Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Flirting With Comics

Flirting With Comics artwork

EP 4 - Who even is Clayface?

Oct 23, 202640 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Surprise!! It's an early episode to coincide with the Muddy Menace (I have no idea if anyone calls him that) getting his own feature film! That's right, this week we're diving headlong into Basil Karlo A.K.A. Clayface. You may have seen him on the Harley Quinn animated series, voiced by Alan Tudyk, or in the Bruce Timm Batman: the Animated Series in the 90's, voiced by Ron Perlman. But this weekend, we're getting a new live action, body horror-centric Clayface on the silver screen (as portrayed by Tom Rhys Harries) in the next installment of the ever growing DC Cinematic Universe. Buckle in, folks, this might be our favorite episode yet! If you want to read about Clayface after hearing about him, check out: Clayface: One Bad Day from 2023 by Collin Kelly, Jackson Lanzig, and Xermanico Clayface: Celebrity Dirt by Jude Ellison S. Doyle and Fran Galan (Limited series in publication, 4 of 6 issues out) Detective Comics: the Rise and Fall of the Batmen (2020) by James Tynion IV with various artists Follow us on Instagram @flirtingwithcomicspod! Or check out our website at https://flirtingwithcomics.buzzsprout.com for more!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Hi, I'm Jill DeWitt.

SPEAKER_00And I'm Joey Voigt DeWitt. And welcome to Flirting with Comics, the podcast where I try to get my wife and you, our listeners, interested in my first love comic books.

SPEAKER_02Welcome back, everybody. This is our first time recording since officially launching our episodes.

SPEAKER_00Woohoo! Woo! Yeah, we have a few episodes out there in the world now.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. It was it was a little touch and go with Spotify.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, surprise, surprise. Spotify had some problems. I've always heard that Spotify can be a little bit tricky on the creator side of things, but I've never been on the creator side to see it happen before. It showed up eventually, but it took a little bit longer for some reason.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we were chatting with Spotify's support, trying to get everything figured out, and it eventually showed up like what, four o'clock in the afternoon.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, for some reason it just took a few extra hours, but it's there now. It's been really great to see all of the outpouring of support that we've gotten from our friends and our family.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, people in the community.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, people in the community, Brad and Lisa from Comic Book Couples Counseling, Chris Hacker from the Oblivion Bar. They've been very, very kind and gracious in reposting and getting the word out and helping us with that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's been so fun to get to talk to people about it, hearing lots of people say that it's been educational, which is great because that's our like mission.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we've already gotten feedback that it's working. People are people are learning about comic books from us.

SPEAKER_02Which is perfect. Speaking of which, what are we talking about today, Joey?

SPEAKER_00Before we dive into our topic for today, I kind of want to do a little bit of scene setting with what we are talking about.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00So we almost forgot about this guy.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_00Which is kind of appropriate because he is kind of a like C list Batman villain.

SPEAKER_01Oh, poor guy.

SPEAKER_00Um, we are gonna be talking about Clayface today. So Clayface is a new upcoming movie from DC. It's the next movie in their sort of expanded universe. Yep. It's villain-centric because Clayface is going to be the main character.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um, and it's kind of taking more of a horror angle, which is an interesting thing for them to be trying to do.

SPEAKER_02I love that DC is trying to branch out into different genres and that kind of thing. Like, we watched the movie Brightburn a long time ago.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And that was really interesting to see like a different side of superhero movie kind of thing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's it's interesting when when you can kind of use the superhero medium rather than having it have to be its own genre.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_00So it is going to be written by Mike Flanagan, who, if you are a fan of horror like I am, you know this guy. He wrote The Haunting of Hill House, The Haunting of Bly Manor, Midnight Mass. He is a big name in the horror community.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00And we've got Tom Reese Harry's, who I don't really know a whole lot about, starring as Matt Hagen and Clayface slash Clayface.

SPEAKER_02Woo! Good job.

SPEAKER_00We know that this is probably an obscure character that people haven't heard of, which is why we were like, hey, this is the perfect thing for us to do an episode on, and I can't believe we almost forgot about him.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we forgot about the movie's release, and so we wanted to try and get an episode out in the same weekend that the movie's releasing. So if you're trying to convince people to go with you, or if you want a little bit of background before you go in.

SPEAKER_00You can you can show them this episode and they can listen to it, or you can listen to it yourself to get yourself prepped for the movie.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, because I don't know how deep they'll go into the background. I'm assuming they'll go pretty deep since he is, like you said, he is the main character in the He's the main character, he's also less known. So I'm sure that they'll give us enough context in there, but sometimes it's fun to go in knowing a thing or two.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. This one also might be a little bit messier because I'm trying to figure out, without having seen the movie, which version of Clayface they're going with. There's a few different versions out there. We know that it's Matt Hagen, but Matt Hagen is kind of ambiguous because it looks like they're doing the Basil Carlo origin. So I'll get into that when we do the backstory stuff. I'm gonna try to make it a little bit more streamlined so that it's not too confusing. I am actually really excited though, because I got some tickets through AwesomeCon to go to an early screening of Clayface on Tuesday, about three or four days before it actually comes out in theaters.

SPEAKER_02Nice. I hope you have so much fun doing that because I will not be joining you. Yeah, I am not a horror movie fan. I especially don't like body horror, which is Clayface's whole deal, you know, like the melting face and all that.

