEAKER_00Totally. And you need to get a babysitter anyway, right? And so when you go to a person and say, hey, my kid has said they want to spend time with you, would you mind babysitting, you know, next Sunday night? Like that's a pretty nice invitation. Win-win-win for everybody, right? For the kid, for the parent, and the adult who's getting invited. Uh, when our kids got older, we played a game. Who would you talk to about? You know, when they're in middle school, high school. Oh, that's right. You know, if you got if you got caught cheating, who would you talk to about it? Wow. And just get them thinking, what adults can they go to?

SPEAKER_04So I want to cycle back to something you just mentioned a moment ago, AI.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_04Lots of questions for folks with the emerging generation around obviously technology as a whole. Um, it's in particular, its impact, especially around emotional health.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Jonathan Haidt.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Um, so I love what the research is indicating on that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_04And then we'll shift over into AI in particular.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Young people are turning to AI. You know, the percentages range, it's up to like 72%, according to one study of young people, are turning to AI for personal support. Not just a Google.

SPEAKER_04Just to get information, not just getting information.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, not just a fancy Google or a way to get a jump start on a homework assignment, but turning to turning to AI for personal support. Um, and now that's one of the higher estimates, you know, somewhere probably between 30 and 70 is the reality. But if you think about it, um, AI is a great sycophant, you know.

SPEAKER_04Oh, every time I use it. John, that's a brilliant question. Brilliant. John, that's a profound observation. John, you're on exactly the right track.

SPEAKER_00Even when you correct AI, it says, you're right. I admit that. So thank you for correcting me.

SPEAKER_04I I shouldn't be so flattering. I'll work on it.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. Yeah, I have to tell my AI, my AI, like, give me the brutal truth, like being critical with me.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, because it's been hard for me because Nancy tends to respond the same way. Totally.

SPEAKER_00So it just indistinguishable. Yes, yes, absolutely. Yeah, because because that's your wife. It's just uh 100% affirming no matter what she thinks. Um so I love your wife. Um I do too.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Um but I assume then, if the ratio is anywhere in that ballpark, kind of by definition, once the shift is from this could help me learn, this could help me acquire information, to I will become emotionally dependent on a non-person that's not a healthy development.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And uh you know, there is some data that about one out of four teenagers say AI knows me better than the people closest to me do.

SPEAKER_04One out of four.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, one out of four already.

SPEAKER_04Which is unprecedented. I mean, no previous generation has faced that reality.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Social media took a lot longer to be adapted. AI, it's been like a tidal wave. So um we had a day with some Fuller faculty and other scholars, and one of them said something to the effect that if there's no someone to make you feel known, you'll turn to something.

SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah. If there's no someone, you'll settle. Yeah. Which is, I mean, when you think about idolatry as kind of idolatry as turning from someone to something.

SPEAKER_00Something. Yeah, I hadn't made that connection, Sean. That's really good. So, um, so AI is here to stay. You know, we're not gonna stop this tidal wave. And for us, we look at it as an opportunity for the church. Yeah, like in the midst of machine learning, machine thinking becoming more prevalent, the need for humans is all the greater. So, you know, this is a clarion call for us as adults and as churches to say, okay, as AI is this tsunami, like we want to be there too, and we want to be present.

SPEAKER_00We want to be engaging young people in spiritual practices. This has been a big theme. I know that's something you talk about quite a bit. You know, we really want uh young people to embody their faith. I think one of the more interesting things that we've been talking about with scholars is also the role of friction in faith formation.

SPEAKER_03Say more.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh this is probably the most intriguing thing to me these days that, you know, AI makes my life easier. Yeah. I mean, I I use AI probably 10 times a day. I understand it's dangers. I'm trying to do what I can about those dangers, but it's a as been said, it it kind of can become a teammate, not just a tool, but a but a teammate. Yep. So um, so there's a lot I love about AI. Um I lost my train of thought. Friction is a good idea. We were talking about friction. And I love things being easier, you know. I I I love hacks, but there are no hacks for interior formation.

SPEAKER_00And when we come to expect that answers are easy, things come quickly, you know, what is that doing to our understanding of Romans 5, 3, and 4? Suffering leads to perseverance, perseverance, character, and character hope. You know, my kids who are 20 to 25, um they're so used to Amazon Prime delivery that, you know, if something takes two days, that's so unreasonable. It's like the dark ages for them, you know. Um, because everything is fast, everything is easy. So that's something else that we're asking.

SPEAKER_00You know, friction and challenges are important for our overall formation.

SPEAKER_04I was reading something quite recently, and it suggested, just to your point, that um if I never have to wait to find anything out, yeah, um, then uh I lose the power of curiosity to motivate and to help me to persist over time. Yeah. Now here's my question. So we have that observation how do I as an adult not move to oh these spoiled entitled young people? You know, back in my day, yeah, we had to work for it six miles uphill both ways to school through the snow.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. How do I how do I absorb that information and not turn into that guy?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So what comes to mind is one of my favorite quotes from Dietrich Bonhoeffer. This is my paraphrase real community is possible when I view myself as the chief sinner. When I view myself as the biggest sinner, if as I'm talking with you, if I'm viewing myself and in touch with my sin, I will see myself as more flawed than you. So whoever we're talking to, whatever the difference is, whether it's age, whether it's social economic status, whatever, whether it's political party, you know, whatever it might be, can I see myself as the bigger sinner?

