Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

FLF, LLC

FLF, LLC artwork

Reclaiming the Christian University [The Ezra Institute Podcast for Cultural Reformation]

Nov 5, 20261 hr 9 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What is the purpose of higher education? Is university simply a pathway to a career, or should it be something far greater? In this episode of the Podcast for Cultural Reformation, Pastor Nate Wright and Dr. Joe Boot are joined by Dr. Ben Merkle, President of New Saint Andrews College and Ezra Institute Fellow for Higher Education, to examine the crisis facing modern universities and the urgent need to recover a distinctly Christian vision for higher education. From the Christian origins of the medieval university to the rise of government-funded, career-focused education, the conversation explores how higher education has drifted from its original purpose of forming thoughtful, virtuous leaders equipped to shape culture. The discussion also examines the moral and spiritual consequences of secular education, the growing resurgence of classical Christian schools, and why rebuilding Christian institutions of higher learning is essential for the future of Western civilization. Drawing on his experience at New Saint Andrews College, Dr. Merkle offers a compelling vision for education rooted in Scripture, the liberal arts, and the formation of Christian cultural leaders. Is the modern university beyond saving, or could the recovery of classical Christian education help shape a new generation of leaders for Christ and His kingdom?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

Today on the podcast for Cultural Reformation, we are joined by Dr. Ben Merkel, and we'll be discussing the Christian University and the classical tradition. Well, welcome back to the podcast for Cultural Reformation. This is a ministry of the Ezra Institute where we work to engage culture with the claims of Christ by equipping current and emerging cultural leaders with biblical worldview, Christian philosophy, and cultural apologetics studies. We do this through print and digital resources. You're listening to one of our digital resources, the podcast for Cultural Reformation. I am your host, Pastor Neat Wright. I am joined as I often am by our president and founder, Dr. Joe Boote, and our very special guest, one of our fellows, Dr. Ben Merkel, who is the president of New Saint Andrews in Moscow, Idaho, has written a few books that we have referenced here on the podcast, and he is our fellow for higher education. Dr. Ben Merkel, how are you? I'm well, it's privileged to be here. We're really excited to have you. How are you, Joe? I'm fighting Fittonate just getting ready for a mission to God conference in the UK and looking forward to having you over this side of the pond actually in a few days time. So I know it'll actually be my first time in the UK. So I'm really excited about that and I'll relate to all of our listeners, the kind of hospitality I received from the boots, we're looking forward to that. So for any of our listeners, we'll be in the UK for the mission of God conference. And then the weekend after that, actually, Joe and I will both be in Winnipeg, where we're doing the think, Christianly on the church conference with some of our pastor friends in Winnipeg. And actually, Dr. Ben Merkel is going to be joining us in the late winter in Edmonton for think Christianly on education conference. So lots coming up and if you're any of those areas, we would love for you to come and see us. But Dr. Merkel, we are here today and we want to talk about kind of reclaiming higher education. And you know, you're our fellow for higher education. You are the president of New St. Andrews, where I think you've been leading the way in a lot of ways. Our church started a classical Christian school. I know Joe, many years ago, started a classical Christian school in the heart of Toronto, Ontario. But in a lot of ways, many of us have been following in the footsteps of New St. Andrews and Logos and everything that's been happening in Moscow. So what do we start a little bit by talking about what is the purpose of higher education as the fellow for higher education as a man who's devoted his life to educating Christianly? What's the purpose of higher education and why is it so important for Christians who are trying to engage the culture? Yeah, I think that's a great question. I like that you made the distinction between just a class of education and then higher education. Because when we talk about like class education, you're talking about those K-12 years, which is about laying a solid foundation of a Christian worldview, you know, the nurture and admonition of the Lord. I think we're commanded to give all of our kids. But when higher education, it is something a little bit different. I think that when it comes to higher education, what you're doing is you're, I think you should be selecting a little bit more narrowly and identifying those young people with a higher ability, potential for cultural leadership. And you're basically laying a deeper foundation, not just the nurture and admonition of the Lord, but actually what is this Christian heritage and what does cultural leadership look like? And what are the skills of that cultural leadership? And I say that you're selecting a little bit more narrowly because I think the broader conception of higher education is higher education is about vocational certification. You need to college degree to get a certain job. So we name all of our degrees after jobs and you know whether you're getting an intelligent degree or an unintelligent degree based on whether your degree sounds like a high paying job or sounds like a low pay. You know, you're getting a job in mechanical engineering or accounting that's your uncle will tell you what things giving good job. But if you're getting that, you know, your college degree and feminist film theory, then, you know, like what's the point of that? So we tend to think that it's about vocational certification. And I think that that is a real first of all, it robs us in two ways. It lies in that it tells all of our kids they have to get a college degree to get a job. And I just don't think that's true. We start pushing college on kids for whom it's a total waste of time and just not a good use of their time or their money. But we act like this is the necessary gate. They have to go through and already get a job. But also we rob ourselves in that we we've quit inculcating those skills of Christian cultural leadership. And we've given our best and brightest over to secular vocational training, rather than helping them to like have an understanding of what is this Christian heritage and what is it look like to build a culture around that? Yeah, that's really good. I think, you know, as we think about modern university and I like I grew up in that that line, right? Just go get the university degree and everything in your life is going to turn out fine, right? Just whatever it is, just go get your whether it's your English degree or your, you know, whatever it is, just go get the degree and everything's going to work out fine. And you know, many guys my age in our 40s, we went and got our degree and we graduated with a bunch of debt and, you know, our degrees were in, you know, English literature or I mine is an infamous study so you can stay on the call bend. But it's, you know, we graduate with these degrees, we have fancy artwork for the wall, we have all this debt. And it's really because our modern universities have slipped away from the idea of the formation of a human, right? And I think that's that's one of the things I've heard you talk about often that I think is so missing in sort of the modern university, right? There's the focus is on career specialization, like you said, or even like training ideological commitments or economic utility. But education sort of moving away from a coherent understanding of truth and the idea that part of its purpose is to shape a human life. It's, it's loves, it's desires, it's, you know, all that. So talk a little bit about sort of the foundation