Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

FLF, LLC

FLF, LLC artwork

Is Christian Nationalism DANGEROUS? Responding To Gavin Ortlund: Blasphemy Laws & Heretic Burning [Reformation Red Pill]

Nov 6, 20262 hr 6 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Our Wonderful Sponsors: - Taste and See Ceramics: Get your Jerusalem Cross mug here: https://tasteandseeceramics.com/ - Montana Coffee Co. https://www.montanacoffeecompany.online/standforsomething?utm_source=rrp&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=youtube&utm_id=RRP+Partnership Code: reformation - Dort Patches: https://dort.store/collections/all Email: Joshua@reformationredpill.com CLUB MEMBERSHIP: https://reformationredpill.com/products/reformation-red-pill-club-membership In this episode, Andrew Isker joins Joshua Haymes to react and respond to Gavin Ortlund on the topic of Christian Nationalism. Other Links: - Follow Andrew Isker - @contramundumpodcast ​

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

Christian nationalism is a label that is used in many different ways. But I worry that some of what goes under this label is actually quite dangerous. You see the scare images? What is the best historic model for Christian nationalism? Is there one ideal or golden era that we could point to? Or does something we can point to and say, here is when this actually worked? Anytime you hone in on one specific era, you start to realize, oh yeah, that time had some problems as well. For example, one of the things we'll talk about in this video is Christians burning each other at the stake and burning non-Christians at the stake. We'll get to come to terms with some of these horrific things that have happened in your history that we need to keep alert to so we don't romanticize the past. Throughout the medieval era, it became just standard and dominant. To think that heretics should be executed by the state. And in many contexts, the church claimed to authority over the state. Why did they think that? Christian nationalist pastor Andrew Isker says that burning heretics is good. And that's what he wants for America. I'm not going to say that, obviously. But... That's it. My main question is why he told me to proclaim to come using the darkness of this time. We must make America Christian again. Hello and welcome to the Reformation Red Pill podcast. I am your host, Joshua Hames. Today we have, well, you guessed it, we have a special episode. It's always very special when we have the one and only Andrew Isker. Thank you. Thank you. For anyone who's new. Who are you, Andrew? What do you do and how can people find you in your work? Yes, my name is Andrew Isker. I am a pastor here in Tennessee. And I also comment on things on the internet in various forms of media. And so, yeah, they could find me, I guess, here a lot of the time. Lately. Which has been nice for the people. Yeah, people are enjoying it. If you're not, that's too bad. Sorry. Hit that dislike button twice just because you don't like it so much. Definitely hit it in the even number of times. That's right. That's right. And I'm also on x.com, the everything app at Bonifus option and on sub-stack. Although I haven't, I keep promising them when I write more stuff. And I never have time. I have a lot of thoughts, but I don't have time. And also, Contra Mondum on YouTube, wherever you get your YouTube's and podcasts, things. Very good. It'll be in the description. You guys go follow them on all the things because I mean, he just brightens up Reformation right? But I think you guys would agree. Especially, I mean, the thing that I keep getting the most positive feedback on is it don't tell me the negative. No, yeah, we don't need to do that. We get enough of that from the lips, but is that you have the jolliest laugh of all time when it comes to the meme episodes. So that's just bringing people in. They love it so much. That's good. Myself included. Like we're doing a meme episode after this for a shoot and I'm just like rubbing my hands together just. This is. Yes. More. It's fun. It's fun. So anyway, let's jump in in today's episode. But before we do, guess what guys? I landed a new sponsor. So those of you might know 1689 cigars. They have a Zen. They have an that's not Zen is the not the company. It is. It is the nicotine pouches. Dort. Dort. Yeah, I've had them. They're really good. They're really good, right? Yeah. Yeah. And so I'm excited about getting those. I'm not advocating you guys pick up a new habit if you don't already do it. But if you already are taking the nicotine pack pouches, come with the question. There's a question company. That's right. And they're also very, very good. Check them out. Link will be in the description for that. Yeah, you're totally trying to get all the young people hooked on. I'm not on Nick. Yeah, that's right. I'm drugs, man. But yeah, so guys, check them out. We also, of course, we have our sponsors Montana coffee company and tastency ceramics with the most gorgeous mugs you've ever seen. All of that. It is the season. It's the holiday season. Go crazy and help us keep the lights on. Means it on to me. Yeah, we're definitely like if like you didn't introduce the topic yet. So I don't want to do it. Do it. I don't want to touch down call, but it's like we're going to critique a Gavin Orteland video. When was this from this? Apparently, really. Here they go. Yeah. And you know, hopefully, hopefully the things we say are insightful and poignant so much so that Mr. Orteland engages with what we have to say. We're going to, I think we're going to treat him very fairly. I think so. We're not going to, we're doing this in good faith. Truly. And I mean, so like the first thing he's going to be like, yeah, like this response to me is sponsored by nicotine. Oh, no. Yeah, that's right. That's right. Like 100 percent. Oh, yeah, yeah, that's right. That's right. He's already these are bad hominem bad guys. These are bad guys. So as I'm smoking. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Like you got to, you got to pay the bills, man. And, and yeah, 1689's great. They are great. Yeah. God's chance. And he's got multiple companies. Check out anything 16 and I love him. Great. Yeah. So great. So great. Yeah. So as Andrew enlightened us to what we will be doing, we will be reacting and responding to the dangers of Christian nationalism. Dangerous. It is very dangerous, but we are not dangerous. We are just your friendly neighborhood Christian nationalist. And, and we got a lot of thoughts on this episode that we're about to dive into. And so we will just dive right on in head first. And you know, Andrew, I think we'll be able to be concise with this one. We'll keep it under two hours. That's it. That's it. That's it. I got it on 1.3 times speed. I know some of you guys just want me going straight, slow, mo one, one times just the I can't do it. Yeah, I can't do it. I can't. I can't. I've been doing 1.5. We're just doing 1.3. So if you got to slow it down, man, you got to slow it down. Sometimes I'll go, I'll go quick. I'll go three times speed if I'm like really trying to get through something. Yeah. And then everyone sounds like Ben Shapiro, like normally. You know, that should listen to him on like four times. You guys literally can't really match it. Let's jump in. Christian nationalism is getting a lot of coverage these days, but I worry that some of what goes under this label is actually quite dangerous. And in this video, I want to develop my concern about that by asking three questions to Chris. Like, you see the scare images? Well, I was thinking we should talk about that. You know, dangerous. Like, yeah, people protested a fraudulent, potentially fraudulent. Yeah, it's right. Allegedly. Allegedly fraudulent. No, I don't think that what's to that to me though on even the if this tells you how fast we're going to get through this episode. We got like three seconds and three seconds. Yeah. But what what's that to me already is selecting those images. That's interesting because I myself have critiques for those images, right? Like the type of Christianity. And honestly, when I was first getting into Christian nationalism before I had done the reading, let's say, the thing that turned me off to the idea or the concept was the excesses that I had seen in kind of the evangelical world of like, Fourth of July services with American flags everywhere and seemingly kind of either worshipping Trump at your church service. Yes. No one like we are not in favor of that. And in fact, I think that's a huge turn off. But what I will say is that what's going on there is it's simply an inversion of what we've talked about in other episodes, the Ordo Amoris, where it's like God is really at the top. He is the foundation and the cornerstone of the Ordo Amoris. And if you get the Ordo Amoris right, it looks like God, family, the people of God, country. Yeah. And like even there, even with the the Schlocky mega church, Fourth of July thing, I give those people a lot of grace because they do not know any better. True. That's very true. And these are extremely well-meaning Christian people that love the Lord. Yeah. And they love their country. Which are two very very good things. Yes. Like when you bring up the Ordo Amoris, like those are they're in there. That's right at the, you know, right at where it should be. And it might be a little, you know, few things are messed up. Yeah. Yeah. Right. A little bit out of order, but they're close to where they ought to be. And like even gelicalism as a whole is is such. I mean, we'll get into some of these things. The American evangelicalism in particular is is kind of messed up. Not because the people are bad or or because all of the leaders are horribly corrupt, although there's some bad ones. It's it's because. And we've talked about this before too. There isn't anything there isn't isn't a central organizing, you know, foundational institution, right? We lost all the main lines that provided, you know, fundamental bedrock, institutional support that that things. Radio outward from. So especially in the 20th century, it's become a highly commercialized thing where. You the thing that drives even gelicalism is the religious market. Right. So what works in the market? That's what we're going to do. There's a pragmatism to it that drives everything. Rather than, you know, concrete bedrock, theological principle that everything is that undergrids everything else. And so, right, these big general mega churches that have the Schlocky, Fourth of July thing, read they're doing that because they're responding to market incentives within the religious market. Because, well, people love America and we're going to be patriotic. Right. Not just out of pragmatism, although that's it's there. But like, this is what the people want. We're going to give them what they want. Yeah. That sort of drives everything. And very rarely do you not, not never, but very rarely do you see big time, even gelical leaders and pastors of churches, like 10,000 people or whatever say, I know this is what you want to do. We're actually going to do this. Right. It happens, but the times that it does happen is noticeable because it's so rare. Yeah. And so, like, I think you, you maybe remember a few months ago, like, you know, Josh Howardton, you know, it was like, hey, we haven't, I haven't preached against, you know, cohabitation and premarital sacks and things like that. And I've let you down. And there's a lot of people in our church that do that. Wow. Because I haven't said anything about it. And I was scared to say anything about it because then everyone's going to be mad at me and leave. And he did. And I think they had like dozens of couples that were living together in the church get married that Sunday, which is like, wow, what you should do. It's like, let's get you out of sin and get there. There are people critical of that. Where it's like, no, no, no, they shouldn't do that. It's like, no, I think, you know, the horse is kind out of the barn there. And let's, you know, rectify the situation. So I'm not critical of that necessarily. And it's like, but that was that's such an uncommon thing for a pastor say, I, this is maybe going to upset a lot of people, but I'm going to do it anyway. Right. Um, and, and of course, like when they do that, that's great. And takes courage and, and, and, and so forth that is very lacking everywhere. But that it's because it's so uncommon. Like it's, that's a, that's a signal. It's a tell that this is, this is really what drives everything. And, and so how you fix that, how you put that tooth, that particular toothpaste back in the tube. And, and, um, have things the way they ought to be. Well, it's kind of some of the stuff we'll discuss. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, exactly. Try to segue it back from my rambling. No, it's good. Good stuff. So, uh, Orland's going to get into his three concerns. And we will diagnose, we will respond in there. There are very, very good answers to his three concerns as we will get into Gavin. If you do end up watching this, we'd love to have you on the show. Love to talk to you about this. Honestly, and, uh, appreciate. Oh, and let me just say this upfront. Um, I definitely have a lot of disagreements with Gavin, but his work on Protestant apologetics has been incredibly important. He's very good. He's been, and there are not enough Christians going into that space. Oh, yeah. Protestant Christians defending Protestantism. And it is a desperate need right now. So Gavin, if you're watching this, really appreciate your work there. And, uh, let's just keep going here. Christian nationalists, but first, let me make two acknowledgements. These will be quick, but don't hang with me through these to get to the substance of the video. We've got to say these two things. First of all, Christian nationalism is a label that is used in many different ways. On one end of the spectrum, this label can be used for just any sort of general Christian influence on government. On the other side, you find, for example, advocacy for civil punishment of religious dissent, like blasphemy laws. For example, sadly in these discussions, you also find horrendous forms of racism and anti-semitism that are present in some of those who espouse this. You didn't have a clip for that. I noticed, I didn't notice that. You could put some, you could put some tweets that are like, we'll all see them. Yeah. Like, you know, and maybe doesn't want to draw attention to certain people. Yeah, that could be a, yeah. And I just, I've just gotten to the point where those two words, I've just struck from my vocabulary and instead decided to use biblical words, biblical ideas, biblical terms. Yeah. Because even the idea that we, like, I was thinking about this today, how we have racism and anti-semitism. What is anti-semitism? Isn't that just racism against Jews, supposedly? So it's like, why is it a separate word? Yeah. Like, why is it specific? Is there an anti-white racism version of that? Because we're experiencing that in that scale in the United States. No, that's not like, when you're the majority group that's targeted for destruction by the regime categorically, no one can do anything to you because you are, you are the unperson. That's right. So that's why there's not like a term for like anti-whiteism or something that has any cache A anywhere because it's like, this is, this is like the factory setting for our entire system. Exactly. So how could you object to it? And so, yeah, I mean, it's interesting. And like, it's such a, those words are used because it's a sliding scale, it's nebulous what counts as that thing. And it can mean, like, do you just really hate black people or do you really hate Jews? Like, just hate them. You just wake up every morning like I specifically for their immutable characteristics because of like that they exist. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, they're in this group. Well, well, that's a bad thing. And I think the overwhelming majority of people would agree that that's bad. That's bad. Of course. But if you are critical of, you know, a particular group's influence on American foreign policy or just American culture and law in general that had very outsized influence on these things, if you're critical, if like you are aware of it and you're critical of it, well, that's, that's like you hate this. You hate people and you want them all dead. Yeah. Or are you aware of, you know, differences between, you know, various races and ethnic groups, just being aware of them? Right? Not even commenting. This group does, you know, tends to do this and this group tends to do that. Um, like having a, any degree of violence that is, is categorically evil. Yeah. Um, and because he's done without malice or without any, or whatsoever, it's like, oh, uh, you know, Creetans, you know, they tend to be liars. Uh, no, that's evil. Can't say that. Well, you've blasphemed with the God of egalitarianism. That's why the prime gods of the primary gods of our current. So when you're using that phrase, those term, that terminology, you're engaging in, in that process of, of decrying any, you know, touching on uncomfortable realities or forbidden realities, uh, which is why, like you see so much about on the internet, uh, where it verges into, into, you know, sinful forms of it, or it's hard to disengage, distinguish whether it's sinful or not, um, is, is because everyone understands if you're in for a penny, you're in for a pound. Yeah. That's right. And, and if you are doing things that are, you know, actually very reasonable, but forbidden, well, then you might as well do the totally forbidden stuff too. Yep. Right? And that's, that's why it's out there. You know, people act the way they do. Yeah, that's right. That's right. Is, is because while I'm going to be condemned, if I dip my toe in the water or if I plunge right in, uh, well, then, I just will do it. Yeah, I tell, I tell young, young people, whenever I'm having this discussion with them, they ask like, what is, what is the definition of racism anyway? And I say, I'll tell you exactly what racism is and how it's defined in our culture. Racism today just means shut up. Like, shut up. I don't like what you're saying. I can beat you over the head with this word and then no one will listen to you. Anything a protected class doesn't like. Yeah. He is racist. Correct. Like, like, like, literally, that's it. Like, if you, if you say, hey, I think we should have, um, voter ID, the vote. Right. That was called racist. That was called racist. Yep. Yep. Why exactly? Um, no one really knows except for, you know, uh, non-white people apparently don't like it. Yeah. That's why I guess as we think about this, even Gavin, I don't know if you will watch this video, but for anyone else who might be friendly to Gavin's perspective, whenever you use these terms in this way, you're buying into a liberal frame and you're letting them control the conversation. They are the ones who define these terms or, um, refuse to define them and use them as like political weapons. It is. And by utilizing them and then trying to import your version of whatever those words mean, you then legitimize that use, that, that, that violent use, I would say that, uh, the liberals use against conservatives and Christians. And that's getting back to Christian nationalism. It's like, we want to overthrow the liberal regime, the gay race, comedy liberal regime and replace it with a true Christian nationalism. And I know why, what I mean by the gay race, comedy regime, I mean the, the, the, the, the founding ideology of this country really was, and what I argue is Christian nationalism. And progressive liberalism is a cancer that is kind of like choked out the, the Christianity from our, from our soil. And we want to undo that. We want to bring back, uh, my thesis is that liberalism has supplanted Christianity as America's civil religion. And what we see kind of, kind of alludes in that, this is the first time we've done one of these where I've watched it before. Yeah, yeah. Uh, and that's, uh, yeah, if Gavin watches this, because like, I know he's, you know, bright dude, and I want to actually think about what he says, because you do when he do these, it's like, this is going to be terrible. Uh, yeah, right, right, right. No, Gavin's really, really intelligent. This is one where I'm like, oh, like this actually, we should, uh, I need to think about some of these things before I speak, um, uh, first time for everything. And, um, uh, but I think what it, what it does, and I would, I would hope, you know, someone like him, um, who appears to operate in good faith would appreciate this is that when you, when, what, what these things do is stigmatize any conversation on forbidden topics, because they have forbidden them. Um, by, by anyone who is mature and reasonable and thoughtful. And, and willing to engage in good faith. Yep. Um, like you're, you're not going to have anyone talk about this stuff and any of these things, um, because you, you will just castigate them and lump them in with, you know, bad people. Yeah. And, uh, and so that is, I think like there's this, this, this confluence of things like as he's saying this stuff, where it's like, well, why, why is it like all these, these people that seemingly are into Christian nationalism online, all the in-ons are like so bad. It says such a pile of things. And it's like, well, a few things have happened in like the last 10 years and that, um, that is like the, you know, certain ideas have found their way in, you know, in online discourse that are forbidden, right? Discuss. And, and people have actually discussed to them. And, and then you have the info, a penny info, a pound thing. Yeah, exactly. They just go headlong into it. Um, and so you still have within the not, you know, the non internet world, but all of these things are highly stigmatized, very taboo, um, but in the online world, at least anonymously, it's not, um, and, and so you have kind of like the worst, in some ways, the worst of both worlds where, you know, the above boards, you know, um, the above board worlds, uh, you know, the professional academic world, like, we'll never, ever in million years engage with a topic like crime statistics. Right. Um, and like why, why is it the way it is, um, in a truthful and honest way? Mm-hmm. And, uh, but on the internet, you will find that. Yep. You know, take, you take you less than 10 minutes to find conversation about these things that is, uh, it might not be very kind and nice and very Christian and behavior, uh, but it will be honest. People are tired of feeling a drip, drip on their leg and being told that it's rain, but there's no rain. There's not a cloud in the sky. They're just tired of it, you know, and you get a yellow puddle on their legs. Yeah, yeah. And they're like, you know what? No, you are, you sir, you're dating on my leg. And I was like, yeah, that's what's going on. And so yeah, those things have happened, and especially among young people, uh, especially among young, like white Christian men, like they understand I am the one who is, you know, targeted for destruction. Yeah. And, uh, are willing to engage in forbidden taboo topics. And, uh, no one like Gavin or, or anyone else with any degree of respectability is willing to honest, you know, honestly discuss things that are willing to dishonestly discuss. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But not, not in any degree of honesty. That's right. Well, uh, we've made it a minute and let's keep going. I mean, he started with his caveats. That's right. We had to go there. We had to deal with those first. Yep. That's right. So we need to be alert to speak against that. Uh, sometimes Christian nationalism just isn't Christian at all, and so that's one of the things. But again, there's so there's a whole spectrum of different entities being referred to by this religion is liberalism. Um, and you call that Christianity. It's very no. That's, yeah, that's exactly right. Well, and, and let all even steal, man, it's point here. There is obviously bad behavior on the internet. Absolutely. By people who claim to be Christianşa nationalist, things that I would repudiate. I'm not going to do the struggle session. like this person, that person. But there's obviously bad behavior. And I don't like bad behavior. But, of course, the orcs that are at the gate threatening to unmake our city have nothing to do with the excesses of Christian nationalism. So that's where we're coming from. It's like, yeah, should we have an in-house discussion on some issues in our own campus? Let's do that. We behave on the internet and that's on and so forth. Even if you are anonymous, right, still should conduct yourself well. You will, everyone, Anon, you will have to answer to King Jesus for every word. So just make sure you're honoring him with your words. We want the Anons to honor Christ with their words and many don't. And that's okay. You know what? I say that's okay. We don't want that. That's not okay. Not okay. But I get why they do. Yeah. Yeah, that's the thing we can understand where they're coming from. I mean, if I object. Exactly. Yeah, exactly. This label. To clarify, I'll often speak of some expressions of Christian nationalism in this video. What I have most in mind here are those versions of Christian nationalism that involve using civil authority to punish religious offenses like blasphemy and heresy and other things like this. Oh, yeah. Like we did it our founding. Like America did for like the first hundred, 150 years. Yeah, exactly. Assistance. Or like America currently does today if you burn rubber over a gay crosswalk. Exactly. Yep. There every society has a God, whether it's capital G or lowercase G, there are always going to be blasphemy laws. It's not whether but which, all classic always. And we have replaced Christianity with liberalism that a secular government has taken the place of God and it will not be blasphemy. That's correct. The things that they value the highest, they do not allow blasphemy. Right. Do understand what much of Christian nationalism may be reacting against. Christian nationalism is popular in some circles, especially among some young men. And I think I understand some of the reasons perhaps why. And that is as a reaction against political withdrawal, political apathy and lack of courage. I just read recently James Davidson Hunter's book to Change the World. It's amazing. It was published in 2010. How much the world has changed since it was published. But he talks about how politics is the tactic of choice for many Christians as they think about changing the world. And he's a lot to say about that in different ways on right and left. Starting in the 1980s, he kind of traces some of this out. But it's also worth saying that in many Christian circles, there has been a huge reaction against this. So for example, many people are very turned off by their religious right. But their response to that is to run in the opposite direction. So there's just total withdrawal from political gay. Yeah, that's right. Yeah. Okay. Stuck it to them. Yeah, it's like your option is like either me or James Telleriko. Yeah, that's what you've got. That's what you've got. Trist political activism and so forth. And so it just bears saying right up front, politics and cultural engagement is a vital area of Christian witness. Christians should speak in this area with clarity and courage. See, I appreciate this. That's good. That's correct. And when we fail to do that, I think sometimes other things will fill the vacuum. Maybe Christian nationalism is one of those things that's happening right now. It's so. Yes. Sorry, like, please. You can prove that. Yeah. The well is thoroughly poisoned. Thank you. Oh, it's filling the vacuum. It's like, well, yes. And no. Well, yes, it is. And it's filling the vacuum precisely with what you just said you wanted to do. Yeah, yeah. Like, like, we should engage in these things. And even the quote that he had from Hunter is true that political power does change things. The reason why there are gay flags and trans flags everywhere, everywhere. The reason why your coworker puts he, him on his email signature. The reason why overnight, the polls regarding gay marriage were, you know, overwhelmingly disapproving of it to overwhelmingly approving of it is not because people woke up one day and said, oh, we've been really mean to gay people this whole time. And now I want to be nice to them, like just spontaneously. Right. It's like, oh, wow, I, you know, I thought it was really gross. And now I think it's beautiful. That's not why. It's because political power did. Correct. The law was changed somehow, you know, not through a constitutional process, but because they founded the