Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

FLF, LLC

FLF, LLC artwork

Christian Nationalism or the American Option [The Pugcast]

Nov 16, 20261 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today’s Pugcast was recorded live at The Weight of Glory conference at the Evangelical Reformed Church of Tacoma, Washington. It is a discussion between PCA pastor Zach Garris and John West, Vice President of the Discovery Institute, on Christian Nationalism, moderated by our own Glenn Sunshine. Zach supports Christian Nationalism, the idea that the government should promote true religion and enforce all of the Ten Commandments; John supports what he calls “the American Option,” a government built around the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights. The conversation covers much more than those topics, and it will be illuminating to anyone interested in learning about the whole debate around Christian Nationalism. Learn more about the Theology Pugcast and contact us: https://www.theologypugcast.com/ Support the Theology Pugcast on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/thetheologypugcast?fbclid=IwAR17UHhfzjphO52C_kkZfursA_C784t0ldFix0wyB4fd-YOJpmOQ3dyqGf8 Learn more about First Pres. Battle Ground: https://www.solochristo.org/ Connect with WileyCraft Productions: https://wileycraftproductions.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

Hello and welcome to the Theology Podcast, Stunglen Sunshine, and this episode was recorded live at the Evangelical Reform Church of Tacoma at their The Weight of Glory Conference. I was the only one there, so I get to do the intro here. The topic is a discussion, really, between Pastor Zach Garis of the PCA and John West, vice president of the Discovery Institute. On the question of Christian nationalism. Pastor Garis takes a Christian nationalist position, meaning that he believes that it is the responsibility of the government to enforce the entire 10 commandments, for example. John West opts for what he calls the American option, which basically is built around the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, the Bill of Rights. So we have the discussion between the two. As moderator, I thought it was my job to stay as neutral as possible. You can decide how well I did that. But for the record, I should acknowledge that I really lean far closer to John West's side of this and Pastor Garis. Like I said, you can determine how impartial I was as a moderator, but I hope you enjoy the discussion. Thank you. Hello and welcome to the Theology Podcast. It's great to have you with us. I am not C.R. Wiley. I am Glenn Sunshine and I'm the sole pups on this particular episode. I'm a retired history professor, senior fellow at the Colson Center for Christian World View and I write. And today we are actually at a conference at the Evangelical Church of Evangelical Reform, Church of Tacoma. So. And in the conference, we have had some lively discussion between Zach Garis and John here, our friend who has been on the show before. And so I'm going to have each of them introduce themselves and then we'll get started with what we've been talking about. So Zach, why don't you go first? Hi, I'm Zach Garis. I'm pastor of Bryce Avenue Presbyterian Church. It's a PCA congregation in White Rock, New Mexico. So it's Northern New Mexico there. I'm John West. I'm vice president of Discover Institute in Seattle and a distinguished scholar of American government and Christian civic engagement at Cornerstone University and Grand Rapids, Michigan. And had a new book out this year called Endowed by Our Creator, The Bible Science and the Battle for America's Soul. Okay, very good. Now, what we've been talking about is under the broad category of Christian-Major Plism. Now this is a what is proper relationship between the government and the Church. And Zach and John have different views on this. So I'm going to ask them each to summarize. And once again, we'll start with you, Zach. So the summarize, my position is basically I think the civil government should promote Christianity as part of the public good. And I think that includes laws related to the first table of the Ten Commandments. So those things such as blasphemy, laws, and Sabbath laws. I think those are permissible. I think there's a prudential question just because something is permissible doesn't mean every magistrate or every civil government should enact particular laws. So there's prudence here. But that was a big part of my argument is that all Ten Commandments are moral law and natural law. And therefore the government can force laws related to those things. So there's two jurisdictions, the state and the Church. So I was a firmman in separation of Church and State, but trying to explain exactly what we mean by that. I reject the concept of a secular state. So I think that's probably a summary. There was other things I touched on of course. Okay, when I talked about with something called the American Option, which I think goes back to the American founding and after, which is a state where you have a limited government that defends earthly peace and justice, but also protects liberty. And so it's limited to, so earthly matters, but eternal salvation. So it really doesn't have power over the doctrine or worship or practice of the Church. So it has limited government, which includes religious liberty. It includes government based on the laws of nature and nature's God, which is a term that our foundation is used. That actually has deep resonance with Christian thought in history. And it means both the laws that God wrote on our hearts that Paul talks about in Romans, but also the laws of the Bible, like the Ten Commandments, or founders thought that those things formed one moral law that spoke together. And so I think that is the moral standard, if you will, that is appropriate for society. And then the third part of the American Option would be having the role of churches in a free society to be able to proclaim both the gospel and morality and try to create the virtues that are needed for a free society to flourish. So as part of this, I am very skeptical of giving the government any authority over what's heresy or not or the actual doctrine of worship. And I think that maybe we can discuss, because some of the things that Zach talks about, I wouldn't necessarily disagree with. For example, just wrapping up, I think that a magistrate can by his own personal example demonstrate Christian truth by his exhortations, by defending religious liberty, which defends the right of churches and parents to raise their kids, according to their Christian convictions. So I think there are things that in our system that government officials, especially if their Christians should do, but I draw a clear line when it comes to doing anything about determining what heresy is or not, or telling pastors what they can or cannot say. And I'm very interested in our conversation of turning tees out, because some of the people we've written with actually do argue on those things. I'd like to find out maybe you disagree with them. I think actually that's a good place for my first question. Where do you two agree? So, we'll start with Zach. Where do you see yourself in agreement with John's position? Yeah, I think we actually have a lot in common, things on which we agree. So I jotted some down, so I'm going to mention some of them, and of course John can correct me if he disagrees at a point. I think we would agree that we want moral and just laws, especially things related to marriage and protection of life, abortion and the like. We both value the American tradition and the Declaration of Independence, Constitution, the founders. We may have some differences over interpreting, applying those things, but we certainly value highly the American tradition. We both seem to want Christians in government. So we want Christian magistrates, but