Oh boy! Theophanies, Christophanies, what are they? And what's the difference? Take Heart with Gory Wing, the world view with Alex Cochman, the Magistrate, with James Baird and Josh Howard, the based Boomer podcast with Mike D. Virgilio, the millennial medic with Jacob Glass, down to Earth theology with Matt Plett, Shadows to Substance with George Seor, five new episodes every week. We are the E-M-Net. I'm George Seor, this is Shadows to Substance, here on the E-M-Network. And we're going to be talking Theophanies and Christophanies, these visible, external manifestations of God, two people who are the most powerful, and the most powerful, and the most powerful, and the most powerful, and the most powerful, and the most powerful, and the most powerful, two people, particularly in your Old Testament. And we're going to talk what the words mean, if there's a difference between them, some of my pet peeves, some of where I think I disagree with the way theologians handle this at times. And so let's get into it. A Theophany, you know, Theos is God, so it's basically a visible, external manifestation of God to a human. And we think of the Moses and the Burning Bush, that is viewed as a Theophany. Many people view Theoshanies as if that's the Father communicating. I would say everybody who uses the idea of Theophany, and I certainly use the word that's a Theophany, because it's formally correct. That's God. All three persons of the Trinity are God. But people tend to want to distinguish as God or the Father from a Christophany, which would be this vision of the Sun, this manifestation, visibly, in creation of the Sun. And I think that's an important distinction here to make is we're talking about something that is visually seen in creation. And this is what I think distinguishes Christophany's and Theophany's from, you know, like just visions or dreams. Now, as I was researching this, because I wanted to make sure, because in my own mind, you know, like a Daniel's dream of one, like a son of man coming on a clouds, that's a dream. It's a vision within a dream, as it were, but it's not something he is seeing as interacting with in creation, physically in front of him, in his right mind, in his consciousness. And to be sure, some people would still call that a Theophany. But I do think we need to distinguish between dreams that say Joseph gets, for instance, or dreams that Daniel sees in his visions, or even how the prophets received their communication. I mean, in some cases, God could appear to them visibly and they gave it, but generally, that's how we think of how the prophet is getting their message. I don't think we should be considering those Theophonies. They're real communication by, and revelation by the God of the universe, supernaturally, of course. But when we think of Theophonies, and again, or Christophonies, we are thinking of, again, like the burning bush. Moses is experiencing this in his consciousness in front of him. That's what we're thinking about. And so, I want to read two stories of what would be Christophonies. And these would be appearances of a pre-incarnate son of God. People would distinguish that as a Christophany, marking it out specifically as the second person of the Trinity, the son. Now, I don't call that, and I'll talk about this later. The pre-incarnate Christ. I don't use that language, and I'll explain why. But I'm okay with calling it a Christophany, because it is a visual manifestation of the second person of the Trinity, who we know becomes man, becomes Christ. So, put that aside for a sec. Let's look at two Christophonies, and then we'll get back to some of these distinctions I'm trying to make. The first one is, in Daniel chapter three, the fiery furnace, very famous example of the fourth man in the furnace. And so, Nebuchadnezzar throws the three men, Daniel's three friends into the furnace, Shadrach, Meshach, and Abendigo. And it says, then, King Nebuchadnezzar, Daniel 3, verse 24, was astonished and rose up in haste. He declared to his counselors, did we not cast three men bound into the fire? They answered and said to the king, true, okay? He answered and said, but I see four men unbound walking in the midst of the fire, and they are not hurt. And the appearance of the fourth is like a son of the gods. And so, Nebuchadnezzar is looking into a real furnace with real fire, with three physical real men and the fire that they are looking into the furnace, with three physical real men and yet he sees a fourth man. This is him not in a dream. This is what he is experiencing in creation. That is a theophany, and more specifically, we would want to say that's a Christophany because we would attribute that fourth man to the son, the second person of the Trinity and the fire with them. That's typically how they're viewed. And again, I'm going to tell you in a minute why I think all Christophany, all theophanies are actually just Christophanies. But the second story I want to talk about just to show this is not like a one-off thing is when Joshua in Joshua chapter 5. When Joshua was by Jericho, he lifted up his eyes and looked and looked and behold, a man was standing before him with his sword drawn in his hand and Joshua went to him and said to him, are you for us? Or for our adversaries? Are you for or against us? And he said no. I love that. But I am the commander of the army of the Lord. Now I have come. And Joshua fell in his face to the earth and worshipped and said to him, what does my Lord say to his servant? And the commander of the Lord's army said, Joshua, take off your sandals from your feet for the place where you're standing is holy and Joshua did so. And I know it says Joshua worships this being and this being obviously accepts the worship. It's not like in the book of Revelation where John bows down before the being and the being says, no, you must not do that. I don't receive worship. That's clearly an angel, a messenger from God. But here this being receives the worship. And so this is a theophony. More specifically, a Christophony. We would view this as Jesus, the son, the second person of the Trinity. Other examples in the Old Testament. Obviously we've already mentioned the burning bush with Moses there, though. God does not appear as a man, but he the bush is burning and his presence is there. And he actually, the bush is on fire, but it's actually not being consumed, which is a picture of the whole incident to be honest, because to come into the presence of God should consume us. And yet this