right to the gay marriage in the Constitution somewhere. Weird. That nine justices came down from cyanide and gave us the law. Yeah. Yeah, you got to do this now. And then overnight, boom, everything, everything turns on a dime. And if you are like publicly oppositional to homosexuality, like you are a thought criminal. Right. You were an evil person. Right. You are, you did to be kicked completely out of society. Cast to the outer darkness. And and political power is what made that happen. Right. And so it changes the world. You know, for good or for ill. Right. It is a constant. Right. This is how God built the world is that some men rule over other men. Right. He gives the sword to men as his minister. And sometimes they wield it faithfully. And a lot of times they do know. Right. But this is a, like, this is a constant throughout history. Men will be governed by someone. Yep. They will be power that is wielded over men. Right. Period. And that's a, that's a thing. I mean, he didn't, I keep, I'm going to get into it. In this thing, like that is the fundamental question that people, the fundamental question that people refuse to ask. Right. It's, it's their government is there. And political power is there. We don't even ask like, what was it for? Why, why, why is it here? Right. Is this something that God wants or not? How should it be wielded? Does he have an opinion about that? Right. That isn't even a, like, even you ask, like, I've been critical in the past of like Mike Johnson or any other, like, even jokal politician. Because like when they talk about politics, it's, it's just assumed that their vision of politics is simply, I guess, be conservative. And then shoehorn some Bible verses to justify the things that you're doing. Yep. Like there isn't a coherent political theory driving them. Like if you, if I had Speaker Johnson here, hopefully he's still Speaker, you know, after tomorrow, as we record this. But if I had him here, I would just ask him like, like, what is the purpose of political power? Right. Like what do you, what, what ends do you accomplish with this thing? And, and that's the fundamental question here that, that I mean, to be, you know, fair to Gavin is at least kind of contemplating. Although it's still within, you know, the factory settings of liberalism. That's right. He's not going to be able to escape it. We want it for you, Gavin. We really do want to pursue now is what does courage look like? And so let me ask three questions that I would put to someone who espouses Christian nationalism. That's clarity on what is meant by that. But also hoping to expose some of the concerns that I have about much of what goes under this label. It's very concerned. Question number one, which historic model of Christian nationalism are you advocating? Much of the Christian nationalism movement results from the retrieval of historic Christian political theology. And one of the concerns I have is a leapfrogging over the 18th, 19th and 20th centuries of Christian political thought to draw from the wells of the 16th and 17th centuries of Christian political thought. And of course, earlier than those as well. And I want to advocate for careful consideration of all of church history. And that includes these last 300 years. It also includes, of course, the pre-constantinient church, the church up until the 4th century where there's a watershed change as church and empire become connected. And so this is already like set up to be very Baptist, which we can't fall. He's a Baptist. He's a Baptist. I thought he, like, I don't know where all the Orlins are on the theological, you know, bloodsharts anymore. So he's still Baptist. He's still Baptist. All right. The track. It makes sense. I assumed that was the case, but good to know. Yeah. My ad for this episode. Yeah, you're over here. It is one that I'm super excited. Guys, don't skip. You want this mug. You've been looking at this mug for a long time. I know you're like, dude, that mug is so sick and it is so sick. And they're finally an official sponsor of the show. She had donated these mugs a while back and I love them. I drink out of this mug and my other Jerusalem cross mugs literally every morning. I wash them every night so that I can use them every day because I don't know. I can't describe it, guys. It is so. It's such a good feeling to drink my morning coffee out of the quality handmade product. It is. It's the best feeling. It's like one of the simple joys in life. I love it so much. So guys, you can support the show by buying the coolest mug ever. Okay? Get it for your husband for Christmas. Get it for yourself for Christmas. Get it for your, you know, for the household. I have three of the Jerusalem cross mugs, one in copper brown, this color, and then one in like a darker, almost black. And it's the best, guys. So you can support what I do here by just getting the coolest mug that you will ever have. So that's that. We'll get back to the video. The question that arises here is, what is the best historic model for Christian nationalism? Is there one ideal or golden era that we could point to or just something we can point to and say, here is when this actually worked. And I think when we start to think about that question, there are two dangers that emerge that I see. The first is romanticizing the past because anytime you hone in on one specific era, you start to realize, oh, yeah, that time had some problems as well. For example, one of the things we'll talk about in this video is Christians burning each other at the stake and burning non-Christians. We'll get there. And, you know, we'll just try to come to terms with some of these horrific things that have happened in church history that we need to keep alert to so we don't romanticize the past. CS Lewis famously spoke of chronological snobbery, which is a prejudice against what is old. And this is a valid concern that just because something is old doesn't mean it is wrong. Today I worry there is a danger in some circles of a kind of reverse chronological snobbery where this is prejudice against what is modern. And we need to make the opposite point in some context just because something. So the point is well taken in that there is a grashes greener that is the grashes greener is endemic to human nature. We always think that, oh, surely, over there, it must be better, right? Yeah, but do you think, you know, he's got the timeline there that any Christians that thought deeply about, you know, the political would look at America or really the West in general year of our Lord 2026 and would say, yeah, things compared to now, you know, politically, sociologically, so on and so forth. Compared to where we sit right now, they've got it better than us, right? They've been there, they're chopping off little boys, penises. Yep. And half the country thinks that's the coolest thing in the world. 70 million little babies murdered 70 million babies in the last 60 years. American women have put to shame every single dictator in American world history and world history and it's not close combined. Combined. Yes, we are making the case that we are worse off and they had something figured out politically that is far superior that what we did not allow such things to happen. And so I don't think it is inverse chronological snobbery to say something has gone wrong along the way that has allowed for these things to occur. Correct. And so we need to look to the past to find them and like his point here, it's always hard to where do we stop? Maybe we need to let him finish this point. Yeah, let's let him. Right. Launch into it. Yeah, yeah, let's let's let's do it. Is new or is later doesn't mean it's wrong. I'll come back to that. The second danger that can arise when he started asking when is the goal? Yeah, well, we can stop it. Yeah. So like the first thing he says, well, where what's the golden era that you're looking for when all these things worked, the golden era and I'm like, well, definitely anytime before 2015. Yeah. Yeah, just pick it. But then you have to ask the question, well, what led to the things that occurred in 2015 and following subject company? And then you have to move a little bit further back. And the question is, well, how much further back, right? Do we need to go? That's always the argument. And my answer to something like this is is not all right. Yeah, we need to make it like 1647 in England. That's where we need to be or 1535 Geneva. That's where we need to be because every context historically is very, very different. We do not have the world of America in 1776. We do not have the world of America in 1976. We don't, you know, and certainly not England in 1647 or Geneva, Switzerland in 1535. So we don't have those things. Those are completely different contexts. But when you weigh, what did those people do within that particular historical paradigm? You can glean things from them. You can think, okay, these are the, these are the realities politically, economically, technologically that are different from where we are today. But what did they do right? And what didn't they do right? You know, with the benefit of hundreds of years of hindsight. And the snobbery is evident in, well, they did all these things bad and wrong. And I would never have done that. And it's like, if you lived then you definitely. So there's that. And then secondly, part of the snobbery is, because he gets into, you know, the, the neo-cavanists in Holland in the, in the late 19th and early 20th century. And he really likes them because they were liberals. Like, I mean, not liberal, like, like Barack Obama or James Telereko or something. But liberal in terms of their views of government, political rights and so forth, like they believed in liberal republicanism wholeheartedly. And so their political views were, were part of that. Were that that's the context in which they lived. And of course, he would say, well, that's similar to our context. So we should learn from, from them. And all of these conversations, all of them inevitably, inevitably are a confusion between questions of theory and questions of practice. Right. And those are two very separate discussions. It's ideally, what would things you look like? Right. It's why it's ideally the, you know, social and political and economic context for this thing that you want. This, what would it be? And that you have to start there. Because then, right, you have a thing that you're aiming for. And that might be a thing that's a thousand years away or 500 years away. That you understand, like, it's not going to get there in a single election cycle or something. And then from there, you could proceed to practice. All right. What would things should we be doing right now? So that one day generations from now, we can achieve, you know, the theoretical idea, or ideal that we are, we're after. And so those things get conflated constantly. Right. They can be conflated by critics all the time. That's all they do is these guys want to get rid of the US Constitution. And, you know, when you engage in a discussion apart from what is extant, right? You're just dealing with theory. You're dealing with, well, with no constraints, how would you want to think, what would you want the world to look like? What would you want your government to look like and how would political power be needed out and so forth? And they hear you saying those things like, well, these guys hate the US Constitution. But these guys, they want to do this, that, the other thing. That's so horrible and terrible. And it's like, no, I'm not proposing doing any of those things in the year 2026. Right. We're looking at like 25, 26 or something. It's, I mean, it took a thousand years of development of Christendom by the time you've got to the Protestant Reformation, like a thousand years. And so the idea that like we're going to, we're going to elect JD Vance and Pete Hegseth and they're going to put women in handmaid's tail rove and reduce them to breeding stock or whatever. Like that's what these people sound like when they're critiquing, you know, political theory. Yeah. Well, because it's like they're, their, their, their, motor stop, a ronda is, uh, thou shalt not do a Christendom. Yeah, yeah. Christendom is evil. That's what it's what it, that's what it, it's what it comes down to. Thou shalt not do a Christendom. Yeah. I mean, it's very, it's a very Baptist critique and I love Baptist. I'm sure there's many, many Baptist watching. And that's friends. Yeah. Some of my best friends are Baptist. But part of it is like Baptist theology is, uh, if it's hand in glove with liberal, liberalism because it's, uh, because one of the core tenets of liberalism is, uh, is individualism. Mm-hmm. And, and Baptist theology, of course, is, is highly individualistic. And, and so you can see how these two things kind of meld together and, and, which is, which is the political liberalism, which is the theological, you know, Baptist, uh, beliefs, uh, we can't always discern. Hard to untangle. Um, and, and it's like, and maybe we're asking the impossible to ask Gavin to like step outside of that. Mm-hmm. Right. Did you envision a world? Now, this is maybe a breakfast question, but like, did you envision a world in which you and no one else are Baptist and the, the, or liberals? And the world instead is, is very covenantal. Mm-hmm. Right. Is very like, individual still exists, obviously. Uh, but they're also part of group. They're also part of Asian and family, uh, and, and so forth, um, where, where it's a world like that. And everyone is cognizant of the fact that they are not an individual into themselves and their own personal preference doesn't, doesn't actually matter that much. Um, and you envision a world like that where everybody thinks that way, um, because congrats you just envisioned like the first, um, we're not going to count anabaptists because they're terrorists. Um, but, uh, the first, you know, 17, 100 years of the church. Um, right. That's, that's, that's what you're, I'm asking you to envision what yourself in the shoes of those people that lived before you before there ever was a John Bunyan or, or whatever. Um, like that, uh, that's what I'm at. Yep. You know, that's what I'm asking. And it's, it's a tall order. It's very hard. Um, like I, I think that best thing is like you, if you can't conceptualize a world other than the one you know and have experienced, um, then you're not going to be able to do justice to historical theology. You're not going to be able to do justice to political theology. Yeah. Uh, and, and in particular, like the, the theology of the Reformation is, um, is inherently political every single, like you read, um, you read any of the reformers, right? You read Calvin's institutes and the entire book, even though he doesn't devote much space to politics really at all, uh, very little, every word has a political implication to it. Right. Um, and if you divorce that from your reading of the institutes or you're, you're reading of anything Luther said or anyone in the Reformation, uh, you will not understand it. Right. Right. No, I think that's, that's absolutely true. And I think of, if I were to be able to ask Gavin a question, it would be, you know, he's kind of right now grilling, you know, what he believes to be the excesses of Christian nationalism. But for him, to your point, Andrew, I would want to ask, okay, would you go to Calvin and Geneva and say, like, how dare you not let the Muslims build their minarets here? Like, just like 50 Ottomans. Yeah. Like, how dare you, uh, not permit, you know, blasphemy to be preached on the street corners in Calvin and Geneva. Like how would you, would you say like, why doesn't Geneva have a drag queen story out? Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Exactly. David French, that's a blessing. It's a blessing of liberty. Yeah. No. So yeah. I think that's what I would want. I genuinely like, again, Gavin, if you watch this, that is a question that I would have for you. You, you seem to believe that, uh, freedom of religion as understood by 20th central, uh, 20th century liberalism should be our, like, operating system, like that. That's what we should have total religious libertinism. Exactly. Um, whereas not only, uh, did we not have that throughout church history, we didn't have that in America. Or the first mosque wasn't built here until like the 1940s. Um, you wouldn't, and as you well know, you, you couldn't even hold political office. And this is after the constitution was ratified in many of the, uh, of the 13 states without being a Christian, like, was that bad? That wouldn't protest without being Protestant. Was that bad? What did God look at that law and go, oh, I am disappointed in that. That's evil or, or was God's God pleased with that law? That's the question. I think, honestly, I think the answer to that question is obvious. Like, is it good to be ruled? I mean, he tells us he can we go back to the Deuteronomic curses, right? Whenever foreigners and women and children are ruling over you, like, you are under God's curse. Okay. So anyway, let's keep going here. Good stuff. Good stuff. It is later. Doesn't mean it's wrong. I'll come back to that. The second danger that can arise when we start asking when's the golden era? What's the gold standard? What do we look to as a model for this historically? When has Christian nationalism worked? We're asking that question. The second danger that comes up is historical selectivity. Well, that's the other thing. Well, that's the other thing. It's like, what do you mean by worked? Yeah. Like, like, what do you mean? Like, even like presupposing that there's this golden era that we can try to recreate. It's like, this is not a question of like producing this golden age. It is, instead, is a question of like, if I'm going to answer the question of like, well, what worked? It's more so like, all right, compared to what? Like, does it work compared to what we have currently? Wait, this is exactly the point. What standards? Let's let him finish this out because you're, this, where you're going right now is, I think where he's going and we can get, let it get in the chest. Yeah, sorry. I'm going to get this. Sorry, Mr. Orland. Where we pluck out some aspects of church history, but ignore their context and the development around them. Now, let me just explain this for a moment. Hang with me here. I think it's worth doing a little bit of a dive into church history on this point. I, anyone who knows me knows I love theological retrieval, which is just learning from the theology of the past. And that's what certainly include political theology. We have much to learn. My first book was on theological retrieval. I talk about this a lot. But part of the value of retrieval is you want to be challenged by what you're engaging. If it ever feels convenient, you're probably doing it wrong. And so we want to be careful never to just pluck out the things we like from church history, but we want to look at the whole of church history. And that means engaging modern political theology as well as pre-modern. And as I say, it also means looking at the early church. So let me give an example of a tradition that I think we are wise to bring into the discussion. And that is the neo-Calvinists, the Dutch reformed theologians of the 19th and 20th century, like Herman Boving and Abraham Kaiber. This is just one example of what I want to say real fast on that is that there are guys in our circles who will just like totally poopoo those guys because of stomach there, political theology they disagree with. And we're going to talk about that some of where I think that all Abe and Herman took some else. But generally speaking, like I have Boving right back here on the shelf, it sits up there because like his reformed dogmatics are like a masterclass in reform theology so, so good. And Abraham Kaiber's lectures on Calvinism are astounding. They are so good. And you can, I think that like with any theological retrieval, we need to be eating the meat and spitting out the bones. Right. And so what's interesting is, is what I think we're about to hear from Gavin is like, he's going to actually offer up the bones that I would spit out. But I want to tell you guys that there is some good meat that do. Yeah, it is. I mean, it's ironic too because it's like, well, we don't want to read what like, you know, we're only going to like, we want to be challenged. And it's like, to Boving and Kaiber challenge you. They challenge your liberalism at all. And the answer of course is no. Well, actually, if he, I would say honestly, they would, they would in some categories. Yes, yes, absolutely. Yeah, for sure. But in the ones that he's going to present now, but the seeds of where we are today, we're already present there 100 and, you know, 30 or 40 years ago, that like liberalism as, you know, metastasized into what we currently have. And I would argue that those things were inevitable that maybe, I want to plug that because that was actually pretty big for my. Yeah, this is good. And this will be some helpful reading for anyone who's interested in like, we're talking a lot about liberalism. If you want to understand liberalism, like reading some of the post liberals like Denine is really helpful, why liberalism failed was pretty foundational and you're kind of describing his thesis. Yeah, even necessarily like describe myself as post liberal. Right. It's more so like, I, yeah, I love the US Constitution, the American political order. I think it's, has been phenomenal. Obviously, it is the, the vestiges of a Constitution Republic are literally the thing keeping us from occupying mass graves right now. Well, that's exactly right. Yeah. Well, I mean, I'm even joking. No, serious. That's 100% true. And so to be clear, well, on that point, I share that sentiment. Absolutely. The problem is that John Adams was right whenever he said that our Constitution was written and designed to govern a moral and religious people. It is wholly inadequate to the government of any other. Our Constitution can't even govern a dig, us because we're degenerate. We have walked away from Christ. And so we're, we don't, we don't relish the fact that we are moving that into a, a political situation wherein, you know, perhaps, yeah. Like the, well, I would say largely the Constitution has been made irrelevant by our political leaders, not entirely, but, but mostly into Andrew's point of messages of it are keeping us alive. They would like, they would like to make it entirely irrelevant. But I, I think, I mean, the issue ultimately is, yes, you can have liberalism and it will work. It will be a great system. So long as you have the populace suited for it. Yep. Right. You can, you can bring as much as much a Republican constitutional liberal theory. Like you can have, you can have all of Somalia learn John Locke all day long and just import John Locke there and you will not have a society that could function as a liberal society. Most Liberia has our Constitution. Exactly. Exactly. You cannot have, and they don't have our country. We will not work because it's the people. It is about the people and we have walked away from Christ. We have become, we have become ungovernable by our own Constitution. So the, the options, we have two options. We will either repent, turn back to Christ as a nation and become governable once again, or we will descend further into chaos at which point we will continue, God will continue to pour out judgment until, you know, until it gets so bad that, you know, we cry out because the judgment is so bad and then he brings order from on high as it were. And I'm hopeful that option A is the route that we will take on day and night. This is what I want to do. This is why we do this podcast. This is why we do everything that we do. And so the problem is that, that liberalism is not a self correcting thing. It, it, it, particularly when it expands further and further when there is more and more and more freedom. Like the, like you read, particularly like the founding era of America and their, their concept was entirely, entirely responsible liberty. It wasn't total and utter free for all anyone could do whatever they want at any time. It was, all right, we, we want to have liberty. We want to have freedoms to do what is right in our own eyes. But only people who are responsible are capable of doing this. Right. If you are incapable of governing yourself in any capacity, then you are not fit for the freedoms that our vision of liberalism gives. I mean, this is, this is, again, this is the lock in right understanding of it as well. And so that's why I am, you know, hesitant to ever adopt the label like post liberal. You know, perhaps in maybe a pragmatic sense where it's like, well, you need, you maybe need a Cincinnati to restore, you know, the republic. But, but I like our system. I like the ones that are found are set up. That's what exactly, but that's what George Washington was. That's right. Literally use American Cincinnati and, right, he did his job and retired to his farm. And he restored that that's what the American revolution, so called was, was a restoration of the traditional rights of Anglo-Saxon peoples that had been stolen from them. Correct. And so, I think, by a derelict king who allowed a foreign government to rule over them. Right. That's the entire thing. That's what it was. It wasn't we, we didn't going to have no kings no more. It was instead, no, our people have lived in this way and had the freedom that they've enjoyed for a millennia, and you've trampled all over that. Right. And we are going to restore it. And so everything that George Washington did, Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, all of the founding fathers in 1776 was categorically unconstitutional. That's right. It was. Yep. They were breaking the, they caught their hunger trees. Yep. If they lose. And so we have to view it that way. That's exactly right. Right. And they're like, there may come a time where it's possible that we would need another George Washington figure in American history once again. I'm not saying that I'm desperately longing for that. Yeah. I don't think anyone in like 1760 was like, man, I just can't wait till we have some dude that just that takes over and is basically a dictator. And that's going to be awesome. Won't it be great? Like no one, no one was thinking that. But the new things were intolerable and bad and something had to give. Something has to be done. Yep. That's right. And so that's sort of my snapshot view of liberalism, I guess. Which you guys will get the more than just the snapshot in two weeks and two weeks. It's two weeks. Okay. Yeah. Cause we're releasing the first one, which we didn't cover the liberalism stuff in the first episode. I think it was the second episode. We'll get to it. Yeah. No, we already, we already recorded it. We're going to be in the club. God save America coming out. You'll see this tomorrow. So it'll be like in two days, Friday. And it's our series where we are training up the next generation of young men to apply their faith in politics and culture. And we do a genealogical genealogy of ideas that really unpacked all of this stuff in great detail. It's going to be a lot of fun. So I mean, I wish it was in more detail where you could spend a few hours on each. Absolutely. Absolutely. Maybe one day we'll get to. Yeah, yeah. Um, anyway, that's coming up soon. We're going to finish point his first question. And then I think we'll do a part, our part to where we can do it. I knew you were going to have to. You already knew. I'm sorry. No, this is this is why we do what we do. The people love it. So the real Gs are all still watching. I had a guy at church on Sunday come up to me and he was like, he's like, I, I, I, I, we, he's like, yeah, I went to the end. I don't really. I'm real great. I know. That's awesome. So actually, we just, we just exposed for anyone who, uh, who's watching this and, uh, doesn't usually watch the end. You got a little hint into what's going on. I'm, you know, this is fight club. I need to take a lock. All right. That's a men. What have I told you that for less than the cost of a couple drive through coffees, you could have premium gourmet coffee delivered straight to your door every single month. And you could even win a free riverfront getaway in the process. Well, I have good news for you. That's exactly what I'm telling you. Montana coffee company is a Christian owned, veteran owned coffee company. That is committed to producing exceptional coffee without compromising their values. They are base Christian brothers. They make excellent coffee and they are fully in support of our mission to make America, Christian again. Ten out of ten highly recommend their new subscription program ensures that you will never run out of the fuel