there's maybe some questions about what they can do. We both want a firm proclamations. I heard of like the president having a call for a day of Thanksgiving, things like that. I think we might have some agreement on Sabbath laws, maybe like possibility, and what that means, possibly different bases for that. He quoted John witherspoon and Charles Hodge, so I we share some appreciation for for those fellows. They said they both had some different things at different points. So there's questions of their views overall, but related to civil government. I affirm what he was saying about institutions outside of civil government being important and having influence. I think that's of course the case, whether it's the family or other just, you know, businesses and civic organizations and the like. I think we'd both agree that America has had a special, Christian is a special influence on America, and America just tied with Protestantism and things here. I think there's questions of why that's particularly the case. It's not necessarily due to government related to regards to Europe, but there's issues there. I think we both oppose leftist totalitarianism. I think we can oppose that. I think both of us would condemn Nazism and are not interested in, and ideologies like that in America. So I think there's a fair amount of agreement. We're both conservatives on the right generally, but there's obviously some differences. I actually think that's a pretty good description. I'll just say on where we agree. I'll just say on the big issue, I do appreciate Zach's, you know, bringing up and some of the people that he cooperates with that make the point that Christians day who want to settle for a nation of just Christians are one among 10,000 and that with, with have a permanent minority voice and that you shouldn't be concerned with actually trying to build culture or build institutions. I agree with that that's a problem. And I think that that, so that mindless sort of pluralism, that's not my goal. And with regard to Sabbath laws, I'll say, I don't think that Sabbath laws inherently are a violative of religious liberty. I actually think in today's society, there are bad ideas, there are other ways to reach those things. But I think if done in the way that was discussed in the 19th century, as the reason was to provide rest from secular labor and to not violate the religious liberties of the Christians who couldn't work then and also to make space so that people could get into the head and church, there's really three big reasons that in most of the arguments, certainly over Sunday males that were made, I think those are consistent with the American system. I happen to think because of the complexity of modern society and other ways to reach some of those things, like saying that you don't have to work on your Sabbath and that's probably not a good idea for today. But I wouldn't classify that in the same level as punishing heresy or commanding that people go to church if they're baptized or punishing false teachers or things like that. So I'm going to ask each of you, do you have any questions or clarifications you'd like to get from the other? But start there and then we'll see where that heads. So Zach, is there anything you wanted to ask John about? Yeah, I would love for John to expand on religious liberty, the concept, so let me maybe clarify a little bit here, because my take would be more than liberty. We want liberty to do what is right and to worship God rightly. So I would understand religious liberty more to relate to Christians. We might have some disagreements amongst Baptists and Presitarians and the like and we're looking to the scriptures. But I don't think that necessarily extends to just anyone. And so I'm thinking of things like Islam or Mormonism and even some of the practices related to things like polygamy, which that runs into, so if it's a religious view of a matter like multiple marriages and multiple wives, where that comes in, I mean, there was like federal pressure on Utah to drop the practice and they did. So I would be like, well, that was a good practice of interfering with their religion. So, and John would probably agree, but I'll let him comment that. So maybe I'll have some follow-ups here, but like, I would ask like, okay, what about liberty for atheists? You know, John Locke opposed that, my understanding. And are there other limits on religious liberty? What exactly is this look like? Great question. And I think historically and even today, yeah, there are limits to religious liberty. So I think the issue, just like their limits to freedom of speech, there are limits to all sorts of things. Proper use of things can be abused. Now, having said that, I think the issue is what are the limits. So for religious liberty, you mentioned polygamy or, I mean, say, with Islam Sharia law, say, for example, or their view of women or some other things. I take Christian science, you know, thinking that kids can't have necessarily surgery that they need. These are things that have been well recognized, you know, from the very beginning of debates. And that's why when I talk about the laws of nature and nature as God, I think there are limits. If someone wants to do child sacrifice or violate the base of natural marriage, those are things that you can regulate. If you're talking about where I would draw the line and where I think, even the early Christians in the first three centuries, because they weren't just, just be clear, when the Christians like, like, Tenshius or even before Tertullian, when they were arguing for religious liberty, they were arguing for it because Christians were being persecuted. But they were also, they were arguing based on appealing to universal principles that they said were applying to everyone. And so I would say when it gets to whether a, you know, the state should be able to regulate what your pastor says on how you get, you know, saved, how you should worship your doctor of speaking in tongues, you name it or in, you know, if you're a non-Christian and believes in it, non-Christian God, I think that, which I would consider probably a demon, I think it is bad news to give the government authority over that. And I based that off of the reason I gave it my talk, basically, our current situation, but also the biblical teaching and the example of the church in the first three centuries. And then the wisdom of experience where when Christians thought that the magistrate should have the power to regulate heresy and punish false teachers and even call synods and oversee them to make sure that they had the right doctrinal result, it turned out really bad. And just one example of this, because this one that Joel Webin, Pastor Joel Webin, when he's promoting that the government ought to be able to tell pastors that they stay in their lane and that they get to and say things that he doesn't like on politics or culture that the government should be able to penalize them, he's sighted at the beginning the role that Constantine played in calling and convening and overseeing the first council of Nicaea. Now on one hand, well that's a great story. It produced the first version of the Nicene Creed, doesn't that great? It is until you actually understand a little more of what went on, which Joel Webin, at least in the podcast I watched, didn't bother to cover, is that by the end of Constantine's life, he was actually varying towards supporting the Aryans with state power who were against Trinity, the Trinitarian conception. And then when he died, his kids really went in that direction so much so that then state power that had been used to convene that council and enforce the Nicene Creed for a while was then used to enforce and persecute violently Christians who actually like Athanasius, Athanasius actually wrote about this and actually wrote about how satanic this thing of self identified Christians persecuting