of shaping human beings as part of higher education. Yeah, well, I like how in the in the in the classical tradition, we name our courses after like basically intellectual disciplines rather than after jobs that you could get. So, you know, students at NSA will study rhetoric, they'll study philosophy, they'll study music, they'll study theology. And nobody taking those courses, at least I hope nobody taking those courses has the expectation that their job is when they graduate, NSA to go out and do philosophy professionally, you know, I'll go out and be a philosopher for money or a, a, a, a, a recreation. But the point is not that we're trying to create this, this vocation for you, but that we're actually aiming at these, these core skills of being a human that take, if you want to really um teach someone to be able to stand in front, up front, and present in a compelling way, to write in a compelling way, um, it takes real time to do that in a, in a really effective way. And yet those skills, even though they don't correspond immediately to one particular job, they empower all work. So somebody who can think critically, can communicate clearly, that can listen and comprehend what's being said, rather than, you know, always talk to tell the students, you have to be able to distinguish between what you were listening to or what you were reading versus thoughts that I was thinking while you were talking. And I think a lot of times, you know, I see conversations happening where there's no conversation happening because nobody is taking the time to actually listen to being what's being said on the other side. They're just interacting with the thoughts that are bubbling in their head while the other person is talking. And taking the time to actually go and do this sort of real basic exercises, the blocking and tackling of learning what, excuse me, what rhetoric is like, what, how language works, what, and what is a compelling argument that ought to command your belief, what is an argument that has fought, taking the time to really understand that well, has a disproportionate effect in all kinds of different jobs. I think that's the other thing that I would just point out and this is increasingly true. If you go back 50 years, you know, 50 to 70, 80 years, it was common to get a job coming out of college and to hold that same job, the entirety of your life, to stay in that discipline, the entire of your life. What we're finding now is careers are intensely fluid. And whereas before your only movement might be moving up, being promoted to management or something like that, now people people move in a real fluid way laterally. You started off as, you know, you were an accountant, then you decided you actually liked real estate, then you ended up as a headmaster of a classical Christian school, and then you went into the ministry or something like that. I just see people who shift careers really, really quickly. Some of it was just because the nature of the way our careers are, but some would also, I think the nature of technology making certain skills are going obsolete really quickly. And so you have to be able to move laterally, really swiftly. And people who are trained to think in terms of just one discipline, this is the thing I know how to do. Don't adjust to that well. Whereas people who are trained to think or like a human and just understand what am I capable of? I can do this, but I could transition over here and do the same thing here. I think our farm were prepared for the for the job market that is increasing in front of us. I think AI and technology and whatnot are going to make things like that liberal arts education far more valuable. Yeah, that's really good. Joe, one of the reasons we wanted to talk to Dr. Merkel today is to kind of piggyback on our conversation with Sarah Jane Bentley from last week. And she kind of discussed education from primary, secondary education. So we wanted to move into this higher education. And one of the things that I don't think many listeners might know is just how much the modern university has its origins and medieval Christendom. Why don't you talk a little bit and then you can maybe punt it over to Ben. How did the Christian world view give rise to the university? Where did this come from in terms of the history of Christendom? Well, I'll probably at Ben speak primarily to that. I'll mention a few things. Before I do though, just a very quick comment on what's just been said because I think it's played the what has just been articulated is played out in the United Kingdom just before our eyes, really, the way in which we've really started to see the decay of the university through this instrumentalism, this pragmatism that Ben was talking about where actually we ended up closing our technical schools, technical colleges, which were training people in to be electricians and plumbers and all of these a lot of these technical practical skills trying to push everybody into the university to do these job type. What job is this going to lead to? And ironically, it's actually led to the undermining of the value of a university degree because now every man and his dog has got one or two and you can get one in pretty much anything. And at the same time with the de emphasis on the technical skills that many people are much more suited for than the university environment, we now have to import or we are importing a lot of the people to do those kinds of jobs that we were preparing people to do, which is one of the justifications for mass migration. So actually it's very interesting how a lot of the issues that we talk about are related to what's happening in the university. And instrumentalism I think is fundamentally undermining education. And that takes us to the sort of origin of the university. The word university itself means unity in diversity. As Christians we believe in a universe, not a multiverse because it's unified in terms of the creator God who has a law order, one law order and structure for all of created reality. And of course the idea was that the God of Scripture, the word of God and the Lord Jesus Christ provide the unity in the midst of the diversity of studies. And really out of the monastery, and I'll bend is much more expert in this area than I am, but essentially out of the development of the takeover if you will and repurposing of classical learning, along with the work of the monastery and the Descriptorium and the Library and the way that they these people translated important texts and began to develop and ascent fuse Hibriak learning with Western learning, gradually emerged this institution that we know today as the university, the greatest I think contribution of the Christian medieval era to the modern world. But as we've been repagonizing as a culture, interestingly the university is in decay because it's not really a university today, it's a multiversity that the and that's why I think it isn't holistic in the way that Ben is talking about anymore that we're not thinking about ultimate person, how you actually form and shape a human person who is made in the image of God for life so that they can actually move in any given direction. We have a multiverse that isn't unified by anything and so it just becomes purely pragmatic, purely instrumental and you may have read actually about big scandal we had recently at Cambridge University with a sort of woke professor there who actually turned out wasn't qualified to be there, he got exposed and then tragically committed suicide, he was made in a sense by the by the woke arati and and their lies you know ended up breaking him tragically. But people are increasingly suspicious now in the UK of the university and what it's even for except for ladening you down with unpayable debts and students are beginning to discover this the average student in Britain leaves university with 50,000 pounds worth of debts about a hundred thousand dollars with a debt net, Canadian terms and it's I think it's even more in the United States especially in the the the better Ivy League institutions better inverted commerce. So I think all these issues are related and I think