you need for those early mornings of prayer, Bible study and mindlessly scrolling through social media, brain rot. I'm just kidding. You guys would never do that. I know you would never do that. Right now, the first 50 subscribers are entered to win a free weekend stay in a beautiful riverfront cabin from river walk properties in Fayetteville, Tennessee. Plus, a complete Montana coffee bundle. Head over to Montana coffee company today. Sign up for their subscription and use code Reformation for 15% off your order. Bryce's King drink accordingly. A strand of Christian history that I think we need to dial in. What I'm going to say here is you don't have to agree with them particularly. But what we want to do is not just leapfrog back to the 17th century Christian political thought and just default toward that without engaging the dialectical unfolding of how things played out in the subsequent centuries. The neo-Calvinists are worth engaging in particular because they wanted a Christianized society, but they had a very different way of pursuing that from earlier reformed Christians and from some contemporary Christian nationalists. For example, the neo-Calvinists vigorously opposed persecution of heresy. Now this is a sad fact of church history. Throughout the medieval era, it became just standard and dominant to think that heretics should be executed by the state. In many contexts, the church claimed authority over the state. Why did they think that? I mean, this is like any kind of hilarious that he brings up chronological snobbery at it. It's like, well, we don't do that. Any time there's like the big, bad, scary thing for anything. Right, in historical study, where it's like, this was really bad. I would, and like an entire society just does it. I mean, you can even even like the Aztecs performing human sacrifice, right? Like tens of thousands of victims and things like that. And we look at it rightfully and we have heard it and it's horrible and awful. But it's like, why would they do that? Why would they do that? Well, they believed that their gods demanded it and it made sense to them. And it's like, just even bringing yourself to be able to do that and ask the question, right, why did they do that? Why did everybody think this is just cool and fine and okay? And so like that question there too, it's like, you're burning heretics. Right, I'm not going to, right? I know like the, the lib hate watchers, right? We watch ones to get you right now, Andrew. Be careful. They want to sue. If the right me Christian nationalist pastor Andrew Isker says that burning heretics is good. And that's what he wants for America. I'm not going to say that. Obviously. But that's what we wanted. Yeah, that's right. The same process of asking the question, why did people think this was good? Yeah. Right, what was in the world? What was the paradigm in which they lived, politically, sociologically, culturally, everything else where pretty much everyone's like, yeah, this is what should happen. Right, that question is never asked. And it's just, we got to condemn these people because that's bad. It's like that, that categorically is chronological snoppery. Exactly. Exactly. So it's so erotic. Like, oh, we're going to do that. Well, you're doing that. Well, yeah, because you're, what he's doing, and this is, I don't know if he's, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and say he's not intentionally doing this, but whenever he shows you those images and those images in particular, those were like meant to display devout people who were really, they loved the Lord. They were Christians through and through and really they were being burned alive. A lot of the people that were standing around them. No, no, I'm talking about like the, like it's meant to depict like these are good, faithful Christians who are simply being burned alive for believing what the Bible actually teaches. What if they both were or what if crowd standing around was and the, like we, you know, maybe like, how do you know what or the other, you know, like it's the assumption though that how we view things today within a liberal paradigm is the eternal and perfect standard for all time. And of course, if you do that, and this is going to save this for the second part that, just in case people don't watch both parts, I need to say this. Like, Gavin's entire, you know, paradigm for what he envisions as the eternal politics of Jesus would condemn King Josiah in, in second Kings, right? I mean, the things that Josiah did, it wasn't a whole lot of religious liberty going on there or Elijah with the prophets with the prophets of veil. Yeah. These are condemn, indemnable acts that are carried out. And of course, like the rebuttal always will, we're not in the old, in the Old Testament, Israel, that's very particular. And it's like, I can grant you that. But even, even bearing in mind that this is a particular dispensation. I can use that word of God's order. At some level, God's saying, this is good and right. And this is what I want you to do. And if it's good and right for them, and right, are you so sure that it's an exceptional case? Are we certain that it's an exceptional base? I don't know if it is. Well, that's what, and this is something I want to get through to anyone who's, a lot of you guys are hearing this for the first time, the first time. The idea that, wait, wait, what if, what if it actually wasn't always the worst possible thing a civil magistrate could do to burn hair, it takes a life? We're not saying we want that from America. I know. We're not saying we want that from America. But what if, and hear me out here, there is a distinction between the ecclesiastical realm and the political realm. And what if God has placed these civil magistrates over a particular polity, a particular people in a particular time in history, and his duty is to order their earthly good and order them to their heavenly good. Because if you want to order a society to their earthly good, it presupposes that you will also be ordering them to their heavenly good because that is the ultimate good, right? And the, and the civil magistrate is, his realm is predominantly the earthly good, but it includes the heavenly good. So whenever you're talking about burning heretics, like if you can place yourself in, you know, Calvin's Geneva or something like that and say, okay, we have, and we have a, a civil polity. I've got a civil polity that God has placed me over. And there is a person and that was the other piece. This is important. It's meant to generate this idea, those, those pictures that he pulled up that really anyone who just believes something that's unorthodox, they're just like throwing into the pyre. Yeah. But what's going on there in survey, survey this or whoever it is, it's like you have a person, it's not the church burning them. That's not their job. That God has not given the sword to the church. It is the civil magistrate who is saying you are destroying the social fabric of our civil polity. You, and not only, not only are you destroying the social fabric, like you are seditious, you are, like there, there's all these different layers of crimes that you are committing in, in, like espousing this heresy. The civil magistrate is it lawful for him to say, well, there comes a point where you become so destructive to the social fabric that it becomes seditious. And that is a capital offense. What I would say is that while I would say it would not be something we would pursue in these United States for various reasons, it is not in principle, evil for a civil magistrate to do that. Yes. Okay. That's the point. And this is a question of theory versus practice. So neither of us is going to say, yeah, this is like Donald Trump should send in the delta force to black bag the PC USA past. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I've like jokingly said that. Right. But it's a joke. Right. Right. We're dealing with a question of theory of, right, say you have Christendom. Right. Right. What do you do then? Right. You have a Christian people, a Christian society, Christian laws, and you have someone who is threatening to unmake and undo all of that, all of that. Yeah. These are, these are not mere, and this is, this is the thing. And I was, yeah, I was going to save this for later, but we'll say it again because we're into two videos. Like, Servitas, for example, or many of the Anapaptists, it's hilarious when, you know, I'm trying to be fair to Gavin here. But when guys like him are like, oh, it's just the worst thing in the world for Christendom to exist where you have this intertwining of, of religion and political power, right, where it's not exactly clear where one begins in the other ends and where the church is directly involved in, in politics. I mean, I think he rightly points out that the church should not, you know, be over the state. Right. I think that's actually, it's correct. I think, we believe in the separate institutions, church and state. Going back to, you know, English history. Yeah, I kind of think that the King Henry, you know, taken out, you know, the, what's the line from Shakespeare? Or is it Shakespeare? How I'm now I'm forgetting, like, well, I'm forgetting my, my lines now. Oh, man, I want my brain. Yeah, it's like that. Right. Well, no one rid me of this. Oh, yeah, yeah, what of this? Oh, okay, now I got to Google it. Yeah, now you got to find it because my brain isn't where I don't, I clearly don't have enough darts nicotine. It's good of this turbulent priest. Yeah, that's it. And right, because I get the issue there is that the Pope was had declared authority over the realm of England. Right. That priests were not subject to civil law. They were only subject to ecclesiastical law and exempt from it. That's a pretty big problem if you're reigning in a place and, oh, by the way, these guys are your subjects, but like if they do bad stuff, real bad crimes, there's nothing you can do. And then they can just scuttle off to some other part of Christendom. So he was asserting the rights of the sovereign over over and against the papacy. So yeah, King Henry hero. Patriot King Henry. And so anyway, I agree with him in principle there. But the question nevertheless is, I mean, this is the question always of Christendom and we'll get to this when we discuss like Constantinism is what do you do when like Bible says every initial bow and Caesar's knee is included there. Right. And what do you do when Caesar's knee finally bows? What do you tell him to do? You tell him like just kind of do things the way you were just not so much pagan stuff. But you're kind of you got to be neutral about everything. You do that maybe or do you say all right, well no, this is how God wants a king to govern. And the king is a father of his people. And so how would you tell a Christian father to govern his household? Right. Well, you kind of tell the same things to to the king, right? A Christian father is not holding up a gun to his child's head and say, all right, say say this prayer right now. Ask Jesus into your heart right now or I shoot. Right. He's not doing that. And neither does a Christian king. Right. Right. How does a Christian father conduct himself? Well, he he treats his children as Christians. He expects them to be Christians. He gives the boundaries. Yeah, he has he rules his house and gives rules for his house that are Christian with the expectation that they would be Christians, right? Even even if they maybe don't become Christian, right in his house. And it's like that makes sense. Like if you want to talk about like a golden age and I don't want to ever do that because history is constantly changing and move like everything. You know, the only constant is change. But you look at like Anglo-Saxon England and King Alfred. And would you like go back to that time and say like, now this is bad, right? You actually need to let the Danes completely overrun everything because if you can't kill them, then like they don't go to heaven. And that's not very gospel of you. Also, you need to let the gays get married. Yeah. Yeah. No, no, like these are Christian kings and they rule this Christians. And so anyway, right, how do you operate within within the context of Christendom? Right. After Caesar is bowed the knee for a thousand years. And then you have someone like Servetus who comes along and I'll just put my cards in the table. John Calvin did nothing wrong. That this man, right, within within this context, right, they say, Oh, Christendom is bad and the melding or the merging or the intricate weaving of religion and politics that's always bad. Um, it's like, okay, well, that's what was. And so that card isn't of that that that's the paradigm in which they lived. But then they're not cognizant of the fact that like Michael Servetus or many of the Anabaptists were not merely guys that just had like a different theological opinion. Right. That's not what they were. Right. These are men who are openly preaching again, and it goes back to what I'm saying, like every word that Calvin wrote, every word that Luther wrote had political implications to them. And because you're in Christendom and theology mattered politically, uh, within Christendom. And so if you're preaching a theology that will tear apart your society, that will overthrow it, that is revolutionary, um, then the state isn't fundamentally dealing with matters of theology. It's right. The state is dealing with matters of the common political order. Yes, correct. And the good of the people. Yep. And so if these are subversives, if they're radicals, you know, in our parlance today, we would define them as terrorists. You have a duty to stamp that out, right, to stop it. And what, and Calvin was like incredibly gracious, like, just do not come here because you will be executed if you come here. So don't even come here. Well, not that. And we have, uh, like you didn't want to. That's right. That's right. Don't come here, man. I get go far from here. Yeah. And even there, it's like he wasn't even a Christian. He denied, he was a, he was literally a heretic. He denied the treaty. And so, but when Gavin is given his, you know, whenever he's, uh, kind of, I would say, doing a little bit of fear mongering, perhaps not on purpose, but like that's what's going on here. I think, uh, I think he wants you to draw the conclusion that like, survey this was just a Christian who was like