each other. So I guess for me that I'm more concerned about the limits, not so much on religious liberty, I think there are, and even the courts today recognize that there's some things you can't do against the moral law and I'm all for that. But when it gets to theological doctrines about salvation, about even generic worship practices, including for non-Christians, I think the wisdom of experience, I don't think the Bible commands that persecution and the wisdom of experience makes it very, very, I'm very, very skeptical that that would ever be a good thing. Okay, I follow up there. So, I mean, my understand with some of the history and like Virginia and some of the southern states, maybe all of the colonies and the like is, the Presetarians and others, they were working towards, well, they want a toleration of their own churches and preaching, but also, you know, working towards religious liberty, it seems like it was somewhat pragmatic as like the Baptist, you know, and Presetarians and Virginia wanted, you know, they didn't want the Anglicans to be the state church, they wanted things to expand. So, it just seems like someone's always in power and all of this with government is a power play. And so like the idea of neutrality sounds nice or some of these limits to religious liberty and morality and the like with the government. I understand what you're saying, John, I also, and just not sure it works, like it seems like we're either going to have leftist like secular totalitarianism or atheism or Christian government, like what we've had lately has kind of been a mix. We still have Christian remnants, but secularism has certainly been on the rise. And so, I guess maybe a couple of practical questions, how do we, how should government approach things like the public schools, which definitely got co-opted by secularism? So, that's one, and then two, can't this view just lead to Islam basically taking over in America, because we're not going to have some religious stand as a government against letting Muslim and things like that. So, there's kind of two, there are two practical ways to approach it. So, with regard to Islam, let me say, and you did ask that before, so thank you for raising it again. I think when you talk about immigration, and this actually comes from earlier in the conference that people watching, listening when we get, you know, we discussed on what basis of someone really in America, and I hold the view that there are lots of fundamental beliefs in our in our founding documents that that provides guidance. If you're someone who wants to impose Sharia law, and everyone, if you are someone who has a view of human rights and the functions of government that is incompatible with the American system, then we're perfectly entitled, in fact, I would say, even obligated to keep you out. And it's not just Islam, say, if you believe in the laws of manoeu as your creation story where you are not created equal, you're created into either the head of the God, and then you rule, or you're a sudra class that is, you know, is, you know, beneath everyone else to serve everyone else, and that's how you think you don't think all men are created equal. You actually believe the opposite. It all be it is for religious reasons. I think that's incompatible with our founding principles, and so perfectly, you know, to keep that out. So, I'm not one who at all is for unlimited immigration, let alone, if you're a vowed atheist, Marxists who thinks that the government is your God, and that there are no God given rights, I think that's a problem. And historically, we have actually had restrictions like that. Now, would you favor, like the federal government taking a position or having laws that would favor Christians and immigration and disfavor non-Christians? I probably would not, but I would get at that at the way that we have certain founding principles on God given rights, on limited government, on consent of the government, on that humans are sinful, so we're not going to be able to install a utopia here through our own power on earth. And that if people do not have the culture or the genuine support of that, those are grounds to keep them out, and I think that screens out a lot. And so I would prefer to do it that way than try to, because of course, for one reason today, you can say, Christian, I will tell you here in the Pacific Northwest, people's definition of what a Christian is is all over the map. And so I would prefer, I think, the better way would be to focus on our founding principles, and that really is more reflective, I think, of the broad sweep of our history. And so it may get to some of the same things that you're talking about, but in a little different way. But public schools, glad you raised that, because that is, I would say, the people who think that public schools, oh, is last 50, 60 years, and the Supreme Court is responsible, and I'm not saying I agree with all those Supreme Court opinions that you cited. But actually, the problem with public schools go back to the very beginning of public education. If you look at Horace Mann in the early 1800s, and these were liberal Christians, or Unitarians, if you look at John Dewey at the turn of the century, the whole problem was taking away from the church and the family education and giving it to the hand of the state. So the problem with public schools, number one, is government schools, government is doing something that throughout most of human history, families have done. And then after that, churches have started and other institutions. And so, but here's where it gets, and this shows why religious liberty is actually so important. So one of the reasons it is so hard in a place like Washington State, and in many states, to have state supported funding for families who want to homeschool or send their child to a Christian school, is because of something known as the Blaine Amendment. And if you don't know about the Blaine Amendment, you should, because it's a very cautionary example of what evangelicals should be concerned about. So in the 19th century, evangelicals thought, oh, we're in the majority. So let's create a constitutional amendment that forbids any state funding of any church-based school. Now, why were they doing that? Well, they thought, well, the church-based schools were going to be Catholics. We don't like Catholics. We disagree with them. Well, we'll control, in some degree, the public schools, although it's sort of almost a deistic, it wasn't really a Christian education, in public schools, it's sort of a deistic education. And so that's fine. And that's what the government should do. They try to get a constitutional amendment. Fortunately, evangelicals in the 19th century failed. Because if they did, all of these school choice that now in something like 20 states have opened up so that you don't have to send your kids to government schools, would have been dead on arrival for the constitution. Unfortunately, although the evangelicals in the 19th century, the Protestants weren't able to get the constitutional amendment, they got it inserted in the state constitutions of places like Washington State. And one reason historically, Washington State doesn't have any of the funding for religious schools and things, or the funding people be able to use their tax dollars for that, is because of that plain amendment language. What have it been better? What have, how education been better had the government may clear that they could support the schools of the choice of the parents? I think on the whole, it would have been, does create some issues. If you have Islamic or other parents, but on the totality when you have a nation that even today, 60%, 56% claimed to be somewhat, Christian at least culturally, would that be better to let parents raise their kids and effective, more effective, I think it would be. So I think there is a problem with public