SPEAKER_00And I think that's part of how we can keep humble.

SPEAKER_04So that I mean, coming back again to the main thing we want folks to take away without judging, yeah. Really what's behind judging wherever it comes from is a sense of superiority and a lack of humility and knowing myself as a sinner. Yeah. And it's like that just seeps into us in such deep ways. Totally. But that's what's coming out of me when I reflexively think about this generation in judgmental ways.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. You know, one of the really good questions we get asked when we share how, especially Gen Alpha, but young people in general want to be listened to without being judged, is invariably there'll be an adult who raises their hand and says, but what if they're doing something wrong? What do I do then?

SPEAKER_02Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_00Totally fair question. You know, I'm not saying we're just bobbleheading our way through life and kind of smiling and nodding and everything that young people do. Sometimes with my own kids or young people I'm close to, there's something that I feel like I need to say to them. Um, one of our mantras is never make a statement if you can ask a question instead.

SPEAKER_04Oh gosh. One more time.

SPEAKER_00Never make a statement if you can ask a question instead, which, you know, I would give myself about a B minus at best at that, despite it being something I've been quoting for like five years. Um, so first, you know, when you have something that you want to talk about with a young person, can you can you make it about questions that you're asking? Now, my own kids, oh, you know, they catch on. And they have said, Mom, some of your questions, they're like quest gestions. And they're not wrong.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, I'm I'm working on asking questions that are truly curious. Yes, and not trying to convince my kids of something.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um, and I gotta say, this is You should do what I tell you to, don't you think?

SPEAKER_04Right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Well, honestly, because of our research, uh, even though my kids are older, they're Gen Z. Um, you know, I really have been trying to, with the questions that I ask, how can I have them be as agenda-free as possible?

SPEAKER_04Genuinely curious.

SPEAKER_00Genuinely curious. Instead of wanting to drive them toward a particular destination. So with one of my daughters, she was trying to choose between A and B. And, you know, I thought A was better. But I said, Well, what do you think are some of the advantages of B? Which I don't know that I would have done before ever researched. I would have just camped out a lot on the advantages of A and the disadvantages of B. Now she ended up choosing A, but she might not have. But I'm glad that I was able to really help her think about both options.

SPEAKER_00So, so you know, when it comes to when you see something that concerns you about a young person, can you ask questions of curiosity? Um, and in fact, we we recommend you start a question with, I'm curious. Oh, that's a great preface. Hey, I'm I'm curious. You know, you I know that you believe this, and then I see this happening in your life. Like, how do those two things come together for you? That's something I've used. That framing is something I've used quite a bit. You say this, I've heard you believe this, but then I see this. Like, how does that come together?

SPEAKER_00Um, but sometimes you do feel like, okay, I just need to tell a young person how I'm feeling.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00Well, I stumbled onto this and it's worked really well for me. When you do feel like, okay, I need to share what I think is truth, what I think scripture is saying, what I ask after that is, what do you disagree with in what I've just said? And I let them critique me. Huh. And I'll tell you, especially my own kids, they love that. Like, you know, they've got a lot of thoughts of where I'm misunderstanding them or the situation, et cetera. But then when I follow up with, uh, well, you know, where might what I said maybe be right or have some a good point to it, then they seem to have been more open to affirm where I was right because I let them critique me first.

SPEAKER_00So, so you know, bottom line, our recommendation is even when there's a truth you need to share, a principle you need to share, how do you make it a conversation following up with questions?

SPEAKER_04A good friend of mine is realizing, because his wife pointed it out to him, that he has this verbal tick where he will say something and he always wants to persuade, so he'll follow that up with it. Does that make sense?

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_04Oh, and he's realized that really he's not asking a question. He's just like, tell me I'm right.

SPEAKER_00Say yes, say yes.

SPEAKER_04And so talking through it, finding another statement like, but I'd really like to hear your opinion. Only then you have to get yourself to the place where you really do want to hear their opinions.

SPEAKER_00Totally, totally, yeah.

SPEAKER_04I'm wondering if this judgmental thing might be tied to uh a book you may or may not know of. I think the number one selling book last year was a book called Let Them.

SPEAKER_00I've heard of it, but I have not read it.

SPEAKER_04I I've just read parts of it, but it was written by a woman, an influencer. We may come back to that word. And uh she she uh her kind of beginning anecdote was her son was going to a prom and he was doing it all wrong. You know, he had not made reservations at a restaurant, he hadn't bought a booth there, he hadn't arranged for transportation, and she's just going nuts on you have to do this, you have to do this, you have to do this. And her daughter finally says, just let him but then won't have any food. Yes. Well let him. Yes, but then he wouldn't have a croissant to give him. Well let him. Yes.

SPEAKER_04And so that let them which which you know I I sometimes will think about God in the garden where an angel would come and say, God, you gotta put a fence around that tree. You gotta tell them they get you know, let them, let them, uh that it's kind of an honoring somebody's kingdom, but yeah, and and that concept, uh, you know, it it's clearly striking a nerve. And I think especially with parents, um, let them, and I wonder if that's connected to that it's so powerful because there's a generation of young people who just feel judged.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And I I have heard an interview with the author of that book, and I think part of what's beauty and beautiful about let them is um part of why I care about whether or not my son has a corsage for the Prom to use the example that you just gave is because I have a picture of what prom should be. And I also, if I'll get real personal here, I want my kid to do it right. Yep. I want to be the mom.