SPEAKER_00So the trailers have been made it very clear that it's gonna be pretty body horror heavy.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So I will be sitting this one out, but hopefully you can find someone to go with.

SPEAKER_00I've already got someone going with me, so don't worry, it's fine.

SPEAKER_02Oh, good, good. They can hold your hand instead of me holding your hand.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Alright, Joey, so hit me with the hopefully not so confusing backstory.

SPEAKER_00Alright, let's get into it. So I want to start out by saying that this is a really old character. The first appearance of the Basil Carlo version of Clayface was in the 1940s.

SPEAKER_02Whoa, 40s?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, actually in 1940.

SPEAKER_02Wow, that's way earlier than I was expecting.

SPEAKER_00He was in um the pages of Detective Comics, which, fun fact, Detective Comics is actually what DC comics, that's what the DC stands for.

SPEAKER_02Whoa.

SPEAKER_00So it's actually Detective Comics Comics.

SPEAKER_02You know, I never questioned what DC stood for before. Yeah, it's I just accepted that it was DC.

SPEAKER_00Because Detective Comics was like their big breakout thing with Batman, they the company eventually became called Detective Comics, and then they shortened it to DC, but now it's DC Comics, so it's Detective Comics Comics.

SPEAKER_02Fun. I like that. But ATM machine type, you know? Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_00Or like Chai T.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So the original version of Basil Carlo was a B-list actor turned serial killer because he found out that they were remaking one of his movies without involving him.

SPEAKER_01Oh no.

SPEAKER_00And he went on a murder spree killing a bunch of the actors in the new movie under the guy's clayface.

SPEAKER_02Wow.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was a much more just sort of like down-to-earth kind of tale. He didn't have any powers or anything.

SPEAKER_01Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_00He was just a guy who was wearing this suit that made him look like he was a big clay monster.

SPEAKER_02Uh.

SPEAKER_00And he was just a serial killer, and that really was what it was.

SPEAKER_02Why did he choose to look like a clay monster?

SPEAKER_00I think that it was the character from the movie. It was like a monster movie, and he was using like the suit from the movie.

SPEAKER_02That's cute. I like that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Also, can we take a moment to appreciate the name Basil Carlo?

SPEAKER_00Basil Carlo is a really cool name.

SPEAKER_02Is Basil spelled like Basil?

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah. I don't remember where. I have it somewhere in my notes here, but it's actually um an homage to two different actors.

SPEAKER_01Oh.

SPEAKER_00Um, I don't remember exactly where the Basil comes from, but the Carlo is a a reference to um Boris Carloff, who was the guy who played the like original Frankenstein movie.

SPEAKER_02Oh cute.

SPEAKER_00Um, so it was like it was made as like an homage to that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, like monster movie.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So this for this is the first version of the character. Um, we're gonna talk about a highly revised version of his backstory, though.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00That's just kind of I wanted to give you a little bit of where he started. That's where that's the original clayface.

SPEAKER_02That's the 1940 clayface.

SPEAKER_00Clayface showed up, and he was just a guy that was kind of insane in a serial killer.

SPEAKER_02Sounds good to me.

SPEAKER_00There are a lot of aspects of that backstory that do carry over, though, so it's kind of fun to see where they came from.

SPEAKER_02Okay, yeah. So this is the new backstory that DC rolls with now.

SPEAKER_00This is the the newer uh around new 52, which was in like 2011.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_00Um, they did a big reboot where this is the new 52 origin that I'm gonna be going with for the most part. Just kind of like that specific one.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00There's a lot of aspects that stayed the same. Like he he is still an actor, but there are some things that change, like now he actually has powers.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_00So this is the one we're really gonna focus on for this episode because I'm pretty sure it's probably the one they're gonna be using for the movie. It just makes the most sense. It's the most recent sort of redone version of it. So let's get into Basil Carlo New 52 version.

SPEAKER_02All right, hit me.

SPEAKER_00So Basil Carlo was born to Vincent Carlo.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00I don't know his mother's name. Oh could not find that, but his father was a cosmetic and prosthetic guy for movies. So he was a a big guy that he would make all the cool masks for movies and stuff through the special effects.

SPEAKER_02That's cool.

SPEAKER_00Vincent was disgraced and fired when they found out that his master putty formula called Renew, which is called R-E-N-U, was actually highly toxic. And was causing serious illness in some of the actors it was used on.

SPEAKER_02Oh no.

SPEAKER_00So young Basil grows up to be an actor and he makes it pretty big because he was incredibly handsome. Oh and he was a pretty good actor.

unknownAlright, okay.

SPEAKER_00One of the films that he was cast in was called Second Skin, where he was really, really wanting this lead role because it reminded him a lot of his father and this like Renew cosmetic thing, the like second skin aspect of it.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00Renew was really popular because it was something where it was basically just a like moldable clay kind of thing that you could like put over someone and then Vincent could just mold it however he wanted.

SPEAKER_02Okay, cool. Yeah, that's that makes sense. That's cool.

SPEAKER_00So this the idea of a second skin reminded Basil of that, and he was like, I really want the lead in this movie.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00He ends up getting it.

SPEAKER_02Yay, good job, Basil.

SPEAKER_00Woohoo! But immediately after, like literally immediately after, he finds out that his dad died. Like literally, he's on the drive home and he gets a call, hey, your dad is dead. And he's like, Oh.