following his heart and trying to like love God and obey him. And what's actually going on is you have someone, a, someone who has been cast out of the church, a heretic who denies a Trinity who is stirring up political problems such that it is actually a detriment to the entire, their entire Christian order. What does a civil magistrate do with that person? Yeah. You have a redder that was sent back in a time machine 500 years. Yeah. Yeah. That's right. And like, that won't, that what do you do? Yeah. But like, that's, that's, that is ultimately the issue. And, and part of the reformation as well is, um, the difficulty for the Protestants was, right, you have, you know, the Shvarmarae, right, the Anabaptists who, again, right, they, you know, Luther opens up this can of worms. No pun intended. That's a good, that's a good, that's a good theology pun for you guys. There we go. But, uh, you'll, you'll, you'll miss a Pandora's box. Oh, my God. These. Yes. Thank you. Uh, right. You'll miss a Pandora's box. And, uh, and, um, yeah, he's not even, no, no worms. He's on a diet. Right. That's right. And he, uh, where the authority of the papacy and the Catholic church in, in, in, in, matters of, of doctrine is challenged. Uh, and this isn't the first time a who has said done this and many others, uh, but for the first time someone has like political protection to do it. And he opens this up that like, oh, the authority of the pope and the, the authority of Rome can be challenged. Hmm. We can actually read the Bible for ourselves. And, and if you have like reasonable, learned men doing that, that's good. Mm-hmm. That works. But if you have, you know, a bunch of randos who are just like, oh, I can read the Bible for myself and come to any conclusion that I want. Uh, well, Bible says right here, I don't have to pay taxes and I can have a hair and movement. Um, and I can revolt against, uh, against, you know, any papaced lords that, that I want to you. And this is, this is what anabaptist did is, and it's like, wow, I just, you know, I think that, and, and, and always it's like this conflation between Baptists and anabaptists where it's like, well, they just wanted, they didn't want to baptize babies anymore. And it was just their sincere heartfelt conviction that they didn't want to be baptized. You know, they wanted, they wanted a profession of faith first and that's, well, that's what I believe. And so these are the good guys and it's like no, no, no, no, no, no, um, right. That it's, it's actually the opposite. Um, right. There's the entire political and social order is bound up within Christendom. And right, if you were a member of society, you're baptized, right? You can, you know, you can feel free to disagree with that theological, of course. Uh, but that's what works. That's the way the world works. And what they were doing is saying, well, I'm a sovereign citizen. And I don't want to be ruled by these guys no more. And coincidentally, I realized that you don't need to be baptized unless you profess faith, right? It's actually, it's a post-hoc justification for their rebelliousness. That's what anabaptist theology was fundamentally, uh, at least at the outset. And, um, and so you have things like moonstor, uh, that, that take place where I mean, this is like, moonstor was, um, was the French revolution before the French revolution. Like these, they, they take over the city, uh, they do this reign of terror there. It's, it's, uh, full of like disgusting, uh, sexual degeneracy, everything else. And the, both the Catholics and the Protestants, like, join forces and put it down. Um, and, and that's viewed as bad. Uh, but of course, it wasn't, right? This, this threatened to, um, left unchecked. Right, this would completely upend the entire political order of Europe. Right, you would have had revolutions everywhere. Um, and, and nothing but chaos and death. Um, and so everyone, whether they're sympathetic to the reformers or whether they are Roman Catholic, or, um, is horrified and terrified that this is why. Um, and so the, the issue for the reformers is we need to show because like, basically, you have all of these kings and lords, like, everyone thinks that like Europe was this highly centralized place, where, where, uh, in the 16th and 17th century. Uh, I mean, there were large kingdoms like England and France, uh, but the Holy Run Empire is this collection, this confederation of very small principalities, every, and, as well as like Northern Europe and into Eastern Europe and Southern Europe and, um, and so like every noble and Lord and Elector and Duke and, and so forth that has, uh, sovereignty over his territory is like this free agent that you're all vying for. Right. And so you are trying to prove to them. Yes. All right. Theologically, we are correct. The Pope is wrong. Right. Persuade them of this and show, right. This is the correct doctrine. This is what the Bible clearly says and here, and this, this can actually also conforms with, with historical theology going all the way back to the church fathers, right, making that case. And then also saying, and if you adopt this, your entire world won't implode. Right. That's what they're like. This is, that's the point of, of, of why Calvin writes the institutes is it wasn't just like here's a cool theology book for everyone to have from the next 500 years. This, this is for the king of France to know that we are not a threat to you. We, we oppose those people, the terrorists, uh, the anabaptists as much as you do. This will not destroy your country, right. If you, if you tolerate us, yep. And, and so, uh, that's what's going on in the reformation. That's why he's like, he's like, in, in having servitas executed, right. It's like he didn't actually, he's not the one that's like, look in the switch. Yeah. Right. But everyone treats it. But like he approves of it, right. But doing that, giving his approval to it is showing to the entire world. We will maintain order. Yeah. If you adopt our theology, right. It will not blow up everything. Mm-hmm. That's why they did it. Not because it's like, well, these people think differently than us and they have sincere objections to our theology, but they got a burn. It's no, these, these people, servitas, men like him, will upend everything and it will end with hundreds of thousands dead. If we let this continue to have, right. That's why it takes place. That's why they did it. Not because they want to just be big meanies and they want their, their really horrible and sinful people that just love killing. It's a, yeah, I want, I wish Gavin, please watch this and come on and I would love to have that discussion because that is spoiler alert for the rest of the video. He does, he is not going to go into anything like that in church history. It's just this, this was bad and we don't want to do it. Like it's meant to play on your emotions. You see those pictures of people burning and you go like, oh, people burning. That, that sounds bad. I don't want to burn at the stake. Yeah. Yeah. I don't want other people to burn. A lot of you guys are Baptist. You guys, I don't want to be drowned. I don't, I don't want to be drowned. I don't want to drown anyone. And you Presbyterians, if you get power, you're going to drown me. Yeah. It's a fun one. Like that's, yeah, it's always the question of like theory and practice. Right. Where are we in history? We have like, birthday and so like again, to like be fair to him. It's like, yeah, I actually do think there are things that you can learn from boving and kiper and how they approach politics. Different things probably that Gavin appreciates. Right. Yeah. I mean, really, no, like that. What took place in the latter half of the 18th or 19th century in in Holland is something very, very remarkable. Absolutely. That that that Christians took political power. And there's something Christian things with it. That's right. And kiper himself, like the the sphere sovereignty model so long as it's not with incredibly rigid, hard edges that say this far and no further, but like as a general principle, the sphere sovereignty model is is absolutely brilliant. And it's kind of essential to even our political understanding in the Americas of like, no, like there are separate institutions that have real authority. And God has ordained those governments, the government of the home, the government of the church, the government of the civil magistrate. And these are real observations that we can see in scripture. Sometimes they have to check each other. Yeah, as well, exactly, exactly. And so there's a lot to be gained to your point. There's a lot to be learned from these guys. It's not things that perhaps Gavin wants to learn, but not always, but yeah. But it would be it would be interesting to have him actually respond because you just laid out a case for burning heretics. I know. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, let me explain that. No, not actually in America, but like you laid out a case for why Calvin was right. Like, like understanding why they did the things they did. Not just this like caricature of like they're just evil people that did evil stuff for no reason and we condemn it because they're evil. Yeah, well, I mean, essentially, the high level is you laid out the case for a civil magistrate protecting his people, protecting, yeah, protecting like political order. If you have chaos, if you have revolution, everybody dies. And not only that, but Gavin presupposes, and even he explicitly states later in the episode, I think we'll get to here in a second, that a civil man, he doesn't trust a civil magistrate to judge on things of religion, but he does trust a civil magistrate to judge on things like crime. Okay. So why does he trust one and not the other? Well, actually, let's let him make the case. And even that, yeah, we keep running ahead, but like, even that is it's saying, well, you're then you're trusting him to to make a conscious choice about religion, which is the coexist bumper sticker. Yeah, yeah, that's the religion he's going to hold. Let's let him make the case real fast. And we'll finish on point one, and then we'll do episode two here, meant at the development of this theology and various contexts, like my video on Yandhus, who's burned at the stake in 1415, he's one of my great heroes. And by the way, I just will let's land the plane on that. We I joke about making the case for burning hair. It's there was absolutely abuses like that. There were there were actual good faith Christians. I mean, we are products of the reformation ourselves. Like there were people who just wanted to like Martin Luther himself. They tried to kill him for trying to get the Bible into the hands of the common folk. They did burn alive. He he folks, I mean, shortly here, the the neo Calvinists, like, like, Bob ink and Kuiper, who objected to the Belgian confession right to article 36. And that's outside I hold to churches, you know, Heidelberg and Belgium confession. And of course, in Holland, right, it's three forms of unity. And I fully subscribed to article 36. They didn't because like, oh, if we do that, then we're going to have to start burning people. And it's like, well, that you're making a few logical leaps to get there. But it's picture Anakin saying, all right, execute article 36. Yeah, that's right. But but like the issue is again, you you have, well, I mean, even even with the Belgian confession, Gidou de Bray was executed by the Spanish authorities for writing the Belgian confession. He was killed, right, or what he believed. So it isn't to say that, oh, yeah, like the inquisition was awesome. And they did nothing wrong or or or anything like that. William Tindale, one of our heroes burned alive. And Thomas Kranmer, like, like, we object to that too. So we're on the same page, Gavin. I think the principle here is the Latin phrase abusus non-tulidusum abuse does not negate or cancel out the proper use of a thing. So what we want to say is that there was a proper use and an improper use. And it has always been throughout the entirety of church history and history itself, human beings abusing good and natural God-given authority. That happens, but that doesn't mean that that authority doesn't exist or that it's always evil when it's exercised. And they're Roman Catholics. They believed that I mean, they would lump in the reformers with the anabaptists. Yes, correct. And say that these people are as much a threat to the political and social order as these other people. Hey, and on that note, what's interesting is what we wanted to because like they had a point, according to our worldview, like the reformers upset the political order completely. They were a threat to the Pope's supremacy over everything. Exactly. And so what's going on here, though, is that what's the passage in acts where the Sanhedrin was concerned about the apostles preaching the gospel. And then I can't who was it that said, OK, we don't want to, hey, let's leave them alone because the high priest, let's leave them alone because if it's not of God, it will go nowhere. But if it is of God, we will be trying to thwart God's plans themselves. So I consider that kind of how similar to how the reformation worked out like the Catholic church, the Roman, the Roman Catholic church, rather, because it's very important. Roman Catholic, by the way, was Roman was kind of a pejorative because the reformers said, no, we're Catholic. Like we're universal. You guys are tied inherently to this like Romanist political system. We're saying that the church is universal regardless. That's a little aside there for you. But, but the Roman Catholic, what was I saying? I went off on a tangent. That their opposition to the reformers was opposing God. Oh, yeah, that's right. And so we, that's right. The reformers really were upsetting the political order, but it was, it was God ordained and blessed. We see this because the most successful nations throughout the entirety of all history. Now, the Protestant reformation, they were. Yeah, yeah, they were. Correct. Yeah. I think, I think that, but also, I mean, of course, like Roman Catholics watching this would object. I know. We love you. And like, you know, when they, when they think of political theology and a golden age and everything, it's like, well, everything went wrong. At the reformation. Reformation. Yeah. Yeah. That's their genealogy of ideas. Yeah. And so it's like, and