SPEAKER_04Because it's a reflection on my parenthood.

SPEAKER_00And if my kid does really good, then I want to be the mom whose son has it together and not the mom whose son, you know, is clueless and doesn't get together.

SPEAKER_04I just think our children probably pick up on that a little bit more than we know.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Okay, now you're getting convicting here, John. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So, you know, when you asked, how can we not judge? I shared about Dietrich Bonhoeffer, but the other thought that came to mind is okay, let's just hold up the mirror to ourselves. And a lot of what we're judgmental about in young people, it's probably really our own insecurities, our own wanting to look a certain way as parents, grandparents, pastors, etc. So what what are we bringing to this?

SPEAKER_04No, it strikes me when you say that like research and data is really helpful and really good, but not mostly because it's going to give us technique and method.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Mostly it will reinforce or point out where my unhealth is damaging other people. Yeah. And I need to go back and be with God and work on my own self because that's they're kind of holding up a little mirror.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Well, and uh you obviously know Dallas Willard far, far, far much better than I do. But you know, just looking at life as God's curriculum for us and relationships is our our constant lab in spiritual formation. And I'll tell you, nothing has formed me more than being a parent. Yeah. There's nothing. Yeah. That more than being a pastor, more than being a professor.

SPEAKER_04But unfortunately, a lot of folks, including a lot of us who do spiritual formation, don't talk much about parenthood as a spiritual discipline.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, right.

SPEAKER_04And I can remember when I first started out as a pastor talking about seeking the kingdom. And one of the women there said it was a lot easier for me to seek the kingdom first when I was in college. I said, How come? And she said, Well, then I had lots of free time. Sure. So I could get up early in the morning, I could read the Bible and pray.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_04And now I have two little kids and they're both under three years old. Yeah. And I can't do that anymore. Yeah. It was like nobody had ever told her maybe caring for, loving, serving two little children is bringing about transformation and pouring more love and spiritual change in you than memorizing the book of Isaiah. Yeah. But it's like that counts and that doesn't matter. It doesn't.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And even when you get frustrated with those two little kids, what is God trying to show you? Yeah. Or what is God's invitation? Well, use that wording. What is God's invitation for you in the midst of the parenting and grandparenting highs and lows?

SPEAKER_04What is uh like I think is I hear you and read you very often, kind of the first uh direction, implication from research is to help churches figure out how do we how do we get uh church right for young people. Um let's take parents for a moment. Yeah. Um lots of people who are listening to us right now, yeah, our parents. Yeah. Uh when you think about the research that you have done and what it points to, what do parents most need to hear?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, let me start with some really encouraging news. Um, you know, research in the last handful of decades.

SPEAKER_04Very few parents kill their children.

unknownOkay.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_04Number one command, the most important of the ten commandments, thou shalt not kill. That's the same thing. Parents needed, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Great. Okay, so we've crossed that hurdle. Excellent. Um, when you look at uh additional research, additional data in the last decades, you know, research is pretty clear. It's hard to find anything more important in a young person's faith formation than parents. So when I earlier said, you know, trusted Jesus-centered adults, that usually starts at home. Now, having said that, there's all sorts of exceptions. Right. We all know young people who have amazing parents and vice versa. And, you know, God works in mysterious ways.

SPEAKER_00But when I look at the research, I've got to say, parents, there's nothing more important than you and your young person's faith formation, which is both encouraging and terrifying to uh you know unaware parent. What's different about Gen Alpha, and this has been fascinating in this our surveys of 3,000 of them so far, is that Gen Alpha is also verbalizing how important parents are.

SPEAKER_04Really?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_04In ways that previous generations were not.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Absolutely. So we talk a lot at Fuller about identity, belonging, and purpose as being the three big questions that young people are wrestling with.

SPEAKER_03So who am I?

SPEAKER_00Where do I fit and what difference can I make?

SPEAKER_03Who am I with my family?

SPEAKER_00Where do I fit and what difference can I make? So we've as we look at identity, belonging, and purpose and faith of Jen Alpha, 13 to 16, 17 year olds. I mean, John, I could show you graph after graph where family is ahead of friends, is ahead of church. Um, parents and grandparents are ahead of friends. Siblings are even uh pegging higher than we would have expected. Really? So there's something about this generation that they're more in touch with the influence of family.

SPEAKER_00Now, why is that? We don't know for sure. We're still trying to figure that out. I think it's partly what we were talking about before that in the midst of the pandemic, in the midst of mental health, for many young people, home is a safer place than other places. Not all young people, and for some young people, home is really not safe, but for many, home is safe. I think the other thing is there's um there's a uh a form of parenting that facilitates family intimacy. It's gentle parenting, you know, that's a trend these days.

SPEAKER_04It is a big trend.

SPEAKER_00It is a big trend. Uh, you know, emotional regulation. We never talked about emotional regulation when I was parents. Wheel of emotions. Yeah, the feelings wheel. Exactly. Exactly. There's a lot of families who have that up on their fridge.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And I think it's a great tool. And I have told my kids, in fact, I told my girls uh a week ago, our 20 and 23-year-old daughters were over, and I told them something I've said many times before. What I would most redo as a parent is I would have given you more space to express your feelings, especially your anger and your sadness. You know, I kind of did, but then I had a phrase, pull it together. I mean, can't you just see me saying pull it together? It doesn't sound like me at all.