SPEAKER_02Not the movie that he was gonna dedicate to his dad.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. He has sort of a panic attack about this. Understandably, he loved his father and he was uh so excited to be dedicating this movie to him.

SPEAKER_01Aww.

SPEAKER_00And he ends up crashing his car as he's trying to drive home and he's on this call. No, and he ends up horribly disfigured.

SPEAKER_02Oh goodness. He's so handsome. He can't take it.

SPEAKER_00In order to keep his career kind of running, he ends up really abusing Renew.

unknownOh.

SPEAKER_00And basically just recreating his old face.

SPEAKER_02Huh.

SPEAKER_00Like just making it look like he was not disfigured.

SPEAKER_02You know what? That's talent.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, it was it was really impressive that he was able to pull that off without anybody ever going. It looks like he had some work done, but I guess it's Hollywood.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, people get work done all the time in Hollywood.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02He could have really uh taken the Hunger Games by storm, PET a style.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, seriously.

SPEAKER_02Painted himself into a little rock, you know.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I forgot that that happened in that movie.

SPEAKER_02I love those movies so.

SPEAKER_00That was a wild idea. Anyway.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_00Um, obviously, him abusing this drug that was known to be able to cause problems for people was not a good thing. It was kind of a bad idea. But ironically, he actually was not suffering too bad from it.

SPEAKER_01Good.

SPEAKER_00I don't know if it was just he was willing to put up with it or if it was just not too bad for him specifically for some reason. The big problem that he runs into is that he starts to run out of renew.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I guess they're not making it anymore.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, because it was deemed dangerous, they stopped making it. It was not for sale, so he had to go try to steal some. He goes to a chemical plant in Gotham City.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00Really physical.

SPEAKER_02Oh, I forgot he was in Gotham City. I forgot he was a Batman villain.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02I forgot this was all happening in Gotham City.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's it is Gotham City. He I feel like a chemical plant in Gotham City is such a classic place where something bad is gonna happen.

SPEAKER_02Yep, yep, you're gonna have to.

SPEAKER_00Especially when you're a criminal breaking into a chemical plant in Gotham City, like you have to know that something bad's gonna happen here, guy.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Though I suppose at this point, he's he's one of the examples. So maybe this was before they had enough examples to point to.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's fair. I mean, he was, you know, he's been around forever.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02He's a classic example.

SPEAKER_00He is. We know what happens in Gotham City when you have a criminal who's trying to steal something, and it usually doesn't end very well for that mentally ill criminal.

SPEAKER_02Nope.

SPEAKER_00Batman shows up, and actually, after talking all of that talk, Batman doesn't ruin his life this time. The aftermath of this is where the problem really arises.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00So after Batman catches him and he is apprehended as a criminal, it makes big news. Hollywood star caught stealing things in Gotham City.

SPEAKER_02Oh no.

SPEAKER_00And with that, the public also finds out about Basil Carlo's disfigurement.

SPEAKER_02Uh oh yeah, you can't you don't have time to put your face on before your mugshot.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he is now outed as having been hiding that for all this time.

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, honestly, it's kind of impressive.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, it's it's impressive, but it's also everyone is gonna feel pretty lied to.

SPEAKER_02Lied to, but also, you know, this day and age, we need to support each other in our in our physical differences.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I imagine that this was the kind of thing where in like the 70s it was a lot more of a oh my god, look how ugly he is.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, oh my god, he's so disfigured.

SPEAKER_00In this day and age, people would he would probably be getting more sympathy than anything else.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um, he does end up losing his career and his girlfriend.

SPEAKER_02Oh, he had a girlfriend.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. She also leaves him because he was hiding it from her as well.

SPEAKER_02Oh.

SPEAKER_00And then Batman decides to be kind of a dick about it. Shocker goes to visit him in the hospital where he's like injured from his run-in with Batman.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, because Batman beats the crap out of people.

SPEAKER_00And Batman shows up and is just like, Carlo, you have to decide who you want to be from here on out. You have a decision to face.

SPEAKER_02Dramatic.

SPEAKER_00Basil Carlo ends up saying, Okay, you're right, I do have a decision to face, and I want my life back.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So he's not gonna give up on stealing that renew. He's not giving up on stealing that dang renew.

SPEAKER_02This is your this is your fault, honestly.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, like honestly, Batman could have been like, let's get you some help instead of showing up and antagonizing him.

SPEAKER_02Batman could have been like, hey man, we're gonna get you some plastic surgery.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, like let's get you some actual plastic surgery instead of using this highly toxic thing that we know you're using and you were trying to steal.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Why doesn't Batman just like get rid of the supply that's in this chemical factory?

SPEAKER_00It's a great question.

SPEAKER_02You know what? Batman eludes me. He he is confusing and at this point it's what he does is what he does.

SPEAKER_00At this point, it's no longer in the factory, though.

SPEAKER_02Oh.

SPEAKER_00So it is now in police custody in a warehouse somewhere.

SPEAKER_02Oh, easier to steal, I feel like.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, kind of.

SPEAKER_02You know?

SPEAKER_00The um the police end up, you know, it's it's contraband and it's evidence. So they end up taking it and putting it in like an evidence warehouse. Okay somewhere.

SPEAKER_02Sounds good.

