Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Fooly Operational: A Star Wars Podcast

Fooly Operational: A Star Wars Podcast artwork

Star Wars: The Living Force

Nov 5, 202611 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

John Jackson Miller's Star Wars: The Living Force gets something beautiful about the Jedi absolutely right. So why did I struggle so much to finish it? I went into this pre-Phantom Menace adventure expecting to love spending time with the Jedi Council. Instead, I found an uneven ensemble story with a brilliant payoff. In this spoiler-filled review, I discuss why the sprawling cast frustrated me, how Qui-Gon Jinn and Sifo-Dyas represent two very different approaches to being a Jedi, and why the ending ultimately won me over. Read my full written review https://mjmunoz.com/living-force/ What did you think of The Living Force? Did the ending make the journey worthwhile for you? #StarWars #TheLivingForce #StarWarsBooks

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

The Living Force gets the Jedi right, but almost lost me. John Jackson Miller is one of my favorite Star Wars authors, and The Living Force sounded like a book practically made for me. A pre -Phantom Menace adventure featuring the Jedi Council? Absolutely. But I have to tell you, there were stretches where I really struggled with this book. And yet, by the end, Miller delivers one of the most beautiful ideas about the Jedi that I've ever encountered in a Star Wars novel. Or movie, or show. So... How did a book that frustrated me so much get something so important about the

Jedi so right? Well, first of all, let me tell you why the book almost lost me. I was really excited to spend time with the Council, but in order to do that, the conceit of the book pushes them to this planet Quen, where they spend time with all these other characters. And besides all of the characters and the side missions almost that they're on, that they interact with, and there's like a hefty amount of interaction with them, we also have this whole... It's not really a subplot. It's really like the main part of the story. It's the main part of the conflict. We have this pirate queen, essentially, Zalastra,

who just keeps getting so much attention in the book. And for good reason. Depa Voav is in deep cover in this sector near where Quen is. And she's dealing with Zalastra, among other pirates. There's five pirate groups. And we just keep spending so much time with them. And it's funny, too, because the book starts off with Qui -Gon Jinn and... Obi -Wan Kenobi which is great because I love those characters um and it gives us this setup that like contextualizes Quinn and what's going on there and it lets us know about the piracy in this I think it's the slice or in this

section of the slice I'm not really sure um but anyway uh Depo's undercover so she's not being a Jedi she's a Jedi but she's not acting as a Jedi and she's doing it alongside Zalastra and Zalastra has this uh girl Kayla who's helping her and It's all this time spent with the two of them, and there's a little bit of looking for Depa, because she's gone missing, and she hasn't contacted them in some time, and they're going to Quinn anyway, but she's there, it's on the way, and Mace wants to go after her, and somebody's warning him not to, and it's this

whole thing. And we spend a lot of time not dealing directly with the Jedi Council, who's the subject of this book, and it really frustrates me. Because it... didn't always work out well now by the end everything ties together but it does it very quickly and almost i don't know like maybe it was so tidy that it was frustrating because it's like okay fine i get it you know you've won me over miller like fine i accept the fact that you had to do this but i still don't like it

um if you contrast that with a book like uh yoda dark rendezvous where the premise is yoda and dooku are gonna have a meeting in secret and it has to be yoda alone meeting dooku alone essentially and you know is it a trap If it is, who's it a trap for? It's this really interesting tension. But there's all these other characters that are in the book. And yet it's like six or seven new characters. And yet I really enjoyed it because I feel like all the new characters in Dark Rendezvous really helped build the context out of who Yoda

is and who Dooku is. And also their relationship as master and apprentice. So that was really satisfying to have the interplay between. the past and the present, and these other characters who are part of the adventure and part of getting to where Dooku is on this other planet, and there's even, like, one character's deeply involved with the backstory there, and Asajj Ventress is in there, and it's just, there's a lot going on, but it all felt laser -focused and purposeful, and it felt like everything contributed. There

were even two droid characters who played a major role in it, and they had, like, such personality and everything that it really worked, and it was wonderful. I believe that was, is it Sean Stewart? Anyway, he did a great job. Amazing book. His only Star Wars book. I've yet to check out his other stuff, but it was really amazing how everything built and just like helped the story. Versus this book, there was so much going on that at some point I went back because I thought I missed something that happened with Depin's last show, but it didn't. Like, I went back and