SPEAKER_00It doesn't sound like you at all. Pull it together. And then I wouldn't even give a time frame. Like we'd be driving them, you got to pull it together by the time we get to grandma's house or, you know, whatever it is. And I can laugh about it with my girls now and our son, but I I would redo that. So I think there's something really beautiful about families making more space for emotions. There's certainly some downsides, and you know, teachers are starting to struggle as this wave of preschoolers and elementary kids come in who are very used to a adult, an adult attending to their emotions.

SPEAKER_00And here's a teacher with 20 to 40 kids. So, you know, there's some downsides probably too, but um, but I do think there's a different family intimacy as we're more open about emotions that this generation is benefiting from.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Let me follow up on that one. I hadn't anticipated with this this direction, but parenting, children, moral and spiritual formation, how all that comes together is kind of fascinating to me. Yeah. And I think of like Deuteronomy 6:4, Hero Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one, him so you love, and then write down these laws, put them on your doorposts, teach them to your children. Yeah. So education generally has been understood, and certainly was in Israel, to include moral education and spiritual education.

SPEAKER_04And part of the understanding was when children are growing up, they will all have desires and the great tension in life is learning to let go of what I happen to desire if it violates the good. Dallas would talk quite a lot about that. Yeah, that's he would essentially describe the battle between the flesh and spirit as flesh is a way of talking about I want this. Yeah, I want this toy, I want this happy meal, I want this job. And uh there's times when it violates the good.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. So I have to learn to die to what I desire if it conflicts with the good. And uh that seems like it involves a certain kind of directedness and an expectation of correction.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Um that uh increasingly in a therapeutic age is a little tricky to pull off as a parent. Yeah. Uh and there was Dr. Spock a little before I was.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, my mom read that.

SPEAKER_04Gentle parenting. Yeah. Um how do you think about that kind of ancient understanding of uh the presence of sin as misguided desire, but then on the other hand, all of the ways in which that can become distorted, misguided.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_04I can remember when I was a kid too, there'd be certain kind of churches that would teach parents you must break the will of the child.

SPEAKER_00Right, sure. Totally.

SPEAKER_04And do enormous damage. And it's like, nope, that's not the idea.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. Let me share something else I wish I had done differently as a parent. Um, that maybe is a way to tangibilize what you said. And I I learned this from another parent. And part of what I love about my job is I get to spend time just listening and talking to parents and grandparents, pastors, leaders. Um, and this one parent said, you know, one of the big themes in our family was Jesus is best. Oh, I love it. Isn't that good? Yeah, yeah. Yep. I heard that a couple of years ago, and I thought, wow, that would have been a really helpful way.

SPEAKER_04That would have been.

SPEAKER_00You know, for a four-year-old or for a 14-year-old. Yep. Like Jesus, Jesus is best.

SPEAKER_04So do you run much into this? The this will uh probably not tend to be inside the church much, but certainly in the culture some children are not old enough to give informed consent. So parents should not take them to church, shouldn't teach them that the Bible is true, um, shouldn't have them be praying to Jesus. They should just wait until they are old enough to make a decision on their own. Do you do you run into that much? And how do you respond to it?

SPEAKER_00I don't run into it very much, and I would respond to it by saying in so many other areas, we do give structured education and formation to kids. So, you know, they they take math classes, they take history, they are on swim teams, et cetera. So why would we not have exposure to the Christian community? Um, be part of it. And that includes, you know, some structured content, intergenerational mentoring, etc. The question that we do run into a lot is hey, my 14-year-old doesn't want to go to church anymore.

SPEAKER_00What do I do?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, what do you what do you say?

SPEAKER_00That's an omnipresent question. So uh a couple things. Number one, um, Eugene Peterson has this great phrase in one of his his in his book, uh, like do for youth, which is such an odd title. But um anyway, it's a quote from scripture um that is about parenting. And he says, you know, keep your kid in the conversation. So if your kid doesn't want to be in the faith community, how do you keep your kid in the conversation? So so what does that actually look like? What we recommend to parents and caregivers is so ask your kid, you know, is there another church you would like to try out?

SPEAKER_00And then you as a parent be willing to go to that other church. We tell parents, I tell parents all the time, your young person's faith formation should be your priority now. You know, you can listen to sermons, you can listen to worship, you can get fed other ways. Please lean into what what your kid wants. So, you know, is there another church? Is there a young life? Is there a youth for Christ that your kid would want to go to?

SPEAKER_04Or another person, mentoring.

SPEAKER_00Another exactly, exactly. Who's who's another person? The other thing I would say, and I used to say this as a youth pastor, you know, going on an overnight or a weekend retreat is worth about six months of going on Sunday mornings, just in terms of social connections. Because usually when a kid says, I don't want to go to church, it's because they don't feel connected socially. They might say, Oh, I don't like the teaching, you know, or the theological boat.

SPEAKER_04Totally. They'll use something.

SPEAKER_00Nine out of ten times. If there's somebody in the other room who likes them, totally. Then they or they had an adult they felt comfortable with. Yeah. And so, you know, we regularly recommend to parents look at look at the next six, nine months of your youth ministry events and ask your kid to choose one.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Choose one something beyond a Sunday, one all day, one overnight or one retreat. And that's what they're going to to give it an attempt. And so, in fact, I just had this parent um reach out to us, and I was getting to know her, and her daughter really didn't want to go to camp, and there were some developmental differences, et cetera. And she went to camp, and um, you know, by hour one, she was mixing it up with all the kids. So, you know, that kid who doesn't want to get out of your van and go to camp, often by hour one or two, you know, they have totally immersed themselves in the community.