SPEAKER_00But somehow, Basil Carlo knows where it is. I don't know how he knows exactly where to find it, but he does, and he goes to try to steal it out of that evidence warehouse.

SPEAKER_02You know, he's famous. He's probably got some connections.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's famous, but he's not very bright because I feel like that's so much. Even stealing it from the chemical plant was a bad idea. Stealing it from a police warehouse is not a good idea, man.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, but also what are you gonna do? You're running out.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I guess that's true.

SPEAKER_02I mean, is he rich? Could he try and like schmooze and buy it?

SPEAKER_00Honestly, yeah, he probably could have been bribing someone to just buy it.

SPEAKER_02Or he could have been. It's Gotham City. There's a lot of people. He could have bought some thugs. Ooh, corrupt cops, too. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, or yeah, he could have hired some people.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Anyway, he decides to do it himself.

SPEAKER_00He goes in there and decides to do it himself. The police just open fire on him. They end up shattering vials of Renew all over him in like the classic comic book fashion where the magic goo gets like falls all over him and he goes, no, and he is transformed into the shape-shifting clay-like substance that Renew already was, but alive. And now he is Clayface. After this, he returns to try to attack the set of second skin.

SPEAKER_00They replaced him as lead actor.

SPEAKER_01Oh.

SPEAKER_00And then Batman thwarts him again.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_00And the first time that he shows up as Clayface.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00He's been a pretty consistent member of Batman's very tragic rogues gallery. But he is usually one of the less evil ones.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00He is just kind of tragic.

SPEAKER_02He just wants to be a star.

SPEAKER_00He really just wants his life back. That's all he ever really wanted.

SPEAKER_02Clayface.

SPEAKER_00However, now that he's stuck as a living clay monster, he kind of doesn't have a lot of avenues for living a normal life.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, does he look claymonster-y?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's a man.

SPEAKER_02Or is he like a normal person?

SPEAKER_00So he can shape shift, but he can't really stay shapeshifted for too long.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_00So it's the kind of thing where a lot of times what ends up happening is that he will find a way to live a normal-ish life, quote unquote, by living somewhere, and when he's inside the house, he'll just have all his blinds drawn and be clay monster. And then if someone comes up to the door, he'll quick shape shift into a normal person and be like, hi, what's up? Um, but because he can't stay shapeshifted for too long, it's not like he can go out and do things.

SPEAKER_02So he's kind of Oh, he can't shape shift for is there like a time limit we know of?

SPEAKER_00There's a I don't think there's a specific time limit. We'll talk about it a little bit more when we get into the powers and abilities.

SPEAKER_02That's true. That's true. But um I'm just it's so interesting. I want to know.

SPEAKER_00It is very interesting. A fun thing about Clayface is that because he's one of the less evil Batman villains, he actually occasionally operates as a hero.

SPEAKER_01Oh, good job.

SPEAKER_00There's been a couple of times where he has shown up and actually fought alongside Batman.

SPEAKER_02Nice. Thanks, buddy.

SPEAKER_00There was one time where he lost his memories.

SPEAKER_02Oh.

SPEAKER_00Because the clay that makes up his brain was damaged. And so it kind of just erased his memories.

SPEAKER_01Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_00And Batwoman took him on as a member of sort of a ragtag team of like people who were just trying to be heroes. Cute.

SPEAKER_02What was that team called?

SPEAKER_00It's called The Outsiders. The Outsiders is kind of a weird team where it's never very consistent, not like the Justice League or anything.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, kind of like a in and out.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_02What's that DD style called? West Marches.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, West Marches.

SPEAKER_02If you're a nerd, yeah, you don't understand a West Marches campaign where people just kind of pop in and out at their It is kind of the West Marches of superhero teams.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, where generally it's not even a there's not even like a specific person who's in charge. It's usually either Batman or Batwoman.

SPEAKER_01Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_00But like who the actual members are really just kind of changes all the time.

SPEAKER_02Depending on the scenario.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. That makes sense. Okay, cool. Sorry for sidetracking us there. That's fine.

SPEAKER_00So after that, another hero known as Ragman, who we will talk about someday.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00Ragman attempts to set him up with a new life and basically just let him have a normal life. Because he loses his memories to the um to the point where at a certain point it's actually that he doesn't even remember the fact that he is a clay monster.

SPEAKER_02Oh no.

SPEAKER_00He thinks he's just a regular guy. So Ragman like gives him a fake social security number and stuff and is like, just go be a normal guy then.

SPEAKER_02Oh, thanks, Ragman.

SPEAKER_00Um, unfortunately, his clay body, because it does regenerate, eventually repairs itself and his memories come back.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. That's good.

SPEAKER_00And he ends up in Arkham Asylum.

SPEAKER_02Aww.

SPEAKER_00Where he actually helps Batman a couple of times during some breakouts that other villains do because Clayface is just sort of like, look, I don't belong out there in the real world, so I'm gonna just stick around here.

SPEAKER_02That's so cute. That's so sad.

SPEAKER_00However, he does actually also at one point decide he's gonna just break out of Arkham himself.

SPEAKER_02Okay, sure.

SPEAKER_00Arkham's not a good place to be.

SPEAKER_02No, I can imagine.

SPEAKER_00But this time that he breaks out, Batman has this sort of realization that, like, Clayface has definitely shown enough of an ability and a desire to be better.