to combat that, you have to contend with my point that actually, the most successful nations in history were Protestant. So like, God seems to have completely blessed the Protestant reformation. Anyway, I digress. Love you guys. Still love you guys. I do too. So anyway, yeah, I think that this issue, right, it gets caricatured, it gets treated as this like comic book morality. And it's not taken with the degree of seriousness that honestly, I would expect more out of from really smart guys. Yeah. That's that's that's how I look at it is like, come on. Like they didn't, they didn't just do this because they're like Sith Lords that are going to do evil stuff. Yeah, that's right. That's right. And that's not why. So anyway, you guys weren't ready for that level of new nuance, but we gave it to you very new ones. That's like, that's what that's what that was my nickname in high school, like Mr. nuance. And I walk through the development of this, the policy of heresy pergation from the late 12th century through the early 15. And I show how this was just standard. And for example, in Thomas Aquinas and the sumatheological, it's right there. Heretics deserve to be severed from the world by death. Those are his words. And that was just typical theology. Why did they phrase it? I mean, maybe I need to go watch that. Maybe, maybe to be fair. He gets into this like, why would they think that? Why would they, why would they ever such a thing? And like we've been saying, like there are reasons. There are reasons. You have the day. Now, when the Protestants came along, unfortunately, they largely retained that essential theology. I wonder why. Why would they do that? Not universally and not in all the particulars, but they basically kept that. That is not universally true. You find opposition to this theology of killing heretics among the anabaptists. And then later, among the baptists. What was the terrorist not what terrorist executed? I have no idea. That's crazy. Themselves. And you also find it in other contexts. So for example, in my recent video where I criticized John Calvin for his role in the execution of Michael Servidas, we should react to that one. Honestly, that would be a fun one. Bastion Castellio as an example of an early reformed advocate for religious toleration. But the point is that killing heretics early. I haven't read Sebastian, but I'm Sebastian Castellio. Yeah, I don't trust him. I can tell by the look at it. Look at him. Yeah, he looks a little fizzy agony, man. Okay, for religious toleration. The point is that killing heretics, this is the brutal part of the history we've got to come to terms with. This was largely retained by the Anglican reformed in Lutheran traditions, not totally. And so for example, when the neo-Calvinists came along, they recognized that in opposing that theology, they were departing from historic precedent. So for example, Article 36 of the Belgian confession references the role of the civil magistrate in removing and destroying all idolatry and false worship of the end of Christ. And Bobbink and Kuiper and many others, even before them, were arguing for a revision of this article. And they were quite frank that this was a revision. Here's Kuiper, how he put it, we would rather be considered not reformed and insist that men ought not to kill heretics. Then that we are left with the reformed name as the prize for assisting in the shedding of the blood of heretics. Then he gives his six arguments against it. You have your delorean and you have the opportunity to bring Abraham Kuiper back from like, what do you say this like 1903 or something. And you just pick him up and boom, we're going back to the future and you just walk around Amsterdam. Right. And you maybe visit some churches in Amsterdam, the handful that are still there. Just let him listen, let him see, you know, the big fat women that are preaching from the from maybe his pulpit. I don't even know. And ask him, how you doing bud? What do you think about this? It's still cool with the Oracle 36 of the Belgian confession or maybe possible. Your liberalism got a little out of hand over the last almost century and a half. You know, I don't know, it'd be interesting to see what, you know, Reverend Kuiper might have to say or Dr. Batting. It might be interesting. I don't know. Like maybe some historical experience after the fact, you know, a hundred years behind sight might maybe persuade them that they were a little. Correct. I don't know. Correct. Theology and concludes we do not at all hide the fact that we disagree with Calvin, our confessions and all of ourologians. Right. They would ask me, uh, bosses, this flag, uh, I don't speak Dutch. And, you know, it's like, well, that's, that's the flag for super enjoyers. Yeah. For, for people that, you know, cut off, you know, parts of their body to become the opposite sex. And all of Holland celebrates this and thinks it's wonderful and great. And, uh, and of course, he'd look around and be like, what are, what are all these Muslims doing here? And like, it would, it would be in modern Amsterdam for five minutes. And he would be saying, what happened in a serious problem? That's right. That's what would happen, man. Actually. It's just, it's just difficult to be that like, well, they are actually are objected to Article 36 of the Belgian confession because they did, they, they want, they just toleration. And it's like, yeah, in, in 1890, Holland, you imagine Holland in like 1890, the people of the, be one, they're all, their most liberal people there would be unfathomably conservative by today's standard. Oh my goodness. The most liberal, the most progressive among them. The, the, the most live people in Holland in 1890 that Abraham Kuiper is dealing with would all be immediately banned from the internet. And we've probably jailed, he'd be jailed by modern Holland. Yeah. Immediately. Yes. Immediately. And it's so it's like, oh my god. Oh my god. What are we doing? What are we doing here? Now, my point here isn't that well, we just need to go with Boving and Kuiper as the gold standard. Yeah, because my point is to say, I would go with them today either. Correct. I would like to engage all of church history or at least take it into account or at least have a principled reason for saying this earlier theology is superior to the later theology and argument. 1890 Holland. Like, I'd be cool living there. Yeah. I would, I mean, yeah, we don't have penicillin or, you know, modern dentistry or any of those things. And, you know, I might already be dead. Actually, but I'd be cool living there. You know, I would be, I'd put on my little wooden shoes and, and, you know, pick some tulips and like life would be pretty good. I mean, considering that 99.9999% of people there would actually be Dutch. And Christian. And Christian. Yep. And I wouldn't have to worry about getting stabbed by a Muslim in 1890 Holland. That would be, that would be a plus. I wouldn't have to worry about getting shot in a drive by shooting in 1890 Holland. There would be, you know, I wouldn't, I mean, maybe I would be discriminated against because I'm an American. But for the thought experiments, like Sam Dutch, be about orange is taller than I am. And I wouldn't have to worry about like, oh, is, or my, or my son's going to grow up into a world where everyone hates them. And they're shut out from every possible opportunity simply because they are white, straight and Christian. I wouldn't have to worry about this. I wouldn't have to worry about is, is my son going to marry a woman that is utterly horrible, even, and, and, and, and totally effeminist, even though she espouses belief in Christ. I don't have to worry about those things in 1890 Holland, absolutely not. Right. And so, like, you're, you're, so like, to take his example, like, very clearly, like, this is kind of the golden age for him. And it's like, yeah, let's, let's have the same particularities and conditions that they existed in. And I'm like, I'll see that to you. Yeah. can do liberalism in 1890 in colonies. That's right. That's cool. We cannot do it today. That's right. That's sorry. Yep. That's right. Be given for that. So in other words, what we shouldn't say is what here's what the Belgian Confession said, for example, or here's what the reformers said, for example, and the alternative to that is just 21st century revisionist views. No, there is dialectical unfolding throughout the modern era and we need to look at the whole picture. Yeah, that's what we're doing. That's my point there. Now just as a quick aside, if you want to learn more about Boving, one of my great goals for my YouTube channel is to encourage the study of church history. Boving is a theological giant. I would love to encourage you to engage more with him. James Eglinton's biography, which I think I'm sorry. I keep to let him talk for 10 seconds and I have to say something, but we can do it. We can pause him anytime we want. That's right. It's our show. That's right. But the the the the fast. I mean, I like I like reading, you know, I like reading guys that that do historical theology. Like I like reading, you know, guys like Carl Truman, for example, like he's got a lot of good stuff. But the the problem, perennially with guys like this is they cannot conceptually inhabit the world in which those things are penned. Like in some ways they can, like I was reading a Truman's book on John Owen. And so he's obviously very familiar. I mean, he's from the British Isles. He's Scottish. I believe he's Scottish, right? Yeah, he's Scottish. They, you know, reformed guys kind of have this, you know, almost like this fetish for Scottish allotions. He's got the accent. Everything's great. That's right. You know, doesn't matter if it's not. But that's an aside. But yeah, like so he has a tremendous amount of familiarity with British history, history of England in the period, history of the English Civil War and so forth. And so it's really good to read, really valuable. But I still don't like as I'm reading it, I still don't get the picture that that he can, you know, like there's there's some like emotional block or or something or psychological block where he cannot inhabit that world himself. And think like a person in that world, right? That's why I like, yeah, I'm sort of a, you know, a cinephile. I like movies, like good movies. And so like I really like the director Robert Egger's because his movies, although I didn't see the last one because everyone said it was terrible. But sometimes people are wrong. So maybe I should. But like he, he builds this world, this historical world, where you're in that world. Like you are like the people there because always movies are so anachronistic, right? Where it's like it's just clearly modern people playing dress up with modern ideas. Yeah, like they think like modern people, they talk like modern people are like feminist egalitarians in the 16th century, and and it's like he does not do at all. And it's so refreshing to see this. But it's like guys who do historical theology, almost to a man cannot do that. Right? They can't like, okay, now I am a man in 1530 Geneva, Switzerland. I think like someone there. I think like I'm living in an inhabiting, you know, wearing the shoes and the clothes of of a 16th century man in Europe. How would I think about these things? How would I think about what Calvin is saying or so on and so forth? Can't do it. Can't not do it. Actually, everything is well, obviously this is very, did this or that or the other side. They can't bring themselves to live in the world as it actually existed. Right. And you do yourself a huge disservice if you cannot do that. Right? You can't actually study history. You can't just study the historical development of theology. If you can't step outside your world, even a little bit, or a lot of it, you won't understand. Right? These will all just be ivory tower theoretical things. And they weren't for these men. Right? You could sit back in your department of historical studies at a seminary, you're making $300,000 a year, you drive in a range rover and you have a pretty comfortable life. And think great things about these great men and their great ideas. But that's not what they were doing. Right. But every single thing that they said had intense significance to the daily life of their people. That's the always like the ironic thing to me is, I mean, all these reform guys just are steeped in ornitheology. And all of it is completely divorced from actual people today and what concerns them and what they, what like what they're thinking about. You know, I know that like in most evangelical congregations in America on Sunday, this last Sunday, most of the people, particularly the men, but also the women are very concerned about what is going to happen on Tuesday. Right. They're worried about it. And most of the pulpits were silent on that issue. These things or if not the pulpit, like the pastor, they have no idea what their pastor thinks about anything politically, politically at least. And so, but they maybe, and like were formed churches. They'll drop a ton of quotes from from Calvin or from, you know, John Owen or theodore Beza or whatever they'll name the guys you haven't even ever heard of. And it's like, oh, that's cool. How does that connect to my life really at all? It's like, that's really interesting stuff. And it's like, our people, Ray, someone to say, well, here's how this connects to life. Right. Here's how this theological idea, because all of this stuff was intensely political and had a direct impact on their life. Like I've been reading a lot on the Reformation as you probably can glean from the last hour and a two hours. Two hours. Dude, we're doing it. Yeah, you just bring me in here because it's like, you know, just talked all time. This is easy content. Yeah, it's like all I gotta do is just bring Andrew, wind him up, put a quarter in and then we go. But it's fascinating to me that just even the idea that the people are needed to have communion in both forms, right? Both bread and wine. This is this sticking point that people are willing to die over. Yeah. It matters that much. And we think of it. It's just like, what's got a trivial? Like, maybe you want the little cracker. Maybe you want some grape juice or whatever. And it's like, these people are going to die if you didn't give them bread and wine. And it's like, because it mattered directly