SPEAKER_00So, so yes, is there another community? Is there an adult? Can we pick something beyond just Sunday morning that you can really connect with others relationally?

SPEAKER_04So, so since you're giving direction, I'm gonna ask you to give some of the pastors.

SPEAKER_00Oh, okay.

SPEAKER_04And I'm thinking in particular now of I'm thinking of churches where um they really have a lot to offer. Maybe the church has been around for quite a while, yeah, but it's aged and there are not uh any or not many children, not any or many young people.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, very kind.

SPEAKER_04And the leadership might say, well, if they came, we would come up with something for them.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04But if there's nothing for them, they're not gonna come. Yeah. What would you say to that church, to that pastor?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Two streams of thought for that question. First, I would ask that pastor, how are you prioritizing young people? Because some of the most depressing research that we've done in the last two years was we did a survey of 600 senior pastors and asked them where young people fell and their priorities. And only, you might not be surprised by this. I was and disheartened. Um, I'll say only one third of the senior pastors who responded to our survey said young people were in their top five priorities.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for saying wow. Yeah, top five priorities. So think about you know what else is up there that young people are six through ten. And then to make it worse, you know, this was a survey from the Fuller Youth Institute. So if anything, it's gonna That should have prompted it. It's gonna lean towards like a social desirability bias that's supposed to be. Exactly. There's definitely a bias there. So if anything, the one-third is a little bit high. So, you know, that's the first question we love asking pastors and church boards. Like, how are you prioritizing young people? And let's get tangible.

SPEAKER_00What kind of resources are you uh allocating to them? Um, and and I mean money and I mean time and I mean energy and I mean facility, because young people can tell if they're a priority or not. Senior pastor, how much time are you spending with young people, getting to know them? Um so that is that is one thing I would say is, you know, really are you prioritizing young people? And then this is just the theme here. Are you listening to young people?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So, you know, one of the first steps we recommend to churches who say, we don't have any young people, they've all left, is to say, well, why don't you go back to the young people who have left and ask them, yeah, well, why did you leave? What could have made a difference? Hey, would you like to be a part of something new?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, maybe they're all 16, 17, they've moved on. Well, who are your 10 and 11-year-olds, your 12-year-olds who you can start building a relationship now and who can become a strong middle school ministry that becomes a strong youth ministry and so on and so forth because you've listened to them. So, yeah, prioritization, real tangible on that. You know, your budget is a manifesto of your priorities.

SPEAKER_04Yep.

SPEAKER_00So, where are young people in your budget? Yeah. And then um how you're actually listening.

SPEAKER_04And if there's pastors listening to us now, are there resources? Are there churches that are learning how to do it right, places that you point people to where, like, if you're serious about it, here's where you can get some help. Yeah. Can they get it from uh from Fuller?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Please go to Foleyouthinstitute.org and sign up for our free every week email. We also have a free John Alpha report um that that goes is a deep dive into all of our research. And we're only about two-thirds of the way done with our research. So we'll have more free reports coming out. And then also for churches that really want to engage with young people, Growing Young has been a book that's really connected with them, where we look at, because we studied several hundred churches that had prior that that were growing with young people, hence the title, Growing Young.

SPEAKER_00What is it that they did? And we specifically get into prioritization because that was one of the six things that churches do. Is that in fact that was often the fork in the road whether a church was prioritizing young people.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00So yeah. So that so that book has a lot of great uh ideas on how churches are prioritizing young people.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, ask you uh about pastors, because obviously you're involved also and at a place that's involved in equipping pastors.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Lots of information about fewer people going into pastoring, they're getting older, they're leaving.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Um, you have watched lots of pastors who don't end well.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Um how do you think about that? What does the church need to do to be uh attracting healthy pastors? What kind of damage does it do when somebody who's in a leadership position does not navigate life with integrity? How do you think through that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I'll just start with the last question. It does a lot of damage. Yeah. Um I'll answer your earlier questions. Uh we haven't talked about this, John, but um we've we've really tried to listen to denominations in the last three or four months. So we've talked to 10 different denominations, uh, Protestant denominations, mainline evangelical, and we've asked them what are your top three needs, opportunities, you know, top three questions you're wrestling with. Every single one of them is saying next gen leadership pipeline.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00And often it's number one. Um, and that's not just true with mainline denominations where the aging is more obvious. So I would say, and and in the midst of denominations saying that this is a question for them, um, not many are prioritizing it and listening to young people. So there is one denomination that said, you know, Fuller, we'd really love to work with you on this. And so we're now creating a partnership with them where both it is gonna be both top-down and bottom-up.

SPEAKER_00How do we invest in young people? And it's gonna start by listening to young people and listening to young people who are in ministry and what led them on that journey. So it's the same principles prioritization and listening, whether it's an individual church or a network or a denomination.

SPEAKER_04I I hadn't thought about that, but I've took the numbers. This is just an anecdotal, but number of folks who would say the pipeline of people who are going into student ministry, youth ministry is drying up, getting smaller.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04And historically, that was the single biggest feeder into people that would then go into becoming senior pastors or whatever the language would be. Yeah. So what's happening there is now impact, impacting what's happening there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, you're absolutely right. And you know, somebody who cares about young people, I do think part of that is because uh the typical youth pastor job is often not sustainable for anybody, um, not financially sustainable. Yeah. So they just can't make it. And so they move into another career or a different form of pastoral ministry. So, so yeah, there's some brokenness inherently, uh, or some existing brokenness in how young people are. There's some existing brokenness in how young adults especially are entering ministry that we need to give them more mentoring, if we can, more financial support.