SPEAKER_01Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_00So he says, Alright, I'll give you a chance. And he offers him a position on the Gotham Knights team.

SPEAKER_01Oh.

SPEAKER_00Also has Batwoman, has a Batgirl, um, Batman, obviously. There's a Robin on the team.

SPEAKER_01Which Robin?

SPEAKER_00It's Tim Drake, Robin.

SPEAKER_01Okay, okay, okay.

SPEAKER_00And they all kind of just work out of a big tower, and it was a run in Detective Comics a little while ago.

SPEAKER_01Oh, a little while ago.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was it was in like the like 2017, 18, I think.

SPEAKER_02Okay. Why'd you say Detective Comics? Because that was instead of just DC?

SPEAKER_00That's the book it was in. Detective Comics.

SPEAKER_02Oh, that book is still in.

SPEAKER_00That is still a book that runs, actually.

SPEAKER_02Oh, I didn't know that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, they took it on as their name, but they also still run Detective Comics.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Is that what Batman comics are like usually run out of?

SPEAKER_00So it's it's a weird thing where they have Batman comics and then they also have Detective Comics.

unknownOkay.

SPEAKER_00Which is usually a Batman stories anyway.

SPEAKER_02Okay, cool.

SPEAKER_00It's just Detective Comics has a little bit more leeway to just be about Bat family. So it sometimes it'll be focused more on Robin or more on Batwoman.

SPEAKER_02Okay, cool.

SPEAKER_00As opposed to the Batman book, which is always Batman.

SPEAKER_02Sweet, sweet. There's a little bit of insight into the comic world for you.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, a little bit of insider info.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It's the same thing actually with Superman as well. They still have action comics and Superman. Right.

SPEAKER_02Can you imagine if we had AC and DC as our two big comic powerhouses? Yeah. AC DC.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's also a band.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I knew. So he's funny.

SPEAKER_00Um, however, not long after he joins this team, things go bad for poor Clayface again.

SPEAKER_01Oh.

SPEAKER_00Uh, Basil Carlo is in a battle where the villains basically in Inject him with something that gets into his clay and basically just drives him insane.

SPEAKER_01Oh that's terrible.

SPEAKER_00Destroying a bunch of the city, he just goes mad.

SPEAKER_02Oh man.

SPEAKER_00Batwoman seemingly kills him.

SPEAKER_02Oh no.

SPEAKER_00With a bullet that is designed to dissolve him.

SPEAKER_02That's brutal.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's pretty brutal.

SPEAKER_02Dang, it is a poor guy.

SPEAKER_00It is revealed pretty quickly after, though, that he had split off a part of himself, and that part survived because it wasn't attached to the rest.

SPEAKER_02Good, good. Yeah, that would make sense if he can just like pull off a little piece.

SPEAKER_00As it stands now, he does have some like bit parts in other stories, but he is one of the Batman villains who truly does desire to change and wants to do better.

SPEAKER_02I feel like we don't have a lot of those, so that's good.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, especially Batman villains.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It is usually either people who are judging him and society won't let him do better. Or it is also sometimes explained as like renew because it has altered his body. It has also sort of altered his brain chemistry.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. That makes sense.

SPEAKER_00So it goes back and forth. Sometimes his usually his return to the side of good is tentative.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It's a little tense because everyone is like, You're Clayface, dude. You're a giant monster, and as we will talk about, he's like kind of really, really powerful.

SPEAKER_02Oh, okay. Very cool.

SPEAKER_00So that is Basil Carlo, Clayface.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00The other version that we have in the movie is Matt Hagen. Matt Hagen. I'm not really gonna go into Matt Hagen's backstory because uh what a lot of people will do is that Matt Hagen and Clayface are sometimes written as just being the same person, where Matt Hagen is his birth name and Basil Carlo is a stage name.

SPEAKER_02Oh, okay.

SPEAKER_00So I'm wondering if that's kind of the angle they're gonna take, or from a lot of the trailers, it kind of seems like they're basically just doing a Basil Carlo story, but they're using the name Matt Hagen.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00Basil Carlo is kind of a crazy name.

SPEAKER_02Basil Carlo is much better of a name. Every time you say Matt Hagen, I think you're talking about the actor. Yeah, I mean it's just the dude's name.

SPEAKER_00It is a very plain name, which I think is part of the reason because they're this DC universe, they're kind of trying not to go like, well, that's not even true. They are kind of going crazy with the comic book stuff. So maybe they just didn't like the name Basil Carlo.

SPEAKER_02I guess. I don't know. Maybe maybe that's that'll be his stage name, like you said in the movie.

SPEAKER_00So maybe.

SPEAKER_02Who knows? Okay, cool. Is there like a is there like a main difference you can give us between Basil Carlo's background and the main difference is that Matt Hagen is usually not an actor. Okay.

SPEAKER_00Matt Hagen is normally just a criminal who ends up getting turned into clayface.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_00Um, he's not as much of a tragic character. He's just a bad guy who ends up becoming clayface.

SPEAKER_02Okay. Yeah, that is much less interesting.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a lot less compelling.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So it sounds like combining them is probably a good call for the movie.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think so.

SPEAKER_02Cause, you know, I feel like we could have the criminal isn't a tragic accident. Oh no, now his life is so tragic. Maybe we feel bad for him a little bit. But the Basil Carlo backstory is much more compelling, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Alright, so now that we've got a good idea of where he came from to get where he is now, let's dive into what this guy actually does. Cause it's crazy.