now maybe T T Ben up to talk a bit more about the origins of of the university because I'd like to hear his take on that. Yeah, yeah absolutely. I just you were inspired by something I said I'm inspired by something you said I think one of the things that we see in the way the university system college education I should be careful because we college means different things in America and to the UK but you use them virtually as similes here. Anyhow one of the one of the things that I think that has happened in the sorry one moment just a second I'm trying to silence. Silence something one of the things that we've seen in that has taken over higher education is it's a comp it's combined with the fact that higher education is now largely funded by the federal government and what's happened is we've stopped seeing education or higher education about inculcating cultural leadership and more about basically certifying vocational skills and what it does is it converts people from being thought being seen in terms of being you're you're a man or woman in the image of God who has this duty to subdue this earth to bring glory back to God it converts them from that to a basically whatever their their vocational skill contributes to the economy and so it starts to see things instead of in terms of culture it starts to see things in terms of economy and what you have is in systems where you get this really officious federal bureaucracy that believes that it has the obligation to control and compose and assemble the the nation's economy then all of the people turn into little widgets that you are saying okay we need more computer programmers no now we need more plumbers no now we need more and they're they want people thought of in terms of their vocational skill so that they can be a cog that the federal government administrative state can sort of manage because that is they really are our government they think of themselves these technocrats that their job is to kind of make the machine war along rather than ervas our representatives in in kind of putting together this government anyhow I think that's one big shift that we have seen with the growth of the administrative state and the federal government in America the federal funding of education that's made education is something totally different we talk about the medieval origins of education and and Joe is rooting it in the what starts in the monasteries and you have the church early on has a sense that we have this biblical learning and it's our job to pass this on to future priests so they have these these schools that are about training up tomorrow's clergy and it moves up into the cathedral schools in the in the middle of the middle ages and then but then what happens is and so at this time if you're if you're clergy you get your education through these these church schools if your nobility if you're if you have a title of some sort then you have sort of the wealth and the power to essentially hire private tutors out of that cathedral school system to get your own children's tutors such that they have this kind of education but what happened was in the late medieval era you kind of have the birth of the the middle class and that's middle class more in the the way the English would use the term than the way the Americans would use the term middle class is a little bit higher up but it's basically the the birth of merchants who are have have gathered enough capital to now kind of establish themselves in business and the cities really sort of take off and you have these merchants that now have a lot of money and they're not nobility so they can't educate their kids the way the the nobility does they're not they're they want their kids to follow them in the merchant class and not become monks and whatnot so they won't don't want to put them into those cathedral schools and that really becomes the birth of this new kind of educational system where they took the heritage of the monastic education but kind of converted it into this education for not necessary a clergyman but somebody who's going to be a cultural leader somebody who's who's going to have appointments in the government appointments in business appointments in the military who's going to be a leader and that really becomes the birth of the university so in the 13th century I think it is this begins in in Italy it makes it quickly to university of Paris has founded Oxford and Cambridge are all founded right this time you have Heidelberg University the next century and and what these are are men of wealth invest in these colleges they fund them and they and they and in the college they fund tutors and whatnot to do the the the training and it all culminates in this examination that if you pass you walk out with a bachelor's degree and this bachelor's education is the becomes the mark of this kind of middle class this cultural leader and I think the fact that England with Oxford and Cambridge did it so well is a big part of why England's economy power and and cultural wealth and whatnot becomes so powerful over the next little bit and basically it's the it's the rise the university that makes Europe become well moved from the medieval ages into the early modern era and I think it's also it's it's it's I think it's the rise of the Europe that may or excuse me the rise of the university that makes the reformation possible you have all of the scholars who are now actually pushing themselves going back to the original texts and then they started to have questions and they start to argue and certain questions can't be answered in this old system and it drives the the the reformation it drives the scientific revolution it it creates the the modern world yeah yeah that's really that's that's really fascinating how that developed and um you know as as we're thinking about sort of the the Christian roots of this um some of our listeners might be listening that and go okay that that history is actually quite fascinating so thank you for that Ben but um how do we get to where we are now like we're we're we're where where's the disconnect how did we get to the uh you know you talked a little bit about how these uh and I thought that was a really interesting insight that uh because the federal government has become the sort of administrative behemoth um we want people identified by their vocational skill set so that they can just become cogs in the machine whereas obviously this all birthed out of we are trying to take dominion we are trying to grow christ kingdom we are trying to see you know um people flourish and uh and even that that merchant class we're trying to get goods that we're taking out of the raw material of creation and bring them to people right there's there's very much cultural mandate language in that whole history that you just shared so what happened where is it just the rise of sort of the administrative state or how did we get from what you described to where we are now well I think that um I think first first of all just uh America's apostasy um no no matter what was going on it was going to ride it to a bad place um right so I think that's the thing at the root I would point to um there's certain little things where you can sort of see a path that that America followed um it's really I I would point um in a lot of ways to um federal money coming into higher education um which really actually began with the GI bill um it's it's actually so it's an interesting story um at the end of world war one right is everything is um going terrible depression and whatnot the soldiers that come back from world war one had been promised this big bonus um that the government failed to pay and there was a huge march on washed in DC they referred to it as the bonus army um it was it was basically almost a revolution in the making um coming against uh so there's a bunch of world war one veterans march on DC and they had to be stopped and shut down with tanks and guns uh a number of people were killed it was a gruesome terrible thing and a terrible stain on the administration so when world war two was starting to come to an end I think um there was a really strong desire to make