SPEAKER_00I would say more training and education to degreed and non-degreed. So uh a much better on-ramp is what we need.

SPEAKER_04Um, another research question. Uh, you know, I I'm interested a lot in how do people get formed spiritually? Yeah. Um most of that, most of what's written about that is written about adults. Yeah. Um, and there's been lots of stuff written over the last few decades about the role of spiritual practices and community and so on. Not as much around children or young people.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04How do you think about approaching formation with young people? What should parents be thinking about? Yeah. Um, what's effective, what works, what doesn't work.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, the good news is that there is more work being done on this with both children and adolescents, thanks to the investment of the Lily Endowment. So they specifically have initiatives on children and worship. That's a major national initiative of theirs. Uh, and then uh faith in AI, how to form young people in the midst of an age of AI. So there's gonna be more and more resources out, definitely.

SPEAKER_04I remember you probably remember an author, Larry Crab, psychologist. When he had kids, he actually bought an overhead projector for family devotions. Yes. I am not kidding. And apparently did not go all that well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_04So uh when I was growing up, that's the kind of the people who talk about family devotions. Periodically, families would try them, they would always be a disaster. I don't know of any family that had them where they weren't great. Yeah, but I think a lot of parents feel probably a low level of guilt.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. For all they're not doing.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, for yeah, for for not knowing how do we help spiritually form our children.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So, you know, as you're talking, uh I think every family needs ideally would figure out what really works for them. Are they a family where it's more about discussion? You know, I have a colleague at Fuller who has young kids and Every Sunday they do act out church where the family, parents included, act out a scripture passage and then talk about it. Like that would not have worked with my husband. I would just say that. He's a more reserved engineer. But for this family, like act out church is great. My husband hates charades.

SPEAKER_00Act Out Church would not have worked for the pals, but it certainly worked for this other family. So, so you know, are you a family that wants to talk about it? Are you a family that wants to explore God's creation more as a way to connect?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00You know, I my because I know more about teenagers than I do children, I will say one of my favorite questions, in fact, I just asked my son about this uh recently and my daughter about this recently, is when do you feel closest to God?

SPEAKER_04Oh, that's a great question.

SPEAKER_00We should all be asking that question of each other, right?

SPEAKER_04Yes.

SPEAKER_00When do you feel closest to God? And then as a parent, how can I help my kid get more of that time? So, you know, when our kids were in our church's youth ministry, for one of our daughters, she felt closest to God when she was with Christian friends. She said, I feel closest to God, Mom, when I'm with friends from church. Okay, how do we make sure you get a lot of that time? Another one of our daughters said, I feel closest to God when I am in nature. She'd love to hang out in our backyard. How do we make sure she gets a lot of outdoors time? Our son would say, I feel closest to God uh when I'm leading worship, because he played guitar.

SPEAKER_00So um, a confession here as a parent. So, in order to play guitar, he had to go to once-a-week worship practice. And before he got his driver's license, guess who had to drive him to worship practice on Thursday nights? Either me or my husband. And so, you know, there were times where uh Nathan, do you really know I'm glad to say, really? Did you really have to go? Don't you kind of already know the songs? Um, but first off, he would say worship rehearsal was one of the times where he did feel closest to God because there was no audience.

SPEAKER_00So it's the songs without any kind of pressure to perform. And then also that was allowed him to play on Sunday mornings and Wednesday nights. And so, you know, I would suck it up as a parent and get my boy to worship practice most weeks, not every week, because I knew that's when he felt closest. So again, when is it for your family, your kid, when do you feel closest to God? I mean, for my husband and me, it's different. Yeah, I feel closest to God, like Bible on lap, journal in the other hand, you know, kind of your prototypical quiet time.

SPEAKER_00My husband, he feels closest to God, hammer in hand.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00He, you know, he loves serving.

SPEAKER_03Yes.

SPEAKER_00And so, how do I make sure that he gets all the service time that he needs and wants? And how do I make sure I have that time that I need in the morning?

SPEAKER_04And then coming back to that initial thought, not judge each other, not how come you're not more like me.

SPEAKER_00Oh, told I didn't think my husband was spiritual enough when we were dating because he didn't seek God like I did. Yeah. And instead, we've learned to learn from each other and appreciate that spirituality in each other.

SPEAKER_04Kind of a hot question in a lot of circles, especially because there's been such a long decline of uh church attendance, belief in God, rise of the nuns, rise of what you guys call the ums. Yeah, yeah. Um, and then people are wondering now, has that ended? Is there revival?

SPEAKER_00Yes, that's a question we get asked all the time. Yeah, and ums, by the way, uh we write about this in Future Focus Church. Ums are young people who you ask them, you know, are you connected with the church? Um usually not really, or kinda is the answer. Um, first off, this question of revival, we do get asked it quite a bit, uh, especially by leaders. And I appreciate what Ed Stetzer says. Uh, if you're wondering if you're in revival, you're probably not in revival. So, you know, let me just say, let's use that as a ground rule.