I... checked out like a 20 or 30 minute section of the book and I was confused and I was like, what's going on? And then I realized, oh, I did hear this, but it's just like so disconnected from the main story. And from what I want to hear, I guess, I don't know, my mind slipped from it or I don't know what, but that was really frustrating to me. The thing that kept me going though, is that I think Miller really understands the Jedi. So again, this is heavy spoilers. So just prepare yourself. I think the most interesting contrast in this book is between Sifo -Dyas and

Qui -Gon Jinn. Sifo -Dyas sees a terrible future and becomes so obsessed with preventing it that he loses sight of the people right in front of him. Which is kind of reminiscent of a Greek tragedy, right? You prevent the doom from coming to you by doing whatever, and it turns out that you have created the own circumstance that's going to bring you down. And Qui -Gon also sees that things are in great danger, but instead of... going down the path of Sifo -Dyas, where

he's trying to care about everything that's going on in the galaxy and trying to orchestrate it. He just wants to focus on doing what's right in front of him, what's right for the people he's near, and he can directly influence, and he'll let everything else work itself out, I guess you could say. Zalastra creates an interesting example because she's hurt by Sifo -Dyas. He's trying to do something, and he's going against the code, too, which I think is very important, and... he harms her and people that she knows

in a real legitimate way. And the council had no idea he was doing this because he was going rogue and doing things on his own. And by the end, they had this big conversation with her and they find out what her grievances are. And they, I think they apologize. And they're like, yeah, sorry, that wasn't us. Sifo -Dyas did the wrong thing. He went beyond what we wanted and what we said was okay. And he didn't defiance us. He was a rebel like you, you frigging pirate. But... i don't think it excuses their crimes at all and i think miller appreciates the difference

between explaining somebody's actions and excusing them but sometimes honestly the way he writes especially uh the two batman books in this one these more recent books that i've read it feels a little bit like he's like sympathizing with the bad guys and that kind of scares me but in the end he pulls together and doesn't um i think it's super interesting anyway um But then getting back to focus on Miller's understanding of the Jedi, which like, so his understanding of the Jedi is that things are complicated and things are hard and things are nuanced and like bad things happen to good people. But that doesn't mean that the good people who are trying to do things the right way and make things good. And

yet sometimes their actions still allow bad things to happen. Doesn't mean they're bad, which is good. So. focusing back on Qui -Gon, he's the only, sorry, he's the one who insists that the Jedi go to Quen because people there actually need help. He experiences this hijacking in the beginning of the book near there, and it's all related back to Quen. So he's paying attention to individuals instead of trying to manage the fate of the whole galaxy, unlike Saipa Diaz. And I think that's what listening to the Living Force is really about. And what's cool is that Qui -Gon's focus on the individual and him telling

the Jedi to focus on the individual ends up saving. So many people. So that's why I think the ending made it worthwhile. The way that everything comes together and closes, comes to a close, is genuinely beautiful. All these seemingly small encounters start coming together and the Jedi end up accomplishing something enormous precisely because they took the time to help individual people, like I said. So all these people that I was annoyed that they were spending time with, like, I'm the target

of this book, I guess. Like, hey. You didn't like this, but it ended up mattering a big deal. Going back to Qui -Gon real quick. Their encounter, his and Obi -Wan's, with these aliens trying to hijack a ship. They end up not killing these guys, which they could have. They end the fight non -violently. They don't even pull out their lightsabers. And they leave them stranded somewhere, marooned somewhere. And they end up getting picked up by Zalastra. And then in the end, these guys end up helping them take down Zalastra. And they get a chance for redemption, too. And it's...