SPEAKER_02Powers and abilities time, baby.

SPEAKER_00Woo. So, like I said, Clayface is actually kinda like insanely broken when it comes to his powers.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_00Because his body is made of this new shape-shifting clay, he can shape shift into basically any form.

SPEAKER_02Ooh. So, like animals too?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Dang.

SPEAKER_00His shape shifting is fine-tuned enough that he can imitate a person almost perfectly as long as he has like seen the details. Like down to the fingerprint.

SPEAKER_02Whoa, that is impressive.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it works really well with his skills as an actor.

SPEAKER_02Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_00That he can kind of disappear and become a do another person pretty easily.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, definitely.

SPEAKER_00There's also seemingly like no size restriction to him.

SPEAKER_02Oh.

SPEAKER_00It kind of doesn't make sense matter-wise because like it doesn't make a whole lot of sense. But he can shrink down to be like the size of a bug. Or if he wants to, he can expand himself to just like fill an entire room.

SPEAKER_02Hell yeah, that's so cool.

SPEAKER_00He can also stretch his limbs to like super long lengths when he wants to, kind of like Mr. Fantastic style, just like stretchy arms.

SPEAKER_01Cool, cool.

SPEAKER_00It's also um because it's e it's a clay-like substance at base, but he can actually control the density of it a little bit as well. So he can make it more like liquid, or he could make it as hard as stone.

SPEAKER_02Fun.

SPEAKER_00He can regenerate from damage, basically any kind of damage.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And even missing limbs, he can just regenerate.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that makes sense.

SPEAKER_00Or if he has his hand cut off, he could regenerate himself back from that hand.

SPEAKER_02Ooh, starfish style.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, basically.

SPEAKER_02Cute. Can he turn into objects?

SPEAKER_00He can, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Nice. He's like running away from the cops and he just like turns into like a mailbox.

SPEAKER_00He could. I I don't think I've ever actually seen him do that. It's kind of an underutilized thing. What he'll do more often is he's the kind of he'll do the kind of thing where he like turns his hand into a big hammer and smashes people with it.

SPEAKER_02Cute. I like that. That's fine. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00He also is um super strong. That super strength is basically uh usually it's kind of scales with his size because he can like grow himself. He'll get really big and then also be really strong.

SPEAKER_02Sure, why not?

SPEAKER_00His ability to like split into other pieces can also be pushed to like super crazy levels. There was one point where he was working with Batman during the Gotham Knights arc where he split himself into 100 people.

SPEAKER_01Whoa.

SPEAKER_00And turned them all into looking like GCPD police officers.

SPEAKER_02Oh.

SPEAKER_00And then use them to just like guide evacuating civilians.

SPEAKER_02Aw, that's sweet. So they were like fully like moving people.

SPEAKER_00Fully fully moving, fully autonomous people.

SPEAKER_02Wild.

SPEAKER_00And then he just back up to into himself again later.

SPEAKER_02That's so cool.

SPEAKER_00It is sometimes even said, this is the one that I I feel like is the most insane, but some sometimes it has been used that he can uh transform himself down to the DNA, which means that he can mimic other metahumans' powers. Because he could just make himself DNA-wise into a Kryptonian.

SPEAKER_02Whoa, that's crazy.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that is insane. That one is a lot less common. That I think is one where That's like overpowered, yeah. It's happened before, but they kind of realize that that's a lot to do. So they were like, maybe we don't want to let him be doing that all the time.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, how would you beat Batman if you are like Superman all the time, but you don't have well, I mean, I guess down to the DNA, maybe he'd still react to Kryptonite, but Yeah, I mean he would. Yeah. So I mean that's but still, like it's still it's still really crazy. That's really powerful. Do we have anybody else in the DC world that like mimics powers?

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_00There's Amazo.

SPEAKER_02Okay. I feel like I I like remembered that happening. Yeah, Amazo.

SPEAKER_00Amazo is the is usually the one where it's it's an android that can mimic people's powers. Okay. Once it like touches them, it can basically mimic their powers perfectly. Cool. But it's the same thing where usually because he's mimicking their powers, he's also mimicking their weaknesses. So he takes Superman's powers, but then he now he's weak to kryptonite. He takes Martian Manhunter's powers and now fire is is a problem for him.

SPEAKER_02Got it, got it. He's a bad guy, right?

SPEAKER_00Yes, he is a bad guy.

SPEAKER_02Okay, cool. Anyway.

SPEAKER_00Clayface also has um a little bit of like basic combat training.

SPEAKER_02Sure.

SPEAKER_00Um, once he started working with Batman, Batman was like, Let me teach you how to fight.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that makes sense.

SPEAKER_00Um, so that you're not just a guy.

SPEAKER_02Can you imagine just like Timothy Shalmay getting these powers and like having to like throw a punch to like kill somebody or something?

SPEAKER_00Like without formal training, it's like that that's kind of the thing, is like Batman was like, Look, you're really powerful, so I need to teach you how to fight so that you're not just throwing random wild haymakers and like busting up the city.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we kind of like our city um unbusted.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Well, as much as unbusted as Gotham can be.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, Gotham's always kind of busted. Kind of busted. But that is about it for his powers and abilities. They're really, really over the top, but they are not as uh not as in-depth.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I love a character with like a wide range of abilities.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Like you can do so many different like cool stuff with your powers, and then you know, it's able to able to show your personality too, kind of.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, show your creativity off a little bit.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And let the writers be creative too.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's true.