sure that we did not make that same mistake again they wanted the veterans who came back from world war two to feel tangibly the gratitude of the nation and so they put together a series of benefits for GI's coming home from world war two which included home loans but also included um uh basically um grants to attend college and so that's that were coming back from world war two um they had this funding to get homes and grants um they expected you know one level of participation but the number of people that actually took the Bennett far exceeded what their expectations were on the home loan front this is in many ways like the birth of um suburbia for america we had to build all these houses um because of this but also um on the on the um college and the participation in the GI bill and the GI benefit to go to college massively exceeded what the federal government was expecting and it became this expectation that a college degree is owed to all of these people the um the the GI bill and eventually we have things like the Pell Grant added the subsidized student loans all those are added but they're all modeled on the GI bill so it's when it first starts I think it's um it can be relatively harmless I mean who who isn't thankful to our our world war two veterans that defended us like you I can I can understand why we did that but it became the pattern that the Pell Grant and the Stafford loans all that followed and and we and we have this um from post-World War Two uh to um you know uh the end of the millennium we have this slow transition to this expectation that the college degree is um kind of owed to everybody and is the definition of entrance into the successful entrance into the workforce and this idea that the government kind of owes it to us um combined with and then this happens back with the GI bill as soon as the government is funding that grant there was a corresponding expectation on the federal government's um part that that if we're paying for it then we get to say what it does and and so that's where you start to get this this kind of technocratic administration of funding and education where the government as the administrative state is exploding in America the government is saying hey we get to say what these colleges do because we're paying for them and so we have certain um we have certain careers we have certain uh vocational skills that we need funded we have to we get to say what this looks like and you get this idea that the American government is actually in charge of and responsible for the American workforce and so rather than have um I think a um rather than have an economy that is um uh this just robbed from George Gilder for a moment and you know the way he describes um um the sort of uh supply side versus demand side economy in one sense in one economy you have this this administration over that is telling everybody what they need to do and the other in the other um view the workforce itself is exploring where it can go and what it can do and I think it's a far more Christian way of thinking about work it it reflects the the um the the dominion mandate and the great commission this idea of like lift your eyes up see what is out there and see what you can make happen that's I think a Christian way of thinking about vocation but um what what this did is this administrative state comes in and covers the sky blocks your view and tells you know I will tell you what I need you to do and I will control where you will go and I think that's the kind of the transition of thinking about education in this new and I godless kind of way that's interesting Joe I wonder if you can tie that into uh what you're talking about in terms of the university um you know being uh uh kind of uh even the name itself coming from this idea of uh uh diversity and unity because uh it's interesting when you think it's sort of thinking about that when you have this sort of um administrative government that's trying to tell people where they fit into the machine um as opposed to and that's very very different you're sort of looking at the collective as opposed to looking at the individual and and you know each individual before god has received the cultural mandate we live corum dayo right and so there's this individualism the good kind of individualism where we all understand the mandate that god has given to us and in a lot of ways education was about becoming the kind of person who can make the impact in the world that god has asked us to that god's commanded us to and kind of finding your place within that so I just want you to kind of riff off what uh what Ben said uh and then I want to go into um kind of the theological what we've lost theologically but I want to give you a chance to riff off of what Ben just said well it's the ongoing I sort of um describe that and uh just taking on board what Ben has um described there which similar process in the UK is the gradually erosion of freedom that you know the birth of the administrative state the state ism that has come to interfere at every level of education um because it is trying to manufacture you know it's trying to program technocratically manage a future it's trying to design the future that it wants but it's interesting it doesn't work and you actually ironically you just start ending up ending up with all of these shortages in different areas when you try and control and manipulate people in this kind of way um the university itself um you know as as Ben as described it and the birth of some of the great universities um today the state you know god involved basically the end of the 19th century in in elementary and the junior and high school education um and today both by direct and indirect subsidies and grants and so forth it basically does try to control the university so we're seeing um not just people's freedom in a sense to to look up as Ben put it and see what where's the need where can I go and and apply myself um the uh the the the the the university is really trying to the the the state is really trying to direct from the time the kids enter the uh preschool where they want children as early as possible by the way in the state preschools right through to university they want to sort of manage the whole process and they're doing this largely through money money talks and so that not just i'm not just talking now about research programs i'm talking about um government loans so government student loans the reasons these students get loaded up with you know tens of thousands of pounds worth of debt is that the government offers them a loan to do it and says hey you know go drink yourself to death that university um and we'll give you a loan to do it while you're doing your degree in queer studies and um you know that sort of stuff uh this is what this is this is what's happening but also the um the direct direct grants that governments are making as well uh civil government is making behind the scenes so instead of the university being a place of freedom of academic freedom and um and of people's kind of freedom to choose and an expression of that um you've now got essentially you know the way Ben put it there is that a college education or a college degree is almost seen as like a human right and this is and this is where getting to you get just tag it on to the list of rights the people think they've got and that the state is going to going to give you a loan to pay for it of course most of this student debt doesn't get repaid um and so it's basically the taxpayer stumping up to thousands and thousands for for millions and thousands is not right it's millions millions and millions um and so you know we're a long way from where we once were where well if you wanted to go to university you either needed your parents uh to pay for it or you needed a scholarship or you needed um a sponsorship uh to go and do it um and uh and now it's it's it's pretty much but people think of it as almost an entitlement uh they feel hard done by if they if they can't do it in Europe of course they want freedom of movement to do it anywhere they like um and um it does lead to this kind of situation where where gradually insteadly