SPEAKER_00Um, there are certainly some exciting bright spots in young people, especially on college campuses. I'm on the board of InterVarsity, InterVarsity crew and other more, you know, independent autonomous ministries. They're seeing some awesome surges in college campuses, you know, spontaneous water baptisms on college campuses. Um, you know, I know someone who's been doing college ministry who's getting a shoulder injury from all the baptisms that she's doing. That's pretty good. You know, so if you're gonna get injured, that's a good reason to get injured.

SPEAKER_00So um, so there certainly are bright spots on college campuses. However, uh, if you look overall at religious participation in community as well as religious practices, we're not yet seeing a surge in young people. Um there are bright spots, college campuses, especially the South. But overall, if we're looking at 13 to 29-year-olds, there's some positive ticks to be sure, but but we would say we're not quite ready to call it revival. Um, I'll go back to our Gen Alpha work though, John, uh, because we we um interviewed not just kids who identified as Christians, but about 50% of our sample.

SPEAKER_00So about 1,500 teenagers didn't identify as Christians, either nuns or different religions. Um and when we asked them about their openness to spirituality, uh, 41% were not open to spirituality, greater spirituality. But if we do the math, that means 59% are. Yeah. Wow. So we we see this generation as being very open to revival. I mean, maybe so post-Christian they're almost pre-Christian, um, more of a blank slate in some ways, not quite as hurt by the church, more of a blank slate, yeah, more open, especially to Jesus.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. How about uh there's been a lot written about uh like the younger generation now engaged in less risky behavior, uh less drinking, less sexual involvement, so things that might avoid problems, but also might not necessarily be driven by virtue acquisition. Yeah how what are you learning about the role of risk in life and what that means?

SPEAKER_00That is, thank you for mentioning that. You know, back to mental health. It's hard to know for sure that it's hard to point to any singular cause that's leading to these mental health challenges with young people. And or, but um, there does seem to be a correlation with cell phones becoming more ubiquitous, more common. Right about that time, mental health risk behaviors increased, and other risk behaviors like drinking, sex, partying, behavioral, drugs, behavioral decreased.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So, in other words, the risk behaviors that one would engage in by themselves in their room when they see other people having a better time on a Friday night than they are, that's going up. Yeah, but the risk behaviors that involve engaging with others are going down. So, so that's one thing I want to say. The other thing I will say is we've been in the midst of our gen alpha research, we've been playing with, you know, what adjectives would we use to describe this generation? And one of the adjectives that's that leaders especially are very much resonating with is they are cautious.

SPEAKER_00They are cautious.

SPEAKER_04Interesting.

SPEAKER_00This is less of a generation that wants to go change the world, like you know, some of us youth group kids from the 80s and 90s wanted to do. This is a generation, uh, you know, again, talking to youth pastors, talking to college workers. When they have a if there's a retreat coming up, a kid doesn't just sign up. Yeah, kid wants to know, okay, where are we gonna sleep and what's the food gonna be? And they just need a little bit more information to feel secure. So uh, you know, I appreciate that ministries are trying to offer more information and schedules of what's coming up and all that, um, so that young people feel safe and can take some riskier steps.

SPEAKER_04So yeah, no, and it feels like something's off with the with the world. Uh developmentally cautious doesn't feel like what we would want for our young people or ourselves when we're younger.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. You mentioned Jonathan Hyde, and we didn't really touch on that earlier, but I think that's I'm so glad that book has made the waves that it has. The anxious generation. Anxious generation. Yeah, I don't know of a book that's sparked more conversation about young people in the last few decades and more positive change.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Schools who are restricting cell phones and families who are, you know, waiting longer before kids get cell phones, et cetera. A lot of really good uh thoughts out of that. But you know, he talks about how this generation or young people in general want risk, but cell phones keep them inside. You know, the Atlantic has said go outside is being replaced with go online.

SPEAKER_04Wow. There's different race online, but it's not like I don't know if this is connected, and I don't know if this is something that your research touches on or that you even would have thoughts about, but there's not much you don't have thoughts about. So I'm guessing it might. Good or bad. One of the one of the trends going on that, as I understand it, is basically unprecedented in human history is the decline in birth rates. Yeah. And uh in 1950, globally, uh women averaged about five children per woman.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Now it's down to 2.2, 2.1 is the replacement.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04A lot of conversation about what's going on with that seems to be not just in the West, maybe a little bit predominantly there. Yeah, sure. People on the right are, you know, trad wives, you ought to have kids, that's your duty. Yeah. People on the left, it's because it's a dangerous world, people are afraid to bring kids in. However, it's it's arguably a less dangerous world than it's ever been before.

SPEAKER_00Ah, right, right.

SPEAKER_04Any thoughts about what's going on there? And in in what ways does that connect, if at all, to what scripture teaches, kind of a faith-infused view of life?

SPEAKER_00Well, you said their thoughts. Well, you said I have thoughts about everything. I actually don't have many thoughts on birth rate, John. So um, but can I say a little bit more about Jonathan Height? Yeah, no, okay, awesome. Uh because this this became particularly relevant for um our family. Uh, my husband's an Eagle Scout.

SPEAKER_03Wow. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So I've become a backpacker.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Because my husband's an Eagle Scout. So, you know, I joke that Dave's introduced me to backpacking and I've introduced him to a good hotel concierge. So, you know, we've rubbed off on each other in a good way, I think. Um, so a couple summers ago, we took our kids uh because of Dave, largely, they love camping and backpacking. And so we took them on a backpacking trip. Each of them got to bring a friend. It was awesome. And the Sierra uh Nevada Mountains, just beautiful. That same summer, we were also able to take them to Cozumel. Um, and we did snorkeling, we did scuba diving because to where?