SPEAKER_02All right, now we know his background, we know his powers. Hit me with personality.

SPEAKER_00As we've already kind of talked about, Basil Carlo is one of the more tragic Batman villains because he genuinely does just want to get back to his life.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00A lot of the time, the only reason that he's doing a lot of crime is because he doesn't really have a lot of choices. He can't just go work at a regular job.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So he ends up stuck doing crime because it's basically his only avenue anymore.

SPEAKER_02So he like robs banks and stuff.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he'll go rob a bank because he's like, hey, I gotta pay rent.

SPEAKER_02I need money.

SPEAKER_00And nobody's gonna hire Clayface.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Oh, can you imagine Clayface just like working at a little ice cream shop?

SPEAKER_00That was exactly what I was picturing too, for some reason. With like his little uniform and I was picturing him with like one of the little like paper hats from like old-fashioned ice cream shops.

SPEAKER_02Oh, and that's so cute. I feel like somebody has art of that somewhere.

SPEAKER_00I'm sure they probably do.

SPEAKER_02If you know Clayface's art of him working at an ice cream shop, super specific, but send it to us. I need to know.

SPEAKER_00Or if you make it.

SPEAKER_02Or if you make it, yeah. Hit me up. Show it to me.

SPEAKER_00Clayface is usually kind of a vain dude, though.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00He's pretty full of himself because I mean, he was really handsome and a pretty successful movie star.

SPEAKER_02It doesn't hard to be humble.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's not surprising.

SPEAKER_02Yep. At least Tom Holland is short. You know, that really keeps him in check.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, keeps his ego in check.

SPEAKER_02Although now he's married to Zendaya, so.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Ego out the window, I'm sure.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Love him.

SPEAKER_00Carlo is not usually the best person, but it's usually more portrayed as he's just like a guy who made it big in Hollywood, which usually requires you to be not a great person.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00So he's not like dangerously insane or anything. He's just kind of an asshole.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. A little bit full of himself, maybe a diva.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, a little bit of a diva.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00Despite his super monstrous appearance, Basil Carlo is still a normal guy at heart who just wants to be normal and live a normal life. Except that's usually not like where it ends, because for him, a normal life is being a Hollywood star.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So that's much much different of a normal life than most of us.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So he will make attempts to get back to that life, to that life of stardom.

SPEAKER_02To that level.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's usually when he says, I want a normal life. It's I want to go back to being a star and I want to get my life back, not just a life back.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. It's kind of hard to fall from grace like that, you know? Yeah. It's a big life difference.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And even as Clayface, he does make some attempts to kind of like keep that fame.

SPEAKER_02Oh, cute.

SPEAKER_00Um, one of the comics that I'm gonna put in our poll list is a great example of that.

SPEAKER_02Can you imagine like Clayface starting like a YouTube channel?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02He starts a YouTube channel and like gets monetization. He works with brands.

SPEAKER_00What's up, guys? This episode is sponsored by Monster Energy because I'm Clayface.

SPEAKER_02Oh my god. That's so good. I was gonna say, like, maybe it's Maybelline.

SPEAKER_00Maybe he's born with it. Maybe it's renew.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Oh, that's so good.

SPEAKER_00Alright, well, that's all I've got for personality. So now we can move into our final section, Jill's final thoughts.

SPEAKER_02Uh-oh, here we come. I feel like I actually have a lot to say about the clayface here, so I'm excited. Yep. All right, let's jump in. I have waited until the very end of the episode to talk about my favorite clayface depiction in the Harley Quinn cartoon TV show.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Oh man, you know, you don't see Clayface on the big silver screen, but he's in the cart the cla Harley Quinn cartoon and he is so sweet.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. They they do a good job in that show of portraying the sort of feeling of he does just want to be famous. That's really his biggest drive, is like, I just want to be a star.

SPEAKER_02I just want to be a star. In the show, he is kind of he's super full of himself, but he's like not a good actor.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02So he like really tries to do these like shows and stuff, and it's like not working.

SPEAKER_00That's one of the big liberties they took with that depiction, is that they made him uh a shitty actor.

SPEAKER_02Him a bad actor.

SPEAKER_00Normally he's normally it's portrayed as him being at least pretty decent. Like he's not terrible, he's just an okay actor or a good actor.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So if you want to see some clayface on screen, hit up the Harley Quinn TV show. It's really, really good. I love it a lot.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Okay, so now into my more round, full final thoughts.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, your general clayface just thoughts.

SPEAKER_02Um, so generally I like him as a character. I think it's really an interesting story. I think that they have a lot of room to play with the character and his abilities.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he is he's got very creative powers, kind of like the hard light constructs, too.

SPEAKER_02Exactly, yeah. I love something with a lot of like variations, super, super cool. So I would love to see some versions of what he can what all he can do. Yeah. So I also love with his powers how randomly powerful he is.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he's not like a big character, but he's very, very powerful.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, like I think it's really fun when there's like a C-list character that's like ridiculously powerful.