certain programs are subsidized in a way that others aren't because with money you can manipulate you can manipulate everything um and so ironically we end up instead of actually being able to um find the people for all these different roles at the state thinks that it needs in this administrative great vast behemoth of the administrative state we end up with these massive shortages all over the place it doesn't work um but that is sadly tragically um where it's uh where it's ended up if you do feel almost as though in Europe uh and i think in France that's actually the state directly pays for people to go to university um it does feel almost as though the university is now a department of state it that's how it feels um and it's you know indirectly controlled by the state um and uh funded by it and the loans are provided by it and of course um Joe and Jill taxpayer are on the hook for all of it yeah so we've talked a little bit about we've talked a lot about the kind of structure and uh economics of it um but one of the things that uh because i want to get to the idea that i do think that there is a resurgence in classical Christian education that uh can't really be ignored and i think we i we want to talk about that we want to talk about where it's going um but one of the things so we've talked about sort of the the economic decline of the social decline of the university but obviously there's been a huge moral decline as well and it it from from a sort of classical education standing you know the theology was always regarded as the queen of the sciences and so you know we organized knowledge under our theological understanding of you know god is the creator we are made in his image you know uh knowledge is revelatory and and so you know let's talk a little bit about what we lost when um we lost the more the the distinctly Christian morality of education so i i'll give that to you first Ben and then um maybe we'll talk a little bit about the resurgence of classical education yeah i mean it's a this is a big topic but i do think um it would take a little while to unpack this all the way but i think that um that transition i was describing of kind of prying you away of understanding yourself um in a biblical sense and your responsibilities and what is what is a person what does it take to be um to fulfill god's calling your life to pry you away from that and to turn you into a cog um in somebody else's economic machine one of the most effective ways to do that is for devious sexual immorality to to to be pushed upon you um there is um god it's interesting to me watching young men and women as they um you know follow love Mary and start families how much um god puts an uncommon amount of natural revelation inside of a um a biblically oriented um love life there when when you put put a different way when a man um falls for a woman marries her and starts having children with her when he holds that first child his world is undone and he he has a radically different understanding of his relationship to the world of his obligations of what is noble and what he wants to die doing and it is um i say it's an uncommon amount of natural revelation because it's it's it's it's an almost a supernatural sort of thing that happens and i think in some place it kind of is supernatural where god uses healthy sexual orientation to help us understand the goodness of his world and the calling that he's called us to it's surprising to me how many men i have heard were converted to the faith simply by holding their their firstborn um you know they suddenly understood there is a god i'm called to serve him this is what i must be there's something so profound and good about that and that that that kind of spirit of of what i want to be what i want to make of this world is really closely tied to that so when you come and you um destroy that with um numbing people to that that that natural revelation that could be there you numb them with um pornography um uh fornication and all of the sort of um sexual deacons that is that you're tempted into in the in the in the college system and that is pushed on you that numbs you to all of those things and it's as if you had all of these these roots that were rooting you into healthy natural revelation and it just goes and it cuts all of them and so i think that the sexual immorality that has been so uh um closely attached to the college experience this expectation that this is where you get drunk you're gonna fornicate you're gonna whatever it's really about cutting all of those roots so that you can now be um um a cog in the machine um how many women see the state as their husband because they have deadened themselves to the hope of having an actual true marriage and they see their career as their child they see um and it's because of what's going on in these colleges and so it's interesting because on the one hand i would say the colleges are about um you know they're teaching you that to have this purely sort of um skill set orientation to what you're getting here but there's actually something far more devious that's that's really truly happening there's a whole worldview that's all wrapped up and they're they're cutting all of your ties to your home and everything while they're reorienting you to this economic vision um nay if i can just really very very quickly just jump in on something that uh that's good to um because uh today uh i was reading in the news in in uh over here in the uk that a new report was just released by the um center for social justice that's a that's a think tank over here in the uk and it was on the so-called relationship recession um where it says young men are now 26 times more likely 26 times more likely to live with their mother than with a wife by their 25th birthday that the study showed that not there's been a 97 percent drop 97 percent drop in the marriage rate for men in their 20s over the past 50 years leading to roughly 3.7 million fewer married people under the age of 30 compared to a couple years after i was born compared to 1976 so you've got 35 percent of young men today aged 20 to 34 currently living with their parents not established in any mature relationships um the college university system has definitely helped stimulate that helped advance it and even this think tank acknowledges of course they never want to identify the religious root of the problem the moral root that we've just been talking about they'll talk about socioeconomic disparities and digital dynamics which actually Ben pornography does get mentioned um you know anxiety levels and so on and so forth but they acknowledge that this relationship recession poses a long-term threat to health personal happiness and the country's economic future because stable relationships are the strongest predictors of physical and mental well-being um and uh this trend of um delaying these key milestones of marriage is creating they acknowledge a massive shift in the social fabric of the UK in other words societies collapsing i mean that that's the long and the short of it it's collapsing and and i agree that this has been impart driven by this obsession with sending everyone as far as it's possible to college or after university uh with the expectation of sexual experimentation immorality distancing them from the morality of their parents from the values of their parents etc etc um and you know this this phase of cutting loose and rebellion and so on and so forth um it you could say it both reflects and maybe help stimulate and drive this this phenomena and it's now being acknowledged as a crisis a crisis a social crisis 97% shift drop in the marriage rate of young men it's it's staggering what's actually happening and that's the thing that i think is important to point out because there's a there's a there's a lie that's happening on the surface college is about getting you vocational skills and that's why all the kids have to go there the government can say you you need to send your kids here or otherwise they don't have a hope of a job they have to come to us to get a job what's actually happening when they get there is all of those roots are being cut