education, but I actually think it's because unfortunately some Protestants were not sufficiently attuned to the dangers of using state coercion to try to get their way. Yeah, I agree with a lot of that. I think the privatization is where it should have gone, but the problem is we have the public schools and there are problems. So it's kind of, I guess the question is kind of like how we approach them now, you know, because because they are training kids and anti-Christian ideologies. The question is, I mean, it just doesn't seem feasible. I mean, there's a lot of things that seem feasible with them, but, yeah, but I think that is the problem is the way they exist now and they're not neutral. They're not religiously neutral. So I think that's true. I think what doesn't seem feasible now, there has been, again, in this state we're kind of enslaved from it because we're at the bottom of a lot of things. But the number of states, just within the last five, six years, who have almost universal school choice now, states with huge parts of the population that they've actually fought the teacher unions and won and in many of these states, actually you can use it for the home school of your choice. And I think that's the problem with the government's choice with very limited government regulation. That has been a huge sea change even now just rolling out. So there is a major major shift underway and I just want to encourage Christians, especially anyone watching this, if you're in one of those states, make use of that and make sure that you elect people who, who preserve that and don't repeal it. And having said that with the public schools we do have, I do encourage Christians to run for school board and do their best. But I think that long term, the solution is not trying to prop up failed public schools, but I think we have some agreement on that. Okay, I'm very interested. So, you know, I don't want to assume that Stephen Wolf and things he said speaks for you, even though you've collaborated with him. So I thought, I'd like to drill down a little bit in your talk. You mentioned Sabbath laws. You mentioned blasphemy, although the example you gave to me more seemed like profanity using Jesus' name in vain, which is a little bit different. And we can maybe delve down a little bit. But Stephen Wolf in his book, and even in the reform Christian politics, gives a lot of other examples. He specifically says the magistrate has the right to punish heresy, false teachers, to have a rule over doctrinal assemblies so that if, you know, they, to make sure they come out right, to, you know, exercise some jurisdiction. And I agree that there were reform thinkers who did argue this. I think it's wrong. I'm wondering your view in principle, does the government have the appropriate role to punish heresy, false teachers, make sure that that ecclesiastical assemblies come out with the right doctrine. So I already mentioned in this conference with people don't know that you do disagree with Stephen Wolf's claim that the government can forcompel people, baptize people to attend church. So that's one area where you seem to disagree with him. But what about punishing, you know, heretics and telling pastors what they can say. And again, I don't want you know, people I think, well, this is just a cheap shot. You have people like Joel Webman who is proclaimed by Stephen Wolf as a friend and even someone who, who a collaborator with him, who specifically advocating that the government tell ministers that stay in your lane and that you get too far left or right in political or, you know, social cultural matters. The government will issue penalties on you. And so that is how you know, it's not just Stephen Wolf saying this. That is how some of his most vociferous supporters are also saying it. So I wonder what your views on those specific cases punishing heresy, you know, the role over ecclesiastical assemblies. And if you have anything more to say about compelling church attendance, but you've already actually dealt with that. Although you did add the qualifier, the baptized kind of after. So which I think still raises a problem. But, like there's questions. If the, if the churches are not carrying out discipline. So if you have a baptized person, they've never been expunicated that does raise a problem. There's never been any formal discipline. Hopefully they're not on a church rolls or something like that. But let me speak to the heresy. I do think the public teaching of heresy would fall under a second commandment violation. So I think this gets into kind of my, maybe the application, my argument related to the first table. I do think it's permissible for the civil government to regulate such things. Again, I do think there's a potential question. And there are obviously concerns if the government's going in the wrong direction. I think the fact is that we do have a heresy laws and blasphemy laws like the left is trying to police these things. So there's always a power play with the government. Trying to police speech and what we believe. And, you know, so we're always working towards protecting Christian righteousness, whether it's Christian conduct in the workplace, being able to hold our Christian views. The left's always trying to punish us for what they would consider to be our heresy because we deny, you know, jackamon egalitarianism or feminism or whatever it is. So again, I don't think that I don't think that is outside of the permissibility of the magistrate. And I think that's, you know, basically the the historic reform view, but there's still is a potential question. Doesn't mean I'm pushing for laws, you know, in America. 26 right now because of, you know, there's some other things that need to dress. Can I ask follow up here? The role of the government is to roll out true religion, who determines what true religion is. I mean, we might say Christianity, but Mormon will tell you their Christian, the Jova's witness will tell you their Christian. And if we want to define true religion, who gets to do it? And if it is the government, aren't we then giving the government the authority over over doctrine of theology? I think the government already makes those decisions. We have, you know, Thanksgiving's a federal holiday. It's Thanksgiving to God Almighty. It's not to some, you know, Hindu God. I realize the concern, but this is why we want Christian magistrates who are actually Christian making Christian determinations because these things are there's already plenty of laws and things related to this Congress already has chaplains they still do. I'd like to see, you know, that one of them's a female. I think that's bad. You know, I don't want Paul white as a religious advisor to Trump. There's these things are already there. I'm just asking for more Orthodox conclusions. So I think this is inescapable. I'm glad you're is it because that is a common thing. Well, you know, everyone is doing it. And so we need to do it. But I, I, that's, that's convenient. But I said, I actually reject that. Say, let's come in America right now. Is it true that people want to shut down what Christians say sure they do? Is it true? Well, let's put in this way. England, which does not have our our bill of rights or or the First Amendment or some other things. It has a state church. And are you freer in England to proclaim the truth of the Christian gospel then or in America? And I think it's hand down in America. And it's not. So this idea that in America that although there's social disapproval and other things that there isn't actually genuinely more freedom for the faithful church that because left wingers are trying to shame people. And yes, they are. So if that's all you mean by, you know, opposing heresy that's not government. Most of the things that you're talking about here in America are not that you're, you know, suppressing heresy is not done by the government. There