SPEAKER_00Uh Cozumel.

SPEAKER_04Cozumel is where?

SPEAKER_00Oh, Mexico. Sorry, sorry, Coast of Mexico. Okay. So this amazing, you know, we had a great uh VRBO, Airbnb, view of the water, amazing food, snorkeling, scuba diving, because we're certified scuba, et cetera. And I asked them, because of this idea of Jonathan Height and kids getting involved in more wrists, I asked them, okay, guys, if you had to choose one of these vacations, backpacking or cosimo, which one would you choose? And I went to each three of my kids individually. All of them said, I don't know.

SPEAKER_00Now, let me just say, backpacking is a heck of a lot cheaper than Cosimo. So we're doing more backpacking than kayaking. Yeah. But I think for my suburban middle class kids, backpacking feels risky.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00You know, you have to figure out where you're gonna sleep, and all you have is what you've carried. And I think that's what draws them to backpacking, is they've had a decently protected life, and this feels more risky.

SPEAKER_04Something in the human spirit wants to risk.

SPEAKER_00Totally. And so for us as adults, you know, it doesn't have to be backpacking, but what is it that stretches our kids out of their comfort zone? Is it is it a new art class? Is it a new relationship? You know, whatever it might be, is it a new hobby? Is it serving somewhere new? Is it interacting with people who are unhoused? You know, whatever it might be, can we offer young people the adult support, that adult accompaniment in the midst of the risk?

SPEAKER_04Which just comes back to um caring and being with and actually observing, caring, trusted, Jesus-centered adults, accompanying young people in life and faith. So, Kara, we have been talking a lot about uh the spiritual formation of other people, pastors, church leaders, young people or so. Yeah. Um, let's make it personal. Uh uh generally, when I get kind of to the end of these conversations, I'll just want to know from somebody um, how have you been being formed? What have you found helpful? What's going on in the heart and character and spirit of Carapow these days?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So normally I can answer that by showing you my cell phone because my wallpaper for my cell phone often expresses what I'm learning about these days. And so if we were to look at my phone, um, it would have three short sentences on it. Uh, three or four years ago, our family was in Italy. And night number two, I woke up at like four in the morning and couldn't sleep. And as a parent of young adults, I was worrying about my kids.

SPEAKER_00There were some stressful situations at Fuller I was worrying about. And I've never heard God speak audibly, but I felt like the Holy Spirit gave me three sentences at four in the morning in Rome. Um this is beyond you, let me carry you and watch me work. This is beyond you, let me carry you and watch me work. And just this morning, as I was praying about a situation at Fuller, it's so interesting. I feel like one of those three sentences feels particularly poignant.

SPEAKER_00So as I was praying about something, I felt like, oh, this is beyond me. And I can just rest that this is beyond me. Other times I feel like God's pointing me toward uh watch me work. You know, any one of those three sentences will be like the bold italic capital letter sentence for me. So yeah, that it's been my mantra really for the last three or four years. This is beyond you, let me carry you, watch me work.

SPEAKER_04And it is amazing how um sometimes naming, I have different words for it, but I thought like a thought like this is beyond you, yeah, brings help and some kind of grace or energy or power or something that if I don't name it, it's beyond me, but it feels crippling. And then when I can just say those words, uh it's okay.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. This is beyond me, but the implication is it's not beyond God, and that's what helps me hold the stress I navigate.

SPEAKER_04I I love those. We will put those in the show notes and make them available.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Thank you. Well, uh, this has been a super rich conversation, and um, I am most grateful. Look forward to doing it again sometime if you're up for it.

SPEAKER_00I would love that anytime.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 013. Surrendering Ambition, Facing Despair, and Living a Bigger Life ft. Mark Labberton

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 35 minAudio

    At 17, Mark Labberton hung two art prints across from his bed. In Napoleon crowning himself emperor, he saw the temptation to build a life around his own ambitions. In Picasso’s three figures, standing close together on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. FN002. John Ortberg on Interpreting Genesis & What It Means to Be Chosen

    Oct 28, 202625 minAudio

    What if understanding the ancient world could change the way you read Genesis? In this episode of Footnotes, Jackson Lane sits down with John Ortberg to revisit John's conversation with Old Testament scholar Tremper...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. FN001. John Ortberg on Transcendence, the Loss of Enchantment, and Curiosity About God | Tyler Staton

    Oct 14, 202641 minAudio

    How are we to remain curious about God? John Ortberg and Jackson Lane return to Formation’s debut conversation with Tyler Staton for the first installment of Footnotes, a new post-show where we get to examine John’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 012. The Apple Store Creator on Why the Most Important Thing You Bring to Work Is You ft. Ron Johnson

    Sep 30, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    What if the most important thing you bring to work isn’t your résumé, your expertise, or even your ideas? Ron Johnson helped transform Target, built the Apple Store alongside Steve Jobs, and later became CEO of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 011. This Ancient Creed Can Rescue Us From Spiritual Homelessness ft. Glenn Packiam | 011

    Sep 16, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    This year the Nicene Creed turns 1,700 years old, and Glenn Packiam thinks it might be the most important thing the modern church has forgotten how to use. In this conversation, John and Glenn talk about the difference...

    Credit the people on this episode