there's a different agenda that's actually happening and so it there's a i i want to make sure it's it's clear i don't i think college is advertised as being about vocational certification that's not what's actually happening there there's there's something else that's happening there's a reprogramming there's an indoctrination that that's happening there that they use that that notion that this is what you have to do to get a job in order to enroll everyone yeah well and it's it's sort of a cross discipline so we've been talking a little bit about the kind of insidious nature of the federal government getting involved the universities themselves losing their morality but i mean media is involved in this like when was the last time you saw a tv show or a movie about you know the kid who goes off to college and his shape to be the man that he's supposed to be for his waifing kids right and it's like that nobody makes that movie right it's it's about the experiment like so all of this is sort of working against the person who's going into university because i think you're absolutely right is is the experience of it has become such a cultural phenomenon and and none of the none of the uh none of the impact is good right i i think of i i started out in ministries a youth pastor and it was amazing to me as i watched graduates um head out and uh and and off to university and and i remember saying the pastors at the time like number one um you know social experiment done youth pastors are not good i can't be one anymore this is actually um you know harmful to the body of Christ um but but it was interesting how often one of the first things that happens you go off to university as joe said you're isolated from your parents you're taken out of the morality of the home uh that you grew up in but you're also dislocated from your church right like there's no you know and and so you see churches that try to bus students in and all this kind of stuff but you're you're disconnected from your church community you're disconnected from everybody who was kind of shaping you as a person and then you're sent off to a bunch of other people who are experimenting and trying to find themselves even even if you're like so when i was at the University of Idaho um you know my my life was really transformed by Christ while i was you of i stood through the ministry of campus crusade it was a wonderful thing it was actually through campus crusade i became reformed which is not the normal effect that campus crusade has on people but um you know it so i'm very grateful to it as a ministry however um i lived in the dorms um i didn't go off campus for anything including church i thought campus crusade was my church which meant um i'm in these years when i'm thinking about who do i want to marry what kind of man do i want to be what does it look like to be a godly Christian leader and literally the the sort of premiere example that i have of that is a 21 or 22 year old like you're your example of first year 30 peaks right there yeah it's not it's not a healthy way of forming you it's one of the reasons why it enters a we we will not have dorms um and because we we want the students to live in the town we don't have a chapel service we tell them it's actually a requirement um that you be attending one of the local even jellicle churches because we don't want to pretend like we are in some way taking that role we need you to be around 80 year olds and two year olds so you have a full sense of what the body of Christ looks like yeah yeah yeah it's just interesting in this conversation it's sort of you know shaped in my mind that university went from or the idea of higher education went from you know shaping a shaping a boy into a man for the rest of his life and what it's really become now is sort of delaying adulthood and you know prolonging adolescence and uh and and so just from that aspect alone it's kind of done a complete 180 in terms of what it once was to what it is now doing it's it's four years of infantilization you you live on on imaginary money you know that these student loans that you're back up and student loans just it's it's the most remarkable debt because whenever like it's such a disservice to an 18 year old to have their introduction to their relationship to debt be a student loan because with all other debt debt is taken on with high scrutiny of your own personal finance your ability to repay it's as great like responsibility that you're taking on and you have to demonstrate I have the capacity to pay this home loan I have the capacity to pay this car loan student loan debt um you qualify for it by showing that you have no capacity whatsoever to pay this um and and you and as a student it's just um you're just like saying yeah I want $50,000 not you you don't have any capacity for understanding what is the what is that demand on the rest of my life going to look like I've never paid a monthly credit card bill um let alone a debt like that and so they're they're living on this imaginary debt they're living in an imaginary place their dorm uh eating out of the cafeteria it's it's all imaginary and the workload itself is decreasing every year like what it takes actually um complete a college degree is right now like roughly maybe 20 to 25% of the amount of work it would have taken 50 years ago it's a complete a college degree so it's this it's just infantilizing and and I and I think that uh you know a lot of this whole failure to launch syndrome that we have right now with our young people a lot of it I think can be traced to our colleges we send them in this experience it's supposed to be the capstone preparing them for adulthood but what we're doing is we're just infantilizing them and then saying now go out and and and they haven't learned how to how to be an adult yeah so I want to get to some good news because we can't we can't leave our listeners with all of this despair Ben um so uh let's talk a little bit about this resurgence in classical Christian education because I do think there is one um you're seeing a lot of churches take on the initiative of starting classical schools out of their church for their what were previously homeschooling communities um so talk a little bit about where you think that resurgence came from and uh and are you hopeful about it I'm I'm immensely hopeful for it I think that the classical Christian education movement is the single biggest cultural win that the Evangelical Church has had in the last like three decades um it it is it is the one place I see where we are really putting points in the board is so one place I see where the the world is running after us um saying now how many how many secular charter schools are now starting under the classical brand um everybody is trying to be classical it's it's funny when I go to um meetings with college presidents and and listening to college presidents introduce their institutions how many of them will try to brand their institution as um as the the capital of classical education or in one way or another everybody wants to claim that brand so I think that something really remarkable has been done there I think that K-12 education was a wasteland and it needed a competitor and I think we did an outstanding job of giving a starting this competitor that actually re-orients everything in my hometown of Moscow we're now um they're they're trying it well today's election day they're they're trying to pass a new levy for building up um putting tens of millions into into the public school system and people who are not connected to Christian education at all are showing wait a minute in Moscow we've had um the school the public school system has lost something like 30% of its students over the last 10 years and we're trying to spend more money on more buildings and they're showing we're right at like 47% of the kids in the Moscow school district are getting private education rather than public we're just few ticks away from being the majority um and I think it's because classical education has done this wonderful thing I think the big danger is and this is the temptation is that whenever you get a victory we