are hate speech laws that have largely been in many instances in America, unlike in Canada or unlike in England, that have actually been struck down. So in fact, most of the things that you're talking about punishing heresy is by private parties here. And if all you mean by that is that Christians should forcibly speak out against heresy and blasphemy like when the president portrays himself in a meme as if he's a Jesus-like figure and that he should be shunned by Christians for doing that. I'm all for that. Or frankly, when someone like Michael Spangler, who's a now defraud pastor from the OPC says that we need a Protestant Hitler or or Cody Justice or what Cory Mueller saying that Hitler is in heaven, I think that's blasphemous. And I'd be happy, but I'll be honest. I'm not speaking specifically of you, but on the Stephen Wolf Joel Webman, a lot of the people in that crowd. They're interested in punishing blasphemy, but I see blasphemous stuff from fellow Christians, pastors and government officials that they don't say squat about. So what do you mean to be really serious about suppressing blasphemy if we're not even calling out and disciplining our own members if they engage in that? I think we should kidnap blasphemers. I mean, you mentioned some of it by some political figures. I mean, I think that's reprehensible. And if we had a godly Congress, they would just impeach and remove presidents and judges and all of these people who blaspheme Christ publicly. So I wish we did have that. And that would be, I think, perfectly reasonable grounds to do so. I think that's consistent. Well, I think the blasphemy laws, I mean, we can talk more particularly. Again, I think you can be against blasphemy or profanity. And that can be handled through social disapproval and other things. Historically, and this is right now, the Christians who are largely being executed and going to death row in Islamic places, it's over blasphemy. And if you look at how Christians applied blasphemy, let me give you, fortunately in America, although there were blasphemy laws by the 17th, 18th century, they were rarely applied. But let me give you an example of one of the few think times it was applied in Maryland in the 1700s. They had a blasphemy law. You had a sea captain or just reading about this, this last week in a history of actually dealing with blasphemy laws. It was a sea captain. He spilled hot tar or hot pitch on his leg or on his feet. And so then said things that were blasphemous. It wasn't just in his room. So people heard it. So he was brought up on charges. He was convicted under Maryland law. What happened to him is they took a hot poker and board through his. His tongue not once, not twice, three times. And then he was put in jail for a year. That's in Christian America. I find it very hard to believe that Jesus was happy with that. Jesus, who on the cross says, father, forgive him, please note not what they do. I am concerned about blasphemy and profanity. I think churches and Christians, if you actually look on social media, the use of profanity and things by Christians and of course, language by Christians. Many self identified Christian nationals. In fact, it's sad to say that on social media, if you have a person who says Christ is king in their bio, probably like 60% chance that they're blasphemy and God calling their other Christians, fags and gays, other things. I've been called that by some of these people when I appeared on the Jeremy Boring show. And so there I go, well, where are these churches and the people who are in the Christian national who say that they're concerned about blasphemy and profanity and of course, language when like it's like rampant and it's not just with the trolls. Yes, everyone has trolls inside. It's with leadership like Joel Webman, who is embraced by Stephen Wolf. I'm not sure Stephen embraces Joel Webman or everything Webman says, so I do think we should distinguish these and I'm not Stephen Wolf. He can speak to some of these. I think you should debate wolf. I really do. I think that would be good to, you know, you go out with the book. You're right. You're right. I did. Yes, but you keep talking about him and not me and my views. So, you know, Wolf is a political theorist. You guys could, could hammer out some of these details. I'm primarily a pastor in theologian. There's obviously some overlap. Wolf and I also complement some in our skill set, which is why we work on the book. So I argued, you know, first table, I don't think John, you've refuted what I've argued about the permissibility for the magistrate to enforce laws related first table. I think my argument is sound. I don't think you've defeated it by any means. And so I think we still disagree there and you're going to go on to some other things. I understand, but I'm not embracing Joel Webman's comments or anything. So there's stuff we can nail down here, but I still think my argument stands. I don't know if you hold, you know, more of the R2K position. It maybe kind of sounds like that. I don't even have even read those people. So I'm not I'm hold what I consider what I called the American option that's based on my reading of American history and American founding. And I, you know, we disagree about whether I refute or not. I mean, I again, I think current experience is the idea that the government should have any authority over church doctrine or punishing heresy. I think is which you've now said in principle, you think you agree with Wolf on that. But I think, especially, potentially maybe they can, maybe they can't. But I, you know, based on I can't think of any politician that I think in America should have control over what my pastor says. what true doctrine is, I think the history of the church and the teaching of the Bible, going back to the parable of the wheat and the tears and some other things I talked about in my talk, do not support that function of civil government and I think that the experience of state, impose orthodoxy also doesn't support it because again, it goes back to who's gonna determine. It wasn't just Catholics and Protestants or Catholics and Protestants, persecuting non-Christians as an example I gave in my talk, John Bunyan, who everyone in this room probably thinks it was a great God, I think he was a great God. He was put in jail for 12 years by fellow Protestants for being, you know, unlicensed illegal preacher. And so I just think that, and I also think it's a false choice that it's either we're in a secular, a godless society or the government has to do it. I have a much more limited view of the role of government. It's important and yes, it is under God, but I don't think it's charged by God to try to bring people to eternal salvation or be really the defender of true doctrine. But, so, but you know, people can disagree about whether that's a reputation or not. Okay, I do. Can I jump in for a moment? Yes, my show. You are the moderator, right? I have another question I'd love to ask on something he wrote. Yeah, well, you mentioned the R2K position reformed or as you prefer radical to K. The original version of two kingdom theology came from Luther. And what he said is God has to do K. There's the left hand kingdom, which is the government and the right hand kingdom, which is the church. Both of them are instituted by God. Both of them are there to promote true godliness, but they do it using different means. And they've got different, they're both working in the same direction, but in different spheres and with different means. Is that roughly where you are in terms of what you're arguing? The Luther would argue that left hand kingdom, the government should be working using its proper means to promote well, to religion. The church does the same thing, but using different means. Is that generally where you are? Yes, but I don't love Luther's approach overall. So the reformed orthodox, and there's a great book