Like basically they don't, they don't really have to change as people. They just have to change their outlook and their mindset and like their morality. So like the things that they're good at, they stay good at those things and they keep doing those things. But instead of using them for negativity, for stealing, for that, for harming other people, they're using them to help people and to do good and to, you know, hire out their services to somebody, um, as like clientele, um, which is really interesting. Um, anyway,

these guys ended up being essential in getting the Jedi masters at the end on Quen to be able to execute this big plan that causes everything Zalastra's trying to do to fall to pieces around her. And it's interesting, too, because Qui -Gon probably could have attacked and killed these guys and been within the bounds of the law and the Jedi code, but that's not enough. He wants to go beyond that. He wants to really deal with these people and help them as people, which I find really impressive. Then there's Depa Balaba and Kyla, this 12 -year -old girl who's been

pulled into Zalastra's world. She's... a criminal, effectively. Depa's compassion gives her a chance at a different life, though, and when you see how these individual acts of compassion come together, the Force almost feels like Providence, weaving everything into something much bigger, which I really appreciate, because that's how I feel like it's supposed to be. I think that's what the Jedi are supposed to be doing, and it's really great. So ultimately, The Living Force is a book I respect more than I love. I think the cast gets unwieldy. I think it spends too much time away from the Jedi Council. And there

were stretches where I struggled to stay engaged. But the ending? The ending really works. Miller reminds us that the Jedi aren't supposed to be people who manage the galaxy from above. They're supposed to be people who listen to the living force and help whoever needs them. And sometimes, saving one life might be how you end up saving millions. That's a beautiful idea, and it's what stayed with me. What do you think, though? Did you enjoy the Jedi Council adventure itself, or was the deeper message about helping individuals

what made the book work for you? Let me know in the comments, and if you want to dig deeper into my thoughts, you can read my full written review at mjmunoz .com slash living hyphen force. There's going to be a link here, though, too.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ahsoka Season 1 is Unfocused |FOOLY OPERATIONAL

    Oct 11, 202328 minAudio

    SHOW NOTES - https://mjmunoz.com/2023/10/11/mjfo-s2e16/ A brief chat on Star Wars Ahsoka as a whole. I think the show was a unfocused. #StarWars #Podcast #Review Fooly Operational CATALOG -...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ahsoka 08 |FOOLY OPERATIONAL

    Oct 6, 202316 minAudio

    SHOW NOTES - https://mjmunoz.com/2023/10/06/mjfo-s2e15/ A brief chat on Star Wars Ahsoka Episode 8. #StarWars #Podcast #Review Fooly Operational CATALOG - https://mjmunoz.com/category/podcast/foswp/ ALL MJ’s PODCASTS -...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ahsoka 07 |FOOLY OPERATIONAL

    Sep 28, 202325 minAudio

    SHOW NOTES - https://mjmunoz.com/2023/09/28/mjfo-s2e14/ A brief chat on Star Wars Ahsoka Episode 7. #StarWars #Podcast #Review Fooly Operational CATALOG - https://mjmunoz.com/category/podcast/foswp/ ALL MJ’s PODCASTS -...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ahsoka 06 |FOOLY OPERATIONAL

    Sep 22, 202319 minAudio

    SHOW NOTES - https://mjmunoz.com/2023/09/22/mjfo-s2e13/ A brief chat on Star Wars Ahsoka Episode 6. #StarWars #Podcast #Review Fooly Operational CATALOG - https://mjmunoz.com/category/podcast/foswp/ ALL MJ’s PODCASTS -...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ahsoka 05 |FOOLY OPERATIONAL

    Sep 13, 202316 minAudio

    SHOW NOTES - https://mjmunoz.com/2023/09/13/mjfo-s2e12/ A brief chat on Star Wars Ahsoka Episode 5. #StarWars #Podcast #Review Fooly Operational CATALOG - https://mjmunoz.com/category/podcast/foswp/ ALL MJ’s PODCASTS -...

    Credit the people on this episode