SPEAKER_00And he's a great example of that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Like, you know, Harley Quinn is powerful in the fact that, you know, she's really like combat trained and that kind of thing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02But she's not so powerful like Clayface.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, she doesn't have the superpowers to back it up.

SPEAKER_02Exactly. So I think that's so interesting, the idea of like him fighting Batman and like that kind of thing. So yeah, but I think it's also really interesting that he's not like full-on villain.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02He's more like a half villain, half hero, but like not as hero. I wouldn't go as far as to call him an anti-hero because he's certainly not heroic most of the time.

SPEAKER_00He's usually on the wrong side of the law.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. Would that make him like an anti-villain?

SPEAKER_00Not quite, because an anti-villain is usually more like Sinestro, where they're pursuing good noble goals with bad means.

SPEAKER_02Oh, interesting. You know, I've never heard the term anti-villain before, so that makes sense. But like that's that's cool. That's good to know. Yeah, that's interesting. So yeah, he's basically just super morally gray, just kind of doing what he needs to to get by.

SPEAKER_00I think he kind of fits well into in DD terms, chaotic neutral.

SPEAKER_02Ooh, yes. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_00He's not gonna follow any rules, he's not gonna follow the law, but he's not doing good or bad necessarily. He's just kind of doing his own thing.

SPEAKER_02In a very chaotic way. Yes.

SPEAKER_00With no no real moral code. He's just like, whatever.

SPEAKER_02I love that. I think that's perfectly accurate.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he sometimes he decides today. I feel like doing good and helping Batman evacuate the city. And then the next day he's like, I need money though, so I'm gonna go rob a bank.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Do most of his crimes consist of like money?

SPEAKER_00Usually, yeah. It's either money or like personal vendettas.

SPEAKER_02Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Okay, yeah. Like going after the set of that movie. Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. That makes sense. Yeah, but those are my thoughts of Clayface. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00You got a pretty good idea for the character. The Harley Quinn show definitely helps you have like more of a feel for him, though.

SPEAKER_02You know, guys, if you don't like reading comics, and it's not that I don't like reading comics, it's good. I just don't do it. But if you like engaging with comic media, then you know, TV shows and like cartoon shows are super, super great.

SPEAKER_00Very low barrier of entry.

SPEAKER_02And for some reason, I think that the like cartoon shows are easier to get into than like the like nitty-gritty like live action shows.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's usually a little more fun to watch. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02So it's definitely the Harley Quinn show does not take itself too seriously.

SPEAKER_01Not even a little bit.

SPEAKER_02Oh my gosh. I have been dying for a new season, and I don't think we're getting it, and I'm so sad.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02We had a cliffhanger. But don't let that stop you from watching. It's a really good show. It's still worth it. Yes, absolutely.

SPEAKER_00All right. Well, that's gonna do it for us here on this episode of Flirting with Comics.

SPEAKER_02Thank you so much for listening.

SPEAKER_00Follow us on Instagram at Flirting with Comics Pod on your preferred podcasting platforms, and please just do us a favor and leave a rating.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, go ahead. If you're on Apple Podcasts, they let you like write a review if you want to, or just DM us and let us know what you think.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we'd love to hear your thoughts.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Our poll list for this episode is Clayface One Bad Day from 2023 by Colin Kelly, Jackson Lanzig, and Hermonico. And for the first time in flirting with comics, I'm gonna be recommending an ongoing series that is currently in publication called Clayface Celebrity Dirt by Jude Ellison S. Doyle and Fran Gallen. And Detective Comics, The Rise and Fall of the Batman from 2020. It's that Gotham Knight storyline where he is a hero by James Tynan IV with various artists on the book. So, you think you're gonna read any of these, Joe?

SPEAKER_02Hmm. I'm flirting with the idea.

SPEAKER_00Well, thank you guys for listening. Maybe we'll get her next time.

SPEAKER_02Thank you for listening and see you in the next issue.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. EP 7 - Who even is Doctor Octopus? (feat. Arden DeRenzo)

    Nov 15, 202653 minAudio

    Welcome back, flirty flock!! Today we have a very special episode of Flirting with Comics as we have our first ever GUEST lecturer! We're joined by our wonderful friend, Arden, to discuss their favorite comic character...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. EP 6 - Who even is Jean Grey?

    Nov 9, 202650 minAudio

    Welcome back again, everyone!! Today on Flirting with Comics, we're diving into another character that recently showed up in Spider-Man: Brand New Day, Jean Grey A.K.A. Marvel Girl or the Phoenix. In Brand New Day,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. EP 5 - Who even is the Punisher?

    Nov 1, 202633 minAudio

    Welcome back, flirty flock!! Today on Flirting with Comics we’re diving into the Scourge of the Underworld, the Murder Messiah, the Terrifying Embodiment of the Second Amendment, Frank Castle A.K.A. The Punisher! He’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. EP 3 - Who even is John Stewart?

    Oct 18, 202638 minAudio

    This week on Flirting with Comics, we're finishing out our Lanterns trilogy of episodes by talking about the other Green Lantern protagonist on the show, portrayed by Aaron Pierre, John Stewart. One of DC's first Black...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EP 1 - Who even is Sinestro?

    Oct 11, 202630 minAudio

    You might've heard about this guy, he showed up in the new DCU project, HBO Max's Lanterns, but only just for a bit. You might be wondering who this guy is and why he's SO important to the main cast. Jill sure was. So...

    Credit the people on this episode