by Jonathan Beakey, he's nephew of Joel Beakey. And it's on the twofold kingdom of Christ and published by Brails, so they're always overpriced. But it's still a good book. And anyway, he shows, I think, demonstraly shows, that the reformed orthodox, they refined some things after Calvin, and they basically affirmed this twofold kingdom of Christ, which is, you have church and state, Christ rules over both, but in different ways and media tourally over the church. But still is ruler over the state. And so that would be a support for some theological, for some of what I've argued. But yeah, some of the R2K, like reformed two kingdoms, they're kind of, they're applying some Lutheran stuff. I think those guys do tend to be Lutheran on something. I'm not a Lutheran, I'm a Presetarian. So I would cite more of the reform, I'd appeal more to the reformed orthodox, though I wouldn't say Luther's always entirely wrong on all of that, but just some distinctions. Yeah, the R2K is really different from Luther's, but that's why I ask a question. But anyway, back to John. So another concern that I raised actually at the end of my talk is that another part of the project, and this is defended by Wolf to some degree in the book that you co-authored with him, obviously not in the chapter that you wrote, is a form of ethno nationalism, and my concern that a lot of the people that certainly Wolf has dealt with have used that, I think, really no, no biblical question really should be associating with, and he's had a hard time disassociating himself. But you want, but that's Wolf. So I want to focus on something that I read that you wrote. You wrote a piece in Chronicles about Robert Gabney, the Southern Theologian, and someone wrote in a criticism of it pointing out that they thought he had left out an important point that Gabney, I think it was after the Civil War, you'll be able to correct me if I'm wrong. Gabney basically was opposed to allowing Black ministers to have any authority over white ministers. And he thought that that was relevant, but in your response, you make a comment that racial hierarchy is not something that I really did, I took it, and so I'd love to have your discussion, but let me phrase it this way. In your view, there's a hierarchy of the races, racial hierarchy, is that consistent or inconsistent with biblical teaching, holding that there is a racial hierarchy? And this is based off of something I read that you wrote. Yeah, I mean, when we're talking about race, you have some biblical categories, the nations and some ethnicities might be better there, but I don't deny the category of race, but I think it's an extrabiblical concept referring to groupings of peoples and the like. So hierarchy, I would need to know what we are referring to. I'm not trying to affirm some caste system or the like. And so what I was commenting on there is that Gabney's views in the post Civil War era and dealing with the church were circumstantial, and he was dealing really with the state of the culture and education of freed blacks in the church. So I don't think we're in the same circumstances today, and so some of that's just trying to understand him historically, but I think it would be good to turn on to the question of equality in this ties in with the propositional nationhood. All men are created equal. I think we all affirm that in some sense, it's in the Declaration of Independence, but I don't think it's always clear what it meant or what everybody understands it to mean. So Gabney there understood it to refer to a legal equality, which would be the English view. And I mean, Mel Bradford has also written on this, and this is, you know, he debated Joppa on these things, where Bradford said, refers to the colonies acting collectively against Britain, not speaking of all individuals. You have to read it in context of the Declaration as a whole, which was a secession document, by the way. And it wasn't an abolitionist document, so when you're dealing with slavery, I realize this gets into things like slavery, and which the Bible speaks to. But I maybe just throw it back to John, I'm curious, how exactly you understand all men being created equal. You know, obviously I think we defermed that all men are human, and there's some rights related to that governmentally, but I'd love to hear your views on that. Well, that's great. I'm actually encouraged. Anyone who wants to know my views on that is to get in doubt by our creator, because I go seven ways that I think all people are created equal or how the founders thought. But we can get to that, but I'm a little bit confused. So I want to, I'm not trying to trap you. I'm trying to actually understand this is what you said in response to the criticism of your article. You were defending Dabney, yes, he was a creature of his time. That was part of your defense. But you start out by saying, there are two issues being raised by your critic. The first is whether biblical hierarchy extends to racial hierarchy. The Bible does not specifically address this. Though the Bible affirms that all humans are made in God's image and that Jesus redeems people from every nation, there is nothing in scripture that teaches that all men are created equal. So what I'm trying to get at is you seem to be punting here and maybe you didn't intend this here. So do you think racial hierarchy, you use the term here, is inconsistent or consistent with biblical teaching? Here you seem to say the Bible doesn't address it. So you're saying that the Bible doesn't tell us whether racial hierarchy is bad. And then you say there's nothing in scripture, this direct word that teaches that all men are created equal. So your view here seems, when I read it, it seems to say that actually, so if you believe that, that's great, but that you don't think scripture teaches that. That seems to be what I'm saying. So I use racial hierarchy because that's what the critic of my article was using. So I was saying he's bringing up an issue that's not a biblical issue. And I was explaining what even Dabney affirmed is that all humans, regardless of race, are the image of God. I think they're gonna reflect that image differently, even sanctification, scripture, the New Testament speaks of us being renewed in the image of Christ. And so we don't all reflect it equally in that regard. And so, yeah, I guess I don't know. I mean, obviously there's differences between ethnic groups and racial groups. And this gets into the equality problem, is if you take, if you just all men are created equal, you could take that away in a sense of like the Jacobin and the egalitarians and the French Revolution. I think that's wrong. I don't think that's what Jefferson or any of the American founders meant. I think they rejected that. Many of them were perfectly fine with slavery. They had some qualms, but they didn't mean, I don't think they meant the declaration to overthrow slavery. The Constitution allowed for even slave importation until 1808. So more slaves coming in. So they certainly were not abolitionists, which you seem to infer in some of your other speaking and writings, but they were not. So I think we do have this disagreement on equality, but it really depends what we mean. I'm not using the word hierarchy in relations to races. That was a response to that man's question. OK, well, so what do you think? The idea of racial hierarchy that say there are some races that are meant to be subordinate to others is unbiblical and the biblical that are incompatible with biblical teaching. I don't think scripture teaches that any particular race or ethnic group is to be subordinate to another people. No. Great. That's great. Can you tell us who Addy Sellingbushes or Stellingbushes of the Pactum Institute? He's saying John. John Adrian Slaibhush. Yes. Slaibhush? Yes. He's a he writes with a Pactum. Pactum Institute, he's a PhD philosopher. And I think that's what he's