always want to then coast and just take in the the the the booty that we the plunder that we've taken it with our victory and we don't um we have to understand the principle of pursuit um so many so many great battles have been squandered by not understanding that once you win you must pursue yeah instead of just sitting down and enjoying the plunder and uh I do fear that we're not pursuing and so what I see a lot of people doing is you know this great kid of 12 education and many of them are acting as if now that scholarship to the college that's going to do all the things that we've just critiqued but now they're giving you a scholarship because you got such great SAT scores because you went to a classical school so they're giving you this prestigious scholarship and parents are seeing that as the reward for their faithfulness and so it's like you were faithful for a K-12 years and my reward is I get to apostatize at a much higher level um it's it is it is sad to see us not carry that that principle of pursuit on but I think that that's that doesn't undo at all the fact that I think K-12 of classical education has been a tremendous victory yeah I agree I think um you know inspired quite frankly uh kind of unashamedly by both of you gentlemen by the model in Moscow and then Joe through Westminster Chapel in Toronto starting a classical Christian school I think about 11 years ago now Joe um we uh 14 there you go and so when I when I started to have anywhere away from I started having kids I knew that um okay by the time they need a school I want to have built a classical Christian school um by the time they need a high school I want to have a classical Christian high school and my kids aren't at the age yet but by the time they need higher education I need a uh Christian liberal arts college and so um I've been really inspired by watching the institution building uh of both of you men um so then talk a little bit about that transition from classical K-12 to the the the education philosophy of new sane anders what makes it different than than the modern universities that we've just spent you know 50 minutes dunking on yeah um well so for one you know we're unashamedly Christian and so it is a deeply devout Christian culture and so our goal is um to complete the enculturation um in the gospel that's been happening indicated 12 years and we're going to be pretty bold and forthright about that in in every possible and other distinctive no federal money um we we try to keep our our price as honest as possible but but related to what we've been talking about one of the central things has been our undergraduate degree is a single degree in liberal arts and culture it's just one general liberal arts degree where we're working on helping you to be the best um Christian man or woman and having your worldview um put together and those skills of cultural leadership kind of passed onto you so it's it's one degree that's expected to take you into we've see some of our students going to be medical doctors some to be lawyers some to be state legislators some to be moms some to be teachers some to be pastors but we're looking particularly for those positions of cultural leadership they're going to have disproportionate impact on on society we want to prepare our students for that with this distinctive Christian liberal arts education um I love that approach I love the the strategy behind it um what would you say to some of the um let's just say a lot of our listeners are homeschooling parents or their kids are in classical education uh through their church right now and uh and some of them and I I don't think this is wrong I think it's actually been a reaction to the modern university that we're talking about a lot of them have just said okay I'm just going to give up on higher education right we're gonna we have this homestead and you're going to take over the homestead or you're going to take on you know we're going to set you up with an apprentice in the church for a trade or whatever the case is and a lot of Christians I think particularly I would say Christians like minded Christians right like reformed Christians or see the world they want to insulate their families um from just the insanity of the culture and so they've given up on higher education what would sort of your your advice or your pitch be to parents um who have kids and say no no no don't abandon higher education just just you know consider a Christian higher education like we have it in New St. Andrews well I would say um first of all I think you have to ask that question should my son or daughter go to college exactly is this something that will be right for them I think that um we we push it on way too many kids and it's it's not healthy so you first have to ask is this something that will be good for them is this a young man a young woman who has an appetite for um learning for intellectual engagement that is outstripping what what their current education is giving them they they they are chomping to read more to argue more they um and I would say um there's that but there's also I have to there's there is a uh I always have a soft spot for the young men who are slackers because I can see I consider myself to have been one of those um if if you would ask if they yeah if you'd look to my high school grades um none of my high school teachers thought I was um fit for college whatsoever and I actually almost flunked out of um college um two years in a row because I did not but it was a it wasn't an aptitude it was where I was morally and whatnot I needed somebody to kick me into pants so I do think you want to look for particularly those young men who might be coasting that need that that challenge put in front of them like you this you've got a young person he I know he can do more but he's coasting because he hasn't had somebody get his face and push him the way he could be pushed that's something we do well um might my instructors love to get young man's face make him rise to the occasion um it's it's it's a it's a sweet thing to see and it's a wonderful it's wonderful to be the kind of institution that can be the forge that creates that kind of maturity so I would say when you have somebody who has leadership qualities um they they want to lead others or they have the capacity to lead others I would say you should be trying to get them into an institution like new sanie andres that's not to say um I think that there are secular places where you can get pushed um but it's just a lot harder to do it with um confidence that it's it's going to end well um but I think you find that kid with that sort of potential you you should be pointing him to a place uh like NSA but like I said I think um there's there's um there is another uh I will say there's another category of kid which is um there are some kids that's not so much that they have strong cultural leadership potential in front of them it's that they have extraordinary aptitude and drive in certain disciplines and this tends to be kids who who it's just clear god made clear to them that they're going to be an engineer or they're going to be a doctor or or a nurse that they're going to go in medical profession or they're going to be an engineer those kids um they they have to get there there's a certain kind of degree they have to get to pursue that career and um it's not nearly as um and uh it's it's a much more that degree and that education is much more um it's not as loaded with with these other sort of worldview issues it's a very technical kind of thing that it's aiming you towards and I think there are some kids that have um a very strong calling to that technical world that need to get a degree like that so a kid who I can tell he wants to be a mechanical engineer and he's coming to NSA because he thinks that this is the only Christian thing to do I tell him you just got to get a mechanical engineering degree we're not going to make you an engineer and and I don't think there's a problem with with that. Mm-hmm it's good that's good um anything as we wrap up here because I want to be respectful of Ben's time Joe anything in terms of kind of wrapping this