to their life. And it's still, of course, it still does matter. But we just, we don't make those, we don't let, yeah, we, we, we don't teach, we don't teach, we don't teach people that it matters. They don't have any idea how much it matters politically. Yeah, yeah, actually. But like the out like they don't like chrysendum and the intertwining of theology and politics. It's like, theology is inescapably political. Absolutely. Every part of it is political because Jesus Christ is king over everything. And so, how we understand him, how we understand his word, we'll inform how we think about everything. That's right. And how we think about who should be in charge of things? What should they do? It matters. Right. It matters tremendously. So, anyway, that's my, I just talked for half an hour. No, I love it. It's a brand. We got, we'll finish up the second. Yeah, he's got like three minutes. I won't, you know, one minute. I won interrupt. I'd love to recommend that. By the way, I wrote a review of that biography before. And I talked about how ex before reading that biography, how he was a social and political vision was. And I talked about it. It's just amazing. I didn't realize this to this extent. Before reading that biography, how he was, he served in the Dutch parliament, he advocated for female suffrage. He was deeply, deeply involved. It's a great example of how rejecting coercion need not mean withdrawal from public life. He was deeply engaged. So he's just someone that's just in front of you. So if you'd like to learn more about bovank and I was just saying letters from the alphabet. Oh, just random. Yeah. That's what I thought I was doing. I drew. Well, you saw the other one too. I mean, since you interrupted, I now I blank check. But like the dangers of colonialism. Oh, scary. Seems like a liberal to me. Oh, boy. But yeah, back, back to you, back up to that quote again. That's why after World War One, great to learn, Giger. I mean, World War One was awful, destroyed Christendom. So like, we will give him the W on one. Yeah. For sure. For sure. Look like he was deeply engaged. And he was just someone I'm trying to win in society. That isn't an inherently bad thing. No, of course not. Either of course. Well, again, going back to like the society that you're living in, you're thinking like, hey, we value women. And like destroying the household. Yep. By saying, all right, the husband and the wife have an equal share in political authority. Hell, I don't think that's a good development. But it's not how God made the world. But it's obvious. And we were talking about this before we live like it's obvious to us living in 2026. That probably I can understand. You talk about getting in the mind of people who lived in their era. Like I could totally understand. I can see why they thought like, this is good. We should do this. Yeah. You know, I get it. Yeah, I get it. I get it again, like hindsight is 20, 20. Don't always agree with how things have turned out. I think, I mean, just even in general, expanding the electorate is a bad thing. Oh, yes. I mean, my whole thing when everyone, anyone brings up the, do you think women should be allowed to vote is I think like very few people should be allowed. I don't think I should be allowed to vote. So I'd be happy if like one out of every 10,000 people got to vote. Yep. And but that's what I think. They need to be intelligent. They need to be conscientious. They need to be Christian. They need to be virtuous. Like head of household, you know, a connection to the past, a connection to the future. Yeah, all these, I mean, this, this was common sense to our founding fathers, but you watched like saying that out loud on a college campus. Like it will literally steal people's breath away. Like I don't know, maybe like the 30,000 best warriors, right? They should be allowed to be. Yeah. Yeah. Just have like, you know, military hunter. I don't know. I don't know. Like, we're just, we're doing theory here. We're just throwing out ideas. I encourage us to read about him. If you'd like to learn more about boving, another great book is this one edited by Gray's Attenta. Okay. As opposed to someone says, and they answer my first question, and they say, yes, we have considered this full span of development. And we just agree with Calvin and earlier views over and against, say, boving and later views. We think the earlier are the correct ones, not because of reverse chronological snobbery. We just have an argument here's the argument. Okay, fair enough. We made it. All right, Gavin, I'm, I don't know what's two hours long, but I'm expecting a response here over the last day. That leads to my second question. We need to slip the parts. Yeah, we will. Yeah, that's right. The, the, the, the industry. You know, I'm, you know, I'm to him. Yeah. Question, which stems from my deep conviction that we don't want to go back to that 17 and 16th century world. Here's the question. What religious freedom should exist in a Christian government? And crucially, this point, who decides how to determine that? teaser. That'll be for the next episode of the Reformation Red Pill podcast. I think we've left you with a lot to think about. Hopefully. Yeah, I mean, honestly, I'm thinking about let's just get practical here for a second. Like, 2019 Joshua would listen to 2026 Joshua and Andrew podcast here and go, I don't know about that. Andrew, that's a, that sounds a little radical. That sounds a little crazy, even though it's clear that you weren't suggesting that we do that in 2026, America, we're operating in the world of theory. You're not constrained by history or what is. Right. You're just thinking, okay, what is good? What's good in right? You know, theoretically, how should a ruler govern so on and so forth? Not, we're not making policy prescriptions for like Donald Trump to carry out. Exactly. Yeah. And so what, what I want to, I guess, communicate to you guys in the audience, anyone who is where I was, I guess part of my podcast is an appeal to 2020 or a 2019 Joshua say like, Hey, there's an argument here that you have that you know nothing about that you've never even considered. A lot of people are going to listen to this episode and encounter for the first time, like an argument that the civil magistrate has authority that they never had considered before. That's perhaps, uh, or just like what the purpose of political power is. Yeah. Exactly. Exactly. You're maintaining order. You're maintaining order. And God has given every civil magistrate. He is according to scripture, God raises up every single king, every single ruler. And he either raises those kings and rulers up for the benefit and blessing of that people or he raises them up for judgment. And so, um, asking yourself like in Calvin's Geneva and these various places throughout Christian history, Christendom, uh, was it good and right for the civil magistrate to protect Christian order or was he was did he have was he duty bound to promote, you know, 20th century secular pluralistic liberalism was it was was he in sin or not promoting that or or did that please God that he would seek to protect good order. And again, uh, the abuse does not negate the proper use. And so what we want to say is that there was abuses and power and authority that is endemic, that is that that happens throughout the entirety of all human history that things can be abused. But that doesn't mean that the thing itself was inherently sinful or evil. So I hope that you investigate this further. We'll, we'll tease it out more and more. You're studying Reformation history. So it'll come up again. Yeah. And like, again, like these are questions of theory. Right. We're dealing with theory here. And and when you're engaging in the questions of theory, it's not like should we do this right now today and try to make this happen. It is right. Is it possible that this is good and right and just for it to be this way, you know, all things be equal? Is it is it possible? Have you ever considered that maybe maybe if the world was just a little bit different than it is today? Right. This might be okay. Um, yeah. Right. Those are the questions that are that we are asking not, not, uh, yeah. Like, so which people do you want to burn at the state, Joshua? And that's right. Like, uh, no, that's not, that's not at all. Uh, what we were saying. But it's like, okay, like 500 years of, of a renewed chrysendum, right, have, have happened. Uh, most people in your society or Christian, again, uh, whether in their true heart of hearts in, in total sincerity or, um, you know, a, maybe a minority that are just nominally. Yeah. Uh, and but that's, that's the world that you now inhabit. Now what do you do? Right? Asking those questions. And those are things that I think people never really consider at all. Um, and so that's why we're asking them because I mean, we're, I think trying to earnestly answer the questions that he asked. Um, and I mean, yeah, we were a little silly there a little bit, but, uh, you gotta be a little silly. Yeah. We're trying to have some fun. Uh, but I, I, I, I, I, I, again, like, I, I think these are things, I mean, yeah, you say 2019, Joshua, I mean, for me, it's probably like 2013 or 2014, Andrew, uh, if I'm saying, because I, yeah, I think I remember, like thinking about Servitas and Calvin, even then and just being a little bit uncomfortable, yeah, yeah, with that idea, um, partly because I hadn't ever considered okay, uh, why would they ever do that? Um, and, and so those are the questions like that, that's why I mean, for me, since I was a small child, was always fascinated by history because, um, often you're, you're studying something that is completely and totally alien. Yeah. It's like you're landing on a different planet and you don't know any of the customs or the ways or, you know, even the language of these people, um, you're exploring very strange new worlds when you're studying history. And, um, a lot of people don't want to do that. They want to just put on like their, um, their 21st century glasses and view everything through those lenses. Mm-hmm. And, and judge the, the things based on that. And you, you really can't do that. No, you can't. No. Well, guys, we're going to land it there and we will do part two coming out the following day. Two of five. Yeah. Yeah. That's right. Dude, that, yeah, by the way, our, our, uh, I think what we started off as like a two part series for immigration is a five part series, but it's fire. So, but it's so important. It's so important. It's so good. And that's, that's why like I, I only feel, you know, tiny bit embarrassed. No, dude, it's, it's so good. Like every time, yeah, every time I come here, it's like, yeah, let's do this video. It's 20 minutes long. So I think we could do it in an hour. And I'm like, yeah, right. Okay. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I just, at this point, I just deserve every time you laugh at me, when I'm writing. All right. Guys, well, that does it for us. Uh, patronize all our sponsors. Please, that's it does. I think we're real quick. My, for my real G's out there, um, because you know who you are. Uh, I've been, I've gotten such good feedback from a lot of my sponsors that are like, hey, we've, we've taken out ads with other people. Like your people, like patronize us. The best. You guys are awesome. And you guys cancel. Look, I'm demonetized on tech talk, demonetized on Facebook, which was our big earner. You know, they try to cancel me six ways from Sunday. You guys help me keep going. So it would mean a ton to me. If you guys were trying to get like 20 of these things moved. That's it. 20 of these things moved this month. And it makes it worth it for our sponsor. So, you know, we, we, we, we do 50 all the better. But like, let's get some mugs off. Yeah, 1000. That's right. That'll actually help. Uh, these are all handmade. So the wonderful woman who actually hand makes these, that would enable them to like buy the property that they're like hoping to buy. So if we get 1000 mugs, yeah, uh, sold all the better. So got you get a burn in stuff. Uh, yeah. That's right. That's, that'll go in the thumbnail. Something like that. Yeah, that's right. You get a burn in stuff. Oh, man. That's terrible. Yeah. All right. That's, uh, let's, let's, let's, we need to shut this down. Get out there and build a fan that expands the kingdom of our Lord Jesus Christ. Amen.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Once in a Lifetime Hike + Thanksgiving Concussion in China + Shenzhen Smuggler [China Compass]

    Nov 21, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Welcome to China Compass on the Fight Laugh Feast Network! I'm your China travel guide, Missionary Ben. Follow me (@chinaadventures) on Twitter/X where I post new/unique Chinese city prayer profiles every single day....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A Plea To Wes Huff [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 20, 202611 minAudio

    Wes Huff's plagiarism controversy has raised serious questions about Christian integrity, accountability, and public repentance. In this special episode, Pastor George Sayour examines the allegations against Christian...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Are Christians Thinking about U.S. Policy in the Middle East in Relation to the Person of Christ? [God, Law, and Liberty]

    Nov 20, 202625 minAudio

    Today David examines what “Biblical worldview value,” if any, Christians would place on the present nation of Israel in determining the United States' policy for Israel and the Middle East if objective knowledge of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 248. What Hinders Maturity in Men? [Leadership Now Podcast]

    Nov 19, 20261 hrAudio

    Tune into this episode of Leadership Now with Dr. Aaron Rock where Aaron provides some wisdom and insight into some of the things preventing men from growing in maturity. More Resources: More resources at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Should Government Enforce God's Law? Responding to Todd Friel [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 19, 202642 minAudio

    Should Christians support laws that force unbelievers to behave morally? Or does God forbid the government from enforcing biblical morality? In this episode of *The Magistrate*, James Baird and Josh Howard respond to a...

    Credit the people on this episode