in is in philosophy. Self-described kinest who publishes Michael Spangler actually making the argument that some races are meant to be over others. And didn't you publish a book by him? I mean, I did no longer. But I had published a book by him and had nothing to do with race. OK. But do you think he was on the question? But so you don't think this is great. I'm wanting to give you an effort because some of your associates don't want to disassociate. So you're saying that you don't think that the views of the Pactum Institute and him are actually really biblical or appropriate. I frankly haven't read a lot of their stuff. So I don't listen to a lot of these guys. But you brought up ethno nationalism. I'd like to know exactly what you mean by that, specifically. I've heard wolves say it's a political question. So I'd love to know exactly what you mean. And whether it's permissible, I assume you would consider like Japan, ethno-nationalist or something. So homogenous people group or something like that. So I'd like some more definitions. If you're going to throw out terms like that, even kinism, they use broadly. It's like throwing out racism nowadays. Everybody's a racist. So what do we mean? We need very clear definitions of what we're going to talk about. I was using terms used by the other people. I mean, Slam Bush calls himself a kinest and publishes Michael Spangler, so I think it's pretty clear what he means by that. It's Steve. I'm going to define it for our audience, but because I'm not sure they know. Well, I mean, it actually is tied to blood and soil the end of idea of races and that only, that basically you should stick with people of your blood. And now you're right when Stephen Wolf talks about ethno-nationalism. That's the way I use the term because that's what he talks about. He's, and many of the reviewers of his book have pointed out, it's hard to actually ascertain exactly what he means because he sort of goes around. And various times he's said that say intermarriage, racial intermarriage, ethnic intermarriage is a relative sin. Then he sort of backtracked on that. He says at one point in his book that no nation properly speaking can have more than one ethnicity. And he certainly does tie it partly to blood and biology. But he's in the reform Christian politics. He sort of backtracks a little bit on that, how central it is. So part of the issue is it's hard to ascertain. But when he has been conjoined with these other high profile people who definitely have those views, or even you were citing Emmy Bradford. Emmy Bradford, I know it. I mean, I know that a graduate student, I actually saw some interactions with him. He was an old-style confederacy is the height of Christian civilization. Now I'm using a little bit of hyperbole, but I mean, why would one really look up to Emmy Bradford's view on Christian civilization given his views of the South? I mean, I'd say, and so that does seem to me. Tell me what was wrong with the South. Well, I'd encourage people to read the speech called the Corner Stand of Speech by Alexander Stephens. He was the vice president of the confederacy. And shortly after the confederates gave a new constitution, which Christians praised because it invoked God. I would say it was kind of blasphemous for the new vote, God. Stephens gave a speech about the cornerstone of the new confederacy and why it was so much better than the old union. And he actually cites the biblical talk about being the chief cornerstone. Well, who's the chief cornerstone? Who's actually being responded to in that in the Bible? It's Jesus. But that's not what he's talking about as the cornerstone of the confederacy. Although he's explicitly citing that biblical teaching and he's transforming it. The chief cornerstone of the confederacy is the new teaching from science that blacks are biologically inferior and that unlike the union, which was based on the false idea of human equality, the confederacy was going to last because it was based on the new truth of science. That's the new cornerstone of their edifice that blacks are inherently biologically inferior. So that's what I think was wrong with the conspiracy. So I actually looked this up. So Stephens, he actually, this is found as journalist found on line, you can find out what he comes. He actually says that the reporter did not accurately represent everything he said. And so like one line here is I did not say nor do I think the reporter represented me as saying that there was a slightest change in the new constitution from the old regarding the status of the African race amongst us. You could read the whole thing, but I think there's some problems with just going to that. Quote, the other thing I would, and I would say I don't, he was the vice president just because he says so. And even if, even if that's accurate, when necessarily represent everyone as part of the confederacy, there are various views amongst the confederates on various things, even regarding slavery. But I would note that there were many orthodox Presetarians who would even be called pro-slavery, like Thomas Smith. I would even throw a davenée in there and Thornwell. They affirmed the equality of all races in the sense of their all main image of God, brothers in Christ. Thornwell said we're happy to call the black man our brother. So, and these are the so-called pro-slavery theologians of the self. Smith defended this stuff, the unity of the races in this regard, against the Harvard scientists and the Unitarians who were peddling the racial, you know, Darwinist theories. And would you have concerns or I think that's right to have concerns over them. I'm just saying that's not a fair view of the South to say that all of the confederates or all of the, you know, southerners, even those who defend its slavery based on Scripture, held this distorted Darwinist view. It's just not true. And so I think you have an inaccurate view of the South. And in fact, you like the Declaration of Independence, John. So do I. It's a cessation document. If you affirm the principles in it, don't you also affirm the right of the colonies and the states, it became the states, to secede. That's an American principle. I think they had the right to secede in the South. I know there's debate over the exact causes. Obviously slavery is part of that, but there was some specifics related to it. But, you know, that's the American tradition. The South, the Confederacy had the right to leave and they did. They just lost the war. So they lost the election. And so actually, did they have the right to secede? They did not have the right to secede. So there was illegal. It was illegal because they lost the election and they were bound by a constitution. And the constitution was not actually violated. So they didn't have to. The right of revolution, just to be clear in political theory, the right of revolution, including in the Declaration of Independence, which talks about this long string of years or patience, is not a general right every time you lose an election. So what happened in the election of 1860 was the, the Democrat vote was split. They lost the election. And so even before Lincoln was inaugurated, could do anything. And Lincoln actually said he wasn't going to interfere with slavery in the, in the deep South because the Constitution wouldn't allow it. They seceded. And that was, it was the opposite of the election. It was the right to do so as part of the free states. The state that compact was an agreement amongst the states is a federated republic. They could leave it any time. You even had the Hartford, you know, those guys thought they could leave. You can. So Democrat government is impossible. This was Lincoln's point. No, no. Lincoln's is wrong. Lincoln was the revolution. This is the problem. I think you hold neo conservative views, Lincolnian views. I'm a paleoconservative. And I like Mel Bradford. And I think he was