God who is indeed a consuming fire draws near to us in the person of Christ and doesn't consume us. Beautiful picture of God protecting us from his holiness in that, in that we can know him personally. But anyway, the voice from the bush comes out. God says, you know, I am, gives his name. And of course we know Jesus later says that he is, his name is I am. And that should give you an indication that the communication from the bush is Jesus, right? But we would say, not we, many people would say, well, that's a theophony. Maybe even say that's the father. And yet Christ identifies with that event, with the same name, because all communication of God in creation is via the second person of the Trinity is my understanding of how God communicates. Even, you know, in the beginning God created the heavens and the earth, then God said, let there be light. And there was light. Well, in John 1, Jesus is the word. And the beginning was the word. And the word was with God. And the word was God. He was with God in the beginning. He's both with and and one with. Like it's, it's, you know, we can't, mind can't comprehend or understand that. But the point is the communication is Christ. Well, is Jesus. Now this side of the cross, we would say Christ. And so I think, you know, all these theophonies are actually the second person of the Trinity. I'm not going to be dogmatic about that, but that's the way I'm going to treat them. And the burning bush to me is the classic example, because that's typically the one that people want to call a theophony and not a Christophony. And here God is identifying his self in a way that Christ himself identifies himself. Another theophony slash Christophony is Jacob wrestling with God. Right? So you have those things. So some of the distinctions I want to make is the theophony Christophony distinction. In my mind, now I guess we can go case by case, but in general, theophonies are actually Christophonies, the second person of the Trinity. It's God communicating and interacting in creation. He does that via the Sun. I want to distinguish also between dreams and visions from Christophonies. From theophonies. Because Joseph's dreams are not the same thing. Him having an awareness and an apprehension of something occurring in his cognitive senses is a different thing than interacting in creation and seeing and hearing and being communicated with and to God. That's a different thing. So Joshua is standing there and where he is standing, he comes across a man who's God. Nebuchadnezzar looks into an actual furnace where he put three men and there's four men in the furnace. These are theophonies different than in my opinion, Daniel having a vision of the Son of Man coming on the clouds. Those visions, those dreams, Joseph has, whatever are no less revelation. They're still revelation, but that's a different thing in my mind. Let's see. I believe all theophonies are actually Christophonies, but you can call them theophonies too because Christ is God or Jesus is God. I don't believe that Jesus is, I mentioned this, I didn't explain it. I don't believe that saying the pre-incarnate Christ is a formally proper designation. Jesus, the second person of the Trinity, becomes the Christ in his incarnation. Now, that was from the foundation of the world. In his being, God doesn't change. He gets all that, but Philippians 2, he comes into creation and takes on flesh. As far as time goes and the created order goes, that is a moment in time. However, that works and eternity is a different story. And so, Christ means the anointed one. This is the new Adam. Jesus isn't the new Adam in eternity past except in concept, but he becomes the new Adam in space and time when he is born and takes on flesh. And is anointed as the anointed one. I think that's what's going on in the baptism. And that may be the one place where you'll see the Father speaking into creation. It's to communicate with the Son. And about the Son and to establish the Father's Son relationship in that this is my beloved Son in whom I'm well pleased. Where this is my Son, listen to him. I don't think that negates what I'm saying about Christophany's and theophonies. I think there's something unique going on there in Jesus as the Christ, but my point is pre-incarnation. There is no Christ. Christ is incarnate. And so, what do you mean, George? I thought you said there's Christophany's. Yes, and I don't know if you know how I realized how I said that. But that is the pre-incarnate son, second person of the Trinity. So the Son always exists as the Son in eternity. And he is pre-incarnate until he comes as Jesus of Nazareth. So I don't know if that's confusing or not, but I don't say pre-incarnate Christ. It's just, to me, it's a contradiction. But he is the pre-incarnate son. So that's another distinction I make in this whole conversation. So let me see if I can go through that quick again. I think all theophonies are Christophonies. I think theophonies and Christophonies are different than God's revelation in dreams. And maybe visions. I mean, the one that's got me, I'm not sure about his Abraham and the flaming smoking pot. Because I said he was put into a sleep. And yet the whole account seems like maybe he's not in a sleep. And so I don't know how to do that. But I do know he's talking to God before he goes into sleep. But there's no evidence that there's anything visible into the flaming pot at any rate. All theophonies are Christophonies. Theophonies and Christophonies are different than visions and dreams. Because they are actually a part of and interacting in and as the physical world. And I don't like the phrase pre-incarnate Christ, even if theologians use it. I think it's a contradiction. But I would think it's appropriate to say the pre-incarnate son of God. Anyway, hopefully this helps you think through some of these things and also gives you some examples of theophonies and Christophonies. And it really does play into what we do here on Shadows to Substance. Or what I do here on Shadows to Substance is I show you how the things in the Old Testament point into the New Testament in particular to Jesus. So as I've said, and as you know I'm George Saylor, this is Shadows to Substance on the EM Network thanks to the sponsors Steadfast Sagarz and Rockwall Bibles. And to our affiliate network or the fact that we're an affiliate with the FLF Network. Our sponsors SteadfastSagarz.com promo code escatology10 RockwallBibles.com Boniface Media Grace and Truth Press Grace and Truth Records