conversation up anything that you wanted to address in closing so that we can tie a bow on this. Well I think um I'm just really glad that Ben said what he said there on a number of counts the first of all asking that more basic foundational question should you know our children are all different should my child be going to university what what is the um what is the objective uh do they what is their aptitude what what's their umpices what's their character like what's their skill set like whether they seem to be moving in their thinking you know it's it's not exasperating our children is not trying is partly involves not trying to ram them into a mold that we specifically designed for them well I've done this and therefore you need to do it sort of a mentality that some the families can adopt is that you know well I was a doctor you're going to be a doctor um a type of thing so that's that's important are are they suited to the university environment and um and anything asking the question you know is the institution uh Christian just like we do about with Christian schools you know a a an American Christian university that has chapel glued on the front end of the day does not make a Christian university and is interesting that Ben said that uh you know NSA they don't even do a chab they're not trying to replace the church they're not trying to pretend to be something else they want that they want their young people engaged and in the local churches um I don't think that means you can't provide some kind of morning devotions uh chapel in a Christian institution but I do think that the the idea that a Christian school is a place that has a Bible class and a and a and a chapel glued on the front end therefore it's Christian we all know that that's a crock and we've got to have the development of distinctly Christian curricula informed by biblical world of life view um and the Haskell tradition which is really a model of it I mean Ben hasn't had a chance to talk about that we haven't got chance today maybe what we should do is scheduler another interview with Ben to talk a little bit more to get into what classical curriculum looks like but it's fundamentally a pedagogy the goal is not to create Romans it's not to create pagan Greeks um it's to look at the the lessons of pedagogical lessons of you know a couple of millennia um of how one teaches of how children learn and then infuse all of that with uh a scriptural world and life view as we as we tack all the topics so um asking those I think it always comes down a lot of these questions come down to pairing things back not accepting the status quo and then asking what are the most fundamental questions I should be asking about my child and their education uh right now and uh the space the Ben is in is not easy because you're really pioneering it's one thing to pioneer new elementary schools um k through 12 and as you mentioned they you know by God's grace my wife and I planted Westminster classical Christian academy and that's led to I think eight or nine now classical Christian academy starting in southern Ontario alone um a university is is the next level up and we need those in Canada um and we desperately need them in the UK and in the UK we bet we haven't even started really I mean we we desperately need a resurgence of classical Christian k through 12 education um uh there is a one attempt at the moment to get a little college going seldom college in the Oxford area with somebody who was connected with um uh NSA which is exciting but this is uh I would say this is a huge my last comment would be this is a huge missional field and the early church grew rapidly in part because it started Christian schools and gradually the pagan schools became defunct this was an area in the early church just like Ben said was going on in their environment where actually the world started to chase them they started to chase the Christian schools they wanted their children in those institutions um that's the way used to be and uh if we're going to reach this generation and and transform the shape of the future the area of education is absolutely critical from uh the from the elementary uh through to the university the recovery of the Christian university is a Christian uh and a biblical in my view necessity for our generation absolutely and and I would just say for anybody who's listening to this and wants to hear uh uh Ben go a little bit more in depth uh come to our thinking Christianly about education conference is going to be in Edmonton uh in the uh late uh late winter early spring and uh his topic that we gave him actually is how classical Christian education built western civilization and so um you know that's absolutely this is at the this is at the heart of um what built uh the the civilization that we have that we're trying to hold on to that we're trying to conserve um and uh and I would just say just uh just to kind of torture you both because I'll bring up a topic and not let either of you talk about something that you really want to you know uh you know uh Ben uh wrote a book uh not that long ago uh called the white horse king where he it's sort of a biography of king Alfred the great and uh Joe always wants to talk about him because he's he's the great english king but uh but one of the things that Alfred did um it's all of his military uh victories is that when he when he saved England he set up classical Christian education that that really was what propelled England into the superpower that it was so lots of fascinating things and I'm with you Ben I think that uh this is this is one of the biggest wins that uh the evangelical Christian community has had in the last several decades is reclaiming Christian education so uh praise god for that okay we've taken a lot of your time thank you for being generous with your time uh Ben uh thank you uh as always Joe for joining us from across the pond and uh in uh in wrapping up this uh episode with our fellow dr ben merkel uh we just want to remind everybody as we always do uh that from him and through him and to him are all things praise be the glory forever Amen we'll see you next week

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Once in a Lifetime Hike + Thanksgiving Concussion in China + Shenzhen Smuggler [China Compass]

    Nov 21, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Welcome to China Compass on the Fight Laugh Feast Network! I'm your China travel guide, Missionary Ben. Follow me (@chinaadventures) on Twitter/X where I post new/unique Chinese city prayer profiles every single day....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A Plea To Wes Huff [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 20, 202611 minAudio

    Wes Huff's plagiarism controversy has raised serious questions about Christian integrity, accountability, and public repentance. In this special episode, Pastor George Sayour examines the allegations against Christian...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Are Christians Thinking about U.S. Policy in the Middle East in Relation to the Person of Christ? [God, Law, and Liberty]

    Nov 20, 202625 minAudio

    Today David examines what “Biblical worldview value,” if any, Christians would place on the present nation of Israel in determining the United States' policy for Israel and the Middle East if objective knowledge of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 248. What Hinders Maturity in Men? [Leadership Now Podcast]

    Nov 19, 20261 hrAudio

    Tune into this episode of Leadership Now with Dr. Aaron Rock where Aaron provides some wisdom and insight into some of the things preventing men from growing in maturity. More Resources: More resources at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Should Government Enforce God's Law? Responding to Todd Friel [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 19, 202642 minAudio

    Should Christians support laws that force unbelievers to behave morally? Or does God forbid the government from enforcing biblical morality? In this episode of *The Magistrate*, James Baird and Josh Howard respond to a...

    Credit the people on this episode