right about the Confederacy and that regard. What about blacks? You don't know. I don't know everything he said about blacks. So I'm not going to speak to that. I'm. Look, with regard to Stephens, I just have to say, I understand that after the Civil War, he tried to say that the reporters, and there were a couple different reports based on that some of the things might have been wrong. He, I don't think he, he claimed that the overall thrust of what he said in the cornerstone address of making, you know, slavery and black inferiority that that, in his view, the vice president of Confederacy. I don't, he didn't, I don't think he denied that. And anyway, what he did say later in his journals was well after the fact when it was like politically toxic to have been saying those things. And so, but even more generally, yes, there were Christians who supported, but I think that's a tragedy. I think that is a rule for us today, the same people who criticize a Tim Keller or other people for not being, you know, appropriately applying Christian standards. I think it is appalling that anyone would want to justify chattel slavery in the South because even apart from, apart from Stephens, the fact of matter, Protestants prided themselves in being able to read the Bible for themselves. Well, what did the South do? It made it illegal to teach slaves so that they themselves could read the Bible. The Bible says that actually kidnapping people in the slavery is punishable by death. Well, how are most of the slaves brought here? They were kidnapped. So I mean, they're, and then the Bible says, I think I don't think it's entirely correct that a lot of the Africans lost wars. And so they were, they were war captives. You have that categorical testament. And then they were, they were, they were, they were, they were then sold. I don't know how much we want to get. There's a lot of complexity. Well, this is, this is illuminating. This is illuminating. Yeah, well, actually, it may be illuminating, but we're running out of time. Okay. So I actually had one question that I would like each of you to answer in a minute or two. So really brief. Given where we are and given your vision of where we ought to be, what are the next steps? In practical terms, what can we do to move in the direction of each of your visions, given the fact that I think we all agree that we're not either of them at this point. So is that cool that you go first? I think we first need more Christians going into politics. As far as if we're talking specifically about government, is that what you're talking about? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So I think that's important. I, I think the church has its job to do. But when we're talking about government, I think we do need more Christians going into law and politics. I think we've just really gotten out of those vocations and we're suffering for it. So I'd like to see more Christians, more Christians in politics, more Christian magistrates. I think John probably agree with that. Though maybe we have some differences over how they would get fleshed out. I think politically we also need to restrict immigration. I think immigration is really the big issue of our day. I think if we get flooded with people who are unlike us religiously, but also culturally in other ways that that we're just not a stable country. We can't handle what, you know, some of what's been going on. And so I think, I think that's just, I mean, that's a huge issue for a lot of young, young Christian men. I know it is just a lot of Americans. So this would be two things. I'd like to see some more success in the Supreme Court striking ever sundown and some different things as far as secularization of our laws. But obviously some of these other things like Sabbath laws, I think that depends on the location, whether you can pass those kind of things. It depends on, it's very circumstantial at this point. So I think to start, we need more Christians working in these areas. I don't disagree with that, but I think I'd say the start is something I talk about in my book, Stockholm Syndrome Christianity is that if we don't get our own house in order, by which I mean that we're training the next generation and the current generation to have a view that Christianity applies to all of life and what it actually means and what Christians throughout history have done in the arts, in medicine, in, you know, down the line in law, then you're not going to have the necessary material or the people who can even go into politics. And so I think that for me, the clarifying call is for churches and paraturch organizations to make, and they are already, and I think this is good, of really making training and mentoring and equipping everyone and giving a vision that whether you're a doctor or a lawyer or a teacher or a homemaker or, you know, a painter that your Christianity does give you a calling for impacting society and then giving a vision for churches that churches aren't just private entities, they're part of the public sphere. So they can put on block parties. They can lobby for things, you know, moral laws and not. They can actually be salt and light in their city, in their neighborhood, in their nation. And that giving churches a vision that goes beyond sort of just electoral politics, although I'm being a recovering political scientist, my PhD in government, I certainly do think that that's important, but I do think that there's some basics of training, equipping, and a vision for churches to be, you know, bulkheads and lights in their community. Okay, so John, thank you for being on the podcast and for all our listeners up there, thank you for joining us. And thank the audience too. Theology Podcast is a ministry of Westminster Presbyterian Church in Battleground, Washington. The Theology Podcast is produced and edited by a widely craft productions of Nashville, Tennessee.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Once in a Lifetime Hike + Thanksgiving Concussion in China + Shenzhen Smuggler [China Compass]

    Nov 21, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Welcome to China Compass on the Fight Laugh Feast Network! I'm your China travel guide, Missionary Ben. Follow me (@chinaadventures) on Twitter/X where I post new/unique Chinese city prayer profiles every single day....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A Plea To Wes Huff [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 20, 202611 minAudio

    Wes Huff's plagiarism controversy has raised serious questions about Christian integrity, accountability, and public repentance. In this special episode, Pastor George Sayour examines the allegations against Christian...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Are Christians Thinking about U.S. Policy in the Middle East in Relation to the Person of Christ? [God, Law, and Liberty]

    Nov 20, 202625 minAudio

    Today David examines what “Biblical worldview value,” if any, Christians would place on the present nation of Israel in determining the United States' policy for Israel and the Middle East if objective knowledge of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 248. What Hinders Maturity in Men? [Leadership Now Podcast]

    Nov 19, 20261 hrAudio

    Tune into this episode of Leadership Now with Dr. Aaron Rock where Aaron provides some wisdom and insight into some of the things preventing men from growing in maturity. More Resources: More resources at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Should Government Enforce God's Law? Responding to Todd Friel [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 19, 202642 minAudio

    Should Christians support laws that force unbelievers to behave morally? Or does God forbid the government from enforcing biblical morality? In this episode of *The Magistrate*, James Baird